On this week's episode of The Conversation, Elisha and jeff take your questions and discuss the latest in leftist tears, immigration, and the upcoming Ben Shapiro lecture at Notre Dame. Also, a new segment is being added to The Conversation.
00:00:07.780I don't know about that. Michael Knowles will be taking your questions live for an entire hour.
00:00:17.560All right, so please remember, you remember this, right? We've been doing this for like 18 months now.
00:00:21.320We've done this for a little bit, but remind me of the rules. What happens?
00:00:23.880So everyone is perfectly clear. Our conversation is streaming for everyone to watch, but only subscribers get to ask the questions.
00:00:31.000Be sure to click the link in our video description if you want to ask a question or become a Daily Wire subscriber.
00:00:36.840And if you become a Daily Wire subscriber for the whole year, you get that amazing Leftist Tears Tumblr that Michael just sipped some delicious L.A. Leftist Tears from.
00:00:44.960There's been a lot of L.A. Leftist Tears lately. We've had a ton of rain.
00:01:32.180And Tifa plans on showing up tomorrow night or Thursday night. You'll be at Notre Dame.
00:01:37.580I'm going to be at Notre Dame on Thursday. It's because at Notre Dame, the president of that university has decided to cover up murals of Christopher Columbus.
00:01:47.080Because Christopher, he is one of the greatest men in all of history. And the left has just decided that Columbus is the devil incarnate.
00:01:54.660So, mostly because they're moral idiots and historically ignorant. So, I'm going to be explaining why Christopher Columbus is one of the greatest men in all of history.
00:02:02.520And apparently, Antifa is upset about that. So, a bunch of losers in black masks have decided they're going to come yell at me. But they're going to get learned once they listen to my speech.
00:02:11.920Do you think they'll actually listen? Do you think they'll come in to the lecture hall and hear you out?
00:02:17.000I don't know if they're capable of listening. I know because those stupid masks, I think, cover up their ears too much. They got some like cotton in your ears.
00:02:24.380It's very chilly. So, we'll see what happens. I think a number of them have already, they've RSVP'd to the Antifa group. I don't think they've RSVP'd to come listen to my lecture.
00:02:33.400But they should because they would probably learn a thing or two.
00:02:35.440And I think the title of the lecture is Columbus, Hero Not Heathen.
00:02:39.540That's right. That was the most politically correct one that I could come up with. There were a few others that got rejected in the drafting folder.
00:02:46.060And it's going to be streamed on all of our Daily Wire and over by our buddies at YAF who are sponsoring it.
00:02:52.220Yeah, it's going to be part of the AFT tour. It's going to be a lot of fun. And people are going to learn a thing or two.
00:02:56.860They're going to unlearn a lot of leftist anti-historical nonsense that they think they know about Columbus.
00:03:02.520And they're going to learn what a wonderful man he was.
00:03:04.480All right, we got our first question. This one comes from Jonathan. He says,
00:03:07.400Hi, Michael. What status do you think that illegal aliens brought to the U.S. as miners should have or have available to them?
00:03:13.700Well, the first question is not what status they should have. The question is what status do they have.
00:03:19.700And the status is not legal. They're not American citizens. They are foreign nationals who were brought to this country illegally.
00:03:27.920So they are foreign nationals and they should be dealt with as foreign nationals.
00:03:32.280And their criminal parents certainly should be dealt with as foreign nationals.
00:03:36.020Now, the question is if you were to come up with some deal as to building the wall, closing the border, dumping a lot of money into border security,
00:03:45.440deporting a lot of other people who shouldn't be here, who are here illegally and should not be here,
00:03:50.500if as part of a deal on that you were to say that part of the compromise is that we would have to give some plausible legal status
00:03:59.740to people who were brought here under the age of 18, I might be willing to consider that.
00:04:04.700But without building the wall, without deporting a ton of other people, without deporting all of the criminals who are populating our jails as illegal aliens,
00:04:12.340without those components, I'm not even remotely interested in hearing any arguments about giving amnesty to the so-called dreamers,
00:04:20.420many of whom are like 40 years old at this point.
00:04:22.360And by the way, they try to present this group of people as they're all going to MIT, they're all joining the military, they're all serving their country.
00:04:31.260If they are, can we replace them with all the Americans who aren't?
00:04:32.840Yeah, right. That's great. I mean, in that regard, I'm very happy to do that.
00:04:36.740But the studies show that simply is not the case.
00:04:39.420They have lower educational attainment, so they have higher access to welfare services.
00:04:45.340So to have a serious conversation about that, you first need to close the border.
00:04:49.320Because, as has been shown by Fusion, by Amnesty International, reported by the Huffington Post, upwards of...
00:04:56.420All of those conservative institutions.
00:04:58.560Between 60 and 80 percent of the illegal aliens who are women and girls that cross this border illegally are raped and sexually assaulted on the journey.
00:05:05.640That is just one example of one of the horrific consequences of illegal immigration.
00:05:10.380And by giving amnesty to millions of so-called dreamers, you create a huge, perverse incentive to continue that awful, degraded, inhuman process of crossing this border illegally.
00:05:23.440So I'm not interested in any sort of amnesty for those dreamers until that border is locked down.
00:05:28.720All right. This question comes from Mick.
00:05:30.640Yeah, that's referring to John Maynard Keynes, who is really misrepresented, I think, in the culture.
00:05:47.160John Maynard Keynes is an interesting thinker and an economist.
00:05:49.660But all we ever think of him for is pumping money into the federal government, pumping the economy full of money.
00:05:58.120We think of him as relating to FDR's policies.
00:06:02.360The idea being that the government should be the driver of economic growth.
00:06:05.700That's how Keynes is used in popular economic arguments.
00:06:09.240But, of course, the government is not productive.
00:06:12.080By definition, the public sector is not productive.
00:06:15.300The only productive part of the economy is the private sector.
00:06:18.220That's where the government gets all of its money from.
00:06:20.420So eventually, as is always the problem with socialism, and by the way, I'm not giving some sort of sophisticated academic dissertation on John Maynard Keynes.
00:06:29.820I'm describing him as he is used in popular arguments.
00:06:33.620The problem with those arguments is the problem with socialism, as Margaret Thatcher observed, which is eventually you run out of other people's money.
00:06:44.600And the people might not feel when they run out of money.
00:06:46.620And you actually might just borrow money from China to run up that debt.
00:06:49.980You might be able to run up $22 trillion of debt.
00:06:53.240But eventually, the jig is up, and you realize that you do not have any of that money.
00:06:58.860And we can try to think of all these cute little ways around the fact that in order to produce wealth, you need to produce anything at all.
00:07:06.620But ultimately, the way to wealth is the productive sectors of the economy, not the government borrowing or printing or taxing more money.
00:10:06.240The other thing that has helped is I have worked as an actor in my life, and you do learn how to memorize things very quickly for the short term and the long term.
00:11:05.800But if you don't learn the facts, then you won't learn how to think.
00:11:08.140That's the little secret they don't tell you.
00:11:09.620I think even as an adult, take a moment, memorize a poem, memorize a psalm, memorize Bible verses, whatever.
00:11:17.260That will help you retain more when then you set aside an hour every single night to read philosophy or history or novels or whatever you're going to read.
00:13:12.940The expanded view of the presidency, I don't think that that's necessarily terrible.
00:13:17.680I think a lot of conservatives take an overly broad view of the powers of the legislature.
00:13:22.640As for the populism, I think a lot of elitist conservatives who want to have their nose in the air and never relate to practical politics take a dismal view of the people.
00:15:14.360But no, between the ages of 13 and 23, I would have called myself an atheist or an agnostic.
00:15:19.140I think a lot of precocious 13-year-olds are attracted to atheism.
00:15:23.420I think precocious 13-year-olds are exactly the right temperament for atheism because it appeals to intellectual pride and ignorance.
00:15:32.580There's a reason why the greatest geniuses throughout all of history have believed in a very similar concept of God, all the way from the ancient Greeks through the present.
00:15:42.380There is no really good argument for atheism.
00:15:46.560The best argument for atheism is suffering.
00:15:49.480The fact that there is suffering and injustice in the world.
00:15:52.380However, I think that actually ends up being an argument for God.
00:15:57.900There are many very good arguments for God from the ontological by Anselm of Canterbury through the Thomistic arguments for God.
00:16:05.620The cosmological argument is very popular.
00:16:07.600So if you want to appeal to your own intellectual pride, all of the arguments for God are far better than the arguments against God.
00:16:19.980Ultimately, though, these arguments are just arguments.
00:16:23.080And all meaningful speech depends upon the ultimate meaning and the ultimate truth with a capital T, which is God.
00:16:30.240So those arguments actually sort of beg the question.
00:16:33.640Ultimately, we're talking about faith.
00:16:37.360We're talking, reason can get you to a certain point, and then there is faith that enters in.
00:17:09.840But regardless of which way you're going to enter, if you're entering from an emotional view, a spiritual point of view, an intellectual point of view, historical, philosophical, through any way,
00:17:20.200the arguments for God are far better than the arguments against God, which I think are basically just fantasies.
00:17:29.020People say that believing in God is wishful thinking.
00:17:35.080Some people wish that they won't be held accountable for what they do.
00:17:38.600Some people wish that life doesn't actually have meaning, that there's not a transcendent moral order, that there isn't virtue, that there isn't telos, that there isn't purpose in your life,
00:17:47.400because it allows you to be decadent at whatever you're doing right now.
00:19:12.420Because, you know, famously on my set, I have a check from Ben for $400 framed because he and I made a bet about the presidential election.
00:19:23.300And then I won the bet, and he had to give me the check, and he was very upset about this.
00:19:26.700Then I published a blank book, and I sold more books with no words than, Ben has probably written a dozen books, and I sold more books altogether.
00:19:34.720And Ben was very angry about this, and then he helped me promote the book, and then he helped me, got me a literary agent, all these things.
00:19:40.280So I think what it is with Ben is that he's got, in all of his brilliant broadcasting, he's got this deep masochistic core.
00:19:52.000And I think it's this essential masochism that got him to green light my show and has led him to keep it around for 300 episodes.
00:20:53.860Go right for the thing that most interests you because that will open up a lot of other historical understanding to you for eras and periods and people and places that you might not have even known existed.
00:21:06.380And then you'll sort of find a path down there.
00:21:08.740The most underrated era of history are the Middle Ages, which some people persist in calling the Dark Ages.
00:21:15.760This is a ridiculous epithet that was developed during the Renaissance by people who thought that they were better than all of those ignorant idiots that came before them.
00:21:25.440You know, like Thomas Aquinas or Dante or the greatest thinkers in all of history.
00:21:31.200That period is hugely underrated and misrepresented, and it provides a lot of terrifically interesting history, to say nothing of philosophy, poetry, all of literature, theology.
00:21:44.920I really like to focus there on medieval British history, medieval continental and Italian history and literature.
00:21:54.880You know, Dante is my favorite poet, greatest poet ever in all of history.
00:22:20.260I know, I've got to get more Catholic about things.
00:22:22.480But that would be a very, like, homeschool parent answer of what is your child interested in, and then take that and that's how you educate them.
00:22:29.080And I would say the same thing about reading, whether it comes to politics or history or any topic.
00:35:49.780What they have done now, though, for the last 50 years is hollowed out education itself.
00:35:55.820You've had people marching through the universities saying, hey, hey, ho, ho, Western Civ has got to go.
00:36:00.660At Notre Dame, they are now covering up artwork of Christopher Columbus, like the Taliban.
00:36:06.220At least they haven't knocked down the walls yet.
00:36:08.220But they are covering up artwork because they are so afraid of exposing their students to art and history because the facts might offend them.
00:36:20.800And universities that have given into that nonsense should first try to fire their presidents and their administrators and the deputy assistant, deputy assistant, deputy assistant dean of inclusion and diversity.
00:40:32.940The bum feels gratitude to me because I've done him a favor.
00:40:37.580Now, if the bum asks me for the sandwich and then Barack Obama rides up on a white horse with a gun in his hand and he points the gun at me.
00:41:53.940This is a dividing line in the pro-life movement.
00:41:57.720The reason I oppose in vitro fertilization is that in vitro fertilization entails abortions.
00:42:03.660It entails the creation of lines of embryos, which are individual human lives.
00:42:08.060They are little babies that you can't quite see yet, but it is the creation of individual human life that are then discarded.
00:42:15.020They are either thrown away or they are destroyed or they are implanted, and then you have four or eight kids, and then some are selectively aborted.
00:42:25.160A couple examples of this have happened where it hasn't entailed abortion.
00:42:34.920She ended up having the eight kids all stick, you know, and as a result of that, because I guess she's pro-life, she wouldn't kill any of them and made this heroic choice to have all eight kids.
00:43:23.200We want more life, but this is one of those tough subjects where the road to hell is paved with good intentions, and I think it would, well, we obviously have to fight the abortion battle.
00:43:33.540We're killing a million babies a year in the United States.
00:43:35.460We also should work into our pro-life message that even those who have the opposite intention, not to destroy life but to create life, can have that unintended consequence, and we cannot accept the premises of IVF because the premises of IVF are the premises of abortion.
00:43:51.660I think especially, like, it's a little Brave New World, too, when you start to hear, maybe that's the wrong analogy to use, Chrissy Teigen and John Legend or Kim Kardashian West and Kanye, that when they do do that, they choose the gender.
00:44:09.640And it's, I don't typically like slippery slope arguments, but if that's the top of the slope, it's going to be real slippery.
00:44:18.180Polls show that huge portions of Americans would favor sex-selective abortions.
00:44:23.220Just to use one example, they would, at this point, if you've got eight kids that you can choose from, you can choose your baby, designer babies, and you even hear the language, you see this all throughout the literature, of balancing our family.
00:44:38.000We already have two daughters, so we're going to balance our family by having a boy.
00:44:42.780What that means is you're killing the girl in the womb.
00:44:44.780You're selecting against the girl to balance your family.
00:44:48.020What that means is discarding your child and killing your child.
00:44:51.720It's very Brave New World-y, of course, and as we see the rise of gene editing, gene-edited babies in China now, which affects not just that baby but the whole genetic line all the way in perpetuity.
00:45:03.280These are bioethical questions that, unfortunately, our society, which is now increasingly a scientific materialist society, is actually unequipped to answer.
00:45:15.120They have such a degraded and shallow view of ethics and moral discourse that they're not equipped for these challenges, which are hurtling toward us if they're not upon us already.
00:45:26.540All right, Obby, I hope I'm saying your name right. Sorry if I'm not. He says, Michael, I have an urgent question. What is your favorite color?
00:46:31.080It, uh, I guess Andrew Jackson, I, really, I would trace the Democrat party to Andrew Jackson, and he's, it's only gone downhill ever since him, so I guess he's, by default, he's my favorite.
00:46:43.980Do you think there's a link between the decline in religiosity in America and the rise in the opiate crisis in America?
00:46:50.640Of course. Of course it is. And not just the, the opioid crisis. The opioid crisis is tied directly to the decrease in the life expectancy of Americans, which has decreased now for two years, for the first time in 50 years.
00:47:05.720Why is it decreasing? It's not decreasing because our nutrition is getting any worse. It's decreasing because of drug overdoses and suicide.
00:47:13.240And why are people killing themselves, and why are they giving themselves drugs and overdosing on that?
00:47:19.000It is because of a decline of religiosity. Religiosity has plummeted. The number of people who have been raised without a religious tradition has skyrocketed.
00:47:27.960The people who are religiously unaffiliated, or who call themselves spiritual but not religious, has exploded.
00:47:34.680Spiritual but not religious, by the way, means I refuse to contemplate God, but I find myself very interesting, so they use this ridiculous term.
00:47:42.680Spiritual but not religious maybe can be a way to be led to true religion, but you've got to start taking it seriously.
00:47:49.040And it has been said ad nauseum, I don't even know who first said it, that all political problems are theological problems.
00:47:58.240St. Andrew Breitbart said politics is downstream of culture. Culture is downstream of religion.
00:48:03.420Culture and cult are etymologically related.
00:48:05.440What a culture worships defines that culture.
00:48:09.060And our culture is starving for purpose, starving for meaning.
00:48:13.260They've bought this lie peddled by cynical fools like the new atheists who say that life is meaningless.
00:48:19.820It's a tale told by an idiot full of sound and fury signifying nothing.
00:48:23.260We turn to warm food and we take a dirt nap when we die.
00:48:27.480There's very little evidence for this.
00:48:28.980There's just enough evidence for it to convince people who have only thought in a shallow way or who are only viewing the world in a shallow way.
00:48:43.320And as a result, you see studies that come out that millennials, more than other generations, are looking for meaning and purpose in their careers, in their daily lives.
00:48:52.380They're looking for it because they don't have it.
00:49:06.220I mean, it's a real problem throughout, certainly in the Catholic Church and throughout, as far as I can tell from a distance, throughout the Protestant churches as well.
00:49:28.340However, we will not fix even one single political problem for very long if we don't fix the question of religiosity and irreligiosity in the country.
00:49:40.060And that problem doesn't show any signs of slowing down.
00:49:43.700Jacob says, with the current climate of gun control, what are your views and is there a way for you to see an idea which could solve this problem in American politics?
00:50:07.260It's the closest opinion I have to feminism because it's the only thing that has ever been devised on this earth that can make a woman as physically strong as a man is having a gun and knowing how to shoot that gun.
00:50:20.100The left is trying to grab our guns because they want to take away our liberty.
00:52:10.520And tune in, because I'm going to be going through for half an hour or an hour debunking the myths surrounding Christopher Columbus and going through the true history of him.
00:52:19.620I also highly recommend a peerless biography of Columbus, Christopher Columbus, Admiral of the Ocean Sea.
00:52:25.900There are also a lot of basically contemporary biographies of Columbus written by people who were there with him at the time.
00:52:50.640The woman, I think it was, who was it?
00:52:52.880Carol Delaney, who wrote Columbus and the quest for Jerusalem.
00:52:56.460She, I don't think she would be considered some arch right-winger.
00:53:00.720And she said, the trouble with the modern attack on Columbus is that they are blaming him for things that he never did.
00:53:07.820They're blaming him for things that other people did, that never happened in the first place.
00:53:12.400And so even in a left-wing biography of Columbus, you're at least going to get the facts.
00:53:16.300With these people, the statue topplers, the ones who want to take down the murals of Columbus, what they are dealing in is fantasy, unreality that even a leftist biography will refute.
00:53:28.540But to begin, read Admiral of the Ocean Sea.
00:54:25.000I don't mean to be too mean to Jefferson.
00:54:26.560But really, you have to look first at Adams, Madison, Hamilton, maybe even throw Jay in there.
00:54:35.540And then you get to Jefferson, who is also wonderful.
00:54:38.580But the guys who wrote The Federalist, the second president of the United States, those were unbelievable, sophisticated thinkers who, through their genius, were able to keep us from turning the way of France and having what ultimately, what Edmund Burke might call a conservative revolution, rather than the Jacobin radicalism that destroyed France and nearly destroyed the entire European continent.
00:55:02.260Can you believe that we're almost to the end?
00:55:06.760All right, Wesley has our final question for today.
00:55:09.940She says her husband and her, she are big fans of your show, and they got to meet you in Dallas, you know, when you, like, ran out on stage.
00:55:17.960I had to fly all around the country for a 60-second gag at the top of Ben's show.
00:55:22.600But it was very fun, and I got to meet a lot of nice people.
00:55:24.600So she says, thank you so much for your work.
00:55:26.700And then she wants to know if the Jussie Smollett problem will lead to the mainstream media asking AOC serious questions about her dumb statements.
00:55:34.820We saw Kamala Harris got asked a question, and then she, like, pretended that she didn't tweet it or something.
00:55:52.260No, the mainstream media won't ever ask a serious question of Ocasio-Cortez.
00:55:55.840The only way that they ever would is if the darling of the socialist wing of the Democrats ever falls out of favor with her party more broadly.
00:56:05.000But they'll never ask her a serious question because conservatives point out that she's a liar and a fraud, and she doesn't know anything about anything, and she's a radical who would destroy the country.
00:56:14.200They'll never ask her a serious question.
00:56:16.240They'll never apologize for the Jussie Smollett thing.
00:56:19.840They'll find a way to present the two Nigerian men that Jussie Smollett allegedly paid to beat him up.
00:56:27.700They will find a way to portray them as white men.
00:56:29.960The way that they'll do it is they'll probably say that it was Ralph Northam and Mark Herring, governor and AG of Virginia, in the most elaborate blackface costume that has ever been worn in all of human history.
00:56:40.720And then they'll say, as they already did, that the governor of Virginia, who's a Democrat, is secretly a Republican.
00:56:46.020That is the way that they will cover it.
00:57:07.200It's a sad note to end on, but that's why you've got to come over here to places like us where we can break through that wall of the mainstream media.
00:57:13.600And that's why you've got to tune in for next month's episode of The Conversation, because, you know, Ben is always super chipper and upbeat.
00:57:25.020And don't forget to subscribe to TheDailyWire.com now and join us for next month's episode of The Conversation, featuring our very own editor-in-chief of The Daily Wire and the host of the fastest-growing conservative podcast in the nation.
00:57:36.140Fastest-growing conservative podcast in the nation?
00:57:37.440Ben Shapiro from the Ben Shapiro Show.
00:57:38.560The fastest-talking conservative podcast in the nation, too.