The Fundie Snark To Religious Extremist Pipeline
Episode Stats
Words per minute
180.59204
Harmful content
Misogyny
45
sentences flagged
Toxicity
55
sentences flagged
Hate speech
57
sentences flagged
Summary
Ben Shapiro's sister, Classically Abby, is a conservative pundit who has built a cult-like cult on her YouTube channel, "Classically Abby." How does she do it? And why does she get so much hate mail from people who don't get it?
Transcript
00:00:00.000
I like seeing people who have taken hard cultural stances be criticized to see how we might be subject to criticism ourselves and what we may be doing wrong.
00:00:11.260
I really like Fundy Fridays and I really like Jen.
00:00:13.500
But yeah, she's in as much of a cult as the people who she covers.
00:00:18.060
They all come from very strong cultures that have skews and blind spots because of those strong cultures.
1.00
00:00:23.300
Not to say that we don't have blind spots either, but still.
0.96
00:00:28.100
They're the good guys in her insane religious cult.
00:00:30.800
She's the good guy and she's doing what the cult is telling her to do.
00:00:35.800
She'd started tongue-in-cheek that are frills of the channel now still speak very much or similar to the small-time career preachers that she criticizes.
00:00:46.100
Her followers call themselves Jenonites and they patronize her.
00:00:50.260
And how is that different from being a preacher in the end?
00:01:01.180
After a tough day today, it is always nice to be able to come back to doing something that we love, which is these conversations.
00:01:13.360
Like, they're so much better than a date because they're, like, recorded and we watch them over and over again.
00:01:18.480
I actually quite enjoy our own YouTube channel.
00:01:23.940
But this is the first time I've ever created something that I really, like, with our books, I don't read them over and over again.
00:01:28.500
But I'm like, oh, I know I made a fun joke in this one.
00:01:32.440
But what actually got us on today's topic was Simone has always been a big fan of Fundy Snark content.
0.58
00:01:41.180
And I have always been a big fan of religious content.
00:01:45.660
And religious content for me includes the deconverts and stuff like that.
00:01:51.780
And where our two worlds interlapped recently was Classically Abby.
00:01:58.700
Being a conservative woman in today's day and age is not easy.
00:02:02.320
So people might not know this, but Classically Abby is Ben Shapiro's sister.
00:02:07.400
And she absolutely spammed YouTube with so, so many ads a few years ago.
0.96
00:02:12.480
If you're on YouTube now and you've been on YouTube for years, you know what we're talking about.
00:02:18.980
You're like, oh my God, I remember when I had to watch her.
00:02:21.000
What got me about Classically Abby, and this actually has boosted my ego so much.
00:02:25.920
Classically Abby, we produce videos every weekday.
00:02:28.940
Classically Abby produces one video a week, but otherwise similar format to us.
00:02:38.620
Whereas we're generally between the low 2Ks to 7 or 8K views.
00:02:44.860
On an average day, because we can look at our statistics.
00:02:47.780
So some of our videos just vastly outperform other ones.
00:02:50.980
Like the old Starship Troopers one is a really high number.
00:02:55.100
But on average, we're getting about 8,000 views per day.
00:03:05.440
Smoking her for a daily channel doing four or five times as well as her weekly channel, which I love.
00:03:14.520
Because she must have spent millions building that up.
0.77
00:03:17.200
And sorry, as to why I love this, people might not know, but we have a beef with Ben Shapiro.
00:03:22.080
He, the first time we really went viral, he was really derogatory towards us and was like, they're nerds.
00:03:28.420
Why does anyone care what these people have to say?
00:03:30.980
And he has just repeatedly, we have tried to get into events that he's doing or has association with.
00:03:39.120
Like we are on a blocked, do not talk to list with Ben Shapiro and everyone who talks to Ben Shapiro.
00:03:50.200
That we've actually like grassroots beginning to build up.
00:03:54.020
So Ben Shapiro's thing is he often switches between whatever movement happens to be hot in the conservative space right now.
00:04:00.440
But I think he would have, like when he switched to all the men's rights content and stuff like that.
00:04:05.040
But he doesn't seem to actually have like his own perspective on things.
00:04:08.740
It's more just like whatever he thinks will get him in the moment clout.
00:04:12.980
So it's not just audience capture, it's audience capture hopping.
00:04:21.180
He tried to help out his sister, which I appreciate to get into the same business.
00:04:27.100
I tried to watch some of her videos and I'm like, I can see why nobody's watching these.
00:04:39.240
There's no, yeah, the most interesting, least interesting takes.
00:04:42.620
But I want to talk about this phenomenon of Fundy Snark.
00:04:47.460
To be clear, Fundy Snark is people with snarky commentary on fundamentalist religions and people
00:04:54.900
who are religious fundamentalists, just in case you're not familiar with it.
00:04:59.760
And it's very different from, I think the reason why we would provide an interesting insight
00:05:05.880
into Fundy Snark is we are people who watch a lot of Fundy Snark content for different reasons.
00:05:11.940
Like I'm interested in how different cultures view other cultural groups and talk about other
00:05:20.560
Or I like seeing people who have taken hard cultural stances be criticized to see how we
00:05:27.840
might be subject to criticism ourselves and what we may be doing wrong.
00:05:31.780
Because my favorite content is, it turns out that I am wrong about something and I should
00:05:37.280
And Fundy Snark helps me because it is, it does all of that.
00:05:49.420
And I'm like, our audience is like 90% male now.
00:05:53.160
This is a very interesting pernagalist argument around Bridgerton though.
00:05:55.300
And we were discussing, this is one of the podcast listeners who is in a very progressive
00:06:02.160
And there's a lot of people who are very progressively coded at least, but who also love Bridgerton,
00:06:08.680
which is an insanely pro-natalist TV show on Netflix that large families, it's all about
0.98
00:06:16.840
And if our viewers want us to do the Bridgerton episode, let us know.
00:06:22.120
So we're going to be talking about a few different channels as examples of Fundy Snark content.
00:06:28.260
And what I find very interesting is the differentiation between the channels in terms of like my
00:06:35.960
perspective on whether or not they are fundamental goods for the world or fundamental negatives
00:06:42.980
Because some of these channels are really just like in a cult, basically.
00:06:46.480
Like the far progressive movement has essentially become a cult.
00:06:49.540
We call it the urban monoculture in our show a lot, stuff like that.
00:06:52.840
But then there's some people who would just seem to be genuinely secular.
00:06:56.600
One of the things I find most interesting about Fundy Snark content is the people who were
00:07:04.360
raised atheist and then turned to Fundy Snark often seem to be the most in a cult of the
00:07:13.940
And the people who were raised Mormon and then turned to Fundy Snark often are the most
0.93
00:07:20.260
like kind and open-minded and genuinely engaging.
00:07:25.680
So just there, which I'm sure you're probably going to agree with.
00:07:29.080
Let's list the channels we're talking about and then hear your hypothesis.
00:07:31.820
So the channels that we actively watch, so people know what we're talking about here,
00:07:44.780
And then Rachel Friday, yes, the subreddit is called Fundy Snark.
00:07:48.160
I would say that like the groups that I say are like fairly benign or even quite positive.
00:07:55.260
I think the two Mormon couples we mentioned was the highest tier being Zelf on the Shelf.
1.00
00:07:59.700
I just see Zelf on the Shelf as being really compassionate about the people that they are
00:08:05.460
targeting to the extent where recently they've done a number of episodes where they are interacting
00:08:10.480
was the girl-defined couple because this couple is open to interacting with them given how
00:08:15.820
open and kind they are towards these individuals.
00:08:18.640
Whereas I put the pedestal of hate content, probably Rachel Oates, and then slightly below
0.93
00:08:26.280
Where these people are really just a progressive version of Libs of TikTok, but not as entertaining.
0.97
00:08:33.940
Libs of TikTok, for people who don't know, they take the most extreme people in this urban
1.00
00:08:39.960
monoculture cult that we talk about and they showcase their behavior and then they attempt
00:08:45.860
to spin sort of a narrative or a perspective where this behavior is actually pretty mainstream
00:08:52.840
But like most progressive, though, this isn't mainstream.
00:08:57.020
Whereas you see a similar thing in, for example, Fundy Fridays, where they will say things like
00:09:03.760
there was in a Duggar video recently where she was saying basically all Republicans are bad
00:09:09.940
and represent a threat to the LGBT community.
0.82
00:09:12.960
And even though more than 50% of Republican voters these days support gay marriage, like it's wild
1.00
00:09:19.640
that these positions they're taking, we'll get more into the wildness of this and the
00:09:23.960
downstream negative repercussions of the positions the extremists are taking.
00:09:35.880
So I think that the reason why born fairly atheist and then remained atheist people have
00:09:42.600
the most skewed Fundy Snark commentary is because they are of the greatest religious fervor.
00:09:49.180
So we've seen that, for example, in polygenic risk scores and generally, religiosity appears
00:09:58.340
But religiosity doesn't mean like you inherit being a Baptist.
00:10:02.460
It means you inherit a kind of religious fervor or tendency to be quite religious.
00:10:07.180
For example, I have family members who used to be a member of the Raj Nation and went like
1.00
00:10:13.300
They just jumped from one harder culture to another harder culture instead of just being
00:10:18.500
So it seems like people tend to gravitate towards hard and soft cultures.
00:10:22.120
And I think that people who are very vehement critics of other cultures are demonstrating
00:10:29.120
the personality tendencies, the behavioral tendencies that drive one to religiosity in the first
00:10:35.220
They just happen to be bowing down to the cult or religion of progressivism, of woke, of whatever
00:10:44.140
And the people who deconvert from hard religions are naturally those whose behavioral and personality
0.99
00:10:51.300
characteristics are less hardline on any sort of culture.
00:10:56.760
They don't gravitate toward that very hard culture.
00:11:01.460
And they're more likely to spin out of hard religions because they just don't have a very
1.00
00:11:09.240
So that's why I think those who have deconverted tend to be a little bit more tempered and reasonable,
00:11:13.360
whereas those who never deconverted from their culture and have yet devoted their careers
00:11:20.300
to a great extent to this kind of commentary and criticism are more vehement.
00:11:28.620
I suspect it's most cultural and genetic because this is something we just see more generally.
00:11:34.460
And it's something that we've talked about on our channel before is a lot of people think
00:11:37.880
like they have left the culture they were born in.
00:11:43.540
And you see the downstream effects of being outside of a hard cultural group, like a religious
00:11:48.580
cultural group, doesn't really show up in individual personality until about two or three
00:11:57.020
And the Mormons who have deconverted were still raised was in Mormon culture.
00:12:01.280
I also think that there's genetic effects here.
00:12:04.040
When I engage with both Mormons and ex-Mormons, both groups I find just, and again, this is probably
1.00
00:12:11.680
a cross between culture and genetics, unusually pleasant people to interact with.
00:12:38.640
Well, this is actually an interesting thing where a lot of people see us, you and me,
00:12:43.280
and they're like, you guys look like brother and sister.
00:12:50.220
And we're like, you look at the Puritan spotting checklist that Scott Alexander wrote, and we
00:12:54.420
were like, off the charts on this, you look at the old of the cultural group, which both
00:13:01.000
of us come from, and I'll put it on the screen here, pictures of Calvinist women.
00:13:04.440
They look all like Simone sisters, or you can put up like famous Calvinists as a group
0.54
00:13:09.840
that I was in from, the group that like founded the Free State of Jones, the John Brown group.
00:13:14.200
You put like a picture of John Brown, and you're like, both behaviorally and physiologically,
00:13:22.940
We need to find that painting where there's some concerned people behind him.
00:13:27.080
So it's more just that we're part of an ethno-cultural group that had a pretty isolated gene pool for
00:13:33.580
a long time that you're just not as familiar with, but it doesn't mean that we aren't also
00:13:39.800
So I suspect that's what we're seeing with the Mormon community, is one, a culture which
00:13:44.620
actually does a pretty good job of creating good action at the end of it.
00:13:49.340
So in our Wikipedia article about us, there is a section on it where it quotes one of my
00:13:54.340
quotes, and I'm actually quite glad they quoted this, because they were talking about my relationship
00:14:01.120
I grew up troubled teen industry, everything like that, which I was sent to by court order,
00:14:05.760
But what I said is, if a parent raises good children, like children who are happy with
00:14:10.260
themselves, happy with their lives, and successful by any secular metric, how can I say that they
00:14:18.720
And the Platt family, the Fundy Snark did a series of videos.
00:14:24.620
Mentioning that all of their kids seem so healthy and happy and well-adjusted, and yet
00:14:31.020
And I'm like, do you see what's coming out of progressive culture?
00:14:36.000
These people are coming out like mentally broken individuals.
0.83
00:14:46.300
Pew found that over half of all white liberal women under the age of 30 have a mental health
00:14:53.140
issue, and just across the board, among this ultra-progressive cultural group, as you can
00:14:58.520
see here, there's just much higher rates of mental health issues than there is in the
00:15:04.880
And this is why I'm so unpersuaded when ultra-progressives are like, why don't you just raise children the
00:15:11.760
Because I'm like, anyone can see, whether I'm looking at the data or I'm just looking at
00:15:16.680
the people I know, that whatever the thing is that you're doing with your kids, it's leading
00:15:27.120
Whereas I just don't see the same thing coming out of conservative households, even when these
0.96
00:15:33.160
kids grow up in childhoods that progressives claim or love to mentally masturbate about
00:15:40.460
mentally breaking these kids or causing them to need therapy when they're adults or causing
00:15:46.820
But really, they're just saying, oh, these are hooks we could use to pull them out of their
00:15:50.980
Not that they're actually pointing out things that are genuinely damaging to these kids.
00:15:55.800
And another really interesting thing I see from a cultural perspective, like the more
00:16:01.200
on the cult spectrum they are, these individuals, whenever they see somebody acting non-culturally
00:16:07.100
normative, their perspective is always to say, get out there and go to a therapist.
00:16:13.980
And as we've talked about, if you look at modern therapy, and you can watch our videos on
00:16:18.640
therapy become a cult, this is an industry I was trained in.
00:16:21.620
They do a bunch of stuff that we were explicitly warned against doing in the early 2000s.
00:16:25.800
They do a bunch of stuff like trauma therapy is what I call it, which is really, they've
00:16:30.880
taken the concept of thetans and they've just inserted the word trauma.
00:16:34.460
And it is much closer to Scientology from the 90s and 80s than it is to what therapy was
00:16:43.320
And this isn't just on Fundy Snark channels either.
00:16:46.180
What's really interesting is across YouTube channels and podcasts, I hear this coming up
00:16:49.840
a lot, like when someone is in, especially the therapy cult, it shows up and they talk
00:16:57.100
They talk a lot about their therapists and how it's very important that people get therapy.
00:17:09.540
And so when they want to convert somebody, they send them to therapists because therapists
00:17:14.080
do two things really well, this cult version of therapy that really is more similar to
00:17:20.820
Scientology from the 80s, is they do a very good job of breaking an individual's connections
00:17:25.160
to their birth culture and family and convincing them that all of this stuff, that if it's not
00:17:29.760
culturally normative, i.e. if it's not part of the urban monoculture, it is trauma, it
00:17:34.960
And they use that to break them from these groups, which cults always do.
00:17:38.700
The first thing a cult always does is try to break you from your family.
00:17:40.880
But they also do a very good job of creating this sort of original sin narrative around
00:17:45.520
the concept of trauma, which historically we would have known a therapist's job is to
00:17:50.960
help somebody emotionally heal, not to create dependency.
00:17:58.280
And you can make more money by creating dependency, which is why this model of therapy out-competed.
00:18:02.820
So do you want to go further on any of these topics before I get into probably the most
00:18:12.280
I think people watch Fundy Snark for a bunch of different reasons, and some it's just cultural
00:18:19.600
I think a lot of it, which is important and it shouldn't be understated, is that people
00:18:25.700
who come from a soft culture and just don't really have a lot of firmly held beliefs or
00:18:30.680
traditions or restraints on their lives feel, and I felt this a lot when I was a kid, which
00:18:35.780
is why I'm bringing it up, this strange fascination with people who come from weird cultures and
1.00
00:18:42.200
have a structured life and have these structured beliefs.
00:18:45.380
And they may say that they hate these people, these religious fundamentalists, but they will
0.89
00:18:51.580
They will follow these people on Instagram and across other channels and watch and maybe
00:18:59.800
But I think maybe even subconsciously, there's a lot of watching that goes on just because
00:19:06.280
there's something compelling and comforting about it.
00:19:14.840
And even Paris socially experienced that lifestyle without actually living it.
00:19:18.500
And without actually feeling like you're condoning it because these are snark channels.
00:19:25.900
And I think that's what a lot of this is about.
00:19:28.320
I also really, the more vehement and you would say like unfair channels like Fundy Fridays,
00:19:34.380
because they provide such a stark contrast of the cultural extremes that we've arrived at
00:19:41.700
Because as you say, like you're cherry picking extremes.
00:19:45.360
This is the libs of TikTok of the flipped version.
00:19:51.160
And it really helps you see what the differences are.
00:19:57.340
If someone needs to know what the differences between weird conservatism and weird progressivism
00:20:02.020
are, watch one of these channels and you'll know where they fall on marriage, on child
00:20:06.280
rearing, on therapy, on trauma, on pets, on how to deal with social media, on jobs, on really
00:20:22.440
So I'm going to get to two fairly offensive points.
00:20:24.840
One is Rachel Oates, who I think is the most extreme version of the Arab monoculture, just
1.00
00:20:30.300
join us, is her arguments, because you see this across videos and I see this across Fundy
00:20:36.460
And she was actually talking about the other Collins family, the more famous Collins family
00:20:40.580
than us, which is this really delightful interracial couple.
00:20:44.580
Carissa using her kids to push her anti-choice, pro-natalist beliefs.
0.84
00:20:52.520
I, the more I learn about them and see people criticizing them, because I find that you can
00:20:57.620
learn about somebody through the individuals who criticize them really well, because I'm
00:21:01.400
like, okay, if this is the worst you could air about them, they seem like delightful people
00:21:08.340
One of the core complaints they had, very similar to us, was like, it'd be better off
00:21:13.800
to have, quote unquote, higher quality, fewer kids other than more kids.
00:21:22.080
And she's just, this is like an obviously true thing.
00:21:24.800
In her next line, she said, don't stop because they can't be in every extracurricular activity
00:21:30.060
Are we really going to base the value of our children's lives on how many activities they
00:21:34.920
And I know Carissa would disagree with me, but I honestly think it's better to help one
00:21:38.820
child really flourish and reach their potential than it is to birth five children who are struggling
00:21:47.420
I feel like so many people like Carissa like to use the excuse of, well, we're scraping
00:21:53.300
And I just feel like as someone who grew up like that, it's not enough.
00:21:57.580
So what Rachel is saying here is she doesn't want these children to exist because they will
0.57
00:22:05.380
live childhoods that are equivalent to her own childhood.
00:22:09.960
Is she really saying that she would be better off not existing, that her childhood was so
00:22:21.100
Because that's what she is denying other people with this argument, a life equivalent to her
00:22:31.860
And I really don't think that that's the perspective she's taking.
00:22:34.780
She genuinely doesn't consider that she is denying an entire human being who will live
00:22:42.080
an entire life the optionality of existence just so another child can get more extracurriculars
00:22:50.060
or have marginally more financial security, which to me is obviously unethical.
00:22:58.220
But this is the standard moral framework that progressive they're using right now.
00:23:01.780
And I'm like, that is like such a like morally horrifying position to me.
00:23:06.700
And I think it's why the urban monoculture will ultimately die is this belief that human
00:23:14.820
And it's just so bizarre to me because it's like this weird, like ultra Catholic belief,
00:23:20.000
but also urban monoculture belief, which is to say that, oh yeah, I know my kids, but
00:23:24.940
if I could marginally, marginally is really what it is here, improve the lives of my other
00:23:30.600
kids and adopt parenting practices, they're more normalized for the urban monoculture's
00:23:35.340
perspective by raising my kids more in line with their value system, which requires fewer
00:23:41.000
kids, really all this no corporal punishment, just you can't, if you have multiple boys,
00:23:47.860
There's no corporal punishment system requires you being able to body check a kid, stay on
00:23:53.640
top of them, basically, if they're doing something really bad.
00:23:56.520
And if you have other kids, that's not an option, right?
00:24:00.000
And they're like, yeah, then you just shouldn't have more, right?
00:24:03.040
And so it's like, why do they take these bizarre perspectives?
00:24:05.420
As we've argued, it's because their culture evolved these perspectives because it uses them
00:24:12.200
People in their culture almost never have kids, or at least at above repopulation rate,
00:24:17.680
And so for that reason, they don't really need to be good at childbearing themselves.
00:24:22.140
They just need to be good at implanting trauma around the perception of trauma.
00:24:26.820
And as we pointed out on studies of trauma, that the effects of trauma are more correlated
00:24:30.580
with a belief of trauma than actually having trauma.
00:24:33.920
There was that great study done that showed when you correlate people who say how much
00:24:38.480
trauma they have, it correlates with their level of psychological dysfunction.
00:24:41.920
However, if you then go back to their childhoods and you look for court records of this and stuff
00:24:47.160
like this, where you can find actual proof of trauma, even in people who say that they're
00:24:52.800
If you find proof that there wasn't actually trauma, and people who say that they're traumatized,
00:24:57.140
So implanting trauma is actually really important in creating this dependency on the urban monoculture.
00:25:01.980
But then I think we have the worst case of this, which has been the appropriation of the
00:25:07.640
gay community, which I think we see on Fundy Fridays.
00:25:10.980
I'm going to, Fundy Fridays, which sees herself, and I don't think that she's doing any of this
00:25:16.820
I just think it's part of the cult that she's in, and she doesn't understand the negative
00:25:22.980
I really like Fundy Fridays, and I really like Jen, who's the main host of Fundy Fridays,
00:25:28.400
But yeah, she's in a very different culture, and she has...
1.00
00:25:36.040
And the cult has done some really questionable things.
00:25:39.280
She's in as much of a cult as the people who she covers.
00:25:43.280
They all come from very strong cultures that have skews and blind spots because of those
1.00
00:25:48.560
Not to say that we don't have blind spots either, but still.
00:25:51.280
Yeah, everybody has their cultural blind spots.
00:25:53.640
But one that just, oh, it grades my nails when I'm watching her channel is she really sees
00:25:57.920
herself as like a spokesperson for queer people and queer culture.
00:26:02.160
And I will put a picture on screen of her and her husband.
00:26:05.340
And people might be like, how dare you question this aspect of her identity?
00:26:09.220
And I'm like, look, I'm going to play a video of her playing race detective with the people
00:26:14.680
I'm not sure the ethnicity of her mother, and I swear I have a reason to bring this up
1.00
00:26:18.640
because I am aware that it is problematic for me as a white person to ask, where are you from?
00:26:24.660
I'm only bringing it up because Kat identifies as Latina.
00:26:28.820
I know a lot of you guys, but I know a lot of you guys don't know that I am myself a proud Latina.
00:26:34.920
I was born in Mexico, in Monte Morelos, in Nuevo Leon.
00:26:38.940
I know that a lot of people just assume that I'm white because I was not lucky enough to
00:26:43.520
inherit my mom's really beautiful dark skin.
0.99
00:26:47.420
But I think that it's important too that people know that us Latinas come in all different
00:26:51.880
I'm trying to call her something that she's not, but I have to report on what I think.
00:27:03.960
And given that she is the type of person who, when she is investigating the way somebody else
00:27:10.700
is approaching life, she would say, well, you don't look Latina to me.
00:27:14.380
Therefore, I am going to doubt your Latina identity, even though you personally identify
1.00
00:27:23.760
And so while I personally wouldn't doubt somebody's racial heritage or identity just because they
00:27:30.180
didn't look a certain way, I can see the logic in doing it.
00:27:33.560
Because if you don't look sufficiently Latina, then you're not going to experience the racism
00:27:41.880
And therefore, it's not good for you to use that identity as a cover for your words and actions.
00:27:47.780
But this all would apply equally well to the accusation I am making here.
00:27:53.500
To be more specific, there is a big difference between being an oppressed minority and identifying
00:28:03.180
If the thing that grants you inclusion into that minority group is not causing you to be
00:28:11.900
oppressed in the way that other members of that group are being oppressed, the oppressed
00:28:16.740
minority status is nothing but a benefit to you because you get to feel like a victim and
0.97
00:28:21.200
identify as a victim without any of the negative consequences of actually being a victim.
00:28:43.160
Lifting up skirts and pulling down pants and just getting in there with your magnifying
00:28:46.720
By the way, if you're wondering why Jen identifies as queer, like what specific type of queer
0.77
00:28:52.600
she thinks she is, Simone has watched literally all of her videos or about all of her videos
00:28:57.840
and she says she can't remember her ever saying.
00:28:59.920
I did some research on the side and the answer that I seem to pull is that she considers herself
00:29:07.000
and her husband considers himself non-binary and their pronouns are her and they and him
00:29:15.220
You know, I don't want to ever misgender someone because I don't particularly, like it's not
0.99
00:29:21.280
important to me and it really hurts some people.
00:29:24.700
So, you know, why would I do something that hurts somebody if there's no benefit to me?
00:29:28.160
So, that's where I think she comes into the queer community.
00:29:32.780
But the article where I pulled that from, unfortunately, was really confusingly worded and I'm not sure
00:29:39.780
if those pronouns or that gender identity claim was referring to them or another influencer
00:29:51.800
This is not me acting outside of the rules that she has set for herself.
00:29:56.800
I'm only doing it because I know that she's okay with playing like race detective and stuff like this.
00:30:00.620
But I look at her and her husband and I'm like, okay, so here's the core problem with this leftist idea
00:30:07.000
that you shouldn't put any gating on the queer community and that if you have dyed hair
00:30:11.620
and snogged a girl in college that you're queer because you don't have to deal with the consequences
0.98
00:30:18.000
because you don't, to everyone else in the world, you look like a straight couple.
1.00
00:30:22.620
You don't have to deal with the consequences of the shit that you are saying
0.99
00:30:26.740
in terms of how that affects the queer community.
0.99
00:30:30.080
When you get out there and you, as somebody who's really just,
00:30:34.620
and we could identify as queer if we wanted to because we are agender,
00:30:38.160
as I constantly point out, by the LGBT community, like extremist cult standards,
1.00
00:30:43.460
not like real gays and lesbians who, depending on the study you're looking at,
00:30:47.680
45% of gay men voted for Trump or it might be a third of gay men in another study.
00:30:52.580
You're like, okay, you got to go for the smaller study because then people believe it more.
00:30:55.360
But you're looking at a pretty big percentage of these people who actually have to live with this.
00:30:58.980
People are like, why are so many like actually gay people have to live with the fact that they're gay?
00:31:03.880
Who have to live with the fact that they're trans, right?
1.00
00:31:06.560
And people around them can see this, support the Republican policies.
00:31:09.580
It's because what are the anti-trans, anti-LGBT, quote unquote, Republican policies?
1.00
00:31:15.340
There's shit like trans people shouldn't be on sports teams
1.00
00:31:17.960
and trans people shouldn't be using bathrooms that don't confirm with their birth gender.
1.00
00:31:22.880
And for a lot of people who can't escape this gay and trans identity,
1.00
00:31:28.540
And in Fundy Freddy, this is not me misinterpreting this shit that they're saying.
0.96
00:31:33.160
They have a full video just on these two topics.
0.96
00:31:36.080
It's first of all, anyone who's, I think, sane and being honest
00:31:39.600
knows that these people shouldn't be on sports teams.
00:31:44.340
And the fact that it's blatantly unfair causes blowback to real trans people.
00:31:49.120
If you're a real trans person, you infinitely would prefer not having a society that has
1.00
00:31:56.780
a reason to hate you and see you as a cheater over getting to participate in the sports team
00:32:04.800
Like, there are not people out there killing themselves because they're not getting to play
00:32:12.360
Lots of kids go through their childhood without any option to play inter-moral sports.
00:32:18.600
And I don't see any leftists freaking out that these kids are going to end up killing themselves.
00:32:26.220
And these are positions that you would only argue if you didn't have to deal with the consequences
00:32:33.180
that are going to come from creating these sorts of carve-outs.
00:32:37.260
Because, of course, as soon as you create a carve-out of this,
00:32:41.640
As soon as you create a carve-out around a certain segment of society where it's harder
0.98
00:32:47.120
to call them out for things, of course some aggressive male cisgender sex pests are going
0.99
00:32:54.460
And it's pretty easy to see that this is happening.
00:32:57.220
A trans person who desperately wants to be seen as a particular gender identity is not
00:33:04.320
going to, when their body looks nothing like that gender identity, go and participate in
0.86
00:33:10.800
a sport where everyone is going to be furious in them because it seems that they have some
00:33:15.580
huge advantage over everyone else, which they obviously do, and then walk around the locker
0.99
00:33:22.900
room like Leah Thomas swinging their penis about in front of full view in front of everyone.
1.00
00:33:29.160
They're not going to do that, and they would want laws in place that prevent people from doing that
0.99
00:33:37.500
And the blowback that that causes the trans community is infinitely worse than any benefit
0.99
00:33:45.120
The laws that Republicans are fighting for that prevent people from doing things like this, using
0.81
00:33:53.840
a trans identity as a shield, ultimately are most beneficial out of everyone they benefit in
00:34:05.020
If you go to somebody who isn't just in this far lefty cult and they're like, would you rather
00:34:10.340
live in a world in which you don't get to participate in the sports team you want to participate in,
0.98
00:34:15.700
but you don't have to deal with aggressive cis male sex pests walking around naked in women's
0.98
00:34:24.580
locker rooms while calling themselves trans and you facing the blowback for that, or one in which
0.99
00:34:29.420
you do have to deal with that and your meager reward is getting to participate in the sports
00:34:37.680
Anyone who's actually like, I just want society to see me for my gender, is going to be like,
00:34:43.620
And these individuals are okay with holding these sorts of positions because they don't
00:34:48.140
have to personally deal with the blowback, because they don't have to walk around every
00:34:52.640
day looking like a trans person, looking like queer people, holding hands with somebody of
00:35:01.260
And this is why these sorts of opt-in queer identities, if anything for them, it's a benefit
1.00
00:35:08.180
because now they look even more like a victim when they're opting into the victim identity
00:35:13.100
that they can just throw off whenever they're in public.
00:35:18.960
Yeah, there was a South Park and I'll include a clip from it here because they know it does.
00:35:23.900
There are just so many amazing women athletes out here today.
1.00
00:35:27.140
Now, this is the first year that a trans woman is in the competition.
00:35:33.980
I have a lot of incredible trans friends who are athletes, and so we're all inspired.
00:35:38.580
And, uh, have you actually ever met Heather Swanson?
00:35:41.640
She's not exactly your average trans athlete.
0.97
00:35:50.360
Miss Swanson, how does it feel to be competing today?
00:35:53.180
I can't tell you how free I feel now that I've started identifying as a woman.
00:36:07.360
Or this, he repeats, he's, oh, it's a complete myth that trans people ever, or really, cis males
00:36:14.720
ever use trans bathroom protections to assault women.
0.81
00:36:19.200
And it's, no, even the studies that are trying to argue it's a myth say it does happen.
00:36:24.340
They just argue it, and I'll put up a statistic on screen here, like a study on screen here.
00:36:28.400
They just say it doesn't happen more when this law is out there.
00:36:32.140
And it's like, do you really think you could get a study published that showed that it
00:36:37.400
Like, if you publish that study at any mainstream U.S. university, you would be at risk of being
00:36:42.420
fired, I mean, very obviously, and you would likely be at personal risk walking around campus,
00:36:51.800
You know, the benefit would be so potentially low from most individual academic perspectives
00:37:00.980
And people who don't understand this type of pressure that academics are under, I think
00:37:04.100
often willfully don't understand it or ignore it, and ignore just how extreme the college
00:37:11.560
Whether it's lesbians who are like, I feel really uncomfortable because a lot of transitioned
1.00
00:37:17.160
women who now identify as lesbians, some of these are cis men, six cis pests, who wanted
0.93
00:37:24.640
to get into lesbian dating apps and pester women, and they found a cultural cheat code to do that.
1.00
00:37:29.460
And if you're like, no, a creepy cis male would never do this, of course they would.
0.89
00:37:35.280
And yet, now when lesbians try to create lesbians who actually have to deal with the fact that
1.00
00:37:40.180
they're actually lesbians and only want to date people who present phenotypically female,
0.89
00:37:44.460
which this person clearly isn't, they have to deal with this.
00:37:47.540
Like in Australia, you might not know this, but there was a case recently where the owner
00:37:51.000
of a dating app is being sued because the dating app used AI to determine if the face of
00:37:57.820
the person who is signing up looked more phenotypically female.
00:38:00.260
So this with the dating app that, by the way, let people in if they were trained.
00:38:07.040
If they didn't pass, they were like, no, because this is for people who prefer phenotypical
00:38:11.620
That women cannot find these private spaces, that lesbians can't find these private spaces
1.00
00:38:15.540
anymore is actually a problem for individuals who have a phenotypical female preference.
1.00
00:38:20.960
And you are saying in the legislation that you're pushing that they shouldn't be allowed.
00:38:25.820
Like you are dismissing the people who have to actually live with the fact that they are
00:38:31.140
same sex attracted or you get the push down of this in school, which happened to us recently.
00:38:35.900
So I'll read a quote here because this happened just right next door to us where a Pennsylvania
00:38:41.420
This was like a 13 year old, by the way, spoke out furiously against teachers and administrators
00:38:45.460
at her school for a transgender student, savagely beating her friend using a Stanley cup.
00:38:56.400
Yeah, you could cut a bitch with it, I'm sure.
1.00
00:38:59.000
When the 13 year old blindsided a 12 year old female victim in the school cafeteria using
00:39:03.400
a cup, hitting her on the head and creating an open wound, the unidentified student had
0.84
00:39:07.700
to be hospitalized and get staples to close the cuts in her head before undertaking concussion
00:39:14.120
However, as one student said, not only did she warn the teachers, the bullying student had
00:39:19.840
a quote unquote hit list, but she added that she was the next one to get assaulted and that
0.79
00:39:27.740
The girl said it was five hours from when I told you it was going to happen.
00:39:32.360
I don't get how you couldn't have stopped that.
00:39:35.020
She added that the girl was bullying her and targeting her every day at lunch.
0.99
00:39:38.220
And you might be wondering, like, how is somebody getting away with this?
00:39:41.480
And it's because they're afraid if they end this, if they apply any disciplinary measures
00:39:47.340
to people of this protected category in our society, if they say, no, you can't go in the
00:39:52.820
restrooms, no, you can't, that this is going to cause a apoplectic freak out from this extremist
1.00
00:40:01.200
If they had come in and said, you appear to be bullying, et cetera, that person could easily
00:40:10.120
Who are like historically, like actually born with a different gender presentation.
00:40:19.220
They understand that they have what is essentially a fairly rare condition and that all of society
00:40:28.000
And that, yes, that might mean that they have to use restrooms at home more often, or they
0.98
00:40:32.000
have to feel uncomfortable sometimes the same way extremely fat people do on airplanes.
00:40:36.740
Like I don't love that fat people have to feel uncomfortable or buy two seats on an airplane,
00:40:41.420
but realistically we can't adopt all airplanes.
00:40:48.660
They know that when society begins to bend over backwards in ways, because of course, if you
00:40:53.480
create this protected class, if you say any male looking individual who says they identify
00:40:57.840
as a woman can now use women's bathrooms, then some tests are going to take advantage of that.
1.00
00:41:02.120
They don't want that happening because that has blowback on them who can't hide.
00:41:07.540
But when you're one of these individuals like Fundy Stark who can just say, oh, I'm gender
00:41:12.600
whatever, but not look in a way where you can't escape the blowback that you are causing for
00:41:20.860
That is genuinely bad for society and bad for the real LGBTQ community.
1.00
00:41:27.300
And you could look at people like us who could claim to be trans because we are agender, which
00:41:31.260
is genderqueer, which would qualify as agender.
00:41:34.980
Sorry, for normal people who don't know what agender is, that basically means I don't feel a strong
00:41:40.200
If I woke up tomorrow, a woman, I wouldn't care.
1.00
00:41:42.280
If Simone woke up tomorrow, a man, she wouldn't care.
0.91
00:41:49.580
I identify as asexual, but gay for Malcolm.
0.94
00:41:55.560
We would fall squarely in the queer community, but I don't say I'm in the queer community.
00:42:03.060
I just try to protect them because I view of I am not a gender presentation that causes
00:42:16.740
Yeah, like I don't walk around telling people that I have an autism diagnosis because I don't
00:42:30.560
I could probably get some special services in some cases, but I'm not going to do that
00:42:37.520
And I think that the resources that should be expended on people who need help should
00:42:44.400
And this is why when we're looking at statistics on voting records to find out like the way
00:42:48.740
these communities actually are, I look at like gay males, for example, instead of general
00:42:54.180
Because if you look at general LGBT statistics, 14% vote Republican, only 14%.
00:42:59.240
It's not the 45% or one third that you see in other studies of when it's just gay men.
00:43:03.520
Because people like this couple, who to me are a straight heterosexual couple in terms
00:43:11.060
of how they present to society, except for like the dyed hair, are just identifying into
00:43:16.780
this queer definition and then polluting the statistics while also causing a blowback on
00:43:29.720
You can actually see it in the statistics, which is support for the queer community has
00:43:34.180
been declining in recent years because of people like this who are saying you cannot be queer
00:43:44.480
I would say you can't be queer supportive and a Democrat because they're supporting the
1.00
00:43:47.500
sex pests who are blowing back incredible negative feelings towards the real trans individuals,
0.98
00:43:55.400
the real just born attracted to the same sex individuals.
0.98
00:44:00.420
And because they are taking this position, they are forcing people on the other side to
00:44:13.720
They are establishing that as a cultural norm.
0.99
00:44:16.480
Even though by the statistics, it's not fucking true.
0.89
00:44:21.540
More than half of Republicans, even when you're talking about older Republicans, you're looking
0.95
00:44:25.960
at 65% of you're talking about young Republicans, but even older Republicans, more than half
00:44:36.000
They're making up a fantasy world that makes them feel like good guys when they are not good
00:44:41.400
guys and they are causing the very harassment that they claim to be fighting against.
00:44:46.380
One thing I wonder is how many people watching all Fundy Snark channels, including the more
00:44:54.380
moderate ones of deconverted Mormons, for example, come from the enemy's field, as it were, are
00:45:01.860
similar to me, somewhat conservative, not agreeing with everything, all the criticism, but just
00:45:09.500
enjoying it. And similar to those who are super progressive, but who follow the accounts of
00:45:15.980
these conservative influencers because they just kind of find it interesting. Do you think that
00:45:20.400
there's a decent number of conservatives and religious fundamentalists who watch these channels
00:45:27.400
I don't think so. That would be like asking, are there a decent number of people in this far
00:45:30.700
urban monoculture cult that watch lives of TikTok? I really don't think that many people
00:45:35.820
cross the border that much, but I guess we'll hear from our audience because I imagine our
00:45:42.600
Yeah, we'll see if they like Fundy Snark as much. And these people will eventually be covering
00:45:47.060
us. We've actually reached out to them because we're open to working with anyone who covers
00:45:50.260
us, even if it's in a negative context. We're always open to interviews. We're always open
00:45:53.980
to talk. I believe that the light of truce destroys evil most effectively. And I think that
00:46:01.060
when people intentionally don't engage with us, and we've reached out to Fundy Snark, for
00:46:06.080
example, by the way, to do videos together and stuff like that.
00:46:09.120
Fundy Fridays, yeah. And some of the other people we've reached out to, we are always
00:46:12.680
open to do videos with people who are ideologically different from us because we think a genuinely
00:46:18.200
ideologically diverse community, not diverse TM, i.e. the approved ideologies by the urban
00:46:23.400
monoculture, but actually diverse community is the strongest community for our country.
00:46:28.700
And I think that Jen of Fundy Fridays comes from a good place and genuinely cares for these
00:46:33.580
people. Like, sometimes bad things happen to the people that she covers, and she...
00:46:37.800
Oh, no, absolutely. No, I see her very much the way that I see some of the people she covers.
00:46:43.880
Yeah, no, from an extremist position in the culture. That's why I hold my stance,
00:46:48.100
that my hypothesis is that she is of the same hard culture profile as the religious fundamentalists
0.95
00:46:56.360
that she covers. She just happens to be wearing a different team's colors, and so she has to...
00:47:01.400
Yeah, and they're insane religious cults. They're the good guys in her insane religious cult. She's
0.88
00:47:06.940
the good guy, and she's doing what the cult is telling her to do. She's just never stepping back.
00:47:11.620
She'd started tongue-in-cheek that are frills of the channel now, still speak very much,
00:47:16.780
are similar to the small-time career preachers that she criticizes. Her followers call themselves
00:47:23.160
Jenna Knights, and they patronize her. And how is that different from being a preacher? In the end,
00:47:28.940
preachers speak to people. They cultivate communities. They have some merch sometimes.
00:47:34.020
There's a... Ooh, vomit. There's just a lot of parallels. And so I just... I think that
00:47:38.940
one thing is fun is it's just like watching a little flame war between preachers. And yeah,
00:47:44.900
I would just say to anyone watching this, don't think we think she's not well-meaning. We just...
00:47:48.480
But I think that most of the people she criticizes are well-meaning.
00:47:51.500
Yeah, I agree. And yes, I do agree that the stance of saying that you are... that you stand for
00:47:58.080
a queer community when you aren't necessarily like subject to the...
0.94
00:48:07.060
Not exactly. There's no rule saying you can't say you're queer. We can say we're queer if we want
0.62
00:48:11.280
to, and we have every right to say that we're queer. We just...
00:48:13.080
Well, no, we can say we're queer, and we would be right to say we're queer if we wanted to. But I don't
00:48:17.180
believe in this identifying with a community when you are not subject to these struggles. In the
00:48:23.960
same way that she would criticize people on her show as like the woman where she was doing the
00:48:28.360
is she really this race thing? She's trying to figure out if she had a right to call herself Latina
1.00
00:48:33.060
because she didn't look Latina. And that's exactly what we're saying. Do you have a right to call
0.84
00:48:38.120
yourself queer and claim the struggles of that community when you don't look queer, when you look
0.85
00:48:43.220
like you're in a heterosexual marriage? And there's a lot of stuff within the queer community where
00:48:47.000
it used to be like, when you get married, it doesn't mean you're no longer bi. It's like, yeah,
00:48:51.020
but you're no longer functionally undergoing the struggles that are unique to bi people in our
00:48:57.260
current society. It does mean that you are not a marginalized community member anymore from the
00:49:04.920
perspective of your lived experience in terms of how that community is dealing with struggles.
00:49:10.480
And so you no longer have to deal with the blowback of your extremist actions, like saying, oh, yeah,
0.90
00:49:18.460
trans people should be allowed on women's sports teams, when that's obviously ridiculous.
1.00
00:49:30.620
And I love how you always try to see the best in people. You are a genuinely good person.
00:49:36.480
person. And I think that as we often say, righteousness isn't determined by an intention
00:49:42.820
to be a good person, because almost everyone intends to be a good person. It's determined by
00:49:47.380
how realistic in terms of the actual downstream effects your view of reality is. The more educated
00:49:56.660
you are on what reality actually is, and the less you are part of just one ideological tribe,
00:50:01.680
the better. And we see with her channel, like in one video, she was lauding communism, for example,
00:50:07.940
like maybe one day there'll be a full communist, she said is a good thing. And I just personally,
00:50:12.340
as somebody who values pragmatism and like the way things actually work when tried to be a person who
00:50:19.100
lauds communism is just to say, I am okay with in exchange for good boy points, i.e. thinking of
00:50:27.580
myself as a good person and having other people see me as a good person, the painful and slow deaths
00:50:32.800
of millions of people, starting often with the minority populations and the most disenfranchised
00:50:39.060
in a society, which is what actually happens when communists come into power.
00:50:42.720
But as I learned from Lemon Month, our holiday in which we engage with subjects we find offensive,
00:50:48.480
I have learned that real communism has not been tried, okay? It is a post-singularity sci-fi world.
00:50:55.560
That is what communism is. That's what it always was. And the big problem with communism is that
00:51:00.880
people are trying it now when we literally don't have the technology for it.
00:51:03.640
We could do a whole episode on this, but I just want to explain the point for people who don't
00:51:07.940
know what she said here. I'm just defending Jen here. She's arguing that in the early days,
00:51:12.500
communism, I don't believe that's what she's arguing for, said that communism can only be tried
00:51:17.000
once we're in a post-scarcity environment. And so some communists are now arguing, yeah,
00:51:21.400
real communism has never been tried definitionally because we're not in a post-scarcity environment.
00:51:25.040
But if somebody is fighting for communism today, because we don't have the technology to create
00:51:30.320
a genuine- If you're fighting for communism today, you should shut your mouth because
00:51:34.120
you should be fighting for AGI and superintelligence that is aligned with human flourishing. Because
00:51:41.060
that is what will herald in true communism. Yes. So you really have to be either a government fascist
00:51:49.020
with an AI department, or you have to be a huge capitalist and raise tons of money to do
00:51:54.920
private AI development. This is actually something I've noticed more broadly between
00:52:00.260
the leftist-rightist divide within the current political environment, not the political environment
00:52:05.240
of the 90s, which is what modern leftists often like to pretend that we are still fighting. But in
00:52:11.060
the current environment, what it really is, is do you actually care about solving a problem?
00:52:15.900
Are you looking for good boy points? So you look at something like the leftist myth that there is a
00:52:21.540
rightist- It's just insane that there's a significant racist base among the right wing. And I will beat
00:52:29.520
this until the clowns come home. 538 polling, very mainstream, Nate Silver. Until Obama was elected,
0.99
00:52:36.240
more white Democrats than white Republicans said they would not vote for a black president. And even now,
00:52:41.780
the difference in racist attitudes between the two parties' bases is marginal. And when you look at
00:52:48.260
the actual effects that the two parties' policies have on racial disparity, you get more of it from
00:52:56.560
the left. When a left-wing government has been in power in the United States in a region for a period,
00:53:02.200
the IQ scores and incomes of both black and Hispanic populations are more distanced from the local
00:53:10.300
white population than when Republicans have been in power. And it's because these systems that they
0.55
00:53:16.200
put in place, you know, affirmative action, everything like that, they are performative good boy point
00:53:22.540
systems, but they make the underlying problems worse. And I think that that's the core difference
00:53:27.760
between rightists and leftists in the modern sense. It's will you sacrifice your public image to
00:53:32.900
attempt to actually fix a problem? Or are you just interested in looking good? And I actually think that
00:53:41.540
this is also what we're seeing with the current Israel-Gaza conflict, because there are not many real
00:53:49.060
pleasant solutions to the current geopolitical issue in that region. And if you actually implemented most of
00:53:56.500
the left-wing solutions, you're going to deal with a scale of death and oppression in the region that is
00:54:04.260
astronomical. I love you to death. You're amazing. And you are so understanding of other people and cultures.
00:54:13.040
If they bring Snark, I'm for them. It doesn't matter.
00:54:15.840
If the Snark candles cover us, they're going to be like, oh my god, their children should be dead!
0.97
00:54:20.500
I'm going to say they should have never been born, but there's no difference.
00:54:27.540
How can you slap? How can you slap? How can you slap? How can you slap me?
00:54:36.320
How can they slap? That's what they say. That's what they say. How can they slap?
00:54:39.520
How could they slap? And how dare she have her baby on the screen? That's going to be a big one.
1.00
00:54:44.400
Yeah. How could they practice corporal punishment? How could they not make their house incredibly warm
00:54:48.460
during the winter? How could they have so many kids if they can't? I don't know. I really don't know.
00:54:55.080
I'm running out of things, but it's usually those things.
00:54:57.860
Oh, and they put too much on their kids because they expect things of them and encourage them to.
00:55:03.100
Yeah. How dare they have expectations? Intergenerational cultural expectations.
00:55:07.040
And that's another thing that gets me. And we'll probably do a full episode on this, but I'll just end it with this.
00:55:11.140
Where people are like, how dare you say that people owe their ancestors anything, right?
00:55:17.140
I'm like, if somebody gave you $100 and said, you go, what do I owe you for this?
00:55:24.380
And then you took that money and you spent it on drugs and pornography, right?
00:55:28.580
Like just something totally selfish. You are a bad and vile person.
1.00
00:55:33.180
And I am glad that people like you won't exist in the future.
1.00
00:55:35.420
If somebody makes, not, doesn't give you $100, they make enormous sacrifices to give you life, life.
00:55:43.960
And they say, and you say, what do I owe you? And they go, all you owe me is to pass the phone, pay it forward.
00:55:49.200
And you're like, fuck that. I'm going to spend it on drugs and sex.
1.00
00:55:52.760
You're a vile person. And I'm glad that your cultural and genetic descendants won't exist in the future.
1.00
00:55:58.680
So lovely. Do you disagree with that statement, Simone?
00:56:08.740
I just say, actually, there are some times where Jen gets really pissed about things that the other side says.
1.00
00:56:13.840
And she takes on a tone that reminds me a lot of you when you get the same level of piss.
1.00
00:56:23.360
My whole thing is when it happens, people who choose not to represent their culture in the future will not inherit the future.
00:56:31.200
We will inherit the future, theoretically, if our kids thrive and flourish.
00:56:43.780
Versus, you're not messing up. You're doing a great job.
00:56:46.640
Were you able to get the pocket thing I got you on your belt?
00:56:52.540
I think I can sit under these aprons. And that's the trouble.
00:56:56.220
But once I figure out how to deal with it under these aprons.
00:57:15.960
Every one of our kids is, like, so amazing in their own way.