Bannon's War Room - July 07, 2026


Episode 5499: Day 2 Of The Charlie Kirk Assassination Trial Cont.

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Episode 5495: Joe Allen Live; Assassination Of Charlie Kirk Trial Begins Episode 5502: Day 3 Of The Charlie Kirk Assassination Trial

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 6 minutes

Words per minute

152.61

Word count

10,157

Sentence count

701

Harmful content

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, the Court of Appeal rules that DNA evidence should be excluded from the case because it is not consistent across forensic DNA testing over time. DNA testing can only be performed on single-sourcing samples, which means there is no way to determine the exact number of contributors to DNA evidence. However, there are a number of ways to estimate the total number of DNA contributors to a crime scene. In this case, a DNA expert testified that this is not a problem.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 ...determinations are not proper for the court to make here for the whole reason that, you know, studies supporting this science, studies opposing this science,
00:00:10 testimony from this expert or that expert about what is reliable, what is not, what's more reliable, what's less reliable, factors that affect all those determinations,
00:00:19 those are all very, very complex decisions.
00:00:22 There will be probably multiple-day hearings dealing with that.
00:00:26 And a probable cause determination is just not the place to conduct that kind of thorough, in-depth, and searching analysis.
00:00:32 Rather, the case law, the Constitution of Utah that says the only purpose of a preliminary hearing is determining probable cause,
00:00:40 the case law, the rules that all say the court does not weigh the evidence at this stage,
00:00:45 but leaves that for a finder of fact, the jury in the end.
00:00:48 And that all supports cutting this line of questioning off at this point
00:00:54 rather than going on into greater depth, Your Honor.
00:01:01 All right.
00:01:04 Based off what's been presented before me,
00:01:07 I'm going to sustain in part and deny in part the objection made.
00:01:11 I'm going to allow this question to be asked,
00:01:14 And so that is denying, but sustained in the sense that this would be the last question.
00:01:20 And if Mr. Burt would choose us to, may go on to a different subject or a different line of questioning.
00:01:28 Sure.
00:01:30 Did that in this report conclude that it remains unclear if visual inspection renders consistent number of contributor estimations across analysts over time?
00:01:44 Can you repeat that?
00:01:45 Yeah.
00:01:46 Did the report, the NIST report that you referenced,
00:01:49 conclude that it remains unclear if visual inspection renders consistent number of contributor
00:01:56 estimations across analysts over time?
00:02:01 I think that goes to the DNA evidence.
00:02:06 Again, we never truly know the number of contributors in a forensic sample.
00:02:13 So like I mentioned before, you could have DNA mixtures that are made up of two, three, four individuals.
00:02:19 I have training.
00:02:20 I have experience.
00:02:21 I followed standard operating procedures.
00:02:24 So I'm making the best determination based on the evidence, the DNA evidence that I have as far as number of contributors goes.
00:02:34 Now, if I could, I'd like to return to your case notes.
00:02:37 And could you display for the witness page 365 of tab number four?
00:02:49 And while he's doing that, by the way, it's true that if you change the number of contributors,
00:02:53 you're going to get different numbers from the software program.
00:02:57 It depends.
00:02:58 So actually, each time you run the software, you will get a different number based on the math that the software system does.
00:03:06 But there are studies and validations that show we don't expect that math to be greatly different, usually by a factor of 10.
00:03:15 Changing the number of contributors, it depends.
00:03:17 If you have a major contributor, someone who's made up most of that DNA profile,
00:03:23 if I originally interpret something as three, calculate a statistic,
00:03:27 if that major contributor is the individual that I'm comparing to,
00:03:31 If I change the number of contributors to two, based on the studies and based on my own experience, it doesn't change the likelihood ratio of that major contributor by much.
00:03:42 But it does change it, correct?
00:03:44 Yes.
00:03:45 And you just said, I think, that even when you put in the same parameters, you don't get the same answer if you run it through SDR mix more than once, right?
00:03:55 That is correct. Based on how StarMix utilizes math and distributions, you will never get the
00:04:02 same answer twice, but it will be no more than a magnitude of 10. So that test is not
00:04:11 reproducible in the sense that you can run a sample or your assumptions in there 10 times,
00:04:18 you could get 10 different answers. That is true. Again, the first time I run StarMix,
00:04:24 I'm not going to get a likelihood ratio of 10 and the second time get 10 quadrillion.
00:04:29 I might get 10 quadrillion the first time, 2 quadrillion the second time,
00:04:34 but even if I run it 10 times, I'm still going to get around the same likelihood ratio value.
00:04:39 Now, could you look at tab number 4, your case notes at page 365,
00:04:46 if you could bring that up to the witness?
00:04:54 Let me know when you have that in front of you.
00:04:57 I think you need to scroll up one page.
00:05:05 There we go.
00:05:08 Can you identify this page from your notes?
00:05:11 Yes, I can.
00:05:12 These were notes that my technical reviewer made.
00:05:15 And my technical reviewer, they will review all of my DNA evidence.
00:05:19 They will draw their own conclusions as far as number of contributors and comparisons, then compare it back to my conclusions.
00:05:28 All right.
00:05:28 So this is regarding the seven sample, correct?
00:05:32 That is correct.
00:05:33 That is one of the samples.
00:05:34 And your original assessment was that there were three contributors to this sample, right?
00:05:39 That is correct, yes.
00:05:41 And that conclusion was reviewed by a reviewer, correct?
00:05:46 Correct, yes.
00:05:46 She read the same electropherograms or the name for the output of this technology you used, correct?
00:05:55 She utilized the same electropherogram, which is the chart that the DNA is on.
00:06:01 And does this page in front of you, is that an accurate representation of your case file?
00:06:06 Yes, it is.
00:06:07 So I'm moving to evidence page 365, and that would be Baker 4.
00:06:19 Mr. McBride?
00:06:21 I'll object on relevance grounds.
00:06:25 All right.
00:06:25 Did you want to respond, Mr. Burt?
00:06:28 Your Honor, it's relevant because the witness originally determined that there were three contributors,
00:06:35 and I'd like her to explain to the court how she reached that conclusion
00:06:39 because I think it does go to the reliability of her testing here.
00:06:43 All right, so as it relates to Baker 4,
00:06:50 and this is her personal notes from Ms. Baker
00:06:55 as it relates to what I'm assuming is State's Exhibit 31,
00:07:02 that these notes were prepared as part of the report in State's Exhibit 31.
00:07:11 I find that it is relevant and that it is admitted into evidence as regards to publication.
00:07:18 What is the request, Mr. Bird?
00:07:20 If I may clarify, I think the testimony was that this was not her notes.
00:07:24 These were the notes of her technical reviewer is what I heard.
00:07:28 If I, please correct me if I misheard that from both sides.
00:07:32 I want to make sure, I want to make sure, are these Ms. Baker's notes?
00:07:37 Could I clarify that?
00:07:39 Absolutely.
00:07:41 Ms. Baker, these are notes in your case file, correct?
00:07:46 These are notes in my case file, but they're not my notes.
00:07:48 And the way your lab works, you're not the one that does all the different steps in the testing process, correct?
00:07:58 That is correct.
00:08:00 Other analysts have input.
00:08:02 That then all goes into the case file, which you have access to and rely upon in rendering your opinions.
00:08:10 That is correct, yes.
00:08:11 And this particular page is a note written by your peer reviewer that you relied upon?
00:08:21 Correct.
00:08:22 After I made my interpretations and drew conclusions, my technical reviewer then reviews the data and draws their own conclusions.
00:08:30 So this was created after I had already drew my own conclusions.
00:08:41 All right, I'm just trying to put it together here.
00:08:50 So the question I'm trying to get to, Council, is was this particular,
00:08:56 I recognize it as it being prepared by someone else,
00:09:00 but as it relates to States Exhibit 31,
00:09:03 was this relied upon in order for States Exhibit 31 to be put together as the report?
00:09:11 Because I'm trying to determine relevancy as it relates to that, and that's a crucial point I don't have the answer to just yet.
00:09:21 Okay.
00:09:23 Let me lay a more adequate foundation.
00:09:26 The case file notes are assessed by you at every step of the analysis, correct?
00:09:38 Not necessarily at every step.
00:09:43 Before I issue a report, before I write a report, I review all of the case notes.
00:09:49 So that will be any communication log entries, any documentation from the laboratory, the biologists that perform the DNA testing.
00:09:59 I will review all of that, write a report, and then give that to a technical reviewer.
00:10:05 They will draw their own conclusions to determine if they agree with me.
00:10:10 If they do, they will sign off, and then my report and my case file will go for an administrative review
00:10:16 to make sure that the laboratory number is correct on all the pages,
00:10:22 that if there's any crossouts, there's dates and initials and so forth.
00:10:25 Those two reviews have to be done before I can actually make it a final report and case file
00:10:31 that gets submitted and sent to the field.
00:10:34 And in this case, correct me if I'm wrong, but the sequence was you originally determined in seven, sample seven, that there were three contributors.
00:10:44 That conclusion got reviewed.
00:10:46 Then you ran some further testing, and then you changed your conclusion, correct?
00:10:52 That is correct, yes.
00:10:53 And before you change your conclusion, you, of course, go back and look at what the reviewer said about her review.
00:11:00 We would have a discussion.
00:11:02 If I say a number of contributors was three, here she notated that it was two.
00:11:08 We had that discussion.
00:11:10 She agreed with three.
00:11:11 So for that step of that process, because again, we're piecemealing this.
00:11:17 Typically in a normal case, we will work all of the evidence.
00:11:20 I will write a report.
00:11:22 For this situation, I had DNA evidence coming to me throughout the day, throughout the night.
00:11:28 So I had reviewers at different steps, which is not usual for a case.
00:11:32 usually I have one reviewer. So in this case, at that particular time, I had a reviewer. Then when
00:11:38 I was submitted additional known samples and used those for comparisons, then I did have additional
00:11:45 conclusions and additional reviewers. But you certainly took into account this notation on
00:11:50 this page before you changed your conclusion, correct? I don't know that I would agree that
00:11:57 I took into account. We had already had that conversation. And again, once I received additional
00:12:02 known samples and additional information from the field, I then did amend my conclusion.
00:12:08 And these notes are kept in the ordinary course of your business?
00:12:12 Yes.
00:12:12 And they're part of the case file that you rely upon in reaching your conclusions?
00:12:18 They are kept with the case file after I draw my conclusions.
00:12:25 So, Your Honor, I think there's a foundation for this. The state has offered all kinds of
00:12:30 hearsay here and certainly this is
00:12:32 there's no question about the reliability
00:12:34 of the entries.
00:12:35 Alright.
00:12:38 Anything further from the parties
00:12:39 before I weigh
00:12:42 in on, well, make my
00:12:44 ruling on Baker 4? No.
00:12:47 The
00:12:48 court finds that it is relevant
00:12:50 and as it
00:12:52 relates to Stakes Exhibit
00:12:54 31 and Baker 4 is admitted
00:12:56 into evidence in regards to publication.
00:12:58 Mr. Burt, what is your request?
00:13:02 That it be published.
00:13:03 All right, to in the courtroom?
00:13:05 Both the courtroom and to the cameras.
00:13:09 All right.
00:13:10 Any objection, Mr. McBride?
00:13:13 All right.
00:13:14 Go ahead and publish that to all screens.
00:13:17 It may be captured by the media.
00:13:20 So these notations at the top there,
00:13:23 7-1 male, discuss 3 NOC, and okay with 3. Could you translate that for us, what that means?
00:13:33 Sure. So when my technical reviewer took a look at the DNA evidence, she determined that male DNA
00:13:40 was present, and she concluded that she would have called it a number of contributor of 2.
00:13:46 She compared it to my conclusions. I said number of contributor 3. So we had a discussion as to
00:13:52 why she thought it was two, why I thought it was three.
00:13:55 And she said she agreed with me calling it three based on her discussion.
00:14:00 Okay.
00:14:01 So was that an extended discussion you had with her or just?
00:14:06 No, this was a quick discussion, and this is not unusual.
00:14:09 We have discussions like this during the technical process quite often.
00:14:12 And the stamp on the bottom approved by Tara Benson, is that the reviewer?
00:14:18 Yes, it is.
00:14:19 All right, thank you.
00:14:20 Now, I want to ask you to look at page 128 of that same exhibit.
00:14:39 No.
00:14:42 Is this an electrophairogram that is a part of your case file?
00:14:48 Yes, it is.
00:14:48 And is this an accurate representation of what's depicted on this page?
00:14:56 I'm sorry.
00:14:57 There's nothing on the screen.
00:14:59 Am I?
00:15:00 Yeah, 128.
00:15:09 Yes, it is.
00:15:10 I move that into evidence, Your Honor.
00:15:12 This would be Baker 4, page 128.
00:15:18 Oh, I thought I already admitted Baker 4. Is this a different?
00:15:23 The previous one was Baker 4, as I understood it.
00:15:27 Yeah, Baker 4, page 365.
00:15:30 Oh, okay.
00:15:32 And so this is Baker 4, page 128.
00:15:38 Right, so the previous admitted exhibit is Baker 4, 365.
00:15:42 The current proposed one is Baker 4, 128.
00:15:45 That's correct.
00:15:45 All right, Mr. McBride.
00:15:46 If I could have just a minute to update my notes on those page numbers.
00:15:50 All right.
00:15:56 365 was the previous one, unless I heard it wrong.
00:15:58 Yes, that's right.
00:15:59 All right.
00:16:00 And the current one is 128.
00:16:09 First, I'll note, this is the first I'm seeing these as exhibits.
00:16:13 Of course, I have this file, but I was unaware that these are going to be offered as exhibits,
00:16:18 so I'm looking to find them in my file as we go.
00:16:22 Second, again, I'm going to object on relevance grounds to the probable cause determination.
00:16:29 We're going through the finite details of the analysis here.
00:16:33 And once again, I think these are appropriate questions to raise in a 702 hearing,
00:16:37 but with the standards that apply at the preliminary hearing that I've already discussed,
00:16:43 I think we're beyond the scope of probable cause determination as we dive into this evidence.
00:16:48 All right. Mr. Burtz.
00:16:50 Your Honor, I think this exhibit is particularly important because the court does not yet have in front of it what an electrophairogram is and how it's interpreted.
00:17:00 And this particular page will illustrate to the court how the analysts interpreted the peaks on this electropherogram to reach the conclusions that she reached, that there were three and not two contributors.
00:17:15 And I think it will assist the court in determining exactly how this comparison process works and what the output looks like so the court can see exactly how the interpretations are being made.
00:17:27 and is this the dose that we're relied upon uh in i'm so i'm viewing stays exhibit 31 as a summary
00:17:37 and this more of showing the work of how the summary was reached am i misunderstanding how
00:17:44 this fits in this fits into uh how the analyst originally was of the opinion that there are
00:17:52 three people here, and not two.
00:17:55 And she will go on to explain how she changed
00:18:00 the interpretation from three to two.
00:18:04 And the point of this is to illustrate to the court
00:18:09 that this is a subjective process, to a certain extent,
00:18:13 and that people can read these things in different ways.
00:18:18 And so I think it will help the court understand exactly what's
00:18:23 being compared here.
00:18:25 You've got peaks on a line, she will say.
00:18:28 And just to let the court know, in response
00:18:31 to Mr. McBride's statement that he was unaware
00:18:35 that this is going to be an issue,
00:18:38 he and I met with this analyst before the preliminary hearing.
00:18:44 The analyst pointed this page out to us
00:18:46 as being illustrative of why she originally
00:18:52 concluded that there were three contributors.
00:18:55 So this is not something that's being sprung on the state.
00:18:59 He was a part of that conversation.
00:19:01 And this particular page was identified by the analyst,
00:19:04 not by me.
00:19:06 So it is important to understand why we went from three to two
00:19:11 and what impact that has on the numbers that the state is offering.
00:19:16 All right.
00:19:17 Anything further?
00:19:18 No.
00:19:20 All right.
00:19:20 Under Utah Rule of Evidence 1102, B4, it says Scientific Laboratory of Forensic Reports and Records,
00:19:32 I find that this is admissible and is admitted into evidence as Baker 4, page 128.
00:19:42 And is there a request to publish this document?
00:19:48 Was that a yes?
00:19:50 Oh, okay.
00:19:51 Yes.
00:19:51 All right.
00:19:52 So published, I'm assuming, to all to that screen as well?
00:19:56 Yes, correct.
00:19:56 All right. It may be published.
00:19:57 Counsel, just as a reminder, as this is a probable cause,
00:20:02 I understand and I appreciate you give me a pointer of where it's going,
00:20:07 but just as a reminder, as probable cause, it is admitted, and you may discuss it,
00:20:15 but I definitely want to keep this within the track of probable cause.
00:20:19 Understood.
00:20:20 All right.
00:20:21 Thank you, Mr. Burt.
00:20:25 Okay.
00:20:27 Is it true what I just told the court that you pointed this particular page out
00:20:32 as illustrating why you originally thought we had three contributors?
00:20:36 Yes, that is true.
00:20:36 So explain to the court, is this an electropherogram?
00:20:40 Yes, this is an electropherogram.
00:20:42 Each of those rectangles at the top, for example, D2S441,
00:20:48 that is that small segment of DNA that I referred to earlier.
00:20:52 And each of those peaks has a corresponding number that is the allele, so that corresponds to the number of repeats that an individual inherited.
00:21:02 And this is why you ultimately, you get this electropherogram not through running it through SDR mix.
00:21:12 There's a different device that you use to produce these electropherograms, right?
00:21:17 Correct. Yes. During the DNA process, this is the last step of that process. So what it's doing is it's, so we, DNA is found in cells of our body. We're taking those cells, we're breaking them open with chemicals to release the DNA from those cells. We're making photocopies of those pieces of DNA so that we can essentially see them.
00:21:40 And then the last step is to separate those pieces by size, and the ultimate output is this electropharogram.
00:21:48 Okay.
00:21:49 And is it true that you set the parameters for what the machine will pop up in terms of numbering the alleles?
00:22:00 Personally, I do not set that up.
00:22:02 That was done during our validation of the chemicals and the software and the instrument that we utilize.
00:22:09 but there are parameters. So the output of the DNA lets me know, for example, the different
00:22:17 types of alleles, but that's not a parameter I set. I want to make sure you answered that.
00:22:24 You set, or your lab sets, what the machine does in terms of labeling particular alleles, correct?
00:22:33 Yes, that's part of the whole process and the validation, yes.
00:22:37 So you could tell the machine, give me all the peaks at whatever level and label them as whatever the alleles are.
00:22:48 I see.
00:22:48 So yes.
00:22:49 So during our validation, we determine our thresholds, our analytical threshold, and that stochastic threshold that I mentioned before.
00:22:56 The analytical threshold is a threshold that was determined during validation that we input into the software that I utilize.
00:23:04 that says, for example, our analytical threshold is 150.
00:23:08 Any peak that is 150 or greater,
00:23:11 the software system will give me that allele call or that number for that peak.
00:23:16 Any peak that's below the 150,
00:23:20 the software system will not give me an allele call for it.
00:23:24 Even though it might be a true allele?
00:23:27 Correct, yes.
00:23:28 So you could say, and you referred to a measurement,
00:23:32 you refer to that as RFUs, right?
00:23:35 Yes, that is the unit.
00:23:37 What does that mean?
00:23:38 It stands for Relative Fluorescent Unit.
00:23:42 So in your lab, you tell a machine only label peaks that come above 150 RFU.
00:23:49 The software that utilizes the information from the machine, yes.
00:23:54 However, it's true, is it not, that in determining the number of contributors,
00:23:58 you look below that 150 RFU level.
00:24:03 And that is true, yes.
00:24:04 All right.
00:24:04 Now, on this, this is only showing four different locations, right?
00:24:11 Correct, yes.
00:24:12 And you see a number of peaks at each one of these locations.
00:24:17 Some of them are labeled.
00:24:19 Some of them are not.
00:24:20 Correct, yes.
00:24:21 So tell us how you originally looked at this and said there's not two contributors, there's three.
00:24:27 Sure.
00:24:28 So first what I do is I count how many labels that I see,
00:24:32 so how many of those little squares under each of those locations.
00:24:36 So for example, at D2S441, there are three squares.
00:24:41 Knowing that one piece of information comes from mom and one comes from dad,
00:24:45 if it's a single source profile from one individual,
00:24:47 I expect to see no more than two squares.
00:24:50 Because I see three, that gives me an indication that there's at least two individuals.
00:24:55 Same thing for the next D19S433 and as well as FGA.
00:25:02 There were three peaks that were called.
00:25:05 So I knew this had to be at least two individuals.
00:25:08 Then what I do is I take a look at the peaks that are not called
00:25:12 and determine could there potentially be a third person included.
00:25:17 So for example, at D2, the location farthest to the left,
00:25:22 I'm asking myself, that 12 in that bottom box,
00:25:26 is it the same contributor as, for example,
00:25:29 the 22 under FGA all the way to the right?
00:25:33 Because I see peaks that are not labeled,
00:25:35 it could be that the 12 belongs to one individual
00:25:39 and those two peaks that are not called
00:25:41 belong to a second or third individual,
00:25:43 and that at FGA, I could be seeing the 22
00:25:46 from that third person, but that second person
00:25:49 has dropped out.
00:25:50 Because I'm able to use information below the threshold and I see peaks, that gives me an indication that I can increase my number of contributors to three, which I did in this case.
00:26:02 Okay.
00:26:02 When did you reach that conclusion, time-wise?
00:26:08 If I recall, it was somewhere around September 12th.
00:26:13 And when did you change your conclusion?
00:26:20 That I would have to refer.
00:26:22 Sure.
00:26:50 I changed my conclusion on September 13th of 2025.
00:26:55 And explain to the court why you changed your conclusion?
00:26:58 I was submitted an elimination sample from Mr. Twiggs.
00:27:02 And an elimination sample is a sample in which it's from a known individual,
00:27:07 and then there's an expectation that the individual's DNA might be present.
00:27:12 In receiving that sample and talking to the investigators,
00:27:15 it was decided that Mr. Twiggs should be used as an elimination.
00:27:21 When I compared him to this sample, all of the DNA, unlike that major contributor, matched to Mr. Twiggs.
00:27:29 So because of that, I determined that there's actually only two individuals
00:27:33 because those small peaks, there was nothing left for a third individual to be compared to.
00:27:40 You use the phrase elimination sample.
00:27:42 sample? That's typically used, is it not, in a situation where you're testing a sample that
00:27:49 has more than one contributor? Not necessarily. An elimination is just simply an individual that
00:27:58 we're expecting their DNA to be there. So for example, if we have a stolen vehicle,
00:28:04 I will request an elimination sample from the known driver of the vehicle so I can subtract
00:28:10 out their DNA to see what I have
00:28:12 left over. It doesn't necessarily
00:28:14 have to be more than one individual.
00:28:16 There certainly has been times where I only
00:28:18 detect that known expected
00:28:19 individual.
00:28:21 You said you had a
00:28:23 conversation with the investigators as
00:28:26 to whether twigs should be
00:28:28 included as
00:28:30 where you talked to them about whether
00:28:33 you should get elimination
00:28:35 samples?
00:28:37 I talked to them with regards
00:28:40 to if I should utilize Mr. Twiggs as an elimination
00:28:43 versus comparing him and offering a statistic.
00:28:47 Okay.
00:28:48 But in your report, you concluded, did you not,
00:28:53 that one of the contributors to both samples was Twiggs.
00:29:01 That is correct, yes.
00:29:03 Right.
00:29:03 You didn't just assume that.
00:29:05 You reached the determination that he was the source
00:29:09 of both those samples?
00:29:11 One of the sources, right?
00:29:13 I don't want to use the word source,
00:29:15 but knowing that there was an expectation
00:29:17 that his DNA could be present,
00:29:19 when I compared him to that DNA sample,
00:29:21 I did see his DNA types present.
00:29:24 So using the word assumed,
00:29:27 that's verbiage that we use
00:29:29 when we calculate our statistical calculation.
00:29:33 I'm letting the software know,
00:29:35 I know this individual is there.
00:29:37 I'm assuming that they're there.
00:29:39 based on my comparisons, I did see evidence that that person was there.
00:29:45 But I guess what I'm confused about is we talked before about how your language should never imply an absolute identification.
00:29:53 But in the body of your report, you say that one of the contributors is Twiggs.
00:29:58 You don't say he's a possible contributor like you do for Mr. Robinson.
00:30:03 You say he is a contributor. Do you not?
00:30:05 I do. And with elimination samples, that's slightly different. So for example, let's say I have a sexual assault case and I have a vaginal swab from a female. She has a consensual partner. I can request an elimination sample from that consensual partner. If I see that they're present, I can say they're present and say the DNA foreign to that victim and that consensual partner is one person, for example.
00:30:30 So it's different than comparing a known individual if they're an elimination sample.
00:30:39 I can say that I expect their DNA to be there.
00:30:42 And based on my interpretation and reviewing that data, they are present.
00:30:47 And based either on your conversations with the agents or other people,
00:30:52 why did you think that twigs was someone whose DNA you would expect in those two samples?
00:30:58 So from what I recall, in speaking with the investigators, Mr. Twiggs was a roommate of Mr. Robinson, and it was thought that those items came from potentially Mr. Robinson's home.
00:31:14 And I don't recall exactly if it was a situation where a particular towel was known to have been in that house.
00:31:22 I don't remember that exactly.
00:31:23 But in talking to the investigators, based on their investigation, it was important to assume potentially Mr. Twiggs was present.
00:31:33 Did any investigator ever tell you that the towel did not come from Mr. Robinson's home but was found in a bush out at the university?
00:31:43 I was aware of that, yes.
00:31:46 So you knew that that towel was not found in a place where you would expect Mr. Twiggs' DNA to be present?
00:31:54 That is correct.
00:31:55 It was found outside of a home, but again, based on speaking with the investigators,
00:31:59 they had information to suspect that that towel came from Mr. Robinson's home,
00:32:06 and I should utilize Mr. Twiggs as an elimination.
00:32:10 Right.
00:32:10 Right. And again, you didn't assume that you actually concluded it based on the match, right?
00:32:16 Based on reviewing Mr. Twig's DNA profile to what I developed from these items, I used him as an elimination sample.
00:32:23 Now, you did various STR mix, what I'll call runs, correct?
00:32:33 That is correct, yes.
00:32:34 And the way this works is you input the number of contributors.
00:32:41 You determine that.
00:32:43 And then they also have something called HD and HP, right?
00:32:49 Correct, yes.
00:32:50 Tell the court what that is.
00:32:51 So those are different propositions.
00:32:53 So in calculating the likelihood ratio, likelihood ratio compares the probabilities of seeing a DNA profile given one of two different scenarios or explanations or hypotheses.
00:33:05 One is that a particular person of interest is a contributor, and the other is that an unknown unrelated individual is a contributor.
00:33:12 So depending on the question being asked is how I set up STAR-Mix, number of contributors.
00:33:19 For example, if I'm utilizing someone as a known elimination sample, I will apply their DNA profile both to HP and HD.
00:33:28 And the theory of this, HP is the prosecution hypothesis, right?
00:33:34 Correct, yes.
00:33:35 And HD is the defense hypothesis.
00:33:38 Correct, yes.
00:33:39 so and and these are things you plug in based on your understanding of what the prosecution and
00:33:46 the defense are contending correct yes so how do you plug in the hd in a case where you don't yet
00:33:51 have a defense postulating what their theory is uh so that is so hd or the defense hypothesis
00:33:59 is simply a the dna profile the probability of the dna profile given that it's another unknown
00:34:05 unrelated person to the prosecution's potential person of interest.
00:34:13 Mr. Burt, I don't want to interrupt your line of questions,
00:34:16 but we've been going for just shy of two hours.
00:34:19 Would right now be a good time to take a 15-minute break?
00:34:21 All right, let's take a 15-minute break.
00:34:24 Let's see.
00:34:25 We'll come back at 3.50.
00:34:29 The court is in a brief recess.
00:34:30 buy gold and put some silver in your pocket i know what you're thinking everything's expensive
00:34:41 right now how am i gonna buy gold pull your head out of the sand one thing you can control right
00:34:47 now that doesn't cost you anything out of pocket is diversifying your retirement savings birch gold
00:34:53 Group will help you convert an old 401k from a previous employer or an IRA into a physical
00:35:00 gold IRA. Let me repeat that. Birch Gold will help you now convert an old 401k from a previous
00:35:08 employer or an IRA into a physical IRA in gold. You know, something that's a hedge against inflation.
00:35:17 Listen to this right now. Birch Gold is going to give you a special America 250, one ounce
00:35:22 silver round for every $10,000 you purchase by July 10th. I'm going to repeat this. With every
00:35:30 $10,000 purchase, you get a free one-ounce silver round America 250 commemoration, a special.
00:35:37 Think about this. 10 years ago, an ounce of gold was about $1,200. Today, it's around $4,500.
00:35:45 Where will it be in 10 years from now? Text Bannon, B-A-N-N-O-N, 989898,
00:35:51 to take advantage of free America 250 silver
00:35:54 with qualifying purchase before the 10th of July.
00:35:58 Again, text my name, Bannon, B-A-N-N-O-N,
00:36:01 to number 989898 today.
00:36:05 Take advantage of this offer.
00:36:07 With qualifying purchases, you get a silver round,
00:36:11 a one-ounce silver round.
00:36:14 Check it out, qualifying purchase.
00:36:16 You got to do it before July 10th.
00:36:18 Do it today.
00:36:18 everyone's focus on how the conflict in the Middle East is raising oil prices but there's
00:36:23 another grim reality to this contention oil isn't the only resource being constrained about one
00:36:30 third of global fertilizer trade happens through this region and with spring planting season on
00:36:36 top of us American farmers are sounding the alarm with some saying they can't afford to plant their
00:36:42 fields when one piece of the supply chain gets hit this hard you know what comes next higher
00:36:47 food prices, reduced availability, maybe even panic buying. That's why having an emergency
00:36:53 food supply at home makes so much sense. And that's where our friends at MyPatriotSupply come
00:37:00 in right now at preparewithbannon.com. That is preparewithbannon.com. We've set up an entire
00:37:07 just site for the war room posse. You go to preparewithbannon.com. That's all one word,
00:37:14 PrepareWithBannon.com. You get a three-month emergency food supply. They'll include a free
00:37:21 mega protein upgrade, an incredible $200 bonus you don't want to miss. It's a simple way to
00:37:28 protect your family from whatever comes next. Go to PrepareWithBannon.com. That is PrepareWithBannon.com
00:37:36 to get your emergency food supply today. That's PrepareWithBannon.com. Do it today. Go check it
00:37:44 Why wait till you're down to your last pill, stuck traveling, or dealing with a packed pharmacy
00:37:49 when you can already have your medications on hand? Seriously. You know what you normally take.
00:37:56 You already know what your family could need. That makes no sense. Smart families don't operate
00:38:01 like that. That's why I love All Family Pharmacy. They're built a better, simpler system to get your
00:38:07 prescription medications. You go online, fill out a quick medical form, licensed doctors review your
00:38:13 request, prescribe if appropriate, and your medications are shipped directly to your door.
00:38:19 No waiting rooms, no pharmacy lines, no insurance nonsense. People are traveling more, schedules are
00:38:25 getting crazier, and have your medications already on hand just makes your life easier. Because being
00:38:30 prepared isn't paranoia, it's common sense. Go visit my friends at allfamilypharmacy.com. That's
00:38:36 one word, allfamilypharmacy.com slash Bannon, and use code Bannon10 to save 10% on your
00:38:44 next order.
00:38:45 Again, that's allfamilypharmacy.com slash Bannon, and use code Bannon10.
00:38:52 Okay, it is Tuesday, 7th of July, Year of the Alert, 2026.
00:38:59 You're in the War Room.
00:39:01 We're going to go and get Wendy Patrick is with us.
00:39:04 We're going to get Wendy up in a second.
00:39:05 for many of you of a certain age that may be reminiscent of the OJ trial right now into the
00:39:11 DNA section. If that doesn't make your eyes cross, nothing will. You're pretty true. I think the
00:39:17 purpose of this is to sit through it. And those of you who go through the entire thing will
00:39:23 have a vote as your grand jury members, maybe on Friday, see where you're coming up.
00:39:28 So, Wendy, Patrick, Wendy, can you get us up to speed on how you've observed this today and what is important?
00:39:37 What's the wheat and what's the chaff?
00:39:39 I observed it with much interest, Steve, because having put on plenty of these witnesses in years past,
00:39:45 I thought this witness did a pretty good job of explaining the process, not just the process, though,
00:39:50 the process of elimination of a known sample of an unknown contributor,
00:39:54 And also how it can be true that an original assumption that there's three people could very easily be narrowed down to two.
00:40:03 You know, at first glance or at first listen to a jury who doesn't know a lot about DNA, it might sound like, wait a minute, you know, this is so different of a result.
00:40:11 But actually, upon examination, she was able to very competently explain it.
00:40:16 I would say the same thing regarding the testimony that comes out with different numbers.
00:40:21 She narrowed that down by saying, yes, the more you run it using the math, you'll get different numbers.
00:40:27 But then she gave the examples of, you know, 10 quadrillion and 2 quadrillion.
00:40:31 And I know it's probably even less than that.
00:40:33 So we're still up in the quadrillions, which is usually where I turn to the jury and say to the expert, tell this jury how many zeros that is, basically to determine that it sounds like a match.
00:40:44 But the prelim is the chance to do exactly what you and I and our viewers just watched.
00:40:49 test the scope of the evidence in terms of the way the witness is going to explain it.
00:40:54 That helps both sides hone their strategy as to how they're going to approach that trial.
00:41:00 What is the purpose right now?
00:41:02 I guess it's definitely the tau.
00:41:04 What other objects?
00:41:06 And what is the purpose?
00:41:07 What is the purpose of the entire thing of trying to show whose DNA is on what?
00:41:12 Because the tau, we don't even know if the tau came from the location.
00:41:17 It was just found out in the woods, correct?
00:41:19 Well, yes, but where was it originally? Apparently it was at the defendant's house. And so the purpose of these types of questions and this line of questioning is just a process of connecting the dots to the rest of the evidence, to the sniper portion of the testimony.
00:41:35 You know, you had the items that were arranged, to the bullets, to the gun, to the trigger of the gun, all the rest of the places where the same DNA was found.
00:41:44 And then putting the two of them together is also relevant because that's also part of the testimony and the storyline, the timeline that's going to emerge.
00:41:53 So it's just tying it up neatly, well, as neat as you can at a crime scene like this, tying it all together in a fashion that will make it not only easy to argue at the end of the prelim, but also easy to think through the way in which you're going to present it at trial.
00:42:08 You know, sometimes we call witnesses out of order because we have to.
00:42:11 But ideally, once you've heard what they're going to say at prelim, you're better able to put them in the order you think would be most beneficial to your case.
00:42:20 Do you think that the prosecution is the prosecution tipping their hand too much to make sure that they get the permission to to go to trial?
00:42:28 You think they're giving too much information here or do you think this is the appropriate amount to make sure?
00:42:33 because their objective here is to make sure that they, on the seven charges, all seven charges go
00:42:37 forward, but most importantly, that this still is a capital murder case, correct?
00:42:43 Absolutely. And I think that it's appropriate. And part of the reason I say that is we know that 0.83
00:42:48 the judge keeps reminding everyone it's just a probable cause hearing, which always makes me
00:42:52 suspect that he's already heard enough evidence, and both sides have to pick up on that as well.
00:42:56 But the prosecution also faces an uphill battle when facing a defense attorney that literally
00:43:02 objects to everything. You know, there are so many trials where both sides stipulate to large
00:43:07 portions of evidence. This is not one of them. So they're going to put in everything they can
00:43:12 just to make sure they don't leave any loopholes for the defense to argue at the end of the prelim
00:43:17 because if they don't establish factually all the charges at prelim, they're not going to have
00:43:21 another shot between prelim and trial. The difference, can you describe for the audience
00:43:26 The difference, the fundamental difference, I guess, the most important difference between this type of evidentiary hearing in Utah and going to a grand jury.
00:43:36 In a grand jury, you don't have the defense there.
00:43:39 They're not objecting to anything.
00:43:40 It's just the prosecution putting its evidence on to try to convince the grand jury.
00:43:47 This is why that famous saying, you can indict a ham sandwich, because there's no counter.
00:43:52 There's no cross-examined.
00:43:53 There's nobody on the fence there to call it out, correct?
00:43:58 Is that the fundamental difference we're seeing in these two processes?
00:44:02 That's a big difference.
00:44:03 But, Steve, the prosecutor has to know they can convict the ham sandwich before they take a case to the grand jury because otherwise it would be in bad faith.
00:44:12 But you did point out the biggest difference is it's one-sided.
00:44:16 You just have the prosecutor, but you don't just have the prosecutor's facts and evidence.
00:44:20 The job of a prosecutor presenting to a grand jury, they're supposed to present both sides.
00:44:25 They're supposed to present all of the evidence, which is why we often second-guess grand jury
00:44:30 verdicts, because we think if it's a secret proceeding, how do we know what evidence was
00:44:35 presented? So that's one of the reasons that a prelim like this is much more transparent and
00:44:41 allows the public, the court of public opinion, and the judge sitting as a magistrate in the court
00:44:46 of law, all to weigh the strength of the evidence at the same time. And that is what you're seeing
00:44:51 happen here, which is different than what would happen at a grand jury if we ever got to learn
00:44:57 about the proceedings to begin with, because most of them are secret. Before we got to the DNA part,
00:45:03 when we left you this morning, there was going to be video. I think there's going to be movement
00:45:07 around the campus, how many times the campus. Don Jr., I think, tweeted out that the guy had
00:45:14 been on the campus, I think, four times within a certain date. And nobody, you know, it didn't
00:45:19 raise anybody's eyebrows. What can you say about the morning testimony? Yeah, there was more of
00:45:27 that. There was more establishing that the defendant here was on campus four times. And
00:45:32 that's important because, you know, apparently he targeted Charlie Kirk. And that was something
00:45:37 important to point out. Also, along those same lines, there was testimony about one of the
00:45:41 officers spotting the place where the sniper probably set up. That's important because,
00:45:46 remember, that's where the DNA was found. That's where sort of the sniper's perch was found. So
00:45:50 this officer was pretty good instinctively in recognizing what would have been a logical
00:45:55 vantage point for that shot, that fatal shot. So yes, there was more evidence today, and the
00:46:01 prosecution cleaned up some of the evidence that wasn't admitted yesterday to make it proper today,
00:46:05 like the original version of a particular video. So what we're seeing as the days go by,
00:46:11 Not only are we having more evidence presented, but we're having evidence that was not inclined to be admitted, according to the judge, now admitted because a proper foundation has been laid.
00:46:21 That's going to benefit both sides in terms of what they think about as they prepare for trial.
00:46:26 What do you mean a proper foundation has been laid?
00:46:29 What does that mean for a layman?
00:46:31 Sure.
00:46:32 For a layman, it basically means if you're going to introduce something into evidence, let's say it's an object, it's a bullet or even an opinion as to what happened.
00:46:41 The witness has to be able to say, this is how I know it's true.
00:46:45 In other words, these are the facts and circumstances I've analyzed in order to be able to say with confidence that this object was what it's supposed to be, what it's purported to be, really does link up with these other portions of the evidence.
00:47:00 And that's important because a foundation without evidence is not a good opinion.
00:47:03 It would be like an expert saying, my opinion is that this defendant fired the bullet without going through all of the things that he or she considered and looked at and listened to to be able to tie it all together to come up with that conclusion.
00:47:18 So the perfect example from yesterday is yesterday there was video footage that a judge ruled was inadmissible because the prosecution didn't have the proper person there to explain the changes that were made to that footage.
00:47:30 Once you bring in that person and they're able to explain what they did and how the video may or may not have been changed, then a judge can be more confident that this is a reliable piece of evidence.
00:47:40 Because even though it's a probable cause hearing, one of the things we saw argued about an hour and a half ago was a judge reminding everybody that, yes, it's probable cause, but he has to understand that the evidence is reliable before he admits it as something that he can consider in determining whether there's enough evidence to proceed.
00:47:58 You said the other day that there's all types of strategy and tactics.
00:48:02 Is that where we see the strategy about this foundation, that they're thinking four or five moves ahead and they're actually thinking four or five moves ahead of one of the trials a year from now of what they've got to lay a foundation today to be able to bring in a piece of evidence?
00:48:15 Is that what you meant?
00:48:17 Yes.
00:48:17 And that's an excellent analogy, because when you think about strategy and being four or five moves ahead, what you're doing is thinking about, well, these are the judges' rulings during the prelim.
00:48:28 How then do I think towards trial and call the witnesses I need to call to establish what I need to have an expert give an opinion, for example?
00:48:37 or one of the law enforcement officers to be able to give an opinion
00:48:40 as to why this bullet would have come from that vantage point
00:48:45 and why the defendant would be likely to be the person in this particular video
00:48:50 when you can't pick him out from so far away, for example.
00:48:53 That would be one of the arguments.
00:48:54 So, yes, it informs strategy.
00:48:56 It also allows both sides to come up with that strategy
00:48:59 through the witnesses they call.
00:49:01 I'll tell you, Steve, one of the biggest challenges
00:49:03 between a prelim like this and a trial possibly a year away
00:49:07 is keeping the momentum going because most prosecutors and defense attorneys have a heavy
00:49:12 caseload. So if the trial were to be next week, both sides would be in an excellent position to
00:49:17 remember what happened this week. They've got to take that time and use it wisely in continuing to
00:49:22 build the momentum between prelim and trial. One of the controversies was about the officer's
00:49:29 body camera and the battery going out. This screwdriver now that shows Twig's DNA on it,
00:49:35 Just the whole finding of the screwdriver and then associating Twiggs, the furry boyfriend, to the alleged assassin.
00:49:46 I guess it's important that they're laying out that there's DNA on the towel and the screwdriver.
00:49:52 Will that cause even more controversy since the screwdriver itself is controversial enough?
00:49:58 Well, it shouldn't, but it's something the defense can argue.
00:50:01 You know, sometimes in cases where there's a lot of pieces of evidence found in different places, it allows the defense to sort of, you know, make it make an argument that, well, we don't necessarily know that these objects are related because they were all found in different places.
00:50:15 But that's where the DNA comes in. If they all came from the same two people, if they all arguably came from the same location, what are we doing?
00:50:24 We're using circumstantial bits of evidence that if we didn't have DNA might not mean anything and tying them together and tying them to this defendant who happened to live with the only other person whose DNA was located on the same items.
00:50:38 That's the way the prosecution is going to present it.
00:50:41 Wendy, before we let you take a break and before we go back, any other highlights from the day you think the audience ought to take in their notebook and just underline?
00:50:48 I think it was interesting that we got a sneak preview of what kind of cross-examination some of the analysts are going to face when you had the argument to admit some of the studies.
00:50:59 Now, the judge was very good about saying this isn't a trial.
00:51:01 We're not going to go into, you know, psychological or evidentiary studies.
00:51:05 But we know that's coming because we saw a little bit of that already.
00:51:08 So I think it just goes to show what kind of a case is coming, that it will be relying not only on physical evidence, but also on reliability of the kinds of physical evidence these experts relied on in arriving at their conclusions.
00:51:21 That's a great question.
00:51:23 I'm going to ask you a quality questions.
00:51:26 What you've seen so far, and we're not through the second day of it, how would you assess both the prosecutors and the defense teams?
00:51:33 Yeah, I think that's one of the areas that I've been noticing most frequently and most fervently when it comes to what kind of a case this is.
00:51:42 So far, so good.
00:51:44 You are seeing a civil proceeding from both sides, the prosecution and the defense and the judge.
00:51:50 It seems like they are getting along fine.
00:51:53 They are gracious.
00:51:54 They're patient.
00:51:55 They are very willing to make their records even when the rulings are something other than they expect.
00:52:00 And that's going to be very important when it comes to trial.
00:52:03 because the jury is not going to like one side or the other basically behaving badly.
00:52:07 I'll say that as a mild way to to portray what we sometimes see in trials that are this contentious.
00:52:14 So far, so good. And I can only hope that they carry that momentum from the prelim through the year.
00:52:19 So it's going to take to actually get into a trial courtroom as you've seen the first two days of the first day.
00:52:24 And let's say two thirds. Have you noticed or is anything gone, any alarm gone off that you feel one or one or both sides have missed something?
00:52:33 have screwed something up, have made a strategic mistake that will come back to bite them
00:52:37 five moves from now, a year from now?
00:52:41 I am loving the chess analogy because you're right.
00:52:43 That's the way you look at it.
00:52:45 You look at it from how is what happens today going to impact down the line?
00:52:49 I haven't.
00:52:49 In fact, if I've seen anything, it's overkill on both sides.
00:52:52 I use that term pejoratively because both sides are probably thinking we've got to make sure
00:52:57 we make every objection.
00:52:59 We try to introduce every piece of evidence because this is a high profile.
00:53:02 It's an important case. Charlie Kirk was a beloved friend, brother and mentor to so many of us.
00:53:08 But also because this is one of those cases where you do not want to drag this group back into court,
00:53:14 especially given how re-traumatizing it is for the friends, family, fans and followers that are packing out that courtroom day after day.
00:53:23 And the state is asking for the death penalty. I mean, this is the ultimate capital murder case, correct?
00:53:29 That's right.
00:53:31 And that's also why you have so much evidence going into the record, because a lot of it
00:53:35 can be used to argue what they need to argue, to talk about how dangerous this was in a
00:53:40 crowd of 3,000 people to fire that bullet, to talk about how Charlie Kirk was targeted
00:53:45 because of his beliefs.
00:53:47 All of the types of things that are relevant in determining that as well, you're seeing
00:53:52 admitted into evidence.
00:53:53 I'm hoping we'll hear even more of that tomorrow.
00:53:56 Sometimes a prelim that's going to be multi-day sort of warms up as the days pass.
00:54:00 But the judge is definitely going to be laser focused as the testimony comes out in picking out those pieces of evidence that we're hearing that are going to go towards that ultimate conclusion.
00:54:10 Because you're right, it is the ultimate penalty on the table, death penalty in this case.
00:54:14 For the seven charges, including the death penalty, do you see, given the thoroughness they're taking on some of these topics, do you see this actually ending with the decision on late Friday afternoon at 5 p.m.?
00:54:31 I think that the judge's goal is to have that happen, and I think the reality that he's been stating at least once or twice every single day, reminding everybody it's a probable cause hearing,
00:54:43 he's probably going to try to get everyone to stick to that schedule.
00:54:46 I wouldn't be surprised if you even hear that in open court at some point,
00:54:50 in addition to reminding everyone it's just a probable cause hearing, because that's his goal.
00:54:55 Now, Steve, one question that still hangs out there for me is whether, let's say the evidence is finished on Friday,
00:55:01 whether or not the judge is actually going to give his ruling on Friday,
00:55:04 or whether he's going to take the weekend to really put his thoughts together concisely to make a dynamite record Monday morning.
00:55:12 Or is he doing it as we go along?
00:55:15 I just think this thing sounds so thorough.
00:55:18 There's so much been presented, and we're only on Tuesday afternoon.
00:55:21 I would assume I'd take the over right now on him taking the weekend and pulling it together to come back Monday because the whole world is watching this trial.
00:55:31 Wendy, thank you so much.
00:55:32 I'm going to take your short break, and then you go back and watch.
00:55:34 I think I'm going to reconvene here in a moment.
00:55:36 So thank you so much for filling us in with your analysis.
00:55:39 Thank you, Steve.
00:55:39 fantastic uh a few minutes before they come back to the courtroom okay a couple of three things
00:55:47 have been happening uh one of them and by the way tomorrow morning show we're going to have
00:55:53 all two hours from 10 to noon and boy does this uh at least it makes myself your humble servant
00:55:59 and our uh crack team in both denver and of course the worm producers really appreciate the time we
00:56:04 have with you tomorrow's going to be absolutely slammed from 10 o'clock to noon as we get in a
00:56:11 full show uh so much going on a couple things uh number one uh memo memo of understanding aside
00:56:18 they're back to uh there's it's back to a shooting it's back to kinetic activity
00:56:23 um the um the iranians the persians have lit up an lng tanker uh from qatar understanding is at
00:56:33 reporting from borders it's on fire they've attacked another i think another vessel also
00:56:39 cencom has announced they have attacked so we're back to the uh back and forth i don't know what
00:56:44 that does with the memory memorandum of understanding about the ceasefire president
00:56:50 trump is in nato and he is telling the uh allies the israelis are making a hardcore effort not for
00:56:56 to President Trump to sell the F-35s to Turkey.
00:57:01 Also, this lack of enthusiasm by some other people for that,
00:57:04 but President Trump says he's going to try to get Congress to approve a sale of F-35s.
00:57:09 Also, Netanyahu has gone out of his way to say that Turkey's the next big threat to Israel
00:57:15 and doesn't think Turkey ought to be involved in the Gaza situation.
00:57:19 So a lot going on in NATO, a lot going on in the Mideast War.
00:57:23 Also in politics, Plattner, he's kind of made a decision.
00:57:29 He says, hey, look, I'll drop out.
00:57:31 He's using his leverage, right, having really been the, you know, beating the governor by such a, the sitting governor by such a large amount.
00:57:42 He's using his leverage and his leverage particularly on the more left-wing side or populist side of the Democratic Party.
00:57:51 He says, hey, I will step down when I can pick who my successor is going to be.
00:57:56 So that's they're having a firestorm over there.
00:57:59 Remember, Maine is central.
00:58:02 If you take Maine off the chessboard and he's up in most of the polling I've seen, he's up is up by a big number in a couple of them.
00:58:08 If you take Maine off the chessboard, even with North Carolina and maybe Ohio going, it's it gets tough.
00:58:18 It's very tough.
00:58:19 They really need Maine to take the Senate.
00:58:21 So this is important.
00:58:22 You're seeing the Democrats in a total meltdown.
00:58:26 I think what's most important there is that the Democrats have no qualms about changing voting procedures, changing dates.
00:58:35 If the 13th doesn't work, it's supposed to be next week chosen.
00:58:38 If they need more time, they'll take more time.
00:58:40 They will do whatever it takes to get the best candidate to run against the Republican.
00:58:47 And look about the redistribution. We left nine seats on the table because established Republicans, it was it was too tough for them to get grease under the fingernails.
00:58:57 I'm particularly in in Georgia and parts of the deep south. I think Alabama, Mississippi and Louisiana.
00:59:05 We left. I don't know. You add Texas in there. You add Indiana.
00:59:10 There's another eight or nine seats that just was too much heavy lifting for the Republicans.
00:59:16 Look at the Democrats. If something happens there in the will of the voters, they could care less.
00:59:20 They're going to change things around until they get whatever they have to do, manipulate whatever they have to manipulate in order to get a candidate that can win.
00:59:29 I continue to say if they can't cheat, they can't win. If they can't steal it, they can't win.
00:59:35 But when they're dealing with their own party and their own primaries, they have no qualms whatsoever.
00:59:39 And on this, I think it makes a lot of sense.
00:59:45 In Georgia and Louisiana, all you heard was all this, oh, my gosh, we've done this.
00:59:50 Hey, what people want to do is they want to win.
00:59:54 And they want to have a path to victory that's out there.
00:59:57 We left, just write this down with your number two pencil.
01:00:02 on the night in November
01:00:04 when we vote
01:00:06 late in the evening
01:00:08 if we're losing the House
01:00:10 by a seat or two
01:00:12 we left eight or nine
01:00:14 on the table
01:00:17 eight or nine on the table
01:00:18 that would have never happened to Democrats
01:00:20 would have never happened to Democrats
01:00:22 I want to thank our sponsors
01:00:25 and particularly our sponsors are really
01:00:26 helping us give all this commercial free
01:00:28 and break free, Real America's Voice, great job
01:00:31 We think it's very important that you see it all because there's a lot of controversy.
01:00:36 Trust me, there's a lot of people that are very skeptical about what they're seeing.
01:00:41 That's why we think it makes sense for you folks to see everything.
01:00:44 Total transparency here so you can see it, question it.
01:00:48 And we will hopefully have not just Wendy, but other people doing analytics over the next couple of days.
01:00:52 I don't see how they get through by Friday.
01:00:55 But on us, Evan charges, the judge is moving along as quickly as he can.
01:00:59 I think he'll give a report of the next week.
01:01:02 I want to thank Birch Gold particularly.
01:01:05 Birch Gold, take your phone and text Bannon.
01:01:07 That would be me.
01:01:09 9-8-9-8-9-8.
01:01:12 Get the ultimate guide for investing in gold and precious metals.
01:01:14 But most importantly, get to talk to Philip Patrick and the team about the silver rounds.
01:01:20 They coming back in?
01:01:21 Okay, we're going to go right now.
01:01:22 Let's go back to the courtroom.
01:01:29 At the very bottom of the page, did you write there on the 15th of September, 2025, spoke
01:01:49 with Special Agent Folger, gave update on report timeline, discussed that upon review,
01:01:56 it was decided that additional statistics needed to be run report will still be issued with twigs
01:02:04 as an assumed contributor per previous discussions with Folger and Carmack you see that yes I do
01:02:11 and and what additional statistics needed to be run at that time so at that time I believe I ran
01:02:19 statistics with just twigs comparing that individual to the sample if I may
01:02:28 refer I think that was the only additional
01:02:49 Yes, after discussion with my reviewer, it was determined that I was also going to calculate
01:02:55 a statistic or compare twigs by himself, comparing him to the evidence, and having that run in
01:03:02 my case file.
01:03:03 Okay.
01:03:05 And could you go to tab 38, page 39?
01:03:11 oh yeah it should not be on the screen let's pull it down from the screen thank you so just to the
01:03:23 monitors of the attorneys and the witness Mr. Burt uh just for the witness right okay just for
01:03:30 witness. 39. And this is it. Yeah, page 39. Is this the DNA report? I'm sorry, the StarMix report
01:03:43 that you that was produced as a result of your inquiry that involved a comparison of the sample
01:03:53 to Mr. Twiggs alone?
01:03:55 Yes, it is.
01:03:56 And is that a six-page report?
01:04:00 Yes, it is.
01:04:02 And is it a true and accurate copy
01:04:04 of the STRMX report for that particular sample?
01:04:11 Do you owe back taxes
01:04:12 or you haven't filed your taxes in years?
01:04:16 Now is the time to resolve your tax matters.
01:04:19 With the national conversation
01:04:21 around abolishing the income tax,
01:04:24 the IRS is fighting back and proving it's here to stay
01:04:27 by becoming more aggressive than ever before.
01:04:30 They're sending out more collection notices,
01:04:33 filing more tax liens,
01:04:34 and collecting billions more in recent years.
01:04:38 If you owe, the IRS can garnish your wages,
01:04:42 levy your bank accounts,
01:04:43 seize your retirement, and even your home.
01:04:46 If you owe or haven't filed,
01:04:48 it's not a question of if the IRS will act, it's a question of when it will act. Right now,
01:04:55 Tax Network USA is offering a completely free IRS research and discovery call to show you exactly
01:05:02 where you stand and what they can stop before it's too late. Their powerful programs and strategies
01:05:09 can save you thousands or even eliminate your debt entirely if you qualify. Don't make a costly
01:05:15 mistake. Representing yourself or calling the IRS on your own waives your rights and cost you more
01:05:21 money. They are not, and let me repeat, the IRS is not on your side. Get protected the right way
01:05:27 with Tax Network USA and start the process of settling your tax matters once and for all today.
01:05:34 Call 1-800-958-1000
01:05:38 That's 1-800-958-1000
01:05:42 Or visit TNUSA.com slash Bannon
01:05:46 For your free discovery call with Tax Network USA
01:05:50 Let me repeat, 800-958-1000
01:05:53 Tell them Bannon sent you
01:05:55 Don't let the IRS be the first to act
01:05:58 Take advantage of first mover advantage
01:06:02 You move
01:06:03 Thank you.