Ali Dawah - DAWAH TO TRANSHIJABI？ - RIGHT OR WRONG？

00:00:00.000 hijab interviewing trans hijabi was he right was he wrong from a juvenile when 0.97

00:00:09.760 my clothes had holes in the and my afro was picky to the 90s

00:00:14.640 Moschino and Versace no laces in Arachis new millennium

00:00:19.360 assalamualaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatuh brothers and sisters and dear friends

00:00:22.200 welcome back to my channel before I start I want to praise Allah

00:00:24.160 the most merciful the most trust or praise His glory and gratitude belong to

00:00:28.160 him so brothers and sisters I want to get straight into it hijab interviewing 0.98

00:00:32.640 trans hijabi was he right was he wrong we're going to discuss this inshallah

00:00:36.920 because there's some there was a YouTube made on video a YouTube video made there

00:00:42.320 was tweets I'm going to discuss all of this from different brothers etc and I

00:00:46.040 don't believe they're coming from a place of harm or evil etc and I'm good with the

00:00:50.100 brothers you know but we just want to discuss so we can have a common

00:00:52.280 understanding most of the time these things happen because of miscommunication

00:00:55.660 misunderstanding and when you talk you're like ah I understand so and I had a

00:01:01.420 telephone discussion as well with Ustad Farid may Allah bless him inshallah we had a

00:01:04.420 nice discussion maybe we had some agree agree to disagree moments but we we said

00:01:10.280 look I understand we understand both each other etc we talk about brothers now a

00:01:14.420 couple of um years ago me and Musa had now went to Birmingham we was invited by a sister to go to

00:01:21.420 the house uh obviously her mum was present uh dad wasn't there and that that her brother was gay he

00:01:27.860 he said that he's homosexual and he had a boyfriend so obviously they didn't know what to do the mom's

00:01:32.000 crying obviously he's upset um and um the daughter's upset because seeing her mum upset and that upset us all

00:01:38.340 so we wanted to speak to him he came down when he saw us he ran back out ran back up now he left the 0.65

00:01:44.420 world of Islam now the question is this now we might see the act of homosexuality as disgusting we 0.98

00:01:51.740 might say you know what is absolutely wrong the question is the following just because you see

00:01:57.380 something to be wrong to be disgusting to be evil to be a sin to be whatever does that mean that the

00:02:06.420 person who's carrying out the act that we start being evil to them and harsh towards them and show our

00:02:11.420 discourse would that work we need to have wisdom allah subhanahu wa ta'ala says in the quran that

00:02:18.200 indeed if he was harsh with them they would have run away from you so allah saying don't be harsh

00:02:23.540 when allah said musa alayhi salam to pharaon who claimed to be a god when allah told the prophet

00:02:30.340 muhammad peace be upon him if he was harsh with who the quraish who are committing shirk billion times 1.00

00:02:36.080 worse than homosexuality and homosexuality is wrong as well let's not say oh that's better it's wrong 1.00

00:02:40.860 as well islamically we believe this to be wrong now in these instances two prophets one's been ordered

00:02:46.860 to be speak you know in a nice tone to the mushriks and one has been sent to somebody who claims to be

00:02:53.820 god one is worshipping idols one is claiming to be god to be an ilah and musa alayhi salam has been

00:02:59.800 told to go and speak to him with words of wisdom and gentleness yes musa alayhi salam became a bit

00:03:05.240 firm after realizing what he dealt with but that is not what we're seeing brothers and sisters

00:03:10.860 so acknowledging that we need to understand that that is we our dawah is not limited to

00:03:18.640 okay you can only give dawah to the mu'mins you know like these um uh super uh salafi uh uh 0.99

00:03:24.320 miscar khawarij minded yeah their attitude towards the muslims only you give dawah only to the people 0.97

00:03:30.400 close to you yeah i mean yeah yeah i hope bida this time you don't go near them etc this ajib weird

00:03:36.320 uh thinking process so the question is this was it right or was it wrong for hijab let's get straight

00:03:43.180 into it now brothers and sisters hijab is a brother to me it's close i talk to him yeah we talk to

00:03:49.500 regular we do something we'll train together we talk we go eat together etc i have a principle in life

00:03:56.460 if i have turned my back against certain family members because of islam um because of the truth

00:04:02.900 of the hack i'm not going to hide that hack because somebody's my friend and if if i've done it with

00:04:07.380 family members in the context where not that i've turned my back but like you know said to him this

00:04:10.800 is wrong and i've been boycotted or etc whatever stuff i've been going through i don't care i want

00:04:15.520 to make something great i used to work with a brother you guys know yeah and i have nothing but love

00:04:19.220 for the brother yeah because i want to make that kind of mention this for a purpose

00:04:21.820 and me ustad adnan rashid and many brothers for years advised the brother and advised in private

00:04:27.420 and private and private why because it's important for us to advise in private it's very important

00:04:34.740 and many years we tried to until we realized the damage that's been caused to the dawah

00:04:39.100 and the youth and even certain actions causing certain people to leave islam

00:04:43.160 was too much for us to turn a blind eye and i had a lot to lose we got besides losing a close

00:04:51.860 brother and friendship and being kind of boycotted maybe they didn't mean to or whatever that's how i

00:04:58.100 felt and there was other things that i lost which i can't get into yeah and it was at stake but i didn't

00:05:04.440 care and i don't care because if it's the hack i don't care if you're my dad my granddad my great

00:05:08.980 granddad the hack is the hack yeah speak the truth even if it's against yourself allah subhanahu wa ta'ala

00:05:13.780 tells us so i want to make something clear muhammad hijab i'm not a yes man if i was a yes man i would

00:05:19.160 have stayed with certain other brothers or worked with certain other individuals i'm not a yes man

00:05:24.520 muhammad hijab if he's wrong i'll tell him he's wrong i'll like i will tell him i don't care if hijab 0.99

00:05:30.480 gets angry or upset or that i don't care i want to make that clear i don't like tiptoe around hijab 0.98

00:05:36.340 oh brother if he's wrong i will come and tell him you're wrong and there's been times where i've

00:05:40.400 told him i'm sorry i mean you're wrong here you're absolutely wrong so the thing is and he's the same

00:05:44.620 attitude with me yeah that's how we are but in this very instance i don't find what was wrong

00:05:50.540 i don't understand a certain brother is tweeting twitter and he's making it seem like we are these

00:05:58.840 american apologetics which we're like yeah homosexuals transgender yeah we love you nice just because 0.84

00:06:04.620 hijab is polite to somebody how does that i don't get it so you can't be polite now you can't be 0.92

00:06:10.900 reasonable you're talking to a 17 year old person who's become a transgender what do you want us to 0.98

00:06:16.640 do insult him shut up you're discussing your evil you're finished you're going to the fire 0.96

00:06:20.680 what do you want us to say that way it's done with wisdom and hikmah and because hijab is speaking 0.97

00:06:27.160 to him to a certain tone he becomes wrong now oh you could you should have you should have been

00:06:31.080 more harsh why can we not speak with respect in a civilized manner to someone and hijab after he 1.00

00:06:39.660 did this discussion the very same person made a tweet saying i look stupid i wish i never went on 0.54

00:06:45.000 there well i think that was the point of what hijab was doing in the context of yes he wanted to speak 0.96

00:06:50.720 to him i don't think he wanted to make him look stupid but he wanted to show some contradicting

00:06:55.320 statements so if hijab is doing that brothers and sisters what i'm trying to understand is the 0.60

00:07:00.480 following i learned a lot from that the way hijab conducted himself the arguments that he used and

00:07:07.040 so many people in the comment section were saying at least you're equipped with it you can't just brush

00:07:11.980 it under the carpet just because it looks ir to you and ir doesn't mean that it is not something that

00:07:17.780 should be addressed yeah you might not stomach it and not like it well okay that doesn't mean we have

00:07:22.660 to stop our dawah just because you seem something ajib and oh in our country we never saw sorry we're

00:07:28.560 not in your country yeah i mean we can't come and make it seem like someone's doing wrong because it

00:07:34.000 looks wrong to you oh why are you speaking like imagine i'm speaking to someone who has intimacy with

00:07:38.240 a piano but i'm not going to be like okay we don't talk to him yeah i just totally disregard him

00:07:43.040 now regarding okay giving him platform i believe when the guy didn't have no shubhat he was not a threat 0.54

00:07:51.060 he has no platform let's be real the guy doesn't have a platform so giving him a platform like what

00:07:56.180 do we mean like if there is somebody who has doubts shubhat the guy is throwing doubt and you're

00:08:01.620 giving a platform we understand this is somebody who's chose to change the agenda and it's all

00:08:06.280 more emotional and this is how i feel and this is you can see that from his statements how is that

00:08:11.220 person a threat i don't understand how was that person a threat no now if your issue is with the style

00:08:18.420 of dawah but i'm so sorry you can't have a go at somebody publicly in the dawah scene you're going

00:08:24.360 public because of his style oh you should have been more harsh you should not have him on there

00:08:29.180 that's your opinion was it haram for him to have him on there was it haram no so then was it haram

00:08:36.060 for him to speak to him in a decent way while dealing with his arguments no so then it's like me

00:08:43.000 i'm going to go and say oh you i don't like your style of dawah it's it's not fair now another

00:08:48.640 thing for example i watched um uh brother sajid's youtube as well um and i know he's coming from a

00:08:54.420 place of and it's like a good place but one thing i disagreed was like yes hijab has made mistakes

00:08:59.640 yeah with the whole uh yes hard interview et cetera mistake in the context of what we know

00:09:04.300 the quran is preserved well we have no doubt somebody who's not qualified in the field 0.99

00:09:09.300 like um he's not qualified that's not his area it's not his expertise yeah i can be an expert in

00:09:15.260 uh i can i can be uh you know construction this doesn't mean i'm going to be an expert in the

00:09:20.440 field of uh i don't know thermodynamics or whatever it might be yeah okay just because you have a field

00:09:26.460 expertise here doesn't mean you're an expert everywhere so that was wrong in the context of i would say

00:09:31.500 that specific thing should have not been done but hijab is interviewing people and he is kind of

00:09:36.640 debunking their show behind and he's had different people in this podcast he's interviewing them yeah

00:09:41.040 now to equate that and see a few mistakes for example certain things that he made and then add

00:09:46.960 this into it is not fair because what you're doing is saying okay hijab was wrong here hijab was also

00:09:51.360 wrong here and this trans hijabi thing it looks ill to me and it's wrong to me therefore 0.99

00:09:58.080 add this to the list that's not fair that's not fair you might be writing the first and the second

00:10:02.760 you can say that it was wrong here you should not have done that okay we understand you let's

00:10:06.300 advise the brother in private is hijab that much of a liability no it's not so to go out doing a 0.97

00:10:12.020 public video i believe it was unfair it was wrong and especially with people that we know you got my

00:10:16.640 number brother call me let's talk it's not fair and then to add this trans hijabi thing which nothing

00:10:22.160 was done haram and he was he dealt with it that so much so the very guy himself admitted that 0.75

00:10:27.240 i was wrong you know i looked stupid so to me i don't understand why is that fair to now add that 0.60

00:10:34.580 to the list and be like oh see hijab did it again that's not fair that's not fair to say oh hijab did 0.59

00:10:39.360 it again because he didn't do it again so and i love these words for the sake of allah all of them

00:10:45.100 yeah all of the mentions that i mentioned well i i have nothing but love but i'm seeing going out

00:10:50.540 public what it does is it causes some kind of disunity now this disunity doesn't mean like you know

00:10:55.740 some people say we're ikhwani muslimin yeah we work with everybody but if i was working with

00:10:58.780 everybody i would not stop working with certain brothers yeah that debunk the very claim that i

00:11:02.160 stop working with certain brothers shows that i'm not ikhwani i don't work with everybody yeah

00:11:04.980 the point is this unnecessary disunity because a lot of people are saying come on was this needed

00:11:09.680 yeah and how does it look at outside to the enemies of islam how does it do because now you're

00:11:14.800 doing you're bringing back old things that were done and you're bringing it and adding this on top

00:11:18.280 like hijab did something wrong with the issue of trans hijab you have a right to disagree and say

00:11:21.940 i would have not you would have not or you would have have a different tone with them does not make

00:11:26.840 hijab wrong so please brothers when like what i'm just saying is when we're doing these things look 0.82

00:11:33.000 you might you have a right to disagree hundred percent i'm not saying you guys don't you dare no

00:11:36.960 please contact me or whoever i'm just saying hijab aki that was wrong you know maybe you should not

00:11:42.820 have done that let's discuss let's talk we're open we're not look we are open we make mistakes i've made

00:11:47.420 mistakes people have advised me in private yeah i've changed those like things that i've seen

00:11:51.420 but for people close to me nothing hurts me more in the context of if i'm doing outright battle

00:11:57.400 but go out and refute me but if i'm not doing something that's outright battle then the thing

00:12:03.180 is you've got my number you can contact me well like a lot of people call me all kinds of stuff

00:12:07.180 yeah like it's jahil this that i've been called you know all kinds of hadiths been applied to me

00:12:13.360 ali dawah ali needs dawah etc while i go through one and comes at other but people that are close

00:12:18.000 to me i'm like brother you got my number for example yeah you could call me let's talk let's

00:12:22.320 discuss you might be right you might have a point but to bring this and we're talking about hikmah

00:12:26.500 and wisdom and then we're and then we're bringing it to the public but it doesn't need to be there

00:12:31.880 because hijab is not a liability with certain context he's not so brothers and sisters what i'm just

00:12:38.180 seeing is in a nutshell i believe what hijab did was right it's a growing problem 1.00

00:12:42.780 this whole transgender thing is a growing massive problem that had to be dealt with brothers and 1.00

00:12:49.060 sisters uh so that's the reason why i'm saying if you want us to just dig under the carpet until 0.99

00:12:54.080 it starts to stink and smell and then we're like okay let's talk about it now well we've got a lot

00:12:57.140 of poo to clean up now so the thing is brothers and sisters i'm just seeing uh and like i said before

00:13:02.400 like brother sajid and brother farid and the rest like all i'm saying is look we know you're coming

00:13:07.380 from a place of good but please talk to us because it doesn't show this unity and some issues going on

00:13:13.160 etc with it's unneeded well like to an issue like this hijab has had discussions in the park with

00:13:18.580 trans hijabis i mean transgender he spoke to them what's the difference he spoke to these people and

00:13:25.720 he's debunked their points all he's done is the same thing with a muslim trans hijabi yeah okay and

00:13:31.500 so what we're just saying is is to reach out to these people when we're doing the dawah and also

00:13:36.320 to make them understand so they don't feel excommunicated and be like okay i'm gay trans

00:13:40.920 jada this is how i'm going to be treated i'm leaving the fold of islam is that good should we 0.98

00:13:44.620 get them to leave islam as well if we can keep them in the fold of islam we will and for people 1.00

00:13:50.120 thinking no you have to be harsh it's better i'm so sorry bring me evidence from the quran and the sunnah 0.99

00:13:54.660 that it is haram for us to dialogue with them um to talk to them in a decent manner yeah in a decent

00:14:01.280 manner if we please bring me evidence yeah okay in a decent manner and um that it's that it's haram

00:14:08.580 for us to have to stay as a muslim even though they're committing a major sin please if not then 1.00

00:14:14.080 these issues in the native will tackle yeah i believe if hijab came and said to me i'm gonna i'm

00:14:18.100 gonna finish off this if hijab came and said to me i'm gonna interview a guy who has intimacy with an

00:14:22.280 animal with a dog yeah i would say look personally is it a growing problem nah not really i better not

00:14:29.540 touch but if it's a growing problem where you're having a massive mass of people having intimacy

00:14:33.000 with animals yeah i'm like well talk and debunking bro yeah do you get what i'm trying to say so the

00:14:38.960 the thing is yes one thing is that we need it's important for us to speak to our elders as well

00:14:43.920 i hope i've covered everything brothers and sisters and i think it's let's be fair inshallah in that

00:14:48.560 context and i'm not saying brothers are not i know they come from a place of good

00:14:51.720 but please with this stuff it should be out the public there's a lot of stuff that i disagree with

00:14:55.860 hijab i speak to in private all the time i will carry on speaking the hijab in private if i believe

00:15:00.520 he's done something wrong and the same with him if he believes i'm done something wrong till the point

00:15:03.900 where i believe or he believes i'm a liability ali dawah is an outright misguided individual who needs

00:15:09.460 to be publicly brothers and sisters this person is wrong ali dawah is wrong he's wrong but there's

00:15:16.060 no such case there's no such case so inshallah let's assume the best thing that our brothers

00:15:21.500 let's understand this is where we was coming from hope you guys understand because we we deal with it

00:15:26.680 on a ground level we see the disruption it causes and these people are leaving islam because they're 1.00

00:15:30.760 feeling unwanted that shouldn't be the case i'm so sorry if our kindness is going to keep them in islam 1.00

00:15:36.200 while we speak the hack not yeah transgender yes great brilliant nobody said that so that's it

00:15:44.320 brothers and sisters uh till next time assalamualaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatuh please do comment in the

00:15:48.640 section below and give me your feedback if i'm wrong i might be wrong just i'm open to it uh

00:15:53.020 that's it goodbye

00:15:54.960 that's it goodbye

00:16:01.940 that's it goodbye

Ali Dawah - November 21, 2020

DAWAH TO TRANSHIJABI？ - RIGHT OR WRONG？

Episode Stats

Summary

Transcript