Based Camp - August 21, 2023


Why Did Men Waste Time Being Gentlemen?


Episode Stats

Length

32 minutes

Words per Minute

183.306

Word Count

6,037

Sentence Count

319

Misogynist Sentences

25

Hate Speech Sentences

16


Summary

In this episode, I sit down with author and author Simone Simone Tate to talk about her new book, "Manners and Masculinity: How To Be Dominant in the 21st Century." Simone and I talk about how society has evolved over the past century, and why it's important to be assertive and assertive in our relationships.


Transcript

00:00:00.000 I think that's one reason why men are misunderstanding what it looks like to be dominant and then
00:00:04.980 ending up just kind of acting like trailer trash when they try to be dominant, you know,
00:00:09.160 it's just, you know, they-
00:00:09.980 Oh my gosh, I love-
00:00:12.140 No, it's true what you're saying, right?
00:00:14.180 Every cultural group has different, more refined ways to handle these dominant fights that don't
00:00:21.540 involve two males making themselves look big and then like physically attacking each other
00:00:25.620 because that's really costly.
00:00:27.940 And this is what Simone means.
00:00:29.440 She mentally is associating this with lower socioeconomic groups because lower socioeconomic
00:00:37.020 groups, like anyone who's resource scarce, are going to have less luxury of the ability
00:00:43.520 to suppress these things.
00:00:45.180 And often their families have been in this situation for multiple generations.
00:00:48.400 So they might have lost even the cultural software for how do I handle a dominance fight with
00:00:55.340 another male other than puffing myself up and then beating him up?
00:00:59.620 I think we've lost, we've lost a lot of the ways that people historically demonstrated dominance
00:01:06.180 in, this sounds terrible, this sounds really classist, but in a civilized fashion.
00:01:11.900 Would you like to know more?
00:01:14.520 Mm-hmm.
00:01:14.920 Hello, Simone.
00:01:18.900 Hello, Malcolm.
00:01:20.020 How are you doing?
00:01:22.120 Absolutely spectacular today.
00:01:25.000 It is so wonderful to have you back from a business trip.
00:01:28.120 So something happened recently that was really telling for me because, you know, I see this
00:01:33.940 was in some conservative communities and it's something that I'm getting really worried about,
00:01:37.480 which is somebody who's like, why do you put your wife's name first when you write books
00:01:44.060 and in correspondence?
00:01:45.760 You know, don't you know that you're the man and that that means you're better than her?
00:01:50.700 And so you should be putting all of your stuff first.
00:01:54.480 And I think this shows how far we've descended from most traditional cultural beliefs, which
00:02:00.680 is if you look at manners books, that's just polite manners.
00:02:04.900 Like opening the door for a woman, like all of these nice little things that guys used
00:02:12.040 to be expected to do for women.
00:02:14.400 And then progressive culture came like a glacier and cleaned all of those things clean, so clean
00:02:21.780 that we don't remember them almost, you know, with Gen Z's coming around and they're trying
00:02:26.020 to reclaim their masculinity.
00:02:27.380 But in so doing, in so reclaiming this masculine role, they, you know, through people like the
00:02:37.920 way that this has been portrayed by individuals like Andrew Tate, it almost comes across as
00:02:42.580 every interaction you have with a woman who like you love and have a long-term relationship
00:02:47.060 with is, is to some extent to exert your dominance over that woman.
00:02:52.200 Whereas most of the traditional cultures in the world will say, no, no, no, no, no.
00:02:56.680 It's to make her feel special and treasured and to protect her.
00:03:01.520 Now, this actually has very big effects if you're talking about long-term fertility of a culture.
00:03:08.320 So why do you do, like, why, it's not just to be nice.
00:03:14.280 Like, I'm not just, you know, within my family's life, putting my wife upon a pedestal to be
00:03:19.840 nice to her.
00:03:20.920 I'm not doing all of these things that we traditionally call manners, like ensuring that I walk on
00:03:25.760 the side of the street where a car is going to splash us, it splashes me first, opening
00:03:30.440 doors, all of these little things like that, standing up from a table when she gets up.
00:03:35.240 Thank you, by the way.
00:03:36.920 Right.
00:03:37.320 No, I mean, I don't do all of those things just to be like a weirdo.
00:03:43.240 I do them for a very specific reason.
00:03:47.600 It's so that when my daughters see the way I treat my wife, they desire that outcome for
00:03:56.480 themselves in the future.
00:03:58.260 And when my sons see the way I treat my wife, they treat their own wives that way.
00:04:05.580 And then their own daughters think, oh, being a wife is awesome.
00:04:12.000 And so someone, I wonder, you had talked to me before about what you've felt like growing
00:04:16.220 up.
00:04:16.860 Right.
00:04:17.500 Yeah.
00:04:17.940 So I thought growing up when I was young just meant, you know, giving a bunch of things
00:04:23.360 up, like giving up your career and then having to take on a whole bunch of additional
00:04:28.080 responsibilities.
00:04:28.800 So just basically meant more work, but, you know, not really being celebrated.
00:04:33.780 Not that my father wasn't absolutely amazing to my mother.
00:04:37.200 He was, but there was no like elevated status in, in Silicon Valley, like in the very progressive
00:04:42.560 Bay area for women.
00:04:44.060 I remember the first time I saw someone stand up when a woman got up at a table.
00:04:48.020 And when the first time I saw a man, like a ceremonially open a door for a woman, I was
00:04:52.300 floored.
00:04:53.420 I really liked it.
00:04:54.200 Well, so you've been around my family, like you've been around my cousin.
00:04:57.820 Yeah.
00:04:58.080 And they're like, yeah, they're, they're very, yeah, they're, they're raised like Southern
00:05:02.220 gentlemen and I'm all for it.
00:05:04.580 But yeah, so there was definitely, I mean, like I had zero incentive to, to, to not only
00:05:09.900 have kids, but get married at all because why, I mean, it just basically meant that you
00:05:15.040 were technically more entangled with a friend that was supposed to make you happy for the
00:05:21.800 rest of your life, which isn't really what, you know, we found marriage to be about and
00:05:25.660 what it's not sustainable.
00:05:26.440 But I think what's more interesting about this is that a lot of these men's rights activists
00:05:32.300 are sort of like manosphere figures that are complaining about your behavior online or
00:05:36.260 missing is, is they think that like showing deference to women is, I don't know, suggesting
00:05:42.780 that they are in a position of power or yielding power to them.
00:05:46.140 And I think it, there's something more interesting at play in American culture there where, where
00:05:51.000 shows of, of power or shows of politeness are no longer seen as shows of power where
00:05:58.700 in, in earlier times they were.
00:06:01.500 So in, in the book, Albion Seed by David Hackett Fitcher, he talks about, especially in the South
00:06:07.860 where the cavaliers first migrated to the American colonies, there was the concept of condescension
00:06:14.180 was very different from what it is in a modern America.
00:06:16.880 Do you remember this part where he, he was basically talking about-
00:06:19.760 Yeah, no, it was a very positive thing.
00:06:21.200 Yeah.
00:06:21.460 So, well, no, condescension was essentially like noblesse oblige.
00:06:24.520 So when you condescended to someone, you, through your more informed or your more powerful,
00:06:29.980 more educated, more, you know, whatever, from a position of power, you were showing kindness
00:06:34.520 to someone who hierarchically, powerfully, whatever was below you.
00:06:39.880 So condescension was like benevolent paternalism.
00:06:44.880 And I feel like part of what has happened in, in American culture is that there's a lot
00:06:50.780 of status anxiety or like, like around even acknowledgement of differences.
00:06:53.840 I think it's more than that.
00:06:55.140 So I think something that the manosphere accurately points out is that as a man, when you show emotional
00:07:02.360 weakness or you defer to a woman in your life consistently, for many women within our current
00:07:09.760 cultural context, they will permanently look less upon you.
00:07:14.760 They will, you know, like you've talked about this.
00:07:17.580 Some people are like, oh yeah, you know, open up to your wife, you know, have a cry, show
00:07:20.980 how sad you are about something.
00:07:22.820 And you've been like, actually, this can permanently damage your relationship with somebody, even if
00:07:27.640 they don't want it to.
00:07:28.660 Yeah, yeah, yeah, because especially because if someone like if they're, I mean, using our
00:07:33.940 terminology, if they're lore in your relationship, the thing that they use to attract you and
00:07:39.700 bring you in was, oh, I'm very powerful.
00:07:42.380 I'm very strong.
00:07:43.900 And the thing of value that I provide to you is to feel like you're always surrounded by
00:07:47.860 this invulnerable, super powerful person.
00:07:50.220 Of course, it's going to break the entire selling point when that person suddenly becomes
00:07:55.280 vulnerable and where you, the other partner, find yourself in a position where you feel
00:07:59.360 like you need to be the powerful one, which, you know, many people just don't want to do
00:08:03.360 that.
00:08:03.580 They want to surrender, you know?
00:08:05.400 No, absolutely.
00:08:06.140 Yeah.
00:08:06.420 And so I think that they do recognize this aspect where.
00:08:10.880 And there's something there, but there it's so there's a big difference between vulnerability
00:08:15.580 and and showing like, I don't know, putting someone on a pedestal or like groveling at
00:08:22.180 their feet and showing a polite deference to to someone.
00:08:27.640 Well, I'll divide this because I think you're capturing something really true, but I called
00:08:32.660 the way I treat you in our family pedestalization, which is to an extent, but it's a bit of a wrong
00:08:37.300 word because I think when we think of pedestalization within the manosphere, what we're thinking of is
00:08:43.180 the way that we sometimes pedestalize a woman who we have a crush on or something like that.
00:08:48.320 Right.
00:08:48.520 And we begin to think too much of them or treat them with too much deference, you know,
00:08:52.240 before relationships start, when I first started dating you, I treated you not this way as
00:08:58.580 much.
00:08:58.960 No, but you know, when I realized and when it was very clear that our relationship was long
00:09:05.980 term and I began to integrate with you identity wise, it became very important when I thought
00:09:12.660 about the image I am portraying to my daughters around what a marriage means.
00:09:17.640 And so this sort of divides things into three broad categories.
00:09:22.320 Okay.
00:09:23.480 Behavior patterns you can show, right?
00:09:25.780 One is the behavior pattern where you as a guy are sublimating yourselves to a wise desires
00:09:32.660 because she is pushing these desires upon you.
00:09:34.940 She is saying, I want this.
00:09:37.360 I want that.
00:09:38.180 I want you to change X, Y, Z about yourself.
00:09:40.840 And you're like, oh, okay.
00:09:42.280 Okay.
00:09:42.800 Yes.
00:09:43.160 Whatever you want, you know?
00:09:44.640 Right.
00:09:45.380 And, and, and this is true.
00:09:46.860 This is a submissive position, which can, if it is not what a woman wants, hurt her perception
00:09:53.060 of you permanently.
00:09:54.480 Totally.
00:09:54.780 Even if you were just trying to make her happy.
00:09:57.160 Right.
00:09:57.360 Then there's the secondary position, which is to say, okay, I am going to constantly show
00:10:04.120 my dominance to the women in my life, constantly build frame in which I am this hotshot and
00:10:12.520 they are this weaker person than me.
00:10:15.820 Right.
00:10:16.020 Um, and one thing that I would always say, and, and this is, this is something I'd so
00:10:22.360 want to, like, I actually think Andrew Tate has some good points.
00:10:25.340 I don't hate everything he says.
00:10:27.100 I think he has some interesting things, but I think the, the one thing I would frame or
00:10:32.400 my biggest disagreement from him is weak women make weak sons.
00:10:36.700 And it's true.
00:10:38.440 And if you have a whole attraction strategy, if you have a whole life strategy for how you
00:10:44.180 are treating your wife that consistently disempowers her, you are making a weak mother and weak
00:10:51.400 mothers genetically and socially will lead to weak daughters and weak sons, which permanently
00:10:57.480 weakens your family line.
00:10:59.220 Well, and furthermore, treating a mother, any mother figure or woman in a relationship like
00:11:04.840 trash, isn't going to inspire daughters to be really excited to enter those relationships
00:11:10.900 or have kids.
00:11:11.140 People are like, oh, my sons will be okay.
00:11:12.740 But then your son's daughters will not be okay.
00:11:15.160 So anyway, but then there's this other category.
00:11:17.280 So I've, I've talked about this dichotomy of categories of, of, of male to female treatment.
00:11:21.160 Yeah.
00:11:21.720 Then there's this other category of treatment, which used to be the gentleman.
00:11:26.620 Okay.
00:11:27.840 And it's funny in historic society, like when, when, when these manners came up, it's almost
00:11:34.300 like they didn't conceive that there might be a world in which women lorded over men.
00:11:39.240 They were just like, how do you not lord over your wife too much?
00:11:42.940 And so this, this whole new category of behavior is like a new thing that nobody really knew
00:11:46.620 how to deal with.
00:11:47.280 So it wasn't really considered when all these rules were created, but a lot of it means that
00:11:51.900 you have to be there to protect your wife and your wife's emotional state to somewhat
00:11:58.600 anticipatorily.
00:12:01.280 Right.
00:12:01.720 So you went on a trip, right.
00:12:04.160 And I know the things you care about.
00:12:05.820 You just came back from a business trip, making our family money.
00:12:08.140 I love that.
00:12:08.620 Right.
00:12:08.900 And I didn't have to go.
00:12:10.700 And I, I know that you don't care about flowers or stuff like that, but you really care about
00:12:15.040 how clean things are.
00:12:16.140 So, I mean, it's a point of having the car detail when you got back and having the house
00:12:19.660 look really pristine when you get back because early in our relationship, which you would
00:12:23.580 leave the house would just fall to hell when she left all the dishes would pile up,
00:12:29.240 everything like that.
00:12:30.180 And I saw it emotionally hurt her.
00:12:32.540 Now, she didn't then go to me and say, Hey, Malcolm, never do this again.
00:12:37.920 Right.
00:12:39.680 But she knew because of the, the priors I had set in our relationship that when I had obviously
00:12:47.980 emotionally hurt her or put her in a bad emotional state that I had shown in the future, I don't
00:12:54.620 like hurting my wife.
00:12:56.080 So in the future, I went out of my way to try to prevent those states.
00:13:00.800 Right.
00:13:01.000 And that showed how much I cared about her while also showing, I think, you know, if I had
00:13:06.980 kids who were more cognizant in the house right now, that dad's really thinking about how mom
00:13:14.620 feels and he's trying to make her feel special, particularly when she puts herself out from
00:13:21.580 the family, but also just every day.
00:13:23.220 But yeah, I think there's something else that has been lost that men are missing out on.
00:13:31.420 And, and it's again, like it comes back to class.
00:13:35.200 Like I was saying earlier, a lot of the discomfort, I think, or a lot of where this got lost was
00:13:39.540 this, this sort of loss of comfort with there being class differentiation, or frankly, in
00:13:44.360 any differentiation, gender differentiation, anything like that.
00:13:47.120 So like men opening doors for women, people acknowledging that there are different social
00:13:51.460 classes, like it just makes people super uncomfortable.
00:13:53.520 And we all pretend that it's not real, even though we all know that it's there and we
00:13:57.980 all experience it every day.
00:14:00.220 And, and if, I think that's one reason why men are misunderstanding what it looks like to
00:14:05.640 be dominant and then ending up just kind of acting like trailer trash when they try to
00:14:10.120 be dominant, you know, it's just, you know, they, they think.
00:14:12.400 Oh my gosh.
00:14:13.420 I love, no, it's true what you're saying.
00:14:15.780 Right.
00:14:16.200 And, and, and this is because when an individual is resource scarce.
00:14:20.600 Oh God, this is going to sound so bad, no matter how I say it.
00:14:24.500 Do it.
00:14:25.060 Okay.
00:14:25.400 Let's not see what an individual is resource scarce.
00:14:27.300 When an individual is under a lot of emotional stress, their inhibitory pathways don't function
00:14:32.520 the way they would normally function.
00:14:34.760 You know, if you had like a full civilizational construct around an individual and they begin
00:14:39.560 reacting in a way that is very animalistic, it's, it's, it's their base impulses.
00:14:46.860 Right.
00:14:47.500 And so when they are asserting dominance, you know, it's what you think you're better
00:14:52.300 than me.
00:14:52.880 You think you're better than me.
00:14:53.960 Well, what is a person saying when they're saying that they're really saying, do you think
00:14:57.360 you're of a higher dominance position than me in this local hierarchy that we've created?
00:15:02.320 How dare you think you are dominant in, in comparison to me?
00:15:06.040 And when they do that, Oh, you think about, you know, they're puffing themselves up like
00:15:09.620 an animal trying to get in like a gorilla and another gorilla, like in a dominance fight.
00:15:13.200 Right.
00:15:13.780 And humans default to this.
00:15:15.300 Right.
00:15:16.140 However, every cultural group has different, more refined ways to handle these dominant
00:15:23.140 fights that don't involve two males making themselves look big and then like physically
00:15:27.340 attacking each other.
00:15:28.440 Because that's really cost.
00:15:30.600 If you have to solve every dominance fight was like actual physical violence, their actual
00:15:35.000 you know, and this is what Simone means when she says she mentally is associating with this,
00:15:43.400 this was, was like lower socioeconomic groups because lower socioeconomic groups, like anyone
00:15:49.840 who's resource scarce is, is, are going to have the less luxury of the ability to suppress
00:15:57.060 these things.
00:15:57.480 And often their families have been in this situation for multiple generations.
00:16:00.820 So they might have lost even the cultural software for how do I handle a dominance fight with
00:16:07.660 another male other than puffing myself up and then beating him up.
00:16:12.140 Right.
00:16:12.340 I think we've lost, we've lost a lot of the ways that people historically demonstrated dominance
00:16:19.200 in, this sounds terrible, it's really classist, but in a, in a civilized fashion.
00:16:24.420 So anyone who's read the original, like Peter Pan by J.M.
00:16:27.700 Berry will recall that the, the constant fight between Peter Pan and Captain Hook was actually
00:16:34.500 pretty interesting.
00:16:35.320 And both of them were like pretty obsessed with good form, good form.
00:16:39.340 They were always like, oh, that was bad form.
00:16:40.980 That was good form.
00:16:41.980 And it wasn't, it wasn't about who won the fight.
00:16:45.420 I mean, they, they both really cared about the fight, the art of the fight, and also like
00:16:48.980 playing with good form.
00:16:50.540 And I think that there's something about traditional successful masculinity that involves good form,
00:16:58.720 not just like successful showing of dominance or violence or disregarding another party.
00:17:05.720 It involves fighting right, fighting fair and fighting clean.
00:17:10.040 I forgot who said this anyway.
00:17:11.800 Well, I'm going to find whoever said it from our listeners.
00:17:15.320 They'll be like, oh, I know who said this quote.
00:17:16.920 So the quote is something like a, a true gentleman is defined by an individual who knows how to
00:17:23.920 open a quarrel and maintain one.
00:17:26.800 And what that means is that actually part of, at least in the Victorian period, being part of
00:17:32.280 this upper class society was about starting specific quarrels with individuals, but also
00:17:39.900 all of the rules for how these quarrels worked, right?
00:17:43.560 You could be one of these guff people who has seen, what's an example of somebody who is like
00:17:48.160 bad at quarrels, Andrew Jackson, right?
00:17:50.820 He'd just shoot anyone.
00:17:51.840 He'd be like, okay, going to a duel, directly to a duel.
00:17:55.480 You disagree with me, duel time.
00:17:57.640 The man did not know how to fight.
00:17:58.960 And that would have been seen within the period.
00:18:00.340 And it was seen within the political advertisements is like a very low class way of handling these
00:18:04.420 disagreements, whereas within these, and again, sorry, we're talking about class so much here.
00:18:10.860 And I really need to be clear what I mean by this in a historic context.
00:18:15.760 Every cultural group had its own complicated set of rules for disagreeing with another individual
00:18:22.800 and conflicting with another individual.
00:18:25.320 But those broke down and would become more and more the pre-evolved set of rules, which
00:18:31.760 previously I referred to as animalistic, but it's really humanistic.
00:18:34.940 It's really the way humans act if they lived on a desert island and were never exposed to
00:18:40.100 any other cultural group.
00:18:41.060 Yeah.
00:18:41.200 Like we're talking about the presence or evidence or trappings of culture, AKA civilization.
00:18:48.020 Like the presence of a set of values of traditions of, of basically pro-social per that culture
00:18:56.680 or religion, um, uh, civilizational technologies or the absence of them.
00:19:02.900 And the problem is what we're discussing is, is that there's, there's basically an absence
00:19:06.320 of civilizational, cultural, religious, whatever you want to call it, technologies in male
00:19:11.760 dominance, especially as demonstrated to women.
00:19:14.100 Right.
00:19:14.700 Well, yeah, but you, you can, I mean, there's other ways around this.
00:19:18.200 So when I was in high school, you know, one of the things I always told you about the,
00:19:20.820 the fights, I got in a lot of fights in detention and stuff like this.
00:19:24.620 And I realized pretty early, there was a specific strategy I would use in my fight.
00:19:28.660 So I would physically often lose the fights individuals.
00:19:32.840 I was not the strongest kid.
00:19:35.400 I mean, I was, I was medium strong.
00:19:36.840 Like I knew how to fight, but I couldn't ensure that I would always win a fight.
00:19:41.940 However, what I could ensure, and I always went into fights with this strategy is always
00:19:47.560 give my opponent a bloody nose or a black eye because after the fight, even if they physically
00:19:54.660 caused more damage, I'm in more pain.
00:19:57.040 I have more long-term damage to my body because of that fight.
00:20:01.020 They walk out and they go to a group and the public sees the two of us and they did damage
00:20:06.320 to my torso or some other area.
00:20:08.340 I have a few bruises that are easy to cover up, but they have a black eye for the rest
00:20:12.640 of the week, or they're walking out of that fight with a bloody nose.
00:20:16.720 People perceive the public perception is they lost the fight.
00:20:21.780 And what they misunderstood going into that fight is they thought the purpose of that fight,
00:20:26.780 even from an animalistic, you know, middle school, high school context was to hurt me.
00:20:32.180 The actual purpose of the fight was to determine our positions in the local hierarchy of our
00:20:39.540 high school or middle school.
00:20:41.200 Actually funny, but most people, our listeners might be surprised that I always was really
00:20:45.680 obsessed with protecting any group that I thought was disenfranchised was in my current
00:20:50.300 community context.
00:20:51.020 So most of the fights I would get into were protecting gay people because I would, so this
00:20:56.280 might seem really weird to a Gen Z audience today, but when I grew up, you know, me standing
00:21:03.620 up to people who were using derogatory terms that I can't even say on YouTube now towards
00:21:09.940 gay kids at my school to protect them was something that would cause them to fight me.
00:21:16.520 I mean, let's talk about why it caused them to fight me, because this is actually really
00:21:18.780 interesting as well.
00:21:19.420 So when you're talking about like how human social hierarchies work, when, when, when one
00:21:25.060 group of people is like making fun of another individual, if I come and I stand up for that
00:21:31.220 individual, I say, Hey, stop this.
00:21:32.940 You guys, I have actually asserted myself even was in their dominance hierarchy as head, like
00:21:38.380 above the highest person was in their dominance hierarchy.
00:21:41.960 And if they capitulate to that, if they walk away, they have lost status within their local
00:21:48.500 dominance hierarchy and was in the global dominance hierarchy of the school.
00:21:51.640 So they're almost sort of like trapped, like they, they can't avoid, and we'll do another
00:21:56.020 episode on, on bullying because this people not understanding how like high school dominance
00:22:00.140 hierarchies work, it causes a lot of bullying, but they're trapped.
00:22:03.020 You know, they actually have to fight me to, to show that, that they haven't lost face,
00:22:09.500 but if they then come out of that fight with physical damage and black eyes were the thing
00:22:13.260 I always really aim for because those last for about a week.
00:22:15.780 And so, you know, they can then tell people, Oh, I beat up Malcolm, but they have a black
00:22:20.740 eye and I look fine on the other side of the classroom.
00:22:23.420 It doesn't sell.
00:22:25.140 It doesn't sell.
00:22:26.000 And, and this is where all of this comes down to is so much of the ways that we act and
00:22:32.460 posture are about changing our dominance positions vis-a-vis other people was in our
00:22:38.500 society.
00:22:38.900 But we forget how those around us are judging that and how those within our own family are
00:22:45.380 judging that.
00:22:46.000 And this is where, when we're talking about the way a man treats a woman in a long-term
00:22:49.420 relationship, why it's very important to like intentionally build a culture for your
00:22:54.080 family.
00:22:54.860 I don't think you ever feel that I am like putting myself in a submissive position to you
00:23:01.160 when I am going out of my way to make you feel good about yourself.
00:23:04.860 Do you, or like, how is it that I have prevented that framing?
00:23:10.640 Yeah, I think, I think it, a lot of it depends on contextualization.
00:23:15.460 So when condescending to a woman or when showing deference to a woman comes from a position of
00:23:22.920 power, then you're, you're asserting dominance essentially.
00:23:26.480 So when, you know, think about all the scenarios of like traditional gentlemen, you know, a traditional
00:23:31.580 gentleman, paying for a meal, paying for a meal that comes from a position of power.
00:23:35.940 Well, hold on, not always.
00:23:37.540 If a, if a, if, you know, there's two different ways you can end up paying for a meal.
00:23:41.620 What is another person's like snidely.
00:23:43.760 Oh, like stiffing you or something.
00:23:45.120 Right.
00:23:45.580 The other one is Southern gentleman style where everyone's fighting to pay for the meal.
00:23:49.580 You know, happens whenever we're visiting my family because the person who pays for the
00:23:53.440 meal has shown their higher social status than the other people in the community.
00:23:56.660 Right.
00:23:57.240 Yeah.
00:23:57.520 Yeah.
00:23:57.920 Yeah.
00:23:58.140 But yeah, so I would say, yeah, opening doors, the, the, the very classic example that freaks
00:24:03.580 me out of the man throwing down his coat.
00:24:06.140 So the woman doesn't, you know, step in the mud puddle.
00:24:09.180 Well, a man who does that has to be in so much of a position of power.
00:24:12.660 They can have people to clean his coat for him or several coats that he can change into.
00:24:16.460 Right.
00:24:16.640 So a lot of these gallant moves actually are dominance displays.
00:24:20.880 It's just, I think people have forgotten the context of them.
00:24:23.860 Whereas when instead it comes from a position of weakness, oh, I'm afraid.
00:24:28.140 And because my female partner is unhappy, I need to go make her happy.
00:24:33.420 Or I'm afraid because my female partner is going to get angry at me.
00:24:37.300 If I don't appease her, then it, you know, comes from the completely wrong position.
00:24:41.860 And it shows a lot of submission on the male part.
00:24:44.140 So I think a lot of it is it's proactive.
00:24:45.860 Like you were saying earlier, one of the things that you do is anticipate my needs.
00:24:50.140 So I'm not asking you to do something.
00:24:52.360 You are anticipating my needs and acting ahead of me acting as though I need something or
00:24:57.400 showing that I need something.
00:24:59.040 So if it's anticipatory and if it's a, if it's a display of having either more emotional
00:25:04.740 control, more resources, more strength, all those sorts of things, you know, like lifting
00:25:09.020 up suitcases for me.
00:25:10.300 And when you always put, you know, my suitcase in the overhead bin, you always handle our
00:25:13.660 luggage.
00:25:14.300 Like that is, that is a, that's a dominance display.
00:25:16.960 So I think that's the key differentiating.
00:25:19.240 How you're culturally relating to it.
00:25:21.720 That makes it one.
00:25:22.820 And I actually think that this is an important thing was in relationships, right?
00:25:26.260 When you are dating a woman, as a guy today, I would say, you get a chance to see how she
00:25:33.660 reacts to gentlemanliness.
00:25:36.860 I guess I would call it if she perceives it as a weakness, right?
00:25:42.680 And I think you can tell pretty quickly, does she, does she think that she's the one scored
00:25:47.180 a point on you by you being gentlemanly to her?
00:25:50.200 There's really nothing you can do.
00:25:51.820 There is no way that that relationship ends happily unless you just go like full Tate and
00:25:58.720 you basically dominate her and treat her like a house slave, right?
00:26:02.820 But if she has the acculturation and the upbringing, which many women, so the great thing is you
00:26:09.580 might be like women these days, no women these days, especially if we're talking Gen Z from
00:26:15.360 the families that are actually having kids.
00:26:17.100 A lot of them have the class, regardless of their economic status, to see that politeness
00:26:24.060 and gentlemanliness is a kindness to them.
00:26:26.740 Because it's many of these more traditional families that are having these large families
00:26:30.100 and women in these families are raised to recognize these things.
00:26:33.900 If you are dating women who don't recognize that when you are opening the door for them,
00:26:39.760 that it is not because you are beneath them, right?
00:26:43.860 If a woman thinks that, then she's trash, right?
00:26:46.360 No, you know, I think it's two things here.
00:26:48.760 One is I feel like the key differentiating factor between submissive male action that's
00:26:54.220 deferential towards women and dominant male action that's deferential towards women is
00:26:58.100 whether it's proactive or reactive.
00:27:01.420 Proactive is a dominance display.
00:27:03.260 Reactive is a submission display.
00:27:05.400 Second, I kind of feel like proactive male dominance displays and deference of women are
00:27:11.020 shit tests from men.
00:27:12.360 So if you as a man take a proactive dominance display, you pay for the meal, you open the door
00:27:16.820 and the your date, your female date, like sniffs at that or doesn't appreciate it.
00:27:23.020 And that's key.
00:27:24.100 Then, you know, she's not a good match.
00:27:26.340 Like she needs to be shown right away that it's super not cool that she did that.
00:27:31.140 And if she doesn't change, then she's not a good match.
00:27:33.320 But it's one of those things where you point out in the practice guide to relationships,
00:27:36.880 how if you don't immediately draw lines with partners and explain this reaction is totally
00:27:42.460 not cool.
00:27:43.480 You know, if we keep doing this, like we are not a we, then, you know, nothing's going to
00:27:48.260 happen.
00:27:48.520 But what do you think about that as, as a.
00:27:50.320 I think that's a really good point.
00:27:51.820 And it comes, you know, when you talk about paying for meals, I think that's almost the
00:27:55.920 core of it, right?
00:27:57.660 Whenever I would date women on the first date, I would usually, unless I took them to an
00:28:03.100 unusually expensive restaurant, like I did with you on the first date, I would usually
00:28:06.620 go 50 50, right?
00:28:08.520 But even when I take them to an expensive restaurant, like when I took you to an expensive restaurant
00:28:12.120 and I would pay for it, if you hadn't thought to pay for it, I would have treated that as
00:28:17.560 a extreme red flag.
00:28:19.420 And you didn't, but you're like, no, no, no, you know, I have to do this.
00:28:22.260 And I'm like, no, no, no.
00:28:23.140 I took you to a more expensive restaurant than you would have gone to.
00:28:25.260 You know, I bought you drinks.
00:28:26.660 You've never really drunk before.
00:28:28.240 You know, so we're, we're, I'm the first restaurant I took her to.
00:28:31.600 Um, she goes, oh, I don't drink and I don't eat meat.
00:28:33.840 And I was like, well, you know, what I say, like, that's not happening if you're dating
00:28:40.060 me.
00:28:40.320 And so she goes, okay, I guess I'm eating meat and drinking, but you know, I, I, I put
00:28:44.280 her in that position, but she still fought back against me paying for it.
00:28:47.440 So I knew that she had a level of gratitude for me doing that.
00:28:50.460 And I think that this is an area where we begin to see a corruption of the gentleman values
00:28:55.180 that can happen after a few generations of a culture.
00:28:57.340 And we need to really work to make sure it never happens, especially with our daughters
00:29:00.180 is just because they know a man is, can show their dominance through paying for something.
00:29:05.080 They should never expect them to.
00:29:07.260 Yeah.
00:29:07.380 And also never exploited.
00:29:08.740 I mean, at least in media, I don't know if this happens in practice.
00:29:12.180 It's, it's implied that a lot of women are like, oh, it's a free meal.
00:29:15.320 Like I'll go on this date.
00:29:16.500 Cause it's a free dinner and I don't feel like paying for dinner, but I want to go
00:29:19.620 out.
00:29:20.160 And that's, that is really screwed up.
00:29:23.220 Or they see it as an exchange.
00:29:24.740 Like I go out, he does this, I get this.
00:29:28.220 Instead of he is showing his, his upbringing through how he's treating me and his level
00:29:34.980 of respect for me.
00:29:36.220 And I do think the other thing that you said there is the anticipatory aspect of being
00:29:40.240 a gentleman when you're in a really like long-term relationship with somebody, you're one of
00:29:47.320 the core things that you're supposed to do as a partner.
00:29:48.900 And you do this for me all the time as well, is you try to understand them the best you
00:29:54.600 can.
00:29:55.320 So, you know, the things that are necessary, the things that are harder for them than for
00:29:59.540 you and, and the, the things you could do to make them feel special and that you aren't
00:30:05.060 doing those things just on days where you're trying to make them special.
00:30:08.560 But that is a natural part of every interaction you have with them.
00:30:14.640 And I think that that is, is the key, but that they never lose their gratitude for that.
00:30:21.080 And as I've said over and over again, when you're choosing who you marry, the single most
00:30:26.000 important thing is not how hot they are.
00:30:29.860 It's, it's not how smart they are.
00:30:32.480 I think the second to the most important thing is work ethic.
00:30:34.480 Work ethic is a very important, but it's how much gratitude they are capable of showing
00:30:39.720 because some people in our society have just been trained out of showing gratitude.
00:30:46.560 You know, if you were to embody, you know, we were talking about Andrew Tate earlier, like
00:30:49.720 a full Tate mindset.
00:30:51.200 I genuinely don't know if he's capable of feeling gratitude for the things the woman in
00:30:56.000 his life do for him.
00:30:57.020 And that would lead to a really like not great long-term relationship.
00:31:01.520 Like, I think he's smart about a lot of things.
00:31:03.040 I just, you know, and it may just be framing.
00:31:05.180 It may just be the way he's showing himself to the public.
00:31:06.760 That's like biteable, like hookable for young guys, but the ability of both yourself and
00:31:13.280 a partner to show and genuinely feel gratitude when the other person anticipates their needs
00:31:19.340 and goes out of the way to address them.
00:31:20.980 I think that's just so, so, so key.
00:31:24.440 And no matter how perfect a partner is for you, if they are unable to feel gratitude when
00:31:30.720 you go out of your way to be nice with them, so they can be the hottest, smartest, richest
00:31:34.860 person in the world.
00:31:36.340 If they don't feel gratitude when you go out of your way for them, the relationship won't
00:31:41.480 last.
00:31:41.840 It will devolve.
00:31:43.600 It might be five years.
00:31:44.860 It might be 10 years.
00:31:45.940 But a breakup of a relationship, especially the longer the relationship is, the more you
00:31:51.460 suffer, you know, either because they get some of your kids who do then get raised in
00:31:55.900 an environment where they're like poisoned against you or all of the other terrible aspects.
00:32:02.300 Well, this has been fun to talk about.
00:32:04.720 I think what we're going to focus in on more with our kids and teaching them like inter, inter-gender
00:32:11.480 relations, is a heavy emphasis on good form, proactive, anticipatory, kind action on both
00:32:21.380 parts.
00:32:21.660 It doesn't matter what gender you are, what role you're playing, whatever.
00:32:25.000 And then looking for gratitude from that partner when you show that action.
00:32:29.400 And if you don't see it, either show that that's super not okay and see if they change
00:32:32.960 or just drop them.
00:32:34.380 Yeah.
00:32:36.100 I love you, Simone.
00:32:37.040 And I hope that our daughters can see that and that they grow up believing and that our
00:32:41.600 sons grow up understanding how a woman should be treated within our cultural group so that
00:32:46.860 their own daughters are really excited to become wives and mothers.
00:32:51.700 I think there's no way they're not going to see it.
00:32:53.820 I love you so much, Malcolm.
00:32:55.180 You're the best.
00:32:55.680 I love you too.