00:06:52She tests the rock now against the wall, she needs to give it to us, and she gets cucumber
00:07:17camera again but yeah so the concept of fair exists in like a chimp and and ape and monkey
00:07:33troops because you know if if someone if there's not good resource sharing in this very immediate
00:07:39environment then you know it's going to cause sort of bad group cohesion but there is no such
00:07:43thing is there fair you can't like divide a cake fairly you can divide it based on criteria that
00:07:48is unfair like who's the hungriest who deserves it most who likes cake the most who is the best
00:07:53kid that day like there are a billion ways to make something fair and none of those ways are
00:07:57and it's important to remember that an equal division is always unfair we live in a society
00:08:02where we prepare pretend like one person one vote is fair the equal division is fair it is not no
00:08:07is one of the least fair systems so a game called fair play already big red flag because there's no
00:08:15such thing as fair but this i'm using is as really just one of many subtle efforts being made another
00:08:21which we're going to discuss today is what boils down to a propaganda book goading men into doing
00:08:26more child care and especially more infant care and i think it's interesting as it echoes some
00:08:30of the themes that we've explored such as subtle efforts to goad women into being more promiscuous
00:08:35and sexually loose and it surfaces some really interesting conversations so where where i found
00:08:41this commentary on this book is from this unheard article titled is child care bad for men a new
00:08:47book accidentally proves it and in this unheard is like that conservative uk thing right um yes
00:08:54yes the ai seems to think that conservative movement in the uk is just like a demonic
00:08:59movement like they're pro men doing everything they're anti-corn no no no this this isn't no
00:09:05this is a guy who's like no this book proves that child care is bad for men and the book the whole
00:09:10point of the book is like good sorry i thought that unheard yeah don't worry no no no no in
00:09:14this justin murvey who is a new father he calls himself a new father but his kid's five years old
00:09:18explores arguments of clinical psychologist darby saxby in her recent book dad brain the new science
00:09:24of fatherhood and how it shapes men's lives, which is basically just a giant propaganda campaign.
00:09:30So let's first look at the propaganda campaign that Saxby wages in her book. Now I'm quoting
00:09:34from the article. Saxby presents new research on the neuroscience of paternity that provides
00:09:39some insights into dad brain, a euphemism for the stress, fatigue, and depression often brought on
00:09:44by early parenting. But she argues the condition is good for men and families, a conclusion that
00:09:50her data does not support. I read the book in hopes of curing my own case of dad brain. Since
00:09:56becoming a father five years ago, I have often felt that my brain is turning to mush, but my
00:10:00hopes were disappointed. Saxby is the head of neuroendocrinology of Social Ties Lab of the
00:10:07University of Southern California in Los Angeles. That's concerning. I know already more red flags.
00:10:13She researches the brain science of paternity with a focus on father's involvement in hands-on
00:10:19child care, performing observational longitudinal studies, measuring various aspects of father's
00:10:25brain activity on hormones before and after the birth of their first child. On average,
00:10:30she has found a man loses, quote, about 1% of his prenatal brain volume, end quote, when he becomes
00:10:37a father. Testosterone levels, too, quote, naturally drop to support their parenting role,
00:10:42end quote. The effect sizes often increase with the volume of child care. This is true of
00:10:48testosterone, gray matter shrinkage in the cortex, activity in the amygdala, changes in oxytocin
00:10:53levels, and the daily downward trajectory of cortisol. Saxby argues that the downward paternal
00:10:59brain reflects more readiness to parent. Brain damage means you're good to go. And that those
00:11:05changes are positive. When men turn up their childcare dial, she contends everyone benefits.
00:11:12Quote, it's not just children who gain an advantage from hands-on dads. These fathers
00:11:16reduce their partner's stress. They enjoy better marriages, dot, dot, dot. Unfortunately,
00:11:23writes the author of Unheard, of the Unheard article, the book suffers from a foundational
00:11:28contradiction. The author claims that fathers are innately wired to participate in care because
00:11:34their brains and bodies respond to babies in ways that, quote, prime nurturing and sensitive
00:11:39caretaking behaviors, end quote. But most of these supposed adaptations only, quote, come online when
00:11:46fathers invest time and practice into parenthood, end quote. That is, when they agree to abide by
00:11:52the prescription that fathers should participate in child care. So basically, he's observing quite
00:11:58fairly that just because fathers are capable of adapting to providing a lot of child care,
00:12:03that doesn't prove, as Saxby wants to imply, that they are wired to provide child care.
00:12:09He wrote in his article, if that were the case, there should be evidence of brain changes before,
00:12:13during and after the birth of the first child but before the father submits to the practice
00:12:18this is precisely what we find with mothers who lose nearly five percent of their gray matter
00:12:23volume during pregnancy before they have engaged in caregiving so you see kind of what she's doing
00:12:30here i don't you need to explain this to me you're not laying this out very well basically saying
00:12:34men are capable of okay let's go back to an argument that you're very familiar with you
00:12:41know how you have this argument that basically when women end up having a lot of sexual partners
00:12:47their sexuality shifts a little bit because maybe something deep inside their mind shifts to the
00:12:53i'm living in a society where i'm a sex slave or where my my town is being constantly raided or i
00:12:58live in a harem and so my body must switch to that mode right it's not necessarily an ideal mode it's
00:13:05a survival mode but it's a different mode and essentially what this woman is arguing is well
00:13:11men don't naturally want to be like caregivers or want to have their you know brain volume reduced
00:13:17by one percent etc etc now i need to note that what's happening in men here is different than
00:13:22what's happening in women and to create a correlation is not not good so what women
00:13:26happens to them their reduction is called synaptic pruning and it's typically involved
00:13:31with an increase in efficiency what's happening in males um this one decreases much darker
00:13:38especially because it's associated with postpartum sleep problems higher levels of depression and
00:13:43increased psychological distress what it looks more like is a stress-induced atrophy which is
00:13:50not streamlining or what's supposed to be happening often more with effect size or more effect size if
00:13:56you do more child care but they can if you really put them in that situation adapt to it just like0.85
00:14:02a woman if you put her in a in a brothel and tell her to get going this sounds like those old-timey
00:14:06like slave books like yes well don't resist it first yes no that is what's happening no that is
00:14:11exactly what this is like it's clear to justin murphy that saxby is operating under this clear
00:14:16impression that men should obviously be obligated to engage in heavy amounts of child care she
00:14:21basically thinks all men should be forced to become active child care providers wrote quote
00:14:26the argument more accurately is that fathers can adapt to child care to some degree when they have
00:14:31to saxby believes that they should have to and he quotes a part of the book in which she writes
00:14:37i've heard the claim that parenting doesn't come naturally to men because they lack biology for it
00:14:41but new research can help us shift that narrative by showing us that parents can be made not born
00:14:45so yeah basically she's like don't worry we can force them and the data that suggests this is that
00:14:51none of the changes happen leading up to the child care they all happen reactive yeah they
00:14:56They happen after men have engaged in heavy levels.
00:15:00And all of the changes are like increased amounts of cortisol involved in like stress and everything like that.
00:15:06Lost gray matter reduction in activity in the amygdala.
00:15:09If you were measuring this in like apes at a zoo or something, you'd be like, this is clearly a stressed out ape in an environment it's not supposed to be.
00:16:22What she's talking to here is that when women are sexually promiscuous, the amount of oxytocin they produce during sex downregulates, making it less likely they'll bond to any specific partner.
00:16:33And it also appears that potentially, and we've done some episodes on this, they may increase in same-sex attractiveness as well because their body essentially thinks they're going to harem or erase as a slave.
00:16:43I know. So I'm going to read some quotes from like what Murphy wrote in the article when you
00:16:50just kind of read this, but also imagining if we were saying the same thing about women and being
00:16:55promiscuous, like that's where I was just like, wow, that's just I don't know. It's it's different.
00:17:00So he wrote, if we're if we're shifting the narrative, that means parenting doesn't come
00:17:04naturally to men. It's constructed. The transformation, as her own data suggests,
00:17:08requires paternal submission to norms and expectations they prefer to avoid,
00:17:12not to mention acceptance of public messaging campaigns in the form of parenting books
00:17:16and this reminds me so much of podcasts like call her daddy where she's like oh sure like you may0.99
00:17:21not want to have sex on the first date but i'm ready for anal it's just my choice you know like1.00
00:17:26trying to normalize that wait is that what she said yeah i've seen like multiple for like call0.99
00:17:32her daddy say she's open to anal on the first date yeah i think i've seen that clip like several0.98
00:17:38times isn't she married with kids well yeah but it's like a before married clip okay right but0.99
00:17:44like she she's normalizing she was normalizing that kind of promiscuity and they they mirror
00:17:51themselves to me i think that they're very complimentary of like on the one hand you have
00:17:55this sort of propaganda of like women it may not be natural to you but i'm proud of the fact and
00:18:00then all these men too it's like well parenting may not come natural to you but i'm proud of the0.71
00:18:05fact that I'm going to take all this paternity leave. And like, there's, it's, it's, I think
00:18:08it's important to be aware of the fact that we are occupying a society in which there's a lot of
00:18:16weird propaganda, essentially trying to push people against the grain of their instincts and
00:18:22also like how they, how they function naturally, making them do more to use an AI analogy, more
00:18:30token heavy tasks personally when they're not well suited for them. Like it's just a more token
00:18:37costly thing. Like it is way more sensible within our relationship for me to care for the infants
00:18:43because it costs me fewer tokens than it costs you more tokens. And the woman admits in this book,
00:18:50basically Saxby admits in this book, it is more token costly for men to engage in child care of
00:18:55infants because this is not something that comes naturally you know she says but it's devious that
00:19:01she would say all this knowing i guess it's just this assumption that everything has to be equal
00:19:04no she's saying she's saying yeah that because mothers need to get more support and deserve
00:19:11more free time that you must make men into compliant partners so here's where murphy gets
00:19:19to the shortcomings of her arguments he points out that quote this bias leads to a great deal
00:19:24of circular reasoning. For example, Saksby points out that fathers who had, quote, a greater sense
00:19:31of meaning, end quote, showed lower stress and found more satisfaction after their child arrived.
00:19:35So she suggests that struggling fathers find, quote, meaning in everyday toil of parenting,
00:19:41end quote, because many fathers fear that by doing childcare, they will break, quote,
00:19:46an unspoken code of masculinity, end quote. This sounds like a very eat their cake thing, like
00:19:51the poors need to learn to love their slavery but also like it reminds me so much of stuff that i1.00
00:19:58heard around women's sexuality when i grew up like women are afraid of exploring their sexuality1.00
00:20:03they fear being called a slut um so they need to be you know told that they should celebrate their
00:20:10you know their bodies etc like it just the parallels to me are just so striking she lauds0.82
00:20:16one psychologist who asks fathers to bring their child into his office as a form of exposure.
00:20:22Finally, she reasons that time, practice, and experience help shape the brain and reports that
00:20:27fathers who took paid leave showed smaller increases in stress and sleep problems after
00:20:33their baby's birth. The cure for not wanting to do more childcare is more childcare. In other words,
00:20:41if a father gets brain damage and depression from doing the unnatural work of hands-on childcare,
00:20:45he should find meaning in his suffering go to a therapist who treats masculinity as a phobia
00:20:51and keep doing child care until the brain damage and testosterone decline makes him forget
00:20:56what vigor ever felt like if none of the above works he might consider an inpatient stay at the
00:21:02university of southern california re-education camp oh wait is this a real thing no i think he
00:21:08made that up but look what you've already done to me look at me i know look you you gave me
00:21:14it's happening little munchkin oh she fell asleep in your lap yeah she she curled up you see0.96
00:21:20indy cats sleep in daddies see that's the problem look at this this is this is you0.99
00:21:25being oppressed i'm being oppressed here people this is obviously i've become i've lost any touch
00:21:33with my masculinity yes this is exactly it yeah i don't need to send you to the university of
00:21:38Southern California region camp. But anyway, Murphy observes that research points to only a
00:21:44weak, tenuous connection between positive child and family outcomes and dad's involvement with
00:21:49child care. And research has also found that more paternal involvement with child care negatively
00:21:54affects income, which typically has a much more profound effect on everyone's outcomes.
00:22:00Some examples that Murphy cites, he wrote in two large British samples, how frequently fathers
00:22:05changed babies' diapers and fed them in the first year of life was not correlated with the
00:22:09children's later behavioral problems at ages 3, 9, or 11. It has a measurable negative effect on
00:22:15income. In 1993, Norway mandated four weeks of paid leave for fathers, which increased the number
00:22:22of men taking leave to 40%, up from 4%, but had only a small effect on children's test scores at
00:22:28age 16. It did, however, reduce their later earnings of fathers who took the leave and
00:22:34possibly their partner's earnings too. So great. To get an understanding of just how damaging this
00:22:40might be, in a Spanish study conducted by Fraer and colleagues, what it found was a 12 percentage
00:22:49point increase in developmental delays when fathers took more leave. The researchers explicitly
00:22:53noted that parental care was replacing, quote, higher quality models of care. Parental care is
00:22:59not what a child should be relying on and what norway is doing it's likely going to cause
00:23:05long-term economic and societal issues for their country in that they are chasing fairness without
00:23:13paying attention to the actual life quality and outcomes of these children um saxby never even
00:23:20asks whether families might be better off if fathers leave infant care to mothers in favor
00:23:24of securing better economic resources for the family and warding off that seems like the obvious
00:23:29first question yeah but again these are going back to the fair play card deck that's not there
00:23:35those cards don't exist those cards don't exist that's how they get you they come this fair play
00:23:41thing is so nefarious by the way i know i can only imagine oh my god one day you come home and your
00:23:46wife's like look i got these cards i saw them on instagram yeah like you have to immediately just0.52
00:23:50grab them throw them out the window so throw them in a fire or you know what like yeah she puts down0.98
00:23:57the stack of cards you put down a stack of dollar bills and you're like all right let's go you know
00:24:02like i don't know man it just it's it's so messed up saxby frames men working outside the home and
00:24:08avoiding child care as being an unusual practice limited to wealthy families when that's obviously
00:24:13not the case murphy points to a 2026 study by british social historian tim disher which found
00:24:20that hands-on care for babies was not expected of working class british fathers at all from 1900 to
00:24:251939. He wrote, the book admits in passing that only 5 to 10 percent of mammal species feature
00:24:32males who care for their young. Touché. He also writes, in the American anthropologist John
00:24:38Withing's study of 136 pre-industrial cultures, Saxby notes the typical arrangement in about half
00:24:45of the cases is that mom and baby sleep together and dad sleeps elsewhere. Looking elsewhere,
00:24:50I found that the standard cross-cultural sample of 186 societies shows regularly close contact
00:24:56between fathers and infants in only three of 154 cultures, about 2%.
00:25:02Just a note, by the way, because that is our arrangement.
00:25:05Like when I have infants, they sleep with me in a bed and you sleep in your room office.
00:25:12Of course you say that with me stuck with a little baby girl here.
00:25:15well again this sort of unsaid thing is like now all the kids the older kids sleep to sneak up to
00:25:21your room to snuggle up to you um and i have the infants but again this is mostly an infant care
00:25:29propaganda piece because when you when we went and you know why it's because she has an infant right
00:25:34now you wait till her kids a bit older then it's going to be a child care propaganda yeah probably
00:25:40honestly but but who knows um at any rate it is super super normal i remember also watching this
00:25:46thing about um i think i talked to you about this uh i'm obsessed with this gyaru um japanese mother
00:25:51who's like six kids or something and and a tv crew followed her initially and then like five years
00:25:57later or something and she did the same thing like they had a super tiny house but the husband slept0.93
00:26:03on like the couch in the living room while she slept in a bed with whatever newborn baby they
00:26:09had. And, uh, yeah, this is just a super common arrangement. It's just, it's, it's, it's extremely
00:26:13normal. Eight years ago, she scooped leftover bath water with a wash basin. They have a new
00:26:21washing machine. It's the supermarket's Tuesday sale in which many items are sold at 88 yen.
00:26:30She buys cabbage, daikon radish, and bananas all for 88 yen each. Eureka targets sale days to buy
00:27:27quote, dads who lost more volume in the cortex told us they had worse sleep quality after birth,
00:27:32Saksby writes. Quote, they also felt more depressed and anxious, and they had more
00:27:37mental health problems, even when we adjusted for their mental health during pregnancy.
00:27:41The same brain adaptations that seemed to track with father's time and bonding with their infants
00:27:46also signaled mental health risks. But I don't care about that.
00:27:51But shut up and just do it more. The testosterone findings point in the same direction with men, lower T, presumably those who are doing more child care and having adapted to it better, quote, struggled more with their mental health, end quote. Higher T dads who presumably felt better overall, quote, found parenting more challenging, end quote. And no surprise, their partners were, quote, more depressed and unhappy in their relationships.0.65
00:28:16so she is framing it very much as um as a zero-sum game which it doesn't have to be
00:28:23I do the infant care you're like bait like you barely I don't let anyone hold the baby you know
00:28:29it's like 100% mine they're like a part of my body for like the first 9-12 months you know
00:28:35like they're all mine all overnight care all everything I don't resent you I'm not worse
00:28:41off for that. I freaking love it. It's awesome. I love the babies. Because your brain brainwashes
00:28:47you to love babies. Yeah, I already lost 5% of my brain volume. It's gone. I've been
00:28:53completely lobotomized. Baby-anized. Yes. I'm not going to foist that lobotomy partially onto
00:29:00you and not have it work. I mean, you'd only lose 1% of your brain volume. You wouldn't go far
00:29:05enough. It's not good. It won't work. But I just find that so interesting and crazy. And so I
00:29:11wanted to look at what maybe other research implied and basically the best supported conclusion
00:29:15that i could find is that an available responsive engaged father is beneficial look at you holding
00:29:22our little indie cat research does not demonstrate a simple dose response rule in which every
00:29:28additional child care hour improves development so basically perceived fairness really does matter
00:29:34alongside the actual division and that's one reason why you know we we have lumpy child care
00:29:40arrangements. Like I do nothing and you do everything. And no, I do all the infant care
00:29:44and you do all the older kid care. Look at, look at her little girl. Look, you're, you're the one1.00
00:29:48holding her. Right. So it's lumpy, but we don't resent each other. And because of that, we're
00:29:54okay. The evidence does not establish that an exact 50, 50 split is optimal for every couple
00:30:00dissatisfaction with the arrangement or unmet expectations and feeling unappreciated. That's
00:30:06where you start to see relationship strain and i think one of the reasons why saxby the researcher0.97
00:30:12who did this whole book and pop propaganda effort thinks that it's a zero-sum game is she's primarily
00:30:18researching couples that live in urban south or southern california where yes very very progressive0.99
00:30:29it's just her presumption in life in general the more work a man does the less work a woman does0.88
00:30:34But in progressive Southern California, you're going to get much more of that view of like women being like, well, if you know, it's I resent this because he's not doing enough work.0.93
00:30:43It's it's it's one of the epicenters of some place that would do fair play cards.
00:30:47But some more detail, this UK Government Commission literature review found that warmth, parenting, confidence, emotional engagement, educational activities and low parental conflict often predicted outcomes better than total time.
00:31:01so it really doesn't matter how much time dad spends on the kids as i said you don't need to
00:31:06change their clothes you don't need to clean the dishes you do it once a week i know the
00:31:10the important is that you're doing it confidently malcolm you throw the soccer ball at them and you
00:31:15tell them to kick it and somehow as long as you do that with warmth uh you know and we're not
00:31:21fighting that's way better than like us fighting me pulling out the fair play cards me making you
00:31:26get the sports card and now you have to interview the kids and you have to book the carpooling and
00:31:31you have to blah blah blah like that is where the kids actually suffer even though you have more
00:31:35hours of involvement technically per that system okay so then also there's this 2024 systematic
00:31:42review of 10 studies that found little evidence of a direct relationship between father involvement
00:31:46and young children's emotion regulation although relationships emerged under particular conditions
00:31:51and also research is mixed when it comes to parental leaves when families have new babies
00:31:56One Spanish quasi-experiment working paper studying extensions of paternity leave reported an adverse effect, actually.
00:32:04Eligibility for four additional weeks increased the proportion of children's screening as developmentally delayed by about 12 percentage points.
00:32:12The researchers identified reduced formal child care and changes in maternal versus paternal care as probably maybe some potential mechanisms in that.
00:32:21But it's a working paper. It's it's not like fully polished yet, but it's still relevant evidence that assuming that more paternal leave doesn't like just always improve outcomes, because clearly in this one, it didn't.
00:32:34Also, income really does cause better outcomes, especially at super low income levels. This one systematic review by Karis Cooper and Kitty Stewart examined 54 studies using randomized experiments, quasi experiments or longitudinal methods designed to get closer to causal effects.
00:32:51And it found very strong support and additional for, sorry, it found very strong support that
00:32:57additional household income improves children's cognitive and educational outcomes with evidence
00:33:02also supporting social behavioral development and some health outcomes and income also improved
00:33:07maternal mental health, parenting and the home environment. So basically the lower your starting
00:33:13income is as a household, the better it is if you just get more money, like more money is going to
00:33:19be way more meaningful yeah obviously and this is why what she's saying is just so harmful to
00:33:23families and children yeah it's like no no because remember that norway study where men were given
00:33:28additional weeks of paid leave and keep in mind this was paid leave they still had lower income
00:33:34and even their wives may have had lower income long term after all that and that's the important
00:33:39thing to remember too and this is why i'm like so iffy on paid maternal leave is like sure maybe
00:33:44you're paid during that period but your lifetime income is probably going to be lower because you've
00:33:47shown yourself to be basically like a disloyal, less productive employee who is kind of a liability,
00:33:54you know, like no one wants to invest in you because who knows if you're going to disappear
00:33:57again to go do your family. But also just the idea of working for an external corporation is like
00:34:03inherently not very pronatalist. Like you can't really be all in on family if you don't have a
00:34:10family business, which sucks. It's hard. Like you can't, you can't go like full, no stress,0.95
00:34:17pronatalist if you do not basically go off the grid and leave industrial society. It's so messed
00:34:23up. Which is, of course, what we have done. Yeah. With our family porn business. With the family
00:34:29porn business. Thank goodness. It's so wholesome. But I think it's fair to say that fathers should
00:34:34provide support. Hey, Indie, do you want to see the IndieCat song? Okay. You can play the IndieCat
00:34:40song for a little bit for Indie. We'll play it at the end. I'm almost done.
00:37:12we'll play it for you really soon the gist is that the research shows that it's important
00:37:16for dads to be involved but they should be involved in ways that are natural to them
00:37:21like writing apis that make songs of them based on yes that is the perfect way i built a little
00:37:27thing for indy cat and indy cat liked her little thing yes exactly and it's it's it makes more0.99
00:37:32sense because moms have the boobs and they have the the uterus you know to do certain other things1.00
00:37:37right? Like it just works out that way. It's, it's easier for mothers to do the overnight1.00
00:37:43care for newborns because it's not exactly like, you know, men can like, I'm sure there are
00:37:49husbands that has somehow managed to turn on breast pumps for asleep wives in the middle of
00:37:55the night, every three hours. There has to be one man who did that. I'm sure. But like, why
00:38:02could an ai do that for you and monitor you i don't know um there are these automated cow milkers
00:38:09they're actually quite amusing to watch the cow just walks up to them and it like
00:38:13it like cleans them and then it like uh does the thing is that what you want for
00:38:18being a breeder let's say that there's like a bed where like you could just roll over you're not
00:38:23beating the breeder accusation here so wait how does that work in the middle of the night you
00:38:28like lay down on no like yeah like so I don't I don't want to get out of bed I don't want to like
00:38:33set up the thing but like if I could just roll over in bed and like lie on like a pillow that
00:38:38just like cleaned and then extracted and then refrigerated or like put into a bottle for me to
00:38:44do for the next feeding like while I'm like feeding the baby right next to me or whatever
00:38:48like that would be so great because like the key is to like not actually fully wake up it's just to
00:38:53The point, though, is that it's important for dads to be involved. I think trying to force things where they're not meant to work or where it works, but to the detriment of the person isn't good.
00:39:07And a major theme of modern society is trying to force people into roles that don't ultimately leave to them thriving, forcing men to just somehow adapt to infant care.