EXCLUSIVE: Olympic Athlete Speaks Out
Episode Stats
Words per Minute
178.46324
Summary
On this week's episode of the Gains For Girls Podcast, we have a special guest on the show to talk about her Father's Day gift to her own dad, who is a loving and supportive father figure to her and her family.
Transcript
00:00:04.300
With a towing capacity of 3,500 kilograms and a weighting depth of 900 millimeters,
00:00:21.780
Introducing Sports Plus from the New York Post,
00:00:24.200
your all-access pass to the very best in Big Apple sports coverage.
00:00:30.320
the Post's legendary voices, Joel Sherman, John Hyman, Mike Vaccaro, Molly Walker, and more,
00:00:35.740
bring you the stories you can't get anywhere else.
00:00:41.700
Text with Post writers? Oh yeah, you're that close to the action.
00:00:46.700
Oh, just a little something called an electric baseball summer,
00:00:52.300
a monumental WNBA season following the defending champs,
00:00:59.860
major shake-ups coming for St. John's basketball.
00:01:02.300
It's all happening, and you don't want to miss a minute.
00:01:10.220
Head to newyorkpost.com slash get sports plus and sign up now.
00:01:30.000
which was the first episode in my new home studio.
00:01:40.780
you get to switch over to youtube.com slash outkick,
00:01:45.360
I think they did a fantastic job and very excited
00:01:51.080
my guest in a more professional setting and manner.
00:01:54.140
And we have lots of other exciting things to come
00:02:14.420
but have an exciting guest to talk about it with.
00:02:42.340
Having someone such a fantastic protector and provider,
00:02:56.500
That's something I actually added on this past week.
00:02:59.680
And I gave him the everywhere pant from Cozy Earth.
00:03:11.140
for those dads who are virtually impossible to shop for.
00:03:23.440
because I was so excited when I got them in the mail.
00:03:33.560
not to mention Cozy Earth has a lifetime warranty
00:03:54.060
So for the dads who give their best from nine to five,
00:03:58.520
you can give them Cozy Earth for their five to nine.
00:04:14.680
To be very, very clear on the front end of this episode,
00:04:25.920
competing in the 2024 Olympic Games in women's boxing.
00:04:33.180
were athletes who identified as trans or transgender,
00:04:43.440
We've actually had conversations on this podcast before,
00:05:31.460
that we saw following these fights, these matches.
00:05:44.720
and these sex tests have been leaked to the public
00:05:48.240
by the IBA, the International Boxing Association,
00:05:51.660
by the IOC, the International Olympic Committee,
00:06:20.340
that she went out and initially released an apology
00:06:47.980
She is a self-proclaimed women's sports enthusiast.
00:18:48.660
who sex tests and results and reports have been leaked,
00:19:07.720
but it's almost as if women don't want to be punched in the face by a male
00:19:36.960
like hammer home how insane this idea is that we're allowing this to happen.
00:20:06.580
it would be objectively funny if there weren't real consequences.
00:20:10.800
if a real woman wasn't being punched in the face,
00:20:13.260
is this not glorified male violence against women?
00:20:21.080
There's a lot of facets to breaking down the barriers of allowing men into women's spaces.
00:20:31.800
using social justice as cover to allow them to physically dominate them,
00:20:42.780
I've been heartbroken for a very long time about this sort of issue.
00:20:46.960
It came into semi-prominence in 2020 when a weightlifter,
00:20:59.560
This is an issue that ultimately it touches on.
00:21:07.860
there are certain forces biologically that men and women are built to withstand,
00:21:15.640
Men can't withstand a lot of things that women can withstand.
00:21:18.560
And women's physiology is not built to withstand a certain amount of physical impact to the neck,
00:21:28.960
in skeleton where the neck is exposed over the sled and the G forces.
00:21:35.580
Female neck muscularity is not generally built to withstand massive forces that press down as a lever on the head.
00:21:42.640
And they suffer severe beatings resulting in CTE later in their life to,
00:21:49.340
What we're seeing when a man who has all of the physiological advantages in power output,
00:21:59.640
everything that is designed to give them a physiological advantage,
00:22:16.400
but it's not right from the fact that it's dangerous.
00:22:22.980
I remember the instance you're referring to in 2020 with the athlete named Laurel Hubbard,
00:22:31.060
which I think the thing about both of these scenarios,
00:22:53.660
but everything to do with being physiologically by all by biology or biologically male.
00:23:05.480
the crazy thing is this is weightlifting and boxing where you would imagine there are,
00:23:10.720
are very significant differences between men and women.
00:23:38.300
the test results indicating that an MRI had determined that Kalief had no uterus,
00:23:48.200
chromosomal testing further confirmed that he has,
00:24:04.080
Obviously you weren't at the summer games where this happened,
00:24:13.820
do you think there were conversations in the Olympic village surrounding this?
00:24:23.220
we were having conversations about Castor like a decade ago.
00:24:48.920
a lot of the misdirection goes to someone has lived as a,
00:24:54.400
and sport is about the pursuit of personal excellence and sporting competition
00:24:59.600
is about the application of that against the fair field of play.
00:25:14.880
And so it's never appropriate to destroy the basic fairness of a
00:25:18.400
competitive field and a field in sporting competition,
00:25:23.180
as a sacrifice to the feelings or the lived experiences of someone.
00:25:29.220
of female sport as a class of sport is in and of itself.
00:25:35.520
And when we destroy that objective line and it gates the entire purpose of
00:25:42.320
it's the very fact that sport is segregated by sex to begin with.
00:25:46.160
It acknowledges that there's a reality that cannot be erased through feelings.
00:26:01.340
everyone knew everyone knew everyone I spoke to in the village.
00:26:05.500
They knew we were quite sure Khalif knew there was,
00:26:12.440
would they parade around a female on a man's shoulders there?
00:26:21.720
but also we just kind of knew that the results were out there,
00:26:29.620
but it was systematically part of an effort to destroy the line that clearly
00:26:34.840
delineates female sport from other types of sport.
00:26:41.780
I wondered that about the Muslim man portion that you mentioned,
00:26:48.500
that's not traditionally how you would handle or approach or treat women in
00:27:01.240
Like any sort of performance enhancing drug is,
00:27:14.220
which I believe of course that biological eligibility and doping belong in the
00:27:20.900
the biological eligibility portion being much more severe even,
00:27:27.600
following this world boxing has now required mandatory testing.
00:27:43.640
to ultimately prove any sort of chromosomal abnormalities or,
00:27:54.020
How do you think Olympic level athletes would respond to the idea of sex
00:28:02.960
international governing body of truck and field sports,
00:28:06.080
they've already implemented this going forward.
00:28:07.620
I think Castor Semenya and that specific case had a lot to do with
00:28:12.000
so they've already said they're going to do it.
00:28:15.980
specific sport governing bodies have said they're going to do this.
00:28:18.980
What do you think the response is from Olympic athletes to the idea of
00:28:26.080
Anyone who has an idea or a concept of fairness in sport should welcome this.
00:28:33.740
you mentioned invasive invasive doesn't really,
00:28:39.340
how much people are familiar with the doping process,
00:28:47.560
let's say you haven't drank for a while and you're dehydrated,
00:28:49.840
a person will watch you and it follow you throughout the day and
00:28:53.780
physically watch you in private urinate into a cup.
00:29:05.120
that has taken place and it's only gotten more advanced in recent times.
00:29:10.860
invasiveness is irrelevant to a process of ensuring a fair competitive field.
00:29:14.900
And it's irrelevant nowadays in particular because it's become an issue,
00:29:25.840
this concept that men could simply switch divisions based on their feelings,
00:29:34.040
then sex testing wouldn't really be a thing now,
00:29:38.840
And we need to submit to it because that's how,
00:29:48.960
like a number of responses when it comes to the issue of trans and sports,
00:29:57.300
It's not a problem because there's no evidence yet.
00:30:08.960
where's everyone winning competitions that still doesn't make it right.
00:30:30.400
it is entirely in the same realm of doping because it tilts the competitive field away from something that is fair.
00:30:36.780
The final thing that people have always said is,
00:30:39.200
then Michael Phelps and people like Michael Phelps who are born with big flipper hands,
00:30:44.960
But that is within the bounds of what we acceptably construe as a competitive field as a,
00:31:01.260
Basketball players can jump higher than my head.
00:31:06.200
it doesn't entitle me to a place on an NBA team for people who can't jump.
00:31:12.700
If you are born biologically superior within your class,
00:31:17.020
But if you are born into an entirely different class,
00:31:25.720
if you're at home and you're watching this and you're thinking to yourself about this
00:31:30.260
try not to get bogged down into the individual arguments about why and why not,
00:31:36.160
and draw yourself a boundary of what is and is not fair.
00:31:41.540
Why is there a segregation between male and female sport?
00:31:45.740
It's not because women wanted their own division,
00:31:48.940
It was to protect men from erasing female accomplishment,
00:31:54.260
And that's also what happens when we have men who cross over because they feel a certain way
00:31:59.420
into the female categories is you're erasing centuries of women's rights advocacy,
00:32:07.520
people pushing for themselves to achieve things that they weren't able to achieve before.
00:32:12.640
And just because someone now feels like that or wants to be that,
00:32:18.200
And it erases a ton of that history and accomplishment.
00:32:27.540
I talk to people all the time who feel themselves to be bogged down when,
00:32:32.040
when people on the other side get into the specific points,
00:32:36.360
He has more elasticity in his shoulder joints or whatever crazy things they'll say.
00:32:43.440
That would equate to about a few decimals of a performance advantage gap,
00:32:59.460
the world record holder and the men's 200 backstroke versus the world record holder
00:33:04.180
and the women's 200 backstroke is about 10 to 12%.
00:33:07.260
that's the case across the board in any sport that is subjective to time and distance,
00:33:14.480
Almost always a man at that level competing laterally is 10 to 12% faster than the woman.
00:33:29.440
yet nothing can overcome a 10 to 12% performance advantage gap in that way.
00:33:37.420
I can't even tell you how many drug tests we had to take competing at the national level,
00:33:49.220
You have someone like literally propped up in the door,
00:33:51.980
watching you pull your pants down to your ankles.
00:33:56.140
do a three 60 spin to make sure there was no device or contraption,
00:34:01.020
and then sit with a cup between your hands and pee into the cup and then hand the cup.
00:34:11.180
we were willing to do that because we knew we had to,
00:34:17.880
we are pure and in the way that we are competing,
00:34:20.120
no one ever complained about it because it was a good thing at the end of the day.
00:34:31.100
A simple cheek swab is a whole lot less invasive than getting your brain essentially caressed and swabbed with a six foot long Q-tip,
00:34:49.060
on top of speaking about the issue of fairness in sports,
00:34:53.640
you have used your platform and openly spoken about what it's like to be a Jew in a time where anti-Semitism is rampant,
00:35:20.960
They go over just issues that they're confronting.
00:35:27.200
I experienced extreme anti-Semitism at the 2018 games.
00:35:30.480
It's originally what pushed me to retire from sport altogether.
00:35:34.280
a jury official at our competition just before the competition started,
00:35:38.920
disqualified a very key portion of my equipment.
00:35:43.740
to do so except for the rule in the rule book that said that the jury could,
00:35:55.980
And he was clearly referring not to Israeli is clearly referring to Jews.
00:36:05.160
Jews are very small segments of the population.
00:36:09.320
I try not to make things about Jews because everyone's just trying to put food on,
00:36:19.000
they should care about their family and they should care about themselves and
00:36:21.160
care about their communities and what they truly care about.
00:36:24.560
the whole thing is exposed societal issues in how we deal with each other.
00:36:38.040
they are on the receiving end of a lot of the fraying of that social fabric or what
00:36:46.720
a lot of what has given rise to the cover of anti-Semitism nowadays is,
00:36:52.340
or has been the explicit permission structure of intersectionality,
00:36:56.280
of grouping people based on a socioeconomic hierarchy or a,
00:37:01.240
an accomplishment hierarchy and viewing them as groups rather than,
00:37:05.960
I think we're seeing quite deadly consequences of that in,
00:37:09.280
in the United States where for years we've looked at,
00:37:22.780
to act against certain classes in the name of repair,
00:37:28.020
And a lot of what we've seen in terms of the anti-Semitism,
00:37:31.460
let's say like the DC shootings or the Boulder,
00:37:45.440
of violence against the United healthcare CEO and,
00:37:53.820
America doesn't stand for shooting people in the back.
00:37:56.740
America doesn't stand for firebombing senior citizens because they're
00:38:00.120
voicing what you believe to be an incorrect opinion.
00:38:08.620
obviously the Jews are receiving the brunt of it.
00:38:21.400
telling people not to dislike other people generally pushes them to
00:38:32.680
anti-semblies is of course hatred of anyone is bad,
00:38:37.700
from a societal standpoint has broken down that this is suddenly
00:38:41.840
Why is it acceptable that a New York city mayoral candidate who's possibly
00:38:51.280
And generally what we've seen is that anti-American values go against
00:39:01.840
It's really hard to reject a whole lot of Christians because people
00:39:07.900
if people were asking me what I've observed in terms of the rise of
00:39:16.260
but anti-Semitism to me has always been viewed.
00:39:20.760
I view it through the lens of like a tea kettle and the sort of social
00:39:24.200
pressure builds up and the social pressure builds up in the,
00:39:27.080
and in intersectionality really built up the pressure in terms of viewing
00:39:30.980
oppressors and oppressed narrative structure as permissive,
00:39:35.580
as permission structures for violence or aggression or discrimination
00:39:51.260
And a lot of other universities and then anti-Zionism is the
00:39:55.360
permission structure that allows that valve to release.
00:39:58.040
So people in polite society can say they hate Israel and then do a
00:40:04.080
Go fire bomb Jewish people or empty 21 bullets at the Jewish museum to
00:40:12.440
if anyone's at home thinking about the problem of anti-Semitism,
00:40:14.820
try not to frame it through the problem of Jews because Jews shouldn't and
00:40:21.020
What we should view it as is how do we relate to our fellow man?
00:40:26.800
Has it been broken down into classes of people and,
00:40:31.580
Or is it purely what American values are supposed to be built on,
00:40:44.480
who strive for merit rather than restorative justice at the expense of
00:40:53.660
what it sounds like you just said to me is that hatred is bad.
00:40:59.040
I don't know who could listen to that and disagree with any of the points that
00:41:06.260
the people or athletes who identify as trans in this understand nothing that,
00:41:14.660
no position that I've taken personally is a position out of hatred or ill will or,
00:41:21.280
animosity towards any one person or group of people.
00:41:24.020
it's just pointing out what is objectively and proven and factually and historically
00:41:30.780
And yet suddenly we've gotten to this point in society where we accept it.
00:41:35.200
I'm in full agreement with everything that you just said that that's pretty
00:42:04.760
And I say that plurally that you've taken publicly.
00:42:11.920
I need to provide a small framework for how I view the role of athletes in general.
00:42:17.960
I'm of the view that when someone is a national athlete,
00:42:21.440
when someone is striving to wear their country's flag,
00:42:25.280
their individuality gives way to the only thing that matters,
00:42:31.220
And so it's the shut up and dribble sort of framework here.
00:42:34.220
When it comes to the NBA or professional sports,
00:42:41.840
of stepping onto a world cup stage or representing on the international stage,
00:42:47.200
the only relevance you have is the country is the relevance the country gave you.
00:42:51.120
And so it's inappropriate to use that platform to shoehorn in social,
00:43:02.480
on a podium wearing the American flag or any other flag and making a political statement
00:43:13.100
that has always been how I operate and that's how I continue to operate on October 7th.
00:43:26.540
even within the framework of speaking out just specifically for the country or the country's views,
00:43:39.760
Druze are very special Arab minority in Israel.
00:43:46.000
everyone was called to Gaza and everyone had to go fight.
00:43:49.260
so I'm not going to fight for some social justice,
00:43:53.120
but I am going to give a voice to what the country is trying to experience because I am an extension of the country.
00:44:01.580
When it comes to issues like the trans in sports,
00:44:05.440
talking to what you mentioned about it's dangerous to speak out.
00:44:15.900
And there's a really big disconnect between the impression of what people,
00:44:23.320
of how much support you get and what you need to do to,
00:44:26.860
Sponsorship is the lifeblood of everyone's journey.
00:44:34.860
you could be sacrificing the entirety of your body,
00:44:39.120
If your life's work is to make the games or to get to a sporting competition,
00:44:42.460
speaking out on a socially unacceptable subject,
00:44:47.220
can place all of that in jeopardy for something that you don't,
00:44:54.600
You're a drip of water in the ocean of public opinion.
00:45:00.120
especially Olympians to speak out on issues like trans in sports.
00:45:09.420
probably greater than 95% of Olympians or people who strive for the Olympic level.
00:45:24.000
It's obscene to the concept of fairness of sport,
00:45:27.860
but you can't speak out against it because the major sponsors embrace it.
00:45:43.620
So are you going to go out and stick your neck out and sacrifice your ability to actually make the games for saying this is wrong?
00:45:51.200
you're going to leave it up to the talking heads because that's their job and your job is,
00:46:01.580
that treads on a national political conversation.
00:46:13.340
And so speaking out is the responsibility to everyone has an obligation that's,
00:46:21.620
is men in sport because men have oftentimes greater sponsorship opportunity to begin with than women,
00:46:34.960
a greater opportunity to potentially speak out without sacrificing much of the field,
00:46:41.040
if a company is going to embrace trans people invading female sports spaces,
00:46:48.380
a woman is going to be biting into a large part of that sponsorship apple by speaking out.
00:47:01.980
to seeing a sport rife with doping and seeing that just happen before your eyes and going,
00:47:11.920
You have an obligation to speak out against unfairness in sport.
00:47:26.160
when we walk into the Olympic stadium for the opening ceremonies in the winter games,
00:47:30.200
there's like maximum two or 3000 people in that stadium,
00:47:34.880
The spectator Olympic sports and high level sports are for the spectators,
00:47:45.240
Of people pursuing athletic excellence and not athletic.
00:47:52.500
If you're all for viewing a sporting competition with a tilted field to play,
00:48:07.260
Then you have an obligation to say unfairness in all forms,
00:48:10.520
even if it hurts someone's feelings is unfairness.
00:48:19.940
I just wish everyone understood it as simply as,
00:48:24.780
and I love that you use the word obligation and describing this because people
00:48:31.440
why do you expect athletes at whatever level to take a stand?
00:48:45.580
who wants to be able to compete and succeed at the highest level,
00:49:01.840
I would imagine compete at the next Olympic winter Olympic games.
00:49:08.940
there's so much that goes into building an Olympic program or,
00:49:13.220
So everything that has to do with the Israeli bombs,
00:49:15.920
the team essentially falls like building the team,
00:49:23.800
I was a mechanical engineer at one point in my life.
00:49:31.420
what's immediately next is just training every day.
00:49:33.660
Athletes take things with long-term views and every day is just a building
00:49:44.000
And so that's really my one and only goal in life right now is to make
00:49:53.040
You really need to dedicate everything you can to,
00:50:08.420
the role of an Olympic athlete to support yourself and to support your
00:50:12.700
But I am going to continue to try to speak out about the issue.
00:50:17.180
I'm becoming more passionate about it because we're continuing to see states even
00:50:27.080
and they're trying to do something akin to carving out exceptions to it.
00:50:32.500
I would point people towards viewing this from a,
00:50:39.020
Hold to a principle that you think is correct and fair.
00:50:42.460
And when people use edge cases or the 1% of cases,
00:50:53.340
So I think the most recent example is in California,
00:50:57.280
you're a trans athlete is allowed to enter a female sporting competition.
00:51:01.620
they then share first place with a biological female.
00:51:10.700
What it has essentially done is it has given a permission structure for a man to share the
00:51:16.660
podium with a woman and for the woman to give legitimacy and cover to that.
00:51:40.380
We all have friends and we all have people that we care about.
00:51:42.940
If you think about something that you've wanted so desperately in your life,
00:51:46.380
Athletes are just like any other person who pursues a PhD or a grand goal,
00:52:00.220
And so I view it very much as any other grand endeavor,
00:52:04.940
Olympic athletes are like people who are starting a startup.
00:52:20.300
And someone comes along and in a most unfair fashion,
00:52:27.780
violates the principles of equality and fairness,
00:52:33.680
all of that hard work and effort and dreams that they had,
00:52:48.700
high school is some of the most formative years of our lives,
00:52:53.840
that we have in university are very formative experiences.
00:52:59.840
set goals and develop themselves in a personal level,
00:53:08.900
you're robbing someone of the fulfillment of that journey.
00:53:25.080
Don't you think Caitlin Clark was there at some point?
00:53:31.560
that athletes have to make to reach the highest levels.
00:53:39.340
There's one thing that comes to mind now that you mentioned it.
00:53:42.220
There was a study done years ago about the harmful effects of promoting
00:53:45.400
people to educational levels that were too hard for them to appropriately
00:54:04.320
at an educational level that was too overwhelming,
00:54:16.320
let's say your masters or for the next level of achievement.
00:54:20.980
if you've robbed someone of an athletic achievement in middle school,
00:54:24.680
what are the odds that they won't try as hard in high school?
00:54:29.840
what is the chance that you have robbed them of a journey of,
00:54:33.480
of the fulfillment of an actual journey that can take them to a far away
00:54:49.540
And you can really destroy someone's personal development by throwing them into a
00:54:56.420
What is the lesson a young person's supposed to learn from that,
00:55:06.420
And you learn that very harshly by watching someone who has 20 to 40% more
00:55:14.820
lap you on a track and it's wholly inappropriate.
00:55:20.440
I appreciate how philosophically yet simple you put that in a way that
00:55:34.780
And I think sometimes even you have politicians or elected officials or,
00:55:42.680
who don't necessarily understand the messaging as well as you just put it.
00:55:53.600
your career and everything that you've got coming up,
00:56:13.120
is to break into the conversation when no one is willing to speak about it.
00:56:19.920
I'm quite grateful for it because it allowed other athletes as well to follow in your footsteps.
00:56:28.860
who kind of joined the roster of athletes who are willing to.
00:56:38.160
being able to understand not just in terms of sports,
00:56:50.720
I think it's incredibly insightful and it does speak to the determination,
00:56:57.180
I think the want for perfection that so many athletes,
00:57:21.700
I gave him the everywhere pant and the all day tea.
00:57:30.920
cozy earth.com and make sure you check us out at youtube.com slash outkick.
00:57:39.140
engage with other people in the comment section.
00:57:48.340
I believe in the 4 PM Eastern hour this past week.
00:57:56.840
I think it looks incredible and I'm sat there and,
00:58:01.600
and someone from the control room in the Fox news channel headquarters is
00:58:10.660
a technical issue on their end to where I stopped receiving audio.
00:58:16.020
And so there's about 15 seconds of the show where will Kane is talking to
00:58:21.180
And I never knew we even came back from commercial break.
00:58:36.020
my new fantastic studio and set up works perfectly.
00:58:43.100
because I literally look like I have not a thought in my mind,
00:58:47.960
nothing going on between these two years and in this brain.
00:58:54.880
appreciate you guys check us out at youtube.com slash outkick,