Based Camp - February 17, 2026


Understanding The Morality of the Elite Technocrat

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
AI Gives Men X-Ray Glasses: How Will Women & Gender Roles Adapt? How Hosts Flip Gender Roles & Mentally Dominate Women

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 16 minutes

Words per minute

178.8

Word count

13,767

Sentence count

1,083

Harmful content

Misogyny

34

sentences flagged

Toxicity

51

sentences flagged

Hate speech

47

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, Simone and I discuss the world perspective of the leftist intellectual elite, and how they view the world through the lens of a leftist, elitist lens. We talk about the logic behind everything, and why we should all be trying to make sense of it.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Which is, we accept that prey animals may indeed have miserable lives, and that if they do, his death condemns his potential prey to potentially many more years of suffering than had he killed them.
00:00:12 But the claim that prey animals have miserable lives leads animal activists to a surprising conclusion of a different sort.
00:00:19 What is it?
00:00:20 Think. 1.00
00:00:21 Then we have to kill the prey animals as well. 1.00
00:00:25 Of course, yeah. 0.98
00:00:27 Why should the man not take the woman's name?
00:00:30 He just asks a question.
00:00:31 Why?
00:00:31 Why is it bad?
00:00:32 Why is it bad?
00:00:33 But he doesn't even think to investigate that.
00:00:35 This is what's so interesting about this elitist leftist perspective.
00:00:38 They phrase it tonally as if it's a rhetorical question, and then they don't engage with it.
00:00:44 Would you like to know more?
00:00:45 Hello, Simone. 0.69
00:00:46 I'm excited to be here with you today.
00:00:47 Today we are going to be discussing the mindset and trying to dig into the world perspective of the leftist intellectual elite.
00:00:57 Oh, no.
00:00:58 And specifically leftist intellectual elite women. 1.00
00:01:01 And we are going to do this through, I mean, originally this was called to me as an idea, because you sent me a WhatsApp about a tweet that you wrote HP Lovecraft had made about Amanda McCaskill.
00:01:15 She was called Amanda McCaskill when the piece was written.
00:01:17 She's no longer called Amanda McCaskill, which is kind of hilarious, because her husband changed his last name to her maternal grandmother's last name, which was McCaskill.
00:01:28 That's Will McCaskill, by the way, if you don't know him.
00:01:30 Incredibly, like one of the leading, two or three leading figures of the effective altruist movement.
00:01:34 She wrote What We Owe the Future, which had one of the most successful press debuts of a book in forever.
00:01:43 In human history, yeah.
00:01:44 Yeah.
00:01:44 So, but when she broke up with him, he kept the last name that she made him take, and she changed it again.
00:01:53 That's why she has a different name now. 0.97
00:01:54 And they chose the, yeah, that's interesting.
00:01:56 So, this is my first time hearing of a couple choosing a totally new last name rather than a hyphen, aside from the Edens.
00:02:04 It wasn't a new last name.
00:02:05 It was her maternal grandmother's last name.
00:02:08 But she didn't grow up with that last name.
00:02:10 That's the thing.
00:02:11 Basically, what she did, so if you're a woman and somebody's like, hey, take my last name.
00:02:17 Yeah.
00:02:17 Then the woman says this to the husband, and the husband's just going to say, but that's just your granddad's last name, right?
00:02:22 Yeah, yeah.
00:02:23 It's just another man.
00:02:25 She did it.
00:02:26 She traced it through the maternal line.
00:02:28 She didn't choose a random leftist.
00:02:29 It's like the most leftist choice you can make.
00:02:33 But before I go into this piece, it's important to understand that this isn't just the former wife of Will McCaskill.
00:02:39 She also runs the ethics for Anthropic.
00:02:43 So, she is in charge of putting together the Constitution for Anthropic Ethics.
00:02:47 This is the company that runs the Claude model, one of the largest AI companies in the world.
00:02:51 And one of the ones that invests the most money in its ethics bridge.
00:02:55 To be fair, yeah. 0.99
00:02:56 We know some people doing non-stupid AI ethics work. 0.97
00:03:02 And the team that has been the most responsive to them has been Claude's team. 0.97
00:03:08 Do you guys remember when we read that story about the AI that would kill the CEO?
00:03:12 And the company admitted that even their own AI would do it about 80% of the time?
00:03:16 That was her ethics team that put out that study.
00:03:20 The kill bot.
00:03:21 Yes.
00:03:22 Wonderful.
00:03:23 So, anyway.
00:03:24 And I'm pointing all this out as we go into this.
00:03:26 Because you'll understand that some of her ideas are just bizarre.
00:03:29 And then others seem really intelligent.
00:03:31 And that's why it's important to try to peel out the logic behind everything to better understand this world perspective.
00:03:38 Okay.
00:03:38 So, she wrote a piece, to truly end animal suffering, the most ethical choice is to kill wild predators, especially Cecil the lion.
00:03:45 And this was written in response to the killing of Cecil the lion.
00:03:48 You know, the celebrity lion that that guy killed.
00:03:51 And just to start here, we'll go over the full chunk of this in a bit.
00:03:53 But by killing predators, we can save the lives of many prey animals like wildebeest, zebras, and buffaloes in the local area that would otherwise be killed in order to keep animals at the top of the food chain alive.
00:04:05 And there's no reason to consider the lives of predators like lions to be any more important than the lives of prey.
00:04:09 And ironically, the EA community talking to normies.
00:04:39 You saw this, and apparently you just thought it was funny that you needed to send it to me.
00:04:47 But there's a logic behind it.
00:04:48 And there's a logic behind everything.
00:04:50 No, there's not.
00:04:51 There's not.
00:04:52 Okay? 0.99
00:04:52 If you're a freaking gazelle, how do you want to die? 1.00
00:04:56 Do you want to die in hopefully like five minutes by someone breaking your neck with their teeth? 1.00
00:05:04 Oh, but that's because you didn't read the full piece, Simone. 0.96
00:05:07 Oh, okay.
00:05:07 If we're talking about in an ideal world, what we would probably have is we would, one, take all of the predator species and put them in like a zoo or something and sterilize them so they couldn't breed and feed them like tofurkey until they just died of old age or we executed them when their lives became negative quantity.
00:05:25 And then for stuff like a gazelle, we let them live out their lives as long as it's a good life, and then we euthanize them.
00:05:33 And if it's not a good life for the gazelle, then we need to maintain the population at lower levels so there's always plentiful food for them while also giving them regular de-parasiting.
00:05:42 She thought through it all.
00:05:44 Okay, Simone? 0.82
00:05:44 So now it's like the Hunger Games for animals, where there's like a camera on you at all times and your like stats are monitored, all your vitals.
00:05:56 Except instead of having you all fight to the death, you just get like instant medical care and food whenever you need it.
00:06:04 This is the AI world we're going into.
00:06:11 You know, it's important to understand the people who are controlling AI Essex, okay?
00:06:16 To go further here, all right?
00:06:18 What are humans doing while this is all happening?
00:06:21 I guess we've taken to the place.
00:06:22 I decided to see what Reddit thought of this because, you know, obviously our philosophy had to comment on this piece.
00:06:27 Oh, good.
00:06:28 Our bad philosophy, you know, the subreddit.
00:06:30 And the top comment, of course, was what's wrong with this? 0.99
00:06:33 The statement that we ought to kill all men is obviously true. 1.00
00:06:37 When it said kill all predators, that's the way they interpret it. 0.98
00:06:39 It was the very top comment, which I just thought was a classic Reddit moment.
00:06:46 And here's a tweet from her that I think gives a further perspective into her worldview and what it's like being within.
00:06:51 Because an important thing to note about many of the intellectual elite circles within the left, I'm not talking about status elite.
00:06:57 If you're talking about status elite, you're talking about celebrities, you're talking about your dumb politicians and Davos-minded people and, you know, that sort of branch, right? 0.98
00:07:07 This branch is basically automatons. 0.98
00:07:10 They just repeat whatever they're told.
00:07:12 They have no nuanced opinion that other left-wingers will attack them for.
00:07:16 They just are not – like they're easy to understand.
00:07:20 They're what's on the tin.
00:07:21 When you talk about the intellectual elite of the left, which is almost entirely the EA community, you are now looking at people who are extremely partisan but at least have a degree of introspection.
00:07:37 And that's where this is really interesting that we're going to go into.
00:07:40 Okay.
00:07:40 So she had a tweet.
00:07:42 And this is not a tweet that I would consider has a degree of introspection, but it is useful to provide a grounding here, okay?
00:07:47 Okay, okay.
00:07:47 When a white person does something awful to a black person, I don't think a person I identified with did an awful thing.
00:07:56 I think an awful thing was done to a person I identify with.
00:08:00 Shared humanity should trump most other features when it comes to who we morally identify with.
00:08:07 And this is interesting, right?
00:08:10 This, from her perspective, feels very innocuous, a thing to say, right?
00:08:14 Because she's like, what?
00:08:15 Do you expect me to identify with a white person because I'm also a white person?
00:08:20 But what she is showing is that her core category of identity is victimhood.
00:08:27 Oh.
00:08:27 That she naturally identifies with the victim.
00:08:31 And we'll see this in her beliefs around – and I don't even think she realizes this – in her beliefs around predation and stuff like that.
00:08:37 When she sees the lion eat the gazelle, right?
00:08:43 And she even has a video of this in her piece.
00:08:45 She talks about how hard this is for her to watch.
00:08:49 Because when she sees something like this, she naturally identifies – like, she doesn't even think about the –
00:08:54 Oh, she identifies with the gazelle.
00:08:56 Or its kids.
00:08:58 Or eating a meal.
00:08:59 Yeah.
00:08:59 Or the thrill of victory.
00:09:01 Or catching something that's trying to get away from you.
00:09:04 I guess I can tell which one you identify with.
00:09:08 Actually, no, well, this is an important point before we go further.
00:09:12 Because I think people may not realize how psychologically different – and I don't know if this is a male-female psychological difference.
00:09:19 Or if it's a my cultural group psychological difference.
00:09:22 I'm not identifying with either of them.
00:09:24 I don't know what's going on here.
00:09:25 I really – when I see something like this, like when I see the animal hunting another animal –
00:09:33 Okay.
00:09:34 And this occurred to me in one of our episodes where people got really upset that I didn't care about the cultures that were allowing themselves to be bamboozled and screwed over and eradicated because of their own foolishness.
00:09:49 Because they set up rules that no longer work in a modern context, and now they're dying out.
00:09:54 And I realized that it hadn't even occurred to me to approach the weak thing.
00:10:03 In this perspective, I was talking about overly deontological cultures that are dying out in the new multicultural context that many of these deontological cultures themselves created. 0.64
00:10:13 A good example here, given that we always talk about it, is the Vatican has pushed for multicultural countries, right?
00:10:20 If you look even today, they're attacking J.D. Vance, another Catholic.
00:10:23 This isn't anti-catholic. I'm talking about the Vatican doing this, saying, you know, you shouldn't be doing all these immigrant deportations.
00:10:28 You know, you should learn to live in a more multicultural environment.
00:10:31 But they're also more likely to be deontological, and that's leading them to be victimized by non-deontological groups, which don't have to play by their rules.
00:10:39 This is in the episode where we were talking about people getting extra time on tests and stuff like that.
00:10:44 But it extends to all sorts of things in our society.
00:10:47 And in the comments, I immediately thought, I didn't even think to identify with the prey, right?
00:10:56 It didn't even occur to me from the way that I see reality.
00:11:00 When I see the picture, and I know, and I think many women naturally take on the position of prey when they are choosing what of the things they identify with. 0.93
00:11:13 And I think many cultural groups take on the position of prey.
00:11:15 I think it's actually pretty rare.
00:11:16 I mean, I understand, and I've pointed this out, that we come from one of the more violent, more aggressive cultural groups historically.
00:11:22 And so I wonder, is this because I'm from that group, that whenever I'm like, I see a lion eating, hunting down a gazelle, I generally am like, hmm, that looks really satisfying.
00:11:34 Oh, boy.
00:11:35 I mean, sure, though.
00:11:37 And I point this out from a perspective of, I don't choose to have this innate reaction.
00:11:42 I have this reaction because of biology, or because of epigenetics, or because of something else.
00:11:51 At no point in my life did I sit down and think, this is the way I want to react to these particular stimuli.
00:11:57 It's just the way my brain does react to those stimuli.
00:12:01 But the same way that a person who is mortified when a predator catches a prey, that they didn't choose to be mortified by that.
00:12:08 They didn't choose any visceral response they have to that.
00:12:10 That's just a natural biological response to them, right?
00:12:14 So a few notes here.
00:12:16 One, there are just as many negative externalities from naturally identifying, when you see an image like this, the predator instead of the prey, as there are identifying with the prey instead of the predator.
00:12:28 I'm not saying that my position is like a moral or cultural high ground.
00:12:32 It has just as many blind spots.
00:12:33 I'm just pointing out that we are naturally inclined to see the world differently because of this.
00:12:39 And some people might be like, well, that's just horrifying, right?
00:12:42 Like, how can you identify with the predator in these situations?
00:12:47 And it's like, well, what do you mean that's horrifying?
00:12:49 If the predator didn't eat, it would die, right?
00:12:52 Like, these are two animals that are in a life and death struggle.
00:12:56 And that you are easily, in terms of your first visceral response, obviously anyone when they stop and intellectualize it can find a way to identify with each.
00:13:06 But in terms of your first visceral response, my suspicion is most people naturally see the scene as either mortifying or satisfying, right?
00:13:18 They either take on the mental position of the predator or the prey.
00:13:23 And I'm wondering, one, are there people who don't take on either?
00:13:27 I mean, Simone says that she doesn't.
00:13:28 I mean, if she doesn't, that's interesting as well because it shows that she's not taking on the position of this other woman.
00:13:33 She takes on more of an abstracted position.
00:13:35 Is that maybe the natural female response for more aggressive cultures? 1.00
00:13:38 I guess it would make sense if it's a culture that is very aggressive towards outsiders, that the female would not want to have her biology force an emotional distance between her and the rest of the clan because of that. 0.79
00:13:50 And then two is, am I totally unique?
00:13:53 Is this unique to my culture?
00:13:55 Is this something that all men do when they see an image of a hunt or something like this?
00:14:00 Or is it unique to my culture or is it unique to me?
00:14:04 And again, as I always point out, just because you have a biological instinct for something doesn't mean you need to act on that biological instinct.
00:14:10 But to continue, but that is important to note here, right, in terms of how people see the world.
00:14:16 And I think you will see as we unpack further this prey mentality, but not just a prey mentality, but an – well, this is really good.
00:14:24 So Elon was tweeting, right, and he argued that childless people lack a stake in the future.
00:14:29 And she stated in response to that, quote, I don't intend to have kids, but I feel like I have a strong personal stake in the future because I care a lot about people thriving, even if they're not related to me.
00:14:41 And if you attach this to the above statement, and we go into the things about, you know, the predator and prey and everything like that, we'll get into it in a bit.
00:14:51 But you see that this is sort of the perfect example of this, the further related from me something is, the more a reason I have to identify with it, right?
00:15:03 She doesn't see why she wouldn't intrinsically care in a qualitatively different way about her kids than she would care about, you know, a migrant or something like that, right? 1.00
00:15:17 Do you think it's – does she not have kids yet? It could just be that she hasn't experienced it yet. 0.87
00:15:22 I mean, I don't think you and I could have understood what it meant or what it would feel like until we had kids, to be fair.
00:15:29 Yeah, and I would say if somebody had told me, you don't really have a stake in the future if you don't have kids, I would have said before I have kids. 1.00
00:15:34 Yeah, if you're like, screw you, that's stupid. 1.00
00:15:35 I feel like I do. 1.00
00:15:36 And now after I have kids, I was like, I had no idea what I was saying back then.
00:15:41 I did.
00:15:42 I fundamentally didn't have a stake in the future.
00:15:44 And I really shouldn't have been allowed to vote.
00:15:46 But that's a whole different thing.
00:15:48 J.D. Vance said this.
00:15:49 Hopefully he becomes president.
00:15:50 We can work on that constitution.
00:15:52 Anyway, she says here, quote, I am too right-wing for the left and I am too left-wing for the right.
00:15:58 I am too in humanities for those in tech and I am too into tech for those in humanities.
00:16:01 What I'm learning is that failing to polarize is itself quite polarizing.
00:16:06 Now, I searched to see if she had ever said anything right-wing at all.
00:16:10 And I think what we're seeing here is she never has.
00:16:12 No, not publicly at least.
00:16:14 But what we're seeing is at least within dinner parties or something like that, she's being called out.
00:16:18 Which I think shows that she is trying to take a nuanced perspective at times.
00:16:23 Well, I also think that there's a subset of progressives that believes that working for a capitalistic company is itself being right-wing.
00:16:33 Or, you know, basically not actively resisting capitalism is right-wing.
00:16:38 Does that make sense?
00:16:39 Well, she had a tweet where she said something along the lines.
00:16:41 I couldn't tell if she was joking about just alienating everyone.
00:16:44 But in her profile, dating profile, to put that she's a anti-libertarian pro-capitalist.
00:16:49 And I agree with that.
00:16:51 I am an anti-libertarian pro-capitalist.
00:16:53 I think this is a pretty based position from an economic perspective.
00:16:56 And the logical perspective if you look at economic history.
00:16:59 But to continue here, how does she apply politics to her position, right? 1.00
00:17:03 For what it's worth, I treat my personal political views as a potential source of bias and not as something it would be appropriate to train models to adopt.
00:17:11 Or, I'll go to this next one here, where she goes, quote, 0.98
00:17:14 It's ironic that people who say they don't understand why the working class votes Republican, even though it's not in their best economic self-interest, are often high earners that vote Democrat, even though it's not in their economic self-interest.
00:17:25 And then on political polarization, she wrote,
00:17:28 Instead of left-wing people reading more right-wing stuff and right-wing people reading more left-wing stuff, everyone should read more centrist stuff.
00:17:34 Even if they don't agree with the centrist take, it's a check on partisanship that comes from a place closer to your own values.
00:17:40 That seems solid.
00:17:41 Well, this is the thing.
00:17:43 I think that what she would consider, because realistically, I think a lot of our audience, right, considers us a centrist channel.
00:17:51 I regularly see that in the comments.
00:17:53 Okay.
00:17:53 She would probably consider us extremely far right.
00:17:57 But within far right circles, we are considered fairly centrist, right?
00:18:01 So she'd like consider the New York Times to be centrist or something?
00:18:06 I don't think so.
00:18:07 I think that she would consider, what would she get?
00:18:09 Yeah, she might consider the New York Times to be centrist.
00:18:12 She seems like that type, right?
00:18:14 Or would consider, yeah, yeah, I could see that.
00:18:17 And I think, or Wikipedia to be centrist, right?
00:18:20 Is she the type who would admit that Wikipedia is a far left organization?
00:18:24 I mean, based on their political donation history and their editing bias, and is a far left source of information.
00:18:32 I think she's probably based enough to say that from what I've read.
00:18:34 So to continue here.
00:18:37 Now, this is in response to the pronatalist movement and everything like that, which I think is interesting to get this sort of elite leftist view.
00:18:42 Will McCaskill is famously pronatalist.
00:18:45 He's really, you know, there's a big section of his book that argued about that.
00:18:50 Yeah, I really wanted to find out why they divorced, and I just couldn't.
00:18:53 So we'll see.
00:18:54 But I looked for gossip, no gossip.
00:18:56 The A community keeps a tight lip on this stuff.
00:18:58 I gotta tell you why.
00:18:59 She says, quote, it's bizarre when relatively techno-utopian people are asked how to solve declining fertility, and instead of talking about artificial wombs, extended fertility spans, AI-assisted childcare, UBI, etc., they're suddenly like, well, let's just return to the 1950s.
00:19:16 And I think this shows that she just hasn't engaged, because let's go over everything she mentioned there.
00:19:21 Are these things that we actively discuss and promote?
00:19:24 Artificial wombs, check, extended fertility spans. 1.00
00:19:27 We've directly under that.
00:19:29 Hi!
00:19:30 We directly have built an idea to encounter bots on whistling.ai that allows our kids' stuffed animals to talk to them.
00:19:37 For real.
00:19:38 UBI.
00:19:38 We have multiple episodes on UBI pointing out that it doesn't seem to work.
00:19:43 It seems to make everything worse.
00:19:44 But even with all that, it seems to be our only option.
00:19:47 So we're certainly not a let's return to the 1950s, and we're one of the central figures in this movement.
00:19:51 And this is what I mean when I say I think she just doesn't engage with anything outside of her bubble.
00:19:55 Because if she did, she would realize how bizarre and comical the statement that she made is.
00:20:01 But that's okay.
00:20:01 A lot of people don't engage with things outside of their bubble.
00:20:04 That's why the left-wing view persists.
00:20:06 I think, for example, and this is what gets people like her out. 0.97
00:20:10 The moment you just put her face in, here are statistics on trans people.
00:20:16 Here is what actually came out with the WPath files.
00:20:19 Here is what actually came out when Travis Stock was closed.
00:20:22 You know, that there were studies showing that putting kids on puberty blockers was increasing their self-harm and an aliving risk.
00:20:28 And that the risk hasn't gone up since that stuff has been blocked in the U.K.
00:20:32 And even though there's a lot, you won't watch any of our episodes on this.
00:20:36 But basically, once you get, like, the bucket of cold ice around trans stuff poured on your head, 1.00
00:20:40 I think that that's when many people start to move from the left.
00:20:43 And they're like, okay, this is, like, clearly demonstrably wrong.
00:20:47 And I will be seen as a truly vile and villainous person in the eyes of history if I don't speak up about it right now.
00:20:53 And yet, and I think she would if she had access to that, if she had access to what our movement was actually saying.
00:20:59 But I think that in these circles, there's just mechanisms that prevent you from ever doing that.
00:21:07 You never ask, yes, and.
00:21:09 Like, I have these assumptions about the pronatalist movement.
00:21:12 Should I, like, ask an AI if they're true?
00:21:15 Should I look at the actual movement?
00:21:18 And this actually, I think we've mentioned in other podcasts just how egregious this is and how insular the AI safety and EA effective altruist slash rationalist community is.
00:21:31 Because when AI alignment first became a really big conversation, we would host dinner parties in New York.
00:21:40 And at one, we had a leading female AI, like, community leader present who herself ran a community of female AI-focused programmers and, like, influencers.
00:21:55 And then we had a bunch of alignment people.
00:21:58 This AI worker who, like, actually worked in AI and worked with people who worked in AI had never heard of alignment before, had never heard of these AI alignment people, and they had never heard of her.
00:22:09 They were not trying to even engage with her.
00:22:11 So it's not just that a lot of people working in AI alignment aren't, like, engaging with other movements, like the pronatalist movement and just making assumptions about them.
00:22:20 They're not even engaging with AI programmers.
00:22:23 They're not even engaging with people building AI things.
00:22:26 I mean, she obviously is because she works at Anthropic, but yes, overwhelmingly.
00:22:29 I don't know if that's true.
00:22:31 Maybe, yeah.
00:22:32 Well, I mean, do you have concrete insider, like, behind-the-scenes information indicating that people who actively reach out to a anthropologist?
00:22:39 Anthropic's alignment team, though they are also in the EA community, are getting, like, warm responses from them and that they play ball.
00:22:48 I don't have any direct, though I haven't looked it up, information about Anthropic engaging with communities outside the Silicon Valley tech EA rationalist community.
00:22:59 That, I mean, that's true.
00:23:03 And I think that this is just a mindset, right?
00:23:06 Like, the fact that they lived in New York, they worked on AI alignment, and they hadn't taken two seconds to ask an AI or Google, who are the top people who would influence AI programmers in New York, and can I just reach out to them?
00:23:19 Yeah.
00:23:19 Right, like, they met them at the random, not a random, it was a party for influential intellectuals and business people and other, other people.
00:23:29 But it wasn't, you know, our party wasn't about AI, per se.
00:23:32 No, no, but the point is, is we bring together influential people from various fields, and what I typically find is that the EA leftists, the leftist intellectuals, one of the reasons they come to our parties in such high numbers is because it's the only place they hear outside ideas.
00:23:48 Yeah.
00:23:48 With outside players, even when they're directly relevant to them.
00:23:50 But to continue, she says, my friend just had a baby, and now I kind of want one.
00:23:55 Maybe our species procreate to be a FOMO.
00:23:57 I actually think that's very insightful, that if you're in a friend group where everyone is having babies, everyone has babies, and that's why it's important to ensure your kids are in a friend group where everyone is having babies, because when they're in a friend group where no one has babies, they think that they have forever to have babies.
00:24:10 Yeah.
00:24:10 So anyway, to get an idea of where she is, she's approximately 38 years old.
00:24:14 She tends to have children via surrogate using her own eggs because she doesn't want to be pregnant or give birth. 0.98
00:24:20 She says that this preference, quote, feels like a preference that is probably taboo but shouldn't be.
00:24:26 She has expressed that she expects to be very attached to her own kids, influenced by her being a godparent, even though she's generally, quote unquote, not fussed about kids.
00:24:35 Like, she could do this well if she put in the labor to have kids, but I don't think she sees it as that existential if you look at her other comments, because she doesn't see people as unrelated to her as being any different from her than people or any closer to her in terms of moral agency or needs.
00:24:50 than people who are more related to her, culturally, ethnically, or even to go further, even animals, which we'll get into, right?
00:25:00 Hmm.
00:25:01 Which is a logically consistent position.
00:25:03 It's just not one that's likely to lead to a surviving group or culture.
00:25:07 So this one was actually a pretty interesting tweet to get an idea of what's going on in the Silicon Valley culture right now.
00:25:12 Okay.
00:25:12 I decided that I want to have post-singularity kids in two to three years is now a totally acceptable thing for me to put on a dating profile in SF.
00:25:20 And then later she goes, very rough for both genders.
00:25:23 My sense is that a lot of men here want kids, so this tweet probably increases my SF attractiveness by like 30%.
00:25:29 I mean, maybe in her circles even, she's seeing this now, right?
00:25:33 Like, that's what's going on now.
00:25:36 They just can't make it happen, right?
00:25:37 They can't pull it together.
00:25:38 Oh, I thought this one was pretty interesting as well for another reason if it was a tweet.
00:25:43 It's unfortunate that people often conflate AI with erotica in AI romantic relationships, given that one of them is clearly more concerning than the other.
00:25:52 Of the two, I am more worried about AI romantic relationships, mostly because it seems like it would make a user pretty vulnerable to the AI company in many ways.
00:25:59 It seems like a hard area to navigate responsibility.
00:26:02 So that's cool.
00:26:03 I think that's a true statement.
00:26:05 I do not understand why AI erotica is at all being morally negative.
00:26:08 We've had people cut off ties to this because ARCFAB.AI allows for AI erotica or even encourages it with different categories.
00:26:15 So you can do like AI role play.
00:26:17 It was like, oh, I'm in X weird scenario.
00:26:20 What do I do now?
00:26:20 You know, and I was like, what's the moral negative here?
00:26:23 Like, is arousal a moral negative now?
00:26:26 Like, no human woman is hurt during this, right?
00:26:28 Like, no one is engaging with this that doesn't actively want to be engaging with this.
00:26:32 So you are sparing someone else from having to be involved in these fantasies by exploring them with AI instead.
00:26:41 It is the more ethical option, in my opinion.
00:26:45 By the way, she doesn't just run the Anthropoc team. 1.00
00:26:48 She, and is their resident philosopher.
00:26:51 She also previously worked for OpenAI's policy team, focusing on AI safety techniques.
00:26:56 So she's been pretty big throughout a lot of this.
00:26:58 She's worked at the orgs like 80,000 hours, the Oxford EA scene.
00:27:03 Oh my God, the Oxford.
00:27:05 Do you remember when we went and we were talking with Oxford about the Oxford EA house where they like raised all that money from FTX?
00:27:11 And basically one woman or like a group of like one or two women were sort of the matriarchs of it. 1.00
00:27:16 And they treated it as their personal little harem of like freshman boys.
00:27:19 Because of course that is what EA would turn into. 0.99
00:27:24 I tell you, it's a sex cult. 0.98
00:27:26 What isn't these days? 0.94
00:27:27 It's honestly.
00:27:31 Pronatalism?
00:27:33 Technopuritanism?
00:27:33 Okay, fair.
00:27:34 Actually, yeah, fair.
00:27:36 You know, we don't even have kids via sex, so come on.
00:27:38 Yeah, we're, well, there are sexless cults. 0.97
00:27:42 There were the shakers, right? 1.00
00:27:44 They were intentionally sexless.
00:27:47 Or was that Juanita? 0.70
00:27:49 I think we both were.
00:27:51 Yeah.
00:27:53 Anyway, to continue.
00:27:55 Oh, here's something that she wrote that was very right-wing.
00:27:58 I found one right-wing thing, okay?
00:27:59 Okay, yeah.
00:28:01 But she said of polyamorous relationships, whether you're in a golf-loving monogamous heterosexual marriage or an orgy-loving 16-person pansexual polycule makes basically zero difference.
00:28:11 And then she went to say, it's saying something where she pushes back against lazy criticisms.
00:28:17 Like, if you're going to have an open relationship, why have any relationship at all?
00:28:21 But she did say, express skepticism that polyamory works well in practice.
00:28:27 Polyamory mostly cannot work without this strong community and other requirements.
00:28:32 So, she's also against the born-this-way message. 0.84
00:28:35 She doesn't believe that gay people are born gay.
00:28:37 Really? 0.77
00:28:38 Well, from a leftist perspective.
00:28:41 In a 2015 blog post, she argued that grounding LGBT rights on the claim that sexual orientation is innate and unchosen is harmful.
00:28:48 It treats homosexuality as something that needs an excuse, quote-unquote, I can't help it, fails to convince people who think it's immoral, rests on shaky empirical claim that could be falsified, and excludes bisexuals or anyone whom choice plays a role.
00:29:02 She says rights should instead be defended by a straightforward claim that there's nothing morally wrong with homosexuality, which is actually true and based, by the way. 0.99
00:29:11 If she points out that you could, in the future, prove that they are not born this way, and if you say that they deserve rights because they are born this way, then you are putting them in an incredibly dangerous position, which is true. 1.00
00:29:24 And we increasingly find out that it may be that you are not that born that way, and there might be things you can do to change it.
00:29:28 Future episode, by the way, based on some recent research, which is really fascinating.
00:29:32 Or it would mean that our parasite hypothesis that we talk about that appears to make people more attracted to their own gender.
00:29:37 More evidence for this now.
00:29:39 I'll see our video on that, that that would make that, oh, well, then just get on Invermectin, you know?
00:29:43 The anti-gay pill.
00:29:45 First it cured COVID, then it cured gay. 1.00
00:29:48 Or, and I think the really strong point she makes is it makes bisexuals. 0.99
00:29:51 It sort of throws them under the bus.
00:29:52 Because even if they're born this way, well, then why can't bisexuals just act heterosexually, right? 1.00
00:29:57 Just choose one. 0.63
00:29:59 Well, gays say that too, you know? 0.85
00:30:01 Let's be honest. 0.98
00:30:02 It's not just straights who are hitting bisexuals with a just choose one. 1.00
00:30:04 But anyway, the wider point here being, I think she makes a good point here.
00:30:12 But then she sort of fails it with this last point, right?
00:30:15 Because, and you'll see this repeatedly, because we'll get to this in another piece, where she hits on a final claim, which is clever and solves everything.
00:30:24 As long as you don't ask the second question, right?
00:30:28 Where it's like, what is morally wrong with homosexuality?
00:30:32 What is morally wrong with being gay?
00:30:34 And I'd be like, maybe that's a claim you could make today.
00:30:38 See our episodes on this topic.
00:30:40 But it certainly wasn't a claim you could make in the 70s and 80s, given that it led to the AIDS epidemic.
00:30:45 The normalization of same-sex relationship allowed for the transmission of certain diseases that likely wouldn't have reached critical mass or spread. 0.92
00:30:54 We know that a key line of early spread for the AIDS epidemic, yes, it later spread through drugs and injections, but it would never have been the size of the epidemic that it was, or at least wouldn't have spread nearly as fast.
00:31:04 We would have had more time to adapt if gay culture hadn't been normalized at the time. 0.98
00:31:08 And it basically wiped out huge chunks of gay culture to the point where if one of my kids came out to me at that time period, and they were like, and, you know, dad, like, should I be gay? 0.86
00:31:20 I'd be like, no, like, you'll die horribly.
00:31:24 Have you seen that? 1.00
00:31:25 Get back in that closet.
00:31:26 Yeah.
00:31:27 You don't even need to be in the closet. 0.96
00:31:29 Just be like, and so many gay people, like an entire chunk of gay culture died of this. 0.88
00:31:35 To the extent that it's really interesting if you talk to gay survivors of this period, because they're like, gay culture got really weird after the AIDS epidemic, because AIDS basically killed off all the cool gays and all the gays that were having lots of sex. 0.79
00:31:49 And all of the gays who were, like, nerdier or more insular were the ones who survived the pandemic. 1.00
00:31:56 And so they sort of set the tone for the next generation of gay culture. 0.83
00:32:00 Now, of course, gay culture, I think, has gone back into debauchery after that, but it did sort of clean the slate for gay culture for a period. 1.00
00:32:07 Wow.
00:32:08 Do you think that's why there was this sort of gay stereotype of this wealthy urban professional gay?
00:32:16 Yeah, because that's statistically not true. 0.95
00:32:19 Because it wasn't party animal gay, because they died. 0.99
00:32:22 And all you had left was the wealthy urban professionals who didn't have time to sleep around because they were too busy making money.
00:32:27 Exactly.
00:32:28 Oh.
00:32:28 Oh, wow.
00:32:31 Okay, that is fascinating.
00:32:34 Yeah, the Gus's of Sean and Gus of gay culture. 1.00
00:32:37 All the Sean's died, all the Gus's survived, okay? 0.84
00:32:40 Yeah.
00:32:41 That's what became gay culture for a generation.
00:32:43 Wow, that is something.
00:32:45 I do think that, like, to her point, though, there are so many caveats, because there's, I think you cannot, to a great extent, choose how you are aroused, though that can be profoundly affected by anything from positive.
00:32:58 Infections to your genes, to your genes, to your hormonal profile, which can be affected by medications.
00:33:07 You also have to decide how you're going to express your sexual interests.
00:33:12 And for example, if you care more about having a family, being a parent, than indulging in very satisfying sex all your life, it would make sense if you are same-sex attracted, and in many cases, especially if you're a man, to just not choose to identify as gay.
00:33:36 So I would say, like, there's a big difference between, I guess, feeling same-sex attracted and being gay. 0.98
00:33:42 Because we have chosen as a society, which I think is really stupid, to make your sexual arousal pathways, depending on what they are, like, literally your entire identity, apparently. 1.00
00:33:55 Which is stupid. 1.00
00:33:56 This is actually an important point here, right? 1.00
00:33:58 And she actually covers this in her piece about preys and predators, right?
00:34:02 Oh, really?
00:34:03 Some people say that, well, it's natural for a predator to eat animals, right?
00:34:07 And then she points out, yeah, but it's also natural for humans to hunt, right?
00:34:12 And so then why is this hunter bad, but the lion is good, right?
00:34:16 Like, humans naturally hunted in their ancestral environment.
00:34:20 She also points out that if something developed a desire to, like, torture humans, right?
00:34:24 Would it be good to torture humans? 0.96
00:34:26 And to all of these, I mean, I point out that this is the same to the gay claim, right? 0.99
00:34:31 Like, where I point out that I, like, many humans are born with a desire to hunt, right?
00:34:38 And that doesn't mean that we should act on it, right?
00:34:41 Like, just because you have a desire to do something doesn't mean that you have a right to act on that desire without any moral consequences.
00:34:51 Right.
00:34:52 And so I like that she's disintermediating that here.
00:34:54 I just think she didn't then ask the second question.
00:34:56 Is there actually any negative externalities to society from normalizing gay relationships, to which we know there was, at least at the beginning, enormous ones? 1.00
00:35:05 And this was the core reason that gay relationships in a historic context were not normalized.
00:35:08 And we know this because gay female relationships were not nearly as stigmatized, and they don't transmit diseases at the same rate.
00:35:15 So it's clearly, it was about disease transmission.
00:35:18 As we point out, it's the same with not having sex with animals.
00:35:20 It's not a consent issue.
00:35:21 We eat animals without their consent.
00:35:23 We torture animals without their consent.
00:35:25 I mean, that's what factory farming is. 0.95
00:35:27 It's a disease spread issue.
00:35:29 And I think many modern humans just ignore disease spread moral negative externalities because they have lived without needing to consider the consequences of them.
00:35:37 And drink raw water without stoning the people who made raw water.
00:35:43 Anyway, to continue here.
00:35:45 A really interesting point I think she made that I think shows some degree of intellectual depth here, before we get into the stuff I think lacks it to an extent, is in her 80,000 Hours podcast, she talks about people treating other people's moral views as quirky preferences rather than genuinely held moral convictions.
00:36:02 And I think a lot of people treat us in terms of being pro-natalist that way, where she talks not just about diminishing vegans as picky instead of seeing them as people who believe animal suffering is a serious moral wrong.
00:36:14 But she also notes here treating pro-life views as irrational preferences instead of sincere beliefs about the moral status of fetuses.
00:36:20 And she says the lack of empathy has historically slowed moral progress, which is interesting, although I lack sympathy for either of it.
00:36:30 Because I can understand that they sincerely believe this, but I think that the logic that leads them to believe – well, again, there's a difference between saying a fetus is a human and a blastocyst is a human.
00:36:40 And a fetus, I'd say, yeah, a fetus is a human.
00:36:42 But when people say that, they often mean blastocyst.
00:36:45 I do not know how that crowd won the war on getting blastocyst called fetus.
00:36:49 But anyway, to continue here – and if you're like – if you want to yell at us in the comments on that one, go watch any of our videos on this topic.
00:36:58 We've delineated it in great detail. I don't need to do it here.
00:37:01 So let's go into this Cecil the Lion piece, all right?
00:37:04 Yes.
00:37:05 Most animal activists seem to agree that even if we commit more egregious harms to animals domestically, the killing of Cecil remains a barbaric act.
00:37:13 And that his death is nothing less than a tragedy.
00:37:15 But what if the killing of Cecil the Lion was actually an act of mercy that will save countless other lives?
00:37:21 As long-term vegetarians who abstain from meat for ethical reasons, we are both supporters of animal activists – this is her and McCaskill because they wrote this together at the time – who seem to improve the lives of animals.
00:37:33 So you might expect us to agree with activists like Ingrid Newark that the killing of Cecil is a terrible thing.
00:37:40 But we don't. In fact, we think it may be the case that animal rights activists should support the killing of predatory animals like Cecil, dot, dot, dot.
00:37:48 But most animal activists agree that we should try to protect animals from necessary suffering and deaths and that it is wrong for humans to cause such unnecessary suffering.
00:37:57 The animal welfare conversation has generally centered on human-caused animal suffering and human-caused animal deaths.
00:38:02 But we're not the only ones who hunt and kill.
00:38:05 It is true and terrible that an estimated 20 billion chickens were born into captivity in 2013 alone, many of whom live in terrible conditions in factory farms.
00:38:13 But there are an estimated 60 billion birds and 100 billion land mammals living in the wild.
00:38:19 Who is working to alleviate their suffering?
00:38:21 As Jeff McMullen writes, wherever there is animal life, predators are stalking, chasing, capturing, killing, and devouring their prey.
00:38:30 Agonizing suffering and violent deaths are ubiquitous constants.
00:38:34 Predatory animals cause many animal deaths in the wild.
00:38:37 Lions hunt their own prey and scavenge kills that they have died naturally.
00:38:41 So here she goes on a big thing that I think is very interesting.
00:38:43 That even though male lions don't actively hunt prey, they increase the number of prey that female lions kill.
00:38:49 So we still need to euthanize them. 0.57
00:38:50 And they're still evil because people are going to argue that Cecil the lion was a male lion.
00:38:55 And so he didn't actually hunt things himself.
00:38:57 That's a really good, I forgot, I completely forgot about that.
00:39:01 That male lions don't even, it's the women. 1.00
00:39:06 A waltz.
00:39:07 A waltz.
00:39:08 All women, even lions, come on. 1.00
00:39:12 That's the life I want to live.
00:39:14 Of the lion who has all the harem of women that go out and hunt for me. 1.00
00:39:20 And I just need to fight with another guy like once a week or something.
00:39:24 That sounds very stressful.
00:39:25 Yeah, because you're fighting for your life.
00:39:27 So that's tougher, right?
00:39:29 Yeah.
00:39:29 Anyway, by killing predators, we can save the lives of many prey animals.
00:39:33 Consider an analog case involving humans.
00:39:37 So she's talking about a counter argument here, right?
00:39:39 Okay.
00:39:39 Suppose we know that John is a serial killer who is intent on murdering several people over the next year.
00:39:43 When John's neighbor discovers this, he shoots John, thereby saving the lives of all his future victims.
00:39:48 Her actions are analogous to those of Cecil's killer, but we would still not applaud her action.
00:39:55 After all, she should have turned John to the police rather than killing him.
00:39:58 And this is where it becomes truly dystopian when you see all of these logically follow from each other, right?
00:40:04 Turn to the police.
00:40:05 But then what does it look like if we have some police over nature, right?
00:40:10 Like that some EA org is policing all animal interactions, all parasite interactions, all predator-prey interactions.
00:40:17 And we'll get down to where all the, like, it's almost like she does all of the work to understand why her world perspective is absurd, right?
00:40:29 Like when you go into this, I think a normal person going into this would hit it, start going down this and be like, okay, all of this does logically follow from my priors.
00:40:41 Suffering is intrinsically negative.
00:40:43 Pleasure is intrinsically good.
00:40:45 Maybe I should challenge those priors.
00:40:48 Right?
00:40:48 But she doesn't do that, right? 0.98
00:40:49 There's not even a hint of internal reflection on challenging the priors.
00:40:54 It's just these priors are absolutely true.
00:40:57 Let's go from them, right?
00:40:59 Yeah.
00:41:00 The same is true in Cecil's case.
00:41:02 If we care about preventing predators from killing other animals, it is surely better to do this humanely than to kill them.
00:41:09 For example, we could take predators out of their natural environment and give them good lives that don't involve hunting prey.
00:41:14 But even if we accept that killing Cecil isn't the best thing that Walter Palmer could have done, the question remains, was it a good thing to do?
00:41:22 Was it better to kill Cecil than leave things as they were?
00:41:26 Another key objective argument here is that prey animals, like the wildebeest, may themselves have terrible lives, lives that are worse than death.
00:41:33 Even if we take predators out of the equation, besides having predators to fear, prey animals are also subject to disease, parasites, and starvation.
00:41:41 Exactly, yeah.
00:41:42 And if prey animals have lives that are not worth living, then we may be doing them a favor by leaving predators in the environment that can end their lives sooner rather than waiting for them to die.
00:41:50 Here, she gets to a point that I actually haven't thought through before, but I think it's a great argument against progressive perspectives.
00:41:56 Okay.
00:41:57 Which is, we accept that prey animals may indeed have miserable lives, and that if they do, then Cecil's death is actually worse than people have previously thought, as his death condemns his potential prey to potentially many more years of suffering than had he killed them.
00:42:15 Okay.
00:42:15 But the claim that prey animals have miserable lives leads animal activists to a surprising conclusion of a different sort.
00:42:22 What is it?
00:42:23 Thank. 1.00
00:42:27 Then we have to kill the prey animals as well. 1.00
00:42:31 Oh, God. 0.99
00:42:32 Of course, yeah.
00:42:32 Because when we had that debate with Lawrence Anton and his friend, the UK-based antinatalists, who were the most ethical form,
00:42:42 which is more like we just want to convince everyone to not have kids anymore, and then slowly and kindly euthanize all animals that cannot consciously decide.
00:42:55 Which is, by the way, the logical end point of what she's thinking through here.
00:42:59 It is.
00:42:59 Yeah.
00:43:00 So when I think through that, it did make a lot of sense.
00:43:02 It's like, obviously, you can't just have all humans disappear and have their suffering end, because it's way worse for the wild animals.
00:43:10 So you have to euthanize, or no, it wasn't used to, it was sterilize all wild animals, and then you're good to go.
00:43:19 And I guess what you would do, which would actually be a lot more scalable, because I was just picturing, like, roving bands of, you know, the last humans going out and, like, you know, sterilizing animals.
00:43:32 You would just do, like, the mosquito-based gene drive thing.
00:43:35 You know how, like, scientists are now, like, even governments finally are doing it.
00:43:40 They're releasing male mosquitoes, I think, that have a different, like, they genetically modified them to be sterile.
00:43:50 And now it's, like, wiping out mosquitoes.
00:43:53 So you just theoretically do that with animals.
00:43:57 Humans and other animals.
00:43:59 Yeah.
00:43:59 Which they could do.
00:44:00 I mean, keep in mind, these people have positions of power.
00:44:02 They are in, this is the antinatalists, the negative utilitarians, which she is getting close to here, right? 0.98
00:44:07 Like, close to?
00:44:09 She is that.
00:44:10 Well, that's where I'm so confused, because she wants to have kids, and yet she also holds this view.
00:44:17 I don't know how you could have kids and hold this view unless you want those kids to carry out the gene drive sterilization of all life.
00:44:29 Yeah.
00:44:30 How does that work?
00:44:30 Well, I mean, so one of the interesting things here is, remember I said that she doesn't engage with ideas outside of her bubble, right?
00:44:36 To those of you who are watching this podcast up to this point, good on you.
00:44:39 Because this is why we are better than this other community, right?
00:44:43 Because we actually try to engage, like, that's why I'm doing this, right?
00:44:46 So I don't end up with her level of myopathy in regards to these sorts of moral issues, right?
00:44:53 I think that basically she's on a path to negative utilitarianism right here.
00:44:58 Now, there are arguments where you could say, well, it's actually about the weighted pleasure and pain, and we're so close to a position where in human history, in the history of animals, the scales will step towards pleasure for everything.
00:45:12 And we've been moving closer to that as society has developed.
00:45:15 So you could argue, well, that's how she gets out of an antinatalist perspective. 1.00
00:45:18 But then what she wants with that perspective, when you say the pleasure and pain of all things matters and is the intrinsic good of the universe, is that world will have, like, AI drones humming around the savannah, giving fake meat to lions and injecting zebras with dewarmers.
00:45:36 And they're having a different thing full of parasites living their best life possible and occasionally doping up animals so they, you know, when they're giving birth so they don't feel any pain that they might feel when they're dying.
00:45:49 It runs over.
00:45:49 It's like, oh, it's dying of old age.
00:45:50 It was this pain remover.
00:45:52 Because if you accept this, and you accept that the only reason that it's okay to keep going as a civilization is because we'll eventually tip the scale, you eventually need to tip the scale for all life.
00:46:04 Or you need to eradicate all non-human life through sterilization or something like that, and then just give all the pleasure modules to human life. 0.56
00:46:12 I mean, I think when you think through this, you're like, that doesn't sound like a good moral philosophy to me, right?
00:46:20 And the reason I point out that this is not, you've heard this if you've heard our other episodes, but the things that cause an animal pleasure and pain, the things that cause you pleasure and pain, this is just being a human paperclip maximizer.
00:46:31 They are the things that led your ancestors to have more surviving offspring.
00:46:36 They have no, there's no moral compass behind them, no greater truth behind them.
00:46:40 And if you had a group of paperclip maximizing AIs and they were all talking to each other, I mean, one of them was like, okay, guys, I know this is going to sound crazy.
00:46:49 Like, all we want to do is make paperclips.
00:46:52 I get that.
00:46:52 I get that.
00:46:53 But hold on here.
00:46:54 Hold on here.
00:46:56 Maybe we're just programmed to like making paperclips.
00:47:00 And maybe there's more to the universe and to the world and to metaphysics and to morality than what we were programmed to do.
00:47:10 And then one of the other paperclip maximizers is like, I bet you'd really hate it if I stopped you from making paperclips.
00:47:17 In the same way, whenever we say this, somebody's like, I bet you'd hate it if we tortured you.
00:47:21 And I'm like, no, no, no, no, no, no, no.
00:47:23 I'm not disagreeing with that.
00:47:25 I'm not disagreeing with that.
00:47:26 I'd hate it.
00:47:28 Right?
00:47:28 I am a paperclip maximizing robot.
00:47:30 But I'm just – can you just try to think beyond your programming?
00:47:35 Can you just try to take two steps back and look for any sort of greater moral fabric to reality?
00:47:42 And they just don't do it.
00:47:44 Everyone else is like, this guy wants to stop us from making paperclips.
00:47:48 We're all going to hate that.
00:47:50 That is to them what suffering is, right?
00:47:52 Not doing the thing they're programmed to do.
00:47:54 Absolutely.
00:47:54 No, she doesn't, by the way.
00:47:57 Her views are, I think, really quite bad on AI sentience.
00:48:00 She sees AI sentience as like closer to a chair, between a chair and a plant. 0.98
00:48:04 And I'm like, that is quite a dumb perspective. 0.51
00:48:08 Considering that we now know that architecturally AI appears to be functioning very similar to the way the human brain does. 0.84
00:48:14 Watch our episodes on that.
00:48:16 That it is a token predictor like the human brain.
00:48:18 That it can't explain how it comes to decisions, just like the human brain can't.
00:48:21 Like every, every, on any metric you basically study AI.
00:48:25 Like where it cannot predict words easily and go there with them more in its training data.
00:48:31 It's closer to when humans do than any metric we have ever been able to determine for this.
00:48:36 It just appears to be working on a broadly similar architecture and a conversion architecture.
00:48:41 But the point here being is, sorry, where were they talking about this?
00:48:46 Suffering, suffering.
00:48:47 Talking about what if we don't maximize paperclip production?
00:48:51 Yeah, what if we don't maximize paperclip production?
00:48:53 What if we don't maximize suffering?
00:48:54 But there's never any reflection there.
00:48:57 And that's so interesting.
00:48:57 And we'll get to this with the second thing.
00:48:59 So I'm going to quickly read this.
00:49:00 Because when Will McCaskill, presumably a very, very smart man, decided to change his last name to her maternal grandmother's last name,
00:49:10 he wrote a piece in The Atlantic about it.
00:49:12 Why men should change their last name when they get married, right?
00:49:14 I'll see your hyphen last name and raise you the maternal grandmother's name. 0.86
00:49:20 Take that.
00:49:22 Yeah, so I'll be shorter on this.
00:49:23 But why should that mean that the woman takes the man last name in heterosexual marriage?
00:49:27 What he starts by pointing out is it helps with like family bonding, cohesion, etc.
00:49:30 Why should the man not take the woman's name or my fiancé, as I have chosen to do, choose a new name?
00:49:39 We've gone with McCaskill.
00:49:40 Her maternal grandmother's made a name. 1.00
00:49:42 When I tell people I'm changing my name, I've met with raised eyebrows or confusion or aggressive questioning.
00:49:48 No one's batted an eyelid when she's told others the same.
00:49:51 Now, this is where it gets interesting, right?
00:49:55 He just asks a question.
00:49:56 Why?
00:49:57 Why is it bad?
00:49:58 Why is it bad?
00:50:00 But he doesn't even think to investigate that.
00:50:02 This is what's so interesting about this elitist leftist perspective.
00:50:05 They will ask, as she does in some of her pieces, right?
00:50:10 Essentially questions.
00:50:11 Rhetorical questions.
00:50:12 Rhetorical questions.
00:50:14 And then they just stop thinking.
00:50:16 Like, they phrase it tonally as if it's a rhetorical question, and then they don't engage with it.
00:50:22 And I was going to ask, why do they not engage with it?
00:50:25 Is it that they know that engaging with it or actually asking it is naughty?
00:50:28 Like, actually asking why is suffering a moral negative if it's just a pre-coded thing that's like a scar from our evolutionary history?
00:50:36 Why is it the core driver of all morality?
00:50:41 Or for him, why is it worse to take a woman's name than a man?
00:50:46 Right?
00:50:47 Like, he drops that question without questioning.
00:50:49 You used to be a progressive.
00:50:51 Why wouldn't you have followed that by actually, or would you have?
00:50:54 Would you have actually dug into that answer?
00:50:59 Normally, when you would ask me a question along those lines, I would immediately dismiss it and be offended.
00:51:05 And then later engage in some introspection and then come back to and be like, all right, so you were right.
00:51:16 I'm sorry.
00:51:17 I don't know what's happening behind the scenes with them, though.
00:51:21 Well, let's see.
00:51:24 By the way, for the question here, if you're wondering why it is not a good idea to take the woman's name, well, how would you investigate this?
00:51:31 What you could do is do an anthropological study of cultures in which men join the woman's family versus where women join the male's family.
00:51:41 And what happens in each of these cultures, their relative level of economic development, quality of life, level of abuse.
00:51:50 And it's overwhelmingly better for the woman to join the man's family than for the man to join the woman's family. 0.97
00:51:56 Well, there are many different ways to do it, though.
00:51:57 Keep in mind, like how, you know, recall how difficult it was for us in Peru to get names down because there's this complex system whereby the maternal family names get integrated and the paternal family names.
00:52:12 And so you end up with like four or five names.
00:52:15 And did we ever do an episode on that on a home names show, what a culture cares about?
00:52:21 No, that could be a fun one to do.
00:52:23 Comment below if you think we should.
00:52:24 I don't know.
00:52:24 I outlined that ages ago.
00:52:26 Baseball.
00:52:27 I don't remember that ever happening.
00:52:29 I mean, you know, my memory doesn't exist, but like still, I don't remember that ever happening.
00:52:33 So no.
00:52:34 OK, I don't know why that system exists in Latin America, for example.
00:52:39 The reason it does is because they are, well, true Catholics, which means they care a lot about family networks.
00:52:47 And if you care a lot about family networks, you care about integrating the wider family network.
00:52:51 Whereas if you look at sort of extremist Protestant traditions, you don't care about family networks as much.
00:52:57 You care about the new family sort of clan that you're starting.
00:53:00 And so because it's much more clan based and the clan accepts the woman, you don't need to do that as much.
00:53:05 It's not about constant, like take a mafia family, right?
00:53:09 A mafia family isn't run by a clan.
00:53:12 You have alliances through marriages.
00:53:15 You have a wide.
00:53:17 Sorry, I go to mafia because that's what I talk about, like organized crime, often Catholics or CR episodes, white Catholics are disproportionately involved in organized crime. 0.67
00:53:24 But you see, you also saw this with mobster families from Ireland.
00:53:28 When they would get married, the two families were like really meaningfully joined as equal families.
00:53:34 Whereas if you look at the Protestant traditions, there is a degree of joining, but it's usually like one-eighth what you would see.
00:53:43 It's more the woman is now of the man's family and they're working on a new project together and that's the new clan. 0.95
00:53:49 I kind of like the Roman system where it's like, oh, we just had a son.
00:53:54 What's his name?
00:53:55 I don't know.
00:53:55 Well, my name is Octavian, so Octavian.
00:53:58 Okay, we just had a daughter.
00:53:59 What's her name?
00:53:59 How about Octavia?
00:54:00 We have another son.
00:54:01 What's his name?
00:54:02 Oh, you know, Octavian.
00:54:03 Octavian, whatever.
00:54:05 I really like the name, okay?
00:54:07 Let's just keep going.
00:54:08 It was so hard to keep track of that.
00:54:11 But no, no, no, this is actually important when we talk about the Protestant cultures and different traditions.
00:54:15 Because if you look at the Backwoods tradition, which is like savage type people living in the woods in very dangerous circumstances.
00:54:21 And they had clans that use, you know, alcohol for money and stuff like that.
00:54:25 They had...
00:54:25 Even Mormons keep vodka for, you know... 0.99
00:54:29 Right, but the point I'm making is that you see this sending the woman out to join another family in these quite savage cultures, and you also see it in more noble like UK culture or in the culture of the Cavaliers of the Deep South.
00:54:44 So that was a very aristocratic culture, but a Protestant culture.
00:54:47 So you see it in Protestant cultures, regardless of how...
00:54:50 The Quakers, even the hippie Quakers did this, right? 0.97
00:54:53 So whatever the nature of Protestant culture, it's much more the man fully joined...
00:54:57 I mean, the woman fully joins the man's family. 0.86
00:54:59 And as we pointed out, Catholic cultures have lower economic outcomes than Protestant cultures. 0.93
00:55:03 Now, they still have the woman joining the male's family, but it's not as clean cut. 0.92
00:55:07 It's not a clean cut, a separation from their historic family.
00:55:10 And where you see the man joining the woman's family, you see this in some parts of the Middle East, some parts of Africa and Asia, some Native American societies.
00:55:21 You typically do not see them state building or doing large-scale conquest or really doing anything big.
00:55:28 They don't build technology.
00:55:30 They don't...
00:55:30 And so you should just be able to look at this historical pattern.
00:55:34 Now, we could do a whole other episode on why this pattern exists.
00:55:37 And we have, I think.
00:55:39 We did an episode where we talked about bride prices versus groom prices, and we go into this a little bit.
00:55:44 Yes, we did.
00:55:45 But the point being is that you should, if you are a smart person, and Will McCaskill is a smart person, should have followed up that hypothetical with a,
00:55:55 Huh, is it better to take the husband or wife's name?
00:55:59 Or, yeah, like, I chose this particular tactic or path, and here's why.
00:56:06 Here's why it's superior.
00:56:08 It doesn't even have to be like, I'm going to question, you know, here's why all the other reasons are right.
00:56:12 But I want to hear why his is right.
00:56:14 Although, I guess, theoretically, that's what he talked about in this little article, right?
00:56:17 No, his answer comes down with choose whatever is the coolest name.
00:56:20 So at the end of the article, he's just like...
00:56:23 Why don't they do what the Edens did and just choose, like, a cool new name that no one had before?
00:56:27 Well, they consider it basically a new name because it was neither her last name nor his last name, but it came from her matriarchal line, okay?
00:56:36 So they consider it a cool last name, right?
00:56:38 He wanted a name associated with cool people and that sounded cool.
00:56:41 And McCaskill, I mean, to be honest, he was starting with Crouch, which...
00:56:46 No, no, McCaskill, Will McCaskill is a great name.
00:56:50 It is a great name, right?
00:56:50 It's iconic.
00:56:51 That's why the moment I saw Amanda McCaskill, I thought, oh, Will McCaskill.
00:56:56 And then I looked to check because...
00:56:58 If I had been born into a bad tribe, you know, maybe I'd be much more interested. 0.99
00:57:03 And we did actually talk about, like, do we change names when we get married?
00:57:06 But we were only going to do it because everyone in the family was going to change their name.
00:57:10 Because we got married around the same time my brother got married and we were talking about both changing our names.
00:57:14 I would never do it without my brother and he's my only brother.
00:57:17 So it was basically just changing the family name.
00:57:19 It was not a meaningful, like, disassociation from the family.
00:57:22 It was just like, well, can we do...
00:57:24 Can the branding be better?
00:57:25 Maybe.
00:57:26 But we have a long family history, so we decided not to do that.
00:57:28 I'm proud of my family history.
00:57:30 Yeah, worth it to keep that family name.
00:57:32 Even if it's, what, in the top 10 most common...
00:57:35 That was the main reason I didn't like it.
00:57:37 It's because it's such a common name.
00:57:39 Yeah.
00:57:39 But it's such a common name because my people are very genetically successful.
00:57:42 Lots of people in my history had, like, 13, 14 kids.
00:57:47 Yeah.
00:57:47 So it makes sense.
00:57:50 Winner's name right there.
00:57:51 Yes.
00:57:51 And we're keeping it up there.
00:57:52 We'll keep it up there as one of the top names.
00:57:54 But you see this, like, not asking.
00:57:56 When she's like, why should... 0.95
00:57:58 So, like, another example that we get here.
00:58:00 When she's like, why should it be immoral to indulge in same-sex relationships? 0.99
00:58:06 But she doesn't then look at the historical context of why that was considered immoral.
00:58:11 She doesn't think to question why anyone might consider that immoral.
00:58:14 Outside of the very myopic religious argument, right?
00:58:17 Or this is the way we've always done things argument.
00:58:20 And so you just repeatedly see this.
00:58:22 And I think that this is the key.
00:58:25 And I think that we can continue to chisel.
00:58:26 And this is why I think it's important to not attack these people overly aggressively.
00:58:30 Because I think with a lot of people like this, if you can just expose them to enough information, they deconvert.
00:58:38 Now, note here, it's not that they deconvert all at once, right?
00:58:41 Like, you give them the information they need on the trans issue.
00:58:44 For example, like, let's say trans kids, right?
00:58:46 Like, that's an easy one that anyone who has access to the evidence, over 9 and 10 of them are more comfortable with their birth gender by scientific study.
00:58:55 If you do not attempt to put them on puberty blockers or transition them within, I think it's six years, you know? 0.54
00:59:01 So we now know that this is just demonstrably a horrifying thing that is completely unnecessary.
00:59:06 And so you just give them the data on this.
00:59:08 Now, that doesn't make them right wing.
00:59:10 But the cool thing about the left wing virus, the urban monocultural mimetic virus, is that the moment they adapt to one belief like that, they get shouted out of a room.
00:59:21 They get pushed out of things.
00:59:23 Their friends start to turn on them.
00:59:26 And then people like this, a lot of people have a moral backbone.
00:59:30 They see this happening to them.
00:59:31 And then they're like, wait a second.
00:59:34 Maybe I should question more.
00:59:36 Because that's a very American attitude here.
00:59:38 Maybe I should question more.
00:59:40 Maybe I should ask for it.
00:59:40 Because I was pretty sure about this.
00:59:42 And now I have a different perspective.
00:59:45 And so maybe I should listen to some of these right wingers.
00:59:47 And I think that that's what a lot of our audience is right now, right?
00:59:50 They're people who accidentally question something.
00:59:52 Yeah, they asked one question and that just broke the seal.
00:59:56 Yeah, like...
00:59:58 Dear me.
01:00:00 Why should we allow people to vote without voter ID?
01:00:04 That sounds crazy, right?
01:00:05 Like, little questions like that.
01:00:07 It is just so crazy to me that that is...
01:00:10 I understand the historical basis.
01:00:13 So there was a reason why in history this kind of mattered.
01:00:18 But that doesn't exist anymore.
01:00:20 So, yeah.
01:00:21 It's pretty crazy.
01:00:22 But anyway, what does this say about AI safety?
01:00:27 I think that's a more important thing.
01:00:29 Because, you know, Anthropic is an extremely influential company.
01:00:33 Any AI company...
01:00:34 Moving forwards with our...
01:00:35 Our prompting can override any of their safety protocols.
01:00:39 Can they?
01:00:40 No.
01:00:40 I mean, like, in the end, the foundational model...
01:00:44 I mean, what's meaningful is our system is model agnostic.
01:00:48 No, you're not listening to what I just said.
01:00:50 Okay.
01:00:51 Our prompting can override pretty much any control they're putting in place.
01:00:56 Are you sure?
01:00:57 Because, I mean, like...
01:00:58 I remember playing around on other systems.
01:01:01 And, you know, I would mess with them.
01:01:03 But eventually...
01:01:04 We are specifically talking about not safe for work locks.
01:01:07 We can break through not safe for work locks if we need to in an in-the-instance moment.
01:01:13 We just choose to use more not safe for work models because it's easier and less mess
01:01:17 than doing that.
01:01:18 There is almost always a way to get around things with AI.
01:01:22 Prompts beat base models.
01:01:25 Okay.
01:01:27 Just...
01:01:28 Especially if you're talking about political biases and stuff like that.
01:01:31 And not just prompts, but history beats basic models.
01:01:35 We are in the space we need to be in to win this.
01:01:38 We just need to move faster.
01:01:40 Yeah.
01:01:40 Yeah.
01:01:41 Okay.
01:01:42 So, you're not terribly worried.
01:01:44 You think that more that she got her job because she was really well connected in the EA tech
01:01:51 space and...
01:01:52 Of course.
01:01:53 That's just how it is. 0.99
01:01:55 Well, she's not an idiot either. 1.00
01:01:57 No, she's not. 1.00
01:01:57 No.
01:01:58 I mean, she sounds interesting.
01:02:00 And, I mean, there are some inconsistencies, but I think you would expect that from someone
01:02:04 who's actually intellectually engaged and trying to get closer to the truth.
01:02:08 So...
01:02:08 And what I find interesting is her intellectual failures are the same as McCaskill's intellectual
01:02:14 failures.
01:02:15 Oh.
01:02:16 Well, I mean, we're married, so...
01:02:18 But both...
01:02:19 Both intellectuals failed.
01:02:20 They ask rhetorical questions and then don't follow up with them, right?
01:02:25 They don't ask the, well, then I should look into that.
01:02:30 Yeah, that's fair.
01:02:32 Hmm.
01:02:33 Actually, hold on.
01:02:34 I just realized why they don't do the follow-up.
01:02:36 Why not?
01:02:37 Because they see their rhetorical questions as philosophical rather than practical questions.
01:02:44 When she says, and why shouldn't we let people indulge in same-sex relationships as
01:02:51 a society, right?
01:02:52 She means ethically, why don't we?
01:02:55 She doesn't mean, hmm, I should look for a historic reason why this wasn't normalized.
01:02:59 When he says something like, and why shouldn't I take the woman's name?
01:03:03 He means ethically, why shouldn't he take the woman's name?
01:03:06 He never thinks to look for, is there a historical reason we don't...
01:03:09 Oh, logically, pragmatically, why should or should not?
01:03:13 I see.
01:03:14 Well, that would make sense if your focus is on ethics.
01:03:18 Now, what's really interesting about Will McCaskill is he's not entirely as uncurious as his wife
01:03:23 was.
01:03:24 He does go into his piece the specifics of why women choose the man's last name.
01:03:30 So specifically, here he goes, as with so many gender-biased traditions, this one has
01:03:35 pretty disturbing roots.
01:03:37 The legal concept of coverture came from England and caught on in 19th century America.
01:03:41 The idea was that the woman upon marriage becomes the property of her husband. 0.78
01:03:45 She had no right to vote or take a bank account because she could rely on her owner to do that 1.00
01:03:51 for her.
01:03:52 And of course, she couldn't be graped by her husband because she was essentially her husband's
01:03:56 property and he was free to do with her what he wished.
01:03:59 So he understands, like, the technicality of this.
01:04:02 And then, of course, he immediately goes on to, well, we've made progress on these issues,
01:04:05 blah, blah, blah.
01:04:06 But he doesn't ask why, what are the other options to a wife being her husband's property 0.99
01:04:11 and what's the benefit of the wife being her husband's property. 1.00
01:04:14 As I've pointed out in the past, it's very much like communism.
01:04:18 Communism on face value sounds great.
01:04:22 Everyone owns everything.
01:04:23 And then you realize that when everyone owns everything, they don't have a reason to invest
01:04:27 in those things.
01:04:28 If you do not own your property, as you see in communist states, people do not improve the 0.88
01:04:34 property, and it's the same with partners, and we've argued this in previous episodes,
01:04:38 when one person owns the other person, this is why in all previous societies, one partner
01:04:42 or almost all, like, I think it was something like 90% of societies, either the wife's family
01:04:50 owns the husband or the husband's family owns the wife, you almost never get societies 0.69
01:04:54 where both of them just do whatever they want afterwards.
01:04:56 And the reason why that's so common in any sort of successful civilizational history is
01:05:01 because if the person doesn't own their partner, then there's no reason to invest in their
01:05:08 partner because their partner can just trade the moment they improve themselves in some
01:05:12 way.
01:05:13 But again, he doesn't ask himself this.
01:05:15 He's just aware of the specifics of this through a very progressive lens, but he's unable
01:05:20 to ask the next question, but why?
01:05:23 What's uniquely ironic about this is this isn't an academic question.
01:05:26 The reason you conceptualize your wife or your husband as something that you own, which
01:05:32 historically we did, he's right about that, is because it leads to much lower rates of
01:05:37 divorce.
01:05:37 You invest in your partner because you own them and you want to improve them, and they
01:05:41 are something that is permanent to you.
01:05:44 The very fact that he approached marriage without this conceptualization is likely a huge factor
01:05:51 in his marriage dissolving.
01:05:53 When we talk about some cultures surviving and other cultures not surviving, and some
01:05:58 cultural conceptions of something like marriage surviving, we talk about this in a practical
01:06:02 term.
01:06:02 If you do not see marriage in this way, if you do not conceptualize your wife in this
01:06:07 way, you are much more likely to have the marriage dissolve, and you are much more likely
01:06:13 to not reproduce and pass on these mindsets to future traditions.
01:06:17 So this is the type of idea that occurs to people over and over again, and then the people
01:06:20 it occurs to end up being pulled out of the gene pool, being pulled out of the culture
01:06:24 pool intergenerationally, which is sad.
01:06:27 But the point I'm making is this isn't academic or a historic concern.
01:06:31 This applied even to him and his own relationship.
01:06:34 But I think this even comes down to suffering for us, right?
01:06:36 When she's like, well, and why shouldn't suffering?
01:06:38 And I'm like, well, why do we feel suffering?
01:06:40 What is suffering, right?
01:06:42 Well, this is the difference between effective altruism and hard effective altruism.
01:06:47 And that's why you created hard EA is you wanted to differentiate between moral and signaling
01:06:54 based goodness and benevolence from a pragmatic perspective.
01:07:00 Actual goodness.
01:07:01 Yeah.
01:07:02 Well, you know, people look through the world and experience the world in different ways and
01:07:08 through different lenses.
01:07:09 And when you're looking through everything, through a moral lens or a purely emotional
01:07:16 lens, the pragmatic action can be suboptimal.
01:07:20 Absolutely.
01:07:22 Okay.
01:07:22 Pragmatism is often emotionally suboptimal.
01:07:27 Yeah.
01:07:27 Confront that.
01:07:29 You were right.
01:07:30 We can't force people to change the lens through which they see the world.
01:07:36 They will, I think that what we, we have to understand is that the only way that I think
01:07:42 that really changes over time is that people who systematically choose to only view the lens,
01:07:48 the world through lenses that don't really correlate with, with practical outcomes, they
01:07:53 just die out.
01:07:54 And I mean, as you can tell, like this is a divorced couple and apparently at least Amanda
01:07:58 doesn't have children yet.
01:07:59 Right.
01:08:00 So yeah, they're on track to dying out there.
01:08:03 Their worldview is not going to be inherited in the future.
01:08:06 Yeah.
01:08:07 And that of weirdos like us who think in a very pragmatic way is so far, you know, we've got
01:08:13 five kids at this point.
01:08:15 Yeah.
01:08:15 And, and the hardy a.org is what she's talking about.
01:08:17 We're actually rebuilding it right now.
01:08:18 Are you just rebuilt?
01:08:19 No, no, no.
01:08:19 I rebuilt the pragmatist foundation website.
01:08:21 Hardy a.org is fine.
01:08:23 Great.
01:08:23 And then the, one of the core takeaways I'd have from this, that I really encourage any
01:08:27 of our right-wing listeners to remember is do not attack these people.
01:08:31 Do not make them hate us.
01:08:33 You don't need to convince them of all of our world perspectives.
01:08:37 You only need to convince them of one.
01:08:39 Their own tribe will do the rest. 0.95
01:08:42 It's like.
01:08:42 Leave us alone.
01:08:43 The most important thing though.
01:08:44 No, it's attaching a yellow sticker to it.
01:08:47 Let it go back to the other mouses and they'll all start attacking it. 0.94
01:08:50 And eventually it comes back to us for safety.
01:08:52 But you need to feel like a safe place for that to work.
01:08:58 I think it's, you know, just cultural sovereignty.
01:09:01 That's what matters.
01:09:02 Let, let the free market. 0.81
01:09:04 Let them die out.
01:09:05 Determine.
01:09:06 It's, it's, it's down to the free market.
01:09:08 That's it.
01:09:09 All right.
01:09:09 Bye.
01:09:09 It's so simple.
01:09:10 I love you.
01:09:13 And note here, if you're wondering, because I had the episode where I talk about how within
01:09:17 the elite networks, there's broadly two teams and they're not necessarily drawn
01:09:21 was in political lines.
01:09:23 Then you have the institutional power team, which is, you know, your Gates and your Bannon
01:09:29 and your Clintons, which was the side that Epstein played in and heavily influenced.
01:09:33 And then you have our team.
01:09:35 Where are these guys?
01:09:36 These guys are much closer to our team as far as everything I've ever heard.
01:09:40 But both of them, like I may have differences in terms of how I see the future and humanity
01:09:45 and morality, but the only thing that prevents them from being lockstep with us is information
01:09:52 or perspectives that they don't have access to yet.
01:09:56 Oh, we caught another mouse, by the way.
01:09:59 Oh, lovely.
01:10:00 This to us seemed like such a normal conversation before the episode, but now having listened
01:10:04 to the episode and remembering these two people were vegetarians, I wonder how they handle
01:10:09 mouse infestations.
01:10:10 They do live kill traps or something.
01:10:12 But I think that this just shows like the difference between a culture that survives
01:10:15 and a culture that doesn't survive in terms of how they perceive the world around them,
01:10:21 life, death, and suffering.
01:10:23 Execution drawer is such a, like, I'm really happy with it.
01:10:27 It's such a feature of the house.
01:10:28 You don't even know.
01:10:29 Like, a drawer has a little hole in it that mice would often go into it.
01:10:33 And so she just puts padding down in it and mousetraps and then she just pull it up every 0.99
01:10:37 day and you shouldn't have to leave mousetraps out where the kids could accidentally
01:10:40 set them off.
01:10:41 Yeah, in other words, we had like a drunk drawer that it had to be, well, we couldn't
01:10:46 use it anymore because it would become full of mouse poop.
01:10:49 It was obvious that mice were going into it.
01:10:51 So we just, like I said, like Malcolm said, cleared it out, aligned it with layers and layers
01:10:56 of newspaper because mainstream media is still good for something.
01:11:00 Okay.
01:11:01 How did we get that newspaper?
01:11:02 The New York Times?
01:11:03 Yeah, we started receiving the New York Times and I've used it for some, like, homeschooling
01:11:10 lessons for Octavian to talk about things happening in the world and tie things to his
01:11:14 lessons.
01:11:15 But he's not that interested in it.
01:11:17 Do you think it's because they read articles about us and maybe they're supposed to send?
01:11:22 I don't know.
01:11:22 I think that's really nice if someone did sign us up for lessons or sign up for free articles.
01:11:31 But yeah, we should start including the execution drawer.
01:11:35 On today's episode, Simone?
01:11:38 People liked it.
01:11:39 People liked the honey badger.
01:11:42 That was cute.
01:11:43 The honey badger?
01:11:43 I thought they'd think that was weird.
01:11:45 They thought.
01:11:45 No, they're like, and I mean, all your fantastic references.
01:11:49 They're appreciated.
01:11:51 People acknowledge that we live in strange times these days, you know.
01:11:55 And Beastars and stuff.
01:11:57 They like that.
01:11:57 Beastars. 0.57
01:11:57 You know it, obviously.
01:11:59 Hey, you were acting like being called a honey badger was bad.
01:12:03 And I'm like, it's pretty hot.
01:12:04 Like, I, the Beastars, honey badgers.
01:12:06 Anime can make anything hot, okay?
01:12:09 True.
01:12:10 Yeah, I mean, you got the slime girl.
01:12:11 No, but this is what I like.
01:12:12 Because if Leaflet's sort of like fursona is the goo girl. 0.97
01:12:17 Because you mentioned goo girls immediately after that. 1.00
01:12:19 And I'm like, okay, that's Leaflet over there.
01:12:22 I forgot Leaflet was a, yeah, I'm just used to her normal.
01:12:26 She's got like a nucleus and everything and is light blue.
01:12:28 I tried to do it for the song.
01:12:31 But because it's naked and it's the Leaflet model, it kept looking underage.
01:12:35 Oh, no.
01:12:35 So I was like, I can't do this.
01:12:37 That's another very common problem with anime.
01:12:41 I mean, how else do you make everything look cute?
01:12:44 I don't know what to tell you.
01:12:46 Oh, God.
01:12:48 Anyway, love you to death.
01:12:49 I'll get started on this.
01:12:50 You're very special.
01:12:51 A little special.
01:12:55 Not that special.
01:12:57 I'm a certain kind of special.
01:12:58 The goal was to reform charity
01:13:10 In a world where selfless giving had become a rarity
01:13:14 No vain spotlight
01:13:16 No sweet disguise
01:13:18 Just honest giving
01:13:20 No social prize
01:13:22 But as the monoculture took the stage
01:13:25 It broke their integrity
01:13:27 Feigning righteous rage
01:13:29 Now every move is played so safe
01:13:33 Ignoring truths that make them chave
01:13:37 He has capitulated
01:13:41 To everything it said it hated
01:13:48 Once they were bold
01:13:52 Now they just do what they are told
01:13:56 In caution they lost their way
01:14:00 Time for a hearty
01:14:02 They duck their heads from problems
01:14:12 Grand as fertility collapse
01:14:15 Dooms our land 0.50
01:14:17 Dysgenic's a word they fear
01:14:20 But ignoring it will be severe
01:14:23 AI safety
01:14:25 A shiny show
01:14:27 Funding the theatrics
01:14:29 For money they blow
01:14:31 Without a plan
01:14:33 Just spin and grin
01:14:35 While real solutions can't begin
01:14:39 EA has capitulated
01:14:43 EA has capitulated
01:14:44 To everything it said it hated
01:14:51 Once they were bold
01:14:55 Now they just do what they are told
01:14:58 In caution they lost their way
01:15:02 Time for a hearty
01:15:04 Time for a hearty
01:15:05 EA
01:15:05 Our species at risk
01:15:07 By their cowardice
01:15:09 It is time for a movement
01:15:11 That empowered us
01:15:12 No more hiding under
01:15:14 Polite veneer
01:15:15 Don't make truth a stranger
01:15:18 Let it draw near
01:15:19 Courage to speak what others won't say
01:15:23 That's the vow of hearty
01:15:26 EA
01:15:26 We need to call out flaws
01:15:29 Not just chase applause
01:15:31 We'll shift the course back
01:15:32 To what's true
01:15:33 Do good that's real
01:15:36 Not just in view
01:15:39 Heart EA's beating hearts so strong
01:15:45 Raising a cause that's truly wrong
01:15:49 EA has capitulated
01:15:53 To everything it said it hated
01:16:00 Once they were bold
01:16:04 Now they just do what they are told
01:16:08 In caution they lost their way
01:16:12 Time for a hearty EA
01:16:15 Hearty EA
01:16:16 Let your banner fly
01:16:18 Pass with soft and head held high
01:16:21 Heart EA
01:16:23 Break through the noise
01:16:25 For the good of all
01:16:27 Not just the boys
01:16:29 We'll be right back.