00:06:47And this is an important point to the American people.
00:06:51We we take their their safety so seriously that we will take extraordinary precautions like we did on Friday to make sure they're safe.
00:07:00On the subject of competence, Rick, and this administration getting rid of the experts, I'm just I think about all of the judges or the people that want to be appointed to the federal bench sitting before Congress and having to say that, no, they're not sure that Joe Biden won the 2020 election, that there are questions having to deny that basic fact of reality.
00:07:26That is the qualification. That's what you need to do to get into this government.
00:07:31And there's there are only a limited number of people who are willing to do that.
00:07:38It has narrowed the pool of people dramatically who are, as you point out, who are willing and are also mendacious enough to go out and hold that lie without without breaking out into laughter.
00:07:52The real problem we're seeing here, it's way beyond just the judges.
00:07:55is any competence in government is going to be outweighed if you ever criticize the president.
00:08:01Any competence in a skill area that the government might need you to have,
00:08:04whether it's being a coder or a virologist or any other subject,
00:08:08if you've ever said a word against the president, you're not getting a job.
00:08:11If you've ever posted something on social media that they don't like, you're not getting a job.
00:08:15All of it now is about this cult-like loyalty and the public performance of that loyalty
00:08:21in the course of pretending that Donald Trump can never be wrong, that he is always perfect,
00:08:29that he walks on water, that nothing in this government has ever gone sideways,
00:08:34even though we see it go sideways, and we're seeing it go sideways right now.
00:08:38There's been a lot of speculation that AI might be a cause of this.
00:08:42Yes, there has. It's completely unfounded.
00:08:45Can you talk to that? I mean, talk to people who are worried that AI implementation might
00:08:49the reason why the planes are grounded i absolutely can first of all i invite all of you to come over
00:08:53to our smart center at the dot so if you haven't been there and i know many of you have please come
00:08:58over and see it but what you'll see is a fantastic use of ai taking in over 200 different data streams
00:09:05providing predictive analytics of around weather and it's making suggestions and then you're going
00:09:11to see every one of the the data analysts that are using the system pick up a phone and call
00:09:17our command center and ask if they would in fact put this flight plan into the system it's done
00:09:21manually it shouldn't be but that's the way we are today so the two systems are not connected
00:09:28anytime we move a trajectory recommendation from the smart system into the nas it goes
00:09:33manually gets data entered into the eram system this is this is it's this is the we we've seen
00:09:41a lot of conversations about ai and um and how it's gotten out and affected different parts of
00:09:49other companies that this is this is not that kind this is predictive analytics
00:09:54we have a tool that will give us predictive analytics on trajectories and on weather
00:09:59we take a feed in but we don't feed anything from this system back in to our network if there is
00:10:06any communication from the intelligence that we get from this predictive analytic tool
00:10:12actually our people in the the smart lab will call uh our command center so we're like it's
00:10:18they're not even connected the phone call is made to go we think you could speed this plane up or
00:10:22slow that one down that's our suggestion and they'll decide whether to accept it or deny it but
00:10:27so it's i've heard all of the uh the speculation but that is that is not true let me tell you what
00:10:34this is not. And this is to the best of our capabilities, looking across the federal government
00:10:42and talking to our private sector partners. And I'll come back to that. We do not see the indicia
00:10:51of a coordinated cyber attack. Let me just be clear about that. And we do not see the indicia
00:10:59of state-sponsored activity here. And we can be fairly confident in that because we know those
00:11:08things exist and we've been looking for them in the past. Let me tell you what we think this is
00:11:15and we think that it is with confidence. Lots of institutions, because these vulnerabilities have
00:11:21been identified, are patching. They're taking their systems down. They're upgrading them.
00:11:27they're putting patches in place. When you do that across sophisticated systems and you bring
00:11:34them back online, as we all know, if we've worked in business, when you take your system down,
00:11:39upgrade it over the weekend, people say, oh, it's going to come back on at 2 a.m. on a Sunday. Well,
00:11:44sometimes it doesn't come back on until 4 or 5 a.m. on a Sunday. This is being done on much
00:11:50larger scale because everybody, and it's a good news story, everybody recognizes it's time to
00:11:56upgrade their systems. And as they upgrade them, they're not coming back as expected in all cases.
00:12:03And in some cases, systems have to hand off to other systems. And those handoffs are not coming
00:12:09back as expected. But this is just an upgrade in patching, an upgrade in systems. And like I said,
00:12:18looking very diligently across the landscape, we are not seeing this as a cyber attack incident.
00:12:27Tuesday, 17 November, Year of Alert, 2026. We've got a group of experts and others for the next
00:12:34two hours to go through all this and even more. Neil McCabe's at the White House. John Gilliam's
00:12:41going to join us. Alexander Bates, we'll walk all this through. It's tough to determine whether
00:12:47it's been cyber attack, whether it has been, um, AI, you know, particularly some of these open AI
00:12:54models, um, in agentic activity. The other question is, is just everybody's so sensitive to this
00:13:02things that would be normal course of business and would not, uh, would not raise anybody's, um,
00:13:08level of interests that are happening. Just seem like all this is not coordinated. It's all
00:13:13happening at the same time and is either coming from one central authority or the random the uh
00:13:20the coincidence is just kind of too overwhelming we're gonna get to all those answers because
00:13:24that is what even it looks like the government's trying to work themselves through at this time
00:13:28we're gonna take a short commercial break want to thank the team for the great cold open of
00:13:32everything that happened uh this afternoon uh birch gold just reminding philip patrick's going
00:13:38to be here momentarily uh philip's actually going to talk to you about having made contact with
00:13:43birch gold to particularly talk through in these uh days of uncertainty why gold is a hedge
00:13:50against times of that uncertainty i think an um nvidia just announced their earnings and i think
00:13:56they doubled revenue we'll get into all that also and how that's going to affect capital markets in
00:14:01the next as we said 72 hours with anthropic getting ready to go public the birch gold special
00:14:07They had a very successful run on Veterans Day.
00:14:11Now they want to talk to you about Black Friday.
00:16:46You know, your sign back there says there's no coincidences.
00:16:48And, you know, I find this all to be very convenient in several ways that it's convenient.
00:16:54One, that it's all happening at the same time.
00:16:56I mean, the sheer odds of all of these different agencies and private entities to be having the same issue at the same time is astronomical.
00:17:09I just it goes beyond reality, I think, as far as coincidences go.
00:17:15The other thing is, is how it's being these issues are coming about.
00:17:20Every single one of the agencies that we've heard from and the private companies in which they have that have been affected, it's all saying that it's because they were updating something because of an internal mistake.
00:17:38So when you look at the totality of circumstances, that's my, when investigating that, Steve,
00:17:43that is my favorite term, because when you look at the totality of all the information
00:17:48that you have as investigator, things really, questions start to arise.
00:17:53And here's the difference between conspiracy theorists or influencers versus investigators
00:17:57is that we look and say, okay, that is possible.
00:18:01But influencers and conspiracy people say, no, no, no, this is what it is.
00:18:05And they actually lock themselves into a real quagmire when they do that.
00:18:11So when I look at this, I say, OK, it could be AI that has infiltrated these computers and routers and all these different things.
00:18:20But I also think that this could be the way nefarious actors get the AI in.
00:18:26So if all of these updates are happening at the same time, I find that very strange.
00:18:31But perhaps these updates are where the AI is being installed nefariously and potentially even by some of the people that work for these agencies and these private companies.
00:18:46I mean, when you look at the airline industry, for instance, that's as liberal and leftist as you can get.
00:18:51When you look at the banking system, leftists run those banking systems.
00:18:56And when you look at the NSA, for instance, there are many leftists still in government and they're nefarious media counterparts.
00:19:11What concerns me is that today, with everything going on, one of the most important was that the NSA's internal, you know, the internal net they've got, which is highly classified, that connects different locations and people inside.
00:19:26When they've had a an issue, they leaked it to was a Bertrand, Natasha Bertrand over at CNN, who's famous for being something that deep state person, the deep state leaks to, whether it's CNN or Politico.
00:19:40She's the one that they came with the letter of the 51 intelligence heads that said that the laptop from hell of Hunter Biden was Russian disinformation.
00:19:52That raises people's antenna right away when they see something like that going on.
00:20:00Steve, look, I mean, you know better than anyone here, the tactics, techniques, and procedures
00:20:06that the left uses, the problem, like with any criminal organizations, is when they use those
00:20:12tactics, or even the Russians, Iranians, any of these individuals, when they use those tactics,
00:20:18they're then exposed. So historically, we can go back and we can look at how AI could be utilized
00:20:24and the nefarious people that might be trying to use this type of a fear tactic, even if that's
00:20:32potentially the only thing that it's for. But we can look at the actors who could have used these
00:20:38things. So AI nowadays, AI is not like it was when you had just hackers doing it, because hackers
00:20:46will potentially leave some type of a footprint because they know this particular way to hack.
00:20:52But AI is different than that. It can maneuver and it can do things that hackers that are an expert in one area aren't able to do. The AI can learn different ways to do it.
00:21:03So when you add to that the areas that are being targeted and historically the people that target those areas and the reasons why they've historically done it, there's only a handful of actors that could be involved in this internationally and internally, domestically within the United States.
00:21:23So you have the tools, you have the actors, and you have the historical reasons that they would do this.
00:21:29And I think if we took a board, Steve, and we put all this stuff up on it like a good investigator, I think we would start to see that there's more than just, oh, we had an internal issue.
00:30:22Basically, Dark Rock Cybersecurity is a group of consultants
00:30:25that battle hard over the years, professional services,
00:30:29federal practice, where we ultimately saw what was in the market
00:30:33and have really been providing a lot of those back-end feeds.
00:30:36Myself, leading the front with a leadership team,
00:30:40we've been deploying not only with the Department of Defense in different cases,
00:30:44but also just the private sector and SMB markets.
00:30:48So, Alexander, when I hear today that NSA, the internal, you know,
00:30:53the most high security, the one they have internally, has got issues,
00:30:57And six officials have reached out to, I think, Natasha Bertrand over at CNN, who famously has put out the letter for the 51 intelligence officials that said the Hunter laptop, which we were part of the team that launched it with the New York Post, was Russian disinformation, which is obviously a lie.0.67
00:31:18when she's putting that out, and then I hear that, you know, the Iranians have a dirty bomb
00:31:24in Washington, D.C., which is clearly, I think, pushed by intelligence services.
00:31:30You don't know what to believe. Is some of this just regular, normal course of business
00:31:34activity going on at these big companies that's been so highlighted because we've had situations
00:31:40and we've had issues global in nature and massive in scale, like Microsoft and like the Groundstop,
00:31:47sir? When these type of situations occur, the first thing is always speculation. But I would
00:31:55say we shouldn't really confuse a pattern of headlines with proof of a coordinated attack.
00:32:01Obviously, as all these organizations are starting to put out their own thoughts,
00:32:06their own communication teams, they're very much going through it. When an incident response
00:32:11occurs, the first phases of that is discovery. And as you're going through discovery,
00:32:16then you progress into containment and eradication.
00:32:19These are all things that are constantly a two steps forward, one step back,
00:32:23potentially two steps back as part of the process.
00:32:25And so if they're being quiet or unintentionally not acknowledging those headlines,
00:32:31that means the teams are head down and actively working on fighting the fires.
00:32:37So, by the way, when we look at it, is this cyber a coordinated activity
00:32:41or could it just be the agentic activity of systems?
00:32:45They're trying to upgrade the AI agentic activity, particularly if it's open source, if it's got some of this Chinese, what I call Chinese coding slop in there.
00:32:54Could it be that we're essentially hacking ourselves or some of this is just from the simple reason you're doing upgrades and this AI has got issues with it also?
00:33:05Maybe some of the agent, maybe it's malevolent on some of the agentic activity and may some of it just be incompetence.
00:33:12i i think you've acknowledged uh all the great topics and the right topics when we move at the
00:33:19speed of disruption that we've been moving at over the past 12 to 18 months uh in the private
00:33:24sector as well as the federal sector things are going to break uh especially when there's large
00:33:29funding initiatives for modernizing critical infrastructure whether that's some of the events
00:33:35that we saw last week as well as uh additionally other infrastructure as an aging organization
00:33:41an aging country. The worst time for a situation or an outage to occur is right when you're
00:33:49switching out end-of-life assets or end-of-life technology and modernizing at that time.
00:33:55The biggest thing that we always teach within the IT world is being able to failover safely.
00:34:00I think one of the things that this country also demands as a consumer, as an American citizen,
00:34:31They've got eight times the demand right now.
00:34:32but their uh their their actual raise has increased i think they're looking at a 100
00:34:38billion a 100 billion dollar ipo uh and that's the money raised um the uh at a 1.4 trillion dollar
00:34:47valuation you mentioned something earlier i just want to make sure people are understand it you're
00:34:53saying at the level we've been going both in the government sector sector the federal sector and
00:34:57private explain to us what's happened over the last 18 months because now you're about to get
00:35:02hit with a new wave of capital for even more upgrades. How crazy has it been over the last
00:35:0918 months in this industry as people try to change out into systems that are really driven by
00:35:14artificial intelligence? I think you hit it. What this really has done, and it's put under a
00:35:22microscope, is what the supply chain ecosystem actually matters, whether you're upstream or
00:35:28downstream. And so I think what I'm really trying to get to is we become so reliant on organizations
00:35:34to perform a specific function for us. Specifically, some of the larger players do not only just what
00:35:41used to be referred to as the cloud, but they're supporting our servers. They're supporting the
00:35:46infrastructure. If they have an outage, it used to just be data collection or an email server.
00:35:52Now we have our communication lines. We don't even know the phone numbers of our employees or family members because everything is so connected. I think what it's pointing to is a dependency on third parties with what you're heading towards NVIDIA as well as some of these, the frontier AI models that are also pushing potentially their IPOs.
00:36:16I think some of the speculation and some of the valuation is also in the future demand.
00:36:21Right now, we've been evaluating the current state and current investments. I think organizations are
00:36:27still understanding what an AI investment means to their organizations that countries are figuring
00:36:33it out as well. I think over the next 12 to 18 months, looking forward, some of the things that
00:36:39we will really start to see is a consolidation of investments, a consolidation of potentially
00:36:46bringing some of those efforts, maybe in-house, talent in-house as well. Because at the end of
00:36:54the day, if you don't have those resources or have that knowledge base, you have to go learn it or
00:37:01hire for it. And so I think the demand is there. I think obviously NVIDIA being one of the top
00:37:08chip producers. They're embedding themselves really well in the supply chain. They're going
00:37:14to be a player to watch very much over the next year or two. I want to go back to you said
00:37:20dependency on third parties. One of the commonalities that struck me on both the things
00:37:27that kind of initiate this at scale was Microsoft and was the FAA ground stop. In both of those
00:37:34situations, correct me if I'm wrong, in Microsoft, as they tried to do these upgrades, they couldn't
00:37:38even find people that were still at the company that knew a lot about some of the issues or some
00:37:45of the things they had to do in upgrading the upgrading they were doing. That institutional
00:37:50memory had gone kind of the same with the FAA situation with these routers. You can tell now
00:37:56that they'd done it successfully before, but clearly there were some issues there about actual
00:38:02knowledge of how, you know, AI systems or new systems are going to integrate or patch into
00:38:07old systems. Is that something that we should look forward to? Make us smarter. How does this thing
00:38:12evolve? Do we now in a world where you're in a transitioning to something different and that
00:38:19something different is going to make us more dependent, but right now it's these kind of
00:38:24fissures between old systems and news shows the dependency that we've really got on the old
00:38:31systems and even more dependency coming forward, sir? Yes. I use this analogy quite a bit. It's
00:38:39very much a tower of babble type of moment where everyone at one point knew the technology and
00:38:44then you disperse and you forget the ways of the old. I think what that should highlight for
00:38:52industries that specifically have aging technology, whether it's critical infrastructure,
00:38:57whether that's manufacturing, which are really the backbone of this country, companies, organizations, agencies really should be emphasizing the knowledge transfer that needs to occur from the technology.
00:39:11Who's going to be the custodian of this technology for the next 5, 10, 15 plus years until we have an opportunity to reinvest and roadmap what our future looks like?
00:39:22again kind of going back to that disruption aspect we've been catapulted forward i think
00:39:28the incredible thing about the ai wave was we were emerging from a covid living situation where i
00:39:36think everyone was that was the status quo being able to work remotely being able to ultimately
00:39:42live through one of the largest business continuity exercises of of the modern profession
00:39:48And then now looking at the disruption of this new technology.
00:39:53So I think industries that haven't necessarily planned for that in a strong and capable way are the ones that are reeling hardest from the changes.
00:40:03As new companies are pushing out emerging technology that is really cutting edge, caring and feeding for the backbone infrastructure still needs to occur.
00:40:14Most of, as I mentioned, the critical infrastructure, that has been roadmapped and budgeted for future investments and changes.
00:40:22But that also doesn't mean that this new system and the new changes that are occurring daily won't potentially create a toxic combination that could lead to an outage.
00:40:34Alexander Bates, where do people follow you on social media?
00:40:37Do you have a website that's at least a website that has not been designated?
00:46:02particularly with the shopping cart and all the malware that's been dumped in some of these systems.
00:46:09Yeah, and I think it just speaks to what you were talking about before, about third-party providers.
00:46:14There's a company called Optimizely, which handles shopping carts and sort of does AI-assisted choice on your, you know, basically getting you to buy products.
00:46:25And so they deal with hundreds of companies.
00:46:28And so adding to all of the things going on with Microsoft and the FAA, people had real life experiences where those sites were down and not working.
00:46:37And it was spread to Apple stores and Levi's dot com and Salesforce dot com.
00:46:43It was a JavaScript that was injected into the Optimizely system.
00:46:52Sunday night, the BBC was the first one to sort of acknowledge that there was a problem shortly before midnight Eastern Coast time here.
00:47:01And then it just sort of spread and spread.
00:47:04Personally, I got a notification that hundreds of sites were down from the New York Post.
00:47:08I clicked on the link and the New York Post site was down.
00:47:11And so I think this sort of exasperated everything, all of the unrest that people were feeling about the other sites going down.
00:47:20But this was a real life hack and the hackers used the exact same tools that were used to hack Turkish websites in September.
00:47:30And so Optimizely said, hey, we fixed it. It's a patch. We never have to worry again. And now it happened today.
00:47:37yeah um thank you i'm gonna come back to you at the white house uh because i still think you gotta
00:47:45look at the ai agentic activity maybe we're self-hacking because the thing that was described
00:47:49the other day at faa is a ddos attack full stop and it looks like to me it's an internal ddos
00:47:57attack because of patching through the the new ai upgrade anyway stand by uh philip patrick you
00:48:04bring up and this is why I just want to make sure people can get to you because now more than ever
00:48:08our sponsors who are associated with people thinking downrange is more important than ever
00:48:16and I think people have to think this through exactly nobody should panic ever should take a
00:48:21deep breath but with everything going on I think more than ever you've just got to get some
00:48:27stability one of the ways you get stability is to make sure your affairs are in order talk about
00:48:33this having wealth versus accessing wealth. And we've heard about, I think Gilliam told us about
00:48:39Paraguay, where they had the situation with the bank failures a couple of weeks ago. I think
00:48:44they're going to, you know, the government's about to change hands or potentially change hands
00:48:47because of it. We've already had a couple of banks hit. And this is why Scott Besson, during the IMF
00:48:54week back in the first week of May, he had all the major money center banks come in and they were
00:48:58sitting there going, hey, we're concerned about AI right now. We're concerned about the combination
00:49:02of artificial intelligence and cyber hacking that we can't control.
00:49:07And I think it was Jamie Dimon and one of the participants there said,
00:49:10you could evaporate a money center bank in 90 seconds.