Regular citizens are fighting back against the City of Ottawa s enormously expensive climate change strategy. I ll show you exactly what they did. I'm Sheila Gunn-Reed, and you're watching The Gunn Show. Did you know that the city of Ottawa has a climate change plan in excess of $50 billion? Did the residents of Ottawa get a say before city council passed that plan? And did they ever get a chance to fight back?
00:07:04.920If people go to ICSC-Canada.com, ICSC-Canada.com, the first button says, Ottawa's Challenge Cities Climate and Energy Plans at Committee Meeting.
00:07:18.900And, you know, we should go through some of them because I think this demonstrates, you know, it's funny.
00:07:25.280I have a friend in British Columbia and he says, I hope Ottawa does go through with their plan because there will be such a catastrophe in Ottawa.
00:07:43.340And I think we've got a pretty critical mass here in Ottawa of people who now realize that the climate change plans are insane.
00:07:51.040OK, I've been giving presentations all over the city for the last couple of years.
00:07:55.200And, you know, practically every week now I get an invitation to go to some group.
00:08:00.060Usually it's a freedom group, you know, because these people are concerned about climate lockdown and things like that.
00:08:05.800But as a consequence, people are reading our report and they're taking chunks out of it and they're starting to grill the actual committee on climate change.
00:08:16.120And so I have here actually the five testimonies that were presented.
00:09:27.000As the seventh coldest capital city in the world, it's irresponsible for Ottawa to only plan for warming when cooling is far more dangerous and some scientists would say more likely.
00:09:38.420It would be like going on a camping trip in an area known to be infested with mosquitoes and black bears and only planning for the mosquitoes.
00:09:47.140Yes, the bugs can drive you crazy, but the black bears can kill you.
00:09:51.320Similarly, heat in Ottawa is not fatal, except for the elderly and other vulnerable citizens.
00:09:58.380And those are people, of course, we should protect.
00:10:00.780But everyone can die when it's minus 30 with no heat.
00:10:06.140Consequently, I ask the committee to direct city staff to incorporate serious preparation for cooling into the climate change master plan.
00:10:14.840I welcome your comments and questions.
00:10:54.180I see that you're also associated with the Heartland Institute, where you're listed as a policy expert.
00:11:02.360The Heartland Institute certainly has a lovely name.
00:11:06.480From what I understand, the Heartland Institute is a U.S.-based conservative think tank that is best known for the work that it does, such as what you do, challenging climate science, but also for the work that it's done in challenging the well-known negative health impacts of smoking.
00:11:25.960Throughout the 1990s and as recently as 2008, the Heartland Institute was working with tobacco company Philip Morris to discredit health risks associated with secondhand smoking.
00:11:39.120And so my first question for you, Mr. Harris, do you know whether or not the Heartland Institute, with whom you're associated, still denies damage done by secondhand smoke?
00:12:09.340I only advise the Heartland Institute on climate and energy.
00:12:12.480I have no involvement with their tobacco issue, and I don't actually know specifically what they say.
00:12:17.420But I used to work for Transport Canada, and as a non-smoker, and at that time a very strong anti-smoker, I actually petitioned the Minister of Transport to stop smoking allowed on long-haul flights because of safety implications.
00:12:31.400It actually shares the smoke throughout the whole cabin, and the pilots therefore have a reduction in visual acuity, which is measurable.
00:12:38.980And we petitioned the Minister to ban smoking on airplanes.
00:12:43.760So to associate me with tobacco is funny because, of course, I am on the other side of the argument.
00:12:50.040Heartland have roughly 150 advisors on many, many topics, and about twice a year they ask me for some input, and I give it to them.
00:12:57.940But they don't pay me, and certainly, you know, their other issues are not related to my work on climate.
00:13:38.780Well, I mean, what he did was a guilt by association logical fallacy.
00:13:43.060I mean, he was just basically trying to say, you can't trust anything this Harris character says because he worked with people who support smoking, you know?
00:13:52.960Now, the next person to speak was Bob Lyman, and that was a long, by the way, the one we just played was by far the longest of them, because I wanted to include his silly question, because it just shows.
00:14:04.880He didn't ask, oh, what should we do to prepare for cooling?
00:14:08.400You know, not a sensible question, which would have been obvious.
00:14:56.020The basic reality here is that reducing emissions in Canada will have essentially zero effect in terms of global temperatures and climate.
00:15:13.300The Ottawa climate plan proposes to spend somewhere between $52 and $57 billion to reduce emissions and to do Ottawa's share, whatever that might be, to contribute to climate change.
00:15:31.140So you have a $52 to $57 billion expenditure, and you have zero environmental benefits.
00:15:39.320That won't pass any kind of a cost-benefit test in any government in the world.
00:15:44.900Except, of course, the Trudeau government.
00:15:49.260No, I guess what he could have said is it won't pass any cost-benefit analysis in any rational government in the world.
00:15:56.200Well, yeah, and I think that's really the crux of the argument.
00:16:00.440Even if you believe that climate change is just lurking out there to get you, how do you justify the expenditure for the literally net benefit of zero?
00:16:25.820It's very much, you know, if you thought we were causing dangerous climate change, it's like you're in an inflatable life raft, and you're puncturing it with a pin, which may cause it to leak out over a period of a year, and your neighbor is using a chainsaw.
00:17:07.940He was a citizen of Ottawa, and he actually, it's interesting, because he, and by the way, all of these, the whole testimonies, each one's about five minutes, is on our webpage, okay?
00:17:16.160If you go right to our homepage, icsc-canada.com, the upper left-hand button, click on it, and you can watch all these testimonies.
00:17:23.200One thing we're going to have on that webpage, by the way, is the Twitter handles of every councillor on the committee.
00:17:30.880And what we're hoping, and this is where, you know, as I said earlier, if we can win in Ottawa, we can win anywhere.
00:29:10.440The Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers is great at being colonized by environmentalists and basically apologizing for the very important, valuable work that they do in the interest of Canadian prosperity, but also human rights and freedom around the world.
00:29:26.540More Canada means more freedom when you are, you know, export, you know, you just don't export energy.
00:29:33.520You export freedom because we're providing jobs and prosperity here and we're offsetting tyrannical sources of energy.
00:29:54.120And the best news actually was that Mark Carney was the keynote speaker at lunch to charge them up.
00:29:59.280It was the most boring speech I think I've ever attended.
00:30:02.000I mean, I thought, great, this is a highlight of the event, you know, put everyone to sleep.
00:30:06.000But regardless, we had people like the Canadian Cement Association, the Canadian Steel Association, you know, these different groups who will be absolutely creamed if we continue along this route.
00:30:17.440But they were up there boasting about, oh, you know, we're reducing greenhouse gases so that we're not causing as much damage as these other countries.
00:30:26.960I mean, they are what the Soviets would have called useful idiots.
00:30:31.140OK, in an attempt to appease the enemy, they admit the enemy's right with respect to the main cause of all this.
00:30:39.440OK, they're not saying, hey, you know, Canada puts out 1.6 percent of world emissions, you know, Ottawa less than 1 percent.
00:30:47.220You know, they don't get into that, let alone the science.
00:30:50.040They accept the science and try to get less damage for their companies.
00:30:54.640You know, so, I mean, I think that's a huge mistake.
00:30:56.700But, you know, Sheila, I got to tell you one thing.
00:30:58.780At the end of this particular committee hearing, the CBC were there with their cameras and everything, and they were interviewing, you know, the climate alarmists.
00:31:07.740So I went up and I said, oh, would you like a different perspective?
00:31:11.800And they said, oh, well, we heard your testimony.
00:33:10.860Yeah, I don't believe the CBC reporters rush anywhere.
00:33:15.120But I can tell you why they don't tell the other side of the story with regard to climate change or even acknowledge that there's another side of the story.
00:33:24.320If you go to the CBC's website, the ombudsman there has made a decision that there is no other side of the story with regard to climate change.
00:33:34.220And so because of that, they will not give equal time to both sides of the debate.
00:33:39.220They won't even acknowledge that there's another side of the debate.
00:33:41.900That's a decision made by management at CBC that they don't even try to hide anymore.
00:36:59.840I mean, these are thousands of references from scientists all over the world publishing in leading peer-reviewed journals who are brave enough to say,
00:38:57.660And, you know, this should be a lesson for other cities and other citizens across the country.
00:39:05.420Calgary, I'm looking at you with your 80 billion dollar plus climate plan.
00:39:10.940Citizens should be turning up their town halls and raising a little hell.
00:39:14.340They can poach exactly these questions and ask these exact questions to their own politicians in cities all across the country, contemplating passing this collective madness onto the taxpayer.
00:39:33.980Because what we'll have on that web page are the Twitter handles and the email addresses of all the councillors on the committee.
00:39:41.060And if they get flooded with emails and tweets that are sent all over the place saying, look, you know, this teacher asked you a really, really good question.
00:39:49.200Will you live the kind of lifestyle for a year that you're telling us we should all live?
00:39:56.080Or, you know, they could ask the question I did.
00:39:58.340Are you going to properly tell the city to investigate the impacts of cooling?
00:40:02.740Because 20 times more people die from cooling than heating.
00:40:06.120You know, so if people start to bombard our councillors, and as I say, it'll be on our website, with these questions, then, yeah, we can have a good chance of killing the climate scare in Ottawa.
00:40:18.200And that will be a great thing to show other cities and other activists.
00:41:12.480Well, and these are the most accessible politicians to you.
00:41:15.100It's going to be kind of hard for you to bend the ear of Justin Trudeau, though getting ragdolled by his security.
00:41:20.600But you can turn up at a council meeting and they can even get to know your face as they've known yours now, Tom Harris.
00:41:25.880And you can, you know, really pin these guys down on their bad ideas.
00:41:30.700Now, you've given out the website a couple of times, but how do people get involved in supporting the work that you do?
00:41:35.480Because despite what Counselor Devine would have the public believe, you're not in the pockets of really anybody, including big oil and big tobacco.
00:41:45.020You guys are just a grassroots organization, a citizens advocacy group.
00:41:50.840So tell us how people can support the work that you do, because you are really up against like big green.
00:43:17.680Yeah, I think we've checked off all the important things that you're doing.
00:43:21.200Tom, thanks so much for coming on the show.
00:43:22.740Thanks so much for your advocacy work.
00:43:25.760And, you know, you're just out there fighting for the taxpayer and fighting for a little bit of sanity to be injected into this conversation.
00:43:52.740Well, friends, we've come to the portion of the show where we invite your viewer feedback.
00:44:00.520I say this every single week, and I realize it's probably getting redundant and possibly annoying to regular viewers.
00:44:05.560But I think it's important to reiterate that, unlike the mainstream media, I actually care about what you think about the work that we do here at Rebel News, for better or for worse.
00:44:14.740In fact, just a couple of days ago, I was at a speaking engagement for Alberta Proud, and somebody came up and talked to me about something that I had said that they didn't like.
00:44:25.500And I'm always happy to address criticisms, comments, story ideas.
00:44:34.240So, of course, I want to hear from you.
00:44:36.240We don't have a sugar daddy named Justin Trudeau reaching into somebody else's pocket to pay us to create work that nobody wants to see except Justin Trudeau himself.
00:44:44.120So, we rely on you, and we care about you, and we appreciate that you do take the time to reach out to us, which is why right now I'll give you my email address.
00:44:55.680Put gun show letters in the subject line so it's easier for me to find because, well, not that I'm lazy, but I do get, like, sometimes it's, like, hundreds of emails a day, depending on what I've said or done on any given day.
00:45:11.860Now, today's letter comes from Bruce Atchison.
00:45:15.260Bruce is a regular viewer of the show and someone who writes in very, very regularly.
00:45:21.200I think he writes in just about after every single show.
00:45:43.260This is on my interview with my friend and colleague, Kian Simone, on our work on the documentary, Church Under Fire, Canada's War on Christianity.
00:45:53.940You can find out more details and support our work at SaveTheChristians.com.
00:45:59.320And there's, like, a perk level for everybody there.
00:46:02.400So, if you give us some money to continue to work on the documentary, we'll give you a little something back, depending on what tier you've donated at.
00:46:09.640So, that you are as invested in the documentary as we are.
00:46:13.120Because truly, like I said, we can't do any of this work without you.
00:46:17.720So, anyways, now that that's out of the way, Bruce writes, what a good show you had tonight.
00:46:21.840And what a shame it is that Christians in North America care so little about their siblings around the world.
00:46:27.560Not only in the Middle East, but also in China, where the Chinese Communist government is enforcing a strict crackdown on Christians and even rewriting the Christian Bible to comport with Communist ideology.
00:46:41.740I keep running smack into the same ignorance wherever I go around here.
00:46:46.640I'm also glad Rebel News is making the Church Under Fire documentary.
00:46:50.080I donated to help make this important video a success.
00:46:52.700Better still, I'm glad the full-length interviews will be available for us donors to watch.
00:46:58.220Yours in Sleepy Radway, Bruce Atchison, and Guramond Delta the Cat.
00:47:06.880And thank you to everybody who has donated at SaveTheChristians.com to help us make the Church Under Fire documentary.
00:47:14.340You will not only get specific perks, but you will get access to special fun behind-the-scenes video updates where you might even see me chasing seagulls in St. John or wearing a Roman soldier costume at Pastor Phil's church in St. John or just outside of St. John.
00:47:34.020So you will see the work as it's progressing and as Kian and I are traveling around the country to gather up these very important stories from the persecuted pastors who stood up to the state in defense of their congregations that the mainstream media and the politicians would love for you to forget.
00:47:53.320Well, everybody, that's the show for tonight.