Full Comment - May 18, 2026


Canada’s too late now to save CUSMA from a Trump rewrite...or worse

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
This is why so many Albertans want to separate Investor interest in Alberta going ‘nuclear’ over Carney’s messaging

Episode Stats


Length

40 minutes

Words per minute

162.13

Word count

6,641

Sentence count

410

Harmful content

Hate speech

8

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Tracy Morin joins me from her home in Washington, D.C. to talk about the ongoing trade talks between Canada and the United States, and why she thinks there's no chance of a deal being struck.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Behind every F-35 jet is a Canadian company.
00:00:03 Horizontal tails built in Winnipeg, engine sensors from Ottawa, and stealth composite
00:00:07 panels crafted in Lunenburg to name just a few.
00:00:09 Thanks to thousands of skilled Canadian workers, the F-35 aircraft is delivering unmatched
00:00:13 capabilities for 20 allied nations around the world and will generate more than $15.5
00:00:18 billion in industrial value for Canada.
00:00:20 This ad is sponsored by the F-35 partner team, Lockheed Martin, BAE Systems, Northrop Grumman,
00:00:25 and RTX.
00:00:26 more at www.f35.com slash canada visit bet mgm casino and check out the newest exclusive
00:00:35 the price is right fortune pick bet mgm and game sense remind you to play responsibly 19 plus to
00:00:40 wager ontario only please play responsibly if you have questions or concerns about your gambling or
00:00:46 someone close to you please contact connects ontario at 1-866-531-2600 to speak to an advisor
00:00:52 Free of charge, BetMGM operates pursuant to an operating agreement with iGaming Ontario.
00:01:02 If you're looking to have a clear picture of where things are at when it comes to trade talks between Canada and the United States, good luck.
00:01:09 Right now, what we're getting is a lot of secrecy, and when we do get messages, they're often conflicting.
00:01:15 Hello and welcome to the Full Comment Podcast.
00:01:17 My name's Brian Lilly, your host.
00:01:19 You'll know that over the last year, Prime Minister Mark Carney has been telling us that deeper integration with the United States, well, those days are over.
00:01:26 Being too close to the Americans, that's a weakness.
00:01:29 And yet, recently at a summit in Toronto co-hosted by the Center for American Progress, Mark Carney not only embraced people like Barack Obama, Alex Soros, and others, he said he's open to deeper integration.
00:01:44 Canada, like Mexico, like Mexico, Canada remains open to deeper integration, including options for fortress North America in selected sectors.
00:01:56 And to be clear, those offers are on the table.
00:02:00 If that leaves you confused, well, you're not alone.
00:02:03 Then, just recently, he also was asked about the talks with the United States and the fact that Honda decided to pull out of its plans for an expanded auto plant here.
00:02:13 The Japanese have made it clear if there is no access to the American market from Canada, they're not going to be investing.
00:02:20 Here's what Carney said in response to that.
00:02:22 Well, as we've said, we're ready to sit down for those negotiations.
00:02:30 We know what the major trade issues are for the United States.
00:02:35 We have a series of issues around the strategic sectors, including the auto sector, the steel sector, aluminum, forest products particularly.
00:02:42 now derivatives of copper and aluminum and steel.
00:02:48 There are big opportunities for both of us
00:02:51 if we can come to an agreement.
00:02:54 It takes Americans to focus,
00:02:56 and I'm sure once they're finished with their discussions with China,
00:03:00 they'll focus.
00:03:00 So where do things stand?
00:03:02 Well, we can look at it from the Canadian point of view
00:03:04 or ask someone in the American capital.
00:03:07 Tracy Morin is a journalist.
00:03:08 She writes for National Post and covers things cross-border from the United States.
00:03:14 She joined me from her home in Virginia.
00:03:17 So, Tracy, you're in Washington.
00:03:19 We've just heard the prime minister say that, well, we're waiting on the Americans.
00:03:24 I'm talking to people in Washington on both sides who say more often than not that, well, actually, the Americans are waiting on us.
00:03:34 It doesn't seem like there's a clear sense of what's going on.
00:03:36 what are you hearing from the folks that you're talking to in D.C. about where the talks are and
00:03:42 who's waiting on who? That's an interesting question, Brian. Thanks for asking. I'm hearing
00:03:48 both, frankly. I'm hearing that the Canadians are waiting for the Americans to reach out,
00:03:53 and I'm also hearing from those in touch with the American negotiators that they are waiting
00:03:58 for the Canadians to reach out and that they're surprised that the Canadians haven't. What's a
00:04:03 little alarming to me in recent days is that there are now suggestions within the Beltway that
00:04:09 Americans may be starting to come to the realization or the supposition that Carney
00:04:15 may not be serious about reaching a deal. I don't know if that's true, but that is something that is
00:04:21 being whispered about more and more, and that is concerning.
00:04:25 It does seem like there is, at the least, a waiting game going on.
00:04:32 And we've heard Carney's team talk openly about this, that, well, maybe we wait until the midterms and maybe things change.
00:04:43 It seems like there's an awful lot in flux right now.
00:04:46 Now, maybe you can explain for listeners in Canada, you know, polling would seem to show that the Democrats are going to take an awful lot of seats in the House in the midterms.
00:04:58 But at the same time, you've got redistricting happening absolutely everywhere across the United States.
00:05:04 You've got blue states saying, oh, we're going to redraw our maps so that it favors Democrats.
00:05:08 Red states saying, we're going to redraw our maps to favor Republicans.
00:05:13 And then you've got that Supreme Court decision on race-based districts, and that's going to change the map.
00:05:19 So do we even know what the map looks like and who's going to win?
00:05:23 It seems like flux would be the best word to describe what's going on.
00:05:28 And in the middle of all this flux, we've got a Canadian government possibly saying, let's just wait and see.
00:05:34 Yeah. Well, here, I'm based in Virginia, and we just had a vote, and the Supreme Court and the state overturned it.
00:05:41 and it will probably be fought all the way up to the U.S. Supreme Court.
00:05:44 So is the map set?
00:05:46 No, probably not for now.
00:05:49 It'll be set November 1st.
00:05:51 Right.
00:05:54 There is, a lot of trade watchers are saying that there is a bit of a waiting game going on
00:05:59 and something that's smart of Carney's team to be laying low,
00:06:03 not risking any tit for tat or any escalatory language in the press,
00:06:07 and that they may be waiting to see if a Democratic Congress might be a little friendlier,
00:06:14 might assert more authority over trade and uphold USMCA, be a little bit easier to deal with.
00:06:23 The problem with that is that it means less certainty for now, of course. It means more
00:06:29 uncertainty for the businesses and the people whose jobs rely on the trade. And there's also
00:06:36 So what you pointed out, we don't know how it will turn out, right? The polls change every day. While it looks like the Republicans may not hold on to the House now, it's months away. And counting Trump out has never been a, it's always been a risky venture.
00:06:52 So I'm not sure that it's the smartest game, but it seems to be what the Kearney team may be doing. They may be waiting it out to see if they can get a more friendly Congress to deal with.
00:07:06 But even then, there's a risk there because it doesn't necessarily guarantee a better outcome for them, right? Because the businesses are lacking certainty now. It prolongs instability. But there is a risk that even if the legislative branch is a little friendlier towards USMCA and towards Canada, it doesn't mean that the White House will be.
00:07:32 So then you might set up an impasse between the legislative and the executive branches, and that just leads to more judicial reviews and more fighting in the courts.
00:07:40 So it's a risky game.
00:07:42 Well, isn't there also the possibility that Democrats are no friendlier to Canada in terms of trade than the Republicans?
00:07:53 Democrats have historically been more protectionist than Republican.
00:07:56 Now, protectionism seems to be in vogue on all sides in Washington.
00:08:03 And so the, you know, if the Democrats take the House, maybe they are friendlier to Canada, but still screwing is over on trade because, well, they've got a steel mill in their district that they want to protect.
00:08:18 Or there's a, you know, a farm group that has bent their ear on country of origin labeling.
00:08:25 Or, I mean, there's any myriad of things that the irritants between Canada and the U.S. on trade don't change that much, regardless of who's in power.
00:08:35 The tone does, but the trade irritants remain the same.
00:08:39 That's right. It's the tone, right?
00:08:41 So you're right that under Biden and other Democrats, there has been an unwillingness to necessarily lift all the tariffs that have been in place or the duties that have been put in place by Republican administrations.
00:08:55 But a number of the U.S. states along the border are desperate for this trade to continue the way it has in the past.
00:09:03 So I think that a Democratic Congress would be much more in favor of retaining USMCA.
00:09:11 And frankly, they're going to be looking to assert some more trade authority over the presidency because that's been lacking over the past year.
00:09:19 So they will be trying to stand up to Trump.
00:09:22 Can you break this down for Canadian listeners?
00:09:25 um trade authority and who has it um i know that it normally rests with congress but congress can
00:09:34 give authority like fast track trade authority to say to the president okay you can go negotiate a
00:09:40 deal then you got to bring it back to us i know that one of the reasons the aipa tariffs were
00:09:47 struck down is that the supreme court said no congress didn't give you that authority
00:09:52 Unfortunately, the Section 232 tariffs, the ones that actually hit Canada, remain in place because, well, that legislation is pretty clear that it gives the president that authority.
00:10:02 So how does this work in terms of the back and forth and what could a Democratic Congress do to support USMCA or KUSMA that isn't being done now?
00:10:15 I could just say that because the USMCA was ratified by Congress, they will be looking to ensure that they have a voice in any major changes to USMCA. They're not going to appreciate it being undermined or maybe even bilateral deals being cut on the side that would interfere with a treaty that they had ratified. And that those voices would be stronger if it's a Democratic-controlled House.
00:10:42 Okay. What about the general sense of Democrats in Washington nowadays? Am I overplaying that
00:10:52 protectionism is in vogue with all parties? Kind of like how everyone used to love China,
00:10:59 and now none of the parties like China. Is it kind of that way in Washington right now?
00:11:05 That seems to be the one area where there is bipartisan agreement,
00:11:09 is being tough on China. Yes. But I don't think that that necessarily extends to Canada. It would
00:11:15 extend to Canada on any outlets through which China may be using Canada to reach the U.S.
00:11:21 markets, but that would be about it. Okay. So it was the Biden administration that wanted us to
00:11:27 block the Chinese electric vehicles. And we put in the 100% tariff on those because of the Biden
00:11:36 administration, not the Trump administration. So the issue of alcohol seems to be a sore spot.
00:11:46 U.S. Trade Representative Jamison Greer brought it up at a hearing, a congressional hearing a
00:11:51 little while ago. I know that as I speak to people in the industry and politicos here in Canada,
00:11:58 they say it is one of the first things that Ambassador Pete Hoekstra raises in absolutely
00:12:03 every meeting. Why are you guys not putting American booze back on the shelves?
00:12:10 How did that become such a huge thing in Washington, D.C.? You think of all the trade
00:12:17 that we do, all the cars, the lumber, the steel, the digital services, and we're talking about
00:12:23 wine and whiskey. Yes, you're right. I think part of it was because the campaign was so public,
00:12:28 It was part of this anti-American sentiment that the Liberal Party successfully used electorally.
00:12:38 And I remember seeing on social all of these ads about Buy Canadian and how all of the U.S. liquor had been cleared from the shelves in these various provinces.
00:12:48 And it has had an impact.
00:12:50 The spirits exports to Canada from the U.S. fell over 70 percent over the past year.
00:12:56 And I saw complaints from Jack Daniels and Woodford Reserve, the company that owns them, that they saw a 59% plunge in Canadian sales over the past year.
00:13:08 So it's definitely having an impact on U.S. liquor companies.
00:13:15 But I also just think it's a big poke in the eye to the Trump administration, right?
00:13:19 And it's been a very public poke in the eye from the Canadian side.
00:13:23 So that's part of what you're seeing play out in the rhetoric from the trade negotiators and from the ambassador.
00:13:30 And President Trump has made it clear he doesn't like getting poked in the eye.
00:13:34 The whole issue around the ad that Ontario was running, quoting Ronald Reagan, seemed to infuriate him.
00:13:41 Now, I don't believe that the ad is why talks were called off.
00:13:45 And I've written about that, that there were other things happening in the background, like, you know, Melanie Jolie putting tariffs on Canadian or on American cars coming into Canada that hadn't previously existed.
00:13:58 and threatening to sue GM in Stellantis.
00:14:01 These things didn't help,
00:14:02 but there really was a sense
00:14:07 that Trump and people around him
00:14:09 felt insulted by that ad.
00:14:12 Did it create a stir otherwise in the United States?
00:14:16 I mean, you're in a pretty political town.
00:14:18 Did anyone ever outside of work say,
00:14:22 oh, how about that Canadian ad in the World Series?
00:14:26 I mean, some people thought it was odd
00:14:28 that it was playing. Some people thought it was funny. I will say most within the beltway
00:14:32 on the Republican side did not want to comment on it because there are a lot of Reagan lovers
00:14:37 here, of course, and they did not want to be seen to be speaking ill of the president's
00:14:44 view on that ad. I don't think it had a major impact for Americans at large. I don't think
00:14:49 that they pay much attention to these things. I don't think Americans in general pay much
00:14:53 attention to foreign policy either. So I'm not sure it will have a lasting impact on the American
00:14:59 electorate. I'll ask the question that, you know, I know the answer to, but it always hurts
00:15:05 Canadians. Do Americans pay much attention to Canada or think about Canada all that much?
00:15:10 Well, we certainly think about Canada when it comes to hockey.
00:15:13 You did have a story recently, though, a poll that showed that Americans thought Canadians were more reliable than Donald Trump when it comes to trade. Tell me about that.
00:15:31 Right. That was based on a Leger poll from late April that said that 50% of Americans trust Canada to negotiate in trade talks in good faith, while only 42% trust the Trump administration to do the same.
00:15:46 And it's an interesting look, right? Like the idea that more people in the United States trust the Canadian negotiation team when it comes to trade talks.
00:15:57 But it's really, when you look at it closely, it's a breakdown along partisan lines. So you're automatically going to have a good 20 percentage points of people on the Democratic side who will say that they're opposed to anything the Trump administration will be doing. So that's already built in.
00:16:11 The real movement, I guess, was with the independents. So it is showing that there is a clear shift in the United States where people are growing increasingly fed up by some of the hostile rhetoric, but also the unpredictability, the higher inflation rates, the higher prices, and the trade tensions.
00:16:32 the uh issue of of kuzma and or usmca and how it impacts daily lives of people in both countries
00:16:43 i'm pretty sure that canadians are more acutely aware of that than americans i know that you know
00:16:49 if we go to your i know you're originally from michigan if we went to michigan and asked people
00:16:53 about free trade they would know all about it because of the auto industry you go to certain
00:16:59 parts of Ohio or New York State. Absolutely, they know about it. But I think it becomes
00:17:05 less important the further away you get from the border. So Jameson Greer said there are
00:17:13 load-bearing walls in this deal, that it's very important. But do average Americans see this as
00:17:22 an important deal? I think so. I think the free trade agreement has been going on for years and
00:17:28 years and that people understand here that it's important to all three economies. They may not
00:17:33 understand the extent to which it is. I would say that there is some concern that Trump's rhetoric
00:17:41 has convinced people who might be slightly right of center in America that he's right about the
00:17:52 Canadian viewpoint. And that we saw it recently in a Gallup poll, for instance, that Americans'
00:18:01 positive views of Canada have dropped by, I think, 11 percentage points over the past year.
00:18:06 Now, American viewpoints of many countries have dropped. And again, that's probably related to
00:18:12 Trump's rhetoric. But they're saying that Trump's rhetoric specifically about Canada has a lot to do
00:18:19 with that drop, and it's largely on the right in America, it doesn't mean that it would stay that
00:18:24 way. But it does show you that the power of the messaging from the presidency does have an effect
00:18:29 on views of Americans towards Canada. And that would relate to the USMCA deal as well.
00:18:38 Yeah, I mean, some of the rhetoric about Canada has been over the top. Look, I'm the first to admit
00:18:42 That you guys have some legitimate grievances when it comes to how we operate this trade deal, just as we have legitimate grievances of how you do.
00:18:52 But some of the claims are simply not based in reality.
00:18:57 All right, we need to take a quick break.
00:18:59 When we come back, I'll look at where things are going from here and whether Mark Carney is just looking for this deal to die.
00:19:06 Back in moments.
00:19:07 there were so many missed opportunities to catch this before the devastating thing happened
00:19:16 a third of them we found literally in the phone book these people were not afraid they knew that
00:19:23 nobody was effectively hunting them they knew they had escaped justice that they were going to die in
00:19:28 their beds when i give talks at law schools is that the charter ultimately is empowering a minority
00:19:33 and it's empowering a minority that's a guild across the country and it's a fairly elite guild
00:19:37 and they killed his lawyers.
00:19:38 Families who were split by referendum
00:19:41 and brothers and sisters
00:19:43 who never talked to each other
00:19:45 for years after the referendum
00:19:46 because they were so angry at each other
00:19:48 because of the emotions on both sides.
00:19:51 The reason he was assassinated
00:19:52 was not because he was trying
00:19:54 to put a satellite into space,
00:19:56 but because the gun that he was creating
00:20:00 had other applications
00:20:02 that made him and the gun very dangerous.
00:20:06 It's finally here.
00:20:07 A new season of Canada Did What?
00:20:10 Host media podcast that revisits the big Canadian political events
00:20:13 you might think you remember and tells you the real story you never knew.
00:20:18 I'm Tristan Hopper.
00:20:19 The voices you just heard are from our brand new season two.
00:20:24 We will unpack some of the pivotal moments that helped define our country,
00:20:27 often without a vote, usually without a plan,
00:20:30 and sometimes without anyone admitting what they'd done.
00:20:34 We'll find out how Canada became a welcoming paradise 0.70
00:20:37 for untold numbers of Nazi war criminals after the Second World War. 0.85
00:20:41 We let them build monuments to their wartime exploits
00:20:44 and even ended up honoring a Nazi fighter in the House of Commons.
00:20:48 And I'm sorry to say that none of that happened by accident.
00:20:52 We'll bring you the little-known story of a troubled Canadian rocket scientist
00:20:55 who turned to a sinister life of selling giant guns to terrible people.
00:21:01 And if that sounds like a spy novel, it ends like one too.
00:21:04 You'll hear the behind-the-scenes story of Quebec's attempted secession from Canada,
00:21:08 and how very close we came to a political crisis that would have made Brexit look like a picnic.
00:21:15 You'll hear about how the much-celebrated Charter of Rights and Freedoms
00:21:18 turned into something its creators never wanted,
00:21:22 and how many of the most extravagant warnings about the document were all quickly proven true.
00:21:27 And you'll even hear about how authorities bungled multiple chances
00:21:31 to stop the deadliest terrorist attack in our country's history
00:21:34 and then proceeded to pretend it never happened.
00:21:37 These aren't dusty history lessons.
00:21:40 They're stories about power, ambition, madness,
00:21:42 and the things about Canada that a lot of people would rather ignore.
00:21:46 But not you.
00:21:48 You won't want to miss an episode.
00:21:50 Subscribe to make sure you get all of Season 2 starting March 2026
00:21:54 anywhere you get your podcasts.
00:21:57 I'm disappointed that I came to Canada,
00:21:59 a candidate that it is very, very difficult to find Canadians who are passionate about the American-Canadian relationship.
00:22:09 Elbows up. Me too.
00:22:12 You know, it was an anti-American campaign.
00:22:16 And that has continued. That's disappointing.
00:22:20 That's Ambassador Pete Hoogstra, Donald Trump's representative in Canada.
00:22:24 And while I, you know, get along fine with Ambassador Pete, not everyone does.
00:22:30 He is not everyone's cup of tea.
00:22:32 Lots of Canadians love to hate him.
00:22:35 And I wanted to ask you, Tracy, what are people saying about Hoekstra in Washington, D.C.?
00:22:41 I've heard not great things about him here as well, unfortunately.
00:22:45 So obviously he caught a lot of headlines by having his exchange the way he did with David Patterson.
00:22:54 And that didn't sit well.
00:22:55 That would be the Ontario trade representative, and they had a blowout in Ottawa back in October, I think.
00:23:03 Right. And it was off the record, but there were people in the room, and they heard the profanities that were used, and it has made the noise.
00:23:12 He's calmed down quite a bit since then, but he's had a few gaffes.
00:23:16 And what I've heard from trade watchers in D.C. is that people were, at least a month ago, they were quite fed up with Ambassador Hoekstra.
00:23:27 They were, the USTR was saying that they were really unhappy with some of the headlines that he was generating in Canada.
00:23:35 And I even had one tell me that if Trump is the most unpopular person in Canada, that Pete Hoekstra is number two, and for good reason.
00:23:43 and that some people in the administration were looking to get rid of him.
00:23:47 Now, I know that he's been more conciliatory recently in the press.
00:23:51 I know he's been doing a lot of podcasts and smaller outlets,
00:23:54 and he's been sounding a lot less antagonistic.
00:24:00 So I don't know if that has changed the views within the administration recently,
00:24:04 but I do know that there's been an effort by Hoekstra to be more engaging.
00:24:08 Well, the politics on both sides, whether it's pronouncements by Donald Trump or Pete Hoekstra that drive the American side or Canadian side to distraction or comments by Prime Minister Carney, like his Davos speech that upset the Americans or something that Doug Ford says when he goes on CNN with Wolf Blitzer, which he knows is just going to get under the president's skin.
00:24:33 And the politicians are really seeming to get in the way of talks in this.
00:24:38 They seem to throw grenades in every once in a while.
00:24:42 And, you know, I watch Jameson Greer, the U.S. trade representative, and we've just appointed Janice Charette as Canada's chief negotiator.
00:24:51 We've got a new ambassador in Mark Wiseman.
00:24:54 We've got a new chief negotiator.
00:24:56 You know, previously, Kristen Hillman had been ambassador and chief negotiator.
00:25:01 But I look at Greer and I look at Charette and I think, okay, these are two people that seem pretty reasonable.
00:25:11 They're both smart.
00:25:13 Put them in a room and let them talk.
00:25:15 I think we'd have a deal by lunch.
00:25:18 Yes, exactly.
00:25:19 But they met back in March, right?
00:25:21 So I believe that Charette met with both Ambassador Wiseman and Greer.
00:25:27 And I think that was the last time anyone had a get-together.
00:25:29 I know that there have been discussions or back-channeling, but there haven't been any formal talks between the two sides.
00:25:34 And that's concerning because it's already now too late for us to hammer out a deal between the U.S. and Canada ahead of the July 1st.
00:25:42 Why do you say it's too late now?
00:25:44 I've just had trade negotiators tell me that based on how the negotiations have gone with the Mexican teams and with Mexico,
00:25:53 that it's taken a number of months to get to a certain point,
00:25:55 and we just don't have that time to hammer everything out on the Canadian side.
00:26:01 So even if they started today, it would go long past July 1st at this point.
00:26:06 All right, so I want to play a clip of Greer.
00:26:10 He was on Fox News the other day, and he was asked,
00:26:14 he was on with Brian Kilmeade, who asked him whether there's the possibility
00:26:19 that talks could just fall apart.
00:26:22 Here's Greer.
00:26:23 The way to think about this is we have a review coming up that's required by U.S. statute and by the agreement on July 1st.
00:26:32 And what that means is that each party to the agreement, each country, has an opportunity to say,
00:26:37 you know what, we'll just renew this, we'll rubber stamp it, or we'll go on the path to exiting the agreement over a period of years,
00:26:44 but during that time we'll try to negotiate resolutions to the issues we see in the agreement.
00:26:48 And I would say that I don't think President Trump is inclined to just rubber stamp this.
00:26:53 USMCA has a lot of stuff in it that's important for the economy, some load-bearing pillars.
00:26:58 But we expected to see a lot more production reshored to the United States, and there wasn't enough.
00:27:03 So clearly there are things there that need to be fixed.
00:27:05 So I think we're going to be in a mode of trying to improve that.
00:27:08 So, Tracy, I mean, what Greer was describing there is that the U.S. could just say on July 1st, we're out, we're going to kill the deal.
00:27:19 That takes a while for it to actually be put in place.
00:27:23 But then that kind of puts us under the gun if we want to renegotiate something else, doesn't it?
00:27:28 I mean, this is a weird position that Canada's in.
00:27:31 Yes. And most of the trade experts I've spoken with have said that they expect the Trump administration to threaten to pull out and that we will start to see a lot more language like that in the coming weeks in the run up to July 1st. But most seem to believe that in the end, the U.S. administration understands the impact that would have on both economies and that they will try to hammer out some sort of deal or at least continue the negotiation.
00:28:01 The wild card is Trump, right?
00:28:02 The problem is nobody knows what he will do from day to day, and there's no predicting it necessarily.
00:28:07 I think that the trade negotiators believe that the threats will continue, but that at the end of the day, they expect some sort of deal.
00:28:16 Whether it will be anything like what we've had in the past or whether it will be hammered out in a bilateral agreement later remains to be seen.
00:28:25 Well, I know in the last round of negotiations, we essentially had to agree to the deal that Mexico had negotiated and just sign on to it at the last minute.
00:28:36 Maybe we end up there again.
00:28:39 Greer's deputy trade negotiator, a guy named Rick Schweitzer, was at a conference recently and did not have the best words to say about Mark Carney.
00:28:50 So I want to play that for you and then ask you what people are saying about Carney in Washington.
00:28:56 So here's Schweitzer accusing Mark Carney of political malpractice for not being serious enough about getting the deal.
00:29:04 I think Carney has made it personal.
00:29:06 I think it's political malpractice for the prime minister of a Canadian, you know, of Canada to pit politically himself against any president.
00:29:16 I don't care what the president is, who the president is, what party they represent.
00:29:20 It's political malpractice.
00:29:21 Canada is dependent upon the U.S. economy.
00:29:24 That's just a fact, right?
00:29:25 That's not hubris.
00:29:27 That's not something that Canada needs to be concerned about.
00:29:30 It's not something Canada can change, right?
00:29:32 The fundamental fact is geography wins out.
00:29:36 Canada is located where it's located.
00:29:38 They can't move shop.
00:29:39 They can have a weak economy that is underperforming and not doing well,
00:29:45 and Carney can feel superior or they can have an economy that participates with as a partner
00:29:50 of the U.S. economy and Carney can do what a grownup should do, which is figure out, figure it
00:29:56 out. OK, so, Tracy, my guess is that views of Carney will go along partisan lines for the most
00:30:03 part. You know, you've got the serious people at the top like the Greers and Scott Besson.
00:30:07 They'll probably have a measured view of them. But the rest, it's going to be partisan of
00:30:11 Republicans, ooh, boo, hiss, and Democrats, he's the savior of the progressive world.
00:30:17 What are you hearing about him?
00:30:20 Or, you know, is this view expressed by Schweitzer something that's kind of prevalent?
00:30:26 Like, this guy's not taking trade talks seriously.
00:30:30 The Trump administration was offended by the Davos speech, right, with Carney kind of
00:30:35 representing himself as the global leader of a progressive movement and globalization
00:30:40 in general.
00:30:41 And it was a bit of a poke in the eye to Donald Trump. So that has not sat well with the president. Meeting with people like Obama and Soros, those types of things are also not sitting well with Republicans. So like there's even been talk of foreign interference and waiting for a Democratic Congress, all of those things, meeting with Obama and Soros, these can be issues that will rile the U.S. administration.
00:31:06 um so some of this relates to the earlier question about whether or not Canada has been making
00:31:13 overtures to the U.S. side and I am starting to get the impression that the U.S. may be waiting
00:31:19 for an apology from Carney or some sort of overture that is apologetic and that maybe the
00:31:24 Canadian side is also waiting for some sort of an apology for the hostile rhetoric and that we're
00:31:28 just waiting to see who blinks first we've got we've got Donald Trump in China right now and
00:31:36 looking to do a trade deal. Mark Carney was there back in January. And my problem with the deal that
00:31:47 Mark Carney wanted to or is trying to strike with China or did is that it goes beyond trade.
00:31:52 It's about a strategic partnership and security issues that I just do not trust China on. 0.86
00:31:59 um i think both of our countries should do more trade with china but there is a lot there does
00:32:07 seem to be a lot of uh anxiety you could say on the american side about what canada is trying to
00:32:17 do with china the electric vehicles the 49 000 moving up to 72 000 electric vehicles the
00:32:22 security partnerships. They really don't want us getting too close to China, do they? 0.82
00:32:32 No, they certainly don't. They want Canada, they want a fortress America. They want a security 0.59
00:32:38 guarantee that keeps China out and protects North America from Chinese interference.
00:32:46 There's also concern that these MOUs haven't been made transparent to people. So there's not a
00:32:52 true understanding yet of what's been agreed to between Canada and China.
00:32:57 Well, we just had a new Democrat MP, Jenny Kwan, who is one of the MPs of Chinese heritage who
00:33:05 was targeted by China in foreign interference, come out and demand that the government release
00:33:11 this, especially on cooperation with police. And yet Parliament has been told, we can't give you
00:33:17 new information on what the RCMP is going to be doing with the police in Beijing.
00:33:23 I mean, that should be worrying for Canadians, never mind our neighbors next door.
00:33:29 What's your sense of where we go over the coming weeks?
00:33:35 Is it a lot of still wait and see?
00:33:37 Is it a lot more rhetoric?
00:33:40 Where do we end up by July 1st?
00:33:44 uh in the coming weeks i think you're going to see a ramp up of rhetoric um on both sides of
00:33:52 course uh i think that the us um the ustr will be trying to finalize the 301 investigation on
00:34:01 forced labor that would give them a little bit more leverage in any usmca review so i know that
00:34:08 Greer is hoping to finalize that by early July.
00:34:12 If that is the case, the 301 investigations are widely expected to lead to more tariffs.
00:34:19 And depending on how broad those are, those could be even stacked on top of the 232s.
00:34:25 That could be quite punishing.
00:34:27 So these would be extra tariffs on Canada.
00:34:30 Correct.
00:34:31 And one trade specialist I was talking to here said he believes that they will find, using that 301 tariff or 301 investigation, that our booze ban is actually an unfair trading practice and we could get more tariffs because of the booze ban.
00:34:49 Have you heard that?
00:34:51 I think that's a different – that would be under a different one, right?
00:34:54 So I think that that – yeah, I think that's a different one.
00:34:57 But, but, but essentially, everyone I've spoken to said that whatever the investigation finds, they expect it to lead to tariffs. So basically, that it's a done deal that this is the way the White House is rebuilding the IEPA global tariff wall. The big, the big concern for Canada is that the IEPA tariffs always had carve outs for the USMCA compliant goods.
00:35:18 So those escaped those tariffs. Same for the replacement. After the U.S. Supreme Court shot down the IEPA tariffs in March, the administration replaced them with the Section 122 tariffs, which are temporary.
00:35:40 Those also had carve-outs for the USMCA-compliant goods.
00:35:43 There is no indication that the 301 tariffs will follow suit.
00:35:49 And I've spoken with an international trade lawyer who actually is concerned that the intention by the administration is for that not to be the case.
00:35:56 Some still hope it will be, but it could be that USMCA-compliant goods are not covered and that a broad 301 tariff on Canada could be quite punishing.
00:36:08 And I've even heard that businesses are starting to be more concerned by that
00:36:12 than they are the USMCA review.
00:36:15 Oh, more headaches.
00:36:18 Maybe headaches that we could, you know, avoid
00:36:21 if Mark Carney decided to try and get a deal instead of playing politics.
00:36:26 But time will tell.
00:36:27 Tracy, thanks so much for the time.
00:36:29 I wanted to just say that the hardening of views in Canada towards the United States
00:36:34 and this anti-Americanism that Carney has used successfully for electoral gains,
00:36:41 which is completely understandable, they could backfire, though, for him, right?
00:36:45 Because it makes it harder for him to make any compromises with the U.S. administration in the long run.
00:36:50 So it makes trade talks harder, makes reaching any sort of agreement harder
00:36:54 if he then has to then go back and sell any major concessions to the Canadian people.
00:37:00 Well, look, I'm hearing from people that don't want us to do any trade with the United States.
00:37:06 I hear from them daily, and they see anything that grants the U.S. one inch, one centimeter.
00:37:15 Make it a centimeter.
00:37:16 They see that as being traitorous, and they would rather us have no trade, which is unrealistic.
00:37:22 But that is kind of the sentiment of many people, and Mark Carney has leaned into that.
00:37:28 So I think you're right.
00:37:29 It could make things much more difficult.
00:37:31 I worry about what this means for our country and our economy.
00:37:36 But thanks so much for your time, Tracy.
00:37:38 Thanks for your insight from Washington or from Virginia.
00:37:42 And enjoy the better weather that you're having down there than we are up here in Canada.
00:37:47 Thanks so much.
00:37:48 Thank you, Brian.
00:37:48 It's been an absolute pleasure.
00:37:50 Full Comment is a Postmedia production.
00:37:53 My name's Brian Lilly, your host.
00:37:54 This episode was produced by Andre Pru.
00:37:56 Theme music by Bryce Hall.
00:37:58 Kevin Libin is the executive producer.
00:38:00 Please remember to hit subscribe, share this on social media, and let your friends know about us.
00:38:05 Thanks for listening.
00:38:06 Until next time, I'm Brian Lilly.
00:38:11 There were so many missed opportunities to catch this before the devastating thing happened.
00:38:18 A third of them we found literally in the phone book.
00:38:22 These people were not afraid.
00:38:24 They knew that nobody was effectively hunting them.
00:38:26 They knew they had escaped justice, that they were going to die in their beds. 0.53
00:38:31 When I give talks at law schools, it's that the Charter ultimately is empowering a minority.
00:38:35 And it's empowering a minority that's a guild across the country.
00:38:38 And it's a fairly elite guild, and the guild is lawyers.
00:38:40 Families who were split by referendum and brothers and sisters who never talked to each other for years after the referendum
00:38:48 because they were so angry at each other because of the emotions on both sides.
00:38:52 The reason he was assassinated was not because he was trying to put a satellite into space,
00:38:57 but because the gun that he was creating had other applications that made him and the gun very dangerous.
00:39:08 It's finally here. A new season of Canada Did What?
00:39:11 Host media podcast that revisits the big Canadian political events you might think you remember
00:39:17 and tells you the real story you never knew.
00:39:20 I'm Tristan Hopper.
00:39:21 The voices you just heard are from our brand new season two.
00:39:25 We will unpack some of the pivotal moments that helped define our country,
00:39:29 often without a vote, usually without a plan,
00:39:31 and sometimes without anyone admitting what they've done.
00:39:35 We'll find out how Canada became a welcoming paradise 0.72
00:39:38 for untold numbers of Nazi war criminals after the Second World War. 0.85
00:39:43 We let them build monuments to their wartime exploits
00:39:46 and even ended up honouring a Nazi fighter in the House of Commons.
00:39:50 And I'm sorry to say that none of that happened by accident.
00:39:54 We'll bring you the little-known story of a troubled Canadian rocket scientist
00:39:57 who turned to a sinister life of selling giant guns to terrible people.
00:40:03 And if that sounds like a spy novel, it ends like one too.
00:40:06 You'll hear the behind-the-scenes story of Quebec's attempted secession from Canada
00:40:10 and how very close we came to a political crisis
00:40:13 that would have made Brexit look like a picnic.
00:40:16 You'll hear about how the much-celebrated Charter of Rights and Freedoms
00:40:20 turned into something its creators never wanted,
00:40:23 and how many of the most extravagant warnings about the document
00:40:26 were all quickly proven true.
00:40:29 And you'll even hear about how authorities bungled multiple chances
00:40:33 to stop the deadliest terrorist attack in our country's history
00:40:36 and then proceeded to pretend it never happened.
00:40:39 These aren't dusty history lessons.
00:40:41 There are stories about power, ambition, madness, and the things about Canada that a lot of people would rather ignore.
00:40:48 But not you! You won't want to miss an episode.
00:40:51 Subscribe to make sure you get all of Season 2 starting March 2026 anywhere you get your podcasts.