The number of single women in the U.S. has increased 55% since 2000, and is on track to reach 43 million by 2023. Why do so many single women vote for the Democratic presidential candidate, Kamala Harris?
00:00:28.660Yeah, and when you disintermediate the family unit, you can use the state both to decrease the BATNA of a woman to not have a partner, while also acting as the caregiver.
00:00:38.940Like, these women are sort of like nuns to the state.
00:00:41.280They're basically married to the state.
00:00:43.860Wow, yeah, that's a great way of putting it.
00:00:48.600And I'd also note that this trend could explain, for example, why Black females overwhelmingly vote Democrat so much.
00:00:54.980Because when you look at the number of single women, 47% of Black adults are single compared to 28% of not-white adults and 27% of Hispanic adults.
00:01:04.460I wish we could see information on the extent to which single women are getting government services.
00:01:36.680I think it is easy to underestimate, one, how heavily Kamala is leading with single women.
00:01:44.600And two, how much Democrats have worked to increase the number of single women and how much that number has increased over the last few election cycles to give them better margins towards victory.
00:02:21.180Single women are actually the only major demographic where Kamala and Democrats are still actually winning, which is what's really interesting.
00:02:37.860I mean, if you look at married men, if you look at unmarried men, if you look at single women, if you look at married women, the only category where Kamala wins is single women.
00:02:51.600Now, obviously, a lot of this was started with J.D. Vance's cat lady comment, which is why I joked on that to begin with.
00:02:59.400Specifically, he said, a bunch of childless cat ladies who are miserable at their own lives want to make the rest of the country miserable too.
00:03:07.860And a lot of people took that really negatively because a lot of women framed that as personal attacks against themselves.
00:03:19.420People say she's crazy just because she has a few dozen cats.
00:03:23.600But can anyone who loves animals that much really be crazy?
00:03:26.800Whereas I understand his sentiment here.
00:03:35.760Obviously, what he means by this is if you don't have a personal stake in the future of the country, you are going to make decisions which don't consider the future of the country, which is something we've repeatedly seen about the exploding amount of debt, the way people are handling things like Social Security and obviously unsustainable manners.
00:03:53.500Nothing about the way the government is run right now, and I'd say both parties are to blame for this to an extent, has the long-term future of the country in mind anymore.
00:04:03.540Yes, the government is excessively short-termist.
00:04:06.200But I thought it was also interesting how, like, Democrat mainstays reacted to J.D. Vance's comment.
00:04:13.440Specifically, Taylor Swift attempted to flip the language on the head, signing off her endorsement of Kamala Harris with, quote-unquote, childless cat lady.
00:04:23.500Besides a photo of Swift and her cat, her cat's name is Benjamin Button.
00:04:28.160Megan Cain said in a social media post that the comment displayed an, quote, insensitivity and cruelty to women, and then, quote, would you say that that comment was in any way cruel to women, or?
00:04:40.980I mean, the cruelty is to women, and we'll do a whole other episode on this, who use cats to masturbate their parenting instinct.
00:04:48.780When I say masturbate, I mean that in a very literal sense, in the same way that sex is designed to attempt to get us to procreate and rear the next generation.
00:04:57.980Women also have these instincts that are designed to want babies, so that they want the next generation.
00:05:03.160And they masturbate these instincts through, instead of childbirth, caring for small pets, which satiates them enough that they do not, I mean, satiates them temporarily.
00:05:14.540We all know that's why they keep getting more, because that's the way this works, is you think that you have satiated this instinct, but you haven't.
00:05:24.280So you get more and more and more until you've got 20 cats and you're sat in the water and fall asleep to the sound of your own screen.
00:05:28.680I want to be a lawyer and a doctor, because a woman can do anything.
00:05:33.760At 24, Eleanor had graduated from Harvard Medical and Yale Law.
00:05:38.560I'm a little burnt out, so sometimes, don't shoot me, I have a glass of wine with Buster here.
00:05:45.800He's a real comfort. I might even get a second cat.
00:05:53.060Any thoughts before I go further, Simone?
00:05:54.820It is insulting to insinuate that all childless women are miserable with their lives, because not all are.
00:06:03.180I don't think Taylor Swift is miserable.
00:06:05.780I'm guessing that Simone made this assumption, thinking that if she was as wealthy and famous and respected as Taylor Swift, that she would not be unhappy.
00:06:13.660But if you actually look at Taylor Swift's songs first, many of them are pining after having a guy who loves and cares for her, which she doesn't.
00:06:21.080And that's part of what her sadness comes from.
00:06:24.220But also, you can look at her songs that specifically talk about it, like the song Antihero, which has the lines,
00:06:30.080When My Depression Works a Graveyard Shift, talking about, well, being depressed.
00:06:34.500And she, in the song Labyrinth, talks about how her breakups trigger depressive episodes.
00:06:40.960And if you look at public statements in interviews like Miss Americana, the 2020 Netflix documentary, she alludes to fame making her fundamentally unhappy, which it doesn't need to.
00:06:52.840I mean, Simone and I have gathered a great deal of fame.
00:06:55.320Just today, another article in The Guardian came out about us, and I guess it's presumably attacking us, but they also published a slide deck we did on how to make new forms of government, which got me really excited.
00:07:06.580And I guess you can choose how you react to the things around you, and single cat ladies choose to react to it in self-indulgent ways, like Taylor Swift does.
00:07:15.080For example, I don't think some of our friends who are childless and cat owners are miserable.
00:07:20.080But, in general, if I were childless and I owned cats, I wouldn't be hurt by this.
00:07:29.460Well, I mean, I think it also shows sort of a victim culture on the left of, like, you know, he made fun of childless cat ladies, therefore.
00:07:41.540If you have a huge amount of cognitive, yeah, I've never taken offense to that, but, like, it's, like, it's an attempt to dehumanize your opponents, and I get that.
00:07:49.960But, like, childless cat ladies is a bit different.
00:07:54.120It's characterization along a stereotype.
00:07:56.340Oh, it's not dehumanization because he talks about how they're miserable with their lives, which I think many of them would argue is important because mental health is a major interest, also, of many single cat ladies.
00:08:07.800So, I think many of them would tell their therapists that they're miserable with their lives.
00:08:12.380It's not an inaccurate characterization, even.
00:09:09.140And you could say, well, maybe it's the Democrats don't get married, but actually, you typically see a change in women after they get married.
00:09:14.400And this brings me to something that you brought up earlier that I thought was really powerful,
00:09:18.500is that a lot of older people are like, oh, well, my daughter is young, and so she's still a Democrat, but when she gets older, she'll become a Republican.
00:09:26.560And you were pointing out, no, she won't.
00:09:29.880Like, that used to be the case, but your daughter isn't married.
00:09:33.680And it's like, when did you become a Republican, you know, to the women who say this?
00:09:37.000And it's like, well, after I got married, and it's like, yeah, well, your daughter isn't getting married and has no ability to get married right now,
00:09:44.620given the way that she views the world and the way she views the opposite gender.
00:09:47.620Well, and even just given the way that relationship markets work, there are so many single women we know who want to be married
00:09:54.200and just can't be married because they're high-achieving women, and it's very, very difficult for them to find uncoupled,
00:10:01.760non-completely weird and ruined in some way, single men who are higher-achieving than them.
00:10:18.120To a great extent, you allowed me to understand that I was permitted to have non-hyper-progressive beliefs,
00:10:28.540and I did basically grow up in a cultural cult where I just thought that there were certain things you weren't allowed to think or believe.
00:21:19.060So she only has, you know, hovering around maybe like 36%, 37% compared to what was around 34% before she was running.
00:21:27.860So this whole Kamala remediation campaign to, like, remediate her public image, it seems to have been incredibly effective among single women, basically fizzled among married women.
00:21:38.640Their impression of her now is not that different than their impression of her before she ran.
00:22:00.500It's not like she should be some single woman icon.
00:22:03.080But definitely, the Brat Summer Association is more of an unhinged, messy, single woman mood.
00:22:16.060And single women certainly appreciate more the sorts of government handouts and services that I think...
00:22:25.080Well, I also think that they're more likely to vote with the crowd because they feel less protected than married women.
00:22:30.960I think the communalist instinct in women might be louder when they feel that they don't have a caregiver.
00:22:37.580Because in those instances, they're more...
00:22:39.480Or there is not another very, very strong, attenuating influence in their lives that might temper their thoughts on things.
00:22:49.900So when they see something in the news or media or someone they admire say something, there isn't some partner or friend next to them being like, I don't know, like poking holes in the arguments, essentially.
00:23:59.440The General Social Survey has found that Americans across the board have become increasingly supportive of access to abortion in any circumstance.
00:24:06.280But the shift among single women has been especially dramatic.
00:24:09.140In its 2022 survey, two-thirds of single women said that abortion should be available for any reason.
00:24:15.540A view held by less than half of single women a decade earlier.
00:24:19.420So our country is becoming more pro-abortion.
00:24:22.920And I think that this is one of those things where you have not seen this same insane rise in Europe.
00:24:28.840And I think that a lot of this is downstream, as we've talked about in other episodes, of the view that life begins at conception, which, by the way, is not a biblical view.
00:24:36.860The Bible very clearly says life begins before conception.
00:24:39.640It's something that the Catholic Church made up about 200 years ago with Pope Pius IX and then was chosen by the Republican Party.
00:24:47.180The Republican Party used to be actually the pro-choice party in the 70s.
00:24:50.540The Republican National Convention, they were more pro-choice than anti-choice.
00:24:53.240But they choose to accept it to try to bring Catholics over, and it didn't even work.
00:24:57.040Catholics still vote overwhelmingly Democrats.
00:24:58.960So I don't know why we keep it as a position.
00:25:32.160I definitely get that because we've met quite a few Protestants who are very suspicious of abortion, even hormonal birth control.
00:25:41.420Before a nervous system has developed, which to me is just – but it's ended up destroying, I think, the Republicans' ability to earn ground share on this.
00:25:49.080And things are moving further and further in the opposite direction, which is leading to more and more abortions, which is, like, you're functionally – like, do you want to, like, win?
00:25:57.520Do you want to lower the amount of abortions?
00:25:59.300Or are you okay with – so that you can masturbate to this aesthetic view towards abortion, continue losing?
00:26:04.960Yeah, this purest view of life begins exactly at conception instead of a more moderated view of, hey, you know, it looks like – you're looking at killing a human regardless.
00:26:18.480But we see it as killing a human when you decide not to have kids.
00:26:21.940So, you know, where you start is arbitrary.
00:26:23.740I think when it really matters that you're killing a human is when you start killing a human that will feel pain as you kill them, and then you need to look at it very differently.
00:26:34.160If we start looking at it at 12 to 15 weeks as, hey, let's put severe controls on this, so many abortions could be managed very differently.
00:26:43.420We could probably have far fewer abortions, as you point out.
00:26:46.100Well, and you pointed this out with people calling you.
00:26:48.780Like, Republicans will call you and be like, I want you to have a, you know, life being in the conception stance.
00:26:52.300And you're like, well, my stance would dramatically – one, it's more likely to pass.
00:26:55.640Two, it would lower the number of abortions when contrasted with my – the person I'm running against.
00:27:01.240So they're like, no, if you won't take this stance, I'm voting for your opponent.
00:27:04.540Yeah, meaning that they're voting for roughly your abortions.
00:27:07.980Yeah, it's just – I think that demonstrates how illogical and virtue signaling –
00:27:15.820Oh, yeah, no, it's about virtue signaling for them.
00:27:17.540They don't actually care about the children, or they would do what would help.
00:27:19.800Apparently not, yeah, because if you did, you would be very focused on anything that gets you marginally closer to your preferences.
00:27:27.780And even if your preferences are absolutely zero abortions ever, you would still want to vote for me, even though I only care about controls after week 12.
00:27:35.340Now, I also know – and this is important to note around all this, when people are like, well, you know, Trump and his abortion.
00:27:42.180Trump has said that if elected, he would veto a national abortion ban.