Join Ben Shapiro, Andrew Klavan, and The God King, Jeremy Boring, as we discuss everything from my new book, to transgender athletes competing in the Olympics, and if it s good that Juneteenth is now a national holiday.
00:06:17.080What triggered you into writing this book?
00:06:19.000How long did it take for you to write it?
00:06:21.240The thing that got me to write it is I actually, I mean, I felt that my first book was my magnum opus.
00:06:27.660And I felt it was extremely true in a Thucydidean sort of a contribution to Western civilization.
00:06:34.100But I did want to write a real book because, one, I had a few things to say.
00:06:40.660But moreover, I wanted to write a real book with an argument and not just a kind of light book because I don't think I want to do it again.
00:42:32.760I think that one of the major problems in American conservatism is that American conservatism is largely comprised of American Christians.
00:42:39.400American evangelicals have a multi-hundred-year tradition or longer of being obsessed with eschatology, being obsessed with the idea that the world is going to end right away.
00:42:52.040Christ is going to come back, and justice is going to be wrought on the earth.
00:42:56.080Listen, I have no problem with eschatology.
00:42:59.120I have a problem with a fixation on eschatology to the point that it causes you to remove yourself from reality.
00:43:06.780So we're very good at winning elections.
00:43:09.640There are more Democrats than there are Republicans in the country, and yet we disproportionately win presidential elections.
00:43:17.120Well, because every election is the most important election of our lifetime, and the next election doesn't matter at all because Jesus is going to come back,
00:43:25.140because I have a big supply of my patriot food buried in the backyard, and I have 10,000 rounds of .223 ammunition.
00:44:23.320But I think it's inherent in conservatism to a certain degree.
00:44:26.240There's a wonderful Gilbert and Sullivan line, every child that's born alive is either born a little liberal or a little conservatize.
00:44:32.700And I think that there's something to that, because one of the things that a conservative can see is that if you pull the string, the suit might fall apart.
00:44:40.880That any little thing that you do might cause the destruction of everything we have.
00:44:44.340And so they've kind of got a negative point of view, not to mention any names.
00:44:52.400Jeremy and I, this is the nature of our friendship, is that basically we get on the phone, and we're going to have a nice, uplifting conversation.
00:44:57.780How bad do you think it's going to go?
00:44:59.360It's going to be so much worse than that.
00:45:09.860And my family, when we sink into the mud, the last thing you're going to see is my career.
00:45:14.100Although what's ironic about that is that actually of the people on this particular show, the two who kept arguing that there will be future elections are actually the supposed two pessimists in the room.
00:45:23.040But when it comes to the sort of argument over what we can do at the local level, I mean, I'm so heartened by the anti-CRT movement.
00:45:33.120I've been more heartened, actually, I think, than the Tea Party movement.
00:45:35.760The Tea Party movement was a, quote, unquote, small government movement.
00:45:38.560It disbanded basically upon Republicans winning back office in 2010, and the Republicans took the heart right out of it because they kept spending.
00:45:47.880And maybe there was never going to be any fight back or any way to fight back against that because when you're in Congress, your job is to, quote, unquote, get things done as opposed to having a mandate to not get things done, which is really what the mandate was in 2010.
00:45:58.120But what we are seeing right now on the local level with people saying this cannot go any further is a wonderful and fruitful pushback that we are seeing from all sides of the political aisle.
00:46:09.740And I will say I am really optimistic about 2022.
00:46:15.280I'm optimistic that the American people are starting to have enough of this crap because if you look at the polls on things like CRT, they are devastating for the Democrats.
00:46:23.600There's a reason why in the last week alone, the Democrats have decided that suddenly voter ID, which was Jim Crow until the last 27 seconds, is now OK with them.
00:46:32.320Stacey Abrams, I was never against voter ID, assuming, of course, that we are like guppies and have short term memory loss and Raphael Warnock doing the same thing in Georgia.
00:46:40.320When the Democrats are starting to back off of their defund the police nonsense and because Eric Adams, of course, is probably going to win the mayoralty in New York running on the basis that we need stronger law enforcement, weaker law enforcement.
00:46:50.760And you're starting to see Democrats go out there like Maisie Hirono, who's a nut, saying we're not the party of defund the police.
00:46:55.520And Jen Psaki getting up and saying, no, it's the Republicans who are really.
00:46:59.600She said it's the Republicans who are probably the party of defund the police.
00:47:03.100They're starting to reverse on their own key principles because it turns out that once again, because American politics is so reactive, Democrats didn't understand their mandate.
00:47:12.100When Trump lost in 2020, the mandate was don't be that guy.
00:47:15.480But it was not get rid of all of his policies.
00:47:48.200The president of the United States literally said yesterday that you shouldn't own guns or care about owning guns because, after all, if you got in a shooting war with us, we will send our F-15s and nuke you.
00:47:58.500Ben, I've never wanted a gun more than this.
00:48:00.960I've got to stop you right there before we say too many mean things about Joe Biden, because, you know, look, I, my first book, my blank book was endorsed by the then president of the United States, Donald Trump, who reasons to vote for young men.
00:48:13.660It's a great book for your reading enjoyment.
00:48:15.020My new book, Speechless, actually did receive an endorsement from the sitting president of the United States, Joe Biden.
00:49:40.460I am a video gamer, and I love them, and I think that they have been attacked by the woke, and they're trying to force them into wokeness, and they've succeeded to a certain degree.
00:49:51.180But they succeed in all these things because conservatives aren't paying attention.
00:49:54.740Video games are more popular than Hollywood.
00:49:56.820They have been more popular than Hollywood for maybe 10 years.
00:50:27.400And they're fun, and they're artistic when they're done really well.
00:50:29.920When I was in Afghanistan, a sentence I always like to say because I feel like Dr. Watson, when I was in Afghanistan, but I would see the soldiers go out and literally get shot at and then come back and play video games where they got shot at.
00:50:41.340And I think that they were actually, you know, a way of training themselves to the heroic mindset.
00:51:32.060Every time you connect to an unencrypted network at cafes, at hotels, at airports, any hacker on the same network can gain access to your private data, whether it's your passwords, your financial details, Michael Knowles' cell phone number, any of it.
00:52:37.740I'm glad that we focused on a little bit of hope because I do feel, you know, as you point out this line, my priest, Father George Rutler, has this line.
00:52:48.960He says, difference between a Scottish optimist and a Scottish pessimist.
00:52:51.720Scottish optimist says, or Scottish pessimist rather says things can't get any worse.
00:52:55.360Scottish optimist says, oh, yes, they can.
00:52:58.760And I think there actually is great cause for hope.
00:53:02.040One of my fears for 2022 and 2024, I think we could easily retake the House.
00:53:08.140And I think that we could do well in 2024 if the elections are fair.
00:53:11.720And I know we're not allowed to make any comments, you know, out of the big tech to shut us down.
00:53:15.820But I'm just pointing out there's always fraud in elections.
00:53:18.340Both sides are always trying to game the system.
00:53:21.180And Democrats took a huge advantage by pushing widespread mail-in voting in some places in contravention of state constitutions, by pushing ballot harvesting, by pushing motor voter laws.
00:53:30.680They've been doing this for decades, right?
00:53:33.340And I was really pleased to see that the Republicans on Capitol Hill have shut down the biggest election power grab that we have seen from Democrats possibly ever.
00:53:45.420S1 and H.R. won the Corrupt Politicians Act.
00:54:10.220And everyone will always tell you why.
00:54:12.480Well, there was this mitigating circumstance.
00:54:14.440You know, we needed one more vote or we needed one more this.
00:54:17.380At a certain point, though, you have to just realize, oh, no, they do exactly what they want to do.
00:54:25.140They don't want to do anything that changes the fundamental argument in the country.
00:54:30.620So, for example, the most unifying issue among Republicans is the abortion issue, the most important social issue, certainly, of the last half century.
00:54:40.960If the right, if our politicians actually act decisively against abortion, then there's no reason to vote for them anymore.
00:54:51.400So, of course, they stood up and did the right thing where the Corrupt Politicians Act is concerned because they personally have something to lose.
00:54:58.800If they let the Democrats completely remake elections in the country, they might lose their power to tell us they're going to do a bunch of things that they'll never, ever, ever do.
00:55:07.040By the way, notice this issue that you're talking about, abortion.
00:55:09.920This is the one issue that basically all the conservatives can agree on.
00:55:14.160Notice, we've actually made some progress on abortion.
00:56:03.900And that means that they're paddling upstream while the left is riding the rapids right downstream.
00:56:09.880And I think that is a more difficult job.
00:56:12.220So here's a great question from a DailyWire.com subscriber.
00:56:14.780At what point do we stop pointing out the left's hypocrisy?
00:56:17.940They couldn't care less, and the sheep will never acknowledge the hypocrisy anyway.
00:56:22.520Are we doing the wrong thing to point out that they're hypocrites?
00:56:24.540I think it's important because there are a group of people in the middle who are under the fundamental assumption that the left is moral and the right is immoral.
00:56:31.560Because that's the line that the left is consistently pushing.
00:56:34.460So when you point out their hypocrisy, you're basically saying, no, you don't hold any sort of moral high ground, particularly on these principles that you yourself do not hold.
00:56:42.800But the general critique, which is that the right needs to stop whining about the left being hypocritical and instead needs to just fight the left on its own terms, I think that there is certainly some truth to that.
00:56:53.040I think that can go too far, and I'm a little afraid of that because I think that there is a push on the right right now to subvert our own fundamental principles with regard to, for example, liberalism on things like free speech in order to, quote, unquote, fight the left.
00:57:05.340And that does not mean that there aren't things that we can do.
00:57:08.880But I think that very often, on the positive side, the critique of hypocrisy suggests that you shouldn't try to shame people who can't be shamed, which I agree with.
00:57:19.460On the other side, it seems to me that very often people who want to critique the right for pointing out hypocrisy really wants to subvert the fundamental principle, which is that there should be an evenly held standard across both right and left.
00:57:30.840Instead, what they say is, OK, well, if the left is going to be hypocrites about things, then we should do.
00:57:34.080We might as well just club them in the face using equally deplorable tactics.
00:57:37.520Did you notice that I have some problems with them?
00:57:39.120The problem with the hypocrisy argument, though, is it too often accepts the values of the left.
00:57:59.680Where they would say, they would be using the argument, they're constantly saying, well, you know, when you critique anybody who's transgender, it's because you're transphobic.
00:58:05.120And then they would critique Caitlyn Jenner and be like, well, now who's the transphobe?
00:58:19.800The third attempt to overturn Obamacare and the court didn't want to take it.
00:58:22.500And there were some conservatives who came out and said, ha ha, oh, the left is going to be so embarrassed because they said that ACB was going to be the vote against Obamacare.
00:59:04.140And my feeling about that is you should have the right, you should definitely have the right to belong to an all-white club or a club that doesn't let Jews in or a club that doesn't let anyone you want.
01:04:02.780I really have no problem at all with Juneteenth.
01:04:04.660In fact, I like the idea of a national holiday celebrating the greatness of a country that ended slavery through the death of hundreds of thousands of citizens.
01:04:11.560I mean, I think we all agree with that idea.
01:04:13.400The fact that it was immediate, the left was, they had such buyer's remorse over Juneteenth.
01:04:18.740If you watch the media, they got angry that the Republicans had voted for Juneteenth.
01:04:31.280And it's like, well, no, Juneteenth is a reminder of how amazing America is that we sacrifice several hundred thousand of our own people to end an evil institution.
01:04:38.240But I will say that to Michael's point, that is what a good Juneteenth holiday would have been.
01:05:34.800It's a pretty damn good thing that schoolchildren learned that since that is now the chief weapon being used against critical race theory.
01:05:40.760So I think that Juneteenth is going to come out the same way.
01:05:43.460I think what's going to end up happening is I think we're going to win this critical race theory fight, which is a revision of what Juneteenth actually is.
01:05:48.900Juneteenth is a sign of American progress.
01:05:50.700It is the Frederick Douglass fulfillment of the Independence Day pledge.
01:05:53.840Frederick Douglass said, Independence Day doesn't apply to black people.
01:05:56.240He said this before the Civil War because it didn't apply to black people because they were not independent.
01:06:00.480And then he said, but I trust that the Declaration of Independence and Constitution of the United States wrote a promissory note that's going to be cashed.
01:06:05.860And Juneteenth is the cashing of the promissory note.
01:06:08.800Now we can also, so now we actually have, honestly, I like Juneteenth in the sense that now we can, I think with fairness, say to the left, we're celebrating Juneteenth because we celebrate July 4th.
01:06:20.000So why won't you stand for the damned flag now?
01:06:49.000I mean, I truly, that would be terrific.
01:06:50.800But I do fear that there is this broad project that Hannah Nicole Jones put out in the 1619 Project, not so much to pervert facts, though she obviously did that in the thesis.
01:07:01.720But as she said, the point of this is to reframe American history, to put slavery at the center of it.
01:07:07.300And Obama said last year, he said Juneteenth, and maybe he'll lose this fight, but he said Juneteenth is not about a victory.
01:07:15.500Juneteenth is only about the work that is done.
01:07:34.240Here's the day when we're going to celebrate all the crappy things about America.
01:07:37.220So what people are going to take away from Juneteenth is this is the day America.
01:07:42.400But what it will end up being for most children in the United States, I predict, and I don't think this is being too optimistic, I think it's pretty realistic, is it will be,
01:07:55.320That's as much deep as they go into politics.
01:07:57.360And all these people who are like, and it's a reminder of the next hundred years of Reconstruction, people are going to be like, well, then why are we celebrating it?
01:08:04.620See, this is the problem with the left's constant move.
01:08:06.620They're constantly engaging in this self-defeating move, and it's kind of funny to watch.
01:08:09.420They just did it this week with Carl Nassib, the linebacker for the Oakland Raiders or Las Vegas Raiders.
01:08:17.180He's this NFL player, active NFL player, comes out as gay.
01:08:20.700Now, I thought to myself, well, first of all, there was this big hubbub over Michael Sam, you remember, back in 2013.
01:08:24.740So I'm not sure what the deal was there.
01:08:27.180But is it historic or is it not historic?
01:08:29.660Because if it's historic, then you kind of have to say, hey, look how much more tolerant America has become of gay people in the United States that you have professional NFL players who are being celebrated for being gay in the United States in 2021.
01:08:43.560Every time the left declares it's a historic moment, they immediately have to buy it back and go, oh, it's not historic because America, it just sucks even more.
01:09:05.720They celebrate so often, for instance, the Tuskegee Airmen who were heroes of mine because when I was flying planes,
01:09:11.100I just loved all the different stories about fighter pilots because when you fly a plane, you suddenly realize fighter pilots are out of their minds.
01:09:18.760They are the bravest people who ever lived.
01:09:21.040And the only, seriously, the only person on Earth, on Earth, and I've met like every famous movie star there is,
01:09:27.040the only person on Earth who ever overawed me was one of the Tuskegee Airmen who came on my show.
01:12:40.120And so there's basically an empty generation of politicians between the age of about 68 and 30.
01:12:46.340Like there's like this entire empty generation of politicians who were either sort of just kind of emptily following in the footsteps of the boomers.
01:12:52.580But there was no harsh rejection of that so much.
01:19:06.180We live in a remarkable time wherein we are almost a different species than all of the people who have come before us.
01:19:14.100In the 20th century, I've said before, after the Second War, we in the West essentially defeated war disease, poverty, and death.
01:19:22.740We essentially arrived at a place where the common tragedies that befell 100% of the population now are quite rare.
01:19:33.280And I think there are a lot of consequences of this, many of them good, but there are negative consequences of this.
01:19:38.900So, one example is, during the pandemic, the great fear that overwhelmed so many in the West about this disease.
01:19:46.380Well, the reason that that great fear about a disease that had a fairly low mortality rate could exist is because of how successfully we have defeated disease.
01:19:55.260If you go back 100 years, everyone died from some disease all the time.
01:21:06.680Every single child who came of age probably had lost their mother and lost siblings.
01:21:11.540Death was such a constant companion that it didn't make you unique and therefore didn't define you.
01:21:16.940War didn't make you unique, didn't define you.
01:21:18.800Disease didn't make you unique, didn't define you.
01:21:21.080And everyone lived in subsistent poverty, really, until the Industrial Revolution.
01:21:26.100For that reason, we almost cannot relate to any humans who have ever gone before us.
01:21:32.980And because we can't relate to them, we can only assume that they were somehow evil.
01:21:39.440Like, you can't place your, it's almost impossible to place yourself in a time and in a place and in a reality, a circumstance that you've never experienced.
01:21:52.040And so, I was thinking about this, it's funny to say this, but I was thinking about it in relation to the UFO conversation that we had the last time we were together.
01:21:59.380That even the fact that we see something mysterious in the air and we think, our first thought is extraterrestrials, is because we live in a time and a place where we have so much fiction around us.
01:22:11.980If you had seen that exact same phenomenon 200 years ago, it could have landed and E.T. could have walked off and you wouldn't have thought extraterrestrial even then.
01:22:22.460You would have thought demon or you would have thought ghost or you would have, because in the reality in which you lived,
01:22:26.620you had a completely different framework with which to understand the world.
01:22:30.800And so, what I want to touch on here for conversation for the group before we close is, how does one overcome all the bias of now, for lack of a better term?
01:22:47.980The fact that we can only think in the very narrow parameters of our own experience.
01:22:53.420How can you understand your place in history?
01:22:55.940How can you understand your place in the cosmos?
01:22:57.520How can you understand your relationship with God?
01:22:59.880How can you understand your relationship with the people on the earth today who don't live in western luxury?
01:23:05.900How can you understand your fellow man if you cannot step out of your experience?
01:23:10.800Did you see the headline that ran a couple of weeks ago?
01:23:14.520It's, I forget which paper, they said,
01:23:15.780Shocking new study from researchers concludes that the aging process cannot be stopped.
01:23:23.620And I looked at that, I said, I'm scratching my head.
01:23:47.840The Brits used to judge their wars in not just decades, but centuries, you know, a hundred years war.
01:23:53.840And even in America, I think, forget just us moderns where we think everything that is older than five minutes ago is somehow crazy and illegitimate.
01:24:02.000Even in America, we really only judge history on the scale of 200 years.
01:24:05.360People that came before us, they were people.
01:25:26.740You know, he could see a scene and understand it and see the mission that he was given before I could ever understand it
01:25:32.680because he just grew up with this thing that was, to me, an actual miracle.
01:25:37.060And so as these children start to learn, you know, this world, we can't possibly grasp the change that has taken place that you are outlining exactly.
01:25:47.340The change is so huge that those of us who were born really even within 20 years ago cannot quite grasp what has happened to us.
01:26:15.980But the hopeful thing is, is that they'll rediscover what you're talking about.
01:26:19.260Even seeing, because all these machines will simply be part of their lives, they'll start to understand, oh, one still dies.
01:26:26.300The eternal questions are still there.
01:26:28.540Freedom versus authoritarianism will still be there, whether we care for the few or the many.
01:26:35.160Still, those are always going to be tensions in human life.
01:26:38.280And once those tensions come back into play, possibly they'll get more realistic.
01:26:42.540And that's the hope, because they will understand.
01:26:44.600I'm telling you, the people who are younger than anybody, you know, 19, 18, 17, they will understand this technology in immediate, instinctive ways that we just never will.
01:26:55.560So I think that the reality is that we absolutely can understand people of the past, which is why we read documents of the past.
01:27:07.040It's why we see ourselves in David or in Moses or in Jesus or why we see ourselves in characters from fiction from 300 years ago.
01:27:14.620It's why we watch movies that are rooted in those same exact archetypes, as Jordan Peterson would say.
01:27:19.560But I think that this is why there's a fundamental war on human nature happening right now, is that as we defeated all of these forces that had been so present and ever-present and heavy in life,
01:27:32.220as we defeated war and death and as we defeated poverty and as the world became richer and more connected and informational deficits could be remedied with a piece of technology that you carry around in your pocket.
01:27:42.280As we did all of that, and as it turned out that the problems of human nature were, in some cases, exacerbated, made worse.
01:27:49.780People have become crueler in many ways in Western society than they were even when I was growing up, like far crueler online than they are in real life.
01:27:56.660People have become far more nasty toward one another.
01:27:58.860People have become far more tribal, and you're seeing it happening in real time.
01:28:02.640The answer to that from people who are at war with the basic religious concept, which is that there is a fundamental and universal human nature,
01:28:09.760people who are at war with that have decided that the problem isn't our failure to recognize human nature and to adapt to human nature.
01:28:16.880Our real problem is in acknowledging that human nature even exists.
01:28:20.520So if we can just obliterate human nature utterly and completely, and we can do that with linguistic tricks,
01:28:25.500we can pretend that human nature is all a social construct as opposed to biologically ingrained.
01:28:31.880We can pretend, I mean, it is called human nature for a reason.
01:28:34.360They can pretend that it has nothing to do with reality and that reality itself is an obstacle to your utter fulfillment.
01:28:40.540This is why when people ask me to steal man Marxism, for example,
01:28:43.660what I always say is that Marxism is a terrible economic theory, but it's actually a spiritual theory.
01:28:47.400It's a spiritual theory that's been around a lot longer than Marx, and that spiritual theory is
01:28:51.200if you restructure the systems in which you live, a new man will be generated.
01:28:54.860A better man will be generated. A new sort of human will be generated.
01:28:58.120And that new sort of human won't be susceptible to any of the things that actually make war and poverty happen, right?
01:29:04.700Because war and poverty don't happen in a vacuum.
01:29:06.240War and poverty happen because human beings are innately sinful, as every religious person knows, right?
01:29:10.240One of the stupidest things I've ever seen said was said by Nelson Mandela, quoted online.
01:29:14.360And it was that the natural state of humanity is prosperity, and poverty is artificial.
01:29:20.060It is, of course, precisely the opposite.
01:29:21.860The natural state of humanity is poverty, and prosperity is artificial.
01:29:26.000And it is only because we recognize our own human nature and then built institutions to militate against that human nature
01:29:30.820that we were able to rise above any of that.
01:29:33.060And once we rose above that, and it turned out that happiness was not the consequence,
01:29:36.580it turned out that we still couldn't fill that hole in the heart that God typically fills,
01:29:41.160then we went to war with human nature itself.
01:29:42.680And so if we wish to reconnect with history, if we wish to connect to other people,
01:29:47.320like even have conversations with other people,
01:29:48.920we're going to have to understand that the person sitting across the table from me
01:29:51.900is not racially essentialist or even sexually essentialist.
01:29:55.040At the bottom line, yes, there are essential characteristics about all of us because we are embodied humans,
01:29:59.580because as Aristotle would suggest, we are in fact soul and body, and we are combined in one.
01:30:05.700But by the same token, we share that exact thing, and we share all the same flaws.
01:30:12.080And once we understand that, we're going to be a lot more understanding toward one another,
01:30:14.720we can actually have conversations, and then maybe we can talk about actually solving some problems.