Ali Dawah - July 26, 2023


PHD ARAB ATHEIST VS MUSLIM - SURPRISING END


Episode Stats


Length

27 minutes

Words per minute

211.1227

Word count

5,807

Sentence count

1

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

22

sentences flagged

Hate speech

17

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, I have a conversation with a PhD astrophysics student who asked me a simple question. Do you believe that DNA has information? Is there intelligence behind it? Do you have objective evidence? Is it possible for DNA to have information?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00.000 can you measure can you can you measure dark matter yes no you can't oh my god you see the 1.00
00:00:06.360 do you realize you're speaking with a fucking phd in astrophysics well you're doing bad you're 0.99
00:00:10.200 doing bad just imagine the people back in the day when they would have to travel certain 0.99
00:00:17.100 distances for months or even years what is one thing that they would carry with them
00:00:21.240 the quran why because they did not have it on their mobile devices or their gadgets 0.86
00:00:26.100 brothers and sisters imagine you have a app the qurani app which not only shows you how much
00:00:32.220 rewards you get but reminds you to read the quran gives you reminders allah says in the quran
00:00:37.840 remind for reminder benefits a believer this app is so phenomenal seven day free trial wherever you are
00:00:44.040 wherever you are whatever you're doing it gives you a reminder to read the quran brothers and sisters
00:00:48.580 we do not need to carry the quran in our hands like we did before now it is on your phone what excuse 0.97
00:00:55.140 will you have on your maqiyama of why you didn't read the quran download the qurani app now and let
00:01:00.160 it testify for you on your maqiyama that you read it wherever you was enjoy the video just asking a
00:01:07.160 quick question can you see dark matter can you see the air now you don't see it but exist but exist
00:01:13.620 but you can measure it good dark matter cannot be seen smelt tasted felt or heard but you can be felt
00:01:21.400 no it cannot be felt how do we know it exists we know no because we see the effects of it
00:01:26.420 then it can be felt no see you believe in something that you see the effects of but you believe you do
00:01:32.480 you deny god when you see the effects of what is the effects of for example the creation you your eye
00:01:36.920 the way you created your body your kidney your lungs your heart i'm not created you're not created 0.98
00:01:41.420 no okay so where did you come from it's a live semen from the bollocks of my dad where did it 0.95
00:01:45.920 come from where did it come from where did it come from where did the bollocks of your dad come 0.98
00:01:49.700 from hiwan minnowi yes i don't know i don't know and they made okay okay can you tell me
00:01:56.320 who gives the sperm the knowledge to swim to the egg who says go go go race race race who does that
00:02:03.040 that's begging the question i'm asking that's begging the question well i'm begging you saying
00:02:07.840 yeah you're begging it okay you're fallible no problem yeah exactly i'm fallible so i'm gonna
00:02:11.800 answer a fallible question how is your fallible question me asking how does the sperm have the
00:02:15.520 knowledge by saying who okay what no problem who gives the knowledge what gives the knowledge
00:02:21.520 what gives the knowledge what gives the knowledge to the sperm intelligence where intelligence okay 0.97
00:02:26.880 if there's intelligence then it cries intelligent designer no okay so there's if there's intelligence
00:02:31.180 Do you believe that there's intelligence
00:02:33.780 In this or information
00:02:35.640 Do you agree there's information in this book
00:02:36.920 I read this book
00:02:38.920 Any book, argument's sake if it's a different book
00:02:41.020 Does this book have information
00:02:42.600 Does that information require intelligence
00:02:45.420 No, not necessarily
00:02:46.760 Are you telling me that this has information
00:02:49.080 But there's no intelligence behind it
00:02:51.100 Information
00:02:52.860 Information, there's information, information requires intelligence
00:02:55.380 You know what information is
00:02:56.480 What do you mean by that
00:02:58.400 You know what information is
00:02:59.980 What information is, I don't know the exact definition
00:03:02.260 What is it, tell me
00:03:02.860 No, but information can be also anything
00:03:04.820 No, of course, the atom is information
00:03:06.420 Of course, yes, yes
00:03:08.180 So if there's information, there's intelligence, like DNA
00:03:10.860 DNA, okay, does DNA have information
00:03:13.820 No, no, no, no
00:03:16.460 No, that's not cut the chase, why, why
00:03:17.900 I am, I'm going to the core
00:03:20.280 I'm at the core
00:03:21.520 The core is, you have to prove your God with objective evidence
00:03:24.180 I am, I am
00:03:24.940 Do you have objective evidence
00:03:25.780 Yes, do you believe that DNA has information
00:03:28.580 Did you hear that guys
00:03:29.600 Yes
00:03:29.960 This person has an objective evidence for his God
00:03:32.380 That means a Nobel Prize is ready
00:03:34.100 I'm ready to receive it
00:03:35.320 Nobel Prize and Templeton Prize 0.99
00:03:36.820 Two fucking million dollars for you 0.98
00:03:38.760 I don't need the money, as long as I prove it, that's fine 0.99
00:03:40.300 Give me one objective evidence
00:03:40.800 Okay, I'm asking you a simple question
00:03:42.060 Do you believe that the DNA has information?
00:03:44.480 You said you had objective evidence
00:03:45.920 Answer the question, give me one
00:03:47.520 Do you, do you accept that the DNA has information?
00:03:51.180 I'm just asking a simple question
00:03:52.340 Running around
00:03:53.680 Actually, look, I'm asking you, who wants to be a millionaire question?
00:03:56.740 Running around, that's not the objective evidence
00:03:58.280 Okay, I'm just asking, okay, okay, okay
00:03:59.880 Okay, okay, I'm just asking a simple question
00:04:02.600 Does DNA have information?
00:04:06.220 Yeah
00:04:06.660 Okay, good
00:04:07.460 If there's information
00:04:08.520 Genetic information
00:04:09.320 No problem
00:04:09.960 No problem
00:04:10.800 If there's information, it requires intelligence
00:04:13.020 Not necessarily
00:04:15.740 Okay, can you tell me why not necessarily?
00:04:17.940 Why not necessarily?
00:04:19.040 I can give you something
00:04:19.940 A phenomenon in nature
00:04:21.580 Tell me
00:04:22.320 Snowflakes
00:04:24.400 Okay
00:04:25.060 Yeah, snowflakes
00:04:27.420 Have you seen a snowflake?
00:04:28.340 Yes, on a microscope, yeah
00:04:29.300 The hexagon?
00:04:31.420 Yeah, yeah
00:04:31.740 Shape of it
00:04:32.060 Yes, yes, yes
00:04:32.640 No intelligence required
00:04:34.240 It's just a chemical bound
00:04:35.520 Oh, no, no, no, no, no
00:04:36.580 Sorry, one second
00:04:37.120 Those chemical bounds have properties to make that
00:04:39.140 It's a pattern
00:04:40.020 If there is pattern
00:04:41.080 Then there's someone who designed it
00:04:42.500 No
00:04:42.780 Yes
00:04:43.320 Can you tell me how you get a pattern?
00:04:45.140 You're pushing the designer
00:04:46.040 No
00:04:46.360 While you're not proving the designer itself
00:04:48.260 I am
00:04:48.520 I am, I am
00:04:49.760 I'm saying those things that you're talking about
00:04:52.080 Have the innate properties to give it that shape
00:04:54.280 You're saying it came from nothingness
00:04:56.780 I'm saying
00:04:57.400 Okay, where did it come from?
00:04:59.200 Okay, where did the properties to make the snowflake
00:05:01.200 That shape come from?
00:05:03.220 Physics
00:05:03.580 Really?
00:05:06.000 What?
00:05:06.420 Really?
00:05:07.520 One second, one second, one second
00:05:08.780 One second, one second
00:05:10.340 Are you telling me
00:05:11.560 Blind processes
00:05:13.200 Gave rise to this?
00:05:15.780 Do you read
00:05:16.320 For example
00:05:17.080 Are you telling me
00:05:17.860 That the snowflake
00:05:20.020 To the DNA
00:05:20.640 To the atoms
00:05:21.680 Which have information
00:05:22.980 All of them have information
00:05:23.940 You're telling me
00:05:25.080 This just comes from physics
00:05:26.280 What do you mean by physics?
00:05:28.280 What does that mean?
00:05:28.940 Physics is an explanation
00:05:29.940 No, physics
00:05:30.500 Physics tells you how it works
00:05:31.780 Not why it works
00:05:32.420 The way it works
00:05:32.880 Thank you
00:05:33.480 So you're talking about
00:05:34.560 How it works
00:05:35.560 I'm asking you
00:05:36.280 Why it works like that
00:05:37.540 Why is begging the question
00:05:38.600 You demand the reason behind it
00:05:39.640 So where
00:05:40.160 Brother, where did it come from?
00:05:41.280 I want to ask a simple question
00:05:41.960 What gave it
00:05:43.100 These intelligence
00:05:43.960 Information to the DNA
00:05:45.520 To the snowflake
00:05:46.420 To you
00:05:47.040 To the atoms
00:05:47.720 There is information
00:05:49.060 Where does this information come from?
00:05:50.900 It requires intelligence
00:05:51.940 The honest answer
00:05:53.020 We don't know
00:05:53.680 You claim the knowledge
00:05:55.500 While you're not providing anything
00:05:56.660 Very simple
00:05:57.240 To me it's very simple
00:05:58.300 If there is information
00:05:59.540 There has to be intelligence
00:06:00.840 And if there is intelligence
00:06:01.940 Of course it does
00:06:02.640 Give me a contrary argument
00:06:03.940 To something that
00:06:05.060 There is information
00:06:06.500 But has no intelligence
00:06:07.380 I gave you
00:06:09.520 The snowflake
00:06:09.960 No, no, no
00:06:10.440 The snowflake has information
00:06:11.820 You're saying
00:06:12.880 It's the science of the gaps
00:06:13.820 We don't know what it is
00:06:15.320 We're not going to say
00:06:16.020 It's not good
00:06:16.740 So what I'm saying is
00:06:17.700 Where does this information come from?
00:06:19.940 Does it come from nothing
00:06:20.680 Or somewhere?
00:06:22.420 It comes from natural processes
00:06:23.480 Natural processes
00:06:25.040 Blind, blind processes
00:06:26.320 So blind
00:06:27.560 No, no, you can't
00:06:29.340 No, you can't
00:06:29.840 Because it's
00:06:30.500 You can call it sotfah 1.00
00:06:31.160 No, you can't
00:06:31.780 A Muslim day loves sotfah 1.00
00:06:32.820 No, no, no
00:06:33.360 There is no coincidence
00:06:34.240 In science
00:06:34.640 No, no, no
00:06:35.160 Exactly
00:06:35.480 So you're a determinist
00:06:37.480 Yes
00:06:38.220 You can call me whatever
00:06:39.320 No, no, no
00:06:39.920 Problem
00:06:40.160 If you say
00:06:40.940 I agree with you
00:06:41.740 In science
00:06:42.240 There is no chances
00:06:43.080 So far
00:06:43.680 There is no objective evidence
00:06:45.380 For God
00:06:45.940 We'll let people decide
00:06:46.760 So you believe
00:06:47.480 In science
00:06:48.240 We'll let people decide
00:06:49.180 You believe
00:06:49.820 Brother, you believe in science
00:06:51.160 That science there is no chance
00:06:52.460 I've given you many
00:06:52.980 Brother, you said
00:06:54.760 I said
00:06:54.980 Where did the information
00:06:55.620 Come from the snowflake
00:06:56.400 You said physics
00:06:57.240 You said physics
00:06:59.000 You haven't
00:06:59.500 You haven't given
00:06:59.940 Can you measure
00:07:00.560 Can you measure dark matter?
00:07:02.960 Yes
00:07:03.180 No, you can't
00:07:04.460 Oh my goodness
00:07:05.540 You see the
00:07:06.160 Do you realize 1.00
00:07:06.940 You're speaking with a fucking PhD 1.00
00:07:08.260 In astrophysics 1.00
00:07:08.780 You're doing bad
00:07:09.620 You're doing bad
00:07:10.660 I'm not even a PhD
00:07:11.800 You cannot see it
00:07:13.540 You cannot smell it
00:07:14.240 You cannot touch it
00:07:14.840 You cannot hear it
00:07:15.460 You cannot feel it
00:07:15.960 Measure it
00:07:16.400 Look, brother
00:07:16.960 It doesn't exist
00:07:17.860 Please open Google
00:07:18.380 Forget Google
00:07:19.480 Your PhD
00:07:20.180 Brother
00:07:20.620 You did PhD
00:07:21.840 We measure the gravity of it
00:07:22.760 Brother, brother
00:07:23.700 Can you see
00:07:24.200 Okay
00:07:24.480 The weight of it
00:07:25.000 No, no, brother
00:07:25.560 You see the effects of it
00:07:27.100 You are a person
00:07:28.560 Who believes in science
00:07:29.460 For you
00:07:30.280 You're talking about
00:07:31.160 You're like more
00:07:31.680 Materialistic
00:07:32.500 Not in the money sense
00:07:33.660 Yeah
00:07:33.820 I am a
00:07:34.340 No, not like that
00:07:35.760 Something that you cannot see
00:07:37.180 Touch, feel, hear
00:07:38.100 Or taste
00:07:38.560 You reject it
00:07:39.620 I gave you the example
00:07:40.600 Of dark matter
00:07:41.340 You said
00:07:41.940 We see the effects
00:07:42.720 And I say to you
00:07:43.580 Well, God exists
00:07:44.120 You don't see him
00:07:44.580 But you see the effects
00:07:45.060 You say no
00:07:45.540 What is the effect of God
00:07:46.540 One second
00:07:47.240 You, the universe
00:07:48.920 Our solar system
00:07:49.920 The gravitational force
00:07:51.020 All of these things
00:07:52.000 Are the impact of that
00:07:52.920 Solar system
00:07:53.440 Why that's happening
00:07:54.220 Can you see your consciousness
00:07:55.700 No, no, we're coming to that
00:07:59.120 That's separate
00:07:59.480 No, we're coming to that
00:08:00.360 I'm not going nowhere
00:08:00.880 Let's come to that
00:08:01.540 Can you see your consciousness
00:08:02.560 That's the wrong question
00:08:04.000 Can you see your consciousness
00:08:05.300 That's the wrong question
00:08:05.860 I'm not going to answer the wrong question
00:08:06.880 No, you know why
00:08:07.320 You're not going to answer it
00:08:07.820 Because you know
00:08:08.240 There is no
00:08:08.940 You can't see your consciousness
00:08:09.720 But you believe it exists
00:08:10.680 No, we can see 1.00
00:08:11.860 This is the hypocrite 1.00
00:08:12.060 No, you cannot 1.00
00:08:12.860 Show me the effect
00:08:13.480 Have you ever heard
00:08:15.240 The MRI
00:08:15.800 FMRI
00:08:16.380 No, they're just scans
00:08:17.880 They're scans
00:08:18.840 8 and 9
00:08:19.500 8 and 12
00:08:20.740 You cannot
00:08:21.500 You cannot see the consciousness
00:08:23.000 We can see
00:08:24.100 No, you cannot
00:08:24.660 You cannot
00:08:25.760 You cannot
00:08:26.720 You cannot
00:08:28.080 Functional
00:08:28.460 Okay
00:08:29.340 I'm going to believe
00:08:31.060 No, we cannot
00:08:32.480 No, it's not
00:08:33.320 No
00:08:33.700 That is not consciousness
00:08:36.260 We can see the thought
00:08:38.120 That is not conscious
00:08:39.060 No, you cannot see thoughts
00:08:40.060 You cannot see thoughts
00:08:41.240 No
00:08:41.520 You're talking about
00:08:42.660 The functions of the brain
00:08:43.660 Of memory
00:08:44.240 What?
00:08:45.240 What is responsible
00:08:46.120 To seeing
00:08:46.500 No, it's not
00:08:47.300 No, it's not
00:08:48.020 There is a whole discussion
00:08:49.000 If the consciousness
00:08:49.760 Is even connected to the brain
00:08:50.740 So I'm asking a question
00:08:51.660 I'm going to believe
00:08:52.520 In your consciousness
00:08:53.780 One second
00:08:54.680 One second bro
00:08:55.560 I'm going to believe
00:08:56.200 In consciousness
00:08:56.620 If you can see it
00:08:57.440 If I can touch it
00:08:58.220 If I can feel it
00:08:58.920 If I can taste it
00:08:59.560 And if I can hear it
00:09:00.220 Why?
00:09:01.000 Because I'm going with your world view
00:09:02.280 You're pushing it to that
00:09:03.560 Can I see
00:09:04.020 Can I see consciousness?
00:09:05.480 We can see the effects of it
00:09:06.580 Can
00:09:06.880 Okay, show me consciousness
00:09:07.980 I want to see it
00:09:09.780 Look, I'm doing your world view
00:09:10.900 MRI imaging
00:09:11.320 Thank you
00:09:11.780 MRI imaging
00:09:12.500 Is just showing you a graph
00:09:13.660 Of effects
00:09:14.480 The brain is having
00:09:15.320 I'm talking about consciousness
00:09:16.560 Say to me Ali
00:09:17.480 Here's my consciousness
00:09:18.600 You can't
00:09:20.020 So then don't say
00:09:21.180 Then you shouldn't use your argument
00:09:23.180 That if I can't see
00:09:24.060 I don't believe
00:09:24.420 Because it shoots you in the foot
00:09:25.340 No, no brother
00:09:26.660 You make me obligatory
00:09:27.480 To answer the wrong question
00:09:27.920 You know why brother?
00:09:28.580 Because you're saying
00:09:29.320 I believe in the matter
00:09:30.920 What I see
00:09:31.440 But now you believe in dark matter
00:09:32.980 You can't see
00:09:33.700 You believe in consciousness
00:09:34.620 You can't see
00:09:35.400 You cannot see it
00:09:36.780 Double standards
00:09:38.240 This is why I say
00:09:39.020 It's not fair brother
00:09:40.220 It's not fair
00:09:40.760 It's not fair
00:09:41.200 If you're going to use the criteria
00:09:42.860 The criteria should be brother
00:09:44.560 Not matter
00:09:45.900 Because the moment you say that
00:09:47.220 You are shooting yourself in the foot
00:09:48.600 Why?
00:09:48.900 Because you believe in things you don't see
00:09:50.620 Taste, smell, touch or hear
00:09:51.880 Yeah, even electrons you don't see
00:09:53.240 Thank you
00:09:53.660 But you believe they exist
00:09:54.440 But there's an electronic around you
00:09:55.640 Can you see it?
00:09:56.620 It's made from electrons
00:09:57.000 But that's my point
00:09:57.940 You believe in things you don't see
00:09:59.620 But I tell you God exists
00:10:00.600 You say no, I don't believe him
00:10:01.540 You know why?
00:10:02.480 Why?
00:10:02.840 Because I have the three assumptions
00:10:04.160 What's assumptions?
00:10:05.980 What's an assumption?
00:10:06.860 What's these assumptions that you have?
00:10:08.440 I exist
00:10:09.120 The universe exists
00:10:10.440 How do you know?
00:10:11.680 How do you know it's not the matrix?
00:10:12.560 It's an assumption
00:10:13.100 Okay, good
00:10:13.640 It's an assumption
00:10:14.380 Okay, good
00:10:14.800 You're right, you're right, you're right
00:10:15.480 It's an assumption
00:10:16.020 Okay, can you prove it?
00:10:17.800 You can't
00:10:18.640 It's an assumption
00:10:18.900 Exactly
00:10:19.400 I believe that I'm a dinosaur
00:10:21.800 You can't
00:10:23.620 Yes
00:10:23.980 And I believe I live in Pluto
00:10:25.040 You can't
00:10:26.400 Yes
00:10:26.640 And I fly on Fridays
00:10:29.100 No, no, I believe it's an assumption
00:10:30.720 Yeah, exactly
00:10:31.820 Do you see people laughing at me?
00:10:32.840 You know why?
00:10:33.180 Because it is an assumption that is absurd
00:10:34.980 Yeah
00:10:35.800 Yes
00:10:36.220 But we know to make the best inference to the explanation
00:10:39.060 To the best inference
00:10:39.980 Is that we look at our universe
00:10:41.580 And we see that there's intelligence
00:10:42.980 If there's intelligence
00:10:43.860 There has to be an intelligent design
00:10:44.940 No
00:10:45.080 That's all I'm saying
00:10:45.860 That's all I'm saying
00:10:46.760 According to your logic
00:10:48.000 You're going to go now to special pleading
00:10:49.540 Because the intelligent designer
00:10:50.920 No
00:10:51.860 It means intelligence
00:10:52.940 It requires also another intelligent designer
00:10:54.660 No, it doesn't
00:10:55.040 Design
00:10:55.520 No, that's infinite regress
00:10:56.660 The intelligent being has to be necessary
00:10:58.680 Yeah
00:10:58.860 You see?
00:10:59.400 Special pleading
00:10:59.960 No, it's not special pleading
00:11:00.560 Exactly
00:11:00.860 It's not
00:11:01.240 Because if not
00:11:02.160 If not
00:11:02.980 If not
00:11:03.360 Everything has a designer
00:11:04.480 Except
00:11:05.000 The designer
00:11:06.240 100%
00:11:07.360 You know why?
00:11:07.940 Because if God had a designer
00:11:09.240 Then we have the fallacy of infinite regress
00:11:10.720 Which is who created that designer
00:11:11.980 That created that designer
00:11:12.720 Infinite regress is not fallible by the way
00:11:14.420 It is
00:11:14.760 It is
00:11:15.220 No, I said it's the fallacy of infinite regress
00:11:16.960 No, it's not a fallacy
00:11:18.040 Why is it not a fallacy?
00:11:18.940 In mathematics it's not a fallacy
00:11:20.180 I'm not talking about
00:11:20.720 In mathematics
00:11:21.120 In mathematics there is infinite
00:11:22.340 In mathematics it's logic
00:11:22.780 In mathematics no, it's abstract
00:11:24.320 Math is logic
00:11:25.100 I know it's logic
00:11:26.460 Yeah
00:11:26.780 But in mathematics can you have infinite?
00:11:29.060 Yes
00:11:29.340 Good
00:11:29.740 But in the real world can you have infinite?
00:11:31.240 Yes
00:11:31.500 No, you cannot
00:11:32.420 Yes
00:11:32.780 Okay, show me infinite in the real world
00:11:34.020 The radiation of the sun
00:11:36.320 No, they are finite
00:11:37.060 They are finite
00:11:37.600 The sun is finite
00:11:38.360 The radiation of the sun
00:11:38.900 It's finite
00:11:39.460 What is finite?
00:11:40.680 It's finite
00:11:41.220 Can you count it?
00:11:41.920 Anything is finite
00:11:42.640 No
00:11:43.140 Can you count it?
00:11:43.600 No, it's finite
00:11:44.360 It's infinite
00:11:45.920 No, it's not
00:11:46.600 No, it's not
00:11:47.420 No, it's not
00:11:48.160 What is it now?
00:11:49.040 No, it's not
00:11:49.460 The radiation
00:11:50.140 If the sun is not there
00:11:51.180 Is there radiation?
00:11:52.780 From the sun
00:11:53.420 We're talking about specifically the sun
00:11:54.340 We're talking about the radiation
00:11:55.880 That comes from the sun right now
00:11:57.200 Okay, if the sun didn't exist
00:11:58.540 Now you've given a hypothesis
00:12:00.020 Thank you
00:12:00.440 So therefore the sun requires to exist for us to get radiation
00:12:03.100 Which shows its dependency
00:12:04.380 It doesn't matter
00:12:06.020 It does
00:12:06.740 He said the proof
00:12:07.760 Brother, you said you're a PhD
00:12:08.960 Look at what you're saying to me, brother
00:12:11.060 Look at what you're saying
00:12:12.100 You're saying to me it's infinite
00:12:13.160 I have a PhD
00:12:13.500 And you don't know that we can measure the dark matter
00:12:15.520 Come on, bro
00:12:16.420 From my research, you cannot taste
00:12:17.900 You can't
00:12:18.340 I don't need Google
00:12:19.100 I've already done my research
00:12:19.880 The point I'm saying is this
00:12:20.900 You said the radiation is infinite
00:12:22.740 But it relies on the sun
00:12:23.940 It's dependent
00:12:24.680 I'm not saying about the dependency
00:12:26.820 We're talking about the infinite
00:12:27.740 I'm talking about dependency
00:12:28.640 I'm talking about dependency
00:12:30.220 Do you see the jump in now
00:12:31.000 I didn't jump nowhere
00:12:31.700 No, no, no, no, no, no
00:12:33.160 No, I said
00:12:34.580 We're talking about infinite now, right?
00:12:35.660 Infinite doesn't exist in the real world
00:12:37.040 I said to you demonstrate
00:12:37.960 You know the light bulb?
00:12:38.920 Yes
00:12:39.120 Neon
00:12:39.680 Yes
00:12:40.200 This actually has infinite radiation
00:12:41.940 No
00:12:42.500 Do you know what infinite is?
00:12:44.880 Something that has no beginning or end
00:12:47.620 Oh boy
00:12:49.160 No, it's not necessarily
00:12:50.620 It doesn't exist in the real world
00:12:52.480 Not necessarily
00:12:53.020 Okay, okay
00:12:53.900 If there is infinite
00:12:55.060 Between one and two
00:12:56.020 You can divide those numbers into infinites
00:12:58.500 Between one and two
00:12:59.780 There is limit
00:13:00.740 The moment you divide
00:13:03.760 Take away
00:13:04.260 You add to infinite
00:13:04.900 It's not infinite anymore
00:13:05.620 If I have infinite amount of biryanis
00:13:07.080 And I eat two biryanis
00:13:07.860 How many biryanis do we have?
00:13:10.580 You see
00:13:10.860 If you understand mathematics
00:13:11.960 You know that there is no subtraction
00:13:13.520 Mathematics is abstract
00:13:14.380 And no plus
00:13:14.960 Mathematics is abstract
00:13:16.520 You're talking about a world
00:13:17.500 That is abstract
00:13:18.040 I'm telling you
00:13:18.760 In the real world
00:13:19.740 Infinite doesn't exist
00:13:20.860 And you can't prove it
00:13:22.200 How big is the universe?
00:13:23.380 Where is the limit?
00:13:23.900 It's among
00:13:24.220 No, it's limited
00:13:25.160 It's limited
00:13:26.380 Yes, the universe
00:13:27.140 The universe is limited
00:13:27.980 Yes
00:13:28.360 It's independent as well
00:13:30.500 Yes 1.00
00:13:30.940 It is rubbish 0.97
00:13:32.600 No problem 0.99
00:13:33.360 Let's no problem
00:13:34.780 Let's go to the recycle bin
00:13:35.960 Let's see if it's rubbish
00:13:36.660 One second 0.77
00:13:37.120 Do you believe the universe is independent?
00:13:39.100 It's a universe
00:13:39.560 Billions
00:13:40.740 Billions
00:13:41.780 How many?
00:13:42.640 How many?
00:13:43.120 How many?
00:13:45.260 Thank you
00:13:45.780 That is dependency
00:13:46.700 You just gave it a number
00:13:48.400 How can it be infinite?
00:13:49.360 Oh, it's infinite
00:13:49.920 Thank you
00:13:51.000 The fact that you can give estimates
00:13:52.940 Dependency
00:13:53.680 Are you really PhD?
00:13:55.360 No
00:13:55.560 Brother, brother, brother
00:13:56.500 Brother
00:13:56.920 Let's suppose it's 500 quadrillion
00:13:59.000 The moment you give it a number
00:14:00.980 It is dependent
00:14:01.820 So how did you say no, sir?
00:14:04.040 It's an estimation
00:14:04.760 You just disagreed with me
00:14:06.140 And you said there are 34 billion
00:14:07.620 That shows its dependency
00:14:09.060 No, actually
00:14:09.420 That's for a trillion
00:14:10.300 Trillion
00:14:11.180 Even better
00:14:11.940 Trillion
00:14:12.760 The fact that you can give it a number
00:14:14.460 Shows its dependency
00:14:15.340 So it's not infinite
00:14:16.660 So it's not infinite
00:14:17.560 No, that's the only known number
00:14:19.320 They know
00:14:19.780 But that is dependency
00:14:21.660 That's the known number
00:14:22.740 They know
00:14:23.200 Okay, do you know
00:14:23.800 What's the second law of thermodynamics?
00:14:25.520 Energy cannot be created or destroyed
00:14:26.920 Yeah?
00:14:27.620 That's the first law
00:14:28.360 Sorry, first law
00:14:29.180 Thank you very much
00:14:29.620 First law, yeah?
00:14:30.300 First law of thermodynamics
00:14:31.440 Energy cannot be created or destroyed
00:14:32.600 I'm not a PhD
00:14:33.420 You are, right?
00:14:34.340 No, no, this one you did
00:14:34.980 Second law
00:14:35.300 No, no, no
00:14:35.820 You know
00:14:36.480 If you know, yes
00:14:37.180 So it's first law
00:14:38.180 Not second law
00:14:38.680 Okay
00:14:38.880 Now
00:14:39.420 The point is this
00:14:40.460 If energy cannot be created or destroyed
00:14:42.420 That means
00:14:43.100 That for example
00:14:43.980 It doesn't mean
00:14:44.700 That it is infinite
00:14:45.840 It means
00:14:46.600 That
00:14:46.960 It means it's eternal
00:14:47.420 No, it does not mean it's eternal
00:14:48.620 You know why?
00:14:50.100 Because the fact that we have a limited amount of energy in our universe
00:14:53.180 Shows it's dependency
00:14:54.000 I'll repeat again
00:14:56.380 I'll repeat again
00:14:56.980 Energy cannot be created or destroyed
00:14:59.020 Yeah?
00:14:59.620 For example
00:15:00.120 We as Muslims
00:15:00.720 We believe in Jannah
00:15:01.440 Jannah is eternal
00:15:03.000 Post-eternal
00:15:03.820 It eternally relies on God for His existence
00:15:06.440 So energy is the same thing
00:15:08.100 We say energy cannot be created or destroyed in a closed system
00:15:11.080 Yeah?
00:15:11.920 Therefore
00:15:12.280 If it's in a closed system
00:15:13.500 If there's a set amount
00:15:15.380 No, no
00:15:15.680 And it cannot be created or destroyed
00:15:16.720 It's dependent
00:15:17.300 Tell me why I'm wrong
00:15:18.500 Yeah, the PhD
00:15:19.480 Let's correct you, alright?
00:15:20.900 Please correct me
00:15:21.780 It's an isolated system
00:15:22.720 Energy cannot be destroyed
00:15:24.000 Okay
00:15:24.440 What do you mean by isolated system?
00:15:26.680 Okay
00:15:27.040 Physics
00:15:28.240 101
00:15:28.840 This is a closed system
00:15:31.800 It means it can radiate heat to the system around it
00:15:34.860 Okay
00:15:35.220 And it can also get heat
00:15:36.820 Yes
00:15:37.160 From the system around it
00:15:38.200 Okay
00:15:38.420 So it can get energy
00:15:39.640 Yes
00:15:40.180 So in this closed system, yeah?
00:15:42.080 An isolated system
00:15:43.100 An isolated system
00:15:43.860 A system that cannot exchange energy, heat, matter
00:15:47.320 Okay
00:15:48.400 So
00:15:48.760 Is our universe an isolated system?
00:15:50.860 Yes
00:15:51.140 Therefore
00:15:51.700 Is it dependent?
00:15:54.320 Within our universe
00:15:55.660 Universe
00:15:56.100 It is dependent
00:15:57.080 Really, for real
00:16:01.960 For real
00:16:02.860 Give me a break
00:16:03.680 How long?
00:16:04.780 Give me a break
00:16:05.520 How long?
00:16:05.900 No, no, no
00:16:06.320 But really, really
00:16:07.140 You're
00:16:07.740 I'm just looking for answers
00:16:09.180 I'm trying to get answers
00:16:10.260 Let's go back to the verses
00:16:11.480 Of the khsura 1.00
00:16:12.140 Go back to the verses
00:16:13.040 But you're going away from this topic
00:16:14.220 You're already saying
00:16:14.680 No, I'm not going away
00:16:15.100 You are
00:16:15.420 Because it's
00:16:16.140 Dependency
00:16:17.160 Infinite doesn't exist in the world
00:16:18.580 It can exchange energy
00:16:19.160 What's your name?
00:16:20.480 Hassan
00:16:20.800 Hassan
00:16:21.100 Hassan
00:16:21.580 Ali, nice to meet you
00:16:22.280 What I'm saying is
00:16:23.060 What I'm saying is
00:16:23.080 Brother Hassan
00:16:23.560 Is that
00:16:24.160 Infinite doesn't exist in the real world
00:16:26.220 My claim is that
00:16:27.160 I know energy cannot be created or destroyed in an isolated system
00:16:29.580 But the point is this
00:16:30.600 Because it can
00:16:31.520 For example
00:16:32.040 If I set this on fire
00:16:32.940 This hasn't disappeared
00:16:33.940 It's just changed form
00:16:34.720 I agree with that
00:16:35.960 But
00:16:36.340 It's changed form to something
00:16:37.840 And the cycle will continue
00:16:39.220 But
00:16:39.940 What I'm saying is
00:16:40.840 If you go to the source
00:16:42.200 Which is
00:16:42.780 I believe the necessary being
00:16:44.040 I believe
00:16:44.840 Allah
00:16:45.660 Created it
00:16:47.080 Gave rise to it
00:16:48.140 This system that we have
00:16:49.580 It's not infinite
00:16:50.500 Because we know
00:16:51.520 Our universe
00:16:52.580 Is either dependent or independent
00:16:53.980 I get your point
00:16:54.780 That's what I'm saying
00:16:55.440 But
00:16:55.880 According to physics
00:16:57.920 An isolated system
00:16:59.080 If it requires a God
00:17:00.260 Then he must be
00:17:01.240 Inside that system
00:17:02.280 Why?
00:17:03.320 I just want to know
00:17:04.100 Because it's an isolated system
00:17:05.320 The name says it by itself
00:17:06.820 It's an isolated system
00:17:07.940 Okay, why does God need to be in the system?
00:17:09.680 I'm just trying to understand
00:17:10.200 Please teach me
00:17:10.740 Because
00:17:11.000 Because the energy inside the system
00:17:12.840 So he has to manipulate the energy inside the system
00:17:15.640 Okay
00:17:15.920 It cannot be outside the system
00:17:17.020 Okay, so we believe
00:17:18.120 Allah
00:17:18.640 Is 0.88
00:17:19.340 Outside the creation
00:17:21.780 So we say
00:17:22.840 When Allah wills it
00:17:24.100 Allah gives it these properties
00:17:25.300 For example
00:17:25.960 We don't know
00:17:27.280 If you get a seed
00:17:28.000 And put it on the floor
00:17:28.680 It drops on the floor
00:17:29.460 It might turn into a tree
00:17:30.780 We say
00:17:31.820 Allah gave the properties 0.99
00:17:32.960 For the earth to exist
00:17:34.220 For the seed to fall
00:17:35.160 So it's automatically
00:17:36.800 Instantly willed to God
00:17:38.980 It all goes back to God Almighty
00:17:40.080 So we're not seeing it as blind processes
00:17:42.160 So
00:17:42.680 We believe energy is created by Allah
00:17:44.320 The fact that it cannot be created or destroyed
00:17:46.320 Is willed by Allah
00:17:47.380 It has those properties to do that
00:17:49.200 That's contradictory
00:17:49.880 Okay, how?
00:17:50.760 The energy cannot be created
00:17:52.040 Then how can God create it?
00:17:53.120 No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no
00:17:54.260 Listen to what I'm saying
00:17:54.980 In an isolated system, yeah?
00:17:56.780 We're talking about
00:17:57.780 When the universe
00:17:58.840 I believe the universe is dependent
00:18:01.260 And I believe it depends on Allah 0.96
00:18:02.840 So therefore
00:18:03.640 This isolated system of the universe
00:18:05.420 Was willed by Allah
00:18:06.640 And the properties that's happening inside
00:18:08.300 Which cannot be created or destroyed
00:18:09.620 There's an initial process of creation
00:18:11.780 From that moment onwards
00:18:13.360 This is what we believe
00:18:14.080 I'm saying
00:18:14.440 Okay, good
00:18:15.200 So we believe
00:18:16.060 That Allah willed it
00:18:17.280 This isolated system now
00:18:19.220 Has its operations within it
00:18:20.860 Which is what?
00:18:21.860 The energy within it
00:18:22.760 Cannot be created or destroyed
00:18:23.700 It is a function
00:18:24.520 That's all we're seeing
00:18:25.700 Then it's a matter of faith, brother
00:18:27.160 No, it's a matter of
00:18:28.060 If, for example
00:18:29.320 The universe is either dependent or independent
00:18:31.760 Do you believe it's dependent or independent?
00:18:33.540 I believe it's dependent
00:18:34.520 It's what?
00:18:35.240 Independent
00:18:35.560 Good
00:18:35.980 Now, brother Hassan
00:18:36.960 If you believe it's independent
00:18:37.880 Based on the energy itself
00:18:38.940 No problem
00:18:39.520 If you believe it's independent
00:18:41.180 Me and you agree on something
00:18:42.760 We agree that we require an independent
00:18:45.980 Call it a being
00:18:47.560 Call it whatever you like
00:18:48.480 You give that title to the universe
00:18:50.580 I give it to Allah
00:18:51.660 I give it to energy
00:18:52.400 You give it to energy
00:18:53.500 So we will say that your God is universe
00:18:57.400 I would
00:18:58.080 Why?
00:18:58.940 No, no, but let me tell you
00:18:59.560 But let me tell you why
00:19:00.480 I wouldn't worship energy
00:19:01.620 No, no, but let me tell you why
00:19:02.520 But the fact that you believe
00:19:04.580 It's made our universe
00:19:06.660 You are in a nutshell
00:19:08.320 Giving the attributes that belong to Allah
00:19:10.240 To the universe
00:19:11.520 Now
00:19:12.220 At least I have evidence
00:19:13.120 Okay, good
00:19:13.660 Now I say
00:19:14.400 Physical evidence
00:19:14.780 Okay, good
00:19:15.240 My definition
00:19:16.120 You have faith
00:19:16.940 No, no, no
00:19:17.520 I don't have faith
00:19:18.380 Christians, they are full faith
00:19:19.400 With me, I have aql as well
00:19:20.500 With logic
00:19:21.020 Now, independency 1.00
00:19:22.700 I kick their asses 1.00
00:19:23.900 Yeah, yeah, that's good 1.00
00:19:24.700 Together we'll join that
00:19:25.960 Yeah, okay
00:19:26.300 So now
00:19:27.060 Brother Hassan
00:19:28.420 Now, if my definition of independent being
00:19:30.800 Is the following
00:19:31.480 It has to be necessary
00:19:32.800 Self-sufficient
00:19:33.900 Not composed of pieces
00:19:35.520 And cannot be any other way
00:19:37.140 Good, okay
00:19:38.960 Now, anything that is dependent
00:19:40.980 Is something that requires
00:19:42.920 Something else for its own existence
00:19:44.060 Is composed of pieces
00:19:45.620 And it can be any other way
00:19:47.320 Now, do you accept that energy
00:19:50.080 Is a form of
00:19:51.840 It's a piece
00:19:52.360 Like it's composed of pieces
00:19:54.440 Substance
00:19:55.680 Good, it's substance
00:19:56.600 We agree that energy can be any other way
00:19:59.360 You can change form
00:20:00.640 Good
00:20:00.880 I say
00:20:02.180 That is dependent
00:20:03.780 The fact that it's dependent
00:20:05.980 I say
00:20:06.800 What does it depend on?
00:20:07.780 It has to depend on the necessary being
00:20:09.600 That's my argument
00:20:11.200 So when you said
00:20:12.160 I believe energy
00:20:13.180 Is 0.88
00:20:13.660 The universe is independent
00:20:14.680 I'm disproving that by seeing
00:20:16.820 If it was independent
00:20:18.380 It would not be composed of pieces
00:20:20.180 And it could not be any other way
00:20:21.580 We know our universe can be any other way
00:20:24.040 And it's composed of pieces
00:20:25.420 Therefore
00:20:26.280 It is dependent
00:20:27.440 If it is dependent
00:20:28.500 What is it dependent on?
00:20:29.860 Which is Allah
00:20:30.240 That's my argument
00:20:30.780 It's still based on faith
00:20:32.880 No, no, no
00:20:33.900 I give logical
00:20:34.700 I give logical
00:20:35.000 I give logical faith
00:20:35.520 I didn't say
00:20:36.280 Uncle
00:20:36.760 I didn't say
00:20:38.140 Let's go close eyes
00:20:39.120 You didn't give anything physical
00:20:39.740 You didn't give anything physics
00:20:40.980 No, Uncle, I did
00:20:42.020 Okay, okay
00:20:42.980 It's a leap of faith
00:20:43.780 And the mu'min 0.94
00:20:44.560 That God created
00:20:45.780 And I don't mind that
00:20:46.620 Okay, okay
00:20:46.880 No, no
00:20:47.620 I promise you I'm not giving faith
00:20:48.640 I'll repeat again
00:20:49.280 My definition of dependency
00:20:50.900 Is the following
00:20:51.560 Something that depends on something else
00:20:53.640 For his existence
00:20:54.300 Yeah
00:20:54.780 Okay
00:20:55.380 Guy, I'll drive you one second
00:20:56.340 Because I can't hear the brother
00:20:57.140 Yeah
00:20:57.300 Number one
00:20:58.520 If it's composed of pieces
00:20:59.980 Number two
00:21:00.820 If it can be any other way
00:21:01.980 The first premise
00:21:03.120 Premise
00:21:03.540 It's wrong
00:21:03.760 Why is it wrong?
00:21:05.160 Is energy not composed of pieces?
00:21:06.320 It's dependent
00:21:06.840 No, one second
00:21:07.620 It cannot be created or destroyed
00:21:08.560 So it's not dependent on anything
00:21:09.800 No, no, no
00:21:10.180 The fact that there is a set amount
00:21:12.280 Shows us dependency
00:21:13.280 Set amount?
00:21:14.800 Yes
00:21:15.080 Trillion
00:21:16.280 For trillion
00:21:17.040 Quadrillion
00:21:17.600 Whatever you want to call it
00:21:18.340 The fact that the energy
00:21:19.760 Is in an isolated system
00:21:21.260 The system is limited
00:21:22.740 Even though the energy
00:21:24.600 Cannot be created or destroyed
00:21:25.540 Within the isolated system
00:21:26.840 It is still limited
00:21:28.160 So that's why I was saying
00:21:29.600 Equals zero 0.95
00:21:30.160 Sorry?
00:21:31.040 Equals zero 0.95
00:21:31.680 What's equal zero?
00:21:33.140 Energy
00:21:33.580 What do you mean equals zero?
00:21:35.460 The whole total amount of energy
00:21:37.020 In the universe
00:21:37.580 Is actually close to zero
00:21:39.680 Okay
00:21:40.340 I don't know what that means
00:21:41.880 Because there is
00:21:42.560 It's like positive and negative
00:21:44.040 So the positive is the energy
00:21:46.140 Okay
00:21:46.600 And what equalizes it
00:21:48.320 Is the gravity
00:21:48.920 So they equalize each other
00:21:50.620 And become zero
00:21:51.260 Okay
00:21:52.660 So
00:21:53.160 They annihilate each other
00:21:54.400 Okay
00:21:55.300 But it has those properties
00:21:56.440 So what I'm saying is
00:21:57.340 That to me
00:21:58.300 Something that's composed of pieces
00:22:00.060 Something that can be any other way
00:22:01.780 Is dependent
00:22:02.740 I know the universe is composed of pieces
00:22:05.060 I know the universe can be any other way
00:22:06.900 No no but one second
00:22:07.780 That's my argument
00:22:08.680 If it's composed of pieces
00:22:10.060 And it can be any other way
00:22:11.040 I say that thing is dependent
00:22:12.760 You said the universe is independent
00:22:15.100 I say it cannot be independent
00:22:16.800 Because it is composed of pieces
00:22:18.060 You're a piece
00:22:18.640 I'm a piece of the universe
00:22:19.440 Therefore
00:22:20.380 If I die
00:22:21.160 It's not the same universe
00:22:22.480 Of course it's the universe
00:22:23.080 But without me
00:22:23.980 It's not going to be good
00:22:24.600 It's going to be a bit boring
00:22:25.460 Yeah
00:22:25.980 So I'm joking
00:22:27.000 Yeah
00:22:27.200 So my wife might differ with that
00:22:29.280 Yeah
00:22:29.440 Anyways
00:22:30.300 Yeah
00:22:30.780 Come to my janazah
00:22:32.040 Please do sadaqa jari 1.00
00:22:32.740 So it cannot be
00:22:34.280 It can be any other way
00:22:35.660 Yeah
00:22:35.860 So therefore
00:22:36.760 If the universe is composed of pieces
00:22:38.900 And it can be any other way
00:22:39.900 It is not independent anymore
00:22:41.320 It is dependent
00:22:42.000 What does it depend on
00:22:43.800 Now that thing that it depends on
00:22:45.420 Has to be independent
00:22:46.420 If it's not
00:22:46.940 Then we have
00:22:47.420 Dependency
00:22:48.300 Depends on dependency
00:22:49.040 Then we can have an infinite regress
00:22:50.880 That's why
00:22:51.760 We don't do the special
00:22:52.640 Pleading
00:22:53.280 We say
00:22:54.040 That being has to be
00:22:55.640 Self-sufficient
00:22:56.420 Necessary
00:22:57.440 Cannot be composed of pieces
00:22:58.800 And cannot be any other way
00:22:59.880 That's why it is necessary
00:23:01.540 And that's where everything stops there
00:23:03.140 It's outside the universe
00:23:03.940 It's outside the universe
00:23:04.760 It's created the universe
00:23:06.320 That's my argument
00:23:06.980 Yeah
00:23:07.440 But that's still faith
00:23:09.040 No
00:23:10.120 No
00:23:10.420 You said to me
00:23:11.140 Let me make it clear for you
00:23:13.740 It's the same faith
00:23:14.900 As some physicists say
00:23:16.040 There is universe
00:23:16.900 Universes
00:23:17.740 Outside our universe
00:23:18.840 It's also faith
00:23:19.680 Thank you
00:23:20.200 It's not based on evidence
00:23:21.340 Yeah the same thing
00:23:22.120 That's a theory
00:23:22.640 It's a hypothesis
00:23:24.440 It happens
00:23:24.980 Okay
00:23:25.280 More than a theory
00:23:26.160 To be honest
00:23:26.800 But yeah
00:23:27.560 It's the same faith
00:23:28.340 But I gave
00:23:29.840 Argument
00:23:30.620 I didn't give faith
00:23:31.160 I didn't say blind
00:23:31.940 Just believe
00:23:32.440 No but I didn't say
00:23:33.640 Allah exists
00:23:34.060 Just believe him
00:23:34.640 No no but yours
00:23:35.200 You have a sharia 1.00
00:23:35.800 You have Allah
00:23:36.620 Put that to a side
00:23:37.840 That's religion 0.65
00:23:38.580 But I didn't come to you
00:23:39.740 With faith
00:23:40.040 I came to you
00:23:40.540 With a logical argument
00:23:41.420 No it's not
00:23:43.220 I did
00:23:43.760 But tell me why not
00:23:44.500 I told you my definitions
00:23:45.380 Of dependency and independency
00:23:46.500 Because you push the energy
00:23:47.080 To be dependent
00:23:47.800 Yes
00:23:48.420 Tell me why not
00:23:49.600 The energy is independent
00:23:50.480 You said it
00:23:50.960 No it's not
00:23:51.560 It cannot be destroyed
00:23:52.360 Or created
00:23:53.040 But okay for example
00:23:54.760 We believe
00:23:56.100 Jannah cannot be created
00:23:57.160 It's something out of nothing
00:23:58.920 That's literal
00:23:59.560 No no no no
00:24:00.580 No no no
00:24:01.400 No no no
00:24:02.640 We believe
00:24:03.580 That something can come from nothing
00:24:04.980 In what sense
00:24:05.940 Allah wills it
00:24:07.060 You believe without an agent
00:24:08.940 It comes from nothing
00:24:09.500 Which is an impossibility
00:24:10.360 I'm not saying
00:24:10.880 It's not coming from nothing
00:24:11.560 Okay good
00:24:12.000 So okay good
00:24:12.780 If it cannot come from nothing
00:24:13.920 Where did it come from
00:24:14.880 It's eternal
00:24:16.460 Okay
00:24:17.360 What's your evidence
00:24:18.120 That it's eternal
00:24:18.620 The first law
00:24:20.640 Which is what
00:24:21.740 Energy
00:24:22.380 It cannot be created
00:24:23.020 It cannot be destroyed
00:24:24.060 In a
00:24:24.500 In a
00:24:26.080 Thank you
00:24:27.280 An isolated system
00:24:28.560 I'm saying is dependent
00:24:29.360 How can an isolated system
00:24:32.420 Very simple
00:24:33.260 Very simple
00:24:33.800 This bottle that I have
00:24:35.200 Inside it
00:24:36.200 Let's say this water
00:24:37.020 Is energy
00:24:37.620 Can somebody please open Google
00:24:38.500 And just write isolated system
00:24:39.940 Can you guys open
00:24:40.620 Please just help him
00:24:41.360 Just write isolated system
00:24:42.120 Just show him
00:24:43.200 Yeah
00:24:43.420 Just write isolated system
00:24:44.580 Write isolated system
00:24:45.560 Now
00:24:45.960 I'm saying
00:24:46.740 Imagine this is the isolated system
00:24:48.240 Yeah
00:24:48.400 In it is energy
00:24:49.640 That cannot be created or destroyed
00:24:50.660 It's just going to be here
00:24:51.540 Forever
00:24:52.480 Argument's sake
00:24:53.060 Yeah
00:24:53.180 That is dependent
00:24:54.980 Because it eternally relies
00:24:57.140 On the necessary being
00:24:58.140 For its existence
00:24:58.920 No
00:24:59.240 Yes
00:24:59.640 That's my argument
00:25:00.460 Yeah but
00:25:00.800 Yes
00:25:01.580 Exactly
00:25:01.860 So as you see
00:25:04.480 Yes
00:25:05.020 Click on this
00:25:05.740 Yeah
00:25:05.900 So you see guys
00:25:07.520 Yes
00:25:07.740 Isolated system
00:25:09.220 Cannot receive energy
00:25:10.520 Yes
00:25:10.900 Cannot radiate energy
00:25:11.760 Yes
00:25:11.940 Cannot receive heat
00:25:12.720 Thank you
00:25:13.140 Closed system
00:25:13.940 Can exchange only heat
00:25:15.360 Which other words
00:25:16.220 Energy
00:25:16.700 Yes
00:25:17.200 And an open system
00:25:18.120 Your argument would work
00:25:19.620 Yes
00:25:19.900 With an open system
00:25:20.620 No
00:25:20.820 It works with all of them
00:25:22.220 You know why
00:25:23.700 Because you said
00:25:24.520 For example
00:25:25.020 It cannot
00:25:25.920 Thank you
00:25:26.880 Please
00:25:27.140 Send it to my house
00:25:28.120 Yeah
00:25:28.400 Really
00:25:29.360 Okay
00:25:29.760 So in an isolated system
00:25:31.540 It cannot receive
00:25:32.380 Or give
00:25:32.920 Yeah
00:25:33.900 Good
00:25:34.300 I have no problem with that
00:25:35.900 I'm saying
00:25:36.680 It is still limited
00:25:38.500 The fact that
00:25:39.700 It cannot be created or destroyed
00:25:40.900 I accept that premise
00:25:42.240 First dynamics
00:25:43.040 First law of thermodynamics
00:25:44.460 Energy cannot be created or destroyed
00:25:46.020 It can change form
00:25:46.700 Fully accept
00:25:47.860 Perfect
00:25:48.440 What I'm saying is this though
00:25:50.080 You're claiming
00:25:50.900 This makes it infinite
00:25:52.640 I say no
00:25:53.340 I'm not saying infinite
00:25:54.080 Okay
00:25:54.360 Eternal
00:25:54.760 Eternal
00:25:55.260 Eternal
00:25:55.720 Okay
00:25:55.960 I say no
00:25:56.860 Because the fact that
00:25:58.200 We ask a question
00:25:58.920 Number one
00:26:00.020 Can you prove
00:26:00.680 That it is eternal
00:26:01.780 In the sense of its existence
00:26:03.260 Not inside the isolated system
00:26:05.120 Because the fact that it's isolated
00:26:07.680 And there's a specific system
00:26:08.800 Shows that it is dependent
00:26:10.320 That's what I'm saying
00:26:11.300 You're talking about inside
00:26:12.120 I'm talking about the outside
00:26:13.720 You're pushing the dependency
00:26:14.680 Without providing any evidence
00:26:15.980 No I am
00:26:16.360 I'm saying inside it
00:26:17.420 Cannot be created or destroyed
00:26:18.340 Yeah
00:26:18.680 But the system within itself
00:26:19.980 Is dependent
00:26:20.520 How do you know?
00:26:21.700 Because it cannot be eternal
00:26:22.760 It can't be infinite
00:26:23.340 It cannot be
00:26:24.180 But you're not providing any evidence
00:26:26.340 I did
00:26:26.640 I did
00:26:26.940 I did
00:26:27.240 I did
00:26:27.900 Very simple
00:26:28.620 Is the isolated system
00:26:29.980 Okay
00:26:30.820 Okay
00:26:31.400 Baba Hassan
00:26:31.960 It's freedom
00:26:32.460 Baba Hassan
00:26:33.140 Is it energy composed of pieces?
00:26:37.120 Yeah
00:26:37.320 Can it be any other way?
00:26:38.840 Like
00:26:39.000 Heat
00:26:40.120 Electric
00:26:40.620 Yeah
00:26:41.040 It's dependent
00:26:42.120 It's dependent
00:26:42.980 No
00:26:43.580 But that's my argument
00:26:45.340 My definition of dependency
00:26:47.420 Is that something composed of pieces
00:26:49.360 And something can be any other way
00:26:50.800 Is dependent
00:26:51.880 Because the opposite of that is
00:26:53.600 The opposite
00:26:54.540 No I'm not
00:26:55.340 Yes yes no
00:26:56.600 Yeah
00:26:56.860 But I'm giving my definitions
00:26:58.440 Composed of pieces can be any other way
00:27:00.560 Those two properties are in the
00:27:02.660 Closed isolated system
00:27:04.280 Therefore it is
00:27:05.760 Requires the independent being
00:27:07.800 Which is not composed of pieces
00:27:08.960 The opposite
00:27:09.360 Which cannot be any other way
00:27:10.880 Therefore this is my argument
00:27:12.880 Alright
00:27:13.900 I accept it
00:27:14.840 Still based on faith
00:27:16.480 I accept it
00:27:17.320 I accept it
00:27:17.860 It was a pleasure talking to you
00:27:18.740 Of course
00:27:19.560 Forgive me if I go with your passion
00:27:20.700 No no no
00:27:22.040 But please let's go back to the verses
00:27:23.860 Please
00:27:24.260 Yes no no let's go to the verses
00:27:25.380 Yeah
00:27:25.560 Surah Fusilat
00:27:26.660 I open my
00:27:27.580 I can read it
00:27:28.340 Where's my phone
00:27:28.900 If you want
00:27:29.960 Yes