Greg Wycliffe - October 14, 2022


Bank fires work at home HR employee who questioned C0vid policies.

Hosted by
Mentioned
Protest in Iran 🇮🇷 vs. 🇨🇦 Trucker Convoy DESPICABLE Behaviour from Ottawa City Councillors at EMA hearing

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 39 minutes

Words per minute

206.84

Word count

20,673

Sentence count

—

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, I interview a brave HR professional who decided to go public with his story of being terminated from his job while working from home during the pandemic. We talk about his experience, why he decided to speak out, and why he felt compelled to do so.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 I'm a Canadian. My name is Greg. I'm so excited to do this interview today.
00:00:05 As a reminder, I have started a Patreon. So if you want to keep content like this alive,
00:00:09 go to my Patreon, patreon.com slash Greg Wycliffe. Now, to set up this interview,
00:00:16 I want to tell you how this all started. Essentially, I sent out a tweet a week or
00:00:21 so ago about the ongoing mandates because people are talking about how the mandates have been
00:00:26 dropped. All the work mandates have been dropped. And I sent out a tweet. I sent out a survey to
00:00:32 say, um, Hey, who's still experiencing mandates at work? Who still needs two jabs to, uh, to go to
00:00:39 work. And I, I posted this on Instagram as well. And it got hundreds and hundreds of responses,
00:00:48 different stories in different industries, spanning you name it, you know, telecom, uh,
00:00:54 banks uh firefighters nurses of course which i've covered before on the channel but i got a message
00:01:00 from a brave individual from one of the major banks and he said hey here's my story um and
00:01:08 we're going to go over his whole story today but but the crazy thing at the at the end of it
00:01:12 is he got terminated when everyone was still working from home so and i like to emphasize
00:01:19 that point because it really doesn't make any sense so we're going to introduce him
00:01:22 uh in just a second here but to give you an idea uh this individual is 31 years old he's an hr
00:01:28 professional for 10 years in canada mostly toronto uh he's got a e-com major in hr minor in law from
00:01:35 myerson university he worked at ibm rogers communications and most recently cibc um where
00:01:44 cibc before being terminated um from working working from home during the pandemic without
00:01:50 further ado let's get him on here mr austin austin cisco thank you so much for joining us there he
00:01:59 is how you doing good good how are you doing i'm doing well i'm doing i'm doing all right um
00:02:08 yeah your uh your story is we're gonna get into to the nitty-ditty nitty-gritty details of course
00:02:16 But, um, I mean, first and foremost, uh, you know, you're going public with this and it's
00:02:24 been a pretty crazy couple of years, families being ripped and torn apart, people losing
00:02:30 their jobs.
00:02:31 And there's, unfortunately, this culture of silence, you know, don't ask, don't tell,
00:02:35 don't, don't make any, a sound.
00:02:37 So first and foremost, like you're making the decision to go, to go public on this.
00:02:42 That takes a lot of bravery.
00:02:43 You know, where does that come from?
00:02:45 like like was there a moment for you to decide to go public or yeah so no it's good question so i've
00:02:52 i've thought about it for probably since it started happening uh but obviously i was still
00:02:58 employed at the bank um was still trying to weigh my options you know sometimes going public and
00:03:02 open about this stuff can actually kind of hurt your position um but you know i think as is the
00:03:08 last year sort of went on um you know we say so lots of people speaking up sharing their experiences
00:03:14 about the mandates and and some of the heavy-handed decisions that employers were making
00:03:18 and my perspective was that majority of the ones that we were hearing about
00:03:22 ones that that people who were maybe on the side of mandates kind of agreed with them they they
00:03:27 understood the logic right you know if you're a nurse working in a long-term care facility you
00:03:31 got to be vaccinated you know i still have my own views on other industries and what they did and
00:03:35 certainly don't agree with mandates but you know you at least could sort of understand the logic
00:03:39 behind it i mean you heard a lot of those stories right doctors nurses firefighters etc
00:03:44 um but what i didn't hear much about was people in my kind of situation um where i was working
00:03:50 from home right which is the bizarre thing about all this is uh i was working from home for two
00:03:55 years uh since february 2020 was the last time i was in the office and then in march work from home
00:04:01 continued working from home up until my dismissal um so for me going public with it and kind of
00:04:07 talking about it is really just to bring more awareness to some of the insanity behind these
00:04:12 decisions right and i think you know over the last year talking with friends and family about
00:04:16 my circumstance and what i went through i you know talking to people who were supportive of
00:04:21 the mandates you know agreed with them but when they heard my story they were like that doesn't
00:04:24 make any sense like they're like there's no way there has to be more to it i'm like there really
00:04:28 isn't right and uh and i think that there's a lot to do with my situation and being in hr
00:04:34 are and just my experiences my education gives me a bit of a unique perspective uh from an
00:04:40 employment law standpoint from uh what employers can and can't do right that gray area like what
00:04:46 they should have done um what would have been reasonable all that sort of stuff so for me it's
00:04:50 really just to share my experience to give people more awareness that hey it's not just those who
00:04:55 are working in long-term care or in high-risk settings who were got terminated for not being
00:04:59 vaccinated it was those who worked from home and didn't agree with with certain you know uh
00:05:05 covid related policies so really you know not not much beyond that just sharing my experience and
00:05:10 kind of letting people know that that situations such as mine did happen um and we'll get into it
00:05:15 you know as you know the whole story so um yeah i don't know where you want to start
00:05:19 yeah yeah no that that is a good point you know you want to speak out to let people know just how
00:05:26 absurd it is how absurd is it well they'll fire you even when you work from home even when there's
00:05:31 really no argument to be made about health or safety whatsoever um yeah so where are we going
00:05:37 to begin let's begin at the beginning because you know uh to give people a timeline around last year
00:05:43 uh like this time last year is more or less like the fall is when uh corporate mandates were kind
00:05:50 of coming down in a lot of places and this is mandates of you need to get the jab to keep your
00:05:56 job or you know a lot of different conversations or different kind of mandates coming at
00:06:01 different companies but this started to come down at your organization CIBC and you sent
00:06:09 the first email you kind of came out and spoke up for the first time and you know tell me what that
00:06:17 writing that first email was like you know were you afraid to speak out at all and also like what
00:06:22 did that email include yeah so yeah so we can go back to the start so to your point it would have
00:06:27 been august of last year so 2021 CIBC along with all of the other major FIs decided to put an
00:06:36 announcement that all employees must be vaccinated by a particular date CIBC's was October 31st of
00:06:42 2021 uh the unfortunate thing with that wording and that announcement is there was no context or
00:06:49 information provided about what would happen come october 31st if you were not vaccinated uh it
00:06:55 didn't talk about what the exemption process would be for religious or medical reasons it didn't talk
00:07:00 about if there was any differentiation between working on site like let's say you're a bank
00:07:05 teller where you're facing clients which you can kind of understand the logic right maybe you do
00:07:09 to be vaccinated at least from their standpoint right but there's no mention of if you work from
00:07:13 home if this was going to matter right so it was just you need to be vaccinated all employees are
00:07:18 required to be vaccinated by october 31st um so that was obviously unsettling uh given my position
00:07:24 i thought you know what nothing is happening concretely yet let's just kind of wait this out
00:07:29 um they were certainly targeting the people who were in the office first right the people who
00:07:33 never went home right the bank tellers the you know the back office had been people who were
00:07:37 you know in the office couldn't do their job from home right they focused on on getting their
00:07:41 information first and you know applying those covet policies um but come october uh they started
00:07:49 asking all employees right to complete kind of an attestation and uh you and i talked about like
00:07:55 what is an attestation right and it's kind of um i don't know if you have that the definition there
00:08:00 but the attestation yeah yeah if you have like an attestation people are confused like what is
00:08:05 attestation right were they just asking you to disclose your status or were they doing more
00:08:10 so as you can see there it's a it's a legal document and a certifiable certifiable document
00:08:15 basically where you would acknowledge having done something or you're agreeing to something right so
00:08:20 it's effectively kind of a contract or or an extension of your employment contract right
00:08:25 depending on the wording in the attestation so they were asking all employees regardless of where
00:08:30 you worked to complete the attestation and that attestation you had to say you had to disclose
00:08:35 your status so you had to say i am vaccinated i am not vaccinated or i choose not to disclose
00:08:43 so that was actually a third option that not all banks did some banks just said you have to say yes
00:08:48 or no i am or i'm not but the CIBC said you can put you choose not to disclose which on surface
00:08:54 it's like oh that's nice right they're you know they're not forcing me to disclose i can say i
00:08:58 choose not to disclose that could be vaccinated it could be i might not be but the problem with
00:09:03 the attestation that at least i saw was that it was what you were agreeing to even if you selected
00:09:09 i choose not to disclose so by choosing not to disclose you're still completing the attestation
00:09:15 and you are agreeing to the terms that are in that attestation um and some of the wording in
00:09:20 there was a bit kind of confusing and i had some questions around it because it said you know by
00:09:24 completing this attestation again even if you choose not to disclose you are agreeing to have
00:09:31 your information used disclosed shared in whatever manner they deem necessary as well as to agree to
00:09:38 whatever health and safety protocols they deem necessary right to manage the pandemic which
00:09:43 also would include possibly maintaining a fully vaccinated status right including boosters right
00:09:48 so they did make a comment about that so for me i'm not vaccinated i chose not to for a variety of
00:09:54 reasons that that's a whole other topic but um i just wasn't comfortable sharing that information
00:09:59 to begin with right because to me i thought in my head okay i work from home right i'm not going
00:10:04 back into the office anytime soon um this is a private medical you know question we've tiptoed
00:10:10 around anything like that in my entire career we were very sensitive about asking people medical
00:10:15 information if they have disabilities all that sort of stuff and then also i wasn't sure what
00:10:20 i was agreeing to right even if i chose not to disclose am i agreeing to follow whatever health
00:10:26 and safety protocols but they weren't telling us what those health and safety protocols would be
00:10:30 like so what am i agreeing to right so i had questions so i guess that gets to your question
00:10:34 about like what was that first email so sorry i just want to interject for one quick moment
00:10:41 yeah so an attestation um you know the definition is certifiable legal document that provides
00:10:47 it's irrefutable proof that an employee did or not take an action like historically an attestation
00:10:53 it sounds like deals with like a very kind of specific scenario for a specific you know employee
00:10:58 and i want to clarify because especially during the past couple years it seems that some words
00:11:05 take on new meaning like you know for example vaccination used to mean like immunity but they
00:11:10 kind of changed that definition uh the cdc changed that definition if i'm not mistaken or the who did
00:11:15 to not even include immunity just just might protect you or hopefully protect you
00:11:19 and is there a similar thing here with attestation as in this is the first time an attestation is
00:11:26 is kind of being presented as oh by the way you also uh are going to agree with health and safety
00:11:33 protocols into the future like is that a unique thing in this scenario would you say at least in
00:11:38 my experience i've never seen it used in this kind of circumstance i've seen attestations used
00:11:45 in hr and in the corporate world and and the only times i've seen it being used is when
00:11:50 like i'll give an example let's say an employee um you know sends emails to their personal email
00:11:55 from their work email right so they they sent something home to their personal email they
00:11:59 wanted to read it they whatever uh and let's say it was company property right company data or like
00:12:04 a company you know document um we would find out about it we would say hey look you can't be sending
00:12:09 you know corporate stuff home you need to delete it uh in order for us to confirm and that you have
00:12:14 fact delete it and you didn't you know disclose it or share it elsewhere or have it stored you
00:12:18 need to sign this attestation you need to sign off and say i deleted it i did this i don't have any
00:12:23 more copies i never distributed it so that's that's where i've seen it right again because
00:12:27 that employee would be certifying that they did not do anything with it that it's destroyed
00:12:32 but what was interesting about this attestation is not just that it's unique that i've never seen
00:12:37 it with respect to um kind of amending your employment contract or agreeing to new employment
00:12:41 terms it was the the the inability for them to just like confirm to me if it was in fact an
00:12:49 extension of my employment agreement right because i was asking questions and that's what drove me to
00:12:52 my email saying hey i'm not sure i'm comfortable with this and and even if i'm comfortable with
00:12:57 the whole uh mandate as it's being rolled out like i have some concerns from a legal perspective
00:13:02 from an ethical or moral standpoint as well um so i that's kind of what brought me to raise my
00:13:08 concerns and send them an email which i kind of escalated up and said here's my concerns uh here's
00:13:13 what i'm hesitant about you know i'd welcome a discussion if there's a learning opportunity for
00:13:17 me to to learn more about the laws or maybe i've missed something like educate me if i'm wrong
00:13:22 that's i've been wrong before right i've misinterpreted uh certain laws or guidelines
00:13:28 or policies before and that's why you know you talk with your one-ups or your your management
00:13:33 team for to get clarity right which which is kind of what led me to that email so i think that's
00:13:38 kind of back to your question right about like was i scared like why did i do it like what did
00:13:42 it contain um so you want to kind of kind of talk about that email a bit yeah this first email um
00:13:48 or maybe we should go over kind of just to clarify for everyone who's watching you know this is this
00:13:53 is austin he got fired from cibc uh he was working from home most people were working from home
00:13:59 uh at the time and we're kind of going over the play-by-play that happened uh for himself and
00:14:05 this might apply to you or anyone else who is still working in a big corporate environment
00:14:10 because um it's not just hey did you get the jab or not uh it turns out that you know this um
00:14:18 attestation that they made employees sign might have had a lot of other stipulations uh and because
00:14:24 austin is uh an educated and and um you know high performing hr professional you're on top of this
00:14:32 you know about employment law and um and yeah it sounds like this attestation i'm gonna get the
00:14:40 the problems with the four problems with this attestation yeah just to clarify for people
00:14:45 yeah so bring up a good point about excuse me the uh the concerns i had right um because i thought
00:14:53 even if i chose not to disclose um that i was agreeing to something right and i didn't want to
00:15:00 blindly agree right to future policies that i might not agree with and let's say they you know
00:15:05 i sign off the attestation i choose not to disclose and it says by completing this you're
00:15:10 agreeing to follow whatever policies we need and then let's say they implement a policy that i then
00:15:15 don't agree with right like testing for example maybe i wasn't comfortable with testing sure
00:15:19 balance or mask use at all times or whatever whatever policies or procedures they were going
00:15:24 to put in place i was not they weren't telling us what that was and my concern was that if i agree
00:15:29 in this attestation and then at a later date they say okay hey you agreed to follow the policies
00:15:34 because you didn't do the attestation you got to follow this and then i say no did i just set
00:15:38 myself up for them to actually terminate me for cause justifiably because i agreed right if i
00:15:44 agree to it'd be like if you worked in a job a heavy machine operator and you agreed to drug
00:15:49 testing as a condition of employment right that's it happens it's common and then you said no i'm
00:15:54 not doing the drug testing they could fire you right because you agreed as a condition of employment
00:15:58 to follow you know x and y you know policy right so there's that the second aspect of it was for
00:16:04 those who did get vaccinated right and they said on that attestation yes i'm vaccinated
00:16:10 in that attestation it made a comment about it being required to maintain a fully vaccinated
00:16:16 status as defined by public health including boosters so my thought was you know and again
00:16:22 I asked them bluntly this question I didn't get a clear answer because I think it's a valid 1.00
00:16:26 question is that if I was vaccinated I complete the attestation saying I am and I agree to
00:16:32 everything in that attestation and at a future date they say you need a booster right similar
00:16:37 to what western university is doing right with their you know vaccine mandate and talking about
00:16:42 boosters now as a requirement to go to school what if your employer now does it and if you said no i
00:16:47 was done it too i don't want a third they said well you agreed to a third as a condition of
00:16:51 employment so if you don't you're now terminated for cause and you've agreed right so that was my
00:16:56 concern was that am i am i and others agreeing to you know future conditions that could really
00:17:03 put us in a position where they could terminate us reasonably for cause right so again that's my
00:17:08 theory my my understanding i asked them this bluntly did not really get a uh concrete answer
00:17:14 uh but was ultimately terminated for not agreeing so it kind of seemed to be that that's how it
00:17:19 played out um so you have the problems with the attestation there so my my first one is it's
00:17:23 sorry hold on hold on is there any evidence of that being the case yet in terms of uh an
00:17:30 attestation being like oh yeah it wasn't just us asking for your vaccination status it was us kind
00:17:36 of getting you to agree to you will be fully vaccinated with boosters into the future or else
00:17:42 we will fire you uh not that i've seen or heard yet right they haven't talked about boosters i
00:17:46 haven't heard anything like that and what's ironic is all of those additional protocols that they
00:17:51 said we need to agree to are currently on hold paused don't exist right so there's no testing
00:17:57 policy there's no mask use policy in the office there's no uh requirement to be vaccinated to be
00:18:04 considered for jobs so there was for a window of like october november until the spring uh and
00:18:09 then they dropped it all right because they realized that the policies didn't really make
00:18:13 sense they weren't effective in in protecting employees health and that they were i suspect
00:18:17 they know that they were discriminatory and a violation of people's privacy yeah so they pulled
00:18:22 back right so there's no evidence now that this attestation could cause further issues but you
00:18:26 know time time will tell we'll see this winter right yeah and uh that came up a lot when i was
00:18:32 asking people about mandates um because when i first kind of made the survey it's like were the
00:18:38 mandates dropped uh are they being enforced uh is it a gray area and someone immediately said uh
00:18:45 greg you need to put an option on there that says they were suspended and it's like isn't that kind
00:18:50 of creepy uh language to use it's like yeah it's it's just temporarily temporarily suspended
00:18:56 and kind of implying it's it's gonna come back you know yeah um so that's concerning right well
00:19:03 now they everyone who's completed the attestation has no recourse right they've they've agreed
00:19:08 right they've they've like my view was they've they created new conditions of employment right
00:19:14 new requirements for your job um that to me are not actually required for the job so so even
00:19:20 forgetting about covet or any kind of that sort of stuff if you make any changes to the conditions
00:19:27 of someone's employment so this is just from like employment law hr if you make any changes
00:19:32 right whatever it may be it has to be a bona fide occupational requirement meaning whatever changes
00:19:38 has to be justified as necessary for the job right like i can't say you know greg you know
00:19:44 as a condition of employment working at home you know you need to you know be drug tested
00:19:49 right that's a perfect example you'd be like that's not required like i don't need that for
00:19:52 safety there's no need for it um so for me like there was no justify of a reason for them to even
00:19:58 ask you know for this information to begin with let alone impose these policies
00:20:02 because i could do my job effectively at home right the the on-site the bank tellers anyone who
00:20:07 who could not work from home it's a bit of a different story i still have different views
00:20:10 on that but certainly anyone who could and did work from home it was there was no need to ask
00:20:16 right and then to me that was a violation of privacy right we've my entire career like i said
00:20:20 we've tiptoed around any kind of medical information due with employees it's highly sensitive
00:20:26 you know we you know if they have an accommodation request because they have medical issues it's
00:20:30 kept very private it's we have a whole process um and that's how it should be right you got to
00:20:35 protect people's privacy um so my my concern in sending this email is i i felt kind of there's
00:20:42 two reasons why i sent the email to my leadership uh one was uh i'm an hr professional and i felt
00:20:49 in my job at the bank if i felt we were doing something illegal you know unethical whatever
00:20:56 that i have a duty to call it out and and ask questions and and get clarity because if i you
00:21:01 know that's what you would expect a good employee to do right if someone is doing something that
00:21:05 you suspect is is illegal or going to get us into trouble or violates employees rights you call it
00:21:10 out so there i was concerned as an hr professional wanting to get clarity and then also just concerned
00:21:15 as an individual because it was going to impact me so certainly when i was writing that email
00:21:21 i was concerned of kind of one the reputational impact it was going to have on me
00:21:26 I was concerned that I might be retaliated against right like terminated for speaking up
00:21:32 at that point based on the direction of where things were going I kind of saw the writing on
00:21:37 the wall and I thought you know what I can't in good conscience not say something and at
00:21:43 least not try to get clarity right at least say hey here's my concerns here's what I think the
00:21:46 legal issues are here's what I'm worried about like help me understand like what what's going
00:21:53 on it and also can you answer my questions about the attestation am i signing a new employment
00:21:57 agreement like just yes or no is this like if i accept this and then i disagree with testing three
00:22:03 months from now if that becomes a policy am i going to get terminated for cause but they wouldn't
00:22:08 answer that right so in my email i i listed off i'm looking at it here just a number of different
00:22:14 laws um right pipeta criminal code regarding consent you know a whole list of things that i
00:22:21 felt is where we kind of write you have them listed there right just and that's just kind of
00:22:25 the surface right anyone who wants to see that read into it you'll see once you start reading
00:22:29 it you'll see how it relates to to kind of my concerns um so i shared that and i also shared um
00:22:37 my concerns that this was really two one a privacy issue because you're asking employees for medical
00:22:42 information uh and then two it's it's discriminatory right because you're effectively saying
00:22:47 hey everyone tell us your your status and they would argue well you know you can choose not to
00:22:52 disclose but they even said if you choose not to disclose be treated as unvaccinated because they
00:22:58 couldn't confirm right if i didn't answer if i chose not to disclose or i ignored the survey
00:23:02 which i did um they would have to deem me as unvaccinated right which is fair right they can't 0.91
00:23:07 confirm that i am so they're going to treat me as unvaccinated but the discriminatory aspect comes
00:23:12 from they're taking this information right this this medical information that they had no right
00:23:18 to ask for at least for those working from home because it's not required for the job
00:23:23 and then they're taking what you answered greg and what i answered and said okay greg if you
00:23:26 said you're vaccinated you're going to follow this set of policies and austin chose not disclose you
00:23:32 didn't respond you're going to follow this set of policies and the policies that they were talking
00:23:36 about in the procedures were going to be different based on your medical choices and what you
00:23:40 responded to so to me i was like is that not like the definition of discrimination is you're you're
00:23:46 applying different policies to different sets of people based on their medical choices right it's
00:23:51 not like hey we need the information that everyone's gonna have to be tested everyone's gonna have to
00:23:55 wear a mask it wasn't that at all right so i i shared that that email uh it led to a phone
00:24:01 conversation with one of my executives um which really didn't go anywhere it was very much kind
00:24:07 kind of like a circular conversation and anyone who's watching or listening right now you know
00:24:12 when people ask politicians questions and they don't even answer it they just kind of like they
00:24:17 say the talking points that's kind of what it was right it was well all the banks are doing it like
00:24:22 it was almost verbatim that right all the banks are doing it legal would legal would have been
00:24:27 involved they they wouldn't have signed off on this if it was going to get us into trouble
00:24:30 but i still said well what about like what do you think like what's your interpretation of the law
00:24:35 no no answer um and it basically came down to my executive at the time saying is this the hill you
00:24:42 want to die on and i will let you know if your position puts you in harm's way right so to me 0.64
00:24:47 like those were it's pretty strong language i'm like okay like am i like i'm gonna die on this
00:24:52 hill like terminated like what does that mean so obviously after that um a bit unsettling uh and
00:24:59 and from from that email we kind of left it as um asking everyone that i still said i think it's a
00:25:06 privacy issue uh and they said well we're not sure what these policies are going to be right the ones
00:25:11 that i said might be discriminatory right we don't know they haven't been rolled out yet we're just
00:25:15 talking about it this was mid-october um and they said let's not debate whether they're discriminatory
00:25:21 or not because we don't know what they are and i said okay that's fair right let's just wait
00:25:24 all right so let's wait see what happens uh and then things just kind of set and i ignored the
00:25:30 deadline of october 31st not knowing if it was going to lead to my termination again at that
00:25:36 point they did not say you know come october 31st this is what's going to happen they just said okay
00:25:42 if you don't complete the attestation we're going to treat you as unvaccinated i said okay that's
00:25:46 fair like you can treat me however you want i'm still working from home there's no there's no
00:25:50 immediate implications to my my employment now although it's obviously at that point was very
00:25:55 unsettling because i still had a long list of questions i was asking them and and not really
00:25:59 getting responses to so um so that kind of got us to the next part so maybe i'll just pause there
00:26:04 um because before we get into kind of when they started listing out the policies um i know we
00:26:10 talked about the attestation my concerns on it so yeah maybe there's there's a few things i wanted
00:26:16 to draw attention to there i think i think we might have kind of got a little bit choppy there
00:26:21 are we still here folks let us know if you're if it's still if the stream is still good
00:26:25 but i think it's a bit smoother now yeah um so i first want to say i mean you are a hr professional
00:26:33 and obviously these mandates that came down are totally new and totally unprecedented to borrow
00:26:41 a term and i just find it so fascinating that you are the guy uh to to be asking questions like
00:26:49 you are it seems you are the only guy who's asking these questions very fair questions you know like
00:26:56 what are the alternatives for people who aren't going to do this like what are the ramifications
00:27:00 for someone who's you know valid questions very valid questions and uh and of course it's
00:27:08 unfortunate that they weren't really met with any answers but i think we kind of just went over this
00:27:12 but more or less you were right on the money in terms of hey this looks like it's going to be
00:27:17 discriminatory and you called out your boss for that or your higher-ups rather and that ended up
00:27:24 being true down the road when kind of testing for the unvaccinated uh yeah came to be so you're right
00:27:30 on the money in other words so it did end up happening you're right so um basically into
00:27:35 november right so the deadline passed right anyone who didn't respond uh or who wasn't vaccinated
00:27:41 again no no communication and and for me even being in hr right like usually we have a heads
00:27:47 up to a lot of stuff we're privy to more things at a corporate level about announcements decisions
00:27:52 particularly decisions impacting employees right um like we're always in the loop where we have
00:27:58 strategy sessions communication sessions about what's going to be discussed what what emails
00:28:02 are going to go out um we were kept in the dark for most of it um so you asked like the question
00:28:08 or made a comment like was anyone like you know i was the only one speaking out at least that's
00:28:12 my only perspective um you know we would have weekly or bi-weekly uh large hr calls with
00:28:18 leadership talking about this and no one was really uh making comments um right some people would
00:28:25 right and they would post anonymously but they wouldn't answer the questions they would just
00:28:28 kind of pick and choose what to respond to on these calls um so i don't know like i know other
00:28:33 people like my colleagues were very frustrated with the lack of communication from our leadership
00:28:38 because we were we're facing the business right so just to give maybe a quick context about the
00:28:43 type of hr job i was in right because people probably listening to this they hear hr and
00:28:47 like what is hr they just hire people fire people um so i'll be very quick as quick as i can in
00:28:53 describing kind of my role in hr and what hr does so if you think of hr i explain this to you greg
00:28:58 it's like to me hr is anything to do with the employee and employer relationship it's a very
00:29:04 basic thing right so that includes recruiting hiring making offers training them developing
00:29:10 them managing their performance dealing with their payroll dealing with their benefits dealing with
00:29:14 their pension investigating them for for misconduct letting people go restructuring all this kind of
00:29:20 stuff falls under the umbrella of hr right and these large companies they have very large hr
00:29:25 teams right so they have people doing payroll right just people doing payroll just people doing
00:29:29 benefits you know just people doing compensation right designing bonus plans and salary plans and
00:29:35 all this other stuff and this would be hr people who specifically focus on this one kind of silo
00:29:40 pillars right and in a small company you'd have like one or two hr people that do all of it right
00:29:44 but in the large large corporate environment it's it's kind of siloed and and and hr it all reports
00:29:50 under hr but then they have people in my type of role which is kind of an hr business partner
00:29:54 uh hr consultant hr manager it's all kind of interchangeable and basically we are called hr
00:30:01 generalists right so we're supposed to know you know a good foundation of all the areas of hr
00:30:06 because we've been exposed to it right we kind of understand payroll and and benefits and and
00:30:10 hiring people and letting them go like we're supposed to be kind of the experts in a little
00:30:14 bit of everything and then what we're done do is we're deployed and we're given a part of the
00:30:19 business and basically there's there's multiple people like me in my role and we all between all
00:30:25 of us we all kind of cover off a section of the business and we are the face of hr for them
00:30:30 okay i think i froze there hang on no i can see it okay it's frozen in mind as long as the video
00:30:39 is good for you guys so it's looking good i was like the face of hr for them right any kind of
00:30:43 hr questions that came up i would deal with right so that that's kind of my my role uh within hr
00:30:49 I know not everyone understands kind of like why I would be privy to certain stuff.
00:30:53 But can I ask you, we got a question actually from a viewer that's pretty interesting.
00:30:59 What if your initial employment contract says something along the lines of, quote,
00:31:04 you agree to abide by all present and future company policies?
00:31:09 Doesn't that set you up pretty much for any jab policy?
00:31:14 My gut feeling is it's a gray area.
00:31:19 i don't i think that at the end of the day any policy or anything that you're agreeing to has
00:31:24 to be reasonable for the role right it has to be a requirement for the job so i think that if they
00:31:31 could justify any change or any policy that says it is this makes sense for your job and you've
00:31:36 agreed to it then probably you're bound by it but in this instance right where they're they're
00:31:42 asking you know people to be tested or to you know get vaccinated even work from home to me
00:31:48 it's it's not justified so that type of language in a an employment contract or whatever you know
00:31:55 may set you up for that but i don't think it means that they can just arbitrarily
00:31:59 add in a policy like what if they said hey it's a mental health pandemic we need all employees to
00:32:03 start taking prozac right like they can't that's not justifiable it's not right they can't do that
00:32:07 so even if you agreed i think it still needs to be a reasonable policy or or whatever it is yeah
00:32:14 going forward right great i'm still i'm still frozen on my end hang on here um you're looking
00:32:21 great over here man you're looking great over here so don't sweat it don't sweat it okay yeah
00:32:25 we'll just leave it that um okay if i kind of just uh speak up i just see my face your face frozen
00:32:30 yeah um no worries so this was too like i was explaining that um you know i was privy to this
00:32:35 stuff my colleagues were were frustrated with the lack of communication the lack of heads up to these
00:32:40 changes but inevitably they they did end up going forward with these discriminatory policies or at
00:32:47 least that's how i viewed them which was you know if you said you're not vaccinated or you chose not
00:32:53 to disclose did not complete the attestation like i did you will have to follow these sets of policies
00:32:59 and if you said yes i am vaccinated you follow this set of policies right so two two distinct
00:33:04 set of policies that people would have to follow and i don't remember all the exact details and
00:33:08 the nuanced stuff but there were two main things uh one was around mask use and the other was
00:33:14 testing so again i don't have the policies in front of me i don't recall exactly what they
00:33:20 said but in effect the mask use one between the two groups uh had the unvaccinated or those who
00:33:26 chose not to disclose having fewer opportunities to take off their mask in the office meaning
00:33:32 i think it was only allowed to take off your mask at your desk while eating but all other times you
00:33:37 must keep it on including common areas where if you're vaccinated you can take off your mask in
00:33:42 common area you can take off your mask in meeting rooms so to me like that's very unsettling like
00:33:47 if i go into the office am i like you know i got a badge like to show everyone like that i wasn't
00:33:52 vaccinated so that was kind of uh unsettling and then the testing right so there the policy was
00:33:58 going to be that when i was coming into the office or if anyone who was unvaccinated chose not to
00:34:04 disclose or didn't complete the attestation they would have to do a test to be testing twice a week
00:34:09 before they come in while the vaccinated would not have to right and at this time like it's more
00:34:14 widely known now that regardless if you got it or not um you know you're able to transmit so to me
00:34:20 i was like there's kind of some broken logic there like i don't understand so once they they said
00:34:25 here are the policies that's when i said okay i have a lot of questions right um you know who's
00:34:30 paying for the testing right who's who's enforcing it am i going to walk into a cibc office and have
00:34:37 to go see a nurse who's going to swab me before i can go to my desk is that what's going to happen 0.91
00:34:42 right and they they started making comments about these policies without really being able to
00:34:47 provide answers right so i asked questions like are you guys paying for the tests they said well
00:34:52 we don't know might have to i'm like well i can't agree to something if i'm gonna have to pay for it
00:34:57 or if i don't know who has access to the results or how they're going to be stored or is it done
00:35:02 on site right do i go in and if i test positive do i go home right and people see me like walk
00:35:07 home like hey i just had coffee with austin why isn't he in the office like oh we must have had
00:35:11 cove like right or just the fact that like they would know that before i enter the office if i'm
00:35:16 getting tested that i clearly am not vaccinated which is again a privacy issue so i was asking
00:35:21 them questions around this uh they they didn't have answers i also asked questions about like
00:35:26 is there any consideration for natural immunity is there any redeployment or option to continue
00:35:34 working from home while we kind of figure this out right because if you work from home right or
00:35:39 if you're in a job that's a permanent work from home job then then really like why do you need
00:35:42 to agree to your testing and mask use if if you're going to be at home um and then ultimately like
00:35:47 what happens if i don't agree right like are you making testing and mask use a condition of
00:35:52 employment right like and if i don't follow will i be terminated um right so i was asking all these
00:35:57 questions i thought they were very valid i still think they're very valid questions and i wasn't
00:36:02 getting clear answers and i said well look it's not that i won't agree or complete the attestation
00:36:06 i just i really want to know what it is that i'm signing what it is that i'm agreeing to
00:36:11 and what the implications are if i don't agree right and they wouldn't they would not respond
00:36:17 like they sorry that's not true they would respond but they would not address my questions directly
00:36:22 they would just say it's for health and safety we need this information to make decisions around
00:36:27 policy um you know we the answers that you want are in the faqs they weren't um so it was just
00:36:33 kind of this back and forth and similar to the conversations i had with them in october it was
00:36:36 just a circular conversation right where it was you know i was just kind of met with the same
00:36:42 talking points um and when i started to get smarter and i was putting in writing being like
00:36:46 please respond to this like just like you know help put my mind at ease or or even if it's an
00:36:51 answer i don't want just confirm um and ultimately when i kept pushing they they said no like they
00:36:57 they said this is a condition of employment there there is no option to not complete the
00:37:02 attestation and there is no option not to agree and then ultimately if you don't agree to these
00:37:08 new terms and these new rules that we're defining placed on unpaid leave and subsequently dismissed
00:37:13 regardless if you're or not so so that was really like kind of where it kind of brought us into the
00:37:20 december time frame um of all this back and forth and again just the their inability to just respond
00:37:26 to my what i still again they're very valid questions uh they just wouldn't respond and it
00:37:32 was just kind of like ignoring it to the point of me obviously feeling very unsettled losing sleep
00:37:37 um you know under tremendous amount of stress not knowing if i was going to lose my job or not
00:37:42 uh it led to me even toronto i'd lived there for 10 years so i moved there when i was 19
00:37:48 uh for school i actually was there more than 10 years because i left in my 30s
00:37:52 having to move back to my parents house uh out of toronto because i was like what if i get fired
00:37:56 and i got rent to pay i got bills i can't afford this like this is a difficult decision so i
00:38:00 effectively uprooted my life moved back home left all my friends in toronto um you know in addition
00:38:06 to all the other stuff that the passports were kind of causing right no gym no restaurants no
00:38:10 hockey no sports um so yeah that kind of led me to december um so you know pause there because
00:38:16 Because we can get into the rest of the timeline and what led to the dismissal.
00:38:20 But maybe, in case I've missed anything, you want to ask some questions there?
00:38:24 Yeah, yeah, absolutely.
00:38:26 I brought this on screen for a second.
00:38:28 You belong at CIBC.
00:38:30 We value diversity and thought, background, and experience as we strive to make an impact
00:38:35 in the communities we serve.
00:38:38 Yeah, you know, it's funny how all the values on their website, it's like, well, if you're
00:38:45 vaccinated like this doesn't apply to you you're you're uh yeah so it's yeah like a lot of these
00:38:51 large corporate companies like they'll have their their values and and i think most people can kind
00:38:57 of know that they're they're they're not they don't always live and breathe breathe them and
00:39:01 certainly seeing how how my situation was handled i certainly don't think they they did um but you
00:39:06 know at least there are there definitely are people within the bank within other banks who
00:39:10 were good people you know good colleagues that i enjoyed working with good teams i thought we did
00:39:14 good work but yeah it's it's it's sad to see that you know they they plaster these values all over
00:39:19 but they they won't live them right and again it was not that i wouldn't complete it i just i wasn't
00:39:25 going to agree without just some valid questions they say you need to agree to testing as a
00:39:30 condition of employment and i said who pays for it and they said you might have to and i'm like
00:39:35 okay so then if i'm paying for it if i don't have a test that week could i get disciplined for it if
00:39:41 if they're out of stock what do i do like all these like you're just thinking ahead right like
00:39:45 what are all these implications and they wouldn't answer so like how could someone agree right to
00:39:50 terms that are vague and unclear right it's it's like contract law 101 right if you're making
00:39:57 amendments or creating a contract it has to be clear and unambiguous like you can't have a vague
00:40:01 language in a contract that's not how it works particularly if you're making making changes um
00:40:06 so yeah it was honestly it was really just bizarre uh the whole thing and i still can't wrap my head
00:40:12 around it that they they actually operated this way and their lack of uh communication um their
00:40:18 lack of understanding or empathy like i was telling them that this is causing a tremendous
00:40:22 amount of stress uh that i was losing sleep over it right not sure if i was going to lose my job
00:40:27 that i worked you know pretty tirelessly over 10 years of my career to get to um so that kind of
00:40:32 brought us to December. Sonor, do you want me to keep going with the timeline here or before you
00:40:37 come? Let me just jump in here for a sec. So for those who might just be joining us,
00:40:43 this is Austin Sisko. He is a HR professional. He knows a lot about employment laws. Well,
00:40:49 he essentially was working at CIBC and was bringing up just some very valid questions
00:40:52 when it comes to the vaccine mandate. And of course, there was this attestation that was
00:40:59 given to employees which is essentially a certified legal document to say not just and this is kind of
00:41:07 an important thing that we kind of skimmed over like it was presented as hey can you just fill
00:41:12 this out to let us know if you got jabbed or not or if you prefer not to disclose but you noticed
00:41:18 you know being an HR professional being somebody who's looking at the details that um it looks like
00:41:23 I actually or whoever signs this or agrees to this also might be agreeing to a bunch of other kind of
00:41:28 stuff in the fine print i.e you agree to have a booster shot no matter what happens in the future
00:41:33 you agree to any health health and safety um guideline in the future um and the major important
00:41:41 issue there is if you do confirm this attestation even if you didn't get vaccinated you might be
00:41:47 confirming oh uh yeah we're gonna fire you for cause um so you don't get any uh severance or
00:41:54 anything like that yeah but uh so i guess just on that that note right which is some of the like
00:42:00 i'm just looking at some of the notes that i had sent them and what i was asking um right like i
00:42:05 was even asking them about like what is the medical exemption process right who manages it for for all
00:42:10 they know that i could have had a medical disability that i just did not want to disclose
00:42:14 but i was curious about what the process was response to that um and i again i wasn't getting
00:42:21 straight answers so i specifically said um if anything can be confirmed i would like to know
00:42:26 in writing if adherence to or enhance the protocols specifically testing is now a condition of
00:42:30 employment and what the repercussions are for not following the guidelines you shared that an unpaid
00:42:35 leave is a likely outcome which i feel is constructive dismissal if this is the approach
00:42:39 then proper notice of the changes to the conditions of employment must be provided right so anytime you
00:42:43 make changes to someone's conditions of employment you need to give proper notice right so it would
00:42:48 go even if let's say you worked in scarborough and now we needed to move you to the mississauga
00:42:54 office that's a change right you're changing the location of where someone needs to show up to work
00:42:58 you would need to give them notice right you need to give them three six twelve months notice
00:43:02 possibly depending on their tenure of this change and and when you make those changes it has to be
00:43:07 very clear right there can't be any or if it's not clear you answer the questions which they weren't
00:43:12 doing right so um so and i told them i felt it's constructive dismissal which basically just for
00:43:18 the listeners uh constructive dismissal is effectively um when an employer changes the
00:43:23 conditions or working arrangements such that the employee feels they have to resign so an obvious
00:43:29 example would be if i was like a senior executive leader you know managing a large team working in
00:43:34 a nice downtown office and then they stripped me of my team and they moved to like the basement in
00:43:39 north york and they said this is where you got to work now right it's it's demoting me it's kind of
00:43:44 changing my my level of responsibility um so i could see is you could make the argument that hey
00:43:49 they're changing these conditions which is forcing me to resign right so that's what i thought
00:43:54 constructive dismissal was um but ultimately yep and constructive dismissal is like at the fault
00:44:02 of the employer and is it not in that they made these changes and i had no other option but to
00:44:10 resign like you forced me to resign right or forced me to quit um but but this is something
00:44:15 that you can like in in terms of litigation like you can kind of say hey yeah yeah so this is yes
00:44:24 yeah you can make that claim and go after them for constructive dismissal you can go after them for
00:44:28 wrongful dismissal as well uh depending on the nature of how you were ultimately terminated uh
00:44:33 with constructive dismissal the work the individual usually has to like resign and then present the
00:44:38 the case that you forced me to resign, right? I didn't do that. I did not resign. I just kept
00:44:43 asking questions. I kept exercising my rights. I kept doing what I thought was the right thing
00:44:49 and the professional thing to do, which was, hey, I have concerns about what you're asking me. I
00:44:53 have valid questions. Can you just please answer the questions? And if you can't, then I can't
00:44:57 agree, right? And again, this whole thing is while I was working from home, right? And yes,
00:45:04 there were talks about returning to the office, right? So that gets us to kind of December. So
00:45:09 maybe I'll just kind of finish off the timeline here. Before we go into that, we've kind of gone
00:45:13 over everything that's wrong with the policies that they were kind of pushing down. You were
00:45:17 asking questions they weren't answering. We'll get to kind of the final part of the chapter
00:45:22 where you ended up being terminated and you tried to escalate things. But before that,
00:45:27 tell me about, because you mentioned that there was a Bankers for Freedom group. I wanted to ask
00:45:33 like who else were you talking to who worked at CIBC
00:45:38 or worked at other major banks?
00:45:39 So like, and what did that look like?
00:45:42 And tell me there must've been a culture of not like secrecy,
00:45:45 but a culture of like, you know,
00:45:47 we can't really be having this conversation
00:45:49 with that publicly.
00:45:50 There was definitely a culture of fear.
00:45:51 People were quite worried.
00:45:53 So I guess to answer your question is that
00:45:56 there were some people internally, like colleagues of mine,
00:45:59 who I spoke with privately about my situation,
00:46:02 looking for advice.
00:46:03 uh they they kind of understood uh they they understood my concerns about the attestation a
00:46:09 few of them were like oh i never read it that way but yeah maybe you're right like maybe it is
00:46:13 maybe you are agreeing to future stuff including boosters and they said oh i never thought of it
00:46:17 that way they just thought of it as a hey we just need some information we're doing it for health
00:46:21 and safety just submit your attestation and you'll be good um so i had some some colleagues empathize
00:46:27 but none willing to speak up either right to say hey like i also don't agree with this or i don't
00:46:34 i suspect there were some but i think most were afraid i did not want to speak up we did not have
00:46:41 very good we call it esat employee satisfactory surveys we did not have very good esat results
00:46:48 within hr at the time primarily that was kind of a culture of just not being kept in the loop with
00:46:55 stuff right not being informed in advance people were getting frustrated so i didn't really have
00:46:59 in terms of my actual network of people who knew me for me uh within the bank i did not have many
00:47:04 people aware of my situation or many people on my side uh but fortunately there there was a large
00:47:11 uh percentage of people uh within you know cibc and other banks who were connecting offline right
00:47:16 so we were connecting through groups on telegram instagram facebook wherever right just saying hey
00:47:21 hey guys, is this happening to you? What are we going to do? Should we get a lawyer? Should we
00:47:25 challenge it? Should we speak up? I'm afraid to lose my job. What if I speak up and then they
00:47:31 fire me? This was coming from people who all had a different life experience than me. Some of them
00:47:38 had kids. Some of them had mortgages where they had a different line in the sand with me than I
00:47:44 did. My line in the sand was I'm not going to complete the attestation because I'm not going
00:47:48 to like play the game and agree that they should even be able to ask it because it's not required
00:47:53 for the job so i'm not going to agree to that i'm not going to agree to testing or mask use
00:47:56 um if it means getting terminated where some of them they said well hey i can still keep my job
00:48:02 even if i'm unvaccinated but i have to agree to testing and mask use which none of them were
00:48:06 comfortable with they felt coerced but some of them felt like they couldn't afford to not have
00:48:11 a paycheck right like it directly impacts your livelihood if you get terminated and if you have
00:48:16 kids you have a mortgage like i said you gotta some of them just had to comply right so we we
00:48:22 connected with people we we explored different options we spoke to lawyers about what to do
00:48:26 we should do ultimately a lot of people just kind of went their own path with what they felt was
00:48:31 best for them which i respect um but certainly there was a culture of fear uh of worry like
00:48:40 like tears on calls people being upset like like oh my god my life's gonna be what do i do
00:48:45 right so it was it was a very stressful time uh and and certainly myself not getting the answers
00:48:51 and knowing kind of my rights and being in hr i still couldn't figure things out so i can only
00:48:57 imagine those who maybe weren't aware of how the interworkings go and what the rights are and how
00:49:02 they can escalate right so it was it was honestly a shitty time uh for a lot of people but i met some
00:49:07 really great people throughout it i have a good community of folks i've i connect with now um
00:49:11 Um, but yeah, there, there was lots and not just within CIBC, but other, other banks,
00:49:17 you know, we would meet at certain protests, right.
00:49:19 Just meet there in person, get to meet them.
00:49:21 Um, but ultimately, like I said, everyone kind of had their own line in the sand with
00:49:25 what they were willing to do to either keep their job or to hold firm.
00:49:29 And other people had different, like some people were in the office, right.
00:49:32 Some of them were bank tellers, right.
00:49:33 Which they have a whole, they're in the office.
00:49:35 It's a whole different ball game than me who worked from home.
00:49:38 Um, but, uh, yeah, I don't know if that answers your question.
00:49:41 Yeah, no, definitely. And, uh, and on top of all this, you are a high performing employee. You were telling me how you met your, your, not your targets, but your, you had a sort of, um, bonus incentive. And even though you were getting let go working at home, they still gave you a raise before you go.
00:50:02 so like for anyone listening if they're like oh there's more to the scenes or austin was a bad
00:50:08 employee or he brought people the wrong way and there was some other reason i never have once
00:50:12 been disciplined in my entire career i've never even had a like a off the record hey like we're
00:50:17 worried you can't do this sort of chat i've always been professional i've always felt like i've done
00:50:21 the right thing i performed to expectations i've gotten my bonus every year so these emails that
00:50:27 you're sending your higher ups you're not yeah you're not posting a bunch of like alex jones
00:50:31 like links and stuff like this like all caps hey it's there there's i was asking them like like i
00:50:40 said why is natural immunity not discussed i had covid like and i've had antibody tests so like
00:50:46 when we talk about that and the fact that i'm even having to ask them about it doesn't make
00:50:50 any sense because i can do the job at home right now that's the whole thing that's bizarre right
00:50:55 is that the job was being done from home if if the if the virus or if in a pandemic that you know
00:51:01 if the virus is that deadly that it requires your employer to impose you know the most extreme
00:51:07 measures against their staff right because it's so dangerous why would you even entertain bringing
00:51:12 them into the office when they can do the job from home right like when we're talking health
00:51:16 and safety like logically it just falls apart it doesn't make any sense right like why would
00:51:20 you even expose them to it yeah right vaccinated included like like let them stay home too right
00:51:26 and i said that there's like you could test i'm like or you could test everyone right then you
00:51:29 know hey everyone going into the office gets tested right and they said it was a logistics
00:51:35 and a supply chain issue right that they couldn't get enough tests i'm like well that's not my fault
00:51:40 like so what we're gonna put more people at risk in the office because you can't afford testing or
00:51:46 can't get enough lie like just let people even even even by their logic it doesn't really make
00:51:51 sense oh so yeah so so again like once i found out that you know completely failing to complete
00:51:57 attestation was going to lead to uh um unpaid leave i said well at this point it's coercion
00:52:05 that's a threat uh i'm under duress and i can't consent right like you you've basically said
00:52:11 agree to these terms right which include testing mask use etc and future potentially future
00:52:16 policies agree like sign here agree uh or be placed on unpaid leave right so to me like that's
00:52:23 that's a threat like how could I you know reasonably agree to that again without them
00:52:28 answering the questions I had um right with with an unpaid leave looming over my head all right
00:52:33 so let's get into the the final chapter here so essentially you're asking these questions about
00:52:38 this kind of mandate that's coming down on all the employees and one of your questions was hey
00:52:43 uh am I gonna lose my job if I don't you know consent to this and you didn't get a clear answer
00:52:48 on that and if i'm not mistaken you were saying that uh you know there's the mandate or sorry
00:52:54 there is the deadline to submit this attestation to confirm whether you're vaxxed or not uh that
00:53:00 deadline passed three weeks or more and then you get an email because you're asking questions about
00:53:06 this you finally get an email from like a higher up vp who's like oh yeah you're gonna lose your
00:53:11 job if you don't do this and this is and this is after the deadline i'm filling this out so you
00:53:16 finally get an answer right so deadline passed on october 31st right leading up to that deadline
00:53:23 there was no confirmation what that would mean if you didn't complete it if you if you said i'd
00:53:29 choose not to disclose like there was no communication and they said okay we'll let
00:53:32 you know what these policies are so eventually those policies came out again i found out about
00:53:37 the policies through our normal communication channels they didn't reach back out to me to say
00:53:41 hey you know i understand you had some concerns here's what's going to be happening here's what
00:53:45 it applies to you? Do you want to talk about it? Nothing like that. I had to follow up with them
00:53:49 saying, hey, I'm hearing that, you know, there's going to be policies around testing and mask use
00:53:53 and this and that. I'm like, I'm still not comfortable signing the attestation. And then
00:53:57 one of my executives said, completing the attestation is a condition of employment as
00:54:02 is adhering to our health and safety protocols. The option to indicate you prefer not to answer
00:54:06 on the attestation with respect to your status, but not completing the attestation is not an
00:54:11 option and not following the protocols is also not an option i think it was as a reminder the
00:54:16 mandatory uh announcement was made on october 20th this year three months ago but again that was vague
00:54:21 so they they said um and then they said they can understand the situation is causing me stress
00:54:27 uh and then they said let me address the first point about completing the attestation but they
00:54:32 ignored every other question i had right so i it just became this back and forth of me saying hey
00:54:38 you know i appreciate you saying this but you're still not answering my questions i've asked them
00:54:43 i can't consent um you know i said um i understand the attestation has a section to say prefer not to
00:54:50 disclose but by responding in this fashion still stipulates that i agree to protocols
00:54:54 slash requirements to follow which are still unclear how is one expected to agree to future
00:54:59 protocols that are not announced in detail valid question right so it was just this back and forth
00:55:05 and then basically um early december uh i got a notice from a generic mailbox uh basically stating
00:55:13 that you know my completion of the attestation is overdue if i don't uh agree uh to the to these
00:55:20 terms and complete it i may be placed and again they started using again very um unsettling
00:55:27 language because it wasn't definitive it was always like you may be or you could right so
00:55:32 So they said, you'll receive a formal discipline letter and subject to added requirements,
00:55:36 including an unpaid leave of absence in January 10.
00:55:39 So finally, they did say you will be placed on unpaid leave.
00:55:43 And the reason why it was January for the unpaid leave, just to give context to people
00:55:48 listening, was in November and December, those who are working from home, the higher-ups
00:55:54 were working on a return to office plan.
00:55:57 So they were trying to figure out when is everyone coming back to the office?
00:56:00 so for hr they said you know we think everyone's going to come back in january that was the target
00:56:05 so there in their mind it was hey you need to agree to these policies right because you're
00:56:10 going to have to wear a mask in the office and we be tested to come into the office so they said if
00:56:15 you don't agree to that come january when everyone comes back into the office you will be that
00:56:21 right you will have not agreed and you'll either show up untested unmasked and that's a violation
00:56:26 as per their definition or i don't show up to work and that's like in subordination right so
00:56:30 like you can see their logic right that's why they're pushing toward this this deadline of
00:56:33 january to say hey you need to complete the attestation or you go on unpaid leave because
00:56:39 of the return because of the return to office coming up that was right because they right
00:56:43 their view was that hey you need to do testing when we feel you need tested to come into the
00:56:47 office and if you haven't agreed to the testing then then you're violating the health and safety
00:56:52 protocols that we've defined yeah and to clear and to clear it up for our everyone listening
00:56:57 everyone was pretty well you said 80 of people were working from home throughout this time like
00:57:04 we're working at home very few people were were in the office through the pandemic
00:57:08 uh even the the public health guidance that we all heard for every industry was
00:57:13 if you are in a position that can be done from home must be doing it at home right like only
00:57:20 only jobs that should be done in the office or on site are jobs that literally can't be done
00:57:24 elsewhere right like a nurse can't be a nurse at home a bank teller can't be a teller at home 0.97
00:57:29 right so majority of people were working remotely right so they they had this return to office date
00:57:34 set for january and that's kind of what the push was to say hey you need to complete the attestation
00:57:38 by december 31st or you'll be placed on unpaid leave so that that was kind of their their final
00:57:44 ultimatum they said well again you're asking me sign here and agree to this or else i'm like that's
00:57:50 that's a threat that's coercion uh at this point i was under a tremendous amount of kind of
00:57:54 psychological uh stress you know not sleeping very well not eating very well um just not again
00:58:01 because it was more frustrating i think just the lack of of communication right that they just
00:58:06 mainly were ignoring my questions which again very valid and it sounds like also you know you have a
00:58:13 job to do as an hr professional and it's doing my job through all this and and on top of that
00:58:20 you are you are taking the time to craft these emails towards your higher-ups to to ask these
00:58:27 questions as well and that's kind of its own effort in and of itself and instead of kind of
00:58:32 being rewarded with answers it's just kind of being deferred deflecting the answers and then
00:58:38 you get a robo email that's like complete this or you will lose your job yeah so so the ironic part
00:58:45 was the the announcement about my unpaid leave happened early december uh at this point in time
00:58:51 when that announcement came the plan was still for me and my colleagues in hr to return to the
00:58:55 office in january uh mid-december a corporate wide decision all the banks pretty much every
00:59:02 industry said hey anyone who's returning to the office we need to halt omicron's kind of out of
00:59:06 control we're not going to expose our employees to that risk all return to office plans are going
00:59:11 to be pushed out to the spring so they said hey austin you're not coming back in january and i
00:59:15 said oh that's great at least that buys us time right because like if i'm not returning to the
00:59:20 office then i'm not violating these policies because i if i'm not going into the office i
00:59:26 don't need to be tested i don't need to be masked um so maybe we can spend more time kind of
00:59:31 go going into the questions understanding my concerns or even if we wind up at the exact same
00:59:37 you know um point where we disagree and it leads to my dismissal at least it's like three months
00:59:42 from now or at least when it's you know all of the logic is flawed at least it's when it means
00:59:47 their own kind of justification right so i was like there's no there's no no reason to terminate
00:59:52 me now or put me on unpaid leave right no one's going back into the office yeah and they said no
00:59:56 we're still going to proceed yeah we're still going to be on unpaid leave in in uh in january
01:00:00 and i thought but for for what right like yes you want me to complete the attestation i have
01:00:05 questions about it but even what i'm agreeing to in that attestation will not be in place in january
01:00:10 it'll be in place you know when we come back in in may or april or whatever i think they're being
01:00:15 so they still decided to proceed and i thought that was like that was insane right it makes no
01:00:20 sense uh particularly as you mentioned um in december i got more than my target bonus for
01:00:26 doing a good job and performing well uh i got a raise that was effective january uh as well right
01:00:32 an annual raise for doing a good job um and and we were short-staffed and and our clients desperately
01:00:38 needed like i say clients i mean like in the people i supported internally they needed help
01:00:43 right and when they found out i was leaving they were like what like who's going to cover for you
01:00:46 there's been so much turnover and change within hr like this is this is going to be disruptive to us
01:00:51 like why can't they just let you work from home and i was like i i don't know i don't have a good
01:00:56 answer for you on that so um when i found out um that they would be um kind of proceeding with my
01:01:06 unpaid leave uh i i felt like i still need to escalate this this is not right at this point
01:01:12 you know when you've repeatedly asked someone um to agree to to new terms of employment
01:01:19 and you failed to respond to their questions you blatantly disregarded their their queries about
01:01:25 you know the legality of it how this impacts me what am i agreeing to right like the the responses
01:01:30 were like to me it's it's like psychological harassment right you're you're at the point
01:01:35 where it's sign here or be threatened with unpaid leave or threatened with dismissal
01:01:39 when the the employee is just asking valid questions and they're just disregarding it
01:01:42 right like like you can imagine it's it's like sign here sign here or you're fired sign here
01:01:46 sign here or you're fired but you have questions and they go unresponded to you so i told them like
01:01:50 this is like psychological harassment right it's causing it's causing me to lose sleep i'm
01:01:55 incredibly stressed feeling more anxious you know i had to uproot my life because of it so all these
01:01:59 things that were incredibly impactful to me at the time um and i thought okay like where else can i
01:02:04 go right like i've tried my one-ups i've tried with my higher-ups like my executive team didn't
01:02:10 go anywhere um so i i did like i've kind of a last-ditch effort to maybe say okay maybe the
01:02:15 ombudsman right can deal with this um right so the ombudsman should be an impartial kind of body
01:02:21 within a corporation that that basically is there as kind of a fail safe to investigate any wrongdoing
01:02:27 misconduct fraud you know embezzlement you know harassment whatever it is um if you need someone
01:02:33 who's kind of impartial because they're not supposed to report into the same structure of
01:02:36 the company they would report you know to the board of directors or someone very senior that's
01:02:41 you know, appear to the CEO type of thing.
01:02:43 And this is literally why an ombudsman exists, right?
01:02:47 To hold-
01:02:49 They deal with employee escalations,
01:02:51 they deal with client escalations.
01:02:52 Like let's say if you're a client
01:02:53 and you felt that something sketchy was going on
01:02:56 with who you were dealing with internally,
01:02:57 like they were breaking the law,
01:02:59 they were doing something wrong, whatever.
01:03:01 You go to the ombudsman, right?
01:03:02 And they're supposed to be kind of like that third party.
01:03:04 You can Google what an ombudsman is,
01:03:05 what their function is in most companies.
01:03:08 So I went to them, right?
01:03:08 again if i went the normal channel that i would for any other type of harassment complaint or any
01:03:14 issue it would go to hr and to er which is employee relations but the problem is is hr myself and er
01:03:21 reports to the same people that i'm having the issues with right so they're not a they're not
01:03:26 an impartial right if you're asking you know a team to investigate the very people that you report
01:03:32 to it's it's like you know it's like if i got asked to investigate my boss it's kind of like
01:03:36 there's a direct conflict there right i'm not gonna i'm not gonna go out my boss because i
01:03:41 could risk losing my job right they're they're not impartial so i went to the ombudsman uh just said
01:03:46 guys like what like what are we doing here this doesn't make sense they're not answering my
01:03:51 questions this is psychological harassment they're just saying sign here or else um like can you just
01:03:56 look into it someone third party who's not involved in the decision making some guidance
01:04:01 um they met with me on christmas eve that was the only date that they could make to meet with
01:04:06 me which is not ideal right you go ahead to christmas you know rehashing this again again
01:04:11 i was having to explain like here's everything i've said here's all my concerns right here's
01:04:15 here's all my unanswered questions my long list of unvalid unanswered questions every question
01:04:21 i've asked and here's either the answers they've given or just no answer at all and even the
01:04:26 answers they gave were often like not really answers right they were just the political
01:04:30 kind of you know circular type of response that you would get when you ask them the same
01:04:34 all the other banks are doing it health and safety we need to keep everyone safe legal would
01:04:39 have looked into it i'm sure you know wouldn't have been decided upon if legal didn't sign off
01:04:43 and all this other stuff and and right so it was this thing so ombudsman met and they said well
01:04:47 look it's not for us to investigate uh employee relations special services needs to right so
01:04:51 they're a dedicated team that deals with you know harassment discrimination the more sensitive type
01:04:55 of complaints uh and i said well they can't investigate a harassment complaint like they
01:05:01 they report to the people that i'm saying are making the policies that are harassing me right
01:05:04 that are putting me in this weird position of sign here or else sign here or else um but lo
01:05:11 and behold they they still did uh they still put me they still had them investigate uh and basically
01:05:18 they did not investigate they just said reviewed the facts and they said this is clear and obvious
01:05:23 not to be harassment um we sorry you feel that way right this is just verbatim um we sorry you
01:05:28 feel that way but you know we're still proceeding we still felt this is justified and you're going
01:05:32 to be put on leave right i said but you even if that's the decision you made like the person who
01:05:38 was responding to me it's a direct conflict of interest so that that's a whole other thing in
01:05:42 terms of um kind of litigation and and what banks and obligations that they have to do with respect
01:05:48 to harassment complaints that i think that they've failed to do but ultimately that that that escalation
01:05:53 went nowhere um but at least it's documented on their end that i did submit the complaint that i
01:05:59 did again share my concerns and then ultimately um the first week of january came which was
01:06:05 ironically uh that my last day of employment at the bank would have been january 7th i think it
01:06:11 was a friday um it was my third year anniversary like the date like three years and on my last day
01:06:19 just to kind of give you a sense of the the tone deafness that's not really the word but just how
01:06:24 tone deaf the organization was was in my team meeting of me my boss you know my dozen colleagues
01:06:29 or so or however many were on the call uh my boss recognized me in front of my colleagues for
01:06:35 completing three years of service knowing that monday i would be on unpaid leave wow so so she
01:06:41 goes hey you know i just want to recognize that austin's been here for three years and what a
01:06:44 great accomplishment that is but everyone's clapping and colleagues like oh it's such a
01:06:47 a pleasure working with you here's to more three more years or you know all these like nice accolades
01:06:53 like hey it's been great working and he's being on persons next week as well do they talk about
01:06:57 that part how you're gonna get that go right and they just said but they knew like oh my boss knew
01:07:02 for sure because she knew at that point like again she was not making the decision she was just having
01:07:06 to execute and do her job so i don't fault her like it's you know been there for a long time
01:07:11 it still feels very icky and kind of inhuman oh i just didn't i thought it was a bad taste of like
01:07:16 Why are you calling out? I've been here for three years knowing that on Monday I'm going to be on unpaid leave and everyone's going to start asking, like, where did Austin go? What happened? Like, where is he? Is he coming back? Like, we need help. We're short staffed. Like, who's going to cover him? Who's going to cover his portfolio? Right. It's a thousand employees or so that I was covering.
01:07:33 um so it was just that and then i got put on unpaid leave on the monday
01:07:38 and then basically from there i got two warning letters while on unpaid leave saying you've
01:07:45 continued to not complete the attestation and agree to these new terms all right including
01:07:50 testing masks etc uh which we feel violates our code of conduct and following the law they you
01:07:56 know they list all the policies that they say i'm violating and then ultimately it was terminated
01:08:01 for cause uh in february february 3rd what's the cause insubordination right their cause was
01:08:10 insubordination and not adhering to their requirement to maintain a healthy and safe
01:08:15 workplace which again i'm like i'm working from home so i haven't even violated the policies
01:08:21 they're referencing had had we all gone back into the office in january i could see them saying well
01:08:26 you didn't agree you need to be tested to come you didn't do that so now you violated it but
01:08:31 at the time when they said i was violating it i was working at home right like not no one in my
01:08:35 team had went gone back in so it was almost like being reprimanded for future violations right um
01:08:42 so was it terminated for cause and for anyone who's listening who's unfamiliar with the different
01:08:47 types of terminations there's effectively termination for cause and termination without
01:08:53 cause i have done i can't even count how many terminations without cause in my career like
01:08:59 being the hr person delivering the news and usually that's like corporate restructuring
01:09:03 layoffs outsourcing right the employee didn't do anything wrong they just were in the wrong role
01:09:08 at the wrong time and we cut their role but in termination without cause you still get severance
01:09:14 right you're still going to get payment right for years of service to compensate you until you find
01:09:18 a job uh you're still eligible for employment insurance benefits through the government if you
01:09:23 lose your job through no fault of your own in a without cause termination
01:09:27 but a for cause or with cause termination it's effectively the capital punishment of employment
01:09:33 law right it is reserved for the most egregious actions by an employee right assault right you go
01:09:40 watch a colleague or regis harassment or sexual harassment that's termination for cause you steal
01:09:46 discrimination for cause you do fraud right like things that are very severe and and and
01:09:51 determining cause and actually terminating someone for cause is a very very high threshold and high
01:09:57 bar to meet and i've only done a handful of them handful of them in my career where someone employee
01:10:02 did something so egregious that we terminate them for cause and the reason we you know you
01:10:07 say it's capital punishment is because it's if you get terminated for a cause you get nothing you get
01:10:13 no severance but you get no payment from your employer everything stops the day you get terminated
01:10:18 and you are ineligible for employment insurance so all the ei that have paid into all those years
01:10:23 i couldn't even apply for ei right because that's kind of the punishment it was you did something or
01:10:27 ought to have known that it was going to be bad you did a bad thing and this is your punishment
01:10:31 which for egregious acts it's kind of reasonable right if you so if you were a pervert and you were 0.97
01:10:37 sexually harassing people in the office and doing really nasty things um right then you deserve to
01:10:41 to be terminated without pay right that that's kind of assuming you can prove cause right so
01:10:46 i was terminated for cause no no payment no ei nothing just uh kind of on my own to look for
01:10:53 work that's crazy so essentially uh asking questions as an hr professional about a vaccine
01:11:02 mandate is is now on the same par as a sexual harassment in a way they're kind of yeah equating
01:11:08 effective right like they equated it to that when you know even when you think of termination for
01:11:13 cause you have to look at like were there reasonable alternatives and and throughout
01:11:17 the entire you know from when they made the announcement mandate to when i was terminated
01:11:22 there were so many simple alternatives that that could have at least you know um minimized my
01:11:28 concerns right if they decided to test everyone i'd say okay that's not you know it's still
01:11:33 invasive i don't really agree but at least it's not discriminatory because you're you're saying
01:11:37 hey greg you're vaccinated you do test austin you do a test right or if they made it voluntary
01:11:41 right to say hey if you want to come back into the office you need to be tested to be on site
01:11:46 which sure fair but you can choose to work from home right like because you can work from home
01:11:50 your job can be done from home um right so there were so many opportunities or just to say hey
01:11:56 you're not coming back to the office yet let's just pause things are changing fast and ultimately
01:12:02 what's ironic is all of the policies that i was raising concerns about and was not agreeing to
01:12:09 right the mask use the testing that sort of stuff um were dropped and i think april or may
01:12:16 uh you can probably find it online anyone who can google they can figure the exact date
01:12:20 um and my colleagues i think went back to the office in like april so there might have been
01:12:24 like a one month period that they could have just let me work from home and then they dropped
01:12:27 everything right and you know there's a reason why they dropped everything because it didn't make
01:12:31 sense it wasn't really serving its purpose is creating a health and you know a safe work
01:12:36 environment for their staff um so that's yeah that's kind of where it led me and and it's it's
01:12:41 the whole thing is unfortunate i thought i was doing the right thing with um raising my concerns
01:12:46 i thought i had valid questions i thought i was professional throughout um and i just it wasn't
01:12:51 getting that and it led to you know like you know the most extreme form of termination uh which is
01:12:57 it's still just mind boggling to me.
01:13:00 Absolutely. And Austin, good on you for,
01:13:03 for speaking up and, and for standing up for what you believe in, because,
01:13:08 well, we need more of that.
01:13:10 And I think you're going to be sleeping better at night than the people who had
01:13:14 to, to terminate you because you, yeah, you kind of, you're,
01:13:20 you're had a question, you had a burning sort of,
01:13:22 this doesn't sit right with me and you were kind of coming forward to,
01:13:26 to voice that.
01:13:26 yeah and what's ironic is is is although i'm probably a rehire status no right if you terminate
01:13:33 someone for cause you put them as a no rehire which means they'll never work at that company
01:13:36 again but what's ironic is despite what had happened with my disagreements in the nature of
01:13:41 my exit as of today i would be eligible to apply and work in the same job i had before there was
01:13:47 never an effort to have me come back to to right the wrongs i even told them via emails after my
01:13:54 dismissal saying guys like it's i know this is what you think now but my view is that as time
01:14:00 goes on it will look even more noxious and silly what we did but it's never too late to do the
01:14:04 right thing like we can fix this like i i will accept an apology i'll accept them trying to
01:14:09 right the wrong and do you know correct themselves in doing the right thing but no efforts are made
01:14:15 right they've just there's not going to be an admitted admission of guilt or any kind of
01:14:20 acknowledgement that what they did was wrong or maybe not the right decision which to me is really
01:14:24 unfortunate because like i i for me as a person and kind of how i am like if i mess up i do
01:14:28 something wrong i'll say it um we all do things in certain times in our life that we think is the
01:14:34 right thing and after we look back we're like yeah you know maybe not the right thing um but uh yeah
01:14:39 no no efforts on their part and it just it's ironic that i i could i could still be working
01:14:44 there uh if they just let me work from home but uh it kind of brought us to where we are now which
01:14:49 you know i think in the long run you know maybe for the best uh i i would not have been able to
01:14:55 sleep comfortably if i um if i agreed to things that i really felt uncomfortable agreeing to and
01:15:01 having that kind of compromise you know for my own values and morals just was not the right thing
01:15:06 yeah yeah what was your egregious if like what was your egregious offense it was being a diligent
01:15:12 hr professional right like i i just i just asked questions any the questions i asked again like
01:15:20 the reason coming on this with you is was like all these people hear about people being terminated
01:15:26 and their things it's like yeah well you were in a high risk setting right no one i've spoken to
01:15:31 about where i've explained the details of my situation goes yeah they were justified in doing
01:15:35 that like other colleagues of mine hr professionals executives you know different industries they're
01:15:40 like wait working from home and they're like wait wait were you going back into the office i'm like
01:15:45 no not even that right so there's no like i haven't met a single person that's like yeah you know what
01:15:50 like you had a choice you did this you could have just done that like yes some people like why
01:15:54 wouldn't you agree to testing i'm like but it's not required right it's the principle right again
01:15:58 because what if they right if you agree to that and it's not required for the job what's them
01:16:02 stopping from saying hey you know we want to do blood work you want to make sure you're healthy
01:16:05 right we want to you know you need to submit blood work once a month there's a condition of
01:16:09 point and make sure you're helping and that's so important over the past two years and why you know
01:16:15 i think it's important to speak up about this stuff because it's like this this is setting
01:16:18 a really creepy precedent on on so many different fronts and so once again good on you for for um
01:16:25 just for speaking up on it thank you for sharing your story uh we've been going for an hour and 15
01:16:30 and i want to kind of you know being a professional human resources person let's talk about the people
01:16:37 who might be watching who might still be in one of these corporate environments uh you know what
01:16:42 advice do you have for employees especially in a big corporate environment or in general
01:16:47 um you know maybe there's somebody for example who has has confirmed this attestation what should
01:16:54 they look out for what options do they have what do you think moving forward for people yes i think
01:17:00 just generally speaking advice for those who work in a large corporate setting um i i got to where
01:17:06 I was in my career working in large corporate. I don't regret the career path I've taken. I've
01:17:11 learned a lot, worked with a lot of great people. It certainly has given me the experience and the
01:17:17 knowledge that I hold today because of those companies that I've worked at, like IBM, Rogers,
01:17:21 and more recently CIBC. Although I would say, you know, anyone who works in a large corporate
01:17:26 environment knows that there is, it's a different type of culture than if you work in a small
01:17:31 company or family-run business whatever um and the advice is just you know be mindful of what you say
01:17:39 and who you say it to uh optics in in large corporate environment are very important um
01:17:45 appearances are very important uh they they certainly prefer the status quo most of the time
01:17:52 and i think anyone who's listening who's worked in a large corporate environment knows that they
01:17:56 are reluctant to change that they just kind of want you know don't rock the boat keep it the same
01:18:01 and and the reality is is if you're you're kind of the type of person to kind of go along with
01:18:05 things and just do your job head down whatever you can succeed and make good money and have a
01:18:10 great career in a large corporate environment but there there will be times where you will
01:18:15 have to compromise on either kind of your values kind of your opinions whatever and just kind of
01:18:21 agree right just to kind of you know not put a target on your back um right to me like i could
01:18:26 have kept my job if i just complied and agreed and said hey i gotta agree to testing even though
01:18:31 i felt it was an overreach and not required for the job i could have kept it right but i to me i
01:18:36 couldn't in good conscience do that um so i would say did you feel this way before this whole
01:18:42 scenario where in order to work in a corporate environment you do kind of have to bite your
01:18:47 tongue at times and kind of keep a low profile low profile but yeah uh yeah yes and no like i
01:18:52 would say for me in my role i started to feel that way like i i left ibm uh primarily because it was
01:18:58 like there wasn't a lot of growth in canada right you know ibm canada is like four percent or three
01:19:02 percent of ibm global so they're kind of an afterthought not much growth but i was also
01:19:07 kind of getting frustrated with like hey like i have ideas we can do things better why don't we
01:19:11 do this and things just kind of like don't happen right they don't change uh so you know i am i i
01:19:17 moved from there to rogers to the bank thinking that you know maybe it was the company right but
01:19:21 But to me, I started to realize it was that large corporate environment, particularly being in HR, I would say I'm not your typical HR person.
01:19:28 I think I have the right values around what I think we should be doing, what's right, what's wrong.
01:19:34 I have a good and more compass in that sense to be in HR, but certainly there's an aspect of kind of virtue signaling, kind of that woke kind of culture that's sort of started to kind of make its way into the large corporate environment, particularly within HR that I found myself like not agreeing.
01:19:51 to a lot of things we were maybe doing or having to kind of roll out to our employees but again i
01:19:54 was like you know what it pays well the rest of my job is interesting i like it i'm good at what i
01:19:58 do so you know i'll just deal with it but there were certainly things up to did the whole kind
01:20:05 of covid you know vaccine mandate that was making me uneasy and just certain things of kind of
01:20:11 examples of it um like i became aware of an instance of an employee at the bank who was
01:20:17 reprimanded and given a warning letter for a comment that they made on instagram and and to
01:20:24 me i thought well wait a second like were they making a comment to a colleague of theirs was it
01:20:28 related to the bank like what was it it was none of those things right it was they made a comment
01:20:33 on an instagram post about a public figure uh questioning kind of like you know just saying hey
01:20:38 you know do with sexual assault and they said hey it's you know this person should have basically the
01:20:43 the employee said this person you know the woman should have known uh who they were dealing with
01:20:47 right like let me know you might have mentioned like if i went on a date with oj simpson and he
01:20:52 like tried to hurt me people would be like dude like what were you thinking you know like but
01:20:56 someone read that thought it was victim shaming which sure you can interpret it that way uh sent
01:21:01 it to the bank uh they investigated it and they reprimanded the employee and to me i asked the
01:21:06 question was it done on company time no was it done on a company asset no is the individual on
01:21:14 their social media linked to the company in any way right are they speaking on behalf you know
01:21:17 people on twitter they say where they work and if you say where you work you got to be a bit more
01:21:21 mindful because there could be at sure you know you're speaking on behalf of the company was there
01:21:25 was there a photo where they're like wearing a CIBC shirt nothing like that there was no linkage
01:21:30 right so basically it was and and the person they were making the comment about was not related to
01:21:35 the bank the person who complained to my knowledge was not an employee right so there was no linkage
01:21:41 so basically it would be it's a freedom of speech thing right they said something in a public space
01:21:46 which is instagram and someone got offended and sent it to the bank and this employee got
01:21:51 reprimanded for it right it was okay this is wild this is it would be like it would be like if i was
01:21:57 driving into the office and i i let's say i flip someone off i give them the finger right that
01:22:05 person follows me and they're really upset like that was mean that was rude you shouldn't have
01:22:08 done that and then they just go knock on the door and they tell my employer to say austin flip me
01:22:12 off on the road in and like imagine that employer like reprimanding me for it right it's like does
01:22:17 that have anything to do with my job does it have anything to do with my performance any of that no
01:22:21 and to make matters worse the employee apologized to us saying i didn't mean to victim shame that's
01:22:26 not what i meant i was just thought i was stating the obvious that this person in this article is
01:22:30 not a they're not a jonas brother right like um they just you know and then they got reprimanded
01:22:37 for it and when you get a warning letter it impacts your bonus right so to me it's just like
01:22:42 when i i saw that kind of example or and heard that example happening i was like this is this
01:22:47 is kind of where it starts right and this is kind of the the extreme version of this kind of overly
01:22:54 sensitive kind of culture that a lot of these companies are kind of experiencing and that
01:22:59 people are seeing um right if if this kind of thing happened if they made that comment in work
01:23:04 meeting to a colleague sure right then there's context of it within work right it would be
01:23:10 you know like if you look at porn on a company laptop you can't do that but it'd be like you
01:23:14 know someone complaining that you looked at porn on your personal laptop and got you in trouble for
01:23:18 it it's like there's no linkage between the personal life and work for there to be a valid
01:23:22 complaint right so it doesn't make any sense so i guess you know the to answer your question um
01:23:27 about was I feeling kind of this way, you know, with not agreeing with the direction of a kind
01:23:34 of large corporate environment. I was starting to feel that way, but I certainly was still
01:23:37 a dedicated employee, wanted to keep working, was still learning a lot in my role, right,
01:23:42 which I thought was helping me round out as an HR professional. But certainly there was
01:23:47 more evidence of these types of things starting to happen.
01:23:50 wow so someone made an instagram comment and not associated with the brand not associated
01:23:59 with the company and then somehow this so this is pretty well cancel culture but except it's
01:24:05 enforced by not really much other than someone complaining to to the company to the corporate
01:24:11 entity yeah yeah it was there was no there was no linkage between the employee's personal life
01:24:18 that conduct and work as far as i was aware um and it's it was just i couldn't believe it the
01:24:24 the the employee could not believe it either they were like like hopefully this is a rare case
01:24:30 hopefully this isn't like a yeah i did not see like this is like a theme or happen regularly
01:24:35 but keep in mind i i worked in just a small subset of the bank supporting the people i did and
01:24:40 and wouldn't be privy to all the other stuff going on um and again like if if someone does
01:24:45 any kind of misconduct at work or does something any anything inappropriate i'm not insensitive to
01:24:50 that stuff in fact i i do think we look into it and we do have a right you know an obligation to
01:24:56 investigate and make sure you know it was handled properly but but for things that people do in
01:25:00 their personal life that have nothing to do with work right like even like unless it impacts your
01:25:05 ability to do your job like let's say you get a dui yes that's personal but it's criminal and and
01:25:10 you might need a car to drive into the office then it becomes our business sure but sharing
01:25:15 an opinion on pop culture yeah that's a little different maybe it's offensive maybe it's in bad
01:25:20 taste but it wasn't like you know an anti-semitic comment it wasn't something that was like you
01:25:24 know attacking someone or calls to violence or or anything that could be is ill it was just
01:25:30 it was a comment that someone got upset about which sure like i read the comment i was like
01:25:34 yeah it's in bad taste but like what does this have to do with their job what does this have
01:25:39 to do with us yeah with our job there's nothing to do with us so yeah i could see if it was like
01:25:43 a guy in a CIBC shirt posting a video of like hey here's my opinion on immigration and it's like
01:25:49 did you have to wear the CIBC shirt for that but uh there's no no linkage whatsoever so like things
01:25:56 like that I'm like that's a bit unsettling um and then obviously you know leading to the behavior
01:26:00 that I saw that I personally experienced with with asking questions valid questions right like
01:26:06 the logic that they followed that led to my dismissal was just it's broken in so many ways
01:26:11 but you know i shouldn't be surprised right based on on what i was starting to see all right so uh
01:26:17 we're almost at a uh an hour and a half here but i do want to ask you kind of one final question
01:26:22 just to wrap it up here uh well i guess a couple questions are you gonna be you know fighting this
01:26:29 what happened at cibc are you going to be taking some legal efforts that's question one and then
01:26:34 also uh you know how has your life changed since since this all happened sure so in terms of the
01:26:40 legal side like i won't get into too much detail there certainly i i feel i'll still take whatever
01:26:45 avenues i need to to right this wrong uh where things are at in that process i'm not going to
01:26:50 get into but certainly at a later date if if there's some sort of resolution or it becomes
01:26:55 more widely known you know we can talk about it and how that all goes but for now um you know
01:27:00 certainly i'm not just going to accept what happened uh and even talking with you here i'm
01:27:04 just sharing my thoughts the truth my side of the story uh and kind of what happened to me and more
01:27:09 you know to just bring more light to it uh certainly if there's anyone listening who's
01:27:13 gone through a similar circumstance and has had either success from a legal standpoint please let
01:27:17 me know uh i recognize that everyone's situation is different right i was not terminated for being
01:27:22 unvaccinated i was terminated for not agreeing to new employment terms which included testing
01:27:27 right so there's a distinction there um so and then the other question in terms of how my life
01:27:32 has changed uh basically a complete 180 in 12 months um so i worked through my 20s uh basically
01:27:41 thinking i would climb the corporate ladder um in my estimation i had the skill you know the the eq
01:27:48 um the the aptitude to be a senior employee at a corporate environment whether director
01:27:54 executive level that was kind of my target and career path i'm like yeah i'll work my way up
01:27:58 i was a senior hr consultant which is one pay grade below director level at the bank nice um so
01:28:05 that's kind of where i thought i was going um but since since this has all happened i i will no
01:28:11 longer work in a large corporate environment uh particularly if that company had any sort of
01:28:16 mandate or um or similar behavior that the bank exhibited like i just i can't in good conscience
01:28:22 unless they've really peddled it back and said hey this was wrong and admitted it um so for me
01:28:27 how it's changed i've had to leave toronto i had to move which was a you know stressful time and
01:28:33 leave the city that i knew and loved with all my friends there i went back to my parents house for
01:28:38 six months until i started to kind of figure out consulting and the work i was going to do going
01:28:42 forward and then moved to calgary so i'm out here one of my good childhood friends lives in calgary
01:28:47 he's been here for almost seven or eight years now he's been bugging me to come out so i moved
01:28:52 like because i was at my parents house i was going to have to move again so my option was back to
01:28:56 to toronto which is you know anyone listening who's in the toronto area knows cost of living
01:29:00 is expensive there knows how uh destructive the the passports were right from september 22nd till
01:29:07 march 13th or whatever the date was in toronto in ontario i couldn't play hockey i couldn't go
01:29:13 to the gym restaurant bar travel any of that stuff so for me moving to alberta at least it's a bit
01:29:18 more um understanding of how those implications can be on people's lives so i moved here
01:29:25 uh and now i've pivoted and i always thought maybe at some point i would gain enough kind
01:29:31 of corporate hr experience learning from them learning what works what doesn't work and then
01:29:36 eventually apply that into my own kind of hr consulting but that was something in my mind i
01:29:40 had like 30s 40s you know start a business then uh but since this happened i've kind of had to
01:29:46 pivot uh i incorporated a consulting company uh earlier in 2022 uh and i've just been working as
01:29:54 private hr consultant with a couple clients uh in toronto while i work from home so um anyone
01:29:59 listening if you're a technical person uh like you have you know your devops software developer
01:30:05 um you know solutions architect tech lead those type of roles if you're skilled
01:30:10 and anything i've said has resonated with you in terms of my way of thinking culture like please
01:30:14 be in touch with me i might have some opportunities for you uh but yeah that's kind of how my life
01:30:18 has changed i've been uprooted my life in toronto and did a 180 uh where i thought honestly i thought
01:30:23 i would be in corporate hr for the better part of my career um and now i've had to kind of
01:30:29 reevaluate and and change and and seeing where hr is going i don't think i fit into those cultures
01:30:35 very well anymore um so if there's anyone listening who's also in hr who's not like woke and not
01:30:42 you know has common sense and a good moral compass like please be in touch i i certainly
01:30:46 um how can they get in touch with you yeah uh so i'd say linkedin even though i'm not a big fan
01:30:52 of linkedin it's too much uh too many pats on the back for each other it's like i'm humbled to
01:30:57 announce that i'm isn't humble like all these kind of um all these these posts that are a bit to me
01:31:02 it's a bit disingenuous right people just you know post stuff so i don't use linkedin for that but i
01:31:06 certainly use it uh to connect with people with candidates for roles that i'm hiring for so
01:31:12 anyone who wants to connect with me you can find me on linkedin austin cisco or if you type in cisco
01:31:17 hr like cisco hr one word uh that's my company name currently cisco hr consulting it's to be
01:31:24 honest it's a placeholder right now i created this company very quickly my logo is like microsoft
01:31:29 paint uh but at some point when i figure out kind of what i want to narrow in with my consulting
01:31:34 business and kind of think it through i'll probably do a rebrand and a refresh and you know maybe hire
01:31:39 some stuff but for now it's just a placeholder but you can find me at cisco hr or cisco hr
01:31:44 consulting on linkedin um or just find me like austin cisco you'll see my profile you'll see
01:31:49 my picture i think i'm wearing a sweater even um so that's how they can get in touch um but yeah
01:31:55 that's that's kind of how my life has changed in the last 12 months wow uh there it is on screen
01:32:02 austin cisco hr or search cisco hr to get in touch with our with our friend austin here um thank you
01:32:10 for sharing all that thank you thank you for taking us through the nitty-gritty and kind of
01:32:13 giving us the play-by-play of, yeah, dealing with these mandates
01:32:19 and really standing up for, you know, the law, employment law,
01:32:25 and employees everywhere.
01:32:26 And I just thought of one last kind of question.
01:32:29 Sure.
01:32:29 How has it been, you know, getting terminated when you're working from home
01:32:35 for health and safety just seems so on its face ridiculous.
01:32:41 Yeah.
01:32:41 and i'm just kind of curious you know your friends and family because you know i've had
01:32:46 this has been like a very very divisive time despite you going through this you know what
01:32:50 have you still had to deal with in terms of people who are just like well why don't you
01:32:53 you should have just got the jab anyway or like why are you asking questions like did you have
01:32:57 to confront kind of like those sort of attitudes yeah a lot of it like you know um my my immediate
01:33:03 family was fairly supportive like my mom was kind of like questioning like do you really want to do
01:33:09 this like are you really going to walk away from your job is this the hill you're going to die on
01:33:14 yeah like stuff yes it is like like kind of my thought was like no like i can't you know you
01:33:18 give them inch give an inch they take a mile and and it's you know i know what is right and i know
01:33:24 what is wrong um you know i i grew up with good parents who kind of instilled those values and
01:33:29 then working in hr for 10 years particularly the type of roles that i've been in i was exposed to
01:33:34 so many uh employee issues legal issues around harassment discrimination changes to employment
01:33:40 contracts all of my jobs with the exception at CIBC like when i was at Rogers and IBM was dealing
01:33:45 with this stuff so i felt like i had a good kind of calibrated sense of what was right and wrong
01:33:50 and i was like what they're doing isn't right so i can't in good conscience agree uh but certainly
01:33:54 i had to deal with um you know people not truly understanding why i was so opinionated and holding
01:34:01 firm in it but when i started to explain people the full context of like i was working from home
01:34:07 this is how employment law works this is how banks and all companies typically would have to operate
01:34:11 for these types of changes right any change to conditions of your employment have to be a
01:34:15 requirement have to be justified for the role most people were like yeah i understand it doesn't
01:34:19 make sense and like no one like you know i think most people when i explained to them the context
01:34:23 in a longer setting they were like yeah this is absurd like how did this even happen right and i
01:34:29 again to this day i still i still scratch my head um it's unfortunate and i think that the
01:34:37 like if i had done something that i thought was wrong let's say i stole money
01:34:41 or or i harassed someone i did something egregious to warrant being terminated
01:34:45 i i would own up to it right i would admit hey messed up i did something wrong i deserve these
01:34:51 you know the repercussions for my actions but this it's just i was working from home
01:34:55 right like that's the that's the part that doesn't make any sense right and and not only that is no
01:35:01 one was going into the office right like we've said many times um and you kept your pants on
01:35:06 when you're on zoom calls all the time oh yeah like i you know i was standing up bringing my
01:35:11 camera to the bathroom and be like oops i'm on the zoom call like nothing like i never i never
01:35:16 was disciplined once in my career uh never even had a a chat of like hey you know you shouldn't
01:35:22 done this like no even warnings ever in my career um and even like i mentioned like i was doing a
01:35:28 clearly enough of a job to get more than my target bonus in december and a raise in january
01:35:33 which like clearly suggests that there was no my performance in my output and and even on the way
01:35:39 out my executives that i supported my non-hr like the business executives where i was their hr guy
01:35:44 they were all saying you know you were such a pleasure to work with um like even hang on here um
01:35:52 one sec um thanks for the super chat anonymous thank you greg and austin thank you for keeping
01:36:01 up poking at the dialogue you know like one of my executives said i'm sad it came to this point i
01:36:06 hope you and them find some resolution in the coming days which enables you to return i love
01:36:10 working with you if there's anything i can do to help let me know right like like and this is what's
01:36:14 one front of my business unit executives right like so there was no they needed the help they
01:36:19 they would have been fine to let me work from home right they're just like we don't care if
01:36:22 in the office just like we need to support why are we going to shoot ourselves in the foot when we
01:36:26 were short-staffed so the logic it just falls apart all over and that's i think what's the
01:36:30 most upsetting is that like i'm a reasonable open-minded guy i'll listen to i'll listen to
01:36:36 people's sides i i even understand their their logic to a point but then some of it starts to
01:36:42 fall apart um and it's just that's i think what was the most frustrating and most upsetting was
01:36:47 just that it was it didn't make sense and I just you know they weren't communicating and I just I
01:36:54 really did not think that was fair so you know but it's led us to where we are today and hopefully
01:36:59 you know people see this and and get in touch and reach out and maybe feel more empowered to
01:37:03 to stand up and speak their mind about their experiences and and just you know be mindful
01:37:09 if you're if you're in a corporate setting just be mindful of what you say in and outside of work
01:37:15 it's not that they're not a it's not that they're a bad place to work I think most of the places in
01:37:20 a corporate setting whether it's good or bad it depends very much on your immediate manager right
01:37:25 if you have a good manager it doesn't matter what bank you're at telecom what tech company you're
01:37:31 at if you have a good boss that's really what matters so anyway that's I don't know if you
01:37:36 have any other questions before we kind of wrap things up no that's everything that's everything
01:37:40 Thanks again, Austin.
01:37:42 You can look up Austin Cisco on LinkedIn if you have any questions or if you're seeking
01:37:48 advice or if you want to get, if you're an HR professional, maybe you want to team up,
01:37:51 anything like that.
01:37:53 So advice, guidance on next steps, like anything, right?
01:37:56 Like it's, you know, just expand the network of people who've maybe been through kind of
01:38:01 similar things like this.
01:38:02 And, or like I said, if you're a technical person and looking for a change and an employer
01:38:06 that's not going to you know play these sorts of games i have some connections so uh be in touch
01:38:12 awesome thanks again austin so much for your time uh and that's going to be it for the stream but
01:38:19 guys if you want to support more content like this there's information in the links below i started a
01:38:23 patreon recently i'm really hoping to keep content like this alive and do a lot more fun stuff and
01:38:29 eventually hire editors so i can get more stuff out to you but uh thanks again austin for your
01:38:34 time and thank you just one last thing for you like sure uh i've followed you for probably i
01:38:40 don't know a year and a bit now uh just seeing your little short clips that were good humor
01:38:43 throughout um you know it certainly appreciate you've done uh it's it's a good way to like
01:38:49 sometimes you just gotta like fight it with humor right like like some of the the skits you do it's
01:38:53 just you you point out how absurd the whole thing is and it's been a good laugh so i appreciate the
01:38:57 work that you've been doing man thank you thank you means a lot means a lot and uh likewise man
01:39:03 likewise because it takes a lot of bravery to hop on a call like this and and uh stand up to a big
01:39:08 big big corporation uh but i think it speaks a lot to your character because you you are
01:39:15 professional you are diligent you know what you're talking about and uh and again adds to the
01:39:22 absurdity that they let you go they let go like of a really really uh an asset to their to their
01:39:27 company obviously yeah it makes sense so if the bank's listening you can always call me and we
01:39:32 can we can reach a resolution hey CIBC you heard it lines open the lines open yeah right it's never
01:39:41 too late to do the right thing and to fix the wrongs in my opinion so um so we'll see where
01:39:46 things go I'll keep you and the listeners updated whenever things change or whenever it's officially
01:39:50 resolved but for now we'll see awesome awesome and with that we will talk to you guys soon thank