Ali Dawah - SH UTHMAN ANSWERS SN£KOS HADITH QUESTION

00:00:00.000 He even understood my question right away.

00:00:02.060 I think that he heard me say the word doubt

00:00:03.760 and he probably deals with a lot of people

00:00:05.180 who ask him questions and he just gets annoyed.

00:00:07.680 But Aki, let me put it like this here.

00:00:08.740 Even if you came to me,

00:00:09.700 if you came to me today in front of the Kaaba

00:00:11.020 and said, well, I have a bit of a doubt.

00:00:12.760 I'm not going to come and say to you,

00:00:13.500 how would I be like you in front of the Kaaba?

00:00:15.220 How are you having a doubt?

00:00:16.140 I have to assume the best and say,

00:00:17.600 hold on a second.

00:00:18.300 It can be a doubt.

00:00:19.760 Aki, there's nothing.

00:00:20.640 Look, doubt.

00:00:21.280 There's two things you do with Shubhahat. 0.97

00:00:22.520 So that doesn't make you a Kafer to have a doubt. 0.98

00:00:23.960 No, Aki.

00:00:27.580 I am a reaver

00:00:28.480 and I was taught how to pray Salah.

00:00:30.180 That means every single time I pray,

00:00:32.300 the person who told me gets the reward.

00:00:34.460 Five times a day,

00:00:35.540 from Fajr to Isha.

00:00:36.920 If you want to support someone like me

00:00:39.380 in learning Salah,

00:00:40.720 then sponsor 10 people

00:00:42.180 for just £100 this Ramadan.

00:00:44.440 Remember the Prophet,

00:00:45.500 peace be upon him, said,

00:00:46.720 charity does not decrease wealth.

00:00:48.880 Click the button and donate now.

00:00:52.600 As-salamu alaykum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh,

00:00:54.400 brothers and sisters and dear friends.

00:00:55.460 Hope you guys are well, inshaAllah.

00:00:56.540 As we told you guys,

00:00:57.520 alhamdulillah,

00:00:58.620 we were invited here

00:00:59.900 by Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala.

00:01:01.480 But before that,

00:01:02.060 Sheikh Uthman Farukh actually

00:01:02.940 in the council group that we're in,

00:01:05.000 he said,

00:01:05.300 Ali, why don't you come to Mecca?

00:01:07.000 And I said,

00:01:07.300 Sheikh, I'm so busy with the lives. 0.97

00:01:08.720 Every single day,

00:01:10.260 I'm doing it live.

00:01:11.020 My wife's saying,

00:01:11.600 actually,

00:01:12.220 she goes,

00:01:12.580 I don't even see you.

00:01:13.800 And subhanAllah,

00:01:14.340 I said to her,

00:01:14.840 buy your tongue a bit, inshaAllah,

00:01:15.800 because at the end of the day,

00:01:16.900 we need $150,000

00:01:18.860 to print 50,000 mats,

00:01:20.420 alhamdulillah.

00:01:21.200 And we're opening Salah hubs

00:01:22.460 all across the UK and Europe.

00:01:24.560 And we've got the app coming out,

00:01:25.840 inshaAllah.

00:01:26.480 And there's so many projects

00:01:27.140 going with the Salah Plus project,

00:01:28.100 as you guys already know.

00:01:29.840 So he invited us,

00:01:31.180 and I thought,

00:01:31.420 you know what?

00:01:32.220 Actually,

00:01:32.520 it'd be nice to do live with them there,

00:01:33.800 because Sheikh Uthman joins

00:01:34.500 our lives every year anyways.

00:01:35.960 So he said,

00:01:36.440 why do you come here?

00:01:37.000 We'll do it here.

00:01:37.340 I said,

00:01:37.600 Sheikh,

00:01:38.000 we love you online with the pixels.

00:01:40.840 It'd be better to see you in person.

00:01:42.160 So we came here,

00:01:42.820 and we had a surprise of a surprise,

00:01:44.420 because then I heard that Sneakers here,

00:01:45.840 Aya Mona,

00:01:46.540 Adam Saleh,

00:01:47.480 Slim, 1.00

00:01:47.720 the whole brothers,

00:01:49.500 everyone is here,

00:01:49.960 subhanAllah.

00:01:50.680 Yeah,

00:01:50.900 God Gali,

00:01:51.300 alhamdulillah,

00:01:51.760 we've got a plan with them

00:01:52.840 about Nas daily,

00:01:54.100 but that's going to come out,

00:01:55.140 don't worry,

00:01:56.040 inshaAllah.

00:01:56.460 Do you know,

00:01:56.720 they do janazah prayer here,

00:01:57.460 we're going to be doing that,

00:01:58.080 inshaAllah.

00:01:58.680 But that's a different topic.

00:01:59.820 So let's get straight into it,

00:02:01.280 inshaAllah.

00:02:01.500 I don't want to hold it any too longer.

00:02:03.640 Sneak up.

00:02:04.320 There was a question

00:02:05.180 that you asked Sheikh Asam al-Aqim.

00:02:07.300 I'm going to ask the question again.

00:02:08.060 Please,

00:02:08.280 if you can ask the question again.

00:02:09.580 I probably phrased it incorrectly.

00:02:12.600 Well, for...

00:02:13.740 Say it the way you said it.

00:02:14.580 So there's a hadith that I read

00:02:17.520 that I've been struggling

00:02:18.580 with comprehending properly

00:02:20.980 and fully believing in,

00:02:23.260 if I'm being honest.

00:02:24.360 And the hadith reads,

00:02:26.000 the Prophet Muhammad,

00:02:27.260 sallallahu alayhi wa sallam,

00:02:27.640 said,

00:02:28.240 the people of Yemen

00:02:29.460 are the best of people.

00:02:30.680 And when I read that,

00:02:31.800 it was conflicting

00:02:32.920 because the reason I became Muslim

00:02:34.080 is because it gets rid

00:02:34.740 of racial supremacy

00:02:35.400 and there's a famous hadith

00:02:36.160 from the Prophet,

00:02:36.820 sallallahu alayhi wa sallam,

00:02:37.080 where he says that

00:02:38.320 there's no race

00:02:39.480 that's superior than the other.

00:02:40.780 We're all created equal

00:02:41.920 and we're judged

00:02:42.340 based off what's in our hearts.

00:02:43.360 So I ask you,

00:02:44.960 Shaykh Uthman,

00:02:45.300 how can there be

00:02:46.940 no racial supremacy

00:02:47.760 within Islam

00:02:48.360 but also the people of Yemen

00:02:49.440 be the best of people?

00:02:50.580 Excellent.

00:02:51.460 First thing,

00:02:52.220 alhamdulillah,

00:02:53.080 that's a great question.

00:02:54.860 And alhamdulillah,

00:02:56.640 in Islam,

00:02:57.520 we encourage you to ask.

00:02:59.540 When you don't know,

00:03:01.380 yassallu al-ahlu al-dhikr,

00:03:02.500 go and ask the people of knowledge.

00:03:04.100 So the people of knowledge

00:03:06.320 should never discourage anybody

00:03:07.960 from asking a question.

00:03:09.320 I'm not going to kick you

00:03:10.220 out of anywhere.

00:03:11.140 We invite you to

00:03:12.200 and welcome you

00:03:13.200 to come and ask questions.

00:03:15.960 And, you know,

00:03:17.400 we don't want to waste time

00:03:18.580 on people that

00:03:19.420 don't want to know the truth.

00:03:20.960 But anybody who's searching

00:03:22.200 for the truth,

00:03:22.840 as I see you being,

00:03:24.620 we never discourage them

00:03:25.820 from asking anything.

00:03:27.400 And we will answer it,

00:03:28.800 inshallah,

00:03:29.320 by the will of Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala,

00:03:31.040 with clear evidences.

00:03:32.900 And then,

00:03:33.620 we accept that it's from us,

00:03:35.680 that we are Muslim,

00:03:36.620 aslama,

00:03:37.160 we submit to it.

00:03:38.380 But we should always ask.

00:03:40.040 So the first thing is

00:03:41.040 the hadith you're referencing,

00:03:42.680 Khayrul Rijal,

00:03:43.500 Rijal al-Yaman.

00:03:44.720 This is mentioned in a riwayah

00:03:46.600 that is mentioned

00:03:47.260 by Imam Ahmad

00:03:48.120 and his musnad

00:03:48.760 and other ulema.

00:03:50.820 This riwayah,

00:03:52.080 there is a problem

00:03:53.200 in the chain of it.

00:03:54.740 So this is something we need to,

00:03:55.840 this is why everybody

00:03:56.540 should understand

00:03:57.120 some of the ulum of hadith.

00:03:59.760 The riwayah,

00:04:00.740 in Sahih Muslim,

00:04:01.960 it mentions

00:04:02.800 al-Iman al-Yaman

00:04:04.020 wal-Hikmah Yamaniya.

00:04:05.820 Yani that,

00:04:06.340 that Iman 0.99

00:04:07.460 is a sifa

00:04:08.580 from the people of Yemen

00:04:09.560 and wisdom

00:04:10.820 is something that is from Yemen.

00:04:12.600 It does not include

00:04:13.780 this section

00:04:14.980 that you mentioned

00:04:15.920 that the best men

00:04:17.340 are the men of Yemen.

00:04:19.060 Right?

00:04:19.340 So,

00:04:20.420 Saeed,

00:04:21.000 ibn Musayyib,

00:04:23.440 he's a tabi'i, 0.86

00:04:24.460 he's the one that reports

00:04:25.600 this from Abu Huraira.

00:04:26.960 Al-Haythami,

00:04:28.020 one of the early scholars

00:04:29.100 who recorded the hadith,

00:04:30.280 said

00:04:30.520 that the rijal

00:04:32.140 are all good

00:04:33.000 except of the fact

00:04:34.220 that Saeed ibn Musayyib

00:04:35.600 never met Abu Huraira.

00:04:37.400 So there's a break

00:04:38.700 in between those two.

00:04:40.460 Right?

00:04:40.580 And because the stronger narration,

00:04:43.000 which is in Sahih Bukhari

00:04:43.820 in Muslim,

00:04:44.540 doesn't have that wording.

00:04:46.920 So what is correct

00:04:47.780 is that no doubt

00:04:49.040 the hadith in Sahih Muslim,

00:04:50.800 this is mahfouz.

00:04:51.980 This is what is

00:04:52.580 the correct wording.

00:04:53.760 So what does that mean?

00:04:54.580 That no,

00:04:55.060 we don't say

00:04:55.800 that the best of men

00:04:57.500 are any particular nationality.

00:04:59.920 Because what we know

00:05:00.840 is the most authentic

00:05:02.080 and clear hadith

00:05:03.180 on the subject

00:05:03.700 tells us,

00:05:04.660 La fadl al-arab al-ajam.

00:05:06.260 There is no virtue

00:05:07.040 of the Arab

00:05:07.540 on the non-Arab

00:05:08.780 or the Ajam

00:05:09.760 or the Arab 0.94

00:05:10.400 on black or white.

00:05:11.820 Except in taqwa,

00:05:12.680 whoever is more pious

00:05:13.660 is closer to Allah

00:05:14.900 subhanahu wa ta'ala.

00:05:16.360 Now,

00:05:17.080 there are hadith

00:05:18.140 that mention

00:05:19.060 the virtue

00:05:19.800 of the people of Yemen.

00:05:21.420 As there are hadith

00:05:22.700 that mention

00:05:23.420 the virtue

00:05:24.000 of the people of Sham.

00:05:25.480 Of the people

00:05:26.040 that are in current day Levant,

00:05:27.680 which is Syria,

00:05:29.180 Lebanon,

00:05:30.260 Jordan,

00:05:30.860 and Palestine.

00:05:31.580 May Allah free it.

00:05:32.540 So this area,

00:05:33.820 that is about

00:05:34.380 how in the end of time

00:05:35.460 this is where

00:05:35.980 iman will be preserved

00:05:37.100 and so on.

00:05:38.660 That means that

00:05:39.340 Rasulullah sallallahu alayhi wa sallam

00:05:40.660 praised different people

00:05:42.140 about different virtues

00:05:44.000 that they had,

00:05:45.060 not showing that

00:05:46.000 one is superior

00:05:46.880 by DNA over another.

00:05:48.340 The Romans too.

00:05:49.260 The Romans, of course. 0.92

00:05:50.720 And even,

00:05:51.600 like for example,

00:05:52.500 I mean let's be real

00:05:53.220 about this, right?

00:05:54.100 If I was to say,

00:05:55.540 you know the Egyptians

00:05:56.220 could build pyramids.

00:05:57.520 Like if you want to talk

00:05:58.540 about building

00:05:59.140 great structures

00:05:59.940 at that time,

00:06:00.820 that's Egyptian, right?

00:06:02.100 That doesn't mean

00:06:03.140 that every Egyptian

00:06:04.120 knows how to build

00:06:04.840 a pyramid.

00:06:05.620 It doesn't mean

00:06:06.200 that they're better

00:06:06.780 than anybody else.

00:06:07.500 It's praising

00:06:08.200 a particular skill set

00:06:09.600 that they had.

00:06:10.400 If I said,

00:06:11.200 man,

00:06:11.440 the people of India

00:06:12.220 in mathematics,

00:06:13.100 they came up with

00:06:13.460 the concept of zero,

00:06:14.680 math is from India

00:06:15.460 or logic and philosophy

00:06:17.140 is from the Greek, right?

00:06:18.560 Yes.

00:06:19.240 But that doesn't mean

00:06:20.180 that they're superior

00:06:21.160 by any DNA, right?

00:06:22.880 We don't believe

00:06:23.620 in a chosen people of God.

00:06:25.440 We believe that

00:06:26.140 everybody is equal

00:06:28.040 in front of Allah

00:06:28.760 subhanahu wa ta'ala

00:06:29.440 and Allah chooses

00:06:30.380 who He wishes.

00:06:31.380 That's why a prophet

00:06:32.260 was sent to every nation.

00:06:34.060 So there were prophets

00:06:34.860 that were Arab,

00:06:35.640 there were prophets

00:06:36.100 that are not Arabs,

00:06:37.260 there were prophets

00:06:37.780 who were black,

00:06:38.500 there were prophets

00:06:38.940 who were white,

00:06:39.540 prophets of every

00:06:40.780 nationality

00:06:41.680 and they're the best

00:06:42.400 of mankind

00:06:42.980 is the prophets, right?

00:06:44.780 Even amongst the sahaba, 0.86

00:06:46.140 the companions

00:06:46.800 of the prophet

00:06:47.340 we had people

00:06:49.000 like Bilal al-Habashi

00:06:50.000 and he was from

00:06:50.860 the best of sahaba

00:06:51.800 and you had like

00:06:52.620 Suhaib al-Rumi

00:06:53.300 and you had

00:06:53.740 Salman al-Farasi

00:06:54.600 even when the Arab 0.99

00:06:55.900 would talk about

00:06:56.520 their lineage

00:06:57.040 the prophet

00:06:57.500 would say

00:06:58.560 that Salman al-Farasi

00:06:59.940 was a Persian man.

00:07:01.240 It's from my household.

00:07:03.080 Ahlulbayt

00:07:03.880 from the people,

00:07:04.560 his household.

00:07:05.260 Why?

00:07:05.800 To show that

00:07:06.540 we are not tied

00:07:07.680 through nationalism

00:07:09.240 rather through iman.

00:07:11.060 When the prophet

00:07:11.700 mentions Ali Muhammad,

00:07:14.680 the family of Muhammad,

00:07:16.280 many of the ulema

00:07:16.980 when they explain this,

00:07:18.260 they said

00:07:18.500 this includes

00:07:19.140 all of the believers.

00:07:20.700 Why?

00:07:21.180 Because we are like

00:07:22.300 the children of the prophet

00:07:23.220 in that spiritual sense, right?

00:07:25.720 So, this is to be clear

00:07:27.500 that in Islam

00:07:28.200 we do not believe

00:07:29.540 that any particular race

00:07:31.640 is superior to the other

00:07:32.940 by DNA.

00:07:34.560 Having said that,

00:07:35.600 no doubt the people of Yemen

00:07:36.960 were a very wise people

00:07:38.620 and at that time

00:07:39.540 they were people of faith

00:07:40.940 when they entered Islam

00:07:42.220 they were strong

00:07:43.260 in their Islam

00:07:44.000 and that virtue was there,

00:07:46.300 no doubt.

00:07:47.400 And every,

00:07:48.880 I mean just to be real,

00:07:49.920 I mean like

00:07:50.100 I don't believe in being fake,

00:07:51.420 I don't do political correctness,

00:07:53.260 I'm straight about this, right?

00:07:55.160 No doubt

00:07:55.820 certain races

00:07:56.900 do have certain skill sets either, right?

00:07:59.580 Look, I mean yeah,

00:08:00.460 I know it's not going to be

00:08:01.120 a politically correct answer

00:08:02.000 but I don't care, right?

00:08:03.180 Like if I was to say

00:08:04.340 that African Americans

00:08:05.540 in America

00:08:06.120 are good at basketball,

00:08:08.160 I'm not being racist, right?

00:08:10.100 I mean look at the percentage

00:08:11.020 of African Americans

00:08:11.880 in the US

00:08:12.380 and look at the percentage

00:08:13.460 that's black in the NBA, right?

00:08:15.000 Or NFL and so on.

00:08:17.120 If I was to say

00:08:17.960 that people of China

00:08:19.080 are excellent at table tennis,

00:08:21.020 it doesn't mean

00:08:21.600 that they're not.

00:08:22.200 It's that they have a skill set.

00:08:23.800 I'm not,

00:08:24.580 I know this wokeism

00:08:25.600 thinks that we cannot mention

00:08:26.920 things like this

00:08:27.620 but it's true, right?

00:08:29.080 Certain people

00:08:29.760 have certain characteristics.

00:08:31.580 That doesn't mean

00:08:32.380 every Chinese

00:08:33.000 is good at table tennis, right?

00:08:35.020 It doesn't mean

00:08:35.600 every black man can ball.

00:08:36.800 Like when I was in high school,

00:08:38.080 I had a lot of friends

00:08:38.740 that were tall

00:08:39.180 African American brothers

00:08:40.160 and everybody expected them

00:08:41.620 to be good basketball

00:08:42.420 but then they weren't.

00:08:43.560 That doesn't mean everyone, right?

00:08:45.420 But these certain characteristics

00:08:46.840 are there

00:08:47.480 and the Prophet ﷺ

00:08:48.860 praised different people

00:08:50.360 for different characteristics

00:08:52.020 including the Persians.

00:08:53.860 You know,

00:08:54.040 he praised,

00:08:54.520 he said,

00:08:54.800 if knowledge was in the stars

00:08:56.580 there would be a Persian 0.99

00:08:57.300 that would go to grab it. 0.80

00:08:58.860 You know,

00:08:59.380 that doesn't mean

00:08:59.980 that they're better

00:09:00.480 than anybody else, right?

00:09:01.840 But as we see

00:09:03.200 in the next generation

00:09:04.580 some of the greatest scholars

00:09:05.860 of Islam

00:09:06.280 including in Arabic grammar,

00:09:07.980 Save Away, 0.88

00:09:08.760 including in Hadith

00:09:09.580 the likes of Al-Bukhari,

00:09:11.040 including in Fiqh

00:09:11.760 like the likes of Abu Hanifa 0.96

00:09:12.760 and so on,

00:09:13.460 they were Persians, right?

00:09:15.080 So, in Islam,

00:09:16.820 in closing,

00:09:17.820 first thing,

00:09:18.460 always ask any question you have.

00:09:20.220 Never feel shy

00:09:21.060 and inshallah

00:09:22.000 by the will of Allah

00:09:22.800 with evidences

00:09:24.220 like I did right now,

00:09:25.780 we will give you the answer.

00:09:27.280 And secondly,

00:09:28.000 we do not believe

00:09:28.880 in the superiority

00:09:29.720 of any race

00:09:30.880 per DNA.

00:09:32.580 But,

00:09:33.540 we do believe

00:09:34.360 that at times

00:09:35.240 certain people

00:09:36.220 stand up for certain principles

00:09:38.020 and they should be praised for that.

00:09:39.860 Like the Ansar, 1.00

00:09:40.680 the people of Medina,

00:09:41.600 even though the Prophet ﷺ

00:09:42.340 is not from Medina.

00:09:43.120 But he said to love them

00:09:44.380 is a part of Iman.

00:09:45.520 Why?

00:09:45.960 Because the service

00:09:46.780 they did for Islam, right? 0.96

00:09:48.600 When the Prophet ﷺ

00:09:49.480 praised the best army

00:09:50.900 to be the one

00:09:51.480 that conquered Constantinople

00:09:53.220 and we know

00:09:53.640 that was in the time

00:09:54.720 of the Ottoman Empire, right?

00:09:55.940 When he talked about

00:09:56.720 so many different virtues

00:09:57.960 of different people,

00:09:58.960 we appreciate people

00:10:00.400 and that their work,

00:10:01.800 but the authentic

00:10:03.200 clear hadith tells us

00:10:04.880 that there is no virtue

00:10:06.560 of anybody per DNA

00:10:08.360 except whoever is more

00:10:09.900 close to Allah in Pairi

00:10:11.460 will be the one

00:10:12.560 that is superior.

00:10:13.820 I mean,

00:10:14.100 one thing I just want to say

00:10:14.820 before I give it to Sneeko

00:10:15.940 is that...

00:10:16.980 Oh, sorry.

00:10:18.600 One thing that I would say

00:10:19.400 before I give it to Sneeko

00:10:19.940 because at the end of the day

00:10:20.520 I came to Islam

00:10:21.180 11-12 years ago

00:10:22.040 and I know how certain things...

00:10:23.800 I'll be honest with you,

00:10:24.280 I can remember the first year

00:10:25.040 when I came to Islam

00:10:25.700 I was walking in Stratford

00:10:27.220 and I was just on my phone

00:10:28.720 looking at some information

00:10:29.940 and I heard that

00:10:30.460 the Sahaba fought each other 0.99

00:10:31.440 and our cameraman here,

00:10:33.100 Rizwan,

00:10:33.420 he had the same thing.

00:10:34.800 I was shocked.

00:10:35.780 I actually had to sit down.

00:10:37.000 I said,

00:10:37.260 what?

00:10:37.480 The Sahaba fought each other? 0.97

00:10:39.180 And then I heard

00:10:39.640 the Prophet ﷺ

00:10:40.200 wife Ayesha and her

00:10:41.220 and the war,

00:10:42.040 I was like...

00:10:42.860 It hit me like

00:10:43.660 someone punched me in the face

00:10:44.460 because in our head

00:10:45.680 we have this false reality

00:10:46.820 and we bring...

00:10:48.200 And we do this a lot of times

00:10:49.580 and I was like,

00:10:50.540 how could the best...

00:10:51.260 How could they fight each other?

00:10:52.980 But the point is

00:10:53.740 when I went to someone

00:10:54.500 to get the answer,

00:10:55.560 if he was to come

00:10:56.280 and say to me,

00:10:57.160 like,

00:10:58.120 you've got uncertainty.

00:10:59.620 Now, again,

00:11:00.140 I want to give a disclaimer.

00:11:01.820 Sheikh Asim Ali Khan,

00:11:02.380 I was in double minds

00:11:03.120 about doing this

00:11:03.600 because the Sheikh

00:11:04.400 had a fatwa against

00:11:05.740 a specific show I was doing

00:11:06.580 and I respect his opinion.

00:11:08.000 I've always said,

00:11:08.480 you know what,

00:11:08.840 and even yourself,

00:11:09.380 I know you have that opinion

00:11:10.320 and I respect that.

00:11:11.140 As long as we are brothers...

00:11:12.800 Myself,

00:11:13.200 I went to an alim 1.00

00:11:13.940 who gave me the fatwa 0.75

00:11:15.180 to go ahead

00:11:15.600 and I understand

00:11:16.100 but as long as we're brothers

00:11:16.820 we have a different opinion.

00:11:17.780 I didn't want to do the video

00:11:18.680 because I didn't want it

00:11:19.200 to come across as if

00:11:19.980 I'm having a go at the Sheikh. 0.93

00:11:21.400 Wallahi,

00:11:21.840 I'm in front of the...

00:11:22.760 Well, the Kaaba is there.

00:11:23.660 Uqsum billah wa rabbul Kaaba.

00:11:25.580 If I have anything

00:11:26.620 against the Sheikh

00:11:27.220 because of that,

00:11:28.020 what he said,

00:11:28.700 there was parts that was true

00:11:29.580 and I apologized

00:11:30.300 that the Sheikh was true. 0.87

00:11:31.760 Haq.

00:11:32.180 And I even apologized for that

00:11:33.760 and even repented for that.

00:11:35.120 I didn't want to do that video

00:11:39.380 I was like

00:11:39.780 you shouldn't be made to feel

00:11:41.440 that you can't ask questions.

00:11:42.860 We have Christians

00:11:43.400 who come to Islam and go 1.00

00:11:44.240 I went to the church

00:11:45.020 and asked a question about Trinity

00:11:46.100 and they said

00:11:46.380 oh, you've got something

00:11:48.120 wrong with your faith.

00:11:49.140 No, you should not be made to feel

00:11:50.540 and I don't think the Sheikh 0.80

00:11:51.400 did it on purpose.

00:11:52.380 We just say that

00:11:53.160 and the enemies of Islam 0.96

00:11:54.620 are trying to use this

00:11:55.220 because Islam is growing 0.87

00:11:56.240 and we can't really blame them

00:11:58.360 and they see Islam as growing

00:11:59.180 and people come into Islam

00:11:59.960 we understand your pain

00:12:01.060 we hear your pain

00:12:01.600 it hurts, it hurts, yeah?

00:12:03.120 But Shaq, you need to have 1.00

00:12:04.380 something to feel.

00:12:04.980 I mean, okay?

00:12:06.080 Yeah.

00:12:06.960 I don't think he even understood

00:12:08.880 my question right away

00:12:09.660 I think that he heard

00:12:10.320 he said the word doubt

00:12:11.440 and he probably deals

00:12:12.200 with a lot of people

00:12:12.860 who ask him questions

00:12:13.660 and he just gets annoyed.

00:12:15.340 But Aki, let me put it

00:12:16.000 like this here

00:12:16.320 even if you came to me

00:12:17.380 if you came to me today

00:12:18.040 in front of the Kaaba

00:12:18.700 and said

00:12:19.000 bro, I have a bit of a doubt

00:12:20.100 I'm not going to come

00:12:20.880 and say to you

00:12:21.160 how would it be

00:12:21.620 in front of the Kaaba

00:12:22.840 how are you having a doubt?

00:12:23.760 I have to assume the best

00:12:24.940 and say, hold on a second

00:12:25.660 it can be a doubt

00:12:26.920 Aki, there's nothing 1.00

00:12:28.140 look, doubt

00:12:28.680 there's two things

00:12:29.540 you do with Shubahat.

00:12:30.220 So that doesn't make you

00:12:30.740 a Kafer to have a doubt? 0.98

00:12:31.680 No, Aki

00:12:32.380 if that's the case

00:12:34.380 me, I've left Islam 1.00

00:12:35.400 when I first came

00:12:36.280 there were some questions

00:12:36.920 that I asked

00:12:37.280 bro, you do two things

00:12:38.800 with doubts

00:12:39.100 and I'm mentioning this

00:12:39.960 for those who have doubts

00:12:40.940 number one

00:12:41.800 you have a doubt

00:12:42.680 and what you do

00:12:43.580 is you let that grow

00:12:44.560 number two

00:12:45.420 you say, I have a doubt

00:12:46.480 I want to go to

00:12:47.400 a person of knowledge

00:12:48.080 and I want to ask

00:12:49.400 and say, I have a genuine doubt

00:12:50.780 let me give you an example

00:12:51.860 at the time of the Prophet

00:12:52.660 a man came to the Prophet

00:12:54.120 and said

00:12:54.580 oh message of Allah

00:12:55.500 we have thoughts

00:12:57.260 in our head

00:12:57.760 about Allah and his messenger

00:12:58.760 that we would rather

00:12:59.480 fall from the sky

00:13:00.140 and be eaten up by birds

00:13:01.120 did the masjid say

00:13:02.640 you had thoughts about me

00:13:04.000 and Allah

00:13:04.660 out

00:13:05.520 not out

00:13:06.900 if the Prophet 0.89

00:13:08.620 will move

00:13:09.260 the sahab will take him out 1.00

00:13:10.820 straight away

00:13:11.780 now what about the man

00:13:13.220 who came and said

00:13:13.900 oh message of Allah

00:13:14.380 make zina permissible for me 0.97

00:13:15.480 did he say

00:13:16.100 to a prophet

00:13:17.400 you don't even come to the sahab

00:13:18.680 you're coming to a prophet

00:13:19.480 to make what 0.87

00:13:20.300 sexual intercourse permissible 0.97

00:13:22.360 he didn't say that

00:13:23.680 he said look

00:13:24.200 let's understand

00:13:25.080 would you want that

00:13:26.080 for your mother

00:13:26.600 oh message of Allah

00:13:27.620 by Allah I would not

00:13:28.400 your daughter

00:13:29.160 by Allah I won't

00:13:29.900 your auntie

00:13:30.480 by Allah I won't

00:13:31.060 he understood the point

00:13:32.340 he said then why

00:13:33.140 do you want to do it

00:13:33.620 to other people

00:13:34.080 what about the man

00:13:35.560 who came and

00:13:35.980 weed in the

00:13:36.900 he weed in the mosque 0.98

00:13:38.240 did he come and say

00:13:39.380 stone him

00:13:40.520 he said let him finish

00:13:42.040 did you say weed

00:13:43.180 weed

00:13:43.960 weed

00:13:44.280 urinated

00:13:45.800 in the UK we say

00:13:47.640 yeah

00:13:48.100 we call it

00:13:49.960 we weed

00:13:50.560 urinated

00:13:52.100 so he urinated

00:13:54.500 so the thing is this

00:13:55.780 Aki 0.90

00:13:57.240 amen

00:13:57.420 we're filming

00:14:01.520 two seconds

00:14:03.780 please

00:14:04.020 catch him

00:14:05.720 catch him

00:14:06.000 look at him

00:14:06.220 trying to run away

00:14:06.680 so the prophet

00:14:07.800 didn't come and say

00:14:08.580 stop him immediately

00:14:09.640 he said let him finish

00:14:10.540 number one

00:14:10.940 he cared about his health

00:14:12.320 because to stop

00:14:13.160 urinating in the middle

00:14:14.980 it can be harmful

00:14:16.280 if anyone's held

00:14:17.120 their urination back

00:14:18.100 he didn't come and do that

00:14:19.560 the prophet

00:14:20.020 that's why Allah 0.73

00:14:21.060 says in the Quran

00:14:21.420 if you were harsh with them

00:14:22.580 they would have run away

00:14:23.480 away from you

00:14:24.420 so my thing was this Aki

00:14:25.500 I felt like what happened

00:14:27.380 and certain things

00:14:28.380 I don't want to go into detail

00:14:29.120 but look bro

00:14:29.860 anytime it goes to anybody

00:14:31.820 who's a new Muslim

00:14:32.700 or a born Muslim

00:14:33.340 who has a shubhaat

00:14:34.040 there is nothing wrong

00:14:35.580 with coming and asking

00:14:36.360 do not feel shy

00:14:37.200 do not feel you're going to be scolded

00:14:38.240 it should not be like that

00:14:39.860 so that's just one thing

00:14:40.660 I wanted to say inshallah

00:14:41.480 and because I've said this before to you

00:14:43.300 with the whole situation

00:14:44.040 with Andrew Tate and this that

00:14:45.040 we ask Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala 0.95

00:14:46.100 to guide

00:14:46.420 but to me bro

00:14:47.560 I'm so sorry

00:14:47.940 I don't

00:14:48.220 bro let me be honest with you

00:14:49.000 I don't praise you

00:14:49.600 because I want a cookie for me

00:14:50.420 I don't

00:14:50.700 let me be honest with you

00:14:51.760 you're my brother in Islam

00:14:53.400 I speak

00:14:54.340 we judge

00:14:54.800 like Umar ibn Khattab said

00:14:55.780 we used to judge from wahi

00:14:57.040 wahi for stop

00:14:57.940 we judge from what's apparent now

00:14:58.960 I see that in you

00:15:00.160 so when I see that in you bro

00:15:01.420 I only praise you

00:15:02.400 because I see

00:15:03.260 your dedication into it

00:15:04.480 subhanahu wa ta'ala

00:15:04.760 like the Japanese sister 1.00

00:15:05.820 who came from a specific

00:15:07.100 wherever

00:15:07.980 yeah subhanahu wa ta'ala

00:15:09.100 I saw the sincerity of her

00:15:10.700 repentance

00:15:11.460 crying

00:15:11.920 in Jilba

00:15:12.760 praying Fajr 0.99

00:15:13.340 she's been a Muslim for six months

00:15:14.420 yeah

00:15:14.900 and subhanahu wa ta'ala

00:15:15.960 anyways

00:15:16.240 I don't want to get into this

00:15:16.820 Andrew Tate

00:15:17.300 two and a half years

00:15:18.120 anyways yeah

00:15:19.540 so yeah no no

00:15:20.360 I'm very angry

00:15:20.900 because you know why

00:15:21.500 and you're coming 0.99

00:15:22.260 and attacking Muslims 0.97

00:15:22.940 and blaming us for 0.93

00:15:23.600 attacks that we didn't do

00:15:24.760 yeah

00:15:25.300 but anyways

00:15:26.520 because our sisters

00:15:27.520 who are walking on the streets

00:15:28.200 get attacked because of

00:15:28.880 your kalam 0.84

00:15:29.360 anyways

00:15:30.660 so the point is

00:15:31.740 that even that sister

00:15:33.020 subhanahu wa ta'ala

00:15:33.380 she got in contact

00:15:33.940 with our salah team

00:15:34.560 we're sending her

00:15:35.320 a guided prayer map

00:15:36.000 yeah

00:15:36.580 and our sister Fajr

00:15:37.740 is going to teach her

00:15:38.280 how to pray salah

00:15:38.800 step by step

00:15:40.320 and by the way

00:15:40.900 those who are watching

00:15:41.620 she's going to join our stream 0.77

00:15:42.540 on the 27th night

00:15:43.240 inshaAllah yeah

00:15:43.680 and we're going to hear her story

00:15:44.860 but Sneeko 0.93

00:15:45.520 if you have any other questions

00:15:46.540 bro here's the chance

00:15:47.220 if you want to

00:15:48.020 any other doubts

00:15:48.700 or things we have

00:15:49.240 no that was a major one

00:15:51.500 I think it's a point

00:15:52.080 to talk about these things

00:15:53.240 that's why I felt

00:15:53.820 comfortable asking that question

00:15:54.820 because the reason

00:15:55.360 I became Muslim

00:15:55.880 was because it's a logical religion

00:15:57.140 yes

00:15:57.760 people saying that it's a cult

00:15:59.020 or that it's blind faith

00:16:00.560 and the reason that I left

00:16:01.740 is because blind faith

00:16:02.860 things like the trinity

00:16:03.560 never made sense

00:16:04.240 thank you

00:16:04.580 just believe

00:16:05.080 don't ask questions

00:16:05.740 I've been told that

00:16:06.580 by priests before

00:16:07.200 just believe it

00:16:08.160 but that never made sense

00:16:09.340 and you know

00:16:10.000 I came to realize

00:16:10.780 that I always was Muslim

00:16:11.740 because when I grew up

00:16:12.740 I wasn't praying to Holy Spirit

00:16:14.040 I wasn't praying to Mary

00:16:14.860 or St. Anthony

00:16:15.560 I was praying to God

00:16:16.280 so the logic behind Islam 0.74

00:16:18.680 is why I'm Muslim

00:16:19.340 and it has nothing to do

00:16:20.300 with any cult

00:16:21.520 or anything people

00:16:22.260 are trying to say

00:16:22.880 to disparage it

00:16:23.540 because they're not

00:16:24.120 actually looking into

00:16:24.800 the context of the conversation

00:16:26.460 or the hadith that was mentioned

00:16:27.480 yeah exactly

00:16:27.920 and another thing

00:16:28.480 that for example

00:16:29.080 the sheikh said

00:16:29.780 you know

00:16:30.480 he didn't mean it

00:16:31.320 is that

00:16:31.860 about the prophets

00:16:32.440 marriage to Aisha

00:16:33.000 you know

00:16:33.520 you're a kafir 1.00

00:16:33.940 that wasn't even

00:16:34.320 the question I was asking

00:16:35.020 no no I know

00:16:35.520 I know

00:16:35.700 but when he said

00:16:36.220 you're a kafir 1.00

00:16:37.160 I was shocked 0.91

00:16:38.500 we were so shocked

00:16:39.960 yeah

00:16:40.120 and maybe

00:16:41.500 I don't know why

00:16:42.580 maybe the sheikh

00:16:43.540 had a specific style

00:16:44.300 but look

00:16:45.160 for example

00:16:45.620 you hold the opinion

00:16:46.680 that Aisha 0.99

00:16:47.800 was not six

00:16:48.560 yeah

00:16:49.140 I don't

00:16:49.960 oh sorry

00:16:50.840 no I don't know

00:16:51.180 tell me

00:16:51.420 so like for me

00:16:53.220 I believe she was six

00:16:54.220 and the consumption

00:16:54.780 of that nine

00:16:55.260 the issue is not that

00:16:56.820 the issue is

00:16:57.420 even if someone came

00:16:58.740 and asked that

00:16:59.620 to hold the opinion

00:17:00.260 to come and say

00:17:00.940 you know

00:17:01.340 is it kafir

00:17:02.540 I was shocked

00:17:03.320 and by the way

00:17:05.480 clarify

00:17:05.760 yeah I do want to clarify

00:17:07.020 I know a lot of people

00:17:08.160 keep thinking this

00:17:09.600 but

00:17:09.800 sorry forgive me

00:17:10.420 I didn't say

00:17:13.680 it's my opinion

00:17:14.160 I'll explain it

00:17:14.900 oh sorry

00:17:15.100 so check this

00:17:16.000 now

00:17:16.200 my reputation

00:17:16.880 of Ali Dawah

00:17:17.760 no no

00:17:18.180 I don't do

00:17:19.780 refitations

00:17:20.240 but

00:17:20.660 clarifications

00:17:22.440 at times

00:17:22.960 but

00:17:23.160 and just

00:17:23.620 this is a point

00:17:24.280 you know

00:17:26.160 subhanallah

00:17:26.680 a lot of people

00:17:27.860 hate

00:17:28.200 and I don't really

00:17:29.200 care about the haters

00:17:29.780 but

00:17:30.120 I'll tell you

00:17:31.220 sneakle

00:17:31.660 subhanallah

00:17:32.220 he's got a lot

00:17:32.860 on his plate

00:17:33.360 he's got a fight

00:17:33.960 coming up

00:17:34.460 he's got training

00:17:35.400 I got Adam Saleh

00:17:37.020 as well

00:17:37.500 Adam where you at

00:17:38.940 I was calling you out

00:17:40.680 bro

00:17:40.920 mashallah

00:17:41.360 he's got a fight

00:17:42.440 coming up

00:17:43.000 Slim's training

00:17:43.780 with him

00:17:44.200 all these brothers

00:17:45.260 all these brothers

00:17:46.100 were busy

00:17:46.680 they just found out

00:17:48.900 right

00:17:49.840 but subhanallah

00:17:51.760 when we said

00:17:52.500 hey let's go for

00:17:53.040 Umrah

00:17:53.320 they left their training

00:17:54.840 they left all of that

00:17:55.700 they came

00:17:56.160 right

00:17:56.740 and that's a sifa of iman

00:17:58.180 they're not getting paid

00:17:58.860 to be here right

00:17:59.420 the whole point is

00:18:00.240 that

00:18:00.820 alhamdulillah

00:18:01.600 they appreciated

00:18:02.660 the opportunity

00:18:03.140 they came

00:18:03.740 sneekle many times

00:18:05.520 may Allah reward him

00:18:06.520 I just want to clarify this

00:18:07.740 he's reached out to me

00:18:09.520 and he's asked me questions

00:18:10.400 and he can be a witness to this

00:18:12.320 I've never kicked you out of my house

00:18:14.300 or hung up on you

00:18:15.620 or anything

00:18:15.920 right

00:18:16.160 we've always taken the time

00:18:18.100 to answer

00:18:18.540 even today when you ask this question

00:18:20.120 was the answer clear

00:18:21.020 yeah

00:18:21.540 good

00:18:22.060 you're good with that now

00:18:23.360 right

00:18:23.640 so we clarify these issues

00:18:25.220 and every time I've given

00:18:26.740 sneekle any kind of advice

00:18:28.020 like if he's doing something wrong

00:18:29.400 if I give him advice

00:18:30.200 he's open to it

00:18:31.280 and he accepts it

00:18:32.080 and you know

00:18:33.200 everybody has shortcomings

00:18:34.360 but I appreciate that about him

00:18:35.920 Ali Da'awah is the same thing 0.99

00:18:37.380 me and Ali Da'awah are brothers in Islam

00:18:38.880 and whoever hates me

00:18:39.980 for loving him

00:18:40.980 you can hate all you want

00:18:42.000 right

00:18:42.340 he may hold views

00:18:44.380 that I don't hold

00:18:45.060 and I may hold views

00:18:46.660 that he doesn't hold

00:18:47.380 and he may have mistakes

00:18:48.860 and I may have mistakes

00:18:50.020 but that doesn't mean

00:18:51.180 we're not brothers in Islam

00:18:52.240 even if I am a sinful person

00:18:55.180 that doesn't mean

00:18:56.140 he should cut me off

00:18:56.940 that means he should reach out to me

00:18:58.840 he should make du'a for me

00:18:59.940 he should come and give me nasiha 0.93

00:19:01.640 and even if I don't accept it

00:19:03.260 he should make du'a 0.70

00:19:04.100 Abu Hanif and Imam Malik

00:19:05.760 they met together in Medina

00:19:07.880 and they disagreed on so many subjects

00:19:10.400 but they didn't stop praying behind each other

00:19:12.360 they didn't stop sitting with each other

00:19:13.840 they didn't cut each other off

00:19:15.580 they even they had a debate

00:19:17.260 as some of the ulema mentioned

00:19:18.420 that they were so fierce

00:19:19.800 that they had sweat coming

00:19:20.820 but they came out praising each other

00:19:22.620 right

00:19:23.160 so we as Muslims

00:19:25.320 have to be able to meet that mature

00:19:27.200 I know everybody online

00:19:28.600 just want to see me

00:19:29.660 refute Ali or Ali refute me

00:19:31.240 but we're not going to do this

00:19:32.360 because you know why

00:19:33.020 because they saved the drama for their

00:19:34.200 for their mama

00:19:34.880 there you go

00:19:35.640 give me that

00:19:36.060 don't leave me hanging there bro

00:19:38.280 save the drama

00:19:39.380 for your mama

00:19:40.340 alright

00:19:41.460 there's a context to that

00:19:42.620 yeah

00:19:42.980 the context of that

00:19:45.560 just because I don't know

00:19:46.460 a lot of people in the UK

00:19:47.060 took it the wrong way

00:19:47.880 in the US

00:19:49.080 I think people understand

00:19:50.080 is that your mother loves you

00:19:51.600 and nobody loves you

00:19:52.940 like your mother 0.52

00:19:53.480 right

00:19:54.140 so when you have some

00:19:56.200 emotional outburst

00:19:57.940 you just want to

00:19:58.580 you just want to complain

00:19:59.880 you just want to

00:20:00.580 have some drama

00:20:01.480 go sit down with your mother 0.98

00:20:02.860 put your head in her lap 0.96

00:20:04.300 and give her your story 0.96

00:20:06.240 and she'll put your head 1.00

00:20:08.000 and she'll give you

00:20:08.860 a warm cup of milk

00:20:09.680 and she'll tolerate you

00:20:10.620 because we won't do that

00:20:11.440 we won't

00:20:12.080 and I don't have time

00:20:13.080 for all that drama

00:20:13.800 you know

00:20:14.120 so save the drama

00:20:15.040 for your mama

00:20:16.140 because she loves you

00:20:17.220 right

00:20:17.560 right

00:20:20.000 so

00:20:20.380 regarding the age of Aisha 0.97

00:20:22.920 now

00:20:23.720 I want to clarify some things

00:20:25.540 because even some of our brothers

00:20:26.600 they

00:20:26.820 they become as if

00:20:29.060 this is like a

00:20:29.840 creedal

00:20:30.360 core

00:20:30.800 aqidah issue

00:20:31.620 like

00:20:32.300 I mean

00:20:32.800 and again

00:20:33.100 I haven't watched the video

00:20:34.140 but from what I heard

00:20:35.500 somebody said

00:20:36.440 oh if you don't believe

00:20:37.040 either kafir or whatever

00:20:37.820 first thing

00:20:39.160 this is not an aqidah issue

00:20:40.180 right

00:20:41.060 when

00:20:41.640 when we believe in Allah

00:20:43.340 we believe in the Prophet

00:20:44.360 we believe in the Malaika

00:20:45.860 the books of

00:20:46.600 that Allah has revealed

00:20:48.420 the day of judgment

00:20:49.260 qadar

00:20:50.280 good and bad

00:20:51.400 and all of

00:20:51.840 this is not the age of Aisha 0.88

00:20:53.360 secondly

00:20:54.680 it's not in the Quran

00:20:55.680 right

00:20:56.620 it's not a part of the wahi

00:20:57.880 or the Quran

00:20:58.500 thirdly

00:21:00.100 what is wahi

00:21:01.160 from the hadith

00:21:02.580 is what the Prophet

00:21:03.320 told us

00:21:04.480 the Prophet

00:21:05.760 never told us

00:21:07.440 the age of Aisha 1.00

00:21:08.060 in no marfoo hadith 0.97

00:21:10.340 hadith that reaches

00:21:11.160 the Prophet

00:21:11.620 what we have

00:21:14.080 is a sahih hadith 0.88

00:21:14.960 and I have no doubt

00:21:16.080 to the authenticity

00:21:16.880 of the hadith

00:21:17.540 people are like

00:21:18.280 oh you're doubting

00:21:18.920 hadith in Bukhari

00:21:19.600 never

00:21:20.000 when did I ever say that

00:21:21.040 we have a hadith

00:21:22.440 that Aisha 0.99

00:21:23.020 said that the engagement

00:21:25.880 was at 6

00:21:27.020 and the marriage

00:21:27.740 was at 9

00:21:28.340 in sahih muslim 0.90

00:21:29.940 also sahih hadith

00:21:31.400 no doubt

00:21:32.340 to the son of the faith

00:21:33.180 right

00:21:33.860 she said I was 7

00:21:35.240 and married at 9

00:21:36.940 so if somebody says

00:21:38.300 if you don't believe

00:21:39.100 in 6

00:21:39.540 you're kafir 1.00

00:21:40.200 what happens

00:21:41.360 to the sahih muslim 0.99

00:21:42.100 al-nabawi

00:21:43.420 one of the classes

00:21:44.480 I'm not reinterpreting anything

00:21:46.220 in the shah

00:21:47.440 sahih muslim

00:21:48.120 he said it could be

00:21:49.300 that she was between

00:21:50.080 those ages

00:21:50.660 or she wasn't sure

00:21:51.400 about the exact age

00:21:52.360 so that means

00:21:53.180 this is not something

00:21:53.940 that she was witnessing

00:21:55.200 she's an amazing

00:21:56.340 narrator in hadith

00:21:57.180 no doubt to her

00:21:58.320 right

00:21:58.700 now

00:21:59.540 my stance is

00:22:01.260 that

00:22:01.980 it is very possible

00:22:03.360 that she was 6

00:22:04.500 or 7

00:22:05.040 at engagement

00:22:05.880 and they waited

00:22:07.220 for her to hit blue 1.00

00:22:08.520 for her to be mature

00:22:09.880 whether that's age of 9

00:22:11.520 or around that age

00:22:12.580 and they got married

00:22:13.560 and I have no issues

00:22:14.420 with that

00:22:14.780 but

00:22:15.160 I did mention

00:22:16.440 that there are

00:22:17.120 other ulema

00:22:17.900 ibn sa'ad

00:22:19.100 and others

00:22:19.500 in their tabaqat

00:22:20.220 that looking at

00:22:21.220 Isma ibn Tabi Bakar

00:22:22.260 give different ages

00:22:23.120 I'm not saying

00:22:23.860 that's my view

00:22:24.540 I'm just presenting

00:22:25.960 that those are

00:22:27.280 in the early scholars

00:22:28.280 of Islam

00:22:28.600 so this is not something

00:22:29.380 like as if

00:22:30.180 we're just restarting

00:22:31.160 this issue

00:22:31.920 at our time

00:22:32.640 what is my stance

00:22:34.060 is that

00:22:35.080 I believe in the

00:22:36.060 Hayat of Aisha 0.94

00:22:36.740 but

00:22:37.540 she is not 0.75

00:22:38.940 reporting something

00:22:39.800 she saw

00:22:40.360 right

00:22:41.360 she's giving something

00:22:42.580 which is from

00:22:43.100 second hand information

00:22:44.140 and the fact that

00:22:45.320 she mentioned

00:22:45.740 6 and 7

00:22:46.480 meaning there's not

00:22:47.360 the dubh

00:22:47.920 there's not something

00:22:48.560 that she's giving

00:22:49.160 in precision

00:22:49.740 this is around

00:22:51.160 about age

00:22:51.900 and

00:22:52.800 we know that

00:22:53.500 she was already 0.80

00:22:54.160 engaged

00:22:54.980 at the time

00:22:55.840 that means

00:22:56.720 according to the

00:22:57.700 according to the

00:22:59.400 customs of the time

00:23:02.140 this was the age

00:23:03.480 that women would be 0.99

00:23:04.280 engaged

00:23:04.780 and she was engaged

00:23:06.260 to a mushrik 0.87

00:23:06.860 and

00:23:07.920 when Allah

00:23:09.420 revealed to the

00:23:10.100 Prophet

00:23:10.300 that you should

00:23:10.960 marry her

00:23:11.420 that engagement

00:23:12.260 was broken

00:23:12.840 secondly

00:23:13.880 they waited

00:23:15.080 until she was

00:23:16.140 physically

00:23:16.740 mature for marriage

00:23:18.160 right

00:23:18.880 that means

00:23:19.520 that she had

00:23:20.100 hit bulub

00:23:20.980 before consummation

00:23:22.520 of marriage

00:23:23.000 once a woman's 0.86

00:23:24.220 body is

00:23:24.980 physically ready

00:23:25.980 then nature

00:23:27.000 is telling you

00:23:27.680 that she's ready

00:23:28.460 for childbirth

00:23:29.460 and marriage

00:23:29.980 and if the

00:23:31.100 customs of that

00:23:31.940 time do not

00:23:32.660 have any

00:23:33.300 anything stopping

00:23:36.320 from it

00:23:36.820 then of course

00:23:37.880 like in our time

00:23:38.700 people go to

00:23:39.120 high school

00:23:39.500 and college

00:23:40.060 and all

00:23:40.360 they don't have

00:23:40.740 any of that

00:23:41.200 when a man

00:23:42.020 was old enough

00:23:42.640 to earn his

00:23:43.460 living

00:23:44.000 he would get

00:23:44.560 married

00:23:44.820 when a woman 0.99

00:23:45.600 was old enough

00:23:46.240 to have children

00:23:46.960 and earn a house

00:23:47.540 they would get

00:23:47.940 married

00:23:48.200 so the fact

00:23:49.120 that they

00:23:49.400 waited until

00:23:50.100 she was

00:23:50.500 past physical

00:23:51.420 puberty

00:23:51.920 meaning according

00:23:52.900 to the customs

00:23:53.420 of the time

00:23:53.960 they were married

00:23:54.520 now was she

00:23:55.840 six or seven

00:23:56.560 or nine

00:23:57.120 or ten

00:23:57.560 it's going to

00:23:59.320 be in that

00:23:59.720 range

00:24:00.100 but we

00:24:01.640 cannot say

00:24:02.360 that no

00:24:02.960 if you don't

00:24:03.360 believe that

00:24:03.760 exactly at

00:24:04.460 this age

00:24:04.900 it happened

00:24:05.260 where do we

00:24:06.240 get this

00:24:06.540 from

00:24:06.760 rather

00:24:08.280 we say

00:24:09.440 that she

00:24:10.360 was at

00:24:10.960 an age

00:24:11.520 and a

00:24:12.460 physical maturity

00:24:13.360 that was

00:24:13.700 correct

00:24:14.140 according to

00:24:14.880 the

00:24:15.120 of the time

00:24:16.240 and we

00:24:16.840 don't believe

00:24:17.580 in presentism

00:24:18.560 meaning judging

00:24:19.480 the past

00:24:20.040 by today

00:24:20.600 in fact

00:24:21.560 in the

00:24:21.920 United States

00:24:22.680 until 1890

00:24:23.920 in Delaware

00:24:24.780 the age

00:24:26.000 for consummation

00:24:27.000 was seven

00:24:27.760 seven

00:24:28.240 I'll send

00:24:29.520 you the book

00:24:29.860 even in the UK

00:24:30.180 William Blackstone

00:24:31.220 I read that book

00:24:32.080 I thought it was seven

00:24:32.760 yeah

00:24:33.100 no it's called

00:24:33.800 jailbait 1.00

00:24:34.360 in British common law

00:24:35.500 it said girls

00:24:35.920 were shot at the age

00:24:36.560 of seven in England

00:24:37.140 and that's

00:24:38.900 consummation by the way

00:24:40.020 that's not

00:24:40.500 engagement

00:24:41.380 also in America

00:24:42.040 250,000 girls

00:24:43.260 at the age of 12

00:24:44.020 13 and 14

00:24:44.660 get married

00:24:45.380 my middle school

00:24:46.480 had a daycare center

00:24:48.240 I mean 12

00:24:49.520 13 year old kids

00:24:50.340 already had

00:24:51.020 Wilson Middle School

00:24:51.820 were having children

00:24:53.080 to be honest

00:24:53.920 they accused the process

00:24:54.520 of this thing

00:24:55.200 but I'll be honest

00:24:55.620 with you

00:24:55.920 it's funny

00:24:56.600 it's like Allah humiliates 0.98

00:24:57.280 because most of you

00:24:58.100 you guys

00:24:58.460 I'll be honest

00:24:58.860 with you

00:24:59.440 pedophilia 0.70

00:25:00.120 if you look at it

00:25:00.740 the ones who are

00:25:01.580 blamed by the office 0.84

00:25:02.180 they're white

00:25:03.460 middle age men

00:25:04.240 and I'm not

00:25:04.800 every white man

00:25:05.800 in that category

00:25:06.200 until

00:25:06.580 that's what it is

00:25:08.420 and they change it to

00:25:09.140 okay

00:25:09.920 yeah

00:25:10.340 so this is

00:25:11.220 I'll send you this

00:25:11.940 to you

00:25:12.780 for clarification

00:25:13.540 and just

00:25:15.180 just as one last

00:25:16.160 point for those

00:25:16.840 that try to

00:25:17.360 throw rocks

00:25:18.380 sitting in glass

00:25:19.000 houses

00:25:19.360 Rashi

00:25:20.700 go look up

00:25:21.440 his commentary

00:25:22.020 according to the

00:25:23.300 bible itself

00:25:23.920 remember the age

00:25:24.440 of Aisha

00:25:24.840 not in the

00:25:25.520 Quran

00:25:25.760 but according to

00:25:26.860 the bible itself

00:25:27.700 according to

00:25:29.040 Rashi

00:25:29.480 the best

00:25:31.280 the best

00:25:31.300 and most

00:25:32.280 accepted

00:25:32.860 commentary

00:25:33.560 by Christians

00:25:34.240 and Jews

00:25:34.600 and you can

00:25:34.980 look up

00:25:35.380 just go to

00:25:36.240 YouTube

00:25:36.420 put up

00:25:37.080 Rashi

00:25:37.480 R-A-S-H-I 1.00

00:25:38.880 commentary

00:25:39.360 and listen to

00:25:40.620 Jews and

00:25:41.300 scholars and

00:25:42.040 Christians

00:25:42.380 praise Rashi

00:25:43.260 he said

00:25:44.320 that according

00:25:45.140 to the bible

00:25:45.800 itself

00:25:46.540 Rebecca

00:25:47.620 was three

00:25:48.280 years old

00:25:49.060 when she

00:25:49.840 consummated

00:25:50.760 her marriage

00:25:51.240 she was

00:25:51.540 married

00:25:52.140 to a

00:25:53.080 40 year

00:25:53.620 old

00:25:54.000 Isaac

00:25:55.140 and she

00:25:56.220 is legally

00:25:58.080 according to

00:25:58.720 Jewish law

00:25:59.740 at three

00:26:00.600 years of age

00:26:01.320 able to

00:26:01.780 fully be

00:26:02.300 married

00:26:02.620 but did he

00:26:03.380 wait for her 0.94

00:26:03.760 to become

00:26:04.120 an adult

00:26:04.480 there is

00:26:05.180 nothing like

00:26:05.780 that in the

00:26:06.160 bible

00:26:06.280 yes

00:26:07.100 look up

00:26:07.700 Rashi

00:26:07.980 it's not

00:26:08.720 my opinion

00:26:09.220 Rashi

00:26:09.540 is a

00:26:12.080 Jewish

00:26:12.380 commentator

00:26:12.960 12th century

00:26:13.980 and he is

00:26:14.900 highly praised

00:26:15.880 as the

00:26:16.300 greatest

00:26:16.580 commentator

00:26:17.280 of the

00:26:17.900 old

00:26:18.040 testament

00:26:18.380 in fact

00:26:19.420 according to

00:26:20.360 the earliest

00:26:20.980 Christian

00:26:21.380 documentation

00:26:22.120 about the

00:26:22.960 age of

00:26:23.380 Joseph

00:26:23.760 and I'll

00:26:24.160 send you

00:26:24.540 scans of

00:26:25.320 all of

00:26:25.620 these

00:26:25.860 Joseph

00:26:26.680 was 90

00:26:27.600 years old

00:26:28.480 when he

00:26:29.040 married a

00:26:29.460 12 year

00:26:30.060 old

00:26:30.380 Mary

00:26:30.880 Mary

00:26:32.720 was 12

00:26:33.320 years old

00:26:33.660 married to

00:26:34.080 a 90

00:26:34.440 year old

00:26:34.740 man

00:26:34.960 today if

00:26:35.700 that happened

00:26:36.180 what would

00:26:36.640 you call

00:26:36.900 that

00:26:37.080 so are

00:26:38.700 you saying

00:26:39.080 Joseph

00:26:39.540 was a

00:26:40.180 paraphral

00:26:40.540 and Mary

00:26:41.220 was being

00:26:41.680 you know

00:26:41.960 right

00:26:42.400 you don't

00:26:43.280 see that

00:26:43.620 right

00:26:43.820 in fact

00:26:44.780 in the

00:26:45.180 gospel of

00:26:45.880 James

00:26:46.260 it also

00:26:47.300 mentions

00:26:47.880 and this

00:26:48.680 is not

00:26:49.500 in the

00:26:49.740 bible

00:26:49.940 today

00:26:50.280 it's one

00:26:50.720 of the

00:26:50.940 other books

00:26:51.660 it mentions

00:26:52.640 clearly that

00:26:53.480 Mary was

00:26:53.900 12 years

00:26:54.300 did I

00:27:02.620 clarify my

00:27:03.280 stance

00:27:03.540 good

00:27:04.440 barakallah

00:27:05.000 and yeah

00:27:05.960 that's it

00:27:06.220 we're here

00:27:06.960 with the

00:27:07.200 champs

00:27:07.520 in the

00:27:10.260 building

00:27:10.520 yes and

00:27:12.220 any

00:27:12.460 reverts out

00:27:13.120 etc

00:27:13.440 again like I

00:27:14.260 said we

00:27:14.660 should

00:27:14.840 obviously

00:27:15.240 assume the

00:27:15.560 best of

00:27:15.860 maybe it was

00:27:17.460 style

00:27:17.740 whatever but

00:27:18.260 just want you

00:27:19.420 guys to know

00:27:19.840 that do not

00:27:20.320 feel shy

00:27:20.760 if you have a

00:27:21.200 doubt it does

00:27:21.920 not make you a

00:27:22.320 disbeliever you can

00:27:22.880 come and ask

00:27:23.420 questions please

00:27:24.700 feel free if

00:27:25.760 anyone makes you

00:27:26.400 feel like oh I

00:27:26.980 have a doubt and

00:27:27.580 they say to you

00:27:27.980 have a jinn in you

00:27:28.620 go read the

00:27:29.220 quran 0.85

00:27:29.500 we're there

00:27:30.700 we're there

00:27:31.000 inshallah

00:27:31.280 videos are there

00:27:32.480 many people's

00:27:32.900 videos are there

00:27:33.260 inshallah to

00:27:33.600 clarify for you

00:27:34.160 guys and that's

00:27:34.940 it may Allah

00:27:35.220 bless and preserve

00:27:35.740 you guys all

00:27:36.140 inshallah

00:27:36.440 best night

Ali Dawah - March 25, 2025

SH UTHMAN ANSWERS SN£KOS HADITH QUESTION

Episode Stats

Summary

Transcript