In this episode, we take a deep dive into the world of anime and discuss some of the persistent questions we ve seen in the medium over the years, such as: Why is it so prevalent in anime? And why does it take place in high school?
00:01:14.040So we were talking about something and you spontaneously had this idea, which just enchanted me because I think you might be right.
00:01:23.020And sometimes when we're looking at the world, there's these little nagging questions which persist beyond reality where it's like, what on earth is going on here?
00:01:34.680You know, you're talking about a big one with sexuality, I'd say is why is it that gay males and straight males are more likely to find the opposite gender repellent than gay versus straight females?
00:01:53.140That's where we can say something is going on here and we can use these sorts of persistent differences or unusual patterns to suss out deeper things that are going on within a population.
00:02:06.340Now, in anime, there are actually many of these.
00:02:11.640And in Japan, there are many of these.
00:02:13.720So our audience may not know this, but my wife was born in Japan and she spent a lot of her childhood going to Japan to trips and stuff like that.
00:02:24.520You know, for her, it was sort of like her home away from home.
00:02:27.280And her middle name is actually Haruko.
00:02:29.460So we even have a Japanese middle name.
00:02:31.880And one, so we're going to go over a few different questions that we've seen sort of persistently in anime.
00:02:38.740And I'll go over the three that I know we're going to cover and then we might come up with some others.
00:02:42.980The first one is, why are, what's the way to say this?
00:02:52.100Why do females who phenotypically present as youth appear in specific situations within anime where if they were presenting that way in live action within most Western countries,
00:03:11.980everyone would literally immediately be arrested.
00:04:40.600I personally wouldn't find this to be that interesting a question, but it may have interesting answers.
00:04:45.160What is going on with all the Eisekei anime?
00:04:47.200That's anime where people are transported to another world.
00:04:50.160Why is this a popular genre right now?
00:04:53.000All right, so let's go to the first question.
00:04:55.240You had an idea that sprung to you one day, and I think it may be accurate.
00:05:01.060Yeah, so we were watching an anime in which there's a dynamic like this.
00:05:04.880It's basically where like a salaryman wakes up in fantasy video game world and then, you know, ends up in one of these relationships.
00:05:14.660And I think most people make the least charitable interpretation of these types of relationships and why people are interested in them.
00:05:20.520Last night we were watching this anime called My Unique Skill Makes Me OP Even at Level 1, where this salaryman basically wakes up in a video game world and starts befriending people.
00:05:30.800And if we go further with the anime explanation, I want to explain what makes it such a unique anime from a watching it perspective.
00:05:38.720And it is so clearly just a desperate fantasy of what if life wasn't terrible in every single angle of the anime that it breaks down many ideas to much more simplistic tropes than they would normally be broken down into.
00:06:00.580It's not a particularly good anime or anything like that, or funny anime or anything like that, but it is notable in its simplicity and honesty with what it's trying to do.
00:06:15.340Right. So the main character immediately makes a friend and the friend he makes is phenotypically very...
00:06:25.580Phenotypically presents as a young human female.
00:06:28.560Yes. And you expect to make the least charitable interpretation of why viewers would be interested in this kind of relationship, which is precisely why you expect if this were all to be live action, that it would be highly illegal.
00:06:41.900However, the more we watched the show and we saw the dynamics of their relationship play out, the more I came to realize, one, this show is the fantasy of a beleaguered salaryman.
00:06:52.940I mean, careers in Japan are famously brutal.
00:06:56.640The hours you're expected to work, the unpaid overtime you're expected to work, the long nights drinking.
00:07:04.080And this is the fantasy of not being in that work culture and also being appreciated for your work and being really good at your work and getting things done all the time.
00:07:11.500It's sort of just this fantasy of everything but the Japanese work culture that still pervades the nation.
00:07:18.700And when you look at what's happening in his life, it's to me a picture of what people, what humans in Japan would like life to look like.
00:07:28.480And it's not this untoward type of relationship I think people would expect it to be.
00:07:34.240I think it's actually cosplaying as a parent, but that Japan lacks the cultural shorthand for a man wanting to be a parent.
00:07:43.520And so instead, it manifests as this perverse type of relationship or is kind of implied to be that perverse type of relationship when like really maybe the trope that is being played out in many of these animes with these phenotypically, what is it?
00:08:09.540Yes, maybe all the animes with these tropes are really more playing on the audience's desire to be a parent and to take care of young people and to raise people and experience the satisfaction of taking care of someone who loves you and appreciates you and admires you.
00:08:26.580And that reminded me a lot of an anime, I think it's called something like Lotte, L-O-T-T-E.
00:08:33.560Um, where, uh, one of these characters that you're talking about is a succubus, um, and...
00:08:40.980So you, you would also totally not, um, charitably interpret that because they're a succubus.
00:08:45.920Well, no, and it's clear that, that the relationship is, yes, while there are like, obviously it's a very questionable relationship, but it is very focused on fathering her.
00:08:57.900And there is actually sort of a sub-genre of, I'd call it father animes, where it's about a guy who either somehow gets attached to a young girl or takes on a fatherly role.
00:09:13.100But often these have, to me, slightly questionable things going on in them.
00:09:16.940Oh, like the anime in which the, the guy's hand becomes a little girl.
00:09:37.360So the, the series is called Midori Days, which follows Seji Samawura, who one day finds his right hand replaced with a girl named Midori Kasugano.
00:09:47.480So what I think is going on here, and so I'm going to say, I don't think that every show that has a character like this is doing this.
00:09:54.700I think that there is a broad differentiation.
00:09:57.520When it's a harem comedy, that, or, or just a harem show, I guess you could call it, where the conflict or plot is primarily around a large group of girls dating a guy.
00:10:07.180It appears that it is actually about, um, the bad thing.
00:10:58.460And here's another thing that I've noticed in the genre of shows where a dad has to be a good dad to a girl that, you know, it's always that the girl is thrust upon him.
00:11:10.840Almost never in any of the ones I can think of that he has her biologically.
00:11:26.200Although keep in mind, again, in Japanese culture, the parenting culture is also very toxic.
00:11:30.820And typically in the culture, the mother does all of the child rearing, just all of it.
00:11:35.100So also I think it's, you know, if a man wants to actually raise a kid, there is no existing cultural trope for that.
00:11:42.680Like they have to be foisted upon them in some strange situation because there would be no normal situation in which they would be involved in child rearing.
00:11:52.260And I think that, and also it can be like, there's certain things that people don't want to admit to themselves given their cultural norms.
00:11:59.780It might be that wanting to be a dad is actually a harder thing to admit to oneself.
00:12:07.060Like wanting to be a good father and failing at it, either because you were stuck at an office all day or because you were never able to find a partner.
00:12:15.820Or failing at that is harder to admit to oneself than failing to, you know, secure one of these bad relationships.
00:12:26.040Wanting to become a dad, if you screw up, if you don't do it right, it's, I think it's a much scarier thing even to aspire to, frankly, because of this is a human life.
00:12:35.460You can screw up pretty much anything else, a marriage, a career.
00:12:38.820And in the end, you're not that bad of a person, but if you screw up an entire additional human's life that you created, like.
00:12:53.980But I think it's right a number of times because I definitely see it.
00:12:57.800Like in the anime that we were talking about, the first one that we're watching right now, their relationship isn't really sexualized at all.
00:13:05.060Like sort of background is implied that they're like dating or something.
00:13:09.360Like he invites her to live in his house immediately.
00:13:13.680Again, I think what's going on is creators assume that they're doing the bad thing, but what they really want is the good thing.
00:13:20.120Because also consider how asexual Japan is.
00:13:22.880So it's both like really sexual and that there's prostitution and there's, you know, obviously like all this anime with fan service.
00:13:29.860Like it is obviously a very, it's a much more sexually free nation in some ways, but then also it's a very sexless nation.
00:13:37.040So I think that many people think, they just assume that some feeling they have is a sexual perversion instead of a like wholesome instinct.
00:13:45.240Again, I think that's what's going on here.
00:13:46.700But the anime's core thing that it is masturbating in an individual is just somebody appreciates me for the work I'm doing.
00:13:55.280And admires me and I can do good work.
00:14:17.460Well, it's so sad that that's the fantasy, that this is this impossible otherworldly fantasy.
00:14:25.320And, and this actually might bring us into why Izeke shows are popular more broadly.
00:14:29.940And I think that you can see that from this anime is, and it's, it's sort of spelled out explicitly in this anime that in our world, in the real world, he can work as much as he wants.
00:14:40.380He can end up, you know, falling asleep at his desk, doing overpaid work at his office every single night.
00:14:49.420He may, you know, there's, there's no assurances.
00:14:52.340It's, it's like you're grinding, like you would in a game, but there is no payoff and everything is systemically unfair.
00:15:00.400You know, you try to do the good thing.
00:15:02.240There's opportunities to do the good thing in an office, you know, take responsibility for something, for some other person not being punished.
00:15:08.100But you don't do it because realistically, you know, you're just going to end up getting punished for that.
00:15:13.020The other person really has no position to help you because you help them.
00:15:16.620It's just an unreciprocal society, and it's a society that doesn't care about you or value.
00:15:23.760When you get home, you've done all this work, and you have a family who is like, why are you home late?
00:15:29.100You know, and in video games, which is often where people go in easy case, video game worlds, they're worlds with rules.
00:16:06.660People feel their lives there are just much less meaningful.
00:16:11.720And so this sort of return and reward for work is deeply meaningful to them.
00:16:18.560But I think that there's other reasons why this form of anime has become popular.
00:16:23.100I think that the biggest is unfortunately a pretty boring one.
00:16:27.060So occasionally when there are shifts in media or how the USA receives anime, the animes that are popular within that exact cycle of anime become quote unquote classics, even if they're not particularly better than other anime or something like that.
00:16:43.300You're saying isekai animes, because of their genre, are just more likely to be globally popular?
00:16:52.260So in the U.S., if you're talking about really famous animes that became popular because of this, you could say, what were the first animes that were really translated and distributed in the U.S.?
00:17:03.400You are looking at Dragon Ball Z and you are looking at Sailor Moon.
00:19:11.300But anyway, so what was I going to say?
00:19:14.580I think I disagree in terms of what has made them so popular.
00:19:18.000I just think people hate the real world.
00:19:20.960You know, the same reason why in Japan you see all this isekai anime is for the same reason why you see all this escapist, zombie apocalypse stuff in the United States.
00:19:32.380But why not just do generic fantasy then?
00:19:35.380So in the U.S., when you're creating a fantasy world, you don't often have somebody from our world randomly put in.
00:19:46.660Whereas in Japan, escapism is like through digital means of video games.
00:19:51.380I just think it's like sort of the outlet that we go to, the de facto outlet.
00:19:56.300I would argue more Americans play video games and would identify themselves as gamers than preppers.
00:20:02.380I will say that you are right that an American genre that is much more popular here than in other countries due to our culture is the fantasy of the world falls apart and you are prepared and dealing with it.
00:20:27.040Japan produces more fantasy games, whereas like stuff like Fallout and first-person shooter games are more likely to come out from American game designers.
00:20:35.720So I think you're also, again, you're missing...
00:20:38.040Yeah, video games are big in America, but they're also survivalist, doomerism war, zombie apocalypse video games.
00:20:44.200Yeah, I was roughly thinking to what you were saying when you're talking about zombie apocalypse, where even the fantasy of a zombie apocalypse is often quite different in Japan than ZOM 100, right?
00:20:52.480That has much more of an izake fantasy.