Bannon's War Room - July 08, 2026


Episode 5502: Day 3 Of The Charlie Kirk Assassination Trial

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Episode 5499: Day 2 Of The Charlie Kirk Assassination Trial Cont. Episode 5504: Day 4 Of The Charlie Kirk Assassination Trial

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 2 minutes

Words per minute

166.37

Word count

10,461

Sentence count

576

Harmful content

Toxicity

12

sentences flagged

Hate speech

17

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

On today's show, Steve and Wenndy discuss the latest developments in the Roblox case, including the release of evidence from the preliminary hearing, and the potential for a mistrial. Also, President Trump returns to the White House after a NATO summit.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:01 This is the primal scream of a dying regime.
00:00:06 Pray for our enemies,
00:00:08 because we're going medieval on these people.
00:00:11 I got a free shot at all these networks lying about the people.
00:00:16 The people have had a belly full of it.
00:00:18 I know you don't like hearing that.
00:00:19 I know you try to do everything in the world to stop that,
00:00:21 but you're not going to stop it.
00:00:22 It's going to happen.
00:00:23 And where do people like that go to share the big lie?
00:00:26 MAGA Media.
00:00:28 i wish in my soul i wish that any of these people had a conscience ask yourself what is my task and
00:00:35 what is my purpose if that answer is to save my country this country will be saved war room here's
00:00:44 your host stephen k bann wednesday 8 july year of our lord 2026 there's so much going on the
00:00:55 The NATO conference is over.
00:00:58 I think the president's heading back.
00:01:00 Pretty fiery.
00:01:01 At one moment, very accommodating for NATO,
00:01:04 saying they had a great dinner, a great meeting, a lot of unity.
00:01:07 And then, on the other hand, putting certain NATO members on blast,
00:01:10 putting NATO sometimes on blast.
00:01:13 This whole situation between Turkey and Israel,
00:01:17 Israel kind of challenging President Trump on his association with Erdogan
00:01:22 in uh turkey and uh what turkey means for um the uh what they intend to do in gaza and other things
00:01:29 so very very very intense today also president trump said hey look i've tried negotiating i've
00:01:35 tried be you know understanding my whole goal is denuclearization that the uh mullahs and uh the
00:01:43 aetola and his uh followers can't have control can't have the finger on a button of a nuclear 0.55
00:01:48 weapon. Now, he did go and reinforce what we said. He's obliterated the he's obliterated the
00:01:52 nuclear program. But he said that's his number one concern. And we're back in it as of tonight.
00:01:58 I think tonight can even be more intense. So we'll have to find out about that. But right now
00:02:03 he's given CENCOM. I think CENCOM just sent out a notice here moments ago about about revving this
00:02:09 thing up. Wendy Patrick joins us. Now, Wendy, this is a very truncated session today. And normally
00:02:15 in federal courts, Wednesdays a day, if they're in trial, they do break to do what they call
00:02:19 court business. All the other trials they're trying to juggle because these people have
00:02:23 massive caseloads. Can you get us up to date? What's your assessment of what we've seen so
00:02:28 far? And what do you anticipate for the rest of the day? What we've seen so far is attempting to
00:02:34 get into the statements, the statements from Mr. Robinson, the statements from Robinson's roommate,
00:02:39 but that has hit a snag, a snag in the sense that procedurally, there was apparently a
00:02:45 lack of meeting of the minds about how we were going to get into this evidence and what was going
00:02:49 to be admissible. So there's been a request to hear more information and more evidence from what
00:02:55 the roommate Lance Twigg said to investigators. Remember, this is important because this is the
00:03:00 person to whom Mr. Robinson allegedly not only admitted his intention to admit the crime, but
00:03:06 afterwards that he did. This is important because thus far we've set the steam, we've connected the
00:03:12 dots in terms of forensics, ballistics, DNA, video evidence. But we're now getting into the
00:03:19 real meat of the case, which is what did the defendant say he did with respect to Mr. Robinson?
00:03:25 Now, for the very first time also, Steve, I've noticed a little bit of the judge getting a little
00:03:30 antsy that maybe there are unanticipated delays that he wants to avoid. Because you remember
00:03:36 what he said at the beginning of the afternoon this case this prelim will be completed by friday
00:03:42 at 5 p.m is are both sides okay with that they both said yes and then here we go right out of
00:03:47 the gate we have this big procedural hurdle but you know what steve they're going to work it out
00:03:51 they're going to talk behind the scenes that they have to and they're going to re-hit the ground
00:03:55 running because as you notice the court has other business today but but but hang on a second this
00:03:59 is what i was saying yesterday and look i'm no professional i'm watching it like and following
00:04:02 you and others um given their seven charges it's a capital murder case and they're asking for the
00:04:09 death penalty um it seemed even yesterday with all the you know all the objections and everything
00:04:16 that it was it was never going to end on friday today even slowed it down more he may say that
00:04:21 but just structurally how do you get through you have all day tomorrow basically from uh nine in
00:04:27 the morning. In fact, audience, we will switch over to 11. But nine in the morning till five
00:04:34 in the afternoon and nine to five on Friday. How do you anticipate getting through everything else
00:04:39 they have to get in basically two days and a couple hours? Because there's only a few witnesses
00:04:45 left. That was the way the judge started the day today is he asked both sides, how many witnesses
00:04:50 do you have left? Prosecution had to, defense had to. And the defense too, the way they were titled
00:04:57 as gun experts didn't sound like it was going to take an entire day.
00:05:01 So given that there are so few witnesses left, that would be the only way that they would
00:05:06 be able to get done by Friday.
00:05:07 And even with some of the hold up today, arguing over procedure, I still think that they're
00:05:13 going to be able to do it.
00:05:14 And remember, the judge keeps reminding them it's just a probable cause hearing, which
00:05:19 tells me he is transmitting to them, we will be wrapping up this at Friday at 5 p.m.
00:05:25 So I think we're going to get there.
00:05:27 I want to make sure the audience understands something
00:05:31 because people are so used to seeing procedurals on TV
00:05:34 and movies and Perry Mason and all that
00:05:36 for the aha moment.
00:05:38 You're sitting here on the furry boyfriend, right?
00:05:44 They're laying out so much information
00:05:46 and having to lay out so much information
00:05:48 and a probable cause.
00:05:49 How does both sides not know exactly the moves
00:05:52 the other side's going to make after this is all over?
00:05:55 Haven't they presented essentially everything in the road map?
00:05:58 There may be a couple of things they they were able to keep hidden.
00:06:01 But like, for instance, on this thing with the boyfriend, they're going in so much detail now about this.
00:06:05 Wouldn't this be the type of thing they'd want to pop at a trial to get the jury to be more inclined to their to their side one way or the other?
00:06:14 That would be the way you'd see it on Perry Mason, wouldn't it?
00:06:17 it would be a surprise at trial. But given the state of criminal law and due process and the
00:06:22 rules of evidence, that wouldn't be the way that they would be allowed to do it. That's what
00:06:27 prelims are for. They're not only for testing certain pieces of evidence, but have you seen
00:06:32 with the Lance Twig's testimony with procedurally, how is it going to be admissible? How much is it
00:06:39 going to be admissible? Are they going to sanitize it? In other words, are there some portions of
00:06:43 this testimony there are too explosive or too irrelevant, you know, where it would be overly
00:06:48 prejudicial to actually allow that to get into the record. Only what's relevant and only what
00:06:54 doesn't fail that test of prejudice versus probative value gets into the record. That's
00:07:00 what the judge is doing today. So there can be no surprises at trial, even though I agree,
00:07:06 that's what many people in the public expect to see, because that's always the way it's portrayed.
00:07:10 When you say about the information and that you just went to your checklist, bang, bang, bang, on either autopsy or ballistics, and remember, I'm a civilian in this, on either autopsy or ballistics, has really overwhelming evidence been laid out that proves it one way or the other?
00:07:30 No, not overwhelming evidence. And one great example of that is the autopsy report was received in evidence, but we didn't see any of the photographs. We didn't hear from any doctors that described the wound. Thank God, because that would have been horrible for those friends, family members and loved ones in the courtroom.
00:07:49 But you don't need to have that at a probable cause hearing.
00:07:52 But that's a great point because that will be what you'll hear at trial.
00:07:56 That will be the details that they'll go into at trial.
00:07:59 In other words, they won't just enter in the autopsy report.
00:08:02 You'll have somebody going through it line by line to determine not just the cause of death, manner of death, but then they'll tie that into the actual bullet that was fired, which, of course, will be tying back to Tyler Robinson.
00:08:13 So, too, with the ballistics.
00:08:15 It won't just be somebody testifying sort of generally about where was the gun found, the DNA on the trigger, which was Mrs. Robertson's, is going to be all of the details as to how exactly they know that, where they found what.
00:08:28 But you can't go into that type of detail that a prelim would never be done with it.
00:08:32 And I know some people are thinking that that's what we're thinking about this prelim, but they're just making their record, testing the strength of the evidence, and they'll be done by Friday.
00:08:40 there are obviously intense um interest and scrutiny on this and there are some people
00:08:50 that have put up and and been on podcasts and put up alternative theories and some people may call
00:08:55 those conspiracy theories and some of them may be a little out there but you do have a large
00:09:00 amount of the public including the war room audience that just sitting there going something
00:09:05 something doesn't feel right about this. They just don't. And I'm one of just something,
00:09:10 something not right about this yet. It appears that we're trying to be sold a narrative. Is
00:09:16 that too harsh? You're a professional and you see this all the time. Do you think this is
00:09:20 pretty straightforward? So for those that are a little skeptical or feel like particularly in
00:09:24 some of the comments made afterwards, you're trying to be sold like an FBI narrative. You're
00:09:29 trying to be sold the established orders narrative that that is too harsh and that actually the way
00:09:34 you see it professionally? This has been going in a pretty professional manner?
00:09:39 Well, I think it's a great question because I've heard and read all the same theories that you
00:09:44 have. And a lot of people say, look at this kid. He's such a sharpshooter. He fired one bullet
00:09:49 and was able to execute Charlie Kirk. I've heard that. I've seen that. The problem in a court of
00:09:55 law is even if the judge has heard all the same things, he can only deal with the evidence that
00:10:00 is before him. And nobody's come forward with any evidence that there was another person involved in
00:10:05 the shooting. Here's a video of somebody else doing it. Here's a video of a conspiracy between,
00:10:09 you know, 10 outsiders that influenced Tyler Robinson to do what he did. If that information
00:10:15 were to come to light, you bet that both sides would brief it and argue it and litigate it in
00:10:20 court. But unless and until something tangible comes of it, we're not going to see it in this
00:10:25 courtroom, even though it continues to be discussed vociferously. I've read all the same
00:10:30 things in the court of public opinion. Do you think there's been enough probing or maybe this
00:10:36 is not the place for it for the deep investigation of Tyler Robinson? Like not just the motives of
00:10:43 his love affair with this furry, but other things like when we went up there, I flew out there the
00:10:50 day that Charlie was uh was assassinated and we set up shop there for three or four days and
00:10:56 actually I went around I was kind of shocked actually given my knowledge of Utah I was kind 0.97
00:11:01 of shocked in Salt Lake City particularly the amount of like gay pride flags out and uh you
00:11:07 know they they have these militias of these uh these transgender ideology militia I was a little
00:11:13 shocked about how well developed that is and there was a situation down in St. George George's where
00:11:19 you know, a guy, one of these guys killed his entire family. Is there any evidence coming
00:11:24 forward or is this the time to get it out there that the FBI or state officials actually sat down
00:11:30 and did a thorough investigation of any sources, any money, any involvement at all, any support
00:11:37 for Robinson? Or is that assumed that it's not important if you've got a love note between him
00:11:44 in the furry. Yeah, I think the love note, the admission is front and center. That's the most
00:11:51 important. In terms of what investigation was being done, you have to imagine behind the scenes
00:11:56 that there was extensive investigation as to this defendant's ties to other individuals.
00:12:01 Okay, but hang on, hang on, hang on, hang on, hang on. Okay, I assume that, you assume that.
00:12:07 Where is that going to come out? Or is it not, if it's, they just, who decides that's not relevant
00:12:12 to even say, we looked at this, we went down this route, they do that in trial?
00:12:17 Or should that be done in this preliminary?
00:12:19 Just if nothing more than the public can be assured that every stone was unturned
00:12:25 to find out any potential involvement of anybody, any institution, any organization
00:12:29 regarding the assassination of Charlie Kirk.
00:12:32 The frustrating thing about a court of law is they don't have to talk about everything they did or looked at.
00:12:38 They have to talk about what they found that's relevant to the case.
00:12:41 So, for example, in a case like this, they may have looked at all the social media they could.
00:12:47 They may have talked to neighbors and friends because, remember, it is relevant why he committed the crime.
00:12:54 Remember that Charlie Kirk was targeted.
00:12:56 So his ideology in that sense was relevant.
00:12:59 But that's probably the extent of it because the judge has to see what's relevant to what I have in front of me in the charging document.
00:13:06 And there's no charges or allegations regarding any kind of conspiracy.
00:13:10 So that's what's frustrating about what we won't get to hear in a preliminary hearing or at trial.
00:13:17 And that's the reason.
00:13:19 And if something were to come to light, Steve, between now and the trial, then we would potentially not only be able to hear about it,
00:13:27 but I wouldn't be surprised if there was some additional hearing to decide how much of that was actually going to be admissible.
00:13:34 And that hearing might be public, too.
00:13:37 Can you hang on for a second, Wendy?
00:13:39 The court is out. If they come back, we're going to cut right to it.
00:13:41 But we are going to take a short commercial break, and I want to thank our sponsors who are very supportive of us doing it.
00:13:48 We want to make sure that wall-to-wall coverage, you hear every minute and see everything that's going to the courtroom,
00:13:54 just like if you were sitting in the grand jury. I think it's very, very important.
00:13:57 We believe we owe that to Charlie, but we owe it to the country just as much because we've got to get to the bottom of the Charlie Kirk situation.
00:14:04 We cannot have, as I said, it can't be a Warren Commission, and we can't have a grassy knoll, right?
00:14:10 We can't be 60, 70 years later questioning what went on.
00:14:16 I want to thank Birch Gold particularly.
00:14:18 Their sale goes through the 10th.
00:14:20 Get free a one-ounce silver round.
00:14:24 It ain't a coin, it's a round.
00:14:25 Go check it out.
00:14:27 Easiest way to take your phone out, text Bannon, B-A-N-N-O-N-A, 9-8-9-8-9-8.
00:14:31 You get to talk to the Philip Patrick team.
00:14:32 And we also get immersed in all types of free, no obligation information, but investing in gold and precious metals in the age of Trump.
00:14:40 We'll take a short break. Wendy Patrick is making it make sense here in the war room on a Wednesday in July.
00:14:48 We'll be back in a moment.
00:14:49 buy gold and put some silver in your pocket i know what you're thinking everything's expensive
00:15:05 right now how am i gonna buy gold pull your head out of the sand one thing you can control right
00:15:11 now that doesn't cost you anything out of pocket is diversifying your retirement savings birch gold
00:15:18 Group will help you convert an old 401k from a previous employer or an IRA into a physical
00:15:25 gold IRA. Let me repeat that. Birch Gold will help you now convert an old 401k from a previous
00:15:32 employer or an IRA into a physical IRA in gold. You know, something that's a hedge against
00:15:41 inflation. And listen to this right now. Birch Gold is going to give you a special America 250
00:15:45 one-ounce silver round for every $10,000 you purchase by July 10th.
00:15:52 Let me repeat this.
00:15:54 With every $10,000 purchase, you get a free one-ounce silver round.
00:15:59 America 250 commemoration, a special.
00:16:02 Think about this.
00:16:02 Ten years ago, an ounce of gold was about $1,200.
00:16:06 Today, it's around $4,500.
00:16:09 Where will it be in 10 years from now?
00:16:12 Text Bannon, B-A-N-N-O-N, 989898.
00:16:15 to take advantage of free America 250 silver with qualifying purchase before the 10th of July.
00:16:22 Again, text my name, Bannon, B-A-N-N-O-N, to number 989898 today.
00:16:29 Take advantage of this offer.
00:16:31 With qualifying purchases, you get a silver round, a one-ounce silver round.
00:16:39 Check it out, qualifying purchase.
00:16:41 You got to do it before July 10th.
00:16:42 Do it today.
00:16:42 everyone's focused on how the conflict in the middle east is raising oil prices but there's
00:16:48 another grim reality to this contention oil isn't the only resource being constrained about one
00:16:55 third of global fertilizer trade happens through this region and with spring planting season on
00:17:01 top of us american farmers are sounding the alarm with some saying they can't afford to plant their
00:17:06 fields when one piece of the supply chain gets hit this hard you know what comes next higher
00:17:12 food prices, reduced availability, maybe even panic buying. That's why having an emergency
00:17:18 food supply at home makes so much sense. And that's where our friends at MyPatriotSupply come
00:17:24 in right now at preparewithbannon.com. That is preparewithbannon.com. We've set up an entire
00:17:31 just site for the war room posse. You go to preparewithbannon.com. That's all one word,
00:17:39 preparewithbannon.com. You get a three-month emergency food supply. They'll include a free
00:17:45 mega protein upgrade, an incredible $200 bonus you don't want to miss. It's a simple way to
00:17:52 protect your family from whatever comes next. Go to preparewithbannon.com. That is preparewithbannon.com
00:18:01 to get your emergency food supply today. That's preparewithbannon.com. Do it today. Go check it
00:18:08 out. Why wait till you're down to your last pill, stuck traveling or dealing with a packed pharmacy
00:18:13 when you can already have your medications on hand? Seriously, you know what you normally take.
00:18:20 You already know what your family could need. That makes no sense. Smart families don't operate
00:18:25 like that. That's why I love All Family Pharmacy. They're built a better, simpler system to get your
00:18:32 prescription medications. You go online, fill out a quick medical form, licensed doctors review your
00:18:37 request, prescribe if appropriate, and your medications are shipped directly to your door.
00:18:43 No waiting rooms, no pharmacy lines, no insurance nonsense. People are traveling more, schedules are
00:18:49 getting crazier, and have your medications already on hand just makes your life easier. Because being
00:18:54 prepared isn't paranoia, it's common sense. Go visit my friends at allfamilypharmacy.com. That's
00:19:01 one word, allfamilypharmacy.com slash Bannon, and use code Bannon10 to save 10% on your
00:19:08 next order.
00:19:09 Again, that's allfamilypharmacy.com slash Bannon, and use code Bannon10.
00:19:17 Here's your host, Stephen K.
00:19:19 Bannon.
00:19:21 Wendy, here's what I'm trying to get at.
00:19:23 Jack Kennedy's murder.
00:19:24 Jack Kennedy was a symbol for guys like my dad in that age, that greatest generation.
00:19:30 Jack Kennedy was a war hero when he didn't have to be.
00:19:33 He volunteered for some of the most dangerous, one of the most dangerous naval jobs in the positions, billets in the Pacific.
00:19:39 His brother died as kind of a test pilot testing bombs over Europe.
00:19:44 These were the best of the best.
00:19:45 His smile, the way he carried himself, he just embodied that American spirit.
00:19:50 And to be assassinated by a guy like Lee Harvey Oswald is one of the things that people, you just, you know,
00:19:55 the prince in Camelot can't be assassinated by a guy like Lee Harvey Oswald, just a stone-cold 0.99
00:20:02 loser. It's the same thing here with Charlie Kirk. Charlie Kirk was the best of his generation. So 0.99
00:20:07 many young men looked up to him. Charlie would go into the bear pit of these universities and take
00:20:13 on all these tough questions, but do it with a smile and say, hey, come up to the front like he
00:20:16 did at the very moment he was being assassinated, being killed with a smile on his face. Charlie
00:20:21 Kirk could have been president of the United States one day. Charlie Kirk was kind of the Jack
00:20:26 Kennedy of his era as far as representing the best of that generation. And to be killed, you know,
00:20:33 one of the engine room, one of our guys in the engine room texted me, said, Steve, I never thought 0.99
00:20:38 I'd watch War Room and have you say the phrase gay furry lover. And I'm sitting there going, 0.51
00:20:42 you're right. It's totally absurd. And not just that. These kids, two young men are Mormons in
00:20:48 utah which were presented as the most stable state in the union with the mormon traditions and in the
00:20:53 in the mormon faith and the mormon belief in family and in the in the assassin the alleged
00:20:58 assassin looks like a normal everyday guy it just it boggles the mind of what we're doing we're
00:21:04 sitting here about an assassination of arguably one of the greatest young men in his generation 0.65
00:21:09 and we're talking about gay furry lovers i mean it just went through the looking glass nothing 0.66
00:21:14 makes sense in this thing, ma'am? Yeah, you know, Charlie Kirk's assassination really changed the
00:21:20 world. I agree with everything you said. He's one of a kind. He's somebody just absolutely stands
00:21:26 out in his generation. You know, I was around the world afterwards and met people everywhere that
00:21:31 weren't even Christians that felt like they'd lost a family member is the way they described it. You
00:21:36 talk about the ripple effect. And then you're right. We're talking in court about some of these
00:21:41 issues and we're looking at Tyler Robinson. And not only does it not make sense, there's a great
00:21:45 sense of injustice on so many levels that's magnified through remembering who Charlie Kirk
00:21:52 was. And you're right, not only was he having that discussion when he was assassinated, the topic was
00:21:57 gun violence. Talk about making it just extra tragic and ironic at the same time. But that's
00:22:02 one of the reasons that you have so many people tuning into a trial like this and trying to figure
00:22:08 out not only how do we make sense of it, but what should the consequences be? Everyone says,
00:22:12 oh, we can't bring them back, but we can bring them justice. And that is also going to include
00:22:17 justice for the Kirk family, for Erica Kirk, for Turning Point USA, for all those beloved friends,
00:22:24 family, fans, and followers in the courtroom that waited since one in the morning to get a seat in
00:22:30 the courtroom. That's one of the things that distinguishes this case, as well as the lack
00:22:34 of a fan club for the defendant somebody asked me last hour about well remember luigi mangioni
00:22:39 had this big fan club you don't see that kind of support for tyler robinson do you
00:22:43 well trust me online these and these people are purely evil but i i don't know i just i
00:22:50 equate this with lee harvey oswald that people could not grasp that jack kennedy was gunned down
00:22:58 in broad daylight by someone like a Lee Harvey Oswald,
00:23:02 just a total creep, and it's tough to understand
00:23:04 that Charlie Kirk was gunned down
00:23:07 and we're having discussions about, you know,
00:23:09 what is gay furry and how does that mean as far as lovers go?
00:23:12 I mean, it boggles the mind, and maybe you're saying
00:23:14 in a court of law it's so limited for evidence,
00:23:17 maybe you need a broader inquiry just to make sure
00:23:19 that every rock has been unturned
00:23:22 to make sure that anyone associated with this at all
00:23:25 is brought to justice.
00:23:27 Now, let me ask you the question about the trial.
00:23:28 In your professional opinion, since this is an intricate chess match of laying foundational elements for moves that you're going to make a year from now, five or six in advance, have you seen any screw-ups, either the defense or the prosecution, on this concept of foundation, where they're laying a foundation for evidence they're going to need later, ma'am?
00:23:49 Not yet. And that's because they are being so meticulous about everything they say and do.
00:23:56 And you know who's partially to thank for that is this judge.
00:24:00 Not only have they briefed this case to death, you pointed that out yesterday, they papered each other to death.
00:24:06 Not only did the judge read everything that was filed, but every time he rules on the foundation that's necessary to introduce a specific piece of evidence,
00:24:14 he goes back and forth, back and forth, making sure both sides say everything they want to say.
00:24:19 And then he articulates a long grounds and rationale for his ruling.
00:24:24 That is the type of thing I expect him to do, not only between now and Friday, but on Friday, when he delivers his ruling, binding the case over for trial.
00:24:33 Everybody knows that's where it's headed. He's heard enough.
00:24:35 But he's really going to make sure that he articulates how all that evidence is admissible.
00:24:40 Because it's hard to screw up in front of a judge that's so meticulous in wanting to create that record.
00:24:46 But you're right. That's what both sides are looking for.
00:24:48 What do we see now that we can exploit five moves later?
00:24:53 And you're saying there's no doubt in your mind we're going to trial on this, as you see it so far?
00:24:58 Unless there's some kind of a plea bargain.
00:25:00 You know, that would require extensive negotiations behind the scenes, and the prosecution would have to want to ever do that.
00:25:06 Do you see any assessment at all of the defense starting to weigh and measure that where they would try to go in and cut a deal to say, hey, we'll plead guilty, but take the death penalty off the table?
00:25:19 Do you see anything in the prosecution's case? Because that negotiation will take place in months, not now.
00:25:25 But do you see, do you sense that that will be one of, given the evidence they're presenting and the foundational elements they're laying out, that the defense could be thinking about that even right now?
00:25:35 Yes, because the evidence is very strong and it's being established very strongly.
00:25:41 You know, as we go day by day, the defense is testing to make sure that the authentication is there, that the relevance is there.
00:25:49 They're testing the evidence to ensure the case is as strong as it looks and sounds.
00:25:53 And when they are convinced that it is, then they'll have that conversation with their client as to, you know,
00:25:58 if it's going to be easier to prove than maybe they thought before they got to prelim, is this something they want to bring up again?
00:26:04 But Steve, the prosecution doesn't have to agree to that. That's up to them. They're going to talk to Erica Kirk. They're going to talk to the family. They're going to talk to everyone they need to, to make that decision. That's a collaborative decision between the family, the fans, the friends, the loved ones, and the state of the evidence, which up till now appears to be very solid.
00:26:24 okay Wendy we're gonna let you take a little break there obviously having a longer break in
00:26:29 the court we'll let you take a break uh and um and uh we'll get to you tomorrow morning
00:26:33 when we're back all right sounds good Steve thank you Wendy Wendy really want to thank you you make
00:26:39 things so clear for audience such a great job you've done for all the rav shows it's ironic
00:26:44 that so much of the controversy around Charlie and Charlie Kirk dealt with Israel and dealt with
00:26:50 the war in the Middle East, right? Well, today, in the irony of ironies, we're back at it. And
00:26:55 what Charlie Kirk tried to stop, which was a regime change war, I know that personally,
00:27:00 because I dealt with Charlie a lot on that very topic. So let's play a clip.
00:27:04 We're back at it tonight on the third day of the hearing, evidentiary hearing of Charlie Kirk. 0.59
00:27:09 We're back at war in Iran. Let's go and play the clip. 0.63
00:27:12 Kind of covering all of the bases today. What else did he say?
00:27:16 Yeah, I think the way you put it, Brianna, mixed messages is exactly right. 0.99
00:27:20 I think the one thing that is clear is that it's unclear what is next when it comes to Iran
00:27:25 and what the president is thinking about how he wants to proceed.
00:27:29 You mentioned some of those angry words from the president just earlier today, in the same day,
00:27:34 hours earlier, saying that he believed the ceasefire was over, that the memorandum of understanding was over,
00:27:40 just to later argue, no, we do not want to go back to full-out war.
00:27:43 He also, at one point, you know, saying that the ceasefire was over in another breath, arguing that it really is up to the negotiators.
00:27:51 He had a lot of praise for Steve Wyckoff, for Jared Kushner, for the vice president.
00:27:55 He said it's up to them to decide how they want to proceed.
00:27:59 But obviously, the president is very frustrated, Brianna, with how things are going, particularly with these negotiations.
00:28:05 He wants them to be farther along.
00:28:07 The nuclear issue was one of the thorniest issues that was left to be settled in the 60-day period that they're currently in,
00:28:15 if this memorandum of understanding is not over, as the president argued, that they needed to work out.
00:28:20 And that's something that is, of course, causing some problems in these talks.
00:28:25 One of the takeaways, though, that I really, you know, I thought was a great question from that press conference
00:28:30 was when a New York Times reporter got up and said, you know, just a couple weeks ago, just last month,
00:28:35 You were arguing that the negotiators were great people, that they're smart people, that they're rational people.
00:28:40 And then today you're now calling them evil and not good to work with.
00:28:45 What changed?
00:28:46 And I do, I believe we have a clip of what the president said then and what he is saying while he was in Turkey.
00:28:52 Listen to both of that back to back.
00:28:55 I mean, they were nice to deal with.
00:28:58 They were strong people, smart people.
00:29:00 I think actually they're smarter than the first and second group.
00:29:03 but they're not radicalized and they're you know looking to help their country you want to know the 0.99
00:29:11 truth they're scum but they're bad people very bad people i think they're incompetent i don't 1.00
00:29:15 want to deal with them anymore they're scum you know what scum is they're scum they're sick people 1.00
00:29:20 as far as i'm concerned it's just a waste of time dealing with them they're liars there's 1.00
00:29:25 something wrong with them they're cuckoo so as you see brianna two different moments two very 0.96
00:29:32 different viewpoints on how things are going and who, you know, the quality of the people that the
00:29:38 United States is negotiating with when it comes to Tehran. The only other thing I would want to
00:29:42 note is for what does come next. You know, the president had said earlier in Turkey that he
00:29:47 believed there could be more strikes on Iran tonight, obviously following the strikes we saw
00:29:52 take place last night. But then later, he seemed to soften that language. So it's really unclear
00:29:56 at this point how they're moving, how they're looking at moving ahead. The one clear thing as
00:30:01 well. It's just Trump is frustrated. He doesn't like how this is going, and he wants there to be
00:30:05 more deal-making, less talking, and less strikes. Yeah, palpable frustration today during that
00:30:12 appearance. The president also said, Elena, there was tremendous unity among NATO allies,
00:30:16 but he also lashed out at various member countries at times. Which is it?
00:30:21 I mean, what a difference, Brianna, a day makes. I mean, just yesterday, there was a lot of tension,
00:30:26 And I think it was unquestionable that many European allies were going into this NATO summit uneasy.
00:30:33 They were unsure of how this was going to go.
00:30:35 The president obviously has been very outspoken.
00:30:38 He's made no secret of hiding the fact that he believes many of these NATO members are not paying what he argues is their fair share of defense spending.
00:30:45 And you saw some of that kind of spill out yesterday, a little bit this morning.
00:30:49 But you're right.
00:30:49 When he came out to speak at this press conference, really concluding this visit, he said there was a lot of unity in the room.
00:30:55 He made a point to argue that a lot of these different leaders had been coming up to him in private, telling them, sir, I love you.
00:31:02 He said that kind of worked well with him.
00:31:04 And, you know, he did previously call out a number of different countries, Spain being one of them.
00:31:09 Much softer language he was using during that press conference when it came to Spain.
00:31:13 All to say, I think this was a successful summit for the overall alliance,
00:31:19 particularly when you look at some of the things that Ukraine has gotten out of this,
00:31:23 new commitments on Patriot defense missiles and things like that. So overall, I think
00:31:26 European leaders leaving happy with how this went and how the president concluded
00:31:31 on a happier note, arguing that there was unity and he was glad to have been there.
00:31:39 The Baltimore engine room has sent me the U.S. Central Command's statement, and it's backed up.
00:31:44 And if we put this video up, if you get to it, it's pretty, we're lighting some things up over
00:31:49 there. Okay, this is U.S. Central Command, and I quote, at the direction of the commander-in-chief,
00:31:54 U.S. Central Command forces have started conducting additional strikes against Iran to
00:31:58 further degrade their ability to threaten freedom of navigation in the Strait or Hormuz. The United
00:32:05 States is holding Iran accountable for recent unjustified aggression against commercial
00:32:10 shipping and civilian crews, freeing navigating a vital international orderway. I think it's
00:32:18 also incumbent that you know we have another briefing from the pentagon and we you know we
00:32:24 go back to being the department of war and not the department of wishful thinking and we just
00:32:29 deal straight with this because we've been told that not simply the air force and the navy but
00:32:34 all missiles are gone and it's obviously not the case they still have the ability to deliver a
00:32:39 punch and deliver a punch against um against the countries in the in the gulf itself particularly
00:32:46 you know, Bahrain, Kuwait, Qatar, UAE, Saudi Arabia, whatever you think of these countries,
00:32:55 and I don't think much of them. They do control a big swath of the world's oil. This is why coming
00:33:01 out of NATO also, I was very disappointed. I didn't see any, and maybe I missed it, and I will
00:33:06 go back tonight and look, but I didn't see forcing them to step up to have the NATO navies down there,
00:33:12 You know, with some commitments from the United States for Ukraine, these guys make commitments and President Trump got them to going to five percent so they can start paying more for their defense and we can start, you know, downplaying it.
00:33:23 But right now, to me, the Strait of Hormuz, the Red Sea, the Suez Canal, those are European problems or Asian problems.
00:33:34 And people better start stepping up and sending their navies up there instead of us having to go back in and do, you know, combat activity around Karg Island. 0.54
00:33:42 combat activity around, um, around, um, uh, the, the Hormuz. And now actually they're talking about
00:33:53 us, you know, carving out our own waterway and have Navy escorts. That's not the role for the
00:33:57 United States of America. This is a sideshow given, uh, our strategic focus on hemispheric
00:34:05 defense, which is absolutely urgent, uh, and very important, including, uh, in the, uh, in the
00:34:11 central pacific now the president was very complimentary of she now he's got this state
00:34:16 visit in late september in the in the burning heat or of the of the midterms she's coming here
00:34:23 for a state visit the president was very complimentary we'll break all that down tomorrow 0.94
00:34:26 but the the chinese just you know gave us a love tap by launching testing a you know submarine 0.58
00:34:32 launch ballistic missile right over the territory into the heart of where cleo pascal has been 0.79
00:34:39 warning us for months and months and months is an active participation of the Chinese Communist
00:34:44 Party to try to roll us back out of the Pacific. Now, Captain Fennell, to the degree that we have 0.86
00:34:48 time, we're trying to get Captain Fennell on for either tomorrow or Friday to go all through that.
00:34:55 It's quite a surprise to people. But the geopolitical situation, the rest of the world
00:35:00 is quite tenuous. And we're still this opportunity cause of refocus. Now we've got,
00:35:05 And look, the irony of ironies, it's on day three of Charlie Kirk's, the evidence you're hearing for Charlie Kirk.
00:35:14 And Charlie Kirk's is central to the no regime option, no regime change option of kind of the American right.
00:35:22 Charlie Kirk was an absolute diehard believer in this and really fought hard that we wouldn't get tangled up in a, in a tangled up in a regime change.
00:35:32 number one, the politics of it. He knew it better than anybody, particularly since he had built a
00:35:37 grassroots organization that focused on young people. And this is how he became a legend. This
00:35:41 is how he became, you know, kind of a mythic in his origin story, about how he started this
00:35:47 organization with nothing, because he had nothing. He started it with just his elbow grease and an
00:35:54 idea, an idea that after we hired him at Breitbart to kind of write about college campuses, this is
00:35:59 one the guy reached out to him after one of his articles said hey what do you think about building
00:36:04 an organization he says I got a whole idea for you guy put a little money in then Charlie you
00:36:08 know worked like crazy the other thing about Charlie Kirk remember everything he started
00:36:14 took a while to get traction one of the great lessons of his life life is the grit determination
00:36:22 and stick to it to this and just hard work besides the demeanor and humble and you know he's a happy
00:36:28 warrior always laughing got that smile all the time you can even see that in
00:36:31 the videos after people are attacking him relentlessly and that is hard to do
00:36:35 that comes from the heart and the spirit that was the spirit of Charlie Kirk and
00:36:40 here we are I can't get over it I mean you know the interim text me right away
00:36:44 as soon as I said I said who would have thought you know last September 9th that
00:36:51 nine months later we've been in a court of law going through a trial of
00:36:56 of evidentiary hearing for the assassination of Charlie Kirk, 0.85
00:36:59 and you'd be talking about a gay, furry lover 0.95
00:37:03 of grown men in this nation 0.93
00:37:09 in the 250th year of our revolution.
00:37:14 Men who were given everything.
00:37:17 These came from well-to-do, not wealthy,
00:37:21 but middle-class folks. 0.99
00:37:23 I think, in fact, the gay furry might have even been in better economic shape than Robinson. 0.94
00:37:31 But Robinson didn't want for anything. 0.99
00:37:35 In one of the most stable societies, at least on the surface, I think we're finding out a lot.
00:37:43 I'm not saying the governor's number one issue was to keep the word Mormon out of this trial.
00:37:49 But, hey, just saying, there's so much here that doesn't make sense.
00:37:54 It doesn't make sense.
00:37:56 That's what we wanted to see.
00:37:57 I mean, Rob, Sig, and Parker came to the same conclusion, Jack, and all of us.
00:38:01 I was adamant, as they were, that real America's voice, and right now we're in a recess as soon as it comes back in.
00:38:07 But that the channel itself, the network itself, regardless of what anybody else did, and regardless of what the ratings were,
00:38:13 if people didn't want to stick with it, that's fine.
00:38:15 But it was we had an obligation. We had a duty to Charlie, a duty to the country.
00:38:22 That if this was going to be kind of what they do in in Utah as grand juries, that we were going to present you with the opportunity to sit and really judgment of this evidence and see it all.
00:38:35 And then have during the day analysis by guys like Wendy Patrick, of course, Jack Posobiec's out there with Kevin Posobiec.
00:38:42 we've got our first team out there as far as the production
00:38:45 I think the only of our top producers
00:38:47 not there is Harry who did such an amazing job
00:38:49 over the 4th of July but
00:38:50 we've got a top team out there and we're
00:38:52 you're seeing it every second of it
00:38:55 it has to be
00:38:56 I said we have to do that for Charlie
00:38:58 people have to see everything from the time the gavel came
00:39:01 down until the time the judge
00:39:03 makes his decision and then if there
00:39:05 is a trial we don't know that
00:39:07 for sure if there is a trial
00:39:09 we'll cover that
00:39:11 wall-to-wall too and we'll put our best team on it and I think it's very a very enlightening
00:39:15 situation but it is a trial remember the investigation is not on trial the evidence
00:39:24 to get to a murder is on trial that's one of the engine room people sent that to me I think it's
00:39:29 very wise um want to thank our and I really want to thank our sponsor for our sponsors who are
00:39:35 bearing with us as we turn over massive amounts of broadcast time I think this week
00:39:40 we're going to be down to, including Saturday, we'll probably be at 40% of the broadcast time.
00:39:46 I really want to thank particularly people like Birch Gold, who've done such an extraordinary job.
00:39:54 Birch Gold, so go to birchgold.com. Make sure you get a copy. I'm now doing the graphics for
00:40:00 the ninth free installment, which you're going to love. Because a little bit ties into,
00:40:05 not totally, but it ties into this, the business model of the United States. And I think you have
00:40:12 to think about the business model of the United States as you think about your own personal
00:40:16 financial condition and situation. This is why we didn't want to get, people came to us to sell
00:40:25 gold. I'm not interested in giving access or selling gold to our audience. I mean, I was
00:40:30 interested in allowing people to understand and to to find out why the dollar is a central
00:40:38 backbone of the world's financial system how it came about what does it mean in the economic
00:40:43 history of the united states uh and what does that mean what does fiat currency mean in regards to
00:40:49 an asset like gold that was totally dismissed for i don't know 100 years okay i'm gonna stop
00:40:55 rambling and we're gonna go back to it's kind of kind of missed that we're gonna go back live to
00:41:00 of the courtroom right now, we're going to continue
00:41:02 in the evidentiary hearing in the assassination,
00:41:05 the matter of the assassination of Charlie Kerr.
00:41:07 Also reviewing what Mr. Novak submitted,
00:41:10 the redactions requested,
00:41:13 and reviewing all parts of it in great detail.
00:41:22 All right, I want to address the objections before me
00:41:27 and starting with Mr. Novak made a hearsay objection as it relates to Mr. McBride,
00:41:33 and the court agrees it is hearsay.
00:41:37 At the same time, I'm only going to consider Mr. McBride's statements to provide context
00:41:45 for the things that Lance Twiggs says and for their effects on Lance Twiggs,
00:41:51 and as such, the hearsay objection as it relates to the statements of Mr. McBride
00:41:56 in State's Exhibit 16 is overruled.
00:42:02 Turning to relevance as it relates to State's Exhibit 16.
00:42:11 And I agree in part and disagree in part as it relates to this objection.
00:42:18 So there are portions of the transcript, or I say transcript,
00:42:22 but what I really mean is State's Exhibit 16, and I appreciate the transcript.
00:42:26 I found that to be helpful.
00:42:28 It's a lot faster than trying to, like, scroll, and so I appreciate that being provided.
00:42:33 It was helpful to the court, and to be fair, I found it to be a true and accurate representation of the actual recording.
00:42:40 So did I listen to every word and compare it?
00:42:43 No, but from what I reviewed, I did not find any inconsistencies just to put it on the record, so there's no misunderstanding.
00:42:49 But there are portions of the transcript, Stace Exhibit 16, which relevance is still not clear to me.
00:43:00 However, as the magistrate, I am able to distinguish between what is relevant to a probable cause determination and what is not.
00:43:11 and what I take into consideration when I make my ultimate decision about probable cause
00:43:19 I will not take into consideration what is not relevant so that is a constant balancing and
00:43:25 evaluation I'm making throughout this this hearing and after this hearing my intent is to review
00:43:33 everything again to be thorough this is not a case where I'm going to be shooting from the hip
00:43:38 in making that determination because this is an important determination,
00:43:42 so I will take the necessary time as is required
00:43:46 and is as necessary to ensure that the constitutional rights of all parties are upheld.
00:43:53 So as I'm making determinations, where I land is pages 19 and 20 of the transcript
00:44:02 as it relates to State Exhibit 16, may contain irrelevant information,
00:44:09 but I will reserve whether I consider those portions
00:44:12 until I've heard the rest of the state's evidence.
00:44:17 Therefore, as it relates to relevance, that ruling is reserved.
00:44:24 Now, turning to the other objection, which is Rule 403, Prejudice.
00:44:30 As I am acting as a magistrate, I do not have the same concerns that my decision will be influenced by undue prejudice as that of a jury.
00:44:40 Therefore, for purposes of admissibility, the defendant's objection is overruled.
00:44:47 Even so, there are portions of this transcript, and again, states Exhibit 16, that may not be admissible at trial and whose relevance I have not yet determined.
00:44:56 In the abundance of caution and to protect the jury pool, the potential jury pool, from hearing potentially inadmissible evidence,
00:45:05 I'm ordering that the audio cannot be published in the courtroom or on camera from page 19, timestamp 3255 until timestamp 3548.
00:45:18 In other words, the state may publish the audio for all portions of the interview other than that one portion.
00:45:23 And when I say audio, I mean audio and video, so both.
00:45:30 I recognize there's approximately only one minute after 3548.
00:45:36 The state can fast forward to that point for it's an approximate one minute and 12 seconds
00:45:43 or may take the time to redact the video as they see fit.
00:45:46 So where I'm landing today is up until from the beginning, until that page 19, 3255, that portion I am ruling is admissible and may be published.
00:46:12 Again, if the state wishes that last minute and 12 seconds to be played,
00:46:19 they can either take the time tonight to redact what the court is not going to allow to be published.
00:46:26 And I wish to differentiate.
00:46:28 I'm considering it all.
00:46:30 But for publication purposes, that portion is not going to be permitted to be played in the courtroom.
00:46:37 Governor, would you state those times, again, that you are ordering not to be published?
00:46:41 I've got 3255 to 3548.
00:46:45 Right.
00:46:46 Those are the two time stamps for that,
00:46:49 and I hope that's helpful as both parties are trying to review on the transcript
00:46:53 and in State's Exhibit 16.
00:46:57 And that's from 3255 to 3548.
00:47:00 Right.
00:47:01 Okay, thank you.
00:47:01 It is not publishable in the courtroom or to be broadcast.
00:47:09 Finally, I want to recognize both parties wanted the benefit of the record to be more specific in their arguments concerning their objections.
00:47:20 So if those arguments pertain to time step 3255 through time step 3548, I'm willing to allow you to do that in a closed hearing.
00:47:31 Please be mindful of the time and keep your arguments succinct.
00:47:35 With that in mind, do the parties have any arguments they feel I have not considered in my ruling that require a closed hearing?
00:47:50 Yes, Your Honor.
00:47:52 And so I'm just going to tell the court what I think the general nature of that is without getting into the details,
00:47:58 because I do think a closed hearing is appropriate.
00:48:00 There are, okay, setting aside the 1102 issue and objections, there are statements in this video by Mr. Twiggs attributed to Mr. Robinson, okay?
00:48:20 Mr. Robinson said.
00:48:23 There are two other exhibits, which I, again, I've said before, I'm confident the state will offer,
00:48:28 which Mr. Twiggs says in this video, those are statements by Mr. Robinson.
00:48:36 Okay?
00:48:37 I will acknowledge that separate and apart from 1102, the statements of a party opponent are admissible if relevant.
00:48:46 In fact, they're not even hearsay, right?
00:48:47 They're excluded from the hearsay rule.
00:48:50 But the question is whether statements of Mr. Robinson, of the nature that I'm referring to, can be published, not considered by the court, but published without violating Mr. Robinson's 14th Amendment due process rights.
00:49:11 And it is our view, as we have said in our earlier papers, that the answer is no.
00:49:16 Publication, especially in the way this proceeding is being published, would violate Mr. Robinson's due process rights under the 14th Amendment.
00:49:32 We previously cited, and the reason why I'm saying this again is not to reiterate something just because if you say it twice, it means something different,
00:49:43 but because my colleagues have suggested that maybe my argument earlier was not clear enough.
00:49:48 And so I want to make sure it is clear so that the court makes a decision based on the arguments of counsel.
00:49:57 The United States Supreme Court said in Estes v. Texas 381 U.S. 532 the following.
00:50:09 In Rideau v. Louisiana, and that's R-I-D-E-A-U, this court constructed a rule that the televising of a defendant in the act of confessing to a crime was inherently invalid under the Due Process Clause of the 14th Amendment, even without a showing of prejudice or a demonstration of the nexus between the televised confession and the trial.
00:50:38 I am not calling the statements of Mr. Robinson confessions, but that is what the state will call them.
00:50:49 And so there are portions of this exhibit and the other exhibits that I've referred to,
00:50:55 which implicate Mr. Robinson's right not to have what the state calls a confession televised.
00:51:02 this court has authorized the televising of this proceeding
00:51:09 and there are reporters in this courtroom who will go outside and speak on what we used to
00:51:18 call television that opinion was from the 60s now we have other forms of technology but i'm just
00:51:24 going to use what the supreme court says because it's the supreme court so we are very concerned
00:51:29 that the publication beyond this court's eyes
00:51:32 of what the state will call confessions at trial
00:51:36 violates Mr. Robinson's due process rights
00:51:42 right here and now today.
00:51:44 And I know that we said that before in the litigation,
00:51:46 but now we're exhibit specific.
00:51:51 If I haven't been clear about the argument,
00:51:55 I want to make sure I'm clear about it
00:51:56 because the court's decision to allow this video to be televised
00:52:03 and the other two exhibits to be shown to the camera in the back of the courtroom
00:52:09 is exactly what the Supreme Court says violates the 14th Amendment.
00:52:15 So, and I appreciate that clarity, and perhaps, again,
00:52:21 if you want to go into closed hearing, we can do so,
00:52:24 or if you want to refer to the pages.
00:52:25 I want to know exactly what you're referring to, whether it's in that 3255 through 3548, which is being excluded, or is it in the 40?
00:52:36 It is not. It is earlier, and it's also the two other anticipated exhibits, so we may as well deal with all of it at the same time.
00:52:44 It's probably easier to do it in a closed proceeding because nobody has to be obtuse.
00:52:49 I don't have to be obtuse in order to protect my client's rights.
00:52:52 No, I appreciate that. And it actually prompts, in order for me to get to that, I do want to ask the state, are you intending to introduce the text messages as an exhibit in this proceeding, the preliminary hearing?
00:53:06 Yes, Judge, we will be attempting to and moving for the admission of the text thread, the discord thread, and I think, and the note that is referenced in Mr. Twiggs 1102.
00:53:23 All right. And let me take one step at a time, just for clarity. And again, Mr. Novak, I really do appreciate you being so precise. It's helping me parse it out so we can address it. Because it's important. And I recognize that you're advocating for your client. And so I want to give it its due time.
00:53:41 The text messages, from my understanding, and either side weigh in, my understanding that those were released to the public months ago in their entirety.
00:53:53 Judge, if I may, they were not released in their entirety.
00:53:57 Portions of them were placed into the charging document,
00:54:00 the information that supported, in part, the charges that the state has filed.
00:54:05 We did not put the entirety of them in.
00:54:08 And now we wish to publish more of them than were included in the charging document.
00:54:14 I see.
00:54:15 For some reason, I thought it was part of an exhibit for a motion.
00:54:18 but
00:54:20 Mr. Milbeck I'm not sure if that's
00:54:23 ringing any bells
00:54:25 I'm aware of the issue
00:54:27 that the court is
00:54:29 commenting on I think the state needs to
00:54:31 account for its decision
00:54:33 to publish text
00:54:35 messages that
00:54:37 directly implicate
00:54:40 the Supreme Court law that we're talking
00:54:41 about and I don't want
00:54:43 to pretend that I can anticipate
00:54:45 what the court's concerns are but
00:54:47 that doesn't cure republication on television of what the state will call a confession in this
00:55:00 proceeding. So in other words, this is not like, oh, the cat's out of the bag or the barn door's
00:55:06 open. This is another opportunity to violate Mr. Robinson's constitutional rights. And I'm not at
00:55:14 all suggesting that somebody is intending to do that, certainly not the court. And I'm confident
00:55:19 that the state's counsel would never intend to do that. But that would be the consequence
00:55:24 of further televising what the state refers to as previously referred to as confessions and
00:55:35 certainly would refer to here in this proceeding as confessions. We are acknowledging that they
00:55:42 are statements of a party. We have not filed anything in this case that publicizes the
00:55:55 text messages, the Discord chat, the note which Ms. Hunt is mentioning, and now that
00:56:00 Ms. Hunt has said that, yes, we want this note to be presented into evidence, and the
00:56:05 court knows what this note is because it's the courts now. Watch the video. That's another
00:56:09 piece of the same problem.
00:56:13 So this is all simplified by the court being extra cautious about Mr. Robinson's constitutional
00:56:24 rights, considering these exhibits to the extent the court deems that they're admissible
00:56:29 and portions of them are relevant, and not further televising them in this proceeding
00:56:37 in a manner which we think is inconsistent with what
00:56:40 the Supreme Court said in Estes v. Texas.
00:56:43 All right.
00:56:43 I appreciate that, Mr. Novak.
00:56:47 Ms. Hunt, would you like to respond?
00:56:51 Because I understand what Mr. Novak's saying,
00:56:55 and there may be a 403 issue as well as it relates to this.
00:56:59 And I'm not going to pretend to read your mind,
00:57:01 but because I can't do that.
00:57:05 All right, Ms. Hunt.
00:57:06 Just to clarify for the record and the court, the state's position is that we would like the audio played.
00:57:13 The audio may be captured by the cameras in the state's position, but we never intended to visually put them on the monitors such that cameras can capture them and, you know, pause or get the actual exhibits, substances of the exhibits.
00:57:31 I believe that was the media's position, if I remember correctly, is that they want everything audio and visually displayed.
00:57:41 But the state's position is we just want the audio played.
00:57:44 Right, but what's it?
00:57:56 So I'm just focused on 16 right now.
00:57:59 Okay, yes, and that's the state's position with regards to Exhibit 16.
00:58:04 So help me understand, what's the difference if the audio is played
00:58:08 or the video is played on what the court is identifying is, well, first of all, 16 is admitted.
00:58:15 So that threshold has been met, but we're dealing with the publication in regards to what is publicized
00:58:22 because this is going to Mr. Novak's argument about publicizing that is different than the
00:58:30 court simply reviewing it in its own privacy. I don't want to misstate your argument, but I
00:58:37 believe that was one of the distinctions you made. The distinction that Ms. Hunt is drawing is, I
00:58:41 think, what people call a distinction without a difference. It doesn't matter whether it's audio
00:58:45 or video, and it doesn't matter whether it's on a television or on the internet or on the radio.
00:58:50 it's going to be broadcast.
00:58:53 And so it doesn't really matter whether it's audio or video.
00:58:56 And it's actually not Mr. Robinson's video.
00:58:59 It's Mr. Twig's video.
00:59:02 And when the court mentioned 403, yes, I think the court did accurately read my mind,
00:59:07 which is fine with me, but it's unfair prejudice of a constitutional dimension,
00:59:12 and 403 is a rule of evidence.
00:59:14 All right. So, Ms. Hunt, as it relates to that publication, help me understand whether it's audio or video.
00:59:28 What's the difference there? Help me understand that.
00:59:31 I disagree that it's a distinction without a difference.
00:59:34 As we've discussed prior in this hearing, UCJA Rule 4-202.02 sub 2 sub J states that exhibits are presumed to be public court records.
00:59:51 And it does give the court discretion to regulate access when necessary to protect the integrity of the exhibit or ensure a fair trial.
00:59:58 So I do want to recognize that.
01:00:00 But that discretion should be exercised narrowly, as we've talked about before with publication regarding this case.
01:00:10 What the state is proposing, we believe, is a narrowly tailored accommodation.
01:00:15 We don't want to display the full exhibits.
01:00:17 Obviously, within states Exhibit 16, the video of Lance Twiggs, he has shown, and it can be seen,
01:00:25 exhibits that the state will then, in the future, move to admit, 16.1, 16.2, the text threads, the Discord threads.
01:00:34 So we're thinking that if it's displayed visually, what the cameras will be able to do is pause that, duplicate them, replicate them,
01:00:43 essentially have access to those exhibits.
01:00:46 What we're trying to do, and maybe they can do the same thing with, I'm sure Mr. Novak will say, they'll do the same thing with audio.
01:00:54 but the hearing the tone the context all of that that's why the state chose to do we could have
01:01:02 done a written 1102 statement from mr twiggs we chose to do as is allowed by 1102 we chose to do
01:01:10 a recording most americans are forced to spend too much money on health care and getting too
01:01:15 little in return if you're one of the millions frustrated by traditional health insurance i want
01:01:20 to tell you about America's health share. Go to Freedom for All Health. That's freedomforallhealth.org
01:01:28 slash Bannon. Now that's a mouthful. Freedomforhealth.org. That's freedomforhealth.org
01:01:37 slash Bannon. And discover why tens of thousands of patriots are joining America's health share.
01:01:44 America's health share reduces your health care costs by an average of 60 percent. And it's
01:01:49 accepted everywhere. In other words, say goodbye to out-of-network limitations. They make healthcare
01:01:55 affordable, transparent, and aligned with your values, free from surprise bills or skyrocketing
01:02:02 premiums. For as low as $68 a month, an individual can get great healthcare coverage minus the
01:02:08 complications and price gouging from healthcare providers. You can completely scrap your current
01:02:14 insurance or use America's health share to supplement your existing policy, even with
01:02:19 Medicare. Simply go to freedomforhealth.org. That's freedomforhealth.org slash Bannon to
01:02:27 learn more. Right now, new members get their first month free with promo code Bannon. It's
01:02:33 time to make America healthy. Join the community of patriots taking back control of their health
01:02:38 care. That's freedomforhealth.org slash Bannon. Freedomforhealth.org slash Bannon, promo code
01:02:46 Bannon. Make sure you go check it out. Immerse yourself in the details of America's health
01:02:51 share. You will not regret it.