Human Events Daily with Jack Posobiec - August 12, 2026


ARREST THE COMMUNISTS: The SPLC Fraud Case & Tyler Robinson’s Newest Defense Filing

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
COMMUNIST ABDUL EL-SAYED BLAMES CHRISTIANS FOR TRANS SCHOOL SHOOTERS NO PLEA DEALS FOR MANGIONE

Episode Stats


Length

48 minutes

Words per minute

178.8

Word count

8,697

Sentence count

479

Harmful content

Misogyny

12

sentences flagged

Toxicity

17

sentences flagged

Hate speech

7

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hey guys, it's Jack. I wanted to let you know that we're starting a new push for subscriptions here on Human Events Daily.
00:00:09 So make sure that when you're listening to this podcast, you hit subscribe, you download it, and you share it with five of your friends.
00:00:16 Make sure they're all going and downloading as well, because we need to get the signal out as much as possible.
00:00:22 Look, we've done so much over the past couple of years since this show started, and we're only going to do so much more.
00:00:29 Let's get it.
00:00:34 This is what happens when the fourth turning meets fifth generation warfare.
00:00:43 A commentator, international social media sensation, and former Navy intelligence veteran.
00:00:50 This is Human Events with your host, Jack Posobiec.
00:00:53 Christ is king.
00:00:54 We grew up in democratic politics together, and I think we both remember well when party
00:00:58 leadership really selected the nominees.
00:01:01 Now, you would never say it that way exactly, but they would.
00:01:05 But you can now.
00:01:06 Now we can.
00:01:06 We're free.
00:01:08 You know, they really did because they would put money behind it.
00:01:11 They would endorse.
00:01:12 And now it looks very much like party leaders are not picking the nominees.
00:01:17 In fact, party leaders pushing nominees is a negative.
00:01:21 It is a negative in many of these races.
00:01:24 My name is Peggy Flanagan. I am the lieutenant governor of Minnesota and I'm really honored and humbled to be here with all of you today. I am incredibly clear that the Somali community is part of the fabric of the state of Minnesota race between Peggy Flanagan and Angie Craig, the Democratic primary for U.S. Senate race.
00:01:46 And this is what it shapes up like. Seventy percent of the votes tallied. Peggy Flanagan is now the projected winner in that race with fifty nine percent.
00:01:55 OK. Wow. What the heck just came in Brown? Was that the that was huge for her?
00:02:04 Yeah. So that was about eighteen thousand votes and she nets two thousand. 1.00
00:02:09 Question. Was that the. That wasn't central count, was it? 0.98
00:02:22 It was a nail biter last night in the Democratic primary for Wisconsin governor early this morning, just after 2.30, the AP calling the race for David Crowley, who will now face Republican Tom Tiffany in November.
00:02:36 You see their progressive Democratic candidate, Francesca Hong, who was leading Crowley in the polls heading into election night.
00:02:43 And Crowley had the endorsement of current Governor Tony Evers.
00:02:46 The defense attorneys have accused Charlie Kirk assassin Tyler Robinson are arguing that there's not enough evidence to go to trial.
00:02:53 They're saying, quote, the state has failed to establish probable cause that the shooter knowingly created a great risk of death to another other than Charlie Kirk and himself.
00:03:03 and welcome aboard today's edition of human events daily we're here live in washington dc
00:03:11 today is august 12th 2026 anno domini ton of stuff going on out there today huge filing
00:03:18 in the tyler robinson case of course we'll be breaking down everything there this of course
00:03:22 the filing from the defense side this is tyler robinson's own defense team we're going to have
00:03:29 our own team of legal experts here on the program to break all of that down. Now, moments ago,
00:03:35 just before the show went live, we also got information regarding a major, major arrest
00:03:44 from the Attorney General himself. Todd Blanche came out at a press conference and stated that
00:03:51 the former director of the Southern Poverty Law Center's Intelligence Project has now been
00:03:58 arrested in California on fraud charges. The director of the SPLC's intelligence project
00:04:07 has just been arrested. Ladies and gentlemen, that's what we're talking about right there.
00:04:14 It is time for a little something that we call the iron law of reciprocity. Iron law of reciprocity.
00:04:22 Todd Blanch was confirmed just a few days ago.
00:04:25 This arrest comes, boom, right now.
00:04:29 Let's not forget what she did. 1.00
00:04:31 She oversaw payments to these informants, 1.00
00:04:34 informants in what she called right-wing extremist groups.
00:04:39 But these groups were being paid and funded by her.
00:04:43 These groups were being organized and controlled by her
00:04:46 and her little intelligence project over there at the SPLC.
00:04:51 Now, we're also, and remember, this was over $1 million to one informant that we're also told that she was having a relationship with, a sexual relationship with.
00:05:03 How wonderful.
00:05:04 How interesting.
00:05:05 And, of course, this goes to, we're talking about the Imperial Wizard of the KKK activity involving the National Alliance neo-Nazi group.
00:05:13 Well, Attorney General Todd Blanche is out publicly confirming the arrest and charges as part of the ongoing investigation.
00:05:18 Barrett previously led the SPLC's hate group tracking work before leaving and co-founding the Global Project Against Hate and Extremism.
00:05:27 The SPLC has disputed the government's characterization, blah, blah, blah. 0.62
00:05:30 Ladies and gentlemen, ladies and gentlemen, it is time to start arresting the communists.
00:05:38 And it is really simple. It is really simple.
00:05:41 It's a law of the universe.
00:05:43 that which is done to us
00:05:45 which will be done to you
00:05:47 to the specific people
00:05:49 who were behind it
00:05:50 these are the people who lied
00:05:52 these are the people who said it all
00:05:53 and by the way
00:05:54 it doesn't escape me
00:05:58 that this is the same intelligence director
00:06:00 and many of these informants
00:06:02 were involved in Charlottesville
00:06:05 the Unite the Right rally
00:06:08 so the Charlottesville rally
00:06:11 was actually an operation and what day is today folks what day is august 12th today is the
00:06:19 anniversary of charlottesville nine years ago today so you know just a little i don't know
00:06:28 we could call it poetic justice i suppose that she's been arrested on the nine-year anniversary
00:06:35 of her own crimes.
00:06:37 A crime that they threatened 1.00
00:06:38 to take down the entire country over. 0.78
00:06:41 They wanted a civil war 0.99
00:06:43 because of the crap that was coming out of the SPLC, 1.00
00:06:46 the crap that was coming out of her mouth, 1.00
00:06:48 the crap that was coming out of all the media mouths, 1.00
00:06:50 and now she's been arrested for fraud. 1.00
00:06:51 And you look at what she's done.
00:06:53 A million dollars in payments 0.55
00:06:55 to a guy she was having sex with 0.93
00:06:56 posing as one of these leaders. 1.00
00:06:59 It's disgusting. 1.00
00:07:00 She's disgusting. 1.00
00:07:01 She's a pig. 1.00
00:07:02 This is horrific. 1.00
00:07:03 and thank God justice is finally being done in America. 0.91
00:07:08 These liars, these fraudsters,
00:07:10 these charlatans need to be locked up for good. 0.99
00:07:15 We'll be right back. 0.85
00:07:16 Human Events Daily.
00:07:31 And Jack, where is Jack?
00:07:33 Where's Jack? Where is he? Jack, I want to see you. Great job, Jack. Thank you. What a job you do.
00:07:45 You know, we have an incredible thing. We're always talking about the fake news and the bad,
00:07:48 but we have guys, and these are the guys who'll be getting Pulisic.
00:07:54 All right, folks, we're back here. Jack Pesoba, Cuban Events Daily. Now,
00:07:58 you may think that you slept all night, but did you? Did you? See, if your body was fighting to
00:08:05 get comfortable, then actually you're going to feel that the next day. Maybe you weren't. That's
00:08:10 why I sleep on a ghost bed. For me, the difference is waking up feeling like my body actually rested.
00:08:16 I sleep cooler, I get better support, and I'm not starting the day with that stiffness and soreness
00:08:20 that follows a bad night's sleep. Ghost bed is engineered to help reduce the reasons your sleep
00:08:25 gets interrupted every ghost bed mattress is designed to relieve pressure help regulate
00:08:30 temperature and support your body with cooling technology built right into every mattress and
00:08:36 ghost bed is made right here in the usa plus ghost bed gives you a 101 night sleep trial try
00:08:41 it at home because the real test of a mattress is how you feel in the morning if you're waking up
00:08:46 sore or tired before the day even starts check out ghost bed for unlimited time during ghost bed's
00:08:52 Labor Day sale, get an extra 10% off their lowest prices of the season. Go to ghostbed.com
00:08:57 slash POSO and use promo code POSO. Again, that's ghostbed.com slash POSO, promo code POSO.
00:09:04 I want to bring on now, so we have this filing. It is a monster filing in the Tyler Robinson case.
00:09:11 This, of course, is the briefing to kind of get everyone up to speed and re-familiarize everyone
00:09:17 with where we are in the case. So we had the initial hearing. However, the judge has yet to
00:09:21 make his ruling. It was decided at the end of that hearing that I attended out in Utah, in that
00:09:27 courthouse, that hot courthouse in the middle of the summer, that in the high desert, that
00:09:33 there would be two briefs, the state, the defense, and then the judge would make his decision. There's
00:09:38 going to be oral arguments on September 1st, about two weeks time. But the defense has filed
00:09:43 their motion here. And from my reading, it seems that their biggest focus is on trying to get the
00:09:51 death penalty off the table. That seems to be clearly what they're focused on here. I read
00:09:57 the entire thing this morning. It was the first thing I did when I woke up and I saw this came.
00:10:00 I read every single word of it. And now we are here to break it down. But because I'm not a
00:10:05 lawyer, I wanted to get the best lawyer I could on it. And that's why I got Andrew Branca, host
00:10:08 of The Andrew Branca Show. Andrew, how are you? I'm doing great, man. How are you doing?
00:10:13 Well, I'm in this position where I think I've got some thoughts about this briefing, but I want to
00:10:20 get it straight from the lawyer. That's why I brought you on. But look, this to me, what jumped
00:10:25 out here is it seems to me their biggest focus isn't necessarily on, you know, the points of
00:10:34 the evidence itself. It's really more on these enhancements, these aggravating factors, which
00:10:40 would trigger in Utah, under Utah law, the death penalty. Right. So the only capital charge here
00:10:48 is that aggravated murder charge, and it's based on the allegation that Robertson knowingly created
00:10:54 a great risk of death to others besides Charlie. If that's the case and the jury would fine for
00:10:59 that, they'd be looking at the death penalty. And anytime you're a defense attorney and you
00:11:02 have a client looking at the death penalty, victory is essentially defined as your client
00:11:07 does not get the death penalty. They get convicted and all the other stuff, that's fine as long as
00:11:10 they're not sentenced to death. So that's their primary concern. They do some hand-waving here
00:11:15 on the other charges. But it's important to keep in mind what the standard of proof is here. We're
00:11:20 not trying to determine guilt on the merits. We're just trying to decide, is there evidence from which
00:11:26 a unbiased jury could rationally find that these charges have been proven? It's essentially a
00:11:32 probable cause level of proof. And unfortunately for the defense, there just clearly is. I mean,
00:11:38 there's vastly more than enough evidence for a jury to consider. We don't have a circumstance
00:11:43 here where no jury could rationally conclude guilt. It's not there. And even on this aggravating
00:11:49 factor, which would be the most vulnerable, it's the one the courts will be most sensitive to
00:11:53 because it carries a death penalty. The arguments the defense is making that there was not a
00:11:59 knowing creation of a risk of death to others simply doesn't hold water here.
00:12:06 Yeah, so I read that part. And so there's two, if I understand this correctly, there's two
00:12:10 counts, aggravating counts that they're adding to this, one being that it was done in the presence
00:12:16 of minors and that it could have threatened others. Right. And and then also this political
00:12:21 targeting. And on the one that you just mentioned, you know, the fact that it took place in the
00:12:26 presence of minors, they're making this strange argument that Tyler Robinson, when he was on the
00:12:32 roof or as they say, the shooter was on the roof. And by the way, they don't dispute that there was
00:12:35 a shooter on the roof, that a shooter can be seen on the roof, that the shooter took a shot on the
00:12:39 roof, that the bullet came from the roof, that it was on a downward trajectory to enter Charlie's
00:12:43 neck, et cetera, et cetera. All the things that we see on the video and that those of us who were
00:12:47 in court and watched the video reported in real time. None of that is disputed. In fact, all of
00:12:52 it is stipulated by the defense team. But what they argue is that the shooter could not have
00:13:00 known from that line of sight that children were in the crowd and in fact fired over the crowd and
00:13:07 not through the crowd. Now, look, again, I'm not a lawyer. That doesn't sound like a very
00:13:12 strong argument to me. Oh, it's not, especially since there's other things that Tyler Robinson
00:13:17 knew. I mean, he had walked around the area prior. He knew the kinds of people that were there. He
00:13:23 knew children were in the area. Are we supposed to believe that he thought for some reason that
00:13:27 all the children that were there when he first walked through were gone when he decided to fire
00:13:32 the shot? That's simply not credible. He would have no reason to believe that.
00:13:37 No, that's exactly right. And in addition to that, so when they talked about the political
00:13:41 motive, I noticed that one thing that was argued at great length during the hearing was not found
00:13:48 anywhere in their brief. And that, of course, was the etchings on the bullets, which I've always
00:13:54 held is where the shooter told the entire world what his motive was. You see trans slogans and 0.91
00:14:02 you see anti-fascist Antifa slogans on multiple bullets. It's as clear as day. I couldn't see a
00:14:08 single reference to that here. Well, they don't want to talk about the evidence that's harmful
00:14:13 to them in this filing, of course. That's the job of the state to do. But again, this is evidence
00:14:18 that's in the record that a jury at trial will be free to consider. So there are facts for a jury to
00:14:25 come to a conclusion of guilt. For them to win on this, none of these facts would have to be in
00:14:30 evidence, which is why they're simply not talking about them in his filing.
00:14:34 That's precisely right.
00:14:35 We're supposed to forget.
00:14:37 Oh, right, right, right.
00:14:38 And of course, the state does obviously reference this in their filing, and of course, brought
00:14:42 it up at the hearing.
00:14:43 And if the oral arguments do take place on September 1st, as is scheduled, pending any
00:14:50 changes, of course, we've seen a lot of delays in this case already, that I am certain that
00:14:56 if there's a question of motive, that's going to be the first thing that's brought up.
00:14:59 Now, another piece of this, though, is that I did want to dig in,
00:15:03 that it seems to me as though there's a number of points here
00:15:07 where the defense is making stipulations.
00:15:10 There's a part where they talk about, and I tweeted this out earlier,
00:15:15 where they talk about the stairwell footage,
00:15:17 and they say that the video evidence shows Mr. Robinson
00:15:20 walking up and down stairs at UVU with a gait impaired
00:15:23 by something long in his pant leg.
00:15:25 The reasonable inference from the evidence provided
00:15:28 is that it was a fully assembled rifle. Now, I don't know that I would agree that you obviously
00:15:34 know that it's a fully assembled rifle, but some kind of rifle, that's certainly for sure.
00:15:41 But it also seems to me that with this, they're pointing out that the video evidence shows their
00:15:46 client on the campus at the time of the crime. Yeah. So an inference, of course, is when you're
00:15:52 coming to a conclusion, not based on direct evidence, but from circumstantial evidence,
00:15:56 you're observing something, you're saying, well, this suggests that this other thing is true as
00:16:00 well. And there's a difference between inference and speculation, and they try to conflate that
00:16:04 in this filing. Speculation is when you're coming to the conclusion based on no evidence. That's
00:16:10 the difference between an inference, where you're actually just extending things you're observing.
00:16:14 Obviously, the limp could mean it would be a reasonable inference. There's something that's
00:16:18 causing the limp. It could be a rifle in the pants. Speculation would be, for all we knew,
00:16:23 he had three rifles. There's no evidence to support that. What was interesting to me is,
00:16:27 I'm not sure I would go so far as to say that they're explicitly stipulating a lot of these
00:16:31 things, but they don't have any counter-argument. I mean, all the evidence is consistent with what
00:16:35 the state's narrative of guilt is here, and they have nothing to the contrary.
00:16:40 Right. You don't see anything. And by the way, I'm going to have to go and check again, but
00:16:45 I didn't see very much response to all the DNA evidence, for example, or fingerprints,
00:16:51 or so many other things that came up at the hearing that, again, in these 41 pages are
00:16:56 just not found.
00:16:57 They don't mention DNA at all that I can recall in this 41 pages.
00:17:01 I'm running my control F right now, and I just don't see it.
00:17:06 Right.
00:17:06 Yeah, nothing in there about it.
00:17:08 Again, they don't want to talk about the things that they don't have an answer to, and that's
00:17:11 one of them.
00:17:13 Right.
00:17:13 And so when you're looking at all of this, does it seem, and I'll just ask you your opinion
00:17:18 here that is, does this seem like it is their strategy then is, you know, kind of saying,
00:17:25 all right, we think this is going to be bound over, it's going to trial, and they're working
00:17:30 backwards from a potential death penalty? Yeah, they very much, of course, would like the death
00:17:36 penalty off the table. This whole knowing creation of a risk to others, for example,
00:17:41 it's kind of silly when you think about the other arguments that have been made in this case. Now,
00:17:45 We know from the forensics, for example, that the bullet fired into Charlie, fragmented, stayed in his body.
00:17:51 There was not an exit wound.
00:17:52 That's not what I would expect from a .30-06 round, but it can happen from a .30-06 round.
00:17:56 There's no question about that.
00:17:57 It's within the realm of reasonable terminal ballistics for that kind of round.
00:18:02 But now they're trying to say, the defense is trying to say, well, no, I mean, these bullets operate like lasers.
00:18:08 You know, there can be no deflection.
00:18:11 There can be no ricochet.
00:18:12 There could be no risk to other people.
00:18:13 Only Charlie was possibly at risk.
00:18:15 from this high-powered rifle round, when in fact they cite the Supreme Court of Utah decisions
00:18:22 on this issue, and those decisions explicitly talk about things like the risk of a ricochet,
00:18:27 the risk of a stray bullet. All of those are clearly present here as the creation of a
00:18:33 knowing great risk of death to others. Their own citations are not supportive of their efforts to
00:18:39 try to get this excluded. In fact, you're coming up on a quick break, but one of the things that
00:18:43 they brought up at the hearing as well the prosecution brought up was the fact that the
00:18:47 the tent behind Charlie it's it's sort of an opaque white wall but again it's still a tent
00:18:52 it's not going to deflect anything if he had missed if the shooter missed anyone standing
00:18:57 behind there walking behind their students staff faculty children anyone would have been at risk
00:19:03 and in fact the shooter had no way of knowing who was behind that tent at the time which I would say
00:19:10 the reasonable inference would be that that does create a knowing risk of death to others
00:19:17 jack prosovic right back here cuban events daily you're a market for sports
00:19:30 hey you know they talk about influences these are influences and uh they're friends of mine
00:19:36 Jack Posobiec
00:19:38 Where's Jack?
00:19:40 He's done a great job
00:19:42 Alright folks, Jack Posobiec
00:19:46 back live here at Human Events Daily
00:19:48 Ladies and gentlemen, in a world that's constantly changing
00:19:50 some things never should
00:19:51 faith, family, freedom, the values you choose to live by
00:19:54 even your wireless provider can reflect those values
00:19:57 That's what Patriot Mobile
00:19:58 has stood for for more than 12 years
00:20:00 They serve Americans who want their dollars
00:20:02 supporting the Christian conservative movement
00:20:04 and organizations defending faith, family, and freedom.
00:20:07 Making the switch is simple.
00:20:08 Keep your number, keep your phone, or upgrade to a new device.
00:20:11 Their 100% U.S.-based customer support team can have you connected in minutes.
00:20:15 If you're still paying off your current phone,
00:20:17 they can even help with a contract buyout.
00:20:19 Patriot Mobile also gives you premium priority access
00:20:21 across all three major U.S. networks,
00:20:23 so you get dependable nationwide coverage without compromising your principles.
00:20:27 If it matters who you trust with your service and where your money goes,
00:20:30 it's time to make the switch.
00:20:32 Go to PatriotMobile.com slash POSO or call 972-PATRIOT.
00:20:36 Use promo code POSO to get a free month of service.
00:20:39 That's PatriotMobile.com or call them 972-PATRIOT.
00:20:42 All patriots make the switch today.
00:20:45 So we're going through this new filing.
00:20:47 It's 41 pages.
00:20:49 I've read every word.
00:20:51 And, you know, we're in the Tyler Robinson case.
00:20:55 We talked about the video evidence confirming that it was Tyler Robinson
00:20:59 walking up and down the stairs at UVU with a gait impaired by something long on his pant leg.
00:21:03 That is the defense. That is not the state. That is not anyone connected to anyone other
00:21:09 than Tyler Robinson's own team. And we, you know, we look at so much here. They're asking to take
00:21:16 the death penalty, asking the judge to take the death penalty off. That is one of their main,
00:21:22 one of their main decisions that to try to, to put out. It does, it does say that the single
00:21:28 bullet followed a downward trajectory from the rooftop and struck only Charlie Kirk. There's a
00:21:35 former Navy SEAL who disagreed with me on that, and I hope that he gets a chance to read this
00:21:39 new report. And the defense team also states that the evidence shows a shooter was on the
00:21:44 low seat center roof in a prone position for approximately 35 to 44 seconds before firing
00:21:50 their weapon once. And so I want to bring up here attorney Andrew Branca, host of the Andrew
00:21:55 break a show. And Andrew, when we're looking at this, let's steel man it, right? Let's steel man
00:22:03 the situation. Devil's advocate, what would you say is the strongest part of the defense's
00:22:09 briefing here today? I think it's strongest if they're speaking to a naive audience about how
00:22:15 firearms work and how accurate they are and how much reliance you can put that you're only going
00:22:20 to hit your intended target and nothing but that. As we talked in the break, I'm a lifelong
00:22:25 competitive shooter. I consider myself pretty good with a gun. I miss. People miss. That's just what
00:22:30 happens. Bullets overpenetrate. Bullets ricochet. The defense would have us believe that the only
00:22:36 possible outcome here was a single round was fired, would strike and kill Charlie Kirk and never
00:22:40 present a threat to anybody else. And that's simply not the reality with a high-powered rifle
00:22:45 fired into a crowded arena. And that's exactly right. And I just think, and you look at the
00:22:51 pictures. And I've, so I've, I've gone to that rooftop myself. I was not there that day, but
00:22:55 I've gone to the rooftop since then. I've seen the photos on the rooftop. I've seen photos that are
00:23:00 from, you know, nearby that, that vantage point where you can see, I mean, it's, it's, it's a
00:23:05 crowd full of people that are between everyone just common sense knows it is a crowd full of
00:23:10 people that the shooter was shooting over. And then Charlie was, of course, and he was, he was
00:23:15 in a, you know, a slightly raised platform. He was sitting, but he was under a tent and there's no
00:23:20 way there's no way that that that shooter was not putting the people at risk and I just don't know
00:23:27 how anyone could sit there and and I get it you know they're they're you know making the argument
00:23:31 they can but it's not a very good one we'd have to imagine that someone standing near Charlie
00:23:37 when that shot was fired would believe I'm totally fine I'm at no risk here of death or
00:23:42 serious bodily injury no and I've talked to people I've talked to many of the people who
00:23:47 were standing right there. And I can assure you that is not what was running through their minds
00:23:51 at that moment when they heard that rifle shot, that crack come out, which, by the way, is a very
00:23:56 recognizable sound. Obviously, a rifle, not something else. Anyone who's done any amount
00:24:03 of shooting knows the difference between the crack and the pop of a rifle versus a pistol.
00:24:09 Everyone looked at the exact spot where the sound emanated. People can triangulate pretty well with
00:24:15 their ears. It's not, you know, it's not something fancy. Everyone can do so. And what's horrific
00:24:21 is that, yes, people, of course, fled in terror afterwards. And we heard testimony from multiple
00:24:27 officers and law enforcement who were there from the school and from other agencies that eventually
00:24:32 came of the aftermath. And people were terrified. This is not a situation where anyone felt that
00:24:38 their lives were not at risk, including, by the way, of the multiple, you know, emotional and
00:24:44 harrowing moments of just watching the evidence, this is only a little piece of it, that we watched
00:24:49 a video, and it had been partially blurred out, of a mother who was there with two very small
00:24:54 children who we know what they saw that day and how that obviously has irrevocably changed their
00:25:01 lives. And the defense arguments in their brief largely consisted of them providing lots of
00:25:07 examples of cases that were more horrific in the sense of how many people were endangered. So
00:25:13 multiple shots fired at multiple people in a particular set of time. And then they say,
00:25:18 and nothing like that happened here. This was just one shot directed at one person.
00:25:23 But what matters is not whether other people were actually killed or bullets were fired into them.
00:25:28 What matters is whether or not there was a risk of death to them. And a high-powered rifle fired
00:25:34 into a confined space creates that risk. It would be impossible to contend otherwise.
00:25:39 No, it certainly would.
00:25:40 And really this, I mean, you know, I don't even know where you go with this, but the idea that the assassination of Charlie Kirk would not be political, I get that they have to make an argument.
00:25:52 But, you know, to me, that just feels like they're cashing a check because I don't think that anyone is going to accept that with any amount of seriousness.
00:26:01 Just a random victim selected here is what we're supposed to believe, I suppose.
00:26:06 No, and unfortunately, I get it, right? 0.81
00:26:09 I almost, you know, I wish we lived in a, believe me, there's nothing I wish for more than we lived in a country where a committed, ardent, anti-fascist, pro-trans activist would climb up on a roof with a Mauser 98 and shoot a guy and kill him in front of the entire world.
00:26:29 I wish to God that that was not true.
00:26:31 I wish, right?
00:26:32 I wish all of that were true.
00:26:33 But it's not.
00:26:34 Right.
00:26:34 This actually is reality.
00:26:36 And this is where we're at.
00:26:37 And so that's what we have to deal with.
00:26:39 We have to deal with the facts as they lay.
00:26:41 Andrew Branca, thank you so much for coming on.
00:26:42 I know it was short notice.
00:26:43 You did a great job.
00:26:44 Tell people where they can go to follow you and get all the analysis and breakdowns that I'm sure you're going to do.
00:26:48 Best places to find me are on X and on YouTube at The Branca Show, B-R-A-N-C-A, The Branca Show.
00:26:56 Yeah, he's got a great show, folks.
00:26:57 He does some other stuff, too.
00:26:58 I loved your breakdown of our great burrito beef debate from the other week was pretty phenomenal.
00:27:07 That's where I found that you're a boomer by two weeks, apparently.
00:27:11 Two weeks, that's right.
00:27:12 He's a two-week boomer.
00:27:13 Barely.
00:27:14 Barely.
00:27:14 I think it's like you and Obama are in that same...
00:27:18 Wow, I had no idea that Andrew Prakka has something in common with Barack Obama.
00:27:22 Who knew?
00:27:22 Who knew, folks?
00:27:24 We'll be right back.
00:27:24 Jack Posobiec, Real America's Voice, Human Events Daily.
00:27:28 one communist on the faculty of one university is one communist too many
00:27:36 one communist among the American advisors at Yalta was one communist too many
00:27:52 all right folks jack we are back live here human events daily real market's voice and of course
00:27:59 we're going through this new filing in the tyler robinson case and i wanted to just say you know a
00:28:06 huge shout out because when we were there on the ground when we were there um covering this day in
00:28:12 and day out we knew that we needed some extra security we knew that we needed some extra
00:28:16 resources, we need to kind of kind of fleet up, if you will. And our friends over at Allegiance
00:28:22 Gold really came in big for us. And they did everything possible to support us, secure our
00:28:27 security team, support our coverage. And we just appreciate the partnership that we have with them
00:28:33 to help making reporting like that in that kind of situation possible. And it also made me reflect
00:28:39 because the idea of security, it means different things to different people. And it has different
00:28:42 aspects to it whether it's you know stories recovering like that or even decisions we make
00:28:47 for our own families and our family's financial status you got to think about protecting what
00:28:52 we've all worked so hard to build that's why i'm especially thankful for allegiance gold you know
00:28:58 we've been working together with those guys for the past five years and relationships like this
00:29:02 are not built overnight they're built on trust consistency and showing up for one another and
00:29:06 we appreciate their support very much we're proud to have them standing with us and if you would
00:29:10 like to learn more, visit protectwithposo.com. That's protectwithposo.com or give them a call
00:29:15 844-577-POSO. Again, that's protectwithposo.com. I want to go through some more. We're getting
00:29:22 these reactions to this. And to me, it really is a bombshell filing in the Tyler Robinson case.
00:29:29 I'm going to bring on now Will Chamberlain of the Article 3 Project. He joins us by phone. Will,
00:29:34 how are you? Doing great. Good to be with you, Jack. You as well. And Will, I know you're running
00:29:38 and around today. You've got so much going on, but I understand you've had time to just really
00:29:43 start to, you know, dig in a little bit on this filing just this morning, but in the Tyler Robinson
00:29:50 case. But to me, what just jumped out at me was that the focus of the briefing really seemed to
00:29:57 be more on the death penalty as opposed to any direct attacks or attempts to, you know, to
00:30:06 chip away at this mountain of evidence that's been presented against their client. And I wanted to
00:30:12 get your take as well on this. I'm not surprising. I'm not surprised by that. It suggests to me that
00:30:19 Tyler Robinson's defense counsel are competent in the sense that they understand that at this stage
00:30:23 of the case, they're not going to be able to prove that there's no probable cause that Tyler
00:30:28 Robinson shot Charlie Kirk, because we heard a week's worth of evidence that there was.
00:30:32 So they're really trying to focus in on what could they possibly win on at this stage.
00:30:37 And really the only thing that's even conceivable is that they defeat the death penalty aspect of this case by trying to mitigate or essentially cast doubt on the question of whether there are aggravating factors.
00:30:50 And, you know, I think that from from the outset, I always thought the only part of this case that wasn't open and shut,
00:30:56 the only part of this case that wasn't completely buttoned up was the question of these aggravating
00:31:00 factors, whether or not Tyler Robinson knew he was trying to shoot and was reckless about other
00:31:06 people being in range. I thought there's at least an argument to be made that he was trying to
00:31:11 kill Charlie Kirk and was only trying to kill Charlie Kirk in a way that was targeted. So
00:31:16 that said, I think the prosecution has the better of the argument here. But I'm not surprised that
00:31:22 the defense lawyers are spending their energy at this stage on trying to defeat that one aspect of
00:31:28 the case. Well, and, and, and, and that seems to be exactly right. And so, but even in doing so
00:31:34 in this, in this filing, you've got statements here from the defense team and, and, you know,
00:31:39 we've been talking about them all day, but statements that the defense team is admitting
00:31:43 that the evidence shows, it doesn't say the evidence appears to show it. No, it says the
00:31:49 evidence shows that a shooter was on the roof of the Losi Center and fired one shot at Charlie
00:31:54 Kirk. And as horrific as that is, and as disgusting as that is, and as much as I every single day
00:32:00 wish that wasn't true, you know, this reminds me of when, you know, we had that video of Lance
00:32:07 Twiggs that was played at the trial, where Twiggs was saying, yeah, that was Tyler Robinson. And
00:32:12 And this wasn't, you know, this wasn't Kash Patel saying it, it wasn't CNN saying it, it's his own boyfriend.
00:32:20 Now we have his own defense team saying these things.
00:32:23 And it's a big moment, it's just a big moment.
00:32:27 Yeah, I totally agree.
00:32:29 I think that it was never, it was just never going to be viable for them to try and claim one of these bizarre conspiracy theories,
00:32:35 like it was an explosion or like an explosive microphone or whatever else people are thinking of.
00:32:43 There's just this overwhelming amount of evidence that there was obviously a shooter on the roof.
00:32:48 There was a gun that was located.
00:32:50 There was the coroner's report and the autopsy showing the presence of bullet fragments inside his body
00:32:58 and nothing resembling the burn marks.
00:33:01 That would be the telltale signs of some sort of explosion.
00:33:04 uh so i mean i think that you know when your defense attorneys are not podcasters you actually
00:33:09 have to like maintain your credibility with the judge and maintain your credibility with the jury
00:33:13 if you're trying to hope to accomplish anything at all and as a result you're not you're not going 0.72
00:33:18 to play so fast and loose with the facts that you just make yourself look like a clown especially
00:33:23 at such an early stage in the proceedings yeah i got i was on a uh you know sort of one of those
00:33:28 panel shows that as as you get into these days and i was asked that question about uh you know
00:33:33 whether it was not a bullet. And I just sort of responded that, you know, everything that I've
00:33:37 heard from day one, from information directly from the hospital to information that was presented
00:33:43 in court, which I sat through, you know, everyone on both sides of the football was discussing
00:33:49 bullets, ballistics, DNA on the casings, the etchings on the casings, which would provide
00:33:56 the political motive. And then, of course, the autopsy report, which unfortunately showed the
00:34:03 fragmentation of that bullet and what it did to my friend's body. And so it always just struck me
00:34:09 as quite strange that these questions would be coming in sometime. And in that case, it was from
00:34:14 a, you know, even a former Navy SEAL who's quite famous. And I just sort of was scratching my head
00:34:20 saying, that's not what all of these officials are talking about. Yeah, I mean, it's really
00:34:26 bizarre that people went down this rabbit hole. And I think people struggle with the difference
00:34:31 between unlikely and impossible.
00:34:36 So, and especially with regards to, you know,
00:34:38 the sort of central question of could a 30-06 bullet
00:34:40 have not gone through and through.
00:34:42 And 30-06s are more likely than not to leave an exit wound, 0.99
00:34:47 but it's not impossible. 1.00
00:34:48 I mean, it reminds me of something like, you know,
00:34:51 a pitcher gets a hit in baseball one out of every 10 times.
00:34:54 It's not impossible.
00:34:55 It's not unheard of.
00:34:56 It happens every day.
00:34:58 It just is, even if it's not the most likely outcome,
00:35:00 It is a regularly occurring outcome, and that's the case with the .30-06 bullet not having
00:35:05 an exit wound, especially given that apparently the bullet was a soft-hit bullet designed
00:35:09 not to go through and through, but rather to expand.
00:35:12 Well, that's right, Will, and in fact, this is actually the ballistics here, and that
00:35:16 likelihood has actually become a point for the state because they're arguing that because
00:35:23 of the propensity for ricochets or through and throughs or, you know, in the military
00:35:30 There's this phrase, you know, bullets do weird things because of that propensity.
00:35:33 That's what creates the aggravated risk to others.
00:35:37 Right. Right. Nobody's nobody's denying that it is a it is a common occurrence for 30-06s to go through and through.
00:35:44 It's just not guaranteed. And there's plenty of examples in history. 0.95
00:35:48 I mean, the most obvious being Martin Luther King, who had a 30-06 bullet.
00:35:53 The 30-06 bullet that killed Martin Luther King was found inside his body, not through and through.
00:35:57 Yeah, and his shoulder, if I believe correctly, kind of went through the jaw and down and just, I mean, obviously, you know, another horrific case.
00:36:05 But again, something we can point to and say it's, you know, that's why they're called odds, ladies and gentlemen.
00:36:10 That's why these things are not certainties, because you never really know what's going to happen when you pull the trigger.
00:36:16 And by the way, that is why there's this aggravated circumstance that when you're pulling the trigger and there is a crowd of people in front of you, including children, minor children, that and if you even if you're only targeting one person, that, yes, you actually are held to a higher standard because you have put all their lives at great risk.
00:36:36 yeah i think that's an that's an excellent point and uh i mean i think the prosecution's
00:36:44 going to end up talking about the propensity for 30-06s to go through and through more and more 1.00
00:36:47 as that i bet we'll see a bunch of that at trial uh you know when they have i bet they're going to
00:36:52 have a ballistics expert and it's going to be the prosecution's ballistics expert who's going to
00:36:56 talk about the propensity for 30-06s to go through and through yes and in addition will the one thing
00:37:02 the prosecution has already stated, and I know for a fact just having been there, and anyone who's
00:37:07 watched it would see this as well, that they were pointing out that that tent, the sort of tent that
00:37:13 Charlie was sitting in front of is, again, that's just canvas. That's not something that's going to
00:37:17 provide any deflective or cover for anyone behind it, meaning had there been a through and through
00:37:25 or had there been a miss of any calculation, anyone standing behind Charlie, walking behind
00:37:32 Charlie, whether it was, you know, a student or a staffer or a teacher or the Pope or whoever,
00:37:38 right, could have been struck and killed because of this propensity. And of course, the shooter
00:37:43 on that roof did not care in the slightest because of his choice and his anger, which in my mind is
00:37:52 clearly politically motivated because of the etchings that we can see on the bullets that he
00:37:57 made that it was politically motivated. Again, Bella Chow, the Antiva Anthem, Hey Fascist Catch,
00:38:05 Notices Bulge, What's This? All of these, again, political, trans, anti-fascist slogans.
00:38:11 We're on with Will Chamberlain. We're going to be right back here at Human Events Daily,
00:38:14 Real Markers Voice.
00:38:27 so we're going to call this the jack posobic appreciation hour i can say confidently i
00:38:36 believe i think josh shapiro would be the vice presidential nominee if it wasn't for jack
00:38:40 and that that is i'll be honest all right folks jack so we are back live here human events daily
00:38:51 real america's voice we're on will chamberlain of the article three project and we're talking
00:38:55 about the new filing, latest filing in the Tyler Robinson case. This is a briefing, of course. So
00:39:02 Will, walk us through, you know, sort of a little bit of just kind of zoom out, you know, where are
00:39:07 we at this point in the case? Why is this briefing being made? What are the steps after this?
00:39:14 So, I mean, we're at a very early stage in the case, right? And if we were in federal court,
00:39:18 we would not even be at the moment when the defendant is indicted, right? And sort of like
00:39:25 a trial schedule, the whole schedule for trial is set. Like, we're still before that point
00:39:29 where you actually make a decision about whether there's even going to be a trial,
00:39:33 whether there's even going to be any further process. So this is very, very
00:39:37 early, which is interesting because we had this, you know, such a wholesome presentation
00:39:41 of the evidence a few weeks ago. But people have to remember, like, this is, we're at
00:39:45 an extremely early stage here. And as a result, like,
00:39:49 I think that's partially why I think the Tyler Robinson defense is
00:39:53 really not trying very much uh they know that you know under the standard of evidence that applies
00:39:58 right now they're just there's just not a lot of viable things they could even theoretically say
00:40:02 uh and so as we discussed earlier they're focusing on like what they think is their best place to
00:40:08 land any kind of punch which is on these aggravating circumstances okay and so so we
00:40:12 should expect more direct attacks on trying to undermine the evidence in in future uh either
00:40:18 filings or, of course, the trial itself.
00:40:23 Yeah, that's right.
00:40:24 Because, I mean, at that point, they might try and make arguments about reasonable doubt.
00:40:27 You know, they might try and cast reasonable doubt on whether or not the person who actually
00:40:31 took the shot was Tyler Robinson.
00:40:32 They might try and cast reasonable doubt on all these other things.
00:40:35 But at this point, the idea that there's not probable cause for the question of whether
00:40:40 this was Tyler Robinson, I mean, that's just a frivolous argument and would undermine their
00:40:45 credibility with the judge.
00:40:46 Right.
00:40:46 So not doing that.
00:40:47 And this is something for folks to remember.
00:40:49 So just zooming all the way out, this is the judge deciding whether or not this will go to trial.
00:40:58 And it's similar to the function that people might think of a grand jury.
00:41:02 However, the biggest difference being that a grand jury is, in fact, behind closed doors,
00:41:07 that that information is typically kept sealed.
00:41:11 That is something, obviously, that was famously broken,
00:41:17 that seal was broken during the Jeffrey Epstein case,
00:41:21 and a lot of the grand jury information came out.
00:41:23 That's something that's not usually done.
00:41:25 But just to kind of point to how that usually goes,
00:41:28 and it required an act of Congress to get that to be on and signed by the president,
00:41:32 which he did sign, by the way.
00:41:33 And the point being is that I actually appreciate that Utah has done this
00:41:39 and chose to do it in such a way where it is public,
00:41:42 where we can see all of this in public,
00:41:44 where the defense, of course, has a chance to respond
00:41:46 as everyone should under our system.
00:41:50 And we're going through their response right now
00:41:52 and we're determining as citizens of our country
00:41:55 and obviously as people who knew Charlie
00:41:57 and cared about him very much,
00:41:59 that we can see and weigh for ourselves
00:42:02 what is going on in the system.
00:42:04 That's actually how I think the justice system should work.
00:42:06 Yeah, I mean, I think it's uniquely helpful at this moment, right?
00:42:11 In this particular case where you had this specific murder leading to a whole host of conspiracy theories,
00:42:18 in a different circumstance, we would have to wait for a trial to see all the evidence.
00:42:23 Like, if it was just a grand jury indicting it, we wouldn't be seeing any of this.
00:42:26 We wouldn't see what was in the state's possession.
00:42:29 Maybe in some motions, they'd hint at it.
00:42:31 But we wouldn't have had nearly as fulsome a presentation of the evidence as we did at the preliminary hearing.
00:42:36 So, yeah, I think we're the beneficiaries of Utah's process here.
00:42:40 Yeah, no, no, certainly I would, I would, I'm not going to, I'm not going to go so far as to say that I, I like the, the length of time that it's taken.
00:42:49 So two days ago, was it Monday, would have been the 11 month anniversary.
00:42:54 And then we're rapidly approaching the one year anniversary.
00:42:58 I'm, you know, I actually, I asked, I asked some, some lawyers, you know, who are more familiar with the Utah system.
00:43:04 I said, is this, you know, is this because it's a capital case?
00:43:08 And the response I heard back was that, no, this is just how Utah does things.
00:43:14 I lost you there for a second.
00:43:15 I apologize.
00:43:15 I didn't hear that last bit.
00:43:17 Oh, I said I heard that.
00:43:18 I was told by some folks who were familiar with Utah that this really is their system.
00:43:23 It's just very, it's very routine.
00:43:26 Very, this is very routine?
00:43:28 Yes.
00:43:30 Yeah, well, I mean, that's, I mean, that's good, I guess.
00:43:33 good for Utah. In some sense, I'm kind of surprised by it, and I'm surprised that defendants tolerate
00:43:40 it, because it does mean that all the evidence of them, it becomes public before a jury is even
00:43:45 selected and to be screened. So I find that to be kind of interesting. Although, I mean, I guess
00:43:51 maybe the point here is that, you know, I was wondering for a long time why did the defendants
00:43:56 not waive the preliminary hearing? And I guess they were hoping, perhaps they were thinking that
00:43:59 they were going to challenge the death penalty issues right away and try and knock them out
00:44:03 early. And that would actually make some sense. No, it may. No, no, we'll, you know, and I know
00:44:08 this is, you know, asking for your opinion and, you know, put it that way. But, you know, at what
00:44:13 point, you know, so if the judge, you know, let's let's say that the judge comes out September 1st
00:44:19 or whenever the ruling comes down next couple of weeks says, all right, they've they've proven the
00:44:24 bar, make the ruling. This is going to trial. At what point would would would we potentially
00:44:30 expect to see perhaps some proffers of a plea deal from the defense team when when would that
00:44:36 usually start uh see what from the defense team say that one more time a plea deal potentially
00:44:42 a what uh offering uh some kind of plea deal i'm sorry i just can't i'm uh my audio is killing me
00:44:52 now i i'm like you know like i keep missing that little key bit of what you're saying oh like a
00:44:56 like a deal to plead guilty in exchange for an offer to plead.
00:45:01 Okay. Well, so there'll be an allocution at some point after the,
00:45:04 after the indictment or right after the,
00:45:06 the charges are held over and then you'll,
00:45:10 you will get a not guilty plea at that point. And I mean, then, you know,
00:45:15 obviously there's a question of whether or not the prosecutors might offer
00:45:17 Robinson some sort of plea deal. I very strongly doubt it. You know,
00:45:23 the the real i i just unless they're they get some sense that maybe maybe the judge will issue
00:45:28 a ruling that he's not certain about the aggravating factors and that might lead to a
00:45:32 world where you get some sort of plea possibly but uh my my suspicion is that there's no real
00:45:39 plea that robinson's lawyers could sign off on that would make sense here um so i mean i think
00:45:46 this is on the trial well and that's you know if that is the case and i'm you know i'm thinking now
00:45:51 of Brian Koberger up in Idaho, you know, would there be perhaps a scenario wherein Tyler Robinson's
00:45:58 team offers to plead guilty in exchange for taking the death penalty off the table?
00:46:05 Yeah, I mean, I'm sure they'll make that offer. I just don't think that the prosecutors will take
00:46:08 them up on it. And the reason is there's just so much more evidence against Tyler Robinson than
00:46:14 there was against Koberger, right? The Koberger prosecution was really reliant on, I mean,
00:46:19 There's no eyewitnesses seeing him.
00:46:22 They're really relying on just a very small amount of DNA evidence and cell phone location evidence.
00:46:28 As compared to here, where everything was written on videotape, you have Robinson on the scene multiple times on video,
00:46:35 his car on the scene, his gun, all the DNA on the gun, the screwdriver on the roof.
00:46:41 So I think that Robinson's going to want to make that offer, and his lawyers are going to suggest it,
00:46:46 but I don't think the prosecutors are going to take them up
00:46:48 because I think they're not nearly as worried about losing a trial.
00:46:52 Well, and I think that's what my view is here as well.
00:46:57 Will Chamberlain, thank you so much.
00:46:58 As always, appreciate you calling in while you're running between different things.
00:47:03 Where can people follow you?
00:47:05 You can follow me at Will Chamberlain on X,
00:47:07 and you can follow what the Article 3 Project is doing at A3Baction.com.
00:47:10 All right, folks, go ahead and give Will a follow.
00:47:12 He's the best on this.
00:47:13 you know it's been 11 months next month it's going to be one year and
00:47:22 I'm one of those guys where I say we have to trust the process we have to trust the process
00:47:28 I was in the military you know sometimes there's big processes that take way longer than I think
00:47:35 they should and you you think you're immune to it you think that you're you know you have that
00:47:42 you have to have that discipline to say again i trust the process and everything's going to turn
00:47:48 out okay but you know nothing's going to make this okay you know even as we go through this every day
00:47:58 that there's a new hearing or some new evidence or there's a new briefing
00:48:03 nothing's ever going to make it okay i think it's ever going to make it better
00:48:06 but there's certain things that have to happen in response when something like that takes place
00:48:13 the iron law of exact reciprocity and reciprocity is coming mark my words
00:48:23 ladies and gentlemen as always you have my permission to lay short
00:48:36 You