Greg Wycliffe - November 22, 2024


Reacting to Arif Virani Answer Questions about Bill C-63

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Bernie Farber from Canadian Anti-Hate Network wants gun ownership to be dependent on your politics Subversive Conservatives in Canada need to be called out | Wyatt Claypool ep. 1

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 45 minutes

Words per minute

173.33

Word count

18,302

Sentence count

392

Harmful content

Misogyny

20

sentences flagged

Toxicity

124

sentences flagged

Hate speech

60

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Live stream from Canada Youth Internet Governance Forum, where Arif Varani spoke about Bill C-63 and the Canadian Anti-Hate Network's campaign against it. We talk about why we should all be concerned about this bill and why it needs to be stopped.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Thank you.
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 okay okay okay okay okay okay okay okay how's everybody we're going to be be doing a short
00:01:19 shorter stream tonight just want to react to some content with a reef verani talking about
00:01:25 bill c63 i might kind of touch on a few couple things before that i know it's earlier than usual
00:01:31 it's a little earlier than it usually is uh it's just what we're doing right now just what we're
00:01:36 doing right now hope everyone's well kev b47 katherine grant mika shrednik dj cameron de
00:01:44 beats cameron de beat says hey greg love you my friend i love you too thanks for watching
00:01:49 uh you know we get it we get it we understand how bad things really are in the country and i you
00:01:57 know i was talking to somebody earlier uh today about this how um it's it's very rare to find
00:02:06 somebody in canada who sees how bad truly things are they recognize how bad truly things are they're
00:02:13 not delusional thinking that Pierre Polyev is going to solve our problems. And they're also not
00:02:19 full of fear and rage and like, can't, can't think of a positive solution of what to do
00:02:28 with their time and energy. And, you know, I've seen this, especially since COVID and the trucker
00:02:35 convoy, where the people that get it, the people that see who admit and confess how bad truly
00:02:41 things are unfortunately a lot of them i feel are still kind of scattered they're afraid or you
00:02:47 know they're they're not focused on an actual constructive solution or they're not optimistic
00:02:53 and to be fair it's not easy it's really not easy to uh to bear the burden of seeing how bad things
00:02:59 are in this country and actually coming up with something uh worthwhile but that being said
00:03:05 different groups are coming up with things that have a more long-term kind of uh solution to it
00:03:11 that's a big reason i started savefreespeech.ca to focus my efforts on something i think worthwhile
00:03:17 which is to campaign against bill c63 and it's going really well you know i started it back in
00:03:23 uh technically july but really august is when i really started to put a lot of time into it
00:03:27 and we're making a documentary which is very exciting the the fundraiser by the way is at
00:03:33 $12,000, which
00:03:36 is amazing. We got another $100
00:03:37 donation last night.
00:03:39 I got word from another bigger donor
00:03:41 that we're going to get another $1,000 donation
00:03:43 in here soon as well, which is amazing.
00:03:46 Anonymous Giver says, glad someone
00:03:47 is fighting this fight. Keep it up. But yeah, if you
00:03:49 want to support what we're doing to stop
00:03:51 Bill C-63 and to discredit
00:03:53 the smear merchants in Canada,
00:03:56 the Canadian Anti-Hate Network, then
00:03:57 go to GiveSang0.com slash
00:03:59 SaveFreeSpeech.
00:04:02 What's new? What's new
00:04:03 with the website glad you asked by the way um if you go to the news tab on saferesiege.ca we
00:04:09 recently posted antifa communists are targeting canadian gun owners yes they are made a whole
00:04:18 video about this this this video i made is a week or two old but i wanted to kind of like
00:04:22 post it in a in an article for people to see and understand uh the politics of these people
00:04:30 and precisely what their attitude is.
00:04:32 And these are the same people behind Bill C-63, you guys.
00:04:35 These are the same people behind Bill C-63.
00:04:39 This would be, the enforcement of Bill C-63
00:04:42 would not be anything other than completely political partisanship.
00:04:47 It would be used for political suppression.
00:04:49 We've already seen that since the convoy, right?
00:04:53 So this bill needs to be stopped.
00:04:56 I don't see much energy from the Conservative Party
00:04:58 to truly push back against this bill or throw out this bill.
00:05:02 But yeah, with that being said, let's get into it.
00:05:05 Let's get into the video we're going to react to here,
00:05:09 which maybe I should actually bring up the fuller context just for the record.
00:05:17 So this is a live stream from Canada Youth Internet Governance Forum.
00:05:23 And they had a guest speaker, which was Arif Varani.
00:05:27 and we're going to react to that now
00:05:30 let me quickly look at the chat hey everybody how's it going
00:05:35 mother of the drummer big d how's it going great north roofer this country died nine years ago
00:05:42 oof oof i mean you can definitely make that argument you can definitely make that argument
00:05:48 um and yeah i mean i'm hoping that this is the beginning of the tsn turning point
00:05:57 kind of the convoy was the tsn turning point we just don't know it yet uh i talked about this
00:06:02 with randy hillier on our interview uh was that yesterday seems like a long time ago
00:06:07 i guess it was two nights ago uh did an interview with randy hillier and uh i talked about how i
00:06:14 think a lot of the seeds were planted a lot of seeds were planted at the convoy the mask fell
00:06:18 off of what this canadian government what their true character is because let's not forget that
00:06:23 the conservative party was essentially on board with all of the lockdowns that took the rights
00:06:28 away of unvaccinated Canadians where you couldn't travel couldn't do anything the conservative
00:06:32 party both major parties were on board with this and um yeah the seeds were planted Canadians saw
00:06:38 how bad things really are and I think we're going to see the fruits of those seeds not right away
00:06:43 it's going to take some time it's going to take some years but I think that's that's really the
00:06:47 beginning of the TSN turning point because I'll say my whole life I wondered what does it mean
00:06:53 to be Canadian what does that really mean is it just maple syrup what does it mean and I saw it
00:06:58 at the convoy I felt it I experienced it it's real uh and that's for the first time ever that
00:07:06 I felt I had really felt it and seen it and experienced it so yeah that was that was the
00:07:12 TSN turning point let's uh all right let's do this let's play this I want to make sure the volume
00:07:17 is not too loud it's digital policy in canada it's a little louder today our keynote speaker
00:07:23 minister will discuss this act all right i gave the introduction already so let's get into it
00:07:29 it's about uh 30 minutes he answers some questions about bill c63 let's get into it let's go let's
00:07:34 freaking go and what it means for canadian youth it is my absolute pleasure to introduce the
00:07:41 honorable minister of justice and attorney general of canada ari frani please join me
00:07:47 in welcoming the minister
00:07:57 big av bigger reef let's go buddy what dana neglected to mention is that i'm also her local mp
00:08:04 which is uh which means we both live in the best area of the city if not the country which is park
00:08:08 delhi park uh but how is everyone doing this morning best area of the city good
00:08:12 Fun fact, I actually ran against Arif Varani in 2019 when I ran for the PPC.
00:08:22 I was actually at the debate table against this guy.
00:08:27 Let me tell you, he's a dangerous politician.
00:08:29 He's a very smooth talker.
00:08:30 He's very good at what he does.
00:08:32 And that's why it's really important for this project, SaveFreeSpeech.ca,
00:08:38 because, you know, this guy isn't like a Stephen
00:08:41 Gilboa bumbling around looking 1.00
00:08:43 like some sketchy idiot. 1.00
00:08:44 No, he's actually quite good at what he does. 1.00
00:08:47 But, I mean, thankfully
00:08:49 for us,
00:08:51 he's, you know, he's lying
00:08:52 because he's for the Liberal Party and
00:08:54 a lot of the stuff he says doesn't
00:08:57 make sense and it's very easy to poke holes in his
00:08:58 arguments and that's what we're going to do now.
00:09:01 So,
00:09:02 I was actually asking a friend
00:09:04 for a clip because in one of the debates
00:09:06 when I was a 2019 candidate,
00:09:08 uh, the, the, the NDP candidate and the green party candidate, they turned their backs on me
00:09:15 every time that I was speaking at a debate. It was quite an experience for those who don't know
00:09:20 the, some of the background or lore. Great North roofer says parliament looks like kindergartners
00:09:26 fighting over who took whose last cookie out of the jet out of the jar. Just a, just a joke
00:09:31 government. Yeah. It's a, it's pretty bad. It's pretty bad, isn't it? It's not getting any better
00:09:37 too and i think more and more canadians are like seeing through it like i think the canadians who
00:09:41 have been following politics for a while have been seeing through it um and i think apolitical
00:09:46 canadians see it and they're like huh this doesn't seem very authentic why is why are all of our
00:09:52 canadian politicians running around talking about different foreign interests every single day like
00:09:57 more and more it seems like 75 percent of the conversation had by the political class i'm
00:10:05 talking media pundits i'm talking politicians 75 of what they're talking about in canada is a
00:10:10 foreign issue or a foreign conflict or a foreign group so rare is it just about like a real canadian
00:10:18 issue affecting canadians if it is it's always just like housing or taxes it's never about the
00:10:23 canadian people right i think that's a very interesting distinction it's never the canadian
00:10:27 people but it's like the foreign people this foreign group this distinct foreign group of
00:10:32 people, identifiable group, but it's never the Canadian people and how they've been affected
00:10:38 and disenfranchised and their statues are being torn down and their churches are burning.
00:10:43 Right?
00:10:43 Like none of that even hits, none of that hits the radar, none of that, that hardly
00:10:46 even is a part of the conversation.
00:10:49 Anyway, we know this already, guys.
00:10:51 If you're watching, you already know this stuff.
00:10:53 We know, Greg, move on.
00:10:55 I'm so happy to be among you today for this event and for this discussion.
00:11:00 The second thing I want to do is just acknowledge
00:11:05 you've already started your conference, but I will acknowledge the territory that we are on.
00:11:08 This is the traditional territory of the Haudenosaunee, the Wendat, the Anishinaabeg, and most recently
00:11:13 the Mississaugas of the Credit. I always
00:11:15 insist on doing land acknowledgments, but as we approach September 30th, which is our third
00:11:21 annual day for truth and reconciliation, we should all be reflective
00:11:24 about what we can do to advance reconciliation in this country.
00:11:28 so yeah just by making that comment right we're going to we're going to save indigenous people
00:11:33 by virtue signaling this stuff is so silly but it is worth noting that a lot of what props up
00:11:40 the importance of bill c63 is a lot of the i'll call crudely woke politics it's a lot of the
00:11:46 identity politics so much of hate speech is dependent on hating only specific groups of
00:11:52 people uh in this case you know you're allowed to hate white people you're you're allowed to hate
00:11:58 canadian history because it's just genocidal as he just mentioned that's basically the implication
00:12:03 um and a lot of the actual uh verbiage or the legal jargon in bill c63 and and really across
00:12:10 the world when it comes to hate speech in western countries it's identifiable groups they use this
00:12:15 term identifiable groups you're not allowed to hate identifiable groups and it essentially implies
00:12:20 you know any type of minority uh that's where the hatred's going to come from and the kind of
00:12:25 implication is that you can't really hate white people that's not really a uh that's not uh really
00:12:31 going to hit the radar of this hate speech laws i've made other content about this you've probably
00:12:36 seen cool papa j magic says hate speech means speech that contradict speech that contradicts
00:12:42 anti-whitism. Yeah, I mean, you could say that. Lee Stewie
00:12:49 says, Arif Arani is if you ordered Justin Trudeau from
00:12:53 Timu. Yeah. Yeah, he's the brown. He's the brown Justin
00:12:58 Trudeau. It's really important for me to be here. It's really
00:13:03 important also for me to be listening to you. I appreciate
00:13:05 you want to hear from me and I'm happy to discuss aspects of
00:13:08 the bill that I've been promoting in Parliament these
00:13:11 past several months uh which is a really important piece of legislation but i think i just wanted to
00:13:16 underscore at the outset your ideas and input are also critical to me in terms of uh helping to
00:13:22 perfect what i think is already a good bill but not a perfect bill in terms of what can be done
00:13:27 to improve it and make it ah okay and we'll see it's not a perfect bill but it's a good bill so
00:13:33 they're already setting this up to you know revising it in committee but um with the help
00:13:39 us say freespeech.ca we're just going to tell them to throw the whole thing out okay to use that
00:13:43 i've made a tweet about this but essentially the anything anything that's good
00:13:48 anything that they deem is good in bill c63 is already redundant they say we're going to stop
00:13:57 things like child pornography that's already illegal that's already flagged by big tech
00:14:03 platforms big tech already has a system to flag content and take down content quickly
00:14:10 so anything on bill c63 that is a positive thing of oh we want to take down harmful content big
00:14:17 tech already does that oh we want to take down illegal content that stuff's already illegal
00:14:21 that's that stuff is already you know managed and and targeted by law enforcement so any of
00:14:28 the sort of virtue of why we need to do something it's already taken care of for the most part by
00:14:33 big tech or our existing legal system so it's very redundant any of the good things about bill
00:14:40 c63 are completely redundant there's nothing actually good and uh productive in this bill
00:14:45 whatsoever other than a lot of the the rhetoric around there's a lot of rhetoric around it right
00:14:52 that says it's over to protect kids it's all just it's all hot air in terms of just sort of at the
00:14:57 outset in terms i'm just gonna pour myself a bit of water yeah you're gonna need that bud you're
00:15:03 going to need some water to get through this uh this train wreck you i need to uh i need to i need 0.74
00:15:10 to you know moisten my i need to drink some water before i spew all this bullshit really helps
00:15:15 let's do a land acknowledgement sort of setting up sort of where things are at and i appreciate 0.87
00:15:20 many people in this room are a lot younger than me i am a tender age of 52 i've got the bald spot
00:15:26 back here to prove it but it's a it's a different world that many of you have grown up in compared
00:15:31 to the world that i grew up in and i appreciate that world comes with challenges i also i think
00:15:36 he's losing his hair because he's so stressed because he's lying all the time that's my theory
00:15:39 on why he has a bald spot anyway appreciate as a father raising two young boys the challenges that
00:15:44 every young person faces in terms of adjusting sort of finding their voice and sort of coming
00:15:49 to terms and sort of as they embrace adulthood and that's quick question arif do you think uh
00:15:55 kids spending seven hours a day on a screen is going to help them help your child develop properly
00:16:01 because throughout this entire conversation on bill c63 not once have i seen a liberal party
00:16:09 member a referani anybody advocating for the bill saying that hey maybe we should spend less time
00:16:15 online that's never something in the conversation it's always just like well we spend eight to ten
00:16:22 hours a day on the internet nothing we can do about that so we better get the government to
00:16:26 babysit us while we do that because because this is i bring this up because if you're a parent you
00:16:33 are concerned about how much time you're spending kids are spending online and what they might be
00:16:37 looking at online but no like it's so it's a genuine concern it's a genuine concern but with
00:16:44 this bill no one is saying hey maybe kids should be online less you know that's never a part of
00:16:50 the conversation which i think is the actual the real sort of um like a genuine talking point a
00:16:58 genuine sentiment that i think a lot of parents have that i think should be addressed and back
00:17:02 to my campaign in 2019 i actually had that as my own sort of policy because when you run for the
00:17:07 ppc you can kind of make up your own policy if you want say hey this is what i would do if i was in
00:17:11 power and i talked about how i would put a lot of money into researching the effect of devices and
00:17:18 internet on young people probably adults too but also young people like like doing the research to
00:17:23 say hey are these like cigarettes are giving smartphones to kids kind of like giving cigarettes
00:17:29 to kids should we look into this and i'm sure you would find you know because i made the joke of
00:17:35 like hey i'm a grown man and i'm addicted to my phone i said that in a debate and everybody laughed
00:17:39 and i'm like it's actually not that funny because we're giving devices to children and there's you
00:17:44 know they're spending more of their waking hours looking at a screen than living in reality and
00:17:50 like kicking a soccer ball around and just kind of like using their their their flesh vehicle
00:17:56 no they're they're just in the device so again like that's a genuine concern that parents have
00:18:02 no one talking about bill c63 is addressing this at all it's just a bunch of fear-mongering
00:18:07 uh about um about other stuff you know it's just taken for granted well kids spend over seven hours
00:18:15 a day online that means we got the government's gotta babysit them cool
00:18:19 great north roofer says my boys are teens and both don't have cell phones uh based this is like
00:18:28 i really man i always ask a parent or a teacher when i meet them what's your policy what's your
00:18:38 protocol for devices what are we doing with these devices and kids because i've seen i've seen you
00:18:44 know parents who i know and you know the kid will be there and they're young and they're just like
00:18:48 swiping away on the ipad and i'm like i just get this feeling of like i don't i feel like there
00:18:53 should be more i don't know if that's going to be good for the you know a toddler but um
00:19:00 cool papa j magic says are you running for office of some kind greg wycliffe that would be so cool
00:19:07 we need good folks like you to speak for us on the government level i ran in 2019 at this point
00:19:13 i'm not going to be running in the immediate future i could in the future um right now i want
00:19:19 to focus on the culture i want to focus on content i'm producing a documentary right now
00:19:24 uh to expose uh the censorship industry to expose things that are happening in this country
00:19:31 and i think a lot a lot of work needs to be done so i'm focusing my efforts on that right now
00:19:37 because i think that's kind of the best place to put my efforts to kind of sway the cultural
00:19:41 conversation um i think getting out there and being a politician and running is very important
00:19:47 And shout-outs to all the people who are running for the PPC
00:19:49 because I really feel that is sort of like you're knocking doors,
00:19:53 you're starting conversations, you're getting involved in the community.
00:19:55 It's like one of the best things you can do to get the word out there
00:19:58 and to let people know, hey, like-minded people like you are out there.
00:20:01 We're here.
00:20:02 We have a professional organization, the PPC. 1.00
00:20:05 And I think that's a really good stepping stone to red pill people 1.00
00:20:09 and to get them into our world of really finding out what's going on. 0.50
00:20:13 And knowing that there's just like normal like-minded Canadians
00:20:15 who are really concerned about what's going on.
00:20:18 But yeah, that being said,
00:20:19 if you want to help me produce bigger and better content,
00:20:23 then go to givesenggo.com slash savefreespeech, okay?
00:20:27 How much is free speech worth to you?
00:20:30 Is it worth the price of a coffee or buying me lunch?
00:20:34 Because, you know, you can help save free speech,
00:20:38 stop this bill just for a small donation like that.
00:20:41 They add up, guys.
00:20:42 They add up.
00:20:43 Anyway, let's get back into this reaction.
00:20:45 the trepidest sort of route for any person sort of I think 10 to 25 ish anywhere they are in the
00:20:57 world whatever era we're talking about but this is a very specific time that we're in and a specific
00:21:02 moment that we're in I think that's really important to underscore and what I want to also
00:21:08 emphasize is that the safety concerns that have been expressed to me are safety concerns that I
00:21:14 see that I hear about, but also ones that I'm personally sort of privy to. And what do I mean
00:21:21 by that? I mean that I cannot divorce my work on this bill from sort of who I am and what I
00:21:26 represent. So you can see right now, he's taken a moment to like, slow down to breathe, he needs to
00:21:33 get emotional, he needs to sell this so so much of, I mean, a lot of the, you know, whatever you 0.98
00:21:39 want to call it left-wing tyranny a lot of the the bullshit that they use to take our rights away 0.89
00:21:45 it's it hinges on this emotional argument of safety and bill c63 is no different so you can 0.94
00:21:51 see you can see he's kind of getting a bit emotional because he's about to tell us how
00:21:54 much of a victim he is because of the color of his skin even though he has the salary of a you know
00:22:01 member of parliament probably lives in the nice area of parkdale high park not the crappy area of
00:22:06 park there high park because there is a very huge distinction of of income in that riding it's
00:22:12 actually very interesting um because you have you have you know a poorer population that genuinely
00:22:17 wants socialism and then you have like super rich people who are like champagne socialists
00:22:21 so uh anyway it's it's quite interesting but let's get ready let's hear about how much of a victim
00:22:28 and how sad it is and how hard it is to be Arif Varani.
00:22:36 So, yes, I'm a parliamentarian.
00:22:38 Yes, I'm a lawyer.
00:22:39 It's good to have an attorney general that's a lawyer.
00:22:41 But I'm also an individual who came here as a refugee from Uganda in 1972.
00:22:46 I'm also a Muslim racialized man.
00:22:48 Racialized. 0.59
00:22:49 I'm raising two Muslim racialized boys.
00:22:52 And I think in terms of when we embrace...
00:22:56 What does that mean, racialized? 0.83
00:22:58 They're racialized 0.89
00:23:00 You know, I could see 1.00
00:23:02 This is going to be a crude example
00:23:03 But I could see if there's like, you know 1.00
00:23:05 An interracial marriage
00:23:10 It's like, they got racialized 0.99
00:23:12 You know, they got racialized
00:23:14 But, you know, if you're like a Muslim couple
00:23:17 And you have a Muslim child
00:23:19 Are they racialized? 1.00
00:23:21 Aren't they just like 0.99
00:23:21 Aren't they just Muslim? 0.98
00:23:24 What does that mean?
00:23:27 What does that mean?
00:23:28 they're racialized anyway let's let's continue online safety we have to understand sort of what
00:23:35 people are facing in terms of where they are how they look what they represent what they're trying 0.94
00:23:40 to articulate and that looks different for somebody who's indigenous it looks different
00:23:43 for somebody who's lgbtq it looks different for someone who's black for somebody who's racialized
00:23:48 for somebody who's a religious minority it's i've it's i this is a stale talking point but it's it's
00:23:55 just so ironic how it's like everyone is so different everyone has totally a different
00:24:00 perspective and like that's really that's a crucial thing you guys it's so it's so important
00:24:06 to recognize how just how different everybody is any anyway it's it's really leading up to the you
00:24:15 know people are bigger victims or people are targeted for how they look like blah blah blah
00:24:18 but uh anyway because there's a lot going on online and a lot of it is cloaked under an
00:24:25 anonymity that emboldens people uh to really challenge people other people's safety and i
00:24:33 think a lot of you pardon sorry hold up pardon pardon pardon uh boomer alert boomer alert
00:24:41 i mean boomer in a in a loving way i mean boomer as in like here's somebody who doesn't
00:24:48 understand how the internet really works and what the internet is let's hear that again do we have
00:24:53 to understand sort of what people are facing in terms of where they are how they look what they
00:24:57 represent what they're trying to articulate and that looks different for somebody who's indigenous
00:25:02 it looks different for somebody who's lgbtq it looks different for someone who's black for
00:25:06 somebody who's racialized for somebody who's a religious minority because there's a lot going on
00:25:12 online and a lot of it is cloaked under an anonymity yeah that's what the internet is
00:25:18 there's a lot there's a lot that goes on on the internet and a lot of it is is cloaked in
00:25:24 anonymity okay welcome to the internet that emboldens people uh to really challenge people
00:25:33 other people's safety it's it's okay so it's the internet though so it kind of just happens
00:25:39 online so it's like it challenges people's safety that's a that's a good one what does that mean
00:25:46 a reef something challenges challenges your safety don't you mean challenges like your
00:25:53 you feeling apps it challenges your sense of feeling absolutely comfortable like everything
00:25:59 is totally fine so it's sort of disturb it disturbs what it it disturbs your worldview
00:26:05 it challenges your safety challenges your safety this guy should have drank more water before 0.94
00:26:14 giving this presentation i'm i'm thinking bullshit i'm thinking he didn't have notes for this 0.54
00:26:18 okay so let's see we we still got 25 more minutes of this struggle session of him pulling stuff out 0.99
00:26:24 of his ass don't worry there's no nudity but you know there is going to be some graphic moments 0.99
00:26:28 It's where Ari Farani is pulling obscene things from his backside. 1.00
00:26:35 But let's continue.
00:26:37 And I think a lot of you in this room can understand what I'm speaking about.
00:26:40 But the online world has become increasingly unsafe.
00:26:43 And I want to pause for...
00:26:44 It's unsafe!
00:26:46 Don't go online!
00:26:47 Don't pick up your phone!
00:26:49 It's not safe, guys!
00:26:50 It's the internet! 0.77
00:26:52 The only thing that's unsafe about the internet are, I don't know, the scammers, the Jeets 1.00
00:26:57 who are scamming people all the all the phishing things like you know most dangerous place on your 1.00
00:27:02 internet is probably your inbox it's probably it's probably you know when when someone's you
00:27:08 know trying to scam you out of money or out of your personal data that yeah maybe it's a little
00:27:15 unsafe there but uh what he's about to go into is hilarious it's like don't open your phone
00:27:20 you're gonna find something that's offensive and offend you yeah that's why i'm going on that's
00:27:26 why i'm going on the internet i want to see something interesting i want to see something
00:27:29 offensive i want to be entertained hello a moment to reflect on if you guys i hope there are some
00:27:37 nerds in the room i presume there's a few who've been following sort of this legislation closely
00:27:41 but when i tabled it it was either the 26th or 27th of february and i was at a podium like this
00:27:47 and they're surrounded by a lot of fellow parliamentarians um but also i was flanked
00:27:52 by a few here comes the sob story he's going to weaponize the sob story that he used when he first
00:27:57 tabled this bill two different people and one of the persons i was flanked by was a woman named
00:28:01 elise bovay you don't need to know her name but i hope you do remember her name but elise bovay
00:28:07 is a black woman from montreal a francophone who dared to enter the fray of discussions about
00:28:13 systemic racism and anti-black racism in the way listen to that verbiage she dared to enter the
00:28:20 fray of talking about racism on the internet like that's so dramatic she she went on reddit
00:28:30 okay she she went on reddit she went on twitter and she tweeted she dared to go into the fray of
00:28:38 online discourse like you're like man you're really making me seem like like every twitter
00:28:45 warrior who goes on and makes a tweet is some valiant brave revolutionary commenter
00:28:52 they entered the fray no you tweeted you were taking a dump and you and you posted something
00:28:59 on the internet i i entered the fray that's so funny wake of george floyd and what elise bovay
00:29:08 faced was intense backlash so much so that at least beauvais sort of resiled from that discussion 0.89
00:29:16 wow she got ratioed okay so so she posted on the internet people responded uh because she
00:29:25 couldn't handle it she resiled from communicating with anyone physically or online uh resiled into
00:29:31 herself and uh it affected her anxiety levels her trauma levels depression you name it and i
00:29:38 reason it affected her trauma levels trauma levels we might need it lee we might need a new uh do i
00:29:46 have the image here oh come on oh crap oh yeah no i have it here we need it we need another graphic
00:29:57 like this for trauma levels what's your trauma level at my trauma levels are rising it's so
00:30:04 traumatic that i can identify the exact level of trauma that i'm going through uh no but this
00:30:09 graphic is the um like the hate how hateful something is because essentially bill c63 for
00:30:16 you if you guys don't know they want to make detestation uh illegal like it's it's it's it's
00:30:22 criminal hate speech to detest something in speech so they're like no no you can still disdain
00:30:29 something you can still dislike something you can still humiliate something but you can't you
00:30:33 can't detest it though you can't vilify it those are the that's the line in the sand any questions 0.92
00:30:39 yeah i have a question how the fuck do you determine that and uh you know we have we have 0.88
00:30:45 an image like this as a joke of course but it's terrifying because this is supposed to be the law 0.98
00:30:49 this is what they want to put into law and you think that a lawyer you think a room of lawyers
00:30:55 can determine the difference between disdain and detest humiliate and vilify
00:31:01 the definition of detestation is intense dislike this bill is absurd it's totally absurd anyway
00:31:12 we might need a trauma levels uh graphic like this lee because uh you know people's trauma
00:31:19 levels need to be addressed my trauma levels are rising right now oh god i got ratioed on twitter
00:31:25 this is the worst day of my life someone told me to kill myself oh yeah welcome to the internet
00:31:34 i i just i can't imagine as someone who's received hate online before i can't imagine
00:31:40 like having to put my life on hold every time i get a hateful comment
00:31:45 it just sounds exhausting to to to take to take that so seriously but uh
00:31:52 Lee Stewie says they're using Supreme Court case precedent.
00:31:57 Yeah.
00:31:58 Yeah.
00:31:59 Hate that.
00:32:00 Hate that.
00:32:01 Hate that they're doing that.
00:32:02 And I'm going to hopefully interview Bruce Party about this because he kind of mentioned this in a Twitter space when I hopped in with him.
00:32:11 And he was saying like, yeah, well, he kind of implied, yeah, well, Supreme Court, it's from the Supreme Court.
00:32:17 So and it's like, OK, but what if the what if the Supreme Court is wrong on this?
00:32:22 is the supreme court ever wrong i feel like they kind of got this wrong i feel like they really
00:32:29 kind of weren't really thinking properly to set such a precedent that detestation and vilification
00:32:38 should be criminal speech because that's super super broad um oh but the supreme court said it
00:32:45 okay i don't care i i i don't know no offense to the supreme court i don't know if you guys uh
00:32:52 have the best track record under justin trudeau especially and um i mean you wear these you wear
00:32:59 these weird santa outfits kind of weird kind of weird santa outfits to be honest anyway let's keep 0.94
00:33:05 it going here because i feel like there's a lot of at least bovets out there that are not able to
00:33:13 find their voice and i raise that because people talk to me a lot about this legislation and about
00:33:19 people's voices and what are you doing to protect free expression and freedom of speech
00:33:26 particularly online and I'm going to address this at length a bit later on in my comments but what
00:33:31 I'd say just at the outset is that I think what we need to ensure that we all understand is that
00:33:36 so much of discourse in civic debate in civic society right now is notwithstanding the fact
00:33:43 I'm here in front of you at a microphone and I'm pleased to be here in person it takes place online
00:33:48 on our phones on our computers etc and if people are impeded from penetrating that virtual town
00:33:53 square that virtual public space then their expressive rights are being lived this is so
00:34:01 ironic man this is so ironic so what he's doing here is he's implying that because hateful people
00:34:08 exist because there's anonymous accounts saying hateful things online uh to this example of this
00:34:16 black woman who got reviled from even commenting because that hate exists um people people can't
00:34:23 participate in free speech because people are getting offended we can't have free speech that's
00:34:30 what he's saying because people are offended because there's these oversensitive people who
00:34:35 are afraid of criticism or afraid of pushback or afraid of anonymous twitter trolls that's why we
00:34:42 can't have free speech it's only when we silence all these twitter trolls and stop all the hate
00:34:47 that's the only way we can have free speech this is such a like orwellian double speak like
00:34:53 inversion of the truth and reality he's saying no no by silencing hate we are going to uphold
00:35:01 democracy and free speech when in reality you are stopping free speech you are you are killing the
00:35:07 free speech by saying these this is hate we need to stop this free speech to allow free speech
00:35:13 it's it's it's it's evil i i would call this villainous i think slickly telling this lie
00:35:21 this inversion of the truth is an evil thing to do i think that this is like a you know this is
00:35:27 like a uh gotham gotham city villain this this type of lying of like no you see um we're gonna
00:35:37 save free speech by silencing the hate because people can only talk once other people have been
00:35:42 silenced that's pretty well what he's saying people can only have free speech if the hateful
00:35:48 people are silent and we're going to determine who's hateful and we're going to determine what's
00:35:53 bad and that's going to help us have a more freedom of speech it's totally insane guys
00:35:59 totally insane i'd also want to point out that there is
00:36:07 a great deal of information that is happening online and that is affecting young people
00:36:13 and the statistics really bear this out the statistics are that a quarter of teens experience
00:36:20 cyber bullying that the number of hate crimes report a quarter of teens experience cyber
00:36:24 bullying i love i love this fact because you know when they were asked that question in a survey
00:36:30 it's like was it a bad thing you know what i mean i've been so i've been cyber bullied
00:36:37 on tiktok i've had children make fun oh look at this old man wow this bro thought he did something
00:36:45 hundreds of likes making fun of me i'm not mad i think it's funny because it's the internet i
00:36:52 I understand that because it's more anonymized, it's more like anonymous in terms of the comments.
00:37:00 This is part of the fun of the internet.
00:37:04 Sure, it's part of the terrifying part of posting content and posting your face out there.
00:37:09 You might get roasted in the comments.
00:37:12 That's just the way it is.
00:37:14 That's part of the game.
00:37:16 You might get bullied.
00:37:17 You might get cyber bullied.
00:37:19 okay and you know you could make the argument that meet the me too movement 1.00
00:37:26 that these women like trying to call out sexual predators or harvey weinstein well that's cyber 1.00
00:37:34 bullying a reef all these people harassing harassing uh harvey weinstein for something 0.98
00:37:40 he did in the past why do they keep cyber bullying him this is such a horrible thing right we need to
00:37:46 stop the cyber bullet you see what i mean like sometimes the mob mentality that manifests on
00:37:51 the internet isn't always a bad thing sometimes it's actually uh like the social policing playing
00:37:58 out you know what i mean the social policing as in if somebody acts a fool if somebody acts like 0.90
00:38:04 an asshole or or a creep or whatever and then people cyber bully them and kind of uh what's 0.98
00:38:11 what's the word kind of condemn them for their actions or for what they said this is sort of 0.99
00:38:15 like the normal social order playing out where, where human beings react to something as a group
00:38:20 because they all agree that they did not like that thing. So this whole thing of trying to
00:38:25 control bullying is just such a mess because bullying is a human. Um, it's like part of
00:38:32 human nature. Uh, there's this book, a reef that, uh, maybe you should read. It's called
00:38:38 the Lord of the flies. Uh, very, very influential book. Sometimes I read it in English class
00:38:44 And it speaks to this idea of human nature and how it's this thing that can kind of descend into chaos when it's not sort of, you know, having some sort of natural order to things.
00:38:55 And this idea that you're going to like stop human nature, you're going to stop people from hatred, you're going to stop people from feeling that human emotion, you're going to stop people from bullying.
00:39:05 Yeah, it's insane.
00:39:07 It's evil.
00:39:07 It's something that a tyrant would do.
00:39:09 Not something that a reasonable, realistic person would do.
00:39:12 It's something that a power-hungry politician would do. 1.00
00:39:17 But anyway, let's continue on with your bullshit presentation. 0.98
00:39:22 ...by police in Canada has increased by 83% since 2019. 0.98
00:39:27 The Toronto police here in our city have reported that they've experienced
00:39:31 a 130% increase in hate-related calls.
00:39:35 I would love to know what classifies a hate-related call.
00:39:38 And I think sort of the irony of all these stats he's listing off is,
00:39:41 you know how popular of a term was hate speech 10 years ago how popular of a term
00:39:46 was hate crimes 10 years ago i can assure you people probably hardly even talked about it that
00:39:52 much compared to now like they're they're they're memeing it into existence they're trying to make
00:39:57 it more and more uh more and more prevalent more and more real it's like casting a spell you know
00:40:03 it's like casting a spell of the unvaccinated are evil you know we need to stop the hate speech the
00:40:10 hate crimes that are happening oh let's see hate crimes yep this is a the safety
00:40:15 2022 71 percent of young canadians reported seeing online hate content
00:40:22 in the previous 12 months which is well above the national average
00:40:26 one in eight people once again like hate content how are they categorizing this is hate content
00:40:32 is hate content is hate content always bad i can't bring it up right now but you know
00:40:37 if you were unvaccinated in canada in 2021 you were hated early 2022 especially you were hated
00:40:47 there were popular you know what's the infamous one the uh toronto star front page i don't care
00:40:54 if they die i'm sick of these people all these comments on the front page of a newspaper this
00:41:02 is a group that was totally hated totally vilified by the prime minister himself are you including
00:41:08 that in your little assessment of hate content on the internet and here's the thing i'm totally
00:41:15 fine with you know that i mean that phenomenon was really disturbing because it was like really
00:41:20 you know who knows what that was going towards but my point is is like trying to just say we're
00:41:26 going to stop hate on the internet is insane because who defines what hatred is i really
00:41:31 doubt he would include the hatred of unvaccinated canadians that was a very real thing uh in recent
00:41:36 history all saw young saw online content daily that could incite hate or violence and for that
00:41:42 matter um truth and reconciliation day the burning of churches the tearing down of sir john a mcdonald
00:41:49 statues what about that hate a reef what about that hate i mean i would make the argument that
00:41:55 the motion that was passed in the
00:41:57 parliament to
00:41:59 say that residential schools are genocide
00:42:01 I would say that has a sort of implication of
00:42:03 hate it implies that
00:42:05 our history
00:42:06 I mean should you like somebody that's genocidal
00:42:09 no you'd probably hate somebody who's genocidal
00:42:11 so you're implying that Canadian history
00:42:13 is inherently genocidal or that
00:42:15 Catholic 0.53
00:42:16 residential schools are inherently genocidal 1.00
00:42:19 i.e. you should hate them 0.97
00:42:21 right but no no no this is a very
00:42:23 specific definition of hate that he gets
00:42:25 to define that the liberal government wants to define that they're going to control it's uh yeah
00:42:31 and they raise this because it's something that just came up earlier this morning i was speaking
00:42:37 at another group about this very same idea and it's about given that statistical path
00:42:43 i feel it's incumbent upon legislators like me particularly people with roles like me as minister
00:42:48 of justice to take action and people said you know reef it's really helpful when you sort of
00:42:53 when you sort of give us illustrative examples so i'll go back to my youth so my youth was okay
00:42:58 i'm sorry i'm sorry before we get into this bullshit story this is just such this is just 0.97
00:43:02 such bullshit this this whole like emotion you know i thought i had to take i had to take action 0.98
00:43:06 i knew i had to do something when i saw these trends this is total bullshit bill c36 this was 0.98
00:43:12 tabled in 2021 they've already been trying to pass hate speech laws it was bill c36 i've made videos 0.87
00:43:18 about it years back and they were doing the same thing they were trying to uh control speech online
00:43:23 under the guise of protecting people from hate speech.
00:43:26 Arif Arani was not involved.
00:43:27 And now they've just repackaged Bill C-63
00:43:29 and Arif happens to be the attorney general, right?
00:43:34 Wait, am I getting that right?
00:43:35 Attorney general, justice minister.
00:43:39 You know, I knew I had to do something.
00:43:40 No, this government was already trying to push through
00:43:42 hate speech laws.
00:43:43 And now you're just taking up that banner
00:43:46 to try and push it through.
00:43:47 No, I saw the trends.
00:43:48 Guys, I saw the trends and I thought,
00:43:50 you know, I need to do something.
00:43:51 It's just such baloney, this guy. 0.60
00:43:56 Smartphone. 0.80
00:43:57 There was one phone in our house.
00:44:00 It was a dial phone like this, for those of you that remember what it does look like.
00:44:04 I've got one calling you does.
00:44:05 By the way, if you're tuning in and you want to help save free speech in Canada,
00:44:08 please go to givesango.com slash savefreespeech.
00:44:10 We're making a documentary award-winning filmmaker.
00:44:14 This movie is going to be on Amazon Video.
00:44:16 It's going to be distributed internationally.
00:44:18 we're doing all types of interviews of people who have been silenced having their characters
00:44:23 smeared by the canadian anti-hate network they're the same people who are behind bill c63 as well
00:44:27 we're going to expose them with this documentary go to givesango.com save free speech thank you so
00:44:33 much for uh the donations um yeah anyway let's get back into it that's good um but i remember
00:44:46 I've got a sister who's three years and three months older than me.
00:44:48 I remember my dad getting very angry when people would call our house after 9 or 9.30 or 10 o'clock to speak to my sister.
00:44:55 It was always boys wanting to speak to my sister.
00:44:58 He was being a protective dad.
00:44:59 I'm not a father of a daughter.
00:45:01 I'm a father of two boys.
00:45:02 But I think any dad would probably react in the same way.
00:45:04 But I raise this both partly flippantly, but also partly just to point out that we don't generally tolerate people who would show up at our houses,
00:45:13 show up at the playground or show up on the phone at 10 o'clock or 11 o'clock or 12 o'clock at night
00:45:19 particularly if they're wanting to chat about things that maybe might be harmful to our children
00:45:23 and yet that's exactly what's happening online all of the time and we need bros bros seriously
00:45:31 comparing irl to the internet you know and i think and this the ridiculous irony of his or
00:45:41 like not irony but the absurdity of his example is that uh the internet doesn't come to you
00:45:47 okay the internet does not come to you you need to open the internet you need to go on a device
00:45:53 and open the internet you need to open it you need to actively go inside and look at it and
00:45:59 go inside of the internet okay that's how you do it he's talking about people showing up at your
00:46:03 door calling you on your phone yeah that's not that's not how the internet works the internet
00:46:10 doesn't call and say like hey look at these hateful comments you know i mean i guess you
00:46:15 could make the argument with notifications that there maybe maybe he's going to go there let's
00:46:20 see need to take action to prevent that in terms of protecting young people in particular i mean
00:46:25 it is hilarious just like the imagery of like i don't know what like a cartoon character of the
00:46:30 internet would look like but like the internet's knocking on your door i'm here to cause harm to
00:46:36 your children oh no it's the internet a reef for ronnie save us don't worry canadians i have bill
00:46:45 c63 the internet's not gonna harm you again yay thank you a reef totally
00:46:54 the internet it's gonna come eat your children ah when in reality though in reality though it 0.98
00:47:04 It is pedophiles. 1.00
00:47:05 It's sexual predators. 1.00
00:47:07 That is a real thing. 0.99
00:47:07 That is coming after your children.
00:47:10 And they're smart.
00:47:11 They're tactful.
00:47:12 They use the internet in a tactful way to sort of entrap and draw in children.
00:47:18 The problem is Bill C-63 doesn't address any of this stuff.
00:47:24 It doesn't address any of the kind of private conversations that people might have on different apps or whatever.
00:47:29 It doesn't touch any of that whatsoever.
00:47:31 so anytime he brings up oh sexploitation pedophiles online yeah your bill doesn't do anything to stop
00:47:39 this so what are you talking about why do you keep lying to people a reef why are you giving
00:47:45 them the impression that bill c63 is going to address this problem of pedophiles and trapping
00:47:49 kids online when this bill would not do anything for that the only thing it's going to do is like
00:47:54 hey we took down child sexploitation content well that kid already got sexploited and it already got 0.82
00:48:01 uploaded to the internet so it's kind of fucking late it's kind of too late to stop that from 0.52
00:48:05 happening isn't it so if you actually want to solve the root of the problem your bill does nothing 0.81
00:48:11 so it's actually very disgusting and detestable a reef that you use these examples of kids being
00:48:19 entrapped by pedophiles on the internet as a reason to pass bill c63 when it would not do
00:48:24 anything to prevent that you're using these tragic stories of kids who have been victims of these
00:48:34 sick monstrous pedophiles to push your legislation that wants to censor the internet you actually
00:48:40 have no interest in protecting children and and some lawyers have actually made the argument 0.98
00:48:46 that this bill might actually help insulate pedophiles and people posting child porn from
00:48:51 consequences it would help give them a buffer if they're getting caught it would help them like you
00:48:56 know burn their hard drives before they uh you know before they get found out
00:49:01 or maybe they're doing something shady in public and then that content gets taken down as harmful
00:49:07 so then the evidence incriminating a pedophile is now no longer on the internet it's harder to find
00:49:13 because it got taken down for harmful content evidence of a pedophile doing detestable things
00:49:19 or creepy things in public is now removed because it's a harmful content.
00:49:25 We've seen this liberal party of Canada. They approve of the pride parade. They approve of
00:49:31 the gender ideology taught in schools. What do you think kids are going to do after seeing that
00:49:36 in schools when they go home and go on the internet? What do you think they're going to
00:49:40 look up? These, this liberal party clearly does not give a fuck about protecting children from 0.98
00:49:46 sexual exploitation if they are rubber stamping and co-signing a pride parade where there's 1.00
00:49:53 naked men dancing around with a bugs bunny mask in front of children fuck off with this argument 1.00
00:50:01 that bill c63 protects kids from from sexual exploitation blow it out your ass it's total 1.00
00:50:06 bullshit anybody buying into this you're naive i have some snow to smell you i have some snow 1.00
00:50:12 to sell you this February 1.00
00:50:14 if you think Bill C63 is going to protect kids online.
00:50:19 But I'd also say to you
00:50:20 that it's not just about protecting my kids.
00:50:21 My kids are literally at that stage
00:50:23 where they're 10 and 13
00:50:24 and the 10-year-old isn't at the stage at all
00:50:26 with the 13-year-old's graduating
00:50:27 from a brutal flip phone
00:50:29 to he wants a smartphone.
00:50:31 My wife and I debated,
00:50:33 he's just starting grade nine
00:50:34 and he's got a smartphone.
00:50:35 He's allowed to have one app on it.
00:50:37 So he had to choose his app.
00:50:39 Apparently Snapchat is the way to go in grade nine
00:50:41 at his high school. But I also can't divorce the fact that he's not just a boy trying to become a
00:50:50 young man, but he's also a boy with a different name. He's a boy that has the same skin color as
00:50:57 me. He's a boy that is Muslim. And what he's going to face is different than what some other people
00:51:03 might face. And I raise that because it's not just my children's reality that informs how I
00:51:08 approach this legislation but it's canada's reality and canada's reality is unfortunately
00:51:14 you know just today you know i've had lots of engagements as minister of justice including
00:51:18 with international counterparts including at things like the g7 and it really troubles me that
00:51:24 canada leads the g7 in a statistic that i don't want to lead in like i want to lead in all these
00:51:29 great economic indicators and democratic governance indicators we lead the g7 in deaths due to
00:51:35 Islamophobia let deaths due to Islamophobia what is that what is that mean how do you even
00:51:44 how do you even quantify that deaths due to Islamophobia deaths due to racism deaths due to
00:51:54 homophobia like I'm telling you somebody somebody's got to expose this whole like stat
00:52:02 this whole stat industry this whole like study industry there's this whole system where people
00:52:07 make these studies to like prove things and they're it's just creating political footballs
00:52:12 for politicians that's all that's is am I crazy or is this is this all that these uh you know stat 0.96
00:52:18 study companies do is they they just craft a study to make a bunch of bullshit statistics 0.91
00:52:23 for politicians like a referani to kind of push around all of this all of this like all these 0.65
00:52:30 weird talking points since 2017 that's pretty startling right 11 people have been cut down
00:52:43 because of their faith in this country and that faith was this long what am i talking about i'm
00:52:48 talking about the quebec mosque shooter whose name i will not repeat in 2017 who killed six
00:52:52 individuals and i'm talking about the person who decided to take a car and drive into a family
00:52:57 killing for an orphaning one i mean did we ever hear the actual background of this person i mean
00:53:04 i'm not gonna lie that was horrific that happened this guy ran over a whole like muslim family in
00:53:10 london ontario but i feel like the re like the sort of reporting on that was very very scarce
00:53:16 in terms of what was actually going on um so yeah once again it just feels like a lot of uh
00:53:24 I mean in terms of the mosque shooter
00:53:26 obviously I disavow that
00:53:28 I disavow violence of all kinds
00:53:30 but
00:53:30 yeah I mean
00:53:34 I don't know
00:53:36 that one in London though I don't know
00:53:37 if anyone's got the link of like more of the research
00:53:40 on that whole incident I would love to know
00:53:42 right that's the
00:53:44 family in London
00:53:45 I don't want to leave that statistic and the reason I
00:53:48 raise that statistic is because it's informative for me
00:53:50 it's motivating for me
00:53:52 but it also leaves clear a pattern of truth it's also worth mentioning uh during the trucker convoy
00:53:59 in manitoba there was an antifa guy who drove a car into a crowd of protesters
00:54:04 like pro-freedom anti-mandate protesters one of them went to the hospital
00:54:10 drove a drove a drove a car into a protesting demonstration no one really talks about that
00:54:17 I'm sure Reef never talks about that
00:54:20 no one ever talks about how a car was
00:54:22 driven into a crowd of
00:54:23 convoy protesters
00:54:25 that is definitely a terror attack
00:54:28 you know it's doing violence
00:54:30 to advocate
00:54:31 for your political beliefs
00:54:33 so
00:54:34 once again it's just hard to take any of
00:54:38 this sob story seriously
00:54:40 when it's like you're clearly just using
00:54:42 this for a political football you're going to focus
00:54:44 on this violence not that violence you're going to focus
00:54:46 on this hate not that hate
00:54:47 yeah right and people like to say well verani you're just sort of espousing is that just
00:54:54 theoretical because i often say online radicalization leads to real world violence
00:54:59 in those two cases and i hope you know i always say online radicalization radicalization leads to
00:55:07 real world violence okay you always say that but again the type a folks in this room follow those
00:55:14 two cases both instances the accused persons who have now been convicted admitted on the stand
00:55:20 under cross-examination that they were radicalized online so it's not theoretical it costs lives
00:55:26 including in this country and no oof i'm not i'm not gonna lie if that that's if that's true that's
00:55:32 a pretty good talking point for him for his side it's a pretty good talking point if he's got that
00:55:39 stat if they admitted this on the stand that they were radicalized online that's a pretty it's a
00:55:43 pretty good talking point for him shit we're gonna have to we're gonna have to work we haven't had a 0.93
00:55:48 pittsburgh tree of life synagogue attack and no we haven't had an orlando lgbtq bar attack where 0.98
00:55:53 49 people were killed in this country uh quick question arif how many churches
00:56:00 how many uh how many churches got burnt down
00:56:03 is that in is that in your little is that included in your study or or what
00:56:09 jennifer francis says a 13 year old boy unalived himself during lockdown in victoria
00:56:17 yeah great point how about the destructive nature of lockdowns or the destructive nature
00:56:22 of the um you know how the unvaccinated were treated yeah it just goes on and on it just
00:56:30 goes on and on like this is a power grab we know this is a power grab it's all it's all a bunch of 0.99
00:56:37 bullshit but you know he does bring some strong 0.99
00:56:39 talking points to the table with this one not gonna lie 1.00
00:56:41 because there's a lot of bullshit 0.99
00:56:42 but this one this one's actually 0.99
00:56:45 like not as easy to just kind of like throw
00:56:47 aside but I'll be damned if I'm gonna stand by
00:56:49 and sort of watch it happen
00:56:50 so it's not just about protecting Muslims it's about
00:56:52 protecting lots of vulnerable people
00:56:55 oh here's another one
00:56:56 what about the Danforth shooting
00:56:58 what about the Danforth shooting when
00:57:02 you know the shooter
00:57:04 somebody who he was related to
00:57:06 had a huge stockpile
00:57:08 of carfentanil and apparently
00:57:10 one of them or both of them
00:57:12 went to a local mosque that they
00:57:14 say was quite radical
00:57:16 as well.
00:57:18 But of course, again, we don't care
00:57:20 about that. That doesn't matter
00:57:22 to Arif. That's not important to Arif.
00:57:24 That's not something that he focuses on.
00:57:26 That type of hate is not 0.99
00:57:28 something that he really gives a shit about. 0.99
00:57:31 So, 0.99
00:57:32 yeah.
00:57:35 This country.
00:57:36 The other component that I think I feel compelled to speak about is this idea that people have mentioned to me, and I'm sort of jumping around my notes here a little bit, but they've said to me that, you know, Arif, you've got a really impressive piece of legislation, and it is impressive, and it's worked on a long time.
00:57:56 It's not sort of my handiwork on the back of a napkin.
00:57:59 It's a four-and-a-half-year process.
00:58:01 And that piece of legislation addresses things such as content that needs to be taken down immediately.
00:58:06 That's child sex abuse material and revenge porn.
00:58:09 It addresses content where we've got to moderate the risk.
00:58:12 So that's incitements to violence and terrorism.
00:58:16 That is fomenting hatred.
00:58:18 That is content that would be used to bully a child and content that would be used to cause a child self-harm.
00:58:22 that's content that he wants taken down within 24 hours from big tech
00:58:27 content that bullies a child
00:58:31 that is just that's so broad man that's so crazy broad that's so crazy broad so any meme about fat
00:58:41 people any meme about making fun of virtually anything that could that could apply to a child 0.99
00:58:49 no don't worry we're going to define what what uh cyber bullying is it's like just fuck off like 0.98
00:58:57 this stuff is so broad it would be insane to have bureaucrats determine this stuff for us 0.97
00:59:01 people have said to me you know arif i feel like we've got this momentum behind the bill but i'm
00:59:06 not sure about all of the bill you know like why can't we just sort of bifurcate it a little bit
00:59:10 let's just deal with the kids part because that's easy like everyone wants to protect their kids
00:59:14 and maybe you know that hate stuff you know maybe we should just sort of pause for a second on the
00:59:19 hate stuff and what i say to people and then they say to me well you know this is what we this is 0.92
00:59:25 how we should do we should actually separate out the bill just to reiterate the whole bill sucks 0.68
00:59:31 there's nothing good in the bill i already covered this anything that's actually good in the bill is
00:59:35 totally redundant there's nothing good in the bill but anyway continue and my response to that
00:59:39 is as follows fundamentally when i take an oath of office as the minister of justice and attorney 0.98
00:59:46 general of canada just so much fucking bullshit this guy my response to this is as follows as 0.98
00:59:52 an attorney general of canada yeah it is to keep canadians safe and i believe in keeping all 0.99
00:59:58 canadians safe yeah okay except yeah okay it's the first point the second point is that
01:00:05 when we look at harms that people are exposed to we've looked at harms comprehensively there are
01:00:11 all types of different harms it is not just child sex predators of which there are many unfortunately
01:00:16 but there are other types of harms that people are exposed to and this bill is meant to address
01:00:20 all of them this bill is also meant to address what we're seeing i'm here at the campus of tmu
01:00:26 it would be indifferent if i was notice how he's not answering the question hey should we separate
01:00:32 this bill isn't some of this completely absurd and he's just like we're tracking the harms the
01:00:37 campus at york or at u of t or any other campus around this country we have seen sometimes because
01:00:44 of geopolitical events sometimes because of domestic events we've seen increasing polarization
01:00:48 and division right and what we've seen is that we need to ensure that in those times that dialogue
01:00:55 occurs but hatred does not and hatred is on the rise and the stats that i read to you
01:00:59 there it is there it is folks we need to make sure that dialogue occurs but hatred does not
01:01:11 this is just like such this is like crazy communist dialogue
01:01:17 i i just want to know what the actual definition of dialogue is i've never
01:01:24 looked it up so
01:01:25 it's like a quick peek
01:01:28 computer
01:01:29 define dialogue please
01:01:31 conversation between two or more people as a feature
01:01:34 of a book play or movie
01:01:36 take part in a conversation
01:01:38 or discussion to resolve a problem
01:01:40 okay
01:01:42 let's have some dialogue
01:01:44 let's have some dialogue
01:01:46 about Israel, Palestine, Arif
01:01:48 we want to make sure
01:01:50 dialogue happens but no hate happens
01:01:52 let's have some dialogue about israel palestine or ukraine russia and let's not have anyone hate
01:02:00 each other good luck this kind of just goes right to the point of why this is totally absurd you
01:02:07 want to have dialogue and it's funny that dialogue actually comes from the noun refers to dialogue in
01:02:13 a book movie or play stories and narratives thrive on conflict characters will hate things
01:02:22 they'll hate other people so it's like this is just a terrible it's a terrible word to use we
01:02:28 need to make sure dialogue happens but there's no hate here's a free lesson here's a free lesson
01:02:34 mr arif you should you should you should have used like debate or something that we should have 0.99
01:02:38 debate without hate oh fuck i just gave him a go i just gave him like a fucking bumper sticker 1.00
01:02:43 fuck you can't hate you can't debate without hate a reef you can't debate without some hate 1.00
01:02:52 but uh that's that sort of thing is just i would be so pissed if he ends up using that holy shit 1.00
01:02:58 all right let's continue all right let's continue but i'd also say to you did i just 0.98
01:03:07 give my enemy a bumper sticker fuck dude and i see you know different people with different 0.94
01:03:13 backgrounds like tmu looks exactly like toronto does and that's why i love this city but it also 0.99
01:03:18 asks you to think about tmu formerly ryerson rest in peace to egerton ryerson's legacy uh taken down
01:03:26 by angry uh indigenous people because they hate white canadian history pretty much those who say
01:03:35 just separate the bill, Arif, because let's just protect just those young people. I say to you,
01:03:40 okay, let's think about the young people, right? Think about my kids, think about your kids,
01:03:44 your nieces, your nephews, your grandchildren. But now let's think about what it looks like for
01:03:49 them online if it's a young girl online as opposed to a young boy. Now let's add a few
01:03:57 layers. Let's think about if that's a young racialized girl. So now we've got a young black 1.00
01:04:00 girl online now let's think about let's maybe she's of somali origin and maybe she's muslim
01:04:05 like me so now i've got a young black somali muslim in a hijab just bringing out the in
01:04:12 well what if they're like the most what if they're in a wheelchair too you should have 0.70
01:04:17 them in a wheelchair to a reef what if they're a young somali muslim girl in a knee cab who's 0.94
01:04:25 lesbian in a wheelchair and she's blind and deaf how many more do you want you come on let's go 0.89
01:04:33 let's let's up the ante here arif if you think all she's facing is sort of eating disorder issues
01:04:40 about her body image i just think you're wrong in fact i know you're wrong because i know that
01:04:47 the vitriol that circulates online is also circulating with young people and they are
01:04:52 exposed to hatred if they're exposed to material that is being fomented towards them and targeting
01:04:59 them this is such a wet dream for helicopter parents i'm just thinking imagine how they just
01:05:07 consider how absurd this this sort of goal is it's it's like hey hey i want to protect my kid
01:05:15 so i'm gonna put bubble wrap all over all the walls i'm gonna wrap mattresses around anything
01:05:20 to make sure they don't hurt themselves ever and they don't fall ever. That's essentially what he's
01:05:25 saying. We're going to make sure that there's no hate on the internet and your child is never
01:05:30 offended and they're never exposed to anything bad ever. That's what I'm going to do.
01:05:36 Totally unrealistic. Are you just here to take away my rights, sir? No, no, no. We're going to
01:05:40 make sure that your kid never trip. They never fall. They're never exposed to hatred. They're
01:05:46 never exposed to any disagreement or anything that might hurt their feelings. Is this even good for
01:05:50 child to completely insulate them from the real world to completely insulate them from anything
01:05:55 that's they might find harmful i mean like where is the character building part where is the part
01:06:01 where you interact with people who you disagree with and you to the point where you might hate
01:06:05 each other on a disagreement doesn't have to be on the israel palestine thing maybe you hate each
01:06:09 other because somebody likes the beatles and the other person doesn't somebody likes this movie
01:06:13 and the other person doesn't and maybe that descends into a flame war as the old school term
01:06:19 goes when you're like arguing with each other online but it's it's it's what he's talking about
01:06:24 is such a wet dream for helicopter parents who want to say like i want to protect my kid from
01:06:30 everything make sure that they don't trip they don't fall they don't they're not exposed to
01:06:34 anything harmful or hateful on the internet what what an absurd goal to have it's the internet guys
01:06:41 it's filled with all sorts of insanity
01:06:43 that's the whole point of it
01:06:45 but no
01:06:47 the government the Canadian
01:06:49 government is going to make
01:06:51 sure that you
01:06:53 your child
01:06:54 never never sees anything
01:06:57 weird on the internet never
01:06:59 it's not going to happen like
01:07:01 I
01:07:03 based on how absurd that is
01:07:05 I bet that
01:07:07 and I don't want this to happen because we're going to
01:07:09 save free speech we're going to stop bill c63 go to savefreespeech.ca but i bet if this bill were
01:07:15 to pass as is big tech would just bail i think big tech would just bail out of canada and say
01:07:21 it's not even worth the trouble you guys are cooked uh you're only 40 million you know we got
01:07:27 we got five ten times your your uh your population your your market base in other countries it's not
01:07:33 even worth our time it's not even worth the financial risk for if you because if you don't
01:07:36 No, there's a huge, there will be a huge financial risk for big tech platforms with Bill C63
01:07:43 if big tech doesn't obey whatever our digital commission says.
01:07:48 If the digital commission says, oh, this is a, you know, this is a, this is bullying
01:07:52 a child online.
01:07:53 This meme about fat people is bullying a child online.
01:07:57 We're the digital commissars of Canada.
01:07:59 Facebook, if you don't take it down, we're going to fine you millions of dollars.
01:08:03 We're going to fine you Facebook for millions of dollars.
01:08:06 There could be hundreds of applications for this happening every single day to Facebook.
01:08:13 They could get potentially, like, imagine getting 100 inquiries a day that you might get fined millions of dollars for.
01:08:20 Yeah, I think big tech will probably just leave the country.
01:08:23 They already did that with the news sharing with Bill C-18.
01:08:27 Why? 1.00
01:08:28 Because these legislators suck, okay? 1.00
01:08:32 Because this liberal party, these bureaucrats in Canada are terrible at their job. 0.99
01:08:36 They're terrible at writing legislation to the point where professional, massive, international, big tech companies are calling them out on their bluff.
01:08:46 And they're just like, this is not even tenable for us.
01:08:48 So we're just leaving the country because you're so bad at writing legislation.
01:08:53 And I feel Bill C63, based on this absurd dream that Arif Farhani says that we're going to protect your kid from anything harmful online.
01:09:01 And based on that, yeah, I'm thinking that they might just nuke the internet or at least nuke big tech from even existing in Canada if this were to go through.
01:09:10 And what I would say to you is that we all need to think about those examples because I think in my job is protecting Canadians, protecting those who are victimized online.
01:09:20 I'm not going to cherry pick which victims.
01:09:21 I'm not going to hang out to dry. 0.98
01:09:23 I'm not going to focus only on child sex predator victims and hanging out to dry the LGBTQ plus community, hang out to dry indigenous people, hang out to dry black Canadians, Muslim Canadians, Jewish Canadians, you name it.
01:09:34 My job is to try and protect to the best of my ability all Canadians.
01:09:38 But I also see to you and I find this very troubling is that because I thought we we learn more coming out of COVID.
01:09:44 Once again, the the absurdity there is crazy. 1.00
01:09:47 how do you protect jewish and palestinian canate uh canate canadians at the same time 0.99
01:09:54 uh like like how do you police the content because sorry you're going to have jewish
01:10:00 canadians complaining about the palestinian protesters and their posts and you're going
01:10:04 to have palestinian canadians complaining about the jewish canadians and their posts 1.00
01:10:07 how do you square that circle you can't you can't this bill's a power grab uh you're a clown 0.99
01:10:16 about the mental health impacts of what people are experiencing online you've seen the u.s surgeon 0.73
01:10:22 general issue a warning literally like think about again for those of you old enough the 1960s
01:10:27 there's a warning tobacco causes cancer this is bad for your health the u.s surgeon general has
01:10:32 issued a warning about social media and what it does to young people that's significant we know
01:10:39 that that is significant right but you're still not even encouraging kids to use their phone less
01:10:44 you're encouraging the government to babysit everybody who ever used the internet in the
01:10:47 country. But what I find troubling is that I don't think anyone in Canada, regardless of whether they
01:10:52 vote for me or hate my party's guts, I don't think anyone in Canada would countenance somebody taking
01:10:56 a firearm into a mosque. No one's going to defend that because it's deplorable conduct. But I find
01:11:02 it troubling that people will take less umbrage at the pernicious mental health impact and trauma
01:11:09 that young people are experiencing who face hatred what it does to their confidence levels their
01:11:14 self-esteem their anxiety their depression their ability to engage that's something that we need
01:11:19 to be thinking about once again stopping the hate online you're interested in that but not the fact
01:11:25 that kids are glued to their screens that part i called it at the beginning that aspect doesn't
01:11:32 get talked about at all uh the cell phone addiction doesn't get talked about at all it's just uh no
01:11:37 we want the government to police speech that's the only that's the only solution no we're not
01:11:41 we're not here to kill free speech in canada and give the government an insane amount of power over
01:11:46 speech and free expression across the country no no no no not at all no this is to protect kids
01:11:51 yeah i also reflect on you that when i stood at this podium and i mentioned
01:11:55 at least bouvet who was with me
01:11:58 also with me at the podium which was a first since october 7th was the national council of
01:12:06 canadian muslims and the center for jewish and israeli affairs why were they both there because
01:12:12 i haven't been hanging out too much recently to be blunt they were both there because they know
01:12:16 that online radicalization leads to targeting of both of their communities and leads to violence
01:12:23 against both of their communities that was salient for me the communities are attacking each other
01:12:30 though a reef you talk about that part oh the oh man we got to exploit that there's got to be an
01:12:41 exploitable uh video for that how do you square that circle man yeah there's got to be something
01:12:48 good there because it really just blows up the absurdity of trying to uh you know police speech
01:12:54 online hey the jewish advocacy group wants this bill because they're afraid of the muslims and
01:13:01 the muslim advocacy group also wants this bill because they uh because they don't like the jews
01:13:06 this is all going to go very well this is going to go great this isn't going to be messy at all
01:13:12 it's also salient that both of them are behind aspects of the bill that people want me to divide
01:13:18 so the people that say keep in the bits about child sex predators but let's you know that
01:13:23 troubling criminal code stuff let's just put that aside for now let's you know we will deal with
01:13:28 that another time in those criminal code provisions are things like a freestanding hate crimes offense
01:13:33 people have taken issue with that well why do we need that i gently point out that it exists in 47
01:13:39 out of 50 states south of the border i haven't seen an erosion of free speech last time i checked
01:13:44 in any of those 47 states south of the border but i also point out that police officers are begging
01:13:50 me for this what was that what was that 47 out of 50 states have a standalone hate hate uh hate
01:13:57 motivated law i've got a fact check that never heard that kind of provision i'm going to get a
01:14:02 bit into the into the into the weeds here so where's jess because i usually pick on jess well
01:14:07 i'll pick on keith this time no jess is easier to pick on i'll pick on jess jess is floating around 0.99
01:14:11 somewhere um if i throw a punch and i'm convicted of assaulting jess my female staffer i may get 30 1.00
01:14:19 days in a provincial facility. If it is demonstrated that I threw the punch at Jess
01:14:24 because I was motivated by misogyny, anti-female sentiment, my sentence could be increased because
01:14:31 it's an aggravating factor. That's 718.2 of the criminal code, but you deal with it on the back
01:14:36 end. And no, your officer. No, no, no. I punched the woman. I don't hate women. Yeah. I may have
01:14:43 punched her in the face, but I don't hate women. Yeah. Okay. So I punched this woman in the face. 1.00
01:14:48 Okay, sure. 1.00
01:14:49 But I don't hate women. 0.99
01:14:51 No, no, no, no, no. 1.00
01:14:52 I just hate this woman. 1.00
01:14:53 I swear. 1.00
01:14:54 Like, it's funny that he's using this as an example.
01:14:58 He's, like, so out of touch of how absurd this is as an example.
01:15:02 I kind of love it. 1.00
01:15:04 I don't hate women.
01:15:06 It was actually when I was chatting with, this is a very simple talking point,
01:15:11 but it was from, I think it was Randy Hillier.
01:15:13 He was like, you know, if you murder somebody, you know, chances are you hated them.
01:15:18 but now we're going to have a hate motivated offense to add to like any,
01:15:23 any criminal criminal charge.
01:15:26 Is it,
01:15:27 you know, 0.83
01:15:27 isn't it implicit that you hated them if you punched them,
01:15:29 but no.
01:15:31 But if we look at their social media and they posted something by
01:15:33 Satanistic,
01:15:34 then we're going to up the charge.
01:15:36 I mean this,
01:15:38 this honestly,
01:15:39 he's talking about,
01:15:40 Hey,
01:15:40 hate motivated,
01:15:41 hate crime charge.
01:15:42 He's talking about it. 1.00
01:15:42 Like it's a good thing.
01:15:45 This would be the perfect tool for tyrants.
01:15:47 this would be like the number one tool for tyrants you could take all of these you could
01:15:53 take all of these mischief charges from the protest from the trucker convoy and then you
01:15:57 could tack on a hate motivated charge and say you did this because you hate group x and now you're
01:16:03 going away for life in prison because that's the maximum sentence for this standalone hate crime
01:16:08 charge why do i feel like a referani is not going to mention that part uh in this presentation 0.80
01:16:15 because he's a swindler because he's trying to take freedom of speech away and he is a dishonest 0.69
01:16:21 weasel we don't know how many of these incidents are actually motivated by hate because it only 0.80
01:16:26 gets considered if a conviction is successful what police officers have said to me is that
01:16:31 there's actually a lot more violence out there where there's mischief vandalism trespass assaults
01:16:36 even sexual assaults or even murders that are happening that are hate motivated but we're not
01:16:41 laying the charge up front so we don't have an ability to track it so imagine a scenario where
01:16:46 you've got how about you just enforce the law when people break the law and adding this whole
01:16:53 hate crime thing to it like what is the utility in that thousands of such incidents they still
01:16:57 only result in hundreds of convictions but we know the scope of the problem that's what police
01:17:02 have told important context too is this guy is a lawyer do you know how much money lawyers would
01:17:10 make if bill c63 passes do you know how like that'll create an entire new industry of lawyer
01:17:16 and law practically to deal with hate crime charges if you're a lawyer that's a huge payday
01:17:22 that's awesome for you if you're a lawyer you probably want bill c63 to pass if you're a lawyer 0.85
01:17:28 oh got more clients oh i got a new swimming pool you got a new villa in italy yeah i fucking love
01:17:35 hate crime let's go that's something that people don't talk about is how you know the the financial 0.54
01:17:41 incentive that lawyers have to create more laws like this where they just constantly have clients
01:17:47 running around running around in and out of the courtroom having their their bill stack higher and 0.83
01:17:53 higher because some poor person oh i gotta fight the hate crime charge like it would be crazy boom 0.97
01:18:00 for uh for the law in like industry of like making money off of bullshit police had eight crimes 0.78
01:18:07 units in this very city are telling me that and yeah a reef is a lawyer so again another thing
01:18:12 that he would never talk about and that i don't like any lawyer would publicly talk about is the
01:18:16 sort of financial incentive the eye like the dollar signs and the eyeballs of these lawyers
01:18:20 when they hear about bill c63 but those groups that are targeted are also telling me that you
01:18:25 know what's a good part about your bill you're increasing the penalties for these types of crimes
01:18:29 for willful promotion of hatred,
01:18:31 public incitement of hatred, advocating genocide.
01:18:33 That's what's in the bill.
01:18:35 And the last response I have to people who tell me,
01:18:37 you know, why don't we just divide it up?
01:18:39 You know, it'd be just so much easier,
01:18:41 such low-hanging fruit just to protect the kids,
01:18:43 is that what I say to them is that, you know,
01:18:46 I've looked internationally at examples about this bill.
01:18:49 And Australia is one example we've looked at really closely.
01:18:52 And Australia moved in this area in 2015.
01:18:55 In 2015, nine years ago, they dealt with children.
01:18:59 Nine years later, Australia has gone way beyond just dealing with children.
01:19:04 If I'm moving for the first time as a minister of the Crown to deal with this issue, I think it's incumbent upon me to address the issue as we see it now, not as the world saw it nine years ago.
01:19:14 So I think that's really important.
01:19:16 There's a lot of components about the bill that my staff hate this because I've deviated wildly from the order that they laid things out here in my comments.
01:19:27 but there's people that have talked to me extensively about this bill and they said
01:19:32 arif it looks like this is just you manufacturing sort of your own vision of canada
01:19:37 this is you manufacturing your yeah they said to me quite candidly that
01:19:45 you know it looks like a bold face attack on freedom of expression in this country
01:19:50 yeah let's clip that that's a good clip that's a good clip this is just you manufacturing sort
01:19:56 of your own vision this is a bold face attack on freedom of speech in this country said to me
01:20:00 quite candidly that you know it looks like a bold face attack on freedom of expression in this
01:20:05 country totally real real he's right and to that i have several responses let's hear it let's hear
01:20:11 the first is that freedom of expression is fundamental in a democracy and i say that as
01:20:16 somebody who had a very tender age but nevertheless my family fled an authoritarian regime in east
01:20:21 Africa, the regime of Idi Amin. So if you want a family that venerates Canada and everything
01:20:25 it represents, it's probably my family. If you want somebody who's going to defend freedom
01:20:30 of expression under section 2b of the charter, it's probably me as minister of justice, not
01:20:35 only because I practice constitutional law, but because my oath as a cabinet minister
01:20:39 is different from every one of my colleagues. We all pledge allegiance to the king.
01:20:44 I'm so tired of this disingenuous. I love free speech is so important. Hey guys, let
01:20:51 mean I said free speech I said I care about it okay that's why we're passing hate speech laws
01:20:57 okay but I talked about I talked about loving free speech it's just I'm so tired of how
01:21:02 disingenuous this stuff is I'll pledge to keep cabinet confidence I pledge to uphold the
01:21:06 constitution and I take that very very seriously but the most important thing I will say to you
01:21:11 about freedom of expression is that hate speech is not constitutionally protected speech okay
01:21:19 says you what do you mean like says you what is hate speech like this is when i first started
01:21:29 researching this bill like no one defines hate like hate just like does not get defined um
01:21:34 the only the only thing yeah and it's like it's ridiculous i'm just gonna repeat that
01:21:40 in this country hate speech is not constitutionally protected speech he's casting a spell
01:21:46 That begs the question that if we don't protect it in the physical space, me here on the campus at TMU, why would we protect it online?
01:21:56 Okay.
01:21:57 It begs the question about, okay, well, then, Verani, what's the definition of hatred?
01:22:01 Like, did you just concoct this on the back of a napkin in some bar in Ottawa?
01:22:05 The answer is no, I did not.
01:22:07 It was actually in one of the offices in Ottawa.
01:22:11 Because we thought about this.
01:22:12 We thought about the kind of criticism we would face.
01:22:14 We thought, you know what would be the safest thing?
01:22:16 We're going to codify a definition that already exists.
01:22:19 Whose definition?
01:22:21 The Supreme Court of Canada.
01:22:22 The Supreme Court of Canada's definition.
01:22:24 Yeah, it's not a good definition, though.
01:22:26 It's not a good...
01:22:27 Intensely disliking is what hatred means.
01:22:33 This is such a terrible defense, though.
01:22:35 I was expecting a better response than this.
01:22:37 This is terrible.
01:22:38 It's from two cases, Keekstra and Watcott.
01:22:41 Watcott is a 2013 decision in the Supreme Court.
01:22:44 I encourage you to look it up.
01:22:45 the definitions around paragraphs 42 to 47. Read those five paragraphs. What does it say? It says
01:22:52 hatred is detestation and vilification. Hatred is not insulting comments, offensive comments,
01:23:01 expressions of disdain or dislike. Okay, why do I point that out? People love to ask me, you know,
01:23:07 you've done a lot of stuff in your career. How does it help inform you in terms of what you're
01:23:10 doing now? I say it helps inform me all the time. It helped that I practice constitutional law in
01:23:14 the city it helped that i was a u.n war crimes prosecutor on the rwandan genocide you know how 1.00
01:23:19 tutsis were described in rwanda in 1994 as cockroaches that should be stamped out that's
01:23:26 called detestation and vilification when you dehumanize another well sorry sorry so any version
01:23:32 of dehumanizing is detestation and you know it's like it it's so annoying it's so disingenuous the
01:23:38 way in which he's like these words are so important and then he's just kind of lumping
01:23:42 them all together with the very first example what that definition does is it sets a high bar
01:23:47 it's not going to affect accent no it doesn't it really does not it really does not set a high bar
01:23:54 and that's the whole problem on toronto on october 17th it's not going to affect colorful jokes at a
01:24:00 yucky yucky comedy cabaret it's not even going to affect people who have legitimate criticism
01:24:05 a better immigration policy see i'm he says this now but you know it's it's like a trust me bro
01:24:13 this is like a trust me bro this moment is like a trust trust me bro trust me bro you won't get
01:24:19 in trouble for that let's just pass the law okay trust me bro you'll be fine all this will be fine
01:24:26 no hey just just trust me bro i know the legislation is totally broad and open to
01:24:32 interpretation but just trust me bro you'll be fine including which country people are coming
01:24:36 in from people express to me all the time as recently as two weeks ago in my riding on
01:24:41 somebody's porch you have too many people coming in from this particular country that is legitimate
01:24:46 debate in canadian society that is protected speech but what it is going to draw differentiation
01:24:52 from is between a casual racial slur what i call awful but lawful language and somebody who calls
01:24:58 for the extermination of a people that's detestation and vilification
01:25:02 once once again he's he's kind of muddying the waters he's conflating two things now he's saying 0.90
01:25:10 that he said uh you know calling people cockroaches that's the that's detestation that's 0.92
01:25:17 vilification well it's also dehumanization so the way he's calling people cockroaches
01:25:21 detestation vilification dehumanization are all three personally i think it's just dehumanization
01:25:28 does that also imply is dehumanization is that also part of what's hatred is that also one of
01:25:34 the thing is d is dehumanization always detestation is it always vilification and
01:25:40 also calling for the death of a group of people is that detestation or is that vilification or
01:25:46 Or is that something else entirely where it's, you know, inciting violence, which is something that's already illegal, if I'm not mistaken.
01:25:53 And really annoying that this is guys.
01:25:56 This is supposed to be the top expert on this bill.
01:25:58 And he's not caring to actually differentiate any of these things. 0.99
01:26:02 He's just giving us the bullshit. 0.99
01:26:04 Cole's notes of like, hey, don't worry, bro. 1.00
01:26:06 Trust me.
01:26:07 Hey, hey, trust me, bro.
01:26:08 Hey, we thought about this a lot.
01:26:09 All right.
01:26:10 It's a really high bar.
01:26:11 Hey, you wouldn't you wouldn't call someone a cockroach, would you? 1.00
01:26:15 you you wouldn't call for the death of people would you yeah let's just pass this fucking 0.99
01:26:19 bow through already shut up for those who say to me oh my god verani you're going to open the 0.99
01:26:23 floodgates every casual comment about colin kaepernick taking in during the american national 0.78
01:26:27 anthem in a football game it's going to throw me in jail i call bs on that to be blunt because if
01:26:33 you think hatred prosecutions because it's the same standard we have the same laws if you think
01:26:39 they're easy to apply right now you're wrong they're sparing partly because most hatred
01:26:45 prosecutions require the consent of an attorney general that remains on the books because of the
01:26:50 careful civil liberties that are at stake what i also say is look closely at what we're doing but
01:26:55 also what we're not doing because again we looked around the planet six countries trust me bro trust
01:27:01 me bro don't worry we won't abuse this bro won't be abused bro it's funny how he's like yeah and 0.95
01:27:06 someone said they're worried about a Colin Kaepernick tweak I call bullshit what do you 1.00
01:27:12 mean you call bullshit like you're the one making the law bro uh you shouldn't have to call bullshit 0.99
01:27:20 you should have you should calmly be saying that is simply incorrect you know what I mean I call 0.99
01:27:25 bullshit he's like very antagonistic against his critics they've moved in this area already 0.94
01:27:29 australia it's giving me ireland france it's giving insecure it's giving tyrant it's giving 1.00
01:27:36 um that he didn't write the script today so uh the uk in the uk they decided to wade into private
01:27:46 communications our bill does not our bill does not talk about individually hosted websites that
01:27:50 don't host user generated content right in france they went too far on freedom expression their bill
01:27:56 was struck down this calibrates in an important manner the other thing what he's missing of
01:28:01 course is that the online harms bill in the uk i forget what it's called it's very similar
01:28:06 name to ours ours is online harms act theirs is like online harms bill um yeah there are people
01:28:13 who are being thrown in jail for criticizing immigration or reef so that is happening with
01:28:19 the with the bill that you've modeled after in the uk so you're lying you're lying to people
01:28:26 you're not telling people that in the uk the online harms bill that they passed is throwing
01:28:32 people in jail for simply attending a protest for simply voicing a particular political opinion
01:28:38 and these people are getting persecuted and thrown in jail under this so-called online harms
01:28:42 legislation that you want to pass but you're telling people with you're telling people
01:28:47 fully throated saying that's not going to happen here it's happening in the uk with a piece of 1.00
01:28:53 legislation that you're modeling yours after why do you why does why are you so full of shit like 0.99
01:28:59 why is it so easy for you to lie about this and like if i'm wrong if you're not lying then maybe 0.97
01:29:05 you should clarify why that's different because as far as i can tell you have not it's really
01:29:12 important to understand you can tell i'm a bit sort of engaged on this because i've been dealing
01:29:15 it for a few months now is that we've got the law we've got the definition who's going to apply that
01:29:22 definition great question very great question who's going to apply the definition so let's go
01:29:27 back to jess i don't even know where she went but she's around here somewhere if jess feels that
01:29:31 something is offside i just want to record i want to rewind that a bit because like like i said it's
01:29:37 giving insecure it's giving like totally full of just like look at this body language
01:29:42 when he says all this who's gonna apply that definition i'll tell i'll tell you who yeah yeah
01:29:47 no we can we got it we got it we know the other thing that's really important to understand you
01:29:52 can tell i'm a bit sort of engaged on this because i've been dealing with it for a few months now
01:29:55 hey canada rv with the ten dollars thank you for the super chat sir would you be able to display
01:30:01 my channel in chat greg it's brand new and could use your help tube is hiding me well you're in
01:30:08 the super chats right now there he is click on it if you're in the chat canada rv check out his
01:30:14 channel he paid ten dollars there you go thank you for advertising on the youtube stream uh what
01:30:20 do you got going on over there you got rvs or what thank you for the donation i appreciate it
01:30:25 we're gonna get through here to keep going is that we've got the law we've got the definition
01:30:33 who's going to apply that definition? Great question. Very great question. Who's going to
01:30:39 apply the definition? So let's go back to Jess. I don't even know where she went, but she's around
01:30:43 here somewhere. If Jess feels that something is offside the definition of hatred, Jess puts up
01:30:48 her hand. The next step is for Metta. So Metta is going to say, well, here's the definition of
01:30:53 hatred. Do we agree with Jess or not? Metta can then decide to moderate Jess's exposure to that
01:30:58 material. Meta is not taking it down. Very important point, right? I told you what's coming
01:31:03 down. Child sex abuse material, revenge porn comes down 24 hours, all this other stuff. We've got to 0.94
01:31:08 reduce Jess's exposure to it, but we're not taking it out of the public domain. If you still think
01:31:14 Meta's decision maybe wasn't robust enough or is too robust, too aggressive, who deals with it? The
01:31:19 Digital Safety Commission. They come in and they say to Meta, well, we don't think you've got the
01:31:23 balance right here. If you still feel aggrieved that no, no, that wasn't hatred, that Jess is
01:31:28 wrong meta's wrong the digital safety commission's wrong you go to court you know what's important
01:31:32 about all four of those actors chess meta the digital safety commission and the court none of
01:31:38 them are named a reefer any or justin trudeau oh what what but they're your best friends what are
01:31:46 you talking about what kind of argument is this it's it's fellow bureaucrats right next to you
01:31:53 who you probably pick and choose to put on the Digital Safety Commission.
01:31:58 What are you talking about?
01:31:59 This talking point is so bad, Arif.
01:32:02 What the?
01:32:03 Am I dreaming?
01:32:06 That is just so...
01:32:08 You know the best thing about the Digital Safety Commission?
01:32:10 They're not me and Justin Trudeau.
01:32:13 Yeah, but they're going to be people that you pick
01:32:14 to be on the Digital Safety Commission.
01:32:17 Like, what the terrible argument?
01:32:21 Oh, my God, that's bad.
01:32:23 this is not something where we as political officials weighed in on what's going to be in
01:32:28 the public domain or not this is where other actors the four that i listed we are not public
01:32:34 officials waiting into what is in the public domain or not that the whole that's the whole
01:32:38 point of you making this bill is you saying i need to protect you know that that was the whole
01:32:43 introduction of this presentation arif of you saying i am going to determine what's good and
01:32:49 what's not good on the canadian internet and i'm going to decide and i'm going to make this happen
01:32:54 with bill c63 that's the whole premise of you is to wade into the public domain of what is allowed
01:33:01 and what is not allowed apply a definition that's entrenched in the statute that's really really
01:33:07 fundamental for people to understand looks like ai i'm not ai other thing that has come up a great
01:33:15 deal about this legislation in terms of sort of people criticizing this stuff but well we like the
01:33:20 points that deal with children and how we prosecute children because we're beefing that up as well
01:33:27 where we can prosecute children of the data the metas of the world have to transfer that data
01:33:32 to an rcmp uh child exploitation center they're clearly scoped into the bill etc that sounds super
01:33:39 creepy hey was your child sexually exploited just send all the photos to the rcmp okay i think i
01:33:46 think we're trying to understand what this is really about here but when people say to me that 0.97
01:33:49 you know okay you've explained to me a bit about the criminal code stuff but you've got this human
01:33:54 rights act aspect i'm not sure about this human rights act stuff like why should people be able
01:33:59 to raise their hand and say this is hate speech that's i love always going over all of like
01:34:04 people's concerns with the bill and it's like hey what about all this hate speech stuff it's like no
01:34:08 no no it's fine and now he's like yeah what about all this human rights stuff and he's like no no 0.76
01:34:12 it's fine like there's so many excuses that he has to give to try and rationalize this trash
01:34:17 piece of legislation it's very funny keep dancing keep singing and dancing buddy keep dancing for 0.90
01:34:22 us monkey boy discriminatory and complain about it in front of the human rights commission
01:34:27 and you know didn't we remove that as a parliament in 2013 you're right the previous government did
01:34:33 removed that under Stephen Harper. Yeah, we did. That removal deprived people of a root and a
01:34:39 recourse vis-a-vis the individual author of the material. So understand that when we talk about
01:34:44 the Digital Safety Commission, that layout that I just gave you, that was all vis-a-vis meta and
01:34:50 what it's exposing me to or not online. But here you would have Jess feeling aggrieved by an
01:34:56 individual, Arif Arani, and what recourse would she have against me personally? People said,
01:35:00 well, you're going to flood. It's going to be all full of BS complaints and bad faith
01:35:04 complaints. It's going to just inundate the commission and oh my God, the sky will fall.
01:35:08 Actually, we know this based on what happened when section 13 of the
01:35:12 Human Rights Code was already in effect. And it wasn't necessarily a flood.
01:35:16 It would be a flood now because a lot's changed since then. Everyone's sensitive to microaggressions
01:35:21 now, Arif. I'm sure you can appreciate that because you opened up your entire
01:35:24 presentation about how sensitive you are to the color of your skin and all this type of stuff.
01:35:28 um and you want and you want to what was it you want to protect people from
01:35:34 def uh defend people from safety but um no we know that the the most of the complaints from
01:35:42 section 13 were like someone abusing the piece of legislation i can't believe he's trying to
01:35:47 defend this this is so funny this is really good actually we'll probably clip this into something
01:35:54 people said well you're going to flood it's going to be all full of bs complaints and bad
01:35:59 faith complaints and it's going to just inundate the commission and oh my god the sky will fall
01:36:03 yeah we thought about that because we heard about it so there's four ways specifically how we
01:36:08 address that oh the first is that we define hatred the same definition i told you applies across the
01:36:14 act so a reef so it's not yeah again very broad definition you say that it's a high bar it's
01:36:20 really not casual comments do not arise to detestation or vilification unless i'm doing
01:36:26 things like calling for the extermination of a people secondly again he's muddying the waters
01:36:31 he's muddying the waters extermination like calling for the extermination of people is already
01:36:36 something that's illegal it's called incitement in the states whatever it's called here that's
01:36:41 already something that is in considered criminal speech calling for the the death of people
01:36:45 and he's saying no no detestation and vilification that's only calling for the death of people
01:36:50 no it's not again you're supposed to be the expert on this bill and you're just muddying 0.99
01:36:55 together all of these words to justify your bullshit it's very very detestable a reef come 0.98
01:37:00 on it's very dishonest we said to the human rights commission that if somebody's going to raise a 0.97
01:37:05 complaint under this new section 13 provision that you have the ability to summarily dismiss it so
01:37:10 for the budding lawyers in the room a summary dismissal mechanism is sort of a prima facie
01:37:15 the case has not been made out they just dismiss it out of hand no hearing nothing just gone
01:37:19 third they've always had the ability to weed out frivolous or vexatious complaints and fourth
01:37:25 rarely in an administrative context if somebody has used the process and is deemed to have abused
01:37:31 the process of the Canadian Human Rights Commission costs can be ordered against them
01:37:35 so it takes time and money to deal with some of these things in the Canadian Human Rights Commission
01:37:39 so you can have a punitive order of costs so if Jess felt aggrieved and I abused the
01:37:43 the provision she gets costs ordered against me and I pay for her legal costs
01:37:48 Like it's, I'm just thinking about, oh man, like we already have so much useless bureaucracy in this country and more and more of it is, is catering to like DEI stuff, diversity, equity, inclusion.
01:38:01 And, and this would really be like the Holy grail bringing in more human rights court stuff, all this taxpayer money spent on a bunch of complaints from people.
01:38:14 Oh, my God, dude.
01:38:17 Like, what a nightmare this country would become if this passes.
01:38:20 These are significant, and these help calibrate the impact of that measure,
01:38:24 which I think is really, really important. 0.98
01:38:29 Okay, what's your last bullshit? 0.98
01:38:30 The key piece, I think, about the legislation is that what we're trying to do 0.99
01:38:35 is ensure online safety for all Canadians.
01:38:39 And we're trying to meet them where they are with respect to the threats
01:38:42 that they're facing.
01:38:43 children adolescents adults i think that's really really critical what we're trying to do is ensure
01:38:50 that we are not leaving any particular group behind
01:38:53 really talk about the burning churches bro talk about the convoy protesters who had a car driven
01:39:05 into them they got vilified by the prime minister they're not going to talk about that we don't want
01:39:10 to leave uh anyone out trying to ensure that people can engage online fundamentally and engage
01:39:17 in a safe manner it's like totally the opposite of no you want to silence and censor people and
01:39:24 take away content that you you deem harmful what i'd say to you is that i hope you're interested
01:39:29 in this bill no doubt you are because you're here at this kind of forum and what i would say to you
01:39:34 is that i also need you to be reflective of canada's reality is that this isn't cookie cutter
01:39:39 legislation this is legislation that involves a lot of factors and people have voices and concerns
01:39:44 that they want to raise and what i want is for those voices and concerns to be raised most
01:39:49 specifically if you have ideas about how to improve the bill strengthen it how to attenuate it or make
01:39:55 it more detailed and precise those are exactly what i want to hear both now but also when this
01:40:00 bill gets to committee because at the justice committee is exactly where through parliamentary
01:40:04 process we're meant to be hearing about how to improve the bill uh i got a great solution for
01:40:10 the bill i got a really good thing for the bill actually i got a this will actually be great i
01:40:17 think i have the perfect solution for the bill um check this out i think this is probably
01:40:28 something like this what do you guys think i think that's pretty good for the bill
01:40:31 i think this would be great for the bill maybe this one i think this this would be good for
01:40:42 this is what we can do with bill c63 right here that one actually that's i think this is some
01:40:48 good this is this is my suggestion uh arif i think this would be probably best for for bill c63
01:40:54 this right here this this image of a trash can because it should be thrown in the trash let us
01:41:03 know if you want to do anything to fix it just throw it out guys just throw it out there's 0.53
01:41:07 nothing good in there it's a shameless power grab from a flailing liberal government it's 0.95
01:41:14 quite pathetic to watch actually but um i mean with any luck uh reef will kind of lose his
01:41:20 credibility as this bill kind of crashes and burns but if you want to ensure that happens
01:41:24 Make sure you support SaveFreeSpeech.ca.
01:41:27 Guys, we are making a documentary that's exposing the agenda behind pushing this bill
01:41:33 and really how biased it's going to be and how it's really all part of a censorship industry
01:41:38 or a political suppression industry to target people who have the wrong opinion in Canada.
01:41:44 If you want to support that, go to GiveSentGo.com slash SaveFreeSpeech.
01:41:48 We've got a couple more minutes here, and then I'm going to wrap it up real quick.
01:41:54 where are we
01:42:01 where'd it go
01:42:09 there we go
01:42:15 what I'd say to you is that it's really critical that it gets to committee
01:42:19 and here is where I'm just going to issue a plain call to action
01:42:23 that we are in a minority parliament right i was just talking to some americans and they can't
01:42:28 fathom how there'd be like four and a half parties and how does that work etc what do you mean you
01:42:32 could have a snap election etc etc so i walked them through all of that but in a minority parliament
01:42:37 we need what we call a dance partner right we need another party to support us getting this
01:42:42 committee and getting this through the house of commons what i'd say to you quite candidly is
01:42:46 please engage with parliamentarians you can engage with liberals as much as you want
01:42:50 but what I would really encourage you to do
01:42:53 is engage with the NDP
01:42:54 and also engage with the Bloc Québécois
01:42:56 so if that means dusting off your LaRousse
01:42:59 and your Bécharel, if you don't know what I'm talking
01:43:01 about, going on to Google Translate so you can
01:43:03 translate a letter in English
01:43:04 into French, please
01:43:07 reach out to different parliamentarians
01:43:09 because it is the Bloc and the NDP
01:43:11 that can help us expedite this bill and its
01:43:13 passage to the House of Commons but
01:43:15 it will not happen without Canadians
01:43:16 standing up and speaking out for what they believe
01:43:19 is necessary all right we believe that in the importance of ensuring that canadians and all
01:43:26 canadians children adolescents and adults are protected from what they're facing online and
01:43:33 empowered to participate online so i will leave it there and i'll be very happy to entertain your 0.92
01:43:38 questions wow what so much i feel like i need to shower after all that bullshit jeez louise anyway
01:43:46 guys thank you so much for watching 0.94
01:43:47 I just wanted to cover that react to that
01:43:50 again if you want
01:43:52 to help save free speech in Canada go to give saying
01:43:53 go.com slash save free speech we're making
01:43:56 a documentary check out
01:43:58 the website save free speech.ca
01:43:59 as well
01:44:00 we got a mailing list at the
01:44:03 bottom of every page there's a little link to the
01:44:05 mailing list to stay updated you can join
01:44:08 our newsletter but aside
01:44:10 from that thank you so much for watching everybody I saw
01:44:12 another super chat can I go back up
01:44:14 and read it thank you Canada RV for the five dollars I meant for you Greg post the direct
01:44:19 link to for them to click on it and in chat you being it you being an owner you can do it by
01:44:24 clicking on my name uh all right buddy there you go there's Canada RV's channel thanks for
01:44:35 watching guys um yeah till next time thanks for watching cheers do do do do do do do do do do do
01:45:05 Thank you.