Ali Dawah - May 31, 2026


MUSLIM LATERN & ALI DAWAH SHARE HALAL OR HARAM IF WOMEN CAN GIVE DAWAH?


Episode Stats


Length

42 minutes

Words per minute

220.31714

Word count

9,286

Sentence count

94

Harmful content

Misogyny

80

sentences flagged

Toxicity

8

sentences flagged

Hate speech

262

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00.000 Muhammad Ali, may Allah bless him, preserve him, his mannerism, I'm one of his fans, I watch his
00:00:03.360 videos, I like his videos, and once again, this doesn't mean we agree. It is not known that any
00:00:08.600 female Sahaba would go out in the midst of non-maharim or other Sahaba, and would start
00:00:14.160 giving them da'wah and lecturing them and this and that. Prophet turned to his companions, imagine
00:00:18.580 she's in front of a non-maharim man. Have you ever heard a better statement by a woman than this one? 0.99
00:00:25.140 There was no thing of scoldment, why are you doing this, why are you, you could have come to me on my 0.92
00:00:27.780 own this is number one and evidence that brother mohammed ali asked once you're in that grave 0.76
00:00:34.340 there's no i could have i would have i should have case closed allah tells us that a man when 0.87
00:00:37.900 his soul is taken away allah says he's going to say what send me back to do hajj umrah salah
00:00:42.740 fasting what no sadaqa brothers and sisters ayera is getting thousands of shahadas monthly 0.50
00:00:48.580 yearly hundreds of thousands of people are coming to islam they are printing quran distributing
00:00:53.060 material training duat brothers and sisters do you want the part of that sadaqa jariah 0.98
00:00:57.580 that goes on forever this is how islam has spread around the world brothers and sisters carry on
00:01:02.060 this legacy of the process sell them inshallah by donating whatever amount inshallah and support
00:01:05.980 ira right now inshallah enjoy the video assalamualaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatuh brothers and
00:01:10.200 sisters and dear friends hope you guys are well inshallah before we go into the video i'm going
00:01:12.840 to repeat the brother uh the words of our brother muhammad ali muslim lantern um that if you know
00:01:17.800 if you guys are not going to watch this in full and just going to take segments out of it and make
00:01:21.560 this a issue between me and brother muhammad ali please abstain and feel that he's my brother in
00:01:26.400 Islam we do dawah in the same location I see him we give salam we love each other for the sake of
00:01:31.300 Allah we disagree with each other on a lot of stuff believe me a lot of stuff um you know there's a lot
00:01:36.220 of stuff that we don't see eye to eye but we are brothers we've sat down I've had debates and
00:01:39.240 discussions with him in certain matters and we've come to agree and disagree and he is my brother
00:01:43.000 and I love him for the sake of Allah he's doing an excellent job in the dawah his mannerism I'm
00:01:47.420 one of his fans I watch his videos I like his videos and once again this doesn't mean we agree
00:01:51.760 yes there's a lot of things that me and Muhammad Ali completely disagree on this is one of them
00:01:55.560 It's just to give the other perspective
00:01:57.080 So what Prophet Muhammad Ali says in the video
00:01:58.820 Which we're going to watch for ourselves
00:01:59.760 Is haq, that is an opinion 0.99
00:02:01.980 That is valid and he follows 0.99
00:02:03.760 And we must respect that
00:02:05.000 When it comes to these issues
00:02:06.040 There is difference of opinion
00:02:07.160 Which is why I'm doing this video
00:02:09.420 And to give it another perspective
00:02:11.140 From the Quran and Sunnah
00:02:12.480 Not from myself, I'm a nobody 0.99
00:02:13.620 Yes, from the Quran, the Sunnah, the Salaf
00:02:16.680 And the scholars
00:02:17.960 Okay, which we're going to dissect in a minute
00:02:19.620 Inshallah
00:02:19.940 So I urge you guys
00:02:21.160 Please watch this in full
00:02:22.400 And learn
00:02:23.540 Today you can learn something
00:02:24.760 You know what, okay
00:02:25.380 there's one perspective there's another perspective there's no meat against him we are both trying to
00:02:29.640 serve the deen of Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala and we ask Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala to accept it from us
00:02:32.660 and please do go subscribe to the brother Muhammad Ali's channel which you guys might know if you
00:02:36.360 don't know subscribe amazing dawah and I personally learn from him myself let's get straight into the
00:02:41.680 video now in this video brothers sisters obviously I'm going to be reacting to brother Muhammad Ali
00:02:44.860 and we just want to respectfully just look at the point of view inshallah where it's coming from
00:02:48.900 and look at another perspective bringing evidences from Imam Bukhari from the Quran from the salaf
00:02:54.820 ourselves and to see is it permissible for women to give dawah yes or no obviously brother muhammad
00:03:01.580 ali's position is no not giving women the dawah to other women that he's of course he hasn't
00:03:06.840 about women giving dawah like examples of muslim mom uh sister itachi if i'm not mistaken forgive
00:03:12.440 me uh sister kora you know those who are observing correct form of hijab who are covering their
00:03:17.980 faces i'm not saying you have to cover your face but i believe it's better with ai like brother 0.71
00:03:21.660 Muhammad Ali mentioned okay so let's get straight into it inshallah I know some people are not going
00:03:27.860 to like what I'm about to say now okay but I don't say things for the sake of the people to be happy
00:03:33.680 I'm not happy what I already said some people are not going to be happy with but what I'm about to
00:03:37.360 say is also we'll have people that are not going to be happy listening to but I am not saying it
00:03:42.280 for your sake I'm saying it for the sake of all and I will have people saying I heard the scholar
00:03:45.960 say it's okay I heard that scholar say it's okay the following is from a scholar brother Muhammad
00:03:49.340 Ali follows. Ibn Taymiyyah. This enjoying good and forbidding evil is a duty that the entire
00:03:54.700 Ummah is obliged to fulfill. It is what the scholars known as an obligation of collective
00:03:59.640 responsibility. Fardul Kifaya. Notice Ibn Taymiyyah does not remove women from this verse. This is
00:04:05.000 mentioned in Sheikh Ibn Taymiyyah's Majmur Al-Fatawah. Also Ibn Al-Kathir seems to indicate that this is
00:04:09.660 for both men and women as the verse is generic not specific to only men. Another scholar that both
00:04:15.840 Myself and Muhammad Ali also take from
00:04:17.780 It's Sheikh Bin Baz who have passed away
00:04:19.500 May Allah have mercy on his soul
00:04:20.780 He said the following in his fatawa
00:04:21.920 A woman like a man has her duty in calling to Allah
00:04:25.240 Enjoying good and forbidding evil
00:04:26.860 The evidences from the Quran and Sunnah apply generally to everyone
00:04:29.880 Except where a specific proof makes an exception
00:04:32.180 The statements of the scholars are also clear on this
00:04:34.680 Among the Quranic evidences in the saying of Allah
00:04:36.900 The believing men, believing women are allies to one another
00:04:39.560 They enjoy what is right and forbid what is wrong
00:04:41.820 In Surah Tawbah
00:04:42.600 And he's saying
00:04:43.400 You are the best nation produced for mankind
00:04:45.180 you enjoin what is right and forbid what is wrong in surah al-imran therefore she must call to allah 0.89
00:04:50.760 with the islamic manners and etiquette required from a man original arabic fatwa from ibn alba's
00:04:55.560 official website which we have quoted in the link below also when we look at the most popular
00:04:59.980 website probably in the world when it comes to fatwa islam qna sheikh munajid the question is
00:05:04.340 asked what do you say about calling people to allah dawah with regard to women and he says the
00:05:07.640 following the fatwa he gives women like men are obliged to call people to allah and to enjoy what
00:05:12.580 is good and forbid what is evil because the text of the quran and sunnah indicate that and the 0.91
00:05:16.400 words of the scholars clearly state that so women have to call people to allah and enjoy what is
00:05:20.380 good and forbid what is evil in note here it says call people it doesn't say call other women
00:05:25.400 or just for children following sorry kainan following the guidance of the sharia just as
00:05:31.540 men are required to do a woman should not be deterred from calling people to allah by feeling
00:05:36.040 of anxiety or lack of patience because of some people looking down on her insulting her or
00:05:41.020 mocking her so this argument of they might be in harm's way this fatwa says that they should still
00:05:45.960 carry on rather she has to put up with that and be patient if she thinks that people are mocking her
00:05:51.100 or making fun of her in some way then she should pay attention to something else which is that she 0.96
00:05:55.900 should be the best example of of observing the hijab in front of non-mahram men and avoiding 1.00
00:06:01.180 mixing freely so you can see that dawah is clearly encouraged and not only that there's precautions 0.98
00:06:06.340 given which is the correct form of hijab in front of non-mahram men which shows that they can give 0.99
00:06:10.740 men and avoiding mixing freely she should be careful to ensure that her dawah is free of 0.99
00:06:15.500 anything reprehensible if she makes dawah to men she must do whilst observing the hijab and without 0.94
00:06:21.520 being along with any mahram man if she makes dawah to women she must call them wisely and making sure
00:06:27.080 that her attitude and behavior is above suspicion so that no one criticizes her or ask why doesn't 0.98
00:06:33.300 she start with herself she has to keep away from clothing that will distract people and avoid all
00:06:37.320 kinds of fitna, temptation, such as displaying her beauty or speaking in soft manner, for which
00:06:42.440 she may be criticized. She must take care to call the people to Allah in a manner which would not 0.95
00:06:46.940 harm her religious commitments or her reputation. What is the ruling behind women engaging in da'wah 1.00
00:06:52.020 to begin with? Now, when I talk about engaging in da'wah, I do not mean sisters doing da'wah to
00:06:56.820 others. Okay, firstly, what Prophet Muhammad Ali said is correct. Okay, people might not like it, 0.92
00:07:01.040 but the haq is the haq. So, this is not about liking a da'wah. I don't think anyone can have 1.00
00:07:05.240 say on the matter of i like it i don't like it with this much same applies to me no one can come 0.78
00:07:09.960 and say oh i like your opinion i don't i'm not my opinion by the bit of what the salaf said and
00:07:14.360 there are two opinions his opinion has to be respected it's not a matter of liking or dislike
00:07:18.120 i don't listen to and go i don't like it i'm like his opinion is valid and whoever's following that
00:07:23.160 should follow that respectfully however the other side of the opinion has to be the same it has to
00:07:28.920 be respected which we're going to bring evidence so that's why i agree it's not a matter of liking
00:07:32.680 or disliking
00:07:33.240 this is a matter of
00:07:34.320 two opinions
00:07:35.680 if they are valid
00:07:36.300 scholars behind the Quran
00:07:37.220 Sunnah Salaf
00:07:37.920 it should be respected
00:07:39.240 this is what the matter is about
00:07:40.120 inshallah
00:07:40.340 I do not mean
00:07:41.760 sisters on WhatsApp group
00:07:42.900 or sisters on Telegram
00:07:43.700 we need all of that 0.99
00:07:44.540 mashaAllah 0.99
00:07:44.940 our sisters writing books
00:07:45.960 that we can all benefit from
00:07:47.420 we're doing research
00:07:48.120 all of that is great
00:07:49.440 alhamdulillah
00:07:50.000 I am the biggest proponent
00:07:51.720 of that
00:07:52.040 I'm talking about
00:07:52.880 sisters doing 1.00
00:07:53.800 this idea of
00:07:55.000 tasadduh
00:07:55.560 where they are in the forefront
00:07:56.480 of the da'wah
00:07:57.120 engaging with men 0.95
00:07:58.520 and doing da'wah
00:08:00.020 here and there
00:08:00.580 and going on channels
00:08:01.500 and making YouTube videos 1.00
00:08:02.520 and lives and what is the ruling behind that it is not known that any female sahaba would go out 0.57
00:08:08.760 in the midst of non-maharim of other sahaba and would start giving them da'wah and lecturing
00:08:15.080 them and this and that if i'm wrong you're welcome to show me okay perfect so obviously
00:08:20.040 brother muhammad ali he's open to it he said if you have it i have evidences from the quran and
00:08:23.960 the sunnah which we're going to dissect inshallah so first let's just go into this so we have two
00:08:27.560 verses in the Quran Surah Tawbah and the second verse is in Surah Yusuf the one in Surah Tawbah
00:08:32.920 if we look at it it says the believing men and the believing women are allies to one another
00:08:36.760 believing men and women are allies to one another they engage they enjoin what is right and forbid
00:08:42.200 what is wrong and establish prayer and give zakah and obey so now Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala
00:08:46.920 enjoining good and forbid and evil is something if you look at Ibn Taymi Ibn al-Qayyim how they
00:08:51.080 explain that it's not something that it's done in secret enjoining good and forbid and evil
00:08:55.000 depends on different situations of course it can be done privately as well but it's also an act of
00:08:58.840 public thing if you see if a sister's walking and sees a brother drinking alcohol she has
00:09:04.360 every right to go and say my dear brother this is haram yes vocally if they have a platform and
00:09:10.600 they see someone doing haram they have to allah did not say the believing men he didn't he did
00:09:15.640 not make this a statement that is specific to men only the believing men and women are allies to one
00:09:21.000 one another and they enjoy good and forbid evil okay they have they can be vocal and we have ample
00:09:25.920 amount of evidence which i'm going to come to in a minute so this statement is not something that
00:09:29.540 is specific number two surah yusuf chapter verse 108 say your prophet that this is my way i invite
00:09:36.960 to allah with insight i am those who i am i and those who follow me glory be to allah there is
00:09:44.300 no statement here saying that this is specifically to men okay it says say your prophet this is my
00:09:48.740 I invite to Allah with insight I and those who follow me men and women follow you so men and
00:09:55.440 women follow the Prophet so these ayahs that are talking about enjoying the good and forbidden evil
00:09:59.780 they are not Allah did not say let there rise amongst you a group of people a group of men
00:10:04.320 Allah did not say that Allah did not specify this now these verses are clear that it is for
00:10:10.380 both men and women yes if anyone can come and say this is specifically for men that women cannot
00:10:15.480 then we can say that now how do we see the implementation of this in the sunnah and we're
00:10:20.860 going to give you examples of female companions vocal very very vocal and we're going to see if
00:10:27.420 the process scolded them or said to them you shouldn't be doing this you should not be saying
00:10:31.200 this rather the process praises them yes okay so let's just go to the next uh part of muhammad 0.98
00:10:37.960 ali's statement inshallah examples of sahabia women that would go out in the midst of other
00:10:42.360 Sohaba men that are non-maharim and they will stand
00:10:44.360 on a podium or whatever and they will 1.00
00:10:46.500 start giving them lectures and reminders
00:10:48.560 and this. Okay, good. So, now we
00:10:50.480 want to bring evidence because obviously it's important for
00:10:52.480 us when we see a statement, we bring evidence
00:10:54.480 and Prophet Muhammad Ali said very clearly. If there is
00:10:56.540 please let me know, inshallah. So
00:10:58.460 and may Allah be pleased with him, report it.
00:11:00.420 I'm just going to go to the crux of the matter. 0.54
00:11:03.040 Then Abu Talha came and proposed 0.60
00:11:04.420 marriage to Umm Sulaym. Umm Sulaym 0.96
00:11:06.340 was, by the way guys, a Muslim woman 1.00
00:11:08.260 and Abu Talha was a kafir
00:11:10.360 here is what transpires so abu talha came and proposed marriage to um salim and spoke to her 0.72
00:11:15.600 about it she said oh abu talha a man like you would not be turned down but you are a non-believer
00:11:20.300 and i am a muslim woman it is not right for me to marry you it is not right for me to marry now 0.70
00:11:25.340 bear in mind guys this is a muslim woman speaking to a non-muslim man who is not her mahram and 0.54
00:11:30.700 they are talking about marriage there's a proposal happening here as you can see he said this is the
00:11:34.980 change this is the chance of a lifetime she said what chance he said the yellow and the white
00:11:39.880 He was tempting her with mahr or dairi or gold and silver
00:11:42.980 She said I do not want any yellow or white 1.00
00:11:45.420 I want you to become Muslim 1.00
00:11:46.920 If you become Muslim that will be my mahr 0.97
00:11:49.080 And I will not ask you for anything else
00:11:50.620 He asked who could help me with that to become a Muslim
00:11:53.280 She said the messenger of Allah peace and blessings of Allah be upon him
00:11:56.620 So Abu Talha went to look for the Prophet Muhammad peace and blessings of Allah be upon him
00:11:59.080 Who was sitting with his companions
00:12:00.400 When he the Prophet Muhammad peace and blessings be upon him said
00:12:03.100 Abu Talha is coming to you with the light of Islam shining on his forehead 0.90
00:12:07.000 So you can see guys
00:12:08.200 in this instance not only is there a muslim woman giving dawah calling this man who's proposing to
00:12:14.140 her yes to islam but they are also talking about marriage the issue at hand is pertaining to 0.96
00:12:18.660 marriage now i'm not saying that muslim woman should go and you know have these kind of um
00:12:23.980 discussions or back and forth with non-muslim men like of course if someone proposes and says look
00:12:27.460 okay you're interested in me yes you can speak to my father i'm not saying it's not haram this is
00:12:31.100 why it's so important for us to understand in this instance this is a marriage proposal happening
00:12:35.440 and at the same time the muslim woman is calling the mushrik man to in islam invited it then we
00:12:41.120 have another example now the next example i'm going to give you is happening in front of many 0.51
00:12:44.640 companions let's go to it we're going to go to someone called asma bint yazid this is a female
00:12:49.760 companion and i want you guys to listen uh very carefully inshallah okay asa bint yazid ibn al-sakan 0.96
00:12:55.440 was a woman from the ansar and the companion of the prophet muhammad she was distinguished for her
00:13:00.960 sagacity and eloquence okay indeed she was nicknamed the all the orator of all women
00:13:08.700 but she was also a woman of learning and she reported the prophets she reported the prophet
00:13:14.160 salam's hadith she was clearly reliable as a reporter abu dawud at timidi and nasai and ibn
00:13:20.320 major as well as other major scholars of hadith related a total of 81 hadith um 80 hadith of her
00:13:26.940 reporting as such she ranks amongst the best learners of the prophet's woman's companions
00:13:31.000 okay so now brother uh muhammad ali said was there ever a case that a woman came vocally in front of
00:13:37.240 the prophet and the companions and done this yes now if it applies to them because that's the non
00:13:41.900 it also applies to non-muslim men or women for that matter yes asma was also keen on jihad joining
00:13:49.280 muslim armies on several occasions she accompanied the prophet on his expedition that led to the fall
00:13:54.760 of mecca islam she also participated in the great battle of yarmouk against the byzantines during
00:14:00.080 the reign of umar ibn khattab she is reported to have killed nine enemy soldiers you know you don't 0.69
00:14:04.920 want to mess with her using the pole of her own tent subhanallah in order to appreciate her
00:14:10.900 knowledge we may relate the following story this is very key here one day she came to the prophet
00:14:16.200 muhammad as he was sitting with a number of his companions now the person is sitting with a number
00:14:22.180 of his companions in a majlis addressing him she said oh messenger of god may both my parents be
00:14:28.780 sacrificed for you this was a traditional phrase of endearment sorry and used mostly figuratively
00:14:35.020 i am a emissary from woman to you so she's spoken with a woman and she's coming as a messenger okay
00:14:40.780 uh to you from uh i am an emissary from woman to you god has sent you as his messenger to both men
00:14:47.340 and woman we believe in you your lord yet we women are restricted homebound we stay in our uh men's
00:14:55.180 homes give giving your giving you your pleasure and bear your children you men have been favored
00:15:01.100 over us with attending friday prayer congregation prayers in mosque visiting the sick attending
00:15:06.360 funerals offering the pilgrimage repeatedly and with that with what is more than that fighting
00:15:12.540 for god's cause so since there's specific things that allah has enabled the man to do that a woman
00:15:16.900 doesn't need to do yes when a man goes out intending pilgrimage or jihad we take care of
00:15:23.080 their property sew their clothes sew their clothes and bring up their children for you
00:15:26.880 do we have the share of your reward now here is very key this is why i want to bring evidence
00:15:32.080 from the quran and sunnah the process say a woman why are you talking on behalf of the men
00:15:36.940 why are you not in your house why are you no no no nothing like that is said something
00:15:42.060 peculiar very interesting the the okay okay the prophet turned to his companions now he's turning
00:15:51.380 to his companions imagine she's the prophet the prophet turned to his companions and asked him
00:15:56.260 them have you ever heard a better statement by a woman than this one who is speaking who is asking
00:16:03.560 about matters of her faith they said we would not have thought that a woman would ever be able to
00:16:10.180 express such meanings as this lady the prophet turned to Asma and said listen woman and inform
00:16:17.960 other woman who sent you that a woman who is a good goodly wife keen to please her husband
00:16:24.580 and during doing what he likes is equal to all of that as she left she was glorifying God and
00:16:30.780 repeating statements of his oneness now the key here is this the Prophet not only praised her
00:16:38.400 He asked the companions
00:16:39.940 Have you come across such eloquent speech
00:16:42.580 They praised her
00:16:44.680 There was no thing of scoldment
00:16:46.300 Why are you doing this?
00:16:46.960 You could have come to me on my own
00:16:48.000 I had a specific majlis just for me
00:16:49.680 The Prophet Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam
00:16:50.680 Without the companions 0.98
00:16:51.300 This is number one 0.99
00:16:52.720 An evidence that Muhammad Ali asked
00:16:55.160 That shows that women are allowed to talk
00:16:58.220 Some believe that she is an aura 0.98
00:17:00.320 Some believe that they should be at their homes 0.97
00:17:03.160 This is true 1.00
00:17:03.960 It's better 0.97
00:17:04.860 But you cannot say it's haram if they do it
00:17:06.660 It is better that they are their homes
00:17:08.620 And that ayah in the Quran 0.99
00:17:09.820 Which Prophet Muhammad Ali mentioned
00:17:10.940 Applies to the wives of the Prophet
00:17:12.900 So this is one instance 0.99
00:17:15.240 This is one instance
00:17:16.000 There is many
00:17:17.180 I will give you guys another one
00:17:18.680 For example
00:17:19.200 This is pertaining to
00:17:20.900 Narrative Abu Hurairah
00:17:22.020 A man came to the Prophet
00:17:22.900 The Prophet sent a messenger to his wives 0.92
00:17:24.700 To bring something for that man to eat
00:17:27.000 But they said that they had nothing except water
00:17:29.220 Then Allah's Messiah said
00:17:30.760 Who will take this person and entertain him as a guest 1.00
00:17:33.140 So you go to a non-mahram man 0.99
00:17:34.240 Who's come and who will take him as a guest
00:17:36.220 And Ansari man said 0.97
00:17:37.660 Aye 1.00
00:17:38.420 So he took him to his wife
00:17:40.400 And said to her
00:17:41.340 Entertain generously the guest of Allah's messenger
00:17:44.100 She said we have got nothing except the meals of my children
00:17:46.820 He said prepare your meal
00:17:48.100 Light your lamp
00:17:49.100 And let your children sleep if they ask for supper
00:17:51.140 So she prepared her meal
00:17:52.800 Lightened her lamp 1.00
00:17:55.380 And made her children sleep 0.99
00:17:56.720 Then stood up pretending to mend her lamp 1.00
00:17:59.420 But she put it off
00:18:00.760 Just so he doesn't know that he's eating the last meal that they have
00:18:03.680 And they turn the lights off to pretend that they're going to eat
00:18:06.080 look at this stood up pretending to meet her to mend her lamp but she put it off then both of them
00:18:11.460 pretended to eat the husband and the wife but they really went to bed hungry just so their guest
00:18:16.280 doesn't feel bad they're eating their food in the morning the Ansari went to Allah's messenger who 1.00
00:18:21.180 said tonight Allah laughed or wondered at your action then Allah revealed but give them immigrants
00:18:27.800 preference over themselves even though they were in need of that and whoever is saved from the
00:18:32.500 Such are they who will be successful
00:18:36.200 This is a man 1.00
00:18:37.820 With a non-mahram 1.00
00:18:39.580 Man and wife 1.00
00:18:41.400 Non-mahram man is hosting 0.90
00:18:43.340 And they turned off the lights 1.00
00:18:44.780 And gave the last dish
00:18:45.540 Now we can come and say
00:18:46.340 Hold on a second bro 0.98
00:18:47.720 How is another man 1.00
00:18:48.640 And his wife 1.00
00:18:50.040 Eating in front of a non-mahram man 1.00
00:18:51.620 Would any of you 1.00
00:18:52.800 Brothers if I said
00:18:53.560 Imagine you and your wife 0.96
00:18:54.920 And there's another man
00:18:55.420 This was their urf
00:18:57.460 There was nothing wrong with this
00:18:58.600 The reason I'm mentioning this
00:18:59.580 Is because
00:18:59.960 It doesn't go back to the thing
00:19:01.320 But it shows you
00:19:02.320 this thing of woman being hidden not seeing etc this that this is not about that now i'll give
00:19:07.600 you another situation this is very very important okay this here ibn al-qaym even explains this is
00:19:14.160 a female companion inviting other male companions to her house to feed them i want to give for the
00:19:19.680 sadaqa yes fatma reported that uh abu amr bin hafs divorced her up her absolutely when he was
00:19:28.320 away from home and he sent his angel to her with some bali she was displeased with him and then
00:19:33.360 when he said i swear by allah that you have no claim on us she went to allah's messenger and
00:19:38.400 mentioned that to him he said there is no maintenance due to you from him and he commanded
00:19:43.200 her to spend the idda in the house of um shariq but then he said the first salam he wanted her
00:19:49.120 to do the period in um um shariq's house that is a woman he said the person said oh hold on a second
00:19:54.400 that is a woman who my companions visit so better she spends this period in the house of ibn
00:20:00.240 ibn um muhtum who was a blind man yes for he is blind man and you can put off your garments
00:20:05.520 and when the idda is over inform me she said when my period of idda is over etc etc etc 0.79
00:20:10.240 so the prophet said go to um sharik's house then he said oh hold on a second that is a female
00:20:15.520 companion of mine even al-qaym says she was a woman who used to serve female male companions
00:20:21.520 who would come to her house and give them food yes so which is showing what showing that subhanallah
00:20:28.160 this thing of woman being covered except look it's better i'm not saying it's not uh brother
00:20:33.760 mohammed ali is correct it is better i'm saying but we cannot come and say now it is haram there 0.99
00:20:38.800 has to be evidence brought forth that woman cannot do dawah they have to be secluded in the houses 0.87
00:20:43.200 etc yes all of this stuff pertaining to this this is an evidence that this woman was feeding male 0.54
00:20:49.040 or companions in her house there was nothing of free mixing how is she not talking she's serving
00:20:53.520 them which shows what that the process had no issue with this subhanallah another case for 0.59
00:20:58.900 example the measure of allah went out for one of his expeditions then when he came back a black
00:21:03.000 slave girl came to him and said oh measure of allah i took an oath if allah returned you safely
00:21:07.860 i would beat the dove before and sing so the measure of allah said to her if you have taken 0.68
00:21:13.680 then of then beat it and if you have not then do not so so she started to sing and beat the dove
00:21:19.420 like singing and abu bakir entered while she was beating it then ali entered while she was
00:21:24.220 beating it then uthman entered while she'd be so she was carrying on singing with the dove
00:21:28.080 and then when umar entered so she put the dove under her and sat upon it so the messiah was
00:21:32.980 said indeed a shaytan is afraid of you oh umar i was sitting while she beat it and then abu bakir
00:21:38.880 entered while she was beating it and then ali entered while she was beating it and then
00:21:41.940 of man until she's beaten it and then when you entered umar she put the duff away meaning umar
00:21:46.320 was a bit harsher and this is where we say brown sisters yes we respect it umar was sharper and
00:21:51.780 there is another instance yes if i'm not mistaken um in bukhari or uh muslim where the process
00:21:57.580 yes is given a lecture and the woman will be very vocal yes and umar i've heard this and walked in
00:22:03.320 the house all of the women ran away and hid and umar got angry and he said something very profound
00:22:07.920 I want you guys to understand
00:22:08.800 Here when they were raising their voices
00:22:11.520 And talking to the Prophet Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam
00:22:13.040 The Prophet Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam had no issue with it 0.62
00:22:15.880 The moment Umar ibn Khattab came 0.97
00:22:18.000 They hid
00:22:18.420 Umar got angry and said
00:22:19.760 Do you fear me more than Allah's messenger
00:22:22.620 This is critical here
00:22:24.540 Just because certain companions had a more staunch view etc
00:22:27.740 Does not mean that is the halal view
00:22:29.840 Because here the Prophet Sallallahu Alaihi Wasallam had nothing 0.99
00:22:31.660 He did not object to it
00:22:33.360 Until Umar ibn Khattab came and he got angry and said
00:22:35.160 Do you fear me more than Allah's messenger
00:22:36.920 meaning that's wrong 0.99
00:22:38.540 you should feel 0.69
00:22:39.760 Allah's mission 0.99
00:22:40.160 if Allah's mission 1.00
00:22:40.740 had no issue
00:22:41.280 that means that
00:22:41.960 is permissible
00:22:42.940 let's go back
00:22:44.100 to the video
00:22:44.500 inshallah
00:22:44.800 and let's see
00:22:45.340 the other points
00:22:45.860 inshallah
00:22:46.080 with brother
00:22:46.440 Muhammad Ali
00:22:47.460 may Allah bless
00:22:47.900 and preserve him
00:22:48.420 has to say
00:22:49.040 now some people
00:22:50.920 will say
00:22:51.380 what they will say
00:22:51.820 here but
00:22:52.220 she was asked
00:22:53.820 sahaba would come
00:22:54.680 and ask
00:22:54.960 they'll say
00:22:55.940 this day and night
00:22:56.540 and when we go to them
00:22:58.340 which I'm going to do
00:22:59.220 show you the verses
00:22:59.820 in the Quran
00:23:00.300 that addresses
00:23:00.740 the wives of the prophet
00:23:01.440 they'll say 0.96
00:23:01.900 oh this is just 0.99
00:23:02.420 for the wives of the prophet
00:23:03.140 but when it comes
00:23:04.680 to this issue
00:23:05.260 they'll say
00:23:06.900 oh no look we have this example okay Aisha was asked yeah it is correct who was Aisha
00:23:12.340 she was the mother of the believers or the other wives they were the mother of the believers
00:23:17.380 so it's like your own mother and they will call her our mother when they would talk to her and
00:23:22.580 who were those people going asking were the sahaba the people with the purest hearts
00:23:26.660 and the best of behaviors okay so here i would say just like a brother like to disagree with
00:23:32.020 Prophet Muhammad Ali here
00:23:32.720 Not to my opinion
00:23:34.960 According to the Quran and the Sunnah 0.69
00:23:36.000 If we say that they are the mother of the believer
00:23:37.460 This is the title given to them
00:23:38.460 If they are genuinely like our mothers
00:23:40.080 Then why is it that
00:23:41.500 For example
00:23:42.180 Being married to them was forbidden 1.00
00:23:44.160 Allah
00:23:44.500 Or they said they cannot marry
00:23:46.060 Why is that given?
00:23:47.160 If they're like our mothers 0.97
00:23:47.680 It's a no-brainer 0.58
00:23:48.440 Number two 1.00
00:23:49.260 If they're our mother 0.98
00:23:50.160 Why did Aisha and her have to wear hijab? 0.80
00:23:52.600 When Abu Bakr and Omar was buried in the house 1.00
00:23:54.820 She would walk around in hijab 1.00
00:23:55.760 They're dead 1.00
00:23:56.060 They're not alive
00:23:56.580 She doesn't have to 1.00
00:23:57.400 She'll wear the hijab 1.00
00:23:58.040 Why was she teaching behind the veil? 1.00
00:23:59.580 If she's our mother 1.00
00:24:00.600 Why would my mother teach behind the veil? Why would my mother wear hijab in front of me? 0.99
00:24:03.560 Why would my mother be told that I cannot marry her? Do you get what I'm trying to say?
00:24:07.320 So it's very clear that this example, I hear what he's saying, it doesn't count because then
00:24:13.960 these issues wouldn't happen. She cannot wear the hijab, etc. But rather she did. So that's
00:24:18.840 an evidence. That's my opinion. That's an evidence clearly from the Quran and the Sunnah that this
00:24:23.800 thing of being the mothers doesn't apply because she did, you know, and she taught many, many
00:24:28.120 I'm not talking about non-Muslims, a random Joe Schmoe, whatever.
00:24:31.940 They were the best of Sahaba.
00:24:34.720 And they would go ask the Prophet who were their believers,
00:24:37.360 who nobody could marry after the Prophet. 0.52
00:24:40.580 And we understand their status.
00:24:42.440 And because they know many things in the household of the Prophet Muhammad
00:24:45.560 that other people didn't know.
00:24:47.480 So they would go and ask Aisha.
00:24:49.620 Now, we're saying, look, Aisha, she was their mother.
00:24:53.080 They were the Sahaba, the best of mannerisms and hearts.
00:24:56.620 But not just that.
00:24:58.120 Allah tells them in the Qur'an
00:24:59.400 وَإِذَا سَأَلْتُمُهُنَّ مَتَاعًا فَاسْأَلُهُنَّ مِنْ وَرَاءِ حِجَابًا
00:25:03.040 If you ask them for something, ask them behind the barrier. 0.92
00:25:05.820 The wife's the prophet.
00:25:07.340 That we're saying, these are people with the best of hearts.
00:25:09.240 They were the mothers of the believers.
00:25:10.360 But Allah is still saying, ask them behind the barrier.
00:25:13.020 Allah says, 0.77
00:25:13.520 ذلكم أطهروا لقلوبكم وقلوبهن
00:25:16.340 That is more pure for your hearts and their hearts.
00:25:20.460 Okay, good.
00:25:20.860 So here's a valid point.
00:25:21.700 What he's saying is basically, this is seen as our mothers.
00:25:24.600 And even yet to Allah gives that thing. 0.98
00:25:27.100 And this is where I say he has a valid opinion 1.00
00:25:29.400 In the sense where it is better 0.95
00:25:31.420 And this is specifically for the prophet's wives though 0.64
00:25:33.580 Let's make it very specific
00:25:34.360 Being in their homes, etc 0.87
00:25:35.900 It is better
00:25:36.780 Now can this be applied to the other woman as well?
00:25:38.760 Yes, it is better 1.00
00:25:40.180 That unnecessary interaction between men and women 0.99
00:25:43.140 100% haq
00:25:44.300 What Muhammad Ali is saying is haq
00:25:46.120 Unnecessary, unneeded, etc
00:25:48.960 Like for me to just go and speak to her sister
00:25:50.500 For what reason, no reason
00:25:51.500 Look, she's a woman, I'm a man
00:25:54.000 These things are bound to happen
00:25:55.700 It doesn't matter how pious you are, brother
00:25:57.060 It doesn't matter
00:25:57.740 It is human nature
00:25:59.840 And I agree that it is better to be safe
00:26:02.340 Better
00:26:02.720 However
00:26:03.640 We cannot come and say it's haram
00:26:05.900 That's the issue here
00:26:06.420 We cannot come and say
00:26:07.200 It is
00:26:08.280 No, no, no
00:26:08.720 You can come and say it's better
00:26:09.580 In certain situations 0.56
00:26:10.360 But this doesn't apply to the dawah
00:26:11.800 Because in the dawah
00:26:12.560 We can even say 1.00
00:26:13.240 There is a need
00:26:14.880 For people like Sister Cora 0.99
00:26:16.140 And Itachi
00:26:17.280 And Muslim Mum 0.74
00:26:18.780 And by the way
00:26:19.520 I'm not trying to overpraise them
00:26:20.760 Because look
00:26:21.280 They might come and do stuff in the future
00:26:22.620 That we will correct them
00:26:23.780 With all your respect
00:26:24.400 Cora, whoever it is
00:26:25.420 And I expect the same with them 0.89
00:26:26.500 With me
00:26:26.780 There might come at times where they might share a platform with me
00:26:29.840 They might come here, we might do a video together, whatever it is
00:26:31.720 But then, there might come a time where we might correct them
00:26:34.480 So I'm not trying to over-praise them and say they're infallible
00:26:36.620 No, no, we're just saying there is a need for them 1.00
00:26:38.400 Especially with radical feminists and nefarghers who are rejecting hadith 0.99
00:26:40.920 Call Imam Bukhari a pedophile 0.91
00:26:42.200 Rejecting, subhanAllah, so much things 1.00
00:26:45.340 Saying Allah is a she, this, that, nonsense, kufar 1.00
00:26:48.520 Stabbers of kufar 1.00
00:26:50.060 If there is any time that we need more sisters that represent Islam in a better way
00:26:53.860 For my daughters, etc. 1.00
00:26:55.660 Is these women 0.96
00:26:56.460 So there isn't it. I'm not even making a message based on need.
00:27:01.520 Put that to a side. We need that.
00:27:03.260 I'm saying based on the Quran and the evidence that I'm giving you from Imam Bukhari, the Quran.
00:27:06.980 Yes, nowhere it specifies that a woman cannot give ta'wah. 0.99
00:27:10.320 The evidence has to be produced that they cannot. 0.99
00:27:13.200 Not speculations of it looks like that.
00:27:15.220 No, no, no. Is there clear evidence?
00:27:17.280 Because we even know, Bim Ba'ath, Shaq Bim Ba'ath even said, and many of them,
00:27:20.620 that a woman can give ta'wah on TV as long as she's correctly covered. 0.78
00:27:23.680 She can do ta'wah. 0.97
00:27:24.200 Why did Allah Azza wa Jal reveal the hijab? 1.00
00:27:26.120 The hijab is a barrier 1.00
00:27:27.480 It's a barrier that the woman makes between her and the other person 1.00
00:27:30.440 Now the danger is when you have a niqabi woman and hijabi woman 1.00
00:27:33.520 Coming and saying we're going to give down 1.00
00:27:35.540 It gives wrong perception 1.00
00:27:36.840 They're more dangerous than a woman that is not covered 1.00
00:27:39.700 Because a woman is not covered 1.00
00:27:40.700 You know that she's doing wrong 1.00
00:27:41.720 You will know
00:27:42.620 Okay look she's doing wrong 0.98
00:27:43.840 She's coming out
00:27:44.660 Okay here I didn't understand what Prophet Muhammad Ali meant 1.00
00:27:46.940 Because what do you mean a woman who doesn't wear the hijab 1.00
00:27:48.940 Is a bad perception 1.00
00:27:51.500 Because what you're saying is
00:27:53.100 Because she's given dawah
00:27:54.220 How is that bad perception
00:27:55.120 I'm trying to understand genuinely 1.00
00:27:55.940 If she's wearing the correct hijab 1.00
00:27:57.580 And she's doing dawah
00:27:58.780 She's not there chitchat 1.00
00:27:59.680 They're just messing around 0.98
00:28:00.400 How does that give a better perception 1.00
00:28:02.320 Like if a non 1.00
00:28:02.920 It's like you're saying basically 1.00
00:28:03.700 If she was not wearing a hijab 1.00
00:28:04.940 It would make it look better 1.00
00:28:06.640 It's like okay
00:28:06.980 We don't expect that
00:28:07.720 She doesn't look Muslim per se 1.00
00:28:08.800 Yeah but the one who's wearing the hijab 1.00
00:28:10.780 That's a garment 1.00
00:28:12.300 We need to carry ourselves better
00:28:13.360 Which another video
00:28:14.440 I'm going to talk about 0.96
00:28:15.180 Being harsh in the dawah 0.78
00:28:16.160 Etc
00:28:16.780 Or you know
00:28:17.640 This tit for tat
00:28:18.460 And winning thing
00:28:19.340 Which I totally
00:28:20.360 90% agree with
00:28:22.040 Brother Muhammad Ali
00:28:22.600 Which I'm going to do a separate video 0.95
00:28:23.740 Which he is very very correct
00:28:25.720 The way you carry yourself
00:28:26.620 100% on point
00:28:28.380 But here 0.54
00:28:29.980 Why would she give a bad perception 0.99
00:28:31.300 If she's wearing the hijab 1.00
00:28:32.420 And the niqab 1.00
00:28:32.860 And she's carrying herself 1.00
00:28:33.820 In the right way
00:28:34.300 If she's not 0.60
00:28:35.180 Yes 1.00
00:28:35.520 If she's wearing a niqab 1.00
00:28:36.600 Doing dawah 1.00
00:28:37.020 And using F language
00:28:37.860 And this language
00:28:38.320 Etc 1.00
00:28:38.580 She's wrong 0.93
00:28:39.700 And yes
00:28:40.420 There were some videos
00:28:40.960 Showed that
00:28:41.260 Sister Cora
00:28:41.980 Saying that
00:28:42.600 May Allah forgive her
00:28:43.280 She was a mistake
00:28:43.980 She was a human being
00:28:44.520 If it's that perspective
00:28:46.000 I understand 0.99
00:28:46.480 But her giving dawah 0.98
00:28:48.120 To say that 1.00
00:28:48.680 Her being a niqab 1.00
00:28:49.840 And giving dawah
00:28:50.380 Gives the wrong perception
00:28:50.960 I have to disagree with her
00:28:51.680 We have evidence
00:28:52.240 From the Quran and the sunnah 1.00
00:28:53.320 That a woman can give dawah 1.00
00:28:54.760 In a way which is not the proper way 1.00
00:28:56.640 Which a Muslim woman should be 1.00
00:28:57.920 And she's coming out 1.00
00:28:58.600 So people would know
00:28:59.640 So nobody would be confused
00:29:01.080 But when an al-qabi or an hijab
00:29:02.600 People can be confused
00:29:03.860 It gives the wrong perception 1.00
00:29:05.480 And other women that are 1.00
00:29:06.940 Practicing Islam or following the religion
00:29:09.140 They may start thinking 1.00
00:29:09.960 Oh that's okay
00:29:10.480 I should do this too
00:29:11.300 Okay good
00:29:11.780 So this is where I disagree with
00:29:12.940 Brother Muhammad Ali
00:29:13.460 May Allah bless
00:29:13.920 Preserve him inshallah
00:29:14.600 And increase him in good life
00:29:16.000 Alhamdulillah 0.99
00:29:16.440 To serve the deen 0.85
00:29:17.320 To say that the fact that 1.00
00:29:19.560 That women are doing dawah 1.00
00:29:20.820 And gives a ba'ar 0.84
00:29:21.380 Basically what Prophet Muhammad Ali is saying is 1.00
00:29:23.040 The other system I watch and say I want to be like her
00:29:24.620 There's nothing wrong with that
00:29:26.240 Because they're not doing anything wrong 0.96
00:29:27.120 Habibi 1.00
00:29:27.440 Like we can't make them 1.00
00:29:29.560 You hold the opinion
00:29:30.580 100% I agree
00:29:31.220 But to make it seem as if they're doing something wrong
00:29:33.540 They're doing what Allah ordered them to do
00:29:35.040 By being covered up correctly 0.99
00:29:36.100 They're doing that 1.00
00:29:37.040 What Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala 1.00
00:29:37.820 Clearly allowed 0.96
00:29:38.680 There's nothing in the Quran 0.98
00:29:39.620 The sunnah from the salaf 1.00
00:29:40.540 Anywhere
00:29:41.020 Saying that they are not allowed to do it
00:29:43.300 Unless there is an opinion 1.00
00:29:44.420 That certain mashayikh follow 1.00
00:29:46.740 100% 1.00
00:29:47.440 If you follow the opinion
00:29:48.200 Stick by the opinion
00:29:49.540 100%
00:29:50.680 However, then those people who follow their opinion to now say that they are doing wrong
00:29:55.540 That is an issue
00:29:57.040 Because you have to respect opinion
00:29:57.940 Say, look, I believe
00:29:59.080 If Brother Muhammad Ali said, my opinion is this
00:30:01.780 100%
00:30:03.420 But if Muhammad Ali is saying this is the opinion, this is wrong
00:30:06.520 Because there is no confrontation
00:30:10.200 There is no thing when it comes to these matters
00:30:13.040 Yes?
00:30:13.820 Of difference of opinion, you cannot come and say you're wrong or right
00:30:15.900 A matter of difference of opinion is respect of difference of opinion
00:30:17.700 Valid
00:30:18.400 I'm not talking about fringe opinions
00:30:19.740 It's not a fringe opinion 1.00
00:30:20.460 This is clear from the Quran and Sunnah that a woman can do dawah
00:30:23.620 There is nothing that says in our tradition that a woman cannot do dawah 1.00
00:30:27.560 It can be more dangerous 1.00
00:30:28.500 The purpose behind the hijab is to make a barrier between you and the opposite jinn 1.00
00:30:32.440 It is not for the woman to go and start engaging with men 1.00
00:30:35.000 And doing dawah to non-mahrim men and this and that 1.00
00:30:37.340 It's not a necessity when we have a man fulfilling this role 0.99
00:30:40.940 Dawah is a 1.00
00:30:42.020 Okay good, here I agree 1.00
00:30:44.800 If there's not a necessity, let's say argument's sake 0.99
00:30:46.580 Even then, yes, I believe there is nothing wrong with women giving dawah
00:30:50.100 Other women hearing it from their voice 0.98
00:30:52.620 Them is better 1.00
00:30:53.800 I believe it's better
00:30:55.380 Now at this time that we're living 1.00
00:30:56.780 With all these nefakis that I mentioned 1.00
00:30:58.360 Trying to misguide the woman 1.00
00:31:00.220 There is 100 billion percent more need for them 1.00
00:31:04.540 And I'm not even using 1.00
00:31:05.680 I'm saying even if those nefakis didn't exist 1.00
00:31:07.500 These feminists 1.00
00:31:08.100 Trying to mislead people to kuffer 1.00
00:31:10.200 Even if they didn't exist 1.00
00:31:11.500 They can do tawa 1.00
00:31:12.120 Let alone 1.00
00:31:13.720 We might come and say
00:31:14.680 There is not a need
00:31:15.680 But if a sister said
00:31:17.280 No I'm saying you don't have a need 0.99
00:31:18.240 But I want to do tawa 1.00
00:31:18.900 I can never stop her 1.00
00:31:19.760 It's fully halal 1.00
00:31:21.300 However, especially at this time
00:31:22.980 There is more of a need 0.95
00:31:24.000 Allah in the Quran 1.00
00:31:25.060 Says in the verse of the hijab 1.00
00:31:27.500 Do not let them not hit with their shoes 1.00
00:31:31.220 Make noise with their shoes
00:31:32.340 Because then people will start
00:31:34.600 To be attracted to them
00:31:36.620 Or think about them
00:31:37.860 Noise with their shoes
00:31:39.340 Let alone now talking
00:31:40.340 And your voice and laughing
00:31:41.580 Here again 0.91
00:31:42.760 This is talking about the woman
00:31:44.140 Who used to use that 1.00
00:31:45.160 To call women to evil
00:31:46.700 We cannot compare that 1.00
00:31:48.700 And say okay
00:31:49.200 Just because what Allah's seen is 0.99
00:31:50.520 Don't even do that with your shoes 0.98
00:31:51.780 And the voice can be awra, etc
00:31:53.380 100% 1.00
00:31:54.020 But this applies to a mushrik woman 1.00
00:31:56.000 Who used to do that 1.00
00:31:57.900 To call women to evil
00:31:59.060 Like call to evil 0.64
00:32:00.040 So the intent was evil
00:32:01.160 Do you know what I'm trying to say?
00:32:02.280 And this can apply to anything 1.00
00:32:03.520 You can have a sister in full niqab 1.00
00:32:04.960 And she can do a specific 0.99
00:32:06.460 Let's say in today's office 0.99
00:32:07.660 A specific gesture 0.99
00:32:08.660 Meaning she's calling men to
00:32:10.300 Haram 0.62
00:32:11.780 So the issue here is that
00:32:13.260 We can't use that 1.00
00:32:14.220 What the mushrik woman used to do 1.00
00:32:15.880 To call men to evil 1.00
00:32:16.880 And then apply that to a sister 0.53
00:32:18.280 And say look here
00:32:18.800 even the bangles are not allowed let alone speaking now laughing etc he's right now if a
00:32:24.260 sister's going there and then you're doing some jokes and that is a lie and that you know i 1.00
00:32:29.140 understand it depends like for a woman because the man has the wrong inclination that's why when 1.00
00:32:34.920 they do studies can men women be friends women say yeah 100 because they don't see the men like
00:32:38.460 that but from a man's perspective it's that yo that's why with me like when i do dawah i sometimes
00:32:43.140 try to crack jokes not both genders why not to have a flirtatious thing i would be like because
00:32:48.380 always refer to them as a sister sister why just so they don't see us religious people as a morbid 0.72
00:32:52.780 you know it's all about you know death and this that i do that for the sake of allah subhanahu
00:32:56.940 ta'ala do you get it and subhanallah but from a woman's perspective if a woman does it let's say
00:33:02.140 sister kora we touch you we're muslim mom the opposite side can take that wrong now i'm not
00:33:06.540 saying there's nothing wrong with smiling or laughing yes but we have to be a bit careful so 0.74
00:33:10.300 i do hear what he's saying there imagine even in acts of worship when the woman go and do pilgrimage
00:33:17.820 when they do the hadith would say they would do they would lower their voices with it
00:33:24.060 would do it quietly if the imam makes a mistake the the man would say subhanallah would raise
00:33:28.620 their voice the woman would make a clap she wouldn't even speak in the prayer to correct
00:33:34.220 why is allah making these these rulings in the prayer wouldn't it make more sense that allah
00:33:40.220 said it's okay in the prayer say allahu akbar that is for allah to say do this rather than
00:33:45.420 it's okay to go and in a youtube channel whatever in front of everyone start talking chit-chatting
00:33:49.340 with men and and doing that okay he's right look if there's any chit-chat there's something right
00:33:53.180 but when it comes to the salah and when it comes to forms of ibadah of doing hajj or whatever
00:33:56.780 this is a matter of khushu we have something called khushu which you know you have to be
00:34:00.460 focused yes that's what was said the best rose for the woman is the back uh and for the men is
00:34:05.740 the front because of this you get these protocols were put in place when they're walking etc these
00:34:09.740 measures are in place to avoid the fitna 100 percent but we can say that is matters to ibadah
00:34:15.260 yes why because if someone's praying salah a brother who's not married and here's a sister
00:34:19.420 saying sorry forgive me yeah okay his heart might be basically like yo i need to get married speak
00:34:25.100 out there who's that sister yeah we men are created in that way so i think that's why the
00:34:29.980 clapping for hundreds it makes sense in matters of ibadah in that sense yeah i'm just saying it
00:34:33.980 can be a hikmah based on that but we can't come and then apply that because we have many ample
00:34:38.300 of evidences of many companies that for example we have arguments which i'll show you umar when he
00:34:44.780 appointed asma asma bin to abdullah yes sorry al-shifa bin abdullah to go and manage the
00:34:50.540 markets she was responsible for managing the markets yes and then we have a narration some
00:34:54.860 weekend etc when the woman about the mahr and said umar bin qatab this is what allah decreed
00:34:59.660 and umar said the man the woman is right the man is wrong in this situation yes there's
00:35:04.620 it's weakened okay it's weakened etc but we know many instances i can give you many examples where
00:35:09.720 women i've given you a couple yes that they were vocal they were outright vocal they did not come
00:35:15.920 the unsurdy woman was praised for it they were asking questions pertaining to you know intimacy
00:35:20.060 etc yes the process and praise them so we can't get specific verses when we look at holistically
00:35:25.600 have anywhere has it been anywhere yes the asha and her teaching etc these things are there there
00:35:33.020 is nothing that says they are not allowed to speak for example imam nawawi uh imam nawawi's
00:35:39.440 conditions for issuing fatawa did not include being male later scholars use this as evidence
00:35:44.260 that qualified women may teach and give legal opinions yes al-bukhari and um al-darda classical 1.00
00:35:51.500 scholars recorded that um al-darda was a jurist whose teaching circles were attended by men 0.98
00:35:56.560 one fatwa summarized in the classical report stated men used to learn from her and seek
00:36:01.140 jurisprudence knowledge from her it also notes that khalif abdul al-malik attended her lessons
00:36:05.940 you had a ruler who attended her lessons subhanallah ibn al-kafeen on female scholarship
00:36:10.340 ibn al-kafeen describes sotayta bint al-mihamli as virtuous and knowledgeable he recorded that
00:36:16.260 she taught quran and religious sciences and that leading scholars praised her for her knowledge yes
00:36:22.020 ibn hajar wrote biography biographies of women who taught hadith to men for example regarding
00:36:26.740 zaid ibn al-qalam he wrote with her death the people's people lost a great deal of hadith
00:36:32.900 knowledge he documented male scholars learning from her and transmitting from her okay so this
00:36:38.660 thing of you can't and these are non-mahram men if it's not mahram then if she can speak islamic
00:36:43.300 dawah was dawah given to which one's better giving dawah to your fellow muslims or giving
00:36:47.700 dawah to non-muslims if this applies here nowhere it says that this is only applied to muslim men
00:36:52.820 no the non-mahram is a non-mahram non-mahram is a non-mahram yes so we see evidence is
00:36:58.740 ample event of evidences i'll give you another one ibn al-qaym wrote extensively about dow in
00:37:03.300 his work such as miftah and zaad al-maad he described calling people to allah allah's
00:37:09.940 path of the prophets and the following sighting say this is my way like i quoted the verse before
00:37:14.180 no one says that that's only for men he does not say they did not come and say this is only for
00:37:18.500 for men because Allah did not say it is only for men. For example, contemporary scholars who
00:37:22.860 permit women to give dawah often reason as follows. Ibn Taymiyyah and Ibn Al-Qayyim considered
00:37:27.820 dawah a duty upon Muslims according to knowledge and ability. Okay, it did not say that for example
00:37:34.100 this is only for people of men. You don't see them specifying and saying this is only for men.
00:37:41.300 Okay, so that's the point. InshaAllah, let's go to the last point inshaAllah of the video.
00:37:45.200 And it's like, subhanAllah people, you need to understand.
00:37:48.780 This is common sense at this point. 0.81
00:37:50.400 For a Muslim woman, always the more hidden the place for her, the best it is for her.
00:37:55.060 Now, people may, look, I'm bringing you the Quran and Sunnah.
00:37:57.940 You don't like what I say, and I'm not saying it for your liking. 0.97
00:38:00.840 I'm not saying it for your liking.
00:38:02.180 I'm saying it for the sake of Allah.
00:38:03.680 If you are a person who fears Allah, who believes in Allah and the Messenger,
00:38:06.280 who wants to submit what the Quran and Sunnah say, here's what it says.
00:38:09.580 You know, in the prayer, the Prophet ﷺ would say,
00:38:11.960 the best rows for women 1.00
00:38:12.940 are the ones in the back 1.00
00:38:13.940 and the worst are the ones
00:38:14.960 in the front.
00:38:15.400 Why? 1.00
00:38:15.680 Because the woman is showing more. 0.99
00:38:17.600 Prophet ﷺ said 0.96
00:38:18.340 the Salatul Mar'a TV
00:38:19.500 that the prayer of a woman
00:38:21.040 in her house
00:38:21.720 or in her home 0.90
00:38:22.440 is better than her prayer
00:38:23.560 in her courtyard
00:38:24.260 because it's more hidden.
00:38:25.900 And her prayer in a chamber
00:38:27.160 is better than her prayer 0.53
00:38:28.700 in her home. 0.74
00:38:29.700 Like the more hidden
00:38:30.860 the better it is.
00:38:32.480 You're defeating 1.00
00:38:33.060 the purpose of the hijab 1.00
00:38:34.080 when you're going out
00:38:34.800 you're speaking to other
00:38:35.540 people hear a voice
00:38:36.320 see your face
00:38:36.860 or see your body
00:38:38.640 or this and that.
00:38:39.820 Especially in this day and age
00:38:40.940 where you were your sisters, you know,
00:38:42.800 AI and what people can do with pictures and images
00:38:44.880 and all of this stuff.
00:38:46.240 Yeah, he's right.
00:38:46.940 With AI and stuff like that, 0.93
00:38:47.860 I would not encourage sisters who are doing dawah 1.00
00:38:49.440 or even being in public sphere, 1.00
00:38:51.300 wear niqab. 1.00
00:38:51.960 Because AI and stuff like that, 0.82
00:38:53.320 mad this has happened.
00:38:54.060 And he's 100% right with that.
00:38:55.380 When it comes to, 1.00
00:38:56.040 it's better for a woman to be in a house, 1.00
00:38:57.260 et cetera, 100%. 1.00
00:38:58.040 These are things that is better to do.
00:39:00.860 However, it does not mean it is haram if you do otherwise.
00:39:04.340 These are things that's better 1.00
00:39:05.160 because otherwise Allah, 1.00
00:39:06.160 and his mission would have made matters. 0.71
00:39:08.560 Absolutely clear.
00:39:09.480 Absolutely clear.
00:39:10.360 Okay.
00:39:10.940 so there is a fitna between men and women however we're not talking about general just
00:39:15.420 chit-chatting etc we're talking about women who are doing dawah defending islam and have knowledge
00:39:20.620 and are propagating and being a role model in a time of error where we have nefaqi feminists
00:39:24.860 who are trying to misguide the woman it is absolutely needed and forget darura yes forget 0.76
00:39:29.180 that forget that let alone we have evidences that's why when brother muhammad ali may allah
00:39:34.860 bless and preserve him and his dawah amazing amazing dawah may allah i genuinely believe
00:39:38.780 this and he knows this yeah genuinely when he says anyone that fears allah i understand what
00:39:44.300 he's trying to say but then what he does is when opinions come from the quran that i've showed you
00:39:48.300 yes giving you quotes of uh you know even taymiah ibn al-qayyim imam bukhari the quran the message
00:39:53.740 of allah you know abu bakar ali uthman so many ample amount of evidence of brothers sisters to
00:39:58.860 subhanallah show you there is an absolute legitimacy that a woman can do dawah yes it's not my words i
00:40:04.460 am a nobody this is the words of the great giants i've said to you this is allah subhanahu wa ta'ala
00:40:08.060 Allah did not specify
00:40:09.280 In join and forbid evil
00:40:11.060 For both men and women
00:40:12.080 There was no stipulations
00:40:14.100 That they cannot do it
00:40:16.300 So all I'm seeing is this
00:40:17.500 Brother Muhammad Ali's opinion
00:40:19.020 Is absolutely legitimate
00:40:20.260 And it is valid
00:40:21.100 If you follow that
00:40:22.440 I 100% respect you
00:40:23.760 One thing I do not respect
00:40:25.420 Is however
00:40:26.160 Those people in the comment section
00:40:27.540 Etc
00:40:27.800 Of thinking there is
00:40:29.080 The opinion
00:40:29.980 Which there is
00:40:31.080 And with all due respect
00:40:31.820 And I believe
00:40:33.060 At this specific time
00:40:34.060 Specifically we need 1.00
00:40:34.840 Many sisters like 1.00
00:40:35.540 Sister Cora
00:40:36.060 Itachi
00:40:36.860 And Muslim Mom
00:40:37.840 To be role models 1.00
00:40:38.700 To our sisters
00:40:39.380 Who have been misguided 1.00
00:40:40.040 By these nefakis 1.00
00:40:40.960 Yes you've got married women 1.00
00:40:42.140 Who are going to concerts
00:40:43.280 Married men 1.00
00:40:44.160 Shame on you 1.00
00:40:44.980 Sending your wife 1.00
00:40:46.020 Doed up 0.99
00:40:46.940 Makeup
00:40:47.740 Lipstick
00:40:48.300 Lip shining
00:40:48.940 Everything
00:40:49.720 Going to concerts
00:40:50.900 And dancing to
00:40:52.640 Other performers etc
00:40:53.900 Allah
00:40:54.780 Shame on you man 1.00
00:40:55.640 And this is what I talk about
00:40:57.060 I believe what Muhammad Ali is saying
00:40:58.080 Is right in these specific instances
00:40:59.340 Sadly
00:41:00.120 But when it comes to 1.00
00:41:00.980 Muslim women doing dawah 0.52
00:41:01.900 It is absolutely permissible 1.00
00:41:03.380 And halal
00:41:03.940 And if anyone says 0.67
00:41:05.200 It is not
00:41:05.800 And claims that this
00:41:06.620 Is the only opinion
00:41:07.340 You have to bring evidence to your claims
00:41:09.480 Other than that, both Muhammad Ali's opinion
00:41:11.640 Well, what he's quoted
00:41:13.120 And what I've quoted from the same sources
00:41:14.620 Is absolutely legitimate
00:41:16.300 And I will end on this 0.97
00:41:17.140 Abu Bakr was married to a woman 0.76
00:41:19.420 And that woman, subhanAllah, was asked
00:41:21.380 He said, who was the best of husbands you had? 0.96
00:41:23.520 And she said, amongst the young, it was Jafar
00:41:25.500 Amongst the older things
00:41:28.120 And he said, it was Abu Bakr
00:41:30.060 No, no, Ali was married
00:41:31.580 She was married to Jafar
00:41:32.900 Then she was married to Abu Bakr, of the oldest
00:41:35.200 And then guess what Ali says
00:41:37.100 He says
00:41:37.640 She was praising her ex-husbands
00:41:40.260 And said you've got nothing left for me
00:41:41.880 Ali said and joked
00:41:42.680 And he said to his children
00:41:44.540 He said look your mother has left nothing for me
00:41:46.300 And she had children from Abu Bakr and Jaffir 0.97
00:41:48.220 The Urf was completely different back then 0.82
00:41:50.940 Completely different
00:41:51.880 Imagine your wife coming and talking about her ex-husbands
00:41:54.220 And praising them
00:41:54.760 Brother you were divorced on the spot 0.95
00:41:56.740 Look at the Urf is completely different 0.62
00:41:59.800 That's all I wanted to say inshallah
00:42:00.820 Until next time
00:42:02.280 This is just an opinion that I want to show you guys
00:42:05.960 The other side
00:42:06.480 Assalamualaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatuh