Greg Wycliffe - August 23, 2024


LIVE🔴 Tribes will Weaponize C-63🔴Reacting to Runkle 🔴 #STOPBillC63 🔴 SAVE FREE SPEECH .ca

Hosted by
Mentioned
LIVE🔴CIJA discusses C-63🔴Online Harms Act is in the Budget 🔴 #STOPBillC63 🔴 SAVE FREE SPEECH .ca 🔴Will C-63 keep kids Safe? 🔴NATO agenda to censor Internet 🔴 #STOPBillC63 🔴 SAVE FREE SPEECH .ca

Episode Stats


Length

2 hours and 51 minutes

Words per minute

143.76

Word count

24,620

Sentence count

660

Harmful content

Misogyny

10

sentences flagged

Toxicity

72

sentences flagged

Hate speech

67

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of Chucky's extremist circus, we discuss Bill C-63 and its impact on free speech in Canada. We also talk about the Canadian political prisoners and how they should be treated as political prisoners.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Oh
00:00:30 We'll be right back.
00:01:00 Thank you.
00:01:30 Thank you.
00:02:00 you
00:02:30 Thank you.
00:03:00 Thank you.
00:03:30 Thank you.
00:04:00 Thank you.
00:04:30 Thank you.
00:05:00 Thank you.
00:05:30 Thank you.
00:06:00 Thank you.
00:06:30 Thank you.
00:07:00 Thank you.
00:07:30 Thank you.
00:08:00 Thank you.
00:08:30 Thank you.
00:09:00 Thank you.
00:09:30 Thank you.
00:10:00 Thank you.
00:10:30 hello everybody hello good evening good morning good morning good evening good evening good
00:10:54 evening. Good morning. Got my Patriot propaganda mug. And yes, some fluorinated, fluoridated,
00:11:06 fluoridated tap water. Hope everyone's doing well. I know you guys were complaining about
00:11:18 the volume last time on this uh background music trying to figure that out how are we all doing in
00:11:25 chat colby melvin kelly lloyd kev before seven vincent remple you're related to michelle
00:11:35 vincent uh canon two flip s3.5 twists two flips three and a half twists that's that's how you
00:11:46 say it, right? Two flips, three and a half twists. James Bullock, Jennifer Francis, how's it going?
00:11:53 Welcome to the stream. Prairie, good evening, everyone. Good evening. Chucky's Extremist
00:12:01 Circus, welcome to the stream. Find your friends with Island Jason. Good evening. Good evening,
00:12:07 sir, Slavador Deli. Art story, Legend of Nelda, Tears of the Incel. That is a name.
00:12:17 That is a username right there. That is a screen name right there. Yes, welcome to the
00:12:23 stream. Tonight, we're going to be reacting to Ian Runkle, also known as Runkle of the
00:12:31 bailey on youtube cool guy he's talking here to um what's his face from toronto sun we'll be
00:12:40 reacting to this video they talk all about bill c63 and uh yeah mr runkle is a mayor mayor he's
00:12:49 a lawyer so we'll be hearing his kind of take his criticisms of bill c63 really looking forward to
00:12:57 it i think we're gonna get some good stuff out of that that's gonna be the main event tonight
00:13:01 um yeah you know there's oh man there were so many things that came across my twitter feed
00:13:09 this morning though that i'm like oh my gosh there's just so much to talk about there's so
00:13:14 much to talk about there's so much to get into um but i thought you know great you got to focus
00:13:19 you got to focus on saving free speech you know that sure sure are there are there hordes of east
00:13:25 indians coming into canada yes there are is there a is there a crazy battle going on right now 0.61
00:13:31 between candace owens and uh uh daily wire people yeah yeah it's quite interesting um
00:13:38 but i gotta keep my eye on the ball here gotta keep my eye on the ball and get ahead of the game
00:13:44 in terms of stopping uh bill c63 focus all my effort on that um
00:13:49 but uh it's just crazy isn't it it's so disorienting when you when you open up twitter
00:13:56 these days all the different things happening and who's doing anything about it you know
00:14:01 it's unbelievable it's unbelievable um and yeah i also said uh you know calling all
00:14:11 calling all patriots or calling all political prisoners that's another thing that i might
00:14:15 to kind of brainstorm just kind of live on air with you guys,
00:14:18 which is the idea that, you know,
00:14:25 even a conservative party supporter,
00:14:29 even a Pierre Polyev supporter,
00:14:33 he might, you know, they obviously don't like Trudeau,
00:14:38 but they might be a low information person as well.
00:14:41 You know, there's probably some conservative party supporters
00:14:43 who was like oh yes the you know the trucker convoy was was too far right like there probably
00:14:51 is a collection of conservative party supporters who who kind of are in that camp they still watch
00:14:57 some mainstream news potentially and even to talk to these people about bill c63 to say hey it's the
00:15:04 end of free speech um they might be like what do you what do you know what do you what do you mean
00:15:09 what are you talking about um and i guess the idea is
00:15:15 we have all these different political prisoners in different forms there's the jeremy mckenzie's
00:15:23 of the world there's the archer pavlowski's of the world there's the the lovely nurses from
00:15:28 frontline nurses you know there's these many different organizations that's just a few off
00:15:32 the top of my head uh there's past other pastors hildebrandt um there's a lot tamara lich chris
00:15:43 barber you know and on and on and the thing is naturally not surprisingly they're all they're
00:15:51 all focused on fighting their legal battle you know as a political prisoner you have to
00:15:56 deal with your legal nonsense that the state is putting you through and i guess it's the idea
00:16:02 of simplifying
00:16:04 and honestly quite frankly
00:16:07 you know
00:16:08 maybe even just commodifying
00:16:10 their story
00:16:12 in a sort of like bite
00:16:13 a little bite size thing
00:16:15 that is quick
00:16:18 and gets to the point of
00:16:20 hey I'm a political prisoner
00:16:21 this is happening
00:16:24 this happened to me
00:16:24 because of my political opinion
00:16:26 this happened to me in Canada
00:16:27 and I guess the idea would
00:16:29 to basically create
00:16:31 a highlight reel of all the political prisoners in canada and just kind of quickly and effectively
00:16:38 show uh canadians like hey this is um this is happening this is uh here are such examples
00:16:46 because i think almost by design that's uh that's not at people that's not the forefront
00:16:56 that's not at the forefront of everyone's mind because of the influence of pierre polyev and his
00:17:03 um you know watered down conservatism and watered down reader uh leadership which is very much
00:17:09 uh you know just more more of the establishment status quo because of this really weak leadership
00:17:15 we it's not that we forget but it's it's not um it's not at the forefront of everyone's mind all
00:17:22 that's at the forefront is we need to vote in the other guy right we need to vote in the other guy
00:17:26 nothing to do with these alarming trends alarming trends of tyranny authoritarianism
00:17:35 what's the other one dictate dictatorships there's all these words right all these words and uh
00:17:43 you know i don't know if the words do it any justice especially for people who haven't heard
00:17:50 of this stuff you know if you believe our our rights and freedoms are being taken away then
00:17:57 yeah you'll probably sure authoritarian you'll hear these words and be like yeah i agree with
00:18:00 that but for someone who doesn't think that using those words might just be kind of like falling on
00:18:06 deaf ears and they'll be left kind of thinking this this person's crazy what are they talking
00:18:11 about whereas if there's more of a compilation of hey here's a story of a whole bunch of different
00:18:19 Canadians who are being targeted for their
00:18:20 political beliefs.
00:18:23 I don't know what label you
00:18:24 put on that, but it's bad news.
00:18:28 Like instead of
00:18:29 maybe the label
00:18:31 you would put on it is, hey, political prisoners.
00:18:33 People persecuted for their opinions.
00:18:35 Like that's something that people could
00:18:36 understand, right? They could see it
00:18:38 that people are being persecuted
00:18:40 for speaking freely and just having the wrong
00:18:43 opinion.
00:18:44 I'm thinking like that might be more powerful, you know?
00:18:49 More powerful.
00:18:51 If that makes sense.
00:18:54 Let's see if this works.
00:18:57 Try something here.
00:19:06 Yeah.
00:19:07 Sometimes I'm doing a lot of note writing on the screen
00:19:20 So I thought I'd just
00:19:21 This would just be an idea
00:19:23 Like giving a sort of quick script to a political prisoner
00:19:26 Hello my name is
00:19:27 Jeremy McKenzie for example
00:19:29 Once I started
00:19:30 Criticizing the RCMP in Canada
00:19:33 I was persecuted by
00:19:34 I was smeared by anti-hate
00:19:36 I was, um, he would have a long list in this year. Like what happened to him in terms of being
00:19:44 persecuted and, and now my life is different would be the second gap. But like, you know,
00:19:50 having some sort of formula to give to each political prisoner, they'd fill it out and
00:19:55 maybe like make a video about it. And then also them saying at the end, I believe I was targeted
00:19:58 for my personal and political beliefs. Boom. And then make some sort of a compilation of that,
00:20:04 you know
00:20:06 that sound crazy
00:20:10 does that make sense
00:20:10 I also changed
00:20:14 the lighting in here
00:20:14 I think it's kind of cool
00:20:17 but
00:20:19 got a little guy
00:20:22 back there
00:20:22 yeah
00:20:25 yeah and I guess
00:20:31 another thing to bring up too
00:20:33 is
00:20:34 because we had we had a really good stream last time because we went over this really
00:20:43 dense video of sieja talking about bill c63 we had um michael geist talking about it and
00:20:53 it was a zoom call for you know a jewish advocacy group and um very interesting stuff
00:21:01 a lot of great questions were asked about it honestly
00:21:04 sidebar
00:21:07 oh my goodness
00:21:10 terrifying photo
00:21:12 terrifying photo
00:21:14 terrifying photo right here
00:21:16 but yeah someone's pointed this out already
00:21:20 a diagonal guy
00:21:21 I can't point this out already
00:21:23 it's interesting how
00:21:24 you know
00:21:26 sexualizing children
00:21:28 not something that the Toronto Star wanted to call out
00:21:31 fred hahn for supporting gender ideology not at all something that toronto star cared to call out
00:21:37 fred hahn for but now that he is saying anti-semitic things or supporting palestine
00:21:44 um or criticizing israel all of a sudden all the mainstream news in canada now hates this guy
00:21:51 uh say sexualize kids all you want push that all over uh schools across ontario but no no no no no
00:21:58 No, no, no, no.
00:21:59 You have a political opinion when it comes to a foreign conflict that we don't like?
00:22:02 Yeah, I don't think so.
00:22:04 You need to resign now.
00:22:06 No, corrupting our youth?
00:22:08 We don't care about that.
00:22:09 You can corrupt the youth as much as you'd like.
00:22:12 Have at it.
00:22:14 No, but you having an opinion on a foreign conflict?
00:22:16 Not all right.
00:22:17 No, not okay.
00:22:18 Not on our watch.
00:22:21 Looks like he's about to eat the microphone.
00:22:23 Yeah, yeah.
00:22:25 There's a lot of things I could say. 0.99
00:22:27 he is a open homosexual uh for example that microphone probably smells terrible 1.00
00:22:33 um i probably shouldn't go into detail detail though because that's kind of gross 0.99
00:22:38 um why his breath would smell so much
00:22:42 derek nelson says as an american most canadians are persecuted though so so are we in many
00:22:53 scenarios yeah um it's becoming more common and the persecution it's quite consistent but it
00:23:03 doesn't just happen by the government you know I could bring up the example of Jordan Peterson
00:23:07 where his regulatory body as a psychologist in Ontario is coming after him for his political
00:23:15 beliefs right and that's totally relevant to the conversation because there's clearly a bias
00:23:21 towards you know generically straight white men who are patriotic and uh yeah just kind of have
00:23:31 kind of like somewhat traditional somewhat conservative beliefs about about the country
00:23:36 and about men and women and uh yeah this is this is really nothing new this isn't anything
00:23:43 groundbreaking I'm sure a lot of you know this already but um yeah it's all kind of part of the
00:23:49 puzzle right it's all part of the uh the puzzle pieces here where are the tweets i was gonna
00:23:56 bring up oh yeah they're over here so yeah uh we were reacting to michael geist on stream the other
00:24:13 night and this was his tweet from uh earlier this evening this afternoon the second day of bomb
00:24:18 threats targeting synagogues in canada to see those that spent months saying nothing fueling
00:24:24 anti-semitism with their hurtful rhetoric or gaslighting the jewish community's fears now 0.68
00:24:29 feigning concern is shameful hypocrisy and yeah i didn't hear about this or bomb threats to
00:24:36 synagogues obviously that's not very fun that's not very good um and michael geist as a lawyer
00:24:44 as a jewish lawyer is obviously concerned about this type of thing i just and you know 1.00
00:24:49 if you saw the stream last time it was very clear that michael geist as a jewish man is very
00:24:57 concerned about the rise of anti-semitism specifically uh like sure it was a jewish
00:25:03 it was a jewish group advocacy advocacy advocacy group that he was talking to on the call
00:25:09 however um you know he clearly i would argue has a bias for that group for that tribe
00:25:19 jewish people so he's more sensitive to anti-semitism and so if you're a palestinian
00:25:26 or if you're someone if you're an arab who is sympathetic to palestinians
00:25:29 doesn't mean you're a hama supporter or even if you were for sake of argument um
00:25:35 you know obviously michael geist and friends and the jewish advocacy group is going to be like we
00:25:43 don't like these people who have this opinion how can we use bill c63 to uh persecute these people
00:25:51 or or silence them or just get their tweets out of the way that's something that geist was saying
00:25:56 on the uh you know on this kind of conversation hey we just want to take it down can we just take
00:26:02 it down let's just like let's just get rid of the person saying this yeah okay so you now you're
00:26:06 sounding like the tyrant right like now you're sounding like the person who wants to just silent
00:26:10 silence somebody um and it needs to be pointed out when it comes to like you know the the rise
00:26:19 of tribalism that i think is happening in canada right now you know michael geist has never tweeted
00:26:24 once about churches church church oh yeah that's anyway nothing to do with burning churches is my
00:26:31 point and uh you might say greg he's jewish why would he care about churches burning down well
00:26:38 he's concerned about bomb threats to synagogues but he's not concerned about burning churches
00:26:45 like everyone has their own priorities okay and especially when we are in different tribes
00:26:52 we prioritize our tribe
00:26:55 and bill c63 is like an opportunity to weaponize this uh weaponize this bill
00:27:05 against other tribes against other groups and it's just it's just very obvious that it would be
00:27:11 very very messy um they did bring that up as a concern that this this bill would be weaponized
00:27:18 it would be weaponized and uh you know i just brought that up as an example like here here's
00:27:24 somebody who is concerned about bomb threats or you know hateful rhetoric online churches burning
00:27:32 down across the country no men no who cares who cares about that i don't care about that those
00:27:39 canadians oh i'm not gonna waste my breath on christian canadians can they completely ignore
00:27:45 that and you can make the same argument for both right because the argument of permitting arson
00:27:52 is oh no but you know the catholic churches did something bad in the past you can say the same
00:27:59 thing about israel but you know hey criticizing israel criticizing jewish people that's okay 0.80
00:28:06 because they're doing bad things over there to palestinians they're bombing you know children 0.75
00:28:11 are dying you know fill in the blank you can make the exact same argument and uh you know the point
00:28:18 is is if you are a tyrant if you are a globalist who wants to you know destroy canada blah blah
00:28:24 blah um in you know there's a lot of institutions you need to slowly infiltrate and start to decay
00:28:31 blah blah blah and you have to make sure that people hate each other uh and this introduction
00:28:37 of bill c63 is like great because not only can you make people hate each other you can make people
00:28:44 start litigating each other tattletaling each other and not even just because they don't like
00:28:49 each other as much as uh well we have a political agenda we want to silence those people whose
00:28:56 opinion we don't like and yeah it's been mentioned many times but it bears repeating as this is a big
00:29:10 sort of part of of the argument against bill c63 which is how open-ended it is how subjective it is
00:29:18 and how it would be simple to take the loopholes in this bill
00:29:24 to justify, justify hatred, to justify harm
00:29:29 and say, now we're going to silence this person,
00:29:31 now we're going to censor this person
00:29:32 because someone's emotions or someone's argument
00:29:35 was enough to take away that person's freedom of speech.
00:29:45 Isn't that great?
00:29:46 Isn't that awesome?
00:29:48 Isn't that fantastic?
00:30:03 Gregorovic says Bill 63 won't pass.
00:30:06 Chill out.
00:30:08 How do you know that?
00:30:09 How do you know that Bill C-63 won't pass?
00:30:14 Bill C-18 passed.
00:30:15 and now we can't get news
00:30:17 on Instagram or Facebook anymore
00:30:19 that's pretty absurd
00:30:22 and insane
00:30:24 you can't get news
00:30:26 on certain social media platforms anymore
00:30:28 if I would have told you that
00:30:30 before Bill C-18 passed
00:30:32 Greg Horovic you would have said the same thing
00:30:34 Bill C-18 is not going to pass
00:30:36 chill out
00:30:36 well it did pass
00:30:38 and that's why I've started
00:30:41 that's why I've started sayfreespeech.ca
00:30:44 because I'm not just going to sit around and watch that happen again
00:30:47 because I really understand where you're coming from, Gregorovic.
00:30:53 Hey, it's not going to pass. Just chill.
00:30:56 That's too absurd and insane.
00:30:59 Oh, wait a minute.
00:31:00 We've already given control of our algorithms to the Canadian government.
00:31:04 We've already let them pass Bill C-18,
00:31:07 which is an objective failure of legislation,
00:31:10 a failure because big tech basically said,
00:31:12 hey, we're going to call your bull up, Canadian government, and now your citizens are not going
00:31:17 to get news on Facebook and Instagram. These bureaucrats in Canada clearly don't know what
00:31:23 they're doing. They have control of the media, so they're able to shape the public narrative, 0.89
00:31:28 the public perception of this bill to make it very easy to just pass the legislation through.
00:31:33 And I believe they're doing the same thing with Bill C-63 because it's to protect kids online,
00:31:38 Greg Orvik you don't what you don't want to protect kids online it's a very clever very very
00:31:44 clever Trojan horse that they're using and Greg Orvik on our last stream we brought up the news
00:31:52 that they are already talking about putting it into the budget they're already budgeting 300
00:31:56 employees for the digital safety board and 200 million dollars just chill out bro it's not going
00:32:04 to pass they're just already putting it into the budget and everything that not everything but a
00:32:11 lot of what politicians are saying and what the news media is saying and what even the police are
00:32:17 saying the police talk about hate hate crime units Gregorovic have you seen what's happening in the
00:32:24 uk they're arresting people for facebook posts ta-da how far off is this really it's not far
00:32:34 off at all it's already happening in western countries they're already budgeting for it
00:32:38 in canada talking about the employees and talking about the money they have a great trojan horse
00:32:44 of protecting kids online and we already have this accountability lag where the conservative
00:32:51 party always comes up short to stop these insane and absurd pieces of legislation just like bill
00:32:58 c18 and just like bill c11 so i think it's very believable that bill c63 would pass
00:33:04 hey bro just chill out
00:33:08 and that just that just that just it triggers me on a whole nother level because
00:33:16 i'm actually writing a substack article right now about the problem the kind of deep deep problem
00:33:23 of canadian identity of sort of this canadian attitude just chill bro hey we're canadian we're
00:33:30 chill we're chill are you upset with where we are where the country's at it's because we've been
00:33:37 too chill that's why we're here because we're too chill so you're going to show up and say hey man
00:33:44 it's not gonna pass just chill yeah i've i've i am um um i've seen this movie before i've seen 0.91
00:33:50 where i've seen what happens we chill out and then we get further fucked over because we were
00:33:56 too chill we were too passive we were too nice so i appreciate your comment but uh respectfully 0.68
00:34:05 no and by the way um what's the harm in being diligent about this you're telling me to chill
00:34:13 out what's the harm in making safe free speech.ca making content exposing what this bill is truly
00:34:19 about because it's really the principle right sure maybe it doesn't pass but the principle
00:34:24 that they're actually going to even suggest this legislation is outrageous it's insane it shows us
00:34:32 the character and the intention of the people in the parliament buildings which is not to have any
00:34:37 freedom not to to completely shut down political dissent entirely or at least give themselves this
00:34:45 tyrannical toolkit to do so the fact that they're even suggesting this is crazy and needs to be
00:34:51 called out people are tired of the political correctness in canada there's even normie
00:34:57 white canadians who are starting to openly complain about mass immigration this is like
00:35:04 like this is a first 0.75
00:35:06 this is a first that regular
00:35:08 Canadians are even starting to complain about this 0.99
00:35:10 and obviously they want to shut us up
00:35:12 they want to be able to
00:35:14 control speech and say oh 1.00
00:35:15 we need to get back to when those Canadians 0.95
00:35:18 were terrified to say anything if they pass
00:35:20 this legislation that is perfect
00:35:21 and they clearly have the intention 0.80
00:35:24 to silence Canadians in that
00:35:26 in that vein and in my opinion 0.62
00:35:28 that is
00:35:29 that is way enough
00:35:32 of a reason
00:35:32 to continue to just ring the alarm bells
00:35:36 about Bill C-63 over and over
00:35:38 and over and over and over again 0.99
00:35:39 until everybody realizes what the fuck 1.00
00:35:41 is up. Pardon my language. 0.99
00:35:44 I'm trying to swear less.
00:35:46 But, um...
00:35:48 But, yeah.
00:35:53 Foglay says
00:35:53 the great Canadian myth. What's that?
00:35:57 Oh, and if you didn't know,
00:35:58 I haven't plugged this yet.
00:35:59 We are starting a, or we are making, rather,
00:36:01 a documentary
00:36:02 on Bill C-63, the people
00:36:05 behind Bill C-63, what it's truly about.
00:36:08 If you want to support that, you can go to
00:36:09 givesengo.com slash savefree
00:36:11 speech.
00:36:13 We're doing great. We already have 4,000 in donations
00:36:15 and
00:36:17 yeah, it's going to really tell
00:36:19 the story of
00:36:21 what this bill is about. Anonymous Giver
00:36:23 gave $10. Keep fighting the good
00:36:25 fight. Droogaloo
00:36:27 Dag. I also submitted that $50.
00:36:29 Alright.
00:36:29 keep fighting the good fight
00:36:32 absolutely
00:36:33 absolutely will do thank you so much for your
00:36:36 donation sir greatly appreciate it
00:36:38 and yeah this money all goes
00:36:40 towards editors
00:36:42 media professionals to make
00:36:45 content to make effective
00:36:47 messaging and
00:36:48 videos and this documentary to
00:36:50 ring the alarm bells to
00:36:52 explain to Canadians what's truly going on
00:36:55 and to fight back against political
00:36:57 correctness in Canada right right
00:36:58 where it matters, which is the legislation
00:37:01 that they're trying to pass right now with Bill C-63.
00:37:03 Because that would really take political correctness 0.84
00:37:04 and enforce it with an iron fist.
00:37:07 Is that what you want
00:37:08 for your country? Didn't think so.
00:37:11 Didn't think so. Who would want that?
00:37:13 Only the far left crazies, of course.
00:37:16 Only the 0.97
00:37:17 far left crazies, of course. I think I actually might
00:37:19 have a good video to react
00:37:21 to. Here we go. Yeah, let's react
00:37:23 to this. Before we get into the
00:37:25 more drier
00:37:27 conversation let's do something a little more fun
00:37:29 this is six buzz
00:37:38 gotta love the six buzz right you guys may have seen this 1.00
00:37:42 woman goes on rant about
00:37:47 tim horton's customer service and claims she was laughed at after explaining that things were
00:37:51 quote done right back in the day let's watch
00:37:55 shall we seriously what is going on anymore in canada like this is absolutely ridiculous i worked
00:38:01 there when i was 15 16 years old you know what it was everything was clean the bathrooms were clean 0.73
00:38:06 stocked every time i go in there it's disgusting my own daughter who's three walked in today and
00:38:11 said ew mommy what's that smell like that's embarrassing like what is going on with you
00:38:16 as a corporation that nothing can go right anymore when it's literally your all you do is give
00:38:22 customer service and food. Like these employees know nothing. When I worked there, when I was 15
00:38:27 and 16 years old, our primary thing was if we weren't busy, you were cleaning, you're mopping,
00:38:32 you're sweeping, you're making sure that everything was stocked. You're making sure
00:38:36 that everything was good to go and that the customer service came first. Now I got laughed
00:38:41 at today when I asked for my two ice caps that I bought and I spent $15 there on three drinks in a
00:38:47 him bit today and i got laughed at when i said he they brought it out and it was up to that line
00:38:54 right there to morton's like amazing so i also worked at tim hortons around that same age there's
00:39:00 probably a good a good percentage of canadians who who worked at tim hortons as their first job
00:39:06 i would fall into that um into that statistic and uh i i kind of love this as almost as a meme of
00:39:13 like i am really tired of these tim hortons employees you know what i mean all these tim
00:39:19 hortons employees they smell bad they sound funny but um yeah this is almost like we're seeing the
00:39:29 birth of a uh of a canadian style of racism here you know where it's like this woman is complaining
00:39:37 about the service at tim horton she doesn't ever say indian people but it's basically cryptically
00:39:44 you know that's kind of that's kind of what the message is in a way um what else is he going to
00:39:51 say oh yeah you know people actually the comments are pretty one of the comments they they won't
00:39:58 even cut a bagel in half anymore it's just a minimum minimum wage job low your expectations 0.91
00:40:03 shut up um we need karens guys we need karens karens are good you know karen is an anti-white 0.54
00:40:12 slur because what is a karen other than a white woman with high expectations a sort of expectation 0.98
00:40:19 of excellence sure it's easy to make fun of them maybe like they're they're very needy oh my god 0.57
00:40:26 my drink's not right but at the same time hey excellence we want excellence in our society we
00:40:33 want something higher we want to we want to aspire for clean things quality things nice things
00:40:41 and the karens are warriors for that shout outs to the karens okay boycott tim hortons and walmart
00:40:51 yeah i can't lie my ice cap was straight liquid last week and my exact thought was after spending 0.62
00:40:55 six dollars on a drink i used to work at tim hortons was damn this place fell off welcome
00:41:01 to new india why do they why do they exclusively why did they exclusively hire indians though
00:41:07 meanwhile starbucks is pretty diverse something is off it's the type of demographic they chose
00:41:13 to hire interesting these have like 4 000 likes 1700 likes why is there a heart next to this one
00:41:24 oh it's because i liked it um boring anyway let's let's listen to the rest of this and i
00:41:33 so i send back the ice caps i literally hand the tray back and i said those ice caps are literally
00:41:38 liquid not ice cap and they're also not even filled so why did i just spend over four dollars
00:41:45 on some ice caps for it not to be done right like this is a customer service thing yes it's just a
00:41:51 a drink at the end of the day, but I'm getting in my car. I'm going to drive to this establishment
00:41:55 to get really crappy customer service and then not the proper drinks made. And then I have to drive
00:42:01 back or just throw it out. And like, I just wasted my money, but you as a corporation gets to keep
00:42:06 yours. That's crazy to me. So anyway, so I say to the three people sitting in the, um, in the drive
00:42:12 through doing my order, I send it back. They send it back to me. I said, this is unacceptable. He
00:42:16 literally gives it back and says, this is to policy. I said, what's your policy? He said,
00:42:21 we can't do any more than that. Like that's it. I said, this ice cup is liquid. It's not even a
00:42:25 fro. It's not how it normally would be like that for everybody knows what an ice cup is. I don't
00:42:28 need to explain to Canadians watching this right now. And I, so I said, so he says to me, Oh,
00:42:35 it's policy. That's all I can do. My manager will get mad. I said, Hmm. I said, we've all worked
00:42:40 at Tim Hortons at some point in our lives. And back in the day, this isn't how it was. And he
00:42:45 goes, Oh, you must've worked for a good manager then because our manager doesn't allow to change
00:42:49 anything with that ice cap. What does that even mean? I said, no, I said customer service and the
00:42:54 way things were done back in the day were done. Right. You know what he did laughed at me. You
00:42:59 know what would have happened back in the day, even though I'm 31 years old, um, we would have
00:43:05 gotten written up a very large talking in the manager's office. And then you would have felt
00:43:10 like an idiot. And then because you made that person's day crappy. Now I'm not one to hold 1.00
00:43:16 energy i'm not going to i'm actually letting it out right now on the camera so then that way tim
00:43:21 hortons can hear this and the rest of canada because i know that people are going to want
00:43:24 to hear this and they all feel the same way so why don't you guys all share in your comments
00:43:28 your your latest situations with tim hortons in canada i'd love to hear it myself
00:43:33 so he says to me oh it's amazing amazing amazing love her energy love her confidence too i love
00:43:41 her confidence how she's like i i know everyone in the country feels the same way okay imagine
00:43:47 pierre pauliev had that confidence that'd be epic i would love to see that um man that was great i
00:43:56 was i was shout outs to her hey i want to interview you let's get you on come on let's chat let's talk
00:44:03 about it um this is gonna happen more and more this is gonna happen more and more and
00:44:10 yeah
00:44:13 huge reason why I
00:44:16 want to focus on stopping Bill C63
00:44:18 because I want to be
00:44:20 like the lead blocker I used to play football
00:44:22 right and in
00:44:24 football you know you run the ball down the
00:44:26 field and you have like blockers
00:44:28 who block the other people from tackling
00:44:30 the person with the ball right
00:44:32 and I think of
00:44:34 save free speech
00:44:36 a lot like being the lead blocker like taking 0.91
00:44:38 away this legislation so Canadians
00:44:40 like this can continue to just speak their mind because it is happening slowly but surely it is
00:44:45 happening but it's very true there will be a terrible chilling effect if this bill were to
00:44:50 pass and it would make it so that the government would definitely uh make an example of someone 0.95
00:44:58 like that just a regular 31 year old mom who's upset with customer service just a regular quality
00:45:05 karen karen in a good way karen in a good way and then they're gonna be get um you know i don't
00:45:12 know written up they're gonna get sent to the principal's office basically that's another way
00:45:16 to look at bill c63 it's like people are gonna be tattling on each other for like i'm offended by
00:45:21 this uh can i take her to human rights court and of course it's absurd of course it's crazy but
00:45:28 it's like again if you're trying to dismantle and ruin a country it's like yeah you're gonna
00:45:31 to try to push through this bill and justify it under uh protecting kids right um
00:45:38 and yeah i guess uh i guess i'll bring up this weird sort of um this weird thing just i mentioned
00:45:49 how it's going to be weaponized by tribes by different groups and this is from the jerusalem
00:45:53 post hold on to your hats uh beau teaches daughter receives let me put me over here
00:45:59 Boteach's daughter receives disturbing
00:46:02 non-kosher pizza delivery in Florida
00:46:03 FBI complaint file
00:46:06 this is over a pizza
00:46:07 a non-kosher pizza delivery
00:46:09 we're getting the FBI involved
00:46:12 this is in America
00:46:13 so there's a 1.00
00:46:17 feud between Candace Owens 0.98
00:46:20 and this Rabbi Shmuley
00:46:22 Boteach
00:46:22 in a new development in the ongoing feud
00:46:26 between Rabbi Shmuley Boteach and
00:46:27 controversial conservative media figure
00:46:29 Candace Owens, Bo Teach's daughter
00:46:31 has filed a complaint with the FBI
00:46:33 after receiving what she believes was a
00:46:35 threatening message delivered in the form
00:46:37 of a pizza to her home in Florida.
00:46:41 So,
00:46:42 a pizza delivery is a threat.
00:46:46 That's where we're at.
00:46:49 This is the son of Shmuley, or the daughter
00:46:51 rather. My father Rabbi Shmuley and I
00:46:53 reported real Candace Owens to the FBI. 0.61
00:46:55 I thought she would have learned her lesson already. 1.00
00:46:57 don't mess with the Jews 1.00
00:46:59 it's so 1.00
00:47:03 like man
00:47:05 that's crazy being able to get away
00:47:07 with saying that is so crazy 1.00
00:47:08 imagine saying don't mess with the whites 1.00
00:47:11 like
00:47:13 the double standard is
00:47:17 so crazy
00:47:18 yeah
00:47:22 they talk about the pizza
00:47:25 being delivered
00:47:26 the non-cocher pizza which she did not order was delivered with a receipt bearing her name
00:47:31 and address but with the phone number that belonged to her father rabbi shmuley bodich
00:47:35 the pizza had not been paid for raising immediate concern
00:47:37 okay hold on that's in
00:47:46 they're not beating the stereotypes jerusalem post you are not helping with the stereotypes
00:47:53 the fact that this is a standalone sentence the pizza had not been paid for raising immediate
00:47:58 concerns oh come on come on no come on come on no the pizza had not been paid for raising
00:48:13 immediate concerns must resist the email forwarded to multiple contacts including
00:48:22 your father stated today i received a pizza pie from domino's which i did not order the receipt
00:48:26 which i've attached below had my name and address on it my and my parents old home phone number the
00:48:32 pie had not been paid for i called domino's and they told me that someone ordered it online this
00:48:37 was obviously a threat from someone online my father and i have been receiving death threats
00:48:42 all week on x the fact that they use my name and home address combined with my father's
00:48:48 home phone number
00:48:49 shows this was a threat
00:48:51 you know
00:48:56 and it needs to kind of just be stated
00:48:57 because
00:48:59 you know
00:49:02 for those who don't know there was this thing called
00:49:03 section 13 for the human rights
00:49:05 tribunal in Canada and essentially
00:49:07 this specific
00:49:09 individual used this legislation
00:49:12 to weaponize
00:49:13 against specific people and to profit
00:49:15 off of it
00:49:16 his name was Richard Warman and he did this to uh you know to his own personal benefit okay
00:49:24 this is also somebody who pretended to be other people online and create all this fake hate and
00:49:30 you know there are examples of fake hate crimes you could use Jussie Smollett as an example
00:49:34 where he pretended to be attacked by Trump Trump mega hat supporters and having a noose tied around
00:49:42 his neck and having bleach poured on him it never happened he made it up uh there's another example
00:49:48 of a fake hate crime where uh there's another example of a fake hate crime where i think there
00:49:54 was like a jewish business who uh again pretended to like attack their own business which is this
00:50:03 is just despicable look this is such an insane lie i'm not saying that that this stuff might not
00:50:08 actually happen however in a situation like this you can't rule it out you can't rule out that uh
00:50:15 you know that these that these people kind of ordered a pizza online to themselves and then
00:50:20 said hey let's just pretend it was a threat to get a jerusalem post article written about us
00:50:25 and to make it seem like we're in physical danger um because that wins a lot of sympathy and that
00:50:31 and that sympathy is is is then used for more i don't know look threats amid anti-semitic
00:50:37 accusations the the address was my daughter's clear message we know who who you are and we
00:50:43 know where you live right after candace started threatening us threatening gonna have to fact
00:50:51 check that um but yeah i mean if you can use a pizza delivery i'm not saying this is what
00:51:00 necessarily happened but if potentially you could use a pizza delivery to justify that you are being
00:51:05 threatened then you can obviously use something like bill c63 to justify silencing people you
00:51:13 don't like um and as i kind of said in the title you know tribes and groups are obviously going to
00:51:21 weaponize they would weaponize bill c63 if it passes to their own personal and political ends
00:51:27 you know it'd be a nightmare it'd be a nightmare it'd be a horrible tattletale culture
00:51:35 um that just would not be fun for anybody
00:51:40 um yeah how are we doing i think we're gonna get into this uh runkle video in a sec
00:51:57 did i see a super chat did i miss the super chat yeah craig bragg five dollars thank you craig
00:52:04 Craig, you should look into going on TimCast IRL to spread the word.
00:52:10 Tim, if you're watching, brother, I'd love to be on the show.
00:52:15 Love TimCast.
00:52:18 Let him know.
00:52:19 Let him know that we're going to say free speech in Canada.
00:52:21 Let him have me on.
00:52:26 Art Story said, yeah, it was a cafe or something getting vandalized by the owner.
00:52:31 yeah that's brutal um i'll have an extra large anti-semitic pizza please says katherine grant 0.99
00:52:39 that's funny jesse is black jewish and gay the ultimate trifecta for faking hate crimes 0.98
00:52:45 real very very good point ngd um but yeah we got to stop bill c63 if you want to support you can 0.97
00:52:53 go to save free sorry you can go to give saying go.com slash save free speech that's where we're
00:52:58 Collecting donations to create the documentary.
00:53:01 To promote the documentary.
00:53:03 We got to get it out there.
00:53:04 We got to spread the message.
00:53:06 And yeah, we appreciate all of your support.
00:53:12 It's a feelings bill, says Prairie.
00:53:14 Yeah, pretty much.
00:53:16 Pretty much.
00:53:21 M Ball says, how do you order pizza online without paying for it?
00:53:26 That's a good question.
00:53:28 trent dab says what kind of pizza was it though well it was it was a non-kosher pizza non-kosher
00:53:33 non-paid-for this is a threat this is assault this is basically terrorism this uh this pizza
00:53:39 order uh you guys are funny okay all right let's get into this video it's 50 minutes
00:53:50 5-0. I think it'll go
00:53:53 a lot quicker than last time.
00:53:57 Yeah, let's just get into it, guys.
00:54:00 How are we looking? How are we looking?
00:54:01 Okay. Okay.
00:54:04 This is from Toronto Sun.
00:54:05 March 11th, so not
00:54:07 long after the Bill C-63
00:54:09 was tabled earlier this year, the Online
00:54:11 Harms Act could censor Twitter,
00:54:13 Netflix, and us. Full comment
00:54:15 podcast.
00:54:18 The Online Harms
00:54:19 act also known as bill c63 it's the latest attempt by the trudeau liberals to try and deal
00:54:25 with regulating the online world look there's some good parts of this parts that say they're
00:54:30 going to deal with look there's some good parts of this yes let's give them the benefit of the
00:54:35 doubt shall we what's this guy's name again uh i should know his name seen him many times i think
00:54:42 he's blocked me on uh twitter actually does he block me on twitter come on what's his name
00:54:50 Guys, what can I think of his name?
00:54:53 Um, Toronto Sun.
00:55:04 Um...
00:55:04 Guys, why can't I think of this guy's name right now?
00:55:12 Anyway.
00:55:13 Maybe I shouldn't get so distracted.
00:55:19 What is this?
00:55:22 Brian Lilly.
00:55:23 Thank you.
00:55:24 Thank you, Brian Everett.
00:55:34 Okay, no, he doesn't have to be blocked.
00:55:35 That's good.
00:55:41 But, yeah, already giving the benefit of the doubt.
00:55:43 You know, there's a lot of things online that we've got to protect from.
00:55:46 Just saying.
00:55:48 Just saying.
00:55:49 Great, great way to start it off. First thing you say about it is, hey, there's some good things about online protections.
00:55:58 With childhood online sexual exploitation, nobody I know is in favor of that. There are portions to deal with revenge.
00:56:05 I would hope not. No one I know is in favor of that. Kind of weird you even have to say that.
00:56:12 Well, again, I don't know anybody in favor of revenge porn, but are there elements of the bill that go too far?
00:56:18 Will they infringe on freedom of expression?
00:56:21 Will they lead to people abusing this for political means?
00:56:25 Those are very real concerns.
00:56:27 Hello, welcome to the Full Comment Podcast.
00:56:29 My name is Brian Lilly, your host.
00:56:31 And this week, we're going to take a deep dive into Bill C-63, the good, the bad, and the ugly.
00:56:37 There's been a lot of commentary that this is a bill that should actually be cut in two.
00:56:41 The online harms portions dealing with children, revenge porn, etc., put into one.
00:56:46 And then all the elements that deal with regulating speech, hate speech, etc., even advocating genocide, should be a separate bill and get longer, deeper, more thoughtful study.
00:56:58 Is that the way to go? What are the portions that we need to worry about? Or do we have some of them taken out of context?
00:57:06 Ian Runkle is a lawyer in Edmonton, criminal defense lawyer.
00:57:09 He also has a very large following online with his YouTube channel, Runkle at the Bailey, where he talks about legal issues, especially firearms on a regular basis.
00:57:19 I do want to say when it comes to splitting the bill, one of the top comments here is.
00:57:25 The bill shouldn't be shouldn't be split.
00:57:27 It should be thrown out.
00:57:28 Absolutely. 0.99
00:57:30 Throw the bill in the garbage with Trudeau and his whole party. 0.77
00:57:33 Parents should be responsible for protecting children, not the government. 0.90
00:57:36 So true.
00:57:39 yeah i talked about this on the last stream but we were responding to the siege talking about
00:57:46 bill c63 and they also kind of had a similar sentiment of hey we should just chop this bill
00:57:52 in two and pass the one and not pass the other and talk about the other one more and this is
00:57:57 again a negotiation tactic to us to still lose ground and give the government more power like
00:58:04 it's not a win to only have part of this bill passed that's still a loss that's still a loss
00:58:10 for us that's still a big fat l and that's probably what pierre polyev is going for like
00:58:17 oh well we're gonna just oppose the bad parts of the bill not the good parts no no the so-called
00:58:21 good parts are gonna be just as bad it's going to be giving the government control they're gonna be
00:58:26 able to take down content um anyway we'll probably get into that but uh again we need to throw this
00:58:33 whole thing out this idea that some of it is good is just not good not not a not a good framework
00:58:37 not a good uh not a good negotiating like frame to be coming from i could i would totally reject
00:58:45 this frame we need to say hey they're trying to kill free speech in canada the whole thing needs
00:58:50 to be thrown out period we reached out to ian to discuss this issue and figure out what he sees as
00:58:56 problems from a criminal defense point of view ian runkul thanks for the time oh thank you for
00:59:03 having me so let's just gotta say this man looks so majestic it's like he's got the flowing hair
00:59:11 i don't know what his background is i'm sensing irish or scottish or welsh or something but uh
00:59:18 very majestic guy let me ask you off the top about the online harms bill um the it seems to be two
00:59:27 bills in one in my view you've got a whole area that's aimed at stopping child sexual exploitation
00:59:33 uh revenge porn things like that and then you've got hate speech incitement to genocide all these
00:59:40 other things does this seem like they've kind of jammed a bunch of things together that the only
00:59:46 thing they have in common is that they might happen online this is really i think sort of an
00:59:52 omnibus bill of all of the things that
00:59:54 happen online that we don't like
00:59:56 sort of wedged into one
00:59:58 big thing but it also
01:00:00 will have some offline applications
01:00:03 as well in terms of
01:00:04 things like the abilities to get
01:00:06 peace bonds
01:00:08 applied to people who they think
01:00:10 might do something
01:00:12 Art Story says he knows
01:00:14 Legolas
01:00:15 What elf?
01:00:19 Runkle is a real
01:00:20 life elf says Lee Stewie
01:00:22 maybe maybe what do your elves i see runkle something might do something which can include
01:00:30 things like house arrest so those provisions it seems that they maybe should sever that off into
01:00:37 a separate bill but there's a lot of problems with this because the government really has this
01:00:43 big idea that they can sort of tame the internet and they're really bad at it i mean that's a good
01:00:51 clip that's a good that's a good clip they think they can tame the internet
01:00:58 and this is the obvious stuff too that i think people can understand instead of just like going
01:01:12 into the minutia of the bill just look at bill c11 c18 and be like hey this government already 0.55
01:01:19 fucked up you can't even get news on on meta on facebook and instagram you think they're going to 0.99
01:01:24 do a good job with this you're foolish they have a bad track record period why why would we let 0.99
01:01:31 them further legislate our internet when they've already messed it up twice contain the internet i 0.98
01:01:36 don't know what it's like in edmonton but you know we've had a uh a dinner between two g7 leaders
01:01:44 shut down because of pro-Hamas terror groups taking over the event venue.
01:01:52 We've had a political fundraiser for local liberal constituency associations shut down
01:02:01 because the same pro-Hamas terror group show up and take over the restaurant in a very affluent,
01:02:07 nice part of town. I'm not sure that you can police the internet when you can't police the streets.
01:02:12 well that's very interesting that these are the only examples that brian lily comes up
01:02:17 with is uh is pro hamas groups um again you know the whole thing of churches being burnt down i
01:02:27 just feel like net like never gets the guess it's uh gets its guess gets the sort of attention that
01:02:33 it deserves uh and along with the political prisoners that we've seen since the trucker
01:02:39 convoy is super relevant to the conversation, uh, of free speech. Okay. One's in chat. If you think
01:02:48 Brian Lilly or Ian Runkle will bring up either the trucker convoy or evidence of political
01:02:54 prisoners in this country to, if you think the trucker convoy will not come up and the concept
01:03:01 of political prisoners already existing in Canada will not come up in this 50 minute long conversation.
01:03:07 One's in chat if you think it will come up.
01:03:10 Trucker convoy, political prisoners.
01:03:12 Two's in chat if you think it will not come up in this conversation.
01:03:14 Well, a lot of the policing, they plan to push on to social media organizations.
01:03:21 And the problem is that in doing so, they're going to create tremendous costs for the social media organizations, both in terms of their internal moderation and processes, but also in terms of potential liability fines.
01:03:36 if they're within Canada, as well as the possibility of inspections.
01:03:42 And so what we might actually see is some of these companies fleeing Canada
01:03:46 in order to take up residence elsewhere to avoid these particular rules.
01:03:52 Okay, so let's get into that in a little bit, but let's go back to...
01:03:55 This is a huge point, though.
01:03:57 This is a huge point, though.
01:03:59 You know, the Canadian government likes to act like they're so great and special
01:04:04 and like you know we're amazing we're such an amazing country our population is relatively
01:04:09 small we're a relatively small market for a big tech company when you have india when you have
01:04:16 america india is over a billion china is over a billion um and america is like a quarter sorry
01:04:24 one third of a billion 300 million people canada is only like 30 or 40 it's like 40 million now
01:04:30 you know, if they do the math of, oh, they're, you're going to want to have us to use all of
01:04:35 these resources to try and silence people and all these resources to like, you know, follow your
01:04:39 directives. They might say, fuck you. We're not even going to let you use Facebook 1.00
01:04:44 in Canada, unless you have a VPN or something like this. And, oh, that would never happen,
01:04:50 bro. Again, this happened exactly with Bill C-18 with the online news act.
01:04:54 now you can't get news in on instagram and facebook so like this concern that runkle
01:05:01 brought up off the bat is a totally valid one because there is a track record of poor legislation
01:05:08 terribly thought of legislation already passed by the same heritage heritage minister that uh
01:05:16 yeah as an objective failure the first question that i asked you and you kind of hinted at it in
01:05:22 the the first answer should this bill be split because on the question of the third time he's
01:05:29 brought this up already third time he's brought up splitting the bill is this the plan mr lily
01:05:35 are you in on the plan that they want to try to split the bill and make one half look good or
01:05:39 something like this jeez sexual exploitation of children online on the question of revenge porn
01:05:44 things like that i don't hear a lot of pushback i don't hear a lot of oh no no no we we need to
01:05:51 have that. There seems to be unanimous consent, unanimous viewpoint that these are things that
01:06:00 we should be looking after. And to me, it seems like if you had that as a separate bill, that
01:06:06 would pass very quickly versus all the other stuff that you and I are going to spend the next
01:06:10 half hour or so unpacking. So should this bill be split? It's certainly a good idea in terms of
01:06:18 separating out for instance the criminal code and human rights act stuff the one thing i will say is
01:06:23 anytime the government tells you we're here to protect the children you should be very very
01:06:29 concerned because that's usually a sort of wrapper for very bad legislation and i think that a lot of
01:06:36 these portions that may very well pass without too much criticism simply because they say this
01:06:59 is to protect children are actually quite um quite dangerous and quite charter infringing
01:07:05 provisions runkle crushing it right now big agree we actually might just listen to that again because
01:07:12 it was so it was such gold idea in terms of separating out for instance the criminal code
01:07:17 and human rights act stuff the one thing i will say is anytime the government tells you we're here
01:07:24 to protect the children you should be very very concerned because that's usually a sort of wrapper
01:07:30 for very bad legislation.
01:07:33 And I think that a lot of these portions
01:07:34 that may very well pass
01:07:37 without too much criticism
01:07:38 simply because they say
01:07:40 this is to protect children
01:07:41 are actually quite dangerous
01:07:44 and quite charter-infringing provisions.
01:07:48 And some of them may actually...
01:07:49 The child exploitation things,
01:07:51 you're worried that there are child...
01:07:53 Brian Lilly cuts him off.
01:07:56 He was cooking.
01:07:57 He gets cut off.
01:07:58 Thanks, Lilly. Great.
01:07:58 charter violations within that.
01:08:03 Absolutely.
01:08:04 For instance, there's...
01:08:05 Unpack that for me.
01:08:07 For instance, one of the things that is forbidden
01:08:10 or will be sort of forbidden
01:08:12 is any sort of visual representation
01:08:15 that shows a child who's being subjected
01:08:17 to cruel, inhuman, or degrading acts of physical violence,
01:08:21 which would include, for instance, the movie Carrie.
01:08:23 um this is it's very difficult to craft these uh okay well look these restrictions the movie
01:08:31 carry there's going to be i want to hear this again because you know this is what we need we
01:08:37 need an autistic lawyer looking at this specific legislation and be like you could totally do this
01:08:41 to ban a movie from the 80s children are actually quite um to or will be sort of forbidden since
01:08:51 one of the absolutely uh for instance unpack that for me uh for instance one of the things that is
01:08:59 uh forbidden to or will be sort of forbidden is any sort of visual representation uh that shows
01:09:05 a child who's being subjected to cruel inhuman or degrading acts of physical violence which would
01:09:11 include for instance the movie carrie um so i think his point there is based on the verbiage
01:09:18 in the legislation is it could be a fictional movie technically could be a tv show technically
01:09:27 could be like a sketch on youtube or a short film on youtube technically and uh yeah that matters
01:09:35 because it's stuff we're writing into law so that that kind of matters especially if that
01:09:40 exception is not accounted for this is it's very difficult to craft these okay well look
01:09:48 these restrictions. The movie Carrie, there's going to be an awful lot of people. I know the
01:09:52 movie you're talking about. I watched it as a kid in the 70s. There's going to be an awful lot of
01:09:56 people who have no idea what we're talking about. This is an old movie. It's an old movie. What is
01:10:04 it about Carrie that would trigger this? It's about a high school student who is very badly
01:10:10 bullied by her peers. And it becomes a horror movie because, you know, she's got magical powers.
01:10:18 But it includes things like a scene quite famously where they trick her into a situation where they can dump pig's blood on her specifically for the purpose of degrading and humiliating her.
01:10:30 There's a lot of like high school movies that include these kinds of scenes of bullying and would be about children because it's high school students.
01:10:40 yeah and so you can say like it's really we don't want to have videos of child abuse out there
01:10:46 but there may actually and the other thing is that there may be good reason to to actually show
01:10:52 even those somebody who sees somebody abusing a child in you know in public may videotape that
01:11:00 and put it online in order to condemn that behavior and yet run afoul of this so it becomes
01:11:07 very difficult to say where the line is and when you when they're sort of painting these broad
01:11:12 broad strokes they're they're going to get a lot of things wrong and there's going to be a lot of
01:11:17 situations where it may uh may not be covered uh perhaps more contemporary uh south park he brings
01:11:25 up a great point there with uh and i brought this up on on other streams but you know what if there
01:11:30 is a legitimate child abuser who gets caught in public or something or other like where there's
01:11:37 a clip of somebody like capturing this person being a vile monster technically you could use
01:11:42 this legislation to take that down like imagine imagine i'm not saying this is true but imagine
01:11:48 if hypothetically justin trudeau was friends with the child abuser and they there's like some
01:11:53 scandalous like video that gets leaked or somebody is able to capture of a horrible monstrous thing
01:11:59 happening to one of trudeau's friends who's who's a monster abusing a child then you can say hey
01:12:04 we'll just use that legislation bill to just take that content off the internet and you know trudeau's
01:12:09 friend is innocent because there's no evidence because we wiped it off the internet because we
01:12:13 have the power to do that now we have the power to take things off the internet now that are on
01:12:20 big tech platforms because we'll threaten to like uh what is it get eight percent of their annual
01:12:27 global profits or 10 million dollars you know think think of what kind of think of the decision
01:12:34 if you're a big tech platform and the government the canadian government says hey if you don't
01:12:40 take down this video it if you don't take down this video then you have to pay us 10 million
01:12:47 dollars or however however many million dollars it would be like it's crazy they probably will
01:12:51 leave the country if if they you know we'll probably just get no big tech platforms in
01:12:56 hand anymore if uh if this bill passes but let's just make sure it doesn't pass how about that
01:13:02 crazy concept right
01:13:03 lee stewie said one time i messaged runkel for legal advice and he got back to me right away
01:13:12 good guy did you message him on twitter lee i haven't reached out to him yet i figured i'd
01:13:17 watch this first just to kind of get his uh his kind of best takes already on the bill to bring
01:13:23 me up to speed with where he's at anyway art story said the person sharing the video like
01:13:33 the child abuse video would be guilty of prejudice or something yeah i mean you never know
01:13:37 you never know he he really runcles was is really cooking there in terms of like they usually get
01:13:43 it wrong when it's so broad like this it could there's so many little loopholes that could be
01:13:49 exploited this is the law this is the law this is important it's important to get this right
01:13:56 because it's it's harder to uninstall a law once it's there let's throw the whole thing out let's
01:14:02 see if see because and what's interesting here too is if i'm not mistaken what runkle is criticizing
01:14:08 is the part that lily thinks is more reasonable about hey let's just get rid of the uh let's just
01:14:14 get rid of the the criminal stuff and the and the um human rights stuff and let's just focus on the
01:14:20 you know childhood sexual online harm stuff which is again what the other podcast i listened to was
01:14:26 saying but he's he's pointing out even the the uh the problems with that as well um oh my god they
01:14:31 killed kenny yes uh that's that's south park south park runs a foul of bill c63 potentially i mean
01:14:40 there's exceptions there in terms of whether or not it has sufficient artistic merit, which
01:14:45 when South Park came out was a hugely debated issue. I think that they've perhaps found some
01:14:51 social traction, but what happens with all of this? I can see the argument for and against
01:14:58 South Park having artistic merit. There are times when expression. I hate when I do that.
01:15:04 here's the thing though what are we actually gaining from passing this bill because the
01:15:12 assumption with all these conversations is like well we have to do something about online harms
01:15:16 and it's like do we what what is what is truly the uh because all i'm seeing is a bunch of far
01:15:22 leftists complaining about people's whose opinion they don't like that's what i see mostly and sure
01:15:28 there's the egregious things like ornography of you know abusing children all of this stuff's
01:15:34 already illegal though it's already against the law big tech already does a whole bunch of stuff
01:15:40 to circumvent that and i brought this up on another stream if they were more serious about
01:15:47 wanting to stop the monstrous stuff of abusing kids and recording it and putting it online
01:15:51 maybe they'd actually name names of large porn companies and actually hone in on that they don't
01:15:58 at all they just they're just blanketing the entire internet it's ridiculous and for those
01:16:04 who don't know yeah there's a massive porn company uh like you know empire that is in uh
01:16:11 headquartered originally i believe in montreal and it's like if they were serious about like
01:16:16 getting that content off the internet then maybe they would actually mention this and actually gear
01:16:20 this uh bill towards that but obviously they aren't it's it's i i really believe it's much
01:16:24 more about uh power grab crap i lost the spot didn't i i think we were around here
01:16:31 you know it's like oh this bill would this bill would uh you know even make um south park 0.85
01:16:38 potentially illegal or content to be taken down yeah do we really need this bill that badly what
01:16:44 like what what truly is the benefit other than patting ourselves on the back and acting like
01:16:48 we're gonna save kids from uh from uh pedophiles pedophiles happen in real life by the way that's
01:16:54 of really where uh anyway that's a whole other other topic let's keep going exceptions there
01:16:59 in terms of whether or not it has sufficient artistic merit which when south park came out
01:17:05 was a hugely debated issue i think that they've perhaps found some social traction but what what
01:17:13 happens with the argument for and against south park having artistic merit there are times when
01:17:20 it cracks me up in times where I cringe. And I think most of us are like that. And so, yeah,
01:17:26 you could have that debate. You could have that argument. But depending on who's interpreting
01:17:31 the law, you're essentially saying, could result in unforeseen instances of people being caught up
01:17:40 in this. Absolutely. And one of the things is that content that is actual child sexual abuse
01:17:48 material is already one of the most vilified and illegal sorts of things you can find online
01:17:55 um yep yep exactly it's refreshing to listen to runkle because it's like
01:18:04 all of the very obvious arguments like that it's like he's one of the only people who i've heard
01:18:12 who heard kind of mentioned the most obvious stuff about this bill and it's like it's just
01:18:17 very refreshing appreciate you appreciate you runkle provider like social media and so forth
01:18:25 as a major category polices the heck out of this and watches for that kind of content on their
01:18:32 media and actively reports it to police one thing that i hope they'll fix because it's very
01:18:37 concerning in this bill is that this could actually make it very difficult to prosecute
01:18:43 uh people who are sharing some of that content online um there's in what way wow uh there's a
01:18:50 provision that if content is uh gets a a notice essentially somebody says this content is
01:18:57 objectionable which hopefully somebody who saw that material would say this content is objectionable
01:19:02 uh the i the provider is required to within 24 hours provide a notice to the person who posted
01:19:10 that content and what are they going to do when they see hey your content was removed we have
01:19:16 we've noticed this is they may start destroying evidence the police will often engage in
01:19:23 lengthier sting operations where they're watching to see where this material goes who's sharing it
01:19:30 and then you'll see those big busts where they arrest like a hundred people okay what we may
01:19:36 instead see is one person who gets a notice side because of these notices yeah somebody who gets
01:19:43 one of these notices is very likely to just say whoa i i need to expect a police visit and then
01:19:50 burn the hard drives lost and and get rid of everything yeah sheesh i've never heard this
01:19:57 argument yet that is crazy so i mean it it is kind of par for the course for the liberal party
01:20:04 right? We're going to help protect kids online. We're going to make it easier for pedophiles
01:20:08 and get away with it as well. That's wow. Big brain. Look, I told you guys, look how big this
01:20:17 man, this man's brain is so big, so big. He's, he's, he's 10 steps ahead. That's very chilling
01:20:26 and disturbing. And he, he makes a fantastic point that I didn't think about. He is a criminal
01:20:30 a lawyer so you know he's he's right there he's right on the ball right on the money making it
01:20:35 easier for pedophiles to get away with it yeah if you want to protect kids online then you should
01:20:44 be talking about this potentiality a riverani if you want to protect if you're saying that you want
01:20:49 to protect kids online with bill c63 then this is something that you need to consider and clearly 0.94
01:20:55 have not almost like you're full of shit and just want to uh usurp more power from big tech and for 0.98
01:21:04 the canadian government to control its own citizens and potentially potentially protect your pedophile 0.99
01:21:08 friends i don't know who knows i don't know who you hang out with the reef geez so i mean hopefully 0.54
01:21:16 they'll put in some sort of exception of like maybe we don't have to give people advance notice
01:21:22 if they're sharing stuff that is that kind of harmful, because I'd much rather see those people
01:21:28 face an actual, you know, is Lily starting to sweat. He's starting to sweat a lot. Suddenly,
01:21:33 am I crazy? Arrest and prosecution. It's absolutely, we should be taking that material
01:21:40 down. But prosecution is important. And if it can interfere with that, that's a problem.
01:21:46 You mentioned earlier that when people wrap themselves up in we're protecting the children,
01:21:51 We should be worried. And it reminded me of, correct me if I've got the bill wrong in Bill C-51, I think it was in the Harper era. And there were a whole bunch of measures in that to to try and deal with different elements that they want to dealt with.
01:22:11 But I believe it was then Justice Minister Vic Taves or Public Safety Minister Vic Taves saying, you're either with the child pornographers or you're with us.
01:22:20 And it was a horrible bill. There were horrible elements to it.
01:22:24 And but he tried to wrap himself up in I'm defending children.
01:22:29 Why aren't you? It is kind of a thing that politicians will do.
01:22:34 Politicians of all stripes. I'm not being partisan here.
01:22:37 I'm picking on Vic Taves as well as worried about what the current government will do.
01:22:41 Is this something that you worry about when you see those statements, when you see these bills that they're just trying to hide other things?
01:22:51 I mean, I'm sure that there is some motivation of, you know, we've got to protect the kids.
01:22:57 The problem is, is that almost it's one of those things that's a real red flag.
01:23:01 Almost every time you see it, there's something in those bills that is really a problem.
01:23:06 and this bill has a lot of issues that um that may create real problems where
01:23:12 the various efforts to regulate the internet that we're seeing including ones that are supported by
01:23:18 the conservative party right now the sort of porn id law are have a real possibility of sort of
01:23:25 creating a balkanized internet where canada gets a lesser internet hold on though hold on
01:23:31 why let him cook ryan oh is he about to criticize the conservative party whoa whoa whoa whoa whoa 0.99
01:23:39 hold on hold on there we're here to shit on just trudeau and the liberals okay okay uh pure 0.98
01:23:48 polyev was asked do you think that uh people should have to verify their age you know that 0.98
01:23:55 that's vastly different than you've got to you know scan your driver's license when you're going
01:24:00 on a porn site um it's uh there's a whole lot of grades in there and that was used by the liberal
01:24:07 party just before they bring out this law to attack him i mean there's politics on all sides on
01:24:12 this oh for sure it kind of drives me nuts it's like we're going to stop the child pornographers
01:24:18 but don't ask anybody their age if they're uh uploading or watching on porn hub well the
01:24:25 concern there is not just that it's don't ask anybody their age it's got to be verified by some
01:24:31 means so it may actually be that you have to post your id or uh have a picture taken of you for uh
01:24:38 for various you know there's technologies that purport to guess your age based on a picture
01:24:44 but that would also not just cover it covers any site that has you know adult content on it which
01:24:49 isn't just Pornhub. It's also Twitter and Reddit. And at that point, if you're needing to have an
01:24:56 ID for everything you do on places like Reddit and Twitter, then we've essentially created a
01:25:02 digital ID, which is a real problem because that can very much suppress speech that might be
01:25:08 legal, but controversial.
01:25:13 Rumble's cooking. I've heard this theory before that the liberal or the conservative bill
01:25:19 is essentially presenting digital id and they're using the whole thing of oh no it's uh you know
01:25:24 we're gonna make sure that you're old enough to watch illicit material online and it's like well
01:25:29 how do we do that if we're not just associating our our identification with our you know internet
01:25:36 browsing history our our presence online uh so runkle nails it here and i'm very interested to
01:25:44 see how lily is about to respond to this because he's criticizing a bill that comes from the
01:25:50 conservative party i believe the bill is what is it 210 or something is it s 210 or something like
01:25:56 this can anyone find find out for me maybe they'll bring it up in a sec and that becomes uh that's my
01:26:03 concern is that it gets wrapped up as we need to protect children but it instead is something that
01:26:09 affects online discourse and speech, including legitimate lawful speech. So that's the concern.
01:26:19 And there's plenty, I should note, all of the concerns that apply to that bill are wrapped up
01:26:25 in C-63, in particular, because there's a section, section 65, and it just says, it's under this
01:26:33 category of duty to protect children. It says, design features an operator must integrate into
01:26:38 a regulated service that it operates any design features respecting the protection of children
01:26:43 such as age appropriate design that are provided for by regulations those regulations won't come
01:26:50 to a vote they can just be it's like the order in council to you know ban firearms and so forth they
01:26:56 can just be put forward with a stroke of a pen and they could say you must have this kind of age
01:27:02 verification tomorrow, you know, assuming that this law was in place, they could just drop that
01:27:08 down. And suddenly all of these companies have to adjust to that. They could do worse than that.
01:27:15 They could do more content. I'm glad that you're raising that because an awful lot of people don't
01:27:20 realize how much in legislation is left to regulation. And regulation is not passed by
01:27:26 parliament. It's not seen by parliament for the most part. It is decided by bureaucrats after the
01:27:32 fact. And what you just described is something that would leave an awful lot of the details
01:27:39 up to someone who is not elected, who we have no recourse with, who has no accountability,
01:27:47 and they're going to decide how the law is applied. Correct?
01:27:52 Absolutely. And typically what we see is a sort of ever-expanding sphere of what they feel should
01:27:59 be their influence bureaucrats very rarely say i should have less power and i should have less
01:28:04 things under me because the more things that they deal with the more money and budget and so forth
01:28:11 and the more important they they get to be and so we can we can imagine that this is going to grow
01:28:18 not shrink so that's a very big concern to me and i mean i want to see a healthy canada
01:28:29 economically. And one of the things that I think Canada does well is our sort of ground game on
01:28:36 social media and on this kind of content. But it will be very difficult for these companies to
01:28:44 consider locating themselves in Canada if they may have to completely change their system at the
01:28:49 stroke of a pen by a bureaucrat. Why would you want to subject yourself to that when it might be
01:28:55 literally millions of dollars in order to adjust these things and then you might have to do it
01:29:02 again in six months wow a lot of good points you brought up there last one basically saying big
01:29:07 tech offices could possibly just leave the country if they if they don't like this sort of tyrannical
01:29:12 rule uh being imposed over them by bureaucratics bureaucrats with their regulations and i actually
01:29:21 have not heard this one either which is section 65 i think it said of the bill where essentially
01:29:27 leaves the door open the back door to additional regulations added by the bureaucrats on what the
01:29:34 digital safety board or whatever we come up with uh worried that it's going to grow and not shrink
01:29:40 yeah and and this totally connects to you know why this bill needs to be completely thrown out
01:29:48 because if they get their foot in the door if bureaucracy gets their foot in the door
01:29:53 if we give them the keys to the castle the keys to starting to just like regulate the internet how
01:29:58 they like even if it's just a small thing it's going to grow it's going to set a precedent
01:30:03 to do more of that to control more of the internet it's uh it's good not good not good
01:30:12 yeah runkle is awesome totally agree sandy klein totally agree alberta climber ian runkle ian
01:30:22 runkle is a ian ian runkle is a good dude he offered to consult with chris lysack's lawyer
01:30:27 on all firearms related issues for free chad chad moment what did i tell you from the beginning
01:30:32 look at the look at the look at the mystique look at the aura the aura is real
01:30:39 yeah at least do we parents should be monitoring monitoring their children on the internet not the
01:30:49 government yeah it's true and and again the problem is i brought this up on a on an earlier
01:30:56 conversation it's a it's a genuine fear for parents it's a genuine fear having your kid on
01:31:03 the internet having your kid on a device oh my god like there's so much scary stuff out there
01:31:07 what are we going to do and then you can see justin trudeau don't you worry we're going to
01:31:11 protect your kids from online harms with this new bill c63 really i'm going to be protecting my
01:31:18 pedophile friends but just pass the bill anyway because you want to feel safe with your children
01:31:24 online but parents are legitimately afraid and giving that trojan horse with this bill of like 0.65
01:31:31 protecting kids it's it's easy it's an easy sell to help lull canadian parents asleep it'd be like
01:31:40 you know what we do need something online we do need something online um so yeah that that that
01:31:46 trojan horse needs to be completely dismantled by exposing uh what this bill is really about
01:31:50 and that's what we're doing at savefreespeech.ca we're stopping bill c63 if you want to support us
01:31:56 You can go to givesendgo.com slash savefreespeech.
01:32:01 It's in the pinned comment.
01:32:03 This is going towards the documentary we are creating.
01:32:07 And it is going to expose the truth about Bill C-63, the people behind it.
01:32:12 The intentions of tyranny, of censorship, of creating more political prisoners,
01:32:17 silencing political opposition.
01:32:19 Again, givesendgo.com slash savefreespeech.
01:32:22 You can send us a donation there.
01:32:24 Greatly appreciate it.
01:32:25 but let's get back to this conversation you know i i've talked to people who are either in
01:32:34 these major tech companies or represent them and as you know my industry my company
01:32:40 they've had a lot of issues with big tech fog fog hallay says give them an inch and they will
01:32:47 throw you in prison for 20 years yeah real the the regular phrase is give them an inch they take a
01:32:54 mile, but yeah, give them an inch and they will throw you in prison for 20 years. Like it's yeah,
01:32:59 exactly. Um, yep. And the whole argument over how many, what percentage of ad dollars go to
01:33:08 Google and Facebook versus everyone else, they're still major players and we're still partners with
01:33:15 them. And they're part of the, the internet economy, as you say, and yet this government
01:33:21 keeps coming up with bills that make it harder and harder for them to operate. And yet there are
01:33:26 conversations about, should we leave? Or should we withdraw certain services from Canada? Should
01:33:34 we scale back in Canada? Which is really bothersome when you think about how much all of us
01:33:42 rely on, whether it's storage services, email services, social media services, all of these
01:33:50 things that are part of the economy that we wouldn't have wouldn't have thought of 15 or 20
01:33:56 years ago they're there now we're going to add these regulations on and that might lead to some
01:34:01 of them saying you know what we don't need canada because they don't want us and it's it is a very
01:34:08 real concern and at those points um we end up with situations where these companies do flee
01:34:14 and then we can't regulate them at all uh the other thing that we with that we may see with
01:34:20 some of these bills is if you prevent people
01:34:23 from doing things legally, they may move things into,
01:34:27 there may be a growth in illegal distribution channels,
01:34:31 which have very few breaks.
01:34:34 And so we may actually end up making our internet worse
01:34:38 by driving out the people who are sort of the good actors
01:34:41 and only creating ones that have no interest
01:34:44 in following any laws whatsoever.
01:34:47 essentially you're talking about the dark web.
01:34:50 Those sorts of things.
01:34:51 Like if we chase out, pornography is controversial,
01:34:55 but we're not going to get it to go away.
01:34:57 And so for instance, if we drive out companies
01:35:00 that try their best to make sure that things
01:35:03 are not too toxic, what you'll instead see
01:35:07 is a massive growth of people seeking out that content
01:35:11 on other sources, which may not follow rules at all.
01:35:16 And that's going to be a major, that's a major concern I have with some of these bills as well.
01:35:22 And when you look at just the legal exposure of operating in Canada,
01:35:29 right now, I'm not sure what the global revenue is for Twitter right now.
01:35:35 I'm just looking, is it in millions?
01:35:38 uh like if the uh sorry i'm not i shouldn't be googling right now but it's eight percent
01:35:45 the fines allowed for penalties are up to eight percent of the operator's close global revenue
01:35:52 or 25 million yeah or 25 million whichever is greater so if you're talking about a company
01:35:59 like facebook or wow whichever is greater that's so obnoxiously written you need to give us as much
01:36:07 money as you have
01:36:09 the most amount of money
01:36:11 if we find something bad if you don't
01:36:13 take the bad thing away that we deem bad
01:36:15 then we're going to find you 25 million
01:36:18 dollars if that's insane
01:36:19 I thought it was lower than that
01:36:21 whichever is higher
01:36:23 8%
01:36:25 of global profits
01:36:27 that is
01:36:29 and cut to the clip of
01:36:33 Arif Verrani saying like we took
01:36:34 we took years developing this legislation
01:36:37 really because this sounds ridiculous and everybody who's actually involved with who
01:36:42 this legislation would affect i.e. the big tech companies i.e. the people who use the internet
01:36:47 every day uh yeah they think it's absurd and terrible it's almost like you were only consulting
01:36:53 with the people interested in silencing political opposition in this country it sounds like that's
01:36:58 like the only people you consulted with the referani potentially i don't know just a theory
01:37:02 for uh google uh google's maximum fine for violating this is a billion dollars
01:37:08 see you google see you next time i'm not gonna have google in canada anymore a billion dollars
01:37:21 a billion dollars if you don't take away if you don't take down this
01:37:27 this meme this this evil meme we're gonna yeah i mean he nailed it a second ago where he said
01:37:34 you know if you're a big tech company and you're consider the the exposure that the legal exposure
01:37:41 of operating in canada where the where the canadian government might somehow force you to get
01:37:47 a billion dollars yeah peace out canada they would not think twice yeah if if i'm google i'm
01:37:56 You might say, you know what?
01:37:59 I don't need to sell Brian his Google Drive account anymore.
01:38:03 I don't need to sell the storage and all the other services that various people buy.
01:38:08 I'm going to camp.
01:38:10 I'm going to leave.
01:38:12 And so we may actually see measures to just say, listen, I mean, as a market, in terms
01:38:17 of our money, Canada isn't the big player.
01:38:20 We're basically the equivalent of the kid who goes to the grocery store once a week
01:38:24 to buy a candy bar out of his allowance and so when we say listen if you want to play in our 1.00
01:38:31 sandbox you have to follow all of these rules they may say we're just happy to block Canadians
01:38:36 and if we start getting blocked off of things like Netflix or you know Reddit or you know or Twitter
01:38:43 we end up with this world where as Canadians we have a lot less access to the net and that's
01:38:50 becoming a very real possibility. Some of these bills, not C63, C63 purports to give orders to
01:38:58 take specific content online. But you've also got C11, C18, and so on. Yeah, and some of those
01:39:04 include provisions to say that websites have to be blocked if they don't comply. You know,
01:39:11 if you don't have enough Canadian content and you're not willing to play ball, then we can block
01:39:16 you from from canada and that's a problem if you're looking at things like you know the bbc
01:39:24 we're never going to convince the bbc to put canadian content on because that's not what
01:39:30 they do they're the british broadcasting corporation um all of these are very you know
01:39:35 serious concerns and to sort of tie that back to bill c63 when we start saying listen if you want
01:39:42 to operate in Canada, we've got all of these rules and, you know, billion dollar fines.
01:39:49 It's easy to just say, you know what, we're going to decamp Canada. You do what you want to do.
01:39:55 We're just going to operate from. Yeah. So we've talked about the issues surrounding things like
01:40:01 the child exploitation, the revenge porn side of things on Bill C-63, but there's a whole other
01:40:08 element i just do want to say that those were a couple of great points he brought up um
01:40:13 and i forgot about that actually for the absurdity of bill c11 that they could
01:40:19 in theory block foreign news sites because they're not canadian enough i'm gonna have to review the
01:40:25 absurdity of these bill c11 because that that'll be part of the same talking point of just
01:40:29 how much of a legislative failure these other internet bills have been so again why would we
01:40:36 keep letting them pass bills if what they've been passing is just total trash um and opens up
01:40:43 the internet or i guess the public to facing the consequences of just really 0.98
01:40:49 i want to say the r word retarded bureaucrats 0.96
01:40:54 but yeah like just like horrible horribly misguided decisions by bureaucrats who are 0.87
01:41:02 trying to control the internet anyway and this is the one that most critics are saying huge impact
01:41:11 on freedom of expression freedom of speech um also you know let me start here i wrote a column
01:41:19 when it first came out my first read-through and of course these are big bills and it takes a few
01:41:23 days to digest and really understand because what people don't understand when you get a piece of
01:41:28 legislation like this is folks like you and I have to spend our time going back and forth
01:41:34 between the existing law and what's there, because you'll get this section that says,
01:41:38 and we replaced this section with this. And you're like, well, what did it say before? And you've got
01:41:42 to go back and forth. And it's dizzying at times. And so it takes a long time for us to break it
01:41:48 out. But my first read on this was, this is not a serious bill for dealing with what are absolutely
01:41:57 issues that folks want dealt with. But when you have a bill that says you're going to get,
01:42:04 and let me read this to you, potentially up to life in jail for either advocating genocide or,
01:42:11 let me read this part, everyone who commits an offense under this act or any other act of
01:42:17 parliament, if the commission of the offense is motivated by hatred based on race, national or
01:42:22 ethnic origin, language, color, religion, sex, age, mental or physical disability, sexual orientation
01:42:27 or gender identity or expression is guilty of an indictable offense in liable to imprisonment for
01:42:34 life. We don't put people in prison for life for murder. Now, I think it's worth noting, well,
01:42:40 nobody's actually going to get a life sentence for most of these things, right? It's a maximum
01:42:45 penalty. It's not going to be the average penalty. But it is going to be very interesting because
01:42:51 some of this could cover some very minor offenses overall uh one of the offenses that people
01:42:57 commit that might trigger this lily was cooking there he's actually cooking there
01:43:03 is mischief um somebody spray paints on you know a mischief let's see if they connect this with
01:43:12 the truck or convoy where a lot of people who got charged were charged with mischief or inciting to
01:43:18 commit mischief anyway a religious building uh something hateful to that religion well okay um
01:43:28 that's that's a detestable crime but it's it's spray paint right at the end of the day and so
01:43:35 it'll be like okay you're facing months in prison as a maximum or up to life but life because of
01:43:43 what you spray painted and what that'll end up meaning is you might end up with a um you know
01:43:50 a jury trial over a spray painting because you're going to have certain rights but also
01:43:55 any other act of parliament could be really um really interesting for instance out on the
01:44:02 east coast we're seeing disputes over fisheries and so if they say well you decided to fish
01:44:09 lobster out of season in order to, you know, because you dislike these other groups,
01:44:15 then now you're facing a life sentence. It's like, what? And for people that don't follow
01:44:24 this issue, I follow it on the, you know, just gently. You're right. That could happen. Someone
01:44:31 could say this is a hate crime. Yeah. I think they're talking about the fisheries on the East
01:44:36 coast if i'm not mistaken there's there's a dispute but i don't know why they're not actually
01:44:40 saying what's actually happening out there probably because it has to do with native groups
01:44:44 but if i'm not mistaken native groups have the privilege of uh fishing outside of season because
01:44:51 of their native status like indigenous whatever it is first nations i don't know but because they
01:44:57 have that status they are able to um you know fish certain species outside of the season which can
01:45:05 really mess up the ecosystem and mess up the kind of regular cycle of of whatever fish it is there
01:45:10 or lobster that they're taking or trapping um and yeah they're saying that like that whole dispute
01:45:16 could be now colored by this hate legislation uh because you know people of different skin colors
01:45:22 is involved and i mean the courts are usually reluctant to find something as a hate crime
01:45:30 because a lot of the time when people say something is a hate crime it's more somebody
01:45:35 with mental illness but oh man i love runkle that is so funny uh my professional lawyer opinion
01:45:50 is when someone's complaining about a hate crime uh usually someone's just mentally ill 0.59
01:45:57 uh that's usually the case 0.59
01:46:01 this is just what i've seen i'm a professional so i am a lawyer i you know there is this real
01:46:12 possibility that you'll get people facing very where the very serious charge is this enhancement
01:46:18 and the other thing that happens is you get people who get into a dispute
01:46:22 and they get angry and they say something offensive specifically to upset the person
01:46:29 that they're angry with and it might be something that they wouldn't otherwise say maybe they've
01:46:33 been maybe they've been punched a couple of times in the face before they they get to saying
01:46:39 something like that but now they've gone from like we're having a bar fight to i'm on the hook for
01:46:45 like there's a maximum of life even if they're not actually likely to get a life sentence 0.84
01:46:51 and look i it's still silly it's still silly you know like
01:46:57 i brought this up earlier what is what's the benefits what are the good things of this bill
01:47:04 what are the good i'm like i don't i'm not seeing any i'm just i'm just seeing so many excuses to
01:47:11 be able to throw more people in jail whose opinion we don't like like the more i research
01:47:17 The more I do research on this bill, the more I see nothing good, very few things good, anything that's already, anything that it might actually help with are already things that big tech silences and censors and takes off their platforms anyway, or are things that are already objectively illegal in this country, like the child porn stuff.
01:47:37 so all the good parts are things that are already reduced by big tech a very well dialed in
01:47:44 professional trans international companies that have their shit together probably hundreds of
01:47:50 employees at each big tech company dedicated to online harms already or the bill the good 0.80
01:47:57 thing about the bill is that it's we're going to stop something that's already illegal
01:48:00 other than that the only sort of benefit like the the things that this bill is adding is just like
01:48:06 It's just problems on problems on problems on problems, loopholes to attach charges to this person or that person based on something they said.
01:48:14 It's a bunch of political correct nonsense that will be used to persecute dissidents, persecute people who have the wrong opinion.
01:48:27 Obviously, like we've kind of we've seen this already happen.
01:48:30 the police are showing up at people's doors for things they're saying on social media
01:48:34 and it's always a thing that is kind of politically charged or it's anti-immigrant or whatever it's
01:48:40 totally legal to say that it's it's legal to criticize things in this country and police
01:48:45 are already showing up at people's doors you know they're they're obviously trying to take
01:48:51 away our freedom of speech with this bill because again like i just said there's no benefits there's
01:48:56 no real benefits other than a whole bunch of loopholes for bureaucrats to use to persecute
01:49:00 people they don't like because of their politics. I'm not against tough sentences. I'm a tough
01:49:06 sentence kind of guy. It just seems like compared to where this current government is on other
01:49:13 issues, getting rid of a mandatory minimum for your third conviction of gun smuggling under C5,
01:49:20 get, you know, reducing sentences for all kinds of other crimes. And then they come up with this.
01:49:26 And I think there's four instances where they've moved the maximum sentence up from two years to
01:49:31 five years to show that they're really, really serious about this. To me, this side of the bill
01:49:38 seems like it's performative, that it is for show rather than being a serious legal attempt to deal
01:49:47 with real problems. And I think that we're going to see a lot of situations where, I mean, nobody's
01:49:54 actually going to get life. It's the maximum on this. The minimum is nothing, but it's a straight
01:50:00 indictable offense, which means that they can't go by summary conviction. It cuts off certain options
01:50:05 in terms of sentencing. We've got summary convictions for terrorism offenses. You hide a
01:50:12 terrorist, you can get a summary conviction, which means if it isn't spelled out in the legislation,
01:50:17 It's a maximum of six months in court or in jail.
01:50:21 Am I correct?
01:50:23 I'd have to check.
01:50:24 I sadly don't have all of the sentencing memorized.
01:50:28 I always check.
01:50:29 But if it isn't spelled out in legislation, a summary conviction, you're not going to jail for more than six months, right?
01:50:35 I think they're up to 18.
01:50:38 But you've got summary convictions for things related to terrorism, and you don't have summary convictions here.
01:50:45 As you say, it could be spray paint.
01:50:47 and it's the testable yes but life this may actually discourage the laying of these charges
01:50:54 and sort of if i'm a prosecutor let's say you've got a guy who has spray painted his you know he
01:51:02 spray painted a shed somewhere and he basically says like whatever um now i'm considering whether
01:51:08 i want to lay this charge well if i lay this charge now this person because they're liable
01:51:14 to imprisonment for life has an entitlement to things like a jury trial and do i really want to
01:51:20 run that on a shed spray painting i might say well no i i don't i'm gonna just leave that out
01:51:28 and so that also becomes a concern the other thing and then people who are upset at the offense
01:51:35 and rightly so say well why aren't you giving them the full charges and it's like well they
01:51:42 lose faith in the justice system because they say well but you could be charging them with more and
01:51:47 you're not so you're not taking this seriously and like let's say it's a religious uh place of
01:51:54 worship as you were saying earlier yeah you know if your church your synagogue your mosque is attacked
01:52:01 that is is very personal is very visceral for you and you're going to want someone to face
01:52:09 full consequences but because this bill goes so far you're saying there's a good chance prosecutors
01:52:15 will just let's leave that aside and then you've got the the public feeling like the prosecutors
01:52:22 aren't taking it seriously and what they really what i mean that that's like fast forward to when
01:52:31 this bill's passed and it's like what you didn't give them life in prison for for spray painting
01:52:36 the synagogue like that's
01:52:38 crazy that
01:52:39 he just went there with that because it's like
01:52:42 where I
01:52:44 thought he was going is although
01:52:46 sure it's a hateful thing that was
01:52:48 done maybe just charge
01:52:50 them for the actual crime of vandalism
01:52:52 and call it a day we already have
01:52:54 laws against this stuff they broke
01:52:56 the law and just
01:52:58 just deal with the regular
01:53:00 law that we already have
01:53:01 but instead
01:53:03 it was the mob mentality of 0.51
01:53:06 these different tribes wanting no no no we want to charge them even more why don't we throw them 0.72
01:53:10 in jail because of this it's it's weird how he just kind of glossed over that as if it's yet 0.89
01:53:14 he basically said yeah it's going it's going to add people to be more tribal and i'd be more
01:53:19 bloodthirsty of wanting to charge them more like can we talk about how that would be a massive
01:53:22 problem brian lily in terms of you know people wanting to weaponize this bill against one another
01:53:27 hopefully that comes up he just kind of presumed all that that was going to happen um really ought
01:53:34 to be doing on on this i think is splitting it into so you know there should be a summary
01:53:40 conviction option for this for those situations that are less serious i can certainly see why are
01:53:45 we assuming that this is like worth like that again why are we assuming that this legislation
01:53:50 is like worthy of being saved or corrected that's what i don't get because runkle are you not sort
01:53:58 of promoting the idea that we should be moving the line of what's criminal to start to involve
01:54:05 speech more to me i feel like this is a horrible precedent to be setting um why is it valid at all
01:54:12 what are the redeeming qualities at all of any of this situations where it might be really really
01:54:18 serious if you've got somebody you know the they've got the swastika tattoo on their forehead
01:54:24 they go to a synagogue they barricade the doors and they set it on fire while everyone is inside
01:54:30 i mean first of all they'd be looking at life imprisonment anyway but well exactly
01:54:36 exactly so why do we need extra charges if that's the case
01:54:43 you know identify the individual criminal for their individual crime
01:54:49 that would be i still think you know that's a situation where you're like okay that's where
01:54:56 we want to take it up to a life imprisonment maximum but we don't necessarily want to do this
01:55:01 over somebody who you know at a bus stop throws an empty coffee cup like is this really the same
01:55:08 category do we need a life imprisonment like maximum does it have to be that indictable
01:55:14 offense that triggers all of these protections or should maybe the the crown be able to say
01:55:18 we're going to proceed summarily in this case because well it might be you know might be more
01:55:25 serious but we still don't need to to go that far you know life doesn't have to be on the table for
01:55:31 this one i want to hear your thoughts on what some all right i need to quickly run to the
01:55:38 little boys room but i wanted to throw something up on screen you guys will probably hate it um
01:55:48 Um, just give me a sec here.
01:55:56 Do, do, do, do, do, do, do.
01:55:58 How long is this?
01:56:00 I don't even know how long it is.
01:56:01 Uh-oh.
01:56:03 I saw this video come across my feed today, so we're going to watch it together.
01:56:08 Well, actually, I'm going to go to the bathroom, but you guys can watch this. 1.00
01:56:11 Cities with the most Indian population. 1.00
01:56:13 Number one, you got Toronto, Ontario.
01:56:15 Toronto has the largest Indo-Canadian population in Canada.
01:56:18 Most Indo-Canadians in Toronto, they live around Brampton, Markham, Scarborough, Etobicoke,
01:56:22 and Mississauga, but mainly Brampton. Number two, Vancouver, British Columbia. Vancouver is home to
01:56:25 the second largest Indo-Canadian population in Canada with a significant presence in Surrey,
01:56:30 Burnaby, Richmond, Abbotsford, and Delta. Number three, you got Calgary, Alberta. Calgary has a
01:56:35 growing Indo-Canadian community primarily in the northeastern and eastern parts of the city. Number
01:56:39 four, you got Edmonton, Alberta. Edmonton also has significant Indo-Canadian population mainly
01:56:44 concentrated in the southeastern and northern areas. Montreal, Quebec. Montreal has a sizable
01:56:49 Indo-Canadian community with many residents living in the neighborhoods of Park Extension,
01:56:53 Cote de Neige, and La Salle. These cities have become hubs for the Indo-Canadian community due
01:56:58 to their diverse economies, educational opportunities, and vibrant multicultural
01:57:02 environments. Top five Canadian cities with the most Indian population. Number one, you got Toronto,
01:57:07 Ontario. Toronto has the largest Indo-Canadian population in Canada. Most Indo-Canadians in
01:57:11 in Toronto. They live around Brampton, Markham, Scarborough, Etobicoke, and Mississauga, but
01:57:15 mainly Brampton. Number two, Vancouver, British Columbia. Vancouver is home to the second largest
01:57:19 Indo-Canadian population in Canada with a significant presence in Surrey, Burnaby,
01:57:23 Richmond, Abbotsford, and Delta. Number three, you got Calgary, Alberta. Calgary has a growing
01:57:28 Indo-Canadian community primarily in the northeastern and eastern parts of the city. Number four,
01:57:32 you got Edmonton, Alberta. Edmonton also has a significant Indo-Canadian population,
01:57:36 mainly concentrated in the southeastern and northern areas. Montreal, Quebec. Montreal has
01:57:41 a sizable indo-canadian community with many residents living in the neighborhoods of park
01:57:46 extension cote de neige and la salle these cities have become hubs for the indo-canadian community
01:57:50 due to their diverse economies educational opportunities and vibrant multicultural
01:57:55 environments top five canadian cities with the most indian population number one top five
01:58:00 canadian cities with the most indian oh my god wow wasn't that great isn't that great news guys
01:58:06 it's amazing don't complain hey if you send the wrong comment if you make the wrong comment
01:58:12 in the comment section of that video you might go to jail okay people might show up at your home
01:58:18 uh you might be put on house arrest actually if we think that you might write the wrong comment
01:58:23 commit a hate speech crime we actually might put you on house arrest anyway uh yeah i i'm sorry to
01:58:31 put you guys through that, but I needed to, uh, go to the bathroom and, oh my God, I played
01:58:39 twice. I'm so sorry, guys. I apologize. I'm back. We're back. What's all these poop emojis
01:58:46 doing here? What are you guys implying? Fat Quinn, fat Quinn glue Google says, Greg needs
01:58:56 some trailer park piss jugs that's gross that's really funny though that that could probably be 0.91
01:59:06 a hook should that be a hook for my streams that i have i have piss jugs and i'll just be here on
01:59:12 camera while i'm going oh is that what you guys want to see i don't know if that would be good 0.99
01:59:19 content that sounds kind of disturbing these Indians have to go back to 0.97
01:59:27 Indiana totally agree man we all came from Indiana okay we've been going for 1.00
01:59:40 about two hours. Um, so let's get through this reaction. Let's keep it going. Let's keep it
01:59:53 going. Take us to the piss jugs. Nope. Nope. No piss jugs. Okay. Have in my view, unfairly 0.95
02:00:04 characterizes thought crimes. Look, I don't like the portions of the bill related to the peace
02:00:08 bond for fear of committing a hate crime. Yeah, not, not my favorite part of the bill. But
02:00:15 it's not. First off, the Harper government put this in and maybe you would know if it's ever
02:00:22 been challenged. The Harper government put this in in one of their last bills in 2015 for fear of
02:00:30 committing terrorism. And it's still on the books. So if it's been challenged, it hasn't been
02:00:36 successfully challenged but there is a requirement that if you're going to try and uh have someone
02:00:44 get a peace bond for fear that they will commit a hate crime you've got to get the attorney general
02:00:49 involved that's a pretty high bar yeah then you've got to take it to a judge and present the evidence
02:00:54 that's a pretty high bar there are at least checks and balances on that that there aren't in other
02:01:00 provisions of this bill, like the Section 13 that we can get into in a moment. I still don't like it,
02:01:06 but do you think that sort of thing would face a challenge or would successfully survive a
02:01:13 challenge? Has this sort of thing been challenged before, this fear of a crime? I mean, that just
02:01:19 leaves me feeling uneasy that you're going to get something for fear of a crime. The thing is that
02:01:24 they have to actually bring evidence to say that that fear is reasonable and is supported. So they
02:01:30 can't simply i don't think that they'd be able to get this on the basis of you have posted online
02:01:35 and you dislike a particular group really you think you simply just think no they would never
02:01:45 do that that would never happen bro that would never happen bro uh i i disagree with you there
02:01:53 runkle um i don't think you know trucker convoy has not come up the different political prisoners
02:01:59 in this country have not come up
02:02:00 where they have used existing laws
02:02:04 to persecute people
02:02:06 who have the wrong opinion.
02:02:09 You have Archer Pervlowski
02:02:10 who got charged with, what,
02:02:12 destroying infrastructure
02:02:13 for simply delivering a sermon
02:02:14 at a protest.
02:02:16 You have Jeremy McKenzie
02:02:18 picking up a whole slew of charges,
02:02:20 all of which have been dropped
02:02:23 or stayed,
02:02:24 and he's a completely innocent man.
02:02:29 he was a very he was one of the probably the most outspoken dissident in the country criticizing
02:02:35 humiliating the rcmp multiple times but they found a way they found a way to make him look 0.88
02:02:42 like a villain based on a bunch of bullshit you don't think they would use this new legislation
02:02:48 to go after dissidents in any way that they can respectfully runkle this is this is the most 0.99
02:02:57 naive that i've seen you here maybe you're not aware of the different political prisoners or
02:03:01 maybe you're don't know the whole story maybe you're not as cynical as me but uh oh they would
02:03:09 never use this legislation to just you know without without evidence and that's what i find so scary
02:03:14 that they're even entertaining this oh no no don't worry bro they need they need evidence they need
02:03:19 to make evidence and make a case and make an argument they've they've made all sorts of
02:03:23 arguments about people they don't like they've said that people are far right and they're evil
02:03:28 and they want to kill us all and they're inherently racist and all this stuff it would not even be that
02:03:33 hard to make make the argument and it comes down to the what the bias attorney general 0.70
02:03:39 to give the go ahead like none of this is making me feel good at all has this sort of thing been
02:03:46 challenged before this fear of a crime i mean that that just leaves me feeling uneasy that
02:03:51 you're going to get something for fear of a crime. The thing is, is that they have to actually bring
02:03:56 evidence to say that that fear is reasonable and is supported. So they can't.
02:04:03 The fear, like, Runkle, is this not, you know, we're getting into the emotions now of like,
02:04:12 hey is your is your fear valid is that a valid fear when has fear actually maybe fear does
02:04:21 probably come up in the law because when it comes to like feeling threatened you need to like
02:04:25 be fearful but um hmm so maybe there is a legal presence for fear anyway let's keep going
02:04:32 simply liquid zoo oh greg please talk to him we'd love to talk to runkle um he sounds like
02:04:39 friendly guy yeah would definitely love to you know after watching this i'll get his take and
02:04:44 i definitely want to ask him some some tough questions about the bill hypotheticals i don't
02:04:50 think that they'd be able to get this on the basis of you have posted online and you dislike a
02:04:56 particular group it would have to be something a little more serious than that because if they
02:05:00 start using it to just police speech then they're going to run into serious charter issues but when
02:05:07 is when has that stopped people in the past you know we we have the whole mandates
02:05:14 the mandates for injections which ended in the trucker convoy that violated our charter rights
02:05:21 did it not no one cared about the charter then you know this this idea that the charter still
02:05:26 means something is is crazy to me we do actually have a number of these provisions that allow for
02:05:32 And the thing is, is like, it's sure there's people putting forth, um, uh, court challenges
02:05:38 right now, using the charter as a precedent to like, you know, like find the government
02:05:41 or whatever it is, but that's not straightforward.
02:05:45 That's not easy.
02:05:46 That costs a lot of money and you're up against the government who has like infinite funds
02:05:51 to defend themselves.
02:05:52 Like, that's not as like, you know, they could still use turn it up a bit.
02:05:58 Sorry.
02:05:58 I'll put my, my, my face closer to the microphone.
02:06:00 having this legislation
02:06:05 in place would allow the government
02:06:07 to pick on people they don't like
02:06:09 and drag them through
02:06:11 accusing them of a future hate crime
02:06:14 and then what
02:06:15 Runkle you're saying that oh but then they could
02:06:17 sue the government after the fact
02:06:19 after their lives have been destroyed for doing nothing
02:06:21 just because someone had a fear that they were going to do something
02:06:24 we're totally skimming over
02:06:26 the insane implications of this
02:06:29 for uh for instance a peace bond if it looks like you're going to get into a fight with somebody
02:06:36 you may never have done so but they they do sometimes impose peace bonds for instance
02:06:41 uh when like two neighbors can't get along and they keep getting into situations
02:06:47 but they do need evidence for that and i don't think we're going to see this used a lot i think
02:06:54 we're assuming it's going to pass i don't think we're going to see this used a lot
02:07:03 why would we why do we need it why do we need to have it why would we want to have a pre-crime bill
02:07:11 a thought it's literally a thought crime bill when you have a big enough fear something's
02:07:16 going to happen then you get to then you get to charge somebody crazy i suspect we'll see
02:07:23 this used actually in situations where people have already committed some sort of hate propaganda
02:07:29 offense or hate crime but hate propaganda offense might be difficult for them to lay out the full
02:07:38 proof or where the circumstances might be such that all right so let me give you an example and 0.94
02:07:44 tell me if i'm on the right track wrong track uh i'm some yahoo some jerk who every weekend goes 0.96
02:07:51 out to a church, the synagogue, a mosque, temple, what have you. And I'm always outside with the 0.98
02:07:58 really nasty slogans. I'm screaming in everyone's face. He's talking about, uh, you know, pro
02:08:04 Palestine or Hamas, Hamas supporters probably hypothetically, but he's, I think he's kind of
02:08:09 anyway, every weekend. Could they eventually just say, you know what? We think he's going to keep
02:08:15 coming back. We need to do something. Is that where this provision would come in or, or is it
02:08:21 something else now the thing is they could probably already use provisions like just the existing peace
02:08:27 bond provisions depending on what it is that you're saying which seems like is a real issue with this
02:08:33 bill is that there's a lot of it where it's there's already provisions in the law yeah i mean one of
02:08:39 the things is that they could put like an electronic monitoring device on you which
02:08:44 that is concerning to me because those are actually incredibly expensive and you pay for
02:08:48 that if they impose it on you um normally you see those on like bail conditions where somebody's
02:08:54 like i will agree to pay for this because otherwise the alternative is that i will
02:08:59 not be let out i'm concerned that they may put these conditions on people and then like
02:09:05 we've imposed on you and you have to pay for it that might be very concerning
02:09:09 and so if you can't pay why is that the most concerning part that you have to pay for it
02:09:13 what why why is having to pay for it the most concerning part not the part about hey we're
02:09:22 we made an argument that we're afraid of you what you might do in the future
02:09:26 uh oh but then he had to he had to pay for his own ankle monitor what injustice pay for it you've
02:09:34 got to stay in jail well they can't really jail you on this because it's a peace bond it's just
02:09:40 like are people going to end up with these debts that can then be enforced i'm not sure how that's
02:09:44 going to end up working but the standards for this i think are going to actually be fairly
02:09:49 high it has to be reasonable ground again think think it's going to be reasonably high
02:09:54 what if everyone involved in the decision making process is totally biased for political reasons
02:10:01 against the person who whatever argument is being made the person who might commit a hate crime in
02:10:06 the future because you can just look at the scenario of the trucker convoy with jeremy mckenzie
02:10:13 or arthur bavlowski or any any other of these uh political dissidents and see how this law would
02:10:21 obviously be used against them obviously and they would work around the clock to make an argument
02:10:26 to get them locked up or monitored with an ankle monitor or what have you just extra
02:10:32 extra legislation to pile on because we already saw them pile on legislation to all these people
02:10:39 who opposed the government agenda during covid we already saw them pile on all sorts of trumped
02:10:45 up charges and the fact that they're not bringing up this angle to this bill of hey remember
02:10:52 political prisoners remember remember political dissidents remember how the government has an
02:10:57 agenda to specifically pick on specific people. The fact that they're not covering this angle is
02:11:03 very, very disappointing. Anyway. For the fear. And usually where you like the main use that you
02:11:10 actually see a peace bonds is situations where somebody has already been charged with a criminal
02:11:15 offense and it gets sort of pled down, even though a peace bond isn't really a plea. So you'll see
02:11:21 situations where like two guys get into a bar fight and instead of saddling them with a criminal
02:11:26 record they'll say how about you guys you know how about you just go on a peace bond and stay
02:11:31 away from that dude maybe get some uh maybe get some treatment you can't both be at billy's bar
02:11:37 on friday and you got to stay away from each other exactly so here you may see situations
02:11:42 where somebody has already committed or likely committed a hate propaganda offense or a hate
02:11:48 crime and instead of going through that full prosecution you may see them imposing this as a
02:11:54 you know as a step down and so it's like rather than proceeding with charges i think that'll be
02:12:00 the main use that you see for this is somebody who's already committed it ian you are are fairly
02:12:06 i don't know this this all feels like it's it's um like all the hypotheticals they're talking
02:12:12 about seems to exist in a world where the government is completely not malicious at all
02:12:19 completely not sort of not ruling with an iron fist at all like you know the the trucker convoy
02:12:26 never happened there's no evidence of political prisoners no it's just going to be how is this
02:12:31 going to affect citizens how how will they use this bill or that bill you know there's nothing
02:12:36 nothing wrong with the government whatsoever um it just i don't know it just seems like a very
02:12:43 sort of innocent uh worldview that they're looking at this this from um as if it's just citizens who
02:12:49 are going to be you know accusing other citizens with it without any sort of political bias any
02:12:54 sort of political agenda at play it's not part of the larger picture whatsoever i mean it would be
02:13:00 really interesting actually to hear runkel's opinion on this bill since everything that's
02:13:04 happening in the uk that's actually a really good place to uh to start from um uh robust in
02:13:13 defending civil liberties you would you would never be charged for criticizing a group of people
02:13:18 people complaining about immigrants in the uk literally getting thrown in jail right now and
02:13:22 charged constantly that would never happen here though and you you seem to be saying
02:13:28 could be some problems with this but don't worry too much about this section
02:13:32 this isn't the part that actually worries me the most so what what does that um things there's
02:13:40 it's largely the the material about what they can take off sorry real quick he doesn't worry you the
02:13:46 most but still as a lawyer as someone who follows legislation and law very closely what other sort
02:13:52 of what is like this part what has existed that is similar to this um part of the legislation
02:14:02 where hey if we make the argument that we're afraid enough that somebody might do something
02:14:07 in the future then we're going to persecute them when has this ever happened in history
02:14:14 like anywhere i don't i don't know that much about the law and the history of law but
02:14:18 again i feel like they're kind of just glossing over this part um
02:14:23 they're saying yeah no if we just if you can make the argument that you think someone's going
02:14:31 to do something bad in the future then yeah we should be able to oh they haven't committed a
02:14:34 crime yet oh yeah yeah i mean a lot of the examples that they use they're just their
02:14:43 example like you know they're i feel like they're really not um there's a naivete in the air in this
02:14:50 conversation especially when you're not considering um the evidence of political prisoners in canada
02:14:56 since uh 2022 offline and what they can um rewind it a bit you know what the the material
02:15:04 most replayed parts coming up most so what what does that um things there's it's largely the
02:15:12 the material about what they can take offline and what they can um you know one of the concerns i
02:15:18 have is actually with the uh the intimate images the revenge porn aspect of things and i think
02:15:25 that that is way too broad it's very and i mean this is one of those things where everyone is
02:15:30 like you shouldn't be doing that you shouldn't be sharing i don't know anyone in favor of revenge
02:15:36 porn except that you will actually if you frame the question right find everyone in favor of
02:15:41 revenge porn okay so what do you think of the sistine chapel beautiful piece of art beautiful 0.91
02:15:49 piece of art and it's actually revenge porn believe it or not uh at least portion of it uh
02:15:55 one of the pope's sort of figures uh was criticizing the painting of it because he felt
02:16:01 that there were too many nudes on it and so michelangelo as a bit of a sort of a you know
02:16:07 take this uh amended one of the figures to put that guy's face on it and then depicted that person
02:16:14 being bitten south of the equator by a snake and that is that's permanently on there it's a nude
02:16:22 figure um and that was specifically done as a screw this guy and it's one that now persists
02:16:29 throughout history but it's also a great work of art is this going to be something that we go
02:16:35 and we know that this person gave no consent to this um there's actually a lengthy history of
02:16:41 using nudity in political commentary, depicting your political opponents as nude, typically
02:16:49 in unflattering ways. We've seen this with Trump, for instance. There's lots of people
02:16:54 who have depicted Trump sort of having a small penis. Obama made a comment about Trump having 0.99
02:17:03 a small penis, I think, the other night at the DNC, the Democratic National Convention. 0.99
02:17:08 in the nude and sort of de-emphasize certain uh body parts well trump has not given his consent 0.98
02:17:16 to that but it also is very broad it is if it is reasonable to suspect that the person had a
02:17:22 reasonable expectation of privacy and the person does not consent to the recording being communicated
02:17:27 well reasonable to suspect is a very very low standard and it doesn't mean that there's no
02:17:35 sort of proof required and so for example if there is um any artificially created image
02:17:43 that depicts somebody in the nude how do you know as if you're the provider how do you know
02:17:48 who this person is there's no requirement to track this person down and so if it just
02:17:54 if somebody creates an image of nobody who actually exists it's just an image of a something
02:18:01 that looks like a person but is not actually duplicating a person and with ai right now
02:18:07 and the image is coming out yep um then the they would have to take that down
02:18:14 notwithstanding the fact that they that there is no actual person who looks like that because the
02:18:19 the organization doesn't know they would say it's reasonable to suspect that this is a person
02:18:25 and so we get into this real thing of policing content and all of this stuff basically they have
02:18:30 have to respond within 24 hours when they get a notice and so we may see a lot of a lot of
02:18:37 situations where people are flagging content and it has to be taken down because there's no way
02:18:43 that they can determine that it's not actually you know intimate content communicated without
02:18:48 consent and that may also apply to things that are not even pornographic because if they have
02:18:53 a 24-hour turnaround and they get something flagged it may well be that the response is
02:18:59 just to take something down so for instance you have your podcast somebody flags it as containing
02:19:05 you know whatever material it might have to be taken down offline until somebody looks at it and
02:19:12 they may not want to go through like if your podcast is an hour they may say it's easier for
02:19:17 us to just take it down and never repost it rather than go through it right so he's talking about how
02:19:24 So when you flag something under this part of the legislation, it would be up to some employee at Facebook or Google to look through the content to make sure it's not like, you know, violating some some crime according to or some content violation according to not Facebook or Google, but to the Canadian government's classification of online content.
02:19:48 see how convoluted that is if you're the facebook employee you have to what watch the content consume
02:19:55 the content make this judgment call um or you can just take it down uh because the consequence of
02:20:02 making the wrong decision is you might have your what your corporation facebook might get find
02:20:09 millions of dollars so a lot easier just to take it down for me as a content creator
02:20:17 your first 24 hours up online, your first 40 hours up online, and you know this from
02:20:23 your very popular YouTube channel, that's when you get most of your views. That's when you get
02:20:28 most of your clicks. And so if you get flagged, if you get essentially swatted, and it's taken
02:20:35 down, you're not getting that back. That's especially, you know, the graph is basically,
02:20:41 it goes straight up and then plateaus in terms of views. You get almost everything within that first
02:20:47 24, 48 hours. And if you have a really good 24 to 48 hours, you can keep going.
02:20:53 But if you don't, it's it's just flat the whole time. Yeah. Oh, absolutely. If you got got hit
02:20:59 in that time and especially you could also consider what if you happen to get the big scoop?
02:21:04 You've got you've got the story no one else has. You know, you get a picture of a politician
02:21:11 like breaking into his ex-wife's house you know something stunning like that yeah you posted online
02:21:18 the pull you know the political party that this targets might have an incentive to make a false
02:21:24 report it gets knocked down for 24 hours everyone's talking about it but you're not getting the
02:21:30 you know you're not getting the traffic of everyone wanting to come and see your pictures
02:21:35 and by the time you get it back online those pictures are probably now everywhere and so
02:21:41 they've managed to effectively punish you for getting this report by preventing you from
02:21:45 successfully monetizing it and if you can't make money in this game then well you're out of
02:21:53 business so well you just keep doing that to if there's a particular news organization that is
02:21:59 critical of a particular party you just keep sniping them every time they try to make money
02:22:04 pretty soon they go to business the abuse potentials for this become very huge
02:22:09 interesting how once again they're talking about the monetary implications
02:22:14 of uh you know having your stuff taken down they never really brought up the i mean they were they
02:22:22 never used the word censorship but like that's kind of it could easily be used that way too
02:22:30 right if there's information that's out there that you don't want out there
02:22:35 that makes xyz look bad um then yeah you get it taken down within 24 hours doesn't go nearly as
02:22:43 viral right so there's censorship potential imagine there was uh you know a government
02:22:50 that wanted to censor its own citizens i know that's kind of like hard it's not part of the
02:22:54 conversation we're having here i'm apparently apparently that's not really coming up but um
02:22:59 imagine a world where the government didn't want to censor its own citizens and had no intention
02:23:06 of doing that ever let me ask you about section 13 coming back i was part of the campaign from
02:23:14 about 05 06 until 2011 i think it was withdrawn uh to get rid of section 13 and
02:23:22 And for this to come back, it seems like the language is trying to be a bit more nuanced.
02:23:32 It's trying to have some parameters around it in ways that it didn't before.
02:23:37 But I'm still concerned about the Human Rights Commission and the Human Rights Tribunal being able to find someone $20,000 based on an anonymous complaint of someone who may or may not have been actually harmed by what was said or done.
02:23:52 um and then it becomes a money-making opportunity for people like we were saying instead of taking
02:23:59 away the monetization ability for a news organization let's say you're making it so
02:24:05 that someone can make 20 grand a pop every time they complain that ian runkel well he said something
02:24:11 i don't agree with ian runkel said something that's against the human rights code and i think
02:24:16 we will, we've already
02:24:18 seen Jessica
02:24:20 Yaniv, for instance, 1.00
02:24:21 filed a bunch of complaints
02:24:23 and has not had a whole lot of success
02:24:26 at the Human Rights Tribunal, but
02:24:28 has filed complaints that
02:24:29 have been found to be unfounded
02:24:32 and apparently for
02:24:34 sort of purposes of
02:24:36 it looks to me like money making.
02:24:38 And so if we see
02:24:40 that kind of practice going
02:24:42 on, you may have bad
02:24:44 actors who are just like, all right,
02:24:46 Let's go, like, sniping these for profit.
02:24:48 But you may also see a lot of reporting just as people saying, well, this is a way to tie someone up.
02:24:57 I don't like what they're saying.
02:25:00 I'll make a complaint.
02:25:02 Now they're tied up in this human rights tribunal stuff.
02:25:05 It can become very difficult to be any sort of political commentator at that point if you're always getting tied up in it.
02:25:12 I think back to Mark Stein's famous case with this. One of the complaints about it was, and this is very timely because we're hitting the month of Ramadan, and this joke only makes sense to you and is only funny if you actually understand Islam in Ramadan.
02:25:31 And one of Mark's comments was, is it just me or does Ramadan come earlier every year?
02:25:39 And of course it does because it comes around every 11 and a half months. 1.00
02:25:42 So yes, that's funny.
02:25:46 But somebody said, no, that's an insult to Islam.
02:25:48 No, it's not.
02:25:49 It comes around earlier every year.
02:25:52 It's a calendar joke.
02:25:53 Yes.
02:25:54 And he was tied up with that for a very long time.
02:26:00 um and that becomes expensive and then you you start self-censoring we saw the case of the
02:26:08 quebecois comedian who made jokes about um a disabled child singer who then ended up having
02:26:15 to go to the supreme court as to whether or not that was um that was a violation
02:26:20 i'm sure that was a a ton of money on the line for for that process um every time somebody is
02:26:30 controversial. And I know that there's people who are going to say, oh, this just affects, you know,
02:26:34 the other people on the side of politics. So I don't care because it'll go after the people I
02:26:40 don't like. It will, I guarantee you, be used against the side that you like as well. So if
02:26:47 you are a right winger, you know, think about what happens if somebody is critical of, you know,
02:26:53 any sort of sexuality, et cetera. If you're on the left, think about what happens when somebody
02:26:59 post something uh in favor of you know diversity equity and inclusion sorts of things all of these
02:27:07 things could be targeted under these provisions and tie people up and we we may end up with a
02:27:14 world where we just can't talk online without people sniping us into court apparently is there
02:27:23 no fight in
02:27:25 Runkle? Like, we may
02:27:27 end up in a world
02:27:28 and you're just going to roll over
02:27:31 and let that happen?
02:27:33 That's so crazy to me.
02:27:35 We may end up in a world where we just can't
02:27:37 talk online anymore.
02:27:40 And you're
02:27:41 okay with that. Or like
02:27:43 you've accepted that that's
02:27:45 our fate. There's nothing we can do.
02:27:48 I guess we're just going to
02:27:49 live in a dystopia.
02:27:51 What
02:27:52 What is this? Come on, man. Like the demoralization in that comment is crazy.
02:28:00 Happens if somebody is critical of, you know, any sort of sexuality, et cetera. If you're on the left, think about what happens when somebody posts something in favor of, you know, diversity, equity and inclusion sorts of things.
02:28:16 All of these things could be targeted under these provisions and tie people up.
02:28:21 And we may end up with a world where we just can't talk online without people sniping us into court. 0.55
02:28:30 Apparently the Human Rights Tribe.
02:28:32 That sounds like such a nightmare. 1.00
02:28:37 We may end up in a world.
02:28:40 Where's the moral outrage?
02:28:42 Can we get morally outraged about something?
02:28:43 Where's the fight?
02:28:44 is the fight where's the oh man he's got the aura he's got the aura we can we can fight this
02:28:51 runcle we can make this go away we gotta fight for it though you know by the way is already
02:28:56 fully backed up without these provisions um so all of this is going to cost us a lot more because
02:29:03 we're gonna have to hire a lot more people to police everything we're saying and doing and
02:29:07 thinking they're all using will it's going this is going to happen when this isn't no no no no
02:29:12 No, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no.
02:29:14 It's not going to pass.
02:29:16 It's not going to pass.
02:29:18 Andy, is this...
02:29:21 I don't deny that either on the child exploitation, the revenge-born side, or on the other side, that there are serious issues here.
02:29:30 But do you get the sense that the government is trying to show that they take it very seriously by having very serious sentences, very serious fines, that they are using a sledgehammer to take on a fly when they could have done this in a much more nuanced way, dealt with the issues that are bothering people in a way that's charter compliant, that doesn't lead to the swatting, and that isn't just about performance?
02:29:59 i would love to see a much more nuanced much more targeted bill and there's no reason why
02:30:07 they can't approach this incrementally they can say listen let's go after the most like the worst
02:30:12 stuff that everyone agrees is bad because there are provisions in here that i think are good
02:30:18 and provisions that i think are well-intentioned that can be later cut you know later fixed in
02:30:25 ways that will the road to hell is paid with good intentions it's got good intentions what does that
02:30:32 ever count for though runkle and legislation who cares if it has good intentions what does it
02:30:37 actually say what's the actual result will make them good but they just want to cover so much
02:30:46 provisions that i think are well intentioned that can be later cut you know later fixed in ways that
02:30:52 will make them good but they just want to cover so much stuff that this ends up including everything
02:31:00 from really really bad content to hurt feelings and it's the hurt feelings area that really can
02:31:07 you know can cause huge problems and it can end up the courts may end up having to look at these
02:31:14 provisions and because they're so broad it can be listen we have to throw out the baby with the
02:31:20 bathwater because you haven't given us any other choice throw it out throw the whole thing out i
02:31:26 agree with that i i think we do need some additional provisions to deal with things like
02:31:32 revenge porn and you know targeted deep fakes and these kinds of things but they have to be
02:31:39 done carefully and they have to be done with nuance and i think this bill needed a lot more
02:31:44 study than it got before it was uh brought forward again so oh well it needs a lot more study a reef
02:31:52 was talking about hey we put so much time into this we put so much time into this years we know
02:32:00 we took years we took years into this bill and we believe that we have struck in the best balance
02:32:05 well runkle disagrees with you a reef oh i have real concerns all right in runkle thank you very
02:32:14 much for your time today and they have to be done with nuance and i think this bill needed a lot
02:32:19 more study than it got before it was i i think we do need some additional provisions to deal with
02:32:26 things like revenge porn and you know targeted deep fakes and these kinds of things i mean just
02:32:34 to be like devil's advocate for this it's like what if we just need to encourage better uh internet
02:32:41 literacy and better sort of you know more cautionary messages to young people of how to
02:32:48 use and consume the internet and i mean at the same time even as i say that i feel like
02:32:53 kids probably on average know more than the grown-ups when it comes to like how to use
02:33:00 the internet and and move around on the internet uh so i do think it's like they're they're kind
02:33:05 of closer to the internet than than the older generation like you know people in their 20s
02:33:11 are much more better versed on internet culture how to disseminate if something is fake or real
02:33:17 or not than the older generations or at least that's what i've found and um yeah i just feel
02:33:24 like this idea of we need to control the internet is totally um misguided because it is you know 0.53
02:33:37 Because it's all it's going to amount to is what you have in China.
02:33:40 At the end of the day, like, you know, maybe it's just like a fallacy to try or it's like it's it's misguided to try and control the Internet because you're always just going to get a greedy government that wants more money and control.
02:33:55 No matter how you cut it.
02:33:57 So it's never going to work because the government is always just going to be looking for more control and money.
02:34:03 you know how how is it ever going to be done law in a lot like a fair and lawful manner
02:34:11 and the other like the major points missed in this conversation was the trucker convoy
02:34:18 political prisoners how there's already evidence of this of the crown persecutors using all sorts
02:34:27 of laws to pin
02:34:29 on political
02:34:31 dissonance, people who have
02:34:32 opinions that are very critical
02:34:35 of the government.
02:34:37 They are already throwing on lots of any
02:34:39 legislation they could. And there's
02:34:41 still political prisoners having to deal with this since the
02:34:43 trucker convoy.
02:34:45 Why did that not come up in the context
02:34:47 of Bill C-63?
02:34:49 All I heard during this whole conversation
02:34:51 was this naive sort of idea of like
02:34:53 no, I mean, it'll
02:34:55 surely if someone is charged for
02:34:57 a pre-crime it won't be done because of this it won't be done just because someone's criticizing
02:35:01 a group of people uh are you sure about that you sure about that because diagonal on jeremy
02:35:11 mckenzie ferryman derrick they were talked about in the news media for that same crime of criticizing
02:35:19 a group of people you know and we we know full well how coordinated the news media is with the
02:35:25 messaging of the liberal government and this idea that bill c63 won't be used as a toolkit
02:35:31 for them to further uh punish people with the wrong opinions is just totally naive to me
02:35:37 it's totally like what planet are you guys living on that that's not a possibility that should be
02:35:44 considered and it's worth mentioning too
02:35:49 that and this is this is an interesting topic i would love to see more people talk about this
02:35:56 topic because it's i was only kind of brought up to me from one the one doctor on the on the west
02:36:02 coast this asian gentleman i forget his name at the moment but he was talking about how you know
02:36:07 lawyers kind of love political prisoners and they love this whole kind of
02:36:12 thing happening since the convoy
02:36:15 because it's a lot of business for them.
02:36:20 We need to talk about the idea
02:36:22 that lawyers are salivating
02:36:24 at the thought of these bills passing.
02:36:29 Because let's face it,
02:36:30 Runkle's a criminal lawyer.
02:36:33 And what do you need?
02:36:34 What does a criminal lawyer need
02:36:36 to stay in business?
02:36:38 He needs criminals.
02:36:39 He needs crimes.
02:36:40 if a legislation is going to be passed to like expand the definition of crime or expand the
02:36:48 reasons why someone might come to him to need his defense that's good for business that's great for
02:36:54 business for these lawyers you know that that that's hey wow why business is great you know
02:37:03 for the whole freedom thing yeah people are kind of getting thrown in jail for their political
02:37:06 opinions and you know persecuted for for having you know much less than committing a crime uh
02:37:12 just kind of saying mean stuff online but uh business business is great for me you know i
02:37:17 just bought a swimming pool just bought a new house bought a new villa in italy you know um
02:37:23 yeah and that and that's and that's a i think it's an important thing to bring up because
02:37:29 yes lawyers are experts lawyers look into this stuff they're very autistic with everything
02:37:34 they also like making money though
02:37:36 and
02:37:39 you probably can't help
02:37:41 but look at it from that perspective
02:37:42 hmm this would be
02:37:45 this would be a great
02:37:47 industry for us
02:37:48 this would be fantastic
02:37:49 but yeah we are
02:37:53 going to wrap it up here guys
02:37:54 thanks for tuning in here
02:37:57 a lot of good some good clips in there
02:38:01 good clips in there hey big super chat from
02:38:02 daryl scurd with five dollars have you seen rowan atkinson's recent comments comparing
02:38:08 britain's new laws with some of his old comedy sketches is that mr bean rowan atkins
02:38:16 atkinson's i think i've seen this clip but i think it was actually kind of from a little while ago
02:38:22 like maybe about a year ago or something like this but i will uh that's a good clip to look
02:38:28 up though i will look up that clip because i know if i'm not mistaken yeah he's talking all about
02:38:33 free speech and this sort of thing um i'll write that in for next time so you don't have to watch
02:38:42 that video of the indian guy talking about how we're being invaded um kelly lloyd says good
02:38:54 points greg thank you for the stream yeah thanks for tuning in if you guys want to support free
02:38:58 speech uh if you want to help us save free speech then please go to give send go.com
02:39:05 save free speech help fund our documentary it's in the works it's really good we've been releasing
02:39:10 some clips on our channels and this goes to pay the editors this goes to pay the people producing
02:39:16 this fine piece of content that's going to expose what bill c63 is actually about uh we need to
02:39:23 have that information out there so we can arm the canadian public to resist this bill whoa big
02:39:30 donation from kim and kevin watson with a hundred dollars we have to stop this insane bill so true
02:39:37 thank you for the huge donation kim and kevin watson really appreciate it and i totally agree
02:39:43 i totally agree and i do want to shout out this uh this this donation from the other night i really
02:39:47 liked his message. We don't stop this by giving in. Our only chance is to fight it. I'll take a
02:39:53 slim chance over no chance. Exactly. Exactly. Let's fight it. Let's throw it out. Let's throw
02:40:01 it out. Edgy DTV says shout outs Juan's butter. He's actually based to subscribe to don't talk
02:40:10 TV. Greg, you should interview him. Yeah, I heard he's another lawyer who's been talking about this
02:40:15 bill um greg have christine on from canadian constitution foundation that's another good idea
02:40:22 another great idea absolutely there's a there's a lot of people we could talk to about this bill
02:40:28 although there's a lot of there's a lot of videos i need to uh well there's a couple of
02:40:36 very important videos that i need to make and they need to be very good um and which is the
02:40:44 really the bread and butter of what we do at savefreespeech.ca which is to make these videos
02:40:50 ringing the alarm bells explaining the bill so i might stream next week but that's something that
02:40:58 i really need to that's really a priority for us for me at savefreespeech.ca to get those videos
02:41:04 out and there's a lot of stuff that i need to do on that front but um thank you for hanging out in
02:41:11 chat i saw some really nice comments lampshade etiquette said thanks greg we're we all thank
02:41:17 you for everything you're doing appreciate it happy to do it voltman platonomist says the
02:41:24 government doesn't care about charters and rights look at the coots four yeah exactly exactly yeah
02:41:29 the coot like the coots four didn't come up these are people man it's it's crazy how they did not 0.69
02:41:35 bring up in that conversation
02:41:37 anything about political prisoners
02:41:39 in this country
02:41:39 the naivety is crazy
02:41:42 the naivete
02:41:44 is insane
02:41:45 but no it's good
02:41:49 it's good we're talking about it we're making it
02:41:51 happen
02:41:51 yeah
02:42:00 thanks for all your comments
02:42:03 we're going to wrap it up here
02:42:04 really appreciate it
02:42:06 yeah also if we're also
02:42:09 on Twitter
02:42:09 at save free speech sorry that's not the
02:42:13 ad the ad is SFS
02:42:15 Canada
02:42:15 SFS Canada
02:42:18 follow us on the Twitter
02:42:20 we are the same thing on the Facebook
02:42:22 Facebook.com slash SFS
02:42:25 Canada
02:42:26 and we're also on Instagram
02:42:29 we have some really cool stuff cooking up
02:42:31 that
02:42:32 might be out by next week.
02:42:35 It'll either be out by next week or
02:42:36 beginning of September, but it's going to be a really good
02:42:39 thing. Talking about the gender 1.00
02:42:41 ideology. Talking about
02:42:43 SOGI. 0.93
02:42:46 Talking about
02:42:47 Antifa.
02:42:49 And obviously how it all relates to
02:42:51 Bill C-63.
02:42:54 We gotta get rid of this
02:42:55 naivete. Gotta get rid of this
02:42:57 naivete. All this
02:42:59 naiveness around this bill is
02:43:01 crazy. It's killing me.
02:43:02 It's driving me crazy, guys.
02:43:05 Crazy.
02:43:07 But hey, thanks again for tuning in.
02:43:11 Where is our song, Greg?
02:43:13 You want me to play a song?
02:43:20 What time is it?
02:43:24 I could maybe play a quick song.
02:43:30 There is a new song.
02:43:31 I don't know if it's ready to be played yet
02:43:36 But
02:43:36 If Lee's requesting a song
02:43:40 I'll play a new song that I've been tinkering on
02:43:43 Alright
02:43:58 Give me a sec to set up here
02:44:01 Where's my pics at? 0.85
02:44:31 where's my tutor at hold on folks hold on okay there's the pig
02:45:01 All right, I'll just do a little fashion way
02:45:31 tuner we don't need no stinking tuners nah it's a good habit to tune
02:45:42 this is the old-fashioned way from idea to submission empower
02:45:48 back in my day
02:46:01 Guys, we're going to react to this tuning video.
02:46:08 Ready?
02:46:18 Yeah, is that loud enough or what?
02:46:19 Is that loud enough?
02:46:25 I think I just need...
02:46:31 Thank you.
02:47:01 Thank you, Greg.
02:47:02 I'm starting from the beginning, and I'll try to leave a meaningful comment.
02:47:06 Appreciate that.
02:47:07 My E is scuffed, says Edgy DTV. 0.99
02:47:12 You're crazy. 0.99
02:47:16 Good enough for me. 1.00
02:47:22 All right.
02:47:25 All right.
02:47:26 So this is, have you guys heard of Beck, the artist Beck?
02:47:31 This is a cover of, uh, or like a parody, I guess.
02:47:35 It's not that funny of a parody, but it's just kind of like a rewrite of one of his songs.
02:47:50 Yeah, okay, let's try this.
02:47:53 Okay.
02:47:53 Okay. 1.00
02:47:56 Tonight, the city is full of Jeets.
02:47:59 And the toilets are overflowing 0.99
02:48:03 A child rapist gets a slap on the wrist 1.00
02:48:08 If they have the darker of skin 1.00
02:48:12 That's right 1.00
02:48:16 It's anti-white 0.99
02:48:20 It's anti-white 1.00
02:48:24 Yeah, they hate whites 0.99
02:48:28 Give the finger to the rock and roll singer 1.00
02:48:38 As he spits upon your history
02:48:41 Crosses torn down through the blood-soaking ground
02:48:46 And on the TV tells you to hate yourself
02:48:50 That's right 0.99
02:48:53 It's anti-white 0.99
02:48:57 There's rising crime 0.99
02:49:02 Open your eyes
02:49:06 So get out your lead pipe pipe dreams
02:49:14 Get out your ten foot flags
02:49:18 The insects are huge and they rain over you
02:49:23 And the drugs won't save your daughters 0.98
02:49:27 and sons, that's right, it's anti-white, it's not far right, it's just anti-white. 0.96
02:49:49 I'll do the first verse again. 0.98
02:49:51 Tonight, the city is full of jeets and the toilets are overflowing. 0.97
02:50:01 Child rapists get a slap on the wrist if they have the darker color of skin. 0.99
02:50:11 That's right, it's anti-white. 0.99
02:50:18 There you go. Hey, you can blame Lee. You can blame Lee for forcing me to sing that 0.87
02:50:39 song yeah if you're curious no not trying to show you the ad
02:51:00 it's a song from Beck
02:51:07 from one of his like
02:51:09 first albums
02:51:11 the feeling of not jogging
02:51:13 the feeling of winning number one