The Trudeau government wants to regulate the news media, and the only questions the reporters have are, what's in it for me? It's April 6th, 2019, and this is The Answer in the Band Show.
00:19:46.360Ça demande bien qui vous faisiez. Merci.
00:19:49.360Yeah, again, just hours after a federal court said we are indeed journalists, Trudeau said we're not.
00:19:55.360So here we are again with Pablo Rodriguez saying that he has invented something called the Qualified Canadian Journalist Organization, the Journalism Organization.
00:20:03.360Again, that was actually a status that was developed a couple of years ago.
00:20:07.360You can see that the media are obsessed with keeping Rebel News out of the club.
00:20:12.360But did you see the answer from Pablo Rodriguez?
00:20:15.360Let me play that again for you. It's very quick. Take a look.
00:20:20.360Well, don't decide who qualifies and who doesn't.
00:20:23.360Of course, that would be terrible in our democracy.
00:20:26.360It's not up to the minister to say, hey, yeah, that's a good idea in this one.
00:20:29.360No, no, not up to the minister or the government to decide who qualifies.
00:20:32.360There are those criteria that you refer to.
00:20:35.360Of course, there are the organizations are already a benefit from the QCGO.
00:20:40.360So they're engaged in the production of original news content.
00:20:45.360They employ two or more journalists, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera.
00:20:50.360Those those critters are defined there.
00:20:53.360Pablo Rodriguez is shocked, shocked that you would think the liberal government would get involved in keeping out Rebel News.
00:21:36.360You're a government journalist, a rented journalist, a paid journalist, a subsidized journalist, a qualified journalist.
00:21:42.360You put an adjective in front of the word journalist and you've pretty much negated journalists because the essence of a journalist is independence.
00:21:49.360Otherwise, you're not into journalism.
00:22:02.360But for today, it means that Pablo Rodriguez and Justin Trudeau are going to take two big American companies, Facebook and Google, and force them to subsidize these QCJOs.
00:22:18.360The thinking being that a lot of advertising these days is not done in newspapers or TV stations.
00:22:24.360It's done on the Internet because you can very much target people.
00:22:31.360The reason Facebook is free to you as a user is because you're the product being sold.
00:22:35.360Facebook knows everything about you, knows who your friends are, knows what you write in private messages, knows the bands you like, the food you like, sees your photos.
00:22:43.360Facebook knows more than you about you because you've forgotten some things about you.
00:22:47.360You've forgotten what you wrote five years ago.
00:22:49.360You've forgotten, you know, what you read five years ago.
00:22:54.360Facebook never forgets and has this mass of data about you.
00:23:00.360That's why Facebook and Google make so much money and people prefer to advertise there because they know all your secrets.
00:23:06.360So the liberals are going to commandeer these companies and force them to subsidize news companies, which for the privilege of linking them, which is weird because as a news publisher myself, I can tell you, you like when you're ranked highly on Google.
00:23:21.360You like when you're shared on Facebook.
00:23:25.360That's what gives you advertising and eyeballs.
00:23:29.360So although Facebook and YouTube do presumably make some money by sending traffic to you, you're the main beneficiary.
00:23:36.360And we know that because most media advertise paid advertise on YouTube and Google and Facebook.
00:23:43.360Anyway, so this QCJO system is Justin Trudeau and Pablo Rodriguez forcing Facebook, YouTube, Google to pay money to Canadian journalists, but only to the qualified Canadian journalists.
00:24:01.360And there's this whole complex system.
00:24:03.360I mean, imagine trying to regulate the media.
00:24:05.360Imagine how intricate and arcane and like a Rube Goldberg machine that is.
00:24:12.360I mean, the complexity, the red tape, the room for corruption, the room for subjectivity, the number of people who are going to make a living being barnacles, being being a kind of parasite on the actual system.
00:25:00.360So instead of journalists being morally outraged that Pablo Rodriguez and Justin Trudeau are nationalizing not just the news media industry, but the social media industry, they've got technical questions.
00:25:12.360It's like they're employees of the government already.
00:25:14.360They're just curious what the new employment rules are.
00:25:17.360I want to show you something, though, because not only are Trudeau and Rodriguez and others trying to basically have a great train robbery and take hundreds of millions or billions of dollars out of YouTube and Google and Facebook.
00:25:30.360And by the way, I mean, I despise those companies.
00:25:58.360But if these social media companies, Facebook, YouTube, Google, Twitter, whatever, if they publish fake news, they're subject to a fine by the government of Canada.
00:26:09.360So now the government isn't just determining who is or isn't a journalist.
00:26:13.360The government of Canada is now determining what is or isn't true.
00:26:18.360What is or isn't a reasonable opinion.
00:26:23.360And they're not just coming up with an opinion on it.
00:26:27.360They will punish these social media companies with up to a 15 million dollar fine.
00:26:37.360As a follow up to that, I would love to hear you expand on the kind of disciplinary action they would face if they do in fact favor those kinds of that kind of content over news.
00:26:52.360But I do have actually a separate question.
00:26:55.360I was hoping that you could speak a little bit more to the decision to put the CRTC in the role of regulator.
00:27:02.360I know you told Boris that it's because of their experience in sort of the broadcasting world.
00:27:07.360But one thing that we've heard repeatedly from experts, including a former CRTC vice chair, is that they are not really that well equipped to regulate social media as their expertise more so lies in the broadcast realm.
00:27:22.360So how do you respond to those criticisms, especially in light of the fairly significant role that this legislation gives them?
00:27:29.360Okay, Rachel, the first answer to the first question is 15 million dollars when they do something like that.
00:27:37.360So that's the clear penalty and it's written in the law.
00:27:40.360The second one about the CRTC, as I said, they do have experience in arbitration in the broadcasting space.
00:27:50.360We've seen them in the past between big companies negotiating.
00:27:53.360But even in this case, their role is very soft compared to what they do elsewhere.
00:27:59.360Because whenever they go to final arbitration, it's not the CRTC that will be the arbitrator.
00:28:04.360There will be a group of people, experts, arbitrators, that are chosen, accepted by the two sides.
00:28:12.360And three of them will be chosen to arbitrate the discussion.
00:28:22.360So you've got these QCJOs, these government journalists, and they're going to get the hundreds of millions of dollars stolen from Facebook, Google, YouTube, etc.
00:28:31.360But that's not enough because if something slips through from some unqualified journalist, independent journalist, well, that's even worse.
00:28:40.360If you dare to have an opinion that's not qualified, YouTube, Google, Facebook, Twitter, Instagram will smash you.
00:28:49.360Because if they don't smash you, they will be smashed.
00:28:52.360Let's say you're some intern working for Facebook and someone writes a post on the pandemic and says something they shouldn't.
00:28:59.360Says maybe ivermectin could work or maybe the vaccines don't work or maybe we should look more into the Wuhan lab.
00:29:42.360If Stephen Harper did this, if Stephen Harper decided to regulate the Internet and punish wrong think with $15 million fines,
00:29:50.360do you think the media questions would have been the way they are?
00:29:54.360If Trump had done that, do you think it would be the way they are?
00:29:59.360Hey, I got another question for you and I'll tell you more about this in the days ahead.
00:30:04.360Do you think when they crafted this, this attack on social media and social media basically means the sharing sites, the user generated sites like YouTube is a big one.
00:30:16.360You know, I counted up the other day amongst all the different social media platforms, including Twitter and Instagram and some of the smaller ones like Getter and Gab and Parler and all that.
00:30:26.360I'm not sure if we're on Gab, but we're on a lot of these sites.
00:30:29.360Between our official company accounts and our journalists, we have more than five million followers on social media, a million and a half on YouTube alone, hundreds of thousands.
00:30:43.360I have a third of a million followers on Twitter.
00:30:46.360Do you think just maybe there's a chance that we were on the politicians minds when they crafted this rule?
00:30:56.360We saw from the question in the scrum that we're certainly on the minds of rival journalists.
00:31:08.360Trudeau talking about us on the floor of the House of Commons.
00:31:12.360Mr. Speaker, in a question about sensitizing journalists, he's quoting rebel media talking points.
00:31:19.360Mr. Speaker, we are going to continue to stand up for immigration, knowing that defending diversity as a source of strength and welcoming people through a rigorous immigration system from around the world is what has made Canada strong.
00:31:32.360And indeed, something the world needs more of, not less of like they want to bring in.
00:31:37.360Ahmed Hassan read literally word for word the same thing.
00:40:21.360We are now facing the prospect of destruction of organized human life on Earth from environmental destruction and not in the remote future.
00:40:36.360We are approaching irreversible turning points which cannot be dealt with any longer.
00:40:49.360It doesn't mean everybody's going to die, but it's going to mean moving to a future in which the lucky ones will be those who die more quickly.
00:41:02.360The first thing, and I was thinking about it for half the time, was that he was writing in grade five when I think he said he was 10 years old about the fall of Barcelona and the rise of fascism across Europe.
00:41:14.360That would have been a very interesting grade five child.
00:41:19.360And when he says that he was the only one who read his paper other than his mom, I agree with him there.
00:41:28.360I would even say he's an expert on certain things.
00:41:31.360But of all the things he said we're going to die from, and the lucky will be the ones who die quickly, you look around the world today, whether it's global corporations, big pharma, surveillance, state, social credit, Chinese style, debanking, deplatforming, possible nuclear war in Ukraine.
00:41:51.360All those things, the thing that Noam Chomsky, expert on, I don't know, information and global politics, the thing he chooses to be the most scared of is global warming.
00:42:07.360Joining us now to talk about this is our friend Mark Marano, the boss of ClimateDepot.com.
00:42:14.360I thought he was going to talk about NATO or a post-American world or the emerging corporate surveillance state.
00:42:23.360But he's worried about global warming.
00:42:26.360Yes, and he has been actually for quite some time, Ezra.
00:42:29.360First of all, most of his fame in the intellectual left and in the media and in sort of progressives has been since the Vietnam War.
00:42:36.360He's a protest guy, hated Reagan, hated the Vietnam War, hated drafts, was a hero to many of those anti-war protesters, which is all fine and good.
00:42:45.360He billed himself as an anti-fascist, as a, you know, fighting the powers that be.
00:42:52.360The problem now, and I see the same problem that runs through Robert F. Kennedy Jr.
00:42:58.360The guy's phenomenal, recognizes the World Health Organization, recognizes all that stuff.
00:43:03.360But then when it comes to climate, there's a blind spot.
00:43:06.360And somehow, all the criticism they gave of everything, they somehow accept Green New Deal style, United Nations, all the same stuff.
00:43:14.360So what Noam Chomsky has said, first of all, just on COVID, he said wearing a mask, refusing to wear a mask is the equivalent of taking an assault rifle to a grocery store.
00:43:25.360He said Trump's denial of climate change was worse threat to humanity than Hitler.
00:43:32.360Here's some of the things Noam Chomsky's known for.
00:43:34.360He said that Biden on climate is further left than any Democratic candidate in memory.
00:43:39.360And that's absolutely true, because Biden is much further to the left than that.
00:43:44.360But what's interesting about Noam Chomsky is he's had that same blind spot.
00:43:49.360He will tell you that we're going to die from climate change.
00:43:52.360He will tell you that unmaskers are essentially committing assault.
00:43:55.360He will tell you Trump is Hitler for climate denial.
00:43:58.360But at the same time, he wants to empower this sort of permanent one party state that's going to strip away all of our freedoms.
00:44:06.360And it just doesn't make sense for a guy who was against the powers that be against the Pentagon, against the man, against the draft, against the, you know, the Pentagon, you know, Pentagon war machine.
00:45:03.360So you would think that if he was alarmed about, you know, a handful of companies controlling newspapers, well, what about the panopticon of these social media companies owned by oligarchs who have a messiah conflict?
00:45:16.360Well, he's not worried about Bill Gates.
00:45:21.360That's where if we need a Noam Chomsky, and I don't know if we do, but if we do, we need it to fight back against the total surveillance state, total censorship machine.
00:45:57.360And here's the thing is, everything you just said, if this were Noam Chomsky of consistent of the old Noam Chomsky going after, you know, the military industrial complex of the war machine, he would come out.
00:46:08.360And first of all, he would have been against the code lockdowns and the mandates.
00:46:12.360He would have been against emergency declarations.
00:46:14.360Because any student of history, you can go back to the Roman Republic, the descent of the Roman Republic into the Roman Empire happened to abuse of emergency power declarations.
00:46:23.360Emergency declarations used in the Middle Ages to further crush people.
00:46:27.360Emergency declarations used in 1933 Germany.
00:46:30.360Emergency declaration used after 9-11 to give us the Patriot Act and the mass surveillance state.
00:46:35.360Any big tech censorship is government censorship.
00:46:39.360And this is what's missing from Noam Chomsky.
00:46:42.360He just wants sort of like this big government style crushing of industry and civil liberties and freedom because we have to fight global warming and the Republican Party, he said, is the greatest threat because of their view on climate.
00:46:57.360And if you actually were a progressive, worried about the old classic liberal anyway, worried about human freedom, Noam Chomsky is tone deaf.
00:47:05.360Noam Chomsky has changed channels years ago.
00:47:07.360And even left wing figures like Jimmy Gore, a former comedian, but he's also from the Young Turks, has done a whole show with Max Blumenthal on this.
00:47:18.360And they talked about the Noam Chomsky of old was against the power.
00:47:21.360But they speculated that it's not really he's against the power.
00:47:25.360He's against the power that he's not aligned with.
00:47:28.360And if you think back, his rise to fame was during the Nixon administration.
00:47:32.360And that was the Republican war machine Pentagon.
00:47:37.360And I think part of it now is the reason he doesn't oppose this corporate fascism is because the progressive left that he's a member of controls corporate America.
00:47:46.360I would argue that it's actually corporate America controlling government and the woke activists controlling corporate America.
00:47:52.360And you're absolutely right, Ezra, as we were protecting against big government these last 40 years, they slipped in essentially the collusion of big government and corporation.
00:48:02.360And that's what we're dealing with now.
00:48:03.360And that's our greatest threat through emergency declarations.
00:48:06.360They want to declare a climate emergency.
00:48:08.360They want to declare they've already declared the COVID emergency.
00:48:13.360Every time this emergency comes, our freedoms go out the drain.
00:48:16.360If Noam Chomsky were relevant, that would be his topic today.
00:48:20.360It's not going on like it's, you know, to the year 2000 about global warming, which, you know, frankly, by the way, this new UN report, the UK Guardian is lamenting.
00:48:30.360There's literally almost zero media coverage of it.
00:48:33.360The new UN report saying now or never, which my answer was great.
00:48:40.360You know, it's funny you mentioned RFK Junior, the Democracy Fund, which is sort of our friends and it's a nonprofit, hosted RFK Junior just last week.
00:48:52.360And to hear him talk about how emergency laws and rules and regulations were imposed on America, it was actually beautiful to hear in the best tradition of what a Kennedy is.
00:49:06.360You know, democratic processes, checks and balances, public hearings.
00:49:11.360You know, to listen to RFK Junior describe how democracy is supposed to work, regs are supposed to work and how none of them.
00:49:19.360He gave the example of a kayak company ordered to put masks on its customers and say, well, yeah, they're going to drown if they're wearing masks.
00:49:27.360And he just said the absurdity and there was no chance to publish the regs and oppose them.
00:49:33.360Like just to listen to RFK Junior talk about how the democracy that he and his family have been a part of for 70 years is violated.
00:49:42.360I found it actually inspiring. And I never thought I would say that in my life about about a Kennedy.
00:49:47.360Now, you're right. I mean, he's an environmentalist, but frankly, most of his environmental work has been very specific, clean water and things like that, as opposed to, you know, abstractions and scientific absurdities like let's stop the entire Earth from extremely gradually emerging from the last ice age.
00:50:07.360So I'm not here as an RFK defender, but to spend an hour with him, as we did last week, he gets it about democracy.
00:50:15.980He loves democracy. I'm going to say this. Robert F. Kennedy Junior, he's to my left, obviously.
00:50:19.940But my God, he sees that democracy is in crisis. And he used the word turnkey totalitarianism.
00:50:25.540He said once all these big government, big business systems are in place, they lock together. You can't get out.
00:50:30.860I see a lot more in common with RFK Jr. than Noam Chomsky, who just feels like he he hasn't caught up with the threat of our generation.
00:50:39.680Yes. Actually, I have publicly forgiven Robert F. Kennedy Junior.
00:50:44.880When I interviewed him in 2014 at the New York Climate City March, he actually said he wanted to jail CEOs, climate skeptic politicians at The Hague with all other world criminals with three square meals in a cot.
00:50:55.880Now, because of Robert F. Kennedy Junior's outspokenness on the vax mandates and lockdowns and masks, I publicly forgave him and said all is forgiven.
00:51:04.740But I still wonder, he talks about bureaucratic capture at the EPA, but doesn't he see essentially the bureaucratic, the capture of our government agencies by a woke mob, by academia, by foundation funding, and by this narrative that they put together?
00:51:24.940And all the solutions to climate change are all the United Nations, Green New Deal, government control, regulations in our life, mimicking the COVID lockdowns, stay-at-home orders, limiting travel, freedom movement, telling you what you can and can't eat.
00:51:41.100So I think at some point, Robert F. Kennedy Junior needs to delineate his climate position from his COVID, because I think he has to either have evolved or he's got a position I don't fully understand, you know, calling for the jailing of climate skeptic CEOs.
00:51:55.740Yeah, I think you're right. I think a lot.
00:51:57.520And you mentioned some other people who are historically on the left, Jimmy Dore, Max Blumenthal, who I think probably called himself a communist before.
00:52:05.060He's phenomenal on COVID. He called him the lockdown left. He's featured in my book. Very impressive. Some of these figures on the left, you would never have expected to step up like this.
00:52:15.020Yeah, it's a reorientation of the political spectrum. I don't even know what right wing means anymore. Some of the worst lockdown politicians in Canada are nominally conservatives.
00:52:25.000Yeah. It really has scrambled things. I mean, it's it's uncanny. But when you think about it, it makes total sense that many of the pandemic scaremongers are also in the same climate business.
00:52:42.060Look at Bill Gates. He just published a book about the threat of global warming.
00:52:46.960He's the guy who wanted to put billions of tons of dust particles in the sky to blot out the sun.
00:52:53.740Yeah. And you have BlackRock buying up real estate. You have Bill Gates, the biggest American farm owner, landowner, according to NBC News.
00:53:01.500And Bill Gates is now producing synthetic meat. So imagine if he gets more control of farms, the single biggest farm owner that he's going to have direct influence on what we eat, how we eat it, how often the price of it.
00:53:13.500This is what people like Noam Chomsky should be focusing on. And RFK Jr. gets this in many respects. But I still don't understand his climate position.
00:53:24.520And again, I know I sound like I'm defending the guy. It's just that I went to this event and I thought I'm ready to disagree.
00:53:30.960And I found myself agreeing much more than I thought. I think, you know, it's funny.
00:53:34.120I said I spoke briefly at the RFK event and I said, there's a saying when you've got nothing left to lose, you're free and you're powerful.
00:53:41.020And that's true. And people who have been fired because they didn't take the vaccine, for example, they're, you know, terrible things have happened to them, but they're liberated and they can speak truthfully.
00:53:50.400But in a way, RFK Jr., he has a lot to lose, his position on the constellation of the left.
00:53:57.860And yet he has dissented. Like I think Noam Chomsky, it's the crazy thing about Noam Chomsky, and I'll end on this note, is that he is supposed to be the ultimate dissenter, the ultimate contrarian, the ultimate objector, the refusenik.
00:54:14.840And yet he's in league with the big tech, the big government, the big media, the United Nations, the global government, the Bill Gates of the world.
00:54:23.960RFK Jr., who comes from American royalty, you know, the Kennedy family, who's part of the establishment, even if he's on the left wing of it.
00:54:31.580He's the one who's acting as the dissenter at great personal cost, I might add.
00:54:36.880We've certainly seen a lot of character of people revealed. Last word to you, Mark.
00:54:41.280You're absolutely right. RFK Jr.'s wife, Cheryl Hines, who's a Hollywood actress, she's on the Curb Your Enthusiasm with Larry David and a lot of other movies.
00:54:48.820So Robert F. K. Jr. is a great personal risk. The problem with someone now like Noam Chomsky, all his anti-Trump rhetoric, his promotion, he's like he would fit in perfectly on MSNBC.
00:54:59.200There's nothing controversial about Noam Chomsky anymore. And many of his old supporters on the left now acknowledge it.
00:55:06.680Interesting stuff. Well, listen, great to see you again, Mark. Thanks for joining us.
00:55:09.900And we'll keep watching ClimateDepot.com for all the news.
00:55:12.760Thank you. All right. Stay with us. More ahead.
00:55:18.820Hey, welcome back. Liberate the Forks says, you forgot about Prince Edward Island.
00:55:32.300They extended mask mandates until April 31st. Well, thank you for that. I'm sorry I didn't know that.
00:55:37.480I didn't mean to leave PEI out. Of course, Quebec has extended it, too.
00:55:43.420And New York City, the way they're going after the toddlers is the craziest thing ever.
00:55:46.920But thank you for reminding me of that. I'm sorry I didn't know that.
00:55:50.740Someone with the nickname Everything is Fine says, considering it's New York City, masks are the least of their worries.
00:55:58.080Well, I guess you could say that there's a lot of problems in that city.
00:56:01.200In fact, that city had the highest net out-migration in America last year.
00:56:07.080Florida had half a million people move into it from other U.S. states.
00:56:13.060It's actually more than the number of people who moved to Canada last year.
00:56:16.720Half a million net in-migration to Florida.
00:56:19.460New York City itself, a quarter million net out-migration.
00:56:23.060New York City, the most amazing city in the world by most measures.