A priest who had been imprisoned inside the Vatican for four years for possession of child pornography has just been reinstated in his position in the Secretariat of State, which has the responsibility for relations with the states. Liz Yor has the details on this.
00:00:55.000Hanwell here at the helm on Steve Bannon's War Room.
00:00:58.000It's that little corner of the week when we get to dig into the developments in the Catholic, Protestant,
00:01:05.000and even occasionally Orthodox spheres bringing to you all these things that mean a lot to you,
00:01:11.000to your daily lives, to your spiritual lives,
00:01:13.000but that which other news organizations tend not to touch.
00:01:17.000And if they touch it, they don't dig into it.
00:01:19.000Folks, you remember last week we discussed the horror story coming out of France,
00:01:24.000where a priest who had been in prison for four years for repeatedly raping a 16-year-old boy had been promoted to the number three position in the diocese.
00:01:42.000That's caused a lot of consternation in France.
00:01:44.000Frank Walker will be up a little later on the show with the developments on that story.
00:01:48.000We've also got something that will interest, especially, I hope, the left, the political left of the spectrum,
00:01:54.000which likes to go on and on about the fact that Europe is so much more civilized than the United States.
00:02:01.000Well, here's the very heart of geographical Europe, Switzerland, considered by many to be the exemplar of continental Europe.
00:02:10.000Horror story coming out of Switzerland, where the over 85s have seen a fourfold increase in the suicide rates there.
00:02:20.000And we'll be discussing what that might mean also for the United States as well.
00:02:25.000I'll be talking a little later on in the show about the maneuvers in Washington state to get priests to break the seal of the confessional.
00:02:38.000But before that, here's an astonishing story detailing how a priest who had been imprisoned inside the Vatican in a Vatican jail for, I think, four years for possessing huge amounts of pornography,
00:02:56.000and specifically child pornography, has just been reinstated in his position in the Secretariat of State, specifically the second section, which has the responsibility for the relations with the states.
00:03:11.000Liz Yor has the details on this. Liz, Liz, I know you've been following this closely.
00:03:16.000Tell me, is this as horrific as it sounds?
00:03:20.000It has been, you know, the Vatican is showing once again how tone deaf it is, rules for the but not for me.
00:03:31.000Full disclosure, my background in law enforcement was one of the things that I did was create the National Cyber Tip Line,
00:03:39.000which allows Americans and people actually around the world to report child pornography into a hotline and we pass on those leads to law enforcement.
00:03:50.000We have here this Father Carlo Capella, who I remember this case very clearly in 2017.
00:03:58.000And I will give you kind of my insight from behind the scenes, not particularly about this case, but what this case is telling me.
00:04:06.000He was an ordained priest in the Archdiocese of Milan.
00:04:10.000He went into the diplomatic corps, which meant that he was part of the Secretary of State's office.
00:04:17.000And he was assigned to the most prestigious, one would argue, embassy, the U.S. Embassy, the Vatican Nunticature Inn in Washington, D.C.
00:04:29.000This priest, Father Capella, went apparently in 2017 during a Christmas vacation to Canada.
00:04:39.000The Canadian officials, I presume it was the Royal Mounted Police, notified law enforcement and issued a nationwide arrest warrant for this cleric on charges of possession and distribution of child pornography.
00:04:57.000And when he was on vacation in Windsor, Ontario, this to me is absolutely this case is really emblematic of we know here that there is a great there's a great problem with child pornography in in the clerical state.
00:05:15.000In 2013, the Vatican issued new supposedly tougher guidelines until the U.S. State Department also notified the Holy See that there was this arrest warrant.
00:05:28.000And asked the Holy See to waive a diplomatic immunity.
00:05:33.000They did not. And this priest fled to Rome.
00:05:37.000Fortunately, the Vatican charged him and they have a criminal court, as you know, Ben, in the Vatican, as well as a canonical court.
00:05:46.000He was found to have more than 40 criminal images and videos, which he shared on social media.
00:05:58.000I need a clarification. Occasionally, when people get investigated by the police for having dodgy images on their phone, it's something they may have received via WhatsApp or WhatsApp group.
00:06:10.000And of course, WhatsApp stores all the images that you receive automatically.
00:06:16.000So anyone adept at managing a phone will be able to go in there and they'll just scan and say, oh, look, there was this image there or that image there.
00:06:23.000So this isn't I just want to I know you said this that they were talking about 40 images here, but this isn't a case where anyone even giving the best will in the world can somewhat innocently say, oh, look, I don't know who sent this to me.
00:06:36.000You know, I told them to stop doing it or what have you.
00:06:39.240This is this is not only possession of images, but as you were just saying, just underline this point, possession and distribution.
00:06:49.560There's no just there's no there's no there's no generous interpretation one can give to this child pornography.
00:06:58.560This computer of this priest came to the attention of the Royal Canadian Mountain Police.
00:07:05.560This was a computer that they were very concerned about by the I would argue the amount of child pornography that was on and the nature of child pornography.
00:07:16.560You know, I won't go into details, but the videos of child pornography are so horrendous and so vile.
00:07:25.560And, you know, the the victims in these cases, we argue in law enforcement that every time these videos are shared, these children are re victimized.
00:07:37.560And so arguably these children are re victimized for a lifetime, millions of times around the world.
00:07:45.560Well, the Vatican criminal court convicted him.
00:07:50.560He pled actually guilty, I believe, and he received five years and a fine.
00:07:55.560He was allowed under they could have given him up to 12 years.
00:08:00.560But, you know, again, in reading this article, it was quite interesting when he was sitting in jail after being convicted.
00:08:07.560And he had several visitors from the secretary of state's department and he was released.
00:08:18.560Unlike many priests, he was not, you know, sent out to pasture like, you know, many priests who want to say the Latin mass.
00:08:27.560No, he was reinstated at the secretary of state's office, the premier, highly prominent, a diplomatic corps in the Vatican, which, you know, to me is number one, rewarding bad behavior.
00:08:45.560And number two, the statements then coming out of the Vatican are just shocking.
00:08:50.560They wanted to give him mercy, show mercy to him.
00:09:01.560And I don't want to preempt the story that Frank's going to go into in more detail later on in the show.
00:09:09.560But have you noticed the language almost is word for word?
00:09:14.560Because I know you've also been studying the situation of the French, I think it's Toulouse, the French archdiocese.
00:09:20.560Have you noticed that the language here in terms of the mercy is almost identical word for word?
00:09:26.560Here's my question to you. Do you think studying these these two cases specifically that there might be some kind of Vatican secret protocol here on the rehabilitation of priests who've been convicted of.
00:09:45.560Some kind of sexual offense in order to have to bring them back to mainstream them to normalize if that would be the right word for this context, because I'm curious about the similarity of the wording here in this case and the French case as well.
00:10:03.560And it's exactly what you're talking about here about the mercy.
00:10:06.560It is. And, you know, it's political favoritism. I think that's what's going on in in the Vatican, that their favorites.
00:10:13.560And by the way, this priest was ordained by none other than Cardinal Martini, who was the founder of the St.
00:10:22.560Golland Mafia, friend of Cardinal McCarrick.
00:10:25.560Obviously, this young priest was on a fast track in the diplomatic corps.
00:10:31.560And, you know, it is shocking to read the statements from the Vatican saying that these crimes were a bump in the road and that he was experiencing a period of fragility because he moved to the Washington embassy.
00:10:46.560I mean, he wasn't sent to Sudan. He wasn't sent to Nigeria or Yemen.
00:10:51.560He was sent to the most prestigious embassy in the world.
00:10:55.560It is shocking to me that once again, Ben, the victims are ignored.
00:11:01.560And here was really a teaching moment for the church to talk about the dignity of children and the exploitation of the Internet and by people.
00:11:12.560And in my reading of this story, in my opinion, there was a tremendous amount of child pornography on his computer.
00:11:21.560So much so that the U.S. and Canada both were demanding action and that this priest submit himself to jurisdiction in the United States.
00:11:32.560You know, this this was a serious case of child pornography.
00:11:39.560You know, basically, his the Vatican, you know, said his hands are our hands are washed.
00:11:45.560He's we're putting him back because after all, where is he going?
00:11:48.560What is he going? What is he going to do?
00:11:50.560Well, we know of bishops and priests in America who've done nothing wrong and have been sent out to pasture with no kind of mercy just because they love the Latin mass.
00:12:01.560Right. And yet here a man who violated the innocence of children by not only downloading child pornography, but sharing it, sharing it around the world.
00:12:13.560I mean, just imagine. And and they want to say, oh, bump in the road of his clerical career and back.
00:12:20.560And back he's back in charge writing speeches for the Vatican secretary of state and doing the important work.
00:12:28.560And, you know, a person like that in a place where they're assigning priests all over the world as diplomats.
00:12:35.560I mean, this to me is shows the Vatican is not taking these crimes seriously after 50 years.
00:12:42.560They you know, this is an issue that they should be sounding the alarm.
00:12:47.560And yet again, they demonstrate that they're tone deaf and that they are not going to protect children.
00:12:55.560So it's to me, we to me, let's see what Leo does with this case. Right.
00:13:01.560Let's see what Pope Leo sends is, you know, looks at this case and puts this guy out to pasture.
00:13:07.560He does not belong in the church. He can go to a monastery as a as a civilian and pray for the rest of his life and do penance.
00:13:16.560But this man should not wear a Roman collar.
00:13:20.560And that's pretty much what Benedict imposed on Marcel Maisel, wasn't it?
00:13:47.560The first Trump administration asked the Vatican to lift the diplomatic immunity on this guy who was basically who was a full fully fledged diplomatic official working for the for the nuncio to the nuncio, who must have been Viganò at that time.
00:14:04.560Right. I think 2017 and the Vatican refused.
00:14:08.560They declined to waive diplomatic immunity.
00:14:11.560Let me just ask you a quick question. Right. Give me one minute on this.
00:14:15.560Do you think there's any possibility this guy holds compromise on on it on on on looking at how quick his he and unorthodox his his reintegration has been back within the secretary to state?
00:14:32.560Do you think he might have something on his files that gives him an easier negotiating hand?
00:14:38.560Well, one is left with that impression, aren't they?
00:14:42.560And in fact, I don't think Viganò Viganò, I think, was gone by then, if I'm not mistaken.
00:14:52.560And, you know, any other pope would have said, yes, he should submit himself to the jurisdiction of the United States for investigation and punishment.
00:15:04.560But this guy was really fast track even through his criminal investigation and the Vatican.
00:15:13.560And the fact that they didn't laicize him when the laws and norms in the Vatican passed in 2013 provided for that.
00:15:21.560So you're left with the impression, oh, he is one of the favorite ones and we are going to exercise mercy instead of judgment on this guy.
00:15:34.560And to me, this sends a loud and clear message, not only to the Vatican, to all those priests that are violating these laws, but also to the people in the pews that we have to demand justice and a change in in the attitude towards these sexual crimes, which are horrendous.
00:15:58.560Horrendous in which, you know, they say, oh, well, there was no contact with children, not on the computer.
00:16:05.560There wasn't by this priest, but on the computer, you would see these children being assaulted by other people.
00:16:12.560OK, Liz, thanks very much for that breakdown.
00:16:15.560We'll be coming back to you later on in the show.
00:16:19.560Since Trump was sworn in, his administration has made enormous progress at a breakneck pace.
00:16:27.560But don't forget, while they're moving mountains for the good of the nation, they can't also take your personal savings into account.
00:16:37.560Just text Bannon to the number 989898 and Birch Gold will send you a free info kit on gold.
00:16:46.560There's no obligation, only useful information with an A plus rating with a better business bureau and tens of thousands of happy customers.
00:16:59.560Text the word Bannon, B-A-N-N-O-N to 989898.
00:17:06.560What if you had one of the brightest minds in the war room delivering critical financial research every month?
00:17:18.560Our go-to geopolitics expert Jim Rickards, a former CIA, Pentagon and White House advisor, has been warning Americans about an AI-triggered financial crash.
00:17:32.560Right now, war room members get a free copy of Money GPT when they subscribe to Strategic Intelligence, Jim's flagship financial newsletter.
00:17:43.560Don't wait until the next meltdown hits.
00:17:46.560Go to rickardswarroom.com and claim your free book.
00:17:53.560So, moving on with the theme of the Vatican approving the rehabilitation, the reintegration of priests who have been convicted of sexual crimes.
00:18:12.560And both the case we're just discussing and the one that we're going to discuss now are actually crimes against children.
00:18:18.560Let's go back to Frank Walker, who was telling us last week about this case in Toulouse.
00:18:24.560Frank, I know you've been following this very closely, but all is not well in the French Catholic Church, right?
00:18:31.560There's been a fraternal correction against this bishop.
00:18:35.560First of all, before you give us the details on this, why don't you just remind us what a fraternal correction is and what it involves in the Catholic environment?
00:18:47.560Well, I think, yeah, in terms of morality, it's when you correct somebody for doing something immoral and you do it in love, even though it's critical.
00:18:57.560And, you know, it's just a way to remind us that you're trying to help this person overcome his sins and get to heaven.
00:19:04.560So that's what a fraternal correction is. And this priest, I mean, this bishop, Bishop Girard from the Vivier Diocese has corrected the Toulouse bishop, who is the one with his chancellor, who is still a priest after many, many years of public outcry and prison over forcibly raping a teenage boy.
00:19:27.560And now he and he, you know, before that, he was vocations director.
00:19:33.560He worked in children's ministry after these things became known, and he then he was moved to an important position in this diocese.
00:19:42.560And he was already before this Toulouse bishop was there. The previous one had him as vice chancellor.
00:19:47.720This guy just moved him up. But I think it's become especially famous because he's been so careless.
00:19:53.560This bishop of Toulouse has been so careless about talking about the mercy.
00:19:58.260What are we supposed to do with him? How can he move forward?
00:20:02.260He's like, it's like a death sentence if we just don't let him continue to be a monsignor and be an important advisor to the diocese.
00:20:09.880So this bishop has from, Vivier has intervened and said, I don't think that the priests and the faithful understand all this, what you call mercy.
00:20:18.280What happened to mercy for the victims?
00:20:19.940And it's only been a month since he's been appointed to this position.
00:20:25.560Maybe, perhaps, we'll see some movement on this that he'll, you know, retract what he's actually said, because he hasn't really quite done that yet.
00:20:32.960He's just continued to make these kinds of bleeding Francis mercy statements.
00:20:39.980And, you know, it's a way to see what is the Labner Mafia.
00:20:43.920There's a report that says this victim of Father Spina, is the name of the guy, himself, tried to get in a seminary many times, but they screened him out.
00:21:10.440Just zoom out and repeat what you've just said.
00:21:13.520The victim here, this guy who was 16 years old, I think back in 93, 94, when he was repeatedly raped by Father Spina, the victim, has now, if I've understood this correctly, as a teacher, he did go into the seminary, if I'm not mistaken, but was refused.
00:21:35.760So he's now a teacher, correct me if I've got this wrong, and he himself, the victim, the guy who had his life turned upside down by this Catholic priest who's now number three, number two or number three in the Toulouse Diocese.
00:21:50.760This victim, become an adult, become an adult, become a teacher, has now perpetrated the same category of crimes.
00:22:02.620I don't think, I don't know if he's, if he's actually, no, there are accusations, I think, that he was, that he was molesting a young girl, right?
00:22:09.580And, um, Frank, just tell me something.
00:22:12.480I had a different question for you, but seeing as you raise this, tell me something.
00:22:16.180Does that not make Father Spina's crimes worse, in effect?
00:22:21.140Because what he did to this young kid, in a sense, has so ruined him, as so often happens in cases of sexual abuse of children,
00:22:29.280that he himself is now within this paradigm of, of, of child sex abuse, and he's repeating the offense.
00:22:37.540Doesn't that make, doesn't that sort of make the crimes even more grave with regards to Father Spina?