PROOF： “The state of journalism in 2019 is worse than you think”
Episode Stats
Words per Minute
151.46056
Summary
In this episode of The Ezra LeVant Show, host Ezra Levenoran tells the story of a crazy story out of Northwestern University, where a conservative speaker was invited to campus to give a speech, and the left had a problem with it.
Transcript
00:00:00.000
Hey Rebels, today I tell you a story out of Illinois, Northwestern University to be precise.
00:00:06.080
It's a crazy story. It's a fun story. It's an American story, but I think it's a Canadian story too.
00:00:13.260
You'll be the judge of that. Before I go, may I invite you to become a premium member of The Rebel.
00:00:19.620
Go to premium.rebelnews.com. It's eight bucks a month, and you get the video version of this podcast,
00:00:25.920
which I think is great. All right, here's today's show.
00:00:30.000
Tonight, I want to show you the state of journalism in 2019. No, it's worse than you think.
00:00:50.680
It's November 14th, and this is The Ezra LeVant Show.
00:00:55.520
Why should others go to jail when you're a biggest carbon consumer I know?
00:00:59.040
There's 8,500 customers here, and you won't give them an answer.
00:01:03.380
The only thing I have to say to the government about why I'm publishing it is because it's my bloody right to do so.
00:01:14.040
Do you know the name Jeff Sessions? He used to be a U.S. senator, really one of the first to endorse Donald Trump
00:01:25.020
That really helped Trump. It was a sign that someone in the establishment took him seriously,
00:01:31.240
and that someone with strong conservative bona fides believed Trump was a conservative.
00:01:36.600
You have to remember, back in 2015 especially, most Republicans took Trump as if not a joke,
00:01:44.600
just a lighthearted, also-ran, maybe some sort of performance art, something unserious.
00:01:50.860
No one could believe that it could happen, especially in those early days.
00:01:57.180
And people thought maybe he was even un-Republican.
00:02:02.640
But Jeff Sessions, in his early endorsement, was a significant counterpoint to that.
00:02:08.760
And Trump rewarded Sessions by appointing him Attorney General, where he served for 18 months.
00:02:16.720
He took a hard line on some issues, very conservative.
00:02:19.980
For example, Jeff Sessions really opposed so-called sanctuary cities, where local politicians just declare
00:02:26.320
they won't enforce immigration laws, even against violent criminals.
00:02:35.680
And wouldn't you know it, now Sessions is looking to get back into the Alabama Senate.
00:02:45.720
When I left President Trump's cabinet, did I write a tell-all book?
00:03:05.860
Second, the president's doing a great job for America and Alabama.
00:03:13.000
Trump is being mean to Sessions, to use a word.
00:03:15.900
But I thought that was a pretty high-minded response by Sessions.
00:03:21.000
I don't think he's Trump's favorite, but there it is.
00:03:23.840
Anyways, whatever you think of Jeff Sessions, he's a man of consequence.
00:03:28.080
He's former attorney general of his own state, former U.S. attorney.
00:03:32.360
He was a senator in Washington for a decade, then Trump's attorney general.
00:03:37.420
But the Republican Student Club at a university in Illinois called Northwestern University,
00:03:44.200
they thought Sessions was interesting enough to invite to campus to give a speech.
00:03:53.360
Of course, as usual, the left on campus had a freakout.
00:03:57.740
Here are some details about their reaction, as published by the student newspaper called
00:04:04.260
Over 150 students protested the event, some holding signs and others chanting F.U.C.K. Sessions.
00:04:13.540
Protesters also stormed the back entrance to Lutkin and attempted to enter the hall by climbing
00:04:23.900
University police officers followed students into Lutkin, knocking some protesters to the
00:04:30.920
And here's the university's president, Morton Shapiro, as reported in the newspaper.
00:04:38.760
Unlike other colleges, Northwestern University PD prevented the protests from fully disrupting
00:04:48.700
The police force showed tremendous restraint and professionalism to make sure that people
00:04:57.720
I'm not a fan of the former attorney general, but he's not going to get hurt at my campus.
00:05:03.480
Although some universities grant amnesty to student protesters, Shapiro emphasized that
00:05:09.800
He said NU makes the rules of engagement very clear.
00:05:13.200
You can protest, you can't hurt anybody, and you can't shut down speech.
00:05:18.240
And if you do, you're going to face the consequences.
00:05:20.440
I think that's much more enlightened than many other universities where they cave in to the
00:05:26.100
cancelers and the de-platformers and the violent thugs.
00:05:29.040
I sort of like that guy, just based on what I read here.
00:05:33.240
Now, of course, the student government at Northwestern is as awful as you'd imagine.
00:05:38.300
Hardcore left-wing, of course, grievance mongers.
00:05:43.460
ASG introduces resolution following Sessions protests to support students of marginalized
00:05:55.340
In response to student protests against former U.S. Attorney General Jeff Sessions' speech
00:05:59.500
at Northwestern, the Associated Student Government introduced an emergency resolution during its
00:06:06.320
November 6th session to provide students with more time and resources.
00:06:10.980
The resolution, which passed 28 to 2, with two abstention votes, called on the university
00:06:15.960
to reconsider attendance policies for students who hold marginalized identities and may have
00:06:22.440
been impacted by the protests, the legislation states.
00:06:26.100
It also seeks to expand comprehensive counseling and the Center for Awareness, Response, and Education.
00:06:34.000
As in, if you're a minority and Jeff Sessions hurt your feelings, you get special grief counselors and more
00:06:45.320
And I'm up-talking all of those sentences, because I'm sure that's how it was spoken at the university
00:06:51.440
student government, whose graduates will go on to be part of the real student government,
00:06:56.220
real government, grown-up government, soon enough.
00:07:03.140
Um, this is just normal butter popcorn, but I have a secret.
00:07:10.920
I put ground pepper over my popcorn, and it adds a little, like, savory dimension.
00:07:19.200
It just makes, you know, like pop secret, but gourmet.
00:07:23.020
Anyways, so I didn't mention that Northwestern has what is regarded as one of the United States'
00:07:34.080
Which is why they also have a daily student newspaper.
00:07:36.980
So this isn't just a hobby or an extracurricular, this Northwestern, daily Northwestern paper I've
00:07:46.300
Here's one of their student reporters covering Jeff Sessions' speech, or more accurately, covering
00:08:01.440
Protesters tried to rush the room where Sessions was speaking.
00:08:21.080
Okay, here's the report on the protests in the newspaper.
00:08:30.640
So let me read a little bit, because it's a window into what it's like on campuses these
00:08:35.420
And I don't think it's much better up here in Canada.
00:08:37.920
Students on Tuesday protested Northwestern College Republicans' decision to host former
00:08:44.740
Attorney General Jeff Sessions, chanting outside Lutkin Hall before attempting to interrupt
00:08:50.280
Sessions' talk by climbing through open windows and pushing through doors.
00:08:55.000
Around 150 protesters, some holding signs reading, no concessions, no racism, no KKK, no fascist
00:09:02.400
And Sessions is a traitor, gathered outside the lecture hall before Sessions was scheduled
00:09:07.420
to speak at 7 p.m., booing and yelling as attendees entered the building.
00:09:11.680
Sessions' talk, hosted by NUCR, was titled The Real Meaning of the Trump Agenda.
00:09:17.320
Some protesters chanted, hey, hey, JBS, you got us into this mess.
00:09:22.320
And I-C-E-K-K-K, how many kids have you killed today?
00:09:27.380
While others called attendees clowns and urged them to stop disguising their racism as free
00:09:34.520
So they're a bit crazy, or maybe more than a little bit crazy.
00:09:40.600
In fact, I think I mentioned before that Sessions was a prosecutor back in Alabama before he was
00:09:47.440
He's the one who, almost 40 years ago, filed civil rights charges against the KKK for killing
00:09:59.300
So yeah, sort of the opposite of a racist, but that's too much journalism-ing for Northwestern.
00:10:08.000
A few days after Sessions' visit, look at this editorial in the student newspaper, addressing
00:10:20.260
Last week, the Daily was not the paper that Northwestern students deserve.
00:10:27.200
On November 5th, former Attorney General Jeff Sessions spoke on campus at a Northwestern
00:10:33.380
The Daily sent a reporter to cover that talk, and another to cover the students protesting
00:10:37.780
his invitation to campus, along with a photographer.
00:10:40.120
We recognized that we contributed to the harm students experienced, and we wanted to apologize
00:10:52.540
for and address the mistakes that we made that night, along with how we plan to move forward.
00:11:03.960
You ran a story that was pretty much 100% in support of the protesters and against Sessions,
00:11:10.800
One area of our reporting that harmed many students was our photo coverage of the events.
00:11:17.780
Some protesters found the photos posted to reporters' Twitter accounts re-traumatizing
00:11:27.540
On one hand, as the paper of record for Northwestern, we want to ensure students, administrators,
00:11:32.980
and alumni understand the gravity of the events that took place Tuesday night.
00:11:36.600
However, we decided to prioritize the trust and safety of students who were photographed.
00:11:42.360
We feel that covering traumatic events requires a different response than many other stories.
00:11:47.500
While our goal is to document history and spread information, nothing is more important
00:11:51.240
than ensuring that our fellow students feel safe.
00:11:54.460
And in situations like this, that they are benefiting from coverage rather than being
00:12:00.800
We failed to do that last week, and we could not be more sorry.
00:12:05.960
This is the sorriest you could ever be in the whole world.
00:12:10.680
You know, that whole safe spaces thing, that whole triggering thing, I think that was
00:12:14.540
just supposed to be a meme or like a joke or sarcasm.
00:12:25.420
It's why people bring signs to protest and have those rhyming chants.
00:12:37.760
Some students also voiced concern about the methods that daily staffers used to reach out
00:12:44.740
Some of our staff members who were covering the event used Northwestern's directory to
00:12:51.740
obtain phone numbers for students beforehand and texted them to ask if they'd be willing
00:13:03.220
We recognize being contacted like this is an invasion of privacy.
00:13:06.980
And we've spoken with those reporters along with our entire staff about the correct way
00:13:15.660
So don't use phones or is it don't use phone books?
00:13:22.100
So you're saying journalists politely contacting people whose names are in a public phone directory
00:13:30.500
asking nicely in advance if they would like to be interviewed.
00:13:40.140
Now, sometimes the answer to such a journalist inquiry is no or even to say no very rudely.
00:13:53.220
That's an extremely long and boring op-ed by Northwestern, the Daily Northwestern.
00:13:59.700
This is like The Onion or the Babylon Bee or some joke?
00:14:04.360
Unfortunately, the Daily Northwestern, let me read some more.
00:14:07.100
Ultimately, the Daily failed to consider our impact in our reporting surrounding Jeff Sessions.
00:14:13.580
We know we hurt students that night, especially those who identify with marginalized groups.
00:14:20.100
According to the Society of Professional Journalists Code of Ethics,
00:14:23.660
ethical journalism treats sources, subjects, colleagues, and members of the public as human beings deserving of respect.
00:14:31.140
So you're apologizing because by telling people what happened in the world,
00:14:35.940
you have hurt their feelings and they feel disrespected.
00:14:44.580
But if you care about that, you are in the wrong profession.
00:14:47.440
You should be in the bubble wrap business or the noise-canceling earphones business or,
00:14:53.220
I don't know, social work or vacation getaways or something where people can avoid bad things.
00:15:01.100
Except that this is journalism by student journalists at one of the leading journalism schools in America,
00:15:11.220
And these baby reporters are all about to graduate and go work in real newspapers and radio stations and TV stations
00:15:20.440
which is reason 14 million why you can never trust the mainstream media.
00:15:54.780
which tells you that I'm in London in the United Kingdom.
00:15:57.780
I have just stepped into a vehicle outside the Royal Courts of Justice at which the High Court is located,
00:16:08.380
though with the traffic the way it is in this country, you never know.
00:16:13.060
The reason I was in London is the reason I'm usually in London,
00:16:16.560
which is to cover the latest litigation involving our friend Tommy Robinson.
00:16:21.460
When I was last out here, I was actually in Luton, which is Tommy's hometown,
00:16:27.400
about 45 minutes north of London, an hour north.
00:16:31.420
And that was when the police and prosecution were suing Tommy to ban him from attending any football game in the United Kingdom,
00:16:39.980
or as they call it here, they call it football, what we call in North America, soccer.
00:16:50.100
It was literally the state deciding that Tommy Robinson was the most dangerous person
00:16:57.080
because he goes to those football games, and we better stop that.
00:17:02.320
You got 23,000 jihadis running around this country,
00:17:12.600
But Tommy Robinson going to football games was what they were prosecuting for.
00:17:17.340
That's what I was doing in Luton about a month ago.
00:17:19.760
But a couple of days ago, Tommy Robinson called me up and said,
00:17:23.180
as I've got this civil litigation against me at the high court,
00:17:27.280
it's a defamation case where a young Syrian migrant, who's a student,
00:17:40.360
Sorry, it's a little bit bumpy, so the camera's jiggling around.
00:17:43.300
So Tommy reported on this, as he says he took the other side of the story.
00:17:48.800
And the kid, his name is Jamal, sued Tommy for a defamation.
00:18:07.720
We didn't actually get into the substance of the case.
00:18:23.240
they talked about one of the issues regarding the witnesses for about 10 minutes.
00:18:29.440
the lawyers talked with each other and with the judge about their fees.
00:18:38.000
I'm a former lawyer myself, and of course I've been involved in litigation,
00:18:42.400
both giving and receiving, in North America and even in other countries.
00:18:49.800
But I have never seen a thing like I saw today.
00:19:06.140
There was a proposal to have seven lawyers on this case.
00:19:10.660
And the lawyers were talking with each other and with a judge called the Master
00:19:26.520
they really weren't the subject of the conversation today.
00:19:30.060
And it was about the lawyers making sure they got well paid.
00:19:37.960
So we were all in this little office of this kind of a judge called a Master.
00:19:48.920
And the senior lawyers were right up against the desk across from the judge.
00:19:52.840
And then there was another row of three more lawyers and Tommy.
00:19:58.380
And then there was me, one other journalist from an alt-left news agency called Press Association,
00:20:12.740
And for 90 minutes, the lawyers said, well, I want to get paid for this.
00:20:25.600
And it was really three lawyers talking about seven lawyers getting paid.
00:20:30.320
And when I say three lawyers, I am including the Master,
00:20:33.500
because, of course, she's a former lawyer, is a lawyer.
00:20:38.940
And the figures they were coming up with were so staggeringly large.
00:20:43.680
Like I say, I've been involved in litigation in various jurisdictions.
00:20:49.000
But if I, and I'm just, there were so many numbers thrown out.
00:20:52.640
But the final number that the Master approved for the plaintiffs,
00:21:02.500
I converted it immediately to Canadian dollars,
00:21:17.900
which is twitter.com slash Ezra Levant for the exactitudes.
00:21:20.820
So more than half a million for the plaintiff's lawyers,
00:21:26.560
if this thing goes all the way, and if they win.
00:21:29.900
I can assure you, although I shouldn't say that now,
00:21:33.040
because this is making me question what I thought I knew about the British legal system,
00:21:37.920
that Jamal will not get that amount of money if he wins.
00:21:46.800
and there was a suggestion that there ought to be seven lawyers.
00:21:57.400
What they, the barrister, the one who argues in the court,
00:22:01.100
and the solicitor is the one who does the groundwork.
00:22:03.540
In Canada and the United States, there is no distinction.
00:22:10.040
I can see now why they have that split profession.
00:22:19.340
And listen, I'm sure all the lawyers in the room were outstanding lawyers.
00:22:22.560
But I have just never in my life seen such insane bills on both sides.
00:22:29.020
And I've never seen the money being sorted out as the first issue.
00:22:38.800
I mean, in Canada, which I'm most familiar with,
00:22:47.660
We won a little bit for this, and we won a little bit for that.
00:22:49.600
And typically, even the winning side gets just a fraction of what they spent.
00:22:54.220
Unless the behavior by the other side was so egregious,
00:23:01.120
But here, the amount of money they were getting approved in advance
00:23:12.160
And the fact that the lawyers were all discussing this
00:23:20.540
they weren't pleading Jamal's case or Tommy's case.
00:23:28.020
I have to tell you, I'm slightly demoralized by the whole thing
00:23:35.460
And I guess that goes to what this lawsuit's really about.
00:23:41.280
This defamation case is not about a young Syrian migrant
00:23:46.700
I don't believe that's what this case is about.
00:23:48.760
I believe it's about throwing anything at Tommy
00:23:53.780
I mean, Tommy's not a threat to the football games either,
00:23:57.840
They'll throw literally anything they can at him.
00:24:07.800
So it was about just slightly less than a two-hour hearing today.
00:24:11.760
There was a 10 or 15-minute break where the master went through things.
00:24:15.540
The final result was her coming up with those dollar figures.
00:24:22.260
But like I say, we didn't even get into any of the substance.
00:24:29.940
which is he doesn't want to turn over the identity of his witnesses
00:24:33.580
to the plaintiffs because he's worried they'll be abused, threatened, etc.
00:24:37.340
So Tommy told me, and I think this video should be up at TommyTrial.com,
00:24:50.820
and he said he's got students ready to testify,
00:24:59.900
He says he's got internal records from the school
00:25:03.140
that all show that this kid was indeed a bully.
00:25:19.220
For maybe 10 minutes, they talked about the fact that,
00:25:21.900
therefore, Tommy wants his witnesses to be kept confidential
00:25:28.880
The judge will obviously be able to know who they are, etc.
00:25:31.140
But he wants them kept confidential from the public
00:25:36.980
And the reason for that we didn't get into today,
00:25:39.300
but I know why, having talked to Tommy and seen his videos and whatnot,
00:25:44.900
the lawyers involved sent an insane Antifa street thug
00:25:52.480
and they live-streamed it, thus revealing his home location.
00:26:03.240
The law firm, instead of sending what's called a process server
00:26:06.220
or a private detective or even a courier or a messenger
00:26:15.640
You can see it on my other video at TommyTrial.com.
00:26:23.140
and live-streamed the visit to Tommy's confidential home location.
00:26:34.040
to the law firm itself because of their abuse of conduct so far.
00:26:40.460
or the benchers or whatever they call it over here
00:27:17.600
on the same phone as I'm doing this live stream.
00:27:23.780
I won't get into the confidential nature of our discussions,
00:27:27.580
but he obviously agrees that this is the law fair,
00:27:33.900
including the kitchen sink, seeing what'll stick.
00:27:35.860
As I say, there was only one other reporter in the room,
00:27:45.100
They probably wouldn't call themselves extremists.
00:27:51.800
but I've seen their misconduct on Tommy reported,
00:27:57.620
I mean, it was a pretty bland and boring hearing.
00:28:02.680
so I'm not even sure how it could be mischaracterized,
00:28:21.820
I'll strike up another live stream and tell you,
00:28:53.920
and I'm serious, there were five lawyers in the room,
00:29:50.680
and it's only paid by conservatives, by the way.
00:30:21.120
So if you want to help cover the cost of my flight,
00:30:31.400
Altogether, it'll be just under $2,000 a Canadian.
00:30:42.160
That's it for today from the streets of London.
00:30:45.480
on behalf of all of us at Rebel World Headquarters,
00:31:13.440
for causing harm and hurt to people's feelings,
00:31:37.460
on behalf of us here at Rebel World Headquarters,