A 19-month-old girl refused to wear a face mask on a WestJet flight, and the airline called the police. When the cops didn't do what they were supposed to do, the airline canceled the whole flight.
00:12:59.740What kind of weirdness is going on in their corporate headquarters where they think bullying their own passengers, including a three-year-old kid or a 19-month-year-old?
00:13:45.580But there's a problem with Mulan, which is the story of a Chinese warrior princess.
00:13:52.480The problem is not with the story itself or how it's told, but where it was filmed, and specifically the credits at the end of the movie.
00:14:04.020Most shocking, as you can see here, the Disney film was filmed in the Xinjiang region of China, which is the Uyghur Muslim region, and it gives special thanks to a variety of Chinese propaganda outlets, including the Public Security Bureau in the city of Turpan, or Tulufan, as it's called in China.
00:14:31.420Well, that's where concentration camps for those same Chinese Uyghur Muslims are located.
00:14:41.080Why would Disney film there to begin with, and why would it so submissively give praise and thanks to so many Chinese propaganda outlets and to the secret police there?
00:14:54.420Joining us now to talk about this is our friend Gordon Chang, a senior commentator on the subject, and I must recommend that you follow Gordon every day on Twitter, which I do.
00:15:06.880He's at Gordon G. Chang on Twitter, and he joins us now via Skype.
00:15:11.660Gordon, the movie itself is not the story.
00:15:24.020Yeah, this is horrific, because as you point out, these are the same people who run concentration camps.
00:15:30.900And as a part of China's minority policies toward the Uyghurs and the Kazakhs, it's not just detaining 1.3 million or perhaps as many as 3 million.
00:15:41.260It's also genocidal policies, institutional slavery, officialized rape.
00:15:50.140And for Disney to film in that area was wrong in itself.
00:15:53.960And certainly to thank them publicly just shows complicity with crimes against humanity.
00:16:00.040I read an interesting story about this in The Washington Post by Isaac Stonefish, and he reminds us that Disney got offside with China more than 20 years ago when it produced a film that was sympathetic to the Dalai Lama.
00:16:18.840And that Disney for years tried to apologize, personally apologized to the senior leadership of the Communist Party to win its way back into the heart of the Communist Party, just like the NBA has, just like so many corporations have.
00:16:37.080And he posits that this is Disney's way of saying sorry and thank you and will bend the knee to you and will never be disobedient again.
00:16:45.340It suggests that this flourish of praising the secret police is a purposeful bond with the Chinese Communist Party.
00:17:10.900It's offensive to all of the ideals that Americans hold.
00:17:16.240Now, when you have companies that do business in China, this is going to happen.
00:17:21.200And it really is up to the White House to establish policies that change the incentives for American companies.
00:17:30.980Because as long as they can do business in Xinjiang or what the Uyghurs call East Turkestan, this type of stuff is going to happen.
00:17:39.080I've seen Secretary Pompeo, the U.S. Secretary of State, get tougher and tougher with China, including the most recent thing I saw was criticism and denunciation.
00:17:53.660And I'm not sure if there's actually trade barriers to importing goods made by these slave labor camps.
00:18:01.340But it would be a shot across the bow of all of Hollywood if the Secretary of State or some trade or commerce secretary were to say,
00:18:13.080if you film a film in Xinjiang that is not an investigative journalistic piece, that will be treated as if you use slave labor to make masks.
00:18:29.160The thing is, Disney is almost taunting the United States and saying, we've chosen sides here.
00:18:36.460Not only are we doing business with China, we will do business with the Chinese security apparatus in Xinjiang.
00:18:42.400And this movie, which we hope to make a billion dollars, is a product of that.
00:18:47.400Imagine if this movie were deemed in something.
00:18:50.060Like, I don't believe in censorship and I don't want totalitarian control of the American economy and certainly not the expressive industries like Hollywood.
00:18:57.640But this is a pretty dramatic flick of the nose to Americans and to Secretary Pompeo by the Disney company.
00:19:05.920They're basically saying we're going to do business with the worst people in the worst place.
00:19:13.720So, for instance, even before the Trump administration, the United States had laws against the importation into the U.S. of goods made with forced labor.
00:19:23.320And what the Trump administration has done is it's actually started to enforce those laws because previous administrations often did not.
00:19:32.160Also, the Trump administration has been sanctioning a number of entities in Xinjiang.
00:19:38.080And I think that a few more sanctions are going to be imposed in the not-too-distant future on products coming out of Xinjiang.
00:19:46.820So, we're moving in the right direction.
00:19:51.480But this is, as you point out, controversial because we're talking about the products of intellectual property, which always raise First Amendment and other concerns.
00:20:00.800You know, it's tough because I know my kids are going to want to watch it.
00:20:05.100They don't understand what a Uyghur is.
00:20:16.320And all these popular American cultural industries are lending their reputations to China in a way that we never saw with the Soviet Union and in a way that we don't see with other rogue regimes like North Korea or Iran.
00:20:34.980It's just China, because it's so economically dominant, every Western capitalist rushes to make a deal.
00:20:46.600How do we put some distance between us so they're not actually turning our kids and our sports fans and our moviegoers into passive allies of the Communist Party?
00:21:00.440And I think you start with a number of measures that are already on the books.
00:21:04.900So, for instance, we know that Nike has a three-decade relationship with a South Korean supplier who has a factory in Qingdao in the northeastern part of China where Uyghurs work under forced labor conditions, essentially slaves.
00:21:21.040And these are religious and ethnic and racial minorities.
00:21:26.980So what we need to do is prevent the importation of goods by Nike into the U.S.
00:21:45.140But the way to stop that would be for the president of the United States to use his powers under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act of 1977 to prohibit the NBA from certain activities in China.
00:21:58.860Now, this is going to hurt the NBA, but given what's at stake and you well laid that out, I think that these are steps that we need to take, because obviously we're talking about American values here.
00:22:12.100And we do not need to raise any more children to believe in totalitarianism, slavery, genocide, and all the rest of it.
00:22:21.460And that's exactly what's happening right now.
00:22:23.660Yeah, especially in this current cultural moment where we're talking about the slavery and racism of the past in America, this great national trauma.
00:22:33.540To turn a blind eye to it in communist China is quite something.
00:22:39.180And I know you're so busy you've got to run to do more interviews.
00:22:42.340We're always grateful when you stop by our place.
00:22:45.340One way that a president could push back in a way that doesn't harm the First Amendment and that isn't really meddlesome is to use the bully pulpit.
00:22:54.380But I've seen Trump do that with other cultural industries that get too woke, whether it's NFL or NBA or – I mean, he's not shy to speak out and criticize.
00:23:07.380And maybe if the president – I mean, the trouble with that is America is so polarized, whatever Trump criticizes, some people reflexively defend just to be opposite of Trump.
00:23:17.420But maybe what we need here is not bans or tariffs or, I don't know, some sort of sanctions, but to change the way we talk about made in China, to denormalize it in general.
00:23:33.380And it's so ubiquitous it's tough, but to start to get people to say, oh, made in China, that's not a free place, is it?