How many people watch The Rebel？ How many Liberals？ You might be surprised...
Episode Stats
Words per Minute
170.28708
Summary
The CBC publishes a fake poll as political propaganda and then covers its tracks. Where are all the fact checkers now? I ll tell you where they are: in fact checking other people's facts, not their own.
Transcript
00:00:00.000
Hello, my Rebels. Today, I take you through two fake news polls.
00:00:04.980
Maybe you caught them, but I wonder if you did, because the usual fact-check media critics,
00:00:09.460
well, they're silent because the fake news came from the left.
00:00:13.580
I hope you enjoyed today's podcast. Before I get out of the way, can you do me a favor
00:00:16.580
and become a premium subscriber? It's eight bucks a month. It's not going to kill you,
00:00:20.480
but it might help us grow and survive and be strong.
00:00:24.940
A premium subscriber gets the video form of this podcast.
00:00:28.000
Just go to the rebel.media slash shows. Eight bucks or 80 bucks for the year.
00:00:32.300
That's a discount. Or type in podcast as your coupon code to get an even bigger discount.
00:00:36.760
But we don't want you to have too big a discount because we still need your help.
00:00:40.100
Besides this show, you get Sheila Gunn-Reed's show and David Menzies' show.
00:00:43.100
I think it's worth it. All right. Go to the rebel.media slash shows.
00:00:51.960
Tonight, the CBC publishes a fake news poll as political propaganda
00:01:01.680
It's August 21st, and this is The Ezra LeVant Show.
00:01:06.460
Why should others go to jail when you're a biggest carbon consumer I know?
00:01:10.240
There's 8,500 customers here, and you won't give them an answer.
00:01:13.960
The only thing I have to say to the government about why I publish it
00:01:28.480
Huge factual error, clear attempt to interfere with an election.
00:01:36.980
the sort of things they accuse others of doing.
00:01:41.820
By the way, they make this habit of checking other people's facts.
00:01:48.540
It's a sly move, this whole fact-check business,
00:01:53.600
not a player in the ongoing game of political persuasion and manipulation.
00:01:58.380
Imagine the chutzpah of a government journalist
00:02:00.800
at the CBC state broadcaster setting himself up
00:02:10.880
Andrew Scheer torques study in claim about the new NAFTA deal
00:02:16.140
Conservative leader's interpretation not accurate, says economist.
00:02:21.820
Why Andrew Scheer's climate plan won't hit Canada's Paris targets
00:02:28.680
Maxime Bernier's false claim about Canada's subsidized immigrants
00:02:33.640
Yeah, I'm starting to see a trend here by Fact Check.
00:02:36.780
The CBC really means liberal war room talking points
00:02:40.160
going out and discrediting the enemies of Justin Trudeau
00:02:43.020
by, I don't know, trying to dig up some economist somewhere
00:02:47.340
who disagrees with a conservative and calling that a Fact Check.
00:02:53.900
That's being a player in the game while pretending you're a referee.
00:02:58.060
I'll tell you about the CBC's Fact Checking error in a moment.
00:03:00.900
But seriously, I mean, isn't every journalist a Fact Checker?
00:03:03.720
I mean, I check my facts, and I try to show you that by putting on the screen
00:03:12.400
I just showed you three pictures of the Fact Check on the CBC's website,
00:03:19.980
Sometimes I just show you a headline, sometimes a chart,
00:03:22.220
sometimes a video clip of someone saying something or showing something.
00:03:26.560
As you talk, you can provide little factual proof points online.
00:03:33.820
You have to take their word for it that they quoted someone accurately.
00:03:36.740
Of course, they can show pictures in a newspaper.
00:03:38.640
My point is, what is a journalist who says they're a Fact Checker?
00:03:45.140
I mean, half of the journalism I do is checking the facts on someone else.
00:03:48.840
Justin Trudeau say, I often check the facts on leftist media like the CBC say.
00:03:54.320
And don't we sometimes disagree on which facts are facts?
00:03:58.980
I mean, the liberals say the conservatives have their facts wrong and vice versa.
00:04:02.260
And in the end, we need an election to sort it all out.
00:04:04.840
As in, there's no definitive answer sometimes because what's so often being argued about is opinion and interpretation.
00:04:12.320
So if the CBC fact checks me, they're probably just giving their opinion on my politics and vice versa.
00:04:22.620
So let's fact check the government journalists at Trudeau's CBC state broadcaster just for a second.
00:04:28.280
The ones who have so much to say about conservatives.
00:04:31.260
Oh, and they love calling conservative media fake news, don't they?
00:04:38.220
NDP and PCs in dead heat heading into Manitoba election, polls suggest.
00:04:48.680
An incumbent conservative premier on the ropes and the rump NDP.
00:04:55.000
A party led by a leader who is, shall we say, a bit physical when it comes to the lady folk.
00:05:01.440
Yeah, call me a skeptic that they're tied in the polls.
00:05:04.300
Let me quote, despite leading in the polls since their election in 2016,
00:05:10.220
Brian Pallister's progressive conservatives have fallen into a dead heat with Wab Canoes' NDP
00:05:15.460
right at the beginning of the 2019 provincial election, reads the report out Friday from polling firm Converso.
00:05:30.320
Poll placed PCs at 31%, NDP at 30%, liberals at 11%,
00:05:51.320
Fake news by a pollster that, well, no one seems to have heard of before.
00:05:55.860
Even Gallup polls had their first poll once, they were new once, but to run a screaming headline
00:06:03.740
that the Tories were doomed and the NDP were in the lead by Converso, a polling company no
00:06:12.040
Some people might be skeptical, might think that's fake news, because it was.
00:06:19.360
The very next day, Converso, the pollster in question, they admitted that they got their
00:06:28.360
And so the CBC sheepishly changed their headline.
00:06:34.100
The day later, pollster says there's a data issue with survey suggesting Manitoba PCs and
00:06:45.900
The original one was what I showed you in the tweet.
00:06:48.220
NDP and PCs in dead heat heading into Manitoba election, poll suggests.
00:06:55.540
Yeah, that's the CBC state broadcaster trying to cover their tracks, trying to hide the fact
00:07:02.020
They absolutely repeated and magnified the fake poll at a time of maximum impact.
00:07:07.980
And now they're saying, oh, yeah, you know that pollster guy?
00:07:13.820
I'm sure there was a data issue, but there's a fake news issue, and that's the state broadcaster's
00:07:20.320
They so lusted for this story, they didn't bother to check it because it was too good to
00:07:25.680
They just really want to believe that the NDP is about to come back and the Manitobans
00:07:33.480
I mean, I don't mean to be a stickler, but where's Jonathan Gatehouse's fact check?
00:07:38.780
Where are the self-righteous media critics and fact checkers?
00:07:48.220
You know, there are some satirical sites on the internet, good for some laughs.
00:07:52.140
The other day, I showed you a quick clip from The Onion.
00:07:54.880
Well, there's a slightly Christian satirical site called the Babylon Bee.
00:08:13.720
Well, Snopes, the left-wing fact-checker, hates the fact that people click on these funny
00:08:20.020
And so Snopes have literally taken to fact-checking the Babylon Bee.
00:08:28.760
Stories published by the Babylon Bee are amongst the most shared factually inaccurate content
00:08:44.160
We wish there were some kind of organized armed force that could fight back against Antifa.
00:08:48.840
Now, you know that's a joke, but it's funny because real life is absurd as a joke these
00:08:57.200
I don't think anyone actually believed the Portland Police said that, but Snopes is literally
00:09:04.800
Hey, I just flew in from Toronto, and boy, are my arms tired.
00:09:10.600
Actually, no, you didn't fly in with your own arms.
00:09:19.840
Snopes rates Babylon Bee, world's most accurate news source.
00:09:25.620
It's a joke, but I'm guessing Snopes fact-checked that one, too.
00:09:29.300
Hey, guys, maybe we can get Snopes to fact-check Star Wars or the Superman movies, because those
00:09:38.820
I suppose it's easier than, say, fact-checking whether or not, oh, I don't know, Jeffrey
00:09:42.180
Epstein, that pedophile financier, actually killed himself in prison.
00:09:45.760
You know, something that we can actually use a good fact-check on.
00:09:50.040
So the CBC ran a fake news poll, and when it was revealed to be fake news, they faked
00:09:56.000
their own headline by pretending it was different.
00:09:58.300
They changed it to pretend they knew all along it was fake, and they blamed the pollster.
00:10:02.520
And yes, he deserved blame for the poll, but they were the fools who ran with it because
00:10:10.360
But look at this, right after the bombshell last week about Justin Trudeau being convicted
00:10:14.200
of breaking the Conflict of Interest Act for pressuring the Attorney General to drop criminal
00:10:18.700
charges against his friends at SNC-Lavalin, like, that's a huge story.
00:10:24.340
Look at the poll that CTV released about corruption of Ontario Conservative Premier Doug Ford.
00:10:33.280
Exclusive new poll suggests voters haven't forgotten about patronage appointment scandal.
00:10:40.040
The poll given exclusively to CTV News Toronto shows 56% of respondents perceive the Doug
00:10:48.260
The poll was given exclusively to CTV, so they didn't actually commission it.
00:10:54.900
Someone gave it to them like the CBC ran with that Manitoba poll.
00:10:58.620
Also curiously timed, all these are timed to change the subject away from Trudeau breaking
00:11:05.660
Who is behind this weird poll that was given to the CTV?
00:11:14.720
The Corbett Communications Survey, given exclusively to CTV News Toronto, shows 56% of respondents
00:11:20.520
perceive the Doug Ford government as being corrupt, while 62% believe too many cronies of the Premier
00:11:27.620
Now, first of all, don't you wish someone might have actually asked these questions about Justin
00:11:31.200
Trudeau the day after he was convicted of breaking the law for corruption?
00:11:39.500
Did Trudeau really do nothing wrong as he continues to claim?
00:11:55.600
It was Corbett Communications run by this guy, John Corbett.
00:12:01.040
Yeah, John, those are the things you put in your diary.
00:12:27.360
If you are professional, you don't say crazy things like that.
00:12:35.280
Non-biased, professional, independent, just the fact.
00:12:40.200
Not just crazy in a neutral way, like, I don't know, you believe in aliens.
00:12:50.740
You're a little bit mad, I think, which is exactly the one thing the public expects you
00:12:58.520
But, hey, just keep pretending that the fake news is on the right or on the independent side
00:13:12.420
It's almost like Justin Trudeau is giving hundreds of millions of dollars to the media bailout
00:13:16.320
to rent these journalists and their pollsters during the election.
00:13:22.960
Last year, the Netanyahu government refused entry to American citizen Catherine Frank and
00:13:46.020
my friend, Vince Warren, who had arrived on a human rights mission.
00:13:51.580
All of these actions do nothing to bring us closer to peace.
00:14:01.320
They maintain the occupation and prevent a solution to the conflict.
00:14:07.140
Fortunately, we in the United States have a constructive role to play.
00:14:12.120
We give Israel more than $3 million in aid every year.
00:14:19.060
This is predicated on there being an important ally in the region and the only democracy in
00:14:29.900
But denying visit to duly elected members of Congress is not consistent with being an ally
00:14:37.400
and denying millions of people freedom of movement or expression or self-determination is not
00:14:50.740
Somali-born Congresswoman Ilhan Omar does not believe that Israel is an ally or a democracy.
00:14:57.480
And she believes that its treatment of Palestinians is an occupation.
00:15:02.900
I present to you the face of the Democratic Party in the United States, quite recognizable
00:15:08.560
to those of us who have observed parties of the left in Europe be colonized by a combination
00:15:18.620
You see this everywhere, especially in Jeremy Corbyn's Labour Party.
00:15:22.760
Joining us now to talk about this unfortunate change in the U.S. Democratic Party.
00:15:26.700
is our friend Joel Pollack, senior editor-at-large at Breitbart.com.
00:15:33.400
You know, in some ways, the kookiest politician in the room, it's like a reality TV show.
00:15:39.860
Whoever says the kookiest thing often gets the camera time.
00:15:43.820
You see that with outbursts in the Republican Party, too.
00:15:47.040
The difference is when there's an outburst in the Republican Party, rogue candidates saying
00:15:51.740
embarrassing things, the party rushes to condemn them.
00:16:00.380
I think of Steve King, who's made a few comments that can be interpreted in different ways.
00:16:13.820
Yeah, they've made her a star because she is a useful symbol to Democrats of a number
00:16:23.100
She's the first Muslim woman in Congress, along with Rashida Tlaib.
00:16:32.640
So the ability of her campaign, I suppose, in 2018 and now her congressional office to
00:16:41.340
play that identity politics game has, in a sense, shielded her from criticism.
00:16:46.720
You'll note, for example, that when she and Rashida Tlaib complained that they were excluded
00:16:52.340
from entering Israel, they keep mentioning that they are Muslim women, as if that were
00:17:00.520
Israel has let something like 70,000 Muslims into the country to visit or whatever in recent
00:17:07.580
I forget if it was months or years, whatever it was, but there was an interesting figure
00:17:11.380
on the Internet from a reliable source, a guy named Avi Meyer, who's worked in the Israeli
00:17:15.780
government before and now works for the American Jewish Committee.
00:17:20.140
But there's no doubt that Israel allows Muslims into the country.
00:17:23.020
Israel is essentially almost 20 percent Muslim.
00:17:26.840
What she's doing is distracting from the fact that it's her policy, her support for boycotting
00:17:33.120
And I think the key fact about that is not only that Ilhan Omar supports a boycott of Israel,
00:17:37.860
the BDS movement, but that she ran explicitly in 2018 on a promise not to support BDS, on
00:17:47.200
You can even Google video of her telling her constituents, her would-be constituents, that
00:17:52.400
she finds boycotts to be counterproductive and would not be conducive to peace.
00:18:01.260
And once she was elected, she decided to throw her office behind this idea of a boycott, even
00:18:07.100
though it is really not even a five percent position among the American electorate or
00:18:13.460
among congressional representatives of the country as a whole.
00:18:16.900
Boycotting Israel basically was soundly defeated in the House of Representatives, the Democratic
00:18:21.000
controlled House of Representatives, by something like 398 to 17.
00:18:25.680
So she actually represents a very, very marginal minority.
00:18:29.680
So to protect the, if I can say this, the idiocy of her point of view, she hides behind identity
00:18:36.640
Now, I think that's a good critique of Ilhan Omar.
00:18:39.520
For example, with Rashida Tlaib, it's worth noting that when she said, look, can you give
00:18:43.860
me a humanitarian exemption to go visit my grandma?
00:18:49.560
And then she said, well, I'm not going to accept that because I don't want to appear
00:18:57.340
She preferred the ability to lecture Israel than to visit her own grandma.
00:19:01.740
Now, let's put aside those facts of the particulars of what they're arguing.
00:19:07.260
To me, I mean, the Democratic Party was historically the party of the Jewish vote, just like the
00:19:14.800
And I would even say the Labour Party to a large degree in the UK.
00:19:20.000
And in fact, to this day, many high ranking elected officials and then Democrats, party
00:19:30.800
I mean, I don't know what the ethnic breakdown is, but it wouldn't shock me if a quarter of
00:19:36.060
all the donations in the Democratic Party were Jewish donations.
00:19:40.720
The biggest donors, for sure, Haim Saban, even George Soros, though he wouldn't call himself
00:19:50.320
Why hasn't the residual Jewish membership of the party, the Jewish membership that might
00:19:56.880
have properly felt at home 10, 15 years ago, why haven't they said a word about this?
00:20:02.740
In the UK, Joel, you slowly see Jews in the Corbyn Labour Party saying, I've had enough.
00:20:11.000
Where are the American Jews and the Democrats, Democratic Party saying, I'm sorry, we've got
00:20:19.020
Well, I think what's interesting is that if you talk to some of the Jewish people who remain
00:20:24.960
on the left, I actually had the opportunity to meet a young Jewish woman from the Labour
00:20:28.360
Party in the UK when I was in Poland earlier this year, and she had not joined the Jewish
00:20:34.880
members of the Labour Party who had left, even though she was deeply critical of Corbyn
00:20:38.520
and admitted that many of his policies were, in effect, anti-Semitic.
00:20:45.660
And I think there is a mental block for people who have become conditioned to seeing conservatives
00:20:52.200
as the enemy and conditioned to seeing Labour Party members or Democratic Party members or
00:20:58.740
the left in general as being on the right side of history, being on the side of the underdog,
00:21:03.060
being on the side of the poor, the weak, the oppressed, essentially being morally correct.
00:21:06.920
It's very difficult for them to make a shift even when the leadership of that party is against
00:21:14.080
them, is profoundly anti-Semitic and or at least tolerant of anti-Semitism.
00:21:18.900
And I think also for donors to the Democratic Party, yes, you also have to understand that
00:21:25.020
the nature of ethnic politics, certainly from a Jewish perspective, has changed over the
00:21:31.340
It used to be that the Democratic Party was almost like a mutual agreement between various
00:21:36.640
different ethnic groups to pursue each other's interests, a kind of intersectional agreement,
00:21:42.280
if you want to put it that way, where, you know, Jewish representatives would essentially
00:21:47.060
convince African-Americans to be pro-Israel and African-Americans would convince Jewish
00:21:51.280
representatives just to support affirmative action and spending in cities on social programs
00:21:55.880
and things like that, which they wanted to do anyway.
00:21:57.380
But there was almost a support for each other's causes.
00:22:01.100
And the rise of the anti-Israel movement and the pro-Palestinian cause and the emergence of
00:22:06.220
Muslim Americans and the Muslim vote as its own unique constituency has really complicated
00:22:11.300
that because it's very hard to fit those two groups together, pro-Israel Jews and anti-Israel
00:22:19.340
And that also dovetails with the emergence of some radical elements in the black community
00:22:24.500
as well in the late 60s, early 70s, which did complicate relations with the Jewish community,
00:22:29.100
talking about not just groups like Louis Farrakhan's Nation of Islam, but others like it, which took
00:22:34.120
a third world perspective and adopted the line that many of the newly decolonized African nations
00:22:40.360
were taking toward Israel, which of course was being pushed by the Soviets, which was
00:22:44.900
So there was always a little bit of tension emerging, but with the arrival of this new
00:22:49.720
community, this new constituency, it became very difficult.
00:22:53.380
And so what many Jews have done, and pardon me while I wave these energy efficient lights
00:22:58.360
back on, you know, they made us install these things, I suppose to save the climate or something,
00:23:04.500
The mentality of many of the supporters of the Democratic Party who come from the Jewish
00:23:12.820
community is not that they're pursuing interests that are of interest or that are central to
00:23:23.120
The new logic is essentially we want to be part of, number one, doing the right thing.
00:23:32.300
And the other is also, and this is very profoundly, deeply rooted, I think, in the Jewish immigrant
00:23:37.120
psyche, but the idea that our success somehow in the West, our new success, because Jews
00:23:43.960
were discriminated against for a long time and excluded and forced to live in ghettos and
00:23:48.280
forbidden from owning land and joining professions and going to university, even in the United States,
00:23:51.820
there were quotas on Jewish attendance at Harvard and things like that.
00:23:54.040
There's a kind of nervousness about Jewish success.
00:23:57.780
There's a nervousness that if we are too visibly successful, then we become a target.
00:24:04.680
And I think that that's a perspective that is broadly shared, even if it's somewhat unconscious
00:24:12.420
And so supporting the underdog, supporting redistribution, supporting causes other than our
00:24:18.320
own is actually seen as almost an insurance policy.
00:24:24.180
And that's why Jews, I think, are one of the few groups that actually seems to regard
00:24:31.300
our own interests as lying in fighting our own interests.
00:24:34.980
In other words, the ultimate act of Jewish moral expression, we're told by Jews on the
00:24:43.020
Someone stood up at a Bernie Sanders town hall I was covering the other day, a Jewish woman
00:24:46.440
who said that she believed the highest moral virtue in Judaism was to oppose Israel.
00:24:51.700
That's not such a strange view to hear anymore on the Jewish left.
00:24:57.180
And it's because the success of Israel makes them nervous.
00:25:05.020
They don't want to be cast as having something others do not.
00:25:08.240
And that puts them on the wrong side of the moral scale that has emerged as the basis of
00:25:15.260
So there's a kind of self-preservation almost that's at work in the minds, I think, of many
00:25:22.100
Meanwhile, of course, they've left the actual interest of the Jewish community far behind.
00:25:26.560
That is to say, the actual continuity of the Jewish community.
00:25:29.700
Many of these Jewish donors to the Democratic Party would think nothing of spending millions
00:25:35.320
of dollars on a super PAC for a Democratic candidate, but would not spend money on Jewish
00:25:40.860
I'm not speaking about all of them, but there are some.
00:25:42.900
They would not spend money on the education necessary to ensure that the next generation
00:25:46.180
of Jewish people knows what Judaism is all about.
00:25:48.780
We don't have very wealthy synagogues and so forth.
00:25:51.620
We don't have sort of centuries-old institutions like the church that will—and even that's not
00:25:57.020
But, you know, we don't have these institutions that stand forever.
00:26:00.980
I mean, synagogues are very vulnerable and often flimsy institutions.
00:26:07.820
The essence of Jewish continuity is essentially education, but education is woefully underfunded
00:26:14.400
And so that's essentially what's happening, is that people are, in their own minds, expressing
00:26:23.940
They're also, in a sense, protecting themselves from being targets for their success, financial,
00:26:29.820
But, meanwhile, neglecting the essence, I think, of what it means to be Jewish.
00:26:32.920
And that's where you have conservative Jews basically saying—I don't mean conservative
00:26:38.020
I mean politically saying, wait a minute, wait a minute.
00:26:40.140
If we're actually talking about the interests of the Jewish community, which are not completely
00:26:44.280
congruent with but overlap with the interests of the state of Israel, we do need to have
00:26:49.180
a strong and secure Israel because it's the final place of refuge for Jews to go if things
00:26:52.760
go badly and because it is our spiritual homeland.
00:26:55.380
We're patriots of the countries in which we live—Canada, the United States, and so on.
00:27:02.800
And we care about the welfare of Jewish people in Israel.
00:27:07.460
Israel is central to our faith, and so we want it to be safe and secure.
00:27:14.380
And I think that is something the conservative Jews basically weigh more heavily than these
00:27:20.300
I think if you had to divide liberal and conservative Jews, it's that liberal Jews believe that the
00:27:24.320
threat to Jewish continuity comes from without, comes from attacks either from the left or
00:27:31.280
And conservative Jews believe that the ultimate challenge is within, that the major threat
00:27:35.180
to Jewish continuity is not so much without, but really is the failure to transmit values
00:27:39.760
from one generation to the next, which is why I think that conservative Jews tend to support
00:27:44.160
Republicans in this country because Republicans share traditional values and also believe in
00:27:51.400
So that's a lot of words for you there, Ezra, but I think that really is what's happening.
00:27:55.940
Yeah, you know, I mean, what you said is very interesting to me because I'm conservative
00:27:59.340
and Jewish, but for our viewers who are not Jewish, I think everything you said there applies
00:28:04.280
to the new vogue on the left of self-hating whites or old stock Canadians, old stock Americans.
00:28:12.260
You know, not a day goes by where you don't see some celebrity say, I'm ashamed to be white.
00:28:22.380
I mean, I think many white supremacists don't even think Jews are technically white.
00:28:27.460
But that same self-loathing that you described in the left-wing Jewish community, I see it
00:28:33.420
with people who are old stock Canadians, old stock Brits, old stock Americans.
00:28:38.160
And by that, I mean typically white, who are ashamed of their success, feel guilty for
00:28:45.520
their success, have been convinced that success must be because they exploited someone else.
00:28:51.680
And they've bought the line of white, in a way, they've bought into this line of white
00:28:56.920
supremacy by saying, yeah, I must have my power because I'm white.
00:29:03.020
I guess what I'm saying is the way you just described self-loathing Jews of the left, I see
00:29:08.140
the same thing in self-loathing non-Jews of the left who feel that to prove their moral
00:29:15.940
worth, they have to undermine any Western tradition or heritage or culture or religion or anything
00:29:23.580
And I think it's a result of too much ease, too much luxury, too much free time, not enough
00:29:32.740
And so we throw things away too casually that actually took an enormous time and effort to
00:29:40.180
I think this indulgence in the idea of white privilege is something you can only do when
00:29:46.620
I mean, I often joke also in a similar fashion that I'd be a socialist if I could afford it.
00:29:52.400
You know, this sort of thinking of redistribution and so forth is of some benefit to people who
00:29:58.520
have enough that they wish to protect by, in a sense, buying off the opposition through
00:30:04.320
But for those who may be white but who are poor, it's of no use whatsoever because you're
00:30:10.780
not benefiting from whatever white privilege exists.
00:30:13.120
And you basically have the same struggle as everybody else does, except you have one strike
00:30:16.740
against you, which is that you cannot benefit from affirmative action.
00:30:19.560
You can't benefit from a presumption that your success indicates success for a broader
00:30:27.320
So to some extent, that mentality is born of comfort.
00:30:29.980
But I also think it's born of a kind of inherent logic in democracy.
00:30:33.860
And this is something that Alexis de Tocqueville warned about 200 years ago when he wrote Democracy
00:30:38.720
in America, which is that with increasing social equality, every small distinction becomes
00:30:46.140
And he foresaw this 200 years ago, that as social conditions become more and more equal,
00:30:52.580
people start to resent what few inequalities do exist.
00:30:55.920
And we live now in an essentially egalitarian society.
00:30:59.240
The difference, of course, is that there are mega wealthy people who have done very well.
00:31:03.460
And they will continue to do well because the best way to make money is to have money.
00:31:11.820
There's not a lot of downward mobility among the super rich.
00:31:14.120
So you are seeing a lot of very wealthy people emerge.
00:31:18.520
But poor people are no longer experiencing poverty as the same sort of phenomenon it was
00:31:25.300
Victor Davis Hanson has written about this during the depths of the recession, going into a
00:31:29.380
community that was impoverished in California and watching people who are technically below
00:31:33.580
the poverty line, put their EBT card, their electronic benefit transfer card, through the credit card
00:31:39.660
reader and taking home consumer goods from the store and things like that, driving pickup trucks.
00:31:44.500
You know, the experience of poverty is different because our system of redistribution is actually
00:31:50.420
And so poverty is not experienced in quite the same way before.
00:31:56.140
The lives of rich and poor are no longer as different, especially in the age of mobile
00:32:01.080
I mean, the homeless people in L.A., and I'm surrounded by them because we have 60,000 of
00:32:04.700
them, homeless people in L.A. have smartphones.
00:32:07.580
That means that essentially the way they're experiencing life is not terribly different.
00:32:17.860
But essentially, there's a narrowing of the gap in terms of how life is experienced.
00:32:22.640
And poor people are experiencing a better quality of life than they once did in being
00:32:27.700
I'm not saying it's easy to be poor, but it's certainly not as difficult as it once
00:32:31.960
And as a result of increasing social equality, small inequalities become intolerable to us.
00:32:37.740
And what's happened is that the new moral calculus politically, as a result of that,
00:32:42.760
is that if you have more, you are inherently under some kind of suspicion.
00:32:50.200
And so white liberals tend to feel very keenly that they are, in a sense, in the wrong.
00:33:03.920
They benefit, in many cases, from being wealthy.
00:33:06.860
And as a result, they have this problem to overcome.
00:33:10.900
There's a great piece about it by a guy named Zach Goldberg, who's a PhD student, who wrote
00:33:15.000
a piece at Tablet Magazine called America's White Saviors.
00:33:18.640
And he writes about how white liberals are the only population group in society that
00:33:23.940
care more about people outside the group than they do about people inside the group.
00:33:27.860
In other words, it's sort of a natural human thing to care about people who are like you
00:33:37.460
It may, in a sense, be a form of self-preservation because there's a realization that if you are
00:33:42.040
perceived as having some kind of privilege, the way to defend yourself from any negative
00:33:47.980
So the act of renunciation is perceived as a form of political and social survival.
00:33:53.300
It's not just goodwill, although for many people it probably feels that way.
00:33:59.520
And I think Jews felt this first because as this moral scale was coming into being, Jews
00:34:06.880
Number one, because we're just a small minority group, most of whose members in the West
00:34:10.260
happen to be white or light-skinned, although Israel, of course, is a country of many colors.
00:34:14.440
But the other reason is that Israel is such a stark success compared to the countries it's
00:34:21.240
And so the illogic of privilege, of success equaling moral suspicion, that was applied to
00:34:29.780
Israel very early on, almost two decades ago, with the start of the Second Intifada.
00:34:34.020
The reason the left almost axiomatically embraces the Palestinian cause and reject Israel, even
00:34:39.180
though Israel is a tiny liberal democracy that upholds everything else the left likes, like
00:34:43.820
gay marriage and transgender rights and that sort of thing.
00:34:46.880
The reason they reject Israel is that Israel is successful in contrast to the other countries
00:34:53.300
When he went to Israel in 2013, he said, it's not fair that the Palestinians don't have
00:34:59.020
The Israel and the Palestinians got a state at the same time from the United Nations.
00:35:02.800
It's just that Israel built their state and the Palestinians didn't.
00:35:05.520
So you might look at that and say, it's completely fair.
00:35:13.220
But what Obama and others on the left do is they look at the outcome and they say, well,
00:35:19.060
That means that those who have have an unfair advantage over those who don't.
00:35:22.960
They don't look at how that advantage was created.
00:35:24.620
Even though it was created justly, they see it as an injustice.
00:35:30.760
Social justice is really just another word for making people absolutely equal in every
00:35:35.040
And so these little distinctions of success and talent and hard work, in a perverse way,
00:35:41.420
they now appear to us as immoral, as the benefits of unjust privilege.
00:35:47.800
And so I think what you're seeing among Jews is also, as you point out, reflected among,
00:35:51.760
as you say, old stock white liberals, people who have who do have some claim to privilege
00:35:57.180
simply by virtue of their longevity in one place.
00:35:59.520
There's nothing really to be ashamed of about that.
00:36:01.260
No individual who can trace their family back two or three hundred years in Canada or the
00:36:07.440
They may have a few extra things to inherit and they may have a heritage and so forth.
00:36:14.280
There's a sense of shame attached to it because it is something they have.
00:36:16.900
Others don't, even though it's just by accident of birth.
00:36:20.160
And the way to to resolve that privilege in their minds is to renounce it.
00:36:25.600
So the way that you basically make your own life easier is to renounce whatever privileges
00:36:33.640
It is a similar process to what's happening in the Jewish community.
00:36:36.260
You're just seeing it much more acutely because Jews as a minority group, even though
00:36:39.820
most are part of the white majority group, feel the pressure particularly keenly.
00:36:45.500
Well, Joel, always an education to talk with you.
00:36:47.960
Thank you so much for giving us so much of your time today.
00:36:54.440
And you've given me too many things to think about.
00:36:59.600
Thanks for being with us and helping guide us through it.
00:37:04.120
There's our friend Joel Pollack, senior editor at large at Breitbart.com.
00:37:09.820
Hey, what do you think about those polls I showed you in CBC and CTV?
00:37:24.060
You know, anyone can be a pollster, I guess, just, you know, these days with online or
00:37:34.000
But the absolute baloney of John Corbett being a crazy conservative derangement syndrome guy
00:37:44.160
You know, I guess anyone can make a mistake, but only the left is so self-righteous and
00:37:51.580
Heal yourself first, fellas, before checking the facts of others.
00:37:57.160
On behalf of all of us here at Rebel World Headquarters, to you at home, good night and