John Bolton - May 01, 2025


Alberta - months from INDEPENDENCE - Canada - months from the END

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Danielle Smith fires a SIGNATURE warning shot - and majority incoming? Jason Kenney is WRONG about Alberta Independence - Let me count the ways

Episode Stats


Length

21 minutes

Words per minute

187.12

Word count

3,945

Sentence count

287

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

James Albers, a Wildrose Party of Alberta member for many years, joins me to talk about the aftermath of the election and what it means for the future of the independence movement in Alberta and the rest of Canada.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Well, I think Albertans are hurt and betrayed. That's how I think Albertans are feeling.
00:00:04 I think Canada as a whole got a sense of that feeling of hurt and betrayal with the way the
00:00:09 Americans are treating us right now. But we're being treated, we've been treated that way for 0.63
00:00:14 the last 10 years. Treated like our interests don't matter. Treated like our economic imperatives
00:00:20 aren't important. Treated like we should be just shut up and just be satisfied with whatever the
00:00:26 central government decides to do, regardless of whether it's constitutional or not.
00:00:30 Hi, it's John and welcome to the channel. Great to have you along. I've got a different set. I've
00:00:34 moved over here in the basement. I do have my big blue mug of coffee, but there's some water in there
00:00:38 right now. And it is three minutes after 7 p.m. the 30th of April. Great to have you along today.
00:00:46 And just a reminder, coming up on Saturday, there is an independence rally in Edmonton at the
00:00:51 legislature. I will be there. I'm going to emcee the event from 1 to 3 if you can be there.
00:00:57 Please show up. Show your support for independence here in Alberta. I'm driving all the way from
00:01:02 Calgary to be there. So certainly if you live in the Edmonton area, you can be there. Again,
00:01:07 1 to 3 on Saturday. Joining me today to talk a little bit about what's happened in the wake of
00:01:14 the election on Monday night and the re-election of the Liberal Party after 10 years of dysfunction
00:01:18 here in the country is James Albers, a Wildrose Independence Party of Alberta member for many,
00:01:25 many years. James, terrific to have you here. Thanks so much for being on with me tonight.
00:01:29 Thank you. It's a pleasure.
00:01:30 So right off the top, I showed that clip of Danielle Smith after the election. She says
00:01:35 that Albertans are hurt and betrayed. How do you feel after the election the other night, James?
00:01:40 Well, I think hurt and betrayed is a good description of it. We were looking at this as
00:01:46 the opportunity, certainly from our perspective anyway, in the independence movement to see the
00:01:52 conservatives come in and maybe, maybe just one last time, take a shot at rejigging confederation
00:01:59 so that it worked for everybody. So that was, I think there was a faint hope in our minds that
00:02:05 that might happen, but, um, the results kind of speak for themselves from, from my perspective.
00:02:09 Anyway, um, Albertans have been let down again. And, you know, when you look at the results on the
00:02:14 map, you know, that wall, uh, heading from, uh, the edge of Ontario all the way out West is, uh,
00:02:21 it's, it says a lot. And I think we need to, we need to just be realistic about our chances of ever
00:02:27 really having a, a seat at the table. Did you have mixed feelings like I did on Tuesday morning?
00:02:33 Because, you know, I remember prior to Trudeau, uh, resigning, uh, on January 6th, a lot of people
00:02:40 online saying they were hoping that he would resign. And I remember doing a video saying,
00:02:44 I don't want the guy to resign. I want him to stick around. Cause I want to punish the liberals.
00:02:47 I want to punish Justin Trudeau. They deserve to be punished being in Albert. And I thought that, 0.99
00:02:52 and then of course, uh, Mark Carney got in and I wanted to see Polly have win because I wanted to 1.00
00:02:58 see the liberals punished. But I woke up on Tuesday morning thinking, listen, the opportunity is even
00:03:02 better now for the independence movement. And did you feel the same way kind of mixed feelings
00:03:06 as I had? No, absolutely. And like I say, I think we were, we were quietly hoping that Polly would
00:03:12 get in, but we've always maintained that, um, Albertans would want to see one last kick of the
00:03:18 cap before making a decision to go on their own. And I think what we saw in the election on Monday
00:03:24 was exactly that. I think Albertans woke up on Tuesday and went, you know what? We can't do this
00:03:29 anymore. And, and for a lot of people, it was like, I've held my breath for 10 years. I've kept
00:03:34 my opinions to myself because the regime in Ottawa wasn't too, um, uh, tolerable with regard to any
00:03:41 kind of dissent, you know, those fringe minority people, that's how that goes. But, uh, I think, I think
00:03:46 Tuesday morning people got up and said, okay, enough, enough. Well, you're in Albertan, you're from
00:03:52 Edmonton originally. You've really only been part of the separation movement, as I understand, for
00:03:58 about the last 10 years since Trudeau got in. Is that correct? That's correct. Yes. So you, you can
00:04:03 think back to the days, probably, um, what, over 40 years now, the national energy program here in
00:04:09 Alberta. I moved out here 12, 13 years ago and people still talk about that. Oh, absolutely. You
00:04:15 know, and it's, it's funny because I served in the armed forces. I remember, I remember watching, uh,
00:04:20 the Canada Russia hockey series and being so proud to be a Canadian. I served in the armed forces. I
00:04:26 was, was proud to, to wear that maple leaf when I traveled through Europe. And then one morning I
00:04:31 woke up and I went, ah, you know what? The country that I loved is, has no, no, no, no longer any use
00:04:39 for me as an Albertan. Uh, and they've left us behind. And it really, uh, it was a real, uh, wake up
00:04:46 call for me after the Trudeau election. What really bothers you about what's been happening
00:04:51 to Alberta over the last 10 years? And again, maybe even going back four decades,
00:04:55 there's been this situation for 40 years or what's bugging you about this?
00:04:58 Well, I think what, what everybody's coming to realize, and for me in particular, is the fact
00:05:04 that we can bang on the door all we want. We're really not going to get in, uh, to any sort of
00:05:10 serious discussion with Ottawa with regard to having an impact that will allow each province,
00:05:15 quite frankly, to, to be an equal and, uh, and an equal partner in Confederation. It's just not
00:05:21 going to happen. And you know full well from your history that it was never designed to give the West 0.86
00:05:27 that kind of, uh, leeway. Uh, the West was always designed to be, uh, an area that fed the, uh, the
00:05:33 metropolis, which was Ottawa, you know, Toronto, Montreal. And that model has worked perfectly. And
00:05:40 I think people just have begun to wake up to the fact that that's not going to change.
00:05:46 The other day, or just yesterday, the threshold for a referendum was lowered. I mean, it's,
00:05:53 it's fascinating. This happened basically a day after or within 24 hours of the election,
00:05:58 but we went from having to get around 600,000 signatures in order to get a ballot for a referendum
00:06:05 here to dropping it down to 177,000 approximately and extending the period out, um, 220 days to get
00:06:12 these signatures. This must seem closer than ever for you. And you must be thinking the time is now
00:06:18 we've got to make this happen. Well, I think there's a recognition that the sentiment is much
00:06:23 deeper and stronger than it ever has been. And so I think that was a good move on her part.
00:06:27 And, you know, I have to say, uh, you know, I belong to a different political party, but we're
00:06:32 big enough to say that, you know, she's done the right thing. She has been, uh, representing our
00:06:37 province, I think, uh, extremely well. And, you know, I'm not afraid to say that, um, that's what
00:06:43 real political discourse should look like, right? When somebody is doing something right, you should
00:06:47 tell them that they're doing something right. And I think for her to, uh, to give the people, um,
00:06:52 uh, place to, uh, to put their voice, I guess, with regard to a referendum. And I'm hearing some
00:06:58 interesting numbers even today that there's several that are floating around that are almost
00:07:03 at that 177,000 threshold. So I don't think it'll be very long before we're contending with, uh,
00:07:10 with the whole idea of a referendum and, and people want to be heard. They, they, they're, they've had
00:07:15 enough. Yeah. From what I understand, this has to be a paper. It has to be paper that has to be done.
00:07:21 And I've seen some online petitions where they've got a couple of hundred thousand people already
00:07:24 signing up. Um, but that doesn't really count. It has to be paper. The thing that I've noticed,
00:07:30 the thing that I've noticed, um, I came from Ontario. I never really understood what the
00:07:36 grievance was for Alberta until I moved here. And I call myself an Albertan now. I understand
00:07:41 completely. Um, what I've seen online over the last couple of days is people seem to think that
00:07:46 Danielle Smith's having a tantrum. People seem to think that voters out here are having a 1.00
00:07:51 tantrum because we didn't get our way when it comes to, uh, the election the other night,
00:07:56 the conservative didn't win. Carney got in. What do you say to those people?
00:08:01 I think what people need to understand is that Albertans have kept quiet for a very long time.
00:08:05 And we've always maintained that when, when Alberta decides it's going to leave,
00:08:09 there's not going to be a lot of fanfare. There's not going to be a lot of posturing.
00:08:12 It's like, no, thank you very much. We're done. Goodbye. And I think people will be shocked
00:08:17 at how fast that happens. Well, I, I actually heard that there's a, there's an opportunity
00:08:22 here. And I think this should be done. There should be a very, very, um, slow effort to move
00:08:29 forward, but this is possibly, this possibly could get on a municipal ballot in October.
00:08:34 We're having municipal elections here. I've heard people saying this could happen as early
00:08:38 as October. This is a lot closer than a lot of people across the country think.
00:08:44 No, I agree. And we, when we were looking at what was happening with regard to the polls and
00:08:49 everything that was happening with Carney and the liberals, I think we recognize that this could
00:08:54 come upon us fairly quickly. And I think the next couple of days or weeks are going to be very
00:09:00 telling in terms of, um, you know, Mr. Carney flip-flopping back and forth on, um, so-called
00:09:06 promises to Alberta, which don't really carry a lot of weight to be totally frank. But if he,
00:09:13 uh, toes the line with, um, Mr. Blanchet and the Québécois and some of the stuff that's going on
00:09:18 there, that's just going to add fuel to the fire. Like the resolve is already there. People are
00:09:23 speaking up that have never spoken up before. It's like Albertans are saying, you know what,
00:09:27 we're not going to be quiet about this anymore. Enough is enough. Well, you brought, I'm sorry,
00:09:31 you brought up Francois Blanchet. So I actually have a clip. Let's play a clip of him. This is
00:09:35 after the election. And then we'll come back and discuss. Okay.
00:09:38 And the fact that there's no future for oil and gas, at least in Quebec and probably everywhere.
00:09:48 And this has to be said and protected. I have a brand new weapon to do that. Mr. Bonin will be
00:09:55 extraordinary carrying that message. So that was Blanchet saying no future for oil and gas
00:10:02 in Quebec and really no future for oil and gas everywhere. I mean, this, we're never going to
00:10:09 get a pipeline out East. If this is the case, the Parti Québécois out there, they feel the same way
00:10:14 about our oil and gas. It's over. It's time to leave.
00:10:17 Well, it is. And to, and to quote, well, not quotes verbatim, but a fellow Albertan and Premier
00:10:24 Ralph Klein, it's like, well, let's just turn off the taps, turn off the taps and see, see how that
00:10:29 works for you. Well, I always remember to quote, and maybe you don't want to say it, but I think
00:10:33 it was let the Eastern bastards freeze in the dark or something like that. A very famous thing that he 0.98
00:10:38 once said, and I've said here on my channel, I have, I have family. I don't want them to freeze in the
00:10:42 dark, but we need to get our oil out. Well, what do you say to people who say, well, we'll be
00:10:46 landlocked? Although I look at the map from the other day and I think we'll take half the country
00:10:51 with us possibly if the independence movement continues to grow. Saskatchewan may be part of
00:10:56 Northern British Columbia as well. Well, you know, the people forget about the fact that Alberta would
00:11:03 have way more power to bargain with places like British Columbia, for example, as an independent
00:11:08 country versus as a province. Right now as a province, we're hamstrung by Ottawa. We can't do
00:11:14 that. But BC has, what, several trillion dollars worth of goods that flow into the port of Vancouver
00:11:19 and out to the rest of Canada, and they would have to go through Alberta. So, you know, it behooves them
00:11:27 to play nice with regard to stuff like that. Being landlocked isn't at all a constriction for what we
00:11:32 need to do as an independent country. There's a lot, we would actually have a lot more freedom to
00:11:38 negotiate in good faith with the people around us, with the provinces around us, and get something
00:11:42 that works for everybody. Well, a few years back, well, actually, it's more than a few years. I've
00:11:46 mentioned here again on the channel, I've got some pictures of a thousand people in an auditorium in
00:11:52 North Calgary. This had been about 2019, and that question was... I was there. Were you there? Well, I was
00:11:57 there, and it was the first time I'd ever gone out, and people were so excited about this. That was
00:12:03 seven years ago, or six years ago now. And I remember somebody asking the question, well,
00:12:08 if you can't get your oil through Quebec now, how are you going to get it if you leave? And the
00:12:13 same thing with British Columbia. And the guy said, well, we'll just tell Quebec they can't have our
00:12:17 oil, and they can't have our money either. You're going to get nothing from us. And British Columbia
00:12:21 basically can't use our borders anymore. And I thought that was an interesting way of putting it.
00:12:26 You brought up Mark Carney. Your thoughts on this guy? I mean, Trudeau 2.0, but I think he's
00:12:33 Trudeau 2.0 even more. I think this guy's really dangerous for the country, and not good for Alberta,
00:12:41 for sure. Oh, absolutely. I call it the biggest misdirect in the history of Canada, where instead
00:12:49 of looking at the abysmal liberal record of which he had much to do, he got people to look the other
00:12:56 way and look at the bad man down in the US. And they use fear. And that's been a liberal tactic
00:13:02 for a long time. And I think that's what I think frustrates a lot of us Albertans as well. It's like,
00:13:07 we don't make decisions based on fear. We make decisions based on what's best for us and our
00:13:11 family and our livelihood. And the fear factor is something that rarely, rarely comes into play.
00:13:18 That's why we were so upset during the whole COVID thing, not to sort of rehash that whole era. But
00:13:23 Albertans have been fiercely independent, and we want to make the decisions that are best for us.
00:13:30 And watching the other parts of the country, I won't say the rest of the country, because I think the
00:13:34 West didn't buy into the baloney. Everybody bought into this fear-mongering, and it was disappointing,
00:13:43 to say the least.
00:13:44 Yeah. You brought up Donald Trump, 51st state. He's been meddling, obviously, meddled in the federal
00:13:54 election. If the independence movement gains traction here, what about meddling from Trump
00:14:01 when that happens? What do you think about the 51st state thing? There are some people in the province
00:14:06 that they want to go talk to the Trump administration about Alberta becoming the 51st state. Would you be
00:14:11 open to that, or are you just looking for independence, our own country here?
00:14:15 Well, two thoughts on that. Number one, Albertans will ultimately decide what that independence looks 0.93
00:14:20 like, number one. Number two, for me, independence doesn't mean serving one country, then serving
00:14:27 another country. Because, sure, Donald Trump's in right now, and maybe everything's looking rosy. But
00:14:32 in four years, there could be a completely different type of administration in there that we
00:14:37 would find very untenable. And so I don't know that jumping from the frying pan into the fire
00:14:42 necessarily makes a good choice. So I'm for independence, not necessarily 51st state. Having
00:14:49 said that, though, I think people misunderstand a lot of what's happening there. Donald Trump is
00:14:56 advancing a foreign policy known as Fortress America. And that includes Canada, that includes Mexico.
00:15:03 He has a very clear agenda, which I'm sure he has communicated to both Mr. Trudeau and Mr. Carney.
00:15:10 And the fact that they're not biting at it, in fact, the fact that they are siding with China. So
00:15:15 there's only two countries that are doing retaliatory tariffs right now, Canada and China. So I don't
00:15:21 think that bodes well for Canada at this point, because Mr. Carney either isn't getting it or is
00:15:27 actually being deliberately antagonistic. You find it fascinating that we went through 10 years of
00:15:35 this, and then they got reelected. It was stunning the other night. And again, so many people just
00:15:40 basically forgot everything because they had Trump derangement syndrome. It was just stunning to see
00:15:46 that happen the other night. And I did want Paulie up to win. He did very well. He actually did very
00:15:51 well. He'd have been the prime minister if this hadn't happened with the 51st state and the liberals
00:15:56 playing it to the YLT. And they did a damn good job of it, you have to say. 0.60
00:16:00 Well, and don't forget, they had the help of the propaganda arm, which was all the mainstream media.
00:16:07 I was at the point where I was only listening to independent media voices on YouTube and other
00:16:14 places like that, simply because you couldn't find a mainstream outlet that would give any
00:16:20 credence or credibility to any of the conservative positions or to Mr. Paulieff.
00:16:25 There'd be lots of time oohing and aahing over Mr. Carney, but every commentary around the
00:16:32 conservatives was negative. And they weren't even trying to hide it. And I think that,
00:16:37 and if that's what we were seeing in Alberta, I can tell you that it was 10 times worse in
00:16:41 Ontario and Quebec.
00:16:42 What do you tell people here, maybe in Alberta, that might have to vote on this in the future?
00:16:47 What benefit will it be for them to be an independent country here in Alberta, as opposed
00:16:52 to being part of Canada?
00:16:54 Well, you know, I just start with a really simple fact that, you know, would Alberta,
00:17:00 what would Alberta look like with that extra just about $70 billion that wouldn't have exited the 0.81
00:17:06 province? You know, what would that have done for us as a province? It's, you know, even with
00:17:11 things, you know, I don't want to go into, you know, get too granular on some of these issues,
00:17:15 but even things like the CPP, Alberta overpays. We don't get nearly as much back from CPP as we pay
00:17:23 into it. We're subsidizing other provinces. If we were actually paying into something that was
00:17:30 a straight across deal, everybody would be better off, even with something as simple as a pension
00:17:37 plan. So from my perspective, you know, we have way more to gain than we have to lose in this case.
00:17:44 And I can tell you that when we start to negotiate, you know, what the federal government actually owes
00:17:51 Alberta in this discussion, I think people will be shocked because nobody's really talked about that.
00:17:58 Well, yeah, basically what happens, you get the 177,000 signatures, you get a ballot. If you get
00:18:05 a clear winner, I think it's 50% plus one on a clear question, then the feds, the provincial
00:18:12 government and Aboriginal groups, First Nation groups, by law have to sit down and talk about
00:18:18 this with Alberta to work out the deal and to work out the future of Alberta and their place in it,
00:18:25 correct? Something like that. Yeah. Boy, it's hard to believe, you know, I heard somebody throw out
00:18:30 October. And I've said a few times on my channel that, you know, separation is closer than you may
00:18:36 think. And it's getting closer day by day. And after the election the other night, it's, it's getting
00:18:42 real close. James, thanks so much for talking to me. I do appreciate it. What would you suggest people
00:18:47 do if they're part of this movement? What should they be doing to, to move it along and to get the
00:18:53 ultimate prize, which is Alberta independence? Well, there's a couple of things that are going on right
00:18:58 now. So you mentioned the rally that's happening up in Edmonton. So that is a joint effort between the
00:19:03 Independence Party of Alberta and ourselves, the Wild Rose Independence Party. We see ourselves as a
00:19:09 movement. So it's bigger than just being a political party. And so that's really important. So get out, make your
00:19:14 voice heard, come to the rally. We're going to be putting on a convention or conference on
00:19:20 independence in June. We haven't got the dates nailed down yet, but that's going to be happening.
00:19:25 I hear that Mr. Manning is also exploring the idea of putting a Western Independence Assembly together.
00:19:31 So keep your, your ears peeled and your eyes on the news and watch for opportunities to get out and
00:19:38 make your voice heard. It was interesting to hear President Manning get involved in this about a week
00:19:42 ago. He said that there'll be a national crisis, basically, if the Liberals win once again. And
00:19:48 then I did read a little bit about him having some type of a committee, getting committees together.
00:19:53 Back in 87, the mantra of the Reform Party was the West wants in. He's actually considering
00:19:59 the West wants out right now, which is pretty amazing considering it's a big name like Preston Manning.
00:20:05 So James, thanks so much for being here. I do appreciate it. I'm sure we'll see you in the future.
00:20:10 And when we find out more about this conference you said you're going to have, I think in June,
00:20:14 get you back on and we'll get somebody on to talk about that as well. Thanks so much for being here.
00:20:18 Okay. We'll see you on Saturday. Absolutely. I'll see James, James Albers. And thanks a lot for
00:20:24 watching the channel. If you like the video, please give me a thumbs up. Subscribe to the channel as
00:20:29 well. We're almost at 30,000 subscribers here. Hard to believe. I'll ring the bell for notifications and
00:20:34 I'll see you in the next one.
00:20:40 Thank you.