John Bolton - November 27, 2025


Jeff RATH FIGHTS for Alberta Independence - 1st Nations arguments fall flat

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Pierre Poilievre STRIKES - Carney the coward COWERS A BIG win For Mark Carney - Columnist James Albers (Western Standard)

Episode Stats


Length

31 minutes

Words per minute

199.06

Word count

6,173

Sentence count

420

Harmful content

Misogyny

9

sentences flagged

Toxicity

9

sentences flagged

Hate speech

5

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, we speak with Jeff Rath, a constitutional lawyer who represented Mitch Sylvester in his case against the Supreme Court of Canada. Jeff talks about how the court handled the case, what went wrong, and why he thinks a referendum on independence is a great opportunity for First Nations.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hi, it's John and welcome to the channel. Hope you're having a great day today. And today we've
00:00:08 got a guest, as you can see on the channel. I've got Jeff Rath here, a constitutional lawyer,
00:00:14 an advocate for independence, working with the Alberta Prosperity Project, representing Mitch
00:00:19 Sylvester in court last week. I got a chance, Jeff, to watch quite a bit of it. I saw a lot
00:00:24 of what happened on Wednesday. I heard a lot of what she said, most of which was on Thursday,
00:00:29 and I heard the wrap-up on Friday as well. Tell me just exactly what was going on here. I know you
00:00:36 were facing off with a number of lawyers here from about five First Nations groups.
00:00:41 Well, and on top of it, not just lawyers from five First Nations groups, but two so-called
00:00:47 friends of the court or amicus curiae that were appointed by the court, one of them being Professor
00:00:52 Adams, Professor of Constitutional Law Professor Adams from the University of Alberta, and then a
00:00:57 lawyer by the name of Woodley from the Reynolds Mirth firm in Edmonton, right? And what was really
00:01:03 shocking to me about all of them, including the law professor and the so-called expert
00:01:09 constitutional litigator, Mr. Woodley, was that none of them were addressing the real issue.
00:01:14 And the real issue is, you know, how can the mere gathering of signatures or the mere holding of a
00:01:19 referendum on independence that the Supreme Court has said is a purely political exercise? This is
00:01:25 the secession reference, has said in the secession reference, is a purely political exercise that
00:01:30 does not affect anybody's legal rights. How could that in any way contravene the Constitution when
00:01:36 it's a constitutional process that's already been approved by the Supreme Court? Not one of them
00:01:41 wanted to address that question, right? And with the First Nations, what really bothered me about
00:01:46 what they were doing was that they don't understand what a huge opportunity Alberta independence is
00:01:53 for the First Nations, excuse me, of Alberta, because they're all ignoring, they're all talking
00:01:59 about Section 35 and talking about treaty rights. And, you know, in some of them in a really, really,
00:02:04 you know, strange kind of way, like one of the issues was, well, what about people that are
00:02:09 criminals? Like, what about criminals, you know, crossing international borders? Well, there's no treaty
00:02:14 right, you know, to carry out your modern way of life throughout the track surrendered. If you're
00:02:20 a criminal, I mean, if somebody's locked up in the Edmonton Max, in the Edmonton Max, they can't go to
00:02:25 the warden and say, well, I have a treaty right that says I can carry on my way of life throughout
00:02:30 the track surrendered, as if I'd ever entered into treaty. So you got to let me out of prison. So I,
00:02:35 you know, I can go do that again, you know, that I can go do that and maybe kill a few more people 1.00
00:02:41 while I'm at it. Right. Yeah. That's ludicrous. Right. So nobody, nobody addressed any of that. 1.00
00:02:45 And then on top of it, there's this one lawyer for, it was on for Miccosuke Cree and Sturgeon Lake,
00:02:51 you know, Orlo Kelly, like she went out of her way to try to tell me that I didn't know who my own
00:02:55 clients were because at one point, um, this poor lawyer that was representing ACFN, you know,
00:03:01 really doesn't know anything about Aboriginal rights or Aboriginal rights law or First Nations
00:03:06 in general. So the court asked him whether he knew if there were any other Dene First Nations besides
00:03:11 his client in Treaty 8, he didn't know the answer. Right. So I stood up and I said to the court,
00:03:19 because I know because I've acted for dozens of them. And I said, well, I said, there's quite a few
00:03:23 other Dene First Nations in Treaty 8. I said, there's all of the, you know, the, um, uh, the 1.00
00:03:27 people in Northeastern British Columbia. I said, there's horse lake, at least horse, the horse lake
00:03:31 in Alberta. And then I've been since reminded by other friends of mine and Cree elders and other
00:03:35 people that I know, you know, Fort Mackay, um, Janvier, Dene Ta, you know, all these other First
00:03:40 Nations that are, um, that are, uh, that are Dene First Nations in Alberta. Um, and, but Orlo O'Kelly
00:03:46 for Miccosuke thought she should stand up and tell the court that the people that I formed, that I've
00:03:52 represented in Northeastern British Columbia on huge cases, were not Dene people, but they were
00:03:57 the Dene Zaw beaver people, you know? So, and of course you just Google it. And of course the Dene
00:04:03 Zaw beaver people, like the Caribou people of, you know, Fort Chippewan, like the dog rib people of the 1.00
00:04:09 Northwest Territories, they're all Dene. Sutena down near Calgary is Dene. But of course, this woman 1.00
00:04:14 thought she had to stand up and correct me on a completely irrelevant point. And, you know, and was wrong
00:04:20 about it. I mean, that sort of tells you the quality of the representation these poor people
00:04:24 have. And Jeff, you've represented a lot of Aboriginal groups and you know a lot about it,
00:04:28 obviously from that, which you just said there, but getting back around to what this was about,
00:04:33 when I was watching, I heard about sections, section two, four of the Alberta Citizen Initiative
00:04:41 Act. And this is the process we're going through here to get a petition, get the signatures and get a
00:04:46 referendum. Section two, four says an initiative petition proposal must not contravene sections
00:04:52 one to 35.1 of the Constitution Act 1982. You should know your rights one to 15. Those sections
00:04:59 are very important when it comes to your personal rights, when it comes to things like a right to
00:05:03 religion and a right to freedom of the press and right to not to have improper search and seizure.
00:05:08 But when we get to 35, it talks more about the rights of first nations people and the treaty rights
00:05:14 of people. And I heard that a lot. Was this, this was all about section two to four, which I do,
00:05:20 two, four, which I mentioned, and this is what we got away from so much. Right. Well, yeah, but again,
00:05:25 section two, four says an initiative petition proposal. So there's a lot of emphasis on the word
00:05:30 proposal, what's being proposed, right? You know, must not contravene any rights contained in the
00:05:37 Constitution, you know, specifically sections one to 35.1 of the, you know, of the Constitution Act
00:05:46 1982. Well, first of all, 35.1, by putting forward this proposal, we're not convening section 35 or
00:05:55 contravening section 35.1. We're triggering section 35.1. The section 35.1 says, if there's any
00:06:05 constitutional amendments that are going to impact on treaty and aboriginal rights under 35 or the
00:06:12 division of powers under 9124 and shift federal powers for Indians and Indian lands to, you know,
00:06:17 to a province, in this case, a country, you know, there has to be a constitutional convention where
00:06:23 the First Nations are able to participate. And this is where you, this is where you jumped in a lot last
00:06:29 week and you're saying, listen, this is a great opportunity for First Nations. It's going to be the best
00:06:34 thing they've ever had, really, right? Oh, 100%. I mean, you know, when Parliament, the Imperial
00:06:39 Parliament in Great Britain created Canada out of thin air in 1867 by the Imperial Act of the
00:06:45 Parliament, First Nations weren't consulted. When the Imperial Parliament in Great Britain
00:06:49 transferred Rupert's Land and the Northwest Territory to Canada in 1868, you know, First Nations
00:06:56 weren't, didn't participate and weren't consulted. When Alberta became a province in, well, when any of the
00:07:03 provinces were created, including Manitoba, British Columbia, Saskatchewan, Alberta, First Nations
00:07:09 weren't consulted or allowed to have any say in the creation of those provinces or those provinces
00:07:14 joining Canada. When the Natural Resources Transfer Agreement was entered into by an act of Canadian,
00:07:20 the Canadian Parliament in 1930, First Nations didn't have a say and weren't consulted. This will be the 0.99
00:07:26 first time in Canadian history that First Nations have had a meaningful say at the constitutional table
00:07:31 to ensure that all of the rights that are violated on an ongoing basis by Alberta and Canada, right,
00:07:39 are actually respected at a constitutional table. So they should see this as a real opportunity
00:07:44 to completely resolve all of their outstanding grievances. I mean, that's in part why I'm doing this.
00:07:51 I think this is an amazing opportunity for First Nations. And certainly, if you read the value of freedom
00:07:56 document that was created by Alberta Prosperity Project, if you look at the Indigenous policies of the Alberta
00:08:03 Prosperity Project, you'll see that, you know, the Alberta Prosperity Project, you know, both in its policies
00:08:09 and through the value of freedom, have nothing but respect for the treaty and Aboriginal rights of the Indigenous
00:08:14 people of Alberta. And we, our goal is to lift the Indigenous people of Alberta out of the crushing poverty and
00:08:21 destitution that Canada has placed them in and has kept them in.
00:08:25 You even, you even brought up, and I think it might have been on Wednesday, you said, you know,
00:08:29 we've still got people in Alberta who haven't got clean drinking water here. And you aren't very
00:08:34 complimentary of the lawyers that were representing the First Nations either, were you?
00:08:38 Well, I just thought it was shocking that they could actually bill for the services that they were
00:08:43 providing. I mean, you know, it was, you know, watching them stumble and stammer and, you know, not know how to
00:08:49 answer questions from the court, you know, not knowing, you know, the ethnography of the clients
00:08:54 they're representing. In Orlo O'Kelly's case, misrepresenting the ethnography of other First
00:08:59 Nations in Alberta simply because she thought it was important. And I still can't figure out why she
00:09:04 thought she should try to make that point, you know, that she should contradict me, you know,
00:09:08 on an ethnographic issue that has little or nothing to do with anything before the court and then be
00:09:13 wrong about it. Right. You know, I thought, frankly, you know, it was embarrassing to watch.
00:09:19 It was embarrassing to sit through. And as somebody who's worked, you know, for 34 years advancing the
00:09:24 rights of Indigenous people in this province, you know, I'm certainly of the view that First Nations
00:09:31 rights and First Nations interests were not well represented by the lawyers that they had in that
00:09:36 courtroom. The other thing that I thought while I was watching it, and I'm no lawyer, I didn't take any
00:09:40 law at all. And at times it was hard to follow. But I heard, and I've mentioned to you when I was
00:09:47 talking the other night, setting up an interview saying, they looked like they were getting way
00:09:51 ahead of themselves, getting over their skis. We were getting way down the line, three or four
00:09:57 processes down the line, as opposed to addressing the actual issue.
00:10:01 Well, and that's the fault. That's the fault of the so-called constitutional experts,
00:10:05 you know, the amicus curiae, right? They came up with this bizarre theory of, you know,
00:10:10 let's put the word proposal together with the word contravene. And proposal means what
00:10:14 you're ultimately seeking to do. You know, Mitch Sylvester ultimately wants Alberta to
00:10:19 be independent from Canada. Well, that's not in evidence before the court. The only thing
00:10:23 in evidence before the court is Mr. Sylvester has put forward a proposal, right, to ask a question
00:10:30 about whether his fellow Albertans wish to become independent from Canada or not, right?
00:10:36 That's it. That's the proposal. People say yes, or they say no. And then once, if they say no,
00:10:42 it's over with. And if they say yes, then it's completely out of Mr. Sylvester's hands.
00:10:46 And it's in the hands of the government of Alberta. So this idea that we sort of look at this,
00:10:52 you know, look at this question, you know, try to figure out what the ultimate end of it's going to be,
00:10:57 hold it up sideways, look past the referendum process to, you know, 15 years in the future,
00:11:02 and say that that is what you have to look at and determine whether that, whatever it might be
00:11:08 15 years from now, or whatever it is, is going to contravene anyone's rights is ludicrous. I think
00:11:14 it's a silly proposition. And one of the things we were talking about, I want to jump on quickly. 0.88
00:11:19 Sure. Sorry, I'll let you ask the question and then I'll talk about the word contravene.
00:11:22 Okay. Well, I was just wondering, the question is, do you agree that the province of Alberta shall
00:11:26 become a sovereign country and cease to be a province in Canada? It's a pretty,
00:11:29 pretty specific question. I think it's to the point as well. And, and I, and obviously it was
00:11:35 chosen very specifically so that it, it, it did. Yeah, to comply with section one, sub three of the
00:11:40 idea. Yeah, it really did. And I wanted to ask you about, um, Court of King's Bench Justice Colin
00:11:45 Feasby, who was overseeing this as well, uh, for somebody who isn't a lawyer, it seemed to me that
00:11:51 he was being at times, uh, kind of argumentative. Is that his job?
00:11:55 No, you can't read anything into that. That's his, that's his style. Um, you know, he gives
00:11:59 lawyers on both sides of the courtroom, I think an equal, you know, equally hard time. Um, you know,
00:12:04 it's, you know, it's kind of Socratic, you know, it's kind of a bit of a Socratic method.
00:12:08 Um, I really like appearing in front of Justice Feasby because he's probably one of the strongest
00:12:12 constitutionalists on the court. I think that's why he was assigned to this case. He's very learned
00:12:18 it in the law. He's very thorough. He reads everything that's in front of him. Um, you know,
00:12:23 so, you know, and on top of it, I think it's going to be because he's so serious about the law and
00:12:28 understands his role as a judge is to apply the law and not to try to change or warp the law.
00:12:34 He understands the difficulty that he has. And he said as much at the end of the hearing,
00:12:39 um, in ignoring the Supreme court and what the Supreme court said in the secession reference,
00:12:44 I don't think he can do it. I mean, the Supreme court said clearly that, um, a referendum question
00:12:49 doesn't affect anybody's legal rights. It's a political process. I haven't made this argument
00:12:53 yet, but I probably will when I get another chance to be back in court on the 5th of December,
00:12:57 but you know, I mean, the Mitch Sylvester's referendum question, no more affects the constitution
00:13:03 than if I were to stand on a soapbox outside of the legislature and, you know, basically scream
00:13:09 and yell about how every section of the, you know, of the charter, you know, needs to be amended,
00:13:14 uh, for whatever spurious reason I could come up with. Right. I mean, you know, nobody's rights are
00:13:20 amended, uh, you know, by somebody asking a question or other people answering a question.
00:13:25 Right. You know, I mean, I, you know, I understand that I don't, you know, I personally,
00:13:29 I don't think that justice fees be crazy about the idea of Alberta independence. He thinks that
00:13:33 there's a lot of potential pitfalls to it or whatever, but do I believe that he's going to
00:13:37 apply the law faithfully? Yes, I do. I think he's a great judge. You, you wanted to come back around
00:13:42 and I heard it a lot. The word contravene, there seemed to be a lot of argument about the word
00:13:47 contravene over these three days. Why? Well, because the, because the friends of the court
00:13:53 of the amicus have taken that word and have stretched it all out of, you know, like, you
00:13:57 know, it's like, they think that that word is a piece of saltwater taffy that they're stretching
00:14:01 to be a hundred miles long. Right. Um, it doesn't, they start out with the normal definition of
00:14:07 contravene, which is to violate or to break a law. Right. Um, and then they stretch it into,
00:14:13 you know, violate, breach or infringe directly or indirectly now, or at some point in the future.
00:14:18 Right. Yeah. So, you know, they stretch the word past all normal meaning. And of course I made an
00:14:24 argument that, you know, sort of on the one in my argument in chief that you have to look at the
00:14:28 structure of the statute itself and how the word is used in the context of the statute. And then
00:14:33 Eva Chipiak hopefully took it one step further for me. And she went through and she counted all of
00:14:38 the times the word contravene was used in the statute and pointed me to all of the specific paragraphs
00:14:43 in the statute where it's used. And it's clear on, in terms of how that word is used in the statute,
00:14:49 it means violate or break period. You can't put any other meaning on it. So how do you violate or break
00:14:56 a constitutional right? You know, by simply asking people a question, right? You know, through,
00:15:02 through, through a process that the Supreme court has called a purely political process that doesn't
00:15:07 affect anybody's rights. You know what I mean? So that's the, that's the, that's the question.
00:15:11 That's the issue before the court that everybody wants to ignore.
00:15:16 How do you think you did? And I know you mentioned, you alluded to it just a moment ago. You've got
00:15:21 to continue. There's still more to go here. I know at the very first part of Wednesday's court,
00:15:27 there were some people who are still wanting to, are interveners, I guess, that you'll be talking to
00:15:34 in December. So how do you think you did over the last three weeks and what's coming up?
00:15:37 Well, I mean, obviously, you know, um, if you look, if you look at the online comments and if I look at
00:15:43 the feedback that I've received and the, uh, uh, you know, and, uh, objectively, you know, how the
00:15:49 arguments went in and then on top of it, if you listen to my, um, 14 year old daughter, I was clearly
00:15:55 the best lawyer in the courtroom.
00:15:56 Well, I would agree. Yeah.
00:15:59 So anyway, no, but I mean, I thought it went very well. And I think, I think more importantly,
00:16:04 we got a, you know, we got a fair hearing and, um, uh, I think we're going to continue to get a
00:16:09 fair hearing. And I think that justice fees be is going to have a very, very, very hard time
00:16:13 on the law ruling against us. Cause like I pointed out to him, I said, okay, you know,
00:16:18 you're opening the door to chaos. If you accept what the other side is saying,
00:16:22 because if you want to ignore what the Supreme court says about secession referenda, not being
00:16:27 legally binding and not affecting anybody's rights, you want to ignore that and rule against
00:16:32 us and accept this crazy definition of the word, you know, uh, proposal and contravene that the
00:16:37 friends of the court have come up with, you're opening the door to chaos because then people
00:16:41 will say, oh, okay, I guess the secession reference isn't binding. And whatever the Supreme
00:16:45 court said about, uh, uh, unilateral declarations of independence being illegal, we can ignore.
00:16:51 And because we can ignore that in the secession reference, we can ignore it in the clarity act
00:16:55 and Alberta should just declare itself independent from Canada and move on. Right. Right. I mean,
00:17:00 that's what he's opening the door to. And I think, you know, I think he understands that I made that
00:17:03 argument to him very clearly. Are you, um, is it universal declaration of independence? Is that
00:17:09 correct? Unilateral, unilateral, sorry. Unilateral. Yeah. And basically for that, all you'd need is a,
00:17:15 is a government to recognize. Yeah. You just need a government that has the guts to declare itself
00:17:19 independent from Canada in much the same way. You know what? I made that point to justice fees,
00:17:23 but he didn't think much of it, but I mean, the government of Quebec effectively declared itself
00:17:28 outside of the constitutional order of Canada this summer, May 27th, my birthday, right? The government
00:17:34 of Quebec handed me an awesome birthday present. They declared that Quebec was no longer bound by or
00:17:39 recognize the crown period. And didn't they present something to the King when he was here too? I think
00:17:44 they presented something, didn't they present something to King Charles? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. They
00:17:47 actually delivered the resolution, hand delivered it to him while he was in Ottawa saying that the
00:17:52 parliament buildings belonged to the Algonquin. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. He did a landing dog. 0.79
00:17:57 So I mean, if Quebec doesn't recognize the sovereignty of his majesty, King Charles,
00:18:02 and that the entire Canadian constitution rests on the sovereignty of King Charles III,
00:18:07 right? And his heirs and successors, Quebec has effectively declared itself outside of, you know,
00:18:14 the scope of the Canadian constitutional order, you know, in a manner that I would suggest amounted
00:18:19 to a unilateral declaration of independence. Yeah. There was an article the other day.
00:18:22 So, you know, and if that's, if that's the case, we don't even need to worry about the amending
00:18:26 formula anymore because Quebec isn't part of the constitution. We need to have a constitutional
00:18:31 conference to address that. And of course, the funny thing about that, that most people don't remember,
00:18:36 but it was Paul St-Pierre Plamondon, the leader of the Parti Quebecois. It was the one that put that
00:18:42 resolution for, for the Quebec National Assembly. Right. Yeah. And Legault was stupid. Couldn't,
00:18:49 you know, like to say face politically, couldn't say, Oh no, we can't have that resolution. So Plumondon tables the
00:18:55 resolution. Right. And they voted unanimously to kick the crown out of Quebec.
00:19:01 There was an, there was an article in the national post about this the other day where they were,
00:19:07 they were talking about Quebec, just unilaterally saying that they were an independent country,
00:19:11 basically. Right. Yeah. And what actually Plumondon was in, I think it was in Calgary last week.
00:19:16 Well, we met with him for four and a half hours. We met with him for four and a half hours when he
00:19:20 was here, Mitch and Dennis and I, we had a wonderful dinner with them. We were, you know,
00:19:23 we had a really lively conversation over, over a bottle of wine or two and really, really enjoyed meeting him.
00:19:29 He and I actually have a very similar background. We're both, we both started out as big firm lawyers,
00:19:33 right? He was at the Psych Benelian. I was at Burnett Duckworth in Calgary. And then
00:19:39 he saw all the crap and corruption that was going on in Quebec because he was a senior, 0.99
00:19:44 he was counsel on the ad scam inquiry. Right. And you know, and then he also, 0.99
00:19:49 we both went to university in England. So he did a, I think a master's at, or an MBA at Oxford. And I did
00:19:57 my law degree at the London School of Economics. So we kind of have that, you know, sort of shared
00:20:01 history, you know, big firm experience, uh, you know, university, you know, uh, English university
00:20:06 experience in common. So he and I actually sort of speak very close to the same language.
00:20:10 So I want to ask you what's coming up, but then I want to move on to something else. Big,
00:20:14 a big day, um, coming up with, uh, Carney and I know, I know, I know that there's just a little bit
00:20:20 more to do on this before we'll get a ruling. Um, you're going to be talking in December.
00:20:25 There's some other people intervening or whatever that Colin Feesby is going to, um, be part of,
00:20:31 and you're going to get your opportunity to talk a bit more. Um, when will this, we may get a ruling
00:20:36 on this and then we can move on from that. Yeah. He, well, he promised that, uh, you know,
00:20:41 because of the new intervenors having a decision out before Christmas, he said it's possible, but
00:20:45 unlikely, but he basically said, you know, scouts honor, you know, judges honor that he'll have it
00:20:50 to us before the 15th of January. And I have no reason to think that he won't. So, um, you know,
00:20:55 we're looking forward to seeing his decision one way or another. We are feeling as one way or another,
00:20:59 we will win, right? Because if he rules against, if he rules against this, then the ball's squarely
00:21:05 in Danielle's lap. And after promising a referendum and then screwing up the legislation that's 0.97
00:21:10 prevented us from moving forward, she's going to be forced to call the referendum 1.00
00:21:14 under section one of the referendum act, or there's going to be all hell to pay within the
00:21:18 party. Because I mean, right now the, uh, you know, Alberta prosperity project and people in
00:21:22 favor of independence are literally, you know, uh, 60 or 70% of the base of the UCP right now.
00:21:29 So, you know, it's, uh, and then we'll find out after this weekend, whether or not we fully
00:21:33 control the board of directors again. So yeah, that's right. The AGM is coming up. So I want to ask you
00:21:39 about this, um, big announcement. I think it's happening in Calgary, isn't it? I think they're
00:21:44 going to be, no, no, the UCP AGM is in that. No, no, no. I'm talking about, I'm talking about
00:21:49 I'm sorry, the, the, the, the ridiculous announcement of the, uh, of the, uh, the,
00:21:54 I call it the memorandum of underachieving, not understanding. It's a memorandum of underachieving.
00:22:00 So I think it's happening in Calgary. Anyway, it's happening here in Alberta. Daniel
00:22:04 Smith is entertaining Mark Carney. He's probably on his way here if he's not here already to
00:22:09 announce this memorandum of understanding, to put a pipeline to the coast. What are your thoughts on
00:22:15 this? Well, I mean, my thoughts are the same as Pierre Paulyev's. I mean, he sure for somebody
00:22:21 that's supposed to be, um, uh, you know, Daniel's friend, I mean, she idolizes him. I mean, I've heard
00:22:26 stories that when she wanted to repatriate the constitution a couple of years ago, he begged her not
00:22:31 to do it or we're not the constitution repatriate the Alberta, the Canadian pension funds that belong
00:22:36 to Alberta to an Alberta pension plan. Yeah. Paulyev begged her not to do it and she listened to him.
00:22:42 So, you know, she, you know, she, uh, uh, has always seen Pierre as being the savior of Alberta.
00:22:48 We need to get him elected because he's going to come and save us. And every time you turn around,
00:22:53 he's pulling the rug out from underneath her feet. Right. So there he was in parliament referring
00:22:57 to her MOU, which she sees as her political salvation. Right. Watch my video. Watch my
00:23:03 video on Wednesday. Yeah. Yeah. Speaking of Canadian interest, this prime minister opposed
00:23:10 the pipeline from Alberta to the Pacific, just like his previous liberal pre-assessor blocked
00:23:16 that same pipeline on Thursday. He'll make one of his grand announcements waving around a meaningless
00:23:22 memorandum, so-called memorandum of understanding. If it's anything other than a public relations ploy,
00:23:28 why won't he say on what date will construction begin on a pipeline from Alberta to the Pacific?
00:23:42 Mr. Speaker, Mr. Speaker, sometimes the question reveals everything.
00:23:47 The memorandum of understanding that we're negotiating with Alberta creates necessary
00:23:55 conditions, but not sufficient conditions because we believe in cooperative federalism.
00:24:00 We believe the government of British Columbia has to agree. We believe that First Nations right
00:24:06 holders in this country have to agree and support all stakeholders after that. That's one parent.
00:24:13 Well, I can. I'll stick it in here. Oh, okay. Yeah. So yeah, play the clip. So yeah. So
00:24:17 he basically refers to it as a meaningless, his exact words were meaningless public relations ploy.
00:24:25 Right. And then, um, you know, and then Carney himself basically says, oh, well, you know, the MOU
00:24:30 creates necessary conditions, but not sufficient conditions, you know, blah, blah, blah, because the
00:24:36 government of British Columbia and the BC First Nations still have to agree. So he's basically saying they have a
00:24:41 veto. Right. So that whole thing with Carney, it almost reminded me of the old Mackenzie King story
00:24:47 when they tried to pin them down on conscription. And he said, you know, conscription of necessary,
00:24:51 but not necessarily conscription. Right. It was just more liberal gobbledygook and doublespeak and
00:24:57 whatever. But it's made Danielle look like a putz. You know, now she has to put on a nice face tomorrow 1.00
00:25:02 and she's probably going to, we'll see if she's going to wear a little, you know, Canada flag costume, 1.00
00:25:06 little red blazer and white shirt, right. Dress up like a Canada flag to try to address this,
00:25:11 to announce this MOU. Right. Right. And, uh, and, and everybody's already said that it's a joke.
00:25:16 Well, you know, and then, and then keep in mind, so vague promises from the liberals that will never
00:25:21 come true, but hard promises from Alberta to spend billions on Pathways Alliance carbon
00:25:27 sucking machines, decarbonizing Alberta oil, screwing our oil patch left, right and center with this 1.00
00:25:33 stupid net zero bullshit. Sorry. You know, I'm going to speak oil patch now. Right. 1.00
00:25:37 Net zero bullshit that Danielle's gobbling up with a fork and spoon because little her boyfriend 1.00
00:25:42 Mark is serving it to her on a plate. And, um, and we don't have a pro hard promise of a pipeline. 0.99
00:25:47 We have a pipeline subject to the wishes of BC and BC first nations. So good luck. She's no further
00:25:56 ahead than she was six months ago, except now I would argue that she's substantially further behind
00:26:02 because, and I've said this before, I mean, she's burning her political capital, like a drunk 1.00
00:26:06 lighting cigars with a hundred dollar bills. Right. And, um, you know, she looks foolish. I mean,
00:26:12 Carney and keep in mind Carney, Nenshi, Ebi, right. All working in concert. Nenshi was a card
00:26:18 carrying liberal until he affected a reverse takeover of the Alberta new Democrat party on behalf of the
00:26:24 liberals in Ottawa. Carney, Ebi and Nenshi are literally running Danielle into a box Canyon to slaughter
00:26:31 her. And she's, it doesn't have the wit to see it. That's what really bothers me.
00:26:35 It's interesting. You say that because you have to look at it this way. And I didn't really think
00:26:40 about this until you just said that, but there's, there's nothing that Mark Carney would like to see
00:26:45 more than having an NDP government here in Alberta and not have the UCP and Danielle Smith.
00:26:51 He would love to do her in, he would love to destroy. Oh, absolutely. Yeah.
00:26:56 And like, and it's the same thing when Trudeau was in power, right. Trudeau and Nenshi would
00:27:01 whipsaw Kenny. So like Kenny wouldn't be moving fast enough for Trudeau on, you know, locking people
00:27:06 in their homes and forcing shots into their arms or whatever. And then, then she would come out on
00:27:10 the Monday after meeting with Trudeau and having a little tete-a-tete and the two of them would
00:27:14 snuggle and, you know, agree on what they're going to do to do to the rest of us. And then Nenshi would
00:27:19 get out on Monday and throw a full blown Nellie fit about you're lucky people. If you don't do
00:27:27 something, I'm going to act on my own. And then Kenny would fold like a cheap suit. Right. So it was
00:27:33 awful. And they're doing the same thing again. It's like Nenshi and Carney and, uh, Carney, Nenshi
00:27:39 and Abby are all just jerking Danielle around. Like she, like, like, and she doesn't have a clue. 1.00
00:27:44 So let me ask, I'm embarrassed to be an Albertan right now.
00:27:47 Okay. So what I want, what I want to do some, I, I want to send people, you've got a sub stack.
00:27:52 I get an email from you every once in a while. It's called the road to freedom. And the one I
00:27:55 got the other day was, if you think Danielle Smith is going to negotiate Alberta's way to 1.00
00:27:59 freedom within Canada, you're not paying attention. That was the opening line, I think, from it,
00:28:03 or at least part of it anyway. But, and if, if there is a pipeline announced tomorrow in, in regards to
00:28:09 the independence movement, do you think this will change anything at all?
00:28:14 No, because we don't care about pipelines. We care about censorship. We care about losing our
00:28:19 freedom of speech. We care about having our guns stolen from us. We care about every time we turn
00:28:24 around, Mark Carney and the liberals find some new way to screw us over as Albertans because they don't
00:28:29 like us. Don't like our culture. Don't like our resentment of government. We don't comply. We don't
00:28:34 obey, you know, all of that stuff. Right. If they were serious about this, right. Why do we still have a
00:28:42 West Coast tanker band? Like Danielle thinks she's getting this big, you know, whatever it is. Right.
00:28:46 How can she even, how can we even raise money to get the capital for a pipeline if it's illegal to 1.00
00:28:53 take oil out of the pipeline and put it in a ship? Right. How can we increase our capacity, you know,
00:28:59 if, you know, to drill oil or gas or whatever it is in Alberta, when, you know, Carney continually jacks
00:29:05 up the carbon tax, who's going to invest in the Alberta oil patch when we're being carbon taxed
00:29:10 to death and there's zero carbon taxes in Texas. All the money's going to Texas right now. It's not
00:29:14 coming to Alberta or it's going to the UAE or, you know, all these other places where Mark Carney
00:29:19 and Brookfield do business. Right. They're not doing business. Brookfield's not investing in the
00:29:25 Alberta oil patch. They're investing in the UAE. You know, it's, it's just completely despicable what's
00:29:31 going on. And Danielle doesn't seem to have the wit to understand it. Jeff, I got to leave it there.
00:29:35 Um, you know, what's funny. I, this video has been recorded at about four o'clock in the afternoon
00:29:40 on Wednesday. It's going up on Thursday morning and you've gone through my whole video from
00:29:44 Wednesday. You got to go watch it because everything you've said here. Well, there you go,
00:29:48 John. Great minds think alike. Absolutely. No, it's unbelievable. I'm sitting here going,
00:29:52 that's what I said this morning. That's what I said this morning. I brought up Polyev. I used
00:29:56 Polyev's clips from CPAC and that's why it's great. It really is. Jeff, it's always a pleasure to
00:30:01 talk to you. It always is. I have to get you back on again. Have fun at the AGM this weekend.
00:30:06 Oh yeah. Believe me. I'll see you there. I'll be the six foot four guy at a cowboy hat and we'll be
00:30:10 having, we'll be having a good time. I can't, I can't wait. I can't wait for, to ask Danielle,
00:30:17 um, how many people she thinks in the room support Alberta independence and then ask the room to raise
00:30:21 their hands if they support Alberta independence. They're not going to let me near a mic. I'll tell
00:30:25 you that. Get your camera. I won't be, I'm not going to be there. I wish I could be,
00:30:28 but I can't be there this weekend. I wish I could. I was hoping that we could have a beer together,
00:30:33 but yeah, well, I don't, I don't, I don't quit drinking about 30 years ago, Jeff. So don't,
00:30:38 don't hold it against me. Maybe we can get you to do what, maybe we can get you to do a report
00:30:43 or something early next week on what you thought about it. Yeah. I'd love to. I'll happily come back
00:30:47 on. It'd be awesome. Jeff's always a pleasure to talk to you. Thanks so much. Okay. Thanks John.
00:30:51 Over out. If you like this video, give it a thumbs up, subscribe to the channel,
00:30:55 ring the bell for notifications. I'll see you in the next one. Thanks John.