John Bolton - May 14, 2026


Be Proud - Without Struggle There Is No Progress - We Will Win!

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Court Rules Against The Petition - Mitch Sylvestre Responds I Asked, You Responded (Your Emails Analyzed) - We Need A Plan

Episode Stats


Length

10 minutes

Words per minute

175.84

Word count

1,785

Sentence count

130

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

A judge threw out the Alberta Separatist Party's bid for a referendum on independence from Canada. What does this mean for the future of Alberta's sovereignty? Is there still a chance for a vote on independence?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hi, it's John and welcome to the channel Thursday, May 14th, 4.56 a.m. I hope you're having
00:00:08 a great start to your Thursday. I appreciate you being here and I do tip the big blue mug
00:00:12 of coffee to you today. I went to bed last night and I slept soundly. I woke up this
00:00:19 morning thinking about the court decision yesterday, which ruled against the Alberta
00:00:23 independence movement. I did a video with Mitch Sylvester yesterday. He was gracious
00:00:27 enough to speak with me. Minutes after this ruling came down, court rules against the petition.
00:00:33 Mitch Sylvester responds, is the vote in jeopardy? Well, is it? I've got a clip in just a moment from
00:00:40 Keith Wilson, who did a fantastic video yesterday. Link in the description. I would suggest you go
00:00:45 watch the whole thing. But I'm going to let Mitch have the final say in this video, which isn't
00:00:49 going to be very long. Without revealing everything it's about, because I was concerned about one
00:00:55 thing in particular. Mitch says, be proud and you should be proud. Now watching Keith, the thing I
00:01:01 got out of Keith's video, other than reassurance, which was very important for me, was the fact that
00:01:08 there really isn't democracy in this province if we have this decision that stands. Danielle Smith
00:01:14 is going to appeal it, a short clip from her in just a moment. We don't have democracy 1.00
00:01:19 if this decision stands. Think of it this way. A group of people in this province have asked
00:01:25 something of their government, not a lawyer. I'm breaking it down to that simplistic thing.
00:01:31 We're asking something of our government. And if a few native chiefs don't like it,
00:01:36 we have to ask them for permission first. Is that democracy? No, it's not.
00:01:42 i also was thinking about frederick douglas this morning and a quote from him frederick douglas
00:01:51 likely the most important person fighting for civil rights in the 19th century
00:01:56 he was an abolitionist he was a black man and he was known to say agitate agitate agitate is that
00:02:03 what we're doing in the alberta independence movement i suppose it is i suppose we're
00:02:08 agitating. We're certainly agitating when it comes to the forever Canada or forever Canadian
00:02:13 people. But here's a complete quote from Frederick Douglass, and I think we should
00:02:17 take this to heart. If there is no struggle, there is no progress. Those who profess to favor freedom
00:02:25 and yet deprecate agitation are men who want crops without plowing the ground. Mitch said
00:02:31 in the interview with him yesterday, we knew this was going to be hard. It was going to be a struggle
00:02:35 and we have to continue struggling to get what we want.
00:02:40 There are people in this province who do not want us to have democracy
00:02:44 and that would be the head, Nenshi.
00:02:46 And for those people who don't live in Alberta,
00:02:48 he is the head of the Alberta NDP.
00:02:50 Here's what he tweeted and this is just a little bit of his tweet.
00:02:54 I don't want to bore you to death.
00:02:55 Today, a judge has thrown out the Alberta separatist petition
00:02:58 because Danielle Smith's UCP government failed
00:03:01 in its legal duty to consult First Nations.
00:03:04 Mr. Nenshi seems to think that we have to ask First Nations for permission in this province, for everything.
00:03:10 Is that what he's going to do if he ever becomes premier, God forbid?
00:03:15 So I am reassured by what Keith Wilson said in his video yesterday.
00:03:20 And here's a short clip from Keith. I think you'll be reassured as well.
00:03:24 Citizens should have the right in a democracy to petition their government,
00:03:30 to bring an issue to their government and say,
00:03:34 we would like you to look at this issue.
00:03:37 That's all the petition was doing.
00:03:40 And the court said no.
00:03:42 Well, the good news is it doesn't matter what the court said here
00:03:47 because the decision has no reach, is very narrow, is very technical,
00:03:55 and in no way limits the authority and the right of the cabinet, the provincial cabinet,
00:04:04 to issue an order in council announcing that there will be a question on independence
00:04:12 in the October 19th referendum.
00:04:15 I think you feel reassured as well after hearing that.
00:04:18 Keith has been very consistent in this.
00:04:21 Last year, he was saying there will be a vote on independence this year.
00:04:25 What does this mean for Danielle Smith?
00:04:26 Well, there's 300,000 people right now who have their names written on petitions sitting at Elections Alberta
00:04:32 who want her to call a vote in a referendum for Alberta independence.
00:04:37 And the pressure is on her.
00:04:39 She said yesterday the government will appeal.
00:04:42 Our government does support Alberta remaining in Canada.
00:04:45 We think that today's decision by the court will deny opportunity to well over 300,000 Albertans
00:04:51 to have their petition verified by Elections Alberta.
00:04:54 we think that this decision is incorrect in law and anti-democratic and we will be appealing it
00:05:02 as a result our cabinet and caucus will of course be meeting in the next couple of days to discuss
00:05:08 the full context and make some decisions after we've had a chance to talk it through whatever
00:05:12 you might think about danielle smith she's against us when it comes to independence but thank you
00:05:17 madam premier for fighting for our right to ask this question thank you very much the pressure
00:05:23 is certainly on her and a lot of people are speculating what might come. I'm not going to
00:05:28 get into that right now. I did speak to Mitch yesterday and Mitch wasn't surprised by what
00:05:34 happened. Again, I'll put the card up at the end so you can watch the whole thing. He wasn't
00:05:38 surprised. I wasn't surprised. Mr. Albertan sent me a text message yesterday. As soon as this came
00:05:43 down, I called it. People knew this was going to happen, that we weren't going to get a favorable
00:05:48 decision yesterday, but there was one thing that I was terribly concerned about when this happened
00:05:54 yesterday. I was thinking about the people who went out starting just after the beginning of
00:06:00 the new year, and they sat out in snowdrifts and collected these signatures, how disappointed they
00:06:05 would be that those signatures were not going to be counted, and I asked Mitch about that,
00:06:10 and Mitch was rather reassuring as well. Now, what I'm concerned about, and I'm sure a lot of people
00:06:16 who worked very hard over four months.
00:06:19 You saw those boxes when you handed them in.
00:06:21 You had a big grin on your face, those people sitting in the snow.
00:06:24 What happens to the signatures?
00:06:26 They were sealed up.
00:06:27 They're sitting at Elections Alberta.
00:06:28 For all I know, you counted them, thank God.
00:06:31 We know there's over 300,000 signatures there.
00:06:33 Are these going to be destroyed, all that work,
00:06:36 and never be counted because of this judge's decision?
00:06:40 Well, I don't think you should look at it that way.
00:06:42 Okay.
00:06:42 I think that what happened when we collected 301,000 signatures is we showed the premier and the UCP government that there's 301,000 Albertans that are prepared.
00:06:54 And I believe the number is actually real.
00:06:56 I know that the number is actually real.
00:06:59 Our process was very stringent.
00:07:01 I wouldn't be surprised if there was any attrition in those signatures.
00:07:04 They had to be signed by the person that was actually signing the paper to authorize that they were actually there.
00:07:11 They have to be vetted according to living in Alberta or not, their age.
00:07:17 And they had to have a physical address.
00:07:19 And then the canvasser had to sign off on it.
00:07:21 So there's lots of steps there.
00:07:23 But the way you have to see this is that you all showed up, you participated, you did the
00:07:28 work, and you told the Premier of Alberta, look, there's 301,000 people that have the
00:07:33 courage to sign this petition.
00:07:35 That number is not going to change whether they destroy it or not.
00:07:39 That number is the message.
00:07:42 And, you know, they play around with it and say, well, we need it.
00:07:45 They asked for $177,000 to trigger the referendum vote.
00:07:49 They got $301,000.
00:07:50 So our premier, right from the beginning, was going to be tasked with making this call.
00:07:55 And you've showed her, in a large way, that you want to vote on Alberta independence.
00:07:59 So don't ever despair and say that all the work that we've done was for naught.
00:08:03 It was totally not for naught.
00:08:05 This would not be happening without that.
00:08:07 And so you should all continue to be proud of yourselves, as proud of yourselves as we all are, for all the work that went into that.
00:08:14 And, you know, it's not for naught at all.
00:08:16 As a matter of fact, like I said, I'll repeat it.
00:08:18 Without that, we don't have a chance moving forward.
00:08:21 You should continue to be proud.
00:08:24 And whether or not those signatures are officially counted by Elections Alberta,
00:08:28 it will be your hard work over the last four months that will eventually get us to a question on a ballot on Alberta independence in October.
00:08:36 And again, I am reassured by what Keith Wilson says.
00:08:39 Mitch also said in that interview, I think he said,
00:08:41 we're going to have the mother of all rallies, so stay tuned.
00:08:45 We'll let you know when that happens.
00:08:46 I'm looking forward to being part of that.
00:08:49 Going back to the Frederick Douglass quote,
00:08:51 if there is no struggle, there is no progress.
00:08:55 And are we agitating?
00:08:57 Is the Alberta independence movement agitating?
00:09:00 Again, the other side would probably think that we are.
00:09:04 But I can assure you, Madam Premier, if we don't get a question on a ballot in October, there will be plenty of agitation.
00:09:15 I want to update you on something.
00:09:18 The other day I asked you to participate and contact me.
00:09:23 I need your help. I wanted to get your thoughts on Alberta independence.
00:09:27 And I wanted you to put in the subject line of my email address, my thoughts on independence.
00:09:34 And boy, did you send me email, 300 emails.
00:09:39 So as soon as I'm done with this video here, I'm going to start using AI to go through all your information.
00:09:46 There is no way I can compile information from 300 email by myself.
00:09:51 I'll have that hopefully for you tomorrow.
00:09:54 It's going to take a lot of work.
00:09:55 Thanks for watching.
00:09:56 I hope you enjoyed this video. If you did, give it a thumbs up, subscribe to the channel,
00:10:02 ring the bell for notifications. I will see you in the next one. Agitate, agitate, agitate.