Juno News - April 09, 2024


Activists say Trudeau should be spending more on climate change

Topics
Mentioned
Western provinces are taking a stand for gun owners Will there be a federal election this fall?

Episode Stats


Length

41 minutes

Words per minute

176.64

Word count

7,418

Sentence count

308

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

7

sentences flagged

Hate speech

5

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

On today's show, True North's Andrew Lawton is in the midst of a trip to the Canada Strong and Free Network Annual Conference in Ottawa, where he's interviewing Tony Abbott. Plus, there's a solar eclipse, and a new report that suggests the federal government isn't doing enough to fight climate change.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcription by CastingWords
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:19 north hello and welcome to you all this is another edition of canada's most irreverent
00:01:29 talk show here on true north it is tuesday april 9th 2024 we are doing things a little
00:01:36 bit differently we're doing the uh old like a weird corner of a hotel room uh set that we have
00:01:42 had to do on a few occasions uh the rest of the week we will be in a an on location studio which
00:01:48 is not based on like propping a laptop up on an ironing board, which sounds crazy, but I've often
00:01:54 said in hotel rooms, ironing boards are the unsung hero of Zoom calls because it's like the only
00:01:59 adjustable height surface you can find in here. So if you just find that the thing collapses in
00:02:04 the middle of the show, that's probably why, but it seems to be working. I am in Ottawa right now
00:02:09 where we are just on the eve of the Canada Strong and Free Network annual conference from which
00:02:14 True North will be broadcasting live the rest of the week.
00:02:18 Things get started there tomorrow afternoon and carry on until the weekend.
00:02:22 We've got some great interviews planned, including with the former Prime Minister of Australia, Tony Abbott.
00:02:28 And who else do we have?
00:02:29 Some of our old friends, the cast of characters you see on the show, like Chris Sims and Aaron Woodrick, will be dropping by in person.
00:02:36 We'll also hopefully find some current, former, and perhaps future politicians.
00:02:40 and then we'll just basically grab anyone who looks interesting who happens to be walking by
00:02:44 the studio. I say studio, by our booth. If they seem interesting, we'll grab them on. So if you
00:02:50 are uninteresting and you walk back and forth like seven or eight times and we don't pull you in,
00:02:54 I'm sorry, you just didn't make the cut. But do keep an eye out for that coverage from True North
00:02:59 over the next few days. One thing I will also bring up here is that I know many of you were
00:03:04 observing the great eclipse yesterday. Like I said, I'm in Ottawa, so we weren't in the
00:03:08 path of totality, but I was still like panicking not to look up just accidentally. I felt, so I
00:03:14 was really tired yesterday. I didn't get a lot of sleep two nights ago. By the end of the day
00:03:18 yesterday, I was, my eyes were hurting because they had just been open for far too long. And I
00:03:23 had that moment of panic of like, wait, did I look at the eclipse? Is this why I was getting all
00:03:28 paranoid? Do I have the long eclipse? Someone who does not have long eclipse is our good friend,
00:03:34 Dr. Nilly Kaplan-Mirth. She is, I'm in her city, so I have to pay tribute to her. Nilly Kaplan-Mirth
00:03:40 is an Ottawa school trustee, and she had her Eclipse goggles ready to go yesterday.
00:03:49 Ah, yeah, she was, as she says in the post, they're trying to troll the anti-science, 0.87
00:03:56 what is it, the anti-sci, I can't read that word, she's trying to, the nitwits,
00:04:00 The anti-science nitwits because she has the progress pride flag, the eclipse glasses, and the N95 mask while she is outside. 0.76
00:04:08 Now, the joke is on her because I suspect she'll be wearing those eclipse glasses basically for the next 10 years anytime she is stepping outside. 0.98
00:04:17 So that's something that we should definitely keep an eye out, no pun intended, for there.
00:04:22 Let me just bring up first and foremost here why I think we are missing the boat on a lot of what government's doing.
00:04:29 So the big climate change file is one that, according to some activists, the federal government is not spending enough money on.
00:04:38 Yeah, this was a story that True North has kept an eye on.
00:04:43 I saw it in the Toronto Star.
00:04:44 Now, their framing of this is a little bit different than what perhaps your and my framing would be.
00:04:49 But there's a research company that focuses on sustainable finance, the sustainable economy.
00:04:55 It's called Corporate Knights.
00:04:56 I hadn't heard of it before they came out with this report saying that the Liberal government has spent, well, I think it was about $39 billion on climate change stuff in the last nine years.
00:05:09 $39 billion fighting against climate change.
00:05:11 And you may think, oh, wow, that sounds like a lot of money.
00:05:14 I'm glad they're calling the government out on that.
00:05:16 Oh, no, no, no.
00:05:17 They're saying that is just a drop in the bucket.
00:05:20 The government should have been spending more, and the government has only spent about 70% of what it said it was going to spend.
00:05:27 So their issue is that the federal government has spent not enough, that they've only spent this money on climate change, and they're actually short by about $14 billion.
00:05:39 So they need to throw more money at the weather, more money on this file, so that they will be able to do what exactly?
00:05:46 Change the weather?
00:05:47 Is that kind of the goal they're after here?
00:05:49 So we will perhaps see what on earth they are attempting to do in due course.
00:05:55 But again, I have no doubt that the government will continue to spend the money
00:05:58 because this is the activist set to whom the government is very much beholden,
00:06:03 more than taxpayers.
00:06:05 And in the budget that's coming up,
00:06:07 Chrystia Freeland and Justin Trudeau have not committed to there being no new taxes.
00:06:11 They say there won't be new taxes for the middle class,
00:06:14 but they aren't saying there won't be new taxes in general.
00:06:18 And I think this is something that we always need to keep an eye on because definitions matter.
00:06:22 What they define as middle class and what they define as being wealthy and subject to increased taxation may differ from what ordinary Canadians who are forced to deal with the rising cost of living have to say about these questions.
00:06:36 So that's definitely something that we should be watching here on the upcoming budget.
00:06:41 And I would also point out that the government is still not dealing with the very imminent and immediate relief.
00:06:48 The people are seeking from it when it comes to the carbon tax. And again, I mean, I know this has been like the broken record subject. We've had carbon tax stories on the show most days, most weeks for the last several months because there was obviously a big lead up to this.
00:07:03 the conservatives decided to make this their hill to die on there was that glimmer of hope when
00:07:07 everyone took to the streets on april 1st across the country and in alberta as my colleague rachel
00:07:12 emmanuel has been reporting they are still protesting about a week and a half on this
00:07:16 increase to the carbon tax they're out there all over the province and it's been going on for
00:07:21 several well for over a week now but all of that is to say the government has been unflinching on
00:07:28 this. They have decided to make the carbon tax their hill to stand on. It was a weird one for
00:07:33 the Liberal government to have some little bit of round of principles on, but they've decided to
00:07:38 stick firm on this and continue defending that carbon tax. Now, what's been interesting to see
00:07:45 is the erosion of federalism here. Now, provincial premiers are supposed to have, in theory, a co-equal
00:07:53 political relationship with the federal government. It's not that the federal government
00:07:57 is overseeing provinces. It's that the federal government has its area of jurisdiction. The
00:08:02 provincial governments have their area of jurisdiction. And the prime minister is really
00:08:06 supposed to be the first among equals in a lot of ways, where they will have first minister's
00:08:11 meetings. First minister's meetings means that the premiers and the prime minister... So I should
00:08:17 actually point out here, in French, premier and prime minister are the same. It's premier ministre.
00:08:23 So Premier and Prime Minister are actually the same role.
00:08:26 You could call Justin Trudeau the Premier of Canada.
00:08:29 You could call Doug Ford the Prime Minister of Ontario.
00:08:32 We don't, but those terms actually used to be more interchangeable, certainly more than
00:08:36 they are today.
00:08:37 In Quebec, Quebec's the only province that calls both the Premier Ministre.
00:08:42 But the reason I bring that up is that Justin Trudeau believes the provinces are there to
00:08:46 do his bidding.
00:08:47 When he wants to impose a carbon tax, he looks to the provinces and says, you guys have to
00:08:52 fall in line on this. And I think that's incredibly dangerous because right now you
00:08:57 have six premiers that are saying, we want a first ministers meeting. We want all the first
00:09:02 ministers of this country to come together, all 14, 10 provinces, three territories, one federal
00:09:07 government. We want them all to come together and have it out over this carbon tax. Let's have an
00:09:12 emergency meeting. And Justin Trudeau's answer to this is, well, you know, we kind of, we already
00:09:19 did this didn't we we we did when did we do it oh uh yeah 2016. so eight years ago you had a meeting
00:09:27 discussed the carbon tax and by the way changes of government have been mounting since then
00:09:32 alberta has gone through two premiers since then every province has had one in some cases two
00:09:37 elections since then and we're supposed to just be happy that oh well yeah we already talked about
00:09:42 that it's a fait accompli it's done yeah it's done no point in discussing it further well
00:09:47 that's not cutting it for many of the provincial governments in this country and you know the
00:09:53 reason that this has been such an interesting tactic from the conservatives is because the
00:09:58 liberals are still with the ndp trying to have the discussion about anything other than what ordinary
00:10:03 canadians are having it about so you may have seen over the weekend true north ran a story about this
00:10:08 alex jones who is the the head of info wars decided to have some kind words to say about
00:10:14 Pierre Polyev. Now, it was kind of reported by some people as an endorsement. It really wasn't
00:10:19 a formal endorsement. It was a vote of confidence. It was an endorsement in the broad sense, but not
00:10:24 like a, I hereby declare, I throw my support behind this guy. But he had put out a tweet when
00:10:30 he said, yeah, I've been following this guy for a while. He's the real deal. And oh man,
00:10:34 the liberal machine just like went apoplectic on this, including outgoing new Democrat MP,
00:10:40 Charlie Angus. This government promised to ban the AR-15. That's the weapon that was used to murder
00:10:47 26-year-old children at Sandy Hook. And yet on Thursday, the Conservative leader was tweeting
00:10:53 that the government wasn't going after the AR-15, but hunting rifles. So little wonder he gets
00:10:58 endorsed by Alex Jones, who's notorious for taunting families of children murdered by the
00:11:03 AR-15. So will the minister confirm, is the government going after hunting rifles or the
00:11:08 AR-15, or is this the Conservative leader being the quote, real deal of disinformation for the
00:11:13 likes of Alex Jones? The Honourable Minister of Public Service, our public safety.
00:11:21 Mr. Speaker, I want to thank my colleague for his question and salute his long service
00:11:26 in this House on behalf of the people of Mayor of Ontario. Mr. Speaker, I share...
00:11:33 I've never had that much applause, Mr. Speaker, in the House before.
00:11:40 Mr. Speaker, I share our colleagues' concern about the Conservative policy with respect to gun control.
00:11:46 We have said from the beginning, law-abiding hunters and sportspersons are not the subject of these regulations.
00:11:53 Mr. Speaker, what we're doing is taking away guns that were designed to kill people on the battlefield,
00:11:59 field. And we're also prepared to compensate the people that bought those guns lawfully.
00:12:04 It's something the Conservative Party will undo and we're committed to keeping Canadians safe.
00:12:09 It's something the Conservative Party will undo. The Conservatives all should have said
00:12:13 here, here when he said that. He was just setting them up for it. It's a weird thing because the
00:12:19 Liberals love talking about this issue. The NDP and them are great partners on this. They can talk
00:12:23 about, ooh, assault rifles, ooh, assault guns. One of my colleagues points out the usage of the
00:12:28 words sports persons. You can't say sportsman anymore. It's sports persons, sports people kind
00:12:34 and all of that. But the reality is it's hilarious when Dominic LeBlanc, the public safety minister
00:12:40 there says this is not going after people who are law abiding gun owners. And then,
00:12:45 oh, we're compensating people who bought these guns lawfully.
00:12:49 Wait, so you're admitting that people who bought these guns lawfully are being targeted by the
00:12:55 so-called gun buyback because it's only the people that bought them lawfully that have to turn those
00:12:59 guns into the government so it's a weird inconsistency and just to contrast it with
00:13:05 yesterday's show when i spoke to the new cfo the new chief firearms officer of saskatchewan as well
00:13:11 as the firearms commissioner that is murray cowan and robert freeberg respectively and they were
00:13:17 talking about how their province has decided to put the law-abiding gun owners that community in
00:13:21 Saskatchewan front and center with their approach. You contrast that with the federal government where
00:13:25 everything is about the way to antagonize lawful gun owners and also gun businesses. And this has
00:13:32 been something I've been harping on for quite some time. You may have seen, I did a documentary
00:13:36 a couple of years back called Assaulted, Justin Trudeau's War on Gun Owners. And in that one
00:13:41 episode was devoted to gun businesses, people that set up shop, they did everything right,
00:13:47 They play by the rules and they were saddled with, in some cases, hundreds of thousands of dollars in inventory, which still, after four years, they have been unable to do anything with because of this gun reclassification and the inability for the government to put its so-called buyback into force.
00:14:05 Now, one of the techniques that the government was going to do was working with firearms industry members, working with firearms stores, and find a way to get these businesses to be able to offload their inventory legally.
00:14:20 Now, this was something that they'd worked out a deal with the Canadian Sporting Arms and Ammunition Association, and actually the CSAAA got a fair bit of pushback from some members of the gun community for agreeing to be a part of this.
00:14:32 And I want to get to that in this interview here, but the president of the Canadian Sporting Arms and Ammunition Association, Wes Winkle, has said it's clear the government is in over its head here.
00:14:42 They bit off more than it could chew. Take your cliche, put it there. It fits.
00:14:46 The government just is floundering and doesn't know what to do to make up for this ambitious goal it set out now, again, almost four years ago to the day.
00:14:55 Wes Winkle joins us again. Good to talk to you again, Wes. Thanks for coming on today.
00:15:02 oh i'm not hearing you there i think you might be muted oh it's this okay i hear you now you hear
00:15:09 me now okay so let me just start off with some of the criticism that you've got because i know
00:15:14 there have been a number of gun activists that i believe operating good faith that
00:15:18 when your organization agreed to work with the government on this thought that it was akin to
00:15:23 selling out absolutely yeah we uh were aware that we were going to receive some pushback on it
00:15:29 we're in a real catch-22 we we have businesses that have these firearms registered to their
00:15:34 inventory uh these these firearms are not saleable they are very expensive to insure
00:15:41 they've been stuck for a long time as unsaleable inventory and we have a lot of members that are
00:15:46 trying to find a way to get their capital out of them and reinvest it in other parts of our
00:15:51 industry and to try to keep their businesses going uh we of course as an association and
00:15:57 you know as business owners want nothing more for this law to be reversed and just to be allowed to
00:16:01 sell our inventory again but there's a reality that businesses have to deal with and right now
00:16:05 that reality is we can't do that so we've always as an industry group have asked the federal
00:16:11 government to consult us on any laws or policy or any change to policy and in this case when they
00:16:16 reached out and asked us to consult it's very difficult to ask to be consulted and then to
00:16:21 turn around and thumb your nose when you're asked so we had a vote as a board of directors and and
00:16:25 had a unanimous agreement that we would enter into discussions and try to negotiate the best
00:16:32 deal we could inside of a terrible situation and that's kind of where we're at we have no interest
00:16:38 or any part of wanting to assist the government in buying back individuals guns or to get in the way
00:16:44 of a gun confiscation program with with people that own these firearms at home and want to keep
00:16:48 them we have nothing to do with that this is just strictly to deal with the dealer's inventory and
00:16:53 for those that don't realize this is all registered in ledgers it's something that everyone knows what
00:16:58 we have and it's when the amnesty expires they have to be dealt with and these businesses already
00:17:05 we've seen so many go out of business we're just trying to help some of these businesses that are
00:17:08 floundering with this inventory and i know there was reporting of the the value of this agreement
00:17:14 that was not money that your organization was receiving from the government correct
00:17:18 Correct. We, again, didn't want our businesses to have to pay for doing any of the federal government's legwork. We're liaisoning with the businesses to try to assist them in this venture. But at the same time, we didn't want them to have to pay for it through the association's donations or money.
00:17:37 So we only agreed to do it if the government would recompensate us for all of our expenses in this project.
00:17:43 So that's where the total contract value was posted of what could possibly the expenses get up to.
00:17:51 But we're only getting reimbursed for our expenditures.
00:17:55 So to bring it outside of your organization specifically and talk about the effect on businesses, how are the business owners on this?
00:18:04 Because I know some are fire breathing activists that are saying, you know, they're kind of like the cold dead hands types that just want to fight this tooth and nail.
00:18:11 Whereas others, I suspect, are like you just described.
00:18:14 They're like, listen, I just want to run my business as it stands right now.
00:18:17 I can't do anything with this inventory, so I want to offload it.
00:18:20 Is there a bit of a split there?
00:18:22 Well, there is definitely a little bit of a split there.
00:18:24 There's a faction of businesses and we knew that they existed.
00:18:29 And, you know, it's one of those things where it's a divisive subject for us because we have to go with what the majority of businesses in our feedback wanted.
00:18:38 And, you know, there are some that are that cold, dead hands mantra.
00:18:42 And I understand it.
00:18:44 And to be honest, I commend them on their conviction on it.
00:18:47 But at the same point, we have businesses that have extremely large volumes of this inventory,
00:18:53 whether they be distributors that had hundreds of thousands of dollars or manufacturers that
00:18:58 hundreds of thousands of dollars, these inventory that just don't have the ability to say,
00:19:04 I can't participate in this. They, they need a way to get out of this. Like I said,
00:19:09 we've had businesses that have reported that just to ensure this inventory has cost them $20,000 a
00:19:14 year. So obviously we have that large disclaimer where we have that problem. So yeah, we've,
00:19:22 we've definitely um tried to get uh uh the best deal we can for those businesses involved
00:19:29 and yeah there's some that uh we're unhappy and they want us to never have a conversation with
00:19:33 the federal government and we understand that we're very frustrated with the amount of attack
00:19:39 we've received from this current federal government but at the same time uh it's hard to become uh
00:19:45 an industry representative or a lobby group if you refuse to talk to the people in charge
00:19:49 So when I did my documentary about this a couple of years ago, there was one store owner I spoke to was in Peterborough or just outside.
00:19:58 And I can't remember the name of the business, but the gentleman I spoke to was Jeff Toomes.
00:20:03 And one of the things that he had shared, which I thought was incredibly concerning, was that the initial order and counsel came out in May of 2020.
00:20:13 He immediately pivots and says, OK, we're going to buy a bunch of this other gun that's kind of similar that people will like.
00:20:18 And then two weeks later, that one's also prohibited. So he attempts to get around the one issue that the government has created. And in the end, he's doubled his problems here. Has the government expressed any contrition for just how arbitrary this is, and how dangerous it is for business owners that actually don't know how to navigate around this when even things they do to try to adapt and mitigate end up screwing them even further?
00:20:43 and they have not i mean this is part of the real problem with the legislation that minister
00:20:49 blair brought forward back in the day is that uh through the order of council and the subsequent
00:20:54 legislation you're banning a style of firearms so there's no mechanical definition for what is
00:21:00 prohibited and therefore it's an arbitrary decision by a panel of people and it's very
00:21:06 difficult for us to know as an industry what is and what is not going to be prohibited when you
00:21:11 start saying stuff like of modern design and stuff like that like what does that mean and nobody
00:21:17 really knows and we have some we have some very interesting discussion topics inside here of
00:21:26 whether a firearm will be allowed or not and then there's times where we get notification that it's
00:21:31 classified as non-restricted which means we can sell it and then it changes again down the road
00:21:36 when there's more volume of this gun getting imported so it's a very difficult business
00:21:40 environment and then what happens of course is our manufacturers that spend uh hundreds of
00:21:45 thousands of dollars to pivot and to try to produce something for the canadian market that's
00:21:49 viable and legal and then it gets prohibited as well they give up on trying to design guns for
00:21:54 the canadian market and again that makes it very hard for our retailers to find product that we
00:22:00 can sell legally to hunters and to target shooters that want to participate in the sports so uh yeah
00:22:07 it's been extremely difficult. Canada has been a very frustrating thing for our manufacturers and
00:22:13 a lot of them have just given up and turned their back on us as a country because they don't know
00:22:18 how to participate in our market anymore. One thing that I wanted to ask about that
00:22:23 as well and people that aren't gun owners may not realize this but a gun is not just a gun. I mean
00:22:27 a gun can oftentimes be a base unit that people add a whole bunch of stuff to and modify. I mean
00:22:33 For example, the much maligned AR-15, one of the reasons that gun is so appealing, that style of gun, it's not one model, is because it's modular and people will buy different parts for it.
00:22:44 And when we talk about this in the context of the buyback, one of the points you raised, and I read this in a piece by Brian Passifium in the National Post, was that the government didn't even seem to realize that complexity with this and just how many thousands and thousands of parts there are that also may or may not fall under this buyback.
00:23:01 And it's not even quite clear if they do.
00:23:03 well for sure and and again you know with the bureaucrats involved in the system how could they
00:23:09 have known there they weren't experts in this field and you know when the government did the
00:23:13 knee-jerk reaction to bring this order and council forward and minister blair there was no consultation
00:23:18 beforehand because it was a knee-jerk reaction and a very fast order and council brought forward
00:23:24 so without consultation and understanding the topic that they're bringing legislation in on
00:23:28 yeah, I actually feel for the bureaucrats in the system that are trying to navigate it afterwards 0.91
00:23:35 because they get thrown a terrible file and say, clean this up. And it really isn't that easy to
00:23:43 clean up. And now we're, as an industry and as a level of bureaucrats, everyone's trying to clean
00:23:50 up the mess that Minister Blair made. So, I mean, we can't talk about this without addressing the
00:23:56 political elephant in the room, which is that there could be an election theoretically at any
00:23:59 point. They're scheduled to be an election by October of 2025. From your knowledge of this
00:24:06 process, will this gun buyback even be in place and buying back? Again, I hate that term, but
00:24:12 will that even be happening by October 2025? I would anticipate with the steps that have
00:24:20 been put forward that there will be firearms purchased from businesses by that point in time.
00:24:25 I believe that will happen.
00:24:28 The one from the individuals, the guns that are in people's houses,
00:24:32 I believe that that is a way more convoluted process.
00:24:36 They're so spread out in a country as rural as Canada.
00:24:40 I don't believe that process gets going by that point in time.
00:24:43 I think that's why you've seen the amnesty get pushed out past the election.
00:24:47 You know, I think, you know, when you've seen the amnesty date announced,
00:24:50 it doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out that this will probably be an election issue.
00:24:54 You know, I think you'll have the the liberals saying, hey, you know, if you vote blue that, you know, this big, bad firearm would be back out in society.
00:25:04 And, you know, I'm sure that's what the plan is and, you know, vice versa for the other side.
00:25:09 But, you know, the reality is, is that these firearms have been stayed in people's cabinets from the day that they were prohibited.
00:25:14 They have never left there.
00:25:16 There's been, of course, no crimes committed with them.
00:25:19 So it's it's it is all political posturing.
00:25:22 That's all it is.
00:25:23 we know that as an industry we've been a pawn in the politics game for a long time and it's
00:25:27 it's frustrating for those of us in business trying to keep people employed and trying to
00:25:32 make a living Wes Winkle president of the Canadian Sporting Arms and Ammunition Association thanks
00:25:37 so much for coming on today Wes good to talk to you thank you for the time we appreciate it all
00:25:41 right thank you and I would just encourage to give the shameless plug again you can check out my
00:25:46 documentary on this assaulted Justin Trudeau's war on gun owners it is a couple years old now
00:25:51 but still just as fresh, although some of the problems are even more acute. There have been
00:25:55 no resolutions, just more problems in that. And as mentioned, one of the episodes dealt specifically
00:26:00 with businesses. We also did an episode on competitive sport shooters, which was quite
00:26:04 interesting. We did four parts. What were the other parts? One, I think, which is focused on crime
00:26:08 and a lot of the law enforcement angle. And maybe I need to watch it again because I've now forgotten
00:26:12 what it was about. So we had a fourth part that was about, oh, it was about, actually, no, that
00:26:17 was the same as the other one i don't know we'll figure it out but it was it was a fun series i'm
00:26:21 glad to do it and i've had a few people reach out and say it might be worth doing a sequel to that
00:26:26 so uh we will perhaps try and put something together see what see what else there is to
00:26:31 cover on that but i wanted to shift gears from one hot button issue to another we have seen over
00:26:37 the weekend the six month anniversary of hamas's horrific attacks on israel and the subsequent
00:26:44 traumatizing of the Jewish people across the world, including in Canada. Now, just to put a
00:26:50 fine point on this, I saw yesterday, just in my travels in Ottawa, a member of parliament who is
00:26:56 from the Jewish community, who has, not in cabinet, not the prime minister, obviously,
00:27:01 who had a police escort, which is something that in this country, we have not seen on just regular
00:27:08 old members of parliament, certainly in my lifetime. And the distinction is, and this has
00:27:13 been reported on, several members of the Jewish community who are members of parliament have
00:27:17 police details because it is otherwise not safe to be walking around this country as a Jew. And
00:27:24 that is a terrifying reality. Jewish businesses have been vandalized. And yes, there have been
00:27:29 attacks in this country on Muslims as well. Horrific attacks. One in my own city where a 0.99
00:27:34 terrible, terrible, vile, evil piece of human filth decided to target a Muslim family for no 1.00
00:27:41 other reason than he wanted to kill Muslims. He's now behind bars, which people would say is 1.00
00:27:47 actually getting off easy. And there's a part of me that's inclined to agree with that, as much as
00:27:51 my position on the death penalty is a little bit more complicated. And then you had that horrific
00:27:57 attack on a Quebec mosque some years back as well. So this is not to say that one group has a
00:28:04 monopoly on being targeted and persecuted, but it is to say that these sorts of attacks have very
00:28:11 political implications and how they are reported. And this was put front and center by a very
00:28:16 thoughtful and detailed analysis that was published by the Aristotle Foundation. It was written by
00:28:22 Raheem Muhammad, who is a columnist with the National Post. He's got a PhD. He's a very well
00:28:27 educated guy. Also very entertaining on Twitter. You should definitely give Raheem a follow there
00:28:32 if you're not already. But he joins me on the line now. Raheem, good to talk to you. Thanks for
00:28:36 coming on today. Andrew, great to see you. I saw you were involved in Jamil's swearing in the other
00:28:40 Jamil Javani, a mutual friend, very cool.
00:28:44 Yes, I haven't actually mentioned it to the audience.
00:28:46 I had the privilege yesterday.
00:28:47 That's why I came up to Ottawa a bit earlier,
00:28:49 being the emcee for Jamil's swearing-in yesterday.
00:28:53 I've known Jamil, and we worked in a number of capacities
00:28:55 before he was a political candidate.
00:28:57 So it was a great honour to be involved in that.
00:29:00 And I was actually quite pleased that when I was emceeing him,
00:29:03 Justin Trudeau didn't just intervene and have the swearing-in cancelled.
00:29:06 So Jamil still gets to be a member of Parliament.
00:29:08 But Rahim, you have taken a very controversial research question here, and I was hoping you could explain it in your own words first, what you set out to look at and then, of course, what you found.
00:29:21 Sure. So backing up a little bit, Canada, which is historically, I think it's fair to say, had a Christian heritage.
00:29:27 It's becoming an increasingly pluralistic country religiously.
00:29:30 According to the last census that was taken in 2021, we're at the point where about 50% of Canadians are Christian and the other 50% either identify with no religion or another religion.
00:29:42 So I think as Canada becomes more religiously pluralistic, it's all the more important that you have strong norms and maintain strong norms of interfaith relations and interfaith civility.
00:29:56 So one way that's been expressed in the past, so as you mentioned, Andrew, in your own hometown of London, Ontario, you had that terrible truck attack against that Pakistani Muslim family during the Quebec City Mosque attack.
00:30:09 It's been a custom and I think an important one for religious groups from across the spectrum,
00:30:16 you know, be they Jewish, Hindu, Christian, whatever, to put out a press release after
00:30:21 something like that happens that will say, you know, we stand with the Muslim community.
00:30:27 You know, we stand against religious hatred and religious violence in all forms.
00:30:31 So we saw that, thankfully, after the Quebec City mosque shooting. 1.00
00:30:35 And we saw that after the London, Ontario truck attack.
00:30:38 October the 7th has been a different story.
00:30:41 And I think it's fair to say the circumstances are somewhat different with October the 7th.
00:30:46 It is an attack that took place on foreign soil.
00:30:48 And fair enough, but a number of Canadians were killed on October the 7th.
00:30:52 And a few of these were Canadians that were actively working with Palestinian groups as
00:30:57 part of the peace process in Gaza.
00:30:59 Others were young Canadians in their 20s that were there for the music festival in
00:31:04 southern israel um so the fact that we haven't seen much in the way of condemnation or much in
00:31:10 the way of regret uh from the muslim community muslim organized muslim groups in canada um
00:31:16 surrounding if not the attack the loss of canadian life and uh you know the the many more canadians
00:31:22 uh who lost members of their extended families on october the 7th um i don't think that bodes well
00:31:28 for uh for religious pluralism and where interfaith relations are in canada at present
00:31:33 And just to put a fine point on this, you're contrasting that with the fact that overwhelmingly Jewish groups, and you list who was in your sample here, were condemning those Quebec City and London, Ontario incidents almost unanimously.
00:31:47 Sure. So even an organization like CJA, the Canadian Association of Jewish Affairs, which I would say is fairly Zionist, if you want to use that word, pro-Israel, right after Quebec City, they put out a statement right after the London, Ontario truck attack.
00:32:03 within 24 hours, they put out a statement condemning each attack and condemning violence
00:32:10 against Muslim Canadians. So they're able to separate violence on Muslim Canadians from the
00:32:16 situation in the Middle East. And unfortunately, again, the detail is somewhat different. In
00:32:21 October the 7th, it's nevertheless been somewhat underwhelming that very few organized Muslim
00:32:27 groups have put out statements, either one condemning Hamas or at the very least expressing
00:32:35 their condolences to those who lost family members during the October the 7th attack.
00:32:42 So, sorry, go ahead.
00:32:43 No, so I agree with your core conclusion because I think there is a double standard here.
00:32:48 I have a slight issue with the methodology in the sense that not only was October 7th
00:32:55 foreign soil and i think your your caveat the canadians were involved is valid but there's
00:33:00 also a much greater political context to is to hamas israel violence than i i would say there is
00:33:08 in an attack by a lone wolf in london ontario or by one in quebec city and and maybe maybe i'm i'm
00:33:15 you know i i'm just curious your thought about that because you must have considered it that
00:33:20 that it's there are political stakes that are different when you're commenting on anything to
00:33:24 do with israel that aren't there with a terrorist attack in canada so what i'd point to is the scale
00:33:31 of october the 7th 1100 um so i believe about 3 000 american civilians were killed on september
00:33:39 the 11th um so you're talking about uh scales you know in the thousands and um you talk about
00:33:44 something like september 11th 2001 you know intellectually i understand the geopolitical
00:33:50 dynamics uh that would lead to an attack on a major american target uh i think that's totally
00:33:56 different from the 3 000 innocent civilians uh that lost their lives on september the 11th and
00:34:03 i would say the same about um about october the 7th you know i understand the geopolitical uh
00:34:09 dynamics at play i understand the complexities of the israel hamas conflict um that doesn't mean
00:34:15 that um you know anything will justify the targeting civilians um and any that that doesn't
00:34:20 in any way diminish the pain of people here in canada who've lost family members and friends
00:34:26 on october the 7th and i think at the very least uh that grief and that suffering uh should be
00:34:32 acknowledged um as part of interfaith relations as far as part of portality uh between uh religious
00:34:40 communities here in canada no i think that's an incredibly well made and it's a well taken point
00:34:46 as well and just looking outside of the event specific observations here i remember when m103
00:34:51 came up which was the anti-islamophobia motion that was a debate i think it was about you know
00:34:56 five or six years ago one of the things that was interesting there was a lot of jewish groups
00:35:00 really stood shoulder to shoulder with muslim groups that are saying yes we need to combat 1.00
00:35:05 islamophobia and then when the discussion shifted to anti-semitism a lot of that reciprocity was
00:35:10 not there and certainly in the last six months hasn't been yeah i mean that's that's a little
00:35:14 before my time to be honest i was in the united states so i remember tangentially uh that was
00:35:19 going on but i didn't pay too close attention to that that whole debate fair enough and i guess i
00:35:26 would ask what you'd think would happen if you expanded this outside of these uh you know
00:35:31 casualty events events with casualties and looked even at smaller scale incidences like vandalism
00:35:37 against mosques and synagogues. Because without having looked at it from a data perspective,
00:35:42 it does seem like there's a great political imbalance in which ones attract the attention
00:35:47 of national media, which ones attract the attention of the tweet from Justin Trudeau,
00:35:51 for example. So is it True North that's been tracking church arson and vandalism?
00:35:58 Yeah, my colleague Cosman Georgia has as well. And I think we're up to well over 100 now.
00:36:01 Yeah. And I've heard maybe a handful of stories about that.
00:36:06 I remember I think it might have been Jerry Butts tweeting something to the effect of, I understand what would make someone want to burn down a church.
00:36:14 But at the same time, you know, so yeah, I mean, I have noticed and I think it's sort of it plays into this sort of EDI framework in which we see Jewish communities and Christian communities as somewhat privileged.
00:36:30 And, you know, by virtue of that privilege, essentially asking for acts of intimidation, acts of antagonism, acts of hatred.
00:36:39 I do agree with you that there's been a substantial imbalance and that church arson story has been incredibly underreported.
00:36:47 One of the few times I've actually actually remember a church arson get a substantial amount of attention in the media was when it was a Coptic Christian church of that of mostly Egyptian Christian parishioners.
00:36:59 And what you did have that sort of minoritized follower or that minoritized parishioner.
00:37:06 So I will say I agree with you 100 percent that I think the reportings of, you know, when you see these actions targeting mosques or synagogues or churches, it has been inconsistent.
00:37:18 Not that any of those of those things are OK.
00:37:21 to bring it back to your analysis from the aristotle foundation i know you're looking at
00:37:27 the data not necessarily the the motivations behind it but but just you know taking your
00:37:31 political mind which i think is certainly a a superb one uh anyone who's read your column
00:37:36 could say do you think the motivation here is just a a deep ideological view that these
00:37:42 organizations hold or do you think it's a part of their own coalition and not wanting to alienate
00:37:49 constituencies they have that make up part of their supporters for whom this will be an issue.
00:37:53 Yeah. And I mean, one thing I will say is you've seen a lot of migration to Canada
00:37:58 over the past 20 or so years from the Middle East. Barbara Kay has a great article about this,
00:38:04 about how this relates to Quebec and Quebec wanting to stay French. And due to colonial
00:38:10 dynamics, a number of pockets of the Middle East and North Africa have sizable communities that
00:38:18 are francophone um so i think you are looking at leaderships uh within muslim organizations
00:38:25 um you have different i think values among the first wave of muslim immigrants uh my parents uh
00:38:31 came over from uganda we're smiling muslim we'd be part of it um and some of the newer arrivals
00:38:35 um from let's say 1995 to present um and i do think part of the story um are these associations
00:38:42 which you know rely on donations rely on uh maintaining and cultivating active membership
00:38:46 bases, attempting to keep those bases together when you have potentially a plurality of viewpoints
00:38:54 toward, you know, do we embrace a more Western pluralistic view of values or more of a hardline
00:39:02 approach? Yeah, years ago, I was in Israel, and I was doing a, it wasn't a formal interview,
00:39:08 but I was doing a roundtable, and there was a Palestinian radio host, and I was a radio host
00:39:12 in canada at the time so i was interested in in his analysis and he had at the time it was 2015
00:39:18 there had been this spate of knives of knife attacks against against israelis and you know
00:39:24 he had said oh yeah he did a caller show a call-in show on his radio program in which he asked is it
00:39:30 okay to stab jews in the streets and which is like a strange question that you would never ask 0.55
00:39:34 a canadian radio we have that is it okay to punch a white supremacist remember that yeah yeah and 0.99
00:39:38 And he was like 17. Yeah. And he was proud to tell me he's like, oh, but most said no. I'm like, Mo, like, so there is a constituency that would call into radio and say, yeah, yeah, you know, stabbing an Israeli is fine. And that, and that has stayed with me. Because when you talk about this, it's like, even a small contingent of these, of any community can have tremendous influence on, on these things. 0.86
00:40:00 So when it comes to, like, not condemning a horrific attack that killed 1,200 Israelis and non-Israelis, as you've pointed out, I think that's incredibly noteworthy.
00:40:10 Well, we have a news report up about it at True North, but you can read the report for yourself over at the Aristotle Foundation.
00:40:16 The author, Rahim Mohamed.
00:40:17 Great talking to you, sir.
00:40:18 We'll see you soon.
00:40:19 I'll see you tomorrow in Ottawa, I hope.
00:40:21 I'm going to be there.
00:40:21 All right.
00:40:21 I hope so.
00:40:22 Thank you.
00:40:23 We'll have to pull you to our little booth and do an in-person chat then.
00:40:26 Wonderful.
00:40:27 Looking forward to it.
00:40:28 All right.
00:40:28 Thanks very much, Rahim Mohamed.
00:40:29 Well, that's it for us for today. I will be live tomorrow, same time, a different place on the Andrew Lawton Show.
00:40:36 But stay tuned. We'll talk to you then. Thank you. God bless and good day to you all.
00:40:40 Thanks for listening to the Andrew Lawton Show. Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:40:59 We'll be right back.
00:41:29 We'll be right back.