Ali Dawah - January 26, 2025UNDERCOVER SPY (CHRISTIAN) CAUGHT OUT
Episode Stats
Words per Minute
217.00627
Summary
In this episode, we talk about why I don't find Islam convincing, and why I believe that Jesus was not crucified by Allah, but was copied by the pagans of his time, and that the Qur'an was copied from the Gnostics.
Transcript
00:00:00.000
I don't find Islam convincing, and for me a lot of it is how it's rooted in paganism
00:00:06.800
and like how the pagans of Mohammed's time called him an heir.
00:00:10.600
Why? Because he would very much take from the Gnostic Christians, he would take from the Jews,
00:00:20.200
If two people are fighting in a UFC and I say, one guy's looking quite beat down,
00:00:24.600
and I say, hey, I want to put my money on that guy, what's impressive about that?
00:00:27.800
Because that's what your prophet did, and I don't find anything impressive for that.
00:00:30.400
So it's not the knockout blow that you think it is.
00:00:33.200
They were going back and forth, there was times when Persians were winning, the Romans won.
00:00:37.800
You'll find out in a minute, yeah? It's very impressive actually.
00:00:39.800
It's actually, I think this is a knockout blow, yeah? For anybody, number one.
00:00:45.800
Listen to me, listen to me, look, you're a Christian, don't come and say to me you're not a Christian.
00:00:48.800
You're a Christian, and you are here lying pretending that, oh I'm just coming to learn, you're not.
00:00:53.800
You are someone that's hostile, you're hostile, you're hostile.
00:00:56.800
You're hostile, brother, listen, listen, brother, it's your janazah, I would do janazah to pray over you.
00:01:00.800
Your funeral was happening, you buried you here.
00:01:03.800
We want to establish an amazing masjid for the sake of Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala in the country of Norway.
00:01:16.800
Click on the link and donate now for the sake of Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala.
00:01:34.800
He saw you out, so he wants to, he came to see you.
00:01:43.800
I'm inquiring, I suppose I'm agnostic, so I don't want to misspeak on the faith or misrepresent it.
00:01:59.800
And for me, a lot of it is how it's rooted in paganism.
00:02:04.800
And like how the pagans of Mohammed's time called him an heir.
00:02:09.800
He would very much take from the Gnostic Christians, he would take from the Jews.
00:02:17.800
So, the evidence is within the texts that outdate the time of Mohammed.
00:02:28.800
Like the Gospel of Judas, the Gospel of Thomas, that very much influenced what Mohammed taught.
00:02:34.800
So, where's your evidence that that influenced that, but rather it's not from the same source?
00:02:38.800
So, the evidence of that is that the people were very much present in the region, these people.
00:02:49.800
And we see that Mohammed was called an heir because he was...
00:02:56.800
What it meant was that he was listening to what he was told and then he was preaching it like it was his revelation.
00:03:13.800
So, yeah, so what I was going to say is the following.
00:03:28.800
Gnostic texts that outdate Islam and clearly influence Mohammed.
00:03:32.800
So, where is your evidence that they influenced him?
00:03:34.800
And number two, can you show me the correlation where, for example, the Qur'an copied from there?
00:03:40.800
Because I can make clear claims, but that's not the case.
00:03:44.800
Because you're claiming that just because they were before, he copied.
00:03:46.800
So, tell me something that is copied from there that the Qur'an has.
00:03:49.800
Okay, the evidence is that we see the Gnostic texts talk about things like the crucifixion of Jesus making it made to appear that way.
00:04:04.800
Allah says that he was not crucified nor was he killed.
00:04:07.800
So, this thing of, for example, understanding what that means.
00:04:10.800
For example, it was appeared so, somebody, the replacement theory.
00:04:14.800
These are all people, scholars, who have said this could be the case.
00:04:22.800
They did not kill him nor did they crucify him.
00:04:24.800
So, the Qur'an doesn't say it was replaced or something like that.
00:04:28.800
So, when you talk about the scholars, as we know, well-respected scholars like Bart Ehrman.
00:04:38.800
Yeah, this will, insha'Allah, teach you how to pray salah, bro.
00:04:42.800
If you have any questions, if you turn to the back, the QR code.
00:04:45.800
The QR code will, you can book instructors that will teach you how to pray salah.
00:04:55.800
So, now, the question is, for example, do you follow the Bible today?
00:04:59.800
So, for me, like I said, I'm inquiring into Christianity.
00:05:01.800
I don't want to misrepresent it or misspeak it.
00:05:08.800
So, if you do, then, for example, if the Qur'an copied, for example, we have a clear example,
00:05:11.800
when it comes to an historical, historical fact that the Bible got wrong, but the Qur'an
00:05:18.800
So, if that's the case, the Qur'an could never come from the Bible.
00:05:21.800
For example, in the Qur'an, in the Bible, when you read the Bible, it talks about the time of
00:05:24.800
Joseph, and it talks about the time of Moses, correct?
00:05:28.800
In the time of Moses, it refers to the ruler as a Pharaoh.
00:05:30.800
In the time of Moses, it refers to the ruler as a Pharaoh.
00:05:36.800
Now, if the Qur'an and the Prophet Muhammad copied from the Bible, it would have copied
00:05:40.800
Because when you look into the Qur'an, the Qur'an also talks about Joseph, Yusuf, and it
00:05:44.800
So, now, when we look at those two instances, the Qur'an makes something very, very unique.
00:05:48.800
When it talks about the time of Joseph, it refers to the ruler as a king, not as a Pharaoh.
00:05:53.800
But when it talks about Moses' time, it says when Moses went to Pharaoh.
00:05:59.800
When they deciphered, as you know, I don't know if you know, hieroglyphics was a dead language.
00:06:08.800
Hieroglyphics when they found out the Rosetta Stone.
00:06:10.800
The Rosetta Stone helped them understand the hieroglyphics.
00:06:13.800
When they understood the hieroglyphics, they came to the conclusion that, at the time of
00:06:21.800
That does not historically follow because there were no Pharaohs.
00:06:27.800
So, the Qur'an, if copied the Bible, why did it not copy that mistake?
00:06:31.800
So, for me, how I would address this, looking at the way it was referred to, differentiates
00:06:38.800
I would say that, within the cultural context, there could have been different ways to refer
00:06:49.800
You saying it's not a problem does not make a problem.
00:06:55.800
No, I'm saying that in language there's different ways to refer to different things.
00:07:06.800
The dynasty, Pharaoh dynasty is later, and also Pharaoh deemed themselves to be gods.
00:07:14.800
So what I'm saying is, the Bible makes that historical mistake.
00:07:22.800
The Bible is making a categorical historical mistake by the findings that we have today.
00:07:34.800
Number one, it proves that the Quran is from God.
00:07:36.800
Number two, it proves that the Bible, the Quran never copied from the Bible.
00:07:40.800
So even if we take that argument at face value, all it demonstrates is that the Quran used the correct title.
00:08:01.800
Because right now, you're just basically saying, I've got nothing to say.
00:08:15.800
In front of my face, you're being this ingenuous.
00:08:18.800
So you're saying you've got a historical title, right?
00:08:30.800
In order for it to claim it's from God, it has to bring certain miracles that we can say, hold on a second.
00:08:38.800
Now, it says that you said Muhammad, peace be upon him, copied from the Christian scripture.
00:08:44.800
This debunks that and proves the Quran is from God.
00:08:47.800
Firstly, the Bible makes a historical mistake, a historical error, historical fallacy, which is what?
00:09:02.800
If the Bible says there were pharaohs, it is making a mistake in history.
00:09:11.800
The Quran says, and when Joseph went to the king.
00:09:15.800
Now, the question I'm asking is, why does the Quran make this unique, subtle correction?
00:09:21.800
Because if it's copying from the Bible, it would copy the mistake, which it doesn't.
00:09:25.800
And we only came to know about this when they found the Rosetta Stone.
00:09:29.800
They deciphered the hieroglyphics and said, well, hold on a second.
00:09:33.800
So, which means that how did the Quran know this historical accuracy?
00:09:39.800
So, first of all, I would say that you're sort of, and again, when I speak on scripture, I don't want to misspeak.
00:09:45.800
So, you're sort of holding the Bible to the same standard you try and hold your Quran to, which it doesn't mean.
00:10:07.800
It doesn't matter if it's a king or pharaoh so much.
00:10:16.800
You just said to me, there's many scriptures, etc.
00:10:21.800
Again, it's like me telling you today is cold, but you're like, no, I feel hot.
00:10:31.800
And I'm not doing this to catch you up, but you know very well you have no answer to it.
00:10:41.800
Number one, the fact that the Quran didn't copy that mistake, does it show that it doesn't copy the Bible?
00:10:47.800
It's the fact that the Quran doesn't copy the mistake.
00:10:49.800
If the Prophet Muhammad was copying the Bible, he would have copied nearly everything.
00:10:55.800
When he was copying this, because the story of Joseph and the story of Moses also mentioned in the Quran.
00:10:58.800
Why did the Prophet Muhammad say, okay, I'm going to copy the Bible.
00:11:07.800
I'm going to call the Pharaoh, not a Pharaoh, I'm going to call him a king.
00:11:11.800
Number two, how did the Prophet Muhammad know this fact if it's from himself?
00:11:18.800
So he could have been copying from oral traditions that held to this fact or that...
00:11:24.800
How could he copy something that they believed this to be Pharaoh?
00:11:29.800
Okay, like I said, he could have copied this not necessarily from the Injil, but from people sort of correcting this mistake or from different manuscripts.
00:11:43.800
He could have got it from other Christians with various different manuscripts.
00:11:55.800
What I'm saying is admit that the Quran didn't copy the Bible.
00:11:58.800
Number two, you cannot answer the fact that how did the Prophet Muhammad know this fact?
00:12:13.800
Now, this is very interesting because the Quran says that the Romans have been defeated in the nearer land.
00:12:19.800
And after their defeat, they will come and win over the Persians.
00:12:22.800
So, do you know the Persian Empire and the Roman Empire were at war with each other?
00:12:30.800
There were times when Persians were winning, the Romans won.
00:12:43.800
Now, in that time, who would you put your bets on?
00:12:45.800
If you've seen the Persians have annihilated Romans.
00:12:49.800
Edward Gibbons, who's not a Muslim, who's a historian on the Roman Empire.
00:12:53.800
He says that the way that the Romans were defeated, them coming back was an impossibility.
00:13:10.800
So, whoever won at the time, first of all, you need to understand that it was a long-going battle.
00:13:16.800
If two people are fighting in a UFC, and I say...
00:13:19.800
One guy's looking quite beat down, and I say, hey, I want to put my money on that guy.
00:13:23.800
Because that's what your profit did, and I don't find anything impressive to that.
00:13:25.800
So, it's not the knockout blow that you think it is.
00:13:30.800
So, in a UFC fight, if two people are fighting, one guy's getting punched down, they've been fighting for a long time.
00:13:36.800
And then I put my money on the guys standing up, like the guys on the floor.
00:13:41.800
Okay, good. That's perfect, because the Qur'an does the opposite.
00:13:42.800
Would you put your money on the one that's been on the floor?
00:13:47.800
You said, what's impressive about the one who's been beat down?
00:13:54.800
If you are genuine, you are about to accept this.
00:13:58.800
It says, the one that's been beat down is going to come back and win the war.
00:14:05.800
It's saying that the Romans have been defeated.
00:14:08.800
Now, the Qur'an is saying, the Romans are going to come back and win the war.
00:14:13.800
So, now I'm going to ask you a simple question.
00:14:15.800
You just said something which, if you are genuine, would you stand by it?
00:14:20.800
The one that's on the floor is going to come back and beat.
00:14:23.800
The Qur'an says the Romans will come and defeat them.
00:14:27.800
The Romans came back in three to nine or three to seven years and beat the Persians.
00:14:33.800
How did the Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him, know this fact?
00:14:37.800
Okay, so he would have made an analysis of the war and the ongoing conflict.
00:14:49.800
I didn't say if it's the Persians of the Romans.
00:14:54.800
You are a full-blown, you're a Christian, you're a disingenuous person.
00:14:58.800
You're telling me, when I speak about scripture, I have to be careful.
00:15:00.800
Listen, why are you so careful if you're not a Christian, if you're an agnostic?
00:15:04.800
I don't want to make sure you present the face of the war.
00:15:08.800
But when it comes to the Qur'an, you're not very careful.
00:15:11.800
You said very clearly, it is not impressive that the one who's being beat for me to put the money on.
00:15:19.800
The Qur'an says the Romans will come back and defeat the Persians.
00:15:31.800
They made a historical analysis of the ongoing conflict.
00:15:48.800
The only way I'm treating you like this is because you are disingenuous.
00:15:52.800
When you said, oh, how is it impressive if the guy on top?
00:15:54.800
And I proved to you, it's actually the one on the floor the Qur'an's predicted.
00:16:02.800
Don't come and say to me you're not a Christian.
00:16:03.800
You're a Christian and you are here lying pretending that, oh, I'm just coming to learn.
00:16:10.800
You're disingenuous because you're misrepresented in my position now.
00:16:46.800
Islam.net is establishing a masjid and a community center.
00:16:47.800
If you donate to build this masjid, Allah will inshallah build a house for you in Jannah
00:16:52.800
Every person who prays in this masjid, every child that memorizes the Quran, you will inshallah