Greg Wycliffe - January 16, 2025


Trump Annexing Canada? 🔴Randy Hillier INTERVIEW🔴Canadian Identity🔴Trudeau Resigns?🔴

Hosted by
Mentioned
Lessons from Convoy 2025 Race is a Social Construct - Kat Kanada

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 48 minutes

Words per minute

138.26

Word count

15,066

Sentence count

323

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

17

sentences flagged

Hate speech

13

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In our first live stream of the new year, Greg and Randy discuss the possibility of Canada being annexed to the United States of America, and whether or not this is a good or bad thing for Canada. Also, Greg asks the question, if Canada were to become part of the USA, who would get the power to pull the trigger?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 welcome everybody to 2025 i think this is my first live stream of 2025 hope you had a good
00:00:13 holiday season i'm here with the one and only randy hillier former mpp here in ontario for uh
00:00:21 frontenac kingston and lanark county is that right i might have got the order wrong
00:00:26 Pretty close. It usually goes Lanark, Frontenac, and Kingston. But other than the order, you got the words correct.
00:00:35 Fantastic. So I am ready to become an American patriot. Maybe I, I might be, be, you know, assume we might be all American. We're going to be talking all about this, this topic of being annexed to America. Is this good for Canadians? Is this bad for Canadians giving up our sovereignty to daddy Trump?
00:00:57 We're going to be talking about this from the financial angle, from the Canadian identity
00:01:01 angle.
00:01:02 So it should be a very fun and fruitful conversation.
00:01:06 I listened to the Twitter space that you did about it just the other night.
00:01:12 And well, let's kind of start there.
00:01:14 What did you think of the conversation that came with that Twitter space, Randy?
00:01:20 Oh, I think it was exceptionally good.
00:01:22 you know i've not done a lot of twitter spaces but it was a good quality i believe high caliber
00:01:30 conversation in large part a lot of good discussion came up and i think some of the unseen advantages
00:01:42 were also developed and came out the conversations about how canada has been in a state of
00:01:50 dysfunction for a long time and also a paralysis of constitutional change so it was good that
00:01:58 this should be seen as an opportunity to speak to a lot of the failings that are going on in our
00:02:09 in our own governance as well as looking at other options and i and i should add just for a moment
00:02:15 Greg, you know, the threat of tariffs and the annexation has been present throughout our entire history.
00:02:28 Our first free trade debate and threat goes back to the 1830s.
00:02:36 And you may, throughout the 1800s, early 1900s, whether it came in the phrase of reciprocity or John A. McDonald's, the old flag, the old nation, the old policy slogan, up until Brian Mulroney's NAFTA discussions, these have been underway throughout our entire history.
00:03:02 And I would say that they have always been used on both sides of the border, but especially here to coerce and cajole Canadians to feel threatened by the Americans and to, you know, there's the boogeyman down below the 49th.
00:03:26 And it has been used by all our political parties as a means to solidify and protect their exclusivity on the governance of our country.
00:03:49 and some might even say and i would say um protect their protection racket that the political 0.99
00:03:56 establishment operate in this country okay uh so so you're a dirty you're a dirty yank you're a 1.00
00:04:04 traitor you're you're sympathetic to these dirty yank i'm just i'm just kidding but uh actually i 0.99
00:04:09 found out we're not live yet on facebook uh your assistant might need the code um if you want to 0.95
00:04:17 get that over to him real quick sorry about that we tried to test that beforehand but for those
00:04:22 who don't know we are streaming on youtube on x slash twitter and we will be starting up soon on
00:04:29 the one and only facebook.com you may have seen can i leave this show for a moment and see if i
00:04:36 can do this or i'm not sure how uh if you want i could mute you and you could just tell me and
00:04:43 then i could relay it to our friend if you want does that work that'll work
00:04:48 all right all righty we're back um yeah so i um let's let's start with this question because i
00:05:09 I think it's very interesting.
00:05:10 And to be fair, I'm a little confused by all this annexation because it sounds, correct me if I'm wrong,
00:05:22 America is going in a sort of hostile fashion going to be like, we are coming after you, Canada.
00:05:28 We are going to impose significant financial penalties until you do what we want.
00:05:34 So I guess my question is, even if Canadians wanted to become part of America, would we even have the power to do that?
00:05:43 Like if the people in Ottawa don't want to become part of America, then, you know, what happens there?
00:05:51 Like do we even have any power or is it still going to be up to Justin Trudeau, the other guy, Carney, or the other guy, Polly F?
00:06:00 You know what I'm saying?
00:06:01 we have we have jurisprudence on this already that the supreme court has already ruled that
00:06:08 the provinces do have the lawful and legal authority to separate from the confederation
00:06:15 okay that's quebec had a number of referendums you know there's a clear-cut um criteria that
00:06:24 must be followed to do so but that is within every province's ability at the current time
00:06:31 so so who's who would pull the trigger who get who has the actual power who has the actual
00:06:37 authority to make that happen in the case of alberta or quebec for example well each province
00:06:44 um either through public pressure or political pressure could announce a referendum uh to
00:06:52 separate from the confederation and as we know quebec has done that on a few occasions
00:06:59 the referendums have never been successful close but not quite and then the province would be
00:07:06 outside of confederation and they can choose what to do as they wish at that time whether it's to be
00:07:12 a standalone nation or attach themselves with some other entity and you know that is part of
00:07:21 canada's history as well like newfoundland joined confederation through a referendum
00:07:27 and the choice was do they want to be a standalone country do they want to attach themselves with the
00:07:33 united states or attach themselves to canada in 1949 and they chose canada in in 49 so
00:07:40 So that is the law of the land as we sit here today.
00:07:52 Now, let's get into the more cynical side of things.
00:07:58 Like this idea that, oh, oh, we're just going to add another state.
00:08:02 We're just going to add another state of Canada.
00:08:05 um i feel like that's to think that we're just going to be like another state is is very you
00:08:12 know naive thinking uh like in another way i mean there's a there's a lot to the sort of exception
00:08:19 how how adding canada to the u.s would be very exceptional in terms of like it's not just like
00:08:24 wyoming it's not just like some other you know chunk of land it's a massive piece of land that
00:08:29 is larger than america itself with a lot of uh you know oceans attached to it a lot of you know
00:08:36 a lot going on in terms of uh land mass so you know this is one of the reasons you know it was a
00:08:44 very um broad but little there was no details to trump's um proposal to an ex-canada zero
00:08:56 And that's why I sent the president a letter last week saying, let's flesh out some of these details.
00:09:07 What are you actually proposing here?
00:09:09 Are you proposing that Canada as a whole join or be annexed as one state?
00:09:16 Or are you talking about each of our provinces joining as a separate state, each with their own elected senators and each with their own congressional seats?
00:09:31 Are you proposing that this be done through referendums?
00:09:35 You know, so I sent off that letter to Trump to ask for some clarification so that Canadians can actually make an informed choice, or at least before you accept or reject a proposal, you need to have some meat on the bones and some details.
00:09:57 So I've sent that off. And I think it's, these are important considerations. You know, obviously, well, I spelled it out. I think this idea of having a singular state called Canada is a, would be a foolhardy idea.
00:10:19 And, you know, that's my position.
00:10:25 But there may be some merit to it if each province would join as a separate state.
00:10:36 But I think, you know, the other thing that is really important to me, Greg, is that I find such astonishing and perplexing, you know, that here all our political establishment parties for decades.
00:10:55 And I mean, for most of my lifetime, have been degrading, diminishing, debasing, and even going so far as Justin Trudeau saying that there is no Canadian identity.
00:11:10 And now, and for the last couple of years, we've kept our flag at half mass because we're supposed to be ashamed of our heritage and our history.
00:11:20 And now, with Trump's single words of a 51st state, we all are supposed to rally around this flag that we've been ashamed of for so long, and who Trudeau says, we have no identity.
00:11:37 Now, this is the zenith of hypocrisy, in my view, that, and it's not just Trudeau, we have been willing to accept an invasion of immigration, of rampant and uncontrolled immigration to that diminishes and dilutes our Canadian heritage and our identity.
00:11:59 but we're supposed to fear the americans uh you know i can't reconcile those that the paradox of
00:12:07 the behaviors and actions of our established political parties with their words
00:12:14 very very well said and we had conversations before this interview where you were saying
00:12:22 this is a good opportunity to talk about canadian identity and maybe reassert our canadian identity
00:12:27 and ironically though it's left-wingers who are trying to do that more so it seems
00:12:34 you know it's it's left-wingers it's trudeau supporters it's these ndp supporters it's
00:12:39 jagmeet singh saying you're not hey hey trump hands off our canadian identity 0.95
00:12:45 uh says the guy in the turban um the hypocrisy is greatest on the left but
00:12:52 the right is not much better in this regard uh you know uh pierre thinks uh canada will be much
00:13:00 better if we have direct flights to amritsar rather than to washington dc that isn't that
00:13:07 clip crazy yeah isn't that clip just absolutely crazy did you see the the recent one that
00:13:13 surfaced he's like surrounded by all of this indian media i guess and he's just like i seek
00:13:19 community i got i got seek people on my cabinet top members of the cabinet and uh amatsar amatsar
00:13:26 he says it three different times in the course of a minute and it's like oh my gosh this this is our
00:13:31 conservative party guy uh quite alarming yeah but if you know if we stay on our present path
00:13:39 there will not be a canadian identity there will not be a canadian culture
00:13:45 um and uh but we're not supposed to fear that we're supposed to embrace that uh but fear
00:13:53 um the americans and you know i'll go back like donald trump has uh asserted that our border is
00:14:01 an artificial border that it's just a line on a map um but you know i think when when justin
00:14:09 trudeau says there is no canadian identity he's reinforcing um trump's assertion that there is no
00:14:17 border um yeah you know why why is it that we want to protect this if if we don't have an identity 1.00
00:14:24 if and according to trudeau we have never had an identity now obviously i think he's full of shit 0.97
00:14:31 um and uh and he's also being dishonest he might not know his identity um but i i know 0.95
00:14:41 what a canadian is um and everybody i know knows what a canadian is um so um but i but i do think
00:14:51 this is it gives us the opportunity we have been in a very dysfunctional form of confederation for
00:14:57 some time. And we have been in a state of political paralysis in trying to solve this
00:15:06 conundrum. And maybe Trump's assertion has got a real silver lining in it that maybe now we can
00:15:16 start addressing the problems in our nation. And that's been very exposed, very coming to light
00:15:24 once again with uh the different positions between alberta and in ontario uh and how to
00:15:33 deal with these uh the big boogeyman of tariffs from from trump yeah yeah no you bring up a lot
00:15:42 of good points there um with the uh the liberals acting like they're more canadian when really just
00:15:51 uh they've been selling us out this whole time um i mean what scares me liberals but but you know
00:16:00 right they they largely but not just him let's it's all established political parties yeah in my
00:16:07 view yeah yeah yeah um i guess why it why it spooks me a little bit is uh you know
00:16:16 this seems like a sort of deal with the devil you know it's like okay hey you're struggling
00:16:24 you're suffering all you got to do just take my hand take my hand and everything will be okay
00:16:29 and what scares me about this is like you can't really undo this you can't just like become part
00:16:34 of america and then stop being part of america like the amount of bureaucratic work paperwork
00:16:40 work it would take to, uh, you know, iron all this out would very much, it wouldn't be something
00:16:46 that's easily undone. And, um, I'm seeing so much optimism from people saying that this would be
00:16:54 good. And I get it. There's a lot of financial upsides. Like we were really in a, in a, in a
00:16:59 rough kind of spot here in Canada, um, because we don't have power here, right? We, we, the Canadian
00:17:05 people fear powerless so you know so why does it matter what we say or how we think it's going to
00:17:14 happen um i i guess like this conversation is is almost like reminiscent of sitting at a pot like
00:17:22 of the when i first joined politics uh with the ppc we'd have these pub nights and people would
00:17:29 and i didn't i didn't hang out on many of the pub nights because i because i realized after a while
00:17:32 it just kind of descends into, well, this is what I think the ideal society is. And this is what I
00:17:37 think the ideal society is. And it's like, okay, well, we have no political power. So that doesn't
00:17:42 really matter. And I feel like it's this conversation of becoming America, it kind of
00:17:48 reminds me of that. It's like, well, this could be great. And that could be great. And this could
00:17:51 happen. And it could be, and it's just pure optimism, and a sort of complete neglection
00:17:58 of the fact of like, well, will you have any political power? Will they have any political
00:18:02 power? No, it's going to be a bunch of bureaucrats. And what creeps me out is this idea that American 0.99
00:18:08 bureaucrats are going to make better decisions than the Canadian bureaucrats. You know what I'm
00:18:15 saying? We're familiar with Canadian bureaucrats and how much we hate them and how much they've
00:18:21 screwed us over. But this idea that somehow American bureaucrats who are unfamiliar with
00:18:27 canada and unfamiliar with canadian people are somehow going to to make better decisions and
00:18:32 sort of like rectify and resolve all the problems here it it seems uh kind of you know kind of like
00:18:41 a fantasy let me address the first thing sure if if if you are indeed powerless um and have no
00:18:49 influence then you are not living in a democracy you are living in communism if you do not have
00:18:57 any agency or influence in the outcome of your country okay so uh is that what we are that we
00:19:06 are helpless uh victims that we are just uh pebbles on the beach waiting for the next wave
00:19:13 to take us to wherever it may take us are we just a snowflake waiting for the next wind to blow us
00:19:19 that's not my view of being a member and a citizen of this country I'm not a helpless victim
00:19:28 I'm not just going to go where some political winds want to take me I may end up going there
00:19:37 but I'm going to fight it or or have my say in in it and I think that's you know both nations have
00:19:45 big problems um and but i think most of us would agree that they have a an executive branch
00:19:55 now elected that recognizes the problems in this nation and is uh at least has given every
00:20:03 indication that it is going to uh smatter and smash um the the deep state and the bureaucratic
00:20:12 state in the u.s no will they be will he be successful i'm not i'm not sure but at least
00:20:18 there's a recognition of it and in the people of the united states had the ability to vote
00:20:27 for their executive branch that promoted that idea here in canada obviously we have a different
00:20:35 system and we don't get to vote for our executive branch but i but i also want to take back
00:20:41 yeah one of the dysfunctions uh i mentioned ford and and smith and here uh doug ford it feels very
00:20:51 threatened or so he says about the uh american tariffs and and his uh solution according to
00:21:02 Doug Ford is for the taps to be turned off of Western energy that go to the United States
00:21:11 as a retaliatory measure. Now, of course, that same oil and gas that flows through the pipelines
00:21:19 to the United States also flows back west and north to Ontario. So if we turn off the taps
00:21:29 of Alberta oil and gas to the US,
00:21:33 the people in central Canada are going to be in the cold as well.
00:21:37 But he's not concerned about the welfare, the revenue,
00:21:44 the prosperity of the people in Alberta and Saskatchewan.
00:21:48 He's playing for political brownie points here in Ontario.
00:21:52 And he's also willing to sacrifice the huge electricity exports
00:21:58 from quebec uh to uh to the northeastern states uh maybe he doesn't realize that our electricity
00:22:08 grids are interconnected and you can't turn off our energy in one direction on electricity
00:22:15 um you know if we turn off our electricity there we're turning off uh the return uh so um but one
00:22:24 of the great problems that this exposes and this was just like the national energy program in the
00:22:29 80s by uh trudeau senior um the senators uh are not elected uh there's a disproportionate number
00:22:41 of senators uh ontario has 24 senators quebec has 24 senators um alberta has six um and they're all
00:22:51 appointed by what right at the moment justin trudeau but they're appointed by the prime minister
00:22:57 um that is one of the improvements i think everybody would say with the american system
00:23:02 that you do have elected senators for each jurisdiction and it's an equal amount of
00:23:10 senators so rhode island doesn't have any fewer or any more senators in california or texas
00:23:18 um you know our this really exposes how central canada ontario and quebec have
00:23:28 benefited greatly from confederation but at the expense of the maritimes and of our western
00:23:36 provinces as well and and they're willing to sacrifice the west again um to protect
00:23:43 uh doug ford's political position here in ontario just out of curiosity real quick um the west
00:23:51 minister system which we inherited i guess from uh from britain did they do the same thing where
00:23:56 the prime minister just uh assigns people senate seats is that the same they have a different
00:24:03 system their their senate is called the house of lords and it's the peerage um so not quite the
00:24:12 same but um um and of course they also don't have uh uh subnational but sovereign jurisdictions
00:24:21 there's no provinces uh they do have now wales has in scotland have a uh their own parliaments
00:24:29 uh and they would be close to our canadian provinces but not quite they they don't have
00:24:36 the ability to succeed as we do here.
00:24:41 Okay.
00:24:42 Guys, folks, if you have a question or comment for Randy Hillier, you can send a super chat
00:24:48 to make sure that we get to it.
00:24:50 We're going to keep on going down this topic of getting annexed by America.
00:24:56 Before we kind of go back into the pros and cons, I kind of wanted to take a step back
00:25:01 to you know realistically do you think this is actually the intention of trump or do you think
00:25:08 this is more of a sort of uh pr sort of um tactic negotiation tactic if you will the story i heard
00:25:16 is he really wants to get greenland but he's just putting trump on or canada on the table
00:25:21 to kind of you know be more more boisterous with his negotiations it's hard to speak to somebody's
00:25:30 motivations and no one can do anything other than speculate on that and and it's not
00:25:38 you know are my speculations any have any greater value or weight than your speculations
00:25:45 but i would say that there i think trump understands that there's a great geopolitical
00:25:51 problem that the Americans are facing with the rising BRICS alliance and the very significant
00:26:02 pressures being applied on the U.S. dollar. So, you know, I'm not sure what all his motivations
00:26:14 are but you can see um there is we are moving away from the unipolar uh american hegemony
00:26:26 uh of the world into a more multipolar uh world and um and i think yeah both all of these the
00:26:37 the his musings on panama on greenland and on canada may all be aligned with or part of this
00:26:50 changing geopolitical world that we're living in so when it comes to the bricks thing
00:26:57 how is us you know america and canada having a good tight relationship good trade relations
00:27:06 how how does that not help us compete with bricks why does it have to be us being consumed by
00:27:13 america for us to you know protect ourselves from the the threat of bricks i don't know why you use
00:27:19 the word consumed by them like if we came in as equal uh and and truly representative uh states
00:27:29 uh with representative democracies is that being consumed by um i mean during the space
00:27:36 during the space last night with uh bruce party he said himself that you know we're coming into
00:27:42 this negotiation from not from a place of strength like we're coming in from the people
00:27:47 with less cards in our hands less less sort of place to make uh and you know at the end of the
00:27:53 it's about power and when it comes to marketers when it comes to business when it comes to
00:28:01 politics i really think the states are much better at all those things and i think we would get the
00:28:07 short end of the stick at every single negotiation table when it comes to setting up how this would
00:28:11 work well well right now we're running away from the table greg we don't we're fearful of the table
00:28:18 Like we won't even go near it. And that's, you know, I think that puts us in a very, very dangerous and precarious position when you won't even face the adversity and sit down and challenge them.
00:28:34 And I have a slightly different view about our abilities as Canadians dealing with the Americans. 0.75
00:28:43 We have shown throughout our history that we may not be as boastful about our abilities.
00:28:53 We may not be as exuberant about our abilities.
00:28:57 But there's clearly through our history, we have shown that we're a very resilient and very tough, even though quiet culture.
00:29:08 And, you know, when the Americans needed toughness to keep the communist Chinese from overrunning their positions in Korea, it was the Canadians who held that cap young and went back.
00:29:27 down um so you know and we have a long proud uh history uh and that didn't just come about because
00:29:35 well we're sort of lucky and we're sort of just in the right place at the right time um
00:29:41 canada does indeed have this very unique uh um history and culture of being again not not boastful
00:29:52 but being bloody well tough and not backing down so um you know we've gone through negotiations
00:29:59 with the americans uh throughout our history um why would we think that we're incapable
00:30:06 or less than able to go through negotiations again well is do you think this is a strong
00:30:14 negotiation tactic from doug ford he's got the hat he's got the uh you know he's doing a press
00:30:20 conference um let's say you're you're in doug ford's shoes or you're in you know um what what
00:30:28 would you do in response to this if you had the freedom of course and you weren't shackled by some
00:30:33 establishment party uh you know what what would your response be or would it be simply what you
00:30:38 did which was sending a letter to trump to ask about the specifics of the arrangement
00:30:41 yeah i sit down and talk uh when somebody's offering up a proposal you sit down and talk
00:30:48 You know, I certainly wouldn't go out to Donald Trump and say, listen, Donald, we're going to sacrifice Alberta, Saskatchewan and our Western provinces just so I can look tough and present some optics that I'm a tough guy.
00:31:08 um you know and that's what he's doing here he's just presenting a uh um a false uh but important
00:31:18 um pr view to the canadian you know rally around the flag and i'll be holding the flag
00:31:25 says doug uh doug ford uh even though he's got half masked the whole time that he's standing
00:31:31 there so um and putting the crews to everybody else i i feel like it's completely insulting
00:31:37 for any canadian politician to wear a hat that says we're not for sale like you haven't sold
00:31:46 out the canadian people in one way or another doug ford you know like that you know what i mean
00:31:51 well this is you know in my time in politics i've often used a term that
00:31:56 you know that you should think of political parties our established political parties
00:32:01 is nothing less than or different than a crime family and and they run a protection racket and
00:32:09 you know and really if you look at the numbers in canada now over half of our total gdp
00:32:17 is public sector spending by our municipal provincial and federal government see they
00:32:23 They consume over 50% of the earnings and the efforts of all Canadians.
00:32:31 You know, who is attacking our families?
00:32:34 Is it Trump or is it our political parties?
00:32:39 Who is creating the homelessness that is rampant and escalating in our country?
00:32:45 Is it Trump or is it our political parties?
00:32:50 Who is it making it that it's impossible for anybody under the age of 40 in this country to be able to afford to buy a single family home and to afford to have a family?
00:33:03 It's not Trump and it's not the United States who's causing that.
00:33:07 That's our own established political parties. 0.98
00:33:10 Who's destroying and promoting this gender dysphoria and attacking our children? 1.00
00:33:19 Is it the Americans or is it our own established political parties? 0.99
00:33:24 But they want us to fear Donald Trump, even though they have savaged and ravaged and plundered the Canadian population to a degree.
00:33:34 not you know it's hard to see another um western liberal democracy being so viciously plundered 0.67
00:33:44 uh as it is in kenda yeah i mean you you make you make a great argument there you know who's
00:33:51 the real enemy what what has trump done to you um but then again one could say well he hasn't
00:33:57 had the trump yes he hasn't had the opportunity to uh you know screw us over yet but i do want to
00:34:02 uh even biden like it was biden causing these things or or before him uh obama or whatnot
00:34:11 no these are the policies that have been uh propagated promoted and entrenched by both
00:34:19 liberal and conservatives and supported by the ndp uh party in canada so like there's there's been
00:34:27 no choice for a long time there's been no political choice for a long time
00:34:34 in kenda all the three major parties are all on the same agenda yeah there's there's no doubt
00:34:43 about that there's no doubt about that and you know i i just i i find the you know maybe maybe
00:34:50 we won't even have a choice and maybe we like we will have to become part of america i don't know
00:34:55 But as someone who's been trying to, you know, invigorate people to give a fuck about Canada, part of my language.
00:35:04 But ever since I've joined Canadian politics, it's like pulling teeth to try to get people to actually care about this place. 0.93
00:35:09 Because a lot of the time we have Americanized media.
00:35:12 They care more about the Mueller scandal or all this stuff about an American policy or an American political scandal.
00:35:21 Not so much about the stuff going on here.
00:35:24 That's changed a little bit.
00:35:25 but it's so hard to get Canadians to care about Canadian politics and I look at it as we are a
00:35:34 younger nation we're a younger nation who hasn't really gone through any sort of big character
00:35:39 building moments especially when it comes to our own government being horribly corrupt
00:35:46 and rectifying that and I'm hoping that we'll be able to build our character and become a distinct
00:35:53 nation into the future but this is this is a kind of you know very pivotal moment where it's like
00:35:58 maybe again maybe we will sort of uh we won't get to mature to be that independent nation and
00:36:04 we'll actually instead sort of you know fall into the fold of the american system just by virtue of
00:36:10 the crooks were in charge for too long and we weren't able to keep our sovereignty because 0.95
00:36:15 a bunch of selfish self-serving uh narcissists uh incestuous ottawa bubble screwed us over for 0.97
00:36:23 too many generations well so the the crooks as i said the crooks and the carnies have been in 0.99
00:36:30 control of this country for too long and and we got another uh crook and carny coming up shortly
00:36:36 from the looks of it but but what what would happen if albert who said today uh or tomorrow
00:36:43 we're going to have a referendum we are not going to allow central canada to put the screws to us
00:36:52 again and we're going to have a referendum to uh to leave confederation
00:36:58 and we want to have either equal representation yeah in an elected representation in the senate
00:37:09 and we want equal representation for all provinces or we're going to have a referendum
00:37:16 to make sure that we have options that doesn't allow ottawa to put the screws to the four million
00:37:25 people who live in alberta maybe that might be a trigger for to get us out of this constitutional
00:37:33 paralysis that we've been in for 40 some years now um and um you know so this is i this is where
00:37:42 i think the real value lies here is this is a um an opportunity that we haven't had in 40 some years
00:37:51 to actually uh look in the mirror and say do we have the gumption do we have the fortitude
00:38:01 to now look at what is wrong with Canada and can we now fix it or are we just those helpless
00:38:12 snowflakes waiting for the winds to blow us around are we that that little grain of sand
00:38:20 waiting for the next current or tide to take us away you know and if we are that helpless
00:38:30 if we are that snowflake well then we will be taken right right and it won't be and we won't
00:38:38 be taken anywhere good yeah yeah and let's i wanted to ask you about that and you started
00:38:45 to answer it so let's dig into that a bit more let's say for just for sake of conversation
00:38:50 uh trump does not annex canada and this doesn't end up playing out how can we as people who want
00:38:58 to improve this country use this sort of talking point use this flashpoint as leverage or as a sort
00:39:05 of jumping off point to kind of push for you know constitutional reform or sort of major seismic
00:39:11 changes because it's very clear that a lot of people have an appetite for you know what this
00:39:18 sort of represents the it's an opportunity for a reset yeah it's an opportunity but it is you know
00:39:24 it's an opportunity for making major changes to the system in Canada
00:39:28 to the benefit of the Canadian people.
00:39:30 Imagine that, right?
00:39:32 Well, our political parties will never do anything like this.
00:39:37 Our established political parties will never undertake ideas
00:39:44 like a referendum or a constitutional discussion.
00:39:49 And we, you know, that is the ultimate third rail in Canadian politics.
00:39:55 Unless there is a threat to them, unless there is a danger to their control over the government.
00:40:05 Why is it a third rail?
00:40:07 Why is it a taboo subject for these Ottawa creatures?
00:40:11 Well, we've created this, like our media.
00:40:14 I don't know if you were around or how much you were paying attention during the late 70s and early 80s with the originally the patriation and then the Charlottetown and the Meech Lake Accords.
00:40:26 Like, it really was put forth as that this is a crisis, that this is, you know, it's an overwhelming mountain that no normal mortal man or woman can climb up this constitutional mountain that we have here.
00:40:48 um and and you better just uh stay at home and uh you know we will threaten the breakup of our
00:40:58 nation if we even begin to engage in a discussion on constitutional reform i'm just yeah no i'm just
00:41:08 gonna bring that up real quick because i i i'm not aware of this piece of history maybe we can
00:41:13 you know continue to talk about it because it sounds interesting the meets lake accord in 1987
00:41:17 Prime Minister Brian Mulroney attempted to win Quebec's consent
00:41:21 to the revised Canadian constitution.
00:41:23 The result was the Meech Lake Accord.
00:41:25 It was an agreement between the federal and provincial governments
00:41:27 to amend the constitution.
00:41:29 The accord proposed strengthening provincial powers
00:41:32 and declaring Quebec a distinct society.
00:41:35 The accord was never put into effect.
00:41:37 Political support for it unraveled in 1990.
00:41:40 Many Quebecois saw the accord's failure in English Canada
00:41:42 as a rejection of Quebec.
00:41:44 Support for separatism soared in Quebec
00:41:46 and led to the 1995 Quebec referendum.
00:41:49 So this idea of changing the Constitution
00:41:52 was then completely vilified as like,
00:41:54 this might break the country, don't try it ever again.
00:41:57 That's right.
00:41:58 And, you know, that was a, you know,
00:42:03 I think it was worthwhile of Mulroney
00:42:07 trying to bring in Quebec into signing onto the Constitution.
00:42:13 Many of the elements of the Meech Lake Accord,
00:42:15 i think were good to strengthen provincial jurisdictions um the the failing was in this
00:42:23 undefined and unknown quebec will be a distinct society and what does what did that actually mean
00:42:31 and nobody nobody wanted to uh enter into any discussions or to flesh that idea out
00:42:39 um so um so both uh newfoundland ran out the clock and never had a vote on uh on the meech
00:42:48 lake accord and uh uh and also um i don't know if you remember this elijah harper a
00:42:56 indigenous canadian who was a mla in the manitoba legislature uh ran out the clock
00:43:02 uh in the manitoba legislature and um and that was enough to kill those two actions killed the
00:43:12 meach lake accord um quebec went and uh a few years later would have their referendum
00:43:19 only missed out by like a point or two um from leaving confederation um and and and canadians
00:43:29 have ever since been let's not even uh uh let's not even think about it um like this is too
00:43:37 dangerous a subject like everything is working just leave everything alone uh uh but things
00:43:45 aren't working you know we have seen a continually uh continued degradation of our heritage of our
00:43:53 wealth of our standard of living um so things aren't working for canadians uh my my children
00:44:02 and my grandchildren are very unlikely to have as prosperous a life or as free a life as me
00:44:11 unless we change paths very soon and and those are the first generations of canadians who will
00:44:21 not do better than than the ones before them and that's that's an indictment that we really
00:44:29 ought to be the ones uh that should be for front and center in our discussions interesting so
00:44:35 i don't know my canadian history very well and that's why i love having conversations with you
00:44:40 because you can tell me about these very significant pieces of history like the
00:44:44 meach lake accord i know you're probably looking at me like greg how the hell do you not know about
00:44:48 this uh but uh i mean this explains a lot i i've always had this this impression that um it's
00:44:55 almost like canadians are disincentivized to care about their politics like it's like oh it's too
00:45:00 complicated don't worry about it and this this flashpoint of the meach lake accord almost seems
00:45:04 like a sort of uh trauma that's informed a lot of our politics of don't do anything too bold okay
00:45:11 don't do anything hey don't try to mess with that don't try to like you know reinvent the wheel here
00:45:16 don't ruffle any feathers right that that's sort of a Canadian identity trope that unfortunately
00:45:22 is more true than it's not true I think but it's interesting that there's sort of historical
00:45:28 events like this representing that demeanor I guess well and this again speaks to one of the
00:45:35 big failings like this attack on our heritage and identity it comes from all quarters our public
00:45:43 education system has uh really downplayed and uh and have graduated uh people with total ignorance
00:45:53 of our history and our heritage um you know and our political parties and our institutions have
00:46:00 also um um you know do the same thing um so you know like but we uh these are not things that we
00:46:11 We should, you know, things like the Meech Lake Accord and the Charlottetown Accord and whatnot.
00:46:17 These are not things that should prevent us from improving our country, but give us cause to actually overcome those challenges.
00:46:31 It is a big challenge, and it ought to be a big challenge to amend our Constitution, but it should not be an impossibility.
00:46:40 if you cannot change your constitution then that is not a a document that protects freedom
00:46:48 it's one that enslaves people yeah if you guys have any questions for randy hillier make sure
00:46:54 that you send a super chat or a comment that'll make sure that i that i get to read it to him
00:47:00 um i want to bring up this uh i did a couple polls on twitter randy uh one was okay canada
00:47:08 So would you rather become part of America or keep your sovereignty?
00:47:13 Some people didn't like that framing.
00:47:14 They're like, what's sovereignty?
00:47:15 What are you talking about?
00:47:17 But I did a second poll to say if Kamala Harris was president, would you want to still become part of America?
00:47:28 And obviously the results were quite different.
00:47:30 If I want to be part of Trump's America, I don't want to be part of Kamala's America.
00:47:36 and i feel like this is significant uh sort of significant you know it's it's a poll on twitter
00:47:44 but at the end of the day i feel like the appetite now for us to kind of just instinctively want to
00:47:50 join america it's coming a lot from the right wing and it there is this sort of gravitation
00:47:56 i think towards trump in general the sort of trust that trump will make canada great again
00:48:02 and before your response i just want to throw like another kind of wrench into the conversation
00:48:07 you know we have a lot of potential democrat voters in canada and as we know there are
00:48:14 city centers like toronto or there's a big population montreal there's a big population
00:48:18 a lot of democrat voters and how do we know that the way that they set up the electoral college
00:48:25 in canada if we do become part of america how do we know that it won't favor once again these sort
00:48:31 of heavily populated city centers to tilt the scales towards uh towards democrats in the future
00:48:39 election and then we've become part of the america that gets ruled over by the next democrat uh
00:48:46 candidate and then uh you know then it's more gun grabs it's more you know censorship it's like you
00:48:54 know out of the frying pan into the into the fire so to speak so i would say you know i think most
00:49:01 people objectively will say that the american constitution and the american republic in their
00:49:09 electoral system has greater checks and balances it's far from perfect but it's it has greater
00:49:16 checks and balances incorporated into it than our canadian system it also has some simplicity to it
00:49:24 Because, yeah, you know that you're voting separately for your representative than from the executive.
00:49:34 Where in Canada, of course, that gets very muddied and murky because we don't actually vote for the executive.
00:49:42 And our head of state is actually an appointment.
00:49:45 Where in the states you have a clear delineation.
00:49:48 You can vote for a Democrat president or executive.
00:49:54 and also vote for a Republican congressman or a Republican senator.
00:50:00 So it's much simpler and easier for people to understand,
00:50:06 I think, as well as the checks and balances.
00:50:11 And obviously, if you frame up that poll question,
00:50:16 it would be the same thing if you framed up a poll question,
00:50:20 do you want to be um do you want to have justin trudeau as prime minister or you know somebody
00:50:28 else like there's going to be um you know um you know then it becomes a personality that your vote
00:50:36 that you're surveying not the the system um and you know the american electoral college and this
00:50:45 again this is why i put out this letter to trump let's let's talk about this what are the actual
00:50:50 proposals that you're you're considering or you want to consider um you know uh each um
00:50:58 if each province was to become an american state then the electoral college votes would be
00:51:05 determined by the population of the the province or the new state um so obviously ontario would
00:51:14 have far more electoral college votes than pei um um but um you know that's that's a built-in
00:51:23 counterweight but all the votes go one way or the other um with the overall plurality um for the
00:51:33 vote for the executive uh not this you know how many seats did you get and uh and you know uh
00:51:42 having um you know as we see here the executive um uh branch of our government the the cabinet
00:51:50 can be elected with um what would be i think trudeau got 36 percent of the vote um uh in the
00:51:58 last um we actually got fewer votes than the progressive conservative party last the last
00:52:05 election. So that becomes that murkiness and that muddiness between seats and actual votes.
00:52:14 So, but again, you know, I think this also offers the opportunity, you know, in many of our
00:52:22 provincial jurisdictions, there's been discussion that there should be some changes and divisions
00:52:29 within our own provincial boundaries. You know, for a significant period of time, there has been
00:52:35 a groundswell of support for northern ontario to be separated from southern ontario there's even
00:52:42 been a lot of discussion about separating um toronto and the dtha from the rest of ontario
00:52:50 there's a lot of discussion in bc about separating uh creating a separate provincial jurisdiction
00:52:57 for the lower mainland from the rest of bc so those are all things that may have um
00:53:06 may be very justified um and and be very credible um uh options to consider um
00:53:16 you know like uh you know we're sort of in this canadians have this sort of fixed
00:53:21 thing that uh government and nations and boundaries and whatnot are inviolable and can never alter
00:53:29 and well again that's just not true we just changed the boundaries of the northwest
00:53:34 territories a few years ago we created a brand new territory um it wasn't that hard it wasn't
00:53:41 that difficult um in 1949 we admitted a an entire a former colony and former independent nation
00:53:50 called newfoundland labrador uh into our confederation now uh you know candace history
00:53:57 is one of uh of like the americans of of changing boundaries but somehow now uh we we think that
00:54:07 this is just impossible to do
00:54:10 yeah yeah yeah no absolutely there's a certain sense of uh permanence that the thing things are
00:54:17 not allowed to change yeah things have always been this way um emma the cat and friends thank
00:54:24 you so much for the five dollars i'm gonna ask your question in a second because it kind of
00:54:29 relates on where i want to take the conversation but i want to i wanted to before we get into emma
00:54:33 the cat and friends question um i want to share another one of my concerns with with this idea of
00:54:41 you know becoming part of america which is it it just seems ever since i've paid attention close
00:54:47 to canadian politics it seems that you know if if canadian interests aren't of the canadian people
00:54:54 i mean of the actual canadian people if they're not being super superseded by the interests of
00:55:00 like trudeau with like you know immigrants and refugees coming first like their interests are
00:55:04 more important if it's not superseded by you know the interest of lobbyists or or foreign special
00:55:11 interests or there's some foreign interference going on or maybe it's the milk cartels the
00:55:15 corporatists coming before canadian interests well it gets superseded by the interests of quebec
00:55:21 right and and it just it feels like there would be another added layer of uh our interests being
00:55:28 superseded once again of course by america so like add on top of all that it's like well
00:55:32 the the interests of america and washington dc is going to come before all of that other stuff
00:55:38 it just feels like it would be another layer um that would separate the canadian people from
00:55:44 actually getting what they want um from the bureaucrats lording over them well i would say
00:55:50 the first number of items that you put there greg are all indeed factual um and correct the
00:55:57 the interests of the canadian people are superseded by the interests of the lobbyists the
00:56:03 interests of um um the canadian people are superseded by the corporate interests they're
00:56:10 also superseded by um special interests and by foreign interests like that is all true uh and it's
00:56:18 it ought to be obvious uh to everyone um you know just think of you know i often use this um myself
00:56:26 and many others have faced significant criminal charges because we were in ottawa or like marco
00:56:34 in in alberta moved a pylon and charged got charged with mischief uh and it's been sentenced
00:56:40 to four months in jail um you know galen weston the owner of loblaws and wallace mccain the owner
00:56:47 of mccain foods were convicted of engaging in a uh decade-long uh price-fixing cartel on bread which
00:56:57 stole approximately 10 billion dollars from canadians um the crown attorneys have never
00:57:04 charged wallace mccain or gaylon weston for that crime the toronto dominion bank was recently
00:57:11 convicted in the united states and fined for facilitating for doing money laundering for the
00:57:19 drug cartels in the movement of fentanyl and they were fined in the united states but but
00:57:26 the toronto dominion bank is headquartered here in ontario in toronto the crime attorneys have never
00:57:32 attempted to charge the directors and and the officers of the TD Bank the you
00:57:44 know and we could go to see SNC-Lavalin was got a deferred prosecution the
00:57:52 Crown Attorneys you know that was the Wilson-Raybould affair in SNC-Lavalin
00:57:58 engaged in significant criminal activity, but SNC-Lavalin and none of their directors or
00:58:06 officers were charged. But people like myself and Leach and Marco and Barber and many others
00:58:14 were the targets. So, you know, that's just one other further proof point that the interests of
00:58:23 Canadians are super super have been superseded by a great many interests for a great long time
00:58:30 now do we want to continue in that system or do we want to see do we want to have a seat at the
00:58:38 table and do we want to negotiate a better outcome for Canadians and have the interests of Canadians
00:58:45 talked about negotiated at the table or again are we going to be just helpless victims so you're
00:58:53 saying you're suggesting ironically by becoming part of america we would actually have get our
00:58:58 power back by having better systems in place to actually get justice and to actually kind of uh
00:59:04 get more of a sort of democratic rule where the people get more of a say or or reinvigorate our
00:59:11 own country and and and alter the failings within our own governance right right and in that previous
00:59:19 example where you where do you think more of the failure is is this a is this a failure of the
00:59:25 justice system and the judiciary or is this more of a of a failure of the you know the system of
00:59:32 governance or is it kind of a little bit of both this is the protection racket that our established
00:59:38 political parties run in this country right okay like that's why the mccains and and galen weston
00:59:46 didn't get charged it's why the td bank didn't get charged uh in snc level and this these are
00:59:52 these are the these are the people who who pay the lobbyists to go and act as their intermediaries
01:00:00 with the um with with the political parties these are the guys who fund uh this is the
01:00:08 the chateau clique this is the family compact of 200 years ago in play today in canada like
01:00:17 that's our system yeah now surely we could find examples of this happening in the united states
01:00:24 in some capacity obviously in this capacity would be that they probably got away with it
01:00:30 or they're you know like i guess i guess you could make the argument in america if there's
01:00:35 enough evidence the crooks will get found out because the justice system is maybe a little bit
01:00:39 more tight and more uh more um what's the word uh effective at actually discerning uh justice
01:00:47 or wrongdoing if that makes sense well i think you know clearly they have very similar faults
01:00:55 with lawfare going on in the united states yeah um as we have been here and and this at the beginning
01:01:04 of the show i said you know is trump going to smash the deep state the administrative state
01:01:12 is trump going to actually break the protection racket between the corporate interests and the
01:01:19 lobbyists um in in their system so you know i i hope he does obviously um uh but at least their
01:01:29 system gives the option to find a trump our system does not our primaries are closed the parties
01:01:40 control our our primaries so in canada we can never have a trump look at the current liberal
01:01:48 leadership race right um and i'm not sure if you're aware of this in in the audience greg
01:01:56 there's a 350 000 down payment just a down payment and you have to find that within two weeks
01:02:06 plus most canadians will not be aware you cannot fund your own leadership campaign in canada
01:02:14 out of that 350 000 that you have to give the liberal party to be a potential to be a candidate
01:02:22 no more than twenty five thousand dollars can come from your own pocket um and so uh and then
01:02:30 there's another big consideration in our system um the maximum contributions to the leadership
01:02:38 race is seventeen hundred dollars per person and legally uh corporations and unions are not
01:02:46 permitted to contribute to that make contributions or donations so where is greg wycliffe going to
01:02:56 find uh those hundreds and hundreds of people who each have a an extra seventeen hundred dollars
01:03:07 in their pocket to give to you for the down payment to run for the leadership of the
01:03:13 liberal party holy smokes so it's you need to create that you said 350k that's just a down
01:03:22 payment and and it's only in increments of 1700 each yeah except for your own 25 000 25k that's
01:03:31 that's that's wild yeah wow so do you know anybody who has that many friends with
01:03:38 $1,700 in their pocket
01:03:41 who can give it to you in the next 10 days.
01:03:44 Yes.
01:03:45 And how many Canadians do you think
01:03:47 fit that category?
01:03:50 Yeah, no, that
01:03:50 is a high bar. That is a
01:03:53 high, high, high, high bar to jump
01:03:55 over just to be part of the leadership
01:03:57 race.
01:03:58 So we can't...
01:04:00 Even if we had a Donald Trump
01:04:03 who said, I've got the
01:04:04 $350,000.
01:04:06 um well sorry donald um uh we're we you can only give 25 000 we don't want you to be able to
01:04:14 uh unduly influence your campaign so we're we've got a limit of 25 000 uh yeah um and and therefore
01:04:23 you get into the this network where the lobbyists are the only that's the network that can generate
01:04:31 That number of people, that number of lawyers and legal partners and engineers at SNC-Lavalin or partners at McCarthy-Tetro or Rose-Fulton-Northbry, it's only the lobbyists who can choose who will be a potential leader.
01:04:57 uh for and that's to say that's a similar system for the conservative party as well
01:05:03 now um this idea of of uh i i was i was thinking there earlier when we were talking about you
01:05:12 better get back to that question from emma uh we will we will we will get it in a second guys
01:05:19 if you have any questions for uh randy hillier then please send in a super chat uh we will get
01:05:25 to emma's question in just a second but uh you know i don't know if this is such a good idea
01:05:31 randy because you know you're you're you're kind of considered a dissident you're kind of considered
01:05:35 a troublemaker and i mean would you rather have the csis bothering you or cia i think i think i'd
01:05:43 rather kind of have something more amateur like csis than than the cia kind of giving you a tough
01:05:50 time for speaking out you know what i'm saying maybe we should rethink this the day i fear my
01:05:56 government um um i am no longer living in a democracy greg um yeah i will never live in fear
01:06:05 of my government um you know that's just uh um that's maybe what they want you to do
01:06:14 But that's not in the cards.
01:06:17 And I would say, you know, if somebody's, you know, it's just, I would, you know, listen, are we being watched?
01:06:28 Are we being listened to?
01:06:29 Of course.
01:06:30 And whether it's from CSIS or the community, the CSE, the communication security establishment, the CIA, you know, whatever.
01:06:43 um um you know i'm i'm not going to uh there's a lot of things that go that are being done that i
01:06:51 don't agree with uh many things that i'd like to see uh fixed um hopefully some of the things in
01:06:59 the in the states like the patriot act and their fisa warrants will get um smashed by by trump as
01:07:06 well um you know um so um but we're not even having those discussions here greg um you know
01:07:17 and and at least they're having that conversation and and they may find a way to um to fix the
01:07:26 significant problems in their uh administrative state uh and and i hope this uh this these musings
01:07:34 these proposals, these ideas, give Canadians the strength
01:07:39 and motivation to start looking at ourselves
01:07:44 and not looking at the United States as the threat
01:07:49 and the danger to us.
01:07:52 We've created our own crisis right here at home for everyone,
01:07:58 all of our youth.
01:07:59 and are we going to sit back and just let that
01:08:02 let our youth, our children
01:08:06 and our grandchildren suffer because of our
01:08:10 helplessness
01:08:11 No, we got to do something about it
01:08:15 and I think you're right, in this situation the silver
01:08:20 lining is certainly that it's got a lot of Canadians thinking about
01:08:23 as I said earlier, how our systems could be much
01:08:28 much better in terms of actually effectively serving the people at the end
01:08:33 of the day.
01:08:33 Now I'm going to get to Emma's question and we're going to kind of talk a
01:08:37 little bit more about the cynicism of maybe the potential downsides or sort
01:08:41 of the,
01:08:41 you know,
01:08:42 globalist conspiracy theory of,
01:08:45 you know,
01:08:45 uniting all of North America.
01:08:47 Do you,
01:08:47 do you have much time Randy or.
01:08:50 Yep.
01:08:50 We've got time to go.
01:08:51 Yeah.
01:08:52 So Emma,
01:08:52 the cat and friends,
01:08:53 thank you for the $5 donation.
01:08:54 Again,
01:08:55 if you guys have any questions for Randy Hillier,
01:08:57 you can send in a super chat. She says, how do you think our becoming or not becoming part of
01:09:03 the U.S. relates to changes from potential future technology, which might pop up in the next 10
01:09:10 years? Well, I'm not sure if I fully understand that. Read that one again. How does future
01:09:22 technology yeah so how do you think us becoming or not becoming part of the u.s relates to changes
01:09:28 from potential future technology which might pop up in the next 10 years i i don't know i don't want
01:09:34 to like speak for the the super chatter emma but but i'm thinking she might be alluding to
01:09:40 what if there's digital id what if there's some sort of like imposing uh law that passes and now
01:09:47 It affects all of North America.
01:09:49 And one simple example actually would be Trump or the U.S. government is about to ban TikTok,
01:09:56 which is a quite popular, you know, application, social media application in North America.
01:10:02 And like, you know, you can say it's a Chinese spy app.
01:10:05 You can say it's a compromise to security.
01:10:07 Some people are saying it's about competition in reality,
01:10:10 that it actually it's going to help Amazon and Meta slash Facebook better compete in America.
01:10:17 That's why they want to oust TikTok.
01:10:19 But you can certainly make the argument that this is, you know, taking away freedom of speech or freedom of sort of information flows when the federal government is imposing something like this.
01:10:30 Well, listen, I think we better be fearful of technology because I don't think we have a very good handle on it.
01:10:38 And it's moving at that speed that we can't comprehend.
01:10:43 But I would say to Emma, are you aware that our Canadian federal government has a policy statement out and a whole directorate engaged in what they call biodigital convergence?
01:11:00 Um, our own government is seeing, uh, the need to converge us as, uh, biological human beings, uh, with digital, um, um, um, and artificial intelligence, um, you know, that is underway.
01:11:21 That's, that's, you know, our governments are engaged in a lot of things that, uh, the, um, people are talking about some of the things that we can see.
01:11:30 the digital central bank currencies um digital ids our artificial intelligence but our own
01:11:39 countries our own governments are uh looking well beyond that and looking at the day when um
01:11:47 well you and i greg wouldn't actually be having this conversation but the board would be having
01:11:53 the conversation on our behalf um you know like uh so are we going to have agency are we going to
01:12:02 have influence in what comes with this rampant and insignificant uh technological changes that
01:12:13 are happening um i think we better and i don't think our system at the present uh in canada
01:12:21 gives us um or it diminishes our agency and diminishes our influence um so um we better
01:12:30 start fixing our systems right now or um it could be the borg uh and not emma asking the question
01:12:37 yeah yeah no that that that's that's well said uh just got a great super chat from chris s
01:12:45 i think that's the if that's the chris that i'm thinking of hey chris thanks for the super chat
01:12:50 He says, when is Randy going to Mar-a-Lago?
01:12:57 Next week or, you know, by Friday?
01:13:01 Do you got a flight yet or what?
01:13:04 Listen, I haven't been to Florida since I left.
01:13:07 The last time I left Florida was January 2020.
01:13:11 And I have not left the country since.
01:13:13 You know, we can probably all add two and two together to see that there was some events after January of 2020 that altered our comings and goings.
01:13:27 Listen, I think it's important that all Canadians speak out, not just Randy Hillier.
01:13:35 And these are important discussions.
01:13:40 I think, you know, let me just add this, like every one of our political parties, Greg, as soon as this thought of annexation was floated, every one of them said, how dare you?
01:13:58 no no no you're yeah we stand with the flag um uh and we will not even consider any discussions
01:14:09 we're not even going to ask you for any details um you know we we do live in a representative
01:14:15 democracy i don't recall any of the party leaders or the 338 members in the house of commons or the
01:14:29 hundreds of mpps and mlas across the country putting out any surveys or any questions
01:14:37 uh asking their constituents what their views are um on this potential annexation now
01:14:45 um you know um you know now i know you put out a poll on twitter but you're not in elected office
01:14:53 um you know people who are in elected office are the obligation is to represent the interests of
01:15:03 their communities um and their constituents and of course in order to do that you actually have
01:15:10 to speak with them and ask their their ask for their feedback um so you know i think that's a
01:15:19 um they've they've all acted in the exact same way with this as they did with covid
01:15:28 as they did with the ukraine war um you know go on and on like this is um again as i said you know
01:15:36 think of these guys as a crime family in the protection racket that they're running and it's
01:15:43 and it's not for the benefit of greg or chris s or or randy hillier um who they're running the
01:15:53 rackets for. Um, and, uh, you know, and, and they want you to think that, um, yeah, not only is
01:16:03 your voice unimportant, um, but it's, uh, it doesn't have any credibility anyway. And there's
01:16:11 no need to, you know, you just be that helpless little snowflake rig and leave, leave the big
01:16:18 subjects uh to um to the big boys um but uh to answer chris if if trump gives me a call
01:16:27 uh and and pays for the flight i'll uh um i'll take a flight down to mar-a-lago uh if not i'll
01:16:36 if he offers me an invite i'll see if jane and i can hop in the the dodge pickup truck and take
01:16:43 a drive down there road trip let's go let's go road trip to mar-a-largo uh you know you you brought
01:16:51 up a great point at the end there of how all of these politicians are acting the exact same way
01:16:56 towards this uh this trump annexation threat and i i think i made a video about it um about the
01:17:05 annexation my main commentary was this just proves how what a failure uh canadian leaders are in our
01:17:11 politics the fact that there's such an appetite for it the fact that uh it's so appealing to so
01:17:17 many people the fact that it would be so easy for trump to just kind of show up and completely
01:17:22 what's that guy's name again pierre yeah i don't really care what he had to say it was complete he
01:17:25 completely humiliated the leadership of our major parties in an afternoon and the appetite that
01:17:33 people have for it i think proves that hey you guys are not leading this country very well and
01:17:38 And I think that's another reason why they were so quick to be like, no, Canadian, Canadian sovereignty.
01:17:43 And we're standing up for Canada, of course. 0.98
01:17:45 And it's like, we can't let them know that we're these corrupt, crooked people.
01:17:50 But I want to get into that real quickly with if this plays out, if we do get annexed by America, what is going to...
01:17:58 I wouldn't use that word.
01:18:00 You know, if we agree to some sort of merger, like this idea that this will be done by force or that there'll be, you know, that's just not in the cards in my world, Greg.
01:18:23 This is a country and we will make the decisions, right?
01:18:28 like that's like who's we though because it's the people who live here so so but my question was you
01:18:36 know if that i was leading to if there's sir if there's a merger who would be making the decisions
01:18:42 would it be the ottawa bubble or would they will they all be fired you almost a lot of these people
01:18:48 who are you know open to this idea of of us converging with america has this idea that
01:18:54 Everyone in the Ottawa bubble might be fired or are we going to have like a bunch of, you know, different Yankees showing up to make all these decisions?
01:19:02 Like who are who's going to be the intermediary?
01:19:04 Who's going to be the people representing the interests of Canada when we're negotiating all of this?
01:19:09 Would it be the Ottawa bubble making those decisions?
01:19:13 Well, hopefully the Ottawa bubble will eventually be fired and that the incestuous bubble.
01:19:20 That's that's hopefully though.
01:19:21 but you know again this is why i said we need to have information we need to have details and in
01:19:27 my letter to trump i said you know if you're serious about this if you're really um then we
01:19:33 have to be looking at this as uh provincial referendums as the mechanism to create uh this
01:19:42 and and also the establishment in my view i suggested a bilateral commission made of equal
01:19:50 numbers of uh intelligent capable canadians and americans to um to sit down and go through the
01:19:59 uh myriad of complexities uh of of integration of various laws and uh time frames and um to
01:20:11 make those sorts of um transitions um so but again you need to have the details before
01:20:20 before you can accept or reject an idea uh what are the details to it so um what's the offer
01:20:29 what's the deal let's make it yeah trump what's the deal and i think i think daniel smith and
01:20:35 And Alberta are running a grave risk right now with the way the Central Canada and the Maritimes are prepared to sacrifice the West once again.
01:20:51 And I think Daniel Smith ought to declare very soon a referendum.
01:20:58 And I would say the same thing with Saskatchewan, like that.
01:21:03 Let's have a referendum.
01:21:04 And ask the people of Saskatchewan and Alberta, is it worthwhile to be driven into poverty to ensure that central Canada benefits in this potential trade war with Donald Trump?
01:21:23 So I'm not actually clear on what's happening here.
01:21:28 So Danielle Smith and some of the Western provinces are, what,
01:21:33 offering themselves up already?
01:21:35 No, no, no.
01:21:38 Danielle Smith came back from Mar-a-Lago, and she said,
01:21:42 get ready, boys and girls.
01:21:44 Trump is going to put the tariffs in place on January 20th.
01:21:50 And, you know, tariffs are not some big, scary, scary thing, you know, for most of Canada's history, both the United States and Canada have had significant tariff walls, you know, that changed with the first NAFTA and then the USMCA.
01:22:12 uh but there's been a lot of our history uh um has been utilized both the united states and
01:22:22 canada have had tariffs so it's not the end of the world um and especially when we don't even know
01:22:28 the tariffs on what like trump has just declared a 25 percent tariff um on that he's going to impose
01:22:37 a 25 percent tariff well most canadians won't realize that there's already a 25 percent tariff
01:22:43 wall on on uh boats built in each country um um any uh if you buy an american boat it's going to
01:22:51 have a tariff on it uh uh if an american buys a canadian boat it's going to have a 25 percent
01:22:56 tariff on it um um you know our uh the dairy cartel uh has got up to 300 percent tariffs on
01:23:05 um on dairy um so you know like let's understand understand what these chairs could be but but
01:23:17 anyway going back daniel smith the premier of alberta has said these things are coming and
01:23:23 coming on january 20th and no she she has said that if we accept the um the central canadian
01:23:34 proposal that we retaliate by shutting off our energy or placing countervailing tariffs on our
01:23:43 energy, that this will cause a constitutional and national unity crisis in our country.
01:23:55 And it should cause a national unity crisis when central Canada wants to forsake and sacrifice other provinces so that Ontario and Quebec manufacturers don't get hit too hard.
01:24:18 so but again you know if i was the premier of alberta right now i would say listen central
01:24:26 canada you you put the screws to us with the national energy program back in the 80s we paid
01:24:33 a dear dear cost for a long time as a result of that policy we're not going to allow you to put
01:24:41 the screws to us again there will be no countervailing care so there will be no turning
01:24:47 off the taps of Alberta oil and gas and if you want to go down that route I'm going to go to
01:24:54 the people and ask them for a referendum whether or not we should leave confederation because
01:24:59 bear in mind Greg and for the audience it was central Canada that prevented Alberta from
01:25:07 building the pipelines to to BC to export their oil and gas to the world other foreign markets we
01:25:16 Central Canada also put the kibosh on the proposal to send oil and gas directly to eastern Canada with the Energy East pipeline.
01:25:32 You know, it was all the central Canadian environmentalists that have hamstrung Alberta and Saskatchewan's ability to export their natural resources.
01:25:44 i i thought it was uh a couple of the bills that came from ottawa like bill c69 and that sort of
01:25:51 thing that well that's why central canada like that's where the the motivations were like um
01:25:59 it wasn't so you mean central canada as in ottawa and those yeah bills okay yeah yeah yeah just
01:26:06 Yeah, they're federal bills, and Alberta is, you know, well, even we have a dysfunctional party system as well, but, you know, Alberta just doesn't have the ability to counter, they don't have the population, they don't have the Senate seats,
01:26:31 They don't have, and they, so, you know, we here in Central Canada has limited Alberta's ability to export their resources.
01:26:46 They only have one marketplace that's to the states.
01:26:51 And that oil and gas is heavily discounted for a number of reasons.
01:26:57 But one of the reasons why it's heavily discounted is because they can't they can't offer it to anybody else.
01:27:03 It's landlocked because there's no pipelines.
01:27:05 Yeah.
01:27:07 There's a great documentary on this called Over a Barrel.
01:27:10 It's about like 30 or 40 minutes long, but it documents.
01:27:15 It's a very interesting story.
01:27:16 essentially uh you know oil tycoon billionaires um from america helped fund a whole bunch of
01:27:24 activism organizations in canada to make canadians hate their own oil and gas industry it's very
01:27:30 interesting um well we in a lot of canadians didn't need much help to do that yeah but i mean
01:27:38 when you got a whole bunch of uh multi-million dollar ad agencies making messaging curating it
01:27:44 helping it along it certainly helps but um i got another super chat from chris s with 14
01:27:51 thank you sir he says miss ontario miss you guys thanks for all the great work if randy did go to
01:27:59 negotiations with trump who'd be his dream team to bring with him keep up the great work
01:28:04 i have uh i have no idea i haven't thought that uh listen there's there's there is a
01:28:14 great many really competent and capable canadians um um and um you know um
01:28:25 you know we've we've done these negotiations before um um very significant substantial
01:28:32 negotiations it's not um um it's not insurmountable um uh but i um i i would hope that there would be
01:28:44 a desire um um on both sides of the border that um like i said this bilateral commission be struck
01:28:53 just to uh even uh flesh out some of these ideas um you know and is there advantages um
01:29:05 obviously there you know there's advantages and disadvantages but you know how how could these
01:29:10 things potentially be mitigated and come out with a win-win situation on um yeah because you know
01:29:18 again speaking back going back to this geopolitical mess that we have in this world this uh this
01:29:24 changing uh unipolar to a multi-polar uh world you know i think the americans do see that as a
01:29:34 significant um long-term um potential negative consequence for them i think that's one of the
01:29:44 reasons why they've um um asserting um the annexation of greenland um um and also asserting
01:29:54 that they uh um would annex panama canal you know listen i'm not in favor um trump has not ruled out
01:30:03 military action on that uh i i'm certainly not in favor of any country um um seizing
01:30:14 other territories by military means um um but um you know that um i think there is a significant
01:30:26 and there's many people in the united states who see that this is a shifting and potentially
01:30:33 dangerous change in world politics and that they want to be ahead of the curve a little bit on
01:30:40 on that and um and and the pressures on canada may in time um become very significant uh depending
01:30:50 on how this rolls out and once again we should be um we should be at the table and and saying
01:30:58 I mean, these are the things that we need to have.
01:31:05 Yeah, yeah.
01:31:06 And to speak on Randy's behalf,
01:31:09 I think his dream team would include probably Drake, Justin Bieber.
01:31:15 You'd have the ghost of Doug, sorry, Rob Ford.
01:31:19 And who else would come with you?
01:31:21 Theo Fleury, I think, would come with you for negotiations.
01:31:25 I would have to sit back and actually ponder and think about all those names and give Justin and Drake due consideration.
01:31:40 All right.
01:31:41 We got a couple more Super Chats, and I want to ask a couple more questions.
01:31:44 Have you got the time, Randy?
01:31:45 Is that all right?
01:31:46 Yep.
01:31:47 So speaking of meeting Trump, Darren Turner sends in $14.
01:31:52 Thank you very much, Darren.
01:31:53 And he says, hey, Randy, you should invite Trump to Scuttlebutt Lodge.
01:31:58 Can't wait to visit sometime myself.
01:32:01 You know what?
01:32:02 I might do that in my next letter to him.
01:32:05 Yeah.
01:32:05 I think he'd like it.
01:32:06 I think he'd like to feed the chickens and kind of check out Perth, Ontario.
01:32:12 It would be great.
01:32:14 Get him in a plaid shirt.
01:32:16 That would be a great photo, wouldn't it, man?
01:32:18 doing some we don't have a golf course at uh at scuttlebutt lodge but we do have a shooting range
01:32:25 so maybe we could get them uh perfect doing some of that perfect perfect perfect um so i'm gonna
01:32:32 go to a voltman's uh super chat in a second too but um i want to bring up one last sort of i guess
01:32:39 more of a pessimistic uh look at at this sort of opportunity which is i see i see a lot of the
01:32:45 people talking about um this transaction of becoming part of america and it really feels
01:32:54 like they're they're treating it like it's a magic button that's going to solve all of our problems
01:32:59 you know and i really feel like the only guarantee of pushing this button is that we will be facing
01:33:05 different problems or maybe just some of the same but but i feel like they're you know to say that
01:33:11 all the problems will go away is very misguided because a lot of people like they like trump
01:33:16 and because he's in charge they feel that this will be a good transaction and it's like i feel
01:33:21 like they might feel a little bit different when trump takes over he decides to level the
01:33:27 parliament buildings and put a massive gold statue of trump uh you know right in the middle
01:33:32 of uh of the square there you know what i mean but um i guess people are very optimistic
01:33:42 and when it comes down to it i just i just worry of you know who is going to actually make the
01:33:50 decisions and i guess a good a good summary question for you is if you're cynical could
01:33:57 you see a scenario based on all the madness that's gone on in our in our lifetimes over the
01:34:03 simply over the past five years could you see a scenario where we get completely screwed over
01:34:10 like like it happens it plays out and we get the short end of the stick somehow there's like
01:34:16 however it's negotiated that we get completely screwed over and now we're part of this north
01:34:22 american union and we have you know now we're just and and sorry to kind of drive home this point
01:34:30 uh be or this sort of question um i think it was bruce party bringing it up yesterday and he was
01:34:37 like let's not get it twisted you know trump sees us as useful for natural resources and territory
01:34:42 and then probably to a third extension as consumers you know um like uh like the canadian
01:34:48 people and what they want like are we going to be naive here and think that like this is really
01:34:53 what trump's trump's main intention is to save the canadian people so listen the problems are
01:35:01 not going to go away um yeah you know like there is no magic bullet in in public policy there is
01:35:10 no magic um in in in governance um what you want to do is to have a system where you can create
01:35:20 a remedy um for whatever the failing is yeah many people in politics that i've seen over the years
01:35:28 greg uh think that we can create perfection or utopia through legislation um and and obviously
01:35:37 if that was true we would have reached it long ago with the amount of legislation that we've created
01:35:42 but what we generally do what I view is and what we don't do but I think is what should be the
01:35:53 purpose of public policy and legislation is to provide a remedy for when failings become apparent
01:36:02 So, you know, there was a good one I heard the other day that with Gavin Newsom in the governor of California, in his term, he has spent $24 billion to address the homeless problem in California.
01:36:21 And the homeless rate has increased by 40% during that period of time.
01:36:27 So his policies and the public expenditure of money has actually escalated the problem and not solved the problem.
01:36:39 And so the point I'm trying to make here is that there is a huge risk, a huge danger if we run away from this.
01:36:50 If we want to put our heads in the proverbial ostrich with the head in the sand, yeah, we've got a real problem.
01:36:59 If we want to shy away from this challenge, we've got a real problem, potentially.
01:37:07 But more likely, if we want to face the challenge, we can actually find remedies for what ails this country.
01:37:18 And whether that remedy is homegrown here with improvements in our constitution, improvements in our representation, or whether it's changes of our borders and elements potentially joining the United States or everyone.
01:37:44 um so but i'm not i'm not prepared to say uh you know what is the best path
01:37:53 until we know the details but i know if we don't ask for the details and examine the path
01:38:02 we run a great danger of just staying on the path that we're on today yeah yeah well said i i i think
01:38:12 you're right the regardless of what happens this sort of whole suggestion this whole kind of stunt
01:38:18 by trump is certainly a catalyst for change a catalyst for people to think about change
01:38:24 in canada uh we got a super chat from voltman pluto thank you so much for the ten dollars sir
01:38:30 he says canadians and pluto he must be that this question must be from way out there
01:38:36 oh yeah this is this is uh sorry voltman plutoni oh yeah yeah my mistake my mistake i didn't read
01:38:43 the whole thing uh he says canadians have been indoctrinated to condemn any form of violence
01:38:49 not knowing that the greatest violence is teaching mindless passive pacifism which allows evil to
01:38:58 rule so not not a question but but but uh but a profound thought nonetheless i wouldn't i wouldn't
01:39:05 disagree with that um you know like um you know that is why um you know our our freedoms
01:39:13 are so significant um and protected to such a degree to give us agency to counter evil
01:39:23 to give us a voice against wrongdoing dishonesty and evil that's why we have freedom of a speech
01:39:30 and freedom of expression it's not so i can choose to go to kfc rather than mcdonald's today
01:39:40 you know it is that we can challenge wrongdoing with impunity that we cannot be harmed or hurt
01:39:50 for challenging against evil and you know i think a lot of canadians have forgotten
01:39:56 uh the purpose and have been i would use his words indoctrinated into believing that
01:40:04 uh consensus and obedience and compliance are are greater virtues than uh challenging evil
01:40:15 yeah yeah i um yeah that's well said i i think the super chatter has makes a really great point
01:40:25 In that there is a sort of, you know, weak character, conflict avoidance that unfortunately a lot of Canadians have adopted.
01:40:36 And I'm hoping that we're seeing the end of that.
01:40:40 I'm hoping that we're, you know, with everything that's gone on over the past five years. 0.99
01:40:43 I think that there's this sort of, you know, there is this sort of domesticated metrosexual male that you'll see in Toronto who are pussy whipped by their wives. 0.99
01:40:53 Excuse me. 0.99
01:40:54 Pardon me.
01:40:55 or they're or they're or by their boyfriend or by their boyfriends of course i'm voting for
01:41:00 trudeau or jagmeet singh because i'm gonna do the right thing but uh i think on the flip side there
01:41:04 are people there are men who are kind of finding their balls and being like what is happening to
01:41:09 this country oh my gosh uh and they're kind of returning to form and getting in touch with their 0.87
01:41:16 masculine and uh starting to not care about being you know prioritizing being nice above everything
01:41:23 else including uh your own self-preservation right but um listen we've attacked masculinity
01:41:31 you know you've heard the term and this has been a part of our public policy in public education
01:41:36 system for a long time is the this concept of that masculinity is toxic um you know and and
01:41:44 And that came into play a long time ago
01:41:47 and has been very effective in neutering the male population in Canada. 0.95
01:41:58 And this is indeed an affliction throughout the Western liberal democracies,
01:42:03 not just Canada.
01:42:05 But, you know, I do think through COVID,
01:42:10 we began to see a greater number of young men finally starting to see that, you know,
01:42:22 if you want to be a pansy in life, you're going to be a doormat or a wallflower.
01:42:29 And it's you better go up and be a man, protect your family,
01:42:35 have the spine and the backbone to speak and speak truthfully.
01:42:44 So I think, you know, COVID, as bad and as negative as COVID was,
01:42:50 it has also provided a silver lining in Canada, in my view,
01:42:57 and has awakened a great many Canadians to understand the depth of corruption
01:43:04 within our political system yeah very well said very well said i think a lot of seeds were planted
01:43:11 during the covet era for exactly what you said which is seeing the actual corruption in this
01:43:16 country and that is why i have started safe free speech.ca and we're making a documentary
01:43:22 documenting people like yourself randy who have been wrongfully arrested with these trumped up
01:43:28 political charges for standing up against vaccine mandates and telling the story of how there is a
01:43:34 system of censorship there is a system of smearing reputations of people like yourself simply for
01:43:41 your political opinion it's not just about throwing people in jail because we don't like your opinion
01:43:45 but there's a whole system of silencing people and if you do want to support that then you can
01:43:50 go to give send go.com slash save free speech.
01:43:54 Someone donated $7 the other day.
01:43:57 Bernie Sanders donated saying just,
01:44:00 just donating to this project to see that it either gets completed or to,
01:44:04 to the people that contributed are reimbursed.
01:44:07 If it isn't the,
01:44:08 the project is certainly under its way.
01:44:11 We have a number of interviews still to complete,
01:44:15 but no,
01:44:15 it is,
01:44:16 it is going full throttle ahead.
01:44:17 There is a slight pivot that's going to happen with Save Free Speech because Bill C-63, the Online Harms Act, is not so much of a threat anymore.
01:44:26 However, we are going to start another campaign to safeguard free speech in Canada because, yeah, there's lots of work to be done.
01:44:35 We're going to start going on the offense, guys.
01:44:37 But, again, if you want to support that, you can find the donate link at savefreespeech.ca or go to givesendgo.com slash savefreespeech.
01:44:46 Is there anything else?
01:44:46 let me make one comment on that if you don't mind of course um c63 is dead now with the
01:44:53 provocation uh again there is there is a silver lining with provocation and that is dead but it
01:44:59 will come back um in some form sure um with uh when pierre polyev wins the election um you know
01:45:09 Pierre Polyev is going to continue to fund all these third-party NGOs and institutions like anti-hate.ca.
01:45:19 They're going to continue to promote this idea that disinformation, misinformation, you know, or let me say this,
01:45:30 that dissenting views are misinformation and disinformation
01:45:35 and must be diminished and suppressed.
01:45:40 So that will, you know, the bill number will be different.
01:45:44 Some of the content may be slightly different, but not much.
01:45:49 So this is a path that all the political parties are on.
01:45:55 and uh and whether it's the crook or the carny uh running the show um you're going to get the same
01:46:04 the same circus absolutely and uh i've seen these this conservative party debate against
01:46:12 this censorship bill and they're like well we just need to enforce the existing hate speech laws
01:46:17 and yeah so no you're absolutely right it's just going to manifest as a new uh bill in the future
01:46:24 And that's why, you know, this website, that's why it's, you know, I'm going to continue to be a safe free speech watchdog.
01:46:30 Because I'm sure something else is going to come up in the near future, not to worry.
01:46:35 But, yeah, thanks so much for the chat, Randy.
01:46:39 I really appreciate it.
01:46:40 You can follow him on Randy Hillier on X slash Twitter.
01:46:44 Is there anything else that you wanted to say before we get going?
01:46:47 No, I've enjoyed the conversation.
01:46:50 I hope people see that there's an opportunity for them to be involved.
01:46:57 There's nothing stops you from phoning up your representatives and saying, I want a referendum on this.
01:47:06 I want to see a bilateral commission established.
01:47:10 I want to see you protecting and defending Canadian identity and culture.
01:47:20 And, you know, and maybe saying, Danielle or Scott or whoever, it's time for you to have a referendum with this on these ideas.
01:47:32 And I would say if you want to follow, I'm on X at Randy Hillier.
01:47:38 It's still being censored heavily.
01:47:41 But my Substack, randyhillier.substack.com is one of my uncensored
01:47:49 or one of my only uncensored platforms.
01:47:52 But I'm also on Facebook and Instagram and Telegram as well.
01:47:56 And I've enjoyed the conversation and hope to continue to find improvements in our country.
01:48:08 As do I, as do I.
01:48:10 Thanks so much again for joining me, Randy.
01:48:12 I'm sure we'll talk again soon.
01:48:14 Thanks for the super chats, everybody.
01:48:16 Thank you so much for watching.
01:48:17 Make sure you like, share, subscribe, all that good stuff.
01:48:20 And yeah, until next time, it's okay to demand higher standard folks.
01:48:26 Thanks so much for watching.
01:48:56 You