On September 10th, 2025, 22-year-old Tyler Robinson was shot and killed on the campus of Utah Valley University. To add to the already tragic situation, CCTV footage showed Robinson, then unknown to the authorities, fleeing the scene and successfully evading capture.
00:06:07.400And I suppose in a way, this is one of the, one of the ways that I deal with things like this is I get to the bottom of it.
00:06:17.880I want to unpack every single piece of it that I can.
00:06:21.840I want to dig in through every shadow, open every closed door, look under every rock to try to understand, not just from the security perspective, the security failures, and the campus and all the rest of it, but even the individuals and even the psychological situations.
00:06:49.320And potentially, maybe then we can even learn, how do we stop the next person who wants to be a Tyler Robinson or a Thomas Matthew Crooks or a Luigi Mangione?
00:07:02.360So, you know, I don't usually talk about it, but that's why I do what I do.
00:07:08.020Because if we don't stop them, they will not stop on their own.
00:07:12.760Right back, Jack Posobiec, Human Events Daily.
00:07:42.200And just to let you guys know, the Wellness Company has one big annual sale.
00:07:46.600This is just in time to fulfill your New Year's resolutions and your loved ones, your family, your friends,
00:07:52.260whether you need a kickstart to your weight loss goals or want to stock up on innovative nutraceutical blends that help you stay in optimal health,
00:07:59.340the Wellness Company has everything to keep you out of urgent care and feeling limitless as 2026 approaches.
00:08:05.900The Black Friday deals run from November 27th to November 30th.
00:08:10.940Save 25% off of all supplements like Recharge, prescription scripts like Ivermectin, and even peptide products like Smile.
00:08:19.760Save 20% off all emergency kits to stay fully prepped and 20% off One Wellness memberships to offset overpriced health insurance.
00:08:28.540All of the well care you need digitally ordered and delivered to your door.
00:08:33.220This is the best time of year to stock up on your favorite products and perfect the chance to grab some holiday gifts for family members and friends.
00:09:37.920So we're, and just like everyone else, we see these leaks, we see this, and I'm just going to call it as it seems like a toxic relationship, you know, and caveats, you know, that that we do believe these leaks are corroborated, that Turkey Tom has photos of the individuals together, of his source, et cetera.
00:09:57.940We do know that other photos from inside work were corroborated to be at the home that Lance Twiggs and Tyler Robinson were living at.
00:10:07.160And I guess, Dr. Chloe, let's imagine, you know, imagine these two were in front of you for some relationship therapy.
00:10:16.680What would your diagnosis be, just reading through some of this?
00:10:25.100If these two were in front of me for some kind of relationship therapy, I mean, I think one of the first things that I would just need to understand is what is their belief about the nature of their relationship.
00:10:39.360From what I understand, Lance Twiggs believed himself to be transitioning, you know, from a man into a woman.
00:10:48.440And, you know, apparently maybe Tyler Robinson might have been what we would call colluding, and we used to call it a folie a deux in psychology, when you have two people that are participating in the same delusion together.
00:11:05.680So I would be interested to understand some of the very basic underpinnings of how they viewed their relationship in the first place, because especially since it appears that Tyler, that shot was fired at the very first trans question that was posed to Charlie Kirk.
00:11:24.940So I think the question of understanding, you know, what exactly they believe themselves to be and what trans meant to them might be important.
00:12:13.140This is the desk that I'm sitting at right now.
00:12:15.200This is the microphone where he launched the Charlie Kirk show.
00:12:17.540I sat here in here with him so many times and he's he's not going to be coming back because of what happened.
00:12:26.020And the evidence points to individual as being the one on the roof who did this, who etched into the bullets the messages towards his his, you know, who he viewed as his oppressor.
00:12:38.860But a guy who's my friend and who was the husband of my friend, Erica, and the father to two small children.
00:12:46.560So I think it's incumbent on us and really as a country to understand why that happened and understand what drove them to this act.
00:12:54.240And I think when you and I were talking about this before, I remember you had said that it almost seemed like like Tyler may have been doing this as a form of acting out of romance romance or the idea that he was trying to protect twigs.
00:13:07.280I'm reading through some of these new leaks and I'm wondering, do you think there could be an angle where he was almost trying to impress twigs by doing this?
00:13:15.860Because we do see that the friend here in these leaks is saying that Tyler was not particularly, you know, sexually experienced.
00:13:24.260He was also not particularly politically experienced, but he knew that twigs was.
00:13:29.080So I wonder if this was a way for him in his perspective to try to think that he was impressing his his his his lover here.
00:13:36.180Yeah, absolutely, Jack. And I think I've heard you use the phrase white knighting before, which to describe this, which I think comes into play as well.
00:13:46.420You know, if if Tyler Robinson fancied himself, you know, as some kind of a hero here, because at this particular developmental age as well, these are very young men.
00:13:59.560They're they're in a way they're still kind of in a late form of adolescence.
00:14:04.560And that's a stage when they can really be craving and seeking social approval and social acceptance.
00:14:12.020They can be trying on a lot of different identities.
00:14:15.120And, you know, I think from things that both of them have expressed online, they may have even fallen prey to some of this extreme vilification of straight white men, especially, you know, conservative straight white men.
00:14:31.660And so trying to really differentiate themselves from that identity as they try to seek out their own adult identity.
00:14:41.540You know, it seems like there there could be a little bit of a goal there as far as, you know, becoming the white knight, but in a little bit of a twisted sense of what it means to be a white knight.
00:14:52.440And that's right. And so when you're when when they're attempting to be, you know, or, you know, if this is true, he's attempting to be this white knight.
00:15:01.340He's thinking, I want to impress my my lover.
00:15:06.220I want to, you know, gain status, gain standing in his eyes, because it does seem like he's been, you know, he's putting this relationship and putting this identity, as you say, ahead of, you know,
00:15:20.520Oh, my gosh, all things like basic human decency and morality, and you sort of your your normal social structures.
00:15:28.840And so one thing that I learned, I guess I would say, serving at Guantanamo Bay for a year that which I did, and working in the interrogation cell is that when you when you hear the radicals, when you hear them, they never think that they are radical, they think that they're completely rational and logical.
00:15:48.220And so it's unpacking that ideology, unpacking that form of thought that gets you to try to understand their motivations for why they did what they did.
00:15:58.080Yeah, exactly. And they certainly, I imagine, got a great deal of input to validate and in a certain way, you know, miseducate them about, you know, what, say, it means to be trans.
00:16:14.120I mean, from what I understand, they both were pretty heavily online, pretty heavily involved in Reddit and Discord.
00:16:21.720And in your recent piece for Human Events, and when you spoke with Megyn Kelly, I thought you explored really well the fact that they went to high school during COVID lockdowns.
00:16:32.120And the way you said it was that they couldn't step out into the world, the world was shut down.
00:16:37.940And so they stepped out into the world online.
00:16:41.140And we also know that that online world is extremely rife with pornography.
00:16:46.440And it does appear that their expression of their sexuality, you know, was in some way tainted by that.
00:16:55.200I mean, I just, I don't think young men naturally wake up saying, oh, I'll be trans or, oh, I'm into furries, right?
00:17:02.020They're obviously getting that somewhere online.
00:17:05.020And I also had shared with you a short while ago, an interesting piece from the Washington Examiner, and it was covered elsewhere, that there were basically some whistleblowers from, I think it was Pornhub or some other place, showing that they actively try to convert.
00:17:23.700They call it convert users of their porn site that maybe are initially just seeking, you know, heterosexual, what we might call vanilla porn, but getting them specifically into trans stuff because they're seeking an ever higher bar of stimulation and, you know, a feeling of taboo.
00:17:41.900And again, when you have these young men that are also at this developmental age seeking a form of identity, I think it could be, unfortunately, a perfect, terrible storm where their sense of identity can even become co-opted into this trans and into this furriness.
00:18:00.900And then it gets rolled up with this, you know, leftist hatred of straight white men in the church.
00:18:06.200I think Twigs had also been online maybe saying some things about leaving religion and Tyler Robinson.
00:18:13.700They were both former Mormons or had grown up Mormon and were leaving the LDS church.
00:18:20.300So that exactly lines up with what you're saying.
00:18:23.460And, in fact, I've spoken to some—I'm Catholic, but, you know, I have some Mormon friends, and I was asking them about this as well.
00:18:30.320And they said, you know, there's this—there are a lot of people in Utah that, you know, form this sort of former Mormon culture.
00:18:39.320And for some people, when they leave the church, what they do is they run in the opposite direction to whatever the furthest thing away from, you know, mom and dad and the way that we were raised is.
00:18:53.440And in this case, yeah, being a member of a, you know, quasi-Antifa trans furry cell using drugs and black market hormones is probably just as far as you can get from a conservative Mormon background.
00:19:06.840Jack Posobiec, Dr. Chloe Carmichael will be right back on Events Daily.
00:19:10.900All right, Jack Posobiec, we're back live here, Human Events Daily.
00:19:23.900Folks, the Gmail breach exposed millions.
00:19:47.380Those leaked email Gmail logins came from criminals compiling people's personal info from data brokers, public search sites, and people databases.
00:19:56.600Right now, your address, phone number, workplace, and even family members are sitting on the open web.
00:20:01.180This is fuel for scammers, hackers, and anyone who wants to target you.
00:20:05.260The Patriot Protect fixes the problem at its root.
00:20:07.940The Gmail leak has much more serious implications.
00:20:13.300Patriot Protect removes that exposure.
00:20:15.140We scrub your personal information from Google search results, 100-plus data brokers, people search sites, hidden databases that feed scammers.
00:20:22.800We automatically, they automatically remove any personal information of yours that gets populated on these sites, the 24-7 protection.
00:20:30.260To lock in your protection for 50% off, we're running a limited time sale through Cyber Monday.
00:20:36.020Go to Patriot-Protect.com and use promo code BF50 for 50% off your protection plan.
00:20:43.580Investigators noted inscriptions that had been engraved on casings, hey, fascist, exclamation point, catch, exclamation point.
00:20:57.740Dr. Chloe, I've, you know, and I'm kind of using my sort of armchair analysis here.
00:21:03.840I'm not an expert like you on some of this, but the disassociation that I see here with Crooks, with Mangione, with Robinson, Twiggs as well, there does seem to be a common thread.
00:21:17.380These are young white men in the 20 to 27 age range.
00:21:22.680They all went through the COVID experience.
00:21:25.020I went to the White House and mentioned this, and people could see that roundtable on left-wing violence.
00:21:31.800And I mentioned it to President Trump himself and said that I'm seeing an interesting profile here of these types of shooters.
00:21:40.440And I don't think we should overlook those commonalities.
00:21:43.700Yeah, I think that you are raising a really good point there.
00:21:47.820So when you talk about dissociation, you know, I also think, for example, as you mentioned of drug use, I think Twiggs has acknowledged online that he used a lot of marijuana as a young person, right?
00:22:02.560And then also the Journal of American Psychiatry acknowledged recently that even just the medium regular dose of ADHD medication is linked to a three-times, three-fold increased likelihood towards issues with psychoticism, which is, of course, a break from reality.
00:22:23.560And then when we have people being steered into this extreme online virtual world, that actually kind of requires a form of dissociation as well when you're disconnecting with the world around you and stepping into this virtual world.
00:22:40.680So I think that you're raising a really good point that all of these young men during COVID were kind of pushed into their bedrooms, pushed into the world of computers, possibly using a lot of marijuana, possibly also on other medications that may have been good for them and maybe not.
00:23:02.520And, you know, I also wonder what's going on with these, in some cases, the parenting.
00:23:08.240I mean, how is Lance, as he discussed online, using not only extremely heavy marijuana use, but he also discussed, you know, drinking large amounts of vodka and things like that.
00:23:19.540I'm wondering where the parents are in all of this as well.
00:23:22.760And so if these young men are not getting grounded in real life through, you know, church, family, being out with friends, they are, as you said, dissociating.
00:23:32.520And when we look at, say, the icons on things like Reddit or Discord, the icons, the logos of those sites, they look like a human that's half robot, right?
00:23:46.960It's inviting this, you know, not the icon in and of itself, but the whole thing, you know, and combined with the excess of porn use.
00:23:55.460I do think that dissociation is a good word for that, to describe what all that adds up to.
00:24:04.380We know that Crooks, Thomas Matthew Crooks, President Trump's would-be assassin from Butler, Pennsylvania.
00:24:09.720One of the last things that he did before he went up on that roof in Butler was search pornography.
00:24:16.080Then we go and we look at Tyler Robinson and they tell us that his social media footprint, his internet footprint includes very strange pornographic searches where he's involved in websites where they're digging into furry porn and stuff that even includes young anthropomorphized children that are involved in these sexual acts.
00:24:59.320I think it starts more vanilla, but they get to a point where they're totally wrapped around the axle because they're completely dissociated with reality.
00:25:07.040And yet we're also told that Twigs' grandfather was the one who actually owned the home where all of this was going on.
00:25:13.200Yeah, you know, that's a good point, too.
00:25:16.540I mean, apparently their parents were in some level financially enabling, you know, this type of lifestyle that they were living, which is a whole other question as well.
00:25:27.280But, you know, as well to your point about Lance Twigs and some of the materials that you sent me here, I noticed that on his TikTok account, on one of his TikTok accounts, the icon, the facial image that was posted there was actually just what appears to be some kind of a furry hat or furry face mask.
00:25:48.780And it was shared, apparently, with a user called Youngest Kami, and, you know, to your point about the youth, and then this looping in of Marxism, which, of course, wants to strip away and break down the family and to strip away and break down religion.
00:26:07.860And so when we stop looking basically upward to think of our identity and we look excessively inward or excessively into the screen of a computer where there's nothing in many ways except this extreme, ironically, capitalist, right, where they're oftentimes so hung up on Marxism.
00:26:28.500But it's this extreme capitalist culture, actually, with, you know, whether it be Pornhub or these other places that are just trying to stir them deeper and deeper into, you know, really extreme pornography, which can dissociate them from just their normal sense of identity and values, again, especially when they're at this really sensitive developmental age.
00:26:52.880So then they're getting flooded with dopamine because they're, you know, using excessive porn, which then is followed by a feeling of emptiness, that they only feel that they can...
00:27:04.120And they're telling themselves that this is the way to get more.
00:27:08.240Quick break. Hold it right there because we can't skip this. We'll be right back. Human Defense Daily.
00:27:17.040There's some published reports out there that this individual, the roommate, may have been transitioned.
00:27:34.120All right, Jack Wasubic, we're back. Human Events Daily.
00:27:37.180We're talking about the psychology of Tyler Robinson and Lance Twiggs.
00:27:41.620I want to toss it back to Dr. Chloe Carmichael.
00:27:43.440She got cut off in the last segment because we are talking about this situation where they...
00:27:49.120You're talking about these young men who are living in, I think, very cases, many cases, depraved states and a very, you know, these are these downward spirals.
00:27:59.940And yet they still keep choosing to continue on this path rather than simply walk away and, you know, think to themselves, I don't need to do this.
00:28:11.420I could, I can walk away and I can go back home and I can go somewhere else.
00:28:15.220And yet they never seem to do it, do they?
00:28:17.880Well, no, but I mean, that's because I think of all of these forces to demonize and confuse them about what it would mean to walk away.
00:28:26.780Like, walk away towards what Charlie Kirk was offering, you know, of a healthy sense of manhood and community.
00:28:35.480You know, Tyler Robinson had been tricked into thinking that Charlie Kirk himself, you know, represented evil and hatred.
00:28:44.280I mean, can you imagine, of course, the irony of saying, well, I have to get rid of all that hatred and so therefore I'm going to, you know, assassinate him.
00:28:52.380But even from a very young age, you know, there's a very haunting photo of Tyler Robinson when he was maybe 13 and he's, you know, absorbed at his computer gaming.
00:29:03.220And his mom, I think, had posted the picture herself with something like, ha ha, now he can, you know, totally ignore us.
00:29:09.520And we know with those online games, they are, they're rife with predators.
00:29:13.660I saw something recently on Sean Ryan's show about Roblox actually has child-facing materials there where kids can relive the simulation of shooting Charlie Kirk or of being in that audience.
00:29:29.560And so, you know, young men are seeking a place where they can feel strong and useful and competent.
00:29:35.800And I think that these online worlds, whether it be through gaming or through pornography or some of these really warped places on Reddit or Discord, are hijacking that sense of manhood and pointing it towards something really awful and perverse.
00:29:53.000So they don't realize they need to walk away because they think that they're developing into a hero.
00:29:57.940They're developing into a hero or perhaps even a type of hero known as a white knight.
00:30:05.400You just mentioned they want to feel strong and useful.
00:30:12.460Why is it that young men don't feel useful in today's society?
00:30:17.440Exactly, because everything that would normally guide them to feel useful, like say to be providers, protectors, you know, leaders within their church and their community, it's all been branded as toxic masculinity to them, especially if God forbid that they should be a straight white male.
00:30:38.660And so, ironically, that desire to be useful and strong and helpful in society, they've been programmed to think the way to do that is actually to tear down society and to separate from, you know, even the fact of their masculinity.
00:30:55.200I think that's why they may be so vulnerable to some of this, you know, trans stuff.
00:31:02.000What better way to step away from what they've been seen as this, oh, I'm just a terrible, toxic, straight white male.
00:31:10.540Oh, even better, I'll be furry or, you know, date people within that space.
00:31:16.000I think it's a disavowal and, as you said, a dissociation from who they are because society in many ways has vilified them.
00:31:24.860And this is a key element here because they're feeling vilified.
00:31:31.120So that's what creates the dissociation in the first place, that they then go and find new outlets, drugs, video games, online pornography, all of these other things.
00:31:42.760Because, and not to mention all of the economic effects as well that I think we, you know, we talk about a lot here on the program in general when it comes to Gen Z and how if you have this sense that the real world has nothing for you, that the real world is against you, that the real world is hostile to you, then perhaps you return back with the sense of being hostile to the world itself.
00:32:07.920And something else that you picked up or that you've mentioned that I wanted to go back to in, and you wrote an entire book about this and it's the question of free speech.
00:32:19.120And so Charlie, of course, was a champion of free speech.
00:32:23.760He was participating in free speech when, uh, when he was shot and killed.
00:32:29.060And in fact, the title of it was his debate me series.
00:32:33.100And you wrote a book, Can I Say That, Why Free Speech Matters and How to Use It Fearlessly.
00:32:40.020So Charlie's perspective was, if you disagree with me, come to the front and let's have a conversation.
00:32:46.640Tyler Robinson, we're told in one of these conversations with his parents before they turned him in and identified him and all this happened, that I have to stop his hate.
00:32:57.460Now, as far as I know, Charlie wasn't ever violent to anyone.
00:33:01.720He never physically attacked anyone, but he did or, or, or did anything, uh, you know, in, in, in any capacity, breaking the law, something like that.
00:33:11.220Why is it that these people view speech itself as a form of an attack on them physically?
00:33:18.800Well, I, I think in part because they've been, you know, programmed to, to feel that way.
00:33:25.660You know, I, I honestly think a lot of this traces back to Marxism and things that they're learning in schools, uh, unfortunately.
00:33:32.820But it really is a very strong thread within the trans movement specifically, that if you should, you know, say to a, uh, uh, quote, trans man, you know, you're actually a woman or, you know, use, use biologically accurate pronouns.
00:33:49.040Um, they'll say you are threatening my existence.
00:33:52.460Um, and I, I think, again, it, there's this issue of dissociation and ironically, as a clinical psychologist, if I'm working with somebody say that, you know, comes into my office and says, Hey, I am seeing, seeing little green men.
00:34:07.420I would not immediately confront them and say, no, you're not.
00:34:18.100I would be trying to explore and understand, you know, what that delusion, what that psychotic delusion, um, you know, represents to the person because everybody knows, psychologists know that if you just come in and you hit them over the head, you know, by telling them that their delusion is false, they will shut down completely and, you know, really act out and act up, um, very much like a, like a trans person who says, you know,
00:34:46.320you're threatening my existence because they've hinged to their existence on something that is untrue.
00:34:52.960Um, so of course it creates a lot of instability.
00:34:56.220That was ironically, the question that was posed to Charlie Kirk is how many mass shooters are trans.
00:35:03.260And ironically, he was shot at that moment, um, you know, presumably by Tyler Robinson, presumably, allegedly, in part, maybe because of his relationship with Lance Twiggs about being trans.
00:35:18.160So he's, he's, he's in this conversation, he's in this relationship, he's viewing his identity, his viewing his, as being wrapped up in this, which is beyond anything that, that the real world offers himself.
00:35:34.900And he, and he just seems totally lost in this, it seems like he was totally lost in this identity to the point where I, I, I suppose I should say he did understand that there would be consequences because we do see these messages.
00:35:48.840We see these, uh, this, this sense with his parents, when his parents do confront him, you know, he, he's trying to get the rifle and bring it back.
00:36:00.680So, you know, is there a sense then, I suppose, that he's almost living like a double life where he's one person with his parents, but he's another person with Twiggs?
00:36:09.720Yeah, I would say it, it certainly does seem that way, you know, kind of a, a bifurcated identity, which again, can be very isolating, um, that, that causes depression.
00:36:21.000It's actually one of the first things an abuser wants to do to a victim is to isolate them and make them feel as if, you know, their, their friends and family don't understand them.
00:36:31.860And I think that's exactly what happens when people go down this awful, you know, trans, furry porn rabbit hole online, where they just get deeper and deeper into this world that really does make no sense, that really is disconnected from reality.
00:36:47.860And then of course, um, you know, the, the dark forces there tend to vilify the person's actual family and say, oh, well, you know, you, you should probably go no contact with them or, oh, you know, they're threatening your existence because, you know, to your point about my book about free speech and the importance of speaking accurately, language is one of our most profound tools as humans.
00:37:11.460It's, um, it's, um, we, we, we, we actually, psychologists sometimes refer to words, um, as objects that are, that are representing prototypes.
00:37:19.640So it's, it's really part of the glue that allows us to communicate together about reality.
00:37:25.840And so when people start, you know, tinkering with that by saying like, oh, well, it's a trans man or, oh, you know, this is a furry.
00:37:34.020Um, and then when other people push back on that language, because it is important to be grounded in reality and to be communicating accurately, um, they, they can start to unravel and become very hostile.
00:37:47.700Jack Posobiec, Dr. Chloe Carmichael, the toxic psychology of Tyler Robinson, be right back here, human events daily in today's special.
00:38:07.660I am filing a notice of intent to seek the death penalty.
00:38:11.540I do not take this decision lightly, and it is a decision I have made independently as county attorney based solely on the available evidence and circumstances and nature of the crime.
00:38:29.640Final segment here with Dr. Chloe Carmichael.
00:38:32.640Dr. Chloe, I know that you've commented on criminal cases before, and look, we're not just speculating on this.
00:38:39.040I, I do believe that, that a lot of this relationship and a lot of the psychology here is going to come up in either in the conviction phase of the trial or in the sentencing phase, because we know that the state of Utah is seeking the death penalty.
00:38:54.580Uh, there have been many cases where the death penalty has been taken off because of psychological issues.
00:39:00.280And it just seems to me that this is certainly going to be one of the big points of contention for the defense team, for Tyler Robinson, that so if he is convicted, convicted on the basis of the fingerprint evidence, of the DNA evidence tying him to the gun, the statements to the parents, the statements to friends, let's say for sake of argument that he is convicted.
00:39:21.960Do you think this will play a role in the death penalty phase?
00:39:25.280Well, I certainly imagine that the defense would attempt to trot that out, but I don't think that they would be successful because the, the behavior of Tyler Robinson following this event clearly shows that he was completely aware of the difference between right and wrong.
00:39:45.580He didn't show up, for example, he didn't show up, for example, he didn't show up, for example, on site and say, hey, everybody, I'm going to do everybody a great favor and shoot Charlie Kirk fully believing that, you know, society would celebrate him.
00:39:55.040That, that would be a suggestion that he was, um, you know, unaware of the difference of right and wrong.
00:40:00.260Other reasons why people might use, you know, a psychological defect as a way to avoid accountability might be, for example, um, a very low IQ or lack of intelligence.
00:40:10.300Um, I don't think that Tyler could plead that either, you know, my understanding is that, um, he was actually very intelligent.
00:40:17.520What he did have, I would say, is an extreme sense of grandiosity, which is, you know, quite common again in young men, which is why it's so tragic that, um, he wasn't, um, I guess, able or willing to just, you know, be around strong men like you, Jack.
00:40:33.900You know, people like Charlie Kirk, ironically, you know, that, that could lead him and shape him and sometimes check him, um, and, and teach him to use his, his, his desire to be a man and to, to stand up for what he believed was right, um, in, in a more cogent and productive way.
00:40:50.500Um, so a person can absolutely be mentally ill, but that doesn't necessarily mean that it's going to feed to an insanity plea because I don't think that there's a lack of competency that his mental illness, if it exists, could be used to, um, to, to suggest.
00:41:06.440Right. So what you're, and, and I want to, I want to break this down because I'm, I know for a fact, uh, almost that, uh, you know, that, um, you know, this is certainly going to be the way that they try to, uh, you know, go for life in prison or, uh, potentially there's been some talk about, you know, not, not officially, but I've had, you know, a lot of commentators saying, well, what if there's going to be a plea deal to take the death penalty off the case?
00:41:34.860Like we saw in the Brian Koberger case up in Idaho and other kids, uh, situation where it looked like a conviction was going to be likely, then what you're saying though, because of his lack of, or I should say, no, because of his direct knowledge of what he was doing, because of his understanding of right and wrong, because we, you know, take all of the, you know, the psychology of, okay.
00:42:02.640Why was he involved in this stuff? Why was he looking at this stuff online? He still understood what he was doing. He understood what he was doing and he made a direct decision to, and, and by the way, he created this plan. He was hiding the gun under his, you know, under his, um, his clothing. This was no active passion is what I'm trying to say. There's a lot.
00:42:21.640It was premeditated. There's pre it's premed, extremely premeditated to the point where, and I, I, I suspect that there's going to be information coming out that this wasn't the first time that he had traveled to this campus, a campus that's hours and hours away from where he lived.
00:42:37.640This was not the same part of Utah where he and twigs lived. I think it was a three hour drive each time that he visited. So it's something that, and they say, when you commit murder, uh, in a premeditated sense, you never commit the murder once that you commit it over and over and over in your mind before you make that final act. And that's clearly what he did here.
00:42:58.520Yeah. In fact, I think some of the text messages, um, if they're accurate, in fact, he, he says that he's been planning this, you know, for about a week. Um, so, uh, it's, it's not as if it were impulsive or an act of passion. It's not as if he lacks intelligence and it's not as if he doesn't have the capacity, um, to understand right and wrong. So I, I, again, with the Brian Kohlberger case, I think there were some other issues, um, where I, I, I think even his confession itself might
00:43:28.440have been part of a plea deal. Um, but my understanding is that, um, Tyler Robinson, I, I don't know, has he actually even acknowledged already, um, you know, that he did this? I, I'm not sure. Do you, do you know if he has?
00:43:40.780Well, no, I don't, I don't believe he has in court, but what we do know is that he's, he's obviously there's the text messages. There's the discord chat where he comes into and says, Hey guys, I just wanted to let you know that was me yesterday.
00:43:54.360And then we're also told that when his parents confronted him, he implied to them that it was in fact him and, and really his parents figured it out. I mean, they, you know, they saw the gun. It was a, um, it was a unique recognizable rifle to them. And then of course the fact that, and, and this is what I keep coming back to, which is even beyond all of the, now, of course, they'll have to prove in court that, you know, the evidence, the DNA, et cetera.
00:44:19.200But the fact that it was his parents that made the idea and not law enforcement, I think that makes a very strong case because what parent is not going to identify their own child.
00:44:28.420Yeah, exactly. And my goodness, we haven't even gotten into talking about say Lance Twiggs is, um, allegedly what his mother was allegedly doing as well with some of the Venmo payments. Maybe we'll save that for another day.
00:44:40.360Um, but no, I, I, I definitely don't see, um, Tyler Robinson being able to successfully plead, um, you know, to insanity because usually, um, I, I think that that type of a plea deal would be offered if the prosecution, you know, needed to get it.
00:44:58.380Or if he actually had a legitimate case, uh, to plead insanity as the reason why he would have done this.
00:45:05.760And I don't see either one of those, uh, being plausible here. My, my hope and prayer, um, is that he, he has to take full accountability for what he did.
00:45:15.280I think that would be, um, actually really good for society as well. I think our society is organized better when people have a sense of accountability.
00:45:24.520So, um, you know, I, I, I love Erica Kirk for forgiving him, but I also don't think that necessarily meant that she, you know, was, um, arguing against the death penalty for him either.
00:45:38.300Yeah. And, and Erica has, um, mentioned this a few times publicly, um, interviews with, uh, Fox News and the New York Times when asked about it that, you know, uh, she, I believe the line she used is that I don't want his blood on my hands.
00:45:54.520And totally understandable because as a Christian, she wants to go to heaven and see Charlie again.
00:46:00.160And, you know, at the same time, I, I, I come from the same perspective as you where it's, it's about correction for society.
00:46:10.100And by the way, Charlie himself was in general, a supporter of the death penalty on the very same grounds.
00:46:15.460He points out that the Bible, um, mandates it early on in even all the way back to the Torah and that Charlie pointed out that it is the proper corrective for society.
00:47:09.420Um, and, but I, I do think that there is again, a value in that, you know, for, for the fact of deterrence and, you know, for the fact of ownership of justice, that it shouldn't be something, you know, that has to be done, you know, in, in private.
00:47:24.440Um, I also, frankly, don't think it should necessarily have to be something that happens with, you know, some kind of a, you know, painless euthanasia procedure either.
00:47:34.300I mean, I, I, I think that there is value in the, in the element of.
00:47:39.080Charlie, Charlie talked about this and we did a show together and people have clipped it up, but he talked about this the exact same way you are.
00:47:46.160Dr. Chloe Carmichael, where can people go to follow you and get the book?
00:47:53.900Um, I'd love to, uh, connect with people there for my book, for my social media, and for little groups about the importance of free speech.
00:48:01.720Ladies and gentlemen, as always, you have my permission to lay ashore.