Juno News - January 17, 2019


Andrew Lawton with Lindsay Shepherd: Standing up for Free Speech in Canada Pt.1

Topics
Mentioned
University free speech policies more focused on "diversity" than free speech The True North Report: What an embarrassing week for Canada

Episode Stats


Length

12 minutes

Words per minute

179.15

Word count

2,296

Sentence count

145


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Lindsay Shepard is a former Wilfrid Laurier teaching assistant and grad student. She is now a columnist with The Post Millennial. In this episode, Lindsay talks to Andrew Lawton about the latest in the Jordan Peterson defamation case.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Welcome, Andrew Lawton here from True North with a bit of a new type of feature we're doing,
00:00:09 which is just having some really in-depth conversations, one-on-one chats with people
00:00:13 who are really at the center of a lot of the key battles that we're seeing in Canada. And one of
00:00:19 the big ones that I've been covering more broadly is the free speech battle, and more specifically,
00:00:24 the way that this has been impacting one person in Canada in particular, and that is Lindsay
00:00:29 Shepard, of course, the former Wilfrid Laurier teaching assistant and grad student, now the
00:00:34 columnist with the Post Millennial here at True North from time to time, and some other places as
00:00:39 well. Lindsay Shepard joins me from British Columbia. Lindsay, good to talk to you. Thanks for coming on
00:00:43 today. Hello, no problem. So this is something that you and I have talked about in the past,
00:00:49 because this whole ordeal that you've been in the mid-step has now been going on for, I think,
00:00:53 like 14 or 15 months here. And now we have the latest chapter of this, which is, of course,
00:00:59 you facing legal action. And I was wondering if you could explain a little bit about how you are now
00:01:06 in the eyes of a claim filed against you responsible for what someone else said about Jordan Peterson.
00:01:12 Sure. So it's a third-party claim. So it does still mean that I'm being sued. So I'm being sued by
00:01:21 professors Rambucana and Pimlott, not the actual university. Don't know if they're planning on
00:01:27 joining in or anything. But for now, it's just doctors Rambucana and Pimlott. So they're saying
00:01:32 that during the meeting that I recorded, because I recorded it, I am responsible for their words,
00:01:39 essentially. So Jordan Peterson filed a defamation suit against them. And by bringing me in as the third
00:01:46 party, they're saying, well, if Jordan Peterson was indeed defamed, then it is my fault, because I
00:01:54 recorded it and gave the recording to media outlets.
00:01:59 The whole point of this, though, this whole ordeal, I find to be rooted in a fundamentally flawed premise,
00:02:05 because at first you're saying, and you noted this, that Jordan Peterson wasn't defamed. But then,
00:02:10 okay, if he was, it was Lindsay's fault. But then you have the apology from Rambucana,
00:02:15 where he says, yeah, I should have never described Peterson in that way. So we've got
00:02:20 three narratives here that aren't just inconvenient to one another, but three narratives that really
00:02:24 are completely contradictory to each other.
00:02:28 Yeah, yeah, I actually was going to bring up Rambucana's apology, which is a public apology,
00:02:33 right? Like, I mean, it's on his website. And he says, you know, I implied that Dr. Peterson is like
00:02:38 Hitler, which is untrue and was never my intention. While I disagree strongly with many of Dr.
00:02:44 Peterson's academic positions and actions, the tired analogy does him a disservice and was the
00:02:50 opposite of useful in our discussion. So I know that this is going through the court system. And
00:02:55 it's important that I mentioned that this has not been proven in court anything. This is just based
00:02:59 on a claim. You're defending yourself, as I think you should, and as you have a right to. But the other
00:03:05 element of this statement of claim that I find so baffling, and I know you've pointed this out as
00:03:10 well, is one section here that I want to read, point nine, where it says that the meeting that
00:03:17 took place, so this inquisition that you recorded, that you shared the audio of, was acting pursuant
00:03:23 to their respective academic freedom. So this meeting, which the school has apologized for, which Rambucana's
00:03:30 apologized for, in their statement of claim, they're saying that meeting was all part of their academic
00:03:35 freedom, and also that it was to just better understand the circumstances. So this was not
00:03:42 an exploratory meeting, in your view. This was really a reprimand, was it not?
00:03:47 Well, yeah. And actually, if you look at the statement of defense they filed in the Peterson suit,
00:03:53 so not in this claim, but in their statement of defense for Peterson, they actually say it was not
00:03:58 a disciplinary meeting, and they say I was never ordered to attend the meeting. So apparently now,
00:04:06 when our supervisors tell us to come into meetings, we can just politely say, oh, no, thanks, I don't
00:04:12 want to come to the meeting. Thanks for the suggestion. So it's kind of, that was a very strange point.
00:04:18 It was a disciplinary meeting. A lot of people haven't listened to the whole recording, because it is
00:04:23 42 minutes. So they just listened to some sort of highlights. But at the end, it is clear that,
00:04:29 you know, there are sanctions. And what, and obviously, what changed the whole narrative here
00:04:33 was that I recorded it, and I recorded it and released it quite quickly. So if I had just not
00:04:40 recorded it, not gone to the media, it would have been a very, very different scenario.
00:04:45 Yeah, and you and I talked about that in the past, that whole idea that this really would have just
00:04:49 been, you know, university student complains about professor had you not been able to produce that
00:04:55 evidence. And even in spite of all of this, I mean, that recording is so revealing. And this is where I
00:05:03 wonder how this revisionism is expected to fly, because this is really being a revisionistic act to
00:05:09 say that this meeting was voluntary, that it wasn't mandatory, and that it was just for better
00:05:14 understanding. Right. And like, I can kind of see their argument with Rambucana's academic freedom.
00:05:21 Okay, sure, it's, it's his course. In the claim, they do make a point to say that, you know, the
00:05:26 clips I played during the class were played without Rambucana's knowledge, approval or consent. And that's
00:05:32 true. But every single class was like that. We didn't need his consent for for anything. It's not
00:05:38 like we met weekly, and planned our courses between, you know, the eight TAs that he had,
00:05:43 I had met him, I think, two or three times in person before that, we were just communicating by email.
00:05:49 But with Professor Pimlot's academic freedom, this kind of seems to me kind of irrelevant, because
00:05:54 many academics came up to me and said, you know, why was Pimlot there? He was the coordinator for my
00:06:01 master's program, which is separate from my TA ship with Professor Rambucana. So it was either some sort of
00:06:08 intimidation tactic. It was him seeing if I was going to stay in my master's program. There's just
00:06:14 no reason for him to be there. His academic freedom is not really relevant, it seems.
00:06:18 And then we've also got to square this with Adria Joel being there. This was the school's,
00:06:23 the titles are just interchangeable words, like you just, it's like Mad Libs, but like the gender
00:06:27 manager, violence coordinator, some odd. But her role there as well speaks to that intimidation.
00:06:33 This wasn't just, you know, a general run-of-the-mill mentorship between you and a professor.
00:06:40 Yeah, exactly. And she's represented by different lawyers. So it's, Rambucana and Pimlot have one set
00:06:48 of lawyers, and then the university and Adria Joel have another one. So they're not in it. I honestly
00:06:54 haven't heard anything from Adria Joel since. She's completely fallen off the map.
00:06:57 So let's explain this part to me here, if you can. The student complaint that apparently triggered
00:07:05 this whole thing, which I was under the understanding had been debunked during the
00:07:09 school's investigation of this, now seems to have come back from the dead in this third-party claim.
00:07:14 And now in this claim filed by Rambucana and Pimlot, we're back to having a student complaint
00:07:20 triggering this.
00:07:20 Yeah, I mean, I guess, are they kind of shifting their language to call it a concern? Something
00:07:27 like that. And it does appear that there was some sort of concern that someone heard. And
00:07:34 it was Adria Joel that approached Rambucana, I think, that made this all happen. But yeah,
00:07:41 I mean, there's a statement that's public on the Wilfrid Laurier website, and it's from
00:07:45 Professor McClatchy, or sorry, President McClatchy. And she is talking about the neutral third-party
00:07:53 fact-finding investigation that happened in December 2017. And, you know, it says there
00:07:59 that basic guidelines and best practices on how to appropriately execute the roles and responsibilities
00:08:04 of staff and faculty were ignored or not understood. I was involved in no wrongdoing. And it has been
00:08:13 made clear to those who were involved in the meeting that Ms. Shepard, oh, in the meeting
00:08:17 with Ms. Shepard, that their conduct does not meet the high standards set for staff and
00:08:22 faculty. So, I mean, that statement is, you know, public.
00:08:28 Sounds like they should be suing McClatchy now, because she's the one that's basically said,
00:08:32 they've got to own that. In a lot of ways, though, and I've thought that you've been in the right
00:08:37 this whole situation, as I think most sensible people have. But do you think that you poked the
00:08:41 bear a little bit too much with your lawsuit against them and against the school? Like,
00:08:46 do you think that this suit is really only a response to that, even though it's filed under
00:08:50 a different one? Sure. Yeah. I mean, but it just didn't seem like they felt like they did anything
00:09:01 wrong. And I just, it seemed like everything was just going to carry on, you know, like I was going
00:09:05 to graduate, I was going to be out of their hair. And then now that, now that I'm gone, they can just
00:09:10 continue doing things the way they want to do things, which includes, you know, meetings like
00:09:15 the one I was in. And so, and a lot of people were, were urging me to sue. So I, you know,
00:09:23 we're going to go with that. Well, good. And you should. And I think that when we look at this
00:09:28 context here of the school's apology, you wrote and tweeted a fair bit after that apology came,
00:09:35 that indicated that this was never really a mea culpa, we move it behind us. I mean,
00:09:40 the way you were treated by professors, the way you were treated by fellow students, I mean,
00:09:44 it's very much stuck with you after that. So for the school to say, and for any of the professors
00:09:51 to say that's old news, wouldn't really fly with your experience of it. And I guess what I would put
00:09:56 to you then, in the context of this third party claim against you, I know you've had many chats
00:10:04 about this with your own lawyer, presumably, what's likely to come here? I mean, is this just a
00:10:08 throwing something at the wall and hoping it sticks? Or is there a very real chance that our
00:10:13 system, from what you understand, could find you culpable for sharing that audio?
00:10:19 I really have no idea. I feel like it could go either way. So it'll honestly, it'll be kind of
00:10:26 interesting to me in a way to see which way our legal system goes to, because it'll kind of
00:10:31 maybe set a precedent.
00:10:32 We have a climate now in Ontario, where the new provincial government has made campus free speech
00:10:39 a priority. And I think a lot of people have taken from the Ontario government's policy,
00:10:43 somewhat of a wait and see approach of, you know, maybe it's good in principle, but will it actually
00:10:48 have the ramifications? But are you convinced that if this policy that Laurier has been compelled to
00:10:54 put forward now, was there two years ago, that you would have gone through this still? I guess that's
00:11:00 the big question. And I know, hypotheticals are challenging. But you were one of the key players
00:11:05 that I think inspired people talking about these policies. Do you think it would have made a
00:11:09 difference?
00:11:12 Um, I'm not sure. It's really hard to answer something like that. Yeah. But what I do, and I agree that it's
00:11:21 kind of a wait and see with this policy right now. But I also fear that no students are going to even
00:11:28 try to rock the boat in any way. You know, now it's seen as like, if you, if you care about free
00:11:35 speech, you are, you know, you've gone too far. So I just worry that already, this policy, you know,
00:11:44 no one's going to act in a way that would, we would need to enact it, if you know what I mean.
00:11:48 We've got your lawsuit against the school and the people in the meeting. We've got Jordan Peterson's
00:11:53 lawsuit. Now we've got the third party claim under Jordan Peterson's lawsuit against you.
00:11:58 Do you have any sense of the timeline of these things and any dates that are coming up imminently?
00:12:05 No, no, it is all pretty complex with all these lawsuits going around. But you know, clearly they
00:12:12 have responded to Peterson's. So they filed a statement of defense. And now they've done this
00:12:18 third party claim. But I actually, my statement of claim was filed before Peterson's against them.
00:12:26 And they actually still haven't filed a statement of defense for that. So that was back in June.
00:12:31 And they're going after you in another unrelated case. Yeah. Wow. Okay, so we don't have like a court
00:12:38 date yet. It's still working its way through the always expeditious legal system. Yes. All right,
00:12:45 Lindsay Shepard, great to have you on about this. Thanks so much for your time today.
00:12:47 Yeah, thank you.