John Bolton - May 12, 2026


Alberta’s Future: 3 Constitutional Models

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
I Need Your Help - Please Contact Me - Your Opinion Matters (please share) Court Rules Against The Petition - Mitch Sylvestre Responds

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 59 minutes

Words per minute

178.32

Word count

21,371

Sentence count

313

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

14

sentences flagged

Hate speech

8

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Join us as we bring in three members of the Alberta Women's Independence Network, Angela, Kathy and Pat, to talk about the upcoming referendum on Alberta's independence from Canada on Oct. 19th, and what that means for the future of the country.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 good evening and thank you everybody for joining a special episode of the levine show as we have
00:00:07 quite the panel for you if you've been paying attention to social media the last day or so
00:00:12 john bolton and others we have a collection of constitutional conversations for you we're going
00:00:19 to presume this is now october 20th and we're starting the conversation about what comes next
00:00:24 because if there is a successful referendum on october 19th we need to start thinking about this
00:00:29 And what's better time to start than now?
00:00:31 As part of the Alberta Women's Independence Network series, this is episode number seven.
00:00:37 And what we're doing is we're going to present to you the conversation with Bruce Pardee.
00:00:42 We've got Matthew Broderley and Dennis Calama, who's going to talk about different types of constitutions.
00:00:48 And we'll just grab that comment. There we go.
00:00:51 And first, we'll go ahead and bring in the Alberta's Women's Independence Network to talk a bit about this episode.
00:00:59 We've got Angela, Kathy and Pat. Thanks for joining us all. Here we go. This is the big
00:01:05 day. Number seven. You guys have been crushing it for six solid episodes. So thank you very
00:01:11 much for doing that. Let's go ahead and start with Angela. Angela, why are we here today?
00:01:15 Well, the Alberta Women's Independence Network is a group of ladies that we got together
00:01:22 a little over a year ago, and our focus has been on reaching out to Albertan women. We also have
00:01:29 men that join us as well, but reaching out to Albertan women and inviting them to join the
00:01:35 conversation around Alberta independence. Our focus has been on education and building community
00:01:41 through respectful dialogue. So as we've been going around the province holding meetings,
00:01:47 and our focus is smaller meetings, in-home meetings, sometimes local cafes, restaurants,
00:01:51 and sometimes town halls more one-on-one face-to-face conversations we keep hearing the
00:01:57 same questions about well what would this look like what would it what could it practically be
00:02:04 if we were to become an independent uh country of alberta and it was the same questions over and
00:02:11 over again and so a couple months ago um we got together and started to discuss like how can we
00:02:20 address these questions in a really meaningful way and we came up with the idea of using a paper
00:02:26 that colonel redmond colonel david redmond had put out in 2024 discussing six national interests
00:02:34 that must be addressed and used in a successful country now his paper was geared towards
00:02:42 canada kind of a call back to what it used to be but when we looked at that paper we realized this
00:02:47 is exactly the perfect framework for this discussion around an independent Alberta and so
00:02:56 we've been holding as you said a series of episodes where we've brought in different speakers
00:03:03 to address these different national interests some of the speakers are from Alberta some of them
00:03:10 have been from outside of Alberta and we've also invited many of our Albertan podcasters such as
00:03:17 yourself jason such as john bolton and corey morgan and a few others to join us in this to
00:03:22 spread this message of um this discussion that we're having fantastic that's a great introduction
00:03:28 and if you haven't caught any of those episodes or even just a couple go catch up after this one
00:03:32 as well because it all comes together i think quite well here so kathy uh great job why this
00:03:39 episode and why these three people because no matter where we go or who we're talking to people
00:03:46 want to know what about our constitution what about what is this going to look like what what's
00:03:51 going to govern us and and how can i say yes to something that i don't have an answer to yet and
00:03:57 so it's been really fun to watch people make that journey through the why the why seems to be
00:04:01 satisfied now it's can we do this and how as angela said what's it going to look like after
00:04:07 and so as we were sitting down the three of us and discussing okay well who could we reach out
00:04:12 two for podcasters and we got that list down but now who could we reach out to for subject matter
00:04:17 experts well these three gentlemen i mean their names just immediately rose to the top and came
00:04:22 out it just made perfect sense and the fact that each of them come at this from a different angle
00:04:28 helps us know that the conversation is going to be very well-rounded that it's going to probably
00:04:34 touch everybody's concerns everybody's wants everybody's needs um all the things that people
00:04:39 are thinking about should be pretty close to address by bringing these three guys together
00:04:44 and thankfully none of them said no so here we are and i'm i'm pen and paper ready man i'm i'm
00:04:51 ready to take notes i'm ready to learn from them and i'm really excited to be able to foster and
00:04:56 facilitate this conversation so that albertans can now take it home and continue to have it as
00:05:02 we go through the summer and get together with family and friends and maybe this could be just
00:05:06 the fireside chat of the summer of 2026 as what is our constitution going to look like
00:05:13 fantastic i'm excited as well i've spoken to all three gentlemen at different times
00:05:16 now we have them all together and there's gonna be a lot of cooks in this kitchen
00:05:20 but i have a feeling it's gonna be very civil pet um as we're going through this one well how
00:05:25 important is it to you that the audience engages and asks questions and gets involved as we do
00:05:29 that as a second half of this episode uh very very important in fact that's kind of the primary
00:05:36 point of going live and I think it fosters because a lot of people think like well okay
00:05:42 who's going to be the boss of the new Alberta and the whole point that we're trying to get across is
00:05:48 that everyone needs to get involved because it's a democratic process so the more people get
00:05:54 involved and the more questions they ask and comments they make and criticisms they bring
00:06:00 forth the better we can build uh this new independent alberta so please jump in and
00:06:06 we look forward to hearing from your comments fantastic i think we're in great hands having
00:06:11 the three of you putting these together running around alberta having conversations and i'm very
00:06:15 excited to get this started so we're going to bring you back at the end during the q a portion
00:06:19 and thank you very much for being here ladies appreciate that a lot thank you okay audience
00:06:25 make sure that you go start putting your questions and comments in there and uh don't be afraid to
00:06:30 direct it to a particular panel member or the entire panel or just a general question on what
00:06:35 you think is going on and then we'll take our best shot at it keep in mind this isn't a debate we're
00:06:40 not trying to see who wins and also understand that we can't set policy at this stage these are
00:06:45 just ideas and conversations at this stage that's why we have so many of them so don't think you're
00:06:50 going to walk away from this understanding exactly where alberta is going to be is multiple paths
00:06:55 and at some point in the future then we'll have a conversation at probably the constitutional
00:06:59 convention on exactly what we have so without further ado let's go ahead and bring in dennis
00:07:04 kelma bruce party and matthew rowley nice to see you all gentlemen as i bring you up here okay so
00:07:13 so what i'm going to do is i'm going to go around the panel quick introduction on each of you uh and
00:07:18 then kind of throw in what is your position on the spectrum of constitutional options we'll start with
00:07:25 dennis so um are you gonna ask me questions or you're only just to tell me to tell people what
00:07:31 i think well first introduce yourself and then just give us your perspective on the spectrum so
00:07:36 where do you fit on the spectrum of the constitutional options so my name is dennis
00:07:40 calvin the only one that probably doesn't have deep constitutional education so i tend to come
00:07:45 at the world primarily from a literally average citizen point of view and that point of view
00:07:52 which i've grown to over time based in part on learnings from bruce party and from matthew
00:07:58 is that the legitimacy of the government flows exclusively from the people through an explicit
00:08:06 written constitution and that government only exists within constitutional boundaries
00:08:12 rights are very specific textual and clearly understandable powers of
00:08:19 government are enumerated specifically in anything not stated explicitly is
00:08:24 prohibited and you can amend the Constitution but it's somewhat
00:08:28 difficult so in simple terms a constitutional Republican like myself
00:08:32 seeks liberty with structure democracy with limits and state authority with
00:08:37 explicit constraints. So that's the point of view I have. Okay, fantastic. Bruce, same question to
00:08:43 you, a little bit about yourself, and then where do you fit on the constitutional spectrum?
00:08:49 Thanks, Jason. I'm the Ontario interloper in this session. I'm a prof at the law school at
00:08:58 Queens, and I run a small think tank called Rights Probe, and I've been talking about the
00:09:04 new possible constitution for alberta for for quite a while now i would i would put the spectrum this
00:09:09 way dennis is the middle man uh i am probably the most radical and matthew is radical in his own way
00:09:21 he wants to take us back to something that we used to have and uh sort of sort of still have but not
00:09:27 exactly so my take is that alberta is going hopefully is going to have a moment where all
00:09:37 things are possible and one of the choices it will have if it chooses to take it is to design
00:09:46 a free country i mean an actually free country and that depends upon its constitution
00:09:51 If it doesn't take that opportunity, then it will end up adopting something for its constitution that it is used to, and that is part of the problem.
00:10:03 So I would characterize these three models this way, if I may.
00:10:07 Matthew's model is a legislative supremacy model.
00:10:13 The legislature can do anything, not restrained by the courts.
00:10:17 dennis's model is a checks and balances model it it tries to insert uh institutions to try
00:10:28 and control each other in competition with each other courts and legislatures and executive and
00:10:34 so on and my model is a is a is a freedom model it's a flipped default model and that means that
00:10:44 essentially that everybody
00:10:46 has ownership of their own lives
00:10:48 and that the state
00:10:50 is not empowered
00:10:52 not legislatures, not courts
00:10:54 not executive branch
00:10:55 nobody is empowered
00:10:57 to provide for the
00:10:59 general welfare, the public interest
00:11:02 the common good
00:11:03 in a way that would require
00:11:06 setting aside your freedom
00:11:08 so my model is the
00:11:10 individual first
00:11:11 all right you pretty much laid that out there now uh matthew how close is he on that one uh
00:11:17 the traditional uh going back a little bit go ahead and introduce yourself and give us your
00:11:22 position on the spectrum of the constitutional options yeah so i'm dr matthew rowley president
00:11:28 of renew alberta and uh bruce said it pretty well i i do think that there's something that we can go
00:11:34 back to uh that though pierre trudeau wrecked our system and though there is opportunity to adjust
00:11:42 in a new constitution and and change a little bit here and there tweak it we started with something
00:11:48 good and it's much better to adjust what is good than to try to remake out of whole cloth something
00:11:55 that may or may not work and then we end up with an equal or an opposite problem so the key elements
00:12:01 that i value in our system are responsible government uh parliamentary structure separate
00:12:07 roles for the head of state and the head of government uh first past the post system of
00:12:12 electoral uh method and then uh a unified power between the executive and the legislative and an
00:12:20 independent judiciary in a non-partisan public sector these are kind of the foundations that
00:12:25 make up our system it's got a thousand year history to it of development and change that's
00:12:30 led us to this. That means it can be flexible where it has to change, but also we have something
00:12:36 that we can start with that has proven to be robust over many, many years. So that is what
00:12:42 I advocate for. It would be probably the most conservative position from a Canadian or an 0.95
00:12:47 Albertan point of view, but it's good to have this opportunity to talk it through.
00:12:53 Fantastic. Thank you, Matthew. So what I'm going to do for this first question is going to be the
00:12:57 same question for all three of you gentlemen it's going to be and i'm going to go from the
00:13:01 most familiar which will be matt uh all the way to bruce so that'll be the order go matt dennis
00:13:07 bruce um what is uh you advocating for that is good so give me one or two things that are good
00:13:14 and then one or two things that will be different so for example matt you say go back to before
00:13:19 pierre elliot trudeau can you remind the listeners what you mean by that so what's a couple things
00:13:25 that are good about the system you're talking about,
00:13:27 and how did it change or go bad with Pierre-Eli Trudeau?
00:13:31 Sounds good.
00:13:32 Well, it provides us a system of responsible government
00:13:35 where the legislature is supreme,
00:13:38 but it's not an empty supremacy or an authoritarian supremacy.
00:13:42 There still must be a responsibility to the people who elect the legislature,
00:13:46 and it's not merely at the time of election,
00:13:50 but during their government they have the requirement
00:13:52 to actually stay responsible to the people that they've been elected by.
00:13:57 In addition to that, we have the reserve power of the Crown
00:13:59 that allows for a kind of a final safety catch if things go bad.
00:14:04 As far as the Canadian experience now,
00:14:08 Pierre Trudeau basically destroyed our Westminster system
00:14:12 by placing the Charter of Rights and Freedoms into his new constitution,
00:14:15 which actually created a judicial supremacy
00:14:18 where the Supreme Court has the right to overthrow law.
00:14:23 The legislature can make a law
00:14:25 and the Supreme Court can say,
00:14:26 no, that's not constitutional and overturn it.
00:14:28 And we've seen them do that a lot.
00:14:30 So a significant problem that I have
00:14:32 with the present day system
00:14:34 is the way that it's been changed
00:14:36 to provide the courts with a sure way
00:14:39 to destroy the will of the people if they so want
00:14:42 and to push especially progressive agendas.
00:14:46 Okay, thank you very much.
00:14:47 Now, Dennis, when we go to you, some Canadians are probably familiar with the Constitutional Republic.
00:14:53 Can you lay out a couple items that would be a benefit?
00:14:56 And then a couple things that you would change or tweak, if any, with what we're familiar with with the U.S. system.
00:15:03 So the things that people will see that would be different under a constitutional republic is, first of all, the people are truly supreme.
00:15:13 You'd see that in the areas of things like referenda, controlling what government can do, binding referenda.
00:15:20 You'd see things like your rights explicitly defined and spelled out in a very textual fashion
00:15:26 that cannot be fiddled around with by a judge who happens to like something different.
00:15:33 And you see very clear paths of what government can and cannot do.
00:15:37 And those are the things that you really can restrict government right down to, for example, putting a cap on how much money they can spend.
00:15:45 So locking them in financially.
00:15:47 So a couple of things that I think we can add in compared to the U.S. system and the ones that are near and dear to my heart are things like term limits.
00:15:56 I think the penalty for a bad politician is far larger than the penalty of losing a good one.
00:16:04 So we see things like explicit term limits.
00:16:06 you get your eight years in office and that's it you're done for your life the other things we see
00:16:12 is again the referendum which i mentioned mentioned earlier which is any citizen can
00:16:16 make a referendum and actually make it stick on the government now you need enough votes
00:16:22 you can't be just a minority doing this but it has to move that way and um so if you push on
00:16:28 those things and tied with one last innovation growing largely from the westminster system
00:16:35 and that is the idea of an oversight branch that is actually the last sober thought to make sure
00:16:41 the rest of government is adhering to the terms of the constitution so that's an addition that
00:16:46 we put in compared to the american system and we think will help stop lock-up that you see
00:16:51 down there frequently okay fantastic uh well done um okay so bruce we're going to come to you and
00:16:57 this is going to be a little bit different because it's a new type of system it's very radical
00:17:01 so can you hit us with a couple of the items that you think are really important to understand
00:17:05 and then kind of lay out um a couple of the items that you think people really should understand
00:17:10 from a cautionary standpoint like this won't be there or that won't be there maybe address two
00:17:16 things that i think you think are good and then a couple things that people have to wrap their
00:17:20 head around that you think are important well one way to explain it is to contrast it with the
00:17:24 models that dennis and matthew are talking about now those two are also very different but here's
00:17:29 is one thing they have in common they're both talking about giving power to the people
00:17:33 but it's very important to understand that that what what this is and is not they're talking
00:17:40 about giving power to the people in the democratic sense that is yeah you can vote it does not mean
00:17:46 giving power to the people individually it doesn't might it does not mean that you are free and by
00:17:51 that i mean this if the people elect a government with the mandate to provide for the general
00:17:58 welfare and that government with the support of the people decide that it needs to override your
00:18:05 freedom then it will have the mandate to do that so for example let's consider covid
00:18:13 covid the covid regime that a lot of us did not like was a product of legislatures
00:18:20 and bureaucracies executive branch if you adopt matthew's model that's what you're going to be
00:18:27 able to get. Legislatures are supreme. Therefore, they can do anything they want, as long as they
00:18:32 have the approval of the people. Now, my model works differently in this sense. One of the things
00:18:39 that both Dennis's and Matthew's model does is start out with a default position. The premise
00:18:45 is this. If you are elected as a legislature, or if you are a court, if you put all the parts of
00:18:51 the state together, courts and legislatures and executives, the state can do anything. Its powers
00:18:57 are unlimited. Its subject matter jurisdiction
00:18:59 is unlimited. Now, Dennis'
00:19:01 model, unlike Matthew's,
00:19:04 sets out an exception.
00:19:06 All powerful,
00:19:07 except.
00:19:09 And the exception in Dennis' model is
00:19:11 your list of rights.
00:19:13 So the state can do anything
00:19:15 except those things that a court decides
00:19:17 when it's gone too far, like your freedom of speech.
00:19:20 Okay?
00:19:21 That also didn't work during COVID.
00:19:24 A lot of us were enraged
00:19:25 because the legislatures and bureaucracy has done a certain thing and then the courts wouldn't fix
00:19:30 it. They said it's fine. My model flips the default. It goes like this. The state, all of
00:19:37 its bits, legislature, executive courts can do nothing. It has no powers except. And now
00:19:48 we'll talk about what we want the state to actually have the power to do. And I've been
00:19:53 listing essentially three things. You want the state to, number one, keep the peace. You don't
00:19:59 want riots in the street. You don't want to be attacked by your neighbor. You want to be able
00:20:02 to call the police. Number two, resolve disputes. If you and your neighbor are fighting over a
00:20:08 fence, you want a place to go to, a neutral place like a court to resolve the dispute.
00:20:13 And number three, protect the country. You want a military. You want borders. You want to make
00:20:19 treaties so one two and three protect protect uh keep the peace resolve disputes protect the
00:20:26 country and not very much else and if you have that structure that architecture that means by
00:20:35 definition you are free because the state does not have the power or jurisdiction to do otherwise
00:20:43 it does not have the power to restrict your speech it does not have the power to restrict your
00:20:47 religion and so on so under my model you do not actually have to try to list all of the rights
00:20:53 that you think you ought to have because they're already done you've already done the most important
00:20:58 bit which is restrain the state now there are a whole lot of details that need to be filled in but
00:21:02 i'll leave it there for now yeah we'll end it right there fantastic and i'm the one that
00:21:07 restricts the speech around here today so sorry about that so the next one will go dennis bruce
00:21:12 and matt um we've seen overreach of all kinds of governments everywhere what mechanisms would there
00:21:20 be within yours dennis that could help restrict respond or even uh hold uh to account uh out of
00:21:28 control government so i know bruce and i have our challenges about agreeing on this but i think you
00:21:35 can define the rights that are applicable in a fairly succinct fashion like under 15 or so
00:21:42 blanket it together so i think you can say basically as long as i can speak as long as i
00:21:46 can move as long as i can bear firearms whatever i'm good and the the control is that if government
00:21:54 tried to impose covid you would you would basically cross over several of those enumerated rights
00:22:01 plus of course you would have the option to go at the government via referendum and in the
00:22:07 constitution draft we've been putting together there is no mechanism for the government to
00:22:11 overrule a um a referendum to overrule a right um without going to the people for a constitutional
00:22:20 amendment which the people will not buy into is my view so i think that there are ways to protect
00:22:26 against those kinds of things within a constitutional republic okay bruce same question what mechanisms
00:22:35 would be in place to deal with any overreach if it happens well i just want okay i i want to
00:22:41 address one of the big tensions in these models which is the conflict we think the conflict is
00:22:47 between people and the government and it often is but there's a conflict between the individual
00:22:54 and the group the individual and the mob so if you rule by referendum if you give power to the
00:23:01 people to vote in a referendum on everything you know every major thing that comes up you give it
00:23:06 to a vote okay so just let's go back to COVID for a minute if during COVID you gave power to the
00:23:12 people to decide in a referendum what's going to happen and you gave a referendum that said
00:23:17 do you think that everybody could be required to take a vaccine and if 75 percent of the people
00:23:26 said yes then everybody would be required to take a vaccine your rights notwithstanding because
00:23:34 that's the premise of the system you're giving power to the people to say you're giving power
00:23:38 to the mob that the the alternative is to say look there are just some places that the state cannot
00:23:45 go it only has a certain number of powers and if and if the if the if the subject matter does not
00:23:52 fall within those powers i'm sorry there's nothing you can do i want to make another very basic point
00:23:58 here's them here's a trap the constitution does not just run on the words that are stated on the
00:24:06 assumption that what the words say is what will be honored we have words in our constitution now in
00:24:11 the canadian constitution they say a certain thing and we found out lo and behold that the court
00:24:18 doesn't think that they mean what they say so if you empower an institution whether it's the
00:24:24 legislature or whether it's the court to have the final say on what the cost is and what it means
00:24:34 then essentially you're being you're being ruled by that institution and not by the constitution
00:24:41 you're being ruled by the people in that institution and not by the words in the
00:24:45 constitution your constitution has to be built structured in such a way that there is nobody
00:24:53 with lasting power inside the state to be able to demand that everybody do things the way they think
00:24:59 they want it to be okay and matt so we're going to kind of massage this one a little bit for you
00:25:05 let's go to the pre-pierre elliot trudeau version not the post one because the post one we've seen
00:25:11 it's difficult to deal with overreach what mechanisms would be in place if we went to
00:25:16 a more traditional version so first of all in bna you looked uh the federal and the provincial each
00:25:24 have their sphere where they have uh the task of doing the governance in those areas i actually
00:25:29 agree with bruce that we could limit those even more and say you know there's a few less that
00:25:33 they can get involved with but beyond that you have a senate and a crown that both provide
00:25:39 a means of sober second thought when they're done right when you don't import wing nuts into the
00:25:44 senate they actually can stop crazy laws and say hold on a second we should think about this you're
00:25:49 invoking the emergencies act because somebody set up a bouncy castle uh we also have to instill the
00:25:55 idea that used to be more common that people don't look to the government for absolutely everything
00:25:59 that the government cannot be at the center again bruce is just uh basically a 1200s richard the
00:26:05 second era Westminster guy. So good job, Bruce. And then I think we also need to recognize that
00:26:12 true legislative supremacy means that if a government goes off track, then when we vote
00:26:17 them out, the legislature that follows does have the ability to straighten it out and correct
00:26:23 what's done. Now that is a slower process, a more conservative process. It's not quite so
00:26:28 satisfactory because you can't instantly throw the bums out or stop what they're doing. But if we have 1.00
00:26:34 the ability to vote in a new party into power that can truly make changes, then if one party
00:26:41 goes off the rails and the chamber of sober second thought fails, you have the opportunity
00:26:45 to adjust it as when the NDP were thrown out in Alberta and the UCP came in and started
00:26:51 changing things back to fix the problems that were done during that time.
00:26:56 Wow, you're really trying to get that Alberta audience on your back or on your side by saying
00:27:02 when the NDP got thrown out.
00:27:03 They loved that one.
00:27:04 Next, we're going to go with Bruce,
00:27:06 then Matt, and then Dennis.
00:27:08 Courts.
00:27:09 What role do courts play under yours?
00:27:12 And how much power do they have?
00:27:14 Or are they restricted?
00:27:15 Let's start with Bruce.
00:27:16 Right.
00:27:16 So the problem with the courts
00:27:18 we have right now,
00:27:19 and especially the Supreme Court of Canada,
00:27:21 our Supreme Court of Canada
00:27:22 essentially has become
00:27:24 a kind of star chamber.
00:27:25 Yes.
00:27:26 Because of the system that we have
00:27:28 with a charter of rights
00:27:30 and because we appoint people
00:27:31 to that chamber until age 75 they can sit there for you know sometimes 20 years and dictate because
00:27:38 they have the power of precedent behind them what the constitution means even though we can all read
00:27:43 the document it doesn't say that but because they have the power that they do that's now what it
00:27:48 means so they are the ones making up the constitution you can't have that system but you still need
00:27:54 courts you still need courts to to to have the power of the state to enforce the law to make
00:28:00 sure that people are not using violence so how do you square that what you do is you change the way
00:28:06 the court that the judges are appointed you don't appoint them at all you elect them and you elect
00:28:11 them for a very short period of time so it's a revolving door there are no vested interests on
00:28:16 the court there is no star chamber you've got you get in you you sit for you can pick and pick a
00:28:22 number six years eight years maximum and then you're out okay and this is going to sound
00:28:28 counterintuitive especially to somebody like matthew but you you get rid of the power of
00:28:33 precedent of the highest court that power gives the highest court the power to dictate what the
00:28:38 law is for the rest of the hierarchy of the courts in the country now if you take that away i mean
00:28:45 in theory i love the idea of precedent that you know like cases should be decided alike but that
00:28:51 power is creating the star chamber giving the power to dictate what the constitution means
00:28:57 if you take that away then that highest court no longer has that power and every single time
00:29:04 the constitution needs to be considered the court in question will go back to the words of the text
00:29:09 itself now there's no guarantee that that court will interpret those words in the way that you
00:29:14 want them to be interpreted in a particular case that's impossible but the mistakes are not going
00:29:21 to act like a de facto coup over the country and in that way in that way what we're trying to do
00:29:30 across the board with respect to courts with respect to legislatures and especially with
00:29:35 respect to the managerial state the executive branch we are trying to diffuse power we're
00:29:41 trying to take power away from all of those branches and give it back to the individual
00:29:48 to decide things for themselves okay now matt you have the unfortunate position because we've all
00:29:56 seen the supreme court so explain to us how we went from magna carta to magna justices and how
00:30:02 would you prevent that what kind of role would courts play uh we would take trudeau's charter
00:30:07 of rights and freedoms out in the backyard and shoot it and bury it somewhere um the the big
00:30:13 difference between pre-charter and post-charter is not just precedent but it's the idea that the
00:30:19 court doesn't just adjudicate based on the law but they have the right to adjudicate the law itself
00:30:27 based upon the charter based upon the constitution and while they use precedent sometimes precedent
00:30:33 as bruce said isn't necessarily a bad thing it gives us direction and all these things
00:30:37 the problem is when the court has the right to weigh the law itself and decide whether the law
00:30:45 is lawful so going back to a pre-pierre elliott trudeau system is to return the court actually
00:30:51 from a place of supremacy even the name supreme court is very dramatic but it is a lie in the old
00:30:58 bna type system because the court was not allowed to overturn law when the legislature made law they
00:31:05 could adjudicate based upon that law and upon the precedent that went before so that's a simple way
00:31:11 to rein in the courts to to say to them you do not have the right to decide if a law is
00:31:17 constitutional or not it is the law that the legislature brought down okay and now dennis
00:31:24 same question what role do the courts play there's a supreme court of the u.s things have to change
00:31:29 circuit courts bunch of types of levels of courts what would that look like here in alberta so the
00:31:34 the way i'm looking at it is that the courts would be able to interpret and apply the constitutional
00:31:42 concepts to law but they can't change the constitution itself they can say this law
00:31:47 needs to go this way or that way or adjudicated in favor of this person versus that person
00:31:53 the part i agree with bruce completely on is we should not have lifetime judges they should be
00:31:59 elected that's my preference there's a school of thought that says they can be appointed
00:32:04 subject to review but the thing they aren't is lifetime they're there for a number of years
00:32:09 pick your poison and they disappear the other thing bruce and i agree on is the absence of
00:32:15 precedence requiring that that precedent be obeyed and followed for life i think judges should be
00:32:22 expected to look at precedence and say yep that makes sense that applies here or no it doesn't
00:32:27 sorry we're not going to pay attention to that one so i agree with him on uh on on those kinds
00:32:33 of things and that's the structures we've built in to the uh to essentially protect people from an
00:32:42 overly powerful supreme court the other thing we've got in our structure is the idea of the
00:32:47 oversight branch the controlling function that says wait a minute this section is getting out
00:32:52 out of control it's also an independent elected branch with a term limit and they can say wait a
00:33:00 minute the judges are going too far we have a means of stopping them reviewing them and if
00:33:05 necessary pull them out of office so we have some limits to on judiciary as well okay and then
00:33:12 oversight we might get back to that one again there dennis i might try i dive a little bit
00:33:17 deeper in that one okay so the next one is from matthew dennis then bruce it's going to be changes
00:33:22 modifications amendments how do we change it once it happens is there a mechanism for it or is it
00:33:28 not necessary uh can you please explain how modifications can happen in the future so sorry
00:33:35 so to my mind uh first of all a constitution should be very very short small and have as little
00:33:43 in the constitutional document as possible and then the details should be in statute and what
00:33:49 that does is it means the basic constitution doesn't have to be amended often but where
00:33:54 statute has to be amended to update it to make provision for something that's changed in the way
00:34:01 life is you know we used to have muskets now we have machine guns what do we do about that
00:34:05 you change those things in statutes rather than in the constitution itself when you do need to
00:34:11 have an amending formula, it should be robust. It should be fairly hard to amend your basic law
00:34:18 because otherwise you are constantly having a turnover. And we see that in different countries
00:34:23 where every new party that comes in amends the basic law and it has this knock-on effect down
00:34:27 through the rest. So you can build an amending formula into it. Something like the 750 model
00:34:33 that we have in Canada is not necessarily bad. The problem is that Canada is so big and so diverse 1.00
00:34:39 with so many different provinces and people that you never can get them to agree on something that
00:34:45 benefits one part of the country because it won't benefit the other so in a country like alberta
00:34:50 where we are more uh homogeneous and united you can have an amending formula that is fairly strict
00:34:57 and still is able to pass whether that be usually through the legislature you know the the two houses
00:35:03 of the legislature and the crown uh creating a formula themselves or whether you have an element
00:35:09 of referenda involved in it is a question that could be open to debate yeah i think ours is
00:35:15 pretty strict so i've been the seven provinces 50 of the population represented maybe it could
00:35:21 be seven provinces to have 50 support within that province so that large ones don't have too much
00:35:28 power on that one dennis back to you on this one now how do you change amend because we know
00:35:32 there's over a couple dozen amendments with the us one so there's a mechanism in place
00:35:37 so a couple of factors um i'm going to actually start in a different spot and that one of the
00:35:42 things that we think needs to be done is the constitutional system and documents have to be
00:35:48 written very clearly and so the ordinary citizen who's not a constitutional scholar can actually
00:35:55 read understand point to things that they say yep that's something i care about and not written in
00:36:02 legalese so that you know you got to be a very smart person like dr party to understand what
00:36:07 the heck it means that's one aspect the second thing is the amending formula we have in the
00:36:11 constitution today is actually two structures one is a super majority of the legislative assemblies
00:36:18 so that would be the senate and assembly of citizens so they have to pass that and lastly
00:36:23 is a referendum by the people and it has to pass that so that is why the constitution has to be
00:36:31 readable and understandable by the average voter now i do agree also with matthew that you don't
00:36:37 put a lot of crap in the constitution that really should be in law we have to find that dividing
00:36:45 point it's never totally black or totally white there's gonna be cases where we say well that 0.95
00:36:50 probably should be in the constitution and now that probably should be in law and that's why we
00:36:54 have these conversations but our structure would be an informed electorate and informed citizens
00:37:00 that understand what they signed up to with the constitution and they being the ultimate authority
00:37:04 by vote okay and bruce the same one to you it's a small constitution it's very limited power very
00:37:12 limited government but if there is a change that's desired how to go about doing that well i think it
00:37:17 should be difficult but not impossible i think i've suggested two-thirds vote in both your
00:37:22 legislative chambers and two-thirds vote in a referendum that's that's difficult difficult enough
00:37:28 um but so while i have a chance though let's one of the difficulties that i have with the premises
00:37:36 of of both matthews and dennis's constitutions is this it is it is appealing to the either the
00:37:47 knowledge ability or ethics morality of the people involved you need a you need an informed citizenry
00:37:54 you need an ethical set of politicians
00:37:56 you need responsible government
00:37:58 the assumption is
00:38:00 you're going to get such people
00:38:02 and the problem
00:38:05 that we've come to today
00:38:06 is that we don't have such people
00:38:08 we don't have those
00:38:11 kinds of people running the show
00:38:12 for my money
00:38:14 the constitution, any constitution
00:38:16 needs to be designed with the assumption
00:38:19 that you are not
00:38:21 going to have moral people running the show
00:38:23 James Madison basically said this you know if angels were to govern men you wouldn't need to
00:38:29 try and restrain them the purpose of the constitution is to restrain the people with
00:38:33 power if if if the people with power were moral and upright and ethical you wouldn't need a
00:38:39 constitution you just go ahead and give them power and tell them to do what was right the whole point
00:38:45 of having a constitution is to restrain the people who will do you wrong and the assumption has to be
00:38:53 that you will always have those people in power and if your constitution doesn't work with those
00:38:59 kinds of people in power then your constitution does not work it has to work regardless of the
00:39:09 character of the people who have power and i know you don't have access to my notes but that was my
00:39:16 next point and the next question was what is the presumed uh mechanism in their honorable or
00:39:22 dishonorable people are going to be running it so bruce i'll come to you third if you want to
00:39:26 tack on any more afterward dennis goes next and then matt because do you have a constitution that
00:39:32 assumes there's going to be good people or not good people dennis i i assume we're going to have
00:39:38 normal average people and the reason why i think we can get there is by eliminating the whole idea
00:39:44 of career politicians with term limits and also controlling the rogue ones via an oversight body
00:39:50 so the expectation is not that we have perfect people being elected because that's never going
00:39:54 to happen but that when they get in they get identified and removed hopefully by the oversight
00:40:02 branch and also they're term limited so the motivation for people to come in i'm going to
00:40:07 to be a politician and make a bajillion dollars pick on justin trudeau starts off at 20 being
00:40:12 worth 20 million ends up worth 350 million based upon a 300 000 a year salary you know there's
00:40:18 something went amiss there so you put those controls in and that's the way i generally see
00:40:23 things is there's a balancing act i get where dr party's coming from saying hey keep it minimal
00:40:28 because it'll get screwed up i get where matthew's going with like keep it stable with the past we're
00:40:33 trying to find that balance between the two and that's why justly the constitutional republic
00:40:38 is in the middle trying to strike that middle balance between these two positions
00:40:42 okay and then matthew we had this conversation this morning and i understand your position but
00:40:49 go ahead and share yours should you be worried if they're honorable or dishonorable what was
00:40:54 your constitutional setup for that uh i do believe that you know every thought of our heart is
00:40:59 inclined towards evil always and that there is always an element of us that is uh perhaps mistrust
00:41:05 untrustworthy which is why we do have to have certain limits but uh i presume i presume albertans
00:41:12 and i presume that albertans will have the ability as they have in the past through many long
00:41:19 wonderful journeys uh they will have good politicians who will last a long time and then
00:41:25 at some point somebody will mess it up and the albertans will turf those people out on their ears
00:41:30 and put in a new set of good people and it's actually the tradition that we have is a strong
00:41:36 independent society that values our leaders but doesn't trust them uh too far and it's that
00:41:44 standard that we can keep as albertans it's essentially what we already have let's keep
00:41:48 doing that within a westminster system that does not have people with different values from the
00:41:54 rest of canada causing it to be muddied making a good argument for independence right there
00:42:01 so thanks for that but uh bruce if you want to attack on after you've heard uh dennis and matt
00:42:07 uh they say a little bit of trust uh but some some restraints and some guidelines yeah no i well
00:42:14 listen i i i i don't think it's an unreasonable desire but i think it's a little naive
00:42:22 because this is how we got to where we are we are in a system now that is being run by
00:42:31 well not to a person i'm not saying everybody in power right now is evil that's not that's not true
00:42:36 but a lot of people in power are doing things that a lot of us don't approve of
00:42:41 and what can we do about it well we have elections that doesn't work you can see it doesn't work
00:42:47 we have elections at the at the provincial level we have elections at the federal level we have
00:42:52 elections at municipal level, do those elections ever really change very much in terms of the
00:42:58 direction of the country, the degree to which our bureaucracies impose upon us? No. You need to make
00:43:05 a fresh start. You need to turn the page here. You're going to have a moment where you're trying
00:43:12 to reestablish a different kind of civilization. If all you do is create some new checks and
00:43:20 balances if you if you do what we've always done you know what we've always done all the way along
00:43:26 for hundreds and hundreds of years starting you know back when the king had power all we have
00:43:30 ever done is move absolute power around the king had it first and then we moved it to legislatures
00:43:38 which is where matthew wants it to rest the americans recognized that legislatures can be
00:43:44 tyrants too and so they put in a bill of rights and gave courts the power to decide when the state
00:43:52 had gone too far that didn't work out either and it worked out better in the states than it ever
00:43:56 has here but it wasn't perfect you can see the holes and now today what's happening is the
00:44:02 legislatures and the courts are moving power back to the king but it's not the king anymore now it's
00:44:09 manage your real estate okay if you want to fix this you're going to stop moving power around
00:44:15 and instead take power away from your government from your institutions from your politicians
00:44:23 from your bureaucrats from your judges take it away take back control your life is yours
00:44:29 if we keep arguing about you know who has the last call who has the last call the courts
00:44:34 Is it an oversight branch?
00:44:36 Is it the legislature?
00:44:37 So these are all state institutions.
00:44:41 The power should not rest with them.
00:44:46 Sounds neat.
00:44:48 I'll use that word for now as we make our way through this one, Bruce.
00:44:51 Okay, so the next one's going to be Matt, Dennis, and then Bruce.
00:44:55 Party system, two-party system, first pass to post.
00:44:59 How's the electoral system?
00:45:00 uh definitely a party system is important all of these things came about because they were needed
00:45:07 that's something to remember and again it's why i i like to be a conservative don't tear something
00:45:13 down until you know what it's for and you've learned to value it and then either change it
00:45:18 or in some cases destroy it but if you cut down a tree because you didn't like where it was and
00:45:23 then you decide that actually it was pretty good you can't just put it back on the stump and hope
00:45:27 it'll keep growing so with things like the party system it came about because there had to be some
00:45:32 order and coherence in forming a government within the legislature and it's good to have
00:45:39 usually a two-party system but i actually like the canadian three-party system believe it or not
00:45:43 you have this kind of wild card party that can be the the protest vote and take the the balance of
00:45:50 power in the parliament from time to time if you want to send the government a certain message you
00:45:56 want to keep them in power but you want to reduce the amount of power they have so a party system
00:46:01 is good and healthy and has its place anytime you have independent people we'll just have
00:46:05 independent legislatures or legislators within five minutes they've somehow grouped themselves
00:46:11 because you need to be able to organize you need to be able to fund it you need to be able to have
00:46:15 some sort of coherence that gets the government's program through the legislature and if it's all
00:46:21 independent it's really great until humans start acting like humans and you have 46 chiefs in the
00:46:27 in the uh in the legislature and nobody's willing to follow anybody else so we have parties to
00:46:33 create order because part of the goal we see the canadian thing peace order good government
00:46:38 is that we should have an ordered government that is good and that functions
00:46:43 okay dennis same question is there a party system and how does that work with the elections well as
00:46:51 as usual i find myself halfway between matthew and and bruce uh one of the concepts that dr party
00:46:57 brought forward is the whole idea of the amateur state get rid of these professionals and that's
00:47:01 something i fully endorse the other thing i agree with on matthew is that there needs to be some
00:47:07 structure needs to be some sort of parties that because people will run around like chickens with
00:47:12 their heads cut off if you just let them wander around so but what we're seeing is something
00:47:18 where there is a party system i actually don't care if it's two or three or five
00:47:22 it probably won't be 25 but they're relatively weaker because um in the case of the westminster
00:47:30 system if the party in power loses a vote of confidence then of course need a new election
00:47:35 and i don't like that at all um so you want to be able to sort of say well you can try and pass
00:47:42 legislation that doesn't make it let's keep on going so you have a weaker party and it's weaker
00:47:47 in part because of things like term limits you can't have career politicians who hang around for
00:47:54 35 years amassing fortunes you say you got your eight years you do your thing two terms in the
00:47:59 senate you're out and so they're still not completely amateurs the way bruce thinks
00:48:04 but they're not completely embedded politicians we can't get rid of and that's the balance we see
00:48:09 okay and then bruce party is there a party system yeah i i broadly agree with dennis
00:48:19 on the term limits thing i do believe in an amateur government that's the way i put it
00:48:24 you do not want a professional ruling class with their thumb over you
00:48:29 but one of the reasons that parties have acquired such a lot of power in our system
00:48:36 is because governments do so much because governments have a lot of power parties have
00:48:45 a lot of power so the real solution to to to parties having too much power is governments
00:48:53 that don't have power what you ideally want is you want a legislature with people who have been
00:49:00 elected sitting in the chamber twiddling their thumbs thinking what are we going to do today
00:49:08 we have no power everything is done we can't interfere this or that we can't dictate that or
00:49:14 this like we have nothing to do and you can have parties there if you want the parties shouldn't be
00:49:21 dictated by the constitution the people want if people who are elected want to gather together
00:49:26 in groups and say we all believe in this well that's fine they're free people they can explain
00:49:32 what it is that they stand for and they stand for it all together that's fine that's a party
00:49:36 so i don't think we should outlaw parties but the importance of parties is is a problem because it
00:49:43 reflects the importance of government the constitution should minimize the importance
00:49:49 of government if you do that then the party problem goes away
00:49:52 so you're raining on the party a little bit but okay that's cool i like that a lot um okay so
00:50:01 now it's going to be dennis bruce and matt for the next one uh is there going to okay dealing
00:50:06 with specifically alberta would there be one level of government or would be a national a regional
00:50:11 municipal how would the government break down if at all let's start with dennis so we see a single
00:50:17 level of government um where municipalities are really the only other layer but they're
00:50:24 essentially creatures of that single layer they would be um paid for by grant they wouldn't be
00:50:30 holding um be able to create laws other than a very minor sense uh under the guise of the
00:50:36 the legislatures and so uh certainly not a provincial level or something in between so
00:50:42 So what we do have, though, is a bicameral system where you've got, like I said, a Senate representing regions and an assembly of citizens representing the will of the broader people, the number of people.
00:50:54 And that's the only structure you have.
00:50:56 I see a lot of nodding out of Bruce in your next, Bruce.
00:50:59 Would you like to add anything to that?
00:51:00 Yeah.
00:51:01 Well, yes.
00:51:01 One level.
00:51:02 One level.
00:51:03 Don't make this complicated.
00:51:05 You don't want to grow your government, make it big and unwieldy like we have now.
00:51:09 We're trying to get away from what we have now.
00:51:12 we have a problem now we're trying to fix it let's not reproduce it that's the last thing you want to
00:51:18 do if you're if you're trying to live in a free country as a lot of albertans are saying and
00:51:25 thank goodness for that let's just ask this question what does that mean
00:51:30 and for my money if you are free you are not coerced by other people that is not by your
00:51:38 fellow citizens and not by the state. That is, you are not subject to their force or threats of force
00:51:44 to make you do what you want to do. One level of government with some very basic rules, and that's
00:51:49 the first one. No force allowed by people or by the state. If you have that rule and you have all
00:51:57 your property rights and so on, you have your contract rights, you're able to deal with people,
00:52:02 then you don't need all the bureaucracy. You don't need municipalities. You don't need all the
00:52:07 layers you don't need all the people you just need simple government with simple principles
00:52:13 to to allow people to run their own lives well matt now the ball's in your court are we going
00:52:20 to get a consensus on this one or should it be broken down further uh first of all i'd say
00:52:25 government is a historic reality because we do need ordering of our lives we have municipal
00:52:31 provincial and federal government uh and you'll see a similar thing in pretty much every country
00:52:36 because there are different layers of order that are required.
00:52:40 We don't want the feds mandating, you know,
00:52:43 where you can take your dog for a walk in the city.
00:52:45 I do think that it's better to have a federal and provincial level
00:52:49 because I envision for Alberta that very soon Saskatchewan will join us
00:52:53 and I'm guessing they won't want to just come in under our laws.
00:52:57 I mean, if they would, cool, but I'm guessing they would still want to have
00:52:59 some sort of provincial autonomy over certain aspects.
00:53:02 So I think it's actually good to have those separate levels of government
00:53:06 with municipalities being a creature of the provinces we have now now i would be open to a
00:53:12 single layer of government but when we're looking at the vastness of even western canada and if we're
00:53:18 believing that other provinces will actually look at us and say hey i want to join it's going to be
00:53:23 a hard sell to them to say yes you can join but you have to give up your legislature and your
00:53:29 areas of government that are under your control we want freedom and it's very hard to say to someone
00:53:35 else give up your freedom to us trust us with all of those areas that previously you've self-governed
00:53:41 so i would preserve the self-government of provinces that we have now with the expectation
00:53:47 that we would see other provinces joining alberta in this project so maybe at the beginning and then
00:53:54 if somebody else joins uh take another look at it but at least we have a two out of three saying
00:53:59 one level of government and with municipal municipalities treated a little bit differently
00:54:03 okay so this one we'll go to bruce dennis and then matt um inquiry is oversight by people
00:54:10 so what kind of power do the people have while the government is functioning so we'll start with
00:54:15 i think i said bruce dennison and matt
00:54:17 you mean in terms of recall and and and such things i don't i don't think if if if you do
00:54:26 things the way i'm suggesting you don't need any of that because the the because governments
00:54:32 legislatures executive branches will have such minimal amount of power to start with
00:54:38 that your complaint if there's going to be one is they're trying to do something they have no
00:54:43 jurisdiction to do if that happens you go to a court and say look this is what the constitution
00:54:48 says the constitution says they have the power to keep the peace result disputes protect the country
00:54:54 and that's all and now they're trying to make me wear a helmet while i ride my bike
00:54:59 that doesn't fit in any of those things make them stop and the court will read the constitution
00:55:03 say yeah you can't do that go away that that's all you need i mean let me give you an example
00:55:09 under your your one maybe make this a little easier um let's say the government decided to
00:55:14 go and invade other countries because they got the power to go ahead and do stuff outside the
00:55:17 border so using all the resources to go and colonize or take other countries sure sure so 1.00
00:55:24 so vote the bums out your your remember the people again under my model the people who are 0.96
00:55:32 in power doing this are not in there very long they're they're up for re-election maybe once 1.00
00:55:38 if if if that and then they're gone and then they're back to being a member of the public
00:55:44 like everybody else there are there is no there's no political elite here there is no ruling class
00:55:49 and so if these people you know want to survive as a normal person after they've done what they've
00:55:55 done they better be damn careful that they use their power judiciously and don't go off the deep
00:56:01 end but i i i don't i'm not inclined to all of these layers of of procedures and checks and so
00:56:11 on it should be clean people should know that they have a vote to elect by the way my bicameral model
00:56:18 just to pick up on something that matthew alluded to is a lot like the american one and i think i
00:56:24 think maybe dennis is as well so what you want to do is you want to elect it's a two-chamber idea
00:56:30 you elect one chamber representation by population that is one person one vote and you elect the
00:56:36 other chamber based upon not population but upon territory that is every equal you know
00:56:42 equally sized piece of Alberta gets to elect like two people to that chamber.
00:56:49 And that way you offset the distorting effects of population concentration in urban areas.
00:56:57 When you have that, like the states does, you know, each state elects two senators,
00:57:02 but elects congressmen based upon population, then you have hopefully a more balanced
00:57:08 representative system and uh and that will carry you to the next election
00:57:12 okay uh dennis same question inquiries overset by people direct democracy what kind of uh tools
00:57:20 exist so i tend to find myself agreeing with uh bruce on a number of points but one of the main
00:57:26 ones is that with term limits you of course uh have to return back to society and if you've been
00:57:32 a really bad politician that's not gonna bode well for how well people uh want to do business
00:57:37 with you or whatever. So I agree with that particular aspect. I do, however, see that
00:57:42 bad people will get into office and try and do things, particularly around getting more money
00:57:47 into their pockets, writing sweetheart deals, whatever the case might be. I think there has
00:57:52 to be a mechanism for citizens of that riding, whether it be for Senate or Assembly of Citizens
00:57:58 part, that they can actually go and say, you know, Dennis, we thought you were a good guy. 0.98
00:58:04 you've proven to be a real idiot we definitely don't want you even for this term certainly not 0.98
00:58:08 another one and have the people of that riding be able to recall you now that has to have a bit of 1.00
00:58:15 a barrier I think some structure that says you have to have a threshold before you can do such
00:58:20 a thing and of course you have to get a majority at least to recall the guy but effectively given
00:58:25 that mechanism and the the last thing is for things a little bit more insidious and harder
00:58:31 to pick out that's where that oversight branch comes in again to say wait a minute we can convene
00:58:35 a grand jury to go after dennis and say you know you're actually working under the table
00:58:40 not visibly and you are subverting the government and the constitution and we have a right to check
00:58:46 you out and ultimately take you out all right then matt uh question to you we've seen the
00:58:52 government over the last at least 10 years get away with a whole bunch of things uh how would
00:58:56 it work under the revised or going back to the original Westminster system so first of all I'd
00:59:04 say with term limits all you do then is you just bump the political elite one level out so instead
00:59:09 of having the political elite be the people that are in forever you have the political elite who
00:59:14 have their puppet who will then sit there for their term limited period but at the end of the
00:59:18 day their masters will still be the ones that determine it a term limit does not in any way
00:59:23 preserve us from a ruling class because ruling classes always do exist and always will it's just
00:59:30 the people that manage to figure out how to work the system so what you need to have is first
00:59:35 accountability to the house ministers government has an accountability to the house they must keep
00:59:41 the confidence of the house and if a minister or the government loses the confidence of the house
00:59:46 they can be fired then they have accountability to public opinion if the public shouts loud
00:59:51 enough and says hey what are you doing sends in petitions then the government realizes that what
00:59:56 they're doing is going to harm them they will lose re-election and in the last ditch similar to what
01:00:01 dennis is saying you have the crown who is actually in charge of appointing the ministers serve at the
01:00:06 pleasure of the crown so if they go off the rails so badly that they won't even listen to public
01:00:11 opinion that they don't care what the house says then the crown steps in and says sorry
01:00:16 your time is done and they dissolve the house or they fire the ministry okay and we're in our last
01:00:23 five minutes before we hit the questions from the audience so audience go ahead and start throwing
01:00:27 those questions in i'm sure you got a few of them um next one it will go in i think the order of
01:00:32 least uh difficulty so we'll go with uh matthew dennis and bruce on this one let's say alberta
01:00:39 picks yours what would the transition from the current government that we have right now
01:00:44 look like to go towards yours so what would the transition look like it'll be difficult
01:00:49 uh be hard what do you think uh matt it should be fairly easy because it involves separating
01:00:56 off ottawa now it's not going to be roses and sunshine there's always an adjustment period and
01:01:01 it's not not difficult it's just easier when all the laws stay the same all the terms stay the
01:01:08 same all of the precedents are the same the structures are all there all we're doing is
01:01:12 adjusting it, looking at the old British North America Act and saying, hey, how do we want to
01:01:18 make it new? Or looking at other Westminster models and saying, how do we want ours to function along
01:01:23 those lines? Adjusting it as we need to, and then going forward from the place that we were, which
01:01:30 allows us to continue in the traditions, the precedents, the conventions of the Westminster
01:01:35 system. You can keep the crown, whether you like King Charles or not, the good news is he has no
01:01:41 direct effect on you in your day-to-day life great great to have them over there on the other side of
01:01:46 the ocean but you can just have a governor general the same as you do you don't have to change a lot
01:01:51 which means that there will not be a lot of upheaval and there will actually be a lot of
01:01:55 stability even as you are making those adjustments and then dennis uh what would the transition look
01:02:02 like to a constitutional republic well it wouldn't be easy but i also don't see it being
01:02:09 extraordinarily difficult because many of the laws we have today up at the criminal code
01:02:15 actually they're not they're not hugely different from what we would want under the constitution
01:02:21 as we imagine it so some of those could be just essentially continued and there would of course
01:02:29 be a body where we'd say we had we would the new legislatures would have to redo this law
01:02:36 very quickly matter of urgency somewhere be fairly minor revisions but again redone
01:02:42 and some almost cut and paste um you know take out the old name canada and put in alberta and
01:02:48 you're done so i see this process going on over a number of years but in parallel i also see a
01:02:54 cleanup of government so i think of the doge kind of thing where you go through and say all right
01:02:59 not only do we clean up the financial mess in the expense of government we also go through
01:03:04 and clean up the legislative mess and get rid of old laws that really ought not to apply may not
01:03:11 fit the constitution and really ought to be simplified and eliminated so i think the
01:03:16 legislatures would be quite busy for the first two or three terms in the model we propose
01:03:23 but after that it should settle down to a more normal level of business with relatively little
01:03:28 uh legislation going on and then bruce obviously it's a little bit more radical and hasn't been
01:03:35 done so there's going to be at least an education portion to this transition what do you think
01:03:39 yeah i'm talking about ending the nanny state and there's going to be some transition there i mean
01:03:47 especially with respect to interests that people have have garnered over time so for example if
01:03:55 been paying into a pension into a state pension well you've been paying money into a pension that
01:04:01 you you need to be able to be granted your interests in that pension even though we're
01:04:06 not going to do that anymore the biggest transition though is the idea to get people's
01:04:13 head around the idea that the state is not empowered to do a lot of these things anymore
01:04:17 like it cannot make policies about most of the things that you're used to the state making
01:04:22 policies about the state has no power to tax and spend on a single-payer health care system
01:04:32 like it can't be done it's not a matter of policy decisions it can't be done
01:04:36 the state does not have the power to dictate curriculum to educate your child cannot be done
01:04:43 so whenever people think of you know how they think that you know social problems ought to
01:04:48 be solved and look to governments to solve it that's not the idea anymore that's the biggest
01:04:54 transition yes there'll be some mechanical things for sure no question about it but the biggest one
01:04:59 is governments are not there to do those jobs people this is on us we do this ourselves okay
01:05:07 and then this last question and it's meant to kind of make you think a little bit about your position
01:05:13 And it's going to go Dennis, Bruce, and Matt.
01:05:16 If you can't, let's just say you can't pick yours.
01:05:20 Which one would you pick of the other two and why?
01:05:23 Start with Dennis.
01:05:25 Tough question.
01:05:27 I'll be blunt.
01:05:28 I think ultimately I would settle on a modified Westminster system.
01:05:34 Because I do believe that, I like libertarianism the way Bruce describes it.
01:05:40 I like the idea of self-sufficiency, but I know that doesn't cover quite a few people.
01:05:45 So I'd probably say no.
01:05:46 I would aggressively work within the Westminster system to put some of the tougher rights in that I've been advocating.
01:05:53 But ultimately, that's where I would go.
01:05:56 All right, Bruce, if you can't go radical, which way do you want to go?
01:06:00 Oh, well, so let's just compare the situation between two representatives of these choices.
01:06:10 The Republican choice, and I know it's not exactly the same as what these folks are, what Dennis and Matthew are prescribing, but just metaphorically, there's the UK, which is still pretty much a legislative supremacy system, and you have the US, which is alleged to be a Republican system.
01:06:29 The U.S. has a Bill of Rights, and the U.K. does not, essentially.
01:06:34 It has the European, but, you know, don't worry about that.
01:06:37 Question, which of these two countries, they both did badly, and we all did badly,
01:06:44 but which of these two countries did worse during COVID?
01:06:49 Which of these two countries did worse during the present free speech crisis?
01:06:54 And so on, down the line of all these problems.
01:06:56 I think on balance you will find, as badly as it has done, the U.S. has fared better under its Republican system than under the British Westminster legislative supremacy system.
01:07:10 I do not trust legislatures to be the final word on anything anymore. 1.00
01:07:18 They do all kinds of crazy, stupid, tyrannical things. 0.99
01:07:22 And so much as I dislike the record of our Supreme Court of Canada on our charter and our constitution, I think they've made a real hash of it. 1.00
01:07:32 But the Americans have done better with their system.
01:07:34 The Americans have what is right now, even though it has lots of flaws in it, their model right now is the gold standard of existing constitutions.
01:07:44 So if I'm going to pick one and not my own, then I'm going to pick Dennis's because it's the closest to the American system.
01:07:51 okay and then matt you can either break the tie or create a three-way tie what's your answer
01:07:57 uh if i can't do the existing if we're forced and all albertans are forced to put their guns
01:08:03 to the head and say we're going to do something new and different and radical one way or another
01:08:07 i would actually be tempted to go with bruce on the logic that i do actually agree with him a lot
01:08:14 in the theoretical sense of the role of government and those type of things the reason that i'm
01:08:20 advocating for what I'm advocating is because of practicality of where we are, the history that we
01:08:26 have, bringing people with us on this journey, et cetera, et cetera. But if we're going to go
01:08:31 no holds barred, I wrote actually a master's thesis arguing pretty much what Bruce is saying
01:08:38 as far as the role of the government and saying that it's actually the role of the church and
01:08:41 other social organizations to do anything social. And I agree with that from a theoretical sense.
01:08:47 the problem is we'd be going from way over here to way over there and that would be too much of
01:08:55 a shock and you would cause such dislocation to people that it would be problematic but if i was
01:09:01 forced to choose i'd actually go hang out with bruce in the radical corner that's incredible
01:09:07 the one that requires no force is the one that you felt forced to choose um and here's kind of
01:09:12 a good example of what we're talking about here so this is why we have these conversations so 0.96
01:09:17 let's jump to our q a we're gonna bring back uh the ladies to help us out with this uh angela
01:09:23 welcome back pat welcome back and kathy welcome back so right before we jump into the questions
01:09:30 i want to ask each one of you a question angela starting with you what do you think of this uh
01:09:34 panel and the conversation we just had here oh fantastic conversation and so needed um
01:09:41 um and and we've been watching the chats and it is just very lively um all these different
01:09:48 thoughts and ideas coming forward has really stimulated I believe a lot of people thinking
01:09:53 about this and um it has probably answered and and giving answered some questions that they've
01:09:59 had for a long time so I'm really really excited for it question for you Pat as well you don't
01:10:04 have to pick a winner but what do you think of this conversation so far oh I like to pick winners
01:10:09 but i won't this time um fabulous conversation everything i thought it would be and more and i
01:10:16 think we should keep doing rounds of it because an hour and a half is just not an um not enough
01:10:22 time so i have a lot of questions hopefully i'll have time to ask them well we put time
01:10:29 term limits on this conversation so uh we've got to feel what that's like uh kathy what did
01:10:34 you think of this conversation this is exactly what we've been waiting for and hoping would
01:10:39 happened tonight and i just hope everybody's ready because we're going to do a part two
01:10:44 we have to i just we do oh yes and three and four and five so did you hear that gentleman
01:10:50 you've been elected to another term okay so let me go ahead i want term limits
01:10:58 two parts so i don't know we'll have to debate this more um the first question is for matthew
01:11:03 directly uh matthew the westminster's model relies more on conventions rather than hard
01:11:09 constitutional limits why should the new nation of alberta rely on unwritten expectations matthew
01:11:15 because it keeps the constitutional limits out of the the realm of the courts and being adjudicated
01:11:23 by the courts if it's convention then it's everybody saying yeah that's how it always
01:11:27 has worked out and you have to go with the way that it was in the past so you know looking at
01:11:33 the u.s with their arguments over a simple idea everyone has to has the right to keep and bear
01:11:39 arms well they're always questioning this and that but the the way you do it with convention
01:11:43 is just so have you always been able to own a gun yeah we've always been able to own a gun then you
01:11:47 can own a gun have a nice day it's actually simpler and it allows public opinion as well
01:11:53 as the legislature to weigh in on it rather than firing it off to the courts all righty
01:11:59 hopefully and we got a few from the same one so we actually took the time to ask a question from
01:12:04 each of you so let's go ahead and do that uh again with alberta nation for independence by the way
01:12:09 they were watching this morning and had questions that bring them this afternoon and that's exactly
01:12:13 what they did this one's for dennis how do you prevent a directly elected president from
01:12:18 accumulating excessive personal power in a young nation well no question that first election is
01:12:25 going to be pivotal so uh let's as voters be really informed on on our who our choices will be
01:12:31 but remember the president is subject to the same term limits the same recall options and everything
01:12:38 that every other elected position is is uh subject to so if the guy tries to do dumb stuff um recall
01:12:45 them uh the oversight branch can check for failures and pull them from office if necessary
01:12:51 and i think that's the control we put in place all right quick answer there thank you very much
01:12:57 dennis and then the next one here is for bruce from the same user uh bruce who has final authority
01:13:03 to interpret the constitution bruce an excellent question an excellent question this is part of
01:13:10 of the problem, right? The answer is
01:13:12 each court
01:13:13 hears each case.
01:13:17 The buck has to land somewhere.
01:13:20 But the answer is not
01:13:22 the Supreme Court, nine judges
01:13:24 who sit for the rest of their lives.
01:13:27 If you leave
01:13:28 it to each court hearing each case,
01:13:30 then the interpretation of that document
01:13:32 might change, might change
01:13:34 from case to case to case to case.
01:13:36 That's unfortunate because that's unpredictable.
01:13:38 We don't want unpredictability.
01:13:40 But on the other hand, if you're going to defuse power inside your system, then you're going to have to leave it with the judges.
01:13:46 And I won't go into details, but I've described a court system wherein you, for example, you have trial courts made of two judges who have to agree in order to convict somebody or find somebody liable.
01:13:58 And the interpretation that they give has to be consistent with each other, the meaning they give to the words of text.
01:14:07 and then you leave that case and you go to the next case with a panel of two and so on so in
01:14:11 other words what you're doing is you're giving more people who are elected and on short terms
01:14:17 short leashes the responsibility of interpreting constitution for the purpose of that case
01:14:23 and that case alone and so their power is curbed
01:14:26 all right uh and because we are still a capitalist society we're gonna bring up our
01:14:35 super chat next and it's a question for all three so let's go ahead and do that uh prairie uh prairie
01:14:41 cossack asks what's the panel panel's opinion on getting rid of universal voting right and making
01:14:46 it a privilege let's start with uh bruce on that one please okay the problem with any of these
01:14:54 ideas like you know it makes sense that only these people should be able to vote or only these people
01:15:00 should be able to do x problem is that that decision itself requires somebody to make it
01:15:06 so who are you going to choose to make that decision like is it the people all together
01:15:11 are we back to mob rule so my answer is no look if you're going to live in a democracy
01:15:16 every citizen and i think it should be limited to citizens every citizen of a certain age
01:15:23 you get a vote in other words the same rules apply to every citizen of majority age other
01:15:31 than if you're going to mess with that then you're really messing around with things
01:15:34 okay so it is a privilege for citizens of majority age um let's go to matt next on that one
01:15:41 i i would agree practically speaking what we have now is what we have uh you know part of me likes
01:15:48 old 40 shilling freehold the idea that you need a stake in the government in the life of the nation
01:15:54 before you have the right to vote so that it avoids the politics of envy and the whole eat
01:15:58 the rich and i'll take from the rich to give to you the poor if you give me your vote but
01:16:03 practically speaking age of majority 18 years old universal voting rights for all citizens
01:16:10 citizens as bruce said is a good standard that has been effective across many countries and many
01:16:17 constitutions all right well dennis let's see if you knock our socks off do you have a different
01:16:22 answer than the two gentlemen there no citizens reach the age of 18 you get to vote that's the
01:16:27 deal the one adder i put in is i think it should be a requirement to vote so i literally think of
01:16:34 i think australia does this you pay a hundred dollar fine if you don't show up to vote without
01:16:38 a you know reasonable excuse because i think that if we're going to depend on citizens uh deciding
01:16:44 how we want to run they sure the heck better not say i'm too tired i'm too lazy i can't be bothered
01:16:49 to vote yeah to be honest with you i kind of like that one as well um this rights and responsibilities
01:16:57 people keep forgetting that responsibility you won't be surprised if i don't but anyway
01:17:02 of course no force right no force in yours the first be with you um okay so uh here we go here's
01:17:09 Here's another one for a little bit more timely for the current system.
01:17:13 Would anyone's system allow floor crossing?
01:17:16 Let's go ahead and start with Dennis on this one.
01:17:19 So floor crossing is this construct in my mind of the Westminster system.
01:17:23 So I see it more as there is no such thing as floor crossing.
01:17:25 It's more about you vote in favor of a proposed law or action where you don't.
01:17:31 It doesn't, you belong to the party the same the day after as you did the day before.
01:17:36 okay and then matt floor crossing i think if in the westminster system it's true there is a room
01:17:45 for it if the uh person who's crossing the floor has truly consulted their constituents and it's
01:17:52 a matter of deep principle and not a brown paper bag or a skeleton in the closet there's actually
01:17:58 a room for someone churchill famously not only ratted but re-ratted uh based on principles so
01:18:05 i think there's room for it but it shouldn't be this shoddy shabby thing that we've just witnessed
01:18:10 and especially if a floor crossing leads to a change of majority that would actually be a cause
01:18:16 for the the king to step in and dissolve the government for an election because you've lost
01:18:21 or you've gained a majority not through the will of the people through an election but rather
01:18:25 through backroom dealing king charles are you listening king charles somebody clipped that
01:18:31 and it's home uh bruce your thoughts no i agree with dennis uh this is one of the flaws for me
01:18:37 of the westminster system if you're in a republican american type system where there's
01:18:42 a separation of of powers between executive and legislature in the in the american system
01:18:48 you know you can belong to one party and vote for or against the bill introduced by the other party
01:18:55 you're elected as as a representative to exercise your own judgment you do what you think is best
01:19:00 and then people will judge your voting record okay fair enough um this next one i think i i
01:19:07 know which is the smallest but let's see what the other two say as well um from healthy full
01:19:12 uh what model has the smallest government limits its future expansion and does not completely give
01:19:18 away monopolies on force let's go with bruce because i already know that answer i think
01:19:22 well mine's the smallest government and has the most limits on its future expansion
01:19:26 does not completely give away monopoly on force.
01:19:30 So let me just describe the way force works in my constitution.
01:19:37 The state can't use force.
01:19:39 It's one of the first rules, because if people are going to be free,
01:19:42 then the state can't be using force against it,
01:19:44 except that the state has to use force to enforce the rule against force, right?
01:19:51 Because if you don't enforce that rule, it's not a rule.
01:19:54 So if you have a law that says no one can use force, then the state needs to use its force to enforce that rule.
01:20:03 So we have not completely given away the monopoly on force.
01:20:07 A monopoly on force for that purpose is the thing that manages to keep the peace.
01:20:14 If you don't have that, then you have anarchy.
01:20:18 The only force is to enforce the use of force.
01:20:21 Okay, lots of forces in one sentence.
01:20:23 congratulations on that one uh dennis your thoughts there uh traditionally us a large
01:20:28 government right so uh how small could that government end up being and do they have uh
01:20:33 monopoly of force so uh definitely within the structure we're looking at it would be
01:20:39 there have the other controls within the constitution we see things for example like
01:20:43 a fixed percentage of the previous year's gdp as a control on spending to keep government from
01:20:50 growing but i also look at the example of texas in the us which has its own constitution its own
01:20:55 structures as they negotiated their way in after um us was formed and you sort of say let's put
01:21:02 some of those structures in place that actually prevent government from meeting too often but
01:21:07 they i think their rule is the government can only meet for so many weeks per year that's it
01:21:12 get your job done and otherwise wait until next year so i think we can put in some controls to
01:21:16 limit um limit the uh the the growth of government and the size of government as far as monopoly on
01:21:23 force this is where bruce and i do disagree i think there has to be some element of managerial
01:21:29 state in there that includes using force much the same way as i think he said and essentially
01:21:35 we can say look my neighbor wants to build a three-story purple chicken coop on their backyard
01:21:39 that's against the law the state is going to come in and remove it or get them to remove it so
01:21:44 there is some element of force in what we're doing. Yeah, you have something against chicken
01:21:49 coops. You said that on my episode as well. I'm not sure what the prejudice is. Maybe you like
01:21:53 pigs. I don't know. Matt, same question. Is there an element of force and how can you have smaller 0.98
01:21:59 government and stop the expansion? I think we do see a good example of this in the current Alberta
01:22:04 government. Albertans like smaller governments and, you know, you usually win when you say,
01:22:09 I'll make the government smaller. Sometimes at the same time, the government just goes ahead and
01:22:13 make something bigger but the ability is there to make the government as small as the electors want
01:22:19 and to limit its future expansion in alberta we see this the person who stands up and says i'm
01:22:25 going to tax you more and do more things usually we say yeah it's a bad idea uh and on the monopoly
01:22:31 of force i do believe government does have the monopoly on lawful force or not a total monopoly
01:22:37 but a like actually like bruce says the monopoly on who gets to have force and adjudicating that
01:22:43 so we should have the right to you know self-defense and these other things where we use
01:22:48 force as private individuals but there should be an adjudicator of that private force in the
01:22:53 government hence law and that goes back to the very dawn of time so in the westminster model it
01:22:59 is up to the electors how small and limited they want their government to be
01:23:03 all right um what i want to do now is i'm going to go to kathy and sorry to put your spot here
01:23:10 but kathy as you were sitting in the chat going through a bunch and then i'll go to pat and then
01:23:14 angela after was there some question or question that came up a lot that you'd like to bring
01:23:18 forward i got a lot more to go so i can keep going through the queue but was there something
01:23:22 that came up a few times while you were in the chat not the ones that i was watching no that
01:23:28 that aren't already here in the general chat that we have going on us ladies here
01:23:34 pretty much is is in there good so i would just keep going okay uh pat i actually think there's
01:23:41 one in here from you uh how about i go ahead and bring that up and then uh we'll address your
01:23:46 question right now so why do you believe a governor general or lieutenant governor is more
01:23:52 effective shield against tyranny than parties oversight branch which can subpoena and remove
01:23:58 corrupt officials uh directly so i guess this is for matt and then we could actually ask the other
01:24:03 two gentlemen to jump in on this one as well after so matt actually it's actually dennis's
01:24:07 oversight branch yes or dennis's yeah not parties can uh yeah i think the lieutenant governor is
01:24:16 more effective yeah uh governor general or lieutenant governor have that ability to fire
01:24:22 if so needed ministers of the crown or other people within that system for this exact reason
01:24:28 Why wait to subpoena them? Why not just fire them if they are? It's meant to be a last resort. It's meant to be the final tool that is used. I think the last time it was actually used was the 1970s in Australia. If I'm correct, Bruce can correct me on that. But it was used in a case where a prime minister refused to vacate his office despite losing an election and the voice of the people.
01:24:54 so there the governor general said you're gone buddy it was as simple as that so it's actually
01:24:59 easier than with a subpoena system or any other sort of thing they just fired them
01:25:05 all right and then dennis will come to you because you're the one that has the oversight branch why
01:25:11 do you think that's more effective than a governor general and lieutenant governor
01:25:14 so so actually the whole concept of the oversight branch came from a discussion between matt and
01:25:19 myself around he was pushing the role of governor general and so forth for the very function he just
01:25:25 described we thought about and talked about it and sort of what i concluded is you need that
01:25:31 final check and balance to get rid of someone that's misbehaving in some fashion so the difference
01:25:40 is i don't trust individuals i actually want to have you know a formal process a grand jury or a
01:25:48 group of people to look at this and look at the evidence and say yes in fact dennis you're a bad
01:25:52 dude out you go rather than depending upon the whim of a governor general governor general or
01:25:58 lieutenant general witness the last two governor generals we've had even the last three or four 0.99
01:26:03 and i go man we're getting some awfully stupid ones i don't see a protection against that 0.98
01:26:08 and then bruce is your position none of the above and if so why 0.98
01:26:12 none of the above none of the above here's why checks and balances are are kind of nice in
01:26:21 theory and sometimes they work but sometimes they don't work a lot of the times they don't work and
01:26:27 they don't work at precisely the moment you need them the most and i think again one of the best
01:26:32 examples of this is covid you didn't have an oversight branch during covid but if you had
01:26:37 would the oversight branch have been different than the other three branches you already have
01:26:42 the legislature the bureaucracy the courts the problem is this when you have checks and balances
01:26:49 inside a single beast that is the state what often happens as is happening today
01:26:56 is that all of those branches which are checks and balances in theory on each other they all
01:27:04 basically are on the same page about the big picture question sure they have their disputes
01:27:10 and quarrels. But in the big picture, they all were on the same page on the necessity for the
01:27:18 state to govern society and keep people safe with the measures that were introduced during COVID.
01:27:24 And none of them would step out and say, no, no, this is wrong. And if you are giving the final
01:27:30 authority to some other branch inside the state to do the same thing, then again, all you're doing
01:27:36 is moving power around you're making the buck stop here instead of here or here or here you
01:27:42 have still not done the most important thing which is to say sorry this is not for you this is for
01:27:50 the individual people out there and you have no jurisdiction to make these calls in the first
01:27:55 place okay fantastic question there pet um angela did you have a question want to throw in here at
01:28:02 this stage or just move on to the next one yeah actually i do so i noticed in the chat
01:28:06 so there was a lot of reaction to the idea of remaining under the crown and so my question is
01:28:13 for matthew how would this actually benefit us as albertans to remain under the crown what does that
01:28:21 do for us so the crown provides us a locus of ultimate authority that is not political
01:28:29 and that does not exercise day-to-day power in other words you can be loyal to them fiercely 0.98
01:28:35 loyal and you can still hate the government's guts and think the prime minister is a doofhead
01:28:41 and both are permitted at the same time it provides us with those ultimate reserve powers
01:28:46 that don't rest or vest authority ultimate in the government as a permanent institution rather the
01:28:53 government comes and goes it is dissolved and reconstituted and there is that sense that
01:28:59 government is not eternal or like bruce said this state that is this ultimate thing that
01:29:04 is above all other things so it protects us from that uh and it avoids the whims of a government
01:29:11 because at the end of the day you have this person who is a thinking feeling human being
01:29:17 who theoretically and i would argue actually with the majority of our kings and queens of the past
01:29:22 care for their people and and are able to help them just one little point with the queen bless
01:29:28 her heart i loved her to death uh she would go in as she was going on walkabout into the store 0.74
01:29:34 to look at the price of goods because she wanted to know what her people were being charged for
01:29:40 food because of course she had people to get her food she cared enough to look at the little 0.93
01:29:45 details to stop and hear the little people and having someone like that who is the father or
01:29:51 the mother of the nation as it were who is disconnected from the daily grind of the
01:29:56 political process provides us a locus for ceremonial and for unity all right um and
01:30:05 something to look at on your dollar bills as well so bruce said check and balances a few times and
01:30:10 the next one is a different type of check and balance uh so dave annis or five to six who
01:30:17 represents 4 525 other dave annis is out there um his question is how does your constitution
01:30:24 strictly for prohibit fiat money printing and the resulting erosion of citizen purchasing power
01:30:30 337 million was printed in february 2026 eroding wealth wow none of that ended up here uh let's
01:30:37 start with bruce on that one great question great question it's important that the state not have
01:30:42 power to do that and that's exactly what i'm describing right so in this flipping the default
01:30:47 thing the state has the power to do nothing except what's the list if the list is keep the peace
01:30:57 resolve disputes protect the country one of the things that's not in that list is printing money
01:31:04 having a central bank setting interest rates having monetary policies it has no power to do
01:31:12 any of those things it cannot be done there is no policy there will be no legislation it is outside
01:31:18 the the limits of what the state is empowered to do period okay dennis yeah i mean while i agree
01:31:29 conceptually with with what bruce wrote the reality is we need money we need means of exchange
01:31:34 and we don't want to have everyone wanting running around with piles of gold or diamonds or
01:31:38 whatever arguing what's worth what so you do need a method of exchange and that's called money now
01:31:45 the fiat money problem is a different one because going off the gold standard for example way back
01:31:50 when was one of the larger mistakes in our histories so within things like the value of
01:31:54 freedom we put in thing put in the aspect that the currency must be backed now do we put that
01:32:00 in the constitution perhaps yes perhaps no but that is the the concept is that the fiat currency
01:32:07 doesn't exist it's this represents so much oil so much precious mineral so much whatever and
01:32:14 we can't issue more currency until we have more of those other precious things of real value
01:32:20 and i think that's the control we could put in fiat currency is is a curse on our on our worlds
01:32:25 for sure and matt the king or queen's all over the currency so how does this work for you
01:32:30 gotta love it a central bank and a currency are important to any modern economy just look all the
01:32:37 great economies have them for a reason but it is true a fiat currency that is unbacked by any sort
01:32:44 of real tangible wealth whether it be commodities gold silver is going to be one that erodes the
01:32:50 wealth of people because it is inflationary now you can avoid that chiefly in statute like i say
01:32:56 keep the constitution small and the statutes do the work but you have to limit the right of the
01:33:02 government to print its way out of its money problems and that comes down to going back to
01:33:07 the last question the limitation of the size of government and the role of government into areas
01:33:13 that they should be and the people saying if you go into those other areas you're going to have a
01:33:18 problem okay and as we get into this next question here um suna soul silver has any country ever
01:33:28 tried bruce's suggestion of government i've honestly never heard of this type of government
01:33:32 before so bruce one for you bud right not to my knowledge never been tried in the real world i
01:33:39 mean lots of people have talked about the various ways that one might achieve an actually free
01:33:45 country uh but in the real world no because there are too many vested interests who are determined
01:33:53 not to do it this way here's one of the problems there's going to be great resistance to this kind
01:33:58 of a model for the very reason if i may put it this way for the very reason is that it would work
01:34:05 it would work to to prevent the accumulation of both political and economic power at at the top
01:34:14 levels of the of the architecture right so no it has not been done has not been done
01:34:20 this is i mean i'd like to think that this is one of those moments where it's possible to
01:34:27 contemplate but if it's not to be then it's not to be all right and this is one of the things
01:34:34 you've said many times if you're going to make a change make a big one make it worthwhile if you're
01:34:39 going to if you're going to go where you've never gone you have to do what you have never done
01:34:43 it sounds like star trek to be honest with you um okay so question out here from matthew
01:34:50 oh sorry pat you wanted to ask something there i saw a hand up there yeah sorry just before we
01:34:55 move on to another question my question then for you is because in theory i very much like your
01:35:02 idea but in practice i feel that especially given the generations of the nanny nanny state
01:35:10 not enough canadians even not enough albertans are able to make that leap right away it's kind
01:35:17 of like jumping off the cliff and my question is would there be a potential where we could start
01:35:23 off with something in the middle like dennis and then have a kind of timeout phase of five or ten
01:35:31 years where we get the people to get used to the idea,
01:35:36 but also to start taking the responsibility needed in order
01:35:39 to actually put this theory in practice.
01:35:42 It's a great question.
01:35:46 It reminded me of an old saying.
01:35:48 It goes like this, in theory, there's
01:35:51 no difference between theory and practice.
01:35:54 But in practice, of course, there is.
01:35:56 uh i think the answer to your question a very good question is no that that's not going to happen
01:36:04 i don't think this is the kind of thing that can be done incrementally for the reasons that you
01:36:10 allude to it's very difficult to do at all it's the kind of thing that has to be done cold turkey
01:36:16 in a moment where everything is on its edge so for example the americans did something
01:36:23 extraordinary and their constitution is not the one that i'm describing but they did for their
01:36:29 time something as different as what i'm describing for this moment and they needed that crisis
01:36:36 for it to happen if they had waited and they said we're going to just reproduce what we have
01:36:43 from britain we're just going to keep the westminster system we're going to keep everything
01:36:46 except maybe not pledge to the king and we'll fix it later on do we think that you know 50 years
01:36:53 after that they would have sat down and said you know folks it's time now to change over
01:36:57 to a completely different thing well no because by then the interests in america will have will
01:37:04 have gathered under the system you established and it will be impossible so this is only possible to
01:37:11 to contemplate because you're making a break with what you have and if you don't do it now
01:37:17 won't happen another way to look at this one pet is um can you move out of your parents house but
01:37:25 go back for dinner and laundry or can you be married and single at the same time a little
01:37:30 difficult a little difficult sometimes you just have to make that leap of faith and get her done
01:37:33 i'm thinking that we build it into the new system like okay you've got five years to get used to
01:37:39 this and then the band-aid comes off well you can't do it that way you could do it that way you
01:37:44 you you could decide on the new system and say fine we're going to have this system looks like
01:37:49 this we're going to have you know a a five years ten years long transition period from one to the
01:37:56 other that might work because then you know what you're going to fine yeah but it can't be
01:38:02 incremental with like growth you have to establish it at the beginning i think is his big point there
01:38:07 yes uh matthew here's one for you now question for matthew thank you alberta nan for independence
01:38:13 Why is the constitutional monarchy model best suited for long-term unity in a newly formed independent Alberta when it has failed in Canada?
01:38:23 It hasn't failed. Canada has failed. And that's not because of the system.
01:38:28 If we had a republic, we'd be in the same situation.
01:38:30 The problem is that we have at least four different cultures and nations trying to unite across a vast continent under one system.
01:38:39 No matter what the system is, it's just too big.
01:38:43 so it's not the issue of you know the king somehow having affected our lives no he hasn't really it
01:38:49 isn't even that the legislature is so bad we voted you're you know the majority in the east voted in
01:38:56 the people who have made all these changes it's because we are not able to have our voice heard
01:39:02 and even if we had a republican model we still would have had our voice not heard so we fix it
01:39:08 by cutting off ottawa not by making dramatic changes to the very foundation of all that we
01:39:14 have it's so so simple get rid of the thing that's causing the problem and don't get rid of anything
01:39:20 else then if there's further problems you go okay we need to change here we need to change there
01:39:25 that's actually the westminster tradition is you do have the living tree and an adjustment that
01:39:30 can be made as you need to but start slow cut cut off the gangrene and then see if you have to cut
01:39:36 off the whole leg and then uh thank you and then back to pet a little bit there so i guess you can
01:39:43 be single and married it's called engagement so you know when the wedding date is so under that
01:39:48 model you're eventually going to get that marriage and get her done um let's go to dennis there's one
01:39:53 here for dennis so dennis what about globalists that prepare one person after another even with
01:39:59 your term limits so interference uh in the process i mean i'll be real clear there is
01:40:08 limited ways a constitution can block every last possible ill and i don't care which one
01:40:15 of the three you look at here what we require more than anything is an informed knowledgeable
01:40:23 electorate who are keeping their eyes open one of things i am i lament frequently is that
01:40:28 the average Albertan doesn't even know how they're governed today they don't know what the rules are
01:40:34 they don't the constitution is they don't know anything and if we continue down that vein yeah
01:40:39 then nefarious people like the globalists will come in and say yeah we'll just fool around with
01:40:44 your system we'll stack in our candidates one after the other and you actually know better off
01:40:49 than you are today so if citizens don't take that responsibility seriously none of these systems
01:40:56 will work oh i think mine will mine will because mine will because there's no power to wield or
01:41:02 very little power to wield the globalists are not going to want to infiltrate my government because
01:41:06 the governments don't do anything i mean there's no point you can't lobby somebody who has no power
01:41:11 and there's no in being a member of the legislature in my kind of country is kind of like why would
01:41:17 you want to do that you're kind of wasting your time so and it will also force the public to very
01:41:23 quickly become responsible and knowledgeable yes yes correct exactly so yeah and matt you want to
01:41:30 throw your head in on this one uh because you actually have a head of state and is it also
01:41:34 going to be hereditary is the next king or queen going to come from the offspring of the current
01:41:40 one yeah i'd just like to say elections are not always the answer uh it's good to have heredity
01:41:46 because then you know there's no reason to politic right hey let's try and get our candidate for the
01:41:52 king. Well, it's whoever is the son of that person is going to be the king. So what are you going to
01:41:57 do? You can't manipulate it. Elections provide for an industry and interests to build their
01:42:05 own strategies to win elections. I was just sitting in a campaign thing where I was learning
01:42:10 how, quite frankly, to manipulate voters, you know, because someone was teaching. They said
01:42:15 more nicely than that but you're teaching people how to use the system to maximize your vote and
01:42:23 minimize the other guy's vote so elections don't guarantee protection that is the people the
01:42:29 populace just what dennis said we need people who are going to think um bruce said it we all agree
01:42:35 on this point who are willing to act and who are willing to be involved in their government
01:42:39 okay um next question for all uh back to prairie uh cossack all countries that adopt
01:42:48 universal voting rights are plagued by vote buying uninformed voting and voting on a short-term
01:42:54 appetite prove me wrong bruce you want to try to tackle that one first oh i wouldn't want to prove
01:43:00 you're wrong i think that's true but the point of my architecture is that it doesn't really matter
01:43:06 that much because the legislature you elect is not going to be doing any fundamental things the
01:43:11 fundamental things are already set out in the constitution as are the limits to the power of
01:43:16 the legislature itself and it's going to attract people so so one of the things one thing is that
01:43:23 one of the things that dennis and i have in common in these models is is term limits for everybody
01:43:27 but my term limit goes like this everybody who has any role in the state in any capacity whether
01:43:35 it's a legislator like a politician a bureaucrat a judge an ambassador a receptionist a consultant
01:43:43 can only work for the state for you know pick a number six to eight years total in their over
01:43:48 their lifetime so if you are a politician for eight years you can thereafter not be a judge
01:43:53 not be an ambassador not be a consultant moreover those people who work for the state
01:43:59 all of them will be paid the median national wage the median national wage in other words
01:44:08 working for the state in any capacity is no way to get power and it is no way to get rich
01:44:13 so you're going to have trouble finding people to do it and who cares about the election you're
01:44:19 going to have people sitting in the chamber with nothing to do okay and then let's go to
01:44:25 dennis next on this one how would you address this if well i mean well i don't think you'd
01:44:31 be proven wrong i think uh bruce has some of the the insight required in the sense that
01:44:37 you know we have to teach our electorate we have to make it not desirable to be in government
01:44:44 a long time there's no big money to be made i mean where he and i differ is not on term limits
01:44:50 uh as a concept but i just say look you do need professionals who can deal with complex things
01:44:57 i come from large united body of work you cannot bring a guy in at the lowest bidder
01:45:03 some guy's going to make 500 bucks an hour doing something he's not going to come to the government
01:45:06 a competent person won't come in for do it for 50. so we have to find a way to somehow
01:45:11 differentiate between the folks that actually wield power so the elected officials the top
01:45:17 level bureaucrats away from the people that are doing the day-to-day work that need to be paid
01:45:23 a competitive wage because you need that skill set and that talent so that's the way i see it
01:45:28 okay then matt i'll throw this question to you as well because there is no term limits you can
01:45:33 have lifelong appointments uh what do you say i think it is important that everybody not be
01:45:39 elected that's why there should actually be appointments that are serious one of the problems
01:45:44 that we had with pierre trudeau and his ilk is they deliberately appointed uh less than bright
01:45:49 people because they wanted to destroy the senate and the crown as legitimate and so they appoint
01:45:57 you know whatever kind of dingbat they can find who can't actually do the job and is who's going
01:46:01 to embarrass the office so appoint good people to those things that can then ensure that they
01:46:07 hold the elected side to account so that the vote buying uninformed voting and voting on a short-term
01:46:13 appetite can't take over the system okay uh question we got two more questions for all and
01:46:21 then we'll start to wrap up so frank asks what is the size of government still 87 mlas let's go
01:46:27 ahead and start with dennis on this one don't have a specific number in mind i think it's uh 87 feels
01:46:34 pretty big for me um i tend to think of something like 40 senators 40 mlas or mps whatever you call
01:46:42 them um because i'd like to see the size of government being small i don't think many things
01:46:47 are improved by having many many voices in the room arguing their points okay and then matt we'll
01:46:54 go to you next and then bruce at the end here uh i think representation by population means you have
01:47:01 to have a fair number because otherwise if you have one person representing 150 000 people it's
01:47:06 just stupid you can't do that so you have to have a large enough house that when we say representative
01:47:11 they truly are representative and on the senate side i actually just in my little personal bna 1.00
01:47:17 set it at 50 members that were divided among the counties and the cities of alberta just as a way
01:47:23 to have enough people that again they represent their part geographically of the province but
01:47:29 again it's not set in stone on that you'd have to think it through more carefully than i did
01:47:35 okay and bruce how would you split it up yeah i'd prefer something smaller but i would imagine
01:47:41 two chambers one elected by population and the other elected by geographical territory so that
01:47:47 you counterbalance the distorting effects of concentration of population other than that 87
01:47:53 might be too many for one chamber but i'm i'm i don't know what the exact number should be
01:47:59 okay and you kind of just you have this power bruce like you know what's coming up uh so i'm
01:48:05 going to still bring it up um how often dave asks how do you make sure the urban centers don't use
01:48:10 their tiny uh their majority to impose their will on rural areas we'll start with you bruce
01:48:16 because you kind of just answered that and then we'll get to matt then dennis yeah yeah you have
01:48:20 you have two chambers and if you have one of those chambers elected by geographical territory
01:48:25 that is you know one or two senators let's call them to be elected to the senate based upon
01:48:31 square footage in the territory and the same size of each territory then you completely offset any
01:48:38 distorting effects of population okay and i just noticed that we're losing matthew shortly so let
01:48:44 me just kind of get to the last one and then we'll start to wrap up with you matthew uh let me go
01:48:48 ahead and get this one off um okay so i just had it let me just go get it question for all uh if
01:48:57 the party system if there's a party system do we abolish whipped votes for representatives to truly
01:49:02 speak for their constituents so the party really controlling the representatives let's start with
01:49:07 Matt, on this one.
01:49:08 I think there is a limited role for whipped votes.
01:49:11 I like, actually, the UK Parliament in this,
01:49:13 where the backbenchers have a lot more autonomy and independence
01:49:16 than they do in Canada, where every vote feels like a whipped vote
01:49:20 and they're all just kind of trained SEALs, if you say it in a mean way.
01:49:24 So I would want fewer whipped votes, but I wouldn't want to abolish them
01:49:28 because if a government's trying to get its agenda through,
01:49:30 it can't have some rogue MP stopping them.
01:49:33 okay matt if you have to run we won't take that as you bowing out of this conversation we know
01:49:39 that you have a schedule so i will move to dennis's on this one party lines they seem to be
01:49:44 pretty solid lately yeah i don't like whipped votes at all i think that there's gonna be some
01:49:49 natural congregation of people to say hey let's all vote this way or that way but i don't see it
01:49:55 across party lines you take the case by case basis of a group of people who like an idea or want to
01:50:02 pursue an idea will they whip themselves to do it for that particular piece of legislation fine
01:50:09 but i don't see a party saying okay dennis you must vote for this because otherwise bad things
01:50:15 happen don't like it okay and bruce if you can answer this one quickly we might be able to get
01:50:20 to matt's closing so because we'll go to that next uh what are your thoughts sure i'm not a great fan
01:50:25 of whip votes but but the but the whip votes happen more frequently in westminster systems
01:50:31 because it's more likely to be a vote that might take down the government.
01:50:34 So if you don't want to lose power, you have to whip your votes.
01:50:38 So that doesn't occur in different kinds of systems
01:50:41 where there isn't the same liability in losing control of the agenda.
01:50:48 Okay, great job.
01:50:49 So, Matt, we're going to go to you first,
01:50:51 so you can do your closing comments,
01:50:53 and then if you have to take off, you take off.
01:50:56 Yeah, I would say first, both Bruce and Dennis are awesome and friends,
01:51:00 which i appreciate and they think deeply and they show us what can be done when we all think when
01:51:07 we all weigh these questions out not as a debate to score points but as helping people to be
01:51:13 educated and to understand so i'd say we have capable people we have smart people we have
01:51:20 knowledgeable people let's get informed and think and then on the other side of independence it's
01:51:26 not a scary unknown, but it's a practical thing that we can look forward and see a way to the
01:51:33 future. Let's look and see how we can make a better province and a better country out of
01:51:40 independence through all of these things. Hear, hear. So I'm the king of this podcast. I'm going
01:51:46 to pirogue you now, Matt. So if you need to leave, you can leave. But thank you very much for being
01:51:51 appreciate you have a good one thanks matt uh dennis uh kind of closing comments what do you
01:51:58 have for us i i echo a lot of what matt says i consider both bruce and matt's friends people
01:52:05 whose opinions i treasure and value and um what really matters to me is that all three perspectives
01:52:13 actually share a very important and common concern and we all understand that freedom
01:52:18 isn't preserved just by
01:52:20 good intentions. It only survives
01:52:23 where durable institutions make
01:52:24 abuses of power
01:52:26 difficult, visible, and reversible,
01:52:28 even if they're small the way Bruce sees it.
01:52:31 And the disagreement amongst
01:52:32 us is not whether power is dangerous.
01:52:34 We all agree it is. The disagreement
01:52:36 is how best to restrain it.
01:52:39 And that's my view.
01:52:41 And Bruce,
01:52:42 closing comments, and then we'll kind of start to wrap up.
01:52:44 But yeah, take your time.
01:52:46 I completely agree as well.
01:52:48 And one of the fantastic things about this moment in Alberta is that I can talk to people like Dennis and Matthew about these things in a serious way, in a way that is, you know, has potential real world implications as opposed to sitting in some dry academic chamber and talking about it theoretically.
01:53:07 So my hat's off to both of them for engaging in this and putting forward their ideas.
01:53:12 It's been a treat to get to know both of them and a treat to be on this podcast.
01:53:17 So thank you very much.
01:53:19 It's certainly all of our pleasure.
01:53:20 We enjoyed it.
01:53:21 And you certainly got a lot of people thinking, Bruce, about yours because there's nothing to look at and say, hey, look, they did great.
01:53:29 But I really like your comment there.
01:53:30 Like, it's so good, they don't want it.
01:53:33 So we don't see it anywhere around.
01:53:35 That's kind of an interesting argument there.
01:53:38 One of my favorite ice creams growing up, and sorry if I say this wrong, but Napoleon, Napoleon, was a strawberry, chocolate, and vanilla because I like a little bit of all of them.
01:53:47 So, Kathy, I'm actually going to come to you next.
01:53:50 Do you see pieces of all of these that you actually like?
01:53:52 And maybe there's a way to kind of create something very different here.
01:53:58 The one that I really have trouble with is with is with Matt, with the Westminster system.
01:54:04 I just it hasn't worked.
01:54:06 I've everybody knows what I'm going around doing my speeches.
01:54:09 It's to bring that education piece as to how we became a province.
01:54:13 And I have never, ever seen it work to our advantage.
01:54:16 So even in a smaller setting in the country of Alberta, I just can't see how there's not going to be one part of the of the country of Alberta that's left out because of the way that it's that it's set up in the Westminster system.
01:54:29 But I'm willing to be proven wrong. I really like what Bruce says.
01:54:34 I'm libertarian, too. So get out of my way. Let me live my life and and let's go on.
01:54:39 And if you do me wrong, we'll do something about it.
01:54:41 But at the same time, Dennis says, you know, he comes in as that measured voice, bringing kind of the two sides together.
01:54:47 That is probably much more palpable for Albertans to be able to wrap their heads around.
01:54:52 So, again, this is why we just have to keep having these conversations so that Albertans go to that referendum, very educated as to what they're saying yes or no to.
01:55:03 And then, more importantly, to the Constitutional Convention that will follow, knowing exactly what's before them and what they're saying yes or no to.
01:55:11 so i just really appreciate this conversation and i look forward to doing it again
01:55:16 fantastic uh angela same question do you think there's a piece of each one of them that you like
01:55:20 or are you just a chocolate vanilla type of gallon forget that strawberry from the crown
01:55:26 yeah i do i honestly do have a hard time um understanding the importance of the crown or
01:55:33 what value it would bring to us um and again like kathy i am um libertarian um leaning for sure um
01:55:44 i like what bruce has to say and i i think it was it's going to take a lot of education to get
01:55:52 albertans to to be able to envision that and to understand that uh what what he is pointing out
01:55:59 um and so if we don't get to that point that kind of leaves us with denisis which would not
01:56:04 necessarily be a bad thing at all i can see a lot of good in it i really do believe that the cure to
01:56:10 what ails us is to have a very active and informed electorate which is why we're having these
01:56:18 discussions and these conversations and why we're inviting folks like if you haven't had a chance to
01:56:23 go and look at the six previous episodes please do you'll find a list of them on our on our facebook
01:56:30 and on our x pages because um we definitely need folks who are informed and and able to
01:56:37 feel confident when they stand in that polling booth and and check that box yeah i don't want
01:56:43 to freak anybody out but it may be one of the most important non-family and personal related
01:56:48 question you ever answer so making sure you're informed on it pet same question can we take
01:56:53 pieces of each of it or are you going to throw out one all together too i think we're going to have
01:56:59 to and uh i think it's no surprise to anybody that in terms of a westminster system it's just
01:57:06 a non-starter and i actually disagree with a couple of things matthew said the uk is a small
01:57:12 country smaller than the land mass of alberta and how well is that going there um and the crown is
01:57:19 not of no consequence because through the governor general the crown controls the military and the
01:57:27 government and so i don't agree with that whatsoever um i'll be honest i'm i'm a bruce party gal
01:57:37 however i don't think that our population as a whole is prepared for that i don't think they'll
01:57:43 go for it and in that sense that's why i asked my question which is can we start with the middle
01:57:52 and put term limits on that and decide in five or ten years you need to get on your feet get used to
01:58:00 the idea of not having a nanny state do everything for you and have a plan for incrementally i am
01:58:08 my background's in behavioral science so we need to incrementally you know properly positively
01:58:15 reinforce people to get them on board um so that's that's kind of my idea and in terms of
01:58:21 the common thread where we need an educated and engaged citizenry rather than either precluding
01:58:30 people from voting or mandating that everyone should vote maybe there should be a test
01:58:38 that you need to pass before you vote which will be educational and you know get you up to speed
01:58:48 before you're making such decisions for your fellow citizens and yourself
01:58:53 should the first question be can you name your representative now
01:58:56 we got about 30 seconds and we're going to lose the stream so i'm going to have to wrap up on
01:59:03 that point and i actually think there's a lot more support than you would think for that kind of
01:59:08 thinking pat so thank you very much to matt for being here uh as well it's a tough position to
01:59:14 take is you're fighting uphill battle because there's a lot of resentment and jadedness because
01:59:20 we're currently in that system uh dennis thank you so much for sharing yours as well i think a
01:59:24 a lot of people understand it they get it and then bruce i think we have to keep talking about
01:59:29 yours some more because if there's a lot of support for it you might be able to see that
01:59:33 radical shift to make this all worthwhile kathy pat angela you all rock but thank you all very
01:59:38 much for being here tonight i appreciate it make sure you share it out there's multiple places you
01:59:42 can find us so share it out follow everybody involved and i definitely want to make sure
01:59:46 that you guys all understand that i love you all very much and god bless thank you jason