Telus building 5G networks with China's Huawei despite revelation of “back doors” in their tech
Episode Stats
Words per Minute
150.52693
Summary
TELUS is building a 5G network with China's Huawei, and they don't even know about it. Is China spying on them? Or are they just chummy with the Chinese Communist Party? Or is it something else entirely?
Transcript
00:00:00.000
Hello, my Rebels. Today, I tell you about a bizarre decision by TELUS, the phone and
00:00:06.360
internet company, to go full China, full Huawei, just days after the Wall Street Journal revealed
00:00:13.200
that Huawei built secret backdoor hacking entrances for the company that TELUS wouldn't
00:00:21.200
even know about. Just incredible. I'll take you through it. But before I do, can I invite you to
00:00:24.940
become a premium subscriber? It's eight bucks a month. You get the video version of this podcast.
00:00:39.220
Tonight, days after it's revealed that Huawei has secret backdoors in its communications hardware,
00:00:54.620
TELUS announced they're going to build their 5G network with Huawei. Are they taking secret
00:01:00.260
bribes from China? It's February 14th, and this is the Ezra Levant Show.
00:01:24.120
The Wall Street Journal broke a big story this week. U.S. officials say Huawei can covertly
00:01:35.120
access telecom networks. Trump administration ramps up push for allies to block Chinese
00:01:40.980
company. Yeah, well, that's the thing. I'm not sure if Justin Trudeau's government is really acting like
00:01:45.860
a U.S. ally these days on everything from taking Omar Khadr off the no-fly list to palling around
00:01:52.660
with Iran's terrorist regime to being chummy with China, despite the fact that China is holding two
00:01:58.680
Canadians hostage and has for over a year now. Anyways, back to Huawei. Huawei, according to U.S.
00:02:04.280
officials, has secret backdoors to their technology that allows the company to get into your private
00:02:09.920
communications. Now, most telecommunications companies allow, let's call them front doors,
00:02:17.220
that let law enforcement listen in to communications if they have a search warrant. I guess in the olden
00:02:23.700
days they'd call that a wiretap, and that's normal. If a policeman goes to court and asks for a search
00:02:31.100
warrant from a judge to listen in or copy a criminal's phone calls or emails, and if the judge agrees,
00:02:37.860
the policeman can take that warrant and show it to the phone company and get that info. That's part
00:02:43.400
of our system. There are checks and balances on that. I've described some of them, the judge. But what
00:02:49.080
if the phone company itself uses that same door to snoop around on its own? No police, no judge,
00:02:58.260
just the phone company. That's what U.S. officials told the Wall Street Journal that Huawei can do.
00:03:04.320
Huawei can do its own wiretaps using those law enforcement doors, and they can do it without
00:03:12.420
the phone companies even knowing. Let me quote from the story, Huawei does not disclose this covert
00:03:19.540
access to its local customers or the host nation national security agency. So Huawei builds a country's
00:03:28.240
phone networks. Sells networks to companies like Bell or TELUS or Rogers for internet and cell phones.
00:03:36.420
Police can search by getting a search warrant to tap into those phones, but they have to go through
00:03:41.740
rigorous legal processes. A judge has to say, yeah, makes sense. But Huawei, who built the network,
00:03:50.260
they can secretly just pop in and do the same thing, and no one notices. Oh, and they're controlled by
00:03:55.960
the Communist Party of China, no big deal. Now, Huawei put out a really weird video yesterday,
00:04:01.640
which was a mix of Western-style media, social media chit-chat, and Chinese-style Soviet awkward
00:04:09.760
talking points. I was riveted, like watching a car crash. I watched the whole video. This Huawei
00:04:15.640
spokesman wandering through doors, talking about doors, back doors, front doors, said the Wall Street
00:04:22.080
Journal story could not be true. And he said, it's obviously not true, because if anyone ever
00:04:28.760
discovered that Huawei really was using back doors this way, well, everyone would immediately stop
00:04:35.860
using Huawei gear. Take a listen. Edward Snowden blew the whistle on this type of back door back in 2013
00:04:42.440
when he revealed that the U.S. National Security Agency pressures some companies to install vulnerabilities
00:04:48.520
in their products. These back doors allow the NSA to circumvent security protocols and get access
00:04:54.420
to otherwise private information. So, does Huawei install these? Hell no. Take all that noise that
00:05:04.960
you hear in the news and put it aside for a second. Think about this. The security of our products is our
00:05:11.200
bread and butter. If anyone ever found a malicious back door in our equipment, every single carrier in the
00:05:17.620
world would drop us in a heartbeat. Really? Is that how it would work? If you own a Huawei cell phone,
00:05:26.040
which are sold in Canada. Let's say you spent $500 on a little handphone. Would you really throw it
00:05:31.700
away, $500 worth of phone away? Because you heard something about internet security? Would you really?
00:05:39.780
Or, let me make that a bigger question. If you're a cell phone company like TELUS,
00:05:44.680
that spends billions of dollars on network hardware, would you really throw that away because you
00:05:53.660
discovered China spying? Would you? Or would you more likely be embarrassed and ashamed of it and
00:05:59.960
terrified that you'd lose your company and your customers, that maybe you'd even be tempted to
00:06:06.460
cover it up and hide the fact that China was spying on your customers in your country because
00:06:10.760
your foolish decision to let Huawei build your national phone company is what let the spying
00:06:16.760
happen. And you don't want to lose your customers or lose your money or write off billions of dollars
00:06:21.420
worth of equipment. So is it really true what that dramatic actor says? That if a phone company
00:06:27.840
discovered that China was spying on their customers, that they'd drop Huawei and never use it again?
00:06:32.740
Yeah, no. And I can say this with certainty because it has already happened, obviously.
00:06:39.540
There's a European cell phone company called Vodafone. And would you look at this? Vodafone
00:06:45.900
found hidden backdoors in Huawei equipment while the carrier says the issues found in 2011-2012
00:06:52.720
were resolved at the time the revelation may further damage the reputation of a Chinese powerhouse.
00:06:58.220
got it. The issues were resolved as in no one was fired. No one stopped using Huawei. What were
00:07:06.840
they going to throw out a billion dollars for the hardware and face international embarrassment?
00:07:10.800
Maybe even a class action lawsuit from their customers if they admitted something was wrong?
00:07:14.580
Or would they just have a private, quiet little meeting at the Chinese embassy maybe over a nice
00:07:20.020
meal maybe and just resolve it? That's the thing. As we've learned recently, Huawei
00:07:26.120
bribes Canadians all the time. Now, sometimes the bribes are legal. Like when Huawei gives millions of
00:07:35.740
dollars to the University of British Columbia and we've learned that this was enough to make
00:07:40.940
the university administration take China's side in the hostage crisis. That's all it takes to make
00:07:46.900
a mighty institution like UBC shill for communist China. Just give them a few million bucks.
00:07:53.560
At least we know about that, though. Unlike, say, the Trudeau Foundation, whose foreign funding
00:07:59.760
skyrocketed after Trudeau became prime minister, but they haven't disclosed who paid that money.
00:08:05.100
Gee, I wonder who. This kind of bribery is massive. I mean, China has what? Two, three trillion
00:08:11.320
dollars worth of foreign currency reserves. What's a few million here or there? What's even a few
00:08:15.340
billion to corrupt the West? And look at this news from a Hong Kong newspaper called the South
00:08:21.060
China Morning Post. Prestigious U.S. schools, including Harvard and Yale, under U.S. investigation
00:08:29.100
over foreign funding gifts from China. And look at this. Yale may not have disclosed at least
00:08:35.900
three hundred and seventy five million dollars in contributions, while Harvard may lack appropriate
00:08:40.160
controls to track money it receives. Gee, I wonder if that's on purpose or by accident that they don't
00:08:46.160
track their money. Authorities have requested records of gifts from foreign sources, including Huawei and
00:08:51.880
ZTE, as well as documents related to China's Thousand Talents plan. Let me read a few paragraphs from
00:08:59.360
this story. The U.S. Education Department announced that it has launched an investigation into Harvard and
00:09:05.320
Yale universities on suspicion of failing to report hundreds of millions of dollars in foreign gifts
00:09:09.960
and contracts from China and other countries. The agency said Yale may have failed to report at
00:09:15.620
least three hundred and seventy five million dollars in foreign gifts and contracts, choosing not to
00:09:19.860
report any gifts and contracts over the last four years. Harvard, it added, may lack appropriate
00:09:25.800
institutional controls over foreign money and fail to fully report all foreign gifts and contracts as
00:09:30.360
required by law. This is about transparency, said U.S. Secretary of Education Betsy DeVoe in a statement.
00:09:37.080
Unfortunately, the more we dig, the more we find that too many are underreporting or not reporting at
00:09:41.280
all. We will continue to hold universities and colleges accountable. You know the thing about
00:09:46.840
universities? When was the last time you've been on a university? It's sort of incredible these days.
00:09:52.080
They sell naming rights for everything. It's like a Formula One car driver with all these patches on his
00:09:59.160
outfit. They name buildings. They name rooms in buildings. Entire schools on a university campuses
00:10:07.120
are named and they're named after the generous donors. I mean donors like the recognition and
00:10:13.780
universities like creating a culture of philanthropists outdoing each other, sort of a competition of who
00:10:19.920
can out donate each other, who gets to name the school after them. It's very healthy, I think.
00:10:25.600
Billionaires buying hospital wings to be named after themselves. We all win when that happens,
00:10:32.360
don't we? I like naming things. I love it. And so do universities. So how weird is it? How odd
00:10:41.320
that these donors don't want to be known. They want to be secret and the universities are helping
00:10:47.440
them keep a secret. That's sort of opposite land, isn't it? Why would you keep it a secret?
00:10:53.940
Unless there's something about it that you're shy about, that you're embarrassed about.
00:10:57.900
Like taking Chinese money for reasons you don't really want to have to explain to the public.
00:11:03.340
Which brings us to Telus. Just an awful, awful phone company. They're all terrible, but I think
00:11:11.200
Telus is the worst. First of all, they're so leftist. It's gross. They recently announced some
00:11:16.240
weird plan that they brag. They're a neutral company, but they're saying they're inspired by
00:11:22.820
the Liberal Party of Canada. What? Are you a company or a political party? What are you doing
00:11:29.180
with shareholder money? Well, look, they're heavily regulated by Trudeau's CRTC, so what do you think
00:11:34.240
they are? They've always been anti-oil sands too, which is when they first irritated me. They're super
00:11:39.900
gross when you remember that Telus was born from AGT, Alberta Government Telephones. They actually
00:11:46.340
come from Alberta, but they hate Alberta now, or at least the oil sands. But boy, do they love China!
00:11:52.580
Take a look at this. Canada's Telus to launch 5G network with Huawei soon. CFO. Canadian telecom
00:12:02.120
operator Telescorp will soon begin rolling out its 5G network, and its initial module will be with
00:12:07.300
Huawei Technologies Company limited its equipment, the company's chief financial officer Doug French
00:12:12.420
said on Thursday. It's important for us to launch our network where the time is right,
00:12:17.460
French said in a statement, adding that the company will continue to collaborate with the
00:12:21.420
Canadian government in building the ecosystem. Gee, I wonder what discussions Doug French has had with
00:12:27.300
the Chinese government. I wonder if there are any undisclosed payments to tell us, any secrets like Yale
00:12:33.480
and Harvard have kept, like Vodafone has covered up. Do you trust Telus? I can't trust them as far as I
00:12:42.820
can throw their phones. Look, this is not a right-wing criticism. This is a Canadian criticism. It's a
00:12:48.800
democracy thing. Here, listen to Barack Obama's National Security Advisor if you think this is just a
00:12:54.920
right-wing thing. Here's Susan Rice. It gives the Chinese the ability, if they choose to use it,
00:13:02.540
to access all kinds of information, civilian intelligence, military, that could be very,
00:13:10.280
very compromising. So I, much as I disagree with the Trump administration on a number of things,
00:13:16.080
on this, their concern about Huawei, I believe they're right. As a matter of protection,
00:13:21.260
would the United States have to have a slightly different security relationship with Canada?
00:13:25.220
Yes. And that will throw the Five Eyes collaboration, which is, serves the security
00:13:31.660
interests of every Canadian and every American into jeopardy. It, we just, it, it can't be done.
00:13:39.360
Can't share. I don't see how we can share in the way we have. It's not a joke. It's truly serious.
00:13:45.660
Yeah, Huawei is really just the corporatizing of China's cyber warfare agency. And now TELUS
00:13:54.440
wants to be their Canadian base of operations. If you use TELUS, if you have a TELUS phone or TELUS
00:14:02.480
internet account or cable, time to switch. How do you feel about being a guinea pig for Huawei? How do
00:14:10.740
you feel about Huawei being able to snoop on your calls and emails and what you watch on the internet
00:14:16.300
without anyone even knowing? So who does want this? Well, Trudeau seems to, he admires China's basic
00:14:25.080
There's a level of, of, uh, admiration I actually have for China. Um, because their, you know, basic
00:14:34.620
dictatorship is allowing them, uh, to actually turn their economy around on a dime.
00:14:39.920
Yeah, that's a bad thing. Um, and our U.S. allies say if we go ahead and build our communication
00:14:47.040
networks with Chinese spyware, like TELUS says they're going to do, the U.S. will cut us off as
00:14:53.520
allies in sharing secrets with us. But maybe, maybe Trudeau sort of wants that. Stay with
00:15:15.500
Well, there's one man who I think knows more about the perils, uh, of allowing Huawei into
00:15:23.340
our communications life. And that's our friend, Gordon G. Chang, who joins us now via Skype.
00:15:30.140
Gordon, I have to say the timing of this announcement by TELUS and their CFO. So this
00:15:36.380
is a very senior executive is just awful to me. I mean, it's right after the Wall Street
00:15:43.140
Journal reveals, uh, what U.S. officials called a secret backdoor that Huawei can get into the
00:15:49.120
networks. It's right after the U.S. Department of Education announces investigations into secret
00:15:54.700
payments to Harvard and Yale by China. The timing is awful, but they seem confident. What's going on?
00:16:04.380
I wish I knew, Ezra, because clearly Huawei is a danger. Um, if you allow Huawei into your 5G network,
00:16:12.400
whether it's a core or non-core equipment, um, it is going to be able to take data. And by the way,
00:16:19.700
that distinction between core and non-core probably is meaningless, um, in reality. So I think that,
00:16:26.400
uh, clearly TELUS is making a grave mistake. Remember, Canada is a five eyes partner of the United
00:16:34.360
States. Uh, this is the United States is going to have to reconsider its relationships with Canada.
00:16:40.740
And so I, I think that, uh, Justin Trudeau, your prime minister needs to have a conversation with
00:16:47.100
that company. Gordon, I watched the official response by Huawei to the Wall Street Journal
00:16:53.460
article about the secret backdoor that Huawei can get in. And they had an actor, uh,
00:17:00.620
make about a six minute video. And we played an excerpt of it earlier. The actor said this,
00:17:07.260
he said, Huawei would never spy on our customers because the first time we did that, all our
00:17:14.160
customers would immediately abandon us. And I thought, well, that makes some logical sense. But then I
00:17:19.880
discovered that Vodafone discovered just this sort of backdoor in 2011, 2012. They didn't dump
00:17:30.180
Huawei. They claim they made a few patches, but if you're a company that's invested billions in
00:17:36.020
Huawei infrastructure, you're locked in. You don't want to write it off. You don't want the
00:17:41.980
embarrassment. You don't want a lawsuit from your customers. You have a lot of incentives to paper
00:17:47.640
it over to actually become an apologist for Huawei. I don't think that, uh, PR line by Huawei holds
00:17:55.600
water. I think, um, they have been caught and there's a, there's a lot of moral hazard by companies
00:18:03.580
to go along with it because otherwise they're in trouble too.
00:18:08.400
Yeah. Well, uh, Huawei servers were used by Beijing to surreptitiously download data from the
00:18:15.480
headquarters of the African union in Addis Ababa from 2012 to 2017. Also, um, two points, uh, Ezra,
00:18:24.640
first of all, China's 2017 national intelligence law requires every Chinese entity to spy if demanded.
00:18:32.840
So that's Chinese law. And the second thing is in the communist party's top down system,
00:18:38.280
nobody can have, can refuse a request from the party to do something. So those conditions by Huawei
00:18:45.940
just don't hold water as a matter of law. They are under a compulsion to spy.
00:18:51.360
Yeah. Let me shift gears a little bit because, uh, Huawei is very much on our minds here.
00:18:57.720
It feels imminent. Like Canada has to make a decision soon. That's just how it feels. I don't
00:19:02.260
know how long Trudeau can kick the can down the road, but I'd like to talk about something else.
00:19:07.060
I see you very active on, on Twitter. And I'd like to remind our viewers to follow, uh, Gordon on
00:19:13.200
Twitter at Gordon G Chang. And we'll put that on the screen. Gordon, one of the things you've been
00:19:18.920
talking about a lot is the coronavirus and how China isn't, well, I mean, like any authoritarian
00:19:25.540
regime, we can't trust what they say. It's probably infused with propaganda and, and, you know,
00:19:33.140
scapegoating or avoiding responsibility. It reminds me of Chernobyl in this former Soviet Union. Let me
00:19:41.460
ask you this. Donald Trump has had China on the back foot because of his massive tariffs. China's
00:19:49.220
growth rate has fallen to the lowest in a generation. Economically, I think it was hurting a bit. Now,
00:19:54.960
on top of that, you have this coronavirus, the actual costs of trying to deal with it, the, the worry,
00:20:03.220
the demoralization, foreign countries stepping away, flight bans, quarantines. I wonder if like
00:20:12.540
Chernobyl, this is something that could cause the unraveling of China just through cost and stress
00:20:21.880
and exposing the brittleness of the communist system. I, I watched the mini series on HBO of, of
00:20:28.260
Chernobyl. And it, although it was, you know, a, an interpretation of history, it convinced me how,
00:20:34.900
how big of a shock to the authoritarian system Chernobyl was. Do you think the coronavirus is
00:20:40.540
the same? Well, it could very well be as a matter of fact, in China, you have a number of people saying
00:20:47.500
the same thing. So for instance, right after the coronavirus outbreak, you had Chinese dissidents
00:20:54.400
actually start to write reviews of the HBO show, Chernobyl, and they didn't mention China because
00:21:00.880
they didn't want to be censored. Um, that didn't work of course, because the censors took it down,
00:21:06.280
but people are discussing this. Also, um, the virus outbreak is have, wreaking havoc on the Chinese
00:21:13.280
economy. So we know that oil demand is now down 20% year on year. All sorts of events that were, um,
00:21:21.240
planned are being canceled, including the Canton fair. And that was scheduled for April and shows
00:21:27.500
that Chinese leaders, um, think that this virus is going to continue for quite some time. So that's
00:21:32.960
a real hit exporters. You have all the cancellations that you talked about of the flights. Um, so I think
00:21:39.920
the Chinese economy is in red territory and that's important because the communist party, one of their
00:21:45.880
two main bases of legitimacy is the continual delivery of prosperity. And you now have an
00:21:51.240
economy that is contracting. Yeah. You know, uh, I, I suppose in some ways it's not important how the
00:21:59.220
virus began. If it came from, as some people allege eating, uh, bats, as some have alleged, I understand
00:22:08.660
that Wuhan is also the location of a, uh, high security biological, uh, research center,
00:22:16.520
Ebola, things of that source that many have said is also a military facility for weapons research.
00:22:24.220
I, I suppose it doesn't matter how it started because it started. Um, do you have any thoughts? I mean,
00:22:30.320
I don't, I want to debunk disinformation and conspiracy theories. We don't want to engage in that,
00:22:37.460
but it is interesting because at the end of the day, Chernobyl was caused because the Soviet system,
00:22:43.880
they cut corners because they wanted to save costs and it was the Soviet way and there was no public
00:22:50.240
interest. So at the end of the day, why Chernobyl went wrong actually was, um, an expression of Soviet
00:22:57.980
communism. Do you have any, uh, conclusions about how this started or is it still too sketchy to be firm
00:23:05.760
on that? Yeah, we don't know how this started. And, uh, China is not helping because, uh, it has not
00:23:12.760
allowed, uh, U S CDC personnel, the centers for disease control and prevention. They haven't allowed
00:23:19.120
U S CDC personnel into China and there is a W H O delegation there, but they're not allowed anywhere near
00:23:26.380
the outbreak. So they're sitting, cooling their heels. Um, so Beijing has been doing its best to try
00:23:31.900
to prevent the world from learning how this started. There are a number of theories, how this
00:23:37.260
started. Uh, you mentioned one of them, it just naturally mutated from bats. Other people are
00:23:42.100
saying that there was a release from that, uh, Wuhan Institute of Virology, that P4 lab that you
00:23:47.680
mentioned. Uh, we really don't know the, the Lancet, which is the authoritative British medical journal,
00:23:54.700
ran an article on January 24, which said that, um, most of the initial cases of coronavirus had
00:24:02.840
nothing to do with the wet market that people point the finger at. Right. Well, Ezra, if that's the case,
00:24:08.760
it means that there's got to be another source and that other source, one of those other sources could
00:24:14.200
very well be the lab. And I actually do think it matters how it started because if the Chinese people
00:24:19.840
believe, as some of them do, that this virus was started, um, from the lab, then there's hell to
00:24:27.400
pay for the communist party because there'll be no forgiving the party. People are already white hot
00:24:32.180
over this. This would make it even worse. Yeah. Very interesting. Well, listen, we're always grateful
00:24:37.840
for your time, Gordon. Uh, and China is certainly in the news, uh, for Canada and will be for, uh, a long
00:24:44.260
time to come. It's great to see you. And once again, I'd like to encourage our viewers to follow
00:24:48.260
Gordon in real time, he's constantly showing news articles that I personally would not have
00:24:54.340
otherwise come across. I recommend his Twitter feed at Gordon G Chang. It's an outstanding education.
00:25:01.000
Thank you, my friend. It's good to see you again. Thank you so much, Ezra. All right. Stay with us
00:25:06.660
more ahead on the rebel. Hey, welcome back. What do you think of the fact that
00:25:18.240
Telus is announcing it's going to proceed with Huawei as part of their cell phone company? I think
00:25:24.980
that is so tone deaf. Remember I told you that Pew Research, which is a liberal, but fairly reputable,
00:25:32.400
uh, research and polling company. They surveyed people all around the world for attitudes about
00:25:39.060
China. And did you know that the country in the world that is most hostile to China, number one is
00:25:47.500
Sweden, believe it or not. Number two is Canada. More than the United States, more than Japan or Korea,
00:25:53.740
Canadians have turned against China because China has turned against Canada. China has seized Canadian,
00:25:59.640
uh, hostages. China has abused us with, uh, barriers against our agricultural exports.
00:26:08.240
Canadians hate China, not the Chinese people, not the Chinese ethnicity, but the Chinese
00:26:13.240
communist government. And now with the Wuhan coronavirus, I can only imagine those numbers
00:26:17.680
are worse. Imagine that's the political context. And you're an executive at Telus and you say,
00:26:24.260
now's a good time to announce we're going with Huawei. How can you not beg the question,
00:26:31.100
are you taking a bribe? Oh, this makes me so mad. What do you think? If you agree with me,
00:26:36.220
go to banhuawei.ca. That's our petition on the subject. I would ask you to sign that petition. We've
00:26:44.300
got to get that stuff out of our system. All right, folks, that's the show for today. Until next time,
00:26:49.360
on behalf of all of us here at Rebel World Headquarters, good night and keep fighting for freedom.