How Self-Actualization Destroyed Western Civilization
Episode Stats
Length
1 hour and 21 minutes
Words per Minute
171.15326
Summary
In this episode, Simone and I discuss the origins of the term "selfactualization" and how it came to be, and why it's a terrible idea. We also talk about the White House's new food pyramid, and how we should all be eating more bread.
Transcript
00:00:00.000
Hello, Simone. I'm excited to talk to you today. Today, we are going to be discussing
00:00:04.420
the popularization and development of the term self-actualization, as well as the damage it has
00:00:12.080
done to society, tracing it. I think it's a horrible concept that is upstream of a lot of
00:00:18.260
what makes the urban monoculture so toxic to a personal framing of reality. We will provide
00:00:25.040
alternate frameworks, which I think are better. And we will also be exploring the interesting
00:00:29.900
truth behind the current term self-actualization, which is that it actually came from a pretty
00:00:34.800
based concept. Self-actualization is, even in the words of the guy who popularized it,
00:00:41.340
a rebranding of the concept of Nisha's Ubermensch for a progressive audience.
00:00:46.900
No! Oh my god, the psyops of that. Wait, so was that Maslow of Maslow's horror TV?
00:00:53.940
Yeah, Maslow was the one who popularized it. And before him, it meant something entirely
00:00:58.260
different. Wow! Okay, I'm really, I'm very curious to see what your ultimate take on all
00:01:04.440
this is. Like, is it going to be a play on that South Park episode of like, we have to
00:01:09.100
invert the pyramid? Are we now putting just survival at the top? Survival at the top? I actually
00:01:16.080
like that a lot! The pyramid doesn't work. We've already tried it.
00:01:19.280
It's upside down. What? Sir, the pyramid is upside down. Turn the pyramid upside down.
00:01:27.540
It can't be serious. That would put butter and fat at the top of the damn food pyramid!
00:01:31.700
Yes, we have to invert the pyramid of Maslow's hierarchy of needs.
00:01:35.440
I love that the White House actually posted a clip from that. Yes! When they changed the
00:01:42.360
food pyramid. And the funny thing is, is everyone was like, I mean, it's basically right. Like
00:01:47.840
the nutritionists were like, I'm not complaining about this. Yeah. No, no, no. Honestly, because
00:01:53.100
you know, I listen to like all leftist media, basically. The leftist critique of it was not
00:01:58.880
that it was substantively wrong, because they can't actually argue against it. It's fairly
00:02:02.920
correct, as you say. So can you imagine what the leftist critique of it instead had to
00:02:07.240
be? It wasn't a respectable way to announce it? No. No, no, no. Okay. Well, okay. Yeah.
00:02:12.840
They were like, well, I can't believe they used stealth work, too. But they took out sugar?
00:02:16.820
No. They did take out sugar, as ever. I know. Well, because you shouldn't. There should
00:02:21.280
be no added sugars, period. There's no point for that. Right?
00:02:23.660
Anyway. No, it was, well, how dare they insinuate that people can afford vegetables and meat? I'm not
00:02:34.700
kidding. I'm not kidding. That is 100% seriously. I think that was a Philip DeFranco take, if memory
00:02:40.540
serves. But yeah, they were, they were very freaked out about it, that someone would have the gall to
00:02:46.060
suggest. Um, and then they even went to a clip of some either Trump administration official or health
00:02:53.420
official talking about that. No, it actually was quite affordable. You know, that, that every,
00:02:58.220
every American adult can eat, uh, you know, uh, a piece of broccoli and a chicken breast and I can't
00:03:05.420
remember some other thing. And they're like, what do you think people can survive off of just a piece of
00:03:12.060
broccoli and a piece of chicken? Like they're just freaking out about it anyway. So that was,
00:03:16.700
that was, but what I love is the idea of a progressive rebranding of the food pyramid,
00:03:21.900
except they just take out all the foods they perceive as expensive. So it's just, it's just
00:03:26.060
all bread that you get in the bread line. It's all the bread. They, they take out all of the,
00:03:31.420
the meat and the vegetables and the fruits. And then they just are like, and we'll add in what,
00:03:37.180
what are other cheap foods like chips and Fritos to like those categories. And it's like,
00:03:41.900
and we're not going to take out sugar because you know, of course in oil, right? You gotta,
00:03:45.580
you gotta deep fry stuff. That's, that's the new approved progressive one that they wanted.
00:03:51.500
I love that you watch progressive media. So you know, this stuff, but let's get into this.
00:03:54.780
They call it bread tube for a reason. I think they're very, very insulted when their bread is...
00:04:03.820
My attempt to make homemade crumpets with my sourdough starter
00:04:12.220
So Kurt Goldstein, a German neurologist and psychologist coined the term self-actualization
00:04:18.620
originally. Oh my God. Am I going to try to pronounce this?
00:04:41.580
It is 1939. So the book is only as old as 1939.
00:04:45.580
Wow. And that was the pre Nietzschean self-actualization.
00:04:50.700
Yes. This was its original usage. The organism, a holistic approach to biology derived from pathological
00:04:58.060
data in man. He introduced it within organismic theory, describing it as a fundamental driver for
00:05:07.500
an organism to realize its full potential and maintain its wholeness, especially in the face of
00:05:17.820
Oh, is it like a lizard with its tail cut off and it self-actualizes if it grows the tail back?
00:05:27.660
I think he's talking more about how brain injuries self-correct. Remember, his background is in neurology.
00:05:34.620
Yeah. It has been like if you have a stroke, you have to relearn your actions.
00:05:38.460
If you're born or you have a serious brain injury as a child, you can typically perform unnoticeably
00:05:46.300
different from other adults, even if and there's been cases where people are born like without a
00:05:50.940
hemisphere of their brain or a huge section of their brain and they can typically live mostly normal
00:05:54.940
life. So, you know, he is he is right in that regards. But what I find interesting is I think if you
00:06:03.020
re-contextualize his initial take on this, which is to say it is a fundamental driver for an organism to realize
00:06:11.340
their full potential and maintain wholeness. If we're just looking at it like that, I think then it's a good term.
00:06:17.500
It basically means to breed because that's what an organism exists to do and not die. Right.
00:06:22.460
Like or just to return to a normal stasis kind of state. Yeah.
00:06:26.860
To say breeding and not dying is self-actualization. I say, you know, okay, good. Yeah, that's that's a
00:06:32.140
decent term. But you are going to go for this is inverting the pyramid already. I can tell.
00:06:36.860
Oh, my God. The concept was popularized by American psychologist Abraham Maslow,
00:06:43.100
who adapted and refined it in his 1943 paper, A Theory of Human Motivation, where he positioned
00:06:49.420
self-actualization as the pinnacle of his hierarchy of needs. Maslow's work gained widespread attention
00:06:55.980
in the 1950s and 1960s through books like Motivation and Personality, 1954, and Towards a Psychology of
00:07:04.140
Being, 1962, framing it as the ultimate human motivation, achieving one's innate potential after
00:07:10.860
lower needs, physiological, safety, love, esteem are met. He studied historical figures like Albert
00:07:17.180
Einstein and Eleanor Roosevelt to identify traits of self-actualized individuals, such as peak
00:07:23.180
experiences, autonomy, creativity, and realistic perception of the world. Roosevelt, of all people.
00:07:29.740
Right. Well, what a cooked brain do you have to be to be like Eleanor Roosevelt, self-actualized.
00:07:35.020
That's who I think of. Well, I mean, even Einstein, right? He, he did come up with some great theories
00:07:42.300
when he was a kid, like, like very young. But if you look at his later work, a lot of it actually
00:07:48.220
held back the field of particle physics and theoretical physics. Yeah. Basically, he hated any ideas in
00:07:54.940
physics that were probabilistic rather than deterministic, which is really important when
00:07:59.500
we were developing the field of quantum mechanics. Though things like spooky action at a distance,
00:08:04.940
he just saw as ridiculous. Basically, if a concept went against his presuppositions,
00:08:11.900
he would push against it. And so a lot of ideas that we needed early in the development of our
00:08:17.580
understanding of the quantum world, which basically breaks a lot of normal physical norms, he was
00:08:22.860
staunchly against it because he was so respected. It held back the field a lot. And so that to,
00:08:28.700
to say that he is the pinnacle of like self-knowledge or an understanding of the world,
00:08:34.220
I think basically shows that Maslow is like the perfect pop psychologist, like the epitome of
00:08:40.540
everything that I hate about pop psychology, because to him, being a self-actualized person
00:08:48.060
basically meant like being a famous person within the progressive sort of washing of history.
00:08:55.580
You know, I'm sure he added, you know, Eleanor Roosevelt and he's like, well, I need some women.
00:08:59.740
So I'll choose one that happened to be married to a successful man. Right. And that's, you know,
00:09:04.860
which I think is really bad for a lot of reasons. I mean, you know, he could have at least gone with
00:09:12.060
like Marie Curie or something. Right. Yeah. Right. She also had a lot of kids, didn't she?
00:09:17.500
Marie Curie or Eleanor Roosevelt? Marie Curie. Right. I think Eleanor Roosevelt was childless.
00:09:24.460
I don't know. You can, you can look it up. Yeah. I think Marie Curie had like four kids or
00:09:29.900
something and Eleanor Roosevelt had zero, but I'll, I'll, I'll correct myself if I'm wrong.
00:09:36.540
Over time, the concept evolved within humanistic psychology, the quote unquote, third force in
00:09:42.460
psychology that emerged in the mid 20th century as a counter to psychoanalysis and behaviorism.
00:09:49.740
Psychologist Carl Rogers contributed in the 1950s by emphasizing quote unquote,
00:09:54.700
actualizing tendency in client centered therapy, viewing it as an inherent drive towards growth and
00:10:01.420
fulfillment in a supportive environment. By the 1960s and 1970s, self-actualization influenced the
00:10:07.740
human potential movement, including practices like encounter groups in Esalen Institute workshops,
00:10:14.700
or Esalen Institute workshops. So I decided to look this up to suit it was in the Esalen Institute
00:10:21.100
is a renowned nonprofit and holistic retreat and education institute located in Big Sur, California.
00:10:27.100
And it is widely regarded at the birthplace in the epicenter of the human potential movement,
00:10:32.460
a mid 20th century wave focused on exploring and realizing untapped human capabilities
00:10:37.340
through psychology, spirituality, bodywork, and personal growth. The Esalen Institute pioneered
00:10:43.340
the integration of Eastern philosophies like meditation and yoga with Western science and
00:10:47.900
humanistic psychology, helping popularize such practices such as gestalt therapy, mindfulness,
00:10:53.100
somatic work, holopatic breath work, five rhythms, dance, rolfing, making them more mainstream.
00:11:01.660
Sounds like a weird cult that was sort of big in that period. Cult, mix of cult and psychology,
00:11:07.340
it was very much like figure it out yourself sort of stuff. I don't think it was necessarily harmful,
00:11:12.380
but if it's what I'm remembering it is. So Simone, what'd you find?
00:11:19.820
Didn't your parents go to Esalen workshops, Esalen Institute workshops?
00:11:24.940
Est is what they went to. Okay. That's what I was thinking of. Est.
00:11:29.180
Marie Curie had two daughters. Oh, I was totally wrong.
00:11:33.500
Marie Curie had two daughters and Eleanor Roosevelt had six children, five sons and one daughter.
00:11:38.220
Oh, with one son dying in infancy. That's really sad.
00:11:41.420
Well, at least Eleanor is meeting our pro natalist agenda here.
00:11:44.940
Yeah, I'm good for her. I was totally wrong on that. Yeah.
00:11:48.460
I love when the people are like, hey, you know, you can't have a lot of kids as a woman and achieve
00:11:53.260
great things, you know? And it's like, well, I mean, the women of history would like to disagree
00:11:57.900
Yeah. You just do it. And that's, it's part of, it's, it's somewhat of a bad toupee thing,
00:12:04.700
Well, no, it's a, it's a them thing, right? Like I, I bet they'd even, he'd get criticized for putting
00:12:09.580
Eleanor Roosevelt on the list because she had so many kids, you know, doesn't make a good progressive
00:12:14.220
icon anymore. And I'm sure people are going to be like, don't you know about her charity work?
00:12:18.060
And it's like, no, I don't because charity work doesn't matter. Generally speaking,
00:12:22.380
charity work doesn't matter in the grand scheme of human history.
00:12:25.500
Sometimes it worsens problems. That's one of our bigger problems.
00:12:28.780
Yeah. It seems to generally make things worse. I agree with that. Unless you approach it in a very
00:12:33.020
specific way, but that's a whole other conversation and not, not today's conversation.
00:12:39.740
So apparently she didn't even do anything that big with charity. Her big thing was
00:12:45.740
joining the UN famously ineffective body and promoting the idea of a universal declaration
00:12:52.940
of human rights, which also famously did very little for anyone important. So apparently to get
00:13:00.300
on this guy's list of self-actualized, if you're a man, you need to invent general relativity. If you're
00:13:07.100
a woman, you need to F a famous person. That's, that's basically the way the world
00:13:12.940
works for these fricking people. But what you can see here that's being described, I think it's very
00:13:18.060
important that around the concept of self-actualization, an alternate form of psychology,
00:13:26.140
and not just an alternate form of psychology, but an alternative school of what psychology is meant to
00:13:31.820
optimize, begin to grow both within the public narrative, but also within the academic institution.
00:13:40.460
Um, and this allowed for some branches of like talk therapy to see their goal as moving the individual
00:13:48.620
towards the concept of self-actualization, which again, here, it really matters what that concept is and how
00:13:57.820
it is derived if it is the goal of a school of psychology. Because what happened with the urban
00:14:06.300
monoculture is it went and when it was trying to determine what is an individual's goal in life,
00:14:13.020
it wanted that goal to sound large and sophisticated and try to remove the accusation that it's just
00:14:21.020
hedonism. And so to academia, which is like, it's priest cast. Right. And it said, well, who, who studies
00:14:27.980
like, what is a life well-lived and it's what psychologists do. Right. So it's okay. Well,
00:14:33.740
what are their various models for what you are optimizing for? And the other schools of psychology
00:14:40.460
don't have as strong of a singular motivational endpoint. And so self-actualization became the
00:14:47.660
end point, the goal of everything was in the urban monoculture.
00:14:53.740
And it began to get worked into a lot of scientific movements as well, as, as you'll see, I, I will
00:14:58.860
point out, I do not think self-actualization was ever good science. I think that it epitomizes,
00:15:03.980
I mean, the mere fact of how he came up with the concept that he basically looked up famous people
00:15:10.300
who he kind of respected or that he didn't think that he'd get a lot of pushback on and then
00:15:14.700
pretended to derive a theory of needs from them. When in reality, he was just thinking through
00:15:23.660
himself. Like if you want to just like blow up Maslow's hierarchy of needs, Stephen Hawking's like
00:15:31.900
clearly Stephen Hawking's didn't just live with, you know, horrible debilitating. Yeah.
00:15:39.660
Yeah. For most of his productive career. But also his caretaker slash nurse was apparently like
00:15:46.700
very well documented as abusive. No toward him. Yeah. So just for more clarification,
00:15:52.620
the abuse accusations come against his second wife, not his first wife, and were in part made
00:15:56.700
by his first wife. And they were investigated by Cambridge police. He always denied them. They
00:16:02.300
later got a divorce. There have been no clarifications about whether they were real.
00:16:05.900
Well, and his sexual needs weren't being met. And I think he told his wife to go sleep with other
00:16:10.060
people, didn't he? He's sort of famous for that. I don't know all of that.
00:16:12.940
But my understanding was he was like, just go, like, I'm really not going to hold you to this
00:16:17.100
marriage because obviously I can't keep up my part physically due to this. So yeah, I mean,
00:16:22.780
he really wasn't, but, but he was 100% making the absolute most of his mind. And this is,
00:16:28.460
that's where I'm really struggling with this because as soon as I heard about Maslow's hierarchy of needs,
00:16:33.260
I got super excited about it because I contextualized self-actualization as being,
00:16:39.740
having everything else sorted in your life, such that you were able to completely live in your
00:16:43.580
prefrontal cortex. You're not in your amygdala. You're not in your high, you're like, you know,
00:16:46.940
you're not, I mean, he's talking about the life lesson he had, but my, my thought was that you are not
00:16:55.900
in survival mode. You're not freaked out about stuff. So you're able to just be totally in your
00:17:00.860
prefrontal cortex and just be about ideas and concepts and advancing civilization and inventing
00:17:06.220
and moving forward science. But that doesn't seem to be what this is about.
00:17:10.140
Which is, no, it's actually, I'm going to create the best analogy for what,
00:17:14.380
the way he actually defines self-actualization. The closest term I have found to the way that he
00:17:19.980
transformed Nietzsche's concept is being OTP clear in Scientology.
00:17:28.300
So it's, so there's a status called being clear, which means you have no more thetans attached to
00:17:34.940
you. One of the highest statuses you can have was in Scientology.
00:17:39.580
Once you have this, basically you are no longer burdened by like the problems of this world.
00:17:44.300
And then you get all these magical powers. And that's basically the way that self-actualization
00:17:49.260
is defined even by Maslow. It's like clear out all of these lower states. And then you enter a state
00:17:59.420
that is either almost magical in its conceptualization or just definitionally good without an explanation
00:18:08.380
But isn't like, well, I mean, think about it this way, right? But people who are hung up on sex and
00:18:14.940
seeking after that, I think, you know, in some way, haven't had their validation or just basic
00:18:22.220
sexual needs met. And so they're held back because they've basically intrusive thoughts about sex.
00:18:26.620
If people are food insecure, they'll have intrusive thoughts about food that, that prevent them from
00:18:31.580
being more productive and moving forward. And you could call those thetans, you can call those whatever
00:18:35.500
you want, but that's, that's a thing. And I think even same with, with, I would argue hedonism,
00:18:40.940
just feeling good implies some level of feeling of insufficient physical security so that you,
00:18:48.220
you actively try to seek out physical comfort because you don't feel like you can get it whenever
00:18:54.380
You've grabbed onto something really important here before, before we got further, but I, I love,
00:18:58.460
this is all stuff I plan to get to later, but I actually think it's really good to bring it in here.
00:19:02.060
You point out the real challenge, which is, are there things that are mentally preventing you
00:19:10.140
from focusing on the bigger concepts in life, a bigger purpose in life? And I'll get to a good
00:19:16.300
way to structure this for yourself, but are there things that are blocking you from reaching that
00:19:21.100
point? And it is useful to have a word for talking about those things. The, the problem is, is that there
00:19:29.820
are two core ways to approach this. One of them is super toxic and one of them is very useful and healthy.
00:19:37.660
And the way that he contextualize it automatically rolls into the toxic category, which is to say,
00:19:44.460
you can either remove all of the things that are blocking you from focusing on the bigger concepts in
00:19:53.980
life, the bigger questions in life by literally removing them from your life, right? By literally
00:20:00.460
never being hungry, never being uncomfortable, never not feeling love, never not having,
00:20:07.420
you know, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. Right. Or you can remove them from affecting you
00:20:19.260
Yeah. To better control what you care about and what you allow to affect you. So, and this isn't a
00:20:24.860
new concept, but one thing I love about Casalesism, people say, here's that from Malcolm. They're like,
00:20:29.420
what? But I, I, I do love this. Is that many of their sects, like the Opus Dei being one of the most
00:20:34.780
famous practice, various forms of mortification and mortification and, and many like mainstream
00:20:40.940
Catholics will do this forms of, of mortification. I think it's an incredibly mentally healthy practice
00:20:46.380
if practiced correctly, where they will wear things like bands that are constantly digging
00:20:51.740
into them and constant pain throughout the day, which they learn to suppress. And when you learn to
00:21:00.780
suppress that pain, that then ability can now be repurposed to suppress sexual desires or desires for
00:21:11.980
food indulgence. You're not going to be super avoidant about stuff just because you think you
00:21:16.460
might feel a little bit of pain and discomfort because you're so used to it. It's the default in
00:21:19.900
your life. Right. You overcome it as somebody like say Stephen Hawking's would write by, or, or Helen
00:21:27.340
Keller would, or something like that, right? Like by learning how to remove its effect on you,
00:21:35.500
i.e. you, you basically learn to make yourself immune to parts of Laszlo hierarchy of needs.
00:21:42.860
And that is where true and meaningful actualization comes from. If there was a concept of actualization,
00:21:49.180
but conceptualizing actualization of being at the top of this pyramid defaults people to wanting to fill
00:21:56.060
all the stages of the pyramid below that before they begin to address the, oh, but I could have
00:22:03.580
just learned to ignore all that stuff. Well, and I think, yeah, I guess, yeah, I just see that as
00:22:09.500
an insane misinterpretation because housing security, food security, and sexual security can be endless
00:22:19.260
voids. And I think you actually see this when we see discussions of socialism or human dignity among
00:22:27.340
the left, where there's been this creep from human dignity involving the right to the pursuit
00:22:35.420
of happiness, for example, right? The right to the pursuit of these things to not only do I deserve
00:22:41.660
food, but also I deserve best in class medical care that I don't pay for. And I deserve a TV and I
00:22:48.540
deserve a house of a certain standard. Like there's just this creep, this hedonic treadmill
00:22:53.020
of like, well, I don't, I don't live a life of dignity if I don't have a smartphone and a flat
00:22:58.540
screen TV and a nice apartment and, and, and, and, and a trip a year, whatever. Right. And these are
00:23:03.900
things that, and yeah, this idea that you will ever be satisfied sexually or food wise, it's not about
00:23:14.380
that. It's about reaching the point at which you don't care anymore. There's, there's not like an
00:23:18.220
amount like you, Oh, you just need 200 sex units. And then you've, you've accomplished this rung of
00:23:23.500
the pyramid. You can move on. So you are absolutely correct about this, Simone. And I hope you're now
00:23:30.620
seeing what I mean when I say that Laszlo's hierarchy of needs built the framework, the, what it means to have
00:23:40.380
reached, you know, Nirvana or what's it called? Enlightenment that it's, it's become sort of
00:23:45.340
enlightenment for progressives, but it is achieved through meeting hedonistic needs underneath it.
00:23:51.580
So even though he, Laszlo would say, well, self-actualization is itself not about hedonism
00:23:58.460
maxing. He basically conceptually set up his framework to lead people down a road of hedonism
00:24:04.860
maxing before they can achieve this. And not just hedonism masking, but sort of self love maxing,
00:24:12.860
right? Kirsha five months ago did a video. I just watched it was like an hour and a half and it was
00:24:17.420
really fascinating and it was titled, and I thought it was like a clickbait when I read it and it was not
00:24:23.420
a clickbait. Father of seven leaves family to become a child. So a, a, a father who was married and taking
00:24:31.020
care of seven kids left his family to enter the eight polyamorous relationship with another man
00:24:40.220
and woman where he acted as their 10 year old kid daughter, who the dad also had relations with.
00:24:48.460
And he would do like play behavior with their granddaughter and stuff to, because he was their
00:24:54.620
daughter. That was who he really was. And there was an NPR piece on this. Like, I think it was NPR.
00:25:02.860
That was the voice they were using. It could have been something other than NPR, but it sounded
00:25:05.820
like a high production value. You're calling that INTJ voice.
00:25:10.060
And hey, I'm technically INTJ, Simone, so I get the words.
00:25:14.060
Yeah, but you don't have, you don't have an INTJ voice. God.
00:25:17.660
But anyway, so they do this NPR. The people hate my voice though. The internet hates my voice, I think.
00:25:23.900
But I don't know. I can't change it. It's very unique. But anyway, so they, they have this
00:25:29.580
interview, right, where they cover him and it's produced and it ends with like a sappy, like,
00:25:36.540
well, in his new life, he has found love without judgment, which he just wasn't able to get from
00:25:46.700
Well, no, no, no. In this new family where he lives as a child. And it was very much like,
00:25:50.540
we hope that like more of the world can reach a state like this. So there were like other people
00:25:55.900
who see this guy doing this and want to broadcast this as like an inspirational,
00:26:01.020
positive story to the world about how his old community was bigoted against his, and it's,
00:26:09.020
it's clear. Like the story is, is, is really like, it shows the degeneracy of the age we live in
00:26:14.940
where his wife tried to like humor his cross-dressing habit, it seems for a long time.
00:26:21.660
And she just decided as sort of the trans movement came out, oh, I'm not a cross-dresser.
00:26:27.740
I am a woman. And he would talk about how his daughter would sometimes like steal his purse
00:26:31.980
or something without realizing it, you know? And he just, you know, live as a woman sometimes at home
00:26:37.580
or whatever. And eventually he learned that he could be a little and, and go down that path.
00:26:42.380
But, and if you want to see other lifestyles, if you want to get an idea of other people who have
00:26:46.060
like Maxis, you can look at our video on Anna Valen's life called the life of a Cenobite,
00:26:50.140
I think is what we called it. It's funny that we're talking about Kirsha right now,
00:26:52.940
because she was the reporter who tried to cancel Kirsha.
00:26:56.700
She has a, a very detailed sub stack about her life and trying to find purpose and meaning.
00:27:02.220
And you can really see that her search for purpose is about a search for self-validation
00:27:12.380
from a wider community, as well as an endless search for hedonism. And they, they both always end up
00:27:23.580
feeling hollow for her at the end because she, in this search for self-validation,
00:27:30.860
has come up with a very odd persona of who she really is. In her case, is a giantess.
00:27:45.340
Oh, you're not going to approach the elephant in the room that she's not a giantess.
00:27:51.900
Right. Well, I mean, the bigger problem is she hadn't even done all of her,
00:27:55.820
she still had male genitalia. And she was confused that the progressives who pretended
00:28:01.980
that they accepted trans people didn't want to validate her in the way she wanted to be validated,
00:28:07.020
which was through giving her sexual access to them. And they didn't want to give them like,
00:28:11.980
they're like, yes, we respect you, but I don't want to sleep with you. Right. Like, and she,
00:28:16.460
that, that for her was not enough validation. So she could never reach the top of the hierarchy.
00:28:20.940
And she needed to basically stop there instead of saying, wait, I have the thoughts in my head
00:28:27.260
of wanting to be X and wanting to be Y, how do I better suppress these wants? Because these wants
00:28:35.580
are not constructive in terms of what I think a meaningful life is. And then it's, what is a
00:28:42.460
meaningful life? Well, now you've moved to self-actualization. As soon as you've entered
00:28:46.460
the conversation of what is actually a life well lived, you've entered the realm of self-actualization,
00:28:52.700
which can be done right now, or, or what meaningful self-actualization is. But to continue here.
00:28:59.660
Actually, just something you said made me think of that line. There's actually several lines in the
00:29:06.300
Bible about this, but basically the, the ones in relation to it's, you don't need to focus so much
00:29:13.020
on materialism, but just being like what God, God provides for birds. Like the birds aren't worried
00:29:18.300
about, I mean, they actually kind of are obsessed with where they're going to get their food, but
00:29:22.220
like God provides, you know, focus on what your job is, whatever that's supposed to be. Right. I'm not
00:29:28.060
remembering the exact lines. Cause I'm not. So the quote she's thinking of is therefore I tell you,
00:29:34.060
do not worry about your life, what you will eat or drink or about your body. What you will wear is not
00:29:38.940
life more than food and the body more than clothes. Look at the birds in the air. Do they not sow or
00:29:44.780
reap or store away in barns? And yet your heavenly father feeds them. Are you not much more valuable
00:29:50.860
than they? So do not worry saying, what shall we eat? What shall we drink? What shall we wear? But
00:29:57.180
seek first the kingdom and his righteousness and all these things will be given to you as well.
00:30:02.860
Therefore do not worry about tomorrow for tomorrow will worry about itself. Each day has enough trouble on
00:30:08.620
its own. That's sort of what we're doing right now. We're at a Jesus take the wheel moment in our
00:30:12.620
lives. We don't know where our future income is going to come from. I mean, our fab is, it's
00:30:16.780
what I'm saying though, is there is a biblical basis for this as well, that, that for arguably
00:30:22.700
thousands of years, people handed down wisdom has been, Hey, don't get too obsessed about food,
00:30:32.540
shelter, money, sex, focus on serving God, whatever that means for you.
00:30:40.860
Yeah. Well, and as interesting is I almost think that this is an inversion of the Buddhist concept
00:30:47.020
of enlightenment. And I think that both show. I disagree. Um, because the, the Buddhist concept
00:30:53.420
of enlightenment involves letting go of your attachment to things. And I think that the point
00:31:00.220
of this is I don't care about the food or the shelter or the sex or the social validation.
00:31:06.860
And that's what I thought the pyramid was all about. I'm talking about Laszlo's contextualization
00:31:11.820
of self-actualization here. Whereas the, the Buddhist is trying to fully suppress all outside desires and
00:31:19.980
wants and everything like that. Not suppress, let go. Say what you want. It's the same thing.
00:31:26.380
Make it. No, no, no. Because it's, it's like, uh, it's, it's, it's, it's let it, you know, the whole,
00:31:34.300
you will not fear if you're a mind killer, you let it pass through you and only you remain.
00:31:38.140
That is very like the Buddhist thing, but just take that and anything that you feel just dukkha,
00:31:42.940
like any, like, you know, you, you are not hunger, like hunger passed through you and only, you know,
00:31:47.420
just take that and apply it to everything. And that's Buddhism. I understand that Buddhists try
00:31:52.220
to say it in a fancy way that makes it seem something fancier than emotional suppression,
00:31:57.100
but what it functionally is, because if you are, you are not emotionally suppressing
00:32:03.420
like some insane sex drive. You did it and you slutted it up and now you just don't care that much
00:32:10.140
anymore. If you are a Buddhist, okay, you are still a human being. You are still feeling
00:32:17.500
hunger. If you are hungry, you have just learned to not allow that emotional pull to make you act
00:32:25.660
on it or to interrupt your other mental processes. I don't know.
00:32:29.100
I call that whatever you want. You can know you and food too. Like you used to like invest a lot of
00:32:34.620
time and going out to eat cool meals and stuff. And now you eat one meal a day and you're like,
00:32:40.700
well, like. Right. But that's because I found out the hack to this. We're going to talk about that
00:32:45.820
later, but the, the, the Buddhist versus the Lazos hierarchy of needs have her, right? The guy who has
00:32:51.900
everything and the Buddhist who has learned to suppress everything. I think both of them have missed the
00:32:57.020
point because once you have reached that state, I E either you have every need that you want fed to
00:33:04.780
you or you have reached enlightenment and you no longer are affected by those needs. The point of
00:33:12.780
reaching those two states should have been the okay. Now that I am not distracted by lower order,
00:33:20.700
biological or self-affirming thoughts. I can think about what is a life actually well lived.
00:33:27.020
And I can construct myself in my lifestyle based on what a life actually well lived is.
00:33:34.060
And if you're just sitting alone in a tip, I do not think by most sane people's standards,
00:33:39.260
that's actually a life well lived. You have done nothing to contribute to the civilization that bore you
00:33:44.700
and that sacrifices with you because a lot of these monks live off of donations, right? You,
00:33:49.020
you are living a life that is fundamentally one of the most hedonistic and self-satisfactory of any
00:33:56.380
living human because it is a life wholly dedicated to your own mental state.
00:34:03.420
Yeah, your little pet project. That is true. That is kind of messed up that everyone else has to work
00:34:09.340
and give you rice for your little rice bowl just so you can get enlightened, but they don't have time
00:34:14.540
to get enlightened because they are too busy surviving.
00:34:17.420
I mean, what they'll tell you is, oh, you drew it in your next life. You, you serve me in this life.
00:34:24.460
I hadn't thought about it that way, but that's, that's a little,
00:34:28.140
I'm sure they have some profound, sort of profound at least answer for that.
00:34:31.420
People who have watched our track videos knows I, I see Buddhism as an anti-spiral religion,
00:34:35.740
and which means that I see it as being a personification of sort of evil on earth.
00:34:42.940
If you haven't watched our track series, which is our like religious series, which I understand
00:34:46.300
if you haven't, the concept of spiral versus anti-spiral is the, it builds on a distinction
00:34:54.300
made in an anime, Gurren Lagann, which is philosophies fundamentally fall into one of two buckets.
00:35:00.140
Either they're about the intergenerational and intermomentary evolution, which is sort of the
00:35:07.260
destruction and building up and improving of things, which makes it a spiral thing, the evolving
00:35:14.300
of things or the reduction of things, the driving to remove humanity suffering from the world, which
00:35:26.700
So a spiral conceptualization of reality sees reality as something that is constantly evolving
00:35:32.460
towards something greater, where anti-spiral beliefs towards reality typically see reality
00:35:39.900
We evolve beyond the person we were a minute before.
00:35:44.380
Little by little, we advance a bit further with each turn.
00:35:49.900
Mark my words, this drill will open a hole in the universe.
00:35:55.020
And that hole will be a path for those behind us, the dreams of those who have fallen, the hopes
00:36:02.780
Those two sets of dreams weave together into a double helix, drilling a path towards tomorrow.
00:36:09.180
In other words, you argue that Buddhism wants to genocide sentience.
00:36:17.820
I remember I first told you this because you were raised partially Buddhist.
00:36:20.460
You went to like Buddhist churches and everything like that.
00:36:26.700
And I was like, yes, it does actually like go read.
00:36:30.300
And then you came back a few days later and I heard you argue that, yes, it does to somebody.
00:36:34.140
And I was like, wait, when did you change your mind on that?
00:36:37.020
Yeah, I just realized that you just, you were right.
00:36:39.580
And then, yeah, when you heard me arguing, that was at one of our dinner parties in New York City.
00:36:43.340
And the guy had lived with like Zen monasteries for a while.
00:36:50.780
And he was like, oh yeah, I mean, you're right.
00:36:55.580
It's just, when you put it that way, it sounds so bad.
00:37:01.100
I can imagine nothing worse in all creation as a cult.
00:37:05.020
I have in one of my fictional sci-fi universes, like the Buddhist being the big bad trying to end reality, you know, and it's-
00:37:13.180
Well, at least Maslow's hierarchy of needs doesn't do that.
00:37:19.740
So the Buddhist version of Maslow's hierarchy of needs is just like a gun at the top of the pyramid and like, do it.
00:37:27.900
I mean, they're, they're, they're, they're actually like anti-utilitarians, right?
00:37:33.500
It's anti-utilitarianism turned into a religion.
00:37:38.620
Negative utilitarianism turned into a religion.
00:37:44.780
All existence is suffering, therefore end existence.
00:37:49.420
We're going to really piss off some watchers who haven't watched our tracks or have gone into this longer.
00:37:53.180
And I can go into a bunch of quotes from texts, but I'm not going to go into here because I know I'm right on this one.
00:38:01.900
Some argued Maslow's model was overly Western and individualistic overlooking collectivist cultures
00:38:07.900
where self-actualization might involve communal harmony rather than personal achievement.
00:38:13.980
Positive psychology in the 1990s and 2000s, led by figures like Martin Seligman built on
00:38:20.860
it by inter integrating empirical research on well-being, flow states from Myla Chisavakalia or something,
00:38:29.100
and eudonic happiness, focusing on purpose and virtue over hedonic pleasure.
00:38:34.380
I am not going to put those dirty foreign words in my American tongue, Samoan.
00:38:42.860
So anyway, positive psychology, I really think is the version of the psychology movement that grew
00:38:52.460
And a lot of EAs act like it's this great form of psychology or this non-harmful form of psychology.
00:39:00.860
By the way, before I get further, if you're wondering about, like, my ultimate hack to
00:39:05.420
the suppression of thoughts and needs, while also, you know, building your life into something
00:39:12.780
where you are working towards the future and working almost, I think, as hard as you can
00:39:23.020
I mean, he was, from the day I met him, the hardest working person I ever met.
00:39:31.740
And you work harder today than you have ever worked since the day I met you, which is insane.
00:39:50.540
So for people who don't know, naltrexone is an opioid agonist which blocks the pleasure
00:39:55.340
pathways that you feel from opioid pathways, right?
00:39:59.580
Which are caused by things like, say, Facebook scrolling, gambling, other addictive behavior
00:40:05.580
I originally started taking it to lower my drinking and it was very effective at that.
00:40:09.420
And then I realized that it basically had a positive effect on almost everything in my
00:40:13.180
life because like, I haven't checked Facebook in like a year, years at this point.
00:40:19.500
I made a post recently, like an update on my life, but I haven't checked Facebook in years.
00:40:23.740
I think I haven't, I have a theory that this might also have a genetic basis because I feel
00:40:33.820
It's like, I just don't like, because I never understood what, what it was like to feel any
00:40:41.340
And then people will be like, well, you didn't really master those, those, you know, impulsive
00:40:48.380
You used something else and it's like, yes, but hold on, hold on.
00:40:56.940
This is like saying the Europeans didn't really beat the native Americans.
00:41:03.500
It's like, well, the point was winning the point of shutting down these emotions, right?
00:41:09.340
Like these impulsive or intrusive thoughts was so that I could focus on structuring my life
00:41:16.540
to be one that, well, from my perspective, what I think matters, and we'll get to how to determine
00:41:20.940
this for yourself that contributed to human civilization.
00:41:26.540
I didn't care about the individual, like, like winning those individual battles was pointless
00:41:34.860
I just wanted it gone so I could focus on work, the bigger thing.
00:41:39.820
And from my perspective, you are being masturbatory and self-indulgent by engaging in a battle that
00:41:49.420
You are the person who, when a forklift is right there, insists on lifting the heavy
00:41:56.620
You get somebody else to saying, well, that'll take you four times as long.
00:42:07.820
And this is actually an example of your self-vision being so intrusive that it beats living a life
00:42:18.860
Because with that time that you spent lifting those boxes rather than using the forklift,
00:42:24.940
you were unable to educate yourself to learn more about the world, develop the world, or
00:42:33.020
act in a way that directly contributed to human civilization.
00:42:35.820
You specifically made a decision to hold your self-image over things of greater value,
00:42:48.540
A note here, I'm not putting myself out here as like a master of, I mean, I think I'm uniquely
00:42:53.100
I've done a lot with my life, like you and I have so far.
00:42:56.460
I mean, five kids, five books, run major companies, graduate degrees from Stanford and
00:43:04.300
Cambridge, a lot of people, CEOs of a company that pulled in 70 million a year at one point.
00:43:13.660
I mean, I hope we continue to grow, but you know, I, I, I, I've done a lot in the time that
00:43:19.020
I've had and it's because I've been able to allow the, the things that distract me to distract
00:43:27.020
But there is nothing less masturbatory about playing video games for a bit every night
00:43:33.660
than there is for taking extra time, doing something quote unquote yourself rather than
00:43:39.420
But to continue here, what are the, the five levels, the original levels of Laszlo's hierarchy
00:43:46.540
So we can sort of talk about this theory and, and, and break down more why it sucks.
00:43:51.900
I think it's a food and shelter, safety, social approval, and then self-actualization.
00:44:00.780
What's really funny here is you got love and belonging confused with sex, but I think that
00:44:06.540
the progressive urban monoculture has morphed it into sex.
00:44:09.900
And so at the bottom, he has physiological leads, basic requirements for survival.
00:44:14.940
These include air, water, food, shelter, sleep, closing, and reproduction as essential
00:44:21.260
We are going to invert the pyramid, have those things and need nothing else.
00:44:33.500
He made reproduction, the bottom level need sex is a bottom level need for him.
00:44:41.660
Which I think is very interesting in terms of how this influenced later fields of psychology
00:44:49.580
Once physiological needs are met, people seek security and stability.
00:44:53.660
Examples, personal safety, financial security, job saving, health, property, and protection
00:45:06.860
Everybody knows that the trans person who's screaming about how when somebody says we shouldn't
00:45:11.580
give, we shouldn't be gender transitioning a seven-year-old and they're like, how could you
00:45:21.660
It's like, no, I'm just like, you know, maybe we shouldn't be doing this to seven-year-olds because
00:45:31.500
And I think, you know, a good book on this is why zebras get ulcers.
00:45:51.500
That a zebra in nature has a series of biological mechanisms that puts their nervous system into
00:46:02.460
an alternate state and a lot of their biology into an alternate state when they think their
00:46:06.860
life is existentially at risk, when they see a lion, for example, right?
00:46:18.060
Your higher cognitive ability has given you the ability to imagine that your life is at risk.
00:46:25.180
We can make synthetic lions and then we are constantly subject to synthetic lions.
00:46:30.220
Whereas the zebra, we're only going to have the lion reaction when there's
00:46:36.060
So that lion reaction, if you utilize that to motivate, so for example, if you utilize that you have
00:46:42.860
an existentially important test coming up to motivate yourself to focus on that test and you genuinely
00:46:49.100
believe this to be existential to you and you allow that to put you in this alternate neurological
00:46:54.940
state, who will be less good at retaining information and everything like that.
00:46:59.740
People who are addicted to blue sky or X or whatever your social media platform is,
00:47:04.860
especially if you've got a lot of rage on it, are putting their health at so much risk because they're just
00:47:09.900
choosing to get enraged by this and they're just, oh, the years they're shaving off their lives.
00:47:17.580
Some people just scroll X and just chuckle incessantly.
00:47:24.780
What actual self-assualization looks like, or a meaningful form of it, is you have existential tests coming up.
00:47:29.660
And instead of letting a fear of the existential nature of the test be what drives you to study,
00:47:35.340
you are clear-minded enough to suppress other needs that you may have in that moment and say,
00:47:40.860
no, I just need to focus on this because it is more important than these other needs I may feel in the
00:47:46.780
moment. This is the area of physiological needs. I think learning to suppress those can be indulgent.
00:47:53.740
You feel physiological needs for a reason often. And the main theological need that I would say that
00:47:58.220
people should learn to suppress at times is arousal because a lot of people feel arousal for a lot of
00:48:03.020
things that just aren't particularly important to serving the need that arousal originally felt,
00:48:08.540
which was getting you to have children, right? As I said, you should think of arousal as saying,
00:48:13.500
you should impregnate that. And if the thing isn't impregnatable, you're like, oh, you're,
00:48:17.980
you're not useful to me right now in this moment, right? You know, this is not a useful,
00:48:23.100
this is not serving the purpose it evolved to serve. So safety needs completely negative, right?
00:48:29.900
Next love and belonging needs also called social needs, the need for interpersonal relationships and
00:48:36.060
a sense of connection, intimate relationships, family bonds, a sense of belonging to a group,
00:48:43.100
affection and feeling accepted by others. This is, again, I think, completely toxic. And I think
00:48:50.300
that this is really who needs being bundled as one. One is having other people accept you the way you
00:48:56.780
accept yourself or see yourself. This is where the trans person says, I want them to accept me as a
00:49:03.020
woman, because that's the way I see myself or the guy who thinks that he's a 10 year old child saying,
00:49:09.020
I want them to accept me and my community and my family and my kids to accept me as a 10 year old
00:49:13.580
child, because that's the way I see and conceptualize myself, right? It can be taken to mean that. And
00:49:19.100
that's just obviously toxic to even on face value, but there's otherwise saying conservative that will say,
00:49:25.420
hey, well, at the very least, you should learn to, you know, you should, you should strive for
00:49:31.340
acceptance from your community and family and everything like that, where I would say, no,
00:49:36.380
not if it is, if it interferes with larger, more important goals for yourself, time spent with family
00:49:45.820
and masturbating. Those needs is no less removing you from either self-improvement through, through
00:49:54.060
education, through whatever you need to improve your ability to act on the world or directly acting
00:49:59.580
on the world to attempt to make the world better. It is, it is removing you from that. And as like,
00:50:05.180
Simone and I have, I think a very healthy relationship and yet we don't interact that much outside of these
00:50:11.980
recordings because our interactions are fundamentally indulgent, be they sexual interactions or be they
00:50:20.780
romantic interactions or love interactions or anything like that, right? So, and I think everybody
00:50:26.940
logically they recognize it, right? You know, I think that you have a duty as far as you have a duty to
00:50:34.300
attempt to help your partner meet needs that they cannot suppress. That is the need for
00:50:41.980
belonging and acceptance and arousal. But you should keep in mind that if you over meet those needs,
00:50:50.780
you functionally hurt their ability to help their wider suppression system. Go in there and you say,
00:50:58.700
I'm going to make sure that you feel completely accepted with whoever you are. I don't think anyone
00:51:03.180
should ever feel that way in a relationship. I know that I can disappoint Simone by not living up
00:51:09.420
to her expectations of me. And that is a good thing. That is healthy in a relationship. There is
00:51:15.900
nothing more hateful a person could say to their partner than I love you as you are. And I will
00:51:22.860
always love you unconditionally, even to a child. What if that child becomes a serial killer or something,
00:51:27.420
right? Like that's a, that's a messed up thing to say to somebody, right? Like those people who are like,
00:51:33.100
well, my son would never do this. They then just deny the person that they created and raised.
00:51:43.580
I agree with you. Sorry, I admitted myself because Tex is singing.
00:51:48.060
And then esteem needs. He then divides this into two parts.
00:51:52.460
In confidence, achievements, independence, and respect for oneself. This is
00:51:56.300
completely toxic. It is not something that you should strive for at all. Either you accept yourself
00:52:05.180
as somebody who is attempting to live a worthwhile life, or you do not. You do not, like if you want
00:52:12.220
to understand our wider philosophy, like if you're like, oh, this philosophy that they're laying out
00:52:15.740
here sounds like a worldview I'd like to understand better, read our book or listen to our audiobook,
00:52:20.860
The Pragmatist Guide to Life, where we lay out an alternate way to live. And I'll go over the basics
00:52:25.740
of that in just a second. But confidence, achievements, independence, respect for oneself,
00:52:32.380
right? If one of my kids can achieve more for the world while they live under our roof,
00:52:41.820
that does not lessen the work that they did while we helped them. Use the tools that you were born with
00:52:50.060
and had access to do not, because if you, if you do the opposite and you allow those tools to say,
00:52:56.220
oh, I don't really have independence because I'm living off of money I inherited or something like
00:53:00.380
that, which we are not people who know this about us. We are definitely not all of the money my
00:53:05.100
family had got stolen, but it is very well documented in court records. You can look this up. I think it's
00:53:09.740
even on our Wikipedia. But if you are a person living off of that and you allow yourself to feel
00:53:16.300
lesser and then do all this indulgent charity giving and everything like that, as opposed to
00:53:22.140
to try to make yourself feel like, oh, I'm a good person, as opposed to say, no, no, no, no, no, no.
00:53:25.980
What role do I need to serve within civilization? What is the optimal role for myself? Every wasted
00:53:32.300
dollar is something you spent on a form of mental masturbation. But this also comes of respect for
00:53:38.380
yourself. You don't need to work on respect for yourself. Be somebody worthy of respecting. Once
00:53:44.700
you develop a world model about a good way to live and a good thing to be, you don't need to worry
00:53:53.100
about respect for yourself because you know if you have suppressed masturbatory desires, right, that you
00:54:02.780
are achieving through your actions or at least attempting to, best you can, something meaningful
00:54:09.420
in civilization. Somebody may ask me, Malcolm, if you didn't have kids, what would you be doing with
00:54:13.980
your life? You know, what would you be focused on in your life? And it's like the same stuff. I'd just
00:54:17.660
be less effective at it, but it wouldn't make me necessarily a lesser person or have less respect
00:54:24.060
for myself because I knew I was acting on the best I could with what I had access to in my biology.
00:54:31.260
And keep in mind, your biology can include things like genetic predilections for addictions and stuff
00:54:37.180
like that. You just have to work on it as best you can to live the most productive life you can.
00:54:43.740
And then the second category here is respect from others. Status, recognition, prestige,
00:54:48.780
strengths. People seek accomplishment, mastery, and appreciation here. People do not really seek
00:54:56.060
respect from others. What people seek from others is they want other people to see and think of them
00:55:03.740
the way that they see and think of themselves. If you have respect from others, but it's through an
00:55:11.100
archetype or a caricature, and we know this because we have a lot of very famous friends that you don't
00:55:16.700
see as authentic to the way you want to be perceived or to yourself, you often see the fame as a noose
00:55:23.180
around your neck. And you will become annoyed by your fans, right? Because they don't conceptualize you
00:55:32.060
the way you wish to be conceptualized. And you see this of a lot of famous actors and musicians and
00:55:37.740
stuff like this, and they end up blowing out. They should have everything they need, right? By Maslow's
00:55:42.700
hierarchy of needs. And yet they seem to be the people most likely to crash out. Why are they
00:55:48.300
the most likely to crash out if Maslow's hierarchy of needs is actually a good way to contextualize
00:55:54.220
what you need from life? Thoughts on that before we go further?
00:56:00.380
I agree. I think you see enough from people whose needs should technically be met per the pyramid
00:56:05.660
that are clearly not thriving and clearly not working on whatever it is you expect them to be
00:56:12.620
working on having those other needs to be met. And again, I think a lot of this has to do with the
00:56:19.020
fact that none of those things lower on the pyramid by modern standards, I think, can be met.
00:56:24.860
So, and I think that you see this even when you look at people who you have met and think about
00:56:32.700
mental stability, right? The people who you know who have tons of wealth, maybe tons of sexual access,
00:56:41.420
tons of, you know, et cetera, like the movie star types, do they seem more mentally healthy and
00:56:47.180
disciplined to you in terms of their, like, on their deathbed satisfaction with your life? Or think of your
00:56:52.940
average, you know, person who you know, who's like, say, Opus Dei or whatever,
00:56:55.820
who's actually going through these mortification rituals, everything like that, attempting to learn
00:57:00.620
self-discipline. Do they not seem more, everybody knows that they're happier and better up and not
00:57:06.620
just happier, but happier in the way that anybody wants to be, right? Like the only true happiness you
00:57:11.580
will ever feel is sacrificing for a goal that you have genuinely sought through and genuinely care about.
00:57:18.620
Well, that's why in general, people who have four plus kids strike me as among those most
00:57:26.620
self-actualized people. They've decided that something that isn't easy is important to them,
00:57:31.660
and they are pursuing it effectively, and they feel a great sense of contentment and alignment
00:57:37.020
as a result of that. It's one of the reasons why this story of this father of seven is so shocking
00:57:41.340
to me because normally when someone goes through the great difficulty of having and raising seven
00:57:46.620
children, you know, they clearly are expressing that they value children and they are very involved
00:57:53.980
in raising those children and feeling pretty aligned and good and contented with that. So,
00:57:59.580
it's so odd to me, this case, but every story is complicated. So, who knows, you know, and sometimes
00:58:07.180
people have a mini stroke and get brain damage or change significantly in terms of their personality,
00:58:13.340
and no one realizes it, or they have a tumor growing and their personality totally changes.
00:58:19.340
And I wouldn't totally put it past, unless this is behavior that has long existed.
00:58:25.420
So, later developments and expansions. So, he developed some few extra parts to the chart in
00:58:31.340
He added cognitive needs, desire for knowing, understanding, curiosity, and explanation. This is the one good
00:58:37.580
thing I think he has. See, I just thought that was part of self-actual, I thought that was self-actualization.
00:58:44.060
No, no, you need that before self-actualization, apparently. So, next here, aesthetic needs,
00:58:49.420
appreciation of beauty, balance, form, and symmetry. No, that just sounds like a sensitivity.
00:58:55.500
Yeah, and transcendence needs, the highest level involving helping others achieve self-actualization.
00:59:01.340
He's directly borrowing from Buddhism here. Peak experiences beyond the self, spirituality,
00:59:06.220
and connection to something greater, e.g., humanity, nature, or the universe.
00:59:10.140
I don't know, this sounds like the life coach problem, where, you know, when you have a life
00:59:17.180
coach, the only thing you ever want to be is a life coach.
00:59:19.500
Yeah, that's where all new life coaches come from. Somebody was working with a life coach,
00:59:23.020
and so the life coach told them, oh, well, you want to be a life coach, because that's what they
00:59:28.460
Well, typically, the advice you get from people gets you to where they are, and, you know,
00:59:32.940
advice from a life coach is going to get you to become a life coach.
00:59:36.060
So, he views this as a shifted focus from pure self-fulfillment to selflessness,
00:59:41.500
which, again, I see is just comical. Like, come on, you're either living a productive life or you're
00:59:46.300
not, right? And part of that productive life can be helping other people break out. I mean,
00:59:51.580
that was the first thing that we did when I was like, I want to do something like purely
00:59:54.860
to help the world. The big early project we had was the Pragmatist Guide to Life,
00:59:59.820
and the moral and philosophical framework laid out in that. And that framework, if you're
01:00:04.380
unfamiliar with it, I'm going to briefly go over it. We're unfortunately going to have to cut this
01:00:07.340
episode in half, because it is too long at this point. We haven't even got into the Nietzsche stuff.
01:00:11.340
What? There's, oh my gosh, wow, okay. That easily breaks into self-actualization versus
01:00:18.060
the Ubermensch. So, I want to quickly talk here about the Pragmatist Guide to Life. Basically,
01:00:23.820
we say that you first need to develop a framework for how you determine what is true in the world,
01:00:29.740
in reality, because it is getting increasingly harder. And so, you have a framework of sources
01:00:34.460
of truth and how those sources interact with each other. Then you use that source of truth to build up a
01:00:40.060
sort of tree of beliefs about how the world works with metaphysical stuff sort of lower on that tree.
01:00:46.620
And if you break something lower on the tree, it breaks everything further down the tree of your
01:00:52.140
beliefs. And we also go over how to build what you think is true. Like, a good example is,
01:00:58.620
because a lot of people are like, well, I just trust academics. And everyone knows that you can't just
01:01:02.060
trust academics anymore. And somebody's like, well, I just trust the church. And it's like, well,
01:01:06.780
you know, historically, the church has, you know, put out specific perceptions of God and its own
01:01:14.620
religious framework that has evolved since they have gone out. So, you know, some level of, even if
01:01:20.220
you're in the most conservative Catholic group, even they know that through the various councils,
01:01:25.900
things have evolved over time, right? So, you know, you, you, you have some more, more internal
01:01:32.940
responsibility to decide things by yourself. And we go over, like, how you can do that. Like,
01:01:38.860
an easy explanation here is, if an organization puts out information that is counter to their
01:01:48.300
goals, it is more likely to be true, right? Like, if an academic puts out information that makes,
01:01:55.580
and they don't have a long history of like anti-trans research or something like that,
01:01:59.260
that makes transness look like a bad idea for kids, you can be like, oh, that's, that's more
01:02:03.980
likely to be true. Or if an oil firm puts out stuff that makes it look like, you know,
01:02:10.860
oil is actually damaging to the environment, you can be like, well, maybe they have some underlying,
01:02:15.260
they're trying to create barriers to entry for small players or something. But it's probably more
01:02:19.100
likely to be true. If, if somebody who is historically been critical of, of gender transition
01:02:25.900
puts out something saying, it's not that bad, you can be more likely to trust that, right?
01:02:29.420
So there's, there's things that you can build here. And then we say, once you have this framework
01:02:32.860
for understanding reality, then you need to determine for yourself, what your objective
01:02:38.140
function is sort of like what a utility function is for computers. But just to say, the weighted mix of
01:02:45.020
things that you are attempting to maximize with your life, like you, you, you likely want some
01:02:50.140
level of hedonism, you know, just in case you're wrong about everything else, but then you want
01:02:54.220
like a multiplier on like how maybe helping others feel good. If that's something you think of as
01:02:59.740
having value, I do not, or building up human civilization or, and we go through in that book
01:03:04.380
all of the various dumb things you may choose. Like, like if it's one of the reasons that hedonism is
01:03:08.780
such a dumb thing to maximize in yourself or others is the things that make us feel good.
01:03:13.180
We only feel because our ancestors who felt them had more surviving offspring. They're not things
01:03:18.620
of intrinsic good. Right. And this is one of the core reasons I see negative utilitarianism as so
01:03:24.860
stupid. If you were programmed to feel something else, like suppose you were programmed to feel,
01:03:32.860
and some humans are actually programmed to feel this because there's weird like poop fetishes to
01:03:37.740
think that rubbing poop on your face, like that makes you feel good. Right. Is that an intrinsically
01:03:43.980
good act now? Because of course not. It's ridiculous. Right. Like that is not a barometer for any form of,
01:03:53.420
of, of objective goodness within our reality. Right. Which is one of the reasons why all of these
01:03:59.180
biological, all of these, you know, when we talk about martyrdom of man, is a very good way to put
01:04:03.740
this to escape, you know, our four footed ancestry, all of these bestial desires and hallucinations,
01:04:12.060
malformations of our world perspective created by this evolved side of us. Everything done based on
01:04:20.140
that is definitionally evil. Yeah. Yeah. All right. Love you, Simone.
01:04:29.980
And you are a great wife and I think are a natural Zen master of this, but I think it's because you
01:04:34.940
got like naltrexone in your vein, your opioid pathways like basically don't work.
01:04:38.220
Yeah. Well, and we know this too, that it, I, we suspect it's genetic because
01:04:42.620
my dad just says that he like just did all the drugs. And he's like, yeah, but I never get addicted
01:04:50.060
to any of them. Yeah. And he would, you know, he'd like take up smoking on, on trips and stuff and
01:04:55.980
then come back and just not smoke anymore. Like he's just, he's literally, I can stop anything whenever
01:05:01.900
I want to. And also whenever I drink, I just get drunk. Like nothing else happens. And I wonder what
01:05:07.340
it is that other people experience that I'm missing when I scroll, I just see stuff. I really
01:05:14.060
want to know what it feels like. I will describe it as being closest to what MSG tastes like.
01:05:21.260
That is the closest other sensation that I can describe as to what the extra feel on top of
01:05:27.420
drinking feels like. So addiction is the umami of emotions. Yes. It's the umami of emotions.
01:05:33.820
Delicious. It's just that, that enhancer of all the other emotions. Salt of emotions. Gosh, wow.
01:05:42.460
Imagine living my life, a life of food with no salt.
01:05:48.540
Umami isn't just salt. No, it's salt and fat, basically.
01:05:51.900
But it enhances the way you perceive other flavors. Yeah. By the way, did you know,
01:05:57.980
there's this, this weird spoon that was invented in Japan? It uses like some kind of ionizer or
01:06:04.780
something else that you can, you can consume low sodium products. But when you eat off of the spoon,
01:06:10.860
I think it uses some kind of electrical current. It's so, it's so Japan. It enables you to taste more
01:06:17.660
of the salt. So you're eating a fraction of the amount of sodium, but you're getting the same sodium
01:06:24.140
taste. Japanese got some cool tech. I'll tell you what. Right. And it's not some kind of,
01:06:28.620
it's not like those stupid, you put a scent cartridge in your water bottle products that you
01:06:34.780
get from a YouTube influencer. It is actually, no, you are tasting the salt. It just sounds so cool.
01:06:42.780
Yeah. So I love that. By the way, another fun fact I learned that I didn't know,
01:06:46.540
and this was from that Kirish video on the guy who wanted to be 10, uh, the original trans child
01:06:51.500
influencer, the one who they, they realized that he, he was the wrong gender. And I think it was
01:06:56.300
three or four. And then they transitioned him or started him on, you know, purity blockers and
01:07:00.860
transition at seven and who was on the cover of national geographic. Like they did a full cover
01:07:05.820
story on him. It was about 10 years ago anyway, or maybe like six years ago or seven years ago.
01:07:14.540
Anyway, that individual now says that becoming trans ruined their lives and they no longer
01:07:20.460
identifies trans identify as that. What is it? By gender or whatever, like
01:07:25.900
gender, multi, multi-gender, whatever it is that people, the, I can't remember.
01:07:31.900
Helicopter Octavian would 100% identify as a attack helicopter.
01:07:36.300
You asked him, this was so funny. So Simone asks him like, do you want to identify? Like
01:07:42.300
there's some people who think you can identify as a helicopter. Oh no, no, it wasn't that it was,
01:07:45.820
it was, do you want to marry a helicopter? That's what you asked him.
01:07:47.900
Yeah. I was joking. I was joking. I was like, if you like helicopters so much, why don't you just
01:07:51.500
marry one? And he was like, I can't marry a helicopter. And I was just thrilled to hear
01:07:58.700
him say such a reasonable thing. He's like, the ring would fly right off. And no, no.
01:08:05.420
Now you're like, is this how you determine whether or not something is-
01:08:11.980
No, I actually really like this interpretation because he has said the point of marriage,
01:08:19.020
in his mind, the point of marriage is putting a ring on something. And if you can't put a ring
01:08:23.100
on something, you shouldn't marry it. I could put a ring on a squirrel's tail though. I could,
01:08:27.340
I could put a ring on a- Great. But Simone, the point I'm making here is that the point of
01:08:33.820
marriage is not putting a ring on somebody's finger. It's getting married to somebody you
01:08:39.500
can impregnate and have children with to start a family with.
01:08:42.700
Well, that's not where he is right now with the whole concept.
01:08:45.340
No, but obviously he's a child. But once he understands that the point of marriage isn't
01:08:51.820
Okay. Then he's like, well, I can't have a child with this person. Therefore, I won't marry them.
01:08:55.740
I see. And somebody would be like, what? You think that somebody who is infertile isn't worthy
01:09:03.900
of marriage? And it's like, if my kid asked me, should I marry this person? They're perfect for
01:09:09.660
me in every other way, but they're infertile. And there isn't another way to have kids like
01:09:13.420
through surrogacy or through artificial wombs. I would say, absolutely. No, don't marry them.
01:09:17.580
And they'd be like, what, do they not deserve marriage? Do they not deserve happiness? And I'm
01:09:20.220
like, no, they can marry somebody else who's infertile, right? Like they don't need to
01:09:23.580
waste the life of a fertile person on their own personal indulgence. And if they were living
01:09:30.380
a purposeful life of sacrifice, they would understand that.
01:09:36.540
And so that's an offensive thing to say, but it's, it's something that, yeah, I absolutely,
01:09:42.140
that is the point of a marriage. I was infertile, Malcolm. Well, we made you fertile.
01:09:51.100
Absolutely. You, you made yourself fertile through technology. Again, not cheating.
01:09:57.740
You've, you've done all of the drugs, all of the extra, you bring every kid into this world
01:10:02.300
with more sacrifice than I think just about any other woman when bringing a child into the world.
01:10:15.340
I mean, I think I would rather have, I had to go through what you were going through and I just
01:10:20.380
lived for hedonism. You haven't seen the drug. She has to take a needle that's like this long into
01:10:24.620
her butt every single day for months with every kid that we have. Like it is, I couldn't even,
01:10:31.180
I look at it and I couldn't even push it in for her. It is so gruesome. It's like, you look at it and
01:10:36.380
you're like, how does that not go through the bone? Yeah. The first time I had to do a needle
01:10:39.500
like that, both Malcolm and I were like, especially cause I'm, I'm on the thinner side.
01:10:43.580
It's going to hit my hip bone. There's no way this is not going to hit my hip bone.
01:10:47.180
I still don't know where it goes. It's honestly, I'm like, I don't know how this works, but it works.
01:10:55.180
I have permanent scarring. You can actually see the permanent scarring from all the needles,
01:10:59.740
but I mean, you know, we're, they're, it's such a nice, like we have other friends who have
01:11:05.260
permanent scarring because they have chronic diseases that have, you know, involved so many,
01:11:10.620
so many blood draws and so many other things. I would much rather have permanent scarring from needles
01:11:17.340
due to trying to create new life rather than fighting for my own. You know what I mean?
01:11:22.300
So it's, it's a very lucky place to be. What, what, what a, what a profound thing to say,
01:11:26.700
Simone, you are a priestess. It's not profound. I'm lucky. It's not a profound. You were just born
01:11:35.500
enlightened. I love it. No, it's true. No, no. I'm lucky that I'm not chronically ill and fighting for my
01:11:40.940
life. And so are you, we should enjoy it while it lasts. Cause it's not going to, I'm going to get
01:11:46.220
cancer for sure. I hope there's better treatments for when it hits. I love you so much. I love you
01:11:56.700
Bye. Now we can do your episode next, or we could try doing the second part of this episode next.
01:12:07.100
Well, I don't know if you've been downstairs, but since Octavian finished his mandatory lessons of the
01:12:12.940
day, he decided he didn't want to fly his RC helicopter. He wanted to set up an elaborate
01:12:19.100
obstacle course for it. And it is elaborate. When you go down, you will see it's a whole thing.
01:12:27.420
It's a whole thing. And also when we went down, there was some kind of bird, I think some kind of
01:12:31.420
finch flying through our kitchen and living room. And I think they came into the same, the same part of
01:12:37.420
our house that the other dead birds that used to be in that cabinet where the bunk beds now are would
01:12:45.100
end up. So I think I sufficiently directed him out of the house for her, but I don't know.
01:12:59.740
People were glad that we were covering it broadly speaking because it's not really being discussed.
01:13:09.100
I mean, if we end up breaking that story and it turns out to be accurate, which I think all the
01:13:13.580
evidence shows that it is right now before like the New York times and the mainstream media breaks it.
01:13:18.780
Oh my God. We deserve so much credit for that. The internet. I deserve internet points. I don't
01:13:23.740
know what those look like. Maybe another me, maybe another know your meme page. I think they've
01:13:29.340
integrated all of our know your meme pages and very sadly, and I'd love if one of our fans fix this
01:13:35.820
because we don't edit our own Wikipedia page, but they took away the picture on our Wikipedia page.
01:13:41.660
It was a picture that your late mother took. How dare they, this, this, this merch, this merch
01:13:47.260
your memory, her efforts. Oh, I'm sure somebody was like, well, it's technically not whatever license.
01:13:53.420
I don't know how to give a picture with the right license. Oh, that's true.
01:13:56.940
Yeah. It's, it's not in Wikimedia Commons. If we can, we can literally just contribute
01:14:01.500
images to Wikimedia Commons. If you want me to.
01:14:04.300
I think that's a good idea. Just dump a bunch of images in and then somebody who wants to use them
01:14:08.220
can that are like ours. So yeah. Yeah. Cause yeah. Otherwise it could be copyright infringement.
01:14:14.460
And technically that was, I guess, copyright infringement of your late mother's work. I'm not
01:14:18.540
really sure how that, that works when someone dies. But anyway, I mean, all our videos are free for
01:14:25.180
public use. Like if anybody wants to like cut up or re-stitch our videos, we would never
01:14:29.740
complete. Yeah. But they're not published online as, for example, Creative Commons.
01:14:35.820
That used to be one of the major nonprofits I would donate to. I really like Creative Commons.
01:14:41.420
Here's a good idea. We put our pictures on the Pronatalist website under a Creative Commons license.
01:14:49.500
So that anybody who wants to take them from there and use them can. So just very clearly
01:14:54.380
put the Pronatalist website under a Creative Commons license.
01:14:56.620
Honestly, I mean, except I think Wikipedia is one of the few exceptions now because of AI,
01:15:02.700
it kind of doesn't matter anymore. You know, things like licenses of that sort are absurd.
01:15:09.020
People shouldn't waste time thinking about that. But I, yeah, I will, I will therefore handle that.
01:15:15.180
One of the most funny comments on what's going on with CCP in terms of substantive and smart,
01:15:20.940
one of our collective friends also who listens to the podcast was saying they don't think it was
01:15:25.820
an attempted coup. They think that Xi Jinping is actually trying to prepare the country for war
01:15:33.260
and like actual war. And that has this person really nervous, but he doesn't think it was a coup.
01:15:40.460
He just thinks that Xi is like doing everything. But Xi arrested the only two sitting members of
01:15:47.100
the council, other than himself. Who were opposed to war with Taiwan. He's like,
01:15:51.100
let's get it done. We're doing this. And if you don't want to do it, you're out.
01:15:54.860
And their entire families. This wasn't like a... You need to. Yeah.
01:16:01.420
If you need to remove all impediments to war with Taiwan and you're ready to go,
01:16:05.900
I could see a world in which that makes sense. This person also pointed out just the sheer
01:16:10.780
and intense opacity of the CCP and its inner workings, which leads to rampant conspiracy
01:16:16.700
theories. So to a certain extent, anyone's guess is as best, as good as anyone else's because...
01:16:22.620
I don't think that's true either. Not anyone's guess is as good as anyone else's. There are people
01:16:27.340
who have in the past made predictions about China's future actions, and those predictions have turned
01:16:32.940
out to be accurate. Or made predictions about what was happening, and then later we learned that that
01:16:37.580
stuff was actually happening. Yeah. That's why I rely on a commenter like Lei's Real Talk, because
01:16:42.380
she is one of those people for me. Oh, that's funny. This same person was like, I hate Lei's Real
01:16:47.100
Talk. Just go back and watch her various predictions she's made and see how those play out. That was
01:16:53.980
exactly his argument against her analysis, actually. By the way, if you had been watching Lei's Real
01:16:58.780
Real Talk and her predictions, you would know all the rumors leading up to the various assassination
01:17:03.900
attempts against these generals and against Xi was predicting that these generals would be ousted
01:17:11.500
dramatically and in a very high-profile way, which is exactly what happened. And in a higher-profile
01:17:16.860
way than any even confirmed insurrectionists had been denounced in terms of how quickly and loudly they
01:17:25.660
were denounced after their arrest and the arrest of their entire families. So the point being here is
01:17:33.260
you would have seen this coming if you had been watching her. You would not have seen this coming if
01:17:38.300
you had been watching mainstream news. And we do know that this happened and it was a complete reversal
01:17:44.540
of things. So this idea of like, oh, she doesn't predict it. Clearly she does have some sort of insider
01:17:49.980
knowledge of what's going on. And I love that some of the people who are just so brain-cut on China are like,
01:17:54.860
no, it's not a major sign that every single major general other than Xi and the person arresting
01:18:00.700
them were arrested in the CCP's military. That's not a sign of a major turnover in how the government
01:18:07.980
works and everyone who can actually arrest or enforce power was removed in a very short period
01:18:13.820
and that was consolidated. I think it just shows the sheer levels of denialism that these people will
01:18:20.140
undertake to believe that the CCP is not undergoing a severe restructuring right now.
01:18:26.380
So yeah, the funny comment that I got actually came from Octavian who saw the title card for
01:18:35.340
the thing, the bleeding Winnie the Pooh. And as we've not read Winnie the Pooh books to him or
01:18:42.060
anything like that, they're just not very substantive or interesting in my opinion.
01:18:45.820
He didn't know who Winnie the Pooh was. And he was like, who is that? Because it's, you know,
01:18:51.260
more interesting than all the faces we put on our podcast normally. And I said, it's Winnie the Pooh.
01:18:56.220
And he suddenly looked very, very disturbed, not because this plush bear was bleeding, but because
01:19:04.620
some horrible person decided to name a bear Pooh. And he was like, I feel very bad for the bear. I'm going
01:19:12.380
to give the bear a new name. Now he's just like on a whole campaign of, we need to save this poor man.
01:19:20.540
His bear has been mistreated egregiously. Who, who could do that? Which I get actually,
01:19:28.220
especially because kids are all about Pooh jokes. How on earth did it work that I guess kids of, of,
01:19:35.180
of that time when those books first were written were not as vulgar as the kids today. They would never have
01:19:41.820
thought that such a term was, maybe they had a different word for excrement, for fecal matter.
01:19:48.380
I don't know. I should look that up anyway. Sorry for distracting from this.
01:19:57.020
Oh, wait. And this is going to be the floor for it.
01:20:05.820
Well, that makes sense. Oh, this is the floor for it. You're right. Look at that.
01:20:09.100
Yeah, look. Yeah, we're making the castle. Wow.
01:20:27.100
Upon the green team and the talent team, it's the black team.
01:20:54.700
Oh, thank you, Octavian. Can you find all the floors for me?