Conservatives are using a losing strategy ｜ Andrew Lawton on Andrew Says
Episode Stats
Words per Minute
192.69867
Summary
This week on Andrew Says, we have Andrew Lawton from True North, and he has a lot to say about the Conservative Party kicking Derek Sloan out of caucus. He also doesn t mix words about the party adopting a losing strategy where the Liberals dictate all the rules, set the overton windows, and just run scared and fire everyone. We also talk about mainstream media narratives and how to battle them, labeling everyone far-right, alt-right.
Transcript
00:00:00.160
Hey guys, it's Andrew. This week on Andrew Says, we have Andrew Lawton from True North,
00:00:04.640
and he had a lot to say about the Conservative Party kicking Derek Sloan out of caucus.
00:00:08.140
He also didn't mix words about the party adopting a losing strategy, where the Liberals dictate
00:00:12.520
all the rules, set the Overton windows, and they just run scared and fire everyone.
00:00:16.840
We also talked about mainstream media narratives and how to battle them, labeling everyone
00:00:23.400
Exclusively on Rebel News Plus, also, you can also see Andrew Lawton talk about cancel
00:00:27.140
culture, how people have tried to cancel him, in fact, when he ran for office, and he does
00:00:31.820
give good advice also on what young Conservatives can do to take part in the culture war.
00:00:43.040
You get this show, you get the Ezra Levant show, you get all the shows, is what I'm trying
00:00:46.680
to say, and for my show, every week you get exclusive content that you won't see on YouTube.
00:00:53.040
Remember, I wouldn't lie to you, except for maybe this once.
00:00:57.140
The mainstream media did not know who I was, being the undocumented foreigner in this
00:01:21.480
land, and they were speaking a little candidly.
00:01:31.000
I keep thinking I can't be surprised by what happens in this country, and then we get another
00:01:35.120
I followed this case, I was here at the last hearing in the Old Valley, when Tommy gave
00:01:40.120
a submission to the judge, where it was obvious that no offence had been committed.
00:01:45.140
They have a bunch of anonymous sources in policing and banking saying that the fact that the killer
00:01:51.340
was able to withdraw $475,000 in cash from Brinks Banking, which does not at all serve consumers
00:02:00.460
directly, is typical of how the RCMP would pay informants or agents.
00:02:06.120
Andrew Lawton is a podcaster, writer, and political commentator with True North.
00:02:16.160
You can find him on Twitter at AndrewLawton, on AndrewLawton.ca, and of course, TNC.news.
00:02:28.480
Now, I first think I saw you for the first time on your own podcast, and as I suspected,
00:02:33.420
all Andrews have great ideas, why don't you tell the people who don't know how you first
00:02:39.620
I know you have a strong broadcasting and writing background.
00:02:43.180
Tell everybody what got you involved in politics in the first place and how you got to be with
00:02:48.480
Well, that's a big, big, long question, but I'll try to give the interesting summation
00:02:52.580
I was working for a mainstream media company, actually, doing a talk radio show for several
00:02:58.940
And after I left that, I took a little bit of a brief foray into politics, and it didn't
00:03:05.160
end particularly well as I lost, but looking back on it, I am actually fairly grateful for
00:03:11.860
And I wanted to do something that was a lot more fun and really giving me a lot more of
00:03:17.800
an ability to talk about the issues that I care about and follow the stories that I
00:03:21.920
So I kind of decided to chart a path in independent media, and I was very grateful that my friend
00:03:27.880
Candice Malcolm had started at the time this small upstart movement called True North.
00:03:33.140
And she had asked if I wanted to do something previously, and it didn't really work out at
00:03:38.300
But this time around, I thought it would actually be a lot of fun, and it was a growing organization.
00:03:42.920
So for starters, it wasn't something that is like it is now with a bigger team and with
00:03:49.060
So the role has morphed, but I wanted to get to a return to broadcasting, and I had actually
00:03:55.060
gotten my start in podcasting before I worked for a radio station.
00:04:01.760
And let's jump right into this stuff here that's been going on.
00:04:09.580
But the Canadian Conservative Party is all over the map right now.
00:04:15.060
They seem to be in damage control weekly, if not daily.
00:04:19.060
And for the past year, it's sort of been, you know, giving people the boot, being on
00:04:25.060
The recent examples, of course, are Roman Baber and now Derek Sloan.
00:04:29.380
Do you think in general it's a good move for the Conservative Party to be on such a defensive
00:04:37.300
And I'd say one of the biggest failings of Conservative parties in Canada, and even more
00:04:42.140
broadly, you can see this around the world, is not setting out their own game and their
00:04:48.400
It is rather playing the left's game on the left's field by the left's rules.
00:04:52.480
And it's never going to work out particularly well.
00:04:55.000
We saw this with Andrew Scheer, where instead of sticking to the principles he had long held
00:05:00.500
throughout most of his time in politics, he was very equivocal in a lot of things when
00:05:05.680
Instead of just planting his feet and saying, this is what I believe, this is what I stand
00:05:10.880
And I think there's a big lesson that the right needs to take from this, which is that
00:05:17.780
You're always going to be called racist, homophobic, this and that.
00:05:21.140
So trying to bend yourself into knots to make it so that you aren't called those things isn't
00:05:28.560
Now, obviously, no one should be any of those things.
00:05:31.120
But the point is that the accusation is always going to be there.
00:05:34.820
One of the things before Derek Sloan was kicked out of the Conservative caucus that really
00:05:40.140
jumped out at me was Aaron O'Toole last week putting out this long statement disavowing
00:05:50.360
The left thinks that you're far right and I'm far right and Aaron O'Toole is far right.
00:05:54.340
The left, I think, thinks Michael Chong is far right.
00:05:56.420
But when someone in Aaron O'Toole's spot says, you know what, we have no place for the far
00:06:01.400
right, all he's really doing is talking about his movement and his party in the terms of
00:06:12.860
One thing that Stephen Harper did very well is he actually wanted to push the line down
00:06:21.680
And there were a lot of areas where I think people could say he could have done more and
00:06:26.520
But Conservatives since then have only been in catch up and defense mode.
00:06:31.420
It's very confusing to me where the line and you mentioned playing, setting their own
00:06:38.460
I'm wondering where the line actually is for somebody like O'Toole, because in the case
00:06:44.040
of Derek Sloan, what you have is a guy who's known as not a good guy, a white supremacist.
00:06:50.480
I didn't hear about him until somebody took a picture with him at the Adamson barbecue
00:06:56.600
So you've got a guy donating a hundred something dollars under a name that most people probably
00:07:01.520
wouldn't be familiar with right off the top of their head.
00:07:04.620
And I would say it was probably very hasty, the Conservative Party, to immediately say,
00:07:16.860
Where is the line where we can draw, where we actually defend?
00:07:19.640
If you're Aaron O'Toole, defend people in our party.
00:07:22.800
Look, I've been involved in politics for a while.
00:07:25.480
And this is from the get go, something that reeks of they wanted to get him out.
00:07:30.560
And this was the first available, quote unquote, excuse they could use.
00:07:34.240
You don't turf someone for this when you could easily defend this in the way that Derek Sloan
00:07:39.740
has by saying, first off, we had 13,000 donors.
00:07:47.500
Thirdly, he wasn't even using his real name and so on and so forth.
00:07:51.400
So this is the situation where the Conservatives acted so quickly because they clearly wanted
00:07:58.160
And this was the first thing they saw that they could kind of use as a cudgel to achieve
00:08:03.440
And then you have to ask the question of why, because if you're someone who has been anti
00:08:08.060
Derek Sloan and a lot of criticism about Derek Sloan has been put towards Aaron O'Toole.
00:08:13.520
If you're one of those people, you're not satisfied by this because Aaron O'Toole still
00:08:18.420
refused to kick Derek Sloan out on this policy or that policy or this statement or that tweet.
00:08:26.840
You don't win any of your critics over by doing this.
00:08:30.920
And what I want to point out now is a few people, not many, but a few people have been asking
00:08:35.980
myself and to a larger extent Rebel News, if you will, how come you guys are going after
00:08:42.440
How come you're not focusing more on what Trudeau is or is not doing?
00:08:45.640
And to that I say, Trudeau isn't doing anything right now.
00:08:49.480
I mean, his last public statement was him, among other things, of course, saying that he doesn't
00:08:53.660
want a vaccine passport, whereas the last few weeks we have O'Toole saying this is racist.
00:09:05.560
What do you think he's gaining by sitting back and watching?
00:09:07.920
Is it just let them burn their own house to the ground?
00:09:12.960
I mean, right now, the opposition, whose job it is to oppose, isn't really able to oppose
00:09:19.000
the Liberals because the opposition's too busy opposing itself.
00:09:21.980
So for Justin Trudeau, why would you get in right now?
00:09:24.820
When the attention is on what looks like a conservative implosion, you just sit back and
00:09:31.140
And when we speak about people who were no longer in the party, who've been ousted, I
00:09:35.360
think of the Karahalioses who started their own party, the New Blue Party.
00:09:41.560
Now, in your personal opinion, do you think any of these people should be the Babers, the
00:09:47.140
Do you think any of these people should be starting their own parties?
00:09:54.500
Well, I mean, the problem with starting new parties is that you see fracturing take place.
00:09:59.780
And I think a great example of this is right now at the federal level.
00:10:04.000
You've had the Libertarian Party, which is a longtime party that's been in Canada.
00:10:10.580
If someone forms a new party on top of that, it's going to completely make it so that everyone
00:10:16.220
just looks like they're running a vanity project.
00:10:18.680
Provincially, you have the Freedom Party, you've got the Libertarian, and now you've
00:10:21.600
got Jim and Belinda Karahalios with the New Blue Party.
00:10:24.240
If someone else were to form a new provincial party again, it would look like each person
00:10:30.920
My concern is less with parties and more with a movement.
00:10:34.360
I mean, if you believe that politicians are cowards or you believe that politicians are
00:10:39.140
mushy or you believe whatever, the answer to that is to make a climate that either gives
00:10:44.980
politicians the ability to stand up for something or to at least create a climate that elects
00:10:51.980
Now, I think there are good people that believe the right things and advocate for the right
00:10:55.760
things in office in Ontario and at the federal level.
00:10:59.020
But the whole point is, is that we have a climate now that makes it very easy for people
00:11:05.480
As you've talked about in the past and as I've covered on my show extensively.
00:11:10.120
So yes, I mean, new parties might solve a short-term need, but creating a new party doesn't deal
00:11:15.560
with the underlying cause of that problem, which is that mainstream parties are apparently
00:11:21.380
not actually open to the big tent of opinions that's always been taken for granted.
00:11:28.860
If putting out a two-page document or having a random person donate to you is the marker
00:11:34.780
for getting kicked out of a caucus or a party, I'd say that's pretty low.
00:11:38.140
And as you said, they probably didn't want them there in the first place.
00:11:41.500
And even if they're making good points, apparently we can't have that in the moderate conservative
00:11:46.300
And that's concerning to me, because like you said, what's going to happen in a snap election
00:11:52.840
Liberals are going to gain a little bit more, probably.
00:11:55.160
Conservatives are going to get a little bit less.
00:11:58.460
But I don't know how this progresses anyone forward in the type of ideas that someone
00:12:04.080
like you or I or somebody who's a viewer of ours might prefer to go.
00:12:10.320
And if they start creating new parties, you're right, it's going to fracture a lot more.
00:12:16.460
It's going to be a lot harder to get proper messaging.
00:12:19.300
So in my personal opinion, I'm thinking that maybe they should try to start a coalition in
00:12:23.240
the PPC or in one of these existing parties and really hammer home the messaging.
00:12:27.920
But I do recognize that on the other side, they're going to say Maxime Bernier and Derek
00:12:34.400
So it's hard to win in a political climate like this.
00:12:39.540
A lot of people are saying that's what O'Toole is doing.
00:12:45.320
Has anyone ever tried to cancel you, Andrew Lawton?
00:12:49.800
Oh, like seven times by lunch usually on most days, I think.
00:12:55.800
And when you're running for office, everyone throws everything they've got at you.
00:12:59.100
And I'm someone who came of age in an era where social media was a thing.
00:13:03.440
So I had inopportune tweets and Facebook posts that, of course, have been screenshotted and
00:13:11.080
I mean, this is a common occurrence in politics right now and in media and in many other sectors.
00:13:16.440
And to the point that I made on the last question about how we need to create a culture here,
00:13:24.600
That's the axiom that was made famous by Andrew Breitbart.
00:13:27.660
And it's truer than ever now, which means that the answer is not going to come through
00:13:32.200
just, you know, electing this person or that person.
00:13:34.820
We have to start winning over hearts and minds in culture.
00:13:37.920
And cancel culture is a huge example of this, because if we don't resist the cancellation
00:13:44.160
of others in our own lives, we're only going to fuel a culture that will eventually come
00:13:51.140
And to your point there, I was going to ask you next of combining the culture and the
00:13:57.080
politics to where it's more of a, I don't want to say mainstream, because that sounds
00:14:01.420
But where it's top of mind, it's not hard for people to talk about certain political
00:14:04.940
issues or not specifically shun anything that they may not have heard of aside immediately
00:14:11.860
So my question was going to be, what's your advice for younger conservatives in Canada
00:14:18.200
They turn on their Snapchat stories or their Instagram stories and see what's trending.
00:14:23.000
And it's all probably completely opposite to what they see as the correct answer to
00:14:28.120
What's your advice to a young conservative who has everything thrown at them?
00:14:31.420
And if they were to come out with their own opinions and speak what their mind, let's
00:14:36.420
say in front of a classroom of their peers, they would get completely cancelled as much
00:14:42.280
What's your advice to them when it looks like maybe from their own point of view that there's
00:14:46.100
nowhere to turn to hear people that they agree with?
00:14:51.880
And I mean, the one thing I will say is that you're going to have a tough few years.
00:14:57.580
I mean, it's not going to be easy if you have two options.
00:15:01.880
You're going to risk being pilloried and mocked and potentially reprimanded for that.
00:15:06.380
And if you keep quiet, you're also dealing with another set of problems, which is not
00:15:10.000
being able to be yourself and talk about these things.
00:15:13.000
So I think that except that neither one is perfect.
00:15:16.060
And then the question is, which do you think is better in the long run?
00:15:19.720
And if you take a stand for something, I'm a firm believer in the fact that you can never
00:15:23.380
look back on that and regret it if you've taken a stand.
00:15:28.700
I think as a culture, what we have to get better at doing is bringing back the art of
00:15:34.560
This used to be something that anyone could do, that I could say something that I think,
00:15:43.480
And, you know, maybe we end on a note where we agree with each other.
00:15:51.700
And I'd say this is mostly coming from the left, as we well know, where they just don't
00:16:04.560
And to bring it back to politicians and partisan politics, we can't accept that.
00:16:09.840
We can't eat at the table that the left has set for us.
00:16:13.340
Now, what's your opinion on the culture and climate in university and colleges?
00:16:17.540
I went to broadcasting school at Humber College, for anyone who's interested.
00:16:21.860
And even there, in a broadcasting setting, I was exposed to new music, new people's opinions,
00:16:29.340
people who are from different parts of the country who believe different things.
00:16:33.280
A dairy farmer, shout out to dairy farmer Alex that I haven't spoken to in 10 years.
00:16:37.860
What do you think is the solution now to reversing course, which appears to be almost
00:16:44.140
It's like they're digressing into more of like a childlike behavior in university and
00:16:48.840
We've seen it all, of course, with Jordan Peterson, if you want to go back a few years.
00:16:53.640
Is it a matter of mandating politics from professors?
00:17:00.380
Is it simply trying to encourage more school groups?
00:17:02.680
There are so many in the United States, Young America for Freedom, Turning Point USA.
00:17:10.860
I do think those sorts of groups are valuable because they make you feel like you're not
00:17:16.260
as much of an outcast as you might feel if you pipe up in your gender studies class about
00:17:22.660
But I would also caution against siloing, which I think is only furthering that inability for
00:17:30.400
If everyone has their own little bubble and they don't go outside of it, I think expose
00:17:38.920
I would say don't actually treat the left the way the left treats the right, because
00:17:44.380
we tend to, I think, as conservatives close down when we hear people talking about, you
00:17:49.280
know, these little buzzwords that we all know are associated with left wing ideology, where
00:17:53.340
I'd say I don't actually be afraid of engaging because some people and again, it may be a minority,
00:17:58.520
but some people, if you catch them as an individual, not in a group, as an individual, you can have
00:18:04.420
The problem is that group speak is a product of group think, and you're never going to get
00:18:09.220
anywhere if you've got the conservative group talking to the liberal group.
00:18:12.300
But one conservative talking to one liberal, I have hope it's possible to have a dialogue
00:18:18.220
My colleague Dave says 30 minutes alone with that person, and I can change their mind.
00:18:22.280
So this new wave of tech censorship we're seeing, and I'm sure you've come across it, don't
00:18:32.120
You can't question anything to do with coronavirus.
00:18:34.580
Have you had any pushbacks or warnings at your company with your show where you've had to,
00:18:40.260
Is this a problem you're facing at your company?
00:18:45.080
I mean, True North has a very open approach to speech, but like anyone else, we get concerned
00:18:50.300
about what's happening with the platforms that we're on, and we try to diversify.
00:18:54.660
We're on Facebook, we're on Twitter, we're on YouTube, we have our own website, we were
00:18:59.260
on Parler while Parler was around, and I personally have that approach as well.
00:19:03.940
And we've also had, on a couple of occasions, our Facebook page vanish overnight.
00:19:07.920
Both times, Facebook will bring it back and say, oh, you know, we're sorry, it's a misunderstanding.
00:19:13.340
But each time, it feels like, is there someone at a switch here that decides, you know what,
00:19:19.560
I've had, in my own Twitter profile over the last few weeks, very fastly dwindling follower
00:19:26.100
And at some points, I'm like, okay, is Twitter messing around with the number?
00:19:29.760
Are conservatives that are following me just quitting Twitter?
00:19:32.340
Or is this part of this mass purge of right-wing accounts?
00:19:35.520
And I think it's probably a combination of all three, or certainly the latter two.
00:19:41.880
And I mean, the challenge with this is that if you are using a social media platform, you
00:19:50.200
If I use Facebook and Twitter and YouTube and I have a Gmail account, I mean, that's
00:19:53.880
all because those companies have decided to offer a product in that way.
00:19:57.520
So I don't like entitlement about these things, but we also have structured our world around
00:20:03.480
And that's, I feel, is the big risk with big tech.
00:20:05.960
We've become far too reliant on these, which if you are in part of a cancelable group, which
00:20:11.060
is what conservatives on social media platforms are, there's a big risk there.
00:20:16.000
Well, I want to point out that it's going even further.
00:20:19.440
And my question is going to be, to play devil's advocate, I always think of my one friend who
00:20:24.400
The libertarian argument of build your own social media platform, build your own web
00:20:34.560
Do we end up with, you know, take the Taco Bell Road on this highway or take KFC Avenue?
00:20:45.300
Do you think it just ends up with a ton of different platforms?
00:20:48.200
Do you think it ends up with people being silenced?
00:20:50.860
Well, I mean, this is something that I've had to reckon with in the last couple of weeks,
00:20:55.240
because I am a libertarian, especially on this issue.
00:20:57.940
So I have always been an advocate of build your own.
00:21:00.480
And it becomes very difficult when it's, well, now you've got to build your own app store
00:21:03.800
and build your own internet and build your own smartphone and not just build your own app.
00:21:08.020
Because Parler, for whatever its technical faults, was conservatives doing that.
00:21:15.260
And then that becomes, of course, its own cancelable platform.
00:21:18.340
And you don't have the ability to have that hosted on a website and all of these situations
00:21:24.000
So my view on this, again, and I hate sounding like a broken record, but there is a cultural
00:21:29.040
aspect on this, because the problem is not going to be solved by technological infrastructure.
00:21:34.340
It's not going to be solved by having a conservative internet, because it's just not practical to do
00:21:39.940
We have to get to a point where we're not succumbing to these boycott campaigns that are becoming
00:21:46.760
You know, the reason that these things have so much success is because companies give
00:21:52.040
If a company turns away a boycott, the boycott campaign tends to just move on.
00:21:59.140
Now, a question I asked Michaela Peterson was around sort of like, you know, everybody has
00:22:06.920
And she mentioned that it was about Jordan Peterson's daughter, by the way.
00:22:11.440
She had a moment where she was really into medicine and medical advice with her diet.
00:22:19.760
And she realized at some point that she couldn't trust, along with the news, she couldn't trust,
00:22:25.460
let's call it political science or the medical industry being propped up by big businesses.
00:22:34.620
As far back as you can remember, maybe it was yesterday.
00:22:38.600
What was the spark that caused you to think, maybe I can't trust everything the news is
00:22:45.340
Maybe I can't trust everything this one person says.
00:22:48.740
Because I think people are still going through that.
00:22:50.440
I ask people a lot now, do you think there's still red pilling going on?
00:22:53.400
And I think people are starting to realize that even with things like coronavirus, you can't
00:22:57.560
trust that just because the government says it or because the WHO says it, that it's actually
00:23:06.600
So with that, I ask you, what was there a moment in your life where you had a realization
00:23:10.960
where maybe you can't believe everything you're reading?
00:23:19.540
But I also don't think that I've consciously had, and that's a great question, by the way.
00:23:23.440
I don't think I've consciously had that red pill moment because I've been conservative
00:23:31.500
And there always has been a bit of a countercultural approach to conservatism, to being on the right.
00:23:38.140
And I mean, it's not to say in my younger teenage years, I think I had my socialistic idealism.
00:23:42.720
But as long as I've actually consciously tried to understand politics, I've been on the right.
00:23:48.220
And I think coming up in that, not from family upbringing, but just from my own, I guess,
00:23:53.320
intellectual upbringing, if you will, I've always been aware of the fact that there is
00:24:01.960
Now, I think when I got my start doing blogging and podcasting, that wasn't a revelation per se,
00:24:09.060
but I think it was an acknowledgement of the mainstream media is not getting it right.
00:24:14.160
And I saw, this is going back to like 2010, 2011, that there was an avenue for independent
00:24:20.580
voices before podcasting was industrialized in the way it is now, before blogging could
00:24:27.020
I was doing it alongside other conservatives, including your boss, Ezra, just because we
00:24:31.740
wanted to, because we liked it and believed in what we were saying.
00:24:35.040
So again, it's not a single moment with a flip switch, but I'd say that was part of the
00:24:40.680
When I was looking at this and saying, you know what, I think I need to be a part of this
00:24:48.040
I wish my worldview was as consistent for as long as yours has been.
00:24:53.920
Well, I mean, let me, I certainly, the ideological journey has changed in that time, I will say.
00:24:59.040
I would not say at all I was as consistent or had the intellectual depth behind my beliefs,
00:25:05.260
but that did come along while I was on that path.
00:25:09.220
Now, the last question I want to ask you before I let you go, and it's not David Menzies related,
00:25:14.000
I promise, we all have our goals and we all have the point that we're trying to make or
00:25:21.000
What is Andrew Lawton personally trying to accomplish?
00:25:30.960
Yeah, I hope it's not too much of a cop-out to say free speech, because that has been,
00:25:37.840
I'd say, the defining value that I tend to always come back to.
00:25:42.960
And sure, I talk about firearms rights, and I talk about taxes, and I talk about cancel
00:25:49.660
But ultimately, the one that I always come back to is free speech.
00:25:53.880
The one that fires me up more than anything else is reading a story about government wanting
00:25:58.620
to create a bureaucracy to regulate social media content or someone being censored.
00:26:06.140
But it's not just about catching up to really bring it full circle to how we started.
00:26:11.260
It isn't just about not wanting to lose ground.
00:26:14.340
I actually want to take a step forward on this issue and have more free speech enshrined
00:26:19.960
in law, but also enshrined in cultural attitudes than we've ever had before.
00:26:23.960
No, I completely agree, and I'm right there with you.
00:26:26.240
And when I talk about number one issues, for me, freedom of speech is right at the top.
00:26:30.420
So you can find Andrew Lawton, Andrew Lawton on Twitter, andrewlawton.ca, and of course,
00:26:36.420
And if you're watching this behind the paywall, which of course I know you are, go to rebelnewsstore.com
00:26:46.740
I just say thank you to all of the subscribers for supporting independent media, and thanks