Juno News - May 30, 2023


Alberta Votes 2023

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
What's your prediction for the election? Jagmeet Singh says he’ll keep supporting Trudeau until elections can be trusted

Episode Stats


Length

4 hours and 30 minutes

Words per minute

185.0

Word count

50,063

Sentence count

2,094

Harmful content

Misogyny

106

sentences flagged

Toxicity

9

sentences flagged

Hate speech

19

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Live from the UCP headquarters in Calgary, Andrew Lawton is joined by Lindsay Wilson and William MacBeth to discuss all things election night in Alberta. Topics covered include: What's going on in the polls? Who's your favourite candidate? What are you keeping an eye on?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 All right. Can you guys hear us on the YouTube stream?
00:00:02 If you can hear us, we're just going to get this rolling.
00:00:04 All right. Welcome, everyone.
00:00:05 That is like the weirdest start to one of these things I've ever done.
00:00:09 Welcome to True North's live election night special.
00:00:12 My name is Andrew Lawton, and I hope you weren't here.
00:00:20 ...sizes I was doing before the show and the clean pants of underwear.
00:00:23 The hot mic moments you get are never as exciting for me.
00:00:25 But it is an absolute pleasure to have you tuned in to this very special night, the 2023 Alberta election.
00:00:33 I have two of our panelists with me here, William Macbeth, who is True North's chief operating officer, a longtime Alberta politico, and also Lindsay Wilson, who's the president of Alberta Proud.
00:00:44 We have a great show planned for you tonight.
00:00:46 We're going to have updates from our correspondent, Rachel Emanuel, very shortly.
00:00:51 And we are also going to have lots of the characters who have been much involved in the election coming in to share their thoughts on what's happening.
00:00:59 Just to put the thing into context here, 30 minutes until the polls close, 30 minutes until polls close.
00:01:06 We're expected to have results pretty soon after that.
00:01:09 And we'll have them really as they come.
00:01:12 and I should just say for context here, there's going to be no minority government
00:01:16 short of some really, really weird, unforeseen event.
00:01:20 It's going to be an NDP majority or a UCP majority.
00:01:23 But with that out of the way, I'm going to ask both of you a question here.
00:01:26 What's the riding you're watching tonight?
00:01:29 Well, the riding I'm most interested in watching is California.
00:01:34 I think that that's one of the ridings that if the NDP are ahead and leading in it,
00:01:40 that's a bad sign for the UCP if it's trending back to the UCP I think that
00:01:46 indicates Calgary as a whole isn't going to go enough NDP in order for them to
00:01:51 win the election and what's yours well I'm your rural girl so I I live out in
00:01:55 Cochrane but the one the writing that I'm keeping my eye on the most would be
00:01:59 Miranda Rosen on the Banff Kananaskis ticket that is traditionally a very
00:02:05 difficult riding they've that's been switched up a bit and lost over the last
00:02:08 couple of elections and so I mean you've got Banff and Canmore and that's typically quite
00:02:13 favorable toward the NDP of course and then you go all the way uh you know into through Bragg Creek
00:02:18 and then out to uh Pritis and Elbow and and and so it's it's really like kind of uniting two totally
00:02:24 different worlds right so you get more of that rural kind of hardcore UCP support you see the
00:02:29 big signs on the big farmer fields and and so it's really interesting I she's been fighting
00:02:34 tooth and nail for that it's that's that's going to be a really interesting
00:02:38 interesting riding yeah and just to ask myself the question as well and answer
00:02:44 it the riding that I'm watching is Edmonton Southwest now this is relevant
00:02:48 for a couple of reasons number one it's one of the only UCP ridings in Edmonton
00:02:52 right now and it's been touch and go the NDP very popular in Edmonton which
00:02:56 won't surprise anyone who's spent much time in Edmonton but it's also the
00:02:59 riding held by Casey Maddu, who's the deputy premier and right now has the only UCB seat in
00:03:05 Edmonton. So that's the one I'm watching. We will get an update on what you have to expect in the
00:03:10 evening ahead from Alberta correspondent for True North, Rachel Emanuel.
00:03:21 Hey, Andrew. Thank you for that. Welcome to the show, everybody. We're very excited to be here
00:03:26 at the UCP headquarters as Andrew mentioned I think it's going to be exciting night I heard
00:03:31 some of the ridings that everyone mentioned they were watching definitely Calgary Acadia that's
00:03:35 Tyler Shandro's riding is going to be one to watch tonight I was there earlier today doing some
00:03:40 streeters getting a sense of the voters as they were heading out of the polls and we're excited
00:03:44 to show you what people had to say on their way out of the exit polls later it seemed pretty mixed
00:03:48 feelings so it's going to be interesting to watch the one I also have a close eye on Calgary Glenmore
00:03:53 that is whitney is six riding so i think depending what those do will be a good sense of whether the
00:03:59 ucp is going to do well or not tonight it's been a very close campaign it's going to be very close
00:04:05 tonight we know that the ucp is going to lose seats in calgary however we are still expecting
00:04:10 them to eke out a majority government at the end of the night at least that's what recent polls have
00:04:15 shown us but certainly it's been a campaign full of lots of personal attacks other things that
00:04:20 we've discussed have been health care and education and tax cuts i know ucp insiders i've spoken to
00:04:27 are hoping that the ballot box question is going to be jobs and the economy but i'm not sure that
00:04:32 it is typically in these types of elections it really comes down to who voters trust do they
00:04:38 want another alberta ndp government or do they trust danielle smith that's something i heard 0.93
00:04:42 today at the polls and we're excited to play that for you later on and we're also interested to see
00:04:47 whether or not the ucp's negative campaigning tactics actually worked we are going to find
00:04:53 about that later tonight as results come as andrew mentioned polls close at 8 pm mountain time so we
00:04:58 are going to have some results for you very shortly and we're excited to bring that to you back to you
00:05:17 Thank you for that, Rachel. We will check in with Rachel as the evening progresses. She's going to have some interviews with folks that are tied into what's happening. And we will, of course, have the results as they come in 26 minutes, 25 and a half minutes to be precise until the polls close. Hopefully start getting some results here.
00:05:36 But let's start talking about the bigger picture of the campaign, though.
00:05:39 And I think let's just start with where we are.
00:05:42 This is the Big Four building on the Stampede grounds in Calgary, where if you were to follow around this campaign, you wouldn't really go that much outside of Calgary.
00:05:52 This has been very much the battleground here.
00:05:55 So is that typical of elections where, you know, it's won or lost here, William?
00:06:00 Yeah, I mean, it's interesting to reflect the changing nature of elections in Alberta,
00:06:05 which even just a couple of elections ago were multi-party elections,
00:06:08 and now they've transitioned to a two-party election.
00:06:12 So you've got New Democrats, you've got the United Conservative Party.
00:06:16 If you look at the distribution of seats in Alberta, it can be roughly grouped into three.
00:06:21 There's Edmonton, there's Calgary, and there's the whole rest of the province.
00:06:25 And apologies to anyone who lives in the rest of the province.
00:06:27 I think you get short-shafted a little bit in this analysis, but as you mentioned earlier on,
00:06:33 the New Democrats expect to perform very well in Edmonton, winning most, if not all, of the seats.
00:06:39 The United Conservative Party is expecting to do very well in the rest of Alberta,
00:06:43 in the rural zones and the smaller cities in the north, central, and south regions,
00:06:47 which means they've both got one zone in their column, Calgary's the battleground.
00:06:52 So this city very much will decide who is going to be the next government of Alberta.
00:06:57 Yeah, now you are the rural girl at heart, but you're not really the battleground.
00:07:00 Rachel Notley's not even bothering with your neck in the woods. 0.98
00:07:03 Oh, no, certainly not.
00:07:04 I mean, Peter Guthrie is my MLA.
00:07:06 Cochran, he's got Airdrie West and Cochran.
00:07:07 And that's always been, I think we have the highest UCP voter turnout per capita in the province.
00:07:14 So, but, you know, I'll tell you, there's more orange signs out there than there were a few years ago.
00:07:18 So that's interesting.
00:07:20 It's the NDP now, the public perception of the NDP now compared to four years ago.
00:07:25 you got to give it to them on marketing it's really the way that their their persona uh and
00:07:32 building that around rachel notley herself i i mean you're seeing things now that you wouldn't
00:07:38 have seen a few years ago so it's interesting yeah and i mean people forget though or maybe
00:07:42 they don't actually when the ndp was in power in alberta they actually did do very well in some of
00:07:46 these rural areas and it was actually uh i think part of why it was so shocking to people that that
00:07:52 victory came when it did so let's talk about what the NDP was really campaigning on because they
00:07:57 weren't trying to be I know a lot of people watching this are not from Alberta you know
00:08:01 Jagmeet Singh was not here campaigning for Rachel Notley they're trying to pretend they're an NDP
00:08:04 that has nothing to do with what NDP people think anywhere else but is that a credible proposal to
00:08:10 Albert yeah no there's it isn't a mistake that you didn't see Jagmeet Singh coming to Alberta
00:08:16 during this election I think what Rachel Notley tried to present herself with in a lot of different
00:08:21 ways is i'm not like those other new democrats i'm not like the toronto new democrats we're a
00:08:27 unique brand of alberta new democrat harkening back to that populist prairie side of the party
00:08:33 did it work that's the real question and i think uh you know it's so interesting people have made
00:08:38 comments that rachel notley wore a blue outfit to the debate a conservative blue outfit if you look
00:08:45 at the lit pieces or the brochures that have been put together where they want to talk about
00:08:48 something good they're doing, it's on a blue panel background, and they put Daniel Smith
00:08:53 on a red background, because in this province, red is liberal, and liberal is bad.
00:08:58 And so all of that's really interesting.
00:09:01 I don't think it worked as well as they would have hoped.
00:09:03 I think there was a belief early in the campaign that maybe people were going to lend or hold
00:09:09 their nose and vote New Democrat because they didn't like Daniel Smith, but a lot of people
00:09:13 remembered they didn't really love Rachel Notley either when she had her four years
00:09:17 in government it was tough times for alberta but were you seeing that in people you spoke to where
00:09:21 you know the ucp was more popular than danielle smith was or maybe rachel notley 1.00
00:09:26 was more popular than danielle smith but the ucp was more popular than the nvp you know certainly
00:09:31 certainly uh daniel smith struggled a little bit you know we can talk about that later but
00:09:35 uh and the ndp it's not about the ndp it's about rachel notley right you look at even all their
00:09:40 signs it's team rachel notley so that's always been really interesting to me uh yeah i don't
00:09:45 know i don't know um i think i think where i think rachel was leading and beating danielle
00:09:53 i think there was a couple of turning points in the last couple of weeks i think that the ucp has
00:09:58 done a pretty good job at disputing the biggest lie that the ndp has unfortunately ran their
00:10:03 campaign on and which is the sound bite that danielle's going to make you pay for a doctor 1.00
00:10:06 so they came out with their health care guarantee and and and we can hold premier smith
00:10:10 she has gone on record to say no alberton will ever pay out of pocket for a doctor and we have
00:10:17 to hold them to their word they've made their health care guarantee on that so um i think
00:10:22 they've done a pretty good job of pushing back on that and i whereas i think that rachel notley was
00:10:26 and the ndp was quite successful on that on that before and i think the debate a couple of weeks
00:10:31 ago i think that was also a turning point i think that the premier smith um won that debate handily
00:10:35 personally yeah and we we have some debate highlights that we'll get to later on but the
00:10:40 one i will say is that everyone on the left side of things was hoping it would be some colossal
00:10:47 crash and burn for danielle's bed so i would argue she had a lower bar she needed to clear going in 1.00
00:10:51 anyway but uh she certainly cleared it and she didn't just hold i think she actually gained a
00:10:57 little bit out of that and i think you gotta also keep in mind like rachel notley is no slouch at
00:11:01 debate i mean she won that election in 2015 because of that debate and and but i feel that
00:11:07 the tone has changed i feel there's too much of an anger machine that i was seeing when i was
00:11:10 watching that debate and i think premier came across as a little more polished a little bit
00:11:14 more premier like and i think that that really shone and i think we've seen a big shift since
00:11:18 then i really think that that was more pivotal some people say it was a bit of a draw i don't
00:11:22 think so i think it was more pivotal than people realize in favor of the ucp leading us into
00:11:26 tonight now we were talking earlier about the ridings that we're watching here are there any
00:11:31 ridings will that really test more about the province-wide picture than just the local story
00:11:38 are there really reliable bellwethers here to watch yeah i mean um as we discussed this is the battle
00:11:44 for calgary the battle for hearts and minds of calgarians so looking at how calgary goes is going
00:11:49 to be the outcome of this election and i think you're going to see it uh not so much in the
00:11:54 downtown and their ridings that surround that, I think those are pretty safe going to go NDP
00:12:00 tonight. But the next rung of ridings out, that they're not really in the suburbs, the full
00:12:05 suburbs yet, they're closer to the core, but that's where the battleground is. And if early
00:12:09 on you start to see those trending up towards the NDP, that's a bad sign for the United Conservative
00:12:16 Party. But if they're holding on to those ridings, even if they have smaller margins,
00:12:21 then I think the UCB is in pretty good shape
00:12:23 and is going to come out of this for the second term under Daniels.
00:12:26 If you are just tuning in here,
00:12:28 this is the True North Alberta election results show.
00:12:31 If you see me plugging away at my computer, I'm not playing solitary.
00:12:35 We are trying to keep tabs on all the things that are happening on social media,
00:12:39 which is a bit easier right now because the polls have not yet closed.
00:12:42 That's going to come in, I think, just over 18 minutes.
00:12:46 So we'll be getting results to you as quickly as we can get them.
00:12:49 And the fun part is sometimes you hear people cheer or start groaning because they got a result that we are just about to get to.
00:12:57 Like I remember in 2019 at the federal election, I was covering from Andrew Scheer's headquarters.
00:13:02 And when Ralph Goodale lost his seat, I don't think anyone could hear me broadcasting because there was such a celebration in the room.
00:13:09 But we are going to get to that.
00:13:10 But just before we get over to Rachel Emanuel, who has an interview lined up, let's talk a little bit about the health care aspect.
00:13:18 Because you brought this up, and it was probably the number one thing.
00:13:21 When I talked to some people that were working on campaigns that were going, they were hearing that at the door.
00:13:26 So the NDP message did seem like it was getting through, that she's going to privatize your health care.
00:13:31 Yeah, but I think what's unfortunate about it is that it's not truthful.
00:13:35 It's not truthful campaigning.
00:13:36 And certainly, you know, in her time as a radio talk show host, Premier Smith, then Daniel Smith,
00:13:41 she pontificated about that's what you do in these shows, and you talk, and you bounce ideas.
00:13:46 and you're a completely different person when you're in that space
00:13:50 as opposed to when you're an elected official, let alone the Premier of Alberta.
00:13:53 So those were sound bites.
00:13:55 They were taken a lot out of context, and there was a lot.
00:13:59 I know people who work in spaces that are union folks,
00:14:03 and their unions were coming to them and really hammering this message home
00:14:09 that you're going to have to pay for a doctor.
00:14:11 And it's dishonest campaigning.
00:14:13 I know we see it.
00:14:14 We see it from both sides, certainly.
00:14:15 but that really that really irked me i had a lot of um a lot of women particularly who i know 0.93
00:14:24 engaged in politics not like people like us and you know they're busy they they've got kids they've
00:14:28 got jobs they've got businesses to run and they asked me well is that true i'm gonna have to pay
00:14:32 for a doctor it's it's really amazing how much that that message stuck and and canadians don't
00:14:37 like that concept it doesn't matter if you if you explain that well we've always had a two-tiered
00:14:42 health care system this is looking at it it doesn't really matter it's canadians just don't
00:14:47 like that concept they see it as an all or nothing thing and they're worried that we're going to
00:14:50 become some u.s version of health care and they're terrified of that so let me ask you william because
00:14:55 our viewers may know you did work for danielle smith in 2012 which unfortunately you could not
00:15:00 clinch the win for her but i i know it was looking very good for a lot of the campaign
00:15:05 danielle smith has done a lot on health care policy as a business advocate as a radio host
00:15:11 as accommodator, and she has advocated for solutions that would involve some private
00:15:15 element to healthcare delivery, and I don't think that should be controversial, but I
00:15:19 realize in Canada it is.
00:15:21 So if you were advising her, how would you have walked that line of saying, yes, I've
00:15:25 talked about these things, but we're keeping this core universal healthcare intact?
00:15:30 Yeah, I mean, it's such an interesting question because the debate tends to descend very quickly
00:15:35 into, well, we either do health care the way we've been doing it
00:15:40 for the last 60 years, or we immediately become the United States
00:15:45 and nobody has public health insurance anymore.
00:15:47 Forgetting these are like two of the least efficient systems in the world.
00:15:51 It's just hilarious that you could think there's 200 countries in the world,
00:15:56 but there's only two ways of doing health care. 0.99
00:15:58 So I think what I would have told Danielle, first of all,
00:16:00 I would have told her to be bold and to carry on with her health spending account promise.
00:16:05 I think that would have been a very tangible thing that parents particularly would have
00:16:09 appreciated, helping to cover things like dental visits, glasses, therapy appointments,
00:16:16 whatever the case.
00:16:17 In terms of the private delivery of health care, I think as long as you always remind
00:16:22 people that even if health care is being delivered by a non-government provider, you are not
00:16:28 being asked to take out your credit card to pay for health care in Alberta.
00:16:32 It is simply the method of delivery that is changing.
00:16:35 And what that has meant, though, that since Alberta has started to move in this direction is we're seeing fewer waiting lists for key procedures.
00:16:42 We're seeing surgeries happening faster.
00:16:44 We're seeing people get hip and knee replacements faster.
00:16:46 They're getting cataract surgeries faster.
00:16:48 And at the end of the day, that's a better quality of life for people waiting for those procedures.
00:16:52 Yeah, and I think that it's actually good that health care policy was discussed,
00:16:56 because oftentimes I think people were fearing that this election would just be about, you know,
00:17:00 whatever Danielle Smith said on the radio five years ago and one of those every day.
00:17:04 there were a lot of character attacks in this campaign i don't think it was as bad as i
00:17:09 expected it to be but did that dominate on the ground that just personality conflict oh i think
00:17:15 so and i think i think that that that tonage came out as well in the debate i know i keep going back
00:17:19 to that but i i certainly think yeah i think so i think it was this was this was i think to me it
00:17:25 was it's been less about the ndp versus the ucp and more about danielle smith versus rachel notley
00:17:32 So here's the big question I have to ask you.
00:17:34 Thirteen years since the last Wild Rose campaign,
00:17:37 how do you rank Danielle Smith to candidate now against Danielle Smith to candidate then?
00:17:42 Well, I mean, for people with long memories who may remember the 2012 election,
00:17:47 one of the things that was cited as a reason Danielle lost was she had a candidate
00:17:51 who said something controversial and that that candidate wasn't dismissed
00:17:57 or wasn't taken off the ballot for the United Conservative Party.
00:18:00 And Daniel said, I can't tell a candidate what to say or think.
00:18:05 Similarly, this time, we did have a candidate who, you know,
00:18:08 talked about a really unpleasant metaphor of a poop cookie,
00:18:13 which I don't think, regardless of the issue, is an unpleasant metaphor.
00:18:16 For those of you playing the drinking game at home, he said poop cookie,
00:18:19 so you have to take a shot now.
00:18:20 Everybody drink.
00:18:21 And quite quickly, Daniel came around and said,
00:18:24 this does not represent our views, and if this person does win,
00:18:27 they will not be allowed to sit in an United Conservative caucus.
00:18:30 So that is at least one sign that Danielle has taken some of the hard lessons of that loss in 2012 and decided, I really don't want to lose another election in Alberta.
00:18:40 Now, are you seeing, I mean, there's a theoretical scenario in which that ends up costing the UCP a very necessary seat tonight.
00:18:47 No, you're right.
00:18:47 If it's a very strange world where somehow we've ended up with 43 United Conservative seats,
00:18:53 43 New Democrat seats, and this one independent,
00:18:56 then that's going to be awkward for everybody having to figure out what level of comfort they have
00:19:01 with working with this individual in the legislature.
00:19:04 But that being said, I actually don't think it's going to be quite that close.
00:19:08 I think the United Conservative Party has the advantage going into tonight.
00:19:12 One thing that I will talk about this a little bit later on,
00:19:14 But obviously, the UCP leadership race that elected Danielle Smith as leader and ultimately premier was overwhelmingly a reaction to,
00:19:23 I think, a lot of COVID frustrations with Jason Kenney from the more independence-oriented wing of the party that were very concerned about the past.
00:19:33 A lot of that didn't import into the general election, which I actually found quite refreshing.
00:19:37 I mean, Danielle Smith really didn't have a difficulty, it seemed like, pivoting to premier mode.
00:19:41 Well, I think she stopped talking about COVID early enough on because she came out a little bit when she was first, when she won the leadership race and she came out talking about COVID and that didn't sit well with people. So I think we just, we just, we need to move forward. It was a terrible chapter. Politicians made mistakes, world mistakes.
00:19:58 Kenny did he make mistakes sure but do people not think Rachel Notley would have made mistakes
00:20:03 or anybody else in that position would have made mistakes it was changing all the time so
00:20:06 it's it's easy for us to say oh I would have or we should have or anything like that but it was
00:20:11 a really difficult time globally so I think we just need to dust ourselves off and we need
00:20:15 his best position to answer this but but what happened to the Kenny loyalists on this election
00:20:25 Did they tend to fall in line or had we seen a kind of a little resistance group?
00:20:31 I mean, my brief answer to that would be I think there was some hard days for a few of them.
00:20:38 I think they didn't particularly warm right away to to Daniel Smith, who they probably in some ways blamed a bit for some of their candidates downfall.
00:20:49 However, the cold hard reality of re-electing an NDP government in Alberta, I suspect has been kind of motivating to many skinny people to say, well, maybe she isn't my choice, maybe she isn't perfect, but gosh, do we really want four years of lefty government back in Alberta? Remember how it went the first time.
00:21:08 I do think it also speaks volumes that there were seven leadership candidates.
00:21:14 Danielle Smith was successful.
00:21:16 Lilo Ahir is no longer.
00:21:18 And the other five got big positions within her government.
00:21:22 I think that was her setting the tone for unity.
00:21:24 Because most importantly, this actually has to start acting like the united Conservative Party
00:21:29 if we want to be prosperous, if the party wants to be prosperous for the next four years and beyond.
00:21:34 For sure.
00:21:35 We are 10 minutes away from polls closing.
00:21:38 This is True North Alberta Election Night Results Show.
00:21:41 For those of you with us from the get-go, thank you very much.
00:21:44 We've improved since that very strange, like, Curb Your Enthusiasm-esque opening.
00:21:48 But you know we are here, and the night is just beginning.
00:21:52 We are going to have, just to give you a little sampling of what's going to come,
00:21:54 we're going to have results as they arrive, starting probably in about 15, 16, 17 minutes.
00:22:00 I think there may be some unsurprising results,
00:22:03 but it will all look very exciting when the numbers start changing
00:22:06 and the map starts going red.
00:22:07 And then some of the battlegrounds.
00:22:09 And just, by the way, I know that format stuff isn't always the most interesting,
00:22:12 but it is relevant.
00:22:14 Ballots were cast by paper, but they're counted electronically,
00:22:17 which generally means we're in for a shorter turnaround on results, ideally, right?
00:22:21 I believe it was the advanced ballots that were counted electronically.
00:22:26 I think it's hand-counting for today.
00:22:28 But that means we should get a large dump of results quite quickly
00:22:32 when they push the magic button,
00:22:34 and it spits out the results for 87 advanced polls in every ridings.
00:22:39 Yeah, and the strange thing whenever you're watching results
00:22:41 is that you never know if the advanced polls are in or not.
00:22:43 But this time we will know if the advanced polls are in or not.
00:22:46 So hopefully we'll get a bit of a better sense of what's happening.
00:22:49 We are going to go to Rachel Emanuel now, 0.74
00:22:51 who has with her UCP campaign strategist and senator-elect,
00:22:55 Erika Baroudis. Take it away, Rachel. 1.00
00:22:59 Hey, guys. So I'm here with Erika Baroudis.
00:23:01 You might remember her from the Alberta Roundup.
00:23:03 She was one of our very famous analysts.
00:23:05 When we last spoke, you mentioned that you were pegging in about 48 seats for the UCP, maybe 48 to 51.
00:23:11 Have you changed your mind, or are you still keeping your estimate?
00:23:14 No, I've had that number for three months, so I'm just going to lock it in.
00:23:16 If I'm right or wrong, we'll see you in a couple hours.
00:23:19 And what riding are you really watching tonight to know if we lose this riding, we're not going to be in good footing?
00:23:25 Yeah, I think a good indicator is if we see good numbers in Calgary Glenmore, Calgary Boat.
00:23:31 So, Katie, I think we'll see a good, strong night.
00:23:34 But, yeah, so I'll be watching those,
00:23:36 and then we'll see how some of the rest of the province goes.
00:23:39 I think we'll be successful in a lot of the donut outside of Edmonton as well.
00:23:42 One of the other things that you mentioned on the show was that after the debate,
00:23:46 you felt that the door is really warm for United Conservative Party volunteers
00:23:50 who are out door-knocking with their candidates.
00:23:52 Did you notice that there was maybe a policy that people were interested in
00:23:55 that they hadn't really cared about before,
00:23:56 or just generally that people had a better impression of leader Danielle Smith?
00:24:00 Meanwhile, you know, we know the NDP tried so much negative campaigning and certainly some of that did work.
00:24:05 Yeah, it definitely, I think, did early on in the campaign.
00:24:09 I mean, outright lying about public health care.
00:24:11 Unfortunately, Albertans believed Rachel Notley for quite some time.
00:24:14 But I do think two things.
00:24:16 Yes, on the debate, I think that's because Premier Danielle Smith looked like Premier Danielle Smith
00:24:21 and Rachel Notley looked like she was auditioning to be the leader of the official opposition again.
00:24:26 So I think that was a clear shift during the campaign.
00:24:28 I also think it was a very close timing to when they released their costing for their platform.
00:24:35 And in that was an increase on the business tax from 8% to 11%, which is a 38% increase.
00:24:41 And I definitely think that's when Albertans started paying attention to the math of the NDP wasn't really making sense.
00:24:47 How are they going to get this revenue in?
00:24:50 How are we going to attract investment?
00:24:52 Businesses coming out left, right, and center, including the Alberta Chamber of Commerce, against this policy.
00:24:57 So, you know, I think ours were consistent policies from the beginning, focused on what Albertans were talking about, the economy, affordability and public safety.
00:25:06 But that was one where it was like, whoa, I can't believe that they're actually going to run on this.
00:25:10 Yeah, I think that was a typical policy that most of us expected to see from the NDP, whereas they've kind of been running as moderates in the election.
00:25:17 But when we talk about really that campaign defining moment and maybe the debate being that moment that really changed the momentum of the UCP campaign,
00:25:23 I felt like she seemed a lot more confident in her appearances after that.
00:25:28 She had that campaign rally in Edmonton.
00:25:29 She seemed really excited.
00:25:30 Her public speaking was on point.
00:25:32 And then again, at another media appearance on Friday, that was her last appearance.
00:25:36 We haven't seen her since then.
00:25:36 And she just seems confident.
00:25:37 She looks like someone who thinks she's going to win the election.
00:25:40 She knows she's going to win the election.
00:25:41 Have you on the campaign felt that momentum since the debate?
00:25:44 Absolutely.
00:25:45 I mean, like I said, she showed she is premier worthy and that she came out. 0.90
00:25:50 That is her wheelhouse, right?
00:25:51 but Rachel Notley is a strong communicator too 0.69
00:25:53 and I don't think Rachel showed up that night.
00:25:55 So I think that was that step up
00:25:57 that Danielle Smith needed for that momentum 0.82
00:25:59 and she kept nailing everything else since then
00:26:03 and it was a strong finish and a positive campaign.
00:26:07 Great, well thank you so much again.
00:26:08 That was Erica Baroudis,
00:26:09 a senior advisor with the UCP campaign.
00:26:12 Oh, we're just gonna have a little bit more time here left.
00:26:14 One thing that I am very curious about
00:26:16 is we know that the compassion intervention
00:26:18 was such a huge policy for the party.
00:26:20 I was surprised to see you guys introduce it.
00:26:22 Basically, that would force somebody who is a danger to themselves or others, a drug addict, into treatment.
00:26:28 What type of reception?
00:26:29 Did people ask about that at the doors or was it something that they weren't really aware of?
00:26:32 You know what?
00:26:33 I think people that maybe have a direct relationship with something like that, they did react to that.
00:26:39 I think that obviously the NDP tried to fear and smear it.
00:26:43 But it is something that we do see across the U.S., across Europe.
00:26:47 It has been shown to work, but it's about trying it in Alberta and seeing if it's applicable
00:26:53 because I think we can all agree at the end of the day public safety is a huge concern
00:26:57 and not just removing those folks from the streets, but also giving them the help that they need
00:27:03 is definitely showing the compassionate conservative side that the UCP has.
00:27:07 Absolutely, and we're hoping to hear from Mike Ellis a little bit later.
00:27:10 He is the public safety minister, so I'm sure that he'll have more to share on that.
00:27:13 Again, thank you so much, Erica, for your time.
00:27:15 Once again, that was Erica Baroudis, a senior advisor with the UCP campaign.
00:27:19 Back to you, Andrew.
00:27:26 Welcome back.
00:27:27 We are, and thank you for that, Rachel.
00:27:29 I believe we have to talk a little bit just because we had Erica Baroudis on there.
00:27:33 The winner of the Senate election is the UCP candidate, which I don't want to take it away from her.
00:27:39 And a Trudeau government federally doesn't mean all that much because the federal government isn't appointing Alberta senators who were elected.
00:27:46 But I do think it brings us around to what, again, was a very interesting theme in the UCP leadership race,
00:27:53 but I don't believe was talked about at all in the general election, which was Alberta sovereignty.
00:27:58 And I'm not talking about secession or separation, but rather just this idea of Alberta asserting itself.
00:28:04 The Sovereignty Act was Bill 1 of the Smith government.
00:28:07 Where did that issue go?
00:28:09 Well, at Alberta Proud, we're really focused on standing up for Alberta and more Alberta and less Ottawa.
00:28:17 And really, the media got really hyped up about this one.
00:28:20 When she first came out with the Sovereignty Act, it was all over the place.
00:28:23 During the leadership race, it was all over the place.
00:28:25 But really, at the end of the day, why is it such a bad thing?
00:28:28 I think a lot of people just honed in on little details of it too much.
00:28:31 I mean, if we look next door, Premier Scott Moe in Saskatchewan is doing wonders with the Saskatchewan First Act.
00:28:38 People love him for it, but why do they hate Danielle for it?
00:28:41 It's the same thing, essentially.
00:28:43 It's just putting us first.
00:28:45 We want to be the determiners of our own resources and our own tax dollars
00:28:51 and all these sorts of things moving in that direction.
00:28:53 That's just removing the Trudeau middleman.
00:28:55 And it was always puzzling to me how mainstream legacy media kind of ran with that
00:29:02 and put such a negative spin on that.
00:29:04 I don't know.
00:29:05 I mean, if you recall back to the leadership race, you would have thought, remember the claims that were being made.
00:29:12 If this act becomes law, you're going to see companies fleeing.
00:29:16 You know, the federal government is going to, you know, send in their own people to run services.
00:29:24 It was a level of hyperbole, not only from opposition politicians, who you expect that sort of thing from,
00:29:31 But every political scientist, every media supporter, they saw it as an opportunity to take a swing at a party and a leader they didn't like.
00:29:43 The reality on the ground, of course, is she introduced it, it became law, and to my knowledge, we barely talked about it afterwards, and certainly not during this election.
00:29:51 Of all of the press comments I watched, I can't recall a single question being asked about the Sovereignty Act and its impact on Alberta.
00:29:59 So, interesting development.
00:30:02 Yeah, and I will say as well, and we'll talk about this a little bit later on,
00:30:06 all of the parties that would pop up that were kind of vying for the same share of votes on the right
00:30:12 really vanished this election.
00:30:14 And we'll talk about that, especially when we see some results.
00:30:16 But right now, I am stretching out my answer because in 25 seconds, polls are closing,
00:30:23 which means nothing in terms of results because we aren't going to get results right at like eight minutes on the dot.
00:30:28 But it's exciting. We announced it. We bring attention to it.
00:30:32 And it means that the end is near, at least for finding out what's happening tonight.
00:30:36 So have I have I sufficiently bought us to? Yes, we can do the five, four, three, two, one.
00:30:43 Holes are closed. Yay. We can pop the champagne.
00:30:46 But before we do that, we'll head over to Rachel Emanuel, who is joined by UCP candidate for Calgary West, Mike Ellis.
00:30:53 Take it away, Rachel.
00:30:54 thanks andrew i am joined by mike ellis as andrew mentioned he is the candidate for calgary
00:31:01 the ucp is going to hold that seat tonight unless something crazy happens
00:31:06 mike ellis is also the minister for public safety and they've been doing a ton of work on that file
00:31:11 something that i was just talking to erica about that caught our attention on the campaign was the
00:31:15 compassion intervention which as i just mentioned to our viewers would essentially force drug addicts
00:31:19 who are a danger to themselves or to others into treatment wondering if you can tell me a little
00:31:23 about what the reception has been to this policy yeah i mean think as you know i did 12 years as a
00:31:28 police officer on the streets of calgary um you know i think that uh you know our our friends on
00:31:33 the uh the left were were uh for sure opposed to this but uh you know look this is something that
00:31:39 we we already do under the mental health act if somebody's posing a danger to themselves or others
00:31:43 we make sure that that person gets the help that they need we also have something what is known as
00:31:48 peach ad and p chip where children might be involved in in alcohol or drugs or children
00:31:52 might be involved in prostitution and it's a piece of legislation that allows families to get 0.99
00:31:58 intervention through the courts to get these kids the help that they need so this is something that
00:32:02 is been long-standing in this province and to answer your question we've actually had a really
00:32:08 good reception from people because they it's it is about compassion because when somebody is
00:32:12 overdosing five to ten times a day you know what's the alternative to give them more drugs and allow
00:32:18 them to continue the cycle of abuse or to actually get them help so that they
00:32:23 can get treatment and live happy and healthy lives again. I think Albertans
00:32:27 are very clear they would like the latter. So when you mention that this is
00:32:30 something that's already being done I'm wondering why we need a piece of
00:32:34 legislation to continue doing it. Well remember it. Mental health is different
00:32:39 than addictions so obviously when somebody is posing a danger to
00:32:42 themselves under the Mental Health Act because they might be suicidal or they
00:32:46 again, might be, you know, another mental health condition, then that's different than somebody who
00:32:51 is in the throes of their addiction and causing harm to themselves. So it actually is two different
00:32:57 things. So I actually had the chance to ask NDP leader Rachel Notley about this policy. She said
00:33:03 that she's spoken to frontline workers, healthcare workers who don't agree with this policy. And I
00:33:08 did mention that at your announcement, you had a bunch of recovered addicts and those in recovery
00:33:12 saying this is really helpful for me. My family was able to find recovery for me because of
00:33:17 programs like this and they were very supportive of it and I mentioned that to her and she said
00:33:20 well we've heard from other people, other addicts, other frontline workers and said that the premier
00:33:25 hadn't actually consulted on this policy. What would be your response to that? Well I think as
00:33:30 you were there I mean we had a young girl who was 16 years old and she said she was in the throes of
00:33:34 her addiction at the age of 12. I am very certain that Albertans, in fact Canadians, would not
00:33:40 believe that giving that little girl drugs and a safe place to use those drugs is the correct 0.61
00:33:46 answer so getting her compassionate intervention as she indicated saved her life and she can now
00:33:52 go on to live a happy and healthy life again right um we have we have talked to uh you know
00:33:58 i i held the safe supply uh committee when i was the minister of mental health and addictions right
00:34:03 and we we had a lot of experts and when i mean experts and we're talking about experts from
00:34:09 from Stanford, from Yale, from Harvard,
00:34:11 experts all throughout Canada,
00:34:13 that we're very supportive of our policies,
00:34:15 and especially when it comes to compassion intervention.
00:34:18 Before I let you go, one final question.
00:34:21 I have to ask everyone, what's your prediction for tonight?
00:34:23 We know the polls are now closed.
00:34:25 What are you expecting the seat count to end up at?
00:34:27 Well, I thank you for the question.
00:34:28 I'm just gonna be cautiously optimistic.
00:34:30 Again, this is my fourth campaign.
00:34:33 You know, look, we don't know, we don't know,
00:34:36 but I will just say this,
00:34:37 I'm very proud of the campaign that the United Conservative Party ran.
00:34:41 I'm proud of our candidates.
00:34:42 I'm proud of the diverse team that we brought together.
00:34:46 And again, I'll be cautiously optimistic.
00:34:47 That was a good political answer.
00:34:49 I'll give you that.
00:34:50 That, once again, was Mike, the Minister for Public Safety and the UCP candidate for Calgary West.
00:34:57 Thank you so much.
00:34:57 Thank you.
00:34:58 Yeah, have a great night.
00:34:59 All right, we're going to head back over to Andrew in just a moment here.
00:35:02 We're hoping to get some results and super quickly to discuss those with you.
00:35:06 and I'm sure Andrew will have more to say about that.
00:35:13 Thank you for that.
00:35:14 Rachel, that was Mike Ellis, the UCP candidate for Calgary West
00:35:19 and I suspect when we look at the pretty surefire ones
00:35:22 he's probably going to be in MLA before long.
00:35:26 They were talking about the opioid drug file
00:35:29 which I think is a very important one
00:35:31 because this was an issue that Danielle 1.00
00:35:32 it's not usually the domain of conservative candidates
00:35:35 But Danielle Smith really ran full steam ahead into this. 1.00
00:35:38 She introduced this policy called the Compassionate Intervention Act,
00:35:42 which essentially allows mandatory treatment and enforces mandatory treatment on people.
00:35:48 This is something that I think is actually good policy,
00:35:52 according to a lot of people that were affected by drug addiction that we're talking about.
00:35:56 Is it good politics? Does this actually move votes?
00:36:00 I think so.
00:36:01 I think there's been a there's been a lot of work done on on not only on the mental health and opiate
00:36:06 crisis that's happening uh but as well in conjunction with the you know uh right supporting
00:36:11 our front lines getting more police officers on the ground so I think it's a it's a broader a
00:36:15 broader scope uh but you know Daniel Smith is sitting pretty good with that I think there's
00:36:21 been a lot of great work doing that's being done there by the UCP on that file of course her chief
00:36:26 of staff is a recovering addict and that is kind of like taking the ndp narrative and kind of like
00:36:32 what are you going to do with that right how do you counter that this is a guy who has lived
00:36:35 experience and um doing this alberta first uh program here and uh i i just think he's i think
00:36:44 i think she's got some really good guidance on that and and i think when you have addicts uh
00:36:48 developing the program i think i think we're on the right track with that and so i would agree i
00:36:53 I think that it's a tough one to campaign on, but I think we've reached a turning point in our city, certainly in Edmonton.
00:36:58 I'm seeing it in Calgary as somebody who lives outside of Calgary, not coming here every day.
00:37:02 But we have a serious problem on our streets, and it's getting dangerous to ride sea trains.
00:37:07 Something needs to be done.
00:37:08 I think we're at a bit of a breaking point with it, and people don't want to see.
00:37:12 I think people are starting to understand.
00:37:14 We want our children to be safe to walk down the streets.
00:37:16 We want seniors to be safe to ride on a sea train, and something has to be done.
00:37:20 And I think, I don't think it did any losses on that, on bringing that forward.
00:37:25 We had polls closed just six minutes ago.
00:37:28 This is the True North Alberta election night show,
00:37:31 joined by William Macbeth and from Alberta Proud, Lindsay Wilson,
00:37:35 and we have Rachel Emanuel in the wings here.
00:37:37 Just one update that came in.
00:37:39 This is from Elections Alberta.
00:37:41 There's a polling station in Rimby, Rocky Mountain House
00:37:46 that is open until 9.46 p.m.
00:37:50 And that riding, which is a fairly safe UCP riding, they say is not going to release results until that polling place is closed.
00:37:56 We're still trying to figure out why, but does this ring any bells?
00:38:00 I saw the notice earlier in the day.
00:38:01 If there was an issue with electricity or if something had happened that made the polling station difficult to access,
00:38:10 then they tend to add time at the end so that people aren't disenfranchised from the right to vote.
00:38:14 You know, we just talked about the interesting issue of the opioid crisis, and I actually think it's an issue where the UCB encircled the New Democrats, took over an issue that would typically be associated with on the left.
00:38:29 And they simply said, look, the evidence shows, and it's clear, that the approach that has been taken is just not working.
00:38:36 We are seeing escalating opioid deaths.
00:38:38 We are seeing escalating random acts of violence on our streets, people being stabbed, people being shot, people being attacked.
00:38:46 And so what we have done is not working.
00:38:48 It's time to try something new.
00:38:49 And the New Democrat response has been, no, we just have to do more of what we've been doing that hasn't worked,
00:38:56 and then it will start working for some reason.
00:38:58 Which I think, you know, rational Albertans said, no, it's the definition of humanity to keep doing the same thing and expect a different outcome.
00:39:05 We're going to do something different.
00:39:07 So I actually think it's going to come out really well for Danielle when she appears to be trying something new and not letting the situation in our big cities really continue to deteriorate like we've seen in other parts of North America.
00:39:19 Go ahead.
00:39:20 I was just going to say, I was just going to add to that.
00:39:22 I think further to what you're saying, William, is that the NDP has been pretty quiet.
00:39:27 They've been pretty quiet on a file that normally they'd be loud and proud about.
00:39:30 So I think that speaks volumes in itself that this new wave might be the right wave.
00:39:36 Just to keep people up to speed on this, we have 87 ridings in the province, 44 seats for a majority.
00:39:44 I've had a few questions from people I suspect are some of our non-Alberta viewers, which is fine.
00:39:48 We welcome you.
00:39:49 I'm a non-Alberta anchor, although my heart lies here and I keep wanting to stay here.
00:39:53 But the thing that I would point out is that people have asked why it's guaranteed to be a majority government.
00:39:58 So let's talk about why there are no other political parties in this province that are viable, which is a relatively new phenomenon.
00:40:04 I mean, I remember even last election, the Liberals, the Alberta Party, had a little bit of a thought that maybe they could be something.
00:40:10 Before then, they had a hefty amount of seats. Where have those parties gone?
00:40:14 I mean, I think that's such an interesting change in how elections happen in Alberta.
00:40:19 You go all the way back to 1993, that was Ralph Klein's first election when he became
00:40:23 premier of the PC party, and he was in a hotly contested election with the then-Alberta
00:40:29 Liberals.
00:40:30 And, well, you'll notice tonight that not only are the Alberta Liberals not going to
00:40:33 win any seats, they're not even running candidates in most ridings.
00:40:37 So they've gone from putting a scare into the PC government of 1993 to being no longer
00:40:43 a competitor.
00:40:44 Well, and they do, I mean, they're not competitive in Alberta generally, but the Liberals federally
00:40:48 have had seats here i mean it's but that has never translated in the last two cycles to any
00:40:53 provincial liberal anything well and if you you can even you only have to go back to 2015 and even
00:40:59 2014 where the democrats were still routinely only getting five or six percent of the vote in a lot
00:41:04 of parts of this this province if the change really happened in 2015 that was when the sea
00:41:10 changed and then from then you've seen the gradual consolidation both on the right and on the left
00:41:16 behind two large parties.
00:41:19 And, you know, Alberta, we're different than other parts of the country.
00:41:23 Our approach to problem-solving is often,
00:41:25 let's start a new political party.
00:41:26 That seems like the way we're ready to go.
00:41:28 But I think a lot of people have now said
00:41:30 it's just too difficult, too expensive, and too hard
00:41:33 to try and get a new party up and off the ground.
00:41:37 So in this case, you're going to see a lot of people just parking their votes,
00:41:40 even if they don't love the two main parties,
00:41:42 but we want those two main parties. 0.95
00:41:43 And the Alberta party, I mean, why is that not a thing anymore?
00:41:46 I mean in so much as it ever was
00:41:48 Well I think the Liberal Party is going to become
00:41:51 more of a thing actually if the NDP
00:41:53 do lose tonight I think we're going to see some interesting
00:41:55 movement on that front over the
00:41:57 next four years but I think
00:41:58 what it comes down to is what you're seeing
00:42:01 is a lot of these little uprising
00:42:02 candidates from other parties
00:42:04 there's a lot of negative campaigning
00:42:06 they're very much focused on the pandemic
00:42:08 they're very much focused on mandates and lockdowns
00:42:11 they're focused on vaccines
00:42:12 and honestly I think Albertans and Canadians
00:42:15 in general are just tired of it they don't want to talk about these things so i don't think the
00:42:18 content of what those candidates are talking about are resonating you see you even see how the ucp
00:42:23 you know they're talking about moving forward and rachel notley and the ndp they talk about moving
00:42:28 forward right we all need to move forward i think that's that's that's the bus that albertans are on
00:42:33 right now we don't want to go back to two years ago it was an awful time for everybody and yeah
00:42:38 yeah and i think we have to talk about the alternatives that have come up in the last
00:42:42 little few years, the Wild Rose Independence Party, the Alberta, the Pulaski Party, whatever
00:42:48 it's called. There was also the other Wild Rose Independence Party that, you know, started up by
00:42:53 Paul Hinman after he was ejected by the Wild Rose Independence. You've got three parties, which,
00:42:59 I mean, in Ontario, you had the same sort of dynamic in 2022. You had two parties that were
00:43:04 set up as protest parties that were not, they didn't make a dent electorally, but they had a
00:43:09 bit more staying power right now largely a lot of those spin-off right-wing parties seem to have
00:43:14 most of their people seem to be fine with danielle smith no i absolutely think you're right i mean
00:43:19 i have to make an alberta party joke i think it's obligatory which i have a very good new
00:43:23 new democrat friend and uh we were out someplace and we were talking about whatever the issue of
00:43:29 the day was and someone joked oh there's nothing that conservatives and new democrats agree on
00:43:33 and my friend said of course there is we both hate the alberta party so that's uh i think that
00:43:38 sums up a lot of people's feelings about about that but you're absolutely right that uh there
00:43:42 are a lot of other options i'm not sure how they're markedly different than a daniel smith-led
00:43:47 united conservative party uh and i think that's why they had such trouble trying to differentiate
00:43:53 themselves and get themselves up and going so uh and on the right what makes the liberal party
00:43:58 different than the green party different than the new democrat party under rachel montley i think
00:44:03 you have a hard time articulating those differences too yeah i think that's a fair point and i mean
00:44:07 I mean, a lot of the people that I met that were in the Alberta independence movement were big fans of Danielle Smith before she became the UCP leader.
00:44:14 And I think some of them might say, yeah, you know, we want to hold her to account.
00:44:16 But I think when push comes to shove and they're staring down Danielle Smith or Rachel Notley,
00:44:21 they're not going to do the Ken Boson cool thing of just staying home and not voting.
00:44:26 But there were even after the last leadership, I think some people that feared Danielle Smith would have a hard time mobilizing the UCP apparatus. 0.89
00:44:35 And she really didn't.
00:44:36 I mean, you know, even Rajan Sani, who was, I think, very much on a different wing of the field from Danielle Smith, you know, ended up running.
00:44:45 No, you make a really good point.
00:44:47 I do think, as Lindsay pointed out, appointing her opponents to high-profile cabinet positions was definitely a message that all types of Conservative are welcome in the united Conservative Party.
00:44:59 It's putting the word united back into that party name.
00:45:02 I think the real challenge for Daniel Smith is actually what happens after the election because holding on to the leadership of a conservative party in Alberta has become an increasingly challenging task.
00:45:15 As Jason Kenney could tell you.
00:45:17 As Jason Kenney can tell you, as Alison Redford can tell you, as Ed Stelmack can tell you, as Daniel Smith herself could tell you, this is not an easy job to keep this party together and going forward.
00:45:29 So I think she's going to have a lot of work ahead of her after this.
00:45:31 Even if she wins with a healthy margin, a healthy seat majority,
00:45:36 she will still have challenges in keeping this party united together behind her. 0.81
00:45:40 Do you see that? Do you see there as being a unity challenge?
00:45:42 Because usually victory is the antidote to disunity.
00:45:45 But do you see William Theory as holding?
00:45:48 Yeah, I see that. I think she does have a heck of a challenge on her hands. 1.00
00:45:51 I really do. I still see it.
00:45:53 I still see some of the more political operatives,
00:45:55 more of the behind-the-scenes people.
00:45:56 They just can't accept Daniel Smith.
00:45:59 and I don't know what that's about
00:46:02 I don't know, I mean we know this is politics
00:46:04 there's a lot of ego involved
00:46:06 there's a lot of history that people have
00:46:08 let's not forget Danielle Smith has been around
00:46:10 for a really long time right
00:46:11 she's been on the Alberta scene her whole life
00:46:13 so you know there's going to be
00:46:15 things that come up from your past
00:46:17 things from when she was a radio talk show host
00:46:19 you know different things like that
00:46:20 and there still is that kind of
00:46:22 I mean is it a united conservative party
00:46:24 some people still wonder that right
00:46:25 there are still the Wild Rosers
00:46:26 there's still the Peace Seers 1.00
00:46:28 I don't know. Let's hope everybody can just work together because I know this from talking to Alberta Proud people.
00:46:33 People are done with everybody being disenfranchised and with the infighting, it's really messy.
00:46:38 It's really ugly. It's not a good look for Conservatives.
00:46:42 And so we really actually do need to get united moving forward.
00:46:45 I don't want you to get too excited. We do have some results for you.
00:46:49 I'm going to be very careful about how I read this to you.
00:46:51 The UCP is leading in two ridings with 67% of the vote overall, with 67 votes cast.
00:47:00 So not the decisive majority territory necessarily, but we do have the Alberta Advantage.
00:47:06 The Advantage Party of Alberta has gotten one vote of those 67, so they can be on track.
00:47:10 Oh wait, something's happening here. I hear the cheering.
00:47:14 All right, Dan Williams is winning his riding with 12 votes, so good for Dan Williams.
00:47:19 It's all uphill for here.
00:47:20 But obviously, at this point in the night, we're not expecting to have anything too decisive.
00:47:24 You know, a lot of the map is already done.
00:47:26 Do we know really how many ridings are really in play here?
00:47:31 Well, from my understanding...
00:47:32 You don't need to give an exact number, just a ballpark.
00:47:34 Are we talking about...
00:47:35 Fifteen.
00:47:35 Fifteen, okay.
00:47:36 And about 14 of those, I think, would have to totally flip, which statistically, I don't know if it's really possible.
00:47:42 Anything can happen, and goodness knows that holsters have been very wrong in Alberta in the last eight years.
00:47:47 but that's my understanding yeah I mean you're looking at a pretty sizable chunk of Calgary
00:47:54 where the war is happening over who's going to control and a handful of ridings in different
00:47:59 parts of the province maybe one of the two Lethbridge seats maybe Banff Kananaskis maybe
00:48:05 Strathcona Short Park but really you're really looking at Calgary I have to be all due respect
00:48:11 to Dan Williams, if the UCP were not leading
00:48:14 in Peace River, this would be a very bad night for them.
00:48:17 Dan Williams is, I believe, the one who chugged the beer
00:48:20 in the legislature. I don't even know what he was celebrating, but he was
00:48:23 celebrating something. What was he celebrating, actually? I'm just going to go
00:48:26 and say, generically, freedom. Okay. What a way to win
00:48:29 rural Alberta. Well, Dan, you know what? The beer stunt won him Peace River,
00:48:33 so good for you, Dan. If you had teetotalers
00:48:35 in your riding, they didn't revolt against you, at least with the first 20 votes in.
00:48:38 And so let's talk a little bit of, you know, the dynamic here,
00:48:43 because obviously the UCP is coming in strong on this.
00:48:47 They have only one way to go, and that's essentially down.
00:48:49 There's not a single NDP-held riding I'm seeing that the UCP is on track to even maybe pick up.
00:48:55 But at the same point, to what you were saying, Lindsay,
00:48:58 a lot has to really go right for the NDP tonight to win.
00:49:02 They have to, they can't miss.
00:49:04 Yeah, and if you looked at some of Daniel Smith's social media feed over the last couple weeks,
00:49:08 she's filling rooms in areas that maybe didn't think she would be filling rooms like she's 1.00
00:49:12 filling rooms in calgary so i don't think i don't see how it's possible at this point but
00:49:17 it's an election anything can happen no i mean i i would say although we've had a lot of fun
00:49:24 on social media about how many people can fit in a room uh you got claims that that a thousand
00:49:30 people in a room that has a published seat count or room count that's only old 400 so you have to
00:49:37 take all of it with a grain of salt. That being said, Daniel Smith does have an uphill battle to
00:49:40 try and take new seats. The USDP did really well in the last election. They won a huge number of
00:49:47 seats. It was always going to be very hard for them to pick up new ones. I think they're kind
00:49:52 of at their high watermark right now. Yeah, and I think that we should talk a little bit about,
00:49:58 and we'll probably get to this later on in the evening, we should talk a little bit about
00:50:01 the Calgary campaign dynamic. Because I know for a lot of candidates, like Daniel Smith was there
00:50:06 standing side by side with them at all of these campaign stops because as we were talking about
00:50:10 she really didn't leave the city of Calgary as much as you might in a normal campaign and I
00:50:15 think to compare it to the last federal election you know a lot of people were frustrated there
00:50:18 and Erin O'Toole was just camped out in Ottawa in this case it wasn't for you know any reasons 0.98
00:50:23 except for this was the battleground this is where Danielle Smith needed to win so the UCP 1.00
00:50:29 is leading in Calgary Buffalo now again I don't know how many votes are in but explain this is
00:50:34 tougher riding for the ucp that's a very tough writing for the ucp i'm just passing on what
00:50:39 one of my colleagues said maybe it's like three votes to two or something i should say i live in
00:50:42 calgary buffalo and uh well i would love nothing more than to see it go conservative blue in this
00:50:49 election hey hold up hold up they're leaning one to zero so our colleague let us astray on this one
00:50:55 i was about to say i have a hard time seeing the ndp's joe cc being defeated all right buffalo
00:51:02 I think he's probably safe there.
00:51:03 Well, you know what?
00:51:04 If that one vote was the one.
00:51:06 We're going to go over to Rachel Emanuel, who's standing by with Jason Leder here on the Alberta Election Night Results Show for True North.
00:51:13 Here's Rachel. 0.98
00:51:16 I'm here with Jason Leder, a Conservative strategist with Enterprise Canada.
00:51:20 Jason, you were just telling me that you were heavily involved in the debate prep.
00:51:24 We were just talking about how well that went over.
00:51:26 What did you do to make Danielle so well prepped? 0.99
00:51:28 we know she's already a really well-spoken and well-rehearsed because she spent so much time on
00:51:32 the radio but she really did exactly what she needed to do during that debate by not getting
00:51:36 off message and staying really positive so maybe you can explain a little bit to our audience what
00:51:40 that debate prep looks like yeah it's it's it's fun you know like it's um it's it's a weird process
00:51:44 you go through two or three days of this where you sort of bat around ideas on what's the best
00:51:48 way but the big thing is to get the big question right and we wanted to do three things in the
00:51:52 debate we want to talk about the economy we want to talk about rachel um not least sort of threatened
00:51:56 38 tax hike and we want to talk about a record and we wanted to do it in a way that was like
00:52:00 really friendly right we expected rachel notley to be quite frankly not be able to hide her to 0.99
00:52:05 sustain her for for me and we try to use that against her so we try to be the friendliest
00:52:09 candidate the most prepared candidate and quite frankly the most optimistic and positive candidate
00:52:13 as well and when we talk about you know your work to discuss jobs in the economy ucp insiders i've
00:52:18 spoken to have said they were really hoping that that would be the ballot box question of the
00:52:22 election do you agree was jobs in the economy the ballot box question of this election or was
00:52:26 it more about trust in a leader I think it was first of all it was both there
00:52:29 was two things that the NDP really wanted to do the trust and leader I
00:52:32 think that was a bit of a mistake by the way they didn't count on us being able
00:52:34 to claw that back to sort of a 50-50 proposition on the two women and on the 0.88
00:52:39 economy I mean that we were sort of one that that side of the campaign for sure
00:52:43 and the NDP gas increase that they promised in the middle of the campaign
00:52:47 I think was a big mistake I think it allowed us to focus right back on the
00:52:51 economy where we wanted to be and it provided a real-world risk to people you
00:52:54 You know, if you're going to voting and you're thinking, well, you know, is the oil sands going to be okay?
00:52:57 Is the economy in Calgary going to be okay?
00:52:59 Is the economy in Edmonton going to be okay?
00:53:00 It gave you something to focus on, which was this threatened tax hike, which has real impacts on real people.
00:53:05 Yeah, that tax hike was surprising.
00:53:06 The NDP really ran as moderates during that, during this campaign.
00:53:10 Except for that tax hike, I think everyone was like, oh, yes, this is what an NDP government means.
00:53:14 So certainly it was a good opportunity for people to sort of hone in.
00:53:17 When we talk about a defying moment of the election campaign, one thing I heard from a lot of conservatives is,
00:53:22 isn't like he's doing very much people i spoke to said they were trying not to over promise
00:53:28 do you think that this was actually a benefit for the campaign that they didn't have too many
00:53:32 announcements or do you think that maybe they could have done a little bit more i don't think
00:53:35 it needed more announcements election campaigns have really changed they're about values and
00:53:39 they're about big picture directional stuff and the question is like you know if we would have
00:53:43 done another announcement on you know skills training or whatever it is like you know all
00:53:46 the various things that you can do the baubles that you can promise to people i don't think it
00:53:49 really punches through anymore and i think people only hear the biggest possible things and what we
00:53:53 wanted them to hear over the last couple remember what it was like to have rachel notley as premier
00:53:57 that wasn't so hot and if you want to keep this economy going you should probably vote ucp and
00:54:02 danielle smith that's all we really wanted them to hear over the last few weeks and i think we
00:54:05 felt we feel pretty good about getting that message out okay just my last question for you here we
00:54:09 have a few polls reporting what is your election prediction for tonight what do you think the seat
00:54:15 count is going to be you have to give me an exact answer none of this copping out about how the
00:54:19 campaign was strong plus or minus 50 i think is probably a reasonable uh you know that's what
00:54:23 we're hoping for obviously i mean it's gonna be a close election we're hoping we're hoping to sort
00:54:28 of get somewhere near that 50 mark for sure that would be a real nice night for us absolutely well
00:54:32 some polls are now reporting so we're gonna go to them now and get a little bit of tape again that
00:54:36 was jason leader a conservative strategist with enterprise canada thanks so much for your time
00:54:40 today yeah all right back to you guys over
00:54:42 well thank you for that rachel as you can hear a little bit of excitement now i don't want to be
00:54:52 the wet blanket but it's important to put in context here we have very very small numbers
00:54:57 of votes in right now 178 votes cast province wide now of those the ucp is leading in riding
00:55:05 is leading in zero riding so uh still i get why everyone early in the night wants to uh
00:55:12 have a bit of a celebration here uh the one thing i will say i love about provincial elections is
00:55:16 you don't play the time zone game like you do in federal elections where you just like you know
00:55:20 just this wave of red and then a wave of blue so uh at this point though i mean the rural we know
00:55:26 it's going to go where it's going to go edmonton a couple of question marks um are you from even the
00:55:32 early sort of feedback you're seeing here re-evaluating your predictions at all because
00:55:37 i haven't gotten you guys to get the numbers yet you're going to lock in your numbers now how many
00:55:41 seats you think the ucp and the ndp are going to get okay i've switched okay i think 51 for ucp okay
00:55:48 uh i said 50 to 37 okay for the ucp okay does that math add up 50 to 37 yeah okay there you go
00:55:59 I thought you said 51.
00:56:00 No, that was 51.
00:56:01 No, 51 to 21.
00:56:03 So I was the pessimist because I said 48, and you did, or you went up.
00:56:07 I did, no, I've gone up.
00:56:09 So Dan Williams getting Peace River has, like, just given you a bout of confidence.
00:56:12 I heard a little bit of booing.
00:56:18 I couldn't tell who was booing,
00:56:19 but I noticed that Astrid in Calgary Buffalo is still holding her 1-0 lead,
00:56:23 so we'll see how things go there.
00:56:26 We are live here.
00:56:28 This is True North.
00:56:28 I'm Andrew Lawton, joined by Alberta proud Lindsay Wilson and True North's very own William Macbeth.
00:56:33 We also have Rachel Emanuel standing by, talking to all sorts of very important and influential people in the wings,
00:56:39 and we're going to throw to that as the evening progresses.
00:56:42 But let's first go to a discussion that Rachel had with a number of people outside the polling stations in Alberta earlier today.
00:56:51 She was around Calgary, getting a sense of how people are voting, what they're thinking.
00:56:55 Let's roll that clip now. 0.95
00:56:58 Hey guys, it's Rachel Emanuel with True North. I'm here in Calgary, Acadia. That's Tyler Shandro's
00:57:06 rioting. He was the Justice Minister under former Premier Jason Kenney and under Danielle Smith.
00:57:11 This is a toss-up rioting. We're not sure which way it's going to go tonight. So I'm out here
00:57:15 talking to some voters to see which way they voted today and what they think is going to happen
00:57:20 later this evening. Stay tuned. So I'm here with Al. What did you think of the election campaign?
00:57:25 This is the 10th one I've seen. It's pretty much like all the previous ones.
00:57:31 Are you comfortable sharing with us who you decided to vote for today?
00:57:34 Yeah, I went with the NDP.
00:57:36 Was there a deciding issue that caused you to vote for the NDP or are you just more left-leaning typically?
00:57:42 Not left-leaning typically. It's just the UCP candidate. I really dislike him, this Chandra guy. 1.00
00:57:50 So you dislike Tyler Chandra. What do you think about Danielle Smith? 0.98
00:57:54 Do you think that she's crazy, sort of as the media and maybe the NDP had portrayed her,
00:57:59 or you're just indifferent to her?
00:58:01 No, I think she's a very controversial figure.
00:58:05 You know, all the past things that she said and she's denying now,
00:58:08 saying I'm a different person.
00:58:10 I don't quite believe that.
00:58:12 So what did you think of the election campaign?
00:58:14 Did you think that the parties had a strong showing?
00:58:18 Yes, you know, the main two, right?
00:58:20 You don't hear much of the others, so it's going to be close.
00:58:24 Are you comfortable telling us who you voted for today?
00:58:27 It was United Conservative Party.
00:58:30 You voted for Tyler Shandro. And what sold your vote on him?
00:58:32 My parents have always been, you know, Conservative Party, so I'm holding that line.
00:58:39 So this is a toss-up riding. It's going to be super close in this riding especially.
00:58:43 How likely do you think it is that Shandro's going to pull out a win today?
00:58:46 It's going to be really close, but I think they'll barely make it.
00:58:51 So I'm here with Janice. Janice, what did you think of the election campaign?
00:58:56 Well, it was kind of depressing.
00:58:59 What made it depressing?
00:59:01 It was just sort of all about personalities and not about issues.
00:59:07 And sort of a popularity contest.
00:59:11 So, yeah, just that's about all I have to say about it.
00:59:16 Are you comfortable sharing with us who you decided to cast your ballot for today?
00:59:20 Not really.
00:59:22 Do you have any predictions about who's going to win the election tonight?
00:59:25 No, I think it's very close.
00:59:27 So I'm here with Casey's. Casey's, what did you think of the election campaign?
00:59:31 Was there one party that you were sold on?
00:59:34 Nope. The election campaign this year was, I felt, very targeted towards who's saying what and who's not doing what they said.
00:59:43 And I honestly would prefer to hear a lot more about the other parties and what they're doing and how everyone can work collectively in order to support the humans that are outside of the government, because that's important.
00:59:59 Casey, are you comfortable sharing with us who you decided to cast your vote for today?
01:00:03 Definitely not NDP.
01:00:05 Okay, so I'm here with Trish. Trish, what did you think about the election campaign?
01:00:09 Did you think that it was interesting, exciting? Did it catch your attention?
01:00:14 It did catch my attention. It did have some interesting issues and yeah, but I knew I was
01:00:22 going to vote for right from the get-go, so I wasn't swayed either way. And what were some of
01:00:27 the important issues that you think were discussed during the election campaign?
01:00:31 Definitely health care and sovereignty and education. Now those are definitely big ones
01:00:38 during the campaign. Are you comfortable sharing with us who you decided to cast your ballot for
01:00:42 today? Sure, NDP. And what did you think about Danielle Smith as a leader of the United 0.98
01:00:48 Conservative Party? Obviously, there was a lot of attacks against her character. Did you think
01:00:51 that those attacks were credible? Were you concerned about, you know, another tenure with
01:00:55 Smith as the Premier? Well, they appeared. They appeared to lead me to think that she's
01:01:02 untrustworthy, but I don't know. I don't know. We'll see what, if she becomes Premier, we'll see 0.93
01:01:06 what happens. So I'm here with Grant. Grant, what did you think of the election campaign?
01:01:12 Well, dirty was the beginning to the end. We'll see what happens now that we voted. But overall,
01:01:21 I wasn't impressed with how the mudslinging started because basically if we can't talk 1.00
01:01:26 two sides and just talk cleanly and plainly, then what's the use?
01:01:31 Do you mind sharing with us who you voted for today?
01:01:34 Sure. UPCs.
01:01:35 so this is a really close riding you've obviously cast your vote for Tyler
01:01:39 Shandro as I mentioned it's it's still toss up we're not sure which way it's
01:01:42 gonna go tonight what are your inclinations Oh not Lee wins I'm moving
01:01:47 back to Saskatchewan but this one well Tyler Shandro I think he's done well in
01:01:55 his post so far so it's one of those things where now when you take a look at
01:02:02 politics and how you can't really trust the information you're getting anymore because we
01:02:07 don't have a media source anymore other than maybe you guys but with the mainstream media the way
01:02:14 that they cover up things and they give only the message they want to give for us to get the
01:02:19 information unless you want to go and do a whole horde of public information requests and try to
01:02:25 go through that and figure things out none of us are really qualified so I'm just hoping that
01:02:31 the next four years whoever gets in power doesn't kill us hey guys it's rachel emmanuel with true
01:02:37 north i'm here in calgary acadia in calgary acadia which is tyler shandro's riding now
01:02:47 this was your one to watch so uh you are the coo so i don't know if you were the one that made 0.60
01:02:50 rachel do her exit polls there and that's why you're watching it so closely but why is that 0.89
01:02:55 riding a relevant one for people just tuning in now uh i mean i think it was absolutely one that
01:03:00 the new democrats thought they would be competitive in uh their incumbent mla uh has had a bit of a
01:03:06 bumpy time on some issues uh you know he was obviously minister of health uh for the beginning
01:03:10 part of the covet 19 pandemic and so i i would say that was definitely one where the new democrats
01:03:18 thought he would be vulnerable and it's also in the part of that belt of riding where the
01:03:23 new democrats have to start winning if they're going to win this election in in the all the
01:03:27 the things that need to go right for them, that's right in that wheelhouse, Lindsay.
01:03:31 Yeah, I would agree with that. So, interesting to see that, for sure.
01:03:35 Yeah, and Tyler Chandro, I mean, he was like a very prominent cabinet minister in the Kenney government.
01:03:41 He was ultimately the fall guy on the health file, but then was given a boost back up by Danielle.
01:03:47 So, quite an endorsement for someone that she probably doesn't see eye to eye on, on some of the key issues, at least.
01:03:52 Well, and of course, Tyler Shandro, as Minister of Justice, is the purported recipient of
01:03:58 the unfair influence that the Premier may or may not have exerted over deferring or
01:04:06 rejecting COVID-related prosecutions.
01:04:08 All of that being said, I feel that the relationship between the Premier and Tyler, I think, is
01:04:15 quite good.
01:04:16 saw Stephen Harper endorse Tyler Sandro in the final days of this campaign, which I think
01:04:23 is a powerful message of support for both Tyler and the United Conservative Party as
01:04:30 a whole.
01:04:31 Yeah, let's talk a little bit about Stephen Harper's endorsement, because he gave one
01:04:34 earlier on that seemed a little bit lukewarm and generic, and then he gave a much stronger
01:04:39 one this week.
01:04:40 And then I was scrolling through Instagram yesterday, and I saw him out there doing personalized
01:04:44 endorsements of individual candidates.
01:04:46 I saw him with Rebecca Schultz
01:04:48 and other Calgary candidates. And Stephen Harper
01:04:50 is a guy who has not really
01:04:52 waded into a lot of
01:04:54 political fights since he left
01:04:56 office. So what do you take from that?
01:04:58 I think how people
01:05:00 should read into that, as well,
01:05:02 Pierre Polyeva came out this week with his official endorsement
01:05:04 of Premier Smith as well, but I think
01:05:06 the best way for people to read into that is that
01:05:08 Stephen Harper
01:05:10 is trying to send a message
01:05:12 to Albertans that this is a really important election you've got two very very different
01:05:16 governments and I think the message that comes with Stephen Harper's endorsement is if you care
01:05:21 about Alberta and you care about standing up for Alberta I believe that we need to give the UCP
01:05:26 four more years this is the only way that we can really take down Justin Trudeau and
01:05:31 and we need to move in this direction so I think that's that's the powerful message with that
01:05:36 we have a few more results for you here we've got more than the 67 votes we had earlier
01:05:41 right now the total vote count that we have courtesy of elections alberta is 2500 votes
01:05:49 cast that's province wide of those five people declined their ballot which is like a very wonky
01:05:54 political thing that if we really get bored later we'll explain to you and of these we have the
01:05:59 ucp leading in 17 and ndp leading in four when we come back in a couple of moments we'll do the
01:06:05 breakdown of which of those are which but right now rachel emmanuel is staying with brad
01:06:10 i'm here with brad tenet he is a senior campaign strategist with wellington advocacy brad you have
01:06:21 been poking fun at the mainstream media online because they seem so eager to report that all
01:06:25 these lifetime conservatives are quote unquote lending their vote to the ndp for the first time
01:06:31 when we know in fact that's not the case tell me a little bit about what's going on here yeah i guess
01:06:36 more than anything you were seeing that the the there were these activists and former mlas that
01:06:41 were repeating the exact same thing they did four years ago when the ndp lost that election by trying
01:06:46 to pretend to be conservative switching to the ndp when really they were against the ucp ever
01:06:50 since it started sometimes satire can be fun in the hectic bit of a campaign so sort of poked fun
01:06:57 at that and uh said i would be a lifetime new democrat uh looking to vote for ucp the first
01:07:02 time so had some fun and and tell me did anyone actually decide to write about your your story
01:07:08 your transition now lending the vote to the ucp for the first time i think a couple caught the uh
01:07:13 joke of it and kind of saw the meltdown funny but no no i wasn't i wasn't reached out for any
01:07:18 exclusive stories so that's disappointing a missed opportunity to be sure and there once again we see
01:07:24 the incredible bias of the legacy media so one of the other really interesting things that you've
01:07:29 been working on during this campaign is the get out the boat in calgary acadia we've discussed
01:07:34 tonight how that is a riding to watch that is tyler chandro's riding tell me a little bit about
01:07:39 what you're expecting to see in that riding tonight yeah riding to watch uh really important
01:07:43 riding i think one that's going to be close and one with the great incumbents so uh we were
01:07:47 giving her all their knocking doors would like to apologize to anybody in calgary acadia we
01:07:51 annoyed a little bit too much but trying to get out of the boat we can i think it's going to be
01:07:56 close but i think uh it's looking good for us you know we saw improvement over the last few weeks
01:08:01 we saw danielle's debate performance really reflect well and we saw the candidate meeting
01:08:05 a lot of people which which worked out really well for us so it's exciting we're to see where
01:08:09 it goes but pretty excited with where we're at as of tonight sure and when we talk about danielle's
01:08:14 debate performance that's something we've talked about a lot on this show tonight a lot on my
01:08:17 podcast throughout the weeks and a lot of people have said that was really a turning point in the
01:08:22 the campaign did you notice that at the doors after the debate maybe the doors warmed a little
01:08:25 bit when people you know heard her name they had a more positive impression of her following her
01:08:29 quite excellent debate performance yeah absolutely i think i think at the start of this the ndp
01:08:34 really doubled and tripled down on negative attack ads they were running and special interest groups
01:08:39 were running millions of dollars worth of attack ads attacking danielle um and it was really all
01:08:43 the ndp had out of the gate was launch volleys of attacks against danielle that led to the debate 1.00
01:08:48 where Rachel Notley had to make her case, and I think she failed at that,
01:08:51 and I think Danielle made hers just fine. 0.97
01:08:53 So after that, I think the NDP negativity kind of waned off,
01:08:58 and at the same time, people had an open eye to conservative ideas
01:09:02 and saw policy and saw a platform they liked.
01:09:05 So, you know, I think that was a bit of the catalyst for the turning point,
01:09:08 but I think a lot built into it.
01:09:11 Sure, and just my last question for you here before we head back to the panel,
01:09:14 I have to ask everyone this.
01:09:16 What is your estimated C count?
01:09:18 Where do you think we're going to end up tonight?
01:09:19 Oh, man.
01:09:20 87 UCP, zero NDP.
01:09:22 Oh, wow.
01:09:23 Very positive.
01:09:23 And I absolutely believe that to be the case.
01:09:25 All right.
01:09:25 Thank you so much, Brad.
01:09:27 Yeah.
01:09:27 All right.
01:09:27 Back to you, Andrew.
01:09:32 This party needs to start appealing to younger voters.
01:09:34 Sorry.
01:09:35 We just about had a lasagna tray cameo there walking in front of Rachel Emanuel and Brad 0.98
01:09:40 Tennant.
01:09:40 So if you were tuning in for the lasagna tray guy, we successfully chased him away.
01:09:44 So he'll be in for our next update in a little while.
01:09:47 Thank you very much for that, Rachel, and thank you, Brad Tennant.
01:09:51 We are just giving you the latest numbers here on the True North Alberta Election Night Show.
01:09:56 7,646 votes cast.
01:09:59 Of those, we have the UCP leading in 34 and the NDP leading in 12.
01:10:05 Now, I've just basically on my maps have zoomed in on Calgary
01:10:09 because that's really the only area that really matters
01:10:12 with the exception of a couple of outlying seats that we're looking at.
01:10:15 But of the seats in Calgary from which there are numbers available,
01:10:19 we're talking about small numbers,
01:10:21 but the UCP is in the lead in every single one of them.
01:10:23 And again, I cannot stress enough,
01:10:24 do not go to bed now saying like Andrew Lawton told you Calgary was winning,
01:10:28 like the people that were against Brexit that went to bed thinking they had won.
01:10:31 It's not that, I'm just saying that of the ones that are in,
01:10:34 the NDP are not faring as well so far.
01:10:36 And even up in Edmonton, the UCP are in the lead in a couple here.
01:10:40 But let's discuss why Calgary is the battleground,
01:10:46 because this is a city that has been through a lot in the last few years.
01:10:49 We know, I mean, True North did a documentary about Calgary and crisis.
01:10:53 And even when you walk around now, downtown come back a little bit,
01:10:56 but it's still not like the Calgary of its glory days.
01:10:59 So what is the profile of Calgary now, electorally and just demographically?
01:11:05 Well, I think that what you're seeing is if the UCP is starting to show early success tonight,
01:11:09 in some of these Calgary battlegrounds.
01:11:12 I think what you're seeing is that you've seen a switch in voters
01:11:14 where they're starting to care more about the opiate crisis,
01:11:18 about crime and public safety.
01:11:20 I think that has become, I was talking about that about a month ago,
01:11:22 I said that's going to become really pertinent these last couple weeks
01:11:25 as we head into election day.
01:11:28 And I think you're starting to see that people,
01:11:31 they don't like the direction that Calgary's moving in,
01:11:33 they don't like all the violent crime,
01:11:34 and same with Edmonton, of course.
01:11:36 We have homeless encampments, our streets aren't safe, 1.00
01:11:39 our public transit isn't safe our offices are getting shot and killed that's not okay
01:11:44 and i think i think we're starting to see a bit of a momentum and if we're seeing these
01:11:49 some of these swing riding shift that way i think that that has that is winning over
01:11:53 any of the ndp's messaging on health care because it fact is you guys at the end of the day daniel
01:11:59 smith made some really big changes with ahs and the ahs's own data is showing that red alerts are
01:12:07 are pretty much no longer. EMS wait times are less, surgery backlog is getting alleviated.
01:12:14 That's a lot of positive change in six short months and maybe people are thinking well maybe
01:12:19 maybe the UCP is the party to do more on the health care file. Maybe there's, I think that's
01:12:25 enough for grabs. Yeah we have a few more numbers in here. The NDP leading in a couple of the downtown 0.59
01:12:31 calgary ridings uh downtown ish you know calgary climb calgary mountain view uh calgary buffalo
01:12:37 as well and just heading up to edmonton here uh we have in this riding a lead i don't believe
01:12:44 is real so i'm not even going to read that one uh but we do have in strathcona sherwood park the ndp
01:12:49 are uh leading right now uh we have in a lot of the edmonton ridings no surprise there
01:12:54 um in edmonton southwest nothing in yet and that was the one i picked on my list
01:12:59 watch, which was Casey Maddew. So right now the total standing is 42 to 22, and the race is to 44.
01:13:08 So we're getting close if these things hold.
01:13:11 No, you're absolutely right. I mean, well, obviously, results can and will change as more polls start reporting.
01:13:18 And particularly, you know, if one party is doing better, say, in the advanced polls than another,
01:13:25 then that could really make a big difference when those polls report.
01:13:28 So, all of that being said, you definitely want to be the party that's leading in more seats than fewer.
01:13:35 And the fact that they're doing that well in Calgary, I'm sure, is very encouraging to the United Conservative Party.
01:13:41 I'm sure, you know, wherever the Premier and her core team are, hold up in some secure room watching these just as we are.
01:13:49 They will be cheering to see the fact that they're leading in so many Calgary ridings.
01:13:52 because, you know, not to rain on the parade of my dear Edmonton family and friends
01:13:58 or even the rest of the province, this was an election above Calgary,
01:14:01 and therefore that's why we're watching this city so closely.
01:14:05 Yeah. Do you see there as being a popular vote issue this election
01:14:08 where the popular vote could go one way and the election could go another way?
01:14:12 Because this is, at the federal level, this has become the story of the last two.
01:14:16 I don't think so. I can't imagine a case where that would happen here in Alberta.
01:14:22 I mean, technically, there are rural ridings of smaller numbers of voters in them than some of the city ones.
01:14:30 That being said, I don't think the discrepancy is so huge that it would ever result in a case where you would see the popular vote going to a party that didn't win the most seats.
01:14:39 I only ask because right now, of the votes that are in, which is, again, 9,900, not huge numbers here,
01:14:44 The NDP is leading in the popular vote, 5,000 to 4,500, but the UCP leading in seats, 42 to 22.
01:14:52 So I was just geeking out on scenarios there.
01:14:55 Let's go in a different direction with this, Lindsay, because obviously Alberta Proud has been connecting with people, I mean, for many years, not just for this campaign.
01:15:04 Have the issues changed in the last few years beyond COVID?
01:15:09 Have they changed or has it always really been about getting Ottawa off our backs, getting the oil out of the ground and these core Alberta issues?
01:15:17 Well, we're into, what, year eight of Justin Trudeau's government.
01:15:23 Albertans are frustrated.
01:15:24 I think they're feeling more and more isolated.
01:15:26 They feel like they don't have a voice.
01:15:28 They feel like, how does this guy keep getting in?
01:15:31 How does this keep happening?
01:15:32 So, unfortunately, through the pandemic, through more of this creation of, I don't know, I'd say U.S.-style politics,
01:15:37 more of an us versus them and more of the focus on the two parties right and less of
01:15:41 these other fledgling parties uh i think i think yeah i think i i i definitely think so yeah some
01:15:49 of our uh some of the people around here i think are seeing the 47 on the screen now and thinking
01:15:54 they've already won it's not that simple is it william no no exactly you know if you think about
01:15:58 the problems with two million people even more possibly voting in this election you you can't
01:16:03 really get that excited when you've only got 10 000 votes in that's you know and i'm the optimist
01:16:08 of the bunch but even i wouldn't be popping champagne parts quite yet i need a few more
01:16:13 results so let's talk a little bit about the theater of this all because we know that again
01:16:18 we're talking about two leaders that are within uh the likelihood of potentially winning tonight
01:16:23 one more likely than others danielle smith and and rachel notley danielle smith is of course
01:16:28 going to be speaking here one way or another tonight uh not going to make an appearance
01:16:32 until we know what's happening so how were you feeling in 2012 you and the leader and all the
01:16:39 other people on the team I mean I will definitely say that we had probably been lulled into a false
01:16:45 sense of security by how many positive polls we had in the first three weeks of the campaign
01:16:50 you know I think we felt that we were really on top of a sea change in Alberta and that we were
01:16:58 going to put an end to a dynastic government. And it was very exciting. Of course, as we
01:17:02 all know, the wheels started to come off the bus in the final week. And anybody who knows
01:17:08 the bus will get the reference. But, you know, when we were sitting in private, it was a
01:17:16 painful reality to realize that we weren't winning and we were going to form an opposition.
01:17:21 We were going to form a smaller opposition than we would have hoped for, 17 seats. And
01:17:26 And it is very difficult because, you know, you go in and you give it your best
01:17:31 and you really want the best to happen and you really are optimistic.
01:17:34 You think, you know, even if not every poll says it, in your heart you think,
01:17:38 oh, I think we've got this.
01:17:40 So it's a rude and harsh awakening when it turns out, no, you don't have it
01:17:44 and that Albertans have made a different choice.
01:17:46 Do you think, Lindsay, that the UCP has been running a fairly confident campaign this time?
01:17:50 Do you think they've taken an eventual win for granted?
01:17:53 I don't know if they've taken it for granted.
01:17:55 I think that they simplified their campaign.
01:17:57 So I think in this last month, since the rip was dropped,
01:17:59 they stopped talking about some of the more contentious things
01:18:02 like the Sovereignty Act, and they really focused on cutting taxes,
01:18:05 making life more affordable for Albertans,
01:18:08 and they just really went gung-ho with that.
01:18:11 And I think that that's probably what's working for them,
01:18:14 is not appealing so much to some of the more outlying issues
01:18:19 that are a little bit more divisive among Conservatives.
01:18:22 They just focused on making life more in Florida, standing up to just transition,
01:18:27 standing up for our energy sector, keeping taxes low,
01:18:31 putting more money back in the pockets of Alberta families.
01:18:33 And I think that that's the messaging that's worked for them.
01:18:36 You bring up the oil and gas sector.
01:18:37 We haven't talked about it a huge amount tonight.
01:18:39 I think it's a good opportunity now because the NDP has to masquerade
01:18:43 as this very pro-energy, pro-oil party.
01:18:47 But as we saw from, you know, Rachel Notley 1.0,
01:18:49 even if there are some people in that party that are a bit more sympathetic to the sector
01:18:54 you also have the you know radical environmentalist anti-oil kooks that you'd expect
01:18:58 in an NDP have they done a good job at sidelining those people this election I don't know there's
01:19:04 there's a lot of what I would define as very eco-radical candidates that are running on some
01:19:10 of these NDP tickets and you know they've come out on Twitter and I think the UCB war rooms
01:19:15 definitely put a lot of highlight around that a lot of like the defund the police rhetoric
01:19:19 and a lot of um you know we just had one of the candidates NDP candidates from Livingston
01:19:24 Kevin Van Tegam coming out you know quotes from his own book a couple of years ago saying oil 0.96
01:19:29 sucks and we're the suckers and comparing uh oil uh oil production to slavery I mean these are 0.96
01:19:35 really ludicrous claims these are very dangerous claims and when you have silence from the Notley 0.99
01:19:40 camp on uh just transition and for people just tuning in now if you're aware the just transition
01:19:45 is the plan under the Trudeau Liberals to essentially get rid of our oil and gas jobs
01:19:50 in favor of green energy jobs.
01:19:52 And when you're hearing silence on that, I think people realize that we need a thriving
01:19:56 energy sector.
01:19:57 We need to do it here.
01:19:58 We have the opportunity to provide the best, some of the cleanest oil and gas, and the
01:20:03 world's going to need more of what we have, not less.
01:20:05 So I think that that's starting to hit home with people.
01:20:07 You know, the oil and gas question is very interesting.
01:20:11 When Premier Notley became premier in 2015, it coincided with a very difficult time in the energy sector.
01:20:19 Energy prices were absolutely at some of their lowest levels.
01:20:25 Alberta faced really tough economic times.
01:20:29 I don't think you can hold Rachel Notley 100% responsible for all of that thing.
01:20:34 I do think her government made some serious mistakes.
01:20:38 I think they meddled in the electricity sector, and as a result, Albertans pay higher prices for power bills.
01:20:46 I think they scared away some investment.
01:20:49 People thought, I'm not sure Alberta is going to be a friendly place to do business,
01:20:53 and we don't know if we want to commit to a project that could take 15 or 20 years to see profitability
01:20:59 if we're going to end up with uncertainty.
01:21:01 So those are things that I think Premier Notley did have to take responsibility for.
01:21:05 And there's also a reason, as Lindsay pointed out, why you're seeing so much of Rachel, so little of every other New Democrat in this province.
01:21:16 And it's because Rachel Notley is the polished, professional, reasonable face of New Democrats.
01:21:22 You know, she's the one who can say, I supported getting a pipeline built to tidewater, the first pipeline in X number of years.
01:21:29 And she said, look, I stood shoulder to shoulder with Alberta's energy sector.
01:21:33 But you don't have to scratch the surface very far to find a lot of people who are not at all supportive of Alberta's energy sector.
01:21:40 Yeah, because those people don't really have another political home.
01:21:42 I mean, the only place they're going to find any potential welcoming home is the NDP.
01:21:48 So it's a party that has to keep the radicals very happy.
01:21:52 Yeah, absolutely.
01:21:54 I don't know.
01:21:54 It's very dangerous when you're seeing such extremism within a party.
01:21:57 It makes you wonder, do these people even like Alberta?
01:22:01 Do they even like us?
01:22:02 if you hate our energy sector so much and do you even like us yeah you may have to buy your own
01:22:08 health care if Alberta doesn't have the oil and gas revenue coming in if you're just tuning in
01:22:13 this is the true north live election night results show for Alberta the election has been a very I'd
01:22:19 say in some ways uneventful campaign but the polls closed 51 minutes ago we are slowly but surely
01:22:25 bringing you the results as they come in right now the ucp is leading 43 to 23 although the
01:22:33 caveat there that i have to keep telling you is that's with about 15 000 votes cast across a
01:22:38 province with 2.8 million registered voters so a drop in the bucket but still uh you hear the
01:22:43 cheers going up periodically behind us and interestingly enough i i'm going back again
01:22:49 to the Calgary breakdown specifically and in Calgary we have the NDP gaining in a lot of those
01:23:00 poor territories very narrow margins I mean one of them is the NDP leading in Calgary West with
01:23:05 one poll in which again I don't think we had the candidate there I think it's looking pretty good
01:23:11 for him Calgary Varsity we have the NDP leading Calgary Mountain View Calgary Acadia but these
01:23:16 again with one two polls reporting so uh the nail biting continues on this i we're sort of
01:23:22 joking about it but if you're a candidate or a campaign staffer this must be just anxiety
01:23:26 inducing it's a truly lousy time in your life i uh i mean i've worked on quite a number of campaigns
01:23:34 and uh you know well you are quite busy on election day itself there's a lot of work to do
01:23:39 we we do something called getting out the vote which is where we do everything we possibly can
01:23:43 get identified supporters up and out but once that's done once they you know the polls are
01:23:48 closed there is nothing else you can do except sit and wait for your scrutineers to start reporting
01:23:54 results and it's agony because you don't know if you're going to end the night as the new mla or
01:23:59 the re-elected mla for this riding or if you're now unemployed and have to go figure out what it
01:24:05 is you're going to do yeah starting next week i don't i'm going to try to improv here uh phil
01:24:10 there's a woman over there with a cut taxes sign if we can borrow that sign I 1.00
01:24:14 want to talk about this a little bit over there so there's a this was a
01:24:18 campaign that the UCP did as kind of a bit of a guerrilla campaign in response
01:24:23 to an attack that the NDP were doing where they were putting up all these
01:24:26 really weird billboards if you know like what is Danielle Smith going to do next
01:24:31 what is Danielle Smith going to do next and they were running this and it was 0.98
01:24:36 not even clear looking at the posters what exactly the point that they were trying to make was and
01:24:42 some very smart ucp stafford i don't know came from in the org chart here i decided to go around
01:24:50 and answer the questions and i saw someone holding up one of these signs uh the answer is danielle
01:24:56 smith will cut taxes uh that was one of them and this is like the exact same branding and fun that
01:25:03 was on the original attack side and it was the baby sign next to their big sign yeah hilarious
01:25:09 i thought this was just brilliant because it was a way to like turn an ad that was otherwise very
01:25:13 odd uh into a utp win oh i've stolen this for a long time i think i love the stormy moody background
01:25:22 that's my favorite part about anything in a campaign that is clever or funny or makes you
01:25:28 think and it proves one of the rules of politics by the way you never ask an open-ended question
01:25:33 because you don't want an answer like that to be answered.
01:25:36 What will she do next?
01:25:37 She'll cut taxes. 0.99
01:25:39 She'll fix health care. 1.00
01:25:40 She'll get our streets saved.
01:25:42 Those were not what I'm assuming the NDP were hoping people would answer that question with,
01:25:47 but I thought it was a great little tactic.
01:25:48 It definitely made me smile when I saw them on the reds.
01:25:50 I saw a very strange ad.
01:25:53 I've been in Calgary for the last few days, kind of just seeing the lay of the land here,
01:25:57 and there was this one sign.
01:25:59 I can't even remember what was on it, which is always good for an ad,
01:26:01 But I remember being so utterly confused at who it was an ad for and it ended up being an NDP ad
01:26:06 But I but it was just not clear. So the NDP have not really been
01:26:11 Certainly on the ad game. I think they've been losing. I think so too
01:26:14 I think I think that you know, they built any piece and really brilliant about building their marketing around
01:26:19 Rachel even their sides team Rachel Notley not team NDP not NDP candidate, but you know, that's in smaller writing, right? Team Rachel Notley
01:26:27 But yeah, I think the UCP, and really I usually give it up to the left when it comes to more of their marketing campaigns because I think they're telling stories from the heart.
01:26:37 I think conservatives, historically, we bore people by talking about taxes instead of talking about it in a real way to people like, hey, mum with the minivan.
01:26:45 Actually, what this means is it's going to cost you $15 more to fill up your minivan every time.
01:26:49 That's what a carbon tax means.
01:26:51 But instead, we tell it in such a boring way as conservatives, like, well, it's going to cost an average blah, blah, blah.
01:26:56 and people's eyes glaze over.
01:26:58 And so I usually give it to the left.
01:26:59 But the UCP, you know, they kind of took the gloves off a bit
01:27:02 and they were pretty funny and punchy with a lot of their marketing
01:27:05 and a lot of their ones showing the extremism of the NDB candidates.
01:27:08 That really stuck with me and a lot of people I know.
01:27:11 And I think we have to remember that the UCP campaign got off to a bumpy
01:27:15 and then almost high-tech start because, of course,
01:27:18 Alberta was facing a massive natural disaster in the first week of an election.
01:27:23 And, you know, most people or some people may not know that despite there being an election, the premier is still the premier until a new premier is appointed.
01:27:32 So Daniel Smith still had to crisis manage.
01:27:34 And I'm sure that threw a wrench into campaign planning for the United Conservative Party.
01:27:40 In my opinion, it was the debate where things started to pivot.
01:27:44 And I think the UCP really got their mojo back after that debate.
01:27:48 Yeah, this probably shouldn't come as a shock to people.
01:27:51 Well, Danielle Smith is leading in Brooks Medicine Hat, which is the riding that she decided to run in after Michaela Pry, who was formerly Michaela Glasgow, stepped down and I believe is now working for the UCB.
01:28:04 I ran into her a couple of weeks ago.
01:28:07 There was some criticism of Danielle Smith for not running in a Calgary riding.
01:28:11 People sort of thought she should have been bold and gone for one of these ridings that, you know, the UCB may or may not have won.
01:28:17 What's your view on that?
01:28:18 Because she wasn't from Brooks or Medicine Hat.
01:28:20 She was from High River.
01:28:21 i would say uh the people who make those suggestions clearly haven't really done a lot
01:28:26 of campaigning because the last thing you want to do is have your leader running in a tough to win
01:28:30 scene you don't want to be worried about what's happening in the leaders riding because you want
01:28:35 the leader out you want her in target parts of the winning over you don't want her having a 0.99
01:28:40 pound doors in her home riding in a desperate bid we'll just ask john tory in ontario who lost
01:28:45 his own right so uh i absolutely you know that's why she didn't run in calgary elbow which was
01:28:50 always going to be a really hard fight for her to win she made the sensible choice of running and
01:28:55 arriving that the ucp were almost guaranteed to keep in their call yeah and i think that i mean
01:29:01 almost guaranteed i think it's also a bit liberal with it but you know strange things have happened
01:29:04 but to her credit she still did campaign in that riding i someone told me and i didn't see these
01:29:08 but she did two of the local candidates debates there she did launch her campaign there so she 0.91
01:29:13 has maintained the connection to that and i think danielle said it was pretty clear earlier on
01:29:18 when she ran in that writing but she wanted to tell rural albertans that she was still going to
01:29:22 represent it wouldn't it it's not an altogether unwelcome message for rural albertans it certainly
01:29:27 isn't as a rural albertan as you guys know i live in cochrane it's uh we would we need to know if
01:29:33 there is a definitely an urban rural divide in this province i think that's probably the same
01:29:37 is probably true in ontario or in other provinces as well but we definitely want to be a premier
01:29:42 that's going to represent our voices in rural alberta absolutely well we are going to have
01:29:47 lots more results in just a couple of moments time the latest update just before we throw away
01:29:52 is that the uh ucp is now using 43 to 31 so it's gone down which is why again you can't be
01:29:59 uh too cocky about this stuff but let's go to rachel emmanuel who is the 0.52
01:30:03 longtime conservative strategist vitor marziano take it away rachel
01:30:06 he is a senior advisor on the ucp campaign you have a couple polls reporting now anything
01:30:18 catching your eyes so far or is it still too early oh it's still too early but i i don't
01:30:21 mind the trends at all i like the percentages um you know it's still too early to really
01:30:26 measure this you're going to watch it carefully all night long it's going to be a long night
01:30:29 there's going to be a lot of cool states i'm more than cautiously optimistic that things
01:30:33 will go okay. Absolutely. So we were talking a little bit about how we're not seeing a huge
01:30:38 turnout right now compared to the advanced poll. Maybe you can explain a little more in terms of
01:30:41 what we're seeing of voter trends for election day voting versus advanced voting polls.
01:30:46 Well, one of the interesting things that happened recently is that there have been
01:30:49 elections where fewer and fewer people have gone to vote on election day. The last election in
01:30:55 Ontario was particularly like that. You had a small number of people vote on election day,
01:30:59 lots of people vote in the advance polls. As of about 5 or 6 p.m. tonight, it looked like that
01:31:04 was happening in Alberta. Now, it's still a little too early to tell. Maybe there was a last-minute
01:31:07 surge. There are lineups in some voting stations, but I wouldn't be surprised if the voter turnout
01:31:13 for election day was only a bit bigger than the advance polls. You mentioned there's going to be
01:31:19 a couple of really close seats tonight. What are some of the ridings that you're watching?
01:31:22 I think just about everything in Calgary is going to be close. I think everything in the
01:31:26 donut around edmonton is going to be close but i'm feeling pretty confident that we're going to
01:31:31 do well enough in enough of those seats to win the election but uh we're going to watch it and
01:31:35 it's uh it's a little bit of a it's a little bit of a crapshoot you gotta you gotta wait and see
01:31:41 there's a lot of coin toss seats i'm pretty comfortable that we're going to win a good
01:31:46 chunk of the 2021 seats that are up for play but uh we won't really know for probably another hour
01:31:51 and a half. Well, it sounds like you are optimistic. Let me ask you, in terms of Danielle
01:31:56 Smith actually, you know, if they win the election, what if she only wins by a really
01:32:00 small majority? Is it going to be hard for her to hold on to that leadership? No, I actually
01:32:04 think that Danielle has done a very good job of listening and accommodating her caucus
01:32:10 and her cabinet. She's got a very different style of leader. I think she'll adjust to
01:32:16 the size of it and we'll be fine. It sounds like you think she has the support of caucus
01:32:21 behind or depend no matter what that size is she has the support of caucus caucus is going to give 0.52
01:32:24 her a chance to put a stamp on government to give her let her run her government earn the trust of 0.99
01:32:29 albertans i'm very confident that uh that over the next four years albertans will be very impressed
01:32:34 with the type of government she runs something i've been asking some of our other guests tonight
01:32:38 is the ucp ran a pretty quiet campaign insiders i spoke just said that was actually intentional
01:32:43 we didn't want to over promise we didn't want to have too many announcements do you think that was
01:32:48 the right move? Or do you think they could have had a little bit more face time, big announcements
01:32:52 with the voters? I think any insider says is intentional as forgetting about the fires.
01:32:57 For about 12 days during this campaign, we couldn't do what we planned to do. So the campaign
01:33:02 we ran was not the campaign we planned, largely because big parts of northern Alberta were on
01:33:07 fire. And during the campaign, the premier was spending half of her days being the premier
01:33:12 rather than being the leader of a party campaigning. So in many ways, we didn't get to run the
01:33:17 election we wanted to run but at the same time Albertans got to see Danielle being who Danielle 0.93
01:33:22 is attention to detail focus on leadership and ability to bring people together an ability to
01:33:26 focus on the things that matter I'm actually glad you mentioned that because we spent a lot
01:33:30 time talking about the fires at the beginning of the campaign but we haven't really talked about
01:33:34 it too much since do you think that the fires were a detriment because Daniel Smith wasn't
01:33:38 able to get on the campaign or do you think it was an opportunity to prove herself as a trustworthy
01:33:42 leader to voters who maybe weren't sold on her it's a little bit of both but ultimately I think
01:33:47 You know, as a campaigner, I would have rather had 12 more days of Daniel Smith campaigning.
01:33:51 We didn't get to do that because of the fires.
01:33:54 So, you know, there's a sense, to me, there's a sense that it was a net negative.
01:33:58 But at the same time, it kind of cancelled out the NDP's narrative that Daniel Smith wasn't up to the job
01:34:04 or wasn't the sort of person you could trust because people got to see or be trustworthy every day.
01:34:09 Just my last question for you here.
01:34:11 Do you think that there was a defining moment of the campaign?
01:34:14 a lot of people have talked they think it was agree disagree the debates were important but it
01:34:20 wasn't because of what happened at the debate it was because of what didn't happen at the debate
01:34:23 um the ndp gambled their entire campaign on daniel smith being unreasonable unalbertan um
01:34:32 off-putting on the debate and daniel smith showed up at the debate and was daniel smith
01:34:36 she had careful attention to detail she was positive and upbeat she was more upbeat than
01:34:41 the NDP was, and that became a good debate. But it wasn't because of anything we did. It was
01:34:47 because of things the NDP didn't do. All right. Well, thank you so much. Once again,
01:34:51 that was Vitor Marciano, a senior campaign advisor on the UCP campaign. We appreciate
01:34:55 your insight today. Back to you, Andrew. All right. If you're just tuning in, I am Andrew
01:35:02 Watton. This is the live True North Alberta election results show for the 2023 election.
01:35:08 if you're really not actually convinced, you know what's happening. This is not the 2019 election,
01:35:13 that one already happened. The UCB won a big majority then. It's going to be probably...
01:35:30 ...from the North and Wilson. I'm sorry, I laughed when I said your name. That was very rude of me.
01:35:36 I've been sitting here for many hours, and I'm from Alberta Proud.
01:35:55 End of sentence, end of thought.
01:35:57 I was still in time waiting for results.
01:35:58 Make sure you read my book when it comes out.
01:36:00 It's short.
01:36:00 Yeah, the polls are basically an hour and five minutes now.
01:36:06 One poll is staying open until 9.46 p.m., which is a very precise time.
01:36:11 22,545 votes cast, and of those, 245 are leading UCP, 29 are leading NDP.
01:36:20 One thing we haven't talked about, which is actually a bit of a, you were saying, contentious issue for even some Conservatives,
01:36:26 is the arena, which, Danielle, really went all in on this campaign.
01:36:30 what's happened there so i can take this back five years ago and conservatives have always been
01:36:35 really divided on the arena thing but i think at the end of the day i think strategically it was
01:36:40 smart it had a lot of criticism and i know my friends at the canadian taxpayers federation are
01:36:45 gonna like me for something they came out very strongly saying this is a bad deal for taxpayers
01:36:49 well you know what it kind of is if you look at it from from that one perspective what's the worst
01:36:54 steal is if calgary loses its nhl team and not to mention that just the nhl team but we need to
01:37:01 rebuild this downtown core we need to create some more vibrancy in the downtown there's just a lot
01:37:06 of potential for revenue in there the whole sales pitch for the for the arena strategically i think
01:37:13 that thought danielle did some favor i think he created some favor for our game in these tighter
01:37:17 battlegrounds in calgary that's what we're seeing i know generally the olympic big when that came up
01:37:23 however many years ago i was guest hosting um i mean i i wasn't even a calgarian so i didn't even
01:37:29 care about uh you know at all that much on the positive side i just took the standard taxpayer
01:37:33 position that i would take if it were in my city i know conservatives were fairly united against that
01:37:41 or is it different campaigns as you see on oh you know full disclosure i was part of the
01:37:47 organizing committee for the nose guy i recall the photo on the front page of what was the
01:37:51 with the Calgary Herald of you celebrating your referendum.
01:37:56 But, I will say, one notable conservative who supported the Olympics a bit was Danielle
01:38:00 Smith.
01:38:01 And, in fact, she spoke about it, a few friends on her show, in favor of it.
01:38:05 Now, I think it's sort of in the same camp as the new arena in that there is the upside
01:38:14 for a lot of good things.
01:38:16 What I like about the arena versus the Olympics is there's far less risk associated with building a new arena than there is what's called a state at Olympic Games.
01:38:25 You only have to look at the dismal track record of the city through a most good Olympic Games to see how expensive and long it looks exactly.
01:38:32 But for Danielle, I think she looks at it and says, we definitely want to keep our flames here in the city.
01:38:38 We definitely want to get some of those great concerts that skip Calgary and go to Edmonton.
01:38:42 I know that, as a Calgarian, that really wrinkles most evidence that gets a better concert than we do.
01:38:48 And if you bring thousands of people into that part of the city on a regular basis,
01:38:53 you're going to see restaurants and bars and other stores benefiting from the spillover of that economic activity.
01:39:00 There's a lot of upside.
01:39:01 Now, this arena deal only happened because, of course, the last arena deal got blown up by Calgary Mayor Jody Gondek,
01:39:08 who insisted they build solar panels on the roof of that arena because you know calgary is facing
01:39:15 a climate emergency so i think daniel also said i think we can all agree that was a ridiculous
01:39:21 thing that the city did they blew up a pretty good deal in order because they wanted solar
01:39:26 panels on the roof of it we're not going to make that saving take again and i think jody gondek
01:39:31 had to wear that and this is why daniel said i support arena just to bring up jody gondek
01:39:37 There hasn't been the hostility between the two that I think a lot of people have seen.
01:39:43 I mean, one example that came up where a Calgary municipal issue was getting fairly broad coverage,
01:39:49 including by True North, was this ban on protesting drag performances,
01:39:53 which Danielle Smith took a more lukewarm position on before eventually kind of taking the free speech side on this. 1.00
01:40:00 Even the climate emergency, I mean, this was declared before Danielle Smith came in. 0.81
01:40:03 But the two have appeared together.
01:40:04 how do you think that do you think it's a working relationship that isn't working
01:40:08 maybe i see i see there's like uh jody gondek and amirjeet sohi in edmonton of course uh
01:40:17 polar opposite from somebody like danielle smith but at the end and at the end of the day you know
01:40:23 we have very left-leaning governments that are running our two major cities in alberta we have
01:40:27 a very left-leaning uh federal government so for us at alberta proud we've been kind of going with
01:40:33 this slogan like can we really afford to pull our goalie from the net by having a left-leaning
01:40:36 government in in in at the province provincial level too right so we need some balance when
01:40:42 we talk about checks and balances uh i think we need to keep in mind like we have very left-leaning
01:40:49 um some might say eco-radical mayors running these two cities and i think danielle's just 1.00
01:40:55 gonna have her work cut out for her to to find that balance with them um i i think it's interesting
01:41:02 I think definitely, I think she's made a really good start in green lighting, the provincial contribution, which is to the infrastructure side of things for the Calgary Arena, which is a $1.5 million project.
01:41:16 But hey, you know what, on the upside for Calgarians, maybe this magical, mythical unicorn, this green line, you know, the biggest infrastructure project, or as some like to call it critics, the train to nowhere, maybe the train can actually take people down to the new event center.
01:41:31 and we all win.
01:41:32 I'd like to think it had that amount of floor planning.
01:41:34 I remain questionable.
01:41:37 Lindsay, your Banff Kananaskis is so far UCP leading
01:41:40 with three polls reporting.
01:41:43 So 23 polls left, but still Miranda Rosen
01:41:45 has a very, very narrow lead in that one over the NDP.
01:41:50 Just for people tuning in now,
01:41:52 why is Banff an interesting one?
01:41:53 Because I know Banff is a fun place for people.
01:41:56 It's beautiful.
01:41:57 It's scenic.
01:41:58 There are great restaurants, but politically wacky.
01:42:01 Well, I think that people in Banff and Camoron, I love Banff and Camoron, I live in Cochrane, it's an hour away, I've spent a ton of time there, of course, and I love going out there, and I think you get people, they're really focused on things like healthcare, on environment, and on tourism, and you definitely get a lot of loud voices on the left that tend to migrate toward those issues.
01:42:23 So you've got that, and then you've got the ranching country,
01:42:26 and you've got Bragg Creek, kind of that middle ground,
01:42:28 and then you've got down to Prittis and Elbow.
01:42:31 And so you've got, like, it's like a real schmozzle. 0.99
01:42:34 It's a really big, like geographically, not population-wise,
01:42:38 but geographically it's a really big riding,
01:42:40 but it's like complete polar opposite sides of the spectrum.
01:42:44 But you do have that population base in Canmore and BAM.
01:42:47 Do you think that is a riding that's going to eventually get split up,
01:42:51 or is it just not there yet population-wise?
01:42:53 So Cochrane was there, so they've already split that up.
01:42:58 So I don't know if they're going to look to that riding again.
01:43:01 I'd say that's eight years out for that one.
01:43:02 On that note, William, I'll add to what you were going to say in asking how much is redistricting up there, the dynamics in Calgary?
01:43:10 Because it seems like quite a bit.
01:43:12 Oh, absolutely.
01:43:13 And not all redistrictings are created equal.
01:43:16 Sometimes you are just tweaking.
01:43:17 And sometimes you get an independent commission that really takes a knife to the existing map,
01:43:24 chops it up, and builds a whole new thing.
01:43:27 So I think what you're seeing right now, this is quite a different layout for the city
01:43:31 than it was back in the early 2000s.
01:43:34 I think that's had a real impact on how some of the vote's going.
01:43:38 But, you know, all cities tend to be comprised of sort of three chunks, if you like.
01:43:45 You've got the urban core, you've got, you know, more of the suburban, and then you've got what we call ex-urban or bedroom community type things, some of which eventually get eaten up as the city keeps growing.
01:43:58 So, you know, I'm thinking of places like Airdrie, which really abuts up to the city of Calgary right now.
01:44:04 There's not a lot of empty space between those two.
01:44:06 The further out of the core you get, the more conservative these places tend to become.
01:44:11 So if you construct ridings that hybrid, to some degree core and suburban, depending on how you draw that line quite finely, you're either giving it to a left wing or making it more open to left wing election, or you're keeping it in more conservative territory.
01:44:27 So that's part of the fight that happens every time we redraw all of Alberta's ridings.
01:44:32 Does it always benefit the left? Is that generally what happens?
01:44:35 No, not always. I would say this is for all of you geek nerds out there who study redistricting.
01:44:42 I know you're all out there. There might only be two of you, but you are walking.
01:44:47 Back in the mists of time in 2004, Edmonton went from having sort of six wholly inside Edmonton ridings
01:44:55 to eight ridings that were a combination of a chunk of Edmonton and a bedroom community around Edmonton.
01:45:01 Edmonton Sherwood Park, Edmonton Beaumont, Edmonton Spruce Grove.
01:45:05 And that meant that almost all those ridings voted conservative
01:45:08 because they had a healthy dose of small-town Alberta
01:45:10 tacked on to a city riding.
01:45:13 Yeah.
01:45:13 Yeah, and that's interesting because in the context,
01:45:17 the suburban votes are always where elections are won or lost.
01:45:20 And even in Alberta, it sounds like that's generally pretty true as well.
01:45:24 Oh, absolutely.
01:45:25 I mean, if you look at the famous
01:45:28 why can't conservatives win a national election always comes down to those suburban ridings in
01:45:34 and around Toronto. I think the same thing is being said to a degree about Calgary. It's all
01:45:39 about how those suburban families, and we are typically talking about families with children
01:45:44 where one or both parents works, and their concerns are, you know, they're concerned about
01:45:51 health care, sure, but they're also concerned about how safe are their kids walking to soccer
01:45:55 practice, or walking home from soccer practice, or gosh, isn't feeding a family of five becoming
01:46:01 so much more expensive because of inflation and the rising cost of living?
01:46:06 So the updates from Elections Alberta have not come in in 14 minutes, so they're still
01:46:13 holding at 45 UCP and 29 NDP.
01:46:18 Now, I've seen some of the other media outlets have some updates since then.
01:46:22 I'm not entirely sure where they're getting their numbers from if the Alberta Elections Bureau's numbers are not coming in.
01:46:28 But we are going to keep you apprised of all these developments.
01:46:32 And again, 45 UCP and 29 NDP according to Elections Alberta.
01:46:37 That's with 22,545 votes cast.
01:46:42 And a couple of people have been asking about Artur Pawlowski's party.
01:46:47 He is currently, I forget his name, is his the Solidarity?
01:46:50 Solidarity, yeah.
01:46:51 They're at 84 votes right now, so we're not seeing the Pulaski momentum
01:46:54 that a couple of you might have won.
01:46:59 Now, this has actually been interesting.
01:47:01 The Wild Rose Loyalty Coalition is at 52.
01:47:05 Small numbers here, but the Splinter Wild Rose Party
01:47:08 is doing better than the original Wild Rose Party.
01:47:10 Oh, goodness, they're just frustrated.
01:47:12 They're just confusing people.
01:47:13 I like to consider myself reasonably well-informed in Alberta provincial politics,
01:47:17 and even I've lost track of who's where and what team and on what party yeah
01:47:22 fair enough and there are also a bunch of other parties I've never heard the
01:47:25 Buffalo Party of Alberta not with any votes in Calgary Buffalo though so it's
01:47:30 like a missed out for yeah they I don't have the home field advantage they're
01:47:33 the Communist Party the Communist Party is at 51 thank you Lindsay and then
01:47:37 since we're just going through I think they go by NDP there we go there we go
01:47:42 the Reform Party of Alberta has four. Let's see, the Independent Party of Alberta has 78,
01:47:48 which is different from the Wild Rose Independence Party. And the Wild Rose, we already did that,
01:47:53 the Pro-Life Alberta Political Association has zero so far. But the Green Party has 125. So these
01:47:59 parties do exist, but they're not particularly politically relevant. The Alberta Party, which
01:48:03 we were talking about earlier, has 1% of the vote. Now, we talked about this a little bit on the
01:48:08 debate show the alberta part has kind of been like this rorschach test for people where you know some
01:48:14 conservatives think it's like a moderate conservative party some liberals think it's a
01:48:18 moderate liberal party like what are they confused okay yeah they're confused i think so i think like
01:48:24 i said what we were talking earlier i think we're going to continue to see them go down we're going
01:48:30 to see more of a rise of probably the liberal party which will maybe make things very interesting
01:48:34 for the NDP in the next election and four years from now.
01:48:36 The Alberta Party, as we've talked about again on our debate show,
01:48:39 has had such an interesting journey.
01:48:41 When it was first established, it was quite right-wing.
01:48:44 It was sort of a provincial reform party
01:48:47 started by a lot of ex-reform types.
01:48:50 And when I say that, it's not that they stopped believing in reform.
01:48:53 They actually opposed the creation of the Canadian Alliance
01:48:56 because they felt it was a watering-down reform principle.
01:48:59 They were too ripe for the alliance in Stockwell.
01:49:01 They took it over.
01:49:02 But then, because this was such a small and, frankly, badly organized political party,
01:49:07 one AGM, a bunch of ex-PCers upset that their party had apparently drifted too far to the conservative side,
01:49:15 took it over, and it became this mushy, centrist party.
01:49:19 But they did have a leader called Greg Clark, and he actually did quite well for them.
01:49:23 He had won a seat for himself.
01:49:26 They had gotten another seat.
01:49:27 I can't remember if it was a floor crossing or if they had won some other way.
01:49:31 But they actually got up to having several MLAs in the legislature, well, quite.
01:49:35 So, of course, the natural thing to do was to get rid of the guy leading it who had had success
01:49:41 and replace him with former Edmonton Mayor Steve Mandel,
01:49:45 who had just lost his own riding in a provincial election.
01:49:49 Critical missteps.
01:49:50 Why they did that is a mystery to me.
01:49:52 So the UCP lead has gone up to 52.
01:49:55 I think the cheering behind there is that Tyler Shandro has a slight edge in Calgary Acadia over the NDP.
01:50:03 Some more pulls in.
01:50:04 We've got a little bit more.
01:50:05 We've got to take a very quick break here.
01:50:07 We're going to do a quick reset and break things down with Rachel Emanuel. 0.99
01:50:11 Stand by.
01:50:12 We're not going anywhere.
01:50:12 We will be right back in 30 seconds.
01:50:25 .
01:50:55 .
01:51:25 .
01:51:55 We are back, thought we'd give you a little look at the crowd.
01:52:12 You look different William, it's good to have you here.
01:52:15 We have tagged out William McBeth, not for anything he said, but just because we wanted
01:52:19 to get the lay of the land with Rachel Emanuel here, a True North Alberta correspondent who
01:52:23 who has been doing a tremendous job chasing around all the movers and shakers of Alberta politics on the floor here.
01:52:31 You've been out there. I've been hearing it every now and then. How are people feeling?
01:52:34 Yeah, so, you know, it's pretty early still.
01:52:37 It sounds like everyone's pretty convinced it's going to be a really, really late night.
01:52:40 But Vitor Marciano, a senior campaign strategist with the UCP, he just came up and he gave a little bit of insight.
01:52:47 And he said it's still quite early, but the polls are trending in the right direction.
01:52:51 He likes the numbers that we're seeing, but certainly it's going to be a long night.
01:52:54 I saw some complaints online, people were saying, it should always take this long.
01:52:58 I feel like we should be a little bit faster, and especially with some of the advanced votes being counted by tabulators.
01:53:03 So hopefully we will start to get some more seat counts in soon enough,
01:53:07 and people don't have to stay up all night waiting for the results of the election.
01:53:11 By that you mean hopefully we don't have to stay up all night waiting for the election.
01:53:14 Yeah, I don't want to stay up all night.
01:53:15 Enlightened self-interest, I believe the saying goes.
01:53:18 Yeah, I mean, obviously we're hearing the tears from behind.
01:53:20 And the last numbers I'm seeing here are 51 UCP, 33 NDP.
01:53:25 Now, this is leading, not declared.
01:53:27 But have we seen any pretty meaningful results yet in Calgary or even anywhere else?
01:53:32 I believe I saw Calgary Acadia came up a little while ago,
01:53:35 and we heard a pretty big cheer from the audience at that point.
01:53:38 It's like Tyler Shandro was leading in the polls that hadn't been reported.
01:53:41 We know that the party has dumped a lot of resources there.
01:53:44 A lot of people that I talked to that went door knocking went in.
01:53:47 Tyler Shandro is riding, and that's going to be one to watch tonight.
01:53:49 I think every single person pretty much brought it up at some point or another.
01:53:53 So people were pretty excited to see that.
01:53:55 And I think overall, like, the polls are reporting pretty well for us.
01:53:58 I mean, it's still so early, but you kind of get your hopes up, I guess,
01:54:00 and you think, oh, well, cleaning, hopefully it stays that way.
01:54:04 Yeah, I mean, Lindsay, I know you've been up here with us,
01:54:07 so you haven't had the chance to walk the floor yet.
01:54:09 But generally speaking, people seem to be in a pretty celebratory mood.
01:54:12 I'm not seeing the nervousness that you sometimes see on election nights
01:54:15 when you aren't sure or you know it's probably not going to go away.
01:54:18 Well, again, I think we go back to that debate a couple of weeks ago.
01:54:21 I think that was a bit of a turning point.
01:54:22 And I think we're just seeing such a slew of pollsters that have been so definitively declaring a UCP majority over the last five to seven days that I think that that tone, there hasn't been any major blunders.
01:54:35 You know, I think we were all thinking with this Gloves Off campaign and, you know, the Rachel versus Danielle, what else is going to come out?
01:54:42 There's been some things that have come out on the premier over the last few things she said in the past in her radio show days.
01:54:47 And I think we were all waiting for, like, another shoe to drop last few days,
01:54:50 and there was nothing, and I was kind of surprised by that.
01:54:53 And I think they've just kind of carved out this path toward victory.
01:54:56 I think things, I think, you know, the wildfire situation,
01:55:00 that was definitely disruptive, but certainly the province acted very quickly
01:55:04 on getting out-of-province help for that and stopped campaigning for those few days.
01:55:09 And the weather also turned, and we got some rain, and that helped.
01:55:13 So the timing of all, it's all these little tiny things that kind of came together.
01:55:17 And I think the stars have sort of aligned for them that, you know,
01:55:20 I don't think we can say we're going to go into this with the UCP necessarily having 51 or 52 seats.
01:55:26 But I think they're, I'd be hard-pressed to see if they're not going to make 44 at least.
01:55:30 Rachel, the last few days of the campaign, I mean, I'm used to seeing leaders go morning to night,
01:55:36 photo op, photo op, rally, rally, rally.
01:55:40 Danielle Smith, she had a press conference, I think it was on Friday,
01:55:43 and that was the last time she had a publicly announced event I know she
01:55:48 popped up to the few little events with local candidates she was running in a
01:55:52 race in Calgary where she was in the Calgary Marathon yeah my hotel room so
01:55:56 I was like cheering on the runners but was definitely not joining them but I
01:56:00 mean what do you make of that if anything that that relatively low-laying
01:56:03 last few days
01:56:05 a lot of people for different takes on it one of the takes that I've heard a
01:56:11 A couple of UCP insiders say is, oh, well, we tried to keep it pretty low-key.
01:56:15 We didn't want to over-promise.
01:56:17 You know, we wanted a few important things that we did promise to really stand out
01:56:20 since the tax cuts, things on jobs, the economy, public safety.
01:56:23 So basically we want to be like the NDP over-promising everything.
01:56:26 So that was one take.
01:56:28 You know, another take was that they had to quickly change their campaign at the last minute
01:56:32 when the wildfires crisis really erupted in northern Alberta at the beginning of the campaign.
01:56:37 That wouldn't exactly seem to extend to the end of the campaign, but Pietro Marciano was just saying to me, you know, we really had to adjust the campaign for those wildfires, and that wasn't something that we had entirely anticipated, so we did change our campaign.
01:56:50 And then another perspective that Sensible shared as well, you know, we've had a little bit of gasp with the media, and maybe it's just better if we don't give Daniel's just too much airtime.
01:56:59 more skeptical view that some people have had is just try to keep it away from the media as much
01:57:04 as possible things are going smoothly things are going in our direction let's not ruin that after
01:57:08 stronger base performance let's just keep things simple and you know the media hasn't been too
01:57:12 friendly to daniel's fans that's no surprise so you know the less air time they can they can give
01:57:16 them maybe it seems a bit of a benefit for the campaign yeah and just on that note i mean i that
01:57:21 press conference that she had uh was marketed as an announcement but there really wasn't anything
01:57:26 to announce at that point, you know, that LeCampagne,
01:57:28 the announcement was NDB bad, UCB good.
01:57:31 So when you have that little to announce,
01:57:32 why just throw yourself to the wolves
01:57:34 and give them an opportunity to get a pound of flesh from you, right?
01:57:37 I think you saw a little less Danielle as well the last couple of weeks,
01:57:39 and you saw a lot more of the team.
01:57:41 So you saw a lot of Rebecca Schultz.
01:57:43 You saw a lot of Brian Jean.
01:57:45 And perhaps maybe this has really worked out for the UCB.
01:57:48 You're seeing those voices showing, you know,
01:57:50 a really effective cabinet and showing a more united front
01:57:54 and showing really capable, experienced MLAs.
01:57:57 Yeah. What were you going to say, Rachel?
01:57:59 Yeah, I was just going to say they had a couple announcements like that.
01:58:02 It didn't even just wait until the end.
01:58:03 They had a couple announcements that were non-announcements.
01:58:06 I drove all the way there, and I was like, all right, we'll see what's happening. 0.97
01:58:08 And it was like, NDP sucks, vote for the UCP. 0.97
01:58:11 And everyone was like, it's okay. 0.97
01:58:13 I don't know if this really qualifies as an announcement.
01:58:14 They did that a couple times, actually.
01:58:16 Yeah, but I mean, again, you expose yourself to the media.
01:58:19 You let them ask about whatever they want.
01:58:21 I mean, if you don't give them an announcement to cover,
01:58:22 They don't have an announcement to cover here.
01:58:25 Just because I asked the other panelists here, Rachel, and now you're swapping in,
01:58:29 what is the riding, if any, that you're paying attention to, that you're kind of interested in?
01:58:33 Yeah, so I did mention this to the audience a little earlier in the night.
01:58:36 I know Calgary Acadia has come up so much, but I've been told that along with Calgary Glenmore,
01:58:42 which is Whitney and Six Riding, are really true to watching Calgary, as well as Calgary Cross.
01:58:46 I know that there's been a lot of efforts being dumped there.
01:58:49 I know a lot of people working on that campaign.
01:58:50 I think they sort of saw it as we're losing Calgary Cross, that's Mickey Amory's riding,
01:58:55 and they were sort of a late effort to really get some speed on the ground
01:58:59 and go out door-knocking, improve that campaign.
01:59:01 So I actually think we might pull off a win in Calgary Cross tonight.
01:59:05 It is a toss-up. It was slightly leading UCP, the last numbers that were reported on 3-3-8 Canada.
01:59:11 So I think those are some to look at across Calgary.
01:59:13 Of course, Calgary Edgemont is going to be another really interesting to look at.
01:59:16 I don't know if we're going to be able to hold that one tonight and then outside of Calgary or rather outside of Edmonton we're sort of looking at the one outside the donut a couple ones there to see if we can pull off a win and those ridings or hold on to seats that currently existed so a couple of those I think we're going to be paying close attention to Moreville and St. Albert see if we can hold that riding as well as Strathcola at Sherwood Park is another one that's Nate Blubish's riding are we going to be able to hold those riding
01:59:46 or are we going to really lose that dome outside of Edmonton?
01:59:49 And, of course, Casey Maddow, I think I heard you mentioned that on the show earlier.
01:59:53 I think everyone's kind of accepted we're probably not going to win that riding.
01:59:56 That's not going to be a UCP win tonight.
01:59:58 And, you know, me as the deputy premier, so certainly a big loss to the party.
02:00:01 There will be big shifts to fill there.
02:00:02 But I think people have generally accepted they're losing the ridings within Edmonton.
02:00:06 And by that, I mean all the ridings that have Edmonton.
02:00:08 It's just a question of can we hold on to some of those ridings inside the dome?
02:00:12 Yeah, and just to look at Edmonton right now on my trusty map here,
02:00:15 Not a lot of poles in Edmonton.
02:00:18 I mean, most of the ridings here have one, two, three reporting.
02:00:22 Like in Edmonton Southwest, it's still going NDP, but that's only with one pole in. 0.82
02:00:27 Calgary, we've got a little bit more in the way of results.
02:00:30 Just to go around here, you mentioned Calgary Glenmore.
02:00:33 UCP currently leading in Glenmore with five poles reporting.
02:00:37 In Acadia, three poles in. 0.98
02:00:39 Sandro's up by six.
02:00:40 Yeah, very tight.
02:00:41 We have in Calgary Klein, that is Jeremy Nixon.
02:00:45 he's leading with four polls and so again it depends on which of those polls we're talking
02:00:50 with here like if it's the you know the the conservative neighborhood then it's not all
02:00:54 that important if it's a neighborhood that's a bit more uh down the road this could tell us
02:00:57 something so we'll see as the night goes on but i guess the question that i would ask would be
02:01:03 did you feel it was an eventful campaign if you were covering it on the ground i know you didn't
02:01:07 really have to go that far uh you know it's like you weren't going up to fort mac and down to
02:01:11 medicine had because so much of it was in calgary but it seemed pretty linear to me like i don't
02:01:16 recall any real bumps yeah i didn't really find that it was super busy kind of really sure to
02:01:22 expect and i've this is my first time covering a provincial election campaign i've covered many
02:01:27 federal leadership campaigns so i was kind of excited because when you cover a federal leadership
02:01:31 campaign if your outlet doesn't have the budget which mine never did they're not actually sending
02:01:35 you out on the campaign because that would be spinning all over canada and most outlets don't
02:01:39 have money for that nowadays or they're only sending their you know one or two reporters
02:01:43 so i was excited to be covering a provincial campaign because it meant that i would be able
02:01:46 to attend all the events in person because you know it's alberta you can pretty much drive from
02:01:50 place to place it's a bit of travel so i was excited to cover this campaign and i did really
02:01:55 enjoy being able to go to the events and being able to get my questions in but it wasn't terribly
02:01:59 busy it wasn't terribly eventful and then of course we had a fair amount of difficulty getting
02:02:03 into those Alberta NDP events so you know maybe they were hosting a lot more
02:02:08 events than they used to be I think two with up to two a day at some point but
02:02:11 we would be lucky to get access to two of their events a week because it's not
02:02:15 only did they not really want us there but they also made it very difficult for
02:02:18 us to actually know the location of those events so on the rare chance we
02:02:22 found out where they were happening we could get there and get inside and get
02:02:25 asked for questions it was great but we didn't miss out on a fair amount of
02:02:30 their announcements and so really we missed out on that and then the UCP
02:02:34 didn't do too much so it wasn't super busy it wasn't super eventful there was a
02:02:37 couple of moments of the campaign that I really noticed you know Danielle Smith
02:02:40 started the campaign with a big announcement on tax cuts and another
02:02:45 really big announcement that she made during the campaign was the Compassion
02:02:48 Intervention Act which we talked about extensively with some of our guests on
02:02:51 tonight those were pretty big announcements but it wasn't super big
02:02:55 and I felt like the NDP spent so much time lobbying insults at the premier and
02:02:59 And I really felt like they stuck, you know, I think maybe some of her comments on the COVID vaccine got a little bit of attention.
02:03:06 But I never really felt like there was a moment where I'm like, wow, we're still talking about this attack that they launched a couple of days ago.
02:03:13 It pretty much seemed like it was something.
02:03:15 And, you know, as a party, you never want to be on the defense.
02:03:17 You never want to be responding because that's the day you lost message.
02:03:21 And so certainly that was a bit of an issue at the beginning of the campaign.
02:03:24 But they were still sort of able to address it and move on, which is something that you really never know how that's going to go.
02:03:29 So if there's another campaign, an attack is completely derail your campaign.
02:03:32 It keeps coming up and you'll grow the campaign.
02:03:35 And so, you know, it wasn't terribly eventful on either side, I would say.
02:03:39 What was your take on it?
02:03:40 I mean, from an Alberta Proud perspective, were you finding, like, there was a lot of engagement or was it relatively low or just kind of moderate?
02:03:48 Well, Alberta Proud, you know, there's a good little red meat base there, certainly.
02:03:52 And there is just kind of a consensus from the people that I talk to every day through Alberta Proud
02:03:58 is that a vote for Notley is a vote for Trudeau.
02:04:02 It's a vote for the NDP Liberal Coalition.
02:04:05 And no matter how much issue people may take with Daniel Smith or some of her MLAs
02:04:11 or some decisions, some of the policies that the UCBs come forward,
02:04:14 what people seem to be really resonating with people is that they're taking a really hard stance on crime,
02:04:21 the opiate crisis, public safety, and trying to do some real change within health care,
02:04:29 which is always such a contentious file for conservatives, certainly.
02:04:35 So you mentioned the addiction issue, which we were talking about a little bit earlier on the panel
02:04:39 after you and the now MLA-elect, I believe, in that riding we're discussing.
02:04:45 And do you think it actually resonated?
02:04:47 Do you think it was something that actually got them votes?
02:04:49 or do you think it was just a policy that they believed in that they thought was important?
02:04:53 Yeah, that's a great question.
02:04:54 That's something that I was wondering as well.
02:04:56 I was actually really surprised to see them announce this policy during the election.
02:05:01 I knew that the government was considering this
02:05:04 because the Globe and Mail had actually filed a freedom and access to information request
02:05:08 to basically learn that this had been something that had been discussed within the Addictions Office.
02:05:15 I suspect that they must have had a source that leaked it to them
02:05:17 because I was a pretty specific agent for them to get that revelation.
02:05:20 I was like, all right, someone leaked this.
02:05:21 So we knew a couple of weeks before the campaign dropped
02:05:23 that this was something that they discussed,
02:05:24 but the UCP government at the time sort of just played it off
02:05:27 and said, well, you know, we put forward lots of different policy proposals
02:05:30 and the Premier likes to look over these things.
02:05:32 I had no idea how serious it was being considered at the time.
02:05:36 And then, you know, sure enough, midway through the campaign,
02:05:38 they dropped this huge policy announcement.
02:05:41 And it was one of the better announcements from the UCP.
02:05:44 they had lots of people in recovery speak about how their family was able to get treatment
02:05:51 for them because they got a court order from a judge that forced them into treatment and
02:05:54 they spoke about how addicts don't really want treatment when you're addicted to something
02:05:59 because all you can think about is that drug and when you can have that drug for another
02:06:03 time. And so it was a really powerful announcement and I think the fact that they had so many
02:06:07 individuals in recovery speak at it made it that much more effective. So of course that
02:06:12 announcement drops it played really well online among my readers obviously a more conservative
02:06:18 base people seemed pretty excited about it of course you had a lot of people that were also
02:06:22 concerned and said okay well this could just as easily be abused so something i've been asking
02:06:27 some of our interviews tonight is hopefully the restrictions about the doors because that was my
02:06:31 question you know it's so specific this is something that the average person is paying
02:06:35 attention to and what i heard was if your life has been touched by addiction you found that the
02:06:41 policy resonated with you. So I sense it probably didn't have a broader appeal to the General
02:06:46 Electric just for maybe these families that are touched by addiction and to be honest
02:06:50 that is a large number of people nowadays. I think most of us even sitting at this table
02:06:54 think about someone we know whose life has been touched by addiction or something that
02:06:57 they're struggling with. So it's hard to say. I would say probably it didn't resonate too
02:07:01 much. I think probably some of the policies that did resonate more are some of the other
02:07:05 work the government is doing on the public safety file and some of their other promises
02:07:08 like the ankle monitor for violent criminals and more sheriffs to really watch those people.
02:07:13 I think those are the types of policies when we talk about public safety
02:07:16 that resonated with the average Calgarian voter.
02:07:19 Yeah, I mean, let's talk about that a little bit,
02:07:21 because I know nationally that's been a huge issue as of late.
02:07:24 We've heard of just all of these stories from all over the country
02:07:27 of people that are out on bail that commit some horrendous act of violence.
02:07:31 Did we see that seep into the Alberta campaign, that justice crime angle?
02:07:36 Yeah, I think that's fair to say.
02:07:38 I think so. I think unfortunately we've had a number of officers that have lost their lives this year and I think that that's factored in. I mean driving around Calgary now compared to when I was a university student here 20 years ago, dating myself, but it really is like night and day. We have a massive problem on the streets and it's going to spread outwards and it's going to spread into our suburban communities and oftentimes when people move from the downtown and pass the university days and they get families and they get bigger houses,
02:08:07 if they live in the suburbs, there's a bit of a nimbyism.
02:08:11 Not in my backyard, I don't care, it doesn't affect me,
02:08:13 I go to work all day, I'm with my kids all night,
02:08:15 I'm not seeing this, but you're starting to see it.
02:08:17 And I think when we're looking at our officers,
02:08:20 it's not safe for them to be on the streets, we need more of them,
02:08:24 I think that that's starting to resonate with people.
02:08:26 I think they're starting to take it more seriously.
02:08:28 And I think a month ago, a month and a half ago,
02:08:30 crime and public safety wasn't as much of a part of this campaign,
02:08:34 and I think it's really become part of this campaign.
02:08:36 And when they came out with, you know, the beds and the Intervention Act and all this stuff on the opiate crisis file,
02:08:43 when you're standing up there and you're united with all the First Nations leaders
02:08:48 and they're telling their own personal stories that, you know, our First Nations communities are dying.
02:08:54 They're being ripped apart by the opiate crisis, which is, you know, we need to really, 1.00
02:08:59 We need their lived experience, combined with the fact that the UCP,
02:09:05 that this whole file is being led by Chief of Staff to Premier Smith,
02:09:08 by Marsha Smith, who's a recovering addict
02:09:12 who was on the streets of East Vancouver for four and a half years.
02:09:15 What do you say to that?
02:09:16 That's lived experience that's informing this.
02:09:18 And to me, that's always the best way to achieve it.
02:09:20 These aren't people, just policymakers in the back rooms.
02:09:23 These are people who've been through the gamut,
02:09:25 and they're doing the proper Indigenous consultation on this.
02:09:27 I think they've approached it the right way.
02:09:29 I see some people that you're supposed to be interviewing walking around.
02:09:33 One of them is the minister and MLA, well, probably MLA-elect Rebecca Schultz.
02:09:39 So we'll let you loose in just a second, but I want to give a quick update here on numbers.
02:09:43 The most recent figures we have from Elections Alberta are that the UCP are leading with 50 and Alberta NDP with 35.
02:09:52 Now we're up to 124,000 votes cast right now, so a pretty significant increase,
02:10:00 and they're coming in more quickly now.
02:10:02 So I think we'll start to get a little bit more in the way of numbers.
02:10:05 And just to some of the key ridings we've been watching,
02:10:07 your beloved BAMP Kananaskis is leading NDP right now.
02:10:11 Calgary Acadia, which William McBeth has been watching, is currently NDP leading,
02:10:15 but again, that's still only with three polls in.
02:10:19 And the one that I was watching, Edmonton Southwest, is not looking good for Casey Maddew.
02:10:24 NDP's still leading there, but again, pretty small margin, just 79 votes.
02:10:29 And that is one that we'll be watching.
02:10:31 Still 15 polls left there, so we could still see that go a different direction here.
02:10:36 So as we watch this and the night goes on, let me just ask about Steve Outhouse.
02:10:42 I know we're hoping to grab him later on.
02:10:44 He's the campaign manager for the UCP.
02:10:46 Have they kind of kept him hidden, or have you had the chance to talk to him tonight?
02:10:51 I haven't actually seen him anywhere.
02:10:52 They've kept him hidden. He wasn't actually on the media list.
02:10:55 So we'll see if he's coming out later and doing some interviews with people.
02:10:58 He has been available. The UCP has been doing their nightly broadcasts
02:11:02 where they kind of speak to voters directly about what they talked about that day,
02:11:05 and they have different candidates on showcasing their work and the policy of the day.
02:11:09 He has been behind the scenes a little bit.
02:11:13 And I think a lot of people were really interested to see that he was chosen as the campaign manager.
02:11:17 Obviously, he ran Leslie Lewis's Federal Conservative Leadership Campaign, the last two of them.
02:11:22 She performed very well in her first time as a leadership.
02:11:25 I think people had less expectations for her because she was so new and she was considered that underdog. 0.98
02:11:30 And then her fundraising numbers just blew people out of the water.
02:11:33 And, you know, we saw she didn't perform as well the second time around.
02:11:36 But here, Polly Ev did so well. 1.00
02:11:38 Yeah, no one blames Steve for that.
02:11:40 No.
02:11:40 All right, well, we'll let you get back to the floor.
02:11:44 We're going to do a brief reset here and get back to our regular panel.
02:11:48 The night is still young, so if you're tuning in, I thank you for it.
02:11:52 Keep tuning in.
02:11:53 We're going to have more results for you in just a couple of moments.
02:11:55 I'm Andrew Law.
02:11:56 This is the True North election night show for Alberta's 2023 election.
02:12:01 Stand by.
02:12:10 .
02:12:40 .
02:13:10 .
02:13:40 .
02:14:10 all right rachel has been completed here this is what we're stuck with now that was rude to
02:14:25 rachel william good to see you welcome back william mcbeth is here we have lindsey wilson
02:14:29 from alberta proud and yours truly andrew lawton from true north as we break down the results which
02:14:36 are kind of it's feast or famine you'll get a whole bunch in a few minutes and then nothing
02:14:40 for quite a while we just had one update 30 seconds ago from elections alberta uh currently
02:14:45 at 52 for the united conservative party and 33 for the alberta ndp this is with 155
02:14:53 thousand votes cast again 2.9 million registered voters uh so that is something you have to keep
02:14:58 in mind and of the ridings we've been watching uh there haven't been any declared flips yet so
02:15:04 So we're still pretty early.
02:15:05 So you said the last time this was wrapped up
02:15:08 like 15 minutes ago.
02:15:10 Yeah, I mean, it's definitely a very different election
02:15:13 to 2019.
02:15:14 I think the scale of the victory in 2019 just meant
02:15:19 it was going to be pretty clear that it was a United
02:15:21 Conservative majority government,
02:15:22 and they were able to declare it faster.
02:15:23 This one is obviously going to be a tire race,
02:15:26 and we're seeing that by the fact that you're seeing
02:15:29 that seat count bounce up and down a little bit.
02:15:31 There's a handful of votes.
02:15:32 changing who's leading yeah and I mean obviously the mood has changed in the
02:15:37 conservative movement I think a lot in the last four years there's a very
02:15:41 different party a very different leader very different just political dynamic
02:15:45 with the last few years but to go back to a discussion we had earlier you think
02:15:50 the unity issue has really been largely dealt with at least for now like we
02:15:54 didn't see a lot of specific disunity in the race no I think I think everybody
02:15:59 was really professional and above board through through through the race it is interesting to see
02:16:05 what danielle smith's journey is if she is successful tonight as premier and what happens
02:16:10 uh you know that is really who knows right we can't predict the future certainly but
02:16:14 yeah it's definitely a different tone and i can speak to you know i live in what's determined like
02:16:18 a ucp safe zone out in cochran right with uh peter guthrie who is our also our energy minister
02:16:24 but it's interesting how many orange signs you see out now as opposed to four years ago you
02:16:29 wouldn't have you barely saw an orange sign in in a town like Cochrane I mean far far less so
02:16:35 it's it's interesting there's definitely it's definitely if this isn't 2019 I think that's
02:16:39 fair to say this is not 2019 and there's a lot of people who are pretty loud and in support of
02:16:46 of the NDP and you know we've noticed a lot in the news in the last couple of weeks we're seeing
02:16:51 long-time Conservatives flipping and coming out and saying that they're supporting the NDP.
02:16:57 What's that all about? I don't really know how much we can read into that,
02:17:01 or can we say were those people ever really Conservatives to begin with? I don't know.
02:17:05 How much, I don't know how unpopular Rachel Notley was personally when she left office. 1.00
02:17:11 I think there were a lot of voters that had a sense of buyer's remorse,
02:17:15 but do you think there are people that have kind of forgotten how bad it was now,
02:17:19 or people that sort of, because it was so long ago,
02:17:21 they don't remember how much they didn't like the NDP?
02:17:24 I mean, I think that's entirely possible.
02:17:28 Rachel Notley won in 2015 against a divided conservative movement.
02:17:32 There were two conservative parties on the ballot, both taking a share.
02:17:36 And, you know, the New Democrats I talked to in 2019 said,
02:17:39 we knew it was always going to be a really hard fight
02:17:41 for us against a united conservative movement without that vote splitting.
02:17:45 But now we get to hear where we are.
02:17:47 And I do think, because it had been a few years, the whole memory of Rachel Notley maybe had softened a bit.
02:17:55 Where I think it changed back was when she proposed that 38% increase to corporate taxes.
02:18:02 That's the Rachel we knew.
02:18:03 And I think everybody went, oh, right, they're not good for business in Alberta.
02:18:08 I'd forgotten that.
02:18:09 And I think that actually was a major turning point for her campaign. 0.99
02:18:12 Oh, I think also buying into getting to this net zero by 2035, I think people are scared
02:18:21 to see what their electricity bills are going to look like, and I think that is perceived
02:18:25 as too much in line with Prime Minister Trudeau.
02:18:27 So I think that works in step with that.
02:18:31 Yeah, and I'm just looking at some of the numbers here.
02:18:33 By the way, your home riding is doing very well for the UCB right now of Cochrane Air
02:18:37 Dree.
02:18:37 It looks like Peter Guthrie has a fairly unsurprising lead there.
02:18:42 And just looking around the Calgary ridings here, not a huge amount of movement.
02:18:46 NDP still leading in Calgary Acadia with one more poll reporting.
02:18:51 In Calgary Curry, which is the one we are watching, the NDP are leading.
02:18:56 In Calgary Glenmore, the UCP have a, I wouldn't say a healthy lead, but they have a lead there.
02:19:02 So we're certainly not seeing a blowout in the early numbers of like some NDP surge,
02:19:08 like Kito Maggi of Main Street was sort of suggesting,
02:19:11 even in spite of what Main Street's own polls and models were saying.
02:19:16 Let's geek out a little bit here.
02:19:19 The history of polling in Alberta elections.
02:19:21 I'll start with you, William.
02:19:23 I mean, yeah, look, the problem with polling is well known
02:19:28 in that we've seen so many examples of where pollsters have confidently declared
02:19:33 that an election was going one way or the other
02:19:35 and then turned out to be nowhere even remotely close to it.
02:19:39 The one I painfully remember, of course, is 2012.
02:19:43 The poll said we would be thundering to a Wild Rose victory,
02:19:46 and of course that didn't happen.
02:19:49 Now you're schlepping it up here with us.
02:19:51 But, you know, the question is, well, then why is polling becoming less accurate?
02:19:54 And I think it's because getting to actual voters is increasingly difficult.
02:19:59 You know, people, a lot of people no longer have home phones.
02:20:02 They only have cell phones.
02:20:03 If they have cell phones, they don't answer phone calls from numbers they don't recognize.
02:20:08 So you're having to phone vast numbers in order to try and get even a tiny sample size.
02:20:15 And, you know, my other gut feeling is that, by the way, not an Alberta problem.
02:20:19 You can look at the United States.
02:20:21 Donald Trump couldn't possibly become president, except he did, based on polling.
02:20:26 So I think it's the fact that people are now just not telling pollsters.
02:20:30 I won't say they're lying, but they're either actively not providing information
02:20:34 or they're not providing information that is statistically useful enough
02:20:39 in order to give an accurate agreement.
02:20:41 No, when I ran in Ontario many years ago and I was going door knocking,
02:20:47 I was finding, you know, one-third said they were voting for me,
02:20:49 one-third said they were voting for the NDP, and one-third said they were undecided.
02:20:53 And I thought, oh, great, I didn't realize the undecidists were just lying to me 1.00
02:20:56 because they didn't want to tell me they weren't voting for me.
02:20:58 So there is a little bit of that in polling.
02:21:01 It is true.
02:21:02 It is sadly something we have to tell candidates that if a voter tells the candidate yes, it's a maybe.
02:21:09 But if a voter does tell a candidate no, you can take that to the bank.
02:21:13 Well, yeah, that is good advice.
02:21:15 But even that clip that we played earlier, the montage of Rachel Emanuel doing her own sort of impromptu exit polling out there,
02:21:22 a lot of people are very cagey at first.
02:21:25 And I think some people, there's still a little bit of vote stigma.
02:21:27 And I think that's probably more a thing with conservative votes,
02:21:31 that people are very nervous to admit in some context,
02:21:34 even in Alberta, that they're conservative.
02:21:36 Well, I think that there's just been a lot.
02:21:38 There's been voter exhaustion has been a big part of the problem,
02:21:41 and which ties in with voter apathy, unfortunately.
02:21:44 And I think we're seeing that.
02:21:46 Definitely the last Calgary mayoral race, we definitely saw that.
02:21:49 I mean, there was also COVID, of course,
02:21:51 but there was a snap federal election that was just three weeks before.
02:21:55 So it was kind of a perfect storm for a low turnout, certainly.
02:22:00 I just want to, by the way, interrupt our programming here, more than that was interrupting our programming here,
02:22:06 to just let you know we're here because we believe that it's important to have an independent media counterbalance to the legacy media's coverage on this.
02:22:15 And if you look at this row that we have down here, Global has this giant studio and CBC has a giant studio.
02:22:22 and then we've got this little section on the end here but we're here we have members of our team
02:22:26 from all over Canada and certainly all our Alberta crew here. This is not cheap so if you can support
02:22:32 the work that True North is doing and take a stand in general for independent media please do head on
02:22:37 to donate.tnc.news donate.tnc.news and also if you are watching on YouTube you can leave a super chat
02:22:46 in the comments and if you have any questions that you want us to answer live on air do super chat us
02:22:53 and ask your question in there and we'll certainly read those out they have to actually be a question
02:22:57 sometimes people will super chat something that is not a question and sometimes we're less inclined
02:23:01 to read those out but we may as the night goes on but truly i just want to say thank you to all the
02:23:06 donors out there who do support true north on the regular and this is a particularly special
02:23:10 location uh so i'll ask you again that website is donate.tnc.news and since we are talking with
02:23:17 independent media i think that was a bit of a theme of this campaign that was one that we have
02:23:23 to actually talk about because rachel notley had a very definitive position on i am only going to
02:23:29 talk to the alberta legislative press gallery reporters so much so of having security remove
02:23:34 key and bexty who we saw earlier and rebel news uh rachel emmanuel got questions into rachel
02:23:39 Notley because she's very loud, and at that point she didn't need the microphone for Rachel
02:23:43 to have heard her question. I don't think it costs them votes, but I do think it is
02:23:48 a very telling example of what a Rachel Notley government would look like.
02:23:53 Well, I think it's terrifying, actually, because when you have somebody who's vying to be the
02:23:58 next Premier of Alberta, not answering, you know, Western Standard, right, the Western
02:24:03 Standard press conference and one of their editors, Nigel Hannaford, and she was just
02:24:09 directly saying we're not going to answer any of your questions well Western Standard is an
02:24:14 accredited news media outlet they're alternative media certainly but they're accredited and they're
02:24:19 in these press galleries and they're they have you know people in the parliament building as well so
02:24:24 this isn't just some fly-by-night blogger and so it was quite I think that that didn't resonate
02:24:29 well with people at all and I think when you combine that with you know bill c11 and c18
02:24:36 coming down the pipeline, people are afraid that we're going to start losing access to the truth,
02:24:40 to information, and I can't, I mean, at Alberta Proud, I advocate all the time for all our partners
02:24:45 in independent media. I think it's so critical, and I think that was a really good glimpse. That
02:24:50 press conference was a really good glimpse at what a Rachel Notley government would look like, and
02:24:54 you know, in talking to alternative media, I know that a lot of reporters are completely cut off from
02:24:58 NDP email lists
02:25:00 and press releases and
02:25:02 we'll have a look at that.
02:25:05 So I would definitely say
02:25:06 one of the weird things about
02:25:08 the NDP's decision
02:25:10 is one of their big end of campaign
02:25:12 messages was
02:25:13 lend us your vote conservative.
02:25:16 Maybe you've never voted NDP
02:25:18 in your life but lend me a vote conservative.
02:25:20 Well then wouldn't you think talking to
02:25:22 media outlets whose
02:25:24 primary audience
02:25:25 were conservative
02:25:27 or people who are at least on the more conservative side of the spectrum,
02:25:31 you would think you would want to preference those media outlets
02:25:34 to try and get your message of lend us through.
02:25:37 Whereas, you know, you go on CBC to try and talk to conservatives.
02:25:40 Okay, you can talk to the more conservatives still watching CBC,
02:25:44 or you can talk to True North and talk to a huge chunk of the conservatives in this problem.
02:25:49 To me, that told me a really, really quick contrast to Rachel Watley on that.
02:25:53 You can lend me your vote. I won't let you down.
02:25:56 Yeah, and I think there's actually an interesting angle there,
02:26:00 and I think Rachel was talking about it a little bit earlier too,
02:26:03 and we'll discuss it later.
02:26:04 This idea that the NDP thinks it's entirely natural
02:26:07 for them to be the new home for conservative voters.
02:26:11 It was odd to see that pitch with a straight face.
02:26:14 I'm just trying to figure out what's conservative about them.
02:26:17 I'm still trying to figure that out.
02:26:18 You've got to do more than put on a blue blazer in a debate
02:26:21 to convince me that you're conservative. I'm sorry.
02:26:23 No, I agree, but I think it goes to the...
02:26:25 I mean, there's some hubris there, certainly, but if the NDP's position was that Danielle
02:26:29 Smith is so outside the mainstream of acceptable political discourse, and it was actually among
02:26:36 the most cynical approaches to politics, that this woman is like, how can even a conservative 1.00
02:26:41 vote for this woman, was basically their approach. 1.00
02:26:43 Absolutely.
02:26:44 I really think that made it hard for conservatives, even ones who maybe weren't thrilled with
02:26:50 a Danielle Smith like UCP. 0.97
02:26:52 I think they didn't like seeing the anger that's welled up from the NDP campaign.
02:26:59 I mean, I think Rachel Notley, one of her biggest assets when she won the first time
02:27:03 was the fact that she was seen as sunny and optimistic, positive,
02:27:08 and a change between the bickering between the Wild Rose and the PC parties.
02:27:12 She was offered some more hopeful policy.
02:27:17 And I think she really did herself in by going so negative, so relentlessly,
02:27:21 against conservative party but i think she even galvanized wavering conservatives back behind
02:27:27 the united conservative party yeah i think you may be right about that just to give you the
02:27:33 latest updates here we have 52 ridings leaning ucp and 35 ridings leading ndp now uh 50 what was
02:27:41 your prediction earlier i was 50 37 okay and you were 51 right i was 51 okay and i was right now
02:27:47 I'm the loser if the current numbers hold but again I have to be the damp blanket and say you
02:27:51 know early days early days but but every time I say that it's less so because right now 244,851
02:27:59 votes are in and as we see this we're also actually seeing 25 percent of polling stations have
02:28:06 reported right now so overall we actually have a bit more clarity certainly in some ridings here
02:28:12 To go back into the ones we're watching in Calgary,
02:28:15 no change yet in Calgary Acadia.
02:28:18 That is still the NDP leading.
02:28:20 Calgary Glenmore, a little bit of a lead increase for the UCP.
02:28:25 We have going around, what was the other one in Calgary we wanted?
02:28:28 Well, actually this one here.
02:28:30 Calgary Bow, yeah, Calgary Bow is UCP leading.
02:28:33 And to pop up to Edmonton, I'm not too, too optimistic yet.
02:28:37 That is a big orange box there, isn't it?
02:28:39 Edmonton is right now looking like an NDP sweep, if current trends hold.
02:28:45 And if you look at Strathcona, Sherwood Park, that is very decisively UCP right now.
02:28:50 Sherwood Park, though, leaning NDP.
02:28:52 So that's that suburban ex-urban cutoff you were talking about.
02:28:55 Yeah, no, absolutely.
02:28:59 The fact is that Edmonton has always felt kind of left out from most conservative governments.
02:29:05 It's a fact that most conservative leaders tend to come from the self-help of the province.
02:29:10 They tend to come from Calgary or are better connected to Calgary.
02:29:15 The one exception I could think of, of course, was when Ed Sjomek won,
02:29:19 but then he immediately adopted some very controversial policies on the energy sector and a few other things.
02:29:26 It's hard for Edmontonians to look and see themselves fully embodied by a party that is so kind of based in Calgary.
02:29:35 We got a super chat here from RetiredRigger38, perhaps not his legal name, who says, keep up the great work.
02:29:42 I said I wouldn't read the non-questions, but it was so nice, RetiredRigger, I had to read it. 1.00
02:29:46 Joe Uber says, down with the NDP and the Liberal Coalition, which is a very generous contribution.
02:29:54 Thank you for that, Joe Uber.
02:29:56 Obviously, I mean, the Liberals are not a political force here, but Danielle Smith did make as a pretty early commitment, 0.99
02:30:02 this idea that a vote for the NDP was a vote for Justin Trudeau,
02:30:06 which I thought was interesting and all altogether uncompelling
02:30:09 because the argument is who's going to stand up against federal intrusion, not the NDP, right?
02:30:14 Absolutely. I think that Rachel Notley just continues to show that time and again.
02:30:17 And I go back to this at Alberta Proud.
02:30:19 We've really focused on a lot of that messaging around, you know,
02:30:22 putting Notley in charge is like kicking your goalie out of the net
02:30:24 because we do have left-leaning mayors running Calgary and Edmonton.
02:30:27 We do have a left-leaning federal government.
02:30:29 so in order to get those checks and balances to get that balance representation can we afford to
02:30:35 do this also at the provincial level it truly is the NDP liberal coalition and you look at a lot of
02:30:40 I mean you look at something like just transition right getting rid of our good paying oil and gas
02:30:45 jobs in favor for quote green energy jobs whatever that means I think that means installing solar
02:30:49 panels or something like that but that was a page right out of the Alberta NDP playbook circa 2015
02:30:57 They actually used the term just transition.
02:31:00 So it's not a coincidence when you start kind of peeling back the layers
02:31:03 and looking at how much that Rachel Nolte really is in step
02:31:07 with the federal Liberals, unfortunately.
02:31:11 Yeah, we have a question from David here.
02:31:13 He says, if the UCP wins, is this indicative of a message for Canadians across the country
02:31:17 to knock it into bad policies of left-leaning government?
02:31:21 Can Alberta politics be extrapolated here, I guess, is the question.
02:31:24 Thank you, David, by the way.
02:31:25 I think that's actually really interesting.
02:31:27 You have different schools of thoughts on how a federal conservative party can win an election.
02:31:33 I think we saw one of them put into action last election, the Erin O'Toole School,
02:31:37 which was to go to the center, hug the center, be slightly more...
02:31:42 Center is a little generous there.
02:31:44 To be slightly, ever so slightly more conservative on some issues,
02:31:48 but otherwise become nearly indistinguishable in many ways.
02:31:52 And I think that failed overwhelmingly because my view has always been, why would people vote for liberal light when they can vote for real liberal and get, you know, it's like, new code was never as good as classic code.
02:32:03 Now, you know, I think one interesting thing that happened in this campaign that I think reflects the fact that the tide has turned someone against the woke, progressive nature of the activist politics of Justice Trudeau was when Calgary bureaucrats tried to cancel Canada Day fireworks.
02:32:22 They, one afternoon, said fireworks are culturally insensitive to the Chinese somehow because they invented them.
02:32:30 I'm still not 100% clear how that is culturally insensitive.
02:32:32 And to First Nations people.
02:32:34 It is insulting to First Nations people who don't feel they're part of Canada and therefore 1.00
02:32:39 they were just going to get rid of them.
02:32:41 Well, you know, the outcry from that was tremendous, you know, even though a handful of lefty city
02:32:49 councillors tried to justify it, a vote was coming of 10 city councillors out of 15 to
02:32:54 get rid of it.
02:32:55 Eventually the administration said, we do, we back them.
02:32:57 And I think that to me is reflective of the fact that you have to be, some people have
02:33:02 really taken this book missing way too far.
02:33:05 And they're trying to say things like you can't enjoy Canada Day and have fireworks because
02:33:09 that makes you racist and bigoted and typical people, average people said, no, it doesn't.
02:33:16 We just like fireworks and we aren't ashamed of a great country like Canada, which even
02:33:21 with its problems is still a remarkable place for us to live.
02:33:25 you even have indigenous leaders community leaders and people like melissa mambarkey coming out and
02:33:29 saying uh first nations people don't want to cancel canada day what are you talking about
02:33:34 so that that uh that didn't really do bode well for calgary city hall that they're making a lot
02:33:40 of kind of silly decisions right now so um and i gotta throw my hats off to my friends in common
02:33:44 sense calgary they put out a petition immediately they were all over that saying help us talk sense
02:33:50 common sense into calgary council to reverse this crazy rope woke decision to cancel canada day
02:33:56 fireworks and call it a visually spectacular display of lights and sounds visually stunning
02:34:05 you could ever think of a better government term for something
02:34:08 yukon strong who i've had on the andrew lawton show is a great advocate for firearms owners and
02:34:13 for the north uh has given a super chat he said if we chase the woke out of alberta we'll chase
02:34:17 I'm out of Ottawa, too.
02:34:18 Cheers from the north.
02:34:20 And Jen sent a super chat and said nothing at all with it.
02:34:24 So a woman of a few words, but we thank you for your generosity, Jen.
02:34:27 Let me just say on that, a question earlier from David that you were discussing about,
02:34:32 you know, is this something we can export if the UCP wins?
02:34:36 I think the inverse is a very important question here,
02:34:39 which is if conservatism can't take hold and win in Alberta, where can it?
02:34:44 And I mean, yes, we've got Saskatchewan and we've got, you know, nominally Ontario.
02:34:48 That's another discussion here.
02:34:50 So I think that's hugely important is that if Conservatives cannot hold the line in Alberta, it becomes very difficult to make the case anywhere else.
02:34:58 And I think it would make it very difficult for this, when I call it the Pierre Pauly of revolution, that's kind of taking over the nation and he's filling.
02:35:04 I mean, we've all been there. We've seen the rallies. We've seen the response.
02:35:07 I don't know the last time we've ever seen a federal Canadian Conservative politician resonate with people that way.
02:35:12 The rallies in Edmonton were like something like 5,000, 6,000 people.
02:35:16 And his rallies in the east, he's filling rooms.
02:35:19 That's the big thing.
02:35:20 My city, London, Ontario, I was chatting with his campaign manager
02:35:24 who used to work with Stephen Harper, and she was looking around
02:35:27 and saying even when Stephen Harper was here,
02:35:29 we weren't getting these numbers at the same menu.
02:35:31 You know, Stephen Harper, they were like, you know,
02:35:33 put the wall across, you know, so everyone thought the room was more full,
02:35:36 whereas with Pierre, they're like people in the hallway
02:35:38 because there's no room.
02:35:39 This is a level of energy that isn't quite comparable to what Danielle Smith commands. 0.98
02:35:44 But Danielle Smith is very much tapping into, I think, some of that momentum, certainly.
02:35:48 And I think having Pierre pitch in, well, I don't think it was all that surprising.
02:35:52 I do think it was very important to see.
02:35:56 Oh, yeah, his endorsement, you know, coming into that with the last week of the campaign, wasn't surprising?
02:36:01 No, of course not.
02:36:02 But it was really important because if there are those people out there who maybe are still on the fence about Danielle Smith
02:36:08 because of all the MSN blow-up about things,
02:36:10 things that she said, some missteps earlier in the campaign,
02:36:14 everything that's happened, the infighting with the UCP over the last two years,
02:36:18 all the COVID stuff.
02:36:19 But there's a lot of those people, they are all poly-ev all the time.
02:36:23 And to see that endorsement, maybe that's what she said,
02:36:25 you know what, I'm going to mark that ballot.
02:36:28 I mean, I think it was tremendously important as a counter-narrative to the,
02:36:32 oh, Conservatives for the first time are lending their vote to the Democrats.
02:36:36 What a way to put a bullet in that concept by saying, actually, the man who routinely gets thousands of people out is firmly in the Daniel Smith camp and urging his supporters to vote Conservative in this election.
02:36:48 Well, and I think it's also important to note as well, you may look at this map and see, oh, wow, you know, the NDP are doing really well in key pockets.
02:36:55 The riding boundaries are very different provincially from federally.
02:36:58 You know, provincially, 87 ridings in Alberta.
02:37:00 The federal Alberta ridings are, what, like in the early days?
02:37:04 No, I think it's in the 30s.
02:37:06 30s, it's that low.
02:37:07 So, yeah, there we go.
02:37:09 Ontario took all of our seats.
02:37:10 Yeah, fair enough.
02:37:11 Even more maddening.
02:37:13 A question from Andrew R., not me, I'm Andrew L.,
02:37:16 but he has a super chat.
02:37:18 Thanks for the great work.
02:37:19 Very much needed perspective.
02:37:21 It's not a question, but thank you nonetheless.
02:37:23 And Herbert Hildebrandt has a question.
02:37:25 Andrew, do you think that a Smith win
02:37:27 could embolden Conservatives across Canada
02:37:29 to be more DeSantis-Trumpian for the long term
02:37:33 and shift the map.
02:37:35 It's not often you get Trumpian as a compliment
02:37:36 from an internet commenter.
02:37:38 So thank you for that, Herbert.
02:37:40 I will say, Danielle did very good at,
02:37:43 not quite the poly-ev level of aggression,
02:37:45 but flipping the script on the journalists.
02:37:47 And even that one event she had a couple of weeks ago
02:37:49 where NDP protesters came,
02:37:52 she didn't apologize for anything.
02:37:54 She came and said,
02:37:54 see, this is what we're dealing with here.
02:37:56 So I do think she has done that,
02:37:58 kind of had that little bite that conservatives need.
02:38:01 Well, I think conservatives,
02:38:02 they need that bite for sure. 1.00
02:38:03 but conservatives have to get off the defense we have to stop apologizing for having conservative
02:38:07 values and we have to bite back when when the the woke left want to say terrible things that
02:38:13 were you know racist or homophobic or all these things well i certainly know you guys would feel
02:38:20 the same way as i do that i know tons of people who identify as you know uh gay or part of the
02:38:28 the LGBTQ community and who are you know of all creed and ethnicities and everything that are on
02:38:34 the conservative spectrum especially you see that a lot at the federal level you know when you go
02:38:37 out to Ottawa and places like that and it's just such a so ludicrous and we've got to actually
02:38:42 take we've got to be more aggressive say no you're not going to ever call me those things I'm none of
02:38:46 those things this stops now and I think Danielle has is taking the reins with that and I appreciate
02:38:52 that she's doing that I think it's smart yeah and we're we're going to cut away in just a moment to
02:38:57 head back over to the floor with Rachel Emanuel.
02:38:59 But just to give a little results
02:39:01 update here, if you're just tuning in,
02:39:03 True North Live. You're just as excited as the audience
02:39:05 is. You're like leaning over to the computer every time.
02:39:07 We have
02:39:08 380,000 votes in.
02:39:11 Quite a significant increase over
02:39:13 last update. And of those,
02:39:15 49 UCP
02:39:16 leading and 38
02:39:18 NDP leading. Now these are just
02:39:21 leading. These are not
02:39:23 necessarily elected. So when
02:39:25 we get further in the night where we have more polls
02:39:27 reporting we're going to be able to call races more definitively and that's when the cheering
02:39:30 behind us will get really really loud which will prompt us to report what it is that exactly was
02:39:36 causing all the cheering but 49 right now for the UCP to 39 NDP so we're still in that territory
02:39:43 that a lot of people thought so we're going to head back to the floor now Rachel Emanuel is there 0.98
02:39:48 with Rebecca Schultz a UCP cabinet minister who it looks like has won or is on the track to win
02:39:55 re-election in Calgary Shaw but take it away Rachel and Rebecca I am here with UCP candidate
02:40:05 Rebecca Schultz she is the candidate for Calgary Shaw Rebecca I just dared to check Twitter and
02:40:10 I'm seeing a lot of complaints from people about how long it is taking for elections Alberta to
02:40:14 tally the results what do you make of this do you think that it's taking longer than usual or you
02:40:18 think people just need to be patient and it'll get here soon enough yeah it's tough to say I've
02:40:22 been hearing that from a lot of people here tonight and some of our volunteers and supporters
02:40:26 checking in to see when they're going to get the results I don't know when that's going to be but
02:40:31 I think everybody's very excited to see what's happening tonight certainly very excited and I
02:40:35 think everyone's also hoping they're not going to be here till 2 3 a.m. as sometimes we'll see
02:40:40 so Calgary Shaw we know is a conservative safe seat everyone's expecting you to win your seat
02:40:44 again tonight some of your colleagues in Calgary I think are feeling a little bit more nervous
02:40:48 What are some ridings that you have your eye on tonight that you're saying if we lose these, you know, it could be bad for the party?
02:40:55 You know, that's a tough one for me to answer.
02:40:57 I don't trust the polls.
02:40:58 And certainly, I mean, we were out there door knocking until after 7 o'clock tonight.
02:41:02 So we're not taking anything for granted.
02:41:04 We're just working hard to the very end.
02:41:05 And I know my colleagues right across Calgary and across the province have been doing the same.
02:41:09 So when you talk about not trusting the polls, we know that they've had a couple pretty big misses in recent elections.
02:41:15 2019 they way underestimated the conservative vote 2012 you know they completely got it wrong
02:41:21 on what was expected for government so I think a lot of conservatives are saying you know I've
02:41:25 seen a lot of elections I've seen a lot of provincial elections and the polls don't really
02:41:29 go the way that they say they're going to go and so here again they're showing a very close race
02:41:34 between the NDP and the UCP with the polls that have been reported so far are you agreeing with
02:41:40 that are you saying yes it is going to be a very close race tonight or do you think the polls
02:41:44 potentially got it wrong again. You know again it's tough to say and the polls
02:41:48 obviously in the last couple of weeks have kind of been all over the place and
02:41:52 so all I all I can say is you know we know what we were seeing Calgary Shaw I
02:41:56 know what I was hearing on the doorsteps it was people saying look we cannot
02:41:59 afford to go back to the NDP we want to continue to see jobs and opportunity and
02:42:03 economic growth and a government that can balance a budget and wants to get
02:42:08 tough on crime and so you know that's what we were hearing and I sure hope
02:42:12 that we see that in the results tonight. Sure. When we talk about what you were hearing at the
02:42:16 doors, one of the things that I heard from UCP insiders is they were saying, we're really hoping
02:42:21 that jobs and the economy is going to be the ballot box question. Do you think that it wasn't
02:42:26 the ballot box question that voters were looking towards something else, maybe looking towards
02:42:30 which leader they trusted more? You know, I heard a lot about jobs, economy and affordability. And
02:42:36 so whether that was cost of living or we can't afford to go back to the NDP, those were things
02:42:41 that I often heard. I mean, you know, some also say that this was a divisive campaign. I definitely
02:42:46 heard that on the doors. I heard people say, look, I heard the NDP ads. I heard them over and over
02:42:50 and over, but I don't know what they're going to offer Albertans. We tried to run a campaign where
02:42:55 we not only highlighted our record, what we've done over the last four years, what we rolled out
02:42:59 in this spring's budget, and that we had a plan to continue to move Alberta forward, whether it
02:43:04 and affordability and lowering taxes these are things that resonated with everyday Albertans
02:43:12 who these issues were top of mind for so you represent a Calgary riding when we talk about
02:43:18 top of mind issues something that I have been covering a lot is the public safety crisis that
02:43:24 we are seeing certainly all across of Canada right now and Calgary is absolutely no exception to that
02:43:30 would you say that you have noticed a difference with people saying I used to take public
02:43:34 transit into work. I don't feel safe doing that anymore. Is that something that actually came up
02:43:38 frequently in your conversations at the door? It is and especially my riding of Calgary Shaw
02:43:43 my riding is it straddles McLeod Trail so we do have a number of C train stations especially at
02:43:49 the end of the line down in South Calgary and so this is something that did come up especially in
02:43:54 communities like Shaughnessy and Somerset where people said look I do take the train. I'm afraid
02:44:00 for my kids to take the train to school I take it every day to work here's what
02:44:04 I'm seeing and so very much people cared that we had made those additional
02:44:08 investments the pilot with the sheriffs helping out to make sure that the LRT is
02:44:12 safe the additional police officers that we invested in as well just a couple of
02:44:17 months ago but then also saying look we're gonna make sure that people feel
02:44:22 safe in their communities but we're also gonna make sure that we're investing in
02:44:25 treatment for those who are really struggling with addictions and so
02:44:28 So people saw that that was reasonable versus a party whose candidates wanted to defund the police.
02:44:34 At a time when this is a top-of-mind issue, I think that the NDP spent more time negatively affecting part of the issues that matter for people.
02:44:42 Yeah, and just because Rebecca mentioned that, I'm going to let my viewers who aren't aware just give them a little bit of information.
02:44:47 There was a lot of Alberta NDP candidates who had a history of defund the police rhetoric,
02:44:53 and Rachel Notley, of course, did not want to talk about that in the election campaign.
02:44:56 she actually said that her government would hire more police officers similar to what the UCP have
02:45:00 already done and what they're promising to do. Now when we talk about that two-part of focusing
02:45:04 on public safety but also focusing on addictions and mental health one of the interesting policies
02:45:10 that you guys put forward was the Compassion Intervention Act. I've asked a lot of guests
02:45:14 about it tonight but something that we're wondering over at True North our readers are really
02:45:17 interested in this is is this something that average voters are asking about at the doors
02:45:21 or is this a type of policy that really only resonates with people who have been touched by
02:45:25 addiction you know I think generally speaking what people care about is that
02:45:29 they feel safe in their communities they feel like they can walk around their
02:45:32 communities that their kids can walk around the communities they can take the
02:45:34 train downtown to work go see a concert or a show and feel safe right and and so
02:45:41 what that means is tackling the crime piece they want to see an additional
02:45:46 police presence and that does help with community safety but they also do see
02:45:50 people struggling with mental health and addictions and they want to know that
02:45:53 that the government cares and has a plan to address that and I think in a compassionate way
02:45:58 that really is at the heart of it about getting people the help that they need.
02:46:03 So I have to ask you again a little bit about the Alberta NDP's plan.
02:46:07 Rachel Notley was asked about safe injection sites and she said no no that's not really
02:46:11 something that our party is interested in doing. We're taking more of a hardcore public safety
02:46:17 approach similar to the UCP. What do you make of that? Do you believe her?
02:46:19 I mean, here's the thing. They have a record. And so in this election, we do have two parties running that each have a record. Our record is those investments in crime and policing, keeping community and detox spaces and mental health supports. What we saw under the NDP was kind of a sole focus on injection sites. And that was their record. That's what they focused on for four years. And so I don't think Albertans believe them.
02:46:45 We're just going to wrap up here shortly, but I have at least one or two other things
02:46:48 I want to ask you super quickly.
02:46:50 So for those of you who don't remember, Rebecca Schultz actually ran in the UCP leadership
02:46:53 race.
02:46:54 And I've gotten a couple of compliments on your ability to handle the media in the time
02:46:58 since then.
02:46:59 People said, you know, she's really worked her way up in her public speaking and made
02:47:03 a lot of gains in her abilities to talk to media and talk to your crowd since the UCP 0.85
02:47:07 leadership race.
02:47:08 And I'm wondering if you felt that that has given you more confidence as a campaigner
02:47:12 And if you felt that has been, you know, an advantage at the doors, having that experience as running for the leader of the party.
02:47:18 Well, thank you. I've never really thought about it that way when I'm out there on the doors.
02:47:22 And this was when I first ran in 2018. And you're running in a nomination against other conservative supporters.
02:47:28 So you have to think about what makes you different. And my approach is just to be genuine to I don't have the answers all the time.
02:47:34 and to be able to say that and to make people know and feel that I am really there to serve them,
02:47:40 that I want to hear their frustrations or their aspirations and their hopes for what Alberta is to be
02:47:46 and then take that and try to do something about it and just to remember who I'm there to serve and to work for.
02:47:52 And I think that makes a difference as well.
02:47:55 Yeah, absolutely. And I think, you know, the party has recognized that because you have been front and center
02:47:58 in many of the announcements that have been made over the last few weeks.
02:48:01 just the last thing that I want to ask you here is we have a couple polls reporting now you know
02:48:06 it is taking a little bit of time but are you feeling confident in what we're seeing so far
02:48:11 tonight are the numbers trending in the direction that you want to see I haven't seen any of the
02:48:17 results because largely I've been uh sitting here chatting uh with you and some of the other folks
02:48:21 in the media um but I think you know longer than people would like but I'm still optimistic and I
02:48:27 think people here are feeling the same way yeah absolutely well thank you so much for your time
02:48:31 we really appreciate that again that was rebecca schultz the ucp candidate for calgary shaw she is
02:48:37 expected to hold her seat tonight and we're of course really looking forward to getting some of
02:48:41 those solid results and sharing with them done with you a little bit later and we're going to
02:48:46 head back to andrew now thank you rebecca thank you
02:48:57 If you are just tuning in, this is shaping up to be a bit of a nail-biter as a lot of
02:49:10 ridings, despite being relatively small, are very slow to report their numbers.
02:49:15 I'm here with William McBeth from True North, Lindsay Wilson from Alberta Proud, and let's
02:49:20 just talk about some of the latest numbers here.
02:49:22 We are currently at 51 UCP leading, 36 NDP leading.
02:49:28 This is with 514,000 votes cast.
02:49:32 We zoom in on the numbers here.
02:49:34 We haven't been given a lot of love to Lethbridge.
02:49:36 Both of the Lethbridge seats are leading NDP.
02:49:39 I think one of them, there was some thinking that maybe the UCP might be able to pull it off.
02:49:44 They still could, but right now that's not where things are headed.
02:49:48 In Calgary, the NDP have kept the lead in Acadia.
02:49:52 which is Tyler Shandro's riding.
02:49:55 Narrow lead, 93 votes, with only 7 of 18 polls reporting.
02:50:00 So just under halfway through there.
02:50:02 In Calgary, Glenmore, UCP are holding.
02:50:04 And Banff, your girl Miranda Rosen, has extended her lead to 978 votes.
02:50:12 That is a huge switch.
02:50:13 With 8 of 26 polls reporting.
02:50:15 So, again, if the Banff and Canmore ones are the ones they haven't put in yet,
02:50:19 that could change yet.
02:50:21 We look in the other ridings here.
02:50:24 We've got Calgary Elbow, which is an NDP lead.
02:50:28 Calgary Curry, a pretty decisive NDP lead.
02:50:31 What were the other good ones in Calgary you were watching, William?
02:50:34 I'm interested in Calgary Edgemont.
02:50:37 That's another riding that the UCB are hoping to hold on to.
02:50:39 All right. In Calgary, Edgemont. Right now, the NDP leading with 12 of 18 polls reporting by about 300 votes.
02:50:52 Yeah, it's, you know, some of these ridings, I think, are just tough.
02:50:56 They were always going to be a little bit closer this election than they were.
02:50:59 That was pegged to be a difficult one from the go.
02:51:01 That was going to be. But, you know, overall, I think that number sitting around 50, 51 seats
02:51:08 for the United Conservative Party is where I think most of us were expecting it to land.
02:51:13 So, I mean, it's not over till it's over.
02:51:15 We don't have to count every single vote to know the outcome,
02:51:18 but you do have to count a decent chunk.
02:51:20 Well, Calgary Klein was one you mentioned earlier that was looking like an NDP gain.
02:51:26 Right now, that is actually not looking to be the case in the numbers.
02:51:31 We have 7 of 18 polls reporting.
02:51:33 So, again, still a bit of room.
02:51:34 but right now Jeremy Nixon holding a 130 or so vote lead.
02:51:40 So at what point is a lead too big to really escape with polls coming in?
02:51:48 That's such an interesting question because my candidates always ask me,
02:51:51 when do I know if I've won or lost?
02:51:54 One of the challenges is riding groups of people, different communities.
02:52:02 One part of your writing might be very, very pro-United Conservative Party, and another part of it might be more NDP.
02:52:09 Unless you know where the polls are in that writing, it's hard to be able to say, oh, we're safe in this one or we're not.
02:52:18 I'll give you a personal and sad example.
02:52:22 When we were doing Joan Crockett's campaign back in the 2015 federal election, we were still waiting on something like 10 polls.
02:52:28 Joan was leading by a small amount.
02:52:31 But when I plotted on a map where all the outstanding polls were,
02:52:35 realized it was all from downtown and from the Beltline for the East Village,
02:52:38 I said, Joan, even though it shows us we're ahead,
02:52:41 I don't think we're going to hold on to it.
02:52:43 And sadly, of course, we didn't.
02:52:45 Yeah, and I think that's the tough chance.
02:52:48 I mean, there's a whole bunch of political wisdom that is circulated
02:52:51 that is very difficult when you're the candidate on the ground
02:52:54 and you just want to make sure you can clinch a victory here.
02:52:56 I mean, ultimately, the old line is, you know, you need how many votes to win, one more than the other candidate.
02:53:02 When you're in functionally a two-party race, it's a little bit more direct than that to see it.
02:53:08 But even then, a lot of these Calgary riotings are very, very close.
02:53:12 We're seeing, you know, back and forth when one poll goes in by, you know, 50 vote, 100 vote margins.
02:53:17 So, again, this idea of some NDP insurgency is not happening, at least it's safe to say.
02:53:24 I don't think so.
02:53:25 You know, going back to what you're saying, it really depends where these poles are located.
02:53:29 And my horse there, Miss Miranda Rosen out in Banff Kananaskis, that might be indicative of that.
02:53:34 She's got a very strong lead right now.
02:53:36 An hour ago, we were seeing a much more smaller lead, a little bit playing around in there.
02:53:41 Or the NDP.
02:53:42 Exactly.
02:53:43 But then again, if those poles are coming in from Prittis and they're coming in from Elbow 1.00
02:53:48 and they're coming in from Bragg Creek versus then we might see a complete swing.
02:53:53 But, I mean, there's really no shockers here.
02:53:56 Certainly, you know, we were talking before, well, what does the Eusepi need to lose, right?
02:54:01 And they need to lose 14 out of 15 of their swing ridings.
02:54:05 I don't see that happening at this point.
02:54:07 I think we're going to land at a very minimum on 47, at the minimum.
02:54:11 Yeah, and I'll just add another one of the Calgary ridings that Rachel Emanuel was talking about earlier, Calgary Cross.
02:54:16 This is Mickey Amory's riding.
02:54:18 He is leading right now, but only by 62 votes and only three polls in.
02:54:24 So that one, I think, is still a bit of a toss-up and could go in a different direction there.
02:54:30 So one thing I'll point up here is that we are going to go back to the floor.
02:54:35 Rachel Emanuel is talking to a guy who's a very fascinating figure in Alberta politics.
02:54:40 I've had him on my show, and with even riding his horse, which in retrospect is very cruel to the horse,
02:54:45 but the horse seemed to do all right with it and that is Tarek Elnega and Tarek Elnega
02:54:51 formerly ran for leader of the Maverick Party but now he's been pretty enthusiastic with
02:54:58 Danielle Smith so in just a moment actually right now we will go to Rachel Emanuel with
02:55:04 Tarek Elnega. I'm here with Tariq Angala he is a conservative commentator so first thing I want
02:55:12 to ask you about is results are taking a really long time tonight people are getting frustrated
02:55:16 twitter is going crazy what's your take why do you think it's taking so long tonight
02:55:20 i think the usual technical delays or you know additional scrutineering or so on i'm not going
02:55:26 to say that anything bad is happening so it's just you know what i say the longer it takes the the
02:55:31 more fun the after party will be so yeah that's fair enough i think that's a good perspective
02:55:35 so we do have some polls reporting are you happy with what you're seeing so far do you think that
02:55:40 things are trending, you know, in the direction of the
02:55:43 or do you think it could go either way at this point?
02:55:46 No, I think it's bang on.
02:55:47 My personal prediction, Rachel, is it's going to be in the early 50s
02:55:50 in terms of seats, 51, 52, 53 in that range for the UCP.
02:55:55 That's my guess and I think that's where it's going to go.
02:55:57 So pretty much on trend there.
02:56:00 And when we talk about, you know, seat projection,
02:56:02 what are ridings that you're keeping a close eye on tonight?
02:56:05 So the closer you get to downtown Calgary,
02:56:07 physically the closer you're going to have to look at riding.
02:56:10 So whether that's Acadia, Varsity, I look at, for example, Elbow and Bow, those are all ridings that are really close.
02:56:18 And what's dangerous about those is even if the UCP win, the NDP candidates running on those ridings are relatively activist candidates.
02:56:25 They're anti-oil. They're very pro-big government, pro-big AHS.
02:56:29 It would be disappointing to see them in the legislature.
02:56:31 So those are the ones to watch because, again, even if the NDP lose and those candidates are in the ledge,
02:56:36 they're going to have a voice that I think goes against Alberta's values. 0.72
02:56:41 And when we talk about some of those candidates having more, you know, radical views, anti-oil views,
02:56:46 something that we observed during the election was that the NDP actually ran as a fairly moderate campaign.
02:56:55 Is that something that you noticed as well?
02:56:56 And do you think that voters sort of fell for it?
02:56:58 Or do you think that they remembered what it was like under an NDP government?
02:57:02 I think the thing is, within the urban ridings, you're seeing a very different demographic to 2019.
02:57:08 So there's a lot of folks that moved either out of country or out of province into Alberta over the last four years.
02:57:15 And there's also a new generation of voters in the urban area.
02:57:19 The thing is, in terms of whether memories are long or short, I think if you go to rural Alberta,
02:57:24 they know very, very firsthand what the disaster the NDP was from 2015 to 2019.
02:57:30 Within the urban area, I think a lot more of a mixed vote.
02:57:33 And that's why, you know, up until last night, it's close.
02:57:36 And that's why I think it's going to be tight.
02:57:38 That being said, those candidates haven't been called out.
02:57:41 They've been kind of doing it on their own.
02:57:43 But if you look into their backgrounds, and this is no conspiracy, they didn't hide this.
02:57:47 A lot of them are anti-oil or pro-big government.
02:57:51 Okay, great.
02:57:52 And, Tarek, just my last question for you here.
02:57:54 What do you think really was the ballot box question of the 2023 Alberta Provincial Election Campaign?
02:58:01 I think it's always common sense policy, economics, jobs, affordability, and a prosperous Alberta.
02:58:08 If there's really one ballot box question, it's definitely do we have a prosperous Alberta or not.
02:58:13 Great. Thank you so much. Once again, that was Tarek Ngala. We're going to head back over to you now, Andrew.
02:58:21 What are you looking for?
02:58:24 All right, we are back. Sorry, I got very excited looking up Robby Picard's magazine, Oil and Gas World magazine.
02:58:31 We swapped in a good friend of Independent Media who does Independent Media himself promoting the oil and gas sector.
02:58:38 You've come down from Fort McMurray to be with us here.
02:58:41 And just while we're talking about results, you've got to explain to me what's going on in Fort McMurray-Wood, Buffalo,
02:58:46 where there's this giant orange splotch on the map right now. What's happening, Robby? What did you do?
02:58:52 So this is a very interesting situation. So what happened was is you've got
02:58:57 Tani Yao and I'm it's really hard for me because I'm literally friends with all of them. I know all of them
02:59:02 So this is a very unique situation. I know them all personally, but here's basically what happened is that
02:59:08 Zol Keefe beat Tani in the nomination, then he was disqualified which puts which put
02:59:14 Tani back in because Tani wasn't running Funky Benjoko decided she was gonna run our city councillor and then you got 1.00
02:59:21 But the Alberta party, so he's, for the first time, you have a little bit of vote splitting happening in our riding.
02:59:28 So I'll be interesting to see.
02:59:30 I'm not, I have to admit that I was a little surprised the NDP are doing, considering how lazy they were.
02:59:35 They didn't even show up to the debates.
02:59:37 There's barely any signs.
02:59:39 But it also goes to show you that even if you're an incumbent, you can't be cocky or arrogant or assume that your seat is safe.
02:59:46 So I think, if anything, this is an eye-opener that all the UCP members need to do with some humanization and not just assume that it's in the bag.
02:59:56 Yeah, and let's talk about the Fort McMurray voter here because I know oftentimes we see in the U.S. you have all these Democrats that move to red states and they bring all of their Democrat voting habits with them.
03:00:08 And Fort McMurray draws people from all around the country, notably Atlantic Canada.
03:00:12 Do they bring their political persuasions with them?
03:00:15 Or are the ones that go to Fort Mac to work in the oil patch,
03:00:18 are they pretty reliable conservative voters?
03:00:20 I would say, at the end of the day, as a rule, yeah.
03:00:23 Fort McMurray very rarely, if it goes conservative, it goes like Wild Rose conservative.
03:00:28 Or it doesn't...
03:00:29 So all the Newfoundlanders in Fort Mac, when they start voting in Alberta, they're voting UCB.
03:00:33 They want jobs.
03:00:34 They want their jobs to be protected.
03:00:36 And the union doesn't necessarily...
03:00:37 think that even though the union supports ndp there's some uncertainty of what can happen but
03:00:43 we are probably the most multicultural city in canada i would even argue that we're more
03:00:47 multicultural than even montreal but when they're there and they understand the importance of the
03:00:51 oil sands they understand the importance of what fort mcmurray brings the rest of this country
03:00:57 i i think they kind of they they will go with the party that will protect that the most but i mean
03:01:02 I mean, it wasn't that long ago that the NDP beat the PCs when Brian Jean was the Wild Rose.
03:01:06 So, I mean, it doesn't surprise me that there is a little bit of pushback against the UCP a little bit.
03:01:13 Well, let's talk about Brian Jean.
03:01:14 We haven't really spoken about him tonight.
03:01:16 He's a guy that vied for the UCP leadership himself, formerly was the UCP leader.
03:01:21 I know there has been some hostility between him and Daniel Smith,
03:01:25 that they've been very good teammates since Daniel Smith won by all accounts.
03:01:29 Do you think that's been...
03:01:31 Oh, I mean, you know, Brian's had such a complex history with one or more of our conservative parties at the provincial level.
03:01:40 Yeah, well, he was a federal MP, too, though.
03:01:42 He was a federal MP. He was representing a very important riding in the parliament.
03:01:47 But, of course, he was the one riding against Jason Kenney, ostensibly to lead the new United Conservative Party.
03:01:53 When that didn't go his way, he decided to move on and do something else with his time.
03:01:59 But then, I think he never really left.
03:02:02 I think he decided he was still the right choice to lead the party, and you saw him come back in that leadership race.
03:02:08 Where I think his plan kind of went a little off the rails was when Daniel Smith campaigned on essentially the same policy platform, but took it one step further than he did.
03:02:19 And, you know, we had a conversation with his longtime political associate, Vitor Marciano earlier, and Vitor once did say, you know, we wouldn't have expected that that was her strategy, and it really did kind of leave us in the lurch.
03:02:33 Yeah, that was the leadership in which there was this, like, weird semantical haggling over sovereignty versus autonomy.
03:02:39 No, I didn't want sovereignty, I wanted autonomy.
03:02:41 It's like, well, you know, to the average voter, that was a very difficult thing to distinguish here.
03:02:46 We were talking earlier on the panel before you joined, Robbie, about the NDP's relationship with the oil and gas sector.
03:02:52 Now, you actually, to your credit, have tried very hard to make inroads with the NDP.
03:02:58 And I think in some cases, you've succeeded.
03:03:00 Where do you rank that party generally on the issues that you care about?
03:03:04 So, back when Rachel Notley became premier, I met with her.
03:03:09 And I got her actually to wear the I Love Oil Sands hoodie, which was kind of a legendary...
03:03:12 And it didn't disintegrate when she put it on.
03:03:14 No, she did. And for her credit, I think she fought hard on the Trans Mountain Pipeline.
03:03:20 She was likable. The problem, though, is it's not so much her. It's the federal NDP. 0.93
03:03:26 It's what are they? What is the end game for Fort McMurray? What is the end game for oil and gas industry?
03:03:32 And I don't trust that they will protect our industry in an offensive way, like not so much like she accepted the carbon tax.
03:03:43 There's all these decisions that hurt us.
03:03:45 The only thing that really scares me is I, not to go kind of sideways from oil and gas,
03:03:50 but I was talking to some people from a region where they got rid of the coal industry
03:03:54 and they were devastated.
03:03:57 Like when you shut down these industries for so-called woke values
03:04:02 without an understanding of the direct economic effects,
03:04:06 I think that's scary and that happened a lot in the Parkland district
03:04:09 and it took them a long time to get over that.
03:04:11 so i don't think that there are strong enough defenders of the oil and gas industry i think
03:04:16 that what we will what we will see more and more of is that saudi arabia and nigeria and russia
03:04:22 will take a lot of our market share if we don't get aggressive there is no such thing as green
03:04:28 energy um their oil industry isn't going anywhere but what happens to our oil industry i think we
03:04:36 need to wake up and be more aware of how easily it could be cut if we don't protect it yeah and
03:04:41 And it's interesting when you mention, you know, the coal industry, because the old sort of model NDP voter was this, you know, union blue-collar worker.
03:04:50 Many of them in Alberta would have worked in coal, would have worked in mining, would have worked in oil and gas.
03:04:54 And it is a strange little dilemma that the NDP has, where it's like, we're going to stand up for, you know, the old blue-collar unionized worker.
03:05:02 But no, no, no, not you guys.
03:05:03 Not the ones in this sector, because you are right.
03:05:05 They've just decided this, you know, woke virtue signaling takes precedence over that.
03:05:10 Well, you know, and what's really funny is such a facade, like if you look at Jack McZine, I mean, you want to talk about, he drives a BMW, he's super rich, you know what I mean?
03:05:18 He has a $10,000 Rolex and he's going to be the beacon of social values and speak out for people.
03:05:23 I mean, it's ridiculous, you know, and that's the thing that I, I grew up NDP in Saskatchewan.
03:05:28 Like it was, I had like the worker versus the business and I was comfortable with that.
03:05:35 But now you've got kind of the NDP, like, especially with the guy that, the head of the union, the 955 union, that, not 955, Unifor.
03:05:44 Oh, yeah.
03:05:44 Jerry G.S., right?
03:05:45 Yeah.
03:05:45 He gets basically kicked out for some crazy allegations of fraud and all that type of stuff.
03:05:50 And those are the guys that are pulling millions of dollars in support away from the Conservatives,
03:05:57 even though in the weird world, I would argue that the Conservatives are more pro-union than the NDP
03:06:02 because the Conservatives are protecting the jobs
03:06:04 that pays those union dues so they can be so political.
03:06:07 You kind of have to laugh at the political history.
03:06:09 If you had told a British Conservative
03:06:12 that the left had lost the support of the coal miners
03:06:17 and the people who work in coal, 0.98
03:06:19 they would think you were a lunatic
03:06:21 because that is literally the heart and soul of the left in Britain 0.92
03:06:25 was the coal mining and coal mining union.
03:06:27 Here, I do think, though, talking of coal,
03:06:30 which is a very interesting thing,
03:06:31 I think it was a misstep from how Premier Kenney tried to talk about reintroducing or reinvigorating coal production in Alberta.
03:06:41 I don't think it was particularly well explained.
03:06:44 And it provided an opening, I think, to the New Democrats to say,
03:06:48 oh, we're the guardians of our precious natural landscapes and our pristine...
03:06:52 I mean, the joke, of course, being that none of them ever go into the nature.
03:06:56 They all live in cities.
03:06:57 But I think that was something where, if you look at a writing like Banff, Canada, and Askes,
03:07:01 where the threat of, say, large-scale coal mining would have been a problem for Miranda
03:07:07 Rosa to explain.
03:07:08 So I think that's why you've seen some movement now, trying to walk back and modify positioning
03:07:14 and messaging.
03:07:15 If you are just tuning in, welcome.
03:07:17 This is the North Alberta Allowed Results Show.
03:07:20 Just to give another plug here, we only get to do this because of the support of our supporters.
03:07:26 So please do head on over to donate.tnc.news.
03:07:29 And if you're watching on YouTube and you want to make a super chat contribution, you can ask a question and we will put it to our panel, which include yours truly, Andrew Lawton, Robbie Picard of the Fantastic Oil Sands Campaign.
03:07:42 Show off the shirt. I've got one of those hoodies. I didn't wear it today because I knew it would be a little warm in here.
03:07:48 and William Macbeth from True North.
03:07:51 Just to give you the lay of the numbers here,
03:07:53 753,821 votes cast, 52% of polls reporting now,
03:08:01 which I think is very important.
03:08:02 So we're starting to see a little bit more formation
03:08:05 in the numbers that we're coming to you with.
03:08:08 We've had a couple of races declared, most not all that surprising.
03:08:12 We're still monitoring some of the Calgary ridings as they come in.
03:08:16 Just to check in with Edmonton here.
03:08:18 Well, no, we'll do a little old Lethbridge.
03:08:20 Lethbridge still both are going NDP, and that's looking fairly certain.
03:08:25 We have in NDP territory in Edmonton still a big box around Edmonton that is orange.
03:08:32 We've still got Strathcona-Sherwood Park.
03:08:36 Then you go to the neighboring riding of Sherwood Park,
03:08:40 and it is leading NDP pretty decisively right now, that one, 1,700 votes.
03:08:45 and Edmonton Southwest, KC Magu, we were watching that one.
03:08:49 Still only three polls reporting there, which is a little odd.
03:08:52 Is this common in elections, in your experience, this delay?
03:08:56 I mean, everyone here seems to be getting pretty restless now.
03:08:58 No, I would say this is unusual.
03:09:00 I really can't understand why after an hour and a half of counting,
03:09:04 they've been unable to get beyond three polling stations reporting.
03:09:07 That's unusual.
03:09:08 Yeah, they've now had two hours and 38 minutes.
03:09:12 So, and we're long past that one polling station somewhere that was open until like 9.46.
03:09:18 So now we can genuinely say all are closed.
03:09:21 Of course, Andrew, we all know that sometimes math is hard.
03:09:23 Yeah.
03:09:24 You know, maybe that's the explanation.
03:09:26 Yeah.
03:09:26 And then to jump back into Calgary.
03:09:29 So this is a bit of an interesting one.
03:09:31 Calgary Klein, now 10 polls reporting.
03:09:35 Jeremy Nixon of the UCP Live.
03:09:37 So this could end up being a bit more of a horse race than even, I think, some of the more pessimistic people thought.
03:09:45 No, absolutely.
03:09:46 Calvary Klein, I think, was going to be a target for the New Democrats. 0.81
03:09:49 They believe that that's close enough to the center of the city, the core of the city, that it would be vulnerable.
03:09:55 Jeremy Nixon, of course, one of two Nixons we have in the Alberta legislature. 0.99
03:10:01 And, you know, I think that he was always going to be in a tough fight, along with people like Nick Millican and Calvary Curry, and some of them, and Varsity, like Jason Copping. Those are some challenging riding things for the UCB to all go on.
03:10:16 just like right before my eyes it flipped from an NDP lead back to uh Tyler Chandro UCP lead
03:10:26 again nine of 18 polls reporting so we're halfway there uh he's got a an 11 point lead right now
03:10:32 uh so this one I think we're probably going to see flip back and forth before the the night is up
03:10:36 right no absolutely I I think that uh you know Calgary Katie was my belt by the riding that I
03:10:43 I thought it was riding that for various reasons, the New Democrats are going to try and target.
03:10:51 And it's kind of riding that isn't natural New Democrat territory, but they have to win if they were to win this election.
03:10:58 I think that, I think after this, when they analyze, UCB analyzes,
03:11:04 they're going to have to really dig into Calgary and understand that Calgary's demographic is changing
03:11:09 and how they target people in calgary they're gonna have to target a little different you know
03:11:14 and i also think that like i think we need to like as a gay guy one of my themes is is that i think
03:11:20 that they need to find a way to stay out of people's bedrooms including in calgary and just
03:11:26 say look i want fiscal responsibility i want a strong oil and gas industry and then i want the
03:11:30 freedom which i think we all agree on to live my life as i choose and i think that that i think
03:11:36 the fear not that most of the ucp candidates i know and all the people in the party they're
03:11:40 pretty cool tell them they're gay anyway like i mean it's there's more gays in the ucp than
03:11:44 they ever admit but i think the perception to a lot of people in calgary is that they're not
03:11:49 as open like even in edmonton i was surprised like i had some meetings with some top business
03:11:54 people in calgary and they were all pro danielle smith and the top people in edmonton these are
03:11:58 people worth hundreds of millions of dollars in edmonton well they thought she was completely 0.98
03:12:02 different than the person i know she is so i think that that is something if i was as i'm going like
03:12:09 humanize your candidates and show a more personal side because most people want to own a home save
03:12:17 money have low taxes and cheap and affordable energy yeah very well said uh just reading a
03:12:23 couple of the super chats here brayden maz uh didn't offer a question or comment with his just
03:12:27 gave a nice contribution i actually know brayden so thank you brayden i mean i think everyone that
03:12:32 that I don't know also, but I just happen to know, Brayden.
03:12:34 And to your point from earlier, this one's interesting.
03:12:37 This is from a woman identified as the Dandelion Way.
03:12:40 Danielle acknowledged vaccine mandates were human rights violations,
03:12:43 not as the official opposition offered no resistance and still promotes them.
03:12:47 Was this a factor for rebuilding trust for UCP?
03:12:50 I think the interesting thing here, this woman says, I was an NDP voter once.
03:12:55 So we are seeing NDP-UCP shifts.
03:12:58 And I think, again, I mean, the COVID situation, Danielle Smith did have a very strong position on that,
03:13:03 that certainly does set her apart from the NBG.
03:13:06 Well, you know, I'm fully vaccinated, but here's what I found very interesting.
03:13:11 A guy in Fort McMurray that's a successful manager has one of the smartest people I know and I work with.
03:13:19 He's not vaccinated. And he explained to me why he's not vaccinated.
03:13:24 And I was shocked at the amount of people that I would have thought would have been the first to get vaccinated, not get vaccinated.
03:13:31 So I think that this hardcore attack on people who chose not to get vaccinated was a mistake.
03:13:39 You know, like one of my family members is a teacher, and she was told that if she didn't get vaccinated, she'd lose her job.
03:13:48 That she got vaccinated, and now her menstrual cycle is not the same ever since.
03:13:54 And when I bring that up, people don't care.
03:13:55 They're like, well, you know, that's as it could be.
03:13:57 I'm like, to take that kind of non-caring approach to people who made a medical choice for them,
03:14:04 I can totally understand how she probably gained a lot of quiet support
03:14:07 because a lot of the NDP supporters did not want to get vaccinated.
03:14:11 This was beyond parties.
03:14:12 This was a very personal issue.
03:14:14 And I think it's a huge mistake to attack the unvaccinated. 0.98
03:14:17 And I think the premier was very true when she kind of stood up for them a bit.
03:14:23 Well, and I think to the discussion we were having earlier, to broaden it out a bit, you know, the NDP trying to say that it should stand as the beneficiary of, you know, UCP to NDP swings.
03:14:32 Well, there can be swings going the other way as well.
03:14:34 And I think in this election, for whatever reason, there have to be at least a few voters out there that are saying, you know, I've always been an NDP, but this Danielle Smith woman isn't as scary.
03:14:43 You know, the interesting thing about vaccination, I agree with Robbie, it wasn't a left-right issue.
03:14:48 It didn't fall exactly on partisan lines, even if large chunks of it maybe did.
03:14:53 But definitely there were cohorts that didn't, and I think if you look at the federal election,
03:14:57 you saw a lot of Green voters who didn't have a candidate because the Green Party collapsed heading into the election.
03:15:04 And they went from the Green Party to the People's Party, which would not have been a natural assumption you might have made about other issues.
03:15:12 But they identify themselves as non-conforming or outside of the consensus on this issue.
03:15:20 issue and they saw the Green Party being that way and they saw the People's Party
03:15:24 being that way. Absolutely voters shifted on this issue. Yeah and I mean we were
03:15:28 obviously talking earlier about some of the fringe right-of-center parties in
03:15:32 this election which as we're seeing in the numbers are you know not even
03:15:35 flipping. I mean I'm not even seeing them and federally there's the backdrop
03:15:39 right now of the by-elections specifically Portage-Lisker where you
03:15:42 have a conservative stronghold and Maxime Bernier running for the PPC in it.
03:15:46 But I do think that Danielle Smith is a fairly crossover candidate,
03:15:50 certainly on different factions of the conservative movement.
03:15:53 Because, you know, even though the hard line of the party on the right side obviously liked her,
03:16:00 she herself is not easy to put into a box like that.
03:16:03 I mean, she's very moderate on social issues.
03:16:06 She's very policy-oriented.
03:16:08 So even if you don't agree with her, she's always been able to kind of explain why she approaches a certain issue.
03:16:14 And I think your point about humanizing is especially important with Danielle Smith because she will never be the caricature that they make her out to be.
03:16:21 My biggest hope is that the conservatives, both federally and provincially, seem to be a bit cannibalistic and they want to eat their own.
03:16:30 I really hope that when she wins tonight that they give her time for the public to get to know her because when you get to know her, she's great. 0.98
03:16:38 Like, I mean, I did a video where, you know, I just challenged people to give her a chance.
03:16:44 And I mean, I've hung out with Rachel Notley, Jason Kenney, Pierre Polyev, Jean Charest.
03:16:49 I've hung out with them all.
03:16:50 And out of all the politicians, I've never seen anyone listen better in my life than she's in a room of people and she listens to me.
03:17:01 She doesn't even have to agree.
03:17:02 But it's not that you're a typical, you know, BS politician that just kind of, oh, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
03:17:06 she's well why do you feel that way she challenges it and she and she's challenging it so she 0.98
03:17:11 understands so i really hope that they the party unites and and and kind of loses this sort of
03:17:18 self-promoting narcissism which exists in there yeah and actually gets behind her because you 1.00
03:17:24 know she's what they need right now i i think she's the female ralph klein she's not perfect 0.99
03:17:30 she's gonna make a misstep you know she's gonna say something like shoot shovel and shut up you 1.00
03:17:34 you know she's going to do all these things but at the end of the day it's for the betterment of 0.67
03:17:38 alberta and it makes alberta a better place to have a fighter and just transition you know that
03:17:44 comes from greenpeace and naomi klein and sappora bermin and now that's moderate it's not a moderate
03:17:51 energy policy no quality by any stretch so you can't take their wording you can't do it like
03:17:56 rachel would do and be like okay well we're gonna have our own carbon tax and we're gonna have that
03:17:59 no you're not going to give us the carbon tax we're not accepting to shut down our main industry
03:18:04 which also provides a great deal of the gdp for this entire country in ottawa like it's we need
03:18:11 someone to kind of say whoa trudeau no and that that's not an easy find so let me go to you on
03:18:17 this william and the bigger picture building off that is the comeback narrative and certainly when
03:18:22 she won the leadership was a big part of it and i made a point in a column i wrote that you know
03:18:28 It was difficult for me to say Danielle Stitt was back because in so many ways she never left.
03:18:32 I mean, she went pretty heavily into a different career other than politics.
03:18:37 She went back into media and really did spend time putting in the legwork, building up her relationships.
03:18:43 And the story that I've told you, she and I were alternating on hosting on 770 CHQR in Calgary.
03:18:51 What was fascinating is I would see the text messages that listeners would send in.
03:18:56 And when I would log in after her, if I were doing the show after her or whatever,
03:19:01 I'd see just the vicious, vicious things that people said about her. 1.00
03:19:05 And I would not wish that on anyone.
03:19:07 And you could hear in her voice when she was on air that every now and then she would get rattled by this.
03:19:11 But she kept plugging away, and she won those people back. 0.96
03:19:16 And ironically, some of her closest friends, I think when she ran for the leadership,
03:19:19 were the people that were her most vicious enemies back in 2015.
03:19:23 Yeah, I mean, I wrongly believe that Daniel Smith was done in politics after the border crossing.
03:19:31 I think it's because I just couldn't figure out how someone could come back from that much anger,
03:19:38 or even who would want to, who would want to willingly subject themselves to month after month of the outpouring of anger that she did.
03:19:49 But to her credit, I think she emerged from it and impressed a lot of people in the process.
03:19:56 They were impressed in her grit and her determination to weather all of that.
03:20:02 And then, you know, she enters this round of this election far more of experience than when she entered the 2012 election, for example.
03:20:13 People forget, of course, Daniel Smith wasn't a politician.
03:20:16 She was working as an advocacy person in a big tank or in an advocacy group, and then went from being the Walrose, the leader of this tiny little new party to serious contender of an election in, you know, less than three years.
03:20:31 It was a remarkably short period of time.
03:20:33 And, you know, I just don't think she knew she had experience in politics that she knew was seasoned enough to handle the difficulties because this was her first election.
03:20:45 She had never run for anything before trying to become premier of Alberta.
03:20:49 That's a really big step to say.
03:20:51 So obviously she doesn't have to do that this time. 0.66
03:20:53 She can say, I know this job better.
03:20:54 I've been doing it for six months.
03:20:56 So let me finish the job I've started.
03:20:58 Yeah, and also, I mean, this is the first time she's done it as UCP leader.
03:21:02 I mean, that's, I think, a part of the dynamic that it's easy to miss.
03:21:04 This is a different party entirely than the Wild Rose of 2012 and 2015 was.
03:21:10 I think the biggest thing conservatives across this country have to do is
03:21:13 The time they spend infighting hurts, like between even Maxime Bernier and he didn't win, so he goes his own way, gets his own party.
03:21:23 The energy in infighting is destroying the movement across this entire country.
03:21:30 So I think that's the first wake-up call.
03:21:32 When it comes to Premier Smith, look, I know so many here.
03:21:36 I was broke-ass when I came to Fort McMurray, okay?
03:21:39 I came from Montreal. I lived in a tent. I had no money. I made some bad decisions.
03:21:43 before and i rebuilt myself i know so many people who come to fort mcmurray who turn their lives
03:21:49 around she's an alberta story massive high total low back on top and that's that belief in yourself
03:21:57 that you're not going to give up that's why i respect her i really really like her i i think
03:22:01 that that i mean my god to go from that to being the premier you got to give her credit the essence
03:22:07 of the alberta's calling yeah that alberta is the the land of opportunity here uh we have one
03:22:12 question from snow canadian no snow canadian i apologize if i'm not pronouncing that right uh
03:22:18 do you think voters that work or make their living from government money plays into voting for the
03:22:22 ndp in edmonton uh does throwing votes worry you on the future government where the government
03:22:28 money to control uh the vote is ndp uh is edmonton ndp territory because edmonton's the capital is
03:22:34 basically the question i mean look i i don't think it's coincidence that the ndp is doing
03:22:39 better in a city that has 60,000 government employees, a huge swath of which belong to
03:22:45 public sector unions, who have benefited from very good salaries, very good pensions and
03:22:50 benefits, and have absolute job security.
03:22:54 So, sure, yes, I do think that's the case.
03:22:56 I don't think that reflects Edmonton as a whole.
03:22:59 I think there are an awful lot of Edmontonians who are just like Calgarians, who believe
03:23:02 in hard work, opportunity, pursuing success.
03:23:06 It's just, it's maybe not quite so obvious or on the surface as it is here.
03:23:12 But, you know, I think it would be a real mistake though for the UCP to simply give up on Edmonton as a whole.
03:23:19 I think maybe it will take more than one election cycle.
03:23:23 But there's definitely a chance for the UCP to begin building back support.
03:23:27 And I look at Ralph Klein, who when he won was never really well liked at Edmonton.
03:23:33 In fairness, Edmonton, you know, he did say he wasn't a big fan of Edmonton, which probably didn't endear him.
03:23:40 But through hard work, he did eventually build up support and could win, you know, a substantial number of seats.
03:23:47 Now, I think it's important for Edmonton to have representation in a united conservative government.
03:23:51 I really hope that this city doesn't only vote New Democrat and then have no voice at the government table when important decisions are being made.
03:24:00 tonight is should be Acadia watch because one more poll came in and it flipped once again
03:24:07 back to an NDP lead so Calgary Acadia has 11 polls reporting NDP now leading by 140 votes so
03:24:16 we are getting in there we have to take a quick break in just a moment here but you are tuned in
03:24:21 to the True North Alberta election night results show I'm Andrew Lawton joined of course by Robbie
03:24:28 Picard right now and William Macbeth and just before we take a little break to do
03:24:32 a reset here I'll let you know we've got in the Banff-Canadascos is pretty
03:24:37 firmly a UCB hold now 11 pulls in out of 26 but a 2,100 vote lead that seems
03:24:44 like a really difficult one to to flip at this time a lot of the other Calgary
03:24:49 ridings that we were keeping an eye on Calgary Glenmore 400 vote lead with 13
03:24:54 22 polls reporting and Banff Kananaskis we talked about so again I think even
03:25:00 some of these ridings that a lot of people thought might have been done are
03:25:03 pretty much holding here so when we come back we're gonna talk about this in a
03:25:08 little bit more detail we're gonna get Lindsay Wilson from Alberta Proud back
03:25:12 into the mix but just some some closing thoughts here Robbie what's your big
03:25:16 message for tonight I think the mess my message is real simple to the UCP don't
03:25:22 turf your leader give her a time to build the party she needs albertans need to get to know her 0.99
03:25:28 um how many ucp leaders or conservative leaders have we been through we've been through quite
03:25:33 a few in the past 10 years and i think it's time to unite behind your leader uh
03:25:40 full time with covet and recovering give your leader a chance all right well thank you for
03:25:45 that robbie william we're going to be talking to you in like 30 seconds but give a give us a thought
03:25:49 I mean, I just had to laugh because I think Robbie is bang on with that one, which is if you keep getting rid of your leader, you're always going to be in a state of flux, and it's going to be hard for you to tell voters what you believe, why you believe in all that.
03:26:06 But, you know, the joke is, I don't know if any of our viewers have ever watched the great John Clase performing in a first show called Faulty Towers.
03:26:13 He, you know, gets away with some crazy little culpable over his sides.
03:26:18 He gets through the skin of his teeth and he goes, right, now for the hard part.
03:26:22 And that's what I worry about this UCB government.
03:26:24 We win the election, everybody takes a day off, and now you have to govern and keep the caucus and the party together.
03:26:30 Now for the hard part.
03:26:31 All right, well, thank you very much for that.
03:26:34 We're going to take a quick break.
03:26:35 We'll be back after a reset in just a moment.
03:26:37 Hang tight.
03:27:05 .
03:27:35 .
03:28:05 .
03:28:35 .
03:29:05 you're back on
03:29:09 yeah you have
03:29:20 congratulations
03:29:22 it's ready
03:29:35 Yes, sorry, one sec.
03:30:05 End.
03:30:35 I got interviewed by the CDC.
03:30:57 UCP having the results they have now, but let's talk about this.
03:31:01 talk about this now right now we are at uh just 52 leading 52 is uh just one above where you were
03:31:08 called no two above you where you were predicting and one above where you were uh and then i have
03:31:14 of course uh i'm the loser right now because i was at 48 uh but uh better to be modest here so
03:31:20 uh what are you thinking of this so far i mean i think it's a tremendous victory for the united
03:31:24 conservative party if you look at public opinion polling over the past six months eight months
03:31:29 a year i think there's a lot of people who thought it was simply impossible
03:31:38 all right well if i may the legacy media has just reached the conclusion that we reach
03:31:46 and they've now declared a majority for danielle's within the ucp things are getting a little
03:31:51 hectic behind us now. I'll let you just soak in this for a moment.
03:32:08 All right well that is the call coming from CTV about a minute behind True North. We were looking
03:32:15 at some of the raw data and we were fairly confident in that. They're finding the same
03:32:19 numbers that we are right now 52 leading and elected for the ucp so still lost right now
03:32:24 about 11 seats for the ucp uh and a gain for the ndp um but all aside a win is a win uh we're not
03:32:32 only in majority territory uh but a healthy enough majority you take out the independent you take out
03:32:38 uh the speaker of the house and this is a it's fairly decisive certainly as we were going to get
03:32:43 at this cycle.
03:32:44 I mean, as I was finishing up saying, I think there was a point in time where a UCP
03:32:50 majority win was seen as impossible, that the New Democrats were polling quite far ahead.
03:32:55 So the fact that Danielle Smith was able to bring it back in six months and lead her party
03:33:00 to a majority government, I think is a remarkable achievement and one she should be rightly proud
03:33:05 of.
03:33:06 I also think she is going to win by enough seats that her majority in the legislature
03:33:10 will be functional.
03:33:11 function she will be able to govern in an effective majority government without being beholden to 0.95
03:33:18 every single vote and having to scrape them a hundred percent of them together every time she
03:33:22 wants to move her agenda forward what are your preliminary thoughts on this lindsay they just
03:33:27 weren't able to turn some of those post calgary ridings they thought that they would be able to
03:33:31 turn those and they thought they would but they weren't able to uh it's interesting to see that
03:33:37 my horse miranda rosa and i thought she would have you know i thought it was a bit of a challenge 0.79
03:33:47 so it's just interesting i i i want to know what's going to happen in the
03:33:51 in the months and the years to come with this strong gold of orange in and around greater
03:33:56 edmonton like it is really orange up there and what's that going to mean is that going to further
03:34:01 the world open divide i think it's really interesting how can the ucp give you more support
03:34:09 i think we if we can get you to move your mic up a little bit you're now being drowned out by uh the
03:34:13 adoring uh ucp fans there so we'll make sure that your analysis is not missed by those tuning in
03:34:18 online welcome by the way uh if you're just joining us now this is the true north alberta
03:34:23 election night results show i'm having to shout everything now i'm joined by lindsey wilson from
03:34:28 Alberta Proud and William McBeth from True North. We just called a moment to go the election for
03:34:34 Danielle Smith and the United Conservative Party. A pretty healthy majority here, 52 seats in which
03:34:40 the UCP is leading or elected right now. So not the numbers they had going into the election but
03:34:47 still very healthy. The legacy media behind us has just reached the conclusion so that's what
03:34:53 they have up on the feed there. We would have hoped the UCP would have put us on there but we
03:34:57 We won't hold that against them.
03:34:58 We'll let them have their moment on this.
03:35:00 Just a pitch, if I can, for supporting independent media.
03:35:04 We're only able to do this because we do not get the government bailout money.
03:35:08 So if you value what we're doing, head on over to donate.tmc.news.
03:35:12 Or if you're watching on YouTube, you can pop us a super chat
03:35:16 and we'll read your question or comment, assuming it's not naughty.
03:35:20 We haven't had any of those so far live on air.
03:35:22 Do let us know about these as they're coming in.
03:35:26 So now, I think the evening is getting a little bit more predictable in nature.
03:35:29 There are still some ridings that we're wondering about, one of which is Tyler Chandros.
03:35:34 I know it's a little early, but it's also not at the same time.
03:35:37 Do you see any obvious cabinet changes now with the new makeup we're likely to see?
03:35:42 I mean, I think we are going to see the health minister probably lose his riding.
03:35:49 The minister of advanced education, I think, is in either a close race or a difficult race.
03:35:55 Minister Nick Milliken and Calgary Curry, I think, sadly, won't be returned either.
03:36:01 So there are going to be, by necessity, changes to the Cabinet.
03:36:06 She's also possibly going to lose her only Edmonton MLA and Deputy Premier Casey Madden from Cabinet as well.
03:36:15 Sadly, it looks like he might not be elected.
03:36:18 So I would say there's changes coming.
03:36:20 I think she's going to have to try and balance representation with fit for job, all of those things. 0.99
03:36:27 But I think, you know, those are good problems to have.
03:36:31 Trying to build a cabinet means you won an election.
03:36:33 And of course, if there's a winner, then there's a loser.
03:36:36 And unquestionably, that will have to be Rachel Lottley and the Democrats.
03:36:40 What does future now hold for her?
03:36:42 Can she hold on to the job of opposition leader? 1.00
03:36:45 Or will the party say that's two consecutive losses in a row?
03:36:49 giving you the boot and going with someone else.
03:36:51 So I'll be interested to see what Rachel Notley announces tonight.
03:36:56 Yeah, there was a Freudian slip there that never was.
03:36:58 But just in on Southwest, which mentioned, that's Casey Matthews, former riding now.
03:37:05 We can call that one for the NDP safely at this point.
03:37:08 12 of 18 polls reporting, NDP up by 1,400.
03:37:12 No way you're closing that gap in six polls.
03:37:15 So, obviously, Casey Maddew, yeah, the lone Edmonton MP or MLA and a pretty senior member of Danielle Smith's government going into this, no longer there.
03:37:26 Do you think at this point the UCP strategy is just to ignore Edmonton?
03:37:31 Or do you think that there is something they need to do to regain that ground?
03:37:34 I think they've got to start with the fringe of, you know, they have to start with greater Edmonton and work their way in.
03:37:41 And I know this is a little closer in places like Strathcun, Sugar Park.
03:37:45 I'm surprised with so long to the Duke and Pharrell there.
03:37:48 And I think they need to just start doing some really good work in there.
03:37:51 And trying to move neighbor back. 0.89
03:37:54 Because a lot of them are going to be very problematic for the party.
03:37:57 It's seeing that blanket of orange that's completely dominating around Everton.
03:38:02 And it's getting bigger every time.
03:38:03 Let's not forget where we're at right now.
03:38:06 It looks like...
03:38:08 So CBC has just woken up to the fact that there is an election going on and CBC has now called
03:38:16 Danielle Smith as having a majority which they were reluctantly doing so it took them until
03:38:21 practically Tuesday. I'm not even joking it's you know 53 minutes to midnight to do what everyone
03:38:27 else had done before so when CBC has acknowledged the Danielle Smith win you know that the win is
03:38:33 in. Yeah I mean Calgary Acadia you were right to pick that one as your one to watch that's ending
03:38:38 up being the most interesting uh raise the evening one of the closest in the evening
03:38:42 uh no more polls than a few minutes ago when we checked in which if you're just joining us
03:38:46 uh 104 for the ndp uh with 11 of 18 polls reporting but every time a new poll has been
03:38:53 coming in it's been paying back forth so i mean who knows i mean there are six and polls left
03:38:59 means it'll likely current trajectory holds but that is not scientific so don't take my
03:39:06 My word for that there.
03:39:07 You go around the ring at Calgary here.
03:39:10 One that is kind of interesting, Rajan Sani has, and I just want to pull up the exact number here.
03:39:18 It looks like she is winning with a 500-vote lead, two polls remaining.
03:39:24 Let's talk about that because she wasn't originally going to be running. 0.96
03:39:27 No.
03:39:28 She had announced that she would not be seeking re-election.
03:39:32 And then she decided that she wanted back in.
03:39:35 I would say that it's possibly a reflection of the riding she had represented was going to be a difficult challenge.
03:39:44 She was then offered a safer seat for the United Conservative Party.
03:39:49 I think that may have motivated her to rethink her exit from public life. 0.85
03:39:54 All right. We have Rachel Emanuel standing by with pollster and former federal Conservative campaign manager Hamish Marshall.
03:40:01 We'll check in with him on what's been happening. Take it away, Rachel.
03:40:05 So I am here with Hamish Marshall.
03:40:11 He was in charge of the internal polling for the UCP during the campaign.
03:40:15 Hamish, UCP insiders that I spoke to during the campaign were very confident, and now we know why.
03:40:20 The numbers that we're seeing so far tonight, do they align with what you saw during the campaign?
03:40:25 We certainly had a lot of very good numbers over the course of the campaign,
03:40:27 especially after Premier Smith's fantastic performance at the debate.
03:40:31 But these numbers exceed even some of our more optimistic projections.
03:40:35 So what we're seeing tonight is actually a better turnout than what you predicted during the campaign.
03:40:40 Well, we've been moving towards the UCP in the last few days,
03:40:44 and they've kept doing that over the weekend and into election day, and we've got a very strong result.
03:40:49 So I heard from some perhaps overly optimistic UCPers that we were going to pick up seats in Edmonton.
03:40:55 Not actually the case. Looks like we're losing Casey Maddow.
03:40:58 He was the only seat that we held in Edmonton.
03:41:00 Did you at any point during the campaign think it was a possibility to pick up some seats inside that dome?
03:41:04 Edmonton was always going to be very, very, very tricky.
03:41:07 The NDP's got an amazing machine there, and the numbers were very, very tough.
03:41:10 The big focus was on those seats around Edmonton, where the NDP put a lot of effort.
03:41:15 But they ran into a blue wall and a group of ridings that really reacted very well to Danielle Smith's message.
03:41:21 So when we talk about polling, it seems that a lot of the pollsters get things wrong in Alberta so often,
03:41:28 certainly in the 2012 election.
03:41:30 Again, in the 2019, they really underestimated support for the UCP.
03:41:34 you know even you said yourself tonight my polls didn't estimate as high as support as we are
03:41:39 seeing tonight why do you think it is why is it so hard to peg down conservative voters in alberta
03:41:44 i think there's a couple of different things i think number one we saw a trend moving towards
03:41:48 the ucp so polls taken a few days ago were probably not as positive for the ucp as ones
03:41:53 as including the votes that people made up their mind today and more people broke to the ucp today
03:41:57 than would have even through two or three days ago so i think that's the first thing
03:42:01 I think it's also, there's a, the media is so omnipresent pushing a pro-NDP message
03:42:07 that there's a little bit of a shy conservative factor that people don't want to tell a pollster
03:42:11 that they're voting UCP, that they might, because they've made you feel bad about it
03:42:15 by the mainstream media, but in the end, they come out and vote.
03:42:19 Yeah, I think those are some really good points.
03:42:21 You know, when we talk about being a candidate in Alberta, you get kind of panicked, people
03:42:25 see the votes, and then you always have those conservatives that say, well, I don't trust
03:42:28 the polls because they've gone it wrong so many times.
03:42:31 At what point as Conservatives do we say we're just going to ignore polls from, you know, sort of legacy media outlets and these legacy pollsters who've gotten it wrong so many times?
03:42:41 Is there a point where we just decide to say it's not worth it for us to really give these credibility because they've gotten it wrong so many times?
03:42:47 Well, I think what everybody has to do is look closely at which pollsters got it right.
03:42:50 Some of the public pollsters did a very good job.
03:42:53 Others weren't as close.
03:42:55 I'm not going to say you shouldn't listen to polls.
03:42:56 I'm a pollster myself, and I believe it can be done right if it's done in a smart way.
03:43:00 and that's what I think people need to do is be a little more literate about which ones are good
03:43:06 and which ones have a more dodgy record.
03:43:09 Yeah, so I mean Danielle Smith was pretty tight-lipped about the internal polling as she would be 0.99
03:43:13 so I guess the question is when are you going to start doing public polling
03:43:16 that will be available for us Conservatives in Alberta?
03:43:19 Well, I've done public polling for True North in the past and maybe I will again.
03:43:22 Just my last question for you here.
03:43:23 We know that Janet Brown has a really good reputation in the province.
03:43:27 she gets it right so often and she typically counts the conservative vote much higher than her
03:43:32 competitors would you say that tonight further solidifies her reputation as the best pollster 0.92
03:43:37 in alberta well i think she's she obviously did a great job in this election and that counts for a
03:43:41 lot thank you so much marshall all right we are back andrew lawton here at the true north live
03:43:54 Alberta election results show now just one little bit of context here I can't show you but
03:44:00 all through the night there has been a lingering area over here where people have been having their
03:44:06 drinks sitting down at tables when the majority was everyone just run from that over to the big
03:44:13 floor where all the excitement and action are happening behind us here obviously we know for
03:44:19 Danielle Smith is going to continue to be Premier of Alberta right now UCP
03:44:24 leading or elected in 52 seats compared to 35 for the NDP what we don't know
03:44:29 though is the outcome of a couple of key seats and we also don't know the fate of
03:44:34 Rachel Notley and we were just chatting when Rachel Emanuel was speaking with
03:44:39 Hamish Marshall about this a little bit do you see a path to hold on for Rachel
03:44:43 The thing is, the problem for the NDP now is who do they have to replace her?
03:44:47 We were discussing earlier that they've really done so strongly in this province based on the brand of Rachel Notley.
03:44:55 We go back to that Team Rachel Notley rather than NDP.
03:44:59 But this is two straight losses in a row.
03:45:03 If we look at history and leaders, it now would be her time to step down to move on from the party. 1.00
03:45:09 party, but who do they have to replace her? They have some serious extremists in this 1.00
03:45:13 party. And I just don't know what that looks like for them. So this might mean a whole
03:45:18 shuffle and rebrand for them. It will be really interesting to see what they have to do.
03:45:22 We have seen losing leaders not really want to go away. And I mean, one example was Andrew
03:45:29 Scheer, who, you know, held on for a little bit. Aaron O'Toole held on for a little bit,
03:45:34 a little bit longer in his case. But the difference between those two and Rachel Notley is that
03:45:38 rachel notley has had now uh this is well this is her third her she won one and two so uh this
03:45:45 isn't just an example of you know kick someone out before they've had a chance to try like
03:45:49 i don't see how unless she just outlasts everyone how she turns around this party's fortunes 0.99
03:45:55 it's a little bit tricky um just you know the point that i think lindsey made is very good
03:46:00 that there is not a lot of heir appearance to uh post rachel notley new democrats i think they
03:46:06 would really struggle uh once and of course the notley name uh in alberta is is a little bit
03:46:13 storied of course her her father was a was a pretty pretty well liked pretty and almost beloved
03:46:18 politician isn't there a notley riding name is that named after him yeah after grant notley
03:46:23 and you know he died in a plane crash very very sadly and so i think she gets a more open hearing
03:46:32 than a typical new democrat would uh so it's possible they may say even after two losses
03:46:40 we still think this is the best we can we can do and they're they may they may stick it up she may
03:46:46 decide she doesn't want to do it anymore though she may say look i've been campaigning for for
03:46:52 you know coming on by the next election will have been like 10 years i really don't want to do this
03:46:57 anymore somebody else should have a chance i want to spend more time with my my family and pursue
03:47:02 other projects so uh does she have the fire in her belly to be leader of the opposition for another 1.00
03:47:08 four-year term and contest another provincial election i don't know so uh just to give you an
03:47:13 update on the numbers here not seeing any movement so far 52 uh 235 for the ucp a couple of super
03:47:20 chats i wanted to read if you're watching on youtube and want to give us some words of
03:47:24 encouragement and some financial support to keep this show going uh please do that for it says god
03:47:31 Congratulations.
03:47:33 Tyler Durden says, Andrew and team, thank you for the excellent coverage and analysis.
03:47:37 You have made provincial politics interesting and informative,
03:47:40 which is a very difficult thing to do, but we've done it.
03:47:44 Tyler says, keep up the great work.
03:47:46 Congratulations to Alberta and Danielle Smith.
03:47:50 Well, thank you, Tyler, and thank you, Sarah, for that.
03:47:53 We're going to have some more updates, and one in particular I see is Steve Outhouse,
03:47:58 who is the campaign manager for Danielle Smith and the UCP.
03:48:02 I see Steve Outhouse is currently being lassoed by Rachel Emanuel into doing an interview.
03:48:08 So we'll get Steve up very shortly to talk about this.
03:48:11 Obviously, now that the win has happened for the UCP,
03:48:14 Steve has emerged from where he was probably quite anxiously watching the results.
03:48:20 Fingernails shorter than when the evening began.
03:48:22 Yeah, another call for the UCP in Calgary there.
03:48:26 So what's going to happen, we're going to have a speech from Rachel Notley,
03:48:29 which will certainly be a concession speech.
03:48:31 Now, she will, as is the protocol, phone Danielle Smith if she hasn't already to formally concede.
03:48:39 And then she'll speak.
03:48:40 And then after that, we'll have, of course, Danielle Smith deliver a speech. 0.98
03:48:45 And we were talking, I think, a little while ago on another show, William,
03:48:49 about how you want to have different speeches for this.
03:48:52 You know, if you win, but it's not a blowout.
03:48:53 But if you win, but, you know, not necessarily narrowly, I mean, which speech do you bring out for this occasion?
03:48:58 I mean, I would say Danielle gets to be maybe a little more triumphant than if she had won in the 40s. 0.85
03:49:05 I think it is a bit of a reflection on the fact she was able to bring the United Conservative Party back into a position to win a pretty strong majority government.
03:49:16 Certainly stronger than what some of the polls would have suggested even a week ago.
03:49:21 So, I mean, I don't think she should take the opportunity to say she has phenomenal cosmic power and should be allowed to do as she pleases. 0.75
03:49:30 I think it's an opportunity for her to talk to the province, reassure them that despite having a majority government,
03:49:37 she's going to continue to govern in the best interests of all Albertans, 0.56
03:49:40 and she's going to talk maybe about some of her priorities going into a new four-year mandate.
03:49:47 Rachel Emanuel has successfully lassoed Steve Outhouse, the UCP campaign manager.
03:49:53 Rachel, Steve, take it away. 0.66
03:49:57 All right, I am joined by Steve Outhouse.
03:50:00 He is the campaign manager for the UCP.
03:50:02 Well, Steve, to start off, congratulations.
03:50:04 How are you feeling right now?
03:50:05 Well, a lot of relief.
03:50:06 It's been a long campaign.
03:50:07 It was a lot of hard work, but we're obviously very thrilled with the results.
03:50:10 So I just spoke to Hamish Marshall, who did the internal polling for the UCP,
03:50:15 and he said that tonight's results are even better than he had polled.
03:50:19 Is that your response as well?
03:50:21 Yes, it absolutely was. Hamish is a tough marker, so he had us a little bit lower than that,
03:50:26 so we were watching the results carefully and looking for signals along the way.
03:50:30 But yeah, these results are even better than what I was hoping for tonight.
03:50:33 UCP insiders that I spoke to throughout the campaign seemed very confident.
03:50:38 They seemed pretty sure that they were going to eke out a win tonight,
03:50:40 and certainly they have more than eke out a win from the looks of things.
03:50:43 Was there ever a point when you thought we might really be in trouble here?
03:50:47 Oh, definitely.
03:50:48 I mean, campaigns for those long campaigns, there's a lot of roller coasters of emotion.
03:50:52 So you have days where you're feeling like you're winning everything and days where you feel like the world is ending.
03:50:56 And we did have a rough second week, I think it's fair to say.
03:50:59 It was pretty obvious to a lot of people.
03:51:01 We were able to pivot back, have a great third week.
03:51:03 The debate was a turning point.
03:51:04 Obviously, the Premier's performance, I think, put a lot of people's minds at ease with sort of the caricature that's been made of her.
03:51:10 and she was able to connect with more people and they saw her that night as the leader she is
03:51:15 and I think that was a big part of the turnaround.
03:51:17 That's definitely something I heard from pretty much everyone I've spoken to here tonight
03:51:20 as well as voters that were unsure.
03:51:22 They saw Danielle Smith perform at that debate
03:51:24 and I think they realized maybe the media's depiction of her wasn't quite accurate or fair.
03:51:30 Would you say that was reflected in your polling as well?
03:51:32 Yeah, absolutely.
03:51:33 There were definitely concerns sort of earlier on in the campaign
03:51:36 because of the way she was being portrayed
03:51:37 and if she was able to connect with more people during the campaign,
03:51:40 We were able to see that improve and then definitely the debate was a pivotal moment people got to watch her on the stage 0.75
03:51:45 See her as a leader see her offer clear policy
03:51:48 You know sort of plans and objectives for the province
03:51:51 And I think that brought a lot of people over and we did see a turnaround and also we heard from candidates at the doors
03:51:55 That things got a lot smoother at that point in time
03:51:58 Something else that was really pivotal in this campaign was of course the Alberta wildfires that crisis broke out in the very first week of the campaign
03:52:05 really drew Danielson's attention from campaigning in Calgary,
03:52:09 where everyone sort of knew the election was going to be decided,
03:52:11 to responding to that crisis up north.
03:52:14 Did you have to sort of reconfigure what your campaign strategy
03:52:17 was going to look like to address the fires?
03:52:19 Yeah, so having the Premier, well, our leader, transition back into Premier mode,
03:52:24 obviously the calendar gets into the weeds,
03:52:27 but there was a lot of events and announcements and things
03:52:29 that had to be totally scrapped or postponed and changed.
03:52:32 We had to roll with it.
03:52:33 She did a great job being the Premier, but obviously for us on the campaign side there was a lot of things going on behind the scenes to try to change and adapt to that.
03:52:42 So that was part of the reason I think our second week was a little bit, she was looking great out there and connecting with, you know, and dealing with the crisis.
03:52:48 But internally, yes, there was a lot of shuffling that had to go around.
03:52:52 Something else I have to ask you, Bo, is some Conservatives said to me, you know, it feels like it's been a quiet campaign side, the wildfire crisis to deal with.
03:53:00 Some other UCP insiders said to me, you know, we didn't want to over-promise, we didn't want to over-announce, over-spend perhaps.
03:53:07 Would you say that this was really an intentional strategy, or do you think that some of the distractions caused you to maybe not have as many announcements as the NDP, who were doing quite a few events?
03:53:17 So, kind of, there's multiple answers to that.
03:53:20 I mean, we are conservative, so we weren't going to be breaking the bank and starting to put the province back into a deficit type of situation.
03:53:26 So, yes, we have a more modest spending package, but I think it's still very effective what we put forward.
03:53:32 You know, but there were the wildfires were again, you know, kind of knocked us off, you know, some of our platform plan.
03:53:38 They all got announced over time, but it did slow some things down.
03:53:41 And then ultimately, because it was boring, I think it's just sort of a testament that, you know, when she when the premier was on her game and able to kind of present herself, she she gave solid answers.
03:53:50 and everyone, again, had set her up to be this caricature 0.86
03:53:54 of someone who would just go out and say crazy things at any given time
03:53:57 and she didn't.
03:53:58 She went out and she delivered her message every day
03:54:00 and so then it was boring because it wasn't, you know, funny for the pundits and so on
03:54:06 who wanted to make fun of her the whole campaign
03:54:08 and I think those folks are sort of eating a lot of crow tonight.
03:54:12 Yeah, absolutely.
03:54:12 One last question for you here.
03:54:14 This is a bit of a controversial one.
03:54:16 I know you've done what you needed to do tonight.
03:54:18 you pulled off a win for the united conservative party but something that i've been hearing not
03:54:21 only from legacy media but also from other conservatives is that you know if danielle
03:54:26 doesn't have a strong showing a strong victory tonight there could be a challenge to her 1.00
03:54:30 leadership in the days and months ahead is that something that you were cognizant of during the
03:54:34 leadership campaign well my primary job is as you say to come in and manage the campaign that's there
03:54:39 i mean so i'm not going to be able to give advice to kind of a you know the ucp overall
03:54:44 All of the results, it is a strong mandate.
03:54:49 And we have, as a party, almost the same amount of popular vote as we had in the last campaign.
03:54:55 You will obviously see our vote totals once elections in Alberta finishes counting.
03:54:59 Then we'll be able to get a better state of that.
03:55:02 But I think she has gotten a strong mandate tonight.
03:55:04 I'm very proud of the Premier, and I think she's going to do a great job.
03:55:07 Thank you so much for your insight, Steve.
03:55:08 Once again, that was Steve Outhouse, the UCP campaign manager.
03:55:12 We really appreciate your insight.
03:55:17 All right, welcome back.
03:55:19 This is the True North Live election night show here.
03:55:22 William Macbeth joins me, as does Lindsay Wilson from Alberta Proud,
03:55:25 and I am Andrew Lawton on what's been a bit of a longer night
03:55:28 than we initially anticipated.
03:55:31 Right now, Lethbridge has been called for the UCD.
03:55:35 Lethbridge East, which is the one that we were watching,
03:55:38 that up until this point has been a fairly NDP-dominant riding in the polls.
03:55:43 What are the Lethbridge dynamics?
03:55:45 Because that's often like the B-side city that we don't talk about
03:55:48 because we're so focused on Calgary and Edmonton here.
03:55:50 Why is Lethbridge one that tends to straddle these two parties?
03:55:54 It's challenging because I think they're a little bit rural or a little bit urban.
03:55:57 I was just down on Lethbridge recently, and I was talking to people there
03:56:01 because they were getting a lot of really good responses for the UCP.
03:56:05 But you drive around that city, and there's a lot of orange signs.
03:56:08 There's a lot of blue signs.
03:56:10 I don't know what the problem is that's happening.
03:56:11 It does have a very large university, which I think does tend to make it skew a bit more New Democrat than you might expect from a small town in Alberta.
03:56:21 But it was also home to, for example, the leader of the Alberta Liberal Party for many years represented one of the two Lethbridge ridings.
03:56:28 So this is a city that has also devoted non-conservative money.
03:56:33 Yeah, and we will check in on some of the Calgary ridings in a moment.
03:56:37 But Rachel Emanuel has been doing tremendous work wrangling everyone.
03:56:41 They're all coming out now that they know they've won.
03:56:43 Rachel Emanuel right now is with Danielle Smith's Chief of Staff, Marshall Smith.
03:56:47 Go ahead, Rachel.
03:56:50 So we are back.
03:56:52 I am now joined by Marshall Smith, Chief of Staff, Chief of Staff to the Premier.
03:56:57 How are you feeling about tonight's results?
03:56:59 Is it what you expected, better than what you expected?
03:57:01 It's actually what I expected, Rachel.
03:57:04 I'm predicting one more seat than we've got right now.
03:57:08 But, you know, the numbers are looking really good.
03:57:11 We are really thrilled and couldn't be happier tonight.
03:57:14 So I have to ask you this because I've been asking this to,
03:57:17 well, I just asked this to Steve Outhouse.
03:57:19 Was there a point in the campaign where you actually felt like
03:57:21 you were pretty worried about what might happen?
03:57:24 I think early on in the campaign, I think before the numbers tightened up,
03:57:28 you know, we're always nervous about going into these contests.
03:57:32 So early on in the campaign is really difficult.
03:57:35 But as the campaign moved on, and in particular at key points in the campaign,
03:57:40 it started to become clear to me the way that this was going to go.
03:57:43 So many of my viewers know, because I cover this quite a bit,
03:57:47 but all of you probably aren't aware of this,
03:57:49 Marshall Smith has really been heading up the province's addiction and recovery file.
03:57:53 And we know that that was such a key topic during this election campaign.
03:57:57 Albertans, Calgarians, Edmontonians were not feeling safe on the streets anymore.
03:58:01 And the government really wanted to tackle that with a comprehensive plan,
03:58:04 both on public safety and on addictions can you speak to a little bit about how important the
03:58:09 addictions file was in this election I think that it was it was very important in the into
03:58:15 our electoral success I think in particular with you know a lot of people in particularly women and
03:58:24 young people don't feel safe on the streets of their own cities and they want something done
03:58:29 about that but they also want people helped in the way that that makes sense and that's going
03:58:34 to be effective so I think that the addiction platform the public safety
03:58:38 platform was very effective at moving women back to the party in the final two 0.98
03:58:44 weeks so just my last question for you here I see that Rachel Notley is giving
03:58:48 her concession speech and I know that my audience is gonna want to hear that so
03:58:51 we're gonna get to that right away but on the topic of the Compassionate
03:58:54 Intervention Act that's something we've talked a lot about tonight do you think
03:58:58 it actually changed anyone's minds we're gonna vote for the UCP or do you
03:59:01 think that it really impacted a specific subset of voters? I do. I mean, we certainly knew what
03:59:06 we were doing when we when we put that together. This is an important piece of legislation. And I
03:59:12 do think that it was effective at bringing a certain population over. Well, thank you so much,
03:59:17 Marshall. Once again, that was Marshall Smith, Chief of Staff to now reelected Premier.
03:59:22 all right we now go to rachel notley conceding in edmonton take it away
03:59:39 opportunity for our future and for the values that we all share however tonight i also know
03:59:45 that we are all very deeply pointed in the old result we had all hoped for a different one
03:59:52 moments ago i called premier danielle smith to concede the race and i congratulated her party on
03:59:59 their victory to all those of you to those who offered their unwavering support their dedication
04:00:12 and their belief in our vision for Alberta in this election.
04:00:16 You are the reason that we fight for what we believe in.
04:00:27 And to our candidates all across this province,
04:00:30 congratulations on your campaigns, successful or not.
04:00:34 You have all demonstrated tremendous leadership.
04:00:38 I have spent the last few months being so inspired by your dedication, by your heartfelt commitment to standing up for Albertans without a voice, your own belief that we can and will come together to be better.
04:00:55 I commend your integrity and your perseverance and your unparalleled work ethic and I will never
04:01:02 ever ever stop being deeply grateful for your decision to join our team so thank you to all of
04:01:09 you and to those new MLAs I say to you welcome congratulations
04:01:25 Get some rest tonight, and then get ready to get right back down to work.
04:01:38 To my amazing, amazing campaign team, I can't say enough.
04:01:45 They are unparalleled in the achievement that they have and that they have done, you know, across the country.
04:01:55 They are just unparalleled in their skill.
04:01:57 I cannot thank that team enough and I cannot thank as well our incredible volunteers enough.
04:02:05 Your commitment, your hard work, your countless hours of effort have been the absolute backbone of our campaign.
04:02:15 you've all shown incredible dedication and passion and I am forever grateful for your support
04:02:28 and I need to say this as well where we fell short the responsibility rests entirely with me
04:02:35 that's that's that's fine that's that's the joys of being the leader you know it's it's fine
04:02:44 it's just it's a thing uh you know it's part of responsibility and accountability those are
04:02:48 things we we care about here but i do know that at the same time we ran a strong
04:02:55 it was based on our beliefs
04:03:02 and it was based on our desire to create a better future for all albertans
04:03:14 NTT, NTT, NTT, NTT, NTT.
04:03:38 To my family.
04:03:40 These guys.
04:03:41 Thank you to the four of you for standing by me in this often very crazy journey.
04:03:48 Thank you to Ethan and to Sophie for accepting the difference that it has been meaning in their lives for all this time
04:03:55 and ultimately turning it into their own pride and their own set of beautiful values that make me very proud.
04:04:11 And thank you again seem like I'm doing this every four years. Thank you again to Lou my lifelong sounding board
04:04:41 Anywho, lifelong sounding board, sparring partner, and apparently personal cheerleader,
04:04:55 but also occasionally for me, all wrapped up into one.
04:04:59 And also, Lou, thank you very much for mopping the kitchen floor today.
04:05:02 That was awesome.
04:05:08 I love you all so much.
04:05:10 now although we did not achieve the outcome that we wanted we did take a
04:05:16 major step towards the unprecedented growth of our party through this
04:05:21 campaign is a warm light one that gives me a lot of optimism for the work to
04:05:27 come my friends let me be clear now is not the time to let up now is the time
04:05:34 Now is the time for us to do the work that has been asked of us.
04:06:03 It is my honor to serve as your leader, and it is my privilege to continue to serve as leader of the official opposition.
04:06:16 Our values will be represented in the legislature.
04:06:20 We will have a say in the future of this great.
04:06:23 We will continue to speak up on behalf of Albertans who struggle to have their voice heard.
04:06:32 We will fight for better health care, better education, better jobs.
04:06:39 And, my friends, we will be unequivocal in our demand for respect for the rule of law
04:06:45 and an unqualified belief in the human rights and basic dignity of all Albertans.
04:07:02 The challenges we face, the challenges facing Alberta, economic, environmental, social,
04:07:10 they all require dedication and determination and we will bring that to Alberta's legislature
04:07:17 tirelessly.
04:07:19 We will never stop working to rebuild our public health care, to support the well-being
04:07:28 of our communities to protect our mountains, our pensions, and our kids' education, all
04:07:34 while ensuring we have an economy that works for absolutely all Albertans.
04:07:43 So to all Albertans, we will be your voice when this government refuses to listen.
04:07:53 And one small message to Danielle Smith and to the members of her new caucus, I say this.
04:08:00 If we had won, because, you know, inside piece of information here, I actually had two speeches
04:08:06 for tonight.
04:08:09 If we had won, our commitment was to have been to do everything that we could to move
04:08:15 past division and to govern for the vast majority of Albertans, to be practical and pragmatic
04:08:22 and to listen to all voices so I am asking you to remember the majority of
04:08:32 Albertans tonight and to commit to a government that prioritizes the need and
04:08:36 aspirations of all Albertans
04:08:45 so in conclusion tonight my friends I just want to say I am so proud of the
04:08:51 work that every single solitary member of our movement of this NDP has done over the last four
04:08:59 weeks. Together we fought passionately for a better future and I am so very very proud to be
04:09:08 the leader of this party. Thank you all very much. Thank you all. Thank you.
04:09:14 Thank you.
04:09:15 It's from Notley, Alberta's official opposition leader, staking her claim, making her intentions
04:09:22 clear.
04:09:23 She intends to stay on as the official opposition leader.
04:09:27 She was very...
04:09:44 .
04:10:14 .
04:10:44 .
04:11:14 .
04:11:44 Thank you.
04:12:14 we're down at UCP headquarters and that's what you're seeing on the screen and soon we'll see
04:12:20 Daniel Smith now elected premier not just inhering it as the leader of the UCP well David if you had
04:12:26 to give the NDP you know campaign a grade what would you say I mean they did as they never sit
04:12:31 right now gain 11 seats obviously it wasn't enough to to form government but you know how would you
04:12:36 grade the performance uh I don't know I guess probably I mean a B at least um I think you've
04:12:42 heard our panel talk about this um the negative ads work to a point and then you need to put
04:12:47 something in um and i think you know maybe they have to go back and take a look at campaign
04:12:53 strategy did we need to raise corporate taxes um as the ndp has said it was still raising to
04:12:58 the lowest rate in the country i get that but that was something the ucp really seized on
04:13:04 to talk about their strength with just taxes maybe if the ndp had put their tax policy in
04:13:09 the window or something right away in the campaign you know i i'm just guessing what some of the uh
04:13:16 the thinking will be as they go through that particular thing so so it'd be it was a better
04:13:19 campaign in this sense too i'll be very interested in looking at the advanced poll numbers historically
04:13:24 conservative parties it doesn't matter the province do better on advanced poll on ground game
04:13:29 and i know both campaign managers who both come out of the harper layton area on on each side
04:13:35 and they both stress finding votes databases uh they both stress very similar methods to success
04:13:42 one steve outhouse is the ucp campaign manager newfoundlander uh and he came into the province
04:13:48 and was hired by daniel smith to do just what he did tonight so congrats to him nate rotman is the
04:13:53 uh campaign manager on the ndp side and uh he probably just probably won another week this is
04:13:59 a live shot of the calgary ucp headquarters and we're just waiting for danielle smith to arrive 0.89
04:14:04 We know it will be momentarily.
04:14:07 I can tell you, Tyler Shandro, I'm getting it in my ear.
04:14:09 Back in the lead in Acadia.
04:14:11 Things are popping in.
04:14:12 Casey Maddu, we have projected defeated now in Southwest.
04:14:15 Nathan Neudorf ahead in Lethbridge.
04:14:17 So some of these close races.
04:14:19 Maybe that's what Daniel Smith is doing.
04:14:21 She's checking out to see what's going on in Acadia.
04:14:23 Well, yeah, we should remind viewers.
04:14:24 Does she still have a justice minister?
04:14:26 We should remind viewers.
04:14:27 We were just talking about concession speech.
04:14:30 We'll have a victory speech here in a moment.
04:14:31 There are still a number of these ridings that are too close to call, and we may not have called by the time we go off the air.
04:14:37 This speech is obviously, I think, is the more interesting one because, as Rachel Notley said at the end of her speech,
04:14:44 in her victory speech, she would have been talking about reaching out to those who did not vote NDP.
04:14:51 Daniel Smith, I think, same thing, needs to reach out to people who did not vote for her.
04:14:57 You know, you can't heal a division unless both parties are ready to sort of do something about that. 0.86
04:15:01 She did lose. She has a smaller caucus than she did when the night started. 0.86
04:15:05 I think she has to acknowledge that.
04:15:07 But then, yes, I think this is where she's, I'm certain this is where she says,
04:15:11 I need to govern for all Albertans.
04:15:13 Some of those losses that you were talking about were cabinet ministers.
04:15:16 So do you see some people who could have the potential to step into those roles?
04:15:21 I'm trying to think. They have a couple of new MLA.
04:15:24 for example i don't know the background as well as all of them typically you want someone you know
04:15:32 when you're forming a cabinet uh daniel smith first of all is from the south of the province
04:15:36 and typically the way premiers in this province do it uh you'll want the finance minister from
04:15:41 the north end of the province usually it's a calgary and edmonton or vice versa um that's
04:15:46 why i mentioned brian gene uh as a potential finance minister he obviously is from one of
04:15:50 of the more northern ridings um but that is some bench strength that might be missing i mean to run
04:15:56 through it millican uh copying jeremy nixon is on the bubble uh shandro is about six votes up
04:16:03 uh newdorf is up a bit maddu is defeated and that's the other point nobody in edmonton there's
04:16:09 from the provincial capital there is going to be no cabinet representation you know that is
04:16:14 something that daniel smith's gonna have to think about as well we'll talk about this david i mean
04:16:17 mean agree or disagree with her policies no matter how you feel about danielle smith this is
04:16:21 remarkable given where she was just a few years ago in her own political career right we're talking 0.99
04:16:27 about a woman who built the wild rose party uh essentially from scratch became leader uh was at
04:16:33 a very tight election at that point in time ended up losing to allison redford crosses the floor in 0.98
04:16:38 an absolutely dramatic stunning turn of events right then loses her own riding nomination for 1.00
04:16:45 the progressive conservatives who'd have thought that she was the mayor of alberta now i mean it
04:16:51 is it's remarkable what she's been able to accomplish we started this show tonight with
04:16:56 your video presentation your retrospective a i remember gosh daniel smith she hasn't aged that
04:17:02 much she still looks pretty youthful 10 years ago but uh when she said in 2012 we played that little
04:17:07 clip in your piece where she said well i guess we have a you got to wait a little longer yeah
04:17:11 took a decade and a bit uh there you go but it remarkable that that that sort of uh circumference
04:17:18 or sort of uh journey uh can happen uh so congratulations to danielle smith on that front
04:17:23 but as i said uh she she did lose some key cabin ministers but yep i'd be all smiles too and she's
04:17:30 entering the room could have been a lot worse you know absolutely all smiles she is not driving in 1.00
04:17:37 in a big blue truck we joke we reference that but of course that is how uh jason kenny entered the
04:17:42 room speaking of jason kenny jason kenny turns 55 years old tomorrow oh yes i don't know where
04:17:48 he is is that a birthday present yes i'm not sure if it's a gift or not i'm not sure about that but
04:17:53 i'm sure he's still supportive of the party no matter who's i mean she did take over what he
04:17:58 built that's kenny did unite that conservative party she's inherited it hasn't blown up yet
04:18:03 that's saying something it may yet blow up again but she's in charge for now all right big cheers 0.83
04:18:09 certainly at ucb headquarters let's listen in to what danielle snick has to say
04:18:15 oh boy thank you
04:18:22 oh thank you my dear friends thank you so much well to paraphrase our dear friend ralph
04:18:30 Welcome to another Miracle on the Prairies.
04:18:38 My friends, this was the very definition of a hard-fought election.
04:18:44 We face the most expensive, fierce, and coordinated opposition in third-party political campaigns in history.
04:18:54 Now, many folks wrote us off, even just as recently as last month.
04:19:00 But you know what happened? Despite it all, today Albertans chose to move our province forward by re-electing a strong, stable, united, conservative, majority government.
04:19:14 Now this victory would not have been possible without the incredible work of so many.
04:19:18 And thank you to our amazing campaign team, to our party and campaign volunteers, and to every single one of you that donated your time and your resources to this campaign.
04:19:28 you all made the difference and thank you thank you
04:19:34 a special thanks to all of our ucp candidates and their spouses families and campaign teams for
04:19:40 your tremendous work and sacrifice regardless of whether you won or lost individually tonight you
04:19:46 made a difference for alberta and we will always be you will always be part of our ucp team so thank
04:19:54 you i'd also like to thank the great people of brooks medicine hat once again yes
04:20:05 you've entrusted me with the responsibility of representing and advocating for your interests
04:20:10 and i am honored and humbled i'm indebted to you and to all the volunteers and i will continue
04:20:15 fighting for you as your mla thank you brooks medicine hat
04:20:19 and of course thank you to my dear husband David thank you so much honey for supporting me for
04:20:33 sacrificing so much of our time together so I can serve our province in this special way
04:20:38 thank you so much for all that you do well my friends the election is now over it is
04:20:48 to put partisan division and personal and political attacks in the rearview mirror.
04:20:54 It's time to move forward together as all Albertans, no matter who we voted for.
04:21:05 And on that note, Rachel Notley called me earlier to concede the election with honour and with dignity.
04:21:13 We all know about our differences of opinion, but I believe that Rachel Notley is a loyal Albertan
04:21:17 who loves this province as much as I or anyone else.
04:21:24 And she is deserving of respect and kindness and gratitude
04:21:28 for the thousands of hours she has sacrificed to serve our democracy.
04:21:32 And I hope you'll join me in genuinely thanking her for her public service.
04:21:38 And just as I would like to thank the hundreds of thousands of Albertans
04:21:42 who voted for the UCP today,
04:21:44 I want to speak for a moment to every Albertan who did not.
04:21:48 I want you to know that my oath is to serve all Albertans, no matter how you voted.
04:21:59 And though I didn't do enough in your judgment to win your support in this election,
04:22:03 I will work every day to listen, to improve, and to demonstrate to you
04:22:08 that I can be trusted to improve on the issues that you care so deeply about.
04:22:12 Now, I won't be perfect, of course, we all know that, but when I make a mistake, I will listen, correct course, and learn from it so that I can improve and become a better leader.
04:22:22 And so I invite all Albertans, regardless of who you supported in this election, to reach out to me with your ideas and your concerns and your questions.
04:22:30 That feedback that you give me, positive and negative, helps make our UCP caucus and I to make better decisions.
04:22:37 And that is what a healthy democracy is all about.
04:22:42 Now, before I go further, I think it's important tonight to recognize the courageous sacrifice of our firefighters and other first responders who are fighting and winning the battle against forest fires across our province.
04:22:58 I'd ask all of us to stand here and applaud our heroes of Alberta.
04:23:06 That is what Alberta is all about. 1.00
04:23:09 we look after each other we take care of each other and we must remember that there is much more
04:23:15 much more that unites us than divides us and we will need to be unified in the days and years
04:23:20 ahead because there's so much work to do together for example we need to make sure that you and your
04:23:26 family keep more of your money for the things that you need especially during this time of high
04:23:30 inflation. We have to make sure that our communities and streets are safe again
04:23:40 for our families and our businesses. And we have to keep powering and
04:23:49 diversifying our amazing economy. And I want to tell every business owner and
04:23:53 investor listening tonight, whether doing business inside or outside of Alberta, we
04:23:58 are throwing our doors wide open for businesses, large and small, to make this province a home
04:24:09 for your business and its employees. Enjoy the benefits of the Alberta tax advantage and bring
04:24:14 your jobs and investments here, because you are both welcomed and valued. And to demonstrate that,
04:24:21 the first bill of our government in the legislative session in the fall will be to guarantee that
04:24:25 Unless Albertans say otherwise by referendum, the only direction business and personal taxes are headed in this province is down.
04:24:41 Because we know that when businesses thrive, people thrive.
04:24:44 And when we grow our economy, we attract the best and brightest from all over the world, and we want that.
04:24:49 we have built the most powerful economy in the country on the principles of free enterprise
04:24:56 entrepreneurship and economic growth let's not ever forget that and let's not ever change that
04:25:06 we also need to ensure that our health care and education systems are the best
04:25:10 in the world not simply adequate not middle of the pack the very best in the world
04:25:15 and that means we need to study the best systems and practices around the world and improve upon
04:25:23 the strong foundation that we've built here but it also means empowering our doctors and nurses
04:25:28 teachers and other frontline professionals along with feedback from patients and parents
04:25:34 to innovate and improve in these areas every single day so i'm asking healthcare and education
04:25:40 professionals tonight, I'm also asking parents and
04:25:43 patients to work with me and the UCP caucus to build a
04:25:47 health care system and an education system that are
04:25:49 models for the entire world.
04:25:55 I know we can do this together and I am here to
04:25:58 listen and to work alongside of you.
04:26:01 And finally, my fellow Albertans, we need to come
04:26:03 together no matter how we have voted to stand shoulder
04:26:06 to shoulder against soon-to-be announced Ottawa
04:26:09 policies that would significantly harm our provincial economy now we have been
04:26:18 made aware that in the coming weeks Justin Trudeau is planning on bringing
04:26:22 forward new restrictions on electricity generation from natural gas that will
04:26:26 not only massively increase your power bills but will also endanger the
04:26:30 integrity and reliability of our entire power grid which we rely on during our
04:26:35 cold and dark alberta winters in addition the prime minister is already ready to introduce a
04:26:41 de facto production cap on our oil and gas sector that if implemented
04:26:49 if implemented built in tens of thousands of jobs lost tens of billions in lost investment damage
04:26:56 our province's fiscal position and bring economic hardship to albertans now i've made myself clear
04:27:02 on this matter to the prime minister in person and in public but i feel we need to do it again
04:27:25 well hopefully the prime minister and his caucus are watching tonight
04:27:32 But let me be clear, this is not a road we can afford to go down.
04:27:38 If he persists, he will be hurting Canadians from coast to coast,
04:27:42 and he will strain the patience and goodwill of Albertans in an unprecedented fashion.
04:27:50 And as Premier, I cannot, under any circumstances,
04:27:53 allow these contemplated federal policies to be inflicted upon Albertans.
04:27:58 I simply can't, and I won't.
04:28:02 And so I invite the Prime Minister to instead halt the introduction of these harmful policies
04:28:22 and come to the table in good faith to work collaboratively with Alberta on an energy
04:28:27 and emissions strategy that will both grow the Alberta and Canadian economies while using
04:28:32 export of alberta lng and emerging technologies to achieve meaningful reductions in emissions
04:28:37 because when canadians work together there is no challenge that we can't overcome i believe that
04:28:42 but it takes two parties acting in good faith to build that meaningful partnership now alberta
04:28:48 is willing to be that partner and we need our federal government to show
04:28:52 So in closing, my friends, tonight is a time for celebration.
04:29:07 We celebrate the candidates that won their election races and the efforts of those who did not.
04:29:19 We celebrate the commitment to democracy of all volunteers and supporters, regardless of party affiliation.
04:29:25 And we celebrate those who have sacrificed to secure and protect our right to vote and be a free and prosperous people.
04:29:32 And we celebrate this beautiful province and all who live here.
04:29:36 this uniquely special place where the best and brightest come from every corner of the world
04:29:48 to join us in building one of the greatest to live and work and raise our families and where
04:29:54 the only things that are larger than our mountains is the compassion and irrepressible spirit of our
04:30:00 people from the bottom of my heart thank you Alberta and may our province remain
04:30:06 Thank you.