00:00:00Hello, Simone! I'm excited to be here with you today. Today, we are going to be exploring when they put Jesus back on the cross.
00:00:09And what I mean by this is that in early Christian communities, it was taboo to depict Jesus on the cross.
00:00:17To understand how taboo it was, the earliest depiction we have of Jesus on the cross is of somebody mocking him with a donkey head.
00:00:27it was literally meant to make fun of christians the next depiction that we have which isn't until
00:00:34the right here's the donkey head it's this is um very great yeah he's saying like go worship your0.96
00:00:42donkey donkey god go worship your donkey god yeah that is that is the the precursor is you would0.97
00:00:47only do this if you were making fun of christians um this is because this is how they pwned their0.99
00:00:52religion they're like yeah you're well there's a number of reasons why you wouldn't do it one is
00:00:57it was a world where people were still being crucified so you know not exactly a great uh
00:01:03feel there feel good moment for a lot of people no but the other is like logical like it was meant
00:01:10to shame and humiliate him he was crucified naked right like that was the goal was maximum
00:01:16humiliation and that's what every public execution was about because you don't need to execute people
00:01:20publicly the only reason you do it is for extra humiliation but it gets worse than just it was
00:01:25used to make fun of christians the first people we know of who did it after this guy is from the
00:01:32second and fourth century and it was used for black magic um well all magic is black magic
00:01:37presumably did you read up on this amount i didn't pick up on black magic in my research explain this
00:01:43to me yeah so the next depictions of jesus on a cross that we have after the one that was meant
00:01:48to make fun of him and that one was around 200 ce are something called magical amulets and we
00:01:56don't know if it was a christian who did this it people argue it probably wasn't because if they
00:02:03were they were at least a very for the time heretical christian because other christians
00:02:07were very against using magic like this because we have we see the uh the a similar style of stuff
00:02:13of um carving called a bloodstone on a mottled green brown jasper um now in the british museum
00:02:21is generally dated to the second or third century ce and it depicted him nude uh and there are many
00:02:30others of these like these are not super rare but it's super so this magical use it includes it's
00:02:35not just the cross it includes depictions of jesus yes a nude humiliated jesus oh my goodness
00:02:42And what we think it probably was, was a non-Christian magician attempting to borrow power from Jesus using this depiction.0.73
00:02:56Yeah, that seems to be the case because when I went through the history, and I'm going to go through it from like sort of start to through the shift so you can see how it all goes.0.87
00:03:05and i have lots of picture examples the first depictions of jesus on the cross by devout
00:03:10christians actually showed him quite defiant they didn't show him suffering this is this is the uh
00:03:15the bloodstone that we have and you can see it has the bloodstone is the right word for those
00:03:19only listening it looks like a stone that has like blood burnt into it with all these creepy
00:03:24on it you know uh language that is common in these magical stones so to be clear here it mixes
00:03:33some biblical tied verses with some verses that appear to be like more gibberish magical words
00:03:41and in the background here i'm putting some depictions of other bloodstones we found
00:03:46dedicated to other gods generally they were just like you put a god on them and they were used in
00:03:51magic spells and it appears that somebody was aware of this jesus guy had a lot of magical power
00:03:56so let's use him because presumably a christian would not be using magic in this way from what we
00:04:02know of christian communities in those communities this would have been considered witchcraft
00:04:05i'm not good you're not like yeah that that looks like like a prop from a horror movie
00:04:10it absolutely does look like a prop from a horror movie yeah so how did something that was only used
00:04:15for black magic and to make fun of christians get reappropriated and uh gentrified by the
00:04:22christian community well i have answers i have answers yeah go for it and this i mean this all
00:04:26comes from my deep inherent discomfort with even walking in especially to like catholic churches or
00:04:33any church that depicted jesus on a cross and even my discomfort with cross imagery like whenever i
00:04:39see a cross around someone's neck i'm like why are we reliving the low point in this amazing
00:04:46you know life i it's just it's it's horrific to me and just here's i asked grok to like just give
00:04:53me give me a picture of uh depictions of jesus on the cross i haven't actually seen the full thing
00:04:59but let's see what grok gives us in terms of like okay here what is considered representative
00:05:04okay a short history the the rabula gospels here we have simabu he looks very sad
00:05:13uh okay gioto they're putting they're making the cross pretty and then we have
00:05:18mantanega all these these are horrible these these look like torture scenes and yet they're
00:05:24they're like high art a lot of christians really like reveling in the suffering of jesus
00:05:30which we saw from the movie the passion um the passion was designed as a movie to be as gruesome
00:05:37as possible uh depiction have you seen it i can't bring myself to watch it yeah i watched it when
00:05:43came out um and i i think that for some christians in the same way that you view it as sort of like
00:05:51a a low point they see it as a high point because it's the climax of the jesus story
00:05:58and the moment in which he suffers for humanity's sins um okay where i mean i understand that he did
00:06:06that but like it's like sad that it happened right like better if we didn't sin right you know but i
00:06:15i uh i understand like in a traditional narrative and i note here that a number of other christian
00:06:21groups also do not depict the cross um the two really big ones are jehovah's witnesses and
00:06:28mormons good on them yeah that's true they just show but they show a different version of jesus
00:06:34that is also inaccurate, which we're going to get to too. Mormons, however, don't have a prohibition
00:06:39against the cross. Most Protestants do not show Jesus on the cross. There's a few Protestant
00:06:45denominations that do, but on average, most Protestants don't because the idea is he's not
00:06:51here anymore. You're depicting the wrong part of the narrative. The point is he's not on the cross
00:06:57anymore, which I would agree with, but I agree with you as well, Simone, that I wouldn't make
00:07:03like a hard rule against it in techno puritanism do not think it well so here's the problem it can
00:07:10look really cool like the crusaders cross the red cross on like white armor looks really cool like
00:07:18i would love like space troopers was like cross armor and stuff like that however however i think
00:07:24the the pragmatist logo works just as well and you can say that it's a hollowed out cross overlaid
00:07:30with a oh for goodness we just let's just drop the cross i do i get big shout out to the church
00:07:36of latter-day saints for even when you look at their logo like most church logos have some kind
00:07:40of cross in them and when you look at the modern logo of the church of jesus christ of latter-day
00:07:46saints it is just the classic mormon jesus with the long hair and the beard in robes like with
00:07:50his arms kind of outstretched in a very sort of welcoming way and i like that that's a positive
00:07:54depiction but so the earliest that we've seen in the artistic record that is to say depictions of
00:08:00jesus uh are of him one no beard short hair healing people uh which is what he almost
00:08:08certainly looked like yes the oldest surviving christian art comes from the late second to early
00:08:13fourth centuries so obviously this is well after simone are you sure this is him he's not black in
00:08:19it welcome oh my god how are we gonna get through this you can see these where these early pieces0.57
00:08:24come up is they're on the walls of tombs in Roman catacombs and in the house church of Dura
00:08:30Europos in Syria. And this is circa 230 to 256. So look, he has been gone for over 200 years.
00:08:39No one now knows what he, there was no like likeness that was described from person to person
00:08:43to person to person that actually made it down accurately at this point. But this is showing him
00:08:49healing a paralytic um other other frescoes will show him walking on water and then there's the
00:08:55dura europis finger let me get that up by the way one thing i will say within techno puritanism that
00:09:00is deeply we'll just say like deeply banned and sinful is the narcissism and and honestly i think0.59
00:09:08psychopathy of race swapping jesus to your race i i am very against both black and overly caucasian0.50
00:09:18jesus so do you feel the same way about like black santa santa's not allowed to change santa
00:09:24santa can change because the depiction that everyone uses of santa has changed so much
00:09:29since the original and he's not a meaningful historic figure in my oh i could yeah so you're
00:09:34saying like because this is moored in actual history this is something that like you're you're
00:09:40presumably with santa it's more like a fun thing you do for kids i don't really ascribe a lot of
00:09:44religious significance to the santa myth okay um i think it's an important part of children
00:09:50jesus presumably you believe he was an actual jewish guy yeah who lived during this period
00:09:56and in terms of an actual jewish guy the oldest known portrait of jesus because also to be clear
00:10:03and i'm going to get into it in a little bit most of the early christian art that you see that's
00:10:07like associated with christianity is symbolic all right it's it's not actually supposed to be like
00:10:11of Jesus is sort of like of acts and you know like other symbols and actually I find that that
00:10:17is the most I would say religiously devout way to artistically render affiliation with Jesus
00:10:25because you don't want to engage in idolatry you don't want to accidentally start worshiping an
00:10:30idol and when you start to depict people you get you start moving in that direction right like
00:10:36before long you've got like a golden statue of Jesus that you're bowing down to or I don't know
00:10:39maybe a statue on a cross that you're like praying in front of which simone we're not
00:10:45gonna get in we're not gonna get in but anyways this is this but i do want to say here that0.61
00:10:51in in this chain of like the disgustingness of like black jesus when you you can know from a0.76
00:10:59fact from the story judas wouldn't have had to kiss him if he was the only black guy in the0.98
00:11:03crowd he could have just been like he's the black guy but if they were all black guys i don't know0.93
00:11:06I look I don't care no we that would be very strange in an ancient Jewish oh all the Jews1.00
00:11:13I forgot right uh so easy but the point here being is I think it's just as bad as Mormon Jesus0.78
00:11:20uh like they depict him as aggressively Caucasian and I'm like that he is not Caucasian buddy like0.57
00:11:27come on no again look at this well I don't know this guy could look plausibly Caucasian as we0.56
00:11:31talked about before like they use the beard which is a Zeus we talked about this in the last episode
00:11:35but really quickly jesus definitely didn't have a beard actually we are probably wrong about that
00:11:42so uh joan taylor's research uh she she's a historian concludes based on the evidence that
00:11:47she could get as a historian that he was about 5'5 with olive brown spin skin and that he most
00:11:53likely kept his hair short but were some kind of short like the jewish philosophers of his era
00:11:58oh yeah short beard fine i'm talking about the long beard the first image that i showed you was
00:12:04more a reflection of early greco-roman styles whereas he probably had a short beard like in
00:12:11this portrait okay so i want to be clear on that this this man clearly has a little although let
00:12:16me but he didn't have a long as i know no only the nazarenes did that in jewish society and if
00:12:23you did it and you weren't a nazarene people would think that you were trying to pretend to be a0.80
00:12:27nazarene and that's the type of thing that would have come up in his trial because they would have
00:12:31said why are you going around pretending to be a nazarene and drinking alcohol drinking alcohol0.57
00:12:36and touching dead things right like you can't do that right like you yeah this is how we also know
00:12:40he definitely did keep the sabbath not just because it says in the bible that that was his
00:12:44habit but because it would have been a major part of his trial when they were trying to find a reason
00:12:49to punish him yeah because remember in the bible like the old testament uh breaking the sabbath
00:12:54is a stonable offense well and in fact i think one person argued one person who listens to this
00:12:59podcast argued to us that like the the mere fact that he does basically troll other jews so much
00:13:05with the way he kept the sabbath as a way to basically try to engage in sabbath reform you
00:13:10know man was like healing people on the sabbath yeah yeah so he was he he very conspicuously
00:13:15engaged in what he thought was the optimal sabbath to try to question the way that sort of
00:13:20bureaucratic creep had ruined the sabbath meaning which i actually think the sabbath is like the
00:13:26key point before we get further in this of the entire jesus story and what you're supposed to
00:13:30take away from the new testament um is the like the line i think that encapsulates the the purpose
00:13:37of jesus in reforming judaism is the sabbath was made for man not man for the sabbath yeah because
00:13:45that line captures the point is basically reframes our entire relationship with god it is god gives
00:13:53us rules for our benefit this produces human flourishing this isn't this ain't gonna ruin you
00:13:59it doesn't have to if it feels bad you're probably doing it wrong essentially all of it all of the
00:14:06the core sins that are discussed in the bible are there because they are bad things to do they are
00:14:15sins against yourself they are things that make your own life worse and they are god just giving
00:14:19you advice like here's the list okay you know don't spend a lot of time thirsting after what
00:14:23other people have on instagram be nice to your parents they're not going to be here forever
00:14:27you know like don't basic stuff stuff that is just strictly beneficial to you as a human being
00:14:35and christianity i think when understood in the way that i understand it is the understanding
00:14:41that all of these rules that can seem arbitrary or like you're following some agreement for god
00:14:48to make God happy, misunderstands everything. No, these were just advice to help you in your
00:14:54own life. Like when somebody comes to us and they go, oh, do you think you need to follow the
00:14:57Sabbath to be right by God? I'm like, no, I think God at one point came down and was like, hey,
00:15:01you should probably like make a concerted point to take one day off a week. And some people were
00:15:06like, no, F you. I don't like all your extra rules. And it's like, okay, sure. That's not
00:15:13the key point in all of this but i just was trying to help you out here people this is why when when
00:15:21a lot of christians are like and that's why we don't need to follow any of the ten commandments
00:15:24it's like what if the ten commands was so bad yeah how is it so so hard to not kill people
00:15:30um to not covet things anyway i want to be clear though the the most common depiction of jesus
00:15:35is of the good shepherd so check him out oh look at that he's wearing a ram on his
00:15:40right so this is the most common early depiction of jesus as the good shepherd although he's a
00:15:46really good shepherd because he's wearing a whole ram on his on his shoulders it's just perching
00:15:50there i think it's really cute actually kind of like a pirate uh he's got the the ram but this
00:15:57this is uh a beardless short-haired youth carrying a a sheep this is borrowed directly from classical
00:16:05cryophoros that is to say ram bearer figure and probably not meant as a portrait of the historical
00:16:12jesus at all like it's more symbolic well yeah because that that would have been seen as you
00:16:17know less idolatrous yeah idolatry by the early church because we are talking about i'm talking
00:16:23about you don't have to talk about i'm going to talk about that because i think it's idolatrous
00:16:26what we're doing anyway um no but not me not me do you see me wearing crosses anyway i just want
00:16:32to be clear. Other early types of art depicting Jesus or referring to him, refer to him visually
00:16:41as a miracle worker, sometimes holding a wand, or as a philosopher teacher in a toga holding a scroll.
00:16:49And in the earliest images, he's often a stocky, short-haired, beardless figure in a short tunic
00:16:54who can only be identified by context. So there might be a lot of false positives in people being
00:17:00like I think this is early art of Jesus because he's not on a cross and maybe that's actually one
00:17:04of the reasons why and this is my speculation here historians are not guessing this why Jesus
00:17:09on the cross became such a popular piece of art or maybe even why people started recognizing that
00:17:14and then assuming it was like the only way to depict him because like because you would know
00:17:18it was definitely otherwise he's just your everyday guy like he because he was one of the people you
00:17:23know he didn't dress in a fancy way he wasn't trying to put on airs and that can make it hard
00:17:27to visually distinguish someone who's god right like that's kind of tough you know because you
00:17:32want to make them aside from like drawing a halo i guess which you could try to do did i wonder when
00:17:37they started drawing a halo on him i'm gonna ask yeah you can ask while i while i move forward
00:17:41right um so the the crucifixion is totally absent from roman catacombs and sarcophagi and the
00:17:48earliest surviving image of the the as you say the crucifixion is actually hostile it's the
00:17:53alexa menos graffito scratched in rome around the year 200 mocking a christian by showing a donkey
00:17:59headed figure on a cross with a little inscription basically amounting to alexa alexa menos worships
00:18:05his god or worships god um so they're basically like go worship your donkey god alexa menos
00:18:11alexa menos alexa menos um so the first christian made depictions and not your weird
00:18:18scary witch stuff that you showed earlier on the bloodstone appear only in the early fifth century
00:18:26with the mascal ivory panel which is currently visible in the british museum we probably walked
00:18:32by it and like didn't think anything of it it looks like this and here you see actually jesus
00:18:37doesn't look like he's suffering in this ivory panel what you're seeing is four men carved into
00:18:41ivory one looks like he's really okay maybe he's hanging from a tree i don't know one looks like
00:18:47hanging from a tree yes that's judas iscariot and below him you can see a bag of coins that he
00:18:53dropped and then you know jesus is he he isn't looking necessarily like he's suffering he's sort
00:18:58of looking up and outward a little bit stoically and then there are sort of people around him
00:19:01looking like they're i'm not sure really it's not very clear you know it's not the best art in the
00:19:08world but they were doing what they could with what they had okay and this was made around the
00:19:13the year 420 to 430 that is way after of course christianity was was was swinging off so just
00:19:20want to be clear about that that's one of the earliest depictions of by you know a devout
00:19:25christian of the the oh the crucifixion what halos yeah you know what they were originally
00:19:31used for oh as a symbol for pagan gods okay no halos no no no no no no so the circle arrayed
00:19:40halos existed in holistic roman and eastern art for uh gods especially the helios or soul
00:19:46and emperors also use them oh my gosh can all the halos in art no no you don't see it on jesus
00:19:54until the fourth century wow okay well so just around the time when the cross and so here's
00:19:58another one of the first times that jesus was depicted on a cross this comes from a very
00:20:03very large like we're talking like two-story carved door it's called the santa sabina in rome
00:20:12it was made circa 432 and this is the earliest public crucifixion image and so do you have any
00:20:19guesses as to why people started depicting jesus on a cross um well i want to note something first
00:20:27before we go further with this it is interesting to me how the stuff within pop culture that people
00:20:34see as fake and pagan is actually not and the stuff in popular culture that people think of
00:20:40as trad christianity is actually fake and pagan examples here which we have episodes on if you
00:20:46want to go watch the uh the idea that christmas comes from a pagan holiday people get so mad
00:20:52with this you've got to you got to watch our episode on that people got so mad at that episode
00:20:57but yes they did just like the evidence was overwhelming um that it did not come downstream
00:21:01they'll say it came from the soul holiday but like the soul holiday which happened on the same day
00:21:05our first depictions of that aren't until after our first depictions of christianity coming to
00:21:09exist people just assume because it was a pagan holiday it came before christianity but we
00:21:13actually don't see it until after christianity and it was first talked about by christian
00:21:17communities who would have known the importance of that date and then before that uh people will
00:21:22try to convict it was like saturnalia but saturnalia was on a completely different set of
00:21:25days it was just like the same month but like the holidays weren't very similar um as you'll see if
00:21:30you go into our episode on that they does it does not appear that like one came for the other
00:21:34that the the eastern people also think of as pagan and i think we have an episode on that uh and if
00:21:40we don't we should make an episode on that so so you've got those things that are not pagan that
00:21:44everyone assumes are pagan and then you've got things uh note it's not that things like eastern
00:21:49don't draw from common non well non-biblical folk traditions but they are folk traditions
00:21:56that arose in an already christian community okay and don't have traceable pagan roots to
00:22:01like basically they're it's such a late phenomenon that there's just no way it came from anything
00:22:07pagan like the easter bunny and stuff like that but there just wasn't paganism still being
00:22:11practiced in these communities to the extent where people would still understand it from
00:22:14win these phenomenon march but to put it another way suppose a christian holiday evolved around
00:22:20the veggie tales cartoon now that's not exactly a biblical thing but it's also not a pagan thing
00:22:26and you could look and say look at this vegetable holiday there was this pagan vegetable holiday
00:22:32all the way back like 4 000 years before but it's like yeah but the origin of this came from
00:22:38a christian children's cartoon and they're like well what makes it christian and i'm like well
00:22:42was meant to teach christian themes in a christian community maybe that's a little strong maybe it's
00:22:48like if you're gonna push it even further bluey okay like bluey isn't pagan okay it's just0.77
00:22:54non-christian in a christian dominated community but the things that are faking gay the things that
00:23:00are actually anti-christian or non-christian are things like the halo things like jesus on a cross
00:23:08things like well that that does have a biblical origin but for a long time it was considered like
00:23:12black magic right yeah or things like uh the beard jesus was a beard that was a sign of long beard
00:23:20yeah they used to depict a roman and greek gods was that and so people started depicting jesus
00:23:24was that to be like look he looks like a god yeah like i'm trying to make him look how do i make him
00:23:29look 18 more authoritative i know i'll make that guy zeus he looks real author every statue you see
00:23:36is of like the gods and they look super beardy so now we've got a crucified zeus jesus would be
00:23:43incredibly confused if you showed him a picture of a guy crucified with a big beard and a halo
00:23:53he's like why is that green god yeah it seems well yeah especially old testament god very like
00:24:02clear about i'm really not cool with you guys worshiping other like i don't this this one
00:24:06idol worship bad two i don't like your other gods and now i'm going to actually argue that
00:24:12the reason why cross worship and cross in art like jesus on the cross became popular
00:24:17is functionally idol worship all right oh tell me yeah so scholars think that art of jesus on
00:24:27the cross became popular because of this sort of legendary discovery of the true cross, the cross
00:24:36on which Jesus was crucified, and cavalry, a.k.a. basically the place where Jesus was crucified,
00:24:44becoming a pilgrimage site. To explain this a bit more tightly, essentially what happened
00:24:49is when you had the creation of the first major pilgrimage site, almost like a religious Disneyland
00:24:56is what it was for its time period is people would go there and then they wanted a souvenir
00:25:02to bring back and the souvenir options of like an anchor or a dove figurine or a fish figurine
00:25:09were just one not very evocative and two not very tied to that specific site and so what they began
00:25:16to use instead was either individual crosses or um what are called pilgrimage flasks which were
00:25:27small bottles that we've even found like stamps and like things to see how they were mass produced
00:25:31in the region to be more specific they were cheap mass-produced souvenirs often flask or round
00:25:38flask shaped with a short neck and sometimes a loop so that they could be worn around the neck
00:25:43Many were decorated or stepped with molded scenes.
00:25:46The crucifix or an empty jeweled cross being adorned was a very common one.
00:25:51However, there were other ones that were tied to the specific regions.
00:25:55These range from specific shrines or temples that were at Jerusalem during the period
00:26:00to more general stuff with a regional connection like the empty tomb or the magi.
00:26:07It's essentially like, you know, you go to Disneyland and you can get the Mickey Mouse,
00:26:11which would be the cross or you can get any of the various rides depicted on it um it just
00:26:17wouldn't make sense to depict a universal sign of christianity like the fish or the anchor or
00:26:22something like that now obviously this later became a universal sign of christianity but
00:26:26i'm talking about during the period and i see pilgrimages to go see relics as classic idolatry
00:26:34let's go find the object and worship it what can we go back like but this is i have no but they'll
00:26:42say they'll say i'm not worshiping it i just using it's helping me get closer to no no guys no no no
00:26:49stop but i have to look remember like during this period people didn't have access like there was
00:26:55very little reading there wasn't a printing press they didn't have access to the bible they didn't
00:26:59know at the time that old testament god was like very clear about this because no one was i think
00:27:05i i'm gonna attribute it to ignorance now however we know better and shame on anyone who engages in
00:27:12this now anyway so hold on simone you've got to listen they'll say it doesn't count because
00:27:18i called it something else no it's like it's not murder because i called it a spray bottle
00:27:23i do love this that you just rename them as icons and and again it's the idea that it's about oh
00:27:33this object helps me get closer to the thing okay that's clearly what you're not allowed to do it's
00:27:39not just a banning of other gods or icons of other gods otherwise it would have been covered by the
00:27:44first commandment the reason you have the clarifying second commandment that many denominations of
00:27:50christianity actually rope into the first commandment to make it not so loud is because
00:27:54it's saying and not this as well given that we just established no other god so when i talk about
00:28:01icons i'm clearly not talking or when i talk about idols i'm clearly not talking about gods i'm
00:28:05talking about idols of even me but again this is because we're protestant max so as in we actually
00:28:13believe in reading the bible we believe in following the actual rules instead of what a
00:28:18bureaucracy made up over hundreds of years but let's so do you know about emperor constantine's
00:28:24mummy no tell me about it she was a famous travel influencer all right she like super made0.99
00:28:32religious pilgrimages the hot thing to do she was the og instagram travel influencer before it was0.84
00:28:41you know we knew it was you know instagram almost or whatever they had back then you know when they0.69
00:28:45were carving their stupid graffiti on stuff so um she like per per the legend helena mother of0.89
00:28:54emperor constantine traveled to jerusalem around the year 326 to 328 and then legendarily prompted0.97
00:29:02by a dream or divine sign she had a temple of venus or aphrodite built over golgotha golgotha
00:29:13if you're wondering not Golgotha as I had originally thought the Calvary by Hadrian
00:29:19torn down so she tore it down and then excavations beneath it uncovered three crosses plus the
00:29:27titulus the the plaque reading Jesus of Nazareth king of the Jews the true cross was identified
00:29:33when a dying woman who touched it was miraculously healed so somehow she's she's gone on vacation to
00:29:41jerusalem takes a pilgrimage tears down a temple built by hadrian and they find some morsels of
00:29:49of lumber as uh as was stated in um jesus shaves by david sedaris and a woman touches a morsel of
00:29:57lumber and is is cured uh miraculously and so they decide that that means that this is definitely
00:30:04that plus the sign um is definitely the true cross okay and what historians actually say is
00:30:09that cross relics were being venerated in Jerusalem by the 340s already. Bishop Cyril of
00:30:15Jerusalem. By the way, I'm going to note, because I'm asking AI this, I don't think Romans just like0.91
00:30:19left the crosses to rot on the hill next to a major city. Oh, you'd think they'd recycled them.
00:30:25I'm pretty sure they were like reused for other stuff. Exactly, exactly. Oh no, I would just
00:30:29recycle the morsels of lumber. But anyway, so Bishop Cyril of Jerusalem mentions them, that is
00:30:35to say the morsels of lumber in sermons from 351, but he never credits Helena with finding them.
00:30:42So I think they just start turning up because this is kind of the, it's chic at the time. Okay.
00:30:48And then the attribution to Helena first appears decades after she died in Ambrose's funeral
00:30:53oration for Theodysius in 395 and Galassius of Caesarean, whatever church history around 390.
00:31:02so most scholars accept that helena was not actually responsible for the discovery of
00:31:06these morsels of lumber and that the relics actually surfaced during constantine's church
00:31:11building on the site so where did the wood go when these alleged pieces of the cross
00:31:18were discovered by someone i don't know during by the way for people who are wondering because
00:31:23i i did need to do a sanity check on this yeah there is no way this was the original cross
00:31:28so for an understanding of how uh the crucifixions were done um they they would take you off with the
00:31:35the horizontal beam um and they would reuse that horizontal beam for other crucifixions sure because
00:31:41i mean it's you know you have to like work hard to well also what was valuable during yeah right
00:31:46like you didn't just especially in a developed area yeah you have to like save trees and stuff
00:31:50you can't just go on so you wouldn't have had just three crucifixes happen to be there you'd
00:31:56have a field of standing beams um that would have been the way they they stayed normally so if they
00:32:03just rotted over time it would look like a standing beam the horizontal beam was taken off when the
00:32:07person was taken off which makes a lot of sense to me because remember jesus had to carry his beam
00:32:11right um the the whole thing he wasn't i i think what this implies is he wasn't carrying a full
00:32:16cross he was carrying the horizontal which also makes sense his mounting beam we could call it
00:32:21how silly would it be for them to put the whole cross back in the ground well and this is i mean
00:32:28it's the same with the ark too like the ark has been stolen so many times or like it's it's been
00:32:33sort of lost and whatnot like it is certainly you're missing the point i'm making here i'm
00:32:37just saying how logistically insane it would be sure jesus to carry and it because that would
00:32:43have to plant the cross like the bottom of the cross into the ground um which which would be a
00:32:50ton of work when you could just do that once and have a standing execution site for sure yeah and
00:32:56no absolutely i i agree i mean and it's not so theoretically the lumber could have stayed around
00:33:02like there is uh almost 300 year old lumber in our house right like i'm trying to get mole off
00:33:08of right now i'm kind of worried about it we're gonna get on that but like it it is like the wood
00:33:12could survive but that it would be there that there would be a placard like what i really think
00:33:18is people are they're seeing they see an industry there's a market opportunity and it's just so
00:33:23tempting to be like this was from the cross like let's uh i will sell it to you for a small fee
00:33:29um and i think that just kind of started happening but then so it basically oh sorry where i went i
00:33:36just want to be clear about where these these pieces of wood still ended up okay at least where
00:33:41people say they ended up so they they say that some of this alleged original lumber stayed in
00:33:48jerusalem and it was enshrined in a silver case in the church of the holy sepulchre that constantine
00:33:53built over the site and part of it went to constantine himself along with the nails the
00:33:58alleged nails because apparently they kept the nails separately i imagine they would reuse the
00:34:03nails too we also know like because we also have very old handmade nails in our house and they're
00:34:08extremely precious no one would like i think they would leave the nails there yeah nails were worth
00:34:15quite a lot you can see i wish i had one sitting around like they're um they're really impressive
00:34:20like handmade nails um and i don't i don't think they would have found them but anyways the alleged
00:34:25nails uh went to rome um and uh helena reportedly brought fragments back to rome as well along with
00:34:33the nails and they were placed in her palace chapel which is now the basilica of santa croce
00:34:37coche jerusalem where they can still be seen as relics um and then even though this started
00:34:45happening and it became chic to go on pilgrimages to see the relics and engage in idolatry because
00:34:51you i'm gonna say because you didn't know better but um the point here being uh one of the things
00:34:55i wanted to check is if the bible gets any of this incorrect with common roman practices
00:34:59yeah um and and no while modern translations say that he he was bearing his own cross the the actual
00:35:06word here could easily mean he was just carrying the horizontal beam the mounting the mountain yeah
00:35:12and and there's no depiction of them like hammering it in or something like that yeah um so uh yeah
00:35:19this all aligns uh exactly but wait so like long story short though cross depictions became chic
00:35:26when what i'm going to argue is a mixture of chic tourism and influencing plus idol worship plus
00:35:35rampant fraud of selling of relics that were all fake which you you showed to be quite plausible
00:35:41started to make people basically want to be like oh like commemorative like i saw the cross and all0.68
00:35:48i got was this stupid cross art um you know like they they wanted to show off uh or they they had0.82
00:35:54seen the a relic the morsel of lumber and despite this fact that that you know you start to see this0.98
00:36:01art emerged at this time because of basically a tourism and fraud fad the subject still stayed
00:36:07pretty uncommon until the sixth century so like 200 years ish later when then finally it spread
00:36:15surprise surprise via pilgrim flasks from the holy land so like literally souvenir tchotchkes
00:36:23from the fraud business industry okay that that is really not good i love that it goes from0.99
00:36:32mockery to black magic to fraud to yeah literally like your stupid i went to cancun shirt uh the0.98
00:36:40the mystery spot bumper sticker that is what this is i'm i'm i'm so angry but also some byzantine0.96
00:36:46art um and and it did not truly multiply in the west until the carol engine era in the ninth
00:36:52century so like it took forever but the earliest populations of it were this this tourism scam
00:37:01fraud fraud thing and it's oh my gosh it just it's so sane but anyway this early art nevertheless
00:37:07shows a living triumphant christ with his eyes open um the dead suffering christ only replaced
00:37:14it around the mid 11th century so it wasn't until even later that we get into this like
00:37:19oh well let's make him suffer i'd love to see him not happy you know i'd love it's so messed up if
00:37:28you actually love jesus um i'm super not cool with it anyway though like you were saying you
00:37:33personally think the cross looks pretty badass right yes i think the crusader cross looks pretty
00:37:40badass yeah you're like oh and you know you were super not alone in this okay um so first off the
00:37:45cross as a sign is definitely older than crucifixion crucifixion imagery because obviously it's one of
00:37:51the simplest things you could possibly do with shapes okay yeah you know it was invented around
00:37:57this time for a crucifixion thing the t-shape was used as a seal by the second century and the
00:38:03storogram which is overlapping tau and rho letters from i think the greek alphabet right appears
00:38:09inside the new testament papyri like p66 around 200 which makes it christianity's early visual
00:38:16reference to the crucifixions because i never seen i guess i had seen this diagram have you
00:38:20seen this before so it looks like a p plus a t a capital p plus a t it's not this ain't rocket
00:38:27science no dear what i find fascinating is it turns out that this symbol was actually used
00:38:31before christians were around as like a monetary sign on coins think of it almost like the dollar
00:38:36sign derivative of the s that's the earliest uh depiction yeah and this this would show up in
00:38:44papyri new testament papyri like p66 and but that was still around the year 200 okay so still
00:38:50the dominant pre-constantinian symbols were the fish the anchor and the dove and they were used
00:38:57very discreetly by a persecuted minority one of the very important thing about like the fish sign
00:39:03and the dove and all that is that it was very difficult these early signs to turn into an icon
00:39:09that you attempted to worship as an intermediary for god in the same way that later symbols were
00:39:14very easy to do that with so keep in mind also right we aren't going to be super like flashy
00:39:20with like well early christians loved getting martyred okay the martyrs were flashy but
00:39:27everyone else was like i'm just gonna draw a dove by the way i don't mean that as a joke i mean that
00:39:34actually there was like a crisis when they took over power in rome and they stopped martyring
00:39:39christians because they didn't know what to do to suffer enough um because they became this i mean
00:39:45jesus was martyred right so like people were like martyrdom is awesome yeah and that's how the
00:39:50monastic movement started is people were like well what else can i go out and live in the desert and
00:39:54try to make my life harder and that can be kind of like martyrdom um and we have an episode where
00:40:00we talk about how martyrdom became so popular but like basically the romans really up how they
00:40:05martyred people they would like we have one account of it and when i say they have how they
00:40:10martyred people they'd be taking a guy to the coliseum and they'd have like two giant guards
00:40:15with him but they'd let him go on like a tour so like say you're arrested somewhere outside
00:40:20rome for being a christian and well what would happen is that you would be taken to rome for
00:40:26your for your coliseum based killing where the lions would eat you or whatever but then on your
00:40:32way as you were escorted back uh for your for your uh execution the the they would let you stop and
00:40:37give sort of talks and i think maybe the the roman guards or the law enforcement were like yeah this
00:40:44will be a scared straight kind of program right but then the christians thought is like my departure
00:40:49tour you know like they're going on tour no and they would get huge crowds of people like and of
00:40:54course like everyone wants to turn out to see the guy who's about to get killed right like he's gonna
00:40:57be eaten by lions let's see what he has to say like oh he must really believe this stuff he's
00:41:01really and then he's surrounded by these two figures that show him authority like these two0.94
00:41:05i know he's flanked by his what do they call them what do the red pillers call them your wingman
00:41:09your yeah yeah it's very red pill dynamic yeah he was he was so hot i'm sure i'm sure they they uh0.74
00:41:15I guess like they couldn't have done anything dumber to, to, if you understood like the message0.71
00:41:21of Christianity, right? Like it also really works with the message of Christianity.
00:41:25Yeah. Yeah. Um, you know, uh, and that was, that was in, uh, you know, early Christians
00:41:31thought, keep in mind life really sucked in Roman society. It did. Like getting to be famous0.81
00:41:37and go out and then like immediate automatic heaven because martyrdom is what they believed
00:41:42back then yeah yeah yeah so that was a thing right so they had to be very but but the ones
00:41:47who weren't because look not everyone wants to be eaten by lions or whatever and so many people
00:41:52were subtle about it and so they used the imagery most commonly again of the um the the anchor the
00:42:01fish or the dove all right and those are those are extremely that's not idolatrous that's not
00:42:06reading idolatrous to me that is not reading i wish we could bring that back fish anchored up i
00:42:11I mean, actually, remember how people used to put those fish magnets on their cars?
00:42:15The fish is really common among Protestants.
00:42:33Because I remember seeing those all the time in the San Francisco Bay Area as a kid, which is saying a lot, because that is a godless place.
00:42:40So, wow, that's that's impressive. Anyway, so the turning point, visually speaking, here was Constantine because he made it OK, as you're saying to, you know, it was legal to be Christian suddenly.
00:42:53And people had the crisis of martyrdom, but they also had this, I guess, renaissance of visual signaling freedom.
00:43:02OK, but basically after Constantine had this vision before the battle of Milvian Bridge in 312,
00:43:10he adopted the Chiro monogram on his army's shields and standards as his public endorsement.
00:43:17and this changed the cross's connotation from a slave's execution device to a revered emblem.
00:43:24Okay, Simone is a little misleading or confused in the way she describes things here and it's
00:43:28easy to understand why. Remember how earlier we were talking about the chiro symbol and it looked
00:43:32a lot like a modern cross and you could be like, oh yes, this came or was a progenitor of the idea
00:43:37of the modern cross? The chiro that Constantine used looked nothing like that. I have an image
00:43:43on screen here it looks more like an x with a p through it you might be able to get a saint
00:43:48andrew's cross from it but like obviously that is not what this was connected to what this actually
00:43:53is or a better way to understand it is similar to a logo that simone and i use that has our
00:44:00initials superimposed on top of each other in an artistic fashion which i have next to it here
00:44:06it was the chai which comes from the k of christos and the ro which comes from the
00:44:12of christos it's more like superimposed initials of the key sounds of the name christ in a way to
00:44:20represent him without using a cross like it's very explicitly avoiding using a cross
00:44:25so let me show you by the way just as long as we're debunking rumors here uh the idea that
00:44:32the fish um was a secret sign of christianity where one person would do one part of the fish
00:44:38and then if they were a christian they would complete the fish that has no historic uh evidence
00:44:43to it that was an idea that was popular in the 19th or 20th centuries that it was a discreet
00:44:49sign of early christianity is absolutely true we see it as early as like the third and the
00:44:52second century um but that it was like this secret ritual or something like that no okay
00:44:58so this is a misorium uh do you know what a misorium is i'd not i'd not heard of one before
00:45:06What we are looking at here is a large, heavily decorated ceremonial silver plate that would be given by a late Roman or Byzantine emperor to a high-ranking civil or military official to mark an important anniversary.
00:45:18But the important thing about this particular misorium is that it depicts Emperor Constantine the Great's son, Constantinius II, accompanied by a guardsman with the chiro depicted on his shield.
00:45:30um so to your point about you can see it it's over here it's uh to the to the left yeah you
00:45:36see the little the like p right there yeah he thinks it's badass like you do and you want to
00:45:42go into battle with that thing on your shield and he made it cool okay well concertine famously put
00:45:47something i forgot what sign it was on his shields and won the battle right yeah that's what that is
00:45:53what i'm talking about that's oh that's what he put on the shield okay yeah because he had this
00:45:56vision before a battle and so he he sort of rebranded the cross from we use this to shame
00:46:04people and execute them and do terrible things to them to like this is a point of pride this
00:46:08is an affiliation with something that it was almost like a what do they call that where you0.86
00:46:15take something where they like they call you a bad name and then you you own the name you
00:46:18appropriate it you yeah i don't know appropriation like with the n-word and the f-word where they're
00:46:23like well i'm going to use it now because reappropriation i think okay he reappropriated
00:46:28the cross um on behalf of christians even though he was a roman and i don't know he didn't he didn't
00:46:34um but christianize like quickly after this either he he converted a fit like the baptism
00:46:40when we so it was often that uh if you were an emperor back then or like a powerful christian
00:46:46you would get baptized later so it doesn't necessarily mean he wasn't fully christian
00:46:53during this part of his life uh the reason they would get baptized later is they thought baptism
00:46:57wiped away your sins and so you want to get it like you accumulate more sins yeah you want to
00:47:03take the shower right before you go but when he forced the council of nicene uh or nicium um that
00:47:11he was still unbaptized right like he was still uh and you know is it sort of forcing the wording
00:47:16on that uh and then excommunicating the people but i think literally banishing them the ones who
00:47:22wouldn't agree with him uh i think shows like the degree of um i mean he really shaped christianity
00:47:28during that period and i think in a way obviously he helped christianity spread which was fantastic
00:47:32but i think he's sort of the root of the institutional rot was in christianity and the
00:47:37idea that like um because he he sort of bureaucratized it right like he used it as his
00:47:43shadow bureaucracy to run the state which was good i mean he he like a chad uh got rid of the
00:47:49praetorian guard thank goodness because they did a lot more backstabbing than they i mean maybe they
00:47:55helped for the most part i i don't know but yeah no no they were they did not help for the most
00:47:59part they were okay wow yeah good on him look he in the in general i i think he good um but yeah
00:48:06no we're gonna name one of our boys after him probably yeah i like constantine i like
00:48:11constantine but constantine for a girl come on he's pretty good kryptea you're not gonna get
00:48:17away from cryptea it is the one name i want more than any name for one of our kids well it is the
00:48:23coolest fucking name not gonna get out of this great great anyway uh basically okay so he made0.75
00:48:31it cool he reappropriated it however um the the plain latin cross only became preeminent as this0.93
00:48:37like christian symbol in the late fourth century so uh it it again was very late i think it's a
00:48:47what early Christians wanted to do or meant to do. And again, this is like by very new Christians
00:48:53who are kind of getting on it as a fad, in my opinion. But that's just my opinion. Also,1.00
00:48:57just a little bit touching on the whole beard gate with Jesus, right? The bearded, long-haired type0.97
00:49:03first appears around 300 in the late third century, early fourth century. And the catacomb
00:49:10of comadilla comadilla holds what is often called the first known bearded christ of the fourth
00:49:18century behold i i present to you first beard dodgy beg which is how i labeled this he um he
00:49:25looks sad he doesn't look like he likes his beard in my opinion um but again that is that is behold
00:49:32the first bearded christ art historians trace the model to imperial imagery yeah because they're
00:49:37also using the halo that would have been a sign of a god exactly they're just like how do i make
00:49:41him look more like an emperor um and above all like jupiter or zeus um with with serapis and
00:49:49aslepius as related sources as a way of showing christ as a cosmic ruler so this is just like
00:49:56zeus but call him jesus that is what we're looking at here which is so crazy that this is the jesus
00:50:03that everyone pictures and like like if someone's like picture jesus you know like they've gone to
00:50:07your head picture jesus this is what's going to show up in your head right the beard of jesus well
00:50:12i mean i would probably picture mormon jesus i don't know why it's it's so iconic but oh this
00:50:17is very interesting yeah um so constantine's mom it does not look like she she deceived people
00:50:26so you think she no from what i could tell historians are like she didn't know she never
00:50:30claimed to have found a cross oh that oh people made it up that was made up later uh that was
00:50:38made up about 60 to 70 years after her visit okay so she was a posthumous travel influencer
00:50:42yeah so so uh her visit what they said the guy who wrote about it said that when she demolished
00:50:49the temple of venus and then excavated it what she found was a tomb which i mean of course there
00:50:56were tombs under ancient temples yeah you couldn't like do anything without coming across but she
00:51:01thought because she had a vision that it was real like christ's tomb um and uh yeah the bordeaux
00:51:07pilgrim around 333 visits also does not mention yes the bordeaux pilgrim also does not mention
00:51:14any crosses at the location it's a bunch of charlatans trying to sell people cross
00:51:19morsels for churches and then also cross flasks as souvenirs for their tourism around 350 refers
00:51:29to pieces of crosses existing and being shown to pilgrims but he does not credit helena with
00:51:33finding them well there you go yeah so that's that is crazy so anyway the story is just a
00:51:40fraudulent story right fraudulent story that's what that's what even by like actual lore of the
00:51:45period, a fraudulent story. Yeah. Anyway, back to bearded Jesus. The Zeus Jesus depictions
00:51:52became popular around 300, but they weren't the only way Jesus was depicted. They still
00:51:59coexisted with the more clean-shaven, youthful, beardless, short-haired Jesus. They still showed0.84
00:52:08him youthful and beardless and the ravenna mosaics of saint upon their nuovo circa 520 show him
00:52:15beardless so even like way way later he's he shows up as sort of the og depiction which is more
00:52:23accurate um the bearded image only became standard in eastern in the eastern church by the sixth
00:52:28century while in the west clean shaven christs remained common until the 12th century and then
00:52:36for whatever reason and it sort of becomes a little bit less clear after that people just
00:52:41adopted maybe it was because also keep in mind that after the fall of rome like seriously fall
00:52:47of roman and you entered into the the the middle ages because now i'm listening to a bunch of
00:52:52lectures in the middle ages there was a ton of this was like the first obviously period of
00:52:58obsession with the height of the roman empire because that was like remember when we had
00:53:03plumbing. That was so cool. Like they really had it figured out. And so everyone was fangirling0.99
00:53:08about Romans. And so they would hold Roman art standards and Greek art standards as a sort of
00:53:14a higher aesthetic standard. So it doesn't surprise me that more Zeus like depictions of Jesus would
00:53:20be popular because the more chic thing would be to kind of go after that style. Just how in like
00:53:27the early 1800s, the neoclassical style was seen as like this sophisticated way to do things.
00:53:31Once again, we became obsessed with Rome. And so I think that's more why after that point, Jesus became depicted in a more, we'll say, Roman pagan style. And then sort of after that, because that was when Western art started to become, you know, that was like the proto-Renaissance. And then the Renaissance set the standard for everything else. So then it just sort of snowballs after that. And then now we can't get away from it.
00:53:56Like, could you imagine if someone tried to reintroduce a short haired, either like short bearded or beardless Jesus, like people would riot?0.97
00:54:14I think that that is a fool's errand, because if you really want to do, quote unquote, the right thing, you need to go as far away from idol worship as possible.
00:54:22and i think if you need symbolism and you want to show your affiliation and pride you should show
00:54:26a fish or a dove or an anchor because you're not gonna mistakenly start to worship those things
00:54:33or a pragmatist gear or a pragmatist gear for techno puritans look that's what you put on the
00:54:38uh on the like techno puritan nun style and pre-style clothing and your fan art yeah and i
00:54:44think it looks just as cool as a crusader cross and i i think it can yeah and i and i like that
00:54:49It contains a meaning behind it, like the mechanistic nature behind reality.
00:54:56And time and deterministic universes, yes.
00:54:59And self-control, like a settings menu or something like that, like you control who you are.
00:55:05I think it works on a lot of levels without risking the negatives of the cross, which is just way too easy to start trying to worship through.
00:55:16and same as which i think are all equally good symbols the dove the fish and the anchor it's a
00:55:23lot harder to accidentally end up iconizing it and using it as an intermediary for worship
00:55:28instead of just use it as a symbol or identification well the first i think it's crazy
00:55:35again to focus on that aspect of his life at all um i mean okay the sacrifice is very meaningful
00:55:42But, like, to try to visually depict what clearly was a point of immense suffering for Jesus, as is documented.
00:55:52Again, my Lord, my Lord, why have you forsaken me?
00:55:55Like, people are like, oh, he was just quoting at the time.
00:55:57And I'm like, I think he was quoting, but also in a lot of pain.
00:56:02Yeah, I don't think, yeah, God didn't, like, poof, you're not feeling it.
00:56:07It's not do a whole like, oh, the lobster doesn't feel anything when you put it in the boiling water.