Greg Wycliffe - August 30, 2024


🔴Will C-63 keep kids Safe? 🔴NATO agenda to censor Internet 🔴 #STOPBillC63 🔴 SAVE FREE SPEECH .ca

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
LIVE🔴 Tribes will Weaponize C-63🔴Reacting to Runkle 🔴 #STOPBillC63 🔴 SAVE FREE SPEECH .ca Is Canada’s Child Care Program a Soviet-Style System?

Episode Stats


Length

3 hours and 3 minutes

Words per minute

154.15

Word count

28,278

Sentence count

418

Harmful content

Misogyny

10

sentences flagged

Toxicity

57

sentences flagged

Hate speech

46

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, I chat with Freedom Fighter Helen about Bill C-63 and her experience as a Freedom Fighter and her involvement with Kids First Canada, a parent-run organization dedicated to protecting children. We talk about the dangers of lockdowns, the lack of support for kids in schools and daycare centres, and the government's role in all of it.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Thank you.
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 Thank you.
00:01:30 Thank you.
00:02:00 Thank you.
00:02:30 Thank you.
00:03:00 Thank you.
00:03:30 yeah sure i can you hear me one two threes check good good yeah good okay great
00:04:00 Thank you.
00:04:30 Thank you.
00:05:00 Thank you.
00:05:30 Thank you.
00:06:00 ladies and gentlemen ladies and gentlemen welcome to the stream this evening hope you're doing well
00:06:15 how's everybody doing in chat here okay okay get the show on the road oh my okay carrie i'm i'm
00:06:25 i'm working on it okay thank you catherine grant howdy hello kev uh let's turn that right down
00:06:35 so the question will bill c63 actually protect children you know i don't have any children
00:06:42 myself but you know i've been trying to poke as many holes as possible in this thing and um
00:06:49 I actually ran into someone in a Freedom Fighters or Freedom Leaders group
00:06:53 who is actually a part of an amazing organization called Kids First.
00:06:59 Kids First Canada, a parent association of Canada.
00:07:03 And she is joining with me.
00:07:05 She's joined with me right now.
00:07:06 We're going to have a conversation all about Bill C-63.
00:07:10 And kind of look at it from different angles.
00:07:13 But let me just, it's going to take a second here to set it up.
00:07:16 So just be patient with me, folks. 1.00
00:07:19 let's let's let's get Helen in here uh right now 1.00
00:07:27 and see if I remember how to do this 0.96
00:07:34 do do hi can I hear you Helen hi good to be here great amazing we can hear you
00:07:44 technology um just gonna line you up over here i'm gonna go yeah i'm gonna go over here awesome
00:07:56 awesome so helen thanks for uh being on the stream uh maybe like give yourself a quick
00:08:03 introduction and tell me a little bit about uh kids first canada and sort of how you came to be
00:08:11 part of this uh part of this organization um and how we got here um kids first parent association
00:08:20 of canada was started in 1987 in alberta we're registered non-profit in registered in bc now
00:08:27 and we're registered charity we're a non-sectarian non-partisan independent volunteer parent run
00:08:36 group and our purposes are support for children's optimal well-being and support and recognition for
00:08:44 parental care of children. I got involved when I was living with my young son in a
00:08:55 basement suite and my upstairs neighbor's landlord had a very small daycare and I realized
00:09:03 that because they actually had a registered daycare and i was just a regular parent they
00:09:07 got a lot of information about stuff including public consultations that regular parents didn't
00:09:12 get and when there was a raid on a grow up next door the rcmp came to the home and told
00:09:20 um the mom upstairs the daycare that because she had a daycare he had to inform her
00:09:26 that there was this grow up next door but as a regular parent you wouldn't get that information
00:09:31 so i thought there's a bias here so there's a problem so that's fascinating so this organization
00:09:36 is from 1987 you said uh by the way let us know if the audio is all right for everybody um
00:09:43 for everybody who's listening um so 1987 you said this organization started
00:09:50 has there been a history of you know parents being concerned about specifically the government
00:09:57 uh not keeping kids safe in canada to get if you could i know there's probably a lot but maybe if
00:10:02 you give me kind of sort of a cold notes of that what that looks like um that safety of kids hasn't
00:10:07 been our main focus but it's been you know one of the many current concerns as you know um uh
00:10:12 optimal well-being of children and parental care of children i mean you've got government
00:10:16 intervening in the parent-child relationship in canada remember the residential schools let's
00:10:21 never forget that at the school system, the mature minor consent laws and the child protection
00:10:28 services, the daycare services. There's many ways that government interacts with the parent-child
00:10:36 relationship. And that's where we kind of like to stand up. Awesome. So before we get into Bill C-63,
00:10:47 I'm curious if because, you know, when it when it comes to, I guess, freedom fighters in Canada or people who are harshly critical of the government, there is obviously a massive influx of that starting with covid and lockdowns.
00:11:02 You know, there's a whole litany of things that are I think are negative consequences specifically for children.
00:11:08 um but tell me how that uh uh well first of all when did you have you been part of kids first
00:11:16 Canada how long you been a part of the organization and how did things about 20 years not since the
00:11:23 beginning but about 20 years so I've been um working on these sort of issues for sure 20 years
00:11:29 yeah so tell me how things may be intensified or got maybe the organization got more popular
00:11:35 uh during covid what was that like well covid was it was interesting right um
00:11:41 i mean in some ways parents some many parents and kids actually did better because the kids
00:11:48 were at home and relationships that have been kind of neglected and stuff were maybe strengthened
00:11:53 in my own neighborhood i saw families walking in the local parks together which i've never seen
00:11:58 together family four or five walking through the trails together near here um and um there definitely
00:12:04 was a silver lining for for some people who were yeah you know but the other side of that was that
00:12:10 this you know the online learning that i mean was just insane you have children kindergarten kids
00:12:16 doing online kindergarten jumping up and down in bed doing online kindergarten pe that's actually
00:12:23 happened and then other kids you know kids 10 years old spending six hours a day online it's
00:12:28 i mean there's you know like if the government really concerns is concerned about children's
00:12:32 well-being they wouldn't be doing most of what they're doing you would never have a child required
00:12:36 to be online six hours a day or online kindergarten would exist but it does exist um and there's no
00:12:43 regard for the research about children's well-being the peer-reviewed research in all these policies
00:12:48 is oh we'll just do remote learning oh that'll solve all our problems and of course it doesn't
00:12:53 solve any problems and creates more so um yeah the government insistence on kids being online
00:13:00 a lot with no restrictions the government doesn't inform parents about the problems government
00:13:04 doesn't restrict access to i mean the schools are increasingly even if you're not doing an online
00:13:11 course uh your kids very likely to be online including maybe on a phone just to do their
00:13:16 their french or their math or whatever it is yeah yeah um so let's get right into it then because
00:13:23 We're kind of segueing into into how this relates to Bill C-63 and this bold claim that the government continues to care so much about children.
00:13:33 We had a phone call several days ago, and I kind of wanted to touch on three broad brushstrokes of topics because, you know, in fighting against this bill,
00:13:44 We need to respect the fact that these politicians are really good at what they do in terms of lying, misleading, deliberately misleading the public with what their stated goals are for this legislation, specifically Bill C-63.
00:14:00 And the Trojan horse is we're protecting kids, protecting kids online from online harms, from bullying, all these things.
00:14:07 and so i wanted to get into that but the three broad brush strokes that we kind of talked about
00:14:12 earlier was in general there really is not a popular conversation about these devices in
00:14:21 kids hands and there's no sort of controls whatsoever or sort of advice you know whenever
00:14:27 i talk to a parent or teacher i always ask them do you have any rules around using these devices
00:14:33 And it's always quite, I find it a little bit creepy when they don't have any rules at all.
00:14:40 And I tell them, well, I'm addicted to my cell phone and I'm a grown man.
00:14:43 And we're giving this to kids a lot.
00:14:47 So that kind of topic of how there's just a total lack of conversation around, you know, being conscious of giving these kids these addictive devices.
00:14:56 uh and then number two and this is a very interesting one which you already alluded to
00:15:02 that there's a trend of schools or uh teachers kind of going around parents when it comes to
00:15:10 the privacy of kids this obviously gets into the uh you know the transgender uh education
00:15:16 indoctrination and then finally the third related point is canadian institutions are quite obviously
00:15:24 guilty of sexualizing children more and more uh and this is one of the stated goals of bill c63
00:15:29 is is to prevent uh you know sexual exploitation of children uh meanwhile our public broadcaster
00:15:36 cbc has aired programs such as cbc drag kids that's just one example but uh broadly those
00:15:44 are kind of the three topics i think i think we'll i think we'll touch upon um is there anything
00:15:50 that you want to want to jump jump into right now helen that to start i know it's a lot but um
00:15:55 well i mean the devices like the restrictions on devices for example um i can i'm more tuned
00:16:01 into what's going on in bc but i'm aware of other provinces too like our our premier david eb here
00:16:08 in bc in february uh said that they were going to look the people sort of got the impression
00:16:16 that they were going to ban cell phones in schools but that wasn't actually what he said
00:16:21 they were the government's going to require the school districts to have a policy about cell
00:16:26 phones the policy could be do whatever you want it's up to the teacher total ban or whatever so
00:16:33 as a parent or a kid going into school you have no idea what that's going to be and you can't
00:16:41 control it and you can't um find out ahead of time really i mean they'll have a policy like a district
00:16:46 might have a different policy than another district but there's no total ban on cell phones
00:16:51 in school for sure there's some kind of restrictions there's something about going on
00:16:56 like this in Ontario Quebec but I'm not I don't know the details of that but he also announced
00:17:01 that they were going to the BC government is going to go after I think the social media companies
00:17:06 for their harms just like they went after the tobacco companies but I mean the government has
00:17:11 in its power right now and always has had the power to for example label devices um just like
00:17:17 we label cigarettes you know um that's been requested or suggested numerous times or to just
00:17:25 reduce the you know that they to have a policy that you you can't just use your phones and devices
00:17:30 and laptops and all the rest of it constantly in the classroom that remote i mean like really you
00:17:34 can take literally can take kindergarten online you can take woodwork online you can take every
00:17:38 single course you can think of in bc online and if you actually are going to school in person you
00:17:44 might be given a lot of online uh work like you're in your french class and you're required to use
00:17:50 your cell phone to access them to do the material to do the course this is and parents children
00:17:57 students have no way of knowing what the teacher's going to require the school's going to require
00:18:01 so it's a total free-for-all and there's no regard whatsoever for the peer-reviewed
00:18:06 findings that show that this is all bad for kids it's bad for their mental health bad for their
00:18:10 physical health bad for their emotional bad for everything and it's a very suboptimal way to learn
00:18:15 for anybody so but they just pursue it and they don't use the power that they have so when they
00:18:20 say they're concerned about kids well then why why even put a just even a public information
00:18:24 campaign campaign out there on buses or leaflets or whatever saying that you know the it's not
00:18:30 recommended for toddlers to be online at all on any kind of screen at all i mean i take the bus
00:18:35 and i literally see babies the parent gives the baby a cell phone and the little baby's eyes are
00:18:43 glued onto that thing and it's like i mean i've talked to the parents you know as much empathy
00:18:49 as i have like that you're damaging your child and guess what they will put it away but they
00:18:53 you know their needs government could provide at least information or restrictions or something
00:18:58 they're not doing anything so when they say they care about kids it's like no you don't i mean
00:19:03 good for you you speak up on the bus and you say hey you know that's really bad for your kid right
00:19:07 you do that i mean i yeah i've done that because i just i'm just it just grieves me just and i i
00:19:13 care about the parent i care about the kid and just have a you know not do it gently it's easier
00:19:18 for a woman to do this you know i'm kind of motherly or whatever so they don't get offended 0.65
00:19:22 and and um but it's it's it's like if i saw a child you know taking cocaine on the bus the
00:19:28 the parent was giving him cocaine, I might say something too. But I mean, there's a role for
00:19:33 government in regulating the corporate corporations selling crap to us that is damaging. Like we 0.98
00:19:41 regulate certain products. And it's like, this is an addictive product. I mean, we know that
00:19:46 children's well-being in Canada is plummeting in mental health, academics, physical health,
00:19:52 well-being uh it's it's it's it's not going well for the kids the kids are not all right and
00:19:58 government has i believe a role to protect kids and they're not i mean the stuff that they say
00:20:04 i mean i know this that they don't care about kids well-being because working on daycare issues for
00:20:08 20 years where all the peer-reviewed research says this is a bad idea this is not good for kids
00:20:14 well-being um and they just they say the federal government says uh that this is the best start in
00:20:21 life the very best start in life for children um like that's what they say who's saying that
00:20:27 the federal government look yeah the federal government um trudeau very this the best start
00:20:32 in life it's like they actually it's in writing it's it says that in their stuff and that the
00:20:35 policies are designed to be their high quality where all the research shows that they're inadequate
00:20:40 low mediocre quality so they're just flat out lying and when you're talking about little children
00:20:45 like when you hurt a little kid or damage their well-being in some way that's not just sort of a
00:20:49 short-term thing like they hurt their knee it's you're you're damaging their the systems that are
00:20:55 building in their their brain their neurons their their their immunity like everything and so you're
00:21:01 creating damaged adults so we when we follow these these policies like in quebec it's 1997 they
00:21:07 started their daycare policy they have increased youth crime this is the the best economists in
00:21:12 canada this is their peer-reviewed research and we you know we're like if we cared about kids we
00:21:20 would follow at least the best research and we'd also respect um you know parents rights to raise
00:21:26 their children you know without the government um actively coercing us financially or socially
00:21:32 i mean when the government keeps telling you keeps telling you like it's been over 20 years i've been
00:21:36 hearing it's high quality it's good for your child's health well-being academics and everything
00:21:42 and then he might start to believe that and therefore follow what they want um even though
00:21:49 it's not true so well if the government said it then it must be true yeah they keep saying it
00:21:54 and these these lies that you that you say they're telling about uh these programs is this
00:22:00 specifically online learning that they say is so fantastic well online learning they i mean they
00:22:05 i mean i'm talking about the daycare programs the online learning they just just i mean covid
00:22:10 it massively ramped up the use of online learning, remote
00:22:13 learning. So they kind of normalized it. And they never
00:22:18 like, like, they just don't. They all everybody knows the
00:22:23 quality sucks. And, and, but they don't say that I mean, and 0.95
00:22:27 there's no, like a warning label like this is, you know, not the
00:22:30 best, but if it's, you know, works for you kind of thing.
00:22:33 There's, there's nothing like that.
00:22:37 Sure, sure. So so let's let's slow down for
00:22:40 minute here um you know you made the comparison to cocaine and uh some people might think that's
00:22:45 silly but even for myself you know if someone if the government said they were gonna take away my
00:22:50 wi-fi and my tiktok i would be like no no stop like there's no way you're doing that but and i
00:22:55 can only imagine the sort of uh even more profound sort of uh impact uh that has on kids in terms of
00:23:01 you know fiending for the uh the dopamine rush and the stimulation that they would get because
00:23:06 you know back in the day for me i had boop boop i had like nintendo like the the original nintendo
00:23:13 entertainment system which was a blippity bloop machine and going outside to kick the soccer ball
00:23:18 was a much more stimulating experience than playing mario but these days with these smartphones and
00:23:24 these tablets with the with the you know retina displays where we literally can't even tell if
00:23:30 it's on a screen or not um that's that's really scary stuff but before we go into sort of the
00:23:36 the online learning stuff i want to kind of kind of rehash kind of what you just addressed there
00:23:42 the the government was wrong there was peer studies proving they're wrong this is all alluding
00:23:47 to the the daycare program yeah yeah that the i mean the government preferentially funds
00:23:54 non-parental care especially daycare centers like institutional care like one child is getting like
00:24:01 30 40 50 000 worth of subsidizing for their care and the other one who's being looked after by a
00:24:07 parent gets zero because the government defines child care to specifically exclude parental
00:24:13 child care so um yeah the bit like literally 30 billion dollars more went into this this system
00:24:19 um in the recent budget so in a way this is financially incentivizing parents to use the
00:24:26 daycare facilities as opposed to taking care of your own child yep or even just having the
00:24:33 ops that like a like what if you wanted to use a grandparent or a nanny or a friend or whatever
00:24:38 those options are either not funded at all or like a little tiny bit of money okay so tell me what
00:24:44 that distinction specifically looks like because you know let's say let's paint a scenario where
00:24:50 um you know you're you're a working mom and you have a kid that needs daycare services
00:24:56 you have what there's a daycare down the street that would be funded subsidized by the government
00:25:02 and then and what yep well like uh the new they call it ten dollar a day daycare so that's not
00:25:10 in every single daycare but uh like for example here in bc have ubc and sfu have daycares and
00:25:18 they charge ten dollars a day no more than two hundred dollars a month so if you're a professor
00:25:23 or a earning a hundred or two hundred thousand dollars or you are like it you get it's practically
00:25:29 free daycare um if you look after your own child you don't i mean if you're going to put that much
00:25:33 money you're putting money into children's care we'll give it to the parents and they will use
00:25:39 for their own costs or other costs or some mix of that but they're definitely incentivizing
00:25:45 institutional care i mean that is the goal i mean this is this is a blueprint written by the oecd
00:25:51 and unesco in 2001 which we are following and the models that that document it's called an
00:25:59 integrated approach approach to early childhood early childhood education and care that that that
00:26:04 blueprint document uh the models that they sort of mentioned include uh china vietnam
00:26:12 cambodia and the soviet union as models of integrated early childhood education and care
00:26:18 i'm sorry 2002 2002 oecd unesco document that's a blueprint for what we're doing here it's
00:26:25 got there's no concern for children's well-being in that that thinking so i'm paint me a picture
00:26:32 of how how it could be different because i guess i'm i'm so jaded by the way things are i i'm kind
00:26:38 of imagining so so how would that work the government would subsidize grandpa to take care
00:26:42 of the kids like what does that look like have we had a system like that in the past well that
00:26:47 basically that uh all that children's care would be funded whatever funding you're doing it goes
00:26:55 directly to the parent based on the fact that based on the number and age of the children and
00:27:00 perhaps also on income um it doesn't it could be a means tested thing or it could be just every kid
00:27:06 gets this share it depends and just depending on the age and the number of children so that's that
00:27:11 that money that's going now like a minority of the population like only about 15 percent of children
00:27:19 are in daycare centers that money goes to that system even if the kid is not in this base but
00:27:27 they're enrolled the money goes there and the vast majority of child care is not funded at all
00:27:34 because it doesn't it does not it's not part of the system so it doesn't you know i mean in that
00:27:40 system like if your child is sick or whatever or only goes for a few hours a day they still get
00:27:45 the full funding so the money goes like we say fund the child fund the child not the system you
00:27:52 know the money should follow the child we say in daycare as well as in education and uh people
00:27:58 could use that as they see fit right so right now the money is are going to the to the system and
00:28:04 not to to the kids so i guess the idea would be you know if you if you have children then you
00:28:09 would have some sort of tax benefit uh to that yeah well i mean there is a child tax benefit
00:28:15 or a canadian child now then they could use they could put the daycare money into that and increase
00:28:20 that or it's called a refundable tax credit or something like that but basically right now you're
00:28:26 incentivizing people to not look after their own children and the money's going like where does the
00:28:30 money go and the system's being paid but the kids away or sick or or uh only using it for a few
00:28:37 hours a day but you're but you're funding it for you know what 80 hours a week or something okay
00:28:43 and let's and let's touch on uh the peer-reviewed research that says that this is uh really bad
00:28:49 stuff could you could you get a little bit into that give us the sort of cole's notes
00:28:54 yeah um to uh kevin milligan and michael baker are top canadian economists like really top
00:29:00 economists they did uh study the quebec system shortly after it was started and then uh 20 years
00:29:07 after it was started um and they found that children's health parents health is worse parent
00:29:14 child conflict is worse kids behavior like aggressive behavior and all is worse and that
00:29:19 in the longer term study they found that youth crime has increased compared to the rest of canada
00:29:25 following the implementation of this program this basically was a massive experiment a huge
00:29:29 social experiment on quebec that didn't happen in other places so they could just compare the
00:29:33 statistics um that are out there and this is what they concluded and they could because the
00:29:38 government's always telling you and all the mps all think that this system this pays for itself
00:29:42 you put a dollar into daycare and it's going to yield two or ten or fifteen or seventeen dollars
00:29:47 benefit and that's not true there they said that at most the um increased tax revenue from increased
00:29:55 um mother's labor or um uh labor participation was maybe covering 40 of the program so you're
00:30:02 losing money on it and it's harming kids and it's harming parents and it's making mothers more
00:30:07 depressed also that was another thing and more marital conflict it gets an all-round bad thing
00:30:12 so that's the peer-reviewed research i mean and there's other peer-reviewed research so you know
00:30:16 the more time a child spends in a daycare center the more risk-taking behavior at age 15 the more
00:30:22 aggression and all the rest of it at uh at younger ages it's it's it's why are we doing this because
00:30:28 there's a lot of research out there that's not peer-reviewed and that's the stuff the government
00:30:32 uses it's it's garbage research that's often published by or written by phds or it could be
00:30:39 like the bank i think the td bank and the royal bank publish this stuff and the canadian council
00:30:45 for policy alternatives and all the daycare lobby people publish this stuff and it might have
00:30:50 somebody some doctorate sign off on it uh but it's not peer-reviewed and it's it flies in the
00:30:57 face of all the peer-reviewed evidence yeah i mean i mean it's so frustrating because
00:31:02 what i was thinking about as you were speaking is even the liberals and the conservatives like
00:31:08 they both sort of love to focus on money stuff of like no like you know the conservatives like
00:31:15 we're gonna save you money and the liberals are like no we're gonna invest in you and give you
00:31:20 money that's gonna help you and never is it mentioned the sort of incalculable incalculable
00:31:26 or inexplicable negative consequences
00:31:30 to the family, for example.
00:31:32 Well, I mean, our policies are harming kids.
00:31:37 Like it's 100% predictable.
00:31:39 I mean, when we're seeing it,
00:31:40 that there's gonna be more addiction,
00:31:42 more aggression, more basically dysfunctional behavior,
00:31:45 more problematic relations and poor health
00:31:47 and immunity like short-term and long-term.
00:31:50 And it's happening.
00:31:53 If you wanna reduce addictions,
00:31:54 one thing you could do is strengthen the parent-child relationship i mean i mean remember
00:31:58 canada has this history um since the mid-1800s of attacking the parent-child relationship and
00:32:04 we're continuing in that vein since the 1800s well yeah the residential school system right
00:32:11 and the compulsory school attendance laws like these were done with no concern whatsoever for
00:32:20 the parent-child relationship it's just yeah yeah so let's go into uh i'm gonna see if i can get you
00:32:28 over here just one second oh my face is all messed up over here now oops how do we do that
00:32:35 just give me a second here
00:32:40 uh i think we'll put us over here so uh can you read this on the screen yeah yeah so this is the
00:32:55 recent stuff um a culture change ontario launches advertising blitz as new cell phone ban goes into
00:33:01 effect for public schools now that sounds like hey this might be a step in the right direction
00:33:05 yeah uh i just read the you know first few paragraphs ontario's new education minister
00:33:10 says that the government has begun an advertising blitz to make students and parents aware of a new
00:33:14 cell phone ban that will be in effect when classes resume next week for the coming school year
00:33:19 students in kindergarten to grade six will be asked to keep their phones on silent and out of
00:33:23 sight for the entire day unless permitted by an educator unless permitted by an educator so
00:33:30 you know well that's not exactly a ban right and i mean a ban means you don't bring your phone to
00:33:38 school or you drop it off at the office at the front when you enter a few a very few schools
00:33:42 have that where you you bring a phone you put it in the office or something at the beginning of the
00:33:46 day um and it's for a lot about the older kids it's okay the cell phones are one aspect but
00:33:51 there's also just the other screens the lap the um you know the uh what do you call those things
00:33:56 the tablets and the screens and well i mean it's a step in the right direction for sure but
00:34:02 um i mean you remember the the computer companies and all that they they don't want this i mean
00:34:09 there's mad huge huge money and the more kids and the more everybody's on screen the more money they
00:34:14 make and once the government's like requiring kids to do their assignments online upload your
00:34:21 photograph online do the chat room online do the with the other students and do your uh powerpoint
00:34:28 projects and use uh uh google docs they routinely ask kids to use google docs for things it's like
00:34:34 they have no concern for privacy at any level i mean it's just routine that's it's totally normal
00:34:39 i mean this year in bc um and if you don't want to use google docs and you don't want your kid
00:34:46 to do all these powerpoint type presentations well you're going to be in conflict with your
00:34:50 teacher which there you go yeah yeah um so let's let's talk more about that the the sort of
00:34:58 digitization of education that's even happening as low as i mean i hope they don't do that in
00:35:03 kindergarten well most very few kindergarten kids would do but but you can do kindergarten
00:35:08 online and a kindergarten class actually was a wasn't even a kindergarten class was a we have
00:35:13 these a drop-in parent child or uh things in schools some schools here in bc called strong
00:35:19 start strong start for age zero to five and when they first opened the one nearest to me they had
00:35:25 three ibm computers in them and a big huge ibm logo really big letters um and they've been donated
00:35:32 isn't that nice of the company and the principal who was opening the things was you know we want
00:35:36 to thank ibm for donating these things it was like well these kids this age shouldn't be on screens
00:35:42 at all and the big huge logo like it's so big even the little you know three-year-olds are
00:35:47 going to ibm in their face all day long or well as long as they're there so i i mean there's just
00:35:53 like they'll they'll sell the kids well-being for a buck they do it all the time it's routine um
00:36:00 it's just it's you hear my frustration you know but i mean part of it like this this i mean this
00:36:08 online stuff this this increasing amount of online stuff in the school system and then couple that
00:36:14 with um okay i don't know the curriculum in the other provinces but since 1995 in bc
00:36:21 personal planning it's called other things as well but personal planning has been a part
00:36:27 of the curriculum and so when you look at the curriculum in these areas
00:36:33 it's in the pe and in the planning curriculum um quick kids are to discuss their personal life
00:36:42 like uh talk about who's in your family who lives in your house um did you ever have a fight with
00:36:49 a friend and how did you resolve that what do you eat what did you eat last week what do you do out
00:36:54 of school what's your gender identity what's your sexuality uh who's your friends i mean is there
00:37:01 anybody at home who cares about you is anybody at school who cares about like and then this is part
00:37:06 of the curriculum it's like like these so the the violation of like propriety like if somebody asks
00:37:13 you these questions you shouldn't answer these questions and they shouldn't be asking them
00:37:17 it's it's not the school's business what's going on in your family life what you eat at home what
00:37:22 you do out of school time um but that's completely routine it's part of the curriculum k to 12 here
00:37:28 in bc um like in grade 10 11 12 you might be asked to um do an assignment where you like it's a big
00:37:36 assignment where you put your photograph up online on some online platform talk about your
00:37:41 personality your beliefs your goals your family members the things you like the things you don't
00:37:46 like and put this all it's like this is what we do here um sometimes like i tutor kids and
00:37:52 and you have friends and my own kids.
00:37:55 And they sometimes feel like,
00:37:57 they sort of feel like they don't wanna do this.
00:37:59 And I say, don't do it or just lie
00:38:01 or just tell your teacher that this is a privacy violation
00:38:04 and I won't do it because it's like back off.
00:38:07 Wow, so I'm so-
00:38:09 Graduation requirement.
00:38:11 It's a graduation requirement.
00:38:12 I'm so confused.
00:38:13 So you said the name of this program broadly
00:38:15 is planning or something?
00:38:18 Well, it's part of the career and personal planning,
00:38:22 of the curriculum and also part of the um a pe which is now physical and health education they
00:38:28 ask these questions but it could be in anything you could do an english course or something where
00:38:33 basically an identity is a big issue like the creation like what is your identity how do you
00:38:39 identify is like in your race or your sexuality or your uh your your religion or your beliefs or
00:38:45 whatever like their identity construction is what the schools are very concerned about here
00:38:52 so when you're reading a novel or a story or something it's not like what did what happened
00:38:57 in the novel and why did that happen in the novel those why did those characters do these things or
00:39:02 whatever it's well how do you feel about and do you relate to that and did something like that
00:39:06 happened to you and how did you deal with it so it's it's you are the kids are the curriculum
00:39:12 and that's it doesn't have to be about sexual stuff but the sexual stuff comes into with the
00:39:18 sexual orientation gender identity stuff and then there's also yeah yes and then there's also um
00:39:24 the um research you know social science research projects they do in the schools
00:39:29 which ask all sorts of questions about your personal life it's like it's like the schools
00:39:34 are not meant to be there for social science research the kids are not lab rats they're not
00:39:38 like you're wasting kids time your government funds they do huge questionnaires um some of
00:39:45 them are focused on sexual issues and stuff like that like how much do you drink how much do you
00:39:49 did you use a condom blah blah blah all these kinds of things um and then they're moving to
00:39:53 high school yeah they'll be in high school yeah but but the uh it sounds like a survey it sounds
00:40:00 like a bunch of surveys asking kids what they're into what they do those surveys yeah but it's like
00:40:05 like they do this in the schools and they don't ask if they use what they call it it's the human
00:40:12 early learning partnership which is in based in bc but these surveys go from them to other provinces
00:40:18 and there's other surveys as well um and there's the sexual type surveys are but they they they
00:40:25 start them in kindergarten and they don't they use what they call passive consent which means
00:40:30 no consent the parents are supposed to be notified about this that they can opt out if they don't
00:40:36 want their kid to participate but they already have all the data that all the kids basic uh you
00:40:42 know um personal education number personal health number they already have all that i mean it's like
00:40:47 the schools are like a place where kids are just being that not just the kids but their families
00:40:51 because the kids ask questions about their family like you know who lives in your house what language
00:40:57 do they speak what do you eat what do you do does anybody like you at home i mean it's just
00:41:02 it's it's really disgusting what happens in school routinely like all the time routine and what's the
00:41:08 argument as to why this would be relevant to educating a child all the image give me give us
00:41:13 all the information of what your your home life is like well well they they say that the information
00:41:18 from these surveys is used to create programs to address needs but no it's actually used to just
00:41:26 data mine the population especially in bc like uh it's it's over the top in bc we have a
00:41:33 organization called population data bc pop data bc.c pop data bc.ca they collect and um
00:41:44 they have all the data on all over 5 million residents of bc all your health information
00:41:51 all your education information uh your your income information your work information they collect it
00:41:59 and this stuff from the schools goes in there it's a key piece because it helps to
00:42:04 collect all the data you got you got that pop data bc.ca you look on the
00:42:08 for researchers and the data it's like it's i'm uh pop data bc.ca i'm getting a sketchy
00:42:17 looking website that's not secure actually right now is there no that's not it no no how about
00:42:24 um pop data maybe it's pop data.bc.ca put another dot in there sorry
00:42:31 the organization is population data this looks yeah and go under the section for researchers
00:42:38 where it says for researchers look under there okay and then go to uh this data available thing
00:42:45 data available click on this yeah uh yeah and uh core versus non-core scroll down go back down
00:42:55 uh data sets uh k to 12 socioeconomic index student assessments
00:43:05 yeah i mean they have all your medical data like for everybody in bc
00:43:10 uh fields available as i see interesting yeah i mean this is this is this is our problem what is
00:43:19 population data about providing services well look at their history thing their goal is to be
00:43:26 the world's number one um source of uh population data like that's their goal if you look in their
00:43:32 history section at the end of the history that's what they have and and this is a this organization
00:43:38 is a um a private it's it's a non-profit society so it's it's not the government but it's completely
00:43:46 funded by the government yet today the very bottom area today over time most world's most
00:43:54 comprehensive data resource on factors that influence human health well-being and development
00:44:01 which is everything interesting interesting i kind of want to watch this video because it'll
00:44:06 probably it's it's it's big brother um and big brother's been in our schools doing this
00:44:13 it's not just the kids it's like everybody i've met if you straight up data and you
00:44:17 of our society what makes some people or communities healthier than others population
00:44:23 health researchers attempt to answer these questions by looking at an individual's social
00:44:28 economic and physical environments when looking at the health of whole communities however
00:44:34 researchers must examine the lives and experiences of many individuals
00:44:39 one of the body has about you this is very creepy it's very creepy and nobody knows about it i want
00:44:45 to i want to play a little bit more you can i think you can read the uh the subtitles i guess
00:44:50 this is pretty small for everybody how do we make this bigger okay just give me just give me a sec
00:44:55 here what's the difference between a regular notebook and whoops sorry sorry folks just give
00:45:02 give us a second here we're gonna we want to give you the content so it's bigger uh i guess we'll
00:45:08 go back over here skip okay uh i know you won't be able to hear it uh helen but we'll just well
00:45:18 i think you should be able to see the subtitles so we'll just start from this creepy guy talking
00:45:24 this creepy nondescript yellow person population health researchers attempt to answer these 0.54
00:45:32 questions by looking at an individual's social, economic, and physical 0.97
00:45:36 environments. When looking at the health of whole communities, however, researchers
00:45:41 must examine the lives and experiences of many individuals. One of the best ways
00:45:46 to do this is to use administrative data, personal information that was
00:45:51 originally collected for another purpose. As British Columbians move through life,
00:45:55 they generate data. When a baby is born, the birth certificate, other life
00:46:01 experiences such as early education, career choices, hospital visits and other health
00:46:11 related issues, getting married, birthing a child, attending college or university, and
00:46:21 dying also produce data in the form of various records and documentation. This type of unique
00:46:27 Information is crucial to learning about what is and isn't making us and our communities healthier.
00:46:34 Administrative data is collected and stored by a variety of government agencies and departments, who we call Data Stewards.
00:46:42 Because of the sensitive nature of much of this personal data, Data Stewards have policies and procedures like the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act to keep it secure and safe.
00:46:54 okay i've seen enough this is this is very very strange no yeah this is this is um it's it's
00:47:03 this is what we're doing in bc we've been doing this for like close to 20 years it's been growing
00:47:08 and it's because it's like it's it's a private organization not that's run it's it's totally
00:47:15 funded by the government but it's not run by the government so it's not like accountable to the
00:47:20 government so the mlas here the provincial politicians don't know about it it's not reviewed
00:47:26 um in in uh the uh in victoria here i mean that's just one example of what's going on it's i think
00:47:34 it's worse in bc but it's coming to a province near you or it's already there but maybe not quite
00:47:38 as extreme as it is here i mean it's all about helping us right helping us yeah let's watch just
00:47:46 kind of the the very end here at one change can make the whole community
00:47:53 healthier for example based on neighborhood rates of child
00:47:58 vulnerability British Columbia made decisions about where to pilot and now
00:48:02 expand strong start programs around the province every individual person's
00:48:08 experience can contribute to valuable research which may then lead to policy
00:48:13 change that benefits everyone everyone contributes everyone benefits
00:48:22 this is so creepy um because it's to me my interpretation is hey you don't need privacy
00:48:29 anymore just give away all of your data and you will make society better it's beneficial for
00:48:36 everyone it's very good it's very good yeah well and i mean this that's one aspect those are like
00:48:42 the surveys done by the social science researchers that they collect this stuff and they mine it they
00:48:49 collect it and they sell it um but then there's also just this routine violation of you know like
00:48:55 i'm not going to ask you about your household or your personal life because i'm just not that close
00:49:00 to you and we're on this you know but it's normal in schools to do that kids are asked to just
00:49:04 talk about themselves and their family members in in ways that like i mean this person came a
00:49:10 stranger came up to you on the street and did that you would know that that's weird like why do
00:49:14 you why are you asking what i ate last week but they're being in culture they're being like you
00:49:18 know that inculturated into a a habit of just you know give your information talk to you about your
00:49:25 personal information to authorities without question and put it up online too usually
00:49:31 or make a poster and put it up on the wall at school about who's in your family like what if
00:49:35 if the child's you know dad died what if there's a kind of weird situation going on and they don't
00:49:40 want to put it on like there's no concern it's anything it's so interesting because it's the
00:49:45 complete opposite of what we were taught when we first had access to the internet which is like
00:49:51 don't give out your information don't give out your information online but but apparently it's
00:49:56 oh if it's the school you know you share as much as you'd like and aside from the whole you know
00:50:01 government uh you know subject or government sort of student or government young person relationship
00:50:07 this is just a very bad lesson in relationships period you know it's essentially encouraging
00:50:13 don't have don't have boundaries uh just you know if someone asks you a question answer it just just
00:50:19 give away you know don't have any sort of wire i mean it's required you have to really like really
00:50:24 fight to say no like i told my if they ask you this tell them no tell them your mom won't let
00:50:29 you you know um it doesn't win you any friends at school or the teachers don't like it when you
00:50:34 tell them no i'm not doing that assignment no i'm not telling you what i ate no i'm not telling you
00:50:37 what i did i mean and and like then if you you alluded to this earlier and it totally uh matches
00:50:45 what you were saying which is you know ibm is going to show up at the school to prey upon kids
00:50:51 like hey look at our machines like look at our brand let's get the kids hooked on this technology
00:50:56 soon yeah but for those who don't know uh very very smart economists for years now have been
00:51:02 saying the new gold is data the new the new gold that you mine is data and it looks like this
00:51:09 organization pop data.bc has kind of found a way around um or i guess a very creative official
00:51:18 over the table way of mining that data through schools because it's not just through schools
00:51:23 but yeah schools are a key part of it yeah yeah um and like what happens with that data who knows
00:51:30 but i do want to kind of take this conversation to a dark uh dark place and tie it back to bill c63
00:51:37 um i i came up with this it was kind of like as a joke but the more and more as as you know
00:51:44 the dystopian continues i i do feel like it's a relevant sort of like uh angle to look at things
00:51:49 and that is called the pedophile rule and the pedophile rule is if you are pushing for a thing
00:51:57 or excited about a thing that specifically a pedophile would like or get excited about
00:52:03 then you should actually not push for that thing you should actually be very questionable
00:52:08 uh towards that that behavior or that policy or that idea and in my opinion this this follows this
00:52:14 fails the pedophile rule this is something that a pedophile specifically would actually be very
00:52:18 excited about it's like oh oh all the information that a young vulnerable person has oh you don't
00:52:22 have a good relationship at home oh oh oh you're interested in this maybe i can like look look you
00:52:28 up on some chat room or something yeah or what do you like to do after school what are your
00:52:33 after school activities you go to the park the library you hang out you do only it's like
00:52:37 and and it's it but it's just training kids to divulge their information to total strangers
00:52:43 as a routine reflex habit from kindergarten on but you know you mentioned boundaries well actually
00:52:49 boundaries and consent is also in the curriculum in bc from k to 12 in the physical and health
00:52:56 education component they're supposed to learn to say for example in kindergarten no i don't like
00:53:03 that or but but that's supposed to be a lesson that's traditionally but they're but they're
00:53:08 actually violating the boundaries of the kids all the time like no i don't want to go to school no
00:53:14 i'm not answering that question no actually i'd rather be at home but my mom can't afford to you
00:53:18 know it's like to have me you know it's like there's there's no this is manipulation of the
00:53:23 concept of consent like because it's really big you gotta do consent all the time but you're well
00:53:28 the kids don't even consent to going to school let alone having a particular teacher or what
00:53:33 they're being taught i mean i'm not saying that they should be able to consent to all that but
00:53:36 it's it's you're you're this pretense that school is the safe place the teachers anybody if you're
00:53:42 a teacher you're safe if you're a parent you know you're probably going to abuse your kid right so
00:53:46 there's this assumption that school is safe government is safe social workers are safe
00:53:50 child protection services are safe like come on man i mean like we weren't born yesterday but
00:53:56 you touch on a very uh interesting trend how how long would you say that trend has been
00:54:03 going on for or would you say goes back to the 1800s that being that uh you know the parents
00:54:08 can't be trusted but the uh the canadian institutions and the government and and these
00:54:13 government funded teachers can be trusted yeah well i would say it does go back to there i mean
00:54:19 it was the uh edgerton ryerson whose ryerson university was named after him he wrote two
00:54:25 reports in 1847 1848 one established the uh compulsory at school attendance laws and the
00:54:33 other one established the uh residential schools and he was doing he was a very devout christian
00:54:38 he was doing it you know i he had good intentions like the road to hell is being paved there right
00:54:43 but and and you know i'm not saying everything that happened was bad because it's not but um
00:54:47 but this he didn't trust the parent-child relationship he said we've got to have these
00:54:52 certified people because they're going to do a better job they're you know this this trust in
00:54:57 certification and and institutions but i mean it hasn't panned out i mean obviously all parents
00:55:04 are flawed and some of them are very very flawed but an institution that's flawed causes way more
00:55:09 damage and like why can't we trust what what is it about parents that you don't like you know is
00:55:15 it it's because a prejudice against the parents is like a prejudice against somebody because of
00:55:20 their color or their religion or where they came from it's exactly the same in the human rights
00:55:24 law it's this discrimination based on your family status and that's not okay so yeah yeah uh i do
00:55:32 want to quickly reference uh an email i got from somebody they they sent an email to the i think it
00:55:38 was a safe free speech email uh and they're really worried that they say i personally feel like this
00:55:43 is a bill that will hurt children as opposed to helping them this is regards to bill c63 there
00:55:48 There are evil layers to this bill that involve so much more control and abuse from these psychopaths.
00:55:53 I think a way to show how this bill will harm children is to dig into how the country protects pedophiles.
00:55:58 Get into the National Sex Offense Registry list and how it was public and is now private.
00:56:04 I can see private for some offenses perhaps, but never private for crimes against children.
00:56:10 You know, this is all new information to me.
00:56:12 I haven't looked into this yet, but I think that, you know, in the spirit of actually protecting kids,
00:56:18 that this is something that we need to pay attention to.
00:56:21 You know, I could bring up the things that have been mentioned before
00:56:24 of, you know, Justin Trudeau next to this liberal guy
00:56:28 or this friend who is, you know, guilty of child pornography or et cetera,
00:56:32 but it looks like it is more deeper than that
00:56:35 in that, you know, these so-called great policies
00:56:38 might actually be all systemic
00:56:42 in making kids more vulnerable to sexual exploitation.
00:56:46 And I think it goes without saying,
00:56:47 the transgender education and specifically what was it it was bill c4 right i'm not sure which
00:56:54 bill that was i think it's bill c4 that is uh essentially uh it's all about gender affirming
00:57:02 care so which is an insidious way to say that uh if you want to change your gender as a young
00:57:10 person it's totally fine uh but if you if you want to try to help a kid not do that then that
00:57:16 now illegal and now kind of equated to as the same as uh you know you like if you try to convince a
00:57:23 kid not to become transgender it's on the same part as being a child pornographer if i'm not
00:57:29 mistaken well they're i mean again it's it's like parents can talk to their children about stuff and
00:57:37 if the government thinks there's that they're not allowed to do that then well that that law
00:57:42 needs to be challenged and and it's very difficult for parents to challenge laws because we're not
00:57:47 like funded by the government to challenge laws for example egal equality for gays and lesbians
00:57:54 everywhere is does a lot of um court cases and they are funded by the federal government um so
00:58:00 that helps with those legal bills i mean you know in any teacher's organization if a teacher was
00:58:05 taken to the the uh teachers union would probably maybe not in all cases but help to fund the legal
00:58:12 bills um right where parents are kind of uh they're vulnerable in that way because they don't have a
00:58:20 like our organization is not a powerful organization right but uh the parents don't
00:58:24 have something any anything like that's equivalent to those kinds of professional union type bodies
00:58:29 and advocacy organizations that are government-funded.
00:58:33 So it's just sort of getting worse and worse.
00:58:37 I mean, I don't know about BC, but part of the thing that started here,
00:58:41 it was in 2006, there was a thing called the Corrin Agreement.
00:58:46 The Corrins were a same-sex couple.
00:58:48 They were both teachers. 0.59
00:58:50 They were sex activists.
00:58:51 That's not a pejorative term in my view,
00:58:53 but they made a human rights complaint against the Ministry of Education
00:58:58 to say that because same-sex marriage had been legalized in 1995, I think,
00:59:05 and so they took their case saying that there's not a depiction
00:59:09 of same-sex couples and parented families in the school curriculum.
00:59:15 So the BC government actually made an agreement.
00:59:18 It never even went to a hearing.
00:59:19 It made an agreement, the coronary agreement, with this couple,
00:59:23 giving this couple the right or the power to review the entire curriculum
00:59:28 every grade every course and make recommendations and to also recommend organizations um to consult
00:59:36 with on these issues and their goal was to quote one of the corns up to queer the curriculum
00:59:42 and they didn't they didn't want parents fields opt out because you know if parents could opt out
00:59:47 that would kind of like defeat the purpose i just looked this up right now this is this is insane
00:59:53 uh the agreement requires that parents not be allowed to pull their children from any of these
00:59:58 classes to provide an alternative delivery of these issues being addressed um wow yeah i mean
01:00:06 bc is so ahead of the insanity on this well we're i think bc i'm not totally sure but it appears to
01:00:13 me that bc kind of we cut the ground and then it sort of goes to the rest of the provinces and we
01:00:17 we can lead the way um but this is some of the sort of underlying stuff that's i mean why would
01:00:24 a couple of anybody be able to be the consultants about anything yeah and to let alone let alone a 0.61
01:00:30 homosexual couple hey we need to look over all the curriculum how how the how the heck did they 0.68
01:00:35 land upon this as the solution or a sort of um that was the policy idea so there you go um yeah 0.95
01:00:43 That sounds like a totally twisted SNL sketch.
01:00:48 Okay, well, we're going to look over this whole education system. 1.00
01:00:51 Let me tell you, it needs to be more queer. 1.00
01:00:54 And if any of these straight parents try to opt out of it, that's insane. 1.00
01:00:59 Well, I mean, from my perspective, parents are legally, morally,
01:01:04 in every way in charge of their child's education.
01:01:06 That's the Supreme Court of Canada.
01:01:07 That's the international human rights agreements about the family
01:01:10 and about education and all the rest of it, 0.96
01:01:12 is that parents are in charge of their kids education and their upbringing and we delegate
01:01:17 to the school so if a if a parent wants that education for their child that's that's okay
01:01:23 parent doesn't want it parent wants some of it but not all of it the parent is in charge so um
01:01:29 but the this sort of going around the parents thing it's like like what's up with that i mean
01:01:35 as soon as somebody's trying to go between the child and the parent there is an issue um you
01:01:42 know and this this routine like it's this routine now to say i mean it's i call it hate speech
01:01:46 because i think it's a form of hate speech when somebody says well we can't tell the parents
01:01:49 because you know they might abuse their kid it's like well can you have isn't there like a some
01:01:53 kind of court hearing required like some kind of a court process to just establish that somebody's
01:01:58 guilty you know so you're guilty for being proven innocent as a parent like you were
01:02:03 we can't tell parents because they might they may whatever uh hurt their kid and it's like 0.54
01:02:09 who how do you determine that it's like saying you know oh if they're black or they're jewish 0.56
01:02:14 or they're scottish or irish they're gonna abuse their kids it's it's um it's it's just like a 0.61
01:02:20 form of ism like a it's like a racism thing it's it's pure discrimination but it's become routine
01:02:26 um and you know even like like the provinces that are restricting some of this to
01:02:31 under 16 okay so when your kid is 16 the schools can go around the parents
01:02:37 i mean like if the child if the child is does something at school or goes to a health care
01:02:44 provider a medical person or whatever or a psychiatrist or psychologist or whatever
01:02:48 and something happens there and the parent doesn't know about it i mean your your kid is oh they just
01:02:56 i guess they're just tired today well maybe they're overdosing maybe they're having a negative
01:03:00 reaction to that medication maybe they stop taking a medication that they need but you don't know but
01:03:05 you are i mean it's your child you're the one nobody else is even going even allowed to be
01:03:12 there to monitor their um you know their daily well-being so you're you're if the kid i mean
01:03:17 kids have died because they've refused to get them uh like addiction treatment and then the
01:03:24 overdose and the parents not allowed to know about the problem the doctor won't tell them
01:03:30 And this Elliot Yurchuk was a 16-year-old in Victoria who died of an overdose because of this.
01:03:38 You know, he refused.
01:03:40 He didn't want the doctor to talk to his parents.
01:03:43 His mother found him dead in his bed.
01:03:45 I mean, this is like, so when they say they carry their children, they don't.
01:03:51 And they don't, they're supposed to, like with the COVID thing, I mean, here in BC and I think across the country,
01:03:58 children were getting to their own emails from the health authorities that they could sign up to get
01:04:05 a get a get the shots without their parents knowledge or consent they could do it on their
01:04:11 own so whatever you think about these shots if your child has one or has not had one you need
01:04:18 to know if you're going on a trip and it requires a shot but you don't know then that's going to
01:04:23 mess you up or the kid had the shot and you don't know maybe they're having a reaction maybe a mild
01:04:27 reaction may be a severe reaction but you don't know and nobody else is there in the home you know
01:04:33 in their daily life to monitor them it's completely irresponsible it's it shows a complete contempt for
01:04:38 children's well-being and for the parent-child relationship and can can you go back can you go
01:04:44 back to how exactly they've justified this to be normal where the the school or the the teacher is
01:04:51 saying no no uh this is just between us we're not going to involve your parent what what was i know
01:04:56 you mentioned it but could you go back to that like what the justification is it's the it's this
01:05:01 it's the idea that the parent may abuse the kid but you can't you can't i mean you know they may
01:05:07 they may not and usually they don't um and parent parent child conflict is normal it's even sort of
01:05:14 required for development parent child conflict interpersonal conflict is normal and to for the
01:05:20 state to put the full weight of the state behind the child on the presumption with no evidence
01:05:28 whatsoever that that parent may be abusive and what does abuse mean like you might yell at them
01:05:35 i mean kid might i mean because yelling at your child or or or any anything that might make them
01:05:40 feel bad in any way uh is is is a considered emotional abuse and you could have the child
01:05:46 protection services launch a case against you but i mean there's also the presumption that parents
01:05:53 are bad and the correlated presumption that the state is good all teachers all social workers
01:05:58 all counselors all all we are they're all all child protection staff you know they're all doctors all
01:06:04 matter they're all good they never harm children ever they've never done that so i mean the evidence
01:06:09 is clear that that's not true so the presumption that's sort of written into the law that parents
01:06:14 are or could be very bad but there's you can the presumption is that the state is always benign
01:06:20 or it is always good which is clearly contradicts all the evidence that we have on those issues
01:06:26 right and and is there a specific piece of of policy or like protocol in schools or you mentioned
01:06:33 it's a law that says well it's in bc it's called the infants act and you might have heard of the
01:06:39 the concept of mature minor consent this is this is recent right no the infants act it's a very
01:06:46 ancient piece of legislation that was modified in the 70s and again in the 90s to allow minors
01:06:52 to consent to or refuse health care treatment if a health care provider broadly defines think that
01:07:02 they're okay to do that um i mean but that's that's for health care providers teachers are
01:07:08 not health care providers maybe the school counselor could be but a teacher has no legislation
01:07:15 to stand on at all a school counselor may be able to stand on that piece of legislation because
01:07:20 they're providing a therapeutic service but a teacher who decides to withhold information from
01:07:24 a parent like i mean the thing is like they get away with this because parents don't take them to
01:07:29 court and um because it's it's a teacher has no there's no there's it's against their actions
01:07:36 against their uh um you know their professional code of conduct to do these sorts of things
01:07:42 they're supposed to engage with parents you're not supposed to hide information with parents so
01:07:45 it's it's and it's also like the human rights codes in all the provinces says that family
01:07:52 status is a protected ground so that means like the status of being a parent of a child or a child
01:07:58 of a parent you can't be prejudiced against that like you can't be prejudiced because because of
01:08:04 their their their color or their race or their religion this is but it's it's just routine now
01:08:09 it's completely routine to i i mean when the when they they you know the provincial government say
01:08:14 well we will we'll um if kids 16 or under 16 well you'll have to inform those parents but
01:08:22 But what about the 16, 17, 18-year-olds? 0.99
01:08:25 I mean, you don't have to inform them because, you know, if they die in their beds, tough shit. 0.99
01:08:31 I mean, what is it? 0.99
01:08:32 I mean, it's nobody else has that.
01:08:35 I mean, parents have a legal responsibility, liability, as well as, I mean, the right and all the rest of it to look after their kids.
01:08:44 And you're taking away.
01:08:45 You're interfering with our legal responsibilities and our rights.
01:08:50 And you're getting away with it.
01:08:51 it's basically because parents have a heck of a time even knowing this stuff they don't i mean i'm
01:08:56 not the typical parent in this way they don't they don't know that these things can happen that's why
01:09:01 you know this like last year there was this huge the million whatever march and all that parents
01:09:06 are it's beginning to wake parents up to how bad it is because they really they're just shocked
01:09:12 like how can you do that how can you do that how can you my child is now calling herself something
01:09:18 else and i didn't even know you never told me how can you do this my kids going getting surgery or
01:09:24 my kids you know on on drugs for antidepressants and i didn't even know it's like and from what
01:09:30 you can see like what are the what are the teachers being told here or what are the teachers
01:09:36 understand that the rules are uh in general when it comes to you know well you can you can just
01:09:42 tell me timmy you don't have to tell your parents about this like do you know kind of what their
01:09:46 understanding of these rules are and what they're told to do i think it would vary it would be
01:09:50 they're getting a message that i mean it's kind of normalize this um call it parent hatred
01:09:57 but individual parent teachers are often parents themselves and or they might just think they would
01:10:03 never do that i mean i i don't work in the school system but i tutor kids and i would
01:10:06 i would hate to do something with a child that the that the parent would have offended the parents
01:10:12 i mean i would i would just apologize profusely and never do it again um because this is sort of
01:10:18 as a somebody who's um has access to a child as a teacher a tutor a coach or whatever you are
01:10:24 that's a you you have been delegated that access by the parent and that's legally speaking according
01:10:32 to the free court of canada so when you uh if so that's a a privileged position like the teacher's
01:10:38 codes of ethics call that a privileged position
01:10:41 to be able to be around the kids and all that.
01:10:45 And you're not allowed to use that privileged position
01:10:48 to advance your own interests,
01:10:50 including ideological interests.
01:10:52 And to go between the parent and the child,
01:10:54 where's the, something goes wrong?
01:10:56 Where's the liability?
01:10:57 Who's liable?
01:10:59 I mean, the teacher's not, they're never held accountable.
01:11:04 held accountable i mean right you know social workers they're not they're not held accountable
01:11:10 i mean unless a teacher actually you know bashes a kid on the head or something they're not
01:11:15 accused of any crime they're like exempt from liability yeah yeah so let's let's talk and we
01:11:22 we need to cover a couple more topics before we before we wrap this up so let's let's keep it
01:11:26 moving here uh you have the time do you okay awesome um so let's talk about sexual exploitation
01:11:34 of children um because you know we kind of alluded to the education and kind of just specifically
01:11:40 we're focusing on the relationship between teachers uh and students and how this it's
01:11:44 kind of muddying the waters in terms of what is private what should be kept from um parents
01:11:48 um but you know could you like if you had a parent in front of you and they were kind of
01:11:58 off in la la land they don't think anything is wrong and uh and you told them no like they're
01:12:05 they're they are sort of exposing kids to more sexual material at younger ages
01:12:11 they said no i don't believe you that's that's that's not happening i don't believe you
01:12:16 What would you tell a parent like that who didn't believe that that was happening?
01:12:20 Well, it would depend on, I mean, here in BC, teachers have something called professional autonomy, which allows them to determine how they're going to teach the curriculum and what resources they're going to bring in.
01:12:34 Resources means books, articles, videos, websites, assignments, anything.
01:12:40 so the way the laws have evolved or the policies evolved in bc teachers who are activists have
01:12:47 carte blanche to bring in whatever they want i mean i'm slightly exaggerating but not very much
01:12:52 so that's what's happening plus they've also pre-approved a bunch of materials that's a soji
01:12:58 123 resource list that has a lot of that many people would consider much of it inappropriate or
01:13:06 against their beliefs or unhealthy or whatever um and so because as a parent you you you have you
01:13:14 have no way of knowing when you put your child in school what they're going to be taught how it's
01:13:18 going to be taught who's going to do it or when there's no way to know because it's in bc the
01:13:23 curriculum is so loose and the teachers have so much autonomy to interpret it and they can bring
01:13:29 in whatever they want it's it's i mean you might have no problem whatsoever but i mean it's not
01:13:35 a teacher it's also the whole school like the principal or the whatever whoever puts up all the
01:13:39 the pride flags and all the other stuff and the posters and the stuff on the walls the displays
01:13:44 and all that i mean parents you know like sneak parents telling me you know they don't have seek
01:13:49 flags they got all these pride flags all over his kids grade two to class in in surrey which is a
01:13:55 lot of seeks live in surrey um so this they don't know what to do about it they get offended
01:14:02 sometimes they quit school sometimes they argue or they go as they go to a private school or they
01:14:06 but most people you know that's not an option you know and um financially and they've been told go
01:14:13 to go to a you know a christian school go to a private school you know but it's like that's just
01:14:17 you're not allowed to say that because those public schools are for everybody they are legally
01:14:21 required to include everybody everybody's supposed to be welcome and recognized and treated with
01:14:26 respect regardless of their religion or their belief or their color or their sexuality or
01:14:30 anything which is pretty hard to do um i mean really it's so diverse how do you accommodate
01:14:36 everybody well you run into problems because you have more conservative minded people who their
01:14:42 beliefs are that you know transgender isn't isn't even real it's it's it's like it's an abomination
01:14:47 so yeah but you also have to accommodate people who thinks transgenderism is a totally valid thing
01:14:52 and obviously you're going to run into conflict there yeah so i think they should accommodate all
01:14:57 think the public system you know the publicly funded learning system should accommodate all
01:15:01 and the way to do that is to one option is to have the parents get the full funding
01:15:07 as an option you know if you're happy at the school that's fine but if but if you want to
01:15:12 kind of like you know make your own education up for your kid you could hire tutors put them in
01:15:16 this school or for that thing or do your own learning or or i mean there's a lot of educational
01:15:20 materials and stuff where i live um there's a two music schools there's four martial arts studios
01:15:26 there's a math school there's another math there's there's tons of stuff in not for everybody but
01:15:32 there's a lot of resources around you don't need to go to school to get an education or you could
01:15:36 go to school or mix it up a bit but if the parents had was there an option to have the full funding
01:15:41 which is it's something like ten thousand or more dollars per year depending on where you are and
01:15:45 all the rest of it uh per kid that they could have that as an option and and they can you know
01:15:52 Right now, the state is supposed to be neutral.
01:15:57 It's not regarding beliefs and morality and religion.
01:16:00 The state, which includes the schools, is supposed to be neutral. 0.99
01:16:03 So they're not allowed to advance Christianity, which they used to do, 0.59
01:16:07 and they're not allowed to advance any other moral philosophy or belief system. 0.70
01:16:12 But they are.
01:16:13 They're aggressively promoting one particular set of beliefs,
01:16:17 this idea that everybody has a sexual orientation and gender identity.
01:16:21 that's a belief statement it's a contested belief statement not everybody accepts that
01:16:25 um but there you are the government's endorsing a particular belief set which we did in the past
01:16:32 with christianity and they need to um you know just stop doing that or or give us more options 0.90
01:16:40 yeah well i mean they're just massive hypocrites so let's get into bill c63 we're going to talk 0.69
01:16:45 about amanda todd the story of amanda todd because this bill does talk about how it's going to stop 0.73
01:16:50 all bullying gonna stop all the bullying that's ever happened but um first of all uh because we
01:16:57 were just talking about the the sexual stuff i mean how does it make you feel as a parent to see
01:17:03 that a liberal minister is presenting this bill that's going to protect kids online and and protect
01:17:08 them from sexual exploitation while this same government is rubber stamps sort of pride parades
01:17:14 where, you know, grown men will be naked in front of children
01:17:17 or rubber stamps the CBC drag kids
01:17:21 or when there's instances of very questionable
01:17:24 borderline pornographic material of minors having sex in schools,
01:17:29 which we presume is a great part of the education system.
01:17:33 How does it make you feel as a parent when this government
01:17:36 who's pushing or rubber stamping all this stuff
01:17:38 is also saying we're actually going to protect your kids
01:17:40 from sexual exploitation with this bill?
01:17:42 well it seems to be contradictory you're speaking out of both sides of your mouth i mean i just know
01:17:49 from all the other issues that they are not concerned with children's well-being and so when
01:17:53 they throw that out it's like oh really then why don't you know so it's um yeah if they're
01:18:02 i mean if parents want their kids to be sexualized i don't know there's actually
01:18:09 some restrictions on that in the law in the child protection law like you can't prostitute your
01:18:14 kids you can't have sex in front of your kids um yeah um but you can take them to the pride parade
01:18:22 yeah so well if that's i mean we have a very diverse society some people want to take their
01:18:27 kid to the pride parade but there there were there are public nudity laws uh and and for the
01:18:34 government again it's a government for to promote and endorse a particular um moral philosophy which
01:18:41 you could call that a moral philosophy it's you know you could call it sex positivism or whatever
01:18:46 they want to call it or relativism or whatever you want to call it it's a it's a moral philosophy
01:18:50 that the government is not allowed to promote a particular moral philosophy it's supposed to be
01:18:55 neutral so they can't just like endorsing one so being neutral what is what is being the state
01:19:03 being neutral actually look like. And yeah, I mean, I would, you know, parents make all sorts
01:19:08 of decisions about lots of things. And I don't agree with every parent's decision about everything
01:19:13 or my own decisions about everything either. But where does the, when the government starts,
01:19:19 it's so involved in all these issues. And it's like, maybe the government should tailor a bit
01:19:25 what it does. I mean, the government is, it's grown the realm, the realm, the sphere of the
01:19:32 government has massively expanded over the centuries and the decades and the years recently
01:19:39 so now the government is in all sorts of areas where it doesn't need to be let let i mean like 0.89
01:19:45 the same sex of the sex activists we're going to call it you know like the jehovah witnesses and
01:19:49 everybody else knock on your door and ask for a donation or put up their kiosk or have their uh
01:19:55 you know fundraisers or their bake sales or whatever they want why why are we um like the
01:20:01 government shouldn't be funding these organizations or promoting a particular belief set of any sort
01:20:06 sort because it's a very diverse country so what's up with that why do we have to jump up and down
01:20:12 and i mean if we had like you know seek flags or uh crosses all over you know public schools 0.99
01:20:20 i mean people would we would know now that that's that's inappropriate because you're promoting a
01:20:24 a particular belief set so making this making the the state neutral is actually very difficult
01:20:32 especially in the school system because in the school system you are going to talk about ideas
01:20:37 and history and all the rest of it so just give people more options like we're going to have a
01:20:42 school that's oh it's it's all pride another school that's no pride and school is half pride
01:20:48 or like we got three stripes of the rainbow but not all i mean i don't know but it's not they're
01:20:52 not interested in that um i mean i think teachers are and the public is but i don't think the
01:20:57 the powers of e are well you know i think the problem is there's always going to be a sort of
01:21:03 vacuum of morality and to say that one isn't more important than the other you know there's always
01:21:08 going to be something that comes out to be more powerful belief like you know you said hey we
01:21:14 should have a more sort of uh neutral system that's more secular and they people would argue
01:21:22 that we have that right now with the rainbow flag they would argue that the rainbow flag is
01:21:25 secular that the rainbow flag is not a moral not a moral imperative even though it clearly is but
01:21:30 but i agree with you but i'm just saying like people are under the impression that that's what
01:21:35 we have right now and it's like this great amazing thing um so i don't think it's like as easy as
01:21:39 just kind of making it neutral because you know i think what we're experiencing right now is a sort
01:21:45 of you know we're experiencing all of these social problems because of this sort of uh
01:21:52 corrupted version of morality that's being presented um by the government and they're
01:21:59 trying to kind of like you know mess with everything without sort of uh kind of robbing
01:22:03 us of our own sort of like um i don't know shared sort of social cohesion yeah that's the commons
01:22:11 the commons i mean the commons is the moral commons it's it's it's like when we've got
01:22:17 such diversity it's a lot harder um but you're not really trying at this point um i mean there's
01:22:24 i mean there's been places where people kick up a fuss because there's a whatever rainbow sidewalk
01:22:29 or something or and they say you know no rainbow sidewalks or else you got a rainbow side where
01:22:35 you got to have like all these other sidewalks or something like that right gotta have a seek
01:22:38 sidewalk gotta have a yeah you know a marxist sidewalk uh you know a you know a green whatever
01:22:44 all kinds of sidewalks but it's like like this just let's just not do that i mean if you want
01:22:49 to have your own sidewalk on your own house or something go right ahead but you're trying to use
01:22:53 the coercive power of the state and the the state's funding to push a particular thing and i mean one
01:23:01 reason they get away with it because people don't don't take legal action because they'll just walk
01:23:06 all over you i mean people just press push their agendas and and nobody really pushes back i mean
01:23:10 they get they get they argue they're protests but it's the legal action very carefully done legal
01:23:18 action to parents don't who knows what the state's supposed to be neutral people even know that the
01:23:22 teachers certainly don't know that i mean generally speaking i mean um they're supposed to respect
01:23:27 everybody of every you know race color religion all the rest of it and sexuality in their class
01:23:31 how do you do that i mean how do you do that um how do you include all i mean so if we're so
01:23:36 diverse it's actually inclusion it's it's almost maybe you can do math together maybe not maybe
01:23:41 so just let let the school system be more diverse like just let it be more diverse and let the
01:23:47 parents drive the education of their kids um you know but people some people want to use the
01:23:53 coercive power of the state to push their particular thing i mean the christians used to
01:23:57 do that um they've backed away from that more or less right um we've been forced to because of
01:24:04 legal action they had to stop doing christian stuff requiring non-christians do christian stuff
01:24:11 and now the tables have completely turned yeah where the people of this kind of rainbow flag
01:24:16 morality are starting to impose their will and their moral beliefs onto everybody uh with an
01:24:21 iron fist and that's what i really think uh bill c63 is it's just uh kind of dressed up with a lot
01:24:26 of uh rainbow and glitter as we're now getting very used to um generally what are your thoughts
01:24:32 on bill c63 have you have you given it or a read at all what's your kind of i wouldn't like to
01:24:38 comment because i haven't i mean i mean i understand the concern about child pornography
01:24:44 and all that kind of stuff that of course needs attention but what do you when they say they care
01:24:50 about kids that's why we're doing this it's like i don't believe you and why you're restricting
01:24:54 everything else um i just i just know that the government does not care about kids so whenever
01:24:59 they say that it's like why don't you why are you doing all these other things and why are you using
01:25:06 this this thing that you know is a genuine concern that many people well almost every every basically
01:25:12 almost everybody shares um to to suppress other kinds of speech and i mean the idea of hate speech
01:25:19 i mean i don't know uh it's so properly defined and it's it's like a potential hate speech what
01:25:26 does all that mean it's like i mean we're allowed to say anything it's yeah it's very it's very
01:25:31 messy but um you know as as an example i tweeted this uh there was this video going viral of this
01:25:38 dad kind of uh confronting these people basically saying hey i think you're filming my daughter at
01:25:44 the beach like can you stop doing that can you not do that what's wrong with you and they
01:25:49 it's a very weird video they act very guilty in it it looks like this guy tries to like delete
01:25:54 stuff off of his phone but um i made the sort of uh commentary that you know these creeps could
01:26:00 weaponize bill c63 to claim that this video is the video exposing them right here is actually
01:26:07 fomenting hatred against them to and insist that this video be taken down so even exposing
01:26:13 potential you know child pornographers uh they could use this legislation technically to um
01:26:20 you know to to hide this video so their faces aren't faces aren't out there they aren't suspected
01:26:26 of being uh you know preying upon children and you know there's a lot to get into in this bill
01:26:32 and you know we don't have to like spend too much time on that but um yeah i mean do you have do you
01:26:39 have any thoughts on? Like, have you heard this kind of
01:26:43 potentiality of how the bill could be used to, you know,
01:26:46 potentially?
01:26:49 Well, this idea that hate, I mean, you're trying to regulate
01:26:52 emotions. I mean, I mean, because it used to be where it's
01:26:57 your behavior, like if I hit you, or if I threatened to hit 0.99
01:27:00 you, you know, I say, I'm gonna hit you, I'm gonna kill you 1.00
01:27:03 that that is a that is a threat or an action. We didn't regulate 1.00
01:27:07 people's emotions like i mean you're allowed to hate people you're allowed to love them you're
01:27:11 like this i mean it's like this is an emotion it's and why you want to like fomenting hate i
01:27:17 mean i mean people feel emotions and you know they ought to regulate their own emotions but
01:27:23 the state isn't there to regulate our emotions um that's your own that's your your own responsibility
01:27:30 or whatever you're uh it's by you know i i don't i don't trust the government in this area i mean
01:27:38 we've got when they i mean we've got where i live there's we're not far from a basically it's a
01:27:45 brothel right well it is a brothel it's been there for years and it was there was more but
01:27:48 there are fewer now yeah a brothel yeah i mean yeah or uh no it's a brothel uh it's uh i think
01:27:57 they call them adult um like body massage parters or something like that oh right right it's a
01:28:03 problem a a rub and tug i believe they're called sometimes so so there's there was i mean there's
01:28:09 fewer than there were but there's still like a number just i mean i live in a like a very like
01:28:13 normal this is not a raunchy area of town it's very mainstream um but are you checking out who's
01:28:20 there like like the child the trafficking that's going on sex trafficking and all that
01:28:25 do you even know who's going in there or like women work there of how old are they um do you
01:28:33 care i mean do you check they only check if there's a complaint and there's no complaint i mean
01:28:39 it's it's and you know the trafficking issue is real i mean it's like it's it's uh like so now
01:28:46 you're gonna yeah and i think the major point is that the trafficking thing is real and the major
01:28:51 uh criminal behaviors happen in real life and it's only after the criminal behavior has happened
01:28:59 in real life that there is then a sort of you know maybe it gets exposed or talked about or
01:29:04 you know pornographic material illegal pornographic that's already illegal uh gets
01:29:08 shared online but uh that's that's a huge uh criticism of this bill that if you know if you
01:29:13 claim to really care about this stuff then uh why isn't there more sort of like in real life
01:29:18 sort of uh precautions that are being taken and i also criticize the bill as well because they you
01:29:23 know they're targeting big tech but they're not targeting uh you know the massive porn enterprise
01:29:29 that is headquartered in canada uh used to be called mind geek it's now called alo but i mean 0.90
01:29:36 i know that it has a uh is a reputation for being a refugee for child exploitation and trafficking
01:29:43 and all that because we're so slack about all these things so say that again i know canada has 0.85
01:29:49 a reputation for um you know being a child porn and trafficking kind of a friendly place because
01:29:56 we don't really enforce laws or we don't really have laws or it's i mean obviously sometimes the 1.00
01:30:00 police do a really good work but there's there seem to be kind of handicapped and i would love 1.00
01:30:06 to know more about this rabbit hole if you can give me any sort of breadcrumbs to i just i just
01:30:11 i just know i've heard that that i don't really have much of the research on that about what
01:30:17 canada's reputation internationally as a place where it's easy to to uh create sell distribute
01:30:26 child porn and trafficking things it's because we're because we don't have a very strong
01:30:31 enforcement or regulatory body to do i mean even this is stuff in the schools like the the books
01:30:36 that well it's not like it's it's pornographic is there's pictures of kids having sex drawings
01:30:43 not photographs and and the police well some parents have taken these books to the police and
01:30:51 it's like well that's so that's that's an educational material or something it's
01:30:56 i mean what like that's a pretty slack attitude towards these images which are images that are
01:31:02 are not supposed to exist images of children in sexual doing having sex or are there sexual parts
01:31:09 of their body are not supposed to be around but then it's educational or something like i mean i
01:31:15 don't know it's like how does this happen or is the rainbow colored haired person would say it's
01:31:19 like no this is actually a good thing because this is this is education right and uh i think you're
01:31:25 absolutely right there there is a lack of sort of i would even say moral character to a lot of uh
01:31:30 canadians and canadian institutions now where a police officer will just be like what do you
01:31:35 want me to do about it like i still got a few hours of my shift like what do you want me to
01:31:38 do about it and then on top of that we the major failure of our news media institution doesn't help
01:31:44 either because they're now subsidized by the government so they're not really interested
01:31:48 in exposing the uh um uh corruption the immorality the degeneracy of our institutions yeah well i
01:31:56 just heard this on the cbc radio this afternoon or um somebody was phoning in and complaining about
01:32:03 well no no it was sorry it was john rust and the new uh he's a conservative party leader here in bc
01:32:09 and he was saying that we're concerned about these things these kinds of books with these
01:32:14 kinds of pictures and images and stuff in the schools and the cbc uh interviewer was saying
01:32:20 what images where are those where's your evidence and it's like well the evidence is all over the
01:32:24 place it's just go to these websites and i mean the thing about child pornography is that you're
01:32:29 not supposed to have it like i can't put those pictures online because that's online and i can't
01:32:34 really show it to you because it's supposed to take it to the police the police it's it's um
01:32:38 it's an illegal substance legal content yeah yeah so i can't really show it to you um or if i do i
01:32:45 might be charged with something but yeah the cbc uh you know this has been a huge issue for a long
01:32:50 time now at least at least a couple years and then she said what is that i've never heard of
01:32:54 that like where's your evidence it's like where where have you been how about cbc drag kids the
01:32:59 cbc drag kids program that you guys find that's part of you know another cbc uh program how's that
01:33:06 for evidence encouraging kids to wear makeup and dance around sexualizing themselves in scantily
01:33:11 clad outfits cbc yeah no that's a typical argument of like oh never saw it no what are you talking
01:33:17 about that's not real and then you show it and it's like don't show that and it's like what
01:33:21 you're not allowed right yeah um okay there's i i sort of have to get going pretty quick here but
01:33:27 okay let's cover uh amanda todd yeah that's yeah so for those who don't uh remember let me bring
01:33:35 it up here amanda todd was a very sort of publicized uh unfortunate suicide of a 15 year
01:33:40 old and she made a video that essentially described uh she used a series of flashcards
01:33:46 to tell her experience of being blackmailed into exposing her breasts on webcam and of being
01:33:51 bullied and physically assaulted the video went viral uh after her death after she uh took her
01:33:56 own life that was back in 2012 um this her story is obviously being used to try and justify bill 0.97
01:34:04 c63 to say like hey this legislation is going to stop uh young women like amanda todd from
01:34:10 uh killing themselves what's your what's your sort of um opinion on that uh well amanda todd
01:34:19 um she was in bc right yeah she was in bc she was like in the just next in coquitland they're 0.95
01:34:27 not too far from where i am she she was bullied i mean that that happened it was a sexual predator
01:34:34 from i think it was the netherlands that that was um predating on her but she she was also
01:34:41 cyber bullied at school and because i am not too long before the mad at todd thing the bc
01:34:50 schools were required to have a code of conduct related to bullying um and so because they had
01:34:57 this code of conduct you can't you know treat somebody badly because of their sex or their age
01:35:02 or their gender or this or that or those other things um the school had no liability when she 0.96
01:35:10 was bullied at school because they had the code of conduct so we covered our asses and if amanda 1.00
01:35:17 was being bullied at school and cyber bullied by kids from school well that's too bad um she she's
01:35:26 i mean would this bill protect amanda i mean when you've you have a friend of mine has a daughter
01:35:33 who's in a not quite as extreme situation but yeah um the police are involved with that the same like
01:35:40 the same kind of issue uh i i i if you're if you've you've allowed you've you've encouraged kids
01:35:50 and to have what they call the sex positive thing in schools and to you expose kids to like
01:35:57 pornography in the schools maybe not always but in some situations you violated their boundaries
01:36:02 routinely routinely for from kindergarten on about what's private and what's not and then
01:36:08 this is gonna help uh i don't know it's like i don't know i just i i kind of i don't i don't
01:36:17 trust them because they haven't protected kids and they haven't they've done things that make
01:36:21 kids more vulnerable i mean they're they're breaking the parent child bound bound bond
01:36:27 they're attacking that they uh and then they this we're gonna we're gonna save you we're gonna save
01:36:33 you and i what's your legislation and why is it so broad and why don't you get on with other things
01:36:39 that that need to be done to to protect children and and you know i mean amanda wasn't a little
01:36:45 girl but she's 15 and 15 year old girls are very very very vulnerable and you've told them that
01:36:51 you've given them you've encouraged them to like to to think that they're not vulnerable
01:36:58 that you can make up your own mind you can do what you want it's your body your freedom your
01:37:02 whatever you can do what you want your parents they're probably wrong they don't know what
01:37:04 they're talking about you know trust trust this trust these total strangers and she was
01:37:10 easily misled and um yeah i mean and just making it easier to to yeah and i guess one obvious sort
01:37:19 of uh kind of criticism or hold a poke in bill c63 is you know how would this legislation stop
01:37:26 what happened to amanda todd from happening amanda todd was preyed upon by you said some 0.72
01:37:30 sexual predator from the netherlands some foreign predator presumably through a private chat room or
01:37:37 you know some sort of who knows uh it eventually turned into some you know private communication
01:37:43 which is not covered uh by the bill and uh you know this seems to be the sort of takeaway always
01:37:51 with bill c63 when you kind of dig into it it's like so how would that have been prevented with
01:37:56 with this piece of legislation and then there really isn't an answer well if it doesn't include
01:38:01 private communication because that's right that's typically how these sexploitation things happen
01:38:08 i mean i think in bc recently we had a a teenage boy took his own life after a very short exposure
01:38:17 to this exploitation situation some some gang or something in africa that's that's a sex-storting
01:38:24 young men boys that's uh it's because it's a private communication it's like well let's let's
01:38:32 talk about let's maybe take a step away from bill c63 for a second because when we were talking on
01:38:37 the phone you mentioned how uh in terms of kids health in general uh there's a lot of downward
01:38:44 trends that are that are really not healthy uh do we know where that's coming from and could you
01:38:48 going to give us a quick grocery list of the state of kids in Canada today?
01:38:55 Some people would say that it's, I mean, the increasing online time of all sorts is harming
01:39:02 emotional well-being, taking people out of face-to-face relationships. They're also
01:39:09 doing less physical activity. So you're just getting physically out of shape. That's been
01:39:15 downward trend for for years and years now um it's it's if you're well i don't know it's like
01:39:23 then they keep attacking to me the parent-child relationship is key and also you allow corporations
01:39:30 like like you know all these you know tech corporations like just you take it you're not
01:39:36 you're not protecting kids from these things like i feel there is a role for the government to
01:39:41 protect children like we have restrictions on you know drugs and alcohol and cigarettes and
01:39:46 driving and all sorts of things and kids are developing and they and you're you're just
01:39:51 letting the corporations do what just go for it you know I mean when a kid can just are you 13
01:39:59 you just have to say yes I mean what is that you know and advertising targeting children you've
01:40:04 Like it was in the 1980s under Ronald Reagan, they removed all advertising restrictions to children.
01:40:13 So you're letting the corporations just have their way with kids and there's no government sort of restrictions.
01:40:19 So it's up to the parents alone to kind of like fend off this massive pressure on the kids.
01:40:25 and parents you know we're not we we actually there is it does take a village to raise a child
01:40:31 in the sense that you're not you can't do it on your own if if you're fighting the school and the
01:40:37 government and the medical people and the advertising and the screens and all this it's
01:40:40 it's just going to go nuts it's like it's it's we don't have a i mean a society should function to
01:40:46 to uh protect children so they become like adults as healthy as possible and we're not doing that
01:40:53 and it's the degrading degrading the whole environment the the psychological environment
01:40:59 the relational environment um that children are raised in and sister up to the parents to do their
01:41:04 best and they're you know they're struggling i mean yeah you will see parents allowing their
01:41:10 their babies and their toddlers to be on screens and you'll i mean the corporations are making
01:41:16 devices and content specifically for very very young children that's like why do we allow that
01:41:21 like why why you know if you care about kids you'll say no we're just not going to do that
01:41:27 you're just not going to make content for little kids you're not going to sell like these cute sort
01:41:32 of you know little tablet things that are specially designed for little tiny kids like
01:41:36 what is that that's just like it's it shows you know we're you know sacrificing children on the
01:41:41 altar of the almighty buck yeah and it's and it is frustrating because there's so much working
01:41:48 against uh kids to thrive and have be mentally healthy um and a lot of it is like you said it's
01:41:56 corporatized it's mainstream you know 13 reasons why a netflix show that basically kind of glorified
01:42:02 childhood suicide if you want to talk about uh programs that are encouraging suicide because
01:42:08 this is another specific section of bill c63 and we also have a government that encourages suicide
01:42:13 with medical assistance and dying so it's it's obviously a little bit hypocritical to say that 0.87
01:42:21 hey although there's all this stuff you know out there that probably doesn't help with your mental
01:42:25 health don't worry we're going to censor the internet us the government is just going to
01:42:30 take you away from all the harms that are out there we're going to protect you from
01:42:34 everything forget about this down hood downward trend of childhood suicide uh you know we're
01:42:42 going to protect you with this bill that's going to give us a whole bunch of control it used to be
01:42:45 i mean it used to be the media kind of self-censored talk of suicide because it is a
01:42:52 contagion like people when you report on that we know that more people will commit suicide we know
01:42:58 that and so they they just didn't do that they was very you know minimal on that kind of reporting
01:43:04 because of you're gonna people are gonna die because you're reporting this stuff um so this
01:43:08 sort of like can we have some sense of propriety or concern for the well-being of others
01:43:14 in our in our way of dealing with these issues all right I appreciate your time so much Helen
01:43:20 I do want to ask just one last question whether it comes to bullying or whether it comes to
01:43:27 helping out a child's mental health like tell me about a positive solution that that you would love
01:43:33 to see uh if you had the keys to the castle and you could kind of you know make a policy or sort
01:43:39 of you know try to make a trend more popular with schools or with parents to to really try to help
01:43:46 their kids out with all this chaos going on restrict screen time the schools should not
01:43:51 be using screen time get rid of this um well they call the personal and social aspect of the
01:43:58 curriculum that's what they call it in bc where they're constantly asking personal questions
01:44:02 where the child becomes the curriculum just stop that or if parents want that let them have that
01:44:08 but you need to let parents have what they want and make it optional yeah make it up that if you
01:44:14 want your kid to be divulging all sorts of personal information you have that choice you have that
01:44:18 go ahead but but it shouldn't be the norm because it's the norm now spend more time with your kids
01:44:22 go walk with your kids teach them how to cook teach them how to clean teach hang out with the
01:44:26 dog you know go swimming together hug your kids love your kids um physically you know cuddle up
01:44:33 um it's parents need to know you're extremely important you might not feel important but
01:44:39 you are the number one influence and what is dr gordon neufeld leading developmental psychologist
01:44:46 parents are children's best bet parents are children's best bet and the teachers with all
01:44:51 dude respect you know like i'm a family full of teachers and that it's like you are you are you
01:44:57 are a delegate you are not you are not the one in charge and you need to have respect those
01:45:03 the propriety of your role your role is to do this you're not doing everything you are not uh there
01:45:09 to um you know create the child's identity or uh influence them with your particular moral
01:45:16 philosophy or religion or whatever you want to call it uh you re i mean you might not agree with
01:45:20 people but you know suck it up it's like we're a very diverse society and and you have to put up
01:45:27 with people who you disagree with and they're going to raise their children the way they would
01:45:31 like and you don't have the right you do not have the right to interfere with that parent child
01:45:34 relationship remember the residential schools and and what do you think about specifically bullying
01:45:41 like what's your kind of do you have like an anti-bullying sort of uh strategy or sort of yeah
01:45:46 well the the i mean children who are bullied because that's going to happen not to everybody
01:45:50 but to many kids at least in some degree sometimes severely the tighter the bond with the parent the
01:45:55 the closer the parent is the less likely the child is to actually uh harm themselves this is just how
01:46:02 it is uh so if your kid has a stronger sense of themselves and of the bond with the parent or
01:46:11 parent grandparents uncles whatever other adults who care about them they are less vulnerable to
01:46:17 the what can happen when you're bullied like to the self-harm and all that uh amanda todd was
01:46:24 clearly extremely vulnerable and and she was relying her relationships were all about the 0.84
01:46:29 internet and she seemed to lack relationships there was something not happening there for her
01:46:35 in terms of her connection to other to loving adults who could protect her kids kids are not
01:46:41 the ones who who raise kids the the system wants kids to be like peer mentors and you hang out
01:46:47 with the peers all the time it's like well you need to the peers need to you need to connect
01:46:52 the kids with the adults adults ones who are going to protect them from that kind of stuff
01:46:56 psychologically anyway and that's interesting you're saying a relationship with the parents
01:47:02 uh when in many ways the uh the system or the uh the school system and the government is encouraging
01:47:08 the opposite of that right um thanks so much for your time uh helen do you want to say anything
01:47:14 about kids first canada.org before we go yeah we're that's our at our email our website kids
01:47:20 first canada.org um you can look at our stuff we're going to be redoing our website um donate
01:47:26 to us join us uh follow we're going to be redoing some of our our pr we are not a wealthy organization
01:47:35 but we're we're doing some looking into taking we're taking legal action about some of these
01:47:39 issues and having funding for that would be great and you would get a charitable tax receipt
01:47:44 and yeah parents you are children's best bet and love your kids and connect with them as much as
01:47:50 possible thank you so much for your time helen and uh yeah we're gonna save free speech if you
01:47:57 actually really quick just want to say to save free speech in canada go to savefreespeech.ca
01:48:03 right on awesome thank you thank you greg all right we'll talk to you later okay bye bye
01:48:09 all righty then okay praise could you do me a favor and oh wait hold on hold on okay good
01:48:19 all right i was worried about that uh i'm like she's still live oh my god um hey that was good
01:48:25 that was a nice chat i um a lot of good clips in there a lot of good clips in there what did
01:48:32 you guys think hey we are going to save free speech in canada we are going to dismantle all
01:48:37 the bullshit arguments for bill c63 um and if you want to support our upcoming documentary go to
01:48:44 give send go.com slash save free speech here it is right here oh now i'm not even on the camera 0.95
01:48:51 anymore um yeah give send go.com slash save free speech here it is right there um yeah guys we're
01:49:01 going to make it happen we're going to do it it's uh it's very very exciting special thanks for
01:49:05 helen to be on the program we are going to react all right we're going to read this uh twitter
01:49:10 thread about um about about about we're going to read this twitter thread about um nato talking
01:49:20 about wanting to uh talking about wanting to um sorry talking about wanting to center the internet
01:49:30 but i really really really really really really really need to go to the bathroom i've been doing
01:49:36 this sort of uh the p dance for the past five minutes part of my language but we are going to
01:49:41 react to a mocha berzigan video while i go to the uh the little boys room here just give me a second
01:49:49 i'm gonna watch it on my phone while i run away here uh this has to do with the coots 4 case
01:49:55 and i'm interested i haven't watched this yet so hold on there we go volume up good
01:50:06 all right i'll be back in a second i'm outside litbridge courthouse here in alberta with the
01:50:14 breaking news on the coots four story nine years is what's being recommended for tony olinik and
01:50:21 Chris Carbert. What do you make of the latest developments? The men were found not guilty of
01:50:27 conspiracy to commit murder. But what do you make of Judge LeBrand's comments from Tuesday?
01:50:32 Yeah, it's very interesting. The lead up after the acquittal and the conviction. I mean,
01:50:38 they were acquitted of the serious charge aspiring to kill RCMP officers. And they were convicted of
01:50:44 the possession of weapons for a dangerous purpose, and the mischief.
01:50:49 Sentencing was set for today, tomorrow,
01:50:52 and we had some additional proceedings earlier this week.
01:50:57 But in between that and shortly after the acquittal and the conviction as a whole,
01:51:03 for them to appeal before sentencing feels like a bit of a message to the justice.
01:51:09 um no justice like no no justice is fond of their proceedings being appealed period so the crown i
01:51:18 feel the crown put the put a notice of appeal out to send a message to justice labrens that
01:51:25 take this into consideration that if you're sentencing doesn't fall in line with what we'd
01:51:31 like to see which is as we've heard this morning nine years for tony olianic and chris carver not
01:51:38 time served nine years so they would be remanded well indefinitely until an appeal or bail and such
01:51:44 i feel that the judge has heard this message and is acting on it tuesday's comments where
01:51:50 at tuesday's comments by the by justice lebran's where he throws out all of chris carver's
01:51:56 testimony calls the man a liar in relation to the events of of of coots and and the events
01:52:03 that led to these proceedings, this prosecution,
01:52:06 it seems very extreme.
01:52:09 It seems like a very sudden move by the justice,
01:52:12 and it reflects this narrative that I've just put out there.
01:52:17 It's quite clear what's happening here,
01:52:19 and tomorrow or later today,
01:52:22 there will be confirmation of exactly how malicious this prosecution really is.
01:52:29 The Crown, one way or the other,
01:52:32 even though they've been acquitted of the serious charge
01:52:35 to kill RCMP officers,
01:52:39 conspiring to kill RCMP officers, 0.88
01:52:41 they will utilize the additional charges
01:52:43 and try to maximize that sentence accordingly.
01:52:48 And that to me is a malicious prosecution
01:52:52 and it's a very unfortunate state of affairs here currently
01:52:55 in Lethbridge, Alberta.
01:52:57 Tomorrow is the big day and I will be here to cover it.
01:53:00 If you would like to support my independent journalism,
01:53:02 please consider donating at media berzagon.com slash donate thank you yes we love media berzagon
01:53:12 that is insane um it actually kind of leaves me speechless
01:53:19 what would we do without people like uh like mocha here honestly to like because this is such an
01:53:27 outrageous story that should be even like international news i don't i wish i was more
01:53:35 versed in sort of how the law works but uh once again sounds like unprecedented stuff
01:53:43 with um the crown sort of threatening or
01:53:50 not threatening but sort of suggesting to the justice like hey we want to see something like
01:53:58 this um let's read this again the crown put a notice of appeal out to send message to justice
01:54:05 the brands that if your sentencing doesn't fall in line with what we'd like to see which is as
01:54:10 we've heard this morning nine years for tony olenek and chris carber i feel that the judge
01:54:15 has heard this message and is acting on it.
01:54:17 Tuesday's comments by Justice LeBrens,
01:54:20 where he throws out all of Chris Carver's testimony,
01:54:22 calling the man a liar,
01:54:24 seem very extreme and reflect this narrative.
01:54:27 I'm outside Litbury's courthouse.
01:54:29 Although the men were found not guilty of conspiracy,
01:54:32 they were found guilty of possessing a weapon
01:54:34 for a dangerous purpose and mischief over 5,000.
01:54:37 Tony was also found guilty of possessing
01:54:39 an explosive substance for a dangerous purpose,
01:54:42 despite the substance being located over 200 kilometers away from the coots blockade wow i mean
01:54:51 it's very much more of what we've already seen which is if you are somebody who
01:55:05 is opposing the government if you're somebody who is effectively opposing the government or
01:55:11 challenging what they're saying or pro at the wrong protest, then you're going to get treated
01:55:17 totally different. You're going to get treated totally different. The law is now just sort of
01:55:22 a suggestion. The law is not really firm. It's sort of a flimsy thing that the government is
01:55:27 going to bat around like a cat batting around a ball of yarn. Um, because you know, it's, it's,
01:55:37 it's just like why why all all of these laws are supposed to mean something right 0.98
01:55:41 they're supposed to mean something but uh no no it's if it makes the government look stupid then 0.96
01:55:51 you know all those rules are out the window 0.93
01:55:53 uh how are we feeling how are we feeling i think we're going to go through this uh
01:56:00 through this twitter thread about nato and how they have a sort of agenda to
01:56:06 censor the internet but uh how are we doing in chat here
01:56:11 trent dab says i think if these two men took the help we offered they would be out right now
01:56:20 were they offered help i haven't um i mean there's so much going on i haven't been keeping
01:56:26 up to date on
01:56:28 everything Hoots 4 related
01:56:31 but
01:56:33 I do want to say
01:56:37 of course if 1.00
01:56:38 support this guy Mocha
01:56:43 when you can
01:56:44 he's a cool guy he's one of the only
01:56:47 independent journalists in this country
01:56:49 that you can count on one hand
01:56:50 and yeah
01:56:52 plus I freebooted his content
01:56:55 so I want to shout him out of course
01:56:57 and I want to interview him too
01:56:59 soon in regards to Bill C63
01:57:01 because
01:57:02 yeah if there's anyone who's going to be targeted
01:57:05 unfairly with everything
01:57:07 that's in Bill C63 it's going to be an independent
01:57:09 journalist like this who is exposing
01:57:11 the insidious
01:57:13 and absurd corruption
01:57:14 in Canada
01:57:17 Sin City Captive says
01:57:21 guest said at the end
01:57:23 Needing healthy, loving guardians with someone suffering bullying in Amanda's case reminded me of Derek mentioning duplessis orphans, healthy Canadian children deemed mentally ill.
01:57:36 I don't even know what that is.
01:57:41 Is that too loud?
01:57:46 I guess I'll look that up. 0.50
01:57:53 jeets are trying to get mocha deported no way that's i mean i guess that sounds about par for 0.96
01:58:05 the course oh my god this sounds so spicy holy crap
01:58:17 derek rance is always on top of like the craziest parts of canadian history that no one's heard
01:58:26 about duplesis duplesis orphans the duplesis orphans were a population of canadian children
01:58:34 wrongly certified as mentally ill by the provincial government of quebec and confined to
01:58:39 psychiatric institutions in the 40s and 50s many of these children were deliberately
01:58:45 mis-certified in order to acquire
01:58:47 additional subsidies from the federal government
01:58:49 they are named
01:58:51 for Maurice
01:58:52 Duplessis
01:58:53 who served as premier of Quebec
01:58:56 for five non-consecutive
01:58:59 terms between 36 and 59
01:59:01 the controversies associated with
01:59:03 Duplessis in particular the corruption and abuse
01:59:05 concerning the Duplessis orphans
01:59:06 have led to the popular historic conception of his
01:59:09 term as premier as
01:59:10 Le Grand Noceur
01:59:14 The great darkness, holy, the grand, la grande noirceur,
01:59:22 refers to the regime of conservative policies undertaken by the governing body of Quebec.
01:59:30 The Duplessis orphans have accused both the government of Quebec and the Roman Catholic Church of wrongdoing.
01:59:37 The Catholic Church has denied involvement in the scandal
01:59:40 and disputes the claims of those
01:59:42 seeking financial compensation for harm done,
01:59:44 as you can imagine.
01:59:45 We didn't do it.
01:59:46 Don't fine us.
01:59:49 It is believed to be the largest case of child abuse
01:59:53 in Canadian history
01:59:53 outside of the Canadian Indian residential school system.
01:59:57 Very interesting.
02:00:04 Duplessis orphans.
02:00:06 Let's see if there's a TikTok about it.
02:00:10 Oh, by the way, we're on TikTok now.
02:00:34 Say Free Speech is on TikTok if you're curious.
02:00:40 um
02:00:45 I know I'm just typing away
02:00:50 what's he doing
02:00:51 what's he doing
02:00:52 Duplessis
02:00:53 Duplessis
02:00:54 you ever hear that theory
02:00:55 it's probably the one theory
02:00:56 that's
02:00:56 whoa whoa whoa
02:00:57 chill
02:00:57 Duplessis
02:01:00 orphans
02:01:03 uh
02:01:08 I'm not seeing anything here
02:01:10 Did I spell it right?
02:01:21 Okay.
02:01:29 Okay.
02:01:29 Yeah, that's the same spelling.
02:01:38 Okay, let's go to YouTube.
02:01:40 Nothing, nothing on TikTok at all.
02:01:49 Okay.
02:01:52 A couple of videos.
02:01:56 Let's watch these.
02:02:01 Oh yeah, we are on,
02:02:03 we are on
02:02:07 tiktok at
02:02:08 savefreespeech.ca is our tiktok
02:02:11 we'll be posting
02:02:13 all of our content there and other stuff
02:02:14 if you guys are on the Chinese spy app
02:02:17 then yeah
02:02:18 which one should we watch here
02:02:20 this is cbc
02:02:23 nothing too long
02:02:29 it's kind of shorter stuff
02:02:31 let's watch the cbc one
02:02:32 Turn this music off.
02:02:38 Do Pless's orphans find connections overseas?
02:02:48 I don't know if I have connections overseas.
02:02:54 Now, let's do this one.
02:02:56 Let's see what the Montreal Gazette has to say.
02:02:59 And we're back.
02:03:00 The team is looking down the barrel of a 455.
02:03:03 Amazing.
02:03:03 We love advertising.
02:03:06 We love it.
02:03:11 Lampshade Etiquette says, love your content.
02:03:13 You're a gem, dude.
02:03:13 Thanks.
02:03:14 Appreciate it.
02:03:14 Appreciate it.
02:03:16 My father-in-law was there.
02:03:18 Everything was hush-hush.
02:03:21 Was your father-in-law Duplessis Orphan or something?
02:03:26 Stranger Things or Dante's Inforno, says Sin City.
02:03:29 One More Quarter says
02:03:31 Excellent conversation earlier
02:03:32 Much thanks to the both of you
02:03:33 Take care out there
02:03:34 Rick Rock
02:03:35 Said Wallbanger
02:03:37 That's funny
02:03:38 Alright let's listen to this
02:03:42 Duplessis Orphans
02:03:45 Albertine Allard is 82
02:03:51 In 1937 at age 8
02:03:53 She became a patient at St. Julien Hospital
02:03:56 She would not leave until she was 38
02:03:59 1937, at age 8, she became a patient at Saint-Julien Hospital. She would not leave until she was 38.
02:04:09 She was in a hospital for 30 years.
02:04:13 Today, she lives with two other ex-patients in a foster home run by Luc Allard and his wife.
02:04:21 Yvon Lamotte worked at the hospital for 32 years.
02:04:28 He's one of a group of residents who want to save the hospital from demolition.
02:04:38 This singing in the background is very creepy.
02:04:43 It's throwing me off.
02:04:47 Across the road, children who died at the hospital are buried.
02:04:51 Other former patients want to see the hospital raised to the ground.
02:04:58 Albertine likes to sing her own version of a Catholic hymn
02:05:02 where she calls herself a malade libéré, a freed patient.
02:05:17 Okay, that was just kind of scratching the surface.
02:05:36 It's, I'm starting to get, I'm starting to suspect that there's not many deep dives on this topic.
02:05:47 which it sounds like a crazy story sounds like another crazy Canadian story of government
02:05:56 corruption that's known that not many people have heard about it reminds me of my normie
02:06:04 friends who are always like oh man Canadian politics is so boring and it's like it's really
02:06:11 a not. It's really
02:06:12 a not. There's just not many people
02:06:14 who are telling a very
02:06:17 captivating story about it
02:06:18 or a captivating enough story
02:06:20 about it.
02:06:28 Yeah, what the...
02:06:29 Canada's dark secret? 0.99
02:06:35 This is just residential 0.72
02:06:36 schools, I think.
02:06:37 catholic scandals again this is a short one anyway this is good this is good stuff to know
02:06:46 okay we're at two hours here so let's go to this uh let's get to this twitter thread already
02:06:50 and uh read truett um or maybe i should yeah let's talk about this actually real quick
02:06:58 actually no i should i shouldn't let the shirt the sugar high hits me
02:07:03 let's read this stuff
02:07:06 where is it
02:07:14 come on
02:07:17 come on now it's over here
02:07:19 boom
02:07:20 all right
02:07:27 so yeah this came across my feed the other day censoring the internet is a nato initiative
02:07:36 the pro nato conservative party supporting bill c63 or
02:07:40 oh the pro i can't even read my own tweet the pro nato conservative party supporting
02:07:47 bill c63 or something similar is very realistic
02:07:50 i should have put this sentence backwards i'm in writing mode right now it's very realistic
02:07:57 that the pro nato conservative party would support bill c63 or something similar
02:08:01 that's how you should have read it uh read it um i mean it goes without saying that uh
02:08:07 when it comes to online censorship and big tech uh the guy who owns telegram recently got arrested
02:08:14 in uh france and then got released recently but he's still being held in france the last report
02:08:23 i heard on that is that he was invited to france by uh macron so yeah i mean i haven't been keeping
02:08:34 close tabs on that but it's certainly relevant to the conversation of uh free speech and censorship
02:08:39 online if the guy on a free speech platform like telegram which has been largely unmolested
02:08:45 by uh censorship like i mean i'm sure i'm sure there's probably some shadow banning and things
02:08:50 going on but um telegram was like so important during covid um telegram was one of the only
02:09:01 platforms that uh i mean there was a time during lockdowns where i was just looking at like the
02:09:09 different diagonal on channels i would just like open up ferryman's um you know telegram feed to
02:09:16 find out what the fuck was going on or some other people that i was following at the time
02:09:20 and that's really all we had you'd be centered on twitter this is before elon on twitter so like 0.75
02:09:25 twitter twitter was censored everything was totally censored
02:09:29 i think i was even going i was going on on gab at that time as well if i'm not mistaken
02:09:36 you couldn't find anything
02:09:37 alright let's
02:09:42 read this Twitter thread
02:09:43 let's wrap it up for the night
02:09:45 come on
02:09:46 alright
02:09:51 NATO 2030 toward a new
02:09:54 strategic concept
02:09:55 that concept being
02:09:57 social media censorship to protect
02:09:59 its political center of gravity
02:10:01 what an interesting concept
02:10:03 well that's pretty
02:10:05 small eh
02:10:06 i don't know if that's much better
02:10:12 war by other means this is from chapter 13 securing nato against disinformation
02:10:21 disinformation fake news and since the covet 19 pandemic erupted in 2020 infodemics have been
02:10:28 added to the vocabulary of societies across the world often conflated with other terms including
02:10:33 misinformation tainted leaks and propaganda disinformation is the use of false or manipulated
02:10:39 information to distort the truth we can trust and undermine democratic discourse and practices
02:10:44 this is all very much the same kind of globalist language that justin trudeau would say you know
02:10:52 it's undermining the democratic discourse you mean you mean it's exposing the uh corrupt governments
02:10:58 that are in place i could see why that would be um a threat to your rule to your false um authority
02:11:09 okay for nato a defensive military alliance based on collective defense an attack against one is an
02:11:20 attack against all that is that's very oh man an attack against one is an attack against all
02:11:28 except for russia right you're allowed to you know nada who nada who is like exists to oppose 0.98
02:11:34 russia you know you're allowed to shit on russia as much as you'd like uh the attack against one 0.82
02:11:39 except for russia is an attack against all this information has until recently been rarely 0.98
02:11:44 discussed much less considered oh it's also worth mentioning for those who don't know
02:11:49 uh i just realized the connection here telegram is owned by a russian guy i'm pretty sure this
02:11:55 guy's Russian. He's from Russia. Um, yeah. So anyway, now we're talking about NATO article
02:12:03 two of the North and North Atlantic treaty, however, underscores that peaceful and friendly
02:12:07 international relations come not from military strength alone, but strong and free member state
02:12:14 institutions and an understanding of the principles behind them. Disinformation, which is part of
02:12:20 broader malign influence operations directly threatens these principles and institutions
02:12:27 its acceleration in recent years has brought disinformation onto the transatlantic agenda
02:12:32 i'm i mean what is this it's so hard to even make any sense of what they're saying
02:12:38 disinformation which is part of a broader malign influence operation directly threatens these
02:12:42 principles and institutions
02:12:44 at the operational level
02:12:49 disinformation could increasingly probe
02:12:51 and erode NATO's defense and
02:12:53 deference at the state
02:12:55 at the strategic level
02:12:57 long-term information operation
02:12:59 there narrative
02:13:00 how old is this
02:13:08 because I mean it makes
02:13:11 it makes sense that this is coming out when everyone is critical of leaders for just sending
02:13:16 so much money to ukraine right you know people are being critical of sending all like billions
02:13:21 of dollars to ukraine and people are complaining about it as they should and now nato is like we
02:13:27 need to stop disinformation nato's enduring purpose could weaken solidarity and cohesion
02:13:34 oh okay sorry that's from the previous thing right 219 yeah 289 so let's do that whole
02:13:44 sentence together at the operational level disinformation could increasingly probe and
02:13:48 erode nato's defense and deference at the at the strategic level long-term information operations
02:13:54 and narratives skeptical of nato's enduring purpose could weaken solidarity and cohesion
02:14:00 To protect its political center of gravity, NATO should crystallize where disinformation fits among the multiplicity of threats likely facing the alliance in the emergent security environment, and then further evolve its approach to countering disinformation.
02:14:19 All right.
02:14:21 Sounds like it's going to be censoring the Internet.
02:14:23 the threat of disinformation disinformation is used strategically to challenge the very
02:14:26 foundations of liberal democracy and of transatlantic relations by affecting political
02:14:32 decision-making societies and the very functioning of democratic institutions this whole thing is
02:14:38 so uh you know it really is the doublespeak they talk so much about democracy and they use this
02:14:46 code word disinformation of people who dissent it's not disinformation it's dissent it's people
02:14:52 who disagree with the NATO agenda.
02:14:55 It's dissenters.
02:14:57 Let's read that.
02:14:58 Let's read.
02:14:58 Let's read.
02:14:59 Let's replace disinformation with dissent
02:15:02 as in differing opinions
02:15:03 than what our agenda is.
02:15:05 The threat of dissent.
02:15:08 Dissent is used strategically
02:15:10 to challenge the very foundations
02:15:12 of liberal democracy
02:15:13 and of transatlantic relations
02:15:16 by affecting political decision-making societies
02:15:18 and the very functioning
02:15:20 of democratic institutions.
02:15:22 Yeah. And of course, the irony there is dissent is supposed to be freely and freely celebrated in a democratic society.
02:15:33 But they've just kind of reframed dissent as disinformation.
02:15:38 Political warfare and disinformation or dissent allow authoritarian regimes to present the authoritarian governance model.
02:15:46 And during COVID-19, it's crisis management as a superior alternative to democracy.
02:15:51 and there's a source here 0.99
02:15:53 that's fucking crazy 0.99
02:15:56 political warfare and disinformation 1.00
02:15:58 allow authoritarian
02:16:00 regimes
02:16:01 to present the authoritarian governments
02:16:04 I'm so 1.00
02:16:06 tired of shit like 1.00
02:16:08 this man 1.00
02:16:09 it never stops
02:16:11 and it's like
02:16:13 this isn't some blue haired freak talking about this
02:16:16 this is NATO
02:16:17 this is NATO
02:16:20 talking about this saying you guys need to worry about the authoritarian regimes by the way we're
02:16:25 going to control everything that you're that you're saying and thinking uh anything that is
02:16:30 disagreeing with us is now disinformation and uh you must be silenced because it's going to
02:16:36 challenge our agenda it it really is i mean it's so trite to bring up 1984 but like it really is
02:16:42 this sort of inverted language that's going on you need to worry about the authoritarian regimes
02:16:49 out there someone actually i think it was um should i get the clip how long will it take me
02:16:54 to find that clip yeah no i'm too lazy to find the clip the clip is uh the clip is the guy from
02:17:07 the clip is the guy from uh trigonometry and he's on a chat with somebody and they say
02:17:17 how many people in Russia
02:17:20 do you think got arrested
02:17:22 for posting online
02:17:24 and they're like I don't know
02:17:26 and the person said 300
02:17:28 or whatever it was
02:17:29 and then he said do you know how many people
02:17:32 got arrested for posting online
02:17:34 in the UK
02:17:35 and I'm pretty sure the number was like 3400
02:17:39 way more people are getting arrested
02:17:42 for speech in the UK
02:17:44 than Russia
02:17:45 who's the authoritarians who are the bigger authoritarian countries at this point you know
02:17:51 this whole democracy thing is so it's such a farce at this point especially whenever it's like
02:17:57 used by nato or the un or globalist politicians but um you guys know this already you guys know 0.97
02:18:06 this already i'm just i'm just beating the same old fucking dead horse at this point 0.57
02:18:09 it's a classic we need to protect democracy tropes as edgy dtv yeah exactly edgy dtv says 0.93
02:18:18 protecting it by taking away people's voices and putting them in jail right right right that's right
02:18:24 that's how we protect democracy we we protect democracy by throwing those who disagree with
02:18:29 us in jail that's what democracy is we have to we have to stop the authoritarians that's the only
02:18:35 way to stop the authoritarians i mean on the plus side this seems like pretty easy to explain to
02:18:44 people how fake this is so i'm you know i'm feeling good for our side because i feel like
02:18:49 they're they're trying to like they're they're using the same lies for like years and years
02:18:54 and it's like it's been decades these lies are running out of gas okay these lies are running
02:19:00 out of gas people are not going to be buying into this anymore um let's continue with this
02:19:06 uh nato agenda worryingly various actors within democratic societies and nato members are also
02:19:16 turning to disinformation and information suppression to advance their political goals
02:19:22 domestically this is just so it's it's so transparent it's like hey people are disagreeing
02:19:31 with us and they have different political goals than us we need to do something about that
02:19:35 that's kind of what's interesting about this globalist language isn't it it's like
02:19:39 you can basically make a report that tells you exactly what you're going to do we are going to
02:19:46 censor the internet we are going to censor everyone we disagree with but you just kind of like use
02:19:50 Different language
02:19:51 And kind of invert the definition of things
02:19:55 Like disinformation is actually dissent
02:19:57 We're the
02:19:59 Authoritarian regime
02:20:00 When we say democratic ruling
02:20:02 We're actually talking about our authoritarian rule
02:20:04 They're a threat to our authoritarian rule
02:20:07 It's all backwards
02:20:08 Just use this reference card
02:20:11 And then you'll be able to decode what we're doing here
02:20:13 We're trying to silence everybody who disagrees with us
02:20:15 Let's read this whole paragraph
02:20:18 can you guys see that okay yeah scroll up a bit okay oops a prominent tool of political warfare
02:20:28 during the cold war soviet campaigns of active measures and desinformase disinformase
02:20:34 sentasia propaganda and disinformation went under the radar for the better part of the past 30 years
02:20:40 in the west the kremlin's military aggression in ukraine illegal annexation of crimea in 2014
02:20:46 revealed Russia's use of information as
02:20:48 a weapon
02:20:48 amplified and strengthened by modern
02:20:52 technologies, social media
02:20:54 and a revamped state
02:20:56 and a revamped state media apparatus.
02:21:03 You know who else
02:21:04 has a state media
02:21:06 apparatus?
02:21:08 Canada does. We subsidize
02:21:10 the news here. Just like
02:21:12 Russia and China 0.81
02:21:14 and North Korea. Isn't that cool?
02:21:16 disinformation campaigns became a central tool for denying justifying and supporting its actions
02:21:23 in ukraine it created an alternate reality meant not only to obscure russia's involvement but also
02:21:29 to completely discredit the i think we're out i think we're out of the
02:21:35 let's see what's the next tweet
02:21:40 is this the same page
02:21:44 okay no this is different we didn't we didn't get the rest of the sentence oh well
02:21:50 NATO's approach to disinformation since its founding NATO's approach to countering disinformation
02:21:54 has evolved alongside the threat environment the alliance has always recognized that security
02:22:00 and stability derived from military as well as non-military means but has historically
02:22:04 prioritized the former over the latter it took several years and the proliferation of direct
02:22:10 disinformation attacks against NATO
02:22:12 for the alliance to recognize the threat
02:22:14 and begin
02:22:15 operationalizing a response, an
02:22:18 ongoing process that continues today.
02:22:21 During the Cold War, NATO
02:22:22 prioritized conventional defense
02:22:23 and deterrence, and
02:22:26 only tangentially considered disinformation.
02:22:30 I'm just going to do the highlighted bits now.
02:22:32 After the
02:22:33 dissolution of the Soviet Union,
02:22:36 the conventional military balance
02:22:38 shifted in NATO's favor.
02:22:40 The alliance began focusing on non-military threats, although not always disinformation.
02:22:45 The 2014 Wales Summit Declaration suggested enhancing strategic communications to counter hybrid threats without naming disinformation.
02:22:57 NATO's current strategic concept likewise excludes disinformation from its list of conventional threats.
02:23:03 while nato was quick to enhance conventional defense and deterrence alongside the eastern
02:23:10 flank after 2014 there was insufficient support within the alliance to similarly adapt its
02:23:15 non-military means blah blah blah most recently the nato 2030 initiative was launched at the 2019
02:23:22 london summit and on the heels of president of france emmanuel macron calling the alliance
02:23:27 brain dead to further strengthen nato's political dimension this was a forewarning of sorts that
02:23:33 nato's non-military malaise could have wider consequences oh god the future is here questions
02:23:42 about the evolution of the disinformation threat strike at the core of nato's political mandate
02:23:45 as a military alliance and its ability to access and respond net war net war has changed the nature
02:23:53 of conflict wait will this make it bigger oh there we oh there we go there we go yeah baby
02:24:00 um net war has changed the nature of conflict with profound implications for disinformation
02:24:10 disinformation and a more general manipulation of the information space through political
02:24:15 economic technology cyber or social engineering tools have emerged in the past decade as profound
02:24:20 mutations in the way we understand security i guess i can't uh damn i can't scroll up for you
02:24:30 guys oh sorry i'm just gonna keep reading uh social media has changed not just the message
02:24:39 but the dynamics of conflict second disinformation and digital deception are used in the battle to
02:24:45 achieve cognitive and behavioral outcomes
02:24:47 in societies. National
02:24:49 militaries are reorienting
02:24:51 to also face information warfare. Significantly
02:24:53 domestic politics
02:24:55 has also recorded around 0.68
02:24:56 reordered around the ability to create
02:24:59 and influence or manipulate
02:25:00 online constituencies.
02:25:03 Mm-hmm.
02:25:10 Online
02:25:11 constituencies.
02:25:15 political actors in most countries whether democratic or not now rely on troll armies
02:25:21 whoa this is getting good political actors in most countries whether democratic or not
02:25:26 now rely on troll armies and digital influencing campaigns to alter democratic processes 0.99
02:25:32 what the fuck 0.99
02:25:34 here's a thought here's a thought if you don't dehumanize the trolls maybe you could say that 1.00
02:25:52 these are actually just citizens of that national country participating in democracy
02:26:00 they're sharing their version of reality
02:26:02 they're sharing their opinion
02:26:03 this is a threat to democracy 0.98
02:26:06 all of these trolls
02:26:07 no it's your citizens voicing an opinion on something
02:26:10 what do you mean
02:26:12 trolls
02:26:13 you're just dehumanizing opinions 0.97
02:26:16 you don't like on the internet
02:26:17 this is nuts
02:26:21 political actors in most countries
02:26:24 whether democratic or not
02:26:26 now rely on troll armies
02:26:28 and digital influencing campaigns
02:26:32 to alter democratic processes.
02:26:37 How is, I mean, calling it,
02:26:40 they try to just dehumanize this practice
02:26:43 saying it's a troll army influencing campaigns.
02:26:47 What's the difference between a democratic campaign
02:26:51 and a troll campaign?
02:26:52 At the end of the day,
02:26:53 it's going to be American citizens pushing for something online.
02:26:58 but no no no the troll army is going to affect the democratic process yeah this shift is domestic
02:27:04 this shift in domestic political debate also has an impact on the alliance's internal functioning
02:27:11 as political actors in some member states are increasingly utilizing information and digital
02:27:16 manipulation they are not only departing from principles and values nato is built upon and
02:27:23 clearly outlined under article 2 of the nato charter but are also creating additional avenues
02:27:27 for malign foreign actors
02:27:29 to infiltrate democratic societies
02:27:31 and weaken them from within. 0.96
02:27:33 What the hell?
02:27:34 Like, democracy does not mean anything anymore
02:27:37 in this NATO report.
02:27:43 They're trying to influence things.
02:27:46 That's a threat to democracy.
02:27:47 So people pushing for their ideas
02:27:50 is a threat to democracy?
02:27:51 That's the whole premise of democracy. 1.00
02:27:54 This shit is so exhausting. 1.00
02:27:56 it's so exhausting to read through this shit 1.00
02:27:58 third authoritarian nations attempt to 0.99
02:28:07 polarize and weaken national security structures diminish trust
02:28:11 in alliances and thus hamper the cohesion and effectiveness of national
02:28:15 and supranational defense structures uh yeah
02:28:19 they're trying to there's a lot of translation there's a lot of
02:28:23 nationalistic people who have political or are gaining political power and they're saying hey 0.97
02:28:30 fuck all of these united nations these globalist uh you know alliances let's just look after our 0.97
02:28:36 own country let's not spend let's not send billions of dollars to ukraine in a war that's 1.00
02:28:41 just a bloodbath that isn't going to change anything
02:28:44 authoritarian nations attempt to polarize and weaken national security and the implication
02:28:53 here is that
02:28:54 you know, nationalists in
02:28:57 western countries
02:28:58 aren't nationalists in western countries
02:29:01 that's just disinformation, that's literally
02:29:03 just Russia puppeteering us
02:29:04 which is precisely the
02:29:07 narrative that came from
02:29:09 you know, about the trucker convoy
02:29:11 I'm pretty sure even Gerald Butts was like
02:29:13 parroting this idea that it's like
02:29:15 oh well people are online and they're getting manipulated
02:29:17 by Russian bots to like care about their own country
02:29:19 it's authoritarian 0.61
02:29:20 yeah
02:29:21 Anti-NATO narratives and conspiracies are an important tool in the arsenal of digital manipulation campaigns undertaken by pro-Kremlin groups.
02:29:39 Well, there you go.
02:29:40 Either you're pro-NATO or you're pro-Kremlin.
02:29:43 There is no in-between.
02:29:45 It's impossible to be a Canadian citizen who just doesn't like your money going to Ukraine.
02:29:50 that just means that you love 0.95
02:29:51 that you love the current Hitler 0.78
02:29:53 which is Putin 0.65
02:29:55 NATO is portrayed
02:29:58 as an alliance that fosters
02:29:59 insecurity rather than protect its members
02:30:02 it is depicted as an
02:30:04 extension of the US military industrial
02:30:05 complex I mean they're the biggest
02:30:08 is that the end of that one yeah
02:30:11 I mean the US military
02:30:13 is the biggest contributor
02:30:16 to NATO if I'm not mistaken
02:30:17 I haven't been reading the captions
02:30:20 yeah these are good captions
02:30:27 during the cold war we prioritized conventional military
02:30:29 but in the social media age we're losing our political support
02:30:32 because people spread quote anti-nato narratives and conspiracies online
02:30:35 so we need to think of war as stopping our own citizens
02:30:38 from speaking freely online
02:30:40 by the way this guy is a executive director
02:30:44 of
02:30:45 what is this
02:30:47 foundation for freedom online
02:30:50 I just started following them recently but
02:30:52 he is a
02:30:54 Mike Benz is a former
02:30:56 state department cyber
02:30:58 security author of the
02:31:00 unpunishable monstrosity
02:31:02 weapons of mass
02:31:04 deletion interesting
02:31:06 because of our own citizen alright let's read
02:31:08 this we need to switch our censorship focus from
02:31:10 external enemies to our own citizens
02:31:12 great an increasing
02:31:14 risk for the transatlantic alliance also comes
02:31:16 from within. The landscape
02:31:18 of disinformation is changing from identifiable
02:31:20 external enemies to blurred boundaries
02:31:22 between foreign state, non-state,
02:31:24 and domestic actors, making attribution
02:31:26 and response increasingly more difficult.
02:31:29 They hate nationalism,
02:31:30 man. They hate
02:31:32 patriots.
02:31:34 Like, NATO just
02:31:36 hates it. Oh, man.
02:31:38 Because our own citizens talk badly
02:31:40 about us online, we need to treat their tweets
02:31:42 as a theater of war.
02:31:44 We need to remove the basic distinction
02:31:45 between peace and war.
02:31:47 We must preserve our political mandate.
02:31:49 We need to push national censorship policies
02:31:52 across all NATO countries.
02:31:54 All right.
02:31:56 Policy recommendations.
02:31:57 NATO should develop a more holistic understanding
02:32:00 of security that encapsulates shifts
02:32:03 in information technologies
02:32:04 and use of strategic narratives.
02:32:06 NATO currently responds
02:32:08 exposed to discrete
02:32:10 finite disinformation campaigns at the operational and strategic levels rather than preparing for
02:32:14 the inherently unpredictable nature of threats in the emergent security environment, recognizing
02:32:19 that unconventional means could pose an existential threat to the alliance. NATO's updated strategic
02:32:24 concept should remove the distinction between conventional and unconventional threats and
02:32:30 emphasize that future threats will occur across the spectrum of peace to war. War is peace.
02:32:40 The alliance should also expand and integrate the political mandates of NATO divisions and 0.79
02:32:47 departments focused on emerging security challenges, including disinformation. This
02:32:53 would first and foremost signify that threats to information integrity would be elevated to 0.77
02:32:58 the same importance as other types of hybrid aggression as in the cyber domain. NATO should 0.61
02:33:03 maintain a degree of ambiguity about whether disinformation constitutes an attack on the
02:33:09 alliance this would be an important step towards equalizing threat perceptions of disinformation
02:33:15 within the alliance and create a set of common denominator policies that would create more
02:33:20 national information policy coherence bruh we nato need to spy on and psychologically dissect
02:33:32 our own citizens in order to see how they interpret narratives online and that threaten
02:33:36 our political mandate nato needs to tell its own story better this is such a tell this is such a
02:33:47 tell we're not brainwashing people very well guys we need to tell our story better we're losing them
02:33:55 we're losing them to disinformation disinformation preys on existing vulnerabilities and
02:34:01 opportunistically utilizes events or crises yeah to make us look bad yeah this can also include
02:34:08 open source intelligence gathering using social media and other technologies to understand the
02:34:13 social context and monitoring how potential target communities attach meaning to or interpret
02:34:17 disinformation narratives this is actually really interesting and directs uh connects directly to
02:34:23 bill c63 like a sort of part of it that i don't think many people have talked about that's been
02:34:28 on my mind, which is if we create a digital safety board, regardless of like stopping
02:34:35 online harms, regardless of that, one of the, um, outcomes, if big tech agrees to it and
02:34:41 they don't just like leave the country, it would give the government and this body access
02:34:47 to a lot of data of certain users on big tech.
02:34:52 They always like to disconnect these two ideas and say, no, no, no, the digital safety commission
02:34:58 is about uh just holding the big tech platforms accountable and it's like well at the end of the
02:35:03 day you get access you get the keys to the castle of big tech and you get to peek behind the curtain
02:35:08 uh government and what will that entail would you get to learn oh someone's someone's pushing a
02:35:15 a misinformation campaign against nato let's research all about let's look into all of their
02:35:20 data how much data can you give us facebook meta how much data can you give us google oh can we
02:35:25 get access to their gmail we want to see that it's an online harms thing you know the potentiality
02:35:31 of of exactly what this is talking about in nato this can also include open source intelligence
02:35:38 gathering using social media they can't do that right now they can't just simply at the drop of
02:35:45 the hat say hey give me a bunch of your citizen social media data big tech would be like uh you
02:35:50 know i know we're shady but we're not that shady but with bill c63 it would give the government
02:35:57 the opportunity to you know strengthen the relationship with social media platforms to
02:36:03 get more data from people saying the wrong things on social media let's read that one more time
02:36:09 this can also include open source intelligence gathering social this can also include open
02:36:15 source intelligence gathering using social media and other technologies to understand the social
02:36:19 context and monitoring how potential target communities attach meaning to or interpret
02:36:26 disinformation narratives see they're already they're already talking about targeting specific
02:36:32 communities it's yeah so much for the disinformation right so much for the disinformation being the
02:36:39 problem it's like no no there's certain communities who are posting this disinformation and we need
02:36:44 to spy on them next tweet we need 24 7 disinformation monitoring system driven by
02:36:49 artificial intelligence oh my god every word our citizens speak every sentence they write
02:36:53 analyzed by a nato political thought crime radar system are you serious how much longer is this
02:37:00 okay just a couple more um let's see what it says here 24 7 disinformation monitoring systems
02:37:09 driven by artificial intelligence what else does it say promising new tools coming predominantly
02:37:15 from the private sector include machine learning
02:37:17 to remove fake social media accounts,
02:37:19 blockchain technology for secure digital
02:37:21 identity systems.
02:37:30 24-7 disinformation
02:37:31 monitoring systems.
02:37:35 That sounds like a nightmare.
02:37:38 Because who gets to decide?
02:37:40 Chat GPT is going to decide.
02:37:42 Oh, sorry.
02:37:43 msnbc.com
02:37:46 said that this was misinformation
02:37:47 sorry
02:37:48 Snopes AI
02:37:50 PoliFact
02:37:52 PoliticoFact
02:37:53 what are the fact checking websites
02:37:55 we're going to have fact check police
02:37:58 of the caliber of Snopes
02:38:00 monitoring
02:38:02 what is disinformation
02:38:04 and automatically censoring it 24-7
02:38:06 no thanks
02:38:08 no thanks
02:38:09 I would just go to the dark web at that point
02:38:12 I'd be like okay
02:38:12 internet's cooked time to uh go on a dark corner of the internet and
02:38:18 that'd probably be even less safe we need to use our muscle as the military to get political 0.80
02:38:26 bodies across nato to pump millions of dollars into brainwashing our citizens psychological 0.99
02:38:32 defense and financially steroid injecting censorship ngos oh and we need to capture
02:38:38 of the media, the ERM independent media. 0.54
02:38:42 Brother.
02:38:43 NATO should also use its political dialogue mechanisms
02:38:46 to create a coherent methodology across member nations.
02:38:50 This could include the creation of institutional networks,
02:38:53 society-oriented activities, infrastructure building,
02:38:56 research, education, and training tools
02:38:58 that go beyond mere debunking and strategic communications.
02:39:03 The Swedish model of psychological defense
02:39:05 also includes crisis modeling drills
02:39:07 for a variety of civil actors, including
02:39:09 media outlets.
02:39:12 Crisis
02:39:12 modeling drills.
02:39:16 I have so many questions.
02:39:23 Just as NATO played
02:39:25 a key role in the 1900s
02:39:26 and early 2000s in getting
02:39:28 Central and Eastern European
02:39:30 countries on a stable democratic
02:39:33 course, Article 2, which calls for
02:39:35 strengthening democratic institutions, should
02:39:37 be brought back to the forefront of political deliberations within the alliance.
02:39:42 NATO's continued support and cooperation with free and independent media
02:39:45 is essential to strengthening resilience.
02:39:48 Secretary General Stoltenberg has stated that,
02:39:52 quote, the best response to disinformation and propaganda
02:39:55 is the free and independent press.
02:39:58 When they ask difficult questions,
02:40:00 then disinformation and propaganda will never succeed.
02:40:03 NATO should therefore encourage
02:40:06 journalist exchanges facilitate
02:40:08 media access to activities and
02:40:10 exercises and urge member states to
02:40:12 invest in a more robust independent
02:40:14 local media presence
02:40:15 this was
02:40:17 this was a
02:40:20 very similar sort of lie
02:40:22 that the
02:40:24 liberal government was trying to push
02:40:25 to fund
02:40:28 the independent media
02:40:30 Let's see if we can find it.
02:40:42 Maybe we'll put local in there too.
02:40:58 This is kind of it.
02:40:59 federal money federal money's kept hundreds of journalists employed in canada but the program
02:41:05 set to expire after mass layoffs across after mass layoffs across country's largest news outlet
02:41:15 diversity hire after mass layoffs across country's largest news outlets we're missing a there
02:41:23 after mass layoffs across the country's largest news outlets independent publications
02:41:28 await news of their fate.
02:41:30 Diversity hire. 1.00
02:41:31 Who wrote this?
02:41:32 AI.
02:41:34 Okay, we cannot continue.
02:41:36 Yeah, the Local Journalism Initiative.
02:41:40 There we go.
02:41:42 Actually, I think this is it here.
02:41:44 Local Journalism Initiative.
02:41:46 March 1st, 2024,
02:41:48 announced 58 million investment
02:41:50 to extend the Local Journalism Initiative.
02:41:54 Local Journalism.
02:41:56 Yeah, so for those who don't know,
02:41:58 I mean, I wonder if we could look this up, too.
02:42:21 Uh, duh-duh-duh-duh-duh-duh-duh.
02:42:26 Is there a big list down here or what?
02:42:28 i mean essentially although there's a bunch of local outlets for news in canada
02:42:44 a lot of them are just under the same three different umbrellas i believe it's bell
02:42:51 rogers and chorus if i'm not mistaken shaw media recently got bought by somebody
02:42:57 shock communications was acquired by rogers in april 2023 so although there's all these like
02:43:07 local local media outlets they're local they're independent no they're they're all under one of
02:43:14 three umbrellas which essentially has an what is it what's the word oligarchy oligopoly uh over
02:43:21 the media industry in the country newspapers radio stations tv stations they're all local
02:43:30 no they're all they're all under the same uh three different umbrellas there are exceptions
02:43:34 but even them they are uh you know they're probably doing the the government subsidy
02:43:42 grift anyhow so it does really make make a big difference they're going to have the same sway
02:43:47 because they're getting paid by the government.
02:43:51 So, yeah, let's read this last part again.
02:43:56 Oh, you guys couldn't see that here.
02:44:01 NATO's continued support and cooperation
02:44:02 with free and independent media
02:44:04 is essential to strengthening resilience.
02:44:06 The best response to disinformation and propaganda
02:44:09 is the free and independent press
02:44:11 when they ask difficult questions.
02:44:12 And disinformation and propaganda will never succeed.
02:44:14 NATO should therefore encourage journalist exchanges,
02:44:16 facilitate media access to activities and exercises
02:44:19 and urge member states to invest
02:44:20 in a more robust, independent, local media presence.
02:44:26 Member states should pay for the news media.
02:44:32 In a democracy,
02:44:34 these are the righteous democratic nations of NATO
02:44:38 encouraging their member states to pay for the news.
02:44:43 Paying for the news,
02:44:45 the state paying for the news
02:44:46 is something that happens in communist China.
02:44:48 It's something that happens in Russia.
02:44:50 It's something that happens in North Korea.
02:44:52 Not in democratic nations at all.
02:44:55 And this is the same NATO warning us,
02:44:56 warning us about,
02:44:57 don't worry,
02:44:58 look out for those authoritarian states.
02:45:01 Look out for those authoritarian countries.
02:45:03 They are telling you the wrong story.
02:45:05 They're manipulating nationalists
02:45:07 and patriots to...
02:45:10 This is distracting me.
02:45:13 They're manipulating nationalists
02:45:15 and patriots from from uh from supporting nato can you believe this they're telling their own
02:45:24 version of reality there there's a troll army trying to manipulate trying to manipulate the
02:45:29 conversation it's a threat to democracy it's it's so repetitive at this point like it's we we see 0.88
02:45:36 it everywhere it's the same it's the same sort of double speak lies it's ridiculous but uh needless 0.96
02:45:43 to say, Bill 0.51
02:45:45 C-63 fits in
02:45:47 perfectly to this
02:45:49 stuff. It just slides
02:45:51 in there.
02:45:53 Chef's kiss.
02:45:57 It fits in right there
02:45:59 with Bill C-63.
02:46:02 Because it gives
02:46:03 the government control and surveillance
02:46:05 over
02:46:07 people online.
02:46:09 All of social media.
02:46:10 so there you go but hey that was uh i apologize if i was kind of low energy tonight you know i
02:46:17 was i was doing all sorts of stuff uh to try and um you know we updated the website actually let's
02:46:24 show this off for a sec it's um there's still a lot of updates coming but you know we are getting
02:46:31 there folks we're making things look better this is the new home page for savefreespeech.ca
02:46:36 you can see the little donate button in the corner there very cute right that goes to the
02:46:43 the give send go page amazing and yeah while we're at the give send go page if you want to
02:46:48 support our upcoming documentary big big things we're going to tell the story we're going to tell
02:46:55 the story of what this bill is actually about and why it would be the end of free speech in canada
02:47:00 and why uh yeah we're going to raise the alarm bells and tell show canada what's really going on
02:47:06 here but um yeah this is the new updated site lots coming there's gonna be a couple a couple
02:47:14 other sections over here coming we do have our social medias on the join us page this this page
02:47:20 still needs a lot of work though i'm not gonna lie i'm not gonna lie oh oh i'm doxing my uh my
02:47:28 WordPress whoops um but uh yeah you know what let's let's let's end it off with uh promoting
02:47:37 this this thing as well which is very very much related I've if you've been following along I've
02:47:42 been uh I've been covering um you know the many different sort of how can we how can we tell
02:47:52 people what's going on with bill c63 how can we explain the urgency to people if they don't know
02:48:00 that political prisoners are a regular thing in this country you know if i if i go to if i go to
02:48:06 like an average normie and say hey like this government or this uh this bill c63 is going to
02:48:11 uh it's going to be used for political purposes to censor people the government doesn't like
02:48:17 you know people might look at me sideways like i have five heads like what do you what do you mean
02:48:21 like when did when has that ever happened when has that ever happened and that's why i'm sending
02:48:28 out a call to freedom fighters or to political prisoners uh you know i i sent out this video
02:48:36 today which uh which kind of explains it hey canada if you have been slandered by the mainstream
02:48:48 media or by anti-hate. I want to hear from you. You see, a lot of people in Canada don't know
02:48:54 that people are persecuted for their political opinions, and that's a very disturbing trend. So
02:49:00 we want to hear and document your story, collect as many as possible to tell the greater Canadian
02:49:05 public that this is going on. So if you're a doctor or nurse who was persecuted during COVID,
02:49:10 If you're a freedom fighter activist who got arrested, if you're a mom or parent who was pushing and speaking up against the transgender ideology in schools, we want to hear from you.
02:49:23 There's a very simple form below here on Twitter or X, and I know that I may have spoken to some of you already before, but still, we want to kind of make sure we're not missing anybody.
02:49:32 And you can fill out that form and send it to info at savefreespeech.ca.
02:49:38 This will help us tell the rest of the country what's really going on in Canada.
02:49:43 That's right.
02:49:44 That's right.
02:49:45 That's right.
02:49:46 We need to send them.
02:49:47 You know, I have talked to a lot of the people who have been persecuted for their political opinions in Canada.
02:49:53 But I want to make sure I'm not missing anybody.
02:49:54 I'm sure there's a lot of people who probably I haven't talked to.
02:49:58 And I do want to hear more about their story.
02:50:01 Get their information.
02:50:02 Get them on a live stream.
02:50:03 Chat with them about their experience.
02:50:06 and the idea is to compile all these interviews compile all these all all this evidence really
02:50:12 like break it down into as simple a form as possible you know short videos short explanations
02:50:19 showing how outrageous all of these things are and just sending sending out these shorts sending
02:50:26 out these these messages showing more canadians that this is happening because i really feel like
02:50:32 the dust is still almost finally starting to settle since the trucker convoy in 2022
02:50:38 and it's almost like a i'm trying to think of like some war analogy where's jeremy mckenzie
02:50:43 when you need him but like you know everyone has scattered since then it's it's kind of it was
02:50:49 chaotic there was this this horrific thing that happened you know beaten by police people are
02:50:54 dealing with that charge people are dealing with this charge people are dealing with all sorts of
02:50:58 they're getting bogged down by social pressures by having to pay for lawyers by
02:51:04 you know maybe their family's getting torn apart all at the same time maybe maybe they're maybe
02:51:09 their regulatory body if you're a doctor or nurse is crunching down on you and now you're in a
02:51:14 lawsuit with them like everybody has to deal with their own battle but they all have the same thing
02:51:20 in common they all have the same thing in common which is these people spoke up about a specific
02:51:27 issue that the government did not like and they faced the consequences for it they were targeted
02:51:33 for their political opinion that is not something that happens in a free country you guys that's
02:51:39 not supposed to be something that happens in a democratic country yet it's happened dozens and
02:51:45 dozens and dozens and dozens of times since especially since the trucker convoy so i want
02:51:52 to round these people up let's get their stories together let's let's get our story straight
02:51:55 let's start championing our side let's put aside our differences and and start you know keep our
02:52:02 eyes on the prize here which is the corrupt regime that runs this place that's making it
02:52:08 so hard for us to to ever get ahead or try to have our actual values heard you know i feel like going
02:52:16 off on on the conservative party right now how how they sort of like pretend to champion our cause
02:52:21 but has has Pierre Polyev mentioned like one political prisoner yet not really uh like he
02:52:29 he he walked with James Topp for like 10 seconds for a photo op and then disappeared
02:52:36 you really don't even hear enough about James Topp either and and and what happened to him
02:52:43 getting smeared by some some ginger journalist was it CTV at the time or globe maybe it was
02:52:51 it was global at the time but i mean you know it's not about and i want to address this too
02:52:57 it's not about like playing the victim it's telling the story telling the story of what
02:53:04 happened to you you know it's not about oh woe is me it's more like no this is real this actually
02:53:10 happened this this because i was talking to jeremy i had a phone call with jeremy a few
02:53:16 weeks ago about this and i've talked to other kind of people in our space before and the gas 0.83
02:53:22 lighting is so crazy and and the normalization of us being shit on is is so it's such a real 0.57
02:53:30 uh phenomena that it's almost like people who are persecuted in canada don't even don't even um 0.98
02:53:38 what am i what am i trying to say here like that they don't even honor themselves they don't honor
02:53:45 the fact that they are being
02:53:47 it's like
02:53:49 it's almost like we have a lack of
02:53:51 because there's been this normalization
02:53:54 of silencing us and there's been
02:53:56 this normalization of dehumanizing us
02:53:58 and pushing us aside we are
02:54:00 not actually honoring and respecting
02:54:02 ourselves like this isn't about being a
02:54:04 victim this is about self-respect
02:54:05 and this is about saying no this did happen to me
02:54:08 and it was wrong and it was
02:54:10 because of the
02:54:11 trends of corruption in this government
02:54:14 and we should do something about it and yes political prisoners people being persecuted
02:54:19 for their political opinions that is a thing that is happening regularly in canada and i'm an example
02:54:25 of that we we and i'm thinking because on previous streams i've brought up uh the canadian race
02:54:35 relations foundation and and they're they're kind of in the background one of these groups
02:54:39 who is trying to push for the censorship and they do it by creating this victim porn
02:54:44 and what they do is they round up a lot of people who have been smeared online or they you know
02:54:50 they've been made fun of online for being like fat and asian or whatever and they're like see
02:54:55 look at these sad people look at these sad people this is why we need to censor the internet 0.92
02:54:58 and you know we i we've looked at that and said you know look how silly this is
02:55:03 this is so cheap it's so dishonest it's so not accurate but but the the value i see in that or
02:55:11 what i take away from that is we need to do our own version of that we need to do our own version
02:55:17 of that they're rounding up people who are crying and mentally ill and like easily offended online
02:55:22 and they're using that as a weapon to push through legislation we need to do our own version of that
02:55:27 which is round up everybody who has been targeted by the government for their political opinion
02:55:31 or targeted in some way for their political opinion
02:55:33 and faced massive consequences
02:55:35 and tell that story to people
02:55:37 and say, there's a lot of people like this in this country.
02:55:39 It's happening in this country.
02:55:42 It's happening.
02:55:43 And look, look at the bill they're trying to pass.
02:55:45 It's only going to give the government more tools
02:55:47 to persecute even more people
02:55:49 for their opinions they don't like,
02:55:50 much like this has already happened to all of these people.
02:55:55 So that's the plan.
02:55:56 That's the plan.
02:55:57 um to start it's very very simple send us an email at save free speech sorry info at
02:56:06 savefreespeech.ca that's where you send your email make sure the email subject is political
02:56:11 prisoner and it's very three very simple fairly simple fairly it's three fairly simple things to
02:56:19 fill out your name and occupation links to articles uh that's slandering your reputation
02:56:26 You know, if you've been slandered in the mainstream media or in an anti-hate article, definitely include those links.
02:56:33 Also, if you've been just simply arrested for your political opinion, that's totally valid as well.
02:56:38 Just, you know, put that in for number two.
02:56:41 And then number three, give a brief two to three sentence summary of your experience.
02:56:45 Just in a nutshell, I know people have very long, I shouldn't say long, I should say complicated consequences that they've had to face.
02:56:56 There was this lawsuit, there was that lawsuit, there's this regulatory body, there's a lot going
02:57:00 on. And, you know, what I'm trying to say is, like, don't
02:57:04 kill yourself trying to fill all this out. Like, you know, just give a brief
02:57:08 summary and then we can get into it in an interview or
02:57:12 something else like this, if you're comfortable, of course, coming on a live stream. But number three
02:57:16 is give a brief two to three sentence summary of your experience in the following fill-in-the-blank format.
02:57:20 Once I started talking about blank, I faced the consequences
02:57:24 of blank and i'm still dealing with blank um again i'm trying to appeal to all the different
02:57:32 people who have faced consequences um for speaking up about their political opinion but um i i thought
02:57:40 that was a pretty kind of fairly simple fill in the blank thing just to kind of give us the quick
02:57:45 bio rundown of uh why you feel you've been you know persecuted for your political opinion
02:57:50 but yeah yeah that's the plan guys that's the plan that's what we're doing with savefreespeech.ca
02:57:58 that's some of the more content that we got cooking up it's not it's not just it's not just
02:58:02 a documentary there's lots lots more stuff lots more moving parts here uh going on but uh once
02:58:08 again if you want to help us save free speech go to give send go.com slash save free speech
02:58:13 send us a donation there this is going towards paying for media professionals editors the
02:58:19 marketing of the documentary itself there's a lot there's a lot of exciting things going on in the
02:58:25 background i'm not going to say what but um that's another thing that's on the to-do list for me which
02:58:31 is updating this uh give send go campaign because i want to show people more specifically uh you know
02:58:38 what they're going to be paying for what it's going to be covering and how it's yeah the effect
02:58:44 that they will have when they click that, uh, that donate button. But, um, guys, thanks so
02:58:49 much for, uh, tuning into the stream. How are we doing in chat here? Raging against the machine
02:58:59 says exactly, Greg, focus on one big issue. That's the idea. That's the idea. And, uh, I, I see us
02:59:07 as all like working together here because there's different fronts to this crazy fifth generational
02:59:13 war we're dealing with i i brought up uh mocha berzigan berzigan media he's focusing on like
02:59:20 seek corruption i guess or like the the seek world world seek organization there's all these
02:59:25 nefarious connections between uh that organization and canadian politicians and a lot of wasted
02:59:31 public funds and he's he's crushing it he's more or less focusing on that kind of issue and stuff
02:59:39 adjacent to that and he's absolutely crushing it and like it's i totally think it's somebody else
02:59:43 who we should be supporting um and there's other examples of that but i think there's a lot of i
02:59:50 think there's a lot of positive um i think it's i think it's a good strategic move to like focus
02:59:56 focus have us all focusing on one thing or another and like really being really strong in that uh
03:00:02 Uh, in that department.
03:00:07 Okay.
03:00:11 In Russia last year.
03:00:13 Okay.
03:00:14 Can I, can I show this?
03:00:15 How do I show this?
03:00:21 Let's try to, let's try to get this to work.
03:00:27 A super helpful dag just sent me, uh,
03:00:30 Just sent me something that I was looking for.
03:00:33 Hold on.
03:00:34 How do I do this?
03:00:43 Oh, doxing.
03:00:45 Doxed.
03:00:45 Oh, does that not work? 1.00
03:00:47 Damn. 0.99
03:00:54 I will save it for another time. 0.99
03:00:57 All right, guys.
03:00:59 Thanks for watching.
03:01:00 or just over three hours perfect kelly lloyd says and air india bombing slash jagmeet
03:01:07 wallbanger says calistani hijinks yes that diagram is wild purple rain says thank you
03:01:15 have a good night thank you purple rain thanks for tuning in guys um yeah appreciate you uh
03:01:25 i guess it's gonna be labor day this weekend that's exciting
03:01:30 there is a song that i have but it's not really done yet but i'll hopefully be able to turn that
03:01:35 around and it's kind of a racist song you know it might be kind of fun for people but uh yeah
03:01:43 we'll talk to you guys later thanks for tuning in love ya make sure you subscribe to our social
03:01:48 medias and all that for safe free speech and um yeah we're gonna do it we're gonna make it happen
03:01:55 Until next time.
03:02:09 Why is that glitching?
03:02:11 Why is the lobby video glitching?
03:02:17 There we go.
03:02:18 There we go.
03:02:25 Thank you.
03:02:55 Thank you.
03:03:25 You