Greg Wycliffe - December 10, 2024


🔴Lawyer Analysis of C-63🔴Does it protect Children?🔴SaveFreeSpeech.ca🔴StopBillC63

Hosted by
Mentioned
this Liberal Party does not care about kids The CBC keeps telling LIES about the Trucker Convoy

Episode Stats


Length

2 hours

Words per minute

153.21

Word count

18,422

Sentence count

344

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

64

sentences flagged

Hate speech

55

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, I chat with Canadian criminal lawyer Nicholas Wands Butter about Bill C-63, which is a bill that would make it easier for police to do whatever they want to do to protect kids online.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Thank you.
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 Hey guys, we're going to get started in just a minute here.
00:01:18 I know there's no sound, so it's kind of weird, but I just got to figure a few things out
00:01:23 here and we'll be right with you.
00:01:26 We'll be right with you in just a moment.
00:01:30 Thank you.
00:02:00 Thank you.
00:02:30 Thank you.
00:03:00 Thank you.
00:03:30 Thank you.
00:04:00 Thank you.
00:04:30 Thank you.
00:05:00 Thank you.
00:05:30 Thank you.
00:06:00 Thank you.
00:06:30 here we go in three two one and we are live everybody thank you so much for joining the
00:06:53 stream i am with a very special guest nicholas wands butter he is a uh canadian lawyer from
00:07:00 stratford ontario a criminal lawyer and he also has a youtube channel which you can subscribe to
00:07:04 a lot of great informational stuff at don't talk tv and uh thanks for joining me nicholas
00:07:10 oh you're welcome my pleasure to be here yeah and i guess don't talk is uh from like you don't talk
00:07:16 to the cops is that the idea absolutely don't don't talk to the police don't talk to the state 0.97
00:07:24 i mean don't talk to csis for example i mean i never thought as a criminal defense lawyer i'd be
00:07:29 helping people out with csis but i've had to do that recently for people essentially committing 0.88
00:07:36 the crime of existing while white is what i call it they you know going out for a hike with a couple
00:07:41 other guys of similar background and now csis starts harassing them had that happen wow 0.82
00:07:46 Wow. Hiking while white. I think they're talking about adding a piece of legislation about that, actually. But I would love to have a kind of like a longer chat and interview with you because you've done a lot of great content and videos and I might react to some of it on the channel. But since you have limited time today, I thought we could get right into some of the stuff on Bill C63. What do you think? 1.00
00:08:10 Sure. Absolutely. Amazing. So as you have most likely heard, there has been a Arif Arani has split the bill into two, likely because he doesn't think the human rights criminal code amendments will stick.
00:08:30 And he's going to try to push through stuff. That's just this stuff is actually going to protect kids online. Right.
00:08:37 yeah well i mean who knows why he's doing it i would hope it's because the criminal uh code stuff
00:08:44 and the human rights stuff isn't going to go through i've actually talked about that a little
00:08:47 bit on my channel i mean there's some crazy stuff in there i'm sure people on your channel already
00:08:51 know all about the the pre-crime stuff like the peace bonds and the house arrest for people who
00:08:57 they think might commit a crime right um let's just make sure this works okay can you you can
00:09:05 still hear me yeah um so yeah this uh tweet was from a referani the other day months of
00:09:11 conservator filibustering have signaled progress on bill c63 our kids can't wait any longer
00:09:16 anyway so there's part a of the bill protects kids online and there's part b so today while
00:09:22 we have uh your expert lawyer opinion i thought we'd go over part a which a reef says all these
00:09:29 part a's and a 1.2 1.3 but essentially it's part one and part four of the actual black and white
00:09:36 legislation of bill c63 is that that that's what he said right that's pretty well accurate yeah
00:09:42 that that's what he's saying they're going to do now they haven't actually done it yet if i actually
00:09:47 have just on my other screen here the uh the um parliament website i mean they still yeah he i
00:09:56 mean he's right c63 is stalled it's still stalled at second reading which is probably good with some
00:10:04 of the concerns i've seen i mean if they've only made it from to second reading since february i
00:10:09 think it's probably unlikely that this would make it into law by november 2025 but yeah it looks like
00:10:16 as you say they're trying to they're they're splitting it hoping that they can get the some
00:10:22 of the other parties to agree to at least part of it and get that in right right and it's been
00:10:29 kind of scary spooky because some conservative freedom-minded voices have kind of softened a
00:10:35 little bit and said oh well he's you know he's throwing this uh you know human rights stuff and
00:10:41 uh amendment to the criminal code aside so i guess we can all agree on just the part that's
00:10:48 going to protect kids online and while i have you here today i thought we could try to answer that
00:10:52 question is part a uh actually is there anything in here actually that's going to protect kids
00:10:58 online so it's kind of an exercise in sort of instead of straw manning the argument i thought
00:11:02 we could steel man the argument and see if there's actually anything in here that uh does protect
00:11:08 kids online so uh should i just hop right into the um the let's let's start with the um
00:11:18 the actual description of the harms where is it here
00:11:22 i think i may have skipped over it yeah sorry
00:11:27 i don't envy you having to go through all this legislation all the time it's it's really
00:11:35 like it i'm not i'm not this is not my cup of tea so it's quite yeah well i mean i'll be honest
00:11:42 a lot of this legislation that the liberal party of canada has come out with since 2015
00:11:47 is not my cup of tea to go through either because the the hallmark of their legislation in my view
00:11:54 and just from my perspective as a lawyer maybe some lawyers would say well it's just because
00:11:58 you're a dumb criminal lawyer not a real lawyer um the hallmark of it is that it's vague and 0.91
00:12:06 word salady so even as a lawyer reading through a lot of it half the time like well i don't know 1.00
00:12:12 what they're saying or or what they're actually what they're actually going to do with this and i
00:12:18 think a lot of the same can be said here uh with when we say is this actually going to protect
00:12:24 children well when we get through it a little bit you'll see what they're doing is so vague and what
00:12:29 they're doing a lot of it is it's all well we're just putting this framework in place and then
00:12:35 regulations are going to give you the details which regulations don't have to pass through
00:12:41 parliament. So it's very undemocratic and also non-transparent because you just put through this
00:12:49 law and then bureaucrats, unelected bureaucrats can just add regulations behind the scenes as
00:12:55 they see fit. Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely. Here's a good example. There's a lot of examples of this, 1.00
00:13:03 but in the purple, this is the commission's mandate is promote online safety in Canada,
00:13:09 contribute to the reduction of harms caused to persons in canada as a result of harmful content
00:13:13 online by among other things and then one of them is facilitating the participation of indigenous
00:13:18 peoples of canada and interested persons in the commission's activities in the purple here right
00:13:25 yeah and what what does that mean i i mean it's a as a law well it's not that's a law that's just
00:13:31 saying that's the purpose or the mandate of the commission so okay the mandate is that they
00:13:36 They apparently want to get individual people more involved, which, okay, that's fine.
00:13:42 I guess what they'd be saying there is the reason that's going to benefit dangers to youth is if they're suggesting that Indigenous youth are at more risk of getting in trouble online, so they want to get their communities more engaged.
00:14:01 I mean, that may or may not be the case.
00:14:04 I do know that it is unfortunately a sad truth that indigenous youth can tend to be a little bit more vulnerable just owing to some of the difficulties they have in a lot of the reserves, especially out west.
00:14:19 I'm originally from Manitoba.
00:14:21 I've been to some of the reserves in Manitoba and some of them are, it's really not good living conditions.
00:14:27 and and there are i mean you know i don't think we want to get too much into the
00:14:34 off topic on that you know there's a lot of factors that go into that but um sure another
00:14:40 example here of how open it ended it is and again this is this is my non-lawyer assessment of this
00:14:46 but it says and this is for the digital safety commission these unelected bureaucrats this is
00:14:51 this section of the bill requirements when making regulations and issuing guidelines codes of conduct
00:14:56 and other documents, the commission must take into account freedom of expression, equality rights,
00:15:02 privacy rights, the needs and perspectives of the indigenous people of Canada, and any other factor
00:15:08 that the commission considers relevant. For example, what if the factor is the rise of racism
00:15:15 or the rise of anti-Semitism? So the commission must consider relevant factors like being
00:15:21 consciously anti-racism. Yeah, absolutely. You've nailed it right there. And that's, you know,
00:15:25 it's they have to consider they get to tell themselves what they consider relevant so it
00:15:31 kind of it takes away any sort of oversight because they end up being the ones who get to
00:15:36 decide what's important but the way that's worded there and you know putting that in there gives them
00:15:42 a nice out to really do whatever they want because even though it has some nice terminology there at
00:15:48 the beginning about having to take into account freedom of expression and equality rights they
00:15:54 can use sub e to just say well you know the rise of hate for example that's more important or more
00:16:03 pressing than the freedom of expression so although we've considered freedom of expression because
00:16:08 we're we have to take that into account we're taking these other factors such as the ones that
00:16:14 you've just listed as a couple of the favorite buzzwords that they like to use they can then
00:16:18 use this to say well see we we've used we've done a to e but we've determined that e
00:16:24 has some more pressing concerns for us or or i mean also the equality rights
00:16:30 because unfortunately i think we if anyone who's read animal farm you know there's the the phrase
00:16:37 all animals are equal but some animals are more equal than others i mean that's a phrase
00:16:43 tailor-made for Canada in 2024 because you see it quality you know some people in Canada are more
00:16:51 equal than others I think that's undeniable I mean I'd be called you know a lot of people
00:16:57 probably say oh that's racist to say that I mean it's racist it's just that that is a fact now I
00:17:01 think the argument is is that right or not you know don't tell me that I'm a racist for noticing
00:17:06 this tell me you know just justify to me is that a good thing that some people have have different
00:17:11 rights than others which they can't so that's why they resort to pejoratives like that yeah and you
00:17:19 know i highlighted other stuff like this this is under chairperson and vice chairperson the
00:17:23 chairperson may make rules respecting the commission's procedures and practices yeah well
00:17:29 yeah just leave that up here because i think that's important notice we're on section 20 here
00:17:33 where it's talking about you know what the chairperson may do or the chairperson's powers
00:17:38 duties and functions but you know we're at we're at section 20 which for a law that's really short
00:17:44 which i can tell you like there's nothing in the preceding 19 sections that actually tells us
00:17:49 anything like this is the first time we're hearing about what powers the commission has it talks
00:17:53 about things that they need to uh what their purposes are what their mandate is it talks
00:17:58 about the composition so sections 12 to 17 is talking about who's in the commission um and then
00:18:06 we get and then you start getting into the chairperson vice chairperson this is where we
00:18:10 get into this this vagueness where you know they make rules regarding the procedures so there's no
00:18:18 nothing in this law saying what the procedures and practices are that they'll just be made up
00:18:24 by the commissioner after this thing is established uh i mean they have to make the
00:18:29 rules publicly available that's good uh and then section 21 you have there the chairperson may
00:18:35 authorize one or more members to exercise any of the commission's powers so again it's not
00:18:41 delineating you know who does what it's just vesting it all in the chairperson and again
00:18:50 it's just let since the law up to this point has told us almost nothing about this commission
00:18:56 just what their mandate is who's going to be in it or like who's um it just says that it's three
00:19:03 to five full-time members appointed by the governor and council i.e the prime minister i
00:19:08 mean the the governor and council technically that's the the governor general but it's one
00:19:14 of the problems with canada is you have the legislative and executive branch are really
00:19:20 combined into one just through a historical anomaly of how our government has developed
00:19:26 since it's a constitutional monarchy but the monarch has abdicated all responsibility and
00:19:31 authority so therefore you have all the power in the prime minister yeah and one of the sorry
00:19:39 were you going to say something else no go ahead um uh i was watching a referani talk to some youth
00:19:48 uh in his writing about bill c63 and he addressed one of the concerns of like oh is it going to is
00:19:54 the digital safety commission going to be biased no i'll tell you why it won't be biased because
00:19:58 none of the people are going to be me or justin trudeau and it's like well it's going to be your
00:20:04 friends though or people that you appoint which is the whole concern yeah it will be people they
00:20:11 appoint because they say when it says appointed by the governor and council what that means
00:20:14 is the prime minister puts the list of people gives it to the governor general saying here's
00:20:20 my quote-unquote recommendation unquote your excellency and then the governor general just
00:20:26 rubber stamps it because again the way things have developed historically in our country it's
00:20:32 considered anathema for the governor general to actually exercise the power that on paper they
00:20:37 have i know i mean i'm not going to get into the whole debate of whether democracy is good or not
00:20:44 even if you assume democracy is the best thing since sliced bread it would still be better if
00:20:49 even the unelected governor general exercised some authority because then there'd be at least
00:20:54 somewhat of a check on the power of the prime minister rather than the prime minister being
00:20:58 able to draft the laws and then do these uh these uh appointments because if we had a republic
00:21:05 like the united states the president would be fulfilling the role or holding the position that
00:21:11 our governor general does so then you'd have actually a different person potentially someone
00:21:16 from a different party who is then deciding who these people will be yeah yeah well let's get into
00:21:24 the actual harms i've gone over this a bunch of times but you know you you are a lawyer you've
00:21:30 practiced law so um these this is the harmful content that the digital safety commission uh
00:21:38 wants to remove from the internet and i highlighted the top two um and i guess i should maybe highlight
00:21:45 this one too um i guess my question is are these things already uh illegal a intimate content
00:21:55 communicated without consent let's go one at a time yeah they are i mean that sub a is already
00:22:01 illegal under the criminal code of canada so part of the question is why do they even need this
00:22:07 commission when you should have the various police agencies already accepting complaints
00:22:13 are looking into these things uh content that sexually victimizes a child or re-victimizes a
00:22:20 survivor well i don't know what they mean by re-victimizes a survivor because if they mean
00:22:24 by re-victimize that doesn't that doesn't exist in the criminal code and i'm not sure what they
00:22:31 mean by by victimizing uh content that sexually victimizes a child assuming that by victimize
00:22:39 they mean uh similar things like the criminal i don't have the the code numbers off the top of my
00:22:44 head but uh they have there are offenses under the criminal code such as making sexually explicit
00:22:50 material available to a minor that that could be victimizing a child but that you know it's
00:22:56 more specific in the criminal code that making content available to a minor is a crime uh things
00:23:02 like uh an invitation to sexual touching like in if someone's or inviting children to engage in
00:23:10 certain sexual acts like you know you hear about these things where people they'll get into these
00:23:14 chat rooms or various things and with children and get them to to turn on their video and do
00:23:21 things that if that's what they mean by victimizes then that is already a crime under the criminal
00:23:28 codes. There's a whole host of things under the criminal code that would cover off sections A and
00:23:33 B, and also section F, really. I mean, there's section F content that incites violence. I mean,
00:23:43 Canada has the hate crime laws that I've talked about a lot on my channel that I think are
00:23:49 really thought crime laws. They say that it's, yeah, inciting violence or hatred towards
00:23:57 individuals there's also things like inciting violence like inciting a breach of the peace
00:24:03 or inciting a riot essentially that would be inciting violence that's already a crime so i'm
00:24:10 not sure you know they're acting as if these things aren't already crimes and if they're not
00:24:16 already being forced but i guess it's the same as their firearms laws right they say oh well
00:24:20 you know people are getting killed so you know as if murder isn't already illegal we have to now
00:24:26 make firearms illegal because you know that that will stop the criminals from using firearms we'll
00:24:32 take all the firearms away from the lawful owners and that'll stop this um similar it's it seems
00:24:39 like the way they're headed here could be something like well we're going to greatly restrict the
00:24:46 liberty that people have to go on the internet uh in order to stop these crimes because right now
00:24:52 and the internet has been for decades kind of the wild west relatively speaking right it's been
00:24:58 completely unregulated um and then that and that's why the internet's a place where you can get
00:25:04 access to i mean there's bad things you can get access to but there's so much good stuff you can
00:25:09 get access to that before the internet you would have i mean even a channel like this you wouldn't
00:25:13 be able to get the type of content that you put out uh back before the internet right because then
00:25:18 it was all like i you know i've seen some of your uh your videos that you've done the kind of the
00:25:23 funnier ones where you're pretending to be different members of the government or things
00:25:28 that that would never see the light of day before the internet because it would the only way you
00:25:32 could get it out would be if some like cbc somehow agreed to to put that on the television which
00:25:40 obviously it wouldn't whereas with the lack of regulation without something the crtc which i
00:25:46 think that's what's coming after this this is really a most likely a stepping stone to eventually
00:25:51 trying to regulate the internet the way television is is regulated where you need the crtc to sign
00:25:56 off on your on your channel right um do you know much about uh this bill c11 the online streaming
00:26:04 act in that regard because it or or even uh the online news act because a lot of people kind of
00:26:10 made that same analogy of like we can't just have all this unregulated content on the internet and
00:26:16 kind of implying that the CRTC needs to step in and regulate everything that people are posting
00:26:23 on the internet yeah I and I I think that is uh not uh I think that's a fair concern for people
00:26:33 to have uh I haven't looked at at c11 uh recently but I know I did look at it when I was looking at
00:26:40 that that's that's the concern the concern i've had and the problem with that one is i'm like c63
00:26:47 i mean that one's made it all the way through uh i mean a while ago back in 2023 it made it all
00:26:54 all the way through the uh through the senate and the house of commons yeah and and part of
00:27:00 the reason i started safefreespeech.ca is i noticed with these with these bills regarding
00:27:06 the canadian internet it was tabled it was going on for a while and then always 10 business days
00:27:14 before it goes into law that's when that's when the conservatives that's when the opposition
00:27:19 starts to talk about it when it's just way too late to actually uh you know raise the awareness
00:27:23 among the public with with one of the most you know the internet is like one of the most crucial
00:27:28 things now for uh for uh you know civilized society especially for one that believes in
00:27:34 free speech and free discourse because a lot of it happens online now um so let's uh we covered
00:27:41 the online harms thing i do want to go back to one thing you said though which is uh because i think
00:27:47 you you kind of bring up a a good point or um it's a phenomenon that really i think is a huge
00:27:54 red flag you were saying sexually victimizes a child or revict like what does that mean
00:28:00 does that mean a chat room does that mean uh you know a service that provides illicit
00:28:06 you know illegal material and it's a red flag to me because they say that they want to protect
00:28:14 kids online and why aren't they more specific why can't they go into like this is a chat room
00:28:21 this is the rules here this is the chat room there or whatever it might be it seems to be
00:28:26 done so cynically and so kind of top down and just sort of like listen let's just give the power to
00:28:31 the digital safety commission we'll make up the rules as we go it's uh very cynically done well
00:28:38 i mean that's certainly a possibility i suppose the flip side is they'd say well we need to give
00:28:42 the commission the flexibility to deal with how quickly the internet evolves which would not be
00:28:48 totally unfair but i think i would say that if they're really serious about this why are they
00:28:56 creating new laws and a new commission why not just give more resources to the rcmp or a mandate
00:29:02 to the rcmp tell them to start cracking down on this stuff and investigating it a lot more because
00:29:09 as i said they already have in place what they need to stop the things that they've listed as
00:29:15 being harmful content it's a matter of resources and priorities yeah no absolutely absolutely
00:29:23 um and i think a good thing to bring up here is porn hub has been caught um enabling human
00:29:34 trafficking and also providing all sorts of inappropriate material and they are headquartered
00:29:40 in montreal canada um i sent you a link before our chat i'm wondering if you had a chance to
00:29:48 to like look into it um because there's you know more or less the owner of porn hub
00:29:54 headquartered in montreal sort of has an existing relationship with the canadian government
00:30:00 and they've been investigated before um do you not do you know much about this investigation
00:30:07 i i don't know much about it uh it's something that i i should probably look into more because
00:30:14 uh i did have a look at what you sent me and yeah it was interesting but it's also frustrating to
00:30:20 read okay they did all these investigations so where are the court cases where are the arrests
00:30:26 and the charges and so again that goes back to my comment of look if they're serious if they
00:30:31 actually want to protect kids they've got the tools why don't they go after these people i mean
00:30:36 mean i mean i don't know why they're not going after these people and people you know i guess
00:30:42 that's a question a lot of people be able to have to think about for themselves of you know why
00:30:46 wouldn't the government go hard after the things like porno i mean they're well within canada's
00:30:51 jurisdiction you can't claim oh well they're hiding in switzerland or in the care some caribbean
00:30:56 island or something they're they're in canada and uh you know i keep coming back to certain things
00:31:03 like now granted uh vice uh the you know the left of center i suppose they call themselves media
00:31:10 group they did a lot of the legwork for the rcmp but you know they still did expended incredible
00:31:15 resources to track down the identity of this this guy um i forget his real name a dark foreigner
00:31:22 it was his screen name you know who he made some pictures for this neo-nazi group which okay i'm
00:31:28 not saying it's good to be making uh content for a group like that but he made some pictures for
00:31:34 them and you're gonna hunt to the ends of the earth and expend millions of dollars of taxpayers
00:31:39 money and how many hours of rcmp officers time to hunt down a meme maker when you've got people
00:31:44 like pornhub doing this stuff or you've got people actually victimizing people that they choose not
00:31:50 to go after interesting so you're saying they definitely like our our law enforcement definitely
00:31:56 has the means to target and go after people when they find content online they don't like
00:32:02 yes yeah now i mean now that was one guy and there's all kinds of other people making stuff
00:32:09 for different all kinds of different groups they chose to after that kind as i said vice did do a
00:32:14 lot of the legwork for them but that shows they have the ability it would so again rather than
00:32:19 creating some new commission with a bunch of commissioners who are probably gonna be pulling
00:32:22 in 200 250 000 a year salaries put that money into uh into rcmp's cyber crime units or local
00:32:32 police forces to to look into this stuff yeah i mean i i think in a different world i could
00:32:37 totally be on board with the online harms act if it had stuff about we're gonna hunt down the
00:32:42 pedophiles we're gonna hunt down the child pornographers you know you got alex jones
00:32:47 talking about it at the podium i'd be i'd be right there i'd be like yeah let's pass this now let's 0.96
00:32:52 let's hunt him down let's get him um but once again it just seems to be very cynically the
00:32:58 the fact that they even just lump all this stuff together with content used to bully a child
00:33:03 content yeah well and i think f and g that's the key right there content that incites violence and
00:33:09 content that incites violent extremism or terrorism uh because that's what i see them
00:33:16 focusing on that's what the police seem to be focusing on in terms of people getting charged
00:33:23 for things i mean as again like why am i as a defense lawyer getting calls from people saying
00:33:28 like hey this cesus agent keeps calling me wanting to talk to me about this hike i went on with my
00:33:33 buddies and then i have to call them to say hey like look my client's not going to talk to you
00:33:38 please leave him alone i mean what like why are they even looking into that that you know and
00:33:46 i think it goes back to the whole you know why did um why was it okay i mean really okay because
00:33:53 people didn't get charged i didn't see riot police or or horse police going in to deal with all those
00:33:59 jews for palestine who occupied the actually went inside and occupied the parliament building
00:34:04 recently and were blocking the prime minister's uh motorcade and that you know they just backed
00:34:09 out like the rcmp guarding the prime minister backed out of that so that they don't send it
00:34:15 don't put down with violence but the freedom convoy which was a bunch like i mean i was there 0.95
00:34:21 i don't know if you were you were there uh you know i was there assholes a dance party at the 0.53
00:34:27 corner of uh uh what was the corner of essex and uh wellington or you know you know that's what
00:34:35 they send in the riot police for but not people who are actually occupying the parliament so
00:34:40 you know i think you have to take these laws any laws only as good as how it's enforced right
00:34:45 So on paper, there's things that are certainly not objectionable, as you said, if they're using this as, hey, we're going to really go after the child pornographers and we're in the human traffickers and we're really going to drop the hammer on them.
00:34:56 Yeah, sign me up. But when I see on the ground who they're actually going after and who do we hear them always talking about when they're talking about violent extremism in the media?
00:35:08 Do you hear them talking about, oh, we're really concerned that there's an increase in jihadism or things like that?
00:35:15 Or do we hear them always talking about, oh, we're concerned about these, you know, white nationalists, extremists and what have you?
00:35:22 That seems what they're always talking about.
00:35:25 And I don't see a lot of evidence that that's actually a problem in Canada.
00:35:28 Unless you take, you know, a definition of white nationalism that's so broad is to encompass anyone who just doesn't hate Canada's entire heritage and culture.
00:35:37 and history.
00:35:39 Mm-hmm.
00:35:39 Yeah.
00:35:42 So I wanted to ask about
00:35:44 the sort of takedown stuff
00:35:46 because I was reading it last night.
00:35:50 It says,
00:35:51 do we need to make certain content inaccessible?
00:35:54 And does this apply to all of the harmful content
00:35:59 or is it just the content
00:36:02 that's actually victimized as a child
00:36:03 or re-victimized as a survivor
00:36:04 or the revenge porn stuff?
00:36:07 yeah so yeah the way this is worded is it's it's specifying in this section that's
00:36:13 that it's content that sexually victimizes a child or re-victimizes a survivor uh so
00:36:20 this particular section doesn't leave it open to to use anything else it's it's zeroing right in
00:36:27 in that first subsection that that's the only content that this particular section applies to
00:36:32 okay um and so yeah they have to make the content admissible to persons in canada which yeah i would
00:36:39 i would hope they would it should i mean you know the sad part is it shouldn't take a lot for
00:36:45 internet for content providers to take that down and make it inaccessible to people but uh you know
00:36:52 i mean i guess that's the doubt the dark side of the uh internet being the wild west and well it's
00:36:59 all they want is money or notoriety and they don't care so they're just gonna let anything go
00:37:03 and what's what i feel silly silly kind of silly about it like obviously that content shouldn't
00:37:09 shouldn't be uh online if it's you know child porn but uh the the bill is like yeah we're gonna take
00:37:16 it down in canada and accessible in canada so it's like okay so if i had a vpn i could still
00:37:22 get it in canada could i not like you know it's it's so it's still it's still accessible globally
00:37:27 you know uh well potentially although i mean in fairness the canadian government doesn't have the
00:37:31 ability to legislate anything outside its own borders so that yeah i mean the vpn is is a way
00:37:39 around that but in fairness the government they only have the ability to order people and that's
00:37:46 that's totally fine i just feel like all the legislation i've seen about the internet from
00:37:53 this liberal government fundamentally doesn't really get how the internet works you know what
00:37:58 i mean like it's kind of it's all just kind of done cynically as like yeah we'll well we'll stop
00:38:03 people in canada from being able to access to it but uh i guess the perfect example too of how
00:38:08 naive it feels is they're like we're gonna create we want you to create tools to block users
00:38:15 and it's like that already exists on pretty well most big tech platforms we want to have
00:38:23 tools where you can flag harmful content and it's like i'm pretty sure that's something that
00:38:29 already exists yeah i think it does it does already exist so yeah some of it does feel like
00:38:36 this is making legislation just so they can say we're doing something yeah and again i i just
00:38:44 keeps coming back to like well look if you really want to do something the criminal code stuff is
00:38:49 already there get the get the police involved but i think the problem is or or the again speaking of
00:38:57 cynicism you know it's a lot cheaper and easier to pass a piece of legislation and then be able
00:39:01 to go on tv and say hey look we've taken these steps it's a lot harder to actually put that 0.51
00:39:06 funding in place especially when we're doing stuff like funding refugee claimants to the tune of over
00:39:14 $80,000 a year to stay in a hotel 365 days a year and have $85 worth of room service per person
00:39:21 per day. And they're not willing to say, hey, you know what? Maybe, I mean, it just shows where
00:39:29 their priorities really are, right? Like they'll talk in front of the TV that our priorities are
00:39:33 stopping the harm to children. I would say if your priorities are really there, then literally put
00:39:38 your money where your mouth is. Say, you know what? We actually don't have these millions of
00:39:42 for refugee claimants. 1.00
00:39:44 I mean, we're sorry that you come from a terrible country 1.00
00:39:47 and that things are really bad there and you're in danger,
00:39:49 but we just don't have the money to pay for your room and board.
00:39:56 We don't have the money to pay for anyone else's room and board,
00:39:58 like our own citizens who've paid taxes and lived here their whole lives.
00:40:01 They don't get that.
00:40:02 So we really can't justify, as bad as we feel for you
00:40:05 and for your situation, we can't justify we need that money
00:40:09 to stop children being horribly victimized and trafficked online.
00:40:15 I mean, that's just one example.
00:40:17 I mean, there's all kinds of things that they spend insane amounts of money on
00:40:21 that I think, but those are the real priorities.
00:40:25 Look at where the money is.
00:40:26 The money is going into things like paying all these obscene amounts of money
00:40:31 for refugees to have a hotel and free food, 0.95
00:40:34 paying obscene amounts of money for pushing all this LGBT stuff and the, you know, the 0.94
00:40:41 library readings and all that kind of stuff. I mean, these people wouldn't be able to do that
00:40:45 if they didn't have government money propping them up. We could list all kinds of things. But
00:40:51 at the end of the day, follow the money. That's where the parties really are. And this stuff feels
00:40:56 a bit like window dressing if they're not backing it up with the money. And as I said, that's all
00:41:01 they need to do they don't really have to pass new laws they could just give the funding and the
00:41:07 the resources to law enforcement and tell law enforcement this is what we want you to prioritize
00:41:13 maybe don't focus so much on the the the guys going for hikes or you know like active clubs
00:41:20 is a big thing that they're really focusing on lately um i don't know if you know if you've
00:41:26 heard of those there from what i've been told it again it's like guys it's like men usually
00:41:33 white men like european heritage getting together to i guess they practice martial arts they go for
00:41:41 hikes they do stuff like maybe say like you know what we're not actually so scared about those
00:41:46 people overthrowing the government because there's barely any of them and all they're really doing is
00:41:50 just hang out together for a bit once a week let's focus on on the the predators online
00:41:57 yeah yeah so speaking of money um they want to hand out very big fines to big tech operators
00:42:08 um have you have you looked into this section of the bill well i've had a look at it so i here's
00:42:16 the thing to keep in mind about these. So these are a fine of not more than 8% of the operator's
00:42:24 gross revenue. So what they're saying is this is the maximum that they could fine any of these
00:42:28 individuals. So the principle when it comes to sentencing under any criminal code or any other
00:42:35 statute is the maximum is reserved for the worst offender in the worst set of circumstances.
00:42:43 so for in a criminal perspective the worst offender would be someone who has a terrible record they've
00:42:50 done this you know dozens of times that you know they're before the court it is the fifth time
00:42:58 they're getting brought up on the same charges or the 10th time or the 20th time uh you know they
00:43:03 have just nothing sympathetic about them they've never done anything to try and fix themselves
00:43:08 they have absolutely no remorse you know you get the idea and then the worst set of circumstances
00:43:13 would be you know the worst possible iteration of that crime so uh you know if um
00:43:22 you know say for example just picking a random crime off the top of my head a crime like uh
00:43:29 fleeing from police if the police are trying to play over you flee from them so the the worst
00:43:34 offender would be someone who's done this multiple times before they have a terrible driving record
00:43:37 that they didn't even have a license at the time and then the worst circumstance would be well not
00:43:42 only did they flee from police it was extreme high speed they drove over a child while they
00:43:47 were fleeing from the police and you know and they end up like destroying a bunch of property and all
00:43:52 that and then when they're finally caught they had a shootout with the police so that you know
00:43:56 that's like the worst possible set of circumstance you could think of so that's where you're going
00:44:00 to finally get the maximum and the maximums are almost never handed out they're very rarely
00:44:07 handed down the absolute maximum so yeah that stuff sounds like a really heavy hit but
00:44:12 uh the only um operator you to use their term that would be getting eight percent of their
00:44:20 gross global revenue or 25 million dollars the the only ones who'd be getting that are ones who
00:44:26 are like serial offenders for not following up with this stuff and uh and it's a really bad set
00:44:33 circumstances but also again it goes back to okay yeah this is the law but are they going to back up
00:44:40 this law with action are they actually going to go after these operators or you know are they
00:44:46 actually going to investigate and prosecute these people right so well what i'm curious about is
00:44:53 what triggers an event like this and there's different you know there's different um you know
00:44:58 anyone who commits an offense under subsection one is liable of this you know every operator
00:45:04 that commits an offense under subsection one is liable of this like there's there's different
00:45:08 penalties for different things and i'm trying to kind of parse it out here um right well that one
00:45:14 refers back to um like it says every operator commits an offense that contravenes an order of
00:45:20 the commission what does that yeah what does contra what does that mean well i imagine it
00:45:26 be something comparable to a court order so you know if the commission i know that for example
00:45:32 the section 91 sub 1 is referenced in there as well and that's the one where the they can an
00:45:37 inspector can for verifying compliance or preventing non-compliance of that may enter any place that
00:45:44 they have reasonable grounds to believe that there's a document so disobeying an order of
00:45:49 the commission would be if you don't let their inspector into your facility to have a look at
00:45:53 your servers or what i mean i guess it would maybe it wouldn't be physically entering their facility
00:45:57 might be uh remotely accessing it so that that would be one example or if the commission said
00:46:06 hey you need to shut down this portion of your site you need to stop you know letting some of
00:46:12 this content be available so someone who i could see someone who i could see actually getting
00:46:21 prosecuted under this would be something like uh uh was it gab which is the like the really you
00:46:28 know where they publicize themselves as the no holds barred free speech version of uh of twitter
00:46:35 i can see them going after gab by saying well hey you've got this quote-unquote anti-semitic or
00:46:42 quote-unquote hateful content on your site you need to shut that down otherwise we're gonna
00:46:47 fine you and then if he doesn't take it down then they'll get hit with the fines i i feel like again
00:46:56 i don't have a crystal ball but just looking at past conduct and looking at the sorts of things
00:47:01 that seem to be getting prosecuted i feel like it's things like gab that they're really gunning
00:47:08 for not things like porn hub because have you heard of anyone from porn hub getting arrested
00:47:13 Whereas the owner of Gab and the owner of Telegram just got arrested not too long ago.
00:47:19 Now that wasn't Canada, but, you know, same, you know, it was another NATO country, another G7 country, you know, they're all kind of similar mindset.
00:47:29 Right. So when my concern and, and, you know, let me know if this is hyperbolic Canadian government, what would then, what would then happen to Facebook?
00:47:40 Would they not get knocked on the door by the Digital Safety Commission?
00:47:44 And it's like, if you don't take this content down, we're going to fine you?
00:47:47 Like, is that what it looks like?
00:47:48 Yeah, that seems to be what this is.
00:47:51 Yeah, I think that's accurate.
00:47:53 And it seems that they could use this as a way to force things like Facebook and X,
00:48:02 formerly Twitter and whatnot, Telegram, Gab,
00:48:06 to force them to enforce the canadian government's view of things especially again like we look at
00:48:12 what is considered hate and you know you you can see these cases and especially look at the cases
00:48:20 where people really get hit hard right like 400 churches 400 christian churches have burnt down
00:48:27 and not a single arrest has been made but if you you know like but then that that lady who uh ran
00:48:37 the coffee shop at the jewish hospital montreal during the big pro-gaza protest there she threw a
00:48:44 nazi salute up and you know now you know they're having a complete meltdown over that i don't know
00:48:49 if that one was actually arrested or not but i haven't followed up on that one but but you can
00:48:54 see like that's you know when churches burn down the prime minister says well it's understandable
00:49:01 why people would be upset and would do that but when someone you know does a jet hand gesture
00:49:07 in the midst of a protest well that's totally reprehensible and we need to um we need to come
00:49:14 down on that so i i don't think you're being i don't think you're being hyperbolic i think that
00:49:19 the ingredients for that are in there and it's under the auspices of we want to stop
00:49:25 child pornography, which would be fantastic. I would love to see them actually doing that and
00:49:29 handing out orders to these big tech companies saying like, you need to take that stuff down
00:49:34 or, you know, we're hammering you with millions of dollars of fines. But
00:49:38 will that occur? I guess we'll just have to, we'll have to see if this even makes it into law
00:49:45 before right i mean we're we're now less than a year away from the next election maybe even sooner
00:49:51 but i you know just seeing the way things have gone i i suspect that uh the uh ndp will continue
00:50:01 to come up with excuses of why they need to prop the government up but at least we know
00:50:05 it won't be any longer than november of next year i mean well i say at least for whatever that's
00:50:10 forth i went on a big rant on my my own uh live stream last week about why i don't i don't think
00:50:16 the conservative party of canada is going to be any big saviors and really change a whole lot but
00:50:23 they they might they probably won't resurrect this bill right i mean well they have their own version
00:50:28 of uh wanting to have stop online harassment they have their own version of wanting to police the
00:50:34 internet but um i know and just let just before me interject there you know keep in mind that the
00:50:42 conservative party of canada they voted unanimously along with the rest of the parliament in favor of
00:50:47 the um conversion therapy bill which is so broadly worded that you could technically be charged with
00:50:56 conversion therapy for having a private conversation with your child who's struggling
00:51:01 with their sexual identity and, you know, having a faith-based conversation with them.
00:51:06 Or I think if someone ratted out their priest of, hey, he gave me this advice in the confessional
00:51:11 that they could run afoul of that.
00:51:13 And the Conservative Party of Canada voted unanimously in favor of that, along with everyone
00:51:17 else in parliament. 0.88
00:51:18 And the Conservatives also, by way of private members' bill, brought us the Holocaust, it's
00:51:25 not even a denial bill.
00:51:26 I mean, it is a crime under that law to deny the Holocaust, but it's also a crime to downplay
00:51:30 it in any way and then it's so broadly worded that i don't even know what that means because
00:51:34 like does that mean you're a criminal if you question even one story that someone said like
00:51:41 for example i'm not saying i deny this or not because i don't want to go to jail but uh but
00:51:47 you know for example the you know people being made into soap or human lampshades i mean that's
00:51:53 been debunked by mainstream historians but not it happened not don't can't question it like i don't
00:51:59 know did that happen like are you allowed to wonder whether that happened or not it's so unclear in
00:52:03 that law um whether you can or not so i can't question it there's electricity on the floors
00:52:10 wooden doors it's all real but i wanted to ask about um because i know we have to go soon 0.92
00:52:15 when it comes to bill c63 like there's already evidence that this liberal government sucks at
00:52:22 writing legislation and it hurts the canadian internet the best example is the online news act
00:52:28 to which now we cannot access news on certain social media platforms.
00:52:32 And in my estimation, this is big tech calling the bluff of Ottawa bureaucrats 0.95
00:52:39 and saying like, yeah, actually your bill sucks
00:52:42 and we're not going to expose ourselves to this financial leeching from this government. 0.90
00:52:48 We're only a 40 million population.
00:52:51 And I guess my suspicion is,
00:52:54 and kind of like what I might use to try to popularize how outrageous this bill is,
00:52:58 is could this bill not um expose big tech platforms to a disproportionate amount of
00:53:06 financial risk by operating in canada well in theory it could but again it comes down to
00:53:16 how i mean how are they going to apply this but you're right i mean big tech could do the same
00:53:21 thing they did with the new stuff and say you know what we're just not taking the risk because
00:53:25 the way you've written this law it's not clear to us what you're saying is not allowed so we're
00:53:31 just going to block users from canada from using our platform that's possible i don't know if
00:53:36 they'll actually do that or not but that that's the problem with legislation that is not very
00:53:43 precisely worded because then people don't know what's illegal and they might just decide i don't
00:53:49 want to take the risk of yeah getting a bunch of fines and so we're just gonna yeah because i mean
00:53:57 you do the math and sure these are like maximum charges but you know let's let's say it's uh 0.69
00:54:03 there's a slew of penalties that one pink tech platform gets uh throughout the year you know 0.91
00:54:10 like the potential liabilities even out in a conservative estimate could be like hundreds
00:54:15 of millions of dollars of liability unless you do what the canadian government wants and you might
00:54:21 say oh well or the the ottawa bureaucrat would say no but we're going to work with the big tech
00:54:26 platforms well from the big tech platform standpoint they're like so you want us to spend a bunch of
00:54:30 resources talking to your bureaucrats to make sure that your version of what is harmful is uh is okay
00:54:37 specifically in canada like that's going to cost us a bunch of money and resources to apply to the
00:54:43 canadian internet you guys are one-fifth of brazil one-fifth of indonesia you know you're half of a
00:54:49 germany you're you're only one california like you know what i think it's actually going to be
00:54:53 easier for us and more profitable for us to just shut down facebook and meta uh completely in
00:54:59 canada sayonara is that is that a possibility it's a possibility i i mean i can't say how likely that
00:55:08 is because that all comes down to their internal calculus but i think we can say it is a possibility
00:55:13 just because we've seen how oh oh you cut out are you there whoops i can't hear you is that me
00:55:23 no i think that's on your end what happened there we can't we can't hear you something cut out
00:55:32 uh oh
00:55:34 uh
00:55:37 CSIS is messing with your soundboard I guess
00:55:39 I uh
00:55:43 no I can't I can't I can't hear you
00:55:45 hello hello
00:55:47 well hopefully uh
00:55:51 hopefully we'll get Nicholas's mic
00:55:53 back working again
00:55:54 um let's go into the
00:55:57 chat for a second
00:55:58 uh
00:55:59 What are you guys talking about in here?
00:56:05 Lampshade deniers straight to jail, says NGDTV.
00:56:10 Yeah.
00:56:13 Yeah.
00:56:14 Thanks, conservative party, for tabling that bill.
00:56:18 Thanks for the liberal party for putting it into their...
00:56:21 They got it through in the budget, the Holocaust denial bill. 0.69
00:56:26 but um yeah any luck over there nicholas no um i could try getting you to
00:56:36 if i don't know what mic you have but sometimes unplugging it then replugging
00:56:40 it in can work i don't know if it's a usb microphone or what
00:56:43 um hmm shoot this is too bad um
00:56:53 give him a few more minutes here
00:56:57 hello
00:57:00 nah it's it's doesn't seem to be working uh do you have to go anyway should should we yeah call
00:57:08 it a wrap okay thank you so much uh nicholas for coming on the show sorry sorry that we can't hear
00:57:13 you right now there there you go government taking away our speech shutting down our microphones
00:57:17 really appreciate your work
00:57:20 everybody go subscribe to his channel right now
00:57:22 don't talk TV
00:57:24 it's actually in the mods
00:57:26 put it in chat but it also should be in the description
00:57:28 thanks again for joining
00:57:30 us and maybe we'll talk soon
00:57:32 I would love to have another sit down with you
00:57:34 because you really know your stuff when it comes to
00:57:36 Canadian law so thanks
00:57:38 thanks so much for joining us
00:57:39 thank you have a good one
00:57:42 oh man that's too bad his mic cut out
00:57:45 but that was great that was a lot of good fun
00:57:47 um it's gonna nuke the canadian internet we need to get rid of bill c63 i i don't know i think i
00:57:55 like i think that's uh i think i want to drive that point home i think i think i want to try
00:58:00 to get the attention of elon musk with that one and say hey talk about this bill elon if you don't
00:58:05 talk about this bill there's going to be canadian bureaucrats in your inbox asking for millions of
00:58:10 of your money because
00:58:13 somebody posted a
00:58:14 meme
00:58:16 that's mean to
00:58:18 that's mean to
00:58:23 Indian immigrants.
00:58:27 You know? But 0.94
00:58:28 yeah, I think we're going to hang out for a little
00:58:31 bit longer here. Maybe we'll actually
00:58:33 go react to one of
00:58:34 maybe we'll go
00:58:37 react to
00:58:39 one of Wandsbutter's
00:58:42 videos.
00:58:46 Because, um...
00:58:48 Yeah, I wish I had more time
00:58:50 to chat with him.
00:58:53 Just give me a second here.
00:58:55 Doot, doot, doot.
00:58:57 Alright.
00:59:00 Don't talk TV.
00:59:02 This is him.
00:59:05 Videos.
00:59:07 I think
00:59:08 it's one of the first episodes
00:59:10 he said is all about
00:59:11 the hate speech laws
00:59:12 71
00:59:17 is it this one?
00:59:27 don't talk TV
00:59:28 I thought he said it's episode 6
00:59:38 hmm I thought this was the one about hate crimes or gonna be this one 16
00:59:46 maybe it's this one yeah I think we might give this a watch
00:59:54 section 2b of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms guarantees the freedom of okay
00:59:59 a hate propaganda yeah this might be it this might be the one oh you can't even
01:00:07 see my face right now there we go caesar with ten dollars thank you for the donation sir christmas
01:00:19 tree reveal when yeah once we get some more super chats we'll do a christmas tree reveal
01:00:25 um but hey if you like what i'm doing here you want to support my work uh we're doing a lot of
01:00:30 work on the documentary right now
01:00:32 for
01:00:34 Save Free Speech to expose the
01:00:36 corrupt managerial class
01:00:38 in Canada. If you want
01:00:40 to support that, you can go to GiveSendGo.com
01:00:42 slash save free
01:00:44 speech.
01:00:47 Yeah, we interviewed some big
01:00:48 names, working on a new
01:00:50 sort of teaser fundraiser video.
01:00:53 Look at these donations.
01:00:54 Alan Cunningham with the $100
01:00:56 from yesterday. Thank you, Alan.
01:00:58 He says, let's make this campaign a 0.98
01:01:00 success any leftover funds can be used to kick jt and his thugs to the curb let's freaking go 0.96
01:01:06 let's freaking go so well said so well said anonymous giver with 20 great work greg thank 0.97
01:01:13 you thank you and or court 45 big donation oh allah show me the reality of all things as it
01:01:22 really is totally true totally true and this was huge this guy is the man the one and only michael
01:01:30 the conqueror i think he's our biggest donor right now uh he's basically sponsoring the
01:01:35 documentary at this point one thousand one hundred and eleven dollars guys oh sevens for michael the
01:01:41 conqueror and chat oh sevens for michael the conqueror and check he is making the documentary
01:01:48 happen and uh it's it's very exciting like a you know i've had to pay for hard drives had to pay
01:01:56 for the gas had to pay for you know the editors and the camera operators we're working with an
01:02:01 award-winning documentarian as well um so it's it's good stuff it's good stuff i actually just
01:02:07 went through actually i went through the shot list yesterday of the entire like like script
01:02:14 of like we need a shot of this shot of this shot of this shot of this shot of this it's uh yeah
01:02:19 It's going to be a legit documentary
01:02:20 It's going to be distributed on
01:02:22 Amazon Prime Video
01:02:26 It's going to be distributed internationally
01:02:28 If we get our highest budgeting goal
01:02:30 It'll be submitted to film festivals
01:02:32 And everything
01:02:33 And you know
01:02:35 The whole reason I'm doing this
01:02:38 Is because I've been in the
01:02:40 Political arena in the right wing for a while
01:02:43 And
01:02:44 Respectfully
01:02:47 I don't see that many solutions
01:02:48 like i see the globalist conservative party of canada i see these like lying career politicians
01:02:55 and outside of that i don't really see that much i don't really see much going on of course
01:03:01 you know my whole journey started with the people's party of canada and that's fantastic
01:03:05 and they're doing what they can to create a platform for people i think they could be you
01:03:11 know better i think they could be more aggressive i think they could put a lot more thought into
01:03:17 more powerful messaging and rhetoric to really capture the frustration of canadians right now
01:03:23 because you know the the let's face it the anti-immigrant sentiment is really strong
01:03:28 the ppc has the policy to address that but it's like the the rhetoric is just simply not strong
01:03:36 enough um but anyway my point is you know i see these other kind of alternative media outlets
01:03:44 And they sort of just prop up the PPC or sorry, the conservative party and Pierre Polyev.
01:03:50 And so it's like, what are we, you know, what's what, what like actual solutions are there out there to like fight this battle in the fifth generational warfare?
01:03:59 And I'm a media guy.
01:04:01 So I'm like, you know what?
01:04:02 We need more media.
01:04:03 We need more people telling our side of the story.
01:04:07 And it needs to be well done.
01:04:09 It needs to be professional.
01:04:10 It needs to be easy to understand.
01:04:11 We need to be educating people on a regular basis about this stuff, and that's why I'm super pumped about this documentary because it's going to tell a very, very, very important story, which is, in a nutshell, identifying the enemy.
01:04:26 Identifying the enemy because, you know, getting Trudeau out, I should bring up the example, but getting Trudeau out, can I find it quickly?
01:04:36 it's just so annoying when I'm cooking
01:04:38 and then I want to like talk about something
01:04:41 to like reference it
01:04:42 and then I have to like go look for it
01:04:44 you know what I mean
01:04:46 how far back is it
01:04:47 when do I talk about it
01:04:49 no I made a tweet about it not too long ago
01:04:53 I should be able to find it
01:04:54 there we go
01:04:57 boom
01:04:58 can a Poly F supporter
01:05:03 explain to me how getting Trudeau
01:05:05 out would fix this problem and what happened the mayor mayor mcquaker of emo was fined five
01:05:13 thousand dollars for refusing to acknowledge pride month and subsequently refused to pay the fine
01:05:18 then he had his bank account garnished i didn't even know you could do this but essentially
01:05:23 against his will they showed up just took the money out of his account they took the money
01:05:30 out of his account so did trudeau do this did the federal liberal party do this no and that's why i
01:05:38 say there's clearly bureaucrats and members of canada's managerial class across the country
01:05:44 imposing their ultra progressive politics on mayors on people and in the documentary we document
01:05:53 other stories of regular canadians teachers lawyers professors patriots parents you name it
01:06:06 high school students and how they're persecuted for their political their beliefs for basically
01:06:13 in some cases just who they are and what they believe in obviously we bring up the convoy
01:06:17 in the documentary but we tell that whole story and identify that enemy of there is this very
01:06:23 bias managerial class in canada and there's also an organization called the canadian anti-hate
01:06:31 network which sort of represents this sort of how these people operate which is to smear
01:06:38 the reputations of people who have the wrong politics and it's done in a very systemic and
01:06:45 very intentional and very insidious way and people need to know about this simply so we can identify
01:06:52 the enemy. We can't solve a problem if we don't
01:06:54 really know what the problem is.
01:06:56 Because right now everyone's running around saying, that's woke, we've got to
01:06:58 stop the woke. And actually there was a reply to this
01:07:00 that's perfect.
01:07:02 There was a reply to this tweet.
01:07:07 Wait, was it this tweet?
01:07:12 Well, the Ontario Human Rights Tribunal
01:07:14 is a provincial creation, enforcing provincial
01:07:16 legislation. It has nothing to do with federal
01:07:18 politics. If you want to get rid of it, look closer to
01:07:20 home well this is exactly right it has nothing to do with Trudeau that was in the tweet though 1.00
01:07:24 was I gonna yeah here we go here we go this guy says easy get rid of the head asshole in charge 1.00
01:07:34 get rid of the left-wing mind virus and the wokeness yeah it's that simple right just get 0.99
01:07:41 Trudeau out and get rid of the left-wing mind virus it's not that simple guys it's not that
01:07:48 simple at all it's like it's that this is you know what this is this is a death star this is
01:07:55 a star wars death star thinking and i remember identifying this back in 2020 essentially what
01:08:04 it is it's this mindset that you know you know the movie star wars a new hope it's the climax
01:08:12 of the movie they're in their x-wing fighters and they gotta go fly in down into the trench
01:08:18 of the Death Star and then shoot
01:08:21 one missile in the chute, in the
01:08:23 little, you know,
01:08:25 hole in the Death Star and then the whole thing explodes 0.82
01:08:27 and then blow up this kid 0.98
01:08:29 then let's go home. And then 0.99
01:08:31 there's like Princess Leia with the buns on her head
01:08:33 and then we all live happily ever after.
01:08:36 That's what this thinking
01:08:37 is. All we gotta do
01:08:39 whoops
01:08:39 all we gotta do is get Trudeau 1.00
01:08:43 out, shoot that little missile into the 1.00
01:08:45 Death Star and the whole thing explodes.
01:08:47 this is delusional thinking this is not a movie we're not in a movie we're in reality
01:08:53 so that's just like that that's not how it's not a simple fix to everything that's going on
01:09:00 and i remember identifying this phenomena back in 2020 when this person named Norman Traversy
01:09:07 you guys remember Norman Traversy he said i'm going to arrest Justin Trudeau i have a pdf paper
01:09:13 from a lawyer i'm going to submit it to the u.s embassy and then donald trump is going to arrest
01:09:21 justin trudeau for like being a pedophile or something he got over a hundred thousand dollars
01:09:26 in funding for his go fund me to print out a pdf and then put the pdf into a mail slot at the u.s
01:09:34 embassy no one even came to see him when he submitted the papers so it's like literally
01:09:38 like a death star where like instead of shooting a missile in the hole of the death star you shoot
01:09:42 in a pdf into the whole of the u.s embassy and then the whole you know and then justin trudeau
01:09:49 gets thrown in jail if you could believe it it didn't work it didn't work nothing happened
01:09:57 nothing happened nothing happened at all and same thing with it's very similar with all we got to do
01:10:04 is get Trudeau out
01:10:06 and all of our problems
01:10:07 will go away.
01:10:10 But stories like this
01:10:11 show us that this is not the case.
01:10:14 This has nothing to do
01:10:14 with Justin Trudeau.
01:10:15 This has nothing to do
01:10:16 with the powers that he has.
01:10:19 There is a managerial class
01:10:21 of people with similar politics
01:10:23 pushing the same politics.
01:10:25 And it's not even about
01:10:26 pushing the politics.
01:10:27 It's about punishing people
01:10:29 with the wrong politics.
01:10:32 And it's always done
01:10:33 in an above board way.
01:10:34 like listen to like the audacity of the people that did this sure sex is great but have you
01:10:44 ever garnished your mayor's bank account after he publicly refused to comply with the tribunal's
01:10:48 order to pay damages that's um like they're so emboldened they're so emboldened they're like
01:10:57 yeah we we uh we took five grand from this mayor's bank account because we don't like
01:11:04 politics because he didn't recognize pride month or recognize some flag or whatever it's crazy
01:11:11 it's absolutely insane but yeah that's why that's why this documentary is important it's it's going
01:11:18 to start exposing the problem and i want to start creating solutions in this place i want to start
01:11:25 creating um and the solution is you know a documentary that's going to tell uh our side
01:11:35 of the story you know it's actually going to tell it properly it's going to expose this managerial
01:11:39 class and then give us you know the moral high ground oh my god look at this james bullock with
01:11:46 150 donation thank you so much for this huge donation 150 keep up the great work infinite
01:11:55 respect infinite respect wow i'm gonna take that to the bank you know i'm gonna take that to the
01:12:03 bank you hear that you hear that i got infinite respect thank you so much for the huge donation
01:12:09 james really really appreciate it um i'm hopefully going to come out with more sort of fundraiser
01:12:15 stuff to to really hype it up and try to do a christmas drive here because um
01:12:19 yeah there's a there's a lot there's a lot of stuff to pay for for this project and i think
01:12:25 it's going to be well worth it um so lee stewie in chat says borderland pride leader says he will
01:12:32 go after anyone who opposes lgbt where applicable because he's a lawyer yeah the i mean these people
01:12:39 are they're aggressively enforcing their politics on people through through like punishment and
01:12:45 through all sorts of things and really what what is the pushback let's let's meditate on that for
01:12:52 a second what is the pushback against these emboldened gay lawyers who are going after
01:12:59 mayors and taking their money because it comes back to it comes back to the conservative party
01:13:07 of canada the poly of the the official opposition and they hardly stand up for any of us i think
01:13:15 ever did didn't even didn't even stand up for tamara litch or chris barber didn't even stand
01:13:22 up for archer poplowski didn't even stand up for i mean the closest thing he did to that was like
01:13:29 taking a photo op with james top which was which was honestly more gross than anything else because
01:13:36 he was there for two seconds then ran away and then uh never spoke of it again this is a canadian
01:13:42 armed forces veteran
01:13:44 who marched across the entire country
01:13:46 with a 50 pound rucksack on his back
01:13:48 to stop vaccine mandates
01:13:50 in the military shows up
01:13:52 for two seconds for a photo op to
01:13:54 pander to people like us then 0.99
01:13:56 fucking disappears 1.00
01:13:57 he's not like Trudeau 1.00
01:14:00 though he's not like a regular 0.97
01:14:02 ass career politician 0.95
01:14:04 he's actually exactly that 0.97
01:14:06 but yeah oh yeah we were going to react to this
01:14:10 that's right
01:14:11 that's right that's right let's react to a uh wandsbutter video let's go how do i fix this
01:14:19 do this let me let me fix this hold on
01:14:23 that doesn't look right um
01:14:29 just a moment
01:14:41 Is that better?
01:14:55 There we go.
01:15:00 All right, let's react to that.
01:15:02 Hate crimes in Canada.
01:15:06 I'm excited.
01:15:07 go uh go subscribe to um to nicholas wandsbutter his channel don't talk tv
01:15:15 lee stewie says imagine if c63 passes and you have people like borderland pride at the helm
01:15:20 filing lawsuits with the human rights commission yeah i mean that's kind of why i do see um
01:15:28 a reefer ronnie splitting up this bill at least as like a small win i think i may have sent the
01:15:33 wrong message on my initial like tick tock about this of how it's like hey this is good news
01:15:37 it's it's good news isn't that they're they're going to put that on the back burner for now
01:15:42 the thing of you know it looks like they're going to put that on the back burner of changing the
01:15:45 human rights stuff and and trying to broaden the definition of criminal hate speech however
01:15:50 it's also bad news because they're shifting their tactic to try and get one past the goalie
01:15:56 and a digital commission you know it's it's going to be a censorship bureaucracy based on what we've
01:16:03 with this government it's going to be a censorship
01:16:05 bureaucracy and I think I'm just thinking
01:16:07 out loud here that's another sort of
01:16:08 reason why I'm excited
01:16:11 about this documentary I don't really feel
01:16:13 like many people
01:16:15 properly identify the problem
01:16:16 because if you go to alternative
01:16:19 media if you go to the rebel news of the world
01:16:21 and the true north southern world and even
01:16:22 the other kind of like YouTube influencers of the world
01:16:25 in Canadian politics all
01:16:27 the problems are reduced to Justin
01:16:29 Trudeau or even just like
01:16:31 the liberal party
01:16:32 When in reality, there's a whole class of bureaucrats who fall in line with being subservient to the corrupt government, the corrupt regime that they all work for.
01:16:46 And very rarely do I see anyone kind of properly identifying the enemy, properly identifying like the villain of the story.
01:16:56 so
01:16:57 yeah we need to start doing that
01:17:00 because otherwise we're just kind of running around with our head cut off
01:17:03 alright let's get into
01:17:04 reacting to this video
01:17:05 then I'm probably going to wrap it up
01:17:09 because I got
01:17:09 I got work to do guys
01:17:12 I got work to do
01:17:13 so this is
01:17:14 Don't Talk TV episode 16
01:17:19 hate crimes in Canada
01:17:20 whoops
01:17:23 hold on let me fix the audio
01:17:25 Section 2B of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms guarantees the freedom of thought, belief,
01:17:35 and expression. However, this right is not unlimited, and as we've discussed previously,
01:17:40 Section 1 of the Charter allows for reasonable limitations on the rights provided in other
01:17:45 sections of the Charter. One of those limits on the right to freedom of expression and thought
01:17:50 comes from the so-called hate propaganda provisions of the Criminal Code of Canada.
01:17:55 This week on Don't Talk TV, I'm going to look at those sections of the Criminal Code
01:17:58 in light of some recent events in the news.
01:18:11 This is not legal advice.
01:18:14 Hello, my name is Nicholas Wandsbutter.
01:18:16 I'm a criminal defense lawyer in Stratford, Ontario, Canada,
01:18:18 and welcome to don't talk tv now the question of hate crimes and hate propaganda has come up in
01:18:24 the news recently two items in particular caught my attention one a gentleman named let's just
01:18:30 check the time so that's february 17th 2021 this was the february before the convoy canadian
01:18:37 nationalist party leader charged with willful promotion of hate so this for those who don't
01:18:41 know this is a hate speech law that's already on the books and it's enforced and used very rarely
01:18:47 So he's going to kind of go over, I think, one of the times it has been used.
01:18:50 Travis Patron, or Patron, not exactly sure how to pronounce his name, who's apparently the leader of the Nationalist Party of Canada, was arrested and charged with promotion of genocide under Section 318 of the Criminal Code and willful promotion of hatred under Section 319 of the Criminal Code.
01:19:08 This was in relation to a YouTube video that he had posted some years ago
01:19:12 and which the Canadian Anti-Hate Network had brought to the attention of the Royal Canadian Mounted Police.
01:19:18 The second...
01:19:18 Wow, there you go.
01:19:20 Canadian Anti-Hate Network bringing something to the attention of the RCMP.
01:19:26 Huh. Huh.
01:19:28 Where have we seen that before?
01:19:30 Interesting.
01:19:31 Starting to see a network start to arise here.
01:19:36 item is from february the 22nd where an article asked why a pub in downtown london called the
01:19:43 ale house hadn't been charged with willfully promoting hatred for a sign that they posted
01:19:48 on their building that said we love chinese people but we hate the genocide and the chinese 0.87
01:19:55 virus that your communist government has inflicted on us now it's important okay whoa 0.68
01:20:00 throwback i forgot about this uh based sign we love chinese people we hate the genocide 0.88
01:20:08 in china virus your commie government has inflicted upon us i mean what's wrong with that 0.61
01:20:14 that's that's i love the covet angst coming out of that you know what i mean 0.68
01:20:19 um austin s says pat king could be any of us and look how easy we be forgotten about i don't even
01:20:29 like pat king but he shouldn't be in jail i know this is totally true this is totally real um
01:20:34 i mean and i don't understand why more people don't get that you know uh these are the canaries
01:20:42 in the coal mine like we saw it since the convoy where people like jeremy mckenzie morgan may people
01:20:50 like arthur paulowski people like henry hildebrandt people like uh yeah pat king
01:20:58 they all uh did i mention uh old rand randy hillier as well like these people were made an
01:21:07 example of for being leaders or being you know representative of a certain politics of opposing
01:21:14 the canadian government and they got punished for it and the thing is is when people get thrown in
01:21:19 jail or persecuted like you know life life moves on unfortunately and unless there's people who are
01:21:28 telling that story then it's going to be forgotten about it's going to be forgotten about and people
01:21:34 are just going to move on and it's sad but that's what happens and it sucks because there's so many
01:21:38 people who are further left or further to the center or maybe they're right wing and they agree
01:21:43 with all these people like pat king who have been thrown in jail but i don't want to associate with
01:21:49 that i don't want to say that i don't it's too risky for me to stand up and defend them and tell
01:21:54 their story and it's like okay well now no one is you know and now uh the fact that that happened
01:22:01 the fact that that was so morally wrong and morally bad and exposed the corruption of the
01:22:07 government you live under now no one's going to hear about any of that now that's not just not
01:22:12 going to be talked about at all and uh then the government's going to do it again and they're
01:22:18 going to do it to somebody who's closer to you they're going to keep coming in from the far right
01:22:22 and they're going to move their way in.
01:22:24 And that's why it's always disgusting
01:22:26 when anyone like to the left of me is like,
01:22:29 oh, I don't want to do that.
01:22:30 I don't want to associate with that.
01:22:31 And it's just like, bro, you're next in line. 1.00
01:22:33 Are you stupid? 1.00
01:22:35 Like, just like, look at what's happened in history 1.00
01:22:38 when there's a rise of a tyrannical government.
01:22:41 They start at the most sort of like the strongest dissidents
01:22:45 who are the most dissenting against the ruling government.
01:22:48 They go after them first, persecute them,
01:22:51 make an example of them try to create laws around it or whatever just to usurp their power and
01:22:56 you know discredit everyone who agrees with that dissident whatever and then they move in from
01:23:01 there uh so and it's really sad because there's a lot of um i mean it's not sad it's just kind
01:23:08 of like the situation we're in in canada there's a lot of infighting right now which i'm kind of
01:23:14 okay with but i think some infighting is good and some infighting is bad and i might i might
01:23:22 kind of make a video or share some thoughts on it to kind of parse out my my thoughts on that but
01:23:27 i mean in a nutshell 0.83
01:23:30 maybe i'll just talk about it now there's a lot of demoralized people in in the right wing of
01:23:40 canada or the freedom movement or whatever you want to call it and they saw what happened during
01:23:45 the convoy they saw how corrupt our government is and they don't see solutions probably because
01:23:52 there aren't many good ones and so they get demoralized and i've been there you know i've
01:23:58 been there i've totally felt that way before it's totally hopeless it's so over um and i think the
01:24:05 solution is to first of all address the fact that you're demoralized and try to remoralize yourself
01:24:11 any way that you can by working on yourself that's always a good first step you know trying to take
01:24:16 care of your immediate family or friends or anyone who's around you your immediate homestead or home
01:24:22 or living situation or financial situation that's always a good place to start but outside of that
01:24:29 it's important to be grounded in reality of what is possible we should have a sort of idealist
01:24:38 kind of like radical imagination in terms of what is possible but there's also something where it's
01:24:44 like okay well what's realistic to do right now what can we do right now what how am i going to
01:24:48 reach that long-term ideal goal and this everything i'm talking about is like solutions oriented
01:24:54 That's the healthy thing.
01:24:55 Take care of yourself, then assess the situation,
01:24:59 aspire for something great that will turn this country around,
01:25:02 but also look at the immediate environment and ask yourself,
01:25:05 what can I actually do to progress towards the goal that I want?
01:25:09 That's the healthy thing to do.
01:25:11 People are not doing that.
01:25:13 There's a lot of right-wing people who are not doing that.
01:25:16 Maybe they're overwhelmed with demoralization,
01:25:19 they're overwhelmed with fear, and they think that the time is out,
01:25:22 it's already too late.
01:25:23 And then they kind of they let sort of, I don't know, resentment and fear take over and it turns into this sort of nasty thing and they just start kind of tearing down everyone around. 0.99
01:25:34 They just start to like shit on everything. 0.99
01:25:37 They start to shit on the PPC, for example. 1.00
01:25:39 They start to shit on Diagalon or Jeremy McKenzie or myself or anyone who's actually trying to do something. 0.98
01:25:45 and it's it's very and and you know to be fair people people like might might between diagonal 0.93
01:25:52 and ppc and they might be fighting back and forth and that sort of thing and this is what i mean
01:25:56 sometimes it's productive in fighting and it's constructive criticism or it's like pushing the
01:26:01 person to be more aggressive or more you know more um more strong and brave with their rhetoric
01:26:10 but on the flip side sometimes it's just kind of nasty and destructive and unproductive and sort of
01:26:19 like it just feels like the person is trying to tear something else down because it feels good
01:26:25 in the moment you know what i said about you're aspiring for a positive goal to try and you know
01:26:29 turn the country around but you also have to look at the reality these people are not having any sort
01:26:34 of aspiration for the future they're like it's totally over there is no future so what can i do 0.95
01:26:38 with the immediate power i have right now i'm gonna go shit on that person right there i have 0.98
01:26:42 the power i have the ability to go shit on that person and it's gonna feel good it's gonna feel 1.00
01:26:48 good to just throw a brick through that window because fuck that it's over anyway bro 0.99
01:26:53 that's what's unproductive that's what kind of needs to stop um i think the infighting can be 0.99
01:27:01 good i think having i think actually i want to host more debates to be honest because i've gotten a
01:27:06 lot of great feedback from that debate uh between the ferryman's toll and um alex cargill aka
01:27:14 trans splendor and i would like to do more debates on those topics because let's face it there aren't
01:27:19 really much debates going on in canada period there's not going to be a debate on the cbc
01:27:24 there's not going to be a debate on ctv news or city tv there's not even going to be a debate
01:27:30 with the conservative party of canada they are very much nope like no discussion if you become
01:27:39 a member you're not even allowed to like you have to write all this stuff to sign your life away to
01:27:43 like not talk about stuff so there's no debate happening there either where's the debate
01:27:49 happening it's like quite frankly the debate is happening online between you know ppc people
01:27:59 diagonal on people whatever it is um maybe some maybe a little bickering with kind of the
01:28:04 conservative gatekeepers but most of the time that they just try to prop up the conservative
01:28:08 party but like there's a lot of very pressing issues going on and like no one's really we're
01:28:12 not really talking about it or parsing it out whatsoever so uh d's in chat if you want more
01:28:20 debates let me see those d's but uh that's pretty well my rant we we gotta we gotta keep things
01:28:26 productive um i think in like i said infighting and disagreement i think can very be very healthy
01:28:32 uh even if it gets heated even like i can see if it gets like sometimes a little nasty or people
01:28:37 kind of like you know mock each other a bit and ridicule each other a bit because that's how you
01:28:41 can get your point across but um aside from that you know when it's just kind of like nasty with
01:28:48 with no real points that that that kind of stuff i think is just i think i think when i see that
01:28:54 stuff i think it's just honestly depressing because it's like people are just demoralized
01:28:57 and this is like the epitome of losing the epitome of losing is you know getting crushed
01:29:02 by the globalist astro-surfed conservative party and then any amount of resistance is
01:29:08 just bickering and fighting amongst each other with no sort of um no sort of
01:29:14 sign that it's going to manifest into anything productive um i think conflicts are good
01:29:24 but it needs to turn into something positive yes look at the d's in chat let's freaking go
01:29:29 let's freaking go um let's let's continue to react to this i a pub in downtown london called
01:29:37 the ale house hadn't been charged with willfully promoting hatred for a sign that they posted on 0.98
01:29:42 their building that said, we love Chinese people, but we hate the genocide and the Chinese virus 0.96
01:29:49 that your communist government has inflicted on us. Now, it's important for Canadians to understand 0.94
01:29:55 the hate propaganda laws, firstly, so that you understand both your rights and your obligations
01:30:00 for public discourse in Canadian society, and also to give some insight into why these charges
01:30:06 are so rarely laid. So in this episode, firstly, I'll cover what is laid out in sections 318 and
01:30:12 319 of the criminal code and it explain what is required to prove charges under those sections
01:30:18 then i'll look specifically at how those sections of the criminal code might apply
01:30:24 against the video in question posted by mr patron or patron and finally i'll look at how
01:30:29 that those sections may or may not apply to the ale house in london ontario
01:30:33 amazing this is stuff we've covered this is stuff we've covered on the channel before but
01:30:40 I'm excited to hear what my rights are in regards to hating things
01:30:45 and what I'm allowed to hate and what I'm not allowed to hate
01:30:48 and what I'm allowed to say and not allowed to say.
01:30:51 Yeah.
01:30:52 So the hate propaganda laws are separated into two sections.
01:30:55 The first, and more serious, but also less often prosecuted,
01:30:58 is section 318 of the Criminal Code, which is advocating genocide.
01:31:02 So that section reads that everyone who advocates or promotes genocide
01:31:05 is guilty of an indictable offense and liable to imprisonment
01:31:08 for a term not exceeding five years.
01:31:09 Now, genocide is specifically defined under subsection 2 as an act committed with the intent of destroying, in whole or in part, any identifiable group, specifically killing members of that group, or deliberately inflicting upon that group life conditions calculated to bring about the destruction of that group.
01:31:25 So if they're trying to prove that someone's advocating or promoting genocide, they have to prove that the person is actually calling for the killing of individuals, or the... 0.79
01:31:32 I wonder if, like, calling to end whiteness qualifies. 0.95
01:31:35 Thanks. Does calling to end whiteness qualify as a call to genocide? Just curious. 0.61
01:31:41 Purposeful imposition of conditions that are so bad that they would most likely die,
01:31:45 or a large number of them would be certain to die. Now, an identifiable group is also
01:31:49 specifically defined in this section. So an identifiable group is defined in this section
01:31:53 as any section of the public distinguished by color, race, religion, national or ethnic origin,
01:31:58 age, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity or expression, or mental or physical disability.
01:32:03 Section 319 is then public incitement of hatred, and there's two ways that individuals can be charged under that section.
01:32:09 The first is under subsection 1 that says that everyone who, by communicating statements in any public place, incites hatred against any identifiable group where such incitement is likely to lead to a breach of the peace.
01:32:21 I'm going to slow this down.
01:32:22 any identifiable group
01:32:27 is that everyone who by communicating statements in any public place incites hatred against any
01:32:36 identifiable group where such incitement is likely to lead to a breach of the peace is guilty
01:32:41 and the maximum is two years on that charge and the sectioned is under subsection two that says
01:32:46 everyone who by communicating statements other than in private conversation willfully promotes
01:32:51 hatred against any identifiable group
01:32:53 is guilty. Now, identify
01:32:55 Hmm.
01:33:09 Abolishing
01:33:09 whiteness has never been more urgent.
01:33:12 Interesting.
01:33:17 Harvard
01:33:17 Magazine. Abolish the
01:33:19 white race. 1.00
01:33:21 Interesting.
01:33:24 Your independent source for Harvard News
01:33:25 since 1898. 0.99
01:33:31 It's time for whiteness as usual to end. 0.99
01:33:37 Interesting. 0.94
01:33:42 The United Church of Canada?
01:33:45 What?
01:33:47 12 steps towards ending white supremacy.
01:33:51 oh my god here's like the 12 steps from like the 12-step program
01:33:59 that's interesting let's keep let's keep going through this video i don't want to get sidetracked
01:34:09 viable group has the same definition for both sections 318 and section 319. now section 319
01:34:17 the Crown does not have to prove that the individual willfully incited hatred but they
01:34:23 do have to prove that what they said was something that would be likely to cause a breach of the
01:34:28 piece. Subsection 2 does not require any proof that the piece might be breached but it has a
01:34:35 more onerous requirement that it be proved that the person willfully promoted hatred by the
01:34:41 comments that they made. The case law in all of these sections says that the incitement must be
01:34:45 both public and direct the case also says that promoting hatred requires more than encouraging
01:34:51 ill will it must be direct and active stimulation of hatred and the accused must be proved to
01:34:59 promote an emotional state of an extreme and intense nature in a supreme court this is all
01:35:06 i i'm excited to hear his commentary on this because this this all is like if they sound
01:35:12 really angry then it's bad then we're then we're gonna determine and like it's just it just goes
01:35:19 to like because the flip side guys is when trudeau is like talking about unvaccinated people and he's
01:35:25 like do we even tolerate these people i mean he sounds nice it sounded nice when he said that
01:35:32 do we even tolerate these people but it also implies
01:35:35 we got to get rid of these people these people now when he said that off i'll say on like cbc
01:35:45 canada radio or whatever um whatever french station it was he was like they don't believe
01:35:51 in science they hate women what do we do with these people do we even tolerate these people
01:35:57 you know it's our political enemies or i wouldn't even say our political enemies anybody who is
01:36:05 in sort of the business of demonizing groups effectively,
01:36:11 effectively keyword, they do it in a sort of cryptic way.
01:36:15 They do it in a passive-aggressive way.
01:36:19 Oh, no, no, no, no, I'm love and light.
01:36:21 I'm love and light, but I'm just against racism.
01:36:26 And you're racist, and that means I'm dehumanizing you. 0.94
01:36:30 And that means people should hate you. 1.00
01:36:32 that means people should hate your guts 0.66
01:36:35 and think that you are everything 0.98
01:36:37 wrong with society but I'm
01:36:39 nice I'm just here to be a good person
01:36:41 I'm just saying
01:36:43 because you like
01:36:45 to tweet or because someone that you like
01:36:47 liked to tweet or said something
01:36:48 you're actually the worst person
01:36:51 ever you're the most morally wrong 0.99
01:36:53 thing that's
01:36:54 cause of all of our society's ills
01:36:57 but I have a
01:37:00 but I have a heart and a rainbow flag in my bio.
01:37:04 So that's,
01:37:05 that's not hate,
01:37:05 right?
01:37:06 That's not hate.
01:37:07 That's because it sounded nice when they talked about it.
01:37:11 Decision titled Her Majesty the Queen and Andrews.
01:37:15 Justice Corey stated,
01:37:17 quote,
01:37:17 hatred is not a word of casual connotation.
01:37:20 To promote hatred is to instill detestation,
01:37:23 enmity,
01:37:24 ill will,
01:37:24 and malevolence in another.
01:37:26 Clearly an expression must go a long way before it qualifies within the
01:37:29 definition of section 319 sub 2 we shouldn't even be legislating this i don't think i mean
01:37:39 like if i hate pedophile like you know it's a kind of cheap example but like if i hate pedophiles
01:37:44 i should be able to be like very you know not like you know i i think i should be able to hate
01:37:52 things i think i should be able to hate evil things i don't think that's outrageous to say
01:37:56 because evil people are out there dishonest people are out there who do immoral things that are worthy
01:38:03 of hatred you know it's it's sort of invalidating uh you know humanity it invalidates the the human
01:38:12 experience to say no you should never be angry you know it'd be nice if we were never violent
01:38:19 but people are going to be violent because they're human beings but this is the difference is this is
01:38:24 an emotion that we all have and it's not even you know it's not even causing any direct harm to
01:38:32 anyone so anyway two in defense of hate so i think this shows right at the beginning that it's very
01:38:39 difficult to prove these sections because of the intensity of the hatred that has to be engendered
01:38:45 by the words that are spoken or propagated by an individual so the crown has to prove that the
01:38:51 individual either directly intended to promote hatred or that the words they uttered were just
01:38:58 so obvious that that would occur, that it was certain or substantially certain that hatred
01:39:03 would result, that that intention is imputed to them. So there's certainly very little room for
01:39:09 gray area and it would seem that comments made by individuals have to be very obvious in their
01:39:15 intent in order for the Crown to prove the case. So let's take a look at these cases that have come
01:39:22 up in the media recently, dealing first with Mr. Patron, or Patron, who was charged on February
01:39:29 the 17th. The video in question is entitled, quote, Beware the Parasitic Tribe, unquote.
01:39:35 According to the Canadian Anti-Hate Network, Parasitic Tribe is a specific reference to
01:39:40 Jewish people. I'm not certain that that's something in common knowledge that courts could
01:39:45 take judicial notice of. Judicial notice is when something is so widely known that courts can
01:39:51 accept it without there being evidence to establish that point. So for example, somewhere to say the
01:39:57 sky is blue, the court can take judicial notice of the fact that the sky is blue because this is so
01:40:02 widely known and you don't need a scientist to come to explain that that is in fact the case.
01:40:07 I'm not so certain that everyone knows that parasitic tribe refers to Jewish people.
01:40:14 I suspect they might have to call experts to prove that beyond a reasonable doubt that that is in fact the case.
01:40:20 In the video in question, Mr. Patron never actually mentions Jewish people.
01:40:27 Now, he does make a number of accusations against these individuals. 0.96
01:40:30 Everywhere these people go, they infiltrate the media, they hijack the central bank, and they infect the body politic like a parasite.
01:40:45 He could be talking about anyone, honestly.
01:40:48 He could be talking about any group.
01:40:50 Is he talking about Somalians?
01:40:53 Maybe Brazilians?
01:40:56 Somalians are in media a lot, right? 1.00
01:40:58 yeah i think i heard that from our wars 1.00
01:41:03 and they seek to control and demoralize us in every aspect i feel like he's just talking about
01:41:13 like liberal politicians though you know of what we try to do it's their world and if they had their
01:41:23 way our entire way of life would be eradicated they don't like us in fact they despise us
01:41:32 now a number of these i think he's actually talking about
01:41:35 journalists maybe maybe that's the parasitic tribe just a thought they should seem fairly
01:41:43 vague to me i i think that the argument would be that they that they promote hatred because he's
01:41:50 accusing these people of doing things that most people would not be happy with and that they don't
01:41:56 like. And he's saying that they're trying to destroy our way of life, for example. So the
01:42:01 inference is that you're going to hate someone who's trying to destroy your way of life.
01:42:06 The Canadian Anti-Hate Network and their complaint filed with the RCMP suggested that the things said
01:42:12 by Mr. Patron in his video have been definitively defined as equaling hate by the Supreme Court of
01:42:20 Canada in the case of Her Majesty the Queen and Keegstra. I'm not certain that they're right in
01:42:25 their interpretation of Keegstra. That case specifically dealt with the constitutionality
01:42:31 of sections 318 and 319 of the Criminal Code and didn't deal directly with whether the things that
01:42:37 Mr. Keegstra said constituted proof of advocating genocide or promoting hatred. Now I think it is
01:42:45 worth noting that Mr. Keegstra was accused of specifically accusing the Jewish people,
01:42:52 and he apparently was a school teacher who actually taught his students that Jewish people 0.99
01:42:56 were, quote, sadistic, child killers, and inherently evil. I suspect that Mr. Patron or Patron's 0.98
01:43:04 defense lawyer, or perhaps himself if he decides to represent himself, would argue that Mr. Keegstra
01:43:10 was much more direct in his incitement and much harsher in the things he was saying. For example,
01:43:17 saying that people kill children is going to enrage people more, I suspect, than saying that
01:43:24 they want to destroy Canadian way of life. Do Mr. Patron's accusations rise to the level of
01:43:30 promoting an emotional state of extreme and intense nature? I think that's something for
01:43:35 a court to decide. It seems to me that this video may be a bit in the gray area. I think there's
01:43:41 certainly arguments to be made for both sides. Now, Mr. Patron was also charged with advocating
01:43:45 genocide under section 319 of the criminal code. This charge, I think it's much clearer that the
01:43:52 Crown will have an extremely difficult time improving. Based on the Canadian Anti-Hate Network
01:43:56 complaint, I take it that where they say he's advocating genocide is when he says near the end
01:44:01 of the video and what we need to do perhaps more than anything is this this is a this guy's intense
01:44:10 i'm i'm curious if nat nationalist.ca is still operating to remove these people once and for all
01:44:17 from our country based on the definition that we covered of advocacy of genocide i don't think
01:44:26 that meets it he's calling for people to be removed from canada now i would suggest that
01:44:31 removal is clearly not killing them that's deporting them and i think it's far from clear
01:44:35 the deportation of people on its face would meet the definition of imposing conditions
01:44:41 that are calculated to bring about the destruction of people
01:44:44 very very interesting very very interesting i do remember hearing about this case a while ago i i
01:44:53 thought he actually did say uh unidentifiable group i thought he actually did refer to
01:45:00 uh i assumed that he may have referred to jewish people in that video but it's it is interesting
01:45:07 that he didn't didn't even say jewish people but the the fact that it was it was like no that you
01:45:16 you mentioned that that it's in the media therefore therefore we know who you're talking about
01:45:22 and that's enough to just 0.98
01:45:25 damn 0.52
01:45:25 turning then to the 0.99
01:45:29 Ale House in London, Ontario
01:45:30 I have an article here from the London Free Press
01:45:33 titled, Did Downtown Pubs
01:45:34 Controversial Sign Cross Criminal Line
01:45:37 so as we can see the sign in the
01:45:39 picture here, it's as I said 1.00
01:45:40 we love Chinese people but we hate 1.00
01:45:42 basically the same, we hate the 1.00
01:45:44 we just, we gotta do
01:45:49 this right now guys, we gotta do this
01:45:50 we got to do this
01:45:55 we got to do this right now guys
01:46:03 we got to do this right now
01:46:20 let's go classic does i commit a hate crime by tweeting that i don't know anyway let's keep going
01:46:27 with the video the ccp the chinese communist party and the case goes on to describe how 0.68
01:46:37 police erred in not charging a downtown london bar owner for signage some called divisive and
01:46:42 even racist one legal activist says i i do want to point out uh this was before it was like common
01:46:49 to uh call out china uh you know foreign interference that's a very common thing back
01:46:54 in 2021 um you would get in trouble for inferring that the virus came from china i'm pretty sure
01:47:03 like i wouldn't even be able to say that on youtube right now uh or like back then rather
01:47:07 but after 2021 i think it might have been maybe it was the end of 2021 when they actually said
01:47:15 oh yeah you know what actually maybe it did come from a lab leak in china and then you were allowed
01:47:20 to talk about it on youtube it was a very interesting how you couldn't associate china
01:47:25 with the virus or with a wuhan lab at first that was very very bad you'd be a horrible person for
01:47:30 doing that and then a year later you could talk you that was a plausible thing because finally 0.82
01:47:36 cnn or the new york times posted an article to say actually maybe that is true but those people 0.98
01:47:43 we shit on before for being bad for talking about that they're still horrible absolutely horrible 0.95
01:47:48 irredeemable and uh you know that sam trusco a western university law professor said he believes 0.99
01:47:55 the signs outside dundas streets alehouse which called covet 19 the china virus sparked intense
01:48:01 public criticism and may violate canada's hate speech laws with all due respect to professor
01:48:06 trusco i think he's clearly wrong that that sign runs afoul of canada's hate propaganda laws firstly
01:48:13 I think that it fails on being directed towards an identifiable group. As we've outlined,
01:48:18 identifiable groups relate to religious groups, ethnicities, nationalities, and nowhere in that
01:48:25 definition do you find political parties. So I don't think that the Chinese Communist Party
01:48:30 would qualify as an identifiable group under the provisions of Sections 318 or Section 319 of the
01:48:37 Criminal Code. So right there, it would not qualify as hate propaganda because it's not directed
01:48:41 towards an identifiable group as defined by the criminal code of canada secondly i would suggest
01:48:46 that deploring a genocide that the interesting so if you even add just a moniker of like the chinese
01:48:57 communist party i don't hate chinese people i hate the chinese communist party 0.89
01:49:03 i don't i don't hate east indians i i just don't like east indians that are uh
01:49:08 uh in my way downtown toronto is that you know what i mean that's an interesting qualifier 0.99
01:49:15 but i feel like in the country of canada they're not going to do you any favors if you're a white
01:49:21 person uh talking about a minority you know i don't think uh i don't think that's how the laws
01:49:29 are set up uh pretty cynical on that one the canadian parliament itself condemned by a vote
01:49:34 By the way, you're allowed to call for whiteness and wanting to end white people. 1.00
01:49:39 That's probably fine. 1.00
01:49:42 You can paint with a broad brushstroke if you're talking about white people. 1.00
01:49:46 It's fine. 0.99
01:49:47 66 to 0 on the 22nd of February 2021.
01:49:52 Condemning a genocide is clearly not engendering hatred.
01:49:56 As for calling COVID-19 the China virus, well, the media is frequently referring to various
01:50:03 strains of COVID-19 based on where they first been identified. So you have the UK strain of
01:50:08 COVID-19, you have the Brazil strain, the South Africa strain, etc. COVID-19 was originally
01:50:14 identified in Wuhan, China. Certainly the argument can be made that using the same naming techniques
01:50:20 that the media uses for various strains, calling the original COVID-19 the China virus is in keeping
01:50:26 with those naming practices. Certainly, no one would accuse the media of promoting hatred.
01:50:31 Therefore, I think it'd be very difficult to make out a charge against the owner of the alehouse.
01:50:36 And that's why he was never charged, because the police looked into this, and they determined that
01:50:41 the grounds did not exist to lay charges under the criminal code. This video is not legal advice.
01:50:47 You should always contact a lawyer for specific advice tailored to your situation. You can call
01:50:52 me at my one eight five five number listed below or another lawyer this week's episode of don't
01:50:58 talk tv we've looked at the hate propaganda provisions of the criminal court of canada
01:51:02 and then we've looked at two specific instances in the news where this has come up and just
01:51:06 i just want to go back to this article london free press so this was uh downtown london i
01:51:14 haven't been to the ill house i went to school there in london but i wanted to just say like
01:51:18 this article and this sort of guy that he quotes in it right here uh western university law
01:51:25 professor you know this might be hate speech laws like this like this article functions
01:51:30 as a chilling effect because i'm i'm this probably came across my eyeballs back during the pandemic
01:51:38 and it was like whoa like this bar owner is getting in trouble for saying this and that
01:51:42 sends a message to the public right that sends a message of like oh he's gonna get you can't do
01:51:47 that oh a lawyer said it's going to be
01:51:49 hate crime law and
01:51:51 like the media plays
01:51:53 a huge function in silencing people
01:51:55 not by even charging but threatening to 0.94
01:51:57 charge having some useless 1.00
01:51:59 academic idiot to be like no 1.00
01:52:01 no that's against the rules 1.00
01:52:03 don't do that
01:52:07 don't do that
01:52:08 and more and more people in Canada
01:52:11 unfortunately give in to that
01:52:13 don't do that oh I don't want
01:52:15 to ruffle any feathers oh my god
01:52:17 and it's because they have no confidence
01:52:19 in pushing back against the insanity
01:52:22 the only sort of confidence
01:52:24 the only sort of small little lane they get
01:52:26 is well I don't like Trudeau
01:52:28 and I'm going to vote for a conservative party
01:52:30 but like is that even
01:52:31 pushing back against the real
01:52:34 problem we need to be pushing with two
01:52:36 hands against this
01:52:38 widespread managerial class
01:52:40 of people
01:52:42 who are imposing their politics upon
01:52:44 Canadians some people call it
01:52:46 woke personally i think woke is sort of a it's not a tangible it's not a good term it's not
01:52:52 specific enough and um it's a pretty clear pattern that our country is hostile towards
01:53:01 canadians like the canadians who have lived here been here for a while um majority white a lot of
01:53:09 them more christian and they actually care about this country and its history uh representing and
01:53:15 reflecting that and there is an open hostility um to those people in this country and that's kind
01:53:22 of a lot of what this managerial class is is opposing by fining people who don't worship
01:53:28 sodomy and worship the rainbow flag um but people don't have any confidence in fighting against this
01:53:33 because not enough people are actually talking about that rebel news is not really talking about
01:53:37 that true north is not really talking about that they're just saying nope just trudeau that's the
01:53:42 only problem. And the reason people don't have more confidence is because there is not enough
01:53:46 voices. There's not enough professional storytelling to kind of embolden people to
01:53:53 show them what's actually happening. What I'm going to be doing is creating a documentary that
01:53:58 is professional and tells the story and identifies the enemy and the villain of this story, which is
01:54:06 this biased political media class of smear merchants of people who are basically left-wing
01:54:14 radicals imposing their politics upon people and just destroying everyone who's in their way
01:54:20 everyone who dares to speak up and people need to hear the story but if you want to support
01:54:25 please go to give send go.com slash save free speech we have a lot planned we almost have
01:54:31 all of the interviews in
01:54:33 Ontario done. There's still a few people
01:54:35 that we need to get
01:54:37 in the bag and interview for the documentary
01:54:39 in Ontario.
01:54:43 I want to name drop right now, but I won't.
01:54:45 But it's good. We got a lot of people
01:54:47 in the bag
01:54:49 already in terms of who we interviewed.
01:54:51 And there will be some clips coming out
01:54:53 before Christmas, that's for sure.
01:54:55 But if you want to support what
01:54:57 I'm doing, help
01:54:58 bring the story
01:55:00 to more Canadians. Help bring the
01:55:02 confidence to more Canadians to
01:55:04 actually identify
01:55:05 the problem. Identify the villain
01:55:08 and then we can all start pushing it back
01:55:10 against that villain. Because we all
01:55:12 really know that getting Trudeau out
01:55:14 is not going to solve this problem
01:55:16 not by a long shot. We need to
01:55:18 embolden ourselves and not be afraid
01:55:20 of these smear merchants. But it's at
01:55:22 givesango.com slash savefree
01:55:24 speech. Ladies
01:55:26 and gentlemen
01:55:27 Thank you so much for tuning in
01:55:31 Thanks for tuning in tonight
01:55:34 How are we doing in the chat?
01:55:40 Verani only has power online
01:55:42 Nah, I think he's got more than power online
01:55:44 He's connected with the Yaga Khan and everything
01:55:47 He's connected with 0.98
01:55:49 He's got more than that, I'm sure
01:55:52 James Lindsay quoting you?
01:55:55 that's kind of interesting
01:55:57 Mayor of Emo
01:56:03 yeah
01:56:03 well thanks for hanging out guys
01:56:05 really appreciate it
01:56:08 Caesar says
01:56:11 you didn't say the magic word
01:56:13 oh can you please donate
01:56:14 to the fundraiser
01:56:17 that would be great
01:56:19 no it's good
01:56:22 it's my first
01:56:24 documentary. I've done a lot of
01:56:26 videos, a lot of interviews, but this documentary
01:56:28 is, I'm learning a lot.
01:56:30 Learning a lot. I kind of have
01:56:32 this, I don't want to say
01:56:34 mentor necessarily, but this guy
01:56:36 is helping us, this award
01:56:38 winning documentarian is helping
01:56:40 us through this
01:56:41 larger storytelling process
01:56:44 and I'm really excited to see
01:56:46 I'm excited to show it to people
01:56:48 and bring it all together.
01:56:51 Richard Mitchell says
01:56:52 thank you for having nicholas wandsbutter on hey my pleasure he's a great guy he's very he's very
01:57:00 well educated and he gets it he gets it you know he's not afraid to be like huh it seems like
01:57:05 they're targeting white people hiking in the woods um who have the wrong politics instead of
01:57:10 pedophiles kind of weird kind of weird kind of strange that the rcmp would prior have those
01:57:16 prioritize prioritize priorities but uh anyway i'm gonna get some dinner thank you so so much
01:57:24 for watching i really appreciate it um what's next am i gonna be streaming later this week
01:57:31 i don't know what's planned this week i just know i got a lot of a lot more work to do oh if you
01:57:37 haven't seen it if you haven't seen it oh man you guys haven't seen the new video i dropped it
01:57:44 actually not long before
01:57:45 this stream.
01:57:49 But
01:57:49 it's very important that you go watch this
01:57:52 video.
01:57:55 Because, or
01:57:56 actually, I don't want to
01:57:58 I want you guys to go watch it
01:58:00 so you can help the algorithm. Okay?
01:58:02 So go help the algorithm if you haven't
01:58:04 seen it already. It is
01:58:06 the latest video on my channel. It's called
01:58:08 The Liberal Party
01:58:09 Does Not Care About Kids.
01:58:12 The Liberal Party does not, whoops,
01:58:14 The Liberal Party does not care about kids
01:58:16 I'll put it in the chat
01:58:18 Go give that a watch
01:58:20 It's very obvious stuff
01:58:22 But
01:58:23 People need to hear it
01:58:25 This is why Bill C63 is not really coming from people
01:58:28 Who have ever cared about children
01:58:29 So go give that a watch
01:58:31 Thank you so much for watching
01:58:33 Love you guys
01:58:34 You guys have been great
01:58:37 And until next time
01:58:39 We'll see you later
01:58:44 Talk to you soon.
01:58:49 Yeah.
01:58:50 Yeah.
01:59:14 Thank you.
01:59:44 We'll be right back.