Dominion Society of Canada - August 26, 2025


How did the Liberal win?


Episode Stats

Length

2 minutes

Words per Minute

207.64273

Word Count

451

Sentence Count

21


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Why did Canada vote for Justin Trudeau in the 2015 election? Why did they vote for him? And why did they not vote for his opponent, Pierre Dorion, who was a much better candidate? In this episode of the podcast, we talk about why the people of Canada voted for Trudeau, and why they voted for him in the first place.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00.000 If there's 70 percent, and I've seen the same polls as you, if there's 70 percent of people who believe there's too much immigration and they want it shut down, why were they voting for this guy?
00:00:09.160 Polyev was talking about it during the election campaign, but I've become more aware that it's pretty much a uniparty in this country.
00:00:17.400 And I thought the conservatives would give us a slower road to hell.
00:00:20.680 And maybe I was right.
00:00:21.620 Maybe I wasn't.
00:00:22.340 Maybe it's good that we're on this fast road to hell so more people wake up quicker.
00:00:25.740 But how is it that the people of this country still voted liberal, even with all of the stuff going on?
00:00:33.620 So for one, Pierre could have made mass immigration a key issue in this election.
00:00:37.620 He failed to do so.
00:00:38.560 He wasted two years making his whole campaign about the carbon tax and Justin Trudeau.
00:00:43.260 And that blew up in his face when both of them were removed at the start of the year.
00:00:46.460 This left him in a difficult position.
00:00:47.900 They talked a little bit about immigration during the election, but it was mostly around opposing the century initiative.
00:00:52.780 It was talking about this scary dystopian world where by 2100, there'd be 100 million people instead of grappling with the issues today.
00:01:00.900 If he had embraced it and talked about the complications caused by mass immigration in this day and age, I think they could have been a lot more successful.
00:01:07.460 But to talk about why Mark Carney won, I think it goes back to those questions about Canadian identity.
00:01:12.000 And an important part about Canadian identity that we didn't cover at the start is this kind of strain of anti-Americanism.
00:01:18.040 Canada as a people, Canada as a country was founded in rejection to America, like a large component of our English speaking kind of founding stock were literally loyalists who were living in the US who fought against the Americans and the Revolutionary War on the side of the British and then as such were kind of pariahs from society and came up north to help start Canada.
00:01:38.320 Canadians like very instinctually have these anti-American instincts.
00:01:42.720 Now, in more recent years, especially in the post-war period,
00:01:45.760 we become very integrated with the Americans culturally, economically.
00:01:49.080 But there's still this lasting instinct within us
00:01:52.060 that just recoils of the idea of becoming America.
00:01:54.820 So when Trump made this the central election issue
00:01:57.520 and the liberals were more quick to kind of jump on it
00:02:00.180 and make it their central response,
00:02:02.080 they spoke to something deep within the soul of the average Canadian
00:02:05.780 that the Conservatives just weren't attuned to.
00:02:08.320 You