Juno News - November 06, 2023


A carbon tax revolt is underway

Topics
Mentioned
Why the left is always wrong (ft. Dennis Prager) Canadian Anti-Hate Network won't look at left-wing hate

Episode Stats


Length

11 minutes

Words per minute

179.79

Word count

2,098

Sentence count

155

Harmful content

Misogyny

18

sentences flagged

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show, True North's Rachel Emanuel tells the story of how she and her colleague were heckled at a press conference with Prime Minister Justin Trudeau in Calgary, Alberta, Canada on Thursday, March 14th.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 Welcome to Canada's Most Irreverent Talk Show.
00:01:16 This is The Andrew Lawton Show, brought to you by True North.
00:01:24 Hello and welcome to you all.
00:01:27 The Andrew Lawton Show here on True North.
00:01:29 on this Thursday, March 14th.
00:01:31 I believe it is, my math is a little rusty
00:01:34 because it, well, it was never good to begin with,
00:01:36 but I believe it is Pi Day, is it not?
00:01:38 March 14th, 314, 3.1415, something, something.
00:01:43 I lose track at five, but Sean will,
00:01:46 Sean's already going in the chat.
00:01:47 So he'll actually be just typing out the digits of Pi
00:01:50 until the end of the show.
00:01:51 So if a clip doesn't play, that's why,
00:01:53 but we'll be up to like, you know, digit 97 or something.
00:01:56 But anyway, Pi Day notwithstanding,
00:01:58 I'm usually more into a different type of pie, not as infinite as the mathematical pie.
00:02:04 But I wanted to pick up where we started off talking yesterday, and it was kind of a last-minute change.
00:02:09 I called an audible because moments before the show began,
00:02:13 my colleague, True North's Alberta reporter and host of Alberta Roundup, Rachel Emanuel,
00:02:19 was very, I would say, rudely given the bums rush out of an Alberta technical college 1.00
00:02:25 when Justin Trudeau was holding a press conference.
00:02:27 He was addressing media, but only certain type of media, not True North and not Counter
00:02:35 Signal, which is run by Kian Bextie.
00:02:37 This was a rather shameful display, but as I remarked yesterday on the show, not all
00:02:42 that unsurprising.
00:02:44 I've had my own run-ins with Trudeau's bodyguards in the past who have barred me from getting
00:02:50 close to him, even where other journalists are permitted.
00:02:52 True North, you may recall, in 2019, actually had to sue her way in to the leaders debate. 0.99
00:02:58 This was not a Liberal Party event.
00:03:00 This was a Government of Canada-run event, the official election leaders debate.
00:03:04 We won, but it shows the lengths through which Trudeau and his minions do not want any independent journalists questioning them.
00:03:11 We were trying to get Rachel Emanuel on the show yesterday, but I think she was actually in a dead sprint to get away from the RCMP when the show was on.
00:03:18 But she did it, and she joins us now.
00:03:21 rachel good to talk to you i i was exaggerating a little bit there but but you actually did have
00:03:25 quite a serious encounter that started with the college's security and ended up with i think
00:03:30 calgary police and rcmp did you not yeah i mean it actually started even before that initially
00:03:36 earlier in the day we had gotten word that trudeau was at a hotel in calgary eventually we narrowed
00:03:41 it down to the sheraton you know you can kind of drive by the hotels keep a lookout for additional
00:03:45 security unmarked you know big black vehicles outside of them things like that a lot of times
00:03:49 these vehicles also have ontario license plates so we knew a little bit what to look for so we
00:03:54 figured that he was meeting alberta premier daniel smith at the sheraton and you know we headed on
00:03:58 into the hotel there into the lobby we're very quickly asked to leave you know maybe we should
00:04:03 have worn some security uniforms or something to look like we belong you know fair enough we waited
00:04:07 outside uh we caught danielle smith on her way out of a side exit there and she was happy to give us
00:04:11 a couple questions quickly of course alberta premier danielle smith often speaks with media
00:04:16 she's very fair about that and she also speaks to all types of media not just independent reporters
00:04:21 or conservative reporters those that would tend to be a little bit more supportive of her policies
00:04:26 then you know we were waiting in a vehicle so we could follow trudeau's motorcade so we could get
00:04:30 the location of his press conference and even while we were simply sitting in our vehicle
00:04:34 waiting for the motorcade to leave police was already giving us a hard time oh you can't wait
00:04:37 here oh you can't park you have to move over there you have to move over here once the motorcade left
00:04:41 you know police vehicles driving in front of us very slowly so we couldn't you know get around
00:04:46 them get closer to the motorcade of course then we were listening to the press conference once the
00:04:51 question period of the press conference started the moderator said the first question is going
00:04:56 to go to the state reporter and that's when keen put it together oh they're at state so he went to
00:05:00 say sure enough there we see his motorcade so we're just kind of waiting waiting in the building
00:05:04 there for him to come down we were going to just try to ask him some questions as he walked over
00:05:07 over to his motorcade. And then, you know, RCMP, Calgary police, they're all there. They're all
00:05:12 giving us a very hard time. As soon as we walked out of that building, we were listening to the
00:05:16 press conference and we figured, eh, once it comes close to an end, we'll walk out. We'll wait near
00:05:20 the motorcade so that we can get our questions in as he, you know, it's a mere 30 seconds,
00:05:25 10 seconds, maybe even he's walking from the building to his motorcade. We've all seen the
00:05:28 clips of reporters following him from buildings to vehicles. And even that, you know, they take
00:05:32 issue with, they start moving the vehicles so that we can't even get a view of him. And then
00:05:37 the police starts being like you got to move further back you got to move back you know they're
00:05:40 trying to push us back at us as far as way as you can you can see a little gap between the vehicles
00:05:43 and the clip that you're playing and that was basically as close as we were going to get and
00:05:46 even that they were you know frustrated with they kept trying to push us back make things difficult 0.68
00:05:50 for us it was one of the most pathetic displays i've ever seen and you can only think to yourself
00:05:54 imagine if they use this kind of energy to actually fix some of the actual countries
00:05:59 some of the issues that we have going on in our country things would look a whole lot better and
00:06:02 then of course just I think it was probably three minutes before he finally finished that press
00:06:07 conference and came out uh state security came up to us and said nope you know we don't want you to
00:06:12 be here you're not accredited media you have to leave and once they say it's a trespassing issue
00:06:17 you do have to leave very quickly or you will be charged with trespassing that's about a $300 fine
00:06:22 I know that Kian has run into that issue with the past during the general election
00:06:25 when independent media had these same issues with you know trying to go to NDP press conferences
00:06:31 so then it gets a little more dodgy and you know trespassing charge isn't the most serious of
00:06:36 things but i think best to avoid it if you can yeah i mean some journalists i guess probably
00:06:41 collect them as as a badge of honor but at a certain point if the prime minister rents out
00:06:45 a hotel ballroom uh for all intents and purposes that's private property and the hotel ballroom
00:06:50 could uh trespass you so i i get why uh you you moved outside there same thing happened when i was
00:06:56 kicked out of uh what was it laurentian university in thunder bay uh trying to attend a trudeau
00:07:01 event. Once they say it's private property and you can't be here, it doesn't matter that Trudeau's
00:07:04 there or not. But I would actually say it goes beyond, it goes earlier than the Sheridan,
00:07:08 because you had done the thing that you're supposed to do the night before, you requested
00:07:12 accreditation. But they do this thing now where they, on Trudeau's itinerary, they don't even
00:07:16 announce where the event is going to be. You have to request accreditation. And they try to basically
00:07:22 make it so that no one can do what you did by just not responding. So they made a concerted
00:07:27 effort early on that you were not going to be permitted absolutely and just to give your
00:07:32 audience a full picture of what's going on behind the scenes there is they've really started to lock
00:07:37 these events down that trudeau is at they do not want people to know where he is they do not want
00:07:42 protesters showing up trudeau is hated in canada right now and especially in the west and people
00:07:48 tend to find out where these events are happening they tend to find out where he's staying and they
00:07:51 go and protest and so we've seen them really up the ante and trying to keep these things secret
00:07:55 I sent out a lot of requests a lot of people in the province who are always in the know
00:07:59 did not know where either of these events were happening they didn't know where the meeting with
00:08:02 the premier was happening and they didn't know where that dental care announcement was happening
00:08:06 so things were really under wraps this time and we just saw the police go to that extra effort
00:08:11 just to make sure that two little journalists wouldn't be able to even so much as ask the 0.98
00:08:15 prime minister a question because that would be too much of a nuisance for our beloved prime
00:08:19 minister and we couldn't offend his ears with you know some some conservative journalists asking him
00:08:24 some questions. We saw something similar with the Alberta NDP. They really tried hard to keep their
00:08:30 press conferences and their announcements under wraps, but in that case, they were also trying
00:08:36 to get the word out to have other people come, so they didn't do so very effectively, and we
00:08:39 typically found them in advance. But it's going to be interesting to see what future visits from
00:08:43 the Prime Minister to Calgary look like, because I think they've decided this is the new model that
00:08:47 they're going to use, where they're just going to be super secretive. We couldn't even get
00:08:50 information from the premier's office. The premier's office said, no, we can't share this.
00:08:55 That would be a breach of security contract with the prime minister's office. So they were taking
00:08:59 this very seriously as well. And I was a little bit like, well, what's the prime minister ever
00:09:02 done for Alberta? Yeah. Has he earned that? Has he earned that from them? Just to go to the policy
00:09:08 aspect here, we've seen this week and I'll be talking about it in a moment, this carbon tax
00:09:12 revolt being waged by seven of 10 provincial premiers so far. Ground zero for that has really
00:09:19 been Alberta. So to some extent, I mean, Trudeau yesterday was in the belly of the beast here,
00:09:24 but absolutely unrepentant when he asked. He went on, I think it was like some eight minute long
00:09:28 rant defending the carbon tax yesterday at that presser, didn't he?
00:09:32 Pretty remarkable. I mean, Justin Trudeau is someone who doesn't learn his lessons. He's
00:09:36 someone who doesn't care what the Canadian people think. We understand that because he chooses to
00:09:40 stay at the most expensive hotels wherever he travels. This has been a controversy for the
00:09:45 prime minister time and time again. He simply does not care about the cost of his luxury lifestyle
00:09:52 that he's passing on to taxpayers. That's one thing that's been incredibly obvious for us.
00:09:56 Another thing is even the simple fact that he won't allow a regular person like myself into
00:10:01 his press conferences to ask questions because I'm not considered an elite accredited media.
00:10:05 I'm honestly just a mom. I've got a very successful podcast, one of the most listened to shows in
00:10:09 Alberta, if not the most popular political podcast in the province. And he isn't even willing to give
00:10:14 me so much as a question or to allow me to enter a room that he's in or probably even look in the
00:10:19 same direction as him if we're being honest so this is a prime minister who generally hates
00:10:24 canadians and so i'm not surprised that he's not budging on the carbon tax something i will say
00:10:28 that is interesting is that i had cheryl out on my show the alberta roundup yesterday she used to be 1.00
00:10:33 the director of communications for former alberta premier rachel notley who as we know is resigning
00:10:37 once a new leader is selected and she said that the carbon tax is poison in alberta right now
00:10:43 It's an extremely unpopular policy. She said that while she agrees with what the policy is trying to accomplish, it's just not going to be very feasible for politicians in Alberta right now. So here we even have someone who worked for the Alberta NDP signaling the fact that this is a policy that's really a no-go right now. So even she can kind of understand this is something we need to change direction on, but not Trudeau because this is a man who is unwilling to admit when he's wrong.
00:11:08 Very well said, Rachel Emanuel.
00:11:10 Glad you emerged unscathed, no handcuffs, no trespassing ticket, but good on you for trying.
00:11:16 Maybe he'll take some time before returning to Alberta because of your effort.
00:11:19 So I appreciate your time as always, Rachel.
00:11:21 Happy to be here. See you guys.
00:11:23 All right. Thank you for that.
00:11:24 And just on the provincial aspect here, I want to talk about this because this is quite a significant issue.
00:11:30 We're talking about this carbon tax revolt that has been waged by 7 of 10 premiers right now.
00:11:37 So the Premier of Alberta, Danielle Smith, the Premier of Saskatchewan, Scott Moe.
00:11:41 I shouldn't commit to naming them all because I usually get a little foggy when I get to Atlantic Canada.
00:11:45 But no, I think I know I can do them all.
00:11:47 I'm going to do it.
00:11:48 All right.
00:11:48 We have Alberta Premier, Danielle Smith, Saskatchewan Premier, Scott Moe.
00:11:51 We have Ontario Premier, Doug Ford.
00:11:55 Oh, I'm already losing track.
00:11:56 No.
00:11:56 And then we have Newfoundland Premier, Andrew Fury.
00:11:59 We have Dennis King in PEI.
00:12:02 We have Blaine Higgs in New Brunswick and Tim Houston in Nova Scotia.
00:12:06 That is seven right there.
00:12:08 The other three, David Eby, Wob Canoe, and, of course, Francois Legault from BC, Manitoba, and Quebec, respectively, are the lone three.
00:12:17 Sean was trying to give me notes, by the way.
00:12:20 I want it known I didn't even look at them.
00:12:21 I did those all by memory.
00:12:23 Sometimes I call Anthony Fury the premier of Newfoundland, though, which I'm not sure either appreciates the confusion on.
00:12:29 But only three premiers have not done what those seven have done.
00:12:35 And those are the premiers of B.C., Manitoba and Quebec, which are all very much all in.
00:12:40 Well, Manitoba is a bit of a weird case, but Quebec and B.C. are all in on the carbon tax.
00:12:45 The other seven, some liberals and some conservatives in there are saying, hey, we need to give our people a break.
00:12:53 We need to give our people a break.
00:12:54 And it's fascinating to me that it's been this issue that has united politicians from different party stripes.
00:13:02 one of the galvanizing forces has been this increase to the carbon tax, which is coming in
00:13:08 September, or sorry, coming April 1st. So just two weeks from now, the carbon tax is going up
00:13:14 yet again, and it has several increases built in. After this year, it's going to continue
00:13:19 to increase. And Wob Canoe, so yesterday he was pushed on this because Manitobans, I mean,
00:13:26 Manitoba is not a warm place.
00:13:29 No one says let's vacation in balmy Manitoba.
00:13:32 It is a very cold place.
00:13:34 So Wob Canoe knows full well that the people he represents are grappling with the cost of the carbon tax.
00:13:40 It's also a very rural place.
00:13:42 People need to drive to get around.
00:13:43 There's no big subway that goes from Winnipeg to Churchill so that people can just take public transit.
00:13:48 This is a significant challenge, but he won't even say whether or not he has asked the government
00:13:56 to put the brakes on the increase.
00:13:58 Take a look at this clip.
00:14:00 Well, we've been very clear
00:14:01 that Manitoba is a really strong case to make
00:14:03 in terms of the carbon backstop
00:14:07 not being applied in our province.
00:14:08 And that's because Manitobans
00:14:10 have made huge investments in renewable power.
00:14:13 And we have a low carbon energy source here in Manitoba.
00:14:17 So our province has taken action to help you.
00:14:19 We've cut the provincial gas tax.
00:14:21 That's 14 cents a liter
00:14:22 that you save every time you gas up.
00:14:24 And so we're going to continue to make life more affordable for people.
00:14:27 Sorry, my question was, will you ask the federal government to cancel the planned carbon increase?
00:14:32 Well, we've made a very clear statement on an ongoing basis that Manitoba is a really strong case to make.
00:14:37 And we're going to continue to make that case that we don't need the backstop here in Manitoba.
00:14:42 So you will ask them not to? You're going to make a formal request?
00:14:47 Who's to say we haven't? That would be an assumption.
00:14:50 Have you?
00:14:50 That would be an assumption.
00:14:51 Have you?
00:14:52 Have you made that request?
00:14:55 You know, conversations that we have with the federal level are private until we decide to make them public.
00:15:01 Will you ask the federal government to pause the carbon tax increase?
00:15:05 Who's to say we haven't?
00:15:07 Okay, well, have you?
00:15:08 Oh, that's confidential.
00:15:09 I can't say it.
00:15:10 So he won't even say whether he's had a conversation with the federal government asking them for relief on the carbon tax.
00:15:17 Now, this is perhaps the NDP in Manitoba getting a little bit of pressure from its federal NDP friends, maybe not wanting to make them look bad.
00:15:25 Alberta NDP leadership candidates right now are completely against the carbon tax.
00:15:30 It's been fascinating to see that even the left wing NDP in Alberta knows it cannot sell a carbon tax to people in that province.
00:15:39 So none of those people vying for the leadership of the NDP, which is already a bit of a thankless job.
00:15:44 You've got folks like Sarah Hoffman there and now Nahid Nenshi entering the race. 1.00
00:15:48 They're all saying, yeah, most of them, not all, are saying, well, we think the carbon tax is toxic, so we are not going to run on that.
00:15:55 Now, in spite of this, when seven of ten first ministers in the federation are saying to the prime minister, you've got to stop this,
00:16:03 this is, in my view, verging on a crisis in federalism for a piece of legislation whose constitutionality is already a little bit dubious.
00:16:12 I mean, yes, the Supreme Court has upheld the carbon tax, but it was on very narrow grounds that they ultimately sided with the government's argument that this was a matter of federal jurisdiction.
00:16:22 So politically, morally, Justin Trudeau should be making a much greater appeal to his provincial counterparts who are not meant to be subordinates.
00:16:31 They're meant to be, it's meant to be where the Justin Trudeau prime minister role right now is the first among equals.
00:16:37 He has his domain. The provincial premiers has their domain.
00:16:41 But instead, he looks at them as minions that have to do his bidding when he orders a carbon tax on the beleaguered residents of those governments that were not putting forward policies of that nature.
00:16:53 Now, Scott Moe in Saskatchewan, they've, I think, been the most aggressive because they've actually just stopped paying the government.
00:16:58 They have stopped remitting the tax.
00:17:01 This was Trudeau's response to that yesterday.
00:17:03 Given that Saskatchewan has decided not to rebate the carbon tax, there's been some
00:17:11 question over possible penalties over the Saskatchewan Premier breaking the law.
00:17:16 It's something that Danielle Smith has been worried about as well.
00:17:20 And it all seems to kind of come back to the carve out for the home heating oil back in
00:17:25 Atlantic Canada. So the question is, what would these consequences be for not rebating the tax?
00:17:31 on the decision by the government of Saskatchewan
00:17:36 to not pay its taxes to the federal government.
00:17:42 As we've seen from a few different premiers,
00:17:44 you can use the notwithstanding clause
00:17:46 to opt out of basic charter rights of Canadians.
00:17:51 I think it's a bad idea, but a number of people are doing it.
00:17:53 You can opt out of the charter of rights and freedoms
00:17:55 by using the notwithstanding clause.
00:17:58 but you can't opt out of the federation you can't opt out of canada we have we are a country of laws
00:18:09 we're a country of rules and responsibilities and it was it's evolved over 150 plus years
00:18:18 to be this extraordinarily successful country we have
00:18:21 and we expect people to obey the law that's what governments expect of their citizens
00:18:29 that's what citizens should expect of their governments he says you can't opt out of the
00:18:37 federation but that's exactly what he's doing by taking such a scornful and disdainful view
00:18:42 of the provinces again there many of them are not even saying get rid of the carbon tax altogether
00:18:48 they're saying hey maybe you cool it on the increase on just adding insult to injury rubbing
00:18:53 salt in the wound uh kicking them when they're down pick your cliche pick your metaphor but he
00:18:58 they're saying just don't do the increase that just don't increase the gas tax the carbon tax
00:19:04 the heating tax the cost of living even further in two weeks give us a break is what they're saying
00:19:09 and he's saying yeah doesn't matter and when provincial premiers like danielle smith like 0.96
00:19:15 like the environment minister in Alberta, Rebecca Schultz,
00:19:17 both of whom have been on the show many times,
00:19:19 have said they cannot even have a relationship
00:19:22 with the federal environment minister, Stephen Gilbeau.
00:19:25 This is what Justin Trudeau says about those concerns.
00:19:29 In regards to my environment minister,
00:19:33 I have tremendous faith and confidence in my environment minister.
00:19:37 And if people are having trouble getting along with them,
00:19:41 maybe they need to look at their own approach to these big issues as opposed to looking at what
00:19:48 he's talking about, which is consistent with building a better future for everyone.
00:19:54 Oh, isn't that nice? It's right up there with Albertans should elect more Liberal MPs if they
00:19:59 want a seat at the table. It's, well, if people can't work with Stephen Gobeau, that's their
00:20:04 problem, not his, not ours, not mine. Justin Trudeau is saying it's his way or the highway,
00:20:09 except there's no highway because Stephen Gilboa wants to effectively ban roads. So tough for all
00:20:14 of us here. Let's delve into this with Colin Craig. He is the president of SecondStreet.org,
00:20:19 which does a lot of tremendous work on health care, which is, I think, at its core, a federalism
00:20:24 debate that takes place. And I know he's also done work on carbon taxes and the like as well.
00:20:29 Colin, good to talk to you. Thanks for coming on today. Just before we delve into the meat of the
00:20:34 carbon tax stuff, what do you make of this fractured relationship between provinces and
00:20:39 government we're not just talking here about you know one lone renegade western premier that is
00:20:44 having difficulty with the trudeau policy you've got seven of ten premiers representing the majority
00:20:49 of the population and of the provinces that are saying to the government stop doing this thing
00:20:55 well look it's always interesting and entertaining when a policy you think is a failure uh starts to
00:21:02 fail and everyone can see it uh at least almost everyone i mean it at its core the carbon tax is
00:21:08 bad public policy. There's no doubt about it. The way that the federal government has gone about
00:21:12 this, it's bad public policy. It's failing. I think most politicians are able to smell that out.
00:21:19 They can see it's bad policy. It's not a good decision. And so they're rebelling. Like you
00:21:23 said, at the provincial level, you've got all these premiers. You said seven. I think there's
00:21:27 a case to argue that lob canoes, so maybe seven and a half, eight, because I mean, he's basically
00:21:33 rejected the policy by cutting their own provincial gas tax to give Manitobans some
00:21:40 breathing room there. So, you know, I think you've got most politicians in the country realizing and
00:21:46 saying this is a bad policy. You got to back away from it. Canadians are struggling right now.
00:21:50 Businesses are struggling. Certainly many of them are. And yet you've got the prime minister just
00:21:56 going full steam ahead on a really bad policy. It's bad politics too, Andrew. I mean, look,
00:22:02 he's down and out in the polls. He's way behind. Cost of living is the number one issue. And he
00:22:08 just keeps raising taxes. Like it's a bad, bad decision politically. It's bad economically.
00:22:15 It is what it is now. Well, and look, I ran for office once previously. And one of the things
00:22:21 that really stood out to me was that of all the thousands and thousands of doors I knocked on and
00:22:26 people I spoke to, when I asked, you know, what your number one issue was, only one person out of
00:22:31 I think 22,000 doors said environment.
00:22:34 And that's not to say it's not an issue that matters.
00:22:36 It's not to say it's an issue that matters to people,
00:22:38 but it tends to be issues like that in my experience
00:22:41 tend to be secondary when your house is on fire.
00:22:45 And by that, I mean your economic house,
00:22:47 when you can't afford groceries,
00:22:48 when you can't afford to fill up your car.
00:22:50 A lot of these things look like luxury items.
00:22:52 And I think it would be reasonable
00:22:54 for the government to say, listen,
00:22:55 we think that just to use their own framing for a moment,
00:22:59 And I think that climate is really important.
00:23:02 I think carbon tax is the best way to get there.
00:23:04 However, I realize that right now Canadians are struggling.
00:23:07 We're going to just put a pause on this while still committing to the overall policy and
00:23:11 objective.
00:23:11 But the issue is they know if they do that, they're going to have to be the ones that
00:23:14 reintroduce it at a certain point.
00:23:16 But you're right that it's bad politics also, because right now you have seven, seven and
00:23:21 a half fingers pointing at the federal government saying, you guys are the reason that people
00:23:25 are having to deal with this increase.
00:23:27 And that's not something they had when they first sold this policy.
00:23:31 No, it's not.
00:23:32 I mean, let's step back for a second here.
00:23:35 When has a prime minister in this country created a tax for everyone else but himself?
00:23:40 I mean, there's probably only a handful of people in this country that don't really have to pay the carbon tax.
00:23:46 The prime minister.
00:23:48 Why?
00:23:48 Because you and I and all your viewers and all the taxpayers in this country pay to heat his residence.
00:23:54 so he's not paying the carbon tax when he has to heat his residence uh he's not filling up any car
00:24:00 at the pumps like the rest of us right he gets chauffeured around someone's always paying for
00:24:05 his transportation doesn't have to pay for their i mean taxpayers pay i believe for some of his
00:24:10 groceries and meals and so forth so he's essentially created this tax that he doesn't have to pay
00:24:15 everyone else does and and so that could be part of why he doesn't understand why so many people
00:24:21 are upset. Never mind the fact that he's making close to $400,000 a year. He's got a golden
00:24:26 pension and so forth. I mean, he's not feeling this issue the same way that everyday Canadians
00:24:31 are. His cabinet certainly isn't either. I mean, they're extremely well paid, again,
00:24:35 golden pension and so forth. They don't have to feel that. But, you know, I think media need to
00:24:41 maybe point that out to him. The second thing is why I think this is failing is just look at his
00:24:45 own behavior right i mean since he declared a climate emergency in parliament he's traveled
00:24:52 to costa rica twice he's traveled down to jamaica twice he's flown to montana he's gone to tofino
00:25:00 a couple times like i mean he's flying all over the place in the government's private jet
00:25:04 and i don't think anyone can begrudge a prime minister for wanting to have some vacation time
00:25:10 but he is saying that there's a climate emergency and he is routinely getting into an airplane
00:25:17 flying all over the place and creating all kinds of unnecessary emissions by his own standard
00:25:23 so i mean he is just demonstrating that the carbon tax has failed or else he would have
00:25:28 changed his own behavior and he hasn't so yeah and that's the problem is that there tends to be
00:25:34 from defenders of the carbon tax a significant overstatement of how many of these carbon emitting
00:25:40 things are are uh are optional or elective for people i mean if you live in the country and
00:25:46 you've got to drive your kids to school uh 50 50 minutes or something or if you have to drive to
00:25:52 work a certain distance or if you need to buy groceries for your family i mean these are not
00:25:57 discretionary things so uh the average canadian is forced to just look at the increased price and
00:26:02 and say, okay, I guess I'm paying that
00:26:03 and not say, maybe I'm only going to drive
00:26:06 three quarters of the way to school this morning.
00:26:08 Yeah, I mean, you're exactly right.
00:26:10 You talked about Manitoba before.
00:26:12 I'm from there originally.
00:26:13 I mean, it gets extremely freezing cold in the winter.
00:26:16 It's not like you can, as you just know,
00:26:18 you can't just go, yeah,
00:26:19 maybe we'll go without heat this winter.
00:26:21 No, you'll die.
00:26:22 You'll die if you don't have proper heat
00:26:25 in Manitoba in the winter.
00:26:27 I mean, we just, for our TV show,
00:26:28 we did an episode on heat pumps recently
00:26:30 and people keep talking about heat pumps.
00:26:32 Very fascinating technology. Maybe it gets better in the future, but you're not surviving in Manitoba all winter on a heat pump. It just won't work. You need to have that natural gas component. Maybe a heat pump can help a bit, but we're not there. I mean, we need these things like natural gas to heat our homes. We need things like gasoline to power our vehicles and so forth.
00:26:55 I mean, the idea that we're all switching to electric cars anytime soon, that's fantasy.
00:27:01 They cost a fortune and, you know, a lot of households are struggling right now to get
00:27:06 by and never mind having to drop $50,000 or whatever on an electric car, right?
00:27:11 This doesn't add up, Andrew.
00:27:13 No, it certainly does not.
00:27:15 Colin Craig from secondstreet.org, great work there.
00:27:18 I wanted to ask you briefly, just while I had you here, about Mark Holland, because
00:27:22 know this way he got under your uh under your skin this past week i think he did yeah i mean he's
00:27:28 just is another example i think of how the elite in this country are often detached from everyday
00:27:34 people i mean if you're a politician you got a lot of money and resources if you ever face a
00:27:39 long wait time in the healthcare system you can go abroad you don't have to worry about it he was
00:27:42 kind of poo-pooing people that do that and and saying like it's it's not necessary we can't allow
00:27:48 that to happen in canada blah blah blah but reality is a lot of people are suffering in this country
00:27:53 it's not just the wealthy that are going abroad i mean we're talking all the time with mid-linked
00:27:58 people who are doing it they're suffering they're living with chronic chronic pain and people can't
00:28:03 do that for a year or two it's inhumane so we need health reform we need a mature discussion about
00:28:09 this in this country to see start to see these reforms happen and ottawa's approach is let's just
00:28:14 throw more money at the health care system and hope things work out and it's not adding up i mean
00:28:20 we've got to move beyond this simply throwing money at the system stage and
00:28:24 our call and i don't think it's the minister to to take us there colin craig thank you very much
00:28:29 sir thanks andrew always appreciate the chat all right likewise one of the most worrying trends
00:28:36 we have seen in canada in the last couple of years has been the weaponization of the judicial process
00:28:43 and how, first off, absent the judicial process is when it comes to matters of civil liberty.
00:28:49 But even when you look at the way that certain cases are prosecuted,
00:28:52 we've all seen stories of this revolving door for people that are arrested
00:28:56 for very violent or very despicable offenses,
00:29:00 and they find themselves out on bail basically immediately.
00:29:03 And then you have, in contrast with that, cases like that of Tamara Leach and Chris Barber,
00:29:08 two of the organizers of the Freedom Convoy who were arrested in February 2022 didn't go on trial
00:29:16 until September 2023 and we are now six months later and their trial is still underway with no
00:29:24 immediately discernible or identified end in sight. Now in the case of Tamara Leach she languished
00:29:31 behind bars I think it was for about 49 days if memory serves whereas Chris Barber was fortunate
00:29:36 enough to get released on bail not long after his arrest but the cases of both of them i think
00:29:43 raise significant questions about whether there is a politicized a politicization of the prosecution
00:29:49 uh you look in contrast to the case in coots four now this is a bit of a trickier one because there
00:29:54 has been for a lot of this a publication ban around key details so i haven't actually been
00:30:00 able to talk about a lot of the case because of this limitation but what we do know is that two
00:30:04 of the coots four were released on lesser charges uh the other two are still incarcerated have been
00:30:10 denied bail and they are awaiting trial on charges of a conspiracy to kill police officers again very
00:30:17 serious charges but they like anyone else have a right to their day in court but i've heard more
00:30:22 than ever before in the time i've covered crime and justice issues people that simply do not trust
00:30:28 the justice system. And there was a fascinating essay in the C2C Journal about the worrisome
00:30:34 wave of politicized prosecutions. It was written by Gwyn Morgan, who is a legend in the Canadian
00:30:41 oil and gas sector. He was the CEO of Encana back when, well, back when it was Encana and also back
00:30:46 when it was a Canadian company. And he's always been a tremendous supporter of True North. Gwyn
00:30:51 Morgan, good to have you back on the show. Thank you so much for your time. Can you hear me, Gwyn?
00:30:58 I don't know if you can hear me. I hear noise coming from your end.
00:31:04 All right, we'll have to sort out that audio issue there and get Gwynne back. But this is
00:31:10 an essay that was a very fascinating and very evocative read. And it's always important when
00:31:15 you're writing about or reporting on justice issues to separate someone's crime or alleged
00:31:22 crime from your assessment of the justice system itself. And it's the same as when you
00:31:28 talk about free speech, you need to be able to talk about the essence of free speech and the
00:31:32 importance of free speech and do so in a way that is dispassionate compared to the individual
00:31:39 expressions. But at the other side of that, you have to also look at just the fundamental
00:31:46 principles of justice. And what are the rights people have? People have a right to face their
00:31:51 accuser they have a right to know what their charges are they have a right to see the case
00:31:54 against them and crucially they have a right to a speedy trial now I don't pretend to be a lawyer
00:32:00 I've covered a lot of cases and I've picked up some of the legal principles along the way
00:32:05 but when you have cases that last years and someone is denied bail in that time period
00:32:11 and no one has seen the case against them it makes it very difficult for the public
00:32:16 which is supposed to have,
00:32:18 the public needs to hold the justice system in repute
00:32:20 for the justice system to have any legitimacy whatsoever.
00:32:24 You have people in the public
00:32:25 that are unable to really deal with this.
00:32:28 And it's not to say that the court of public opinion
00:32:30 is driving the real court process
00:32:33 and the real legal process.
00:32:34 But if you don't have confidence in the system,
00:32:38 if you don't have confidence in the process,
00:32:40 the process itself just is basically meaningless.
00:32:43 And that's when you have cases
00:32:44 where people are protesting outside courts
00:32:47 because they just believe that everyone is co-opted.
00:32:50 And again, it's an amusing story,
00:32:52 but I think it's relevant to this.
00:32:54 This week, there was a Supreme Court decision
00:32:56 and the Supreme Court decision was,
00:33:00 it had a paragraph that was just
00:33:02 one of the most bizarrely worded,
00:33:04 sloppily worded paragraphs
00:33:06 in which Justice Sheila Martin,
00:33:08 who was appointed by Justin Trudeau,
00:33:09 I think in 2017,
00:33:11 you had Sheila Martin say
00:33:14 that a woman was a confusing word and instead of using woman you should use the less confusing 0.96
00:33:21 person with a vagina and this was summarily mocked by a lot of observers then people said well no 0.96
00:33:27 she didn't say that what she actually meant was this and and it kind of underscores the confusion 0.98
00:33:31 there because someone's reading what is officially law in canada now part of a supreme court decision
00:33:37 and they can't seem to agree on what it's all about and then you had the supreme court the
00:33:41 female justices on the supreme court last week on international women's day march 8th they were all 0.98
00:33:47 posing for this photo and the accompanying tweet was basically talking about gender-based
00:33:53 appointments to the court instead of merit-based appointments and again how can you have confidence
00:33:59 in the justice system when this is the type of rhetoric that courts are putting out and to bring
00:34:05 bring it back into the covet realm for a moment you may recall there was a case in uh well it
00:34:11 it wasn't a case. It was an interview. I think it was with Le Devoir. It was a French language
00:34:16 publication that the Chief Justice Richard Wagner did. And in that interview, he was speaking about
00:34:22 the Freedom Convoy and spoke about Ottawa being under siege. He spoke about these, basically this
00:34:29 lawlessness, I think anarchy, I think he used the word anarchy in the streets of Ottawa. And here
00:34:34 you have a case where, okay, the Chief Justice is playing political pundit now. How is he to respond
00:34:41 when a case about the Freedom Convoy invariably goes before the Supreme Court? And how are people
00:34:46 supposed to have confidence in his decision when he has already given his personal opinion about
00:34:51 this thing that may be at the core of a case? So I think there are plenty of reasons that people
00:34:57 can and are, can distrust and are generally distrustful of the justice system and of the
00:35:04 justice process. But it brings about the bigger question of how do you restore that trust,
00:35:10 especially when it looks like there is a politicization underway and there is politicking
00:35:16 going on in what is supposed to be, again, reason free from passion. The old line, I believe it was
00:35:21 Aristotle said, or at least is often attributed to Aristotle. I realized I learned it was Aristotle
00:35:27 from Legally Blonde, and I'm not sure if Legally Blonde had accurately quoted him, but nevertheless,
00:35:32 Legally Blonde notwithstanding, this is why I'm not a lawyer, because I just quote
00:35:36 Reese Witherspoon chick flicks when I'm talking about the law.
00:35:39 But all of that notwithstanding, we have Gwyn Morgan back on.
00:35:42 We've sorted out the gremlins in the system here.
00:35:44 Gwyn, good to have you back on.
00:35:46 Thanks for coming today.
00:35:47 Oh, thank you.
00:35:47 And the reason I have this passion, I'm not trying to be like the old Captain Morgan the pirate.
00:35:53 It's really because I just had an eye operation and I have to have it on for a few days.
00:35:57 All right.
00:35:58 Well, I hope you're healing up and I appreciate you not letting you get in the way of our interview, the schedule today.
00:36:03 But so you've delved into this incredibly important issue here in the politicization of the political process.
00:36:09 And I'm always clear to say that, you know, we have to see in some of these cases which are still ongoing, what the courts are going to find and what the facts are.
00:36:17 But why was this bothering you so much looking at this from the sidelines?
00:36:22 Well, when you look at this whole situation, when you talk about the truckers convoy, the prosecution of them,
00:36:28 There's been eight persons associated with the convoys, both at Coutts and in Ottawa, who have served nine years in jail without parole, with which what now a judge has ruled is not even a crime.
00:36:46 And yet, you know, we open the papers every few days and we see a violent, somebody killed by someone released on the catch and release system, committing a murder, a horrible murder.
00:36:57 And so the only explanation for this, Andrew, is political interference in the justice system.
00:37:06 And I think it starts at the top.
00:37:09 Let's unpack that for a moment, because do you think the issue is that there is a case of judges taking their marching orders, perhaps not explicitly, but implicitly from political leaders?
00:37:20 Or do you think it's just in who's getting appointed to the bench?
00:37:22 Do you think it's just that leaders are appointing judges of a certain political persuasion and this is just their bias on display?
00:37:30 Well, there's no doubt about the first part, about the last part of that.
00:37:33 I mean, the Supreme Court, the head of the Supreme Court, just a recent, he's been appointed by Trudeau.
00:37:43 And so the court is, there's no question the Supreme Court is now politicized to an extent that probably never before.
00:37:52 yeah and and you had mentioned in your piece the story that i just shared on the show a moment ago
00:37:58 of him doing an interview and i mean the idea of supreme court justice is doing interviews
00:38:02 i think is problematic for a number of reasons this is one of them but he gives his opinion
00:38:07 about this issue that like anyone knows is going to end up before him as a case in some form whether
00:38:14 it's someone appealing their criminal charge or whether it's the emergencies act going before the
00:38:19 Supreme Court, but he's already now put on record that he believes the Freedom Convoy was holding
00:38:23 people hostage. So how is he expected to set that aside when he makes an adjudication on the convoy
00:38:29 or a case related to it? He can't be expected and he won't. That's the problem. I mean,
00:38:35 we've had, what we've had is eight persons arrested for participation in Freedom Convoys
00:38:42 and they have served nine years nine years in jail without parole
00:38:49 for something that now has been ruled not even it's not even it's been ruled by a recent judge
00:38:56 it's not even a crime so where do you think this issue started or when do you think it started
00:39:03 because i i would say that there have probably been i i think that the issues are a lot more
00:39:07 explicit and in your face now but i i don't think this is a new phenomenon i i wouldn't even argue
00:39:11 and you may disagree gwen that i wouldn't even argue it started with justin trudeau
00:39:17 well i don't know it seems like that's such a long time ago my friend stephen harper would
00:39:23 would have wouldn't have had anything like this so i think that the whole deterioration of the
00:39:27 systems is is consistent with their trudeau uh reign and his actions on the freedom con on the on
00:39:35 and the Emergencies Act itself were now seen to be unnecessary and possibly illegal.
00:39:44 Yeah, and you had mentioned, just to go back to that point we were discussing a few moments ago
00:39:48 about, you know, whether this is, you know, whether they're picking up implicit signals,
00:39:52 these judges, or getting direct interference.
00:39:56 No one seems interested in asking.
00:39:58 I mean, that's the lack of curiosity from some of my colleagues in the media about these issues
00:40:02 has been quite maybe not astonishing but disappointing well one of the things in my
00:40:07 column i spend quite a bad time was how the terrible treatment of tamara leach 1.00
00:40:11 who's a an indigenous woman who went to help out with the communications and an organization of the 0.95
00:40:19 convoy but she never committed a crime and she has been persecuted continuously and one of the 0.91
00:40:26 things, and her case is still going on. It's still going on today, and the trial will resume soon.
00:40:36 And yet, this woman has been persecuted beyond reason, because that can only happen 0.94
00:40:47 if there's direction from the top. Well, and the thing I would also point out in the case of
00:40:53 Tamera Leach is that like the argument for keeping her behind bars because she spent she I think it 1.00
00:40:58 was 19 days she was released and then rearrested for another 30 days so I think 49 was the total
00:41:03 I might be you know give or take one or two but she I mean she was unvaccinated she couldn't board 1.00
00:41:08 a plane she wasn't a flight risk uh she wasn't violent she wasn't at risk to reoffend because
00:41:13 the protest was over like there was no defensible reason to keep her incarcerated and especially
00:41:18 when you contrast it with all of these catch and release policies that you've alluded to
00:41:22 where people who are reoffending are being just sent out of jail immediately after their arrest?
00:41:29 Well, this is a petite woman who was charged with committing the offenses of obstructing 1.00
00:41:38 police officers and endangering the public. This little woman, she was marched to a jail, 1.00
00:41:46 thrown down into a cell and then and then eventually it put into another part of the
00:41:52 jail system back and forth and her trial is still going on she's still being persecuted 1.00
00:41:57 and the prosecutor himself has said that they want to make a special case uh to show teacher
00:42:03 a lesson and when that happens uh you how can that otherwise happen without some that if either
00:42:10 implicit or explicit interaction and that's an important point because i ideally if you are
00:42:16 I mean, yes, sentencing is in a roundabout way meant to be a deterrent.
00:42:20 But when you're on trial, you want the case to be about you and your conduct and your actions,
00:42:25 not you as a symbol for society that the prosecution wants to punish.
00:42:30 And they have done that with Tamera.
00:42:31 They've been very explicit about that.
00:42:33 They don't want to just put her on trial. 0.52
00:42:34 They want to put the whole convoy on trial through her. 0.85
00:42:38 Well, I think that's exactly right.
00:42:40 And, you know, you probably saw that recently.
00:42:42 A judge came out and actually ruled that there was no crime committed.
00:42:46 with a with a freedom convoy yeah well that the yeah that it wasn't an emergency the federal court
00:42:52 decision that you know basically the entire premise of this national emergency just did not
00:42:55 exist yeah no very very well said it was a great piece in c2c journal called the worrisome wave of
00:43:02 politicized prosecutions i don't i don't think you could hear me when i i did my initial introduction
00:43:07 but i i said you were a legend in oil and gas and i'm uh grateful for your work at the helm of
00:43:11 in Canada, which is neither a Canadian nor called in Canada anymore. So you're a representative of
00:43:16 the glory days of that. But Gwyn Morgan, always good to talk to you. Thanks for coming on.
00:43:20 Thank you, Andrew.
00:43:21 All right. And thanks for your support of True North as well. It's very much appreciated. That
00:43:25 does it for us for today. We'll be back to, well, no, we won't be back tomorrow. I'll be back on
00:43:30 Off the Record tomorrow, but the Andrew Lawton Show resumes on Monday. So have a wonderful weekend.
00:43:35 We'll see you on Monday. Thank you. God bless and good day to you all.
00:43:41 to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:44:11 We'll be right back.
00:44:41 We'll be right back.
00:45:11 You