Juno News - October 12, 2023


Air travel Covid vaccine mandate is back in court

Mentioned
CBC refuses to call Hamas terrorists Hamas calls for global ‘Day of Jihad’ (ft. Melissa Lantsman)

Episode Stats


Length

44 minutes

Words per minute

169.07

Word count

7,559

Sentence count

382

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

6

sentences flagged

Hate speech

25

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The Federal Court of Appeal heard a four-hour long argument yesterday between government lawyers and lawyers for people challenging the government's ban on unvaccinated people getting on planes or trains. And it's not long before the government rescinded the ban.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Transcribed by ESO, translated by —
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 welcome to canada's most irreverent talk show this is the andrew lawton show brought to you by true
00:01:20 north hello and welcome to you all the andrew lawton show here canada's most irreverent talk
00:01:30 show the end of another week at least insofar as this program is concerned but fear not true north
00:01:37 has you covered and i'll just put in a bit of a plug before we get into what's turned out to be
00:01:42 a rather busy show true north nation is taking place and what is it it's next saturday so i guess
00:01:48 That's nine days away in Calgary.
00:01:51 So if you are from Calgary or Alberta or anywhere in the country or the world, in fact, and want to come on by, I will be there.
00:01:58 Premier Danielle Smith will be there.
00:02:00 Brett Wilson, the star of Dragon's Den, is going to be there.
00:02:05 Lots of your favorites at True North will also be there.
00:02:09 MP Stephanie Cusey, we've got...
00:02:11 The problem when I start naming everyone is that I'm bound to just miss someone.
00:02:15 So I'm not doing that intentionally.
00:02:16 I'll stop naming right now, but it's going to be a lot of fun. And we have, well, I don't want to
00:02:21 oversell it, but we have a little surprise. Well, it's a big surprise. Like it's a big physically
00:02:26 large surprise, which is not me. I'm not referring to myself. I, you know that I'm there. I'm the
00:02:31 physically large non-surprise, non-surprise, but it's going to be great fun. And we still have
00:02:36 some tickets available. I think we're getting close to that sellout point, but I do hope to
00:02:40 see you all there. You can find the details at truenorthevents.ca. But all of that aside,
00:02:46 let me talk about this big hearing that was taking place yesterday before the Federal Court of
00:02:53 Appeal. Now, this is, I don't want to get too bogged down in the legal ins and outs here,
00:02:58 but the Federal Court of Appeal heard a four-hour long argument back and forth between government
00:03:06 lawyers and lawyers for people challenging the vaccine mandate for air travel now this may seem
00:03:13 like a bit of a distant memory right now because it has been a couple of years since this was first
00:03:18 floated it was something that justin trudeau promised in the 2021 election remember this
00:03:26 you deserve a government that's going to continue to say get vaccinated and you know what if you
00:03:31 don't want to get vaccinated that's your choice but don't think you can get on a plane or a train
00:03:37 besides vaccinated people and put them at risk. Yeah he didn't just advocate for this policy or
00:03:47 implement it. Justin Trudeau campaigned on this. He actually went to voters and said I would like
00:03:53 to bar the unvaccinated from planes and trains and federally regulated workplaces. You couldn't work 1.00
00:04:00 as a bureaucrat in the federal department of widgets unless you were vaccinated against
00:04:06 COVID. That was obviously a winning proposition. Justin Trudeau emerged victorious in that election
00:04:12 and proceeded with the policy and later the even more punitive policy of requiring vaccination
00:04:18 from truckers to cross the border back and forth between Canada and the United States. But one of
00:04:25 the things that I will point out about this is that the federal government had these mandates,
00:04:29 they escalated them they did them in spite of scientific evidence and data arguing against them
00:04:36 science and data saying that these things were not actually necessary we're not keeping people
00:04:41 out of the hospital we're not saving lives but the federal government persisted anyway
00:04:45 so there was a challenge put forward by a number of different people one of them was former
00:04:50 newfoundland premier brian peckford one of them was the leader of the people's party of canada
00:04:55 Maxime Bernier. Now Bernier in particular had a very interesting approach to this. His case was
00:05:01 not just I'm a Canadian that wants to go and see grandma. He was saying, listen, I'm a federal
00:05:06 politician. Part of my job is to crisscross the country and speak to Canadians. This law
00:05:13 is preventing me from doing something that is fundamental to democracy and to the democratic
00:05:19 process. So that was the argument that was put forward. Now, the legal process is very slow at
00:05:25 times. It took some time for this case to go before the federal court. By the time it did,
00:05:31 the federal government had already rescinded the mandate. Now, the language they used was that it
00:05:37 was suspended. It wasn't over. It wasn't done. They didn't say, we're sorry. We shouldn't have
00:05:43 done this. We're never going to do it again. They said, we're suspending it and we might bring it
00:05:46 back. And there was also another press conference where the government started talking about
00:05:50 reworking its definition of fully vaccinated. So it might have actually been the case where you
00:05:56 had to be boosted within a certain period of time to travel. So all of that is important context to
00:06:02 the federal government's argument that we shouldn't even have a court case on this. We
00:06:07 shouldn't even hear this argument. It is moot, which is to say that it's not a live issue. This
00:06:13 is what's at stake. The federal court said it's moot. There's no point in hearing this. The
00:06:16 mandate's over. That was the discussion that went towards the federal court of appeal yesterday,
00:06:22 which now has the decision to make about whether they should actually have a hearing on the merits
00:06:28 of this mandate in the first place. Eva Chipiuk knows this file well. She joins me now, a lawyer
00:06:33 with Chipiuk Law. Eva, good to talk to you again. Thanks for coming on today. My pleasure. Thanks
00:06:38 for having me. Now I mean obviously when we put the word moot in our stories we put it in quotation
00:06:44 marks because it's a term that has a meaning in law and I think has a reason in law but it's one
00:06:49 that I think has been very convenient for the government here because anytime they've had an
00:06:54 issue that they don't want to really have it answered in court they do this and oftentimes
00:07:00 with alarming success even the Emergencies Act the federal government has said oh well I mean
00:07:05 the Emergencies Act is over now. Nothing to see here. It's all moot. So it's not surprising they've
00:07:10 tried that here, but it's concerning that the courts have so far gone along with it.
00:07:14 Very much agree with you on that. And those were the arguments that, of course, the lawyers were
00:07:19 making in court. And at the first instance, I recall one of, I thought, the most powerful
00:07:25 arguments that at least Keith Wilson brought forward is, what are the other option for
00:07:30 Canadians then? Do you want to see them back in Ottawa in a protest? This is the forum to resolve
00:07:38 these issues and these disputes, especially issues that are this contentious and this polarized and
00:07:45 political, in fact. So we're seeing these battles on Twitter. Wouldn't it be a more sophisticated
00:07:52 place to have this evidence heard and open to the public in an established forum like the court
00:07:58 system so public interest is a huge point on it and so i can't see how they suggest that it's not
00:08:07 in the public interest so you know i i think you probably saw in some of the tweets that 20 000
00:08:14 people were registered to watch that hearing yesterday that appeal i don't i doubt that
00:08:19 that's ever happened in canadian history before so just on that fact alone it shows what an
00:08:25 intense amount of public interest there is yes and i mean the one thing that the lawyers have
00:08:31 mentioned both at the federal court level and in the appeal hearing yesterday also was that
00:08:36 the government's own language suggests this was just a suspension they've not taken it off the
00:08:41 table they've not said we'll never do it again and that's where i think the mootness argument
00:08:46 kind of falls flat here because if you follow this through to its natural conclusion anytime
00:08:51 the federal government does something on a temporary basis they can dodge accountability
00:08:57 because they say well the fact scenario is different there's no point in having this
00:09:01 discussion again there's no point in litigating the old one because when we bring the new one in
00:09:05 it's going to be different than a live issue and it basically means that there will never be a
00:09:10 ruling on what is really a core constitutional question did this violate your mobility rights
00:09:15 as a canadian who was not able to travel yeah i was just trying to take some notes because of
00:09:21 so many things always come up but uh a hundred percent um so one of the the government was
00:09:27 definitely painting the picture that the suspension the word suspension doesn't really
00:09:31 mean anything it was rescinded in the end because it expired so what many canadians actually don't
00:09:38 know it was an interim order um that continuously expired every two weeks so if it didn't expire
00:09:46 they would renew it. And so they're kind of like, well, it expired, so it's gone. And
00:09:53 whether it's suspended or rescinded would be a more appropriate word. It's not
00:09:57 effective in law anymore. So that means it's not law. But one of the points that was made yesterday,
00:10:03 which I also think is very important, is because these were interim orders, they weren't debated
00:10:08 in the house of commons and in the open public forum so a decision like that maybe that's where
00:10:18 the court should say okay let's let's dissect this a little bit more because when there's like
00:10:24 a year or two of public debate and everyone can have their say on it and that that seems more
00:10:29 democratic a better use of everyone's time if that's the kind of law we were challenging
00:10:34 then maybe I see the point. But in this case, it was like all these very reactionary responses
00:10:42 on a short-term basis. Maybe that doesn't make sense. Let's just talk about these. Let's debate
00:10:47 this as adults and as people that have questions on this. So for many reasons, that didn't really
00:10:54 make sense. And so those were some of the points that were made yesterday. And one thing that's
00:11:00 very important to note is on the first instance, the federal court judge said, well, you know,
00:11:05 it's not live, it's not an active law now, but if it is, you're welcome to come back to court.
00:11:11 This is after all the parties have put in a lot of time and effort and Canadians have either 0.94
00:11:17 donated through charitable organizations that were involved in this or directly.
00:11:23 So you're just asking citizens and Canadians to continuously front a challenge to the government.
00:11:28 I don't think that's the appropriate use of anyone's time or funds, or Canadians should be 1.00
00:11:35 asked of that anyway. Well, and I would also jump on that point, because I think that's an important
00:11:39 one, Eva, which is that one of the core arguments behind courts using mootness and finding mootness
00:11:45 is that judicial resources are scarce. There's a cost and an effort and a time that it takes to
00:11:51 litigate a case. I would argue that hearing the case once and for all actually takes fewer
00:11:58 judicial resources than hearing it every year or every two years or every three years
00:12:03 if something like this is reintroduced. I mean, we are a legal system that is based on precedent,
00:12:09 and you can't actually have common law unless you hear the cases that are going to form the
00:12:14 precedent for how the law is in the future. The mental gymnastics, Andrew, have been interesting
00:12:20 Because what the courts at the first instance said, and then the questions from the court judges yesterday were similar, or at least one was, is, well, the science at that time was what it was.
00:12:33 So how can we, if even if we address it now, if this comes back in a year or two, the science is going to be different.
00:12:40 So this is going to be a waste of everybody's time.
00:12:43 And that goes against exactly what you were saying.
00:12:47 The rule of law precedents in Canada.
00:12:49 It's always facts specific. Facts are going to always massage a case a little bit one way or the other. But the reasoning behind it, that's the reason that everyone's in court, was the reasoning behind the government's decisions and the mandates, even whether the interim orders make sense or whatever.
00:13:09 none of that is being discussed or debated of course the science is going to be different
00:13:13 probably we'll be all be more knowledgeable if this ever came forward again but it's not on the
00:13:19 scientific points only that the court is being asked to hear this case so it was very concerning
00:13:26 to hear that in the first instance and then again yesterday i i've told this story on the show many
00:13:31 many times so bear with me if you're one of the members of the audience that have heard it but in
00:13:35 In 2019, when the Leaders Debates Commission barred True North and Rebel from covering the debate,
00:13:41 we went to federal court, we secured an injunction, and we were able to go and cover the debate.
00:13:46 And then after the debate, we wanted to proceed with the case because we thought there was a big
00:13:50 problem here of a government body arbitrarily deciding which journalists can and can't have
00:13:55 access to government-run events. And the court said, as it did in the vaccine mandate case,
00:14:00 well, the debate's over. You got what you wanted. There's really no point in hearing this.
00:14:04 Because there's never going to be another debate.
00:14:07 Yeah.
00:14:07 And then you fast forward to 2021, literally the identical thing happens.
00:14:12 In this case, not with us.
00:14:13 We were accredited, but Rebel experienced the same thing.
00:14:16 And they went before the court and the same government said, this is mood.
00:14:19 It's kind of an academic point.
00:14:21 It doesn't really matter.
00:14:22 Did the same thing and they started from zero again.
00:14:25 So I think that, you know, there is a very real debate to be had here again.
00:14:29 I mean, if they have a trial on the facts and on the merits, it may not go the way that Mr. Peckford and Mr. Bernier and all of them want it to.
00:14:37 But at the very least, they should be heard and the government should be forced to defend the constitutionality of this, which right now it hasn't been forced to do, has it?
00:14:46 Yeah, no. And your example is a perfect highlight of judicial economy. How does it make sense to bring this to court again? And especially when so many resources were spent already with all the parties, three months, like at least it was months and months of already since the since the case was started.
00:15:09 but it was at least two months of daily cross-examinations, which is a massive endeavor.
00:15:15 And so the actual court case was scheduled for three days. That's not a huge amount of time
00:15:21 considering the huge issues at stake. And like I said, the public interest, the polarity,
00:15:27 all of that stuff, I think it was three, maybe five days. But to ask all the parties to just
00:15:33 start all over again, and then maybe we'll listen to it. But then why wouldn't we be in the same
00:15:37 position again then? Why wouldn't the court make the same arguments again? Yeah, very, very well
00:15:43 said. Your coverage of this on Twitter has been quite good, not just for people in who know the
00:15:48 law, but I'd say especially for people that aren't lawyers. You've explained the issues very well.
00:15:52 Eva Chibiuk, always a pleasure. Thanks for coming on today. Thanks for having me. All right. Thank
00:15:57 you so much. It's funny when I talk about these issues, which were, I mean, the dominant issues
00:16:01 in the Canadian political landscape for the better part of three years, they do seem like relics
00:16:07 of a bygone era. And I think they are. And I think it's a good thing that mandates are now
00:16:12 just seen as so distant and so past and so old that we're not going to bring them back.
00:16:18 The government of Alberta yesterday, I got a bit nervous because I saw a headline that it was
00:16:22 reimposing masking restrictions in healthcare environments. But then you look at the fine
00:16:27 print and you realize they're really just saying, yeah, but any individual hospital can come up with
00:16:31 its own policy and override what was sort of a baseline that Alberta Health Services was putting
00:16:36 forward now whether they should have done it at all is something that you can discuss and debate
00:16:41 but the whole point is is that we cannot allow uh the very unscientific way government approach
00:16:47 these things to stand without being challenged and this is why i've been a proponent of an inquiry
00:16:53 and this is not to besmirch the the work that people involved with the national citizens inquiry
00:16:58 are doing but the final product the final report will really have no basis in law will not be a
00:17:04 matter of the public record in terms of the government's approach to this. So I think we do
00:17:10 need to have these discussions still. Kenneth Green has done a tremendous job. He is a senior
00:17:15 fellow with the Fraser Institute and has a piece out COVID-19 hygiene theater, masks and lockdowns,
00:17:23 solid science in quotation marks or science veneer. Dr. Kenneth Green joins us now. It's
00:17:29 good to talk to you again, Kenneth. Thanks for coming back on. Good to be with you.
00:17:33 You know, science is something that is not a one-size-fits-all solution, I think.
00:17:38 It's a process, and it's one that people will learn from and adapt,
00:17:43 and you bring in new evidence and you revise your hypotheses and conclusions.
00:17:47 The scientific process, though, I'd say took a bit of a bludgeoning over the last three years, didn't it?
00:17:52 It did.
00:17:53 And you put your finger on a very important point, which is people misunderstand what science is.
00:18:01 We talk about the science, and there is no such thing as the science
00:18:05 any more than there is the flow of water.
00:18:09 It's a process, right?
00:18:11 And so it's a process.
00:18:12 Really what it is, it's trial and error formalized.
00:18:16 It's formalized trial and error learning.
00:18:18 That is, you create a hypothesis, you do an experiment, you publish it,
00:18:23 you repeat it, you test it, you come to conclusions, you publish it,
00:18:26 somebody else tests that.
00:18:27 It's an integrated trial and error learning.
00:18:30 But it's not an authoritative voice. At any given time, in fact, almost all of the studies that are being done will be wrong, right? They will not be repeated and they will not be confirmed.
00:18:44 and so so when when people invoke this this entity of that we're following the science
00:18:51 that's not a thing that's a they may construct in their mind what size is at any given moment but
00:18:57 but it's not really a thing and the thing is governments when they did this uh created a
00:19:03 real problem because they they gave people the illusion that there was this fixed body of
00:19:07 knowledge where all people all scientists come together and say vote and say this is reality
00:19:14 and that the government was just following that.
00:19:19 But, of course, looking back,
00:19:20 if you actually look back at the literature that existed at the time,
00:19:23 the body of scientific literature, which is a real thing,
00:19:28 if you looked at that at the time that they were making their decisions
00:19:31 to impose masking, to impose social distancing,
00:19:34 to impose stay home, stay safe,
00:19:36 three months to flatten the curve,
00:19:39 three weeks to flatten the curve,
00:19:40 three months to flatten the curve,
00:19:41 three years to flatten the curve,
00:19:42 If you look back at the actual literature that was published at the time, as a group called the Cochrane Library has done formally, what you find is there was no evidence that any of those measures would reduce the transmission of COVID or the severity of COVID or the duration of COVID or which parts of the population were affected by COVID.
00:20:08 But the evidence was very, very, very, very weak and inconsistent, and mostly negative,
00:20:17 mostly that is found as the biological common sense would tell you, viruses are not affected
00:20:27 by much.
00:20:28 Viruses are a force of nature.
00:20:30 They're like earthquakes and tornadoes.
00:20:34 It's very difficult for humans to influence a virus that is passing through a population.
00:20:38 of any kind uh and so um yeah so so yeah i think we have a problem with regard to and i
00:20:45 the issue of how governments portrayed what they were doing with regard to science because they
00:20:50 corrupted uh science they corrupted people's understanding of science they corrupted faith 0.98
00:20:56 or belief in science that science is a good way of knowing uh and i think all that is all dangerous
00:21:03 uh because yeah this is that i might be you know i'm still i'm a scientist i have to you know have
00:21:09 to to i've trained in the sciences like doctorates in environmental science and i still believe
00:21:14 science is the best way of knowing uh how the world actually works and and empowers us to to
00:21:21 make the world better make a better place for the world when you bring up the trust in science i
00:21:26 think that's a key point here is that it's not even like in the long run what the government did
00:21:31 really helped it because i i think even very dutiful diligent otherwise obedient people that
00:21:37 wanted to follow whatever justin trudeau and theresa tam were telling them will start to get
00:21:42 suspicious when there can be a complete reversal like i mean the ones that we've all talked about
00:21:46 here are you know you don't need masks don't worry about the mask don't wear masks to everyone wear
00:21:51 a mask from you know border closures are racist to we have to close the border to uh you know the
00:21:56 the vaccine will prevent transmission too.
00:21:58 No, no, no, we never said it.
00:21:59 Like if they had approached this
00:22:01 with a bit more humility
00:22:02 and said, we are learning as we go,
00:22:05 this is what we think now.
00:22:06 And then we changed it
00:22:07 because this came up.
00:22:08 There would probably be
00:22:10 a little bit more forgiveness there,
00:22:11 but we didn't hear that.
00:22:12 And in fact, the efforts
00:22:14 that official institutions went to
00:22:17 to block dissent and criticism,
00:22:19 which as you indicated,
00:22:21 Kenneth, is part of the process,
00:22:23 just completely erodes
00:22:24 that they were really interested
00:22:25 in real science yeah i think that's right i think i think uh there was actually a breach a breach
00:22:31 in the wall of trust of science as an institution and particularly the idea of scientific medicine
00:22:38 um i don't think we'll ever recover or or the the public health agencies the the cdc the centers
00:22:45 with disease control u.s um environment can the the health canadian health authorities i don't
00:22:51 think they'll recover their reputation because it's what you said which is at a certain point
00:22:55 You know, there's a saying, which is, oh, somebody posted something on Twitter, Twitter X, whatever you want to call it, and as people say, they said the quiet part out loud, and they shouldn't have done that, which is they revealed their inner truth, which is that the government is not using science, and the people who are coming out saying that they were the champions of science also were stating things that would be shown to be, as you said, 180 degrees.
00:23:25 wrong within such a short period of time that it's undeniable to people that they you point
00:23:33 out the window right somebody says it's raining out you you point out the window it's not raining
00:23:39 there's a certain point where people can't deny that they're being misled and i think that's
00:23:43 happened that i think covid was was a case in that um it was of that sort where where the
00:23:50 the complete turnaround was so obvious and when they when they were when they finally resorted
00:23:53 saying the science is changing day by day even people who have no background in the sciences
00:24:01 have to understand or know that science because you have to do experiments you have to publish
00:24:05 them you have to write and so forth can't change day by day just one one quick question in closing
00:24:16 here kenneth i mean in politics there's a desire to move beyond this and really not to live in
00:24:21 2020 2021 2022 which i i'm sympathetic to in science is there still a bit of lingering
00:24:28 curiosity have you have your colleagues in various fields of science thought that you
00:24:32 know maybe we should go and look back empirically did this work did this work or have they sort of
00:24:38 tried to move on as well well i'm i'm not embedded at a university or in the institution of science
00:24:45 uh these days i'm not in which is why you're so reliable but those of us on the on the outside
00:24:51 tangential side who are are analysts or students of what's going on in science certainly uh think
00:24:58 something needs to be done and and and there are there are more and more um polls and and uh things
00:25:04 coming out showing that people just don't trust uh the science to the science anymore i find that
00:25:10 troubling and and i've said the same thing as you have or something similar to what you have which
00:25:14 is until there is some process of reconciliation, some process of admission by the agencies,
00:25:22 not just while we should have communicated better, which is, I think, the highest they've
00:25:27 gotten at the U.S. health agencies, while we need to communicate more and better, until there is
00:25:33 actually some sort of process in which they admit we were making stuff up, we were arbitrary and
00:25:39 capricious. We did immense damage to people's lives. Literally, probably much more damage than
00:25:45 COVID did. We're fired. We're fired. We're leaving this field because we can't bring anything
00:25:54 positive. Until there is some process of reconciliation and admission of blame,
00:25:59 there won't be any healing. But this goes back a long way. This goes to climate change as well,
00:26:08 which we've talked about in the past, which is until there's an admission that the process,
00:26:14 that the interpretation of actual scientific information was corrupted. And here's why,
00:26:20 and here's how, and here's how we're not going to do this again. You won't get a restoration
00:26:25 of trust. I think that's all there is to it. Very well said. The essay in the Fraser Institute
00:26:33 is COVID-19 Hygiene Theater, Masks and Lockdowns,
00:26:37 Solid Science in air quotes or scare quotes
00:26:40 or science veneer.
00:26:42 And that is by Dr. Kenneth Green.
00:26:43 Always a pleasure.
00:26:44 Thanks for coming back on.
00:26:45 Oh, it's good to be with you.
00:26:47 All right.
00:26:47 Thanks very much, Kenneth.
00:26:48 Have a wonderful rest of the week and weekend.
00:26:50 We have been covering over the course of the week
00:26:54 on this show and in True North's coverage more broadly,
00:26:58 the horrific terror attacks that have been taking place
00:27:01 against Israel and against Israelis.
00:27:03 And we've been covering the Canadian response to this, both from Canadian officials and also from Canadian communities, both Jewish and non-Jewish.
00:27:13 And well, on one hand, I think it is very easy to dismiss this for some of these people that want to have their heads in the sand about the world as just an Israel thing.
00:27:23 I would encourage you to look more closely.
00:27:26 The attacks that are taking place against Israelis are, if a lot of the rabid anti-Israel and anti-Semitic folks have their way, not going to be limited to Israel at all.
00:27:37 A Hamas official has actually called for a global jihad, in his words, against Jewish people around the world.
00:27:46 We have in London, England, schools that have said they will close tomorrow.
00:27:50 We've had synagogues that have had to ramp up security.
00:27:52 And I've not really heard from the federal government much in the way of very definitive
00:27:57 steps that are taking place to protect the Jewish people tomorrow in communities across
00:28:03 Canada.
00:28:04 Conservative Party of Canada Deputy Leader and Thornhill MP Melissa Lanceman joins me
00:28:09 now.
00:28:10 Melissa, let me just first and foremost say my thoughts and condolences are with your
00:28:14 community and your friends and family through this time.
00:28:18 I'm not a Jewish person.
00:28:19 And I'm a great ally of Israel, but I've not had to shoulder this the way Jewish people in Canada have. 0.99
00:28:25 How real are these concerns about tomorrow?
00:28:29 Well, look, I think they're a big concern from so many members in the community.
00:28:35 And first off, I should say thank you.
00:28:37 And thank you to all of those who have reached out, who, you know, don't have to say the things that they did,
00:28:44 but super appreciative of the thoughts and the prayers, certainly for the people on the ground.
00:28:52 But in our own community, there is a heightened sense of fear.
00:28:58 And that's exactly what these messages are intended to do.
00:29:01 You know, when a terrorist leader calls on something like this around the world,
00:29:07 its intention is to destabilize the normal daily lives of Jews living in communities abroad. 0.57
00:29:13 abroad and instill fear in the community. And that's exactly what it's doing.
00:29:19 One of the things that is so inspiring whenever Jews are targeted in attacks is the resilience
00:29:25 of the Jewish people. I mean, this is a community that has survived the Holocaust,
00:29:30 has survived numerous attacks on the existence of Israel and continued ones. This is very different
00:29:36 than a lot of these stories that have emerged in the last few years, both in death toll and
00:29:41 And I think the narrative, and I'm wondering just in general, when you see a lot of the discussions in the media and online about this, what are they missing?
00:29:50 Well, look, I think depending on which media you're looking at, they're missing the point entirely.
00:29:55 We have media in Canada that won't use the word terrorist when they talk about Hamas.
00:30:02 So, you know, that's a complete revision of what is happening here. 0.92
00:30:07 You have the sick, sadistic terrorist organization committing crimes on women, on children, on elderly Holocaust survivors, kidnapping them.
00:30:19 We've heard stories and frankly seen images that we've never really seen before. 0.89
00:30:25 You almost are watching this in real time as if you would be on a body cam if you were interested in that kind of thing.
00:30:32 And this is disheartening, certainly, for the community and the resilience for the community.
00:30:39 You're right. Throughout history, biblical history, there is instance after instance of those trying to eradicate the Jewish people.
00:30:48 And this genocidal terrorist group is no different. 0.99
00:30:51 Their goal is one goal, and that's the eradication of Israel and the eradication of Jews around the world. 1.00
00:30:57 The federal government has, I think, said the right things when it comes to condemning Hamas. 0.96
00:31:02 Justin Trudeau and your leader, Pierre Paglia, both spoke very eloquently on Monday night.
00:31:06 They've been unequivocal that Hamas is a terror group.
00:31:09 When you look at the efforts that the government has been doing, or I mean, in some cases not
00:31:14 been doing to help Canadians in Israel, though, tremendous doublespeak here.
00:31:19 I mean, on one hand, we were hearing from the foreign minister, Melanie Jolie, that
00:31:23 everything was hunky-dory and that the officials in Tel Aviv were working all through the weekend.
00:31:27 And then we find out yesterday that the embassy was, in fact, closed.
00:31:32 and everything was being handled out of Ottawa.
00:31:34 What's your take on this?
00:31:35 I mean, is the government doing enough to help Canadians
00:31:38 just this basic consular role
00:31:40 that global affairs is supposed to be providing?
00:31:43 Well, look, certainly not.
00:31:44 And we've managed to call and push the government.
00:31:47 For the people watching, they might understand.
00:31:52 The writing that I'm so lucky to represent
00:31:54 has the largest number of Jews anywhere in the country.
00:31:58 And at any given time,
00:32:00 There are tons who are visiting, studying, you know, celebrating something in Israel.
00:32:06 So the very fact that they would reach out to our office suggests that they're not getting the answers that they need from government.
00:32:13 You know, nobody on the other end of the phone, an auto standard reply saying, you know, please don't travel to Israel, to people who are in Israel, saying that the embassy is open, the embassy is closed.
00:32:24 Call this number.
00:32:25 But nobody answers.
00:32:26 And when you're in a situation where you are fearful, you should at the very least expect that the government is going to answer the phone.
00:32:36 So they were slow off the mark, slow to start.
00:32:38 And finally, finally, after a major push, do we have the first flights out of Canadians wanting to come home?
00:32:46 You mentioned that fear is the goal for Hamas and its supporters.
00:32:51 Just in closing, Melissa, what's your message to Jewish Canadians, but I'd say all Canadians for taking the next few days and weeks? 0.83
00:32:59 This is all Canadians. And I would say, you know, watch, you know, watch who has the courage to stand by their by their conviction.
00:33:06 Watch very carefully that the words that are used, you know, for for those in our in our own community here north of Toronto and in Jewish communities and in other communities across the country.
00:33:16 you know, stay vigilant and we will make sure that we continue to push on the government
00:33:22 to keep Canadians safe wherever they are, whether they are in Canada or they are traveling abroad
00:33:27 and want to get home. Deputy Conservative Leader Melissa Lansman, thank you so much for coming on
00:33:33 and try to stay as comfortable and as peaceful as you can in these very difficult times. Thank you.
00:33:40 Thanks so much. All right, thank you. That was Melissa Lansman, the Deputy Leader of the
00:33:45 Conservative Party. I want to move on and take a bit of a different view of this, a bigger picture
00:33:50 view, if I may, on this thing, because oftentimes the people who are very against Israel are against
00:33:56 the idea of Israel. They may say, I'm critical of this particular thing the Israeli government
00:34:02 has done. And as I've said, that's absolutely a fair discussion or criticism. But really what
00:34:07 they're doing is masking what is at its core a contempt and an opposition to the existence
00:34:13 of Israel. And this is where the term anti-Zionist is often being used as a substitute for anti-Semitic
00:34:21 because someone is trying to cloak their genuine beliefs here. And it's amazing how often this is
00:34:27 kind of cloaked in human rights language, the language of human rights. No, we're not
00:34:31 anti-Semitic. We're just supporting human rights for Palestinians. Well, my next guest knows human
00:34:37 rights in an international context very well. Sarah Teach is an international human rights
00:34:42 lawyer. She is with the Macdonald Laurier Institute. She's also the co-founder and
00:34:47 executive director of Human Rights Action Group. Sarah, good to talk to you. Thanks for coming on
00:34:53 today. Just let's start there for a moment, because we often hear human rights, I think,
00:34:58 appropriated by people that have a very anti-Israel view. Right, absolutely. I think what we're seeing
00:35:06 come to the fore, especially now, is a lot of human rights defenders are not actually approaching
00:35:11 human rights in a principled way. Because if they were, they would be against these human rights
00:35:16 violations that Hamas has been committing. And when you talk about that, I mean, we're all
00:35:23 seeing these images, which I'm not sharing on this program. People that want to can go and look them
00:35:28 up. And there's a huge amount of denialism. And, you know, I bring this into the context of
00:35:33 Holocaust history, and we wonder how could anyone deny the Holocaust? Well, look at what people are
00:35:37 doing in real time to deny Holocaust atrocities when we have a much more information, data and
00:35:43 photographic evidence in real time than we did about the Holocaust. Right. And we're seeing 0.64
00:35:50 people deny things that are undeniable at this point. We have videos, we have photos of the
00:35:55 crimes. There are photos of tiny corpses and people are still denying like in a widespread
00:36:01 manner on social media this, that the beheaded babies are calling that a myth. They're calling
00:36:05 that false information. I'm not even sure how you do that when you have photographic evidence.
00:36:11 One of the distinctions that we often hear is that, okay, you know, your issue is with Hamas,
00:36:16 not with the Palestinian people. And I think there is an important distinction there. Israeli 0.91
00:36:20 citizens are not the same as IDF soldiers. Hamas militants are not the same as individual people
00:36:26 in Gaza that have nothing to do with this conflict. But on both sides, casualties are caught up in
00:36:32 this. I mean, you look at Israel's response to Gaza right now, cutting off access to water,
00:36:37 electricity. I know that's being criticized by human rights activists. And I was wondering what
00:36:41 your take on that is. Right. I mean, I think that that's only going to get worse, frankly. And it's
00:36:46 heartbreaking. It is devastating to see photos of Gaza babies who are innocent being pulled from
00:36:51 the rubble. I think what folks need to remember, and I think this is the message that's sort of
00:36:55 already getting lost, is that it's Hamas that has responsibility for this. And when calls are 0.69
00:37:00 coming up for de-escalation by Jolie and others, it's almost not taking into consideration that
00:37:06 there are still 150 plus hostages in Gaza. It's not possible to de-escalate unless and until
00:37:14 Hamas releases those hostages. Well, yeah, and I think that de-escalation has become another one
00:37:20 of these words that seems to be a euphemism now, because when people are talking about de-escalation,
00:37:25 And they're not calling for Hamas de-escalation because Hamas was the one that escalated. 0.56
00:37:31 And by that, I mean, just created this conflict, I mean, in terms of the latest iteration of
00:37:36 it with its attack on Saturday, an attack for which it's been quite proud and has talked 0.79
00:37:40 about expanding and doing more of.
00:37:43 And I think that's the important part that's also missing, is that Israel unilaterally 0.86
00:37:48 withdrew from Gaza in 2005.
00:37:50 That is as de-escalatory as it gets, but has it diffused the conflict? No.
00:37:57 No, not at all. And you see this sort of messaging come out of pro-Israel accounts and Israel
00:38:02 government as well, that when Israel pulled out of Gaza, the Palestinian people in charge at the
00:38:07 time, which was not Hamas right away, they had this opportunity to build up Gaza like a modern 0.98
00:38:13 day Singapore or Dubai. And they've received so much money in international aid. And instead,
00:38:18 all that money has been funneled into Hamas leadership. The head of Hamas lives in a villa
00:38:22 in Qatar. He's not even there. He lives the life of luxury. And this money is going towards building
00:38:27 tunnels, collecting weapons that are then used to attack innocent Israelis. And, you know, there's 0.57
00:38:33 again, when you criticize the Israeli blockade, well, what about Egypt, right? There's also a
00:38:36 border with Egypt and Egypt has not let in the Palestinians through their border as well. So
00:38:41 there's a lot of misinformation here, a lot of misplaced blame. And certainly Hamas does not
00:38:46 have the best interests of Palestinians at heart. Yeah. And I think that's where oftentimes people
00:38:51 don't look enough at the other Arab countries that have made their own decisions on this, which
00:38:55 again, domestic considerations play into as well, but they have a similar, I'm trying to be very
00:39:02 careful with my language here, but a lot of Arab countries have not done anything to support
00:39:07 Palestinian people in a humanitarian way, but they love to point the finger at Israel and say that 1.00
00:39:12 it's the source of all the problems. Right. No one's blaming Egypt for locking down their border.
00:39:17 No one. I haven't seen that anywhere. No. And Israel and Egypt, for its part, has been kind
00:39:23 of instigating in its way by saying, oh, yes, we warned Israel and we did this and did that. 0.96
00:39:29 Moving on from this, I mean, the international community loves to crap on Israel. I mean, 0.93
00:39:33 it's one of the United Nations favorite pastimes. And at a certain point, I mean, what outcome can
00:39:39 there be, but for Israel to disengage from a lot of these institutions. And I think the lack of
00:39:44 nuance, I mean, from all the people that like to call for nuance, the lack of nuance they've given
00:39:48 about the situation has been quite shocking. Right. I mean, I don't know about disassociating
00:39:53 from the institutions. I do still believe that those institutions are important, but certainly
00:39:57 Israel cannot listen and will not listen to calls for de-escalation at this time. And if you see 0.81
00:40:02 that coming out of the EU, the United Nations, when Israel has 150 plus hostages in the territory,
00:40:08 There's no way that they're listening.
00:40:10 And frankly, they shouldn't.
00:40:12 What's, I mean, no one has the crystal ball here.
00:40:15 But if you were to see where this is going to go, I mean, Hamas is not showing signs
00:40:19 of de-escalating on its part.
00:40:21 Israel has to, cannot just sit down and say, and just let it happen in the interest of
00:40:26 a quote unquote de-escalation.
00:40:27 So where does this go?
00:40:29 I mean, I don't see a lot of outs here.
00:40:31 No, that's the heartbreaking part of this all is that Hamas, because they don't care 0.99
00:40:35 about their own people. I don't see a realistic possibility that they're just going to give back
00:40:40 the hostages. Because frankly, if they did, I think Israel would back right down. I mean,
00:40:44 this is what Israel cares about at the end of the day is the hostages. And Hamas knows this, 0.69
00:40:48 and they're taking advantage of this, right? So if Hamas continues to hold on to the hostages,
00:40:53 Israel cannot back down. Israel cannot look away from its people and not try to get those people 0.75
00:40:57 back. And it's the Palestinian civilians that are going to pay the heavy price. 1.00
00:41:01 Yeah, very well said.
00:41:03 Sarah Teach is an international human rights lawyer 0.90
00:41:05 and co-founder of Human Rights Action Group.
00:41:08 Sarah, thank you for coming on today.
00:41:10 Thank you so much for having me.
00:41:11 All right.
00:41:12 You know, I shared this a little bit
00:41:14 at the beginning of the week
00:41:15 and I've been, to be honest,
00:41:17 trying to find the time and energy
00:41:19 and emotional strength to put this all in writing.
00:41:23 And I'm finally doing it
00:41:25 and I'm gonna have a newsletter out this afternoon.
00:41:27 So if you are subscribed to my Substack, you'll see it.
00:41:29 If you're not, you can get subscribed now.
00:41:31 It's at andrewlaughton.substack.com.
00:41:34 But to give you a bit of a primer on this,
00:41:36 if you have not gathered in the last three days,
00:41:39 Israel is a country that has deep meaning to me
00:41:42 and not because of my Jewish faith,
00:41:44 although certainly my Christian faith
00:41:46 has played a significant role
00:41:48 in my relationship with Israel,
00:41:50 but also my understanding and appreciation for history
00:41:54 and for the complexities of the world
00:41:56 and for the human story of Israel.
00:41:59 I was chatting about this with Melissa Lansman a few moments ago.
00:42:02 The one recurring theme throughout history is anti-Semitism, but the corollary to that
00:42:07 is resilience.
00:42:08 Resilience is an absolutely essential and pervasive part of the Jewish story.
00:42:15 And I have no doubt whatsoever that Israel will survive this, that the Jewish people
00:42:20 will survive it.
00:42:22 But it's important to look around and see all the people who are not contributing to
00:42:26 the attacks on Israel with their rockets or their knives or their guns, but the people who are 0.78
00:42:32 contributing with their words. And I'm looking at a lot of you that occupy positions of leadership
00:42:38 and power in universities and unions in governments who are very morally indistinct
00:42:44 from Hamas. You may not be violent, but you share the same goal, which is an utter contempt 0.95
00:42:49 and disdain for the beacon of light in the Middle East. So I'll leave you with that. More of my
00:42:56 thoughts coming out in that sub stack and we'll have more coverage over the weekend at true north
00:43:01 to the jewish people watching and listening shabbat shalom i hope you have a very safe weekend and to
00:43:06 all canadians thank you god bless and good day to you all thanks for listening to the andrew
00:43:11 Lawn Show. Support the program by donating to True North at www.tnc.news.
00:43:41 We'll be right back.
00:44:11 We'll be right back.
00:44:41 Thank you.