Juno News - December 12, 2025


An Ontario school board is forcing parents to recite land acknowledgements

Topics
Mentioned
Carney eyes MASS IMMIGRATION ARCHITECT for U.S. Ambassador role Another MP Crosses the Floor

Episode Stats


Length

23 minutes

Words per minute

166.36

Word count

3,979

Sentence count

252

Harmful content

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Another publicly funded Ontario school board forces parents to read a political statement at the start of every meeting, and then ban them from even discussing it at all. That s the heart of a judicial review launched by Dr. Jeff Horstman, a lecturer at the University of Waterloo and the father of kids at the Waterloo Region District School Board. Jeff s legal challenge argues that compelling parents to recite land acknowledgements violates their charter rights, and for him that s especially in the realm of freedom of conscience and expression.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Another publicly funded Ontario school board forces parents to read political statements, in this case a land acknowledgement at the start of every meeting, and then ban them from even discussing it at all.
00:00:11 That's the heart of a judicial review launched by Dr. Jeff Horstman, a lecturer at the University of Waterloo, and he's also the father of kids at the Waterloo Region District School Board.
00:00:22 Jeff's legal challenge argues that compelling parents to recite land acknowledgements violates their charter rights, and for him that's especially in the realm of freedom of conscience and expression.
00:00:33 Today we'll look at how this case could shape the limits of compelled speech, ideological enforcement, and democratic accountability in school governance, possibly even across Canada.
00:00:45 I'm Melanie Bennett. This is Disrupted.
00:00:51 Today I'm joined with Jeff Horstman. Thank you so much for joining me today.
00:01:01 Oh, thank you for having me, Melanie.
00:01:03 Okay, so let me give a little bit of background context.
00:01:07 Jeff, I invited you because you recently submitted a legal challenge to the Waterloo Region District School Board on the basis of their requirement for mandatory land acknowledgement.
00:01:19 I'll just give a little bit of background detail as to why I'm interested in this case.
00:01:24 In the late spring, early summer, I was covering the story of Catherine Cronos, which many people might be aware of.
00:01:31 She objected to a land acknowledgement.
00:01:33 The video went viral.
00:01:35 She was sanctioned.
00:01:36 She was removed from her parent council.
00:01:39 And then she was reinstated with the involvement of the JCCF, the Justice Center for Constitutional Freedoms, and it was this whole thing.
00:01:45 And she's still in the process of dealing with that.
00:01:48 And it came to my attention recently that you guys at a different board, so again, this is the Waterloo area.
00:01:56 It's a different area.
00:01:58 The Parent Involvement Committee, individuals on the Parent Involvement Committee, including yourself, were also challenging the idea of land acknowledgements.
00:02:07 And I had the pleasure, shall we say, of attending the last meeting.
00:02:13 And in there, something I found very curious, because in Catherine's case, it was the principal who involved himself in whether or not the school council should be allowed to do land acknowledgements.
00:02:25 But in your case, in Waterloo, in the Parent Involvement Committee, it was the Director of Education who specifically said,
00:02:32 we are not going to note this in the minutes, we're not going to talk about this, we're just going to do it, and that's that.
00:02:36 Correct?
00:02:37 Right.
00:02:38 And in the meeting I attended, what I heard was pretty incredible, and I wrote about this, that the committee decided that they were going to note it in the minutes.
00:02:48 In fact, you know, this acknowledgement, we'll put it in there, or this objection to the land acknowledgement, we're going to put that in the minutes.
00:02:53 But we're not going to write that the Director mentioned anything.
00:02:56 We're just going to ignore that bit, and I heard this disagreement between everyone.
00:03:03 What I wasn't expecting is the very next day after I published this article, you, sir, came out with a legal challenge with the JCCF.
00:03:14 So how about we start this way?
00:03:16 Why don't you start by just giving us an overview of your legal challenge with JCCF?
00:03:23 Sure, this legal challenge is a judicial review, and it stems from the fact that at my parent council or school council, the board has said that we are required to have land acknowledgements at this council.
00:03:43 They've said, furthermore, that it cannot be discussed, right?
00:03:49 There is no opportunity for me to discuss or challenge this or have any substantive engagement on the issue at all.
00:04:00 It's really to align with the board's commitment to truth and reconciliation.
00:04:04 So that's really, essentially, the board just told me no.
00:04:08 Now, this is a process I had engaged in for quite some time.
00:04:11 Since early 2025, I started trying to discuss with the school council chair, the principal, and, of course, now a board-level equity advisor or something.
00:04:27 That's how it ended up.
00:04:28 That was the person who said it can't be discussed.
00:04:31 Okay, so I'm going to quote from the legal challenge.
00:04:34 It says that this is in communication from the school board.
00:04:39 And I don't think we know who this was at this point, but anyway.
00:04:42 So it says, conversations are actions that question the validity of equity-focused initiatives, including those designed to support historically and currently marginalized groups, risk undermining the dignity of members of our community.
00:04:56 Right, so we don't want to question any of our equity-focused initiatives, is what they're saying.
00:05:02 The WRDSB commitment to equity and human rights means that certain topics, certain topics, particularly those that diminish or delegitimize the experience of equity-deserving groups, must be approached with care and alignment with Ontario's human rights code.
00:05:17 So they are saying, we're not going to discuss this.
00:05:21 Like, if you want to talk about indigenous issues, we're just not going to talk about this.
00:05:26 Right, that's what they're saying.
00:05:28 And this came up very early in my discussions with the chair in early 2025, that discussions about land acknowledgements could be a violation of the Human Rights Code.
00:05:43 And so at that point, I think one of the points I brought up to the chair is, I think it would be appropriate for parents to know ahead of time what topics are potential violations of the law.
00:05:55 I don't think it's fair that we have these invisible tripwires that we wouldn't know about.
00:06:00 I think there should be some place where they're listed.
00:06:03 Right, and of course they can't do that.
00:06:06 Well, that would basically be saying that, they're saying it, okay, so we'll use different language.
00:06:14 You can't break the law.
00:06:16 I'll use an analogy.
00:06:17 You can't break the law.
00:06:18 You should follow the law.
00:06:19 But the idea is that you should be able to discuss and question elements about a law because that's the process of democracy, right?
00:06:27 So we should be able to question policies because perhaps those policies are wrong or maybe there's some issues with it.
00:06:33 But what they're saying here is they're not saying that it's a question you can't even discuss the policy or the law, right?
00:06:42 So that's kind of what they're saying, which is very, very interesting that this particular school board is so upfront and honest about that that's what they're doing.
00:06:53 But part of this legal challenge, the thing that I actually found the most interesting and I think could have broader implications, not just for land acknowledgments, whether you agree with land acknowledgments or not,
00:07:04 this is on the basis of your freedom of conscience.
00:07:09 And that's interesting because a lot of times when we're talking about school boards and people objecting to some of these, I guess, we'll just call them walk policies.
00:07:18 They tend to be on the basis of religion, like freedom of religion.
00:07:22 But we forget that we also have freedom of conscience within the charter.
00:07:26 What made you decide to go with that?
00:07:27 Well, it's really because for me, it was just a clear matter of conscience.
00:07:36 I have very strong beliefs, first of all, that we should be able to discuss things.
00:07:42 The acknowledgments themselves are somewhat secondary, but I do object to the acknowledgments on the basis that this is singling out a particular ethno-sectarian group for special consideration.
00:07:55 I don't think this is helpful to be spending time talking about a certain group in a very sacred way, right?
00:08:03 I think these are very religious statements, particularly the way they're done.
00:08:07 To me, they come across that way.
00:08:10 So in terms of conscience, I'm being told that I have to silently listen.
00:08:16 To participate in a meeting fully, I have to silently listen to this very statement that I disagree with quite strongly.
00:08:28 I have to silently listen.
00:08:30 And that really acts as a way to involuntarily endorse or launder these political or religious statements.
00:08:41 And manufacture an appearance of consensus among all council members.
00:08:48 And furthermore, we don't even know who else objects.
00:08:55 I still haven't been able to figure out who's on council technically.
00:08:57 There's no list posted.
00:09:00 There's a lot of all sorts of bylaws that aren't being adhered to.
00:09:05 So I just don't know, right?
00:09:06 So really, back to the conscience, it really is just the fact that I'm sort of being forced to sit through this and make it appear as though I consent.
00:09:17 Yeah, but if also people are being told that they're not allowed to even discuss certain topics that come under the umbrella of equity-deserving groups or equity initiatives.
00:09:27 If council members or community members are told this, they might not even express that they agree with other people who disagree, shall we say?
00:09:36 So there's a barrier there.
00:09:38 And that's more under the freedom of expression, right?
00:09:41 Correct.
00:09:43 One of the other things that I found really interesting is, as well as talking about freedom of conscience,
00:09:47 you were raising the idea that these land acknowledgments, you felt, and part of your conscience was telling you,
00:09:55 that actually they're kind of racist, and because you do not consider yourself to be a racist person,
00:10:00 that you felt you were being encouraged to make statements that you felt were racist.
00:10:07 Yeah, I don't know if I use the term racist, but I think in terms of individual dignity,
00:10:13 I believe in the inherent dignity and worth of people as individuals.
00:10:19 So it would be racist to the extent that we are dividing people based on race or ethnicity.
00:10:27 We are dividing them and then saying that certain groups have special rights or they have some particular connection to the land.
00:10:38 It's really a blood and soil type of ideology that is being inculcated through the council, and I object to that.
00:10:47 So, yeah, I think racist is probably, yeah, that's probably a reasonable term to use. 1.00
00:10:54 Yeah, I think I was using my own phrasing in there.
00:10:57 I don't think you actually did call them or actually use that particular term.
00:11:00 But it's interesting phrasing it that way because a lot of people who object to a lot of diversity, equity, and inclusion ideas
00:11:07 tend to do so on the basis that they feel that it's actually reversing the concept of racism, right?
00:11:12 And so this kind of comes across in this particular legal challenge.
00:11:16 Now, I want to go back to the meeting that I attended because what I didn't know when I was listening and writing the article
00:11:24 was that the director, when he interjected in the original meeting, I think it was back in September,
00:11:33 and he said, no, we're absolutely not going to note that, you know, our board is pro-truth and reconciliation.
00:11:37 We're actually not going to discuss that.
00:11:38 He was doing so on the basis of what you were told, that we don't discuss these topics.
00:11:43 We just do them.
00:11:44 And then the meeting that I attended back in late November, all of a sudden, oh, we don't want to put down that the director said anything.
00:11:52 We want to definitely get away from that.
00:11:55 And it seems to me that the change in attitude between those two meetings might be a reflection on some of the conversations
00:12:02 that you were having behind the scenes with the school board and the JCCF.
00:12:06 Are you allowed to talk about that?
00:12:07 Is that correct?
00:12:08 Or was that going on even longer?
00:12:10 No.
00:12:11 So, no, the action that we filed was after that meeting.
00:12:17 So it would have no reflections.
00:12:19 And I don't think because the board was very clear.
00:12:22 The last interactions I had with the board, I sought clarity.
00:12:25 It was very clear in an email, we are going to require school councils to do land acknowledgements,
00:12:33 and they're not things that can be discussed.
00:12:35 And that was really the last I heard of it from the board.
00:12:40 Yeah.
00:12:40 So where do you go from here?
00:12:43 Good question.
00:12:44 I guess we'll see what happens when it goes for review.
00:12:49 We're going to file the affidavit, go through the process.
00:12:53 And I hope that the board will reverse its decision, but we'll see.
00:12:59 Yeah.
00:12:59 It's really interesting, too, because I noticed that oftentimes talking about these issues,
00:13:04 mainstream media don't really cover it.
00:13:05 And I noticed that that was being picked up by legacy media.
00:13:10 I can't remember exactly off the top of my head which ones, but be things like CTV or City News.
00:13:17 I don't think those are the correct ones.
00:13:19 But yeah, there was CTV Kitchener and the Waterloo Record, and they both covered it fairly.
00:13:25 So I'm quite encouraged by that.
00:13:28 I don't know why they picked it up, but they did.
00:13:31 Yeah.
00:13:32 It must be something that's resonating with the readership.
00:13:35 I think people are starting to find these things off.
00:13:39 And perhaps people are recognizing with the Cowichan decision that's starting to resonate in people's minds,
00:13:46 that there actually are consequences for property rights.
00:13:50 So maybe that's just starting to pick up, and people are really starting to want to put the brakes on this,
00:13:55 or question it at least, or just think, we should talk about this.
00:13:59 It wasn't really talked about, right?
00:14:01 Yeah, and so I don't know your region that well.
00:14:05 I've only been a few times.
00:14:07 But if I'm not mistaken, there's the Six Nations, and there's been some questions around ownership of land
00:14:14 and some disputes over a long period of time.
00:14:18 And I've actually continued attending Catherine Cronus, which is not you guys.
00:14:23 It's sort of a different story, but it's all about the land acknowledgement,
00:14:25 whether or not those are appropriate.
00:14:27 But it seems that those areas, both Hamilton and Waterloo, which are kind of close together,
00:14:37 seem to have a lot of opposition to getting rid of these land acknowledgements.
00:14:41 The schools do seem very, very, very keen on silencing any objection to that, particularly in this area.
00:14:48 Do you think it has anything to do with the issues in the Six Nations, the land disputes?
00:14:54 That's a good question.
00:14:55 I have no idea if it does.
00:14:57 Because I don't know who advises the board on these acknowledgements.
00:15:04 One thing that's interesting, at the meeting, a board meeting recently, I think in September,
00:15:11 the Waterloo Region District School Board, the chair opened the meeting in a way that I'd never seen before.
00:15:18 It was very extended, very sacred-sounding, talking about Indigenous sovereignty and Turtle Island.
00:15:28 And then last night I attended a town hall, not a town hall, but it was the board was promoting it that way.
00:15:35 And it was discussing the strategic plan that they've got, and front and centre, it talked about Indigenous sovereignty.
00:15:43 So, maybe this is something that activists have infused, you know, the consultants, and perhaps that's one explanation is that they think this may have some legal advantage to some of these settlements.
00:15:57 I don't know. I hadn't thought of that before.
00:15:59 Yeah, that's probably a bit of an unfair question, because obviously this has nothing to do with your particular legal challenge, right?
00:16:04 I was curious to talk about one other thing, and that's why this is important that it's happening at school councils, or parent councils, and parent involvement committees.
00:16:16 Now, my understanding is that these particular groups, whether it's parent involvement committee or parent council, which are similar but not quite the same thing,
00:16:24 that they are governed by parents, and although they are there to advise the board, they should not be governed by the board.
00:16:31 This is why it matters that, say, the principal in Hamilton got involved, and the director of education in Waterloo got involved,
00:16:38 because they shouldn't be getting involved in parent-led governance, but they did in these particular cases.
00:16:45 Would you like to maybe talk a little bit about how it's important for parents to understand that they're the ones in charge of these particular groups, right?
00:16:54 Like, that's your way in.
00:16:55 When we hear right now about how the Minister of Education is creating these parent organizations, I can't remember what they are off the top of my head,
00:17:02 but within the board, there's these groups, and they're supposed to help parents, and so on and so forth, and that's great.
00:17:07 Sure, that could work.
00:17:08 But also, parent council is supposed to be for parents.
00:17:11 It's supposed to be led by parents, governed by parents, and the communication between parents and the board.
00:17:15 Yeah, and the parent involvement council, this PIC, is a little different than the school councils.
00:17:22 I think the school councils have a little more independence, whereas PIC is a board group of parent volunteers to kind of help with parent involvement.
00:17:31 So they're slightly different.
00:17:31 But this, my case, involves the school councils, and these councils are arm's length, and in the statute, it's quite clear that one of the roles is to hold the board accountable,
00:17:44 and the schools accountable to parents, right, so that we can help improve student outcomes and well-being, right?
00:17:51 It's this type of language.
00:17:52 So I've always viewed my role on these councils as an accountability role, that it's very important that this is, I don't know how else,
00:18:03 you try to bring, you want to make change in the school and the direction of education, you have concerns,
00:18:08 you can bring them to council and try to discuss them.
00:18:11 In practice, I've never seen the councils functioning that way.
00:18:15 I've been on three different councils, and they always appear to be quite driven by the principal, quite controlled, and in line with board priorities.
00:18:29 The chair often seems to be very friendly with the principal, which isn't necessarily a bad thing, but it's almost a deferential relationship.
00:18:40 I feel that the chair is kind of listening to what the principal says.
00:18:44 There's not a lot of, I've never been able to have really what I consider to be important educational topics discussed at council.
00:18:53 It'll be the time is taken up, you know, after an extensive land acknowledgement, there's going to be, you know, a presentation about our advising group,
00:19:02 or, you know, the students will talk about what they're doing.
00:19:04 It's all feel-good type of stuff, you know, long presentations about a particular programming at the school, you know, fine,
00:19:12 but it's never been a place where, here's my concern about how we now don't have grade 11 English.
00:19:20 It's more, again, being politically infused.
00:19:22 We've never been able to have discussions about CRRP or any sort of these critical race theory issues.
00:19:29 But technically, that should be the place where you should have a voice as a parent to discuss concerns.
00:19:35 You would think, but I think a lot of, even the parents seem to be quite deferential.
00:19:42 I feel that there's, and maybe this is a broader cultural problem in our country,
00:19:46 is that we very much look to government for answers, and we're very like, oh, is that okay if I do this?
00:19:53 It's, people don't, I don't think they've read the Education Act or understand what their rights are, what their role is.
00:19:58 They seem to just show up, and the principal sets the agenda and kind of runs things with the chair,
00:20:04 and they just kind of ask, oh, can I do this?
00:20:08 So, I think that's a more serious systemic cultural problem.
00:20:13 Yeah, so you're a parent who's definitely been at the forefront with some other parents as well in different school boards,
00:20:18 but there's certainly some parents who are less afraid of, or who are more willing to push what the established zeitgeist is in the education system.
00:20:28 But would you have any advice for parents who might be concerned about some of these things going on in schools and what they can do?
00:20:34 Yeah, I would say you have, you can talk about it, and in fact, you should insist upon it.
00:20:40 And I think, you know, it's a good idea to talk to your teacher and your principal.
00:20:44 Usually, principals are very good about having a discussion.
00:20:47 You know, I had a nice, long conversation with my principal, and I think that's important.
00:20:50 But I think the most important thing is to connect to parents, to other parents.
00:20:55 And you're not going to do that through official channels with the board.
00:20:59 I've tried that, and they're very good at keeping you isolated.
00:21:01 They really don't want you talking and getting together and organizing.
00:21:05 You have to do that independently.
00:21:07 And so I think connecting, I mean, like we have a group at Waterloo that's quite active, this Empower group.
00:21:15 So, I mean, you can reach out to us.
00:21:17 But I think that's the key is to start networking with other parents and finding out what they think and learning.
00:21:26 Because a lot of people just don't know about what's going on.
00:21:28 They'll see something strange.
00:21:29 It doesn't make sense, but no one else is talking about it.
00:21:32 Well, I haven't really thought about it.
00:21:34 Well, I will say that in your area, there has been some success, specifically with land acknowledgments.
00:21:39 I believe one of the members of Empower, Cristina Bayros Fernandez, at her school council was able to remove the land acknowledgement from parent council.
00:21:49 So, I mean, these things can be successful.
00:21:51 They do happen.
00:21:52 And sometimes we don't talk about some of those successes.
00:21:55 They happen in small areas.
00:21:56 Maybe it's not widely known.
00:21:58 So, I'll just share that to end the discussion that we're having today.
00:22:01 And that was really actually an excellent example because it took a long time.
00:22:06 It was building those relationships over time.
00:22:08 And they came to a really good compromise where those who really want to have that somber reflection just show up a few minutes early.
00:22:16 They can do it.
00:22:17 And then the meeting starts on time where they get to business.
00:22:19 Everyone sort of agreed on that.
00:22:20 So, there are good compromises here.
00:22:24 Okay.
00:22:24 I didn't realize that was the way that it was done.
00:22:26 Yeah.
00:22:27 That just shows that there are ways that people can follow their own conscience without being forced into it.
00:22:31 It's really important to them to have that.
00:22:33 It's almost like a prayer.
00:22:34 You know, it's deeply important to them.
00:22:36 But also, if you don't have those discussions, if you don't talk about it, you can't come to an arrangement where everybody feels that they're happy with what's happening.
00:22:45 Right?
00:22:46 Right.
00:22:46 Right.
00:22:47 And that's the issue.
00:22:48 It's just we haven't been able to have the discussion.
00:22:51 And that seems to be the official position of the board that you cannot discuss it.
00:22:55 Okay, Jeff, I will be watching this case very closely.
00:22:59 I definitely think that there is some potential implications that are broader than this in terms of freedom of conscience.
00:23:04 And if Canadians should be compelled to do things that they feel deeply goes against their beliefs.
00:23:11 So, thank you for doing this.
00:23:14 And, yeah, I hope to speak to you soon about the same topic.
00:23:17 All right.
00:23:18 Wonderful.
00:23:18 Well, thank you so much for having me, Melanie.
00:23:20 That's it for today's episode of Disrupted.
00:23:22 This story is definitely a reminder that parents can speak up, even when school boards or the media try to shame or silence or discredit you or tell you that you're not allowed to talk about things.
00:23:35 Talking about tough topics takes courage, I know, and it can be difficult.
00:23:39 But that's how we hold public institutions accountable.
00:23:43 So, keep doing it.
00:23:44 And if you found this helpful, possibly consider liking, subscribing, and sharing it with someone who needs to hear it.
00:23:53 For True North, I'm Melanie Bennett.