01:06:36.500Well, we're going to make sure that no one's ever offended for having, you know, different personality traits or looking different from others.
01:06:44.000It like it turns into this like kindergarten, kindergarten nonsense so quickly.
01:09:19.860I'm a bit surprised in terms of the conservative party's approach to the legislation.
01:09:26.280It's important when you think of the Online Harms Act, the essence of what it is that the bill is attempting to recognize.
01:09:35.540Are you listening to this guy? This sounds like somebody's got a case of the Mondays. Like, this is brutal.
01:09:43.220I'm going to be trying to take a shot.
01:09:45.160...attempting to recognize his issues. There are two categories, if I can put it that way, of what one would classify as harmful contact that is specifically being dealt with with C-63. The issue...
01:10:02.160He meant harmful content, not harmful contact.
01:10:05.440But this guy's probably still drunk from the night before.
01:16:49.180I wonder whether the Honorable Member could address his mind to whether this particular legislation may have some effect of gaining Canadian control over those people within our jurisdiction on an app such as Telegram.
01:17:07.400Okay, who's the conspiracy theory here? Who's the conspiracy theorist? What did he just say there?
01:17:13.620They're trying to take us over. The Telegram's going to take over the country.
01:17:16.940Your legislation may have some effect of gaining Canadian control over those people within our jurisdiction on an app such as Telegram.
01:17:28.480I think that they're going to gain control of the country.
01:17:33.020You think you're really in a position to say that you're going to gain control and there's fucking traitors in your midst that have not been identified, by the way?
01:17:40.440Yeah, no, let's worry about the Telegram users.
01:17:45.560i'm trying not to like swear as much but holy i know i'm swearing a lot and i'm trying not to0.58
01:17:51.540swear that's how that's how outrageous this is i'm like trying my hardest not to swear
01:17:54.980um by the way very interesting that uh they're demonizing telegram meanwhile porn hub which is
01:18:05.240an hour down the road headquartered in montreal has been guilty of human trafficking sexual
01:18:10.980trafficking on pornhub uh but they're not i guess pornhub isn't named but they're gonna name
01:18:17.320telegram because there's right-wing people on telegram it's not attacking the far right though
01:18:23.060we're gonna ignore the jewish pornographers at pornhub but we're gonna focus on the right-wing
01:18:30.580people on telegram we're not targeting the far right but we are naming telegram cool such as
01:18:36.940I think that the legislation is a good, solid first step in addressing many of the issues, in good part, that the members actually just raised, Mr. Speaker.
01:18:49.540There are so many mischievous players, not only here in Canada, even more so outside of Canada.
01:19:05.560Kevin Lamoureux, who represents Winnipeg North, allows foreigners to corner him and get him to push for international students who scammed the system to stay in Canada despite the rules.
01:19:14.300And Kevin says he stands for the interest of Canadians.
01:19:23.100We'll look at what we can do to apply pressure to be fair.
01:19:27.940I can tell you, working with the minister provincially, and hopefully with Minister Miller, we will promise to work as hard as we can, whether it's myself or Malaya, in trying to keep you here in that room.
01:19:40.480So, I've actually been wanting to learn more about this story, but essentially, in a nutshell, international students, you know how there was people protesting on Prince Edward Island?
01:19:51.860They did this in Winnipeg already and won.
01:19:53.940international students already did this in Winnipeg and it looks like this MP
01:19:58.560I was supporting them and caved at the same guy who wants to take your freedom
01:20:03.480of speech away this is like the worst type of like a liberal white man you
01:20:06.540could imagine dude look at look at look at the physiognomy here this is crazy
01:20:10.440frail oh my god oh my god he's like a walking skeleton or something what
01:24:23.820It's time we meet their call and meet their demands.
01:24:26.560At the end of the day, when you take a look at Bill C-63, you have organizations like the National Council of the Canadian Muslims, the Center for Israel and Jewish Affairs, two outstanding organizations in support of passing Bill C-63.
01:24:42.900I don't think this guy even believes what he's saying. Like, this guy is just so going through the motions. Oh my god. I find it so entertaining.
01:24:50.480to three we've heard tremendous support for this legislation from all sectors of society
01:24:59.440including sieger that has called for more strict penalties for hate propaganda prompting them to
01:25:04.160get behind this bill what i would say to him is that when law enforcement and victims families
01:25:08.560are talking to me and our government about the fact that they can't get a handle on this issue
01:25:13.160because even when their children take their own lives the victimization of the family continues
01:25:18.140after death they ask for one thing and one thing only which is that the images be taken down that
01:25:23.720is what this bill will do it will take down the images and reduce those from circulating online
01:25:28.740that abuse children this legislation is about this this holy shit this was actually impressive
01:25:35.920in terms of how much different uh a reef just like slung and flung together here from different0.95
01:25:43.460sides different parts of the bill different issues he's saying hey yeah the the jews want
01:25:48.940harsher hate crime laws by the way take the images down protect the kids like he's just like slamming0.71
01:25:54.040it all together into one statement he just doesn't give a he just doesn't give a shit no one's even
01:26:00.000calling him out on it either we've heard tremendous support for this legislation from all sectors of
01:26:04.400society including sieger that has called for more strict penalties for hate propaganda prompting
01:26:09.280them to get behind this bill okay so seija wants stricter penalties for hate crime propaganda
01:26:15.140got it what i would say to him is that when law enforcement and victims families are talking to me
01:26:21.180and our government about the fact that they can't get a handle on this issue what issue are you
01:26:26.260talking about hate hate crime propaganda or are you talking i see i think he just switched over
01:26:32.140to something to do with child pornography there's some victim unless he's talking about a victim of
01:26:37.420hate propaganda because even when their children take their own lives okay now children are taking
01:26:42.820their own lives because of hate crime propaganda or because of some other issue which you didn't
01:26:48.720just specify the victimization of the family continues after death they asked the victimization
01:26:53.500of the family continues after death because the kid killed himself are we talking about porn or
01:26:58.580we talking about hate crime propaganda arif for one thing and one thing only which is that the
01:27:02.720images be taken down okay so it looks like he's talking about something to do with pornography
01:27:07.720but he was talking about hate crime propaganda at the beginning so he's just kind of slapping
01:27:13.300it all together in some impassioned speech which once again really doesn't make any fucking sense
01:27:19.200it's just kind of slamming a bunch of alarmism together into some nice beautiful salad and
01:27:24.920unfortunately it works on people who don't pay attention so that is what this bill will do it
01:27:29.280will take down the images and reduce those from circulating online that abuse children this let
01:27:35.020he started with hate crime propaganda and then ended with abuse children amazing well done well
01:27:43.060done look at that great what a round of from a reef there very very impressive legislation is
01:27:49.400about children it's about exploitation of individuals that are being uh pictures being
01:27:56.040exploited onto the internet without consent the legislation is there it's tangible has a wide
01:28:02.220spectrum of support why won't the conservative party today allow it to pass to committee at the
01:28:07.920very least oh my god so this is another good one just for um again you want to talk about consent
01:28:17.000you want to talk about non-consensual stuff and you're not going to bring up Pornhub
01:28:49.240It's not very sophisticated. Whereas there already is an existing relationship between the Canadian government and Pornhub where they've gotten Pornhub in trouble to be like, why don't you have more better, you know, rules and regulations for when content is being uploaded to get someone's consent who's in the video or whatever.
01:29:09.140and so like there's an exist there's an existing sort of conversation that exists between the
01:29:13.800canadian government and porn hub yet for some reason it doesn't really come up at all with
01:29:18.520bill c63 like at all um and if you want to talk about sexual exploitation childhood sexual
01:29:25.200exploitation which has gotten on to porn hub before you know it would make sense to mention0.91
01:29:29.980porn hub yet these fucking people are not talking about porn hub probably because uh they just want0.78
01:29:36.240to pass this law to kill free speech0.91
01:35:32.580But the liberals response activity continued criminal.
01:35:36.320online criminal activity continues to surge, but the Liberals' response has been to push
01:35:43.100censorship bills that force Canadians into a false choice between their safety and free expression.
01:35:51.100What's the online criminal activity, Mr. Brock?
01:35:56.800Instead of addressing the real issues, this Liberal legislation silences Canadians under the guise of
01:36:04.140security creating bloated bureaucracy canadians yeah i mean i once again a much better angle for
01:36:11.580the argument would be to say that they are using children as a shield they're saying that they're
01:36:16.740going to protect children but really this would not protect children if they did even a little
01:36:20.300bit of research they could expose this whole porn hub thing and why it's clearly not going to
01:36:23.840protect kids but they don't even they don't even take that angle they validate the protecting kids
01:36:28.700angle, which again, gives them a very, very weak frame in terms of, uh, you know, winning this
01:36:34.340debate, but let's keep it rolling here. I'm pretty sure it only gets worse from here.
01:36:42.060MP Larry Brock accurately states how bill C 63 includes punishments of up to life imprisonment
01:36:47.880for a new standalone hate crime law for nonviolent offenses and that the liberals are misdirecting
01:36:52.100people about the significance of this unprecedented legislation. Okay. This sounds good.
01:36:55.940Bill C-6-3 introduces a dangerous new provision, an offence motivated by hatred,
01:37:04.360which could impose a life sentence for even minor infractions under any act of Parliament.
01:37:12.960This broad, unchecked provision opens the door to the possibility, Mr. Speaker,
01:37:19.080that mere words alone could lead to life imprisonment.
01:37:23.540While the government claims that a serious underlying act must occur for this punishment to apply, that is simply not reflected in the text of the bill.
01:37:37.060Section 320 of the Criminal Code would be amended to state, quote,
01:37:42.360everyone who commits an offense under this act or any other act of parliament is guilty of an
01:37:50.100indictable offense and liable to imprisonment for life end of quotes bill c63 introduce that was not
01:37:58.080bad that was not bad getting a little bit into the actual bill and why it's ridiculous let's see
01:38:06.800next mp larry brock states how section 13 will be brought back with bill c63 to prosecute people
01:38:12.340for hate speech under the Human Rights Tribunal with far less standards of proof than the
01:38:16.240Criminal Code. Section 13 was previously repealed for restricting freedom of speech.
02:01:58.960Well, so that sounds like more of targeting people who are hateful and working with CSIS and why is it always ethnic minority groups like like this is so liberal coded.0.78
02:02:16.020this whole thing is liberal coded as fuck like this whole thing of ethnic minority groups are0.83
02:02:22.300the ones who are in trouble uh we need to do something about the ethnic minorities work with0.82
02:02:27.760cesis call out the hate speech get more get more police here is to stop the hate speech
02:02:32.980to make it stop let's enforce more hate speech laws get cesis involved and protect ethnic minorities
02:02:40.880that that should like that that should be that is the liberal argument in favor of this bill
02:02:49.840yet it's coming out of the mouths of conservative mps yes it is that bad i don't want to criticize
02:02:58.300the conservative party though i'm not gonna all these people are like i don't want to cut i don't
02:03:03.920want to criticize the conservative party of canada i don't want to criticize fear polyev
02:03:08.020i just want to get trudeau out yeah so you can get the conservatives in who want to enforce hate
02:03:14.000speech laws that are already on the books so they can work with thesis and work with ethnic minority
02:03:21.760groups who are being targeted you know newsflash white conservative man this conservative party is
02:03:28.140not on your team like they're they're not working for you uh and until you open your mouth and start
02:03:36.360complaining about that and causing pain to them by complaining and holding their feet to the fire
02:03:42.560and saying, that's not good enough. Why aren't you working for me? They're going to keep working for
02:03:48.760the East Indian population, the Hindu population, the Jewish population, whatever minority group0.79
02:03:55.020is saying, hey, conservative man, work for me now. Look at me. You work for me now. Until white0.51
02:04:02.420canadian people don't start doing that then the conservative party is just going to take you for
02:04:07.960granted they're just going to feed you some trudeau hate and then they're going to take you for granted
02:04:12.640take you for a ride because you don't have the self-respect to open your mouth and stand up for
02:04:20.240what you believe in and say hey you're not representing me fuck you change please me0.55
02:04:27.540i'm a constituent too please me do something that'll satisfy me as your constituent we're0.89
02:04:36.760not even speaking up for ourselves and we're expecting us to be coddled to or served by these
02:04:43.860public servants you know like like people only know that you're in pain and need help when you
02:04:49.700say something if if you don't say something then then no one can help you it starts it starts with
02:04:56.860saying something and there's just like there's such a culture of silence with like conservative
02:05:01.400supporters who are just like oh i better not say anything and it's like okay let's just let's just
02:05:07.140watch us continue to circle the drain then all right another another reason the conservatives
02:05:16.660oppose bill c63 from the liberals is because one of the recent leaders of the canadian human rights
02:05:22.520Commission, which would oversee Section 13 regarding hate speech accusations from Bill C-63.0.59
02:05:28.920Okay, someone's an anti-Semite. Now, the member opposite wants to know why we're voting against
02:05:34.020this legislation, and there are many, many reasons. But one of the reasons that really
02:05:38.020came to light over the summer is that their government actually appointed an anti-Semite
02:05:43.960to lead the Canadian Human Rights Commission. Now, the member opposite wants to know why we're
02:05:48.240voting against this legislation and there are many many reasons but one of the reasons that
02:05:52.660really came to light over the summer is that is that their government actually appointed
02:05:57.340an anti-semite to lead the canadian human rights commission oh my god dude
02:06:05.020does it get any like petty or personal in this the reason we don't want to support this is because
02:06:13.560they have an anti-Semite over there well you're a far right person well you're an anti-Semite well
02:06:19.160you're a you're an Islamophobe you're this you're that these people are saying they're using the
02:06:26.480same language okay and it's the same language that real regular people don't are are tired of
02:06:34.040we're tired of all this hate speech talk we're tired of all this well you offended me and my
02:06:39.660group and my tribe's offended and dah, dah, dah, dah, dah. It's ridiculous. It's ridiculous.
02:06:48.700Conservative MP Michelle Rempel-Garner wants to scrap the parts of Bill C-63 that deal with
02:06:54.720Orwellian controls of free speech, but keep some of its contents that deal with child exploitation
02:07:00.240and merge them with their newly proposed Bill C-412. She also mentions harassment.
02:08:03.740I.e., if I said, hey, Michelle Rempel-Garner is going to this event, and I tweeted it, and I said, come protest with me, let's go make her life difficult because I don't like the legislation she's passing or the things she's done as a politician with this new legislation that they're proposing, they might be able to say, oh, Greg's committing criminal harassment online by wanting to protest at an event of a politician.
02:08:28.700Like if you look at what necessitates or like what you need to meet the threshold of harassment, it sounds like the way that people treat politicians.
02:08:39.440It's like, hey, let's go protest this person. Let's go mess with this person here because that's what you do in a democracy is you protest against public officials.
02:08:49.580but that's my most kind of cynical take uh on this legislation they're proposing which would
02:08:55.440insulate public servants insulate uh politicians from uh from that type of criticism and they say
02:09:03.220oh you want to credit you want to habitually criticize public servants and politicians for0.67
02:09:07.880fucking over your country or fill in the blank well guess what now you're criminal yeah now0.76
02:09:12.760you're criminally harassing us so now you have to deal with more legal bullshit so you're going0.86
02:09:16.220to think twice before harassing a politician we live in a free country by the way up the
02:09:21.660harassment immediately victims groups of all political stripe are crying out for this bill
02:09:26.480c63 doesn't do this i just like every i can't even go two seconds without getting triggered
02:09:33.160on these clips bro these are good clips good clips edgy i i i i can't go two seconds without
02:09:38.620getting triggered though who's asking for this what do you mean groups of all political stripe
02:09:43.480and immediately victims groups of all political stripe are crying out for this bill c63 doesn't
02:09:49.080do this they're crying out they're crying out for this really everything that these people bring up
02:09:55.420is so disconnected from regular people like she's like all these victim groups are crying out for
02:10:00.680this legislation to protect people from online harassment and then they're saying yeah we have
02:10:05.500we have a seat this is the liberals now we have a seizure group we have this like canadian race
02:10:10.420relations group all these groups are so fantastic and they want this legislation these groups are
02:10:15.900basically just warts on the liberal party they're warts on the ass of the liberal party these these
02:10:22.500warts on our ass obviously love this legislation yeah they're warts on your ass that came from you0.60
02:10:27.980like are you of course they they like what you're doing they're literally grown out of your ass
02:10:34.860liberal party well they really like what we're they really like our legislation yeah of course
02:10:39.560they do they literally live in your ass crack and then it's like and then the conservatives are
02:10:46.380like oh all these victims groups are crying out for this any regular person is like what are you
02:10:51.800even talking about this bill c63 doesn't do this these groups are con yeah these groups are the
02:10:58.980canadian anti-hate network yeah of course the canadian anti-hate network wants something like
02:11:03.340this they would essentially just oh my god i'm i'm not going to go off on that tangently but
02:11:09.480C-412 also includes an immediate legislated duty of care for online operators.
02:11:19.520C-63 proposes to allow big tech companies to manipulate what would be in that duty of care five years into the future
02:27:35.280Yeah. So before I get into this, like, you know, sometimes we read stuff about World War Two in the 20th century and corrupt regimes and how slowly but surely our rights were taken away and like the boiling frog and what would that look like?
02:27:53.660that's not going to happen here and in many ways we we saw a version of this already happen
02:27:58.400during covid uh you know we we saw the sort of depersoning of unvaccinated people uh very much
02:28:06.600i would say like what happened to jewish people in world war ii whether it just be this propaganda0.98
02:28:11.760of like you know these people are dirty these people are gross like don't let them in your0.96
02:28:15.520business uh that's pretty well what was ramping up here in canada in uh in 2021 and 22 and uh so
02:28:25.660we we saw this year of learning from history that uh affected our entire society like you know it
02:28:32.880was it was a failure of society it was a failure of our institutions of our of the powers that be
02:28:38.660to remember the lessons from you know the world war ii
02:28:44.480the lessons of these corrupt regimes of the 20th century and now with the censorship of both both
02:28:55.880with the censorship of the internet and the slow but sure sort of persecution of hate we're seeing
02:29:02.120a similar thing happen where we are failing to learn we are failing to remember uh the history
02:29:09.240of the 20th century of corrupt regimes and and what um what what was lost and what was really
02:29:18.020so dear to people which is which is freedom of speech and you know they talk about how hey we're
02:29:24.560going to start hunting you know i'm trying to think of the best example it might it might be
02:29:28.580like communist china or whatever but you know they would have a system of spying on citizens
02:29:34.320getting citizens in trouble look at this just got what's going on there bro what's going on with0.83
02:29:42.180a reef a reef's having a long week i hope the video i made about him and uh his smiley muslims
02:29:49.520is uh helping him lose sleep anyway but yeah i let's watch this clip with that in mind are we