Poilievre's BRILLIANT 42 seconds - Was it enough？
Episode Stats
Words per Minute
191.45865
Summary
I watched the debate last night and I came out of it thinking the same thing as I went into it. Have you ever changed your mind based on what you saw on a debate? Do you agree with Mark Carney or do you disagree with him?
Transcript
00:00:00.000
Hi, it's John and welcome to the channel 403 a.m. It is Friday, April the 18th with the big blue mug
00:00:06.400
of coffee. Hope you're having a great day today. I certainly am. And just a reminder to click on
00:00:12.540
subscribe and you'll help out the channel. If you like the video, please give me a thumbs up.
00:00:16.980
One other thing I want to do before I talk about last night's debate, which I did watch,
00:00:21.520
I want to thank all the contributors, all the people who are out there doing great work. A lot
00:00:25.940
of these clips I get off of X, I get off of YouTube. I want to thank you so much. Juno News,
00:00:30.920
Rebel News, Mark Nixon, Government is Corrupt, and others. I don't always attribute all the things
00:00:36.220
I get here on this channel to the people who are creating them and I apologize for that,
00:00:40.180
but I wanted to make sure you got some credit. Thanks again. So I watched the debate last night
00:00:45.340
and I came out of it thinking the same as I went into it. Certainly not going to change my mind
00:00:51.200
and I was thinking back and maybe you thought the same thing. You've watched a lot of debates over
00:00:55.160
the years. Have you ever changed your mind based on what you saw on a debate? Probably not.
00:00:59.680
Now, maybe if you're undecided, it might sway you one way or the other, but two hours of debate in
00:01:05.660
English last night. I'm glad I watched the English one because the best part of the whole debate,
00:01:10.800
I could have avoided all of it because the very best part of the debate was the last 42 seconds.
00:01:21.440
Only in Canada could someone start where I began and get to the stage. I was born to a single mother
00:01:28.760
and adopted by school teachers who raised me to believe in the incredible Canadian promise that
00:01:34.540
anyone who worked hard could do anything. That promise feels broken today. Many of you worried about
00:01:43.480
paying your bills, feeding your families, or ever even owning a home. You're worried your kids are in
00:01:49.340
danger. But I'm here to say it doesn't have to be this way. With change, we can restore the
00:01:55.760
Canadian promise so that hard work gets you a beautiful house on a safe street under a proud
00:02:06.400
An absolute beautiful moment from Pierre Polyev. And you can almost see his eyes well up a little
00:02:13.280
bit while he's saying that. He truly believes that. It's a message he talks about very often
00:02:18.420
in his rallies. Now, unfortunately for him, he was the last person to speak. And maybe the people who
00:02:25.040
tuned into Mark Carney in his fear closing statement, which I'm going to get to in just a moment, didn't get
00:02:30.160
a chance to hear Polyev. Then again, Polyev did have the last word in the debate last night. So compare
00:02:36.260
this to what Mark Carney had to say. Now, other people were thinking about this last night. And it was
00:02:41.380
something that came to mind while I was watching the debate. Everything is a crisis to Mark Carney
00:02:46.240
and the Liberal Party. And this plays really well. As I've said here before, James Madison said,
00:02:50.900
crisis is the rallying cry of the tyrant. Everything is a crisis to the Liberals. And they are depending
00:02:57.280
on people to believe that there was a climate crisis, a housing crisis, an economic crisis,
00:03:02.960
tariff crisis. Donald Trump is a crisis. And even in the closing statement, Mark Carney, well, it was a
00:03:08.700
crisis. We are facing the biggest crisis of our lifetimes. Donald Trump is trying to fundamentally
00:03:16.060
change the world economy, the trading system. But really what he's trying to do to Canada, he's trying
00:03:21.560
to break us so the U.S. can own us. They want our land. They want our resources. They want our
00:03:27.280
water. They want our country. We're all going to stand up against Donald Trump. I'm ready. I've
00:03:35.260
managed crises over the years. I've built strong economies. We will fight back with counter tariffs.
00:03:41.940
We will protect our workers and those businesses. And we will build the strongest economy. We will
00:03:47.460
build Canada strong. I'm asking for your support, the honor of doing so. Thank you.
00:03:53.880
Looking at Carney's message and then looking at Polyev's, who would you rather put your trust in?
00:03:58.640
The one who's trying to play on your fears and manipulate you? Or the one who's talking about,
00:04:03.080
you know, hope and doing something good for the country? I think the answer is clear here. And again,
00:04:08.680
who knows how many people tuned out before they heard those 42 seconds out of pure Polyev's mouth.
00:04:14.540
And I think it's interesting because Polyev represents the young people. I saw some videos
00:04:19.220
pop up online last night. Young people going on TikTok, trying to encourage their grandparents
00:04:25.300
not to vote liberal because their futures don't look very good under the liberal government.
00:04:31.320
They're asking people to vote for Polyev because Polyev represents some hope to them.
00:04:36.420
While Carney represents the fear. Now, the other thing I find interesting as well, I was watching
00:04:40.540
Juneau News last night and that's where I watched my live feed, Candace Malcolm talking to David Knight
00:04:45.460
Legg. And about two minutes and 40 seconds into the discussion, they were doing some post-debate
00:04:52.820
analysis. Legg had a great point here and I've mentioned it here on my channel as well.
00:04:57.620
I actually think the problem for Mark Carney that became apparent during this debate is that already
00:05:03.620
a lot of his themes are dated. You could sort of feel that the wheel is turned over the course,
00:05:09.720
even over the course of this last few weeks, on Donald Trump as a crisis. And it sounds a little
00:05:16.080
stale. I don't think people are feeling that Donald Trump is the crisis right now.
00:05:20.280
Can Mark Carney continue along with this fear campaign, which is seeming rather stale?
00:05:25.360
Can you do it for the next week and a half? I was watching Warren Kinsella talking with Brian
00:05:29.640
Lilly and others on the Toronto Sun feed last night. Kinsella says it's over. We might as well vote.
00:05:35.800
Nobody's going to change their mind at this point. Nothing was changed with these two debates.
00:05:39.540
I don't know whether that's the case, but we'll have to see. Now, as far as the debate
00:05:43.180
goes itself, there were some highlights and lowlights. I'm not going to go into the clips
00:05:47.380
very long, but the real low light of the night was Jagmeet Singh. I mentioned yesterday, why
00:05:53.300
is he even on stage? He seemed like a petulant child looking for attention last night. Couldn't
00:05:57.880
stop interrupting Pierpoliev. Some people suggesting he's already made a deal with the liberals for
00:06:03.940
after the election. I don't know whether that's the case because chances are Singh won't even be
00:06:08.380
around. He might not even get reelected in his riding. But at one point, Steve Pakin, who did a
00:06:13.520
pretty damn good job moderating last night, is a good journalist, had to tell Jagmeet Singh finally
00:06:18.620
just to basically shut up. Steve, the question that Canadians have to ask is whether he's got the
00:06:28.200
Mr. Singh. Sorry, he has the floor. Now, as far as block leader Yves-Francois Blanchet, I said
00:06:34.260
yesterday that he shouldn't be on stage, but I'm glad he was on stage last night. I think he was the
00:06:39.020
best one on stage. I think he won the debate. It means nothing, but I think he won the debate.
00:06:45.760
A man who represents only Quebec, and he brought it up all the time last night. It became rather
00:06:50.720
boring to hear him say it. A man who is no friend of Canada, certainly no friend of Alberta because
00:06:55.260
he doesn't want oil and gas, but he got the best shots in last night. And here's one. I'll just show
00:07:00.440
one to you. And this is when Jagmeet Singh was making a statement. Just listen to what he says. It's
00:07:06.340
great. What I found very troubling is that the past number of years, the liberal government record
00:07:13.640
is one where we have spent the most subsidies compared to any other country in the G7 on
00:07:19.520
subsidizing oil and gas. These are highly profitable companies. You voted for it. I think that's the
00:07:24.100
wrong thing to do. We fought against it again and again. No, you voted for it. And then the liberals
00:07:28.000
have continued to do it. And so my question really to Mr. Carney is, Blanchet actually went after Carney
00:07:33.920
for his offshore bank accounts and went after him for Brookfield a number of times. I think he was the
00:07:38.580
most entertaining part of the debate last night. I say he won the debate. He didn't really win
00:07:43.600
anything, but I was glad he was there. It was very entertaining to hear what he had to say. Biggest
00:07:47.880
fail on the night, Mark Carney, no doubt about it. And he laid up one for Pierre Polyev that Polyev
00:07:54.540
couldn't have hoped for. The left seems to think Polyev's security clearance is a big deal. And it's
00:07:59.760
quite logical why he hasn't got his security clearance. And Carney asked him about it last night.
00:08:05.500
As soon as it started to come out of his mouth, I leaned forward and I thought,
00:08:09.580
he's actually going to go here? And Polyev went in and he ended up with a slam dunk.
00:08:15.580
I'm not going to play the whole clip, just a little bit of a clip. And he even gave a bit
00:08:19.580
of a nod to former opposition leader, NDP leader, Tom Mulcair.
00:08:24.180
But when the government made this recent offer, they said that if I got the secret security clearance
00:08:30.680
briefings, that I would be gagged under the security law and I could be prosecuted if I spoke
00:08:36.860
freely about matters of foreign interference. Now, given that Canada has experienced Chinese
00:08:44.180
interference by Beijing, the government of China, in two consecutive elections, I needed to do my job
00:08:51.040
to speak freely without fear of prosecution. Even Thomas Mulcair, the former leader of the NDP,
00:08:57.580
said that when he was the leader of the opposition, he never would have accepted the kind of gag order
00:09:03.500
that your government and Mr. Trudeau's government was attempting to impose on me.
00:09:07.820
There were no knockout punches during the debate. All Carney had to do was survive this,
00:09:13.120
and he survived it quite well. So again, I don't think this really swayed too many people's minds.
00:09:18.300
Were there any knockout punches? No. I think the best moment of the night
00:09:21.160
was when Pierre Polyev talked about, don't you really want four more years of this? And the same
00:09:26.980
people that have been running the country for the last 10 years are running the country right now.
00:09:33.580
And are you prepared to elect the same liberal MPs, the same liberal ministers, the same liberal
00:09:38.040
staffers all over again for a fourth term? Mr. Carney, Justin Trudeau's staffers are actually here with
00:09:44.500
you at this debate in Montreal, writing the talking points that you are regurgitating into the microphone.
00:09:50.020
How can we possibly believe that you are any different than the previous 10 years of liberal
00:09:56.880
government? Carney survives the debate. I wasted an hour and 56 minutes of my time, could have watched
00:10:04.500
the last four minutes to get the closing statements, in particular Carney's message of fear and crisis
00:10:10.320
compared to the change that Pierre Polyev is promising and some hope for the future, which was
00:10:15.860
his best 42 seconds, I think, of this campaign for sure. I'm almost more interested in this election
00:10:22.340
to find out if the polls are correct because they've swung so far since the beginning of this year. I think
00:10:27.680
this is a neck-and-neck race right now, which isn't good for the conservatives because they have to win
00:10:32.380
a majority outright. Otherwise, if they win a minority, it's over, folks. Coalition government,
00:10:38.240
the Liberals, NDP, bloc will all team up and we'll be on the outside looking in and we might be looking
00:10:45.320
at the end of Canada as we know it. And I believe that 100%. Thanks so much for watching this video.
00:10:52.700
I do appreciate it. I hope you enjoyed it. If you liked it, please give me a thumbs up. Subscribe to
00:10:58.420
the channel as well. I appreciate that. If you'd like to get notifications, you can ring the little bell