In this episode, we discuss why Asian parents don t seem to like being parents, and why it might have something to do with the lack of joy they get from being around other ethnic groups. We also discuss some of the cultural practices that keep Asian parents from wanting to have kids.
00:00:24.980And in addition to that, you see this correlated heavily, I think, in part with why so many Asian countries have ultra-low fertility rates or their level of income.
00:00:36.320I mean, if you're saying, why are they so low fertility?
00:00:40.420Well, you know, it might have something to do with them not liking being parents.
00:00:46.420And this is actually brought to my attention by Simone, which I thought was really interesting.
00:00:49.820The second thing we're going to dig into is interesting customs focusing on Korea, as an example here, because it is the lowest fertility of these countries.
00:00:59.680So we're going to look at what it feels like to be an average Korean or what Koreans are saying in the polls right now.
00:01:04.940And then we're going to go from that to some of the ceremonies that shocked me.
00:01:08.760These ultra-expensive ceremonies that Koreans have to have.
00:01:12.320Oh, that I was telling you about, like the first birthdays, things like that.
00:01:15.220Yeah, first birthdays, the postpartum, I didn't realize what percent of Koreans went to these like special postpartum spas.
00:01:53.800I think that the genetic thing could be part of it.
00:01:56.180See, our episode is Low East Asian Fertility Genetic.
00:01:58.600There is an evolutionary reason why it may be lower, which would also tie to parenting joy.
00:02:04.100But the second thing that I think it might be, and I think this is probably the bigger thing, is I think that we should divide parenting on an axis.
00:02:13.240You know, like that political axis chart?
00:02:16.620Oh, every time I hear axis, I just think hot, crazy.
00:03:23.680Yeah, we do what they actually enjoy because we really love them, which is we do their favorite activity of the day, and then we take them to a store and they get to get anything they want.
00:03:31.260That's way better than we're still going to.
00:03:32.900You don't allow me to take the kids to the store barely ever.
00:03:38.540One, one day a year, they get to go to a store.
00:03:41.060You just, you were just criticizing me for that.
00:03:43.700The point here being, Simone, is compared to most other people, and I would even say, because I encourage our kids to fight, I encourage them to roughhouse.
00:04:05.100I think many people would see us, well, maybe not as aggressive or intentionally cruel as tiger parents.
00:04:13.320We do things that are harsher than some of the things that tiger parents do.
00:04:17.280So, like, when I look at my own upbringing, I reference things like my parents being like, I was like, well, what if I get kicked out of school?
00:04:35.300If they're not thriving, if they're not living up to their potential as a Collins, then they don't deserve any support.
00:04:42.140And even tiger moms give their kids support when they're struggling.
00:04:44.640But what I was going to argue here before we got very derailed is I think that the high touch plus high ruthlessness category of parenting, it's very hard to enjoy because you are doing all of the hardest parts of parenting.
00:04:58.740And I think it's the lowest fertility parent group, whereas I think our parenting group, the ruthless and low touch parenting group, is the highest fertility of all the parenting groups because it's both effective and requires very little time.
00:05:36.720Yeah, and this is their big caveat here was this is only for English speaking Asian parents.
00:05:42.180It doesn't necessarily speak for parenting in East Asia.
00:05:44.360But when you look at birth rates in East Asia, you're like, I mean, no, actually, remember the study that we looked at that was how important are various things to you in your life?
00:05:52.960And it compared European countries and East Asian countries and in European countries, like in the top, like three was always like family.
00:06:01.500Oh, and South Koreans especially put material wealth over.
00:06:07.400Well, no, in fact, of where they rank things, if you look at the countries on Earth that rank family the lowest in terms of the satisfaction it gives them, they are all in Southeast Asia.
00:06:18.900Well, and I don't know how accurate they are, but in K-dramas, family and in-law is typically the source of, they're the source of stress and drama and terrible Machiavellian action, not support, love and inclusion.
00:06:33.460So if you're looking at how rewarding they find it, Black, 45% see it as very rewarding.
00:06:40.180Hispanic, 45% see it as very rewarding.
00:06:43.900And here you see whites in the middle at 31%.
00:06:46.580I'd also put Black parenting in the same category as art parenting, which is, I think, why Blacks find parenting much more enjoyable than other ethnic groups.
00:06:55.000Yeah, I mean, when you look across, and this is from the Pew Research Centers, like it's part of a larger survey results report on race, sorry, on parenting in America today.
00:07:06.520But this is Section 2, Race, Ethnicity, and Parenting.
00:07:10.900It just looks like Black families and Hispanic families are just way more family-oriented, kid-oriented, they enjoy it, they're into it, and they're more likely to represent it as the most important thing.
00:07:22.520Did you have a lot of Hispanic friends growing up?
00:07:25.200I had some, not a ton, but they were definitely more family-oriented.
00:07:30.780The points I'm making is while they are more family-oriented, they are much more in the low-touch, ruthless category of parenting than white families are.
00:07:39.120Yeah, no, their parents weren't forcers, for sure, and they were very low-touch.
00:07:42.540What was really weird to me about, because most of my friends in high school were Asian, and then a few, I had a few white friends, and the weird, it's just that, you know how in some kid cartoons, it's just all the kids and you never ever see parents?
00:08:01.060Like, it's like, to a weird extent, like, but these people feed you, you live in their house, why are they not in this show?
00:08:08.740So, that's how it was with my Asian friends.
00:08:16.980You know, now that you mention it, I never met any of my Asian friends' parents.
00:08:20.740And what's really weird is when I contrast that with my white friends, I was, like, as much friends with their parents as I was with them.
00:08:29.480I think they may actually not be indicative of parenting style, but indicative of parental racism.
00:08:35.480I think that the kids may have felt that there would have been a degree of disapproval by bringing white kids around.
00:08:41.180I don't know, but they were just so, I don't know, because that's, here's the weird thing, actually, is I would hang out sometimes at their houses.
00:08:48.260Whereas I would hang out at, like, my white friends' houses, and their parents would serve me grilled cheese sandwiches and tomato soup, and they'd be there.
00:08:54.700And they're like, hey, how are you doing?
00:09:22.640And they were super, like, cool and welcoming and friendly.
00:09:25.340They were, like, now as an adult, like, when I think upon the different ethnic groups of my friends as a kid, the white parents were, like, uncomfortably absent.
00:10:14.260Even just noticing these cultural differences, like, now that I'm thinking through it historically, and I'm like, oh, yeah, that was definitely.
00:10:20.900It's like, I'm putting other graphs on screen here.
00:10:22.920This isn't just this pupil that found this.
00:10:25.900Something else from the pupil that I wanted to talk about, though, which I found was really interesting, which was not just how they themselves enjoyed parenting or saw it as the most important thing in their lives.
00:10:35.360But the survey results on how differently they wanted to raise their children from how they were raised.
00:10:48.560That despite really, really loving parenting, the Hispanic families were the most likely to say that they wanted to raise their children somewhat or very differently from their parents.
00:11:01.740Because you'd think when you look at the other stats, oh, you know, I see parenting as a big deal.
00:11:08.840And yet they're like, but I've got to do it really, really for my mom and dad.
00:11:12.620That that just surprised me because I would just assume that, like, you know, our whole thesis is you are you have an 18 year sales pitch to your kids.
00:11:21.180They had such a great experience that they want to pass that on to their own children.
00:11:25.780And here what we're seeing is something very different.
00:11:27.880They're like, well, my experience sucked, but I'm really into doing it again.
00:11:33.140But an interesting thing, I was just thinking about my Hispanic friends growing up in the same way that when you hung out with white people, there was always like their parents would come and join along.
00:11:42.780When you hang out with Hispanic friends, they always bring along some like other friend group that they expect you to like immediately get along with.
00:11:53.740I had this happen to be a number, especially when I was living in.
00:11:57.940Well, so I would go to like Mexico or something or go to other Central American countries where my families would know, like other wealthy families.
00:12:05.240And they just pawn us off with the kids.
00:12:07.640Then the kids would always be like, OK, we're going to go play soccer with all the other guys.
00:12:11.180But we're going to go like and white kids would like never do this or very rarely do this.
00:12:16.240I very rarely had a white kid expect me to get along with another group of people just because I wanted to hang out with them.
00:12:24.480Whereas with Hispanic kids, while it wasn't their parents that you were immediately expected to get along with, it was a separate social network that had its own dominance hierarchy.
00:12:34.880And it was really uncomfortable because you were always at the absolute bottom as the new guy.
00:12:49.580I was like, I'd always rather be alone than at the bottom of a social hierarchy.
00:12:54.280But I think that you see the answer to this before we go further in this particular statistic, which is I might have lost the statistics here is Asian parents expect a lot more of themselves as parents than other S-singers.
00:13:08.240And you'll see this as we go through the anecdotes here.
00:13:11.800Yes, we moving in for my son's new job.
00:16:23.120And then they say, if your mental model of South Korea does not match this, it's your mental model that's wrong, not the data that's wrong.
00:16:31.300And I think that, well, I mean, I want to go over this chart more broadly because it's like more weird or scary than that even.
00:16:39.960So if you're looking at men versus women, younger generation versus older generation, people who see South Korea as hell and the younger generation, it is 83.1% of young women and 78.4% of young men.
00:16:58.620But in terms of old people, like, is it super lower?
00:17:02.00064.4% of older women and 63.9% of older men.
00:17:07.300So interesting, about the same for the two older genders, but still well over.
00:17:10.600They are not happy despite the incredible rise in living standards in the country just because the culture is, if you watch our other episode of low fertility rates in South Korea, is genuinely hellish in many ways.
00:17:22.940I would not raise my kids in that culture.
00:19:37.900It's become expected that they take on a lot of their roles at work, but they are still expected to take on as many of their roles at home as they did back when they were full-time homemakers.
00:19:48.800And it's really hard to be a woman in that sort of environment.
00:19:52.960While at the same time, men are completely dehumanized by the female population,
00:19:57.180they really do not care about the sacrifices that men are making.
00:21:04.280And I actually kind of, like, having lived in Korea, it is way, at least, perceptionally harder to move up within the country than it is in a place like the United States.
00:21:16.180Like, the systems are really quite against you.
00:21:20.700They go, then, if you have doubts about this particular survey or its results, note that it's consistent with other independently conducted surveys.
00:21:27.400They have one here in the Korean Times.
00:21:28.760And then they have one here that says, good comment for the thread.
00:21:33.460And this person is saying, having been here for two months, here are my thoughts.
00:21:37.460I'm more aware of what the 18 to 35 age group thinks, but I don't really know about the older generation.
00:21:42.600It's obvious that this country has evolved very fast economically, but it's had some social issues that are not being addressed properly.
00:21:50.560Having the lowest fertility rate in the world is revealing something.
00:21:53.700I think they're experiencing the same changes we observed in the West when we wanted women to work.
00:21:59.880First, I believe they didn't give women the right to work because it's kind and progressive.
00:22:04.940I believe they didn't want 50% of the population not creating value.
00:22:08.560That said, Korean women are working as hard and earning as much money as Korean men, but they're still treated as if they couldn't survive without a man.
00:22:16.940This creates a situation where the man has a very hard time seducing a woman for long-term relationships.
00:22:23.860I spoke to some Korean girls, and some of them told me that they felt they were being treated like shit.
00:22:28.720One of them even used the term grape meat, which shocked me because if you were just traveling there, you wouldn't imagine this.
00:22:36.520If you take the list, work very hard at school to avoid being a failure and shaming your family.
00:22:41.740Once you're done, military service for men.
00:22:47.200You're literally a slave to your in-wood or your parents.
00:22:50.160Tip your car windows because social nerves have restricted you from interacting with strangers unless you're a worker, clerk, waiter, colleague, or customer.
00:22:59.140Your goal is to buy a Korean word, and it means home, and never leave its surroundings.
00:23:05.020For this, you have to work 80 hours a week.
00:23:07.320If you're a woman, you're also getting harassed by men in your free time.
00:23:10.640If you're trying to divorce, get killed, be addicted to Korean dramas because this is the only thing you can relax with, rarely leave your home.
00:23:18.980If you're a man, you have a pretty bad opinion of women who hang out and are not considering them for long-term relationships.
00:23:39.280But yeah, I really saw the same thing when I was in Korea.
00:23:42.400My company was as nice as a company could be to women.
00:23:45.080It was a high-tier VC firm to work at.
00:23:47.820And even there, you know, I wonder, do you motivate yourself?
00:23:53.420Like, when you're just going to an office every day, an office life is so structured, and there's so much office theater, are you just living like a theatrical game of a life in a hope of not disappointing X or Y group?
00:24:07.620Like, no real dreams of improving things or making things better.
00:24:13.760Your thoughts before we go further with the specific practices in Korea?
00:24:17.460No, it just, I think this is a great example of a culture that has hit modernity and broken.
00:24:29.120This is exactly why culture has to be updated.
00:24:32.620Yeah, this is why you have to be flexible and be willing to update your culture.
00:24:35.400Because I do not think Korean culture as it is structured, and you'll see more of this in a sec, could conceivably serve off.
00:24:41.880No matter what they did, I don't understand how they're going to survive.
00:24:44.420And again, our other Korean movie video goes into many more structural reasons for this.
00:24:49.660This is almost sort of like an addendum to that that goes over just, like, insane specifics.
00:24:55.120So here is one example of an insane specific additional cost for kids.
00:25:00.840Korean postnatal hotels, also known as the Shajuan, and I'll put some pictures on screen of this, are special, like, they're really nice looking.
00:26:08.220Because, like, you have to kind of learn how to unclog them and, like, how to have to manipulate the breast in the right way to, like, unclog it.
00:26:18.580And someone who knows what they're doing could have fixed that a lot faster for me before I figured it out.
00:26:24.460And this is mostly for first- or second-time mothers.